Hadith Rejector DECIMATES a Sunni at Speakers' Corner [subtitles]
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 05. 2023
- Quran is sufficient for Religious knowledge.
GOD has sent Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) with 1 book to unite the community.
They have 20+ books that divided it.
Apparently their hadeeth books teaches them "where is mecca"
@DUSDawah
#allah
#god
#quran
#islam
#speakerscorner
#shamsi
الرافض الحديث يفضح السني - Zábava
We live in an age where ignorant people are considered scholars of the religion.
This!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yessir
I reverted to Islam August 2022. I thought Muslims were one. Now the more I learn the more I seem to be confused with the amount of disagreement and interpretations. I also recently have just finished reading the Quran. All I know for a fact is that there is no deity other than Allah ((swt)) and Muhammad (pbuh) is his messenger. May Allah grant us all truth
4:27 And it is Allah’s Will to turn to you in grace, but those who follow their desires wish to see you deviate entirely ˹from Allah’s Way˺.
Dear brother warm welcome to Truth and goodness! What you need to know is that we do accept the authentic statements of Muhammad SAW. May Allah keep you on the Straight path.
If you are getting confused then stop watching such debates and start reading simple hadeeth books like Riyad-us-Saliheen. May Allah reward you.
A bedouin with unkempt hair came to Allah’s Messenger (s) and said, “O Allah’s Messenger (s)! Inform me what Allah has made compulsory for me as regards the prayers.” He replied: “You have to offer perfectly the five compulsory prayers in a day and night (24 hours), unless you want to pray Nawafil.”
The bedouin further asked, “Inform me what Allah has made compulsory for me as regards fasting.” He replied, “You have to fast during the whole month of Ramadan, unless you want to fast more as Nawafil.” Bedouin again asked, “Tell me how much Zakat Allah has enjoined on me.”
Thus, Allah’s Messenger (s) informed him about all the rules (i.e. fundamentals) of Islam. The bedouin then said, “By Him Who has honored you, I will neither perform any Nawafil nor will I decrease what Allah has enjoined on me. Allah’s Messenger (s) said, “If he is saying the truth, he will succeed (or he will be granted Paradise)
Bro there 100s of verses like 3:31-32, 47:33 where Allah orders us to obey and follow the Messenger only through which we have got practical Islam with minute details which was the duty of Messenger. The Quranists reject the Quran and that's disbelief. A trick of Satan out of 1000s of tricks to mislead a believer . So strive to find the truth as in Quran 29:69
After the time of the prophet s.a.w he said the muslims would disunite and only the first 4 caliphs would be rightly guided. We have to stick to quran and sunnah as taught to us by the 4 schools of thought. Anything else and we will go astray.
Where tf is the decimation?
Open your heart and you will see
The argument of a loser@@Quran_Alone_Dawah
Shamsi dealt with this individual
بالتي هي أحسن
@@HammersmithMasjidIslamicCentre 🤣
Came here to listen to the hadith rejector's arguement, Shamsi still made more sense.
fr
🤣 I laugh but it's honestly sad. May Allah help these Sunni mushriqeen use the 2 brain cells they collectively have to the best of their abilities
I'm Sunni, but Shamsi was exaggerating here. I can only understand his attitude, if he feared the laymen became astray from the Qur'aniyyah, but otherwise, it's too much.
@@geeljire9247 Yes, we are so astray for following the book of Allah alone. Allah will surely send us to hellfire for only following his fully detailed and fully explained, clear book.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah I wouldn't consider Qur'aniyyah to automatically be people of the Hellfire, that's something Allah (swt) decides and not me, nor do i takfir Muslims with that mindset. It's just that i consider Sunni Islam to be correct, and trying to see why Shamsi would exaggerate like this, although technically he wouldn't even consider me the same sect as he's Madkhali and i'm Ash'ari.
My brother you are passionate about Islam but I agree with Shamsi here. May Allah guide you
Ameen
Ameen
and may God guide you because you have chosen wrong
@@OmarRamzino.. you are wrong.. the hadith rejectors are disgusting... wallahi
As an outsider looking in its easy to see that the hadith has been compromised like the bible has. Anyone can right down but they thought jesus (pbuh) or Muhammad (pbuh) said or ordered. The only thing trustworthy is the quran. Pride and arrogance is a scary thing and all religions have them and if you think you dont then you should do some deep reflection. Why would Gods word be secondary to the Hadith? It doesnt make sense. Only quran is from God. Hadith is from Men
Shamsi destroyed you, you couldnt prove any of your claims you dont even dare to answer
How 😂
All he kept saying was where’s Mecca … where’s Mecca
He made no argument
@@DomaScholes you kuffar are actually delusional 😂
Quran or hadith doesn't come with a GPS
he basically cut that part from his perspective Shamsi its quite suspicious
Lol contradicted himself by being a proud sectarian haditiyoon 😅😂
This is how they become when confronted with facts, they place so much emphasis on hadeeth that they often forget and even contradict the Quran.
These people cannot even fathom or perform the most basic of tasks, because instead of thinking for themselves using reason and logic, they have to run to Hadeeth.
Ok tell me how u know how to pray?
@@burakcoskun1865quran says pray how you have been taught and theres hadith that says muhammad said dont write anything from me that isnt quran
@@reallyrocc4546 verse about the latter?
@@burakcoskun1865 (Narrated by Muslim, al-Zuhd wa’l-Raqaa’iq, 5326)
@@burakcoskun1865 Thank you for proving OP's point
*“Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day.”*
Everything you rejectors of the deen of Allah reject dismantled by this one verse Allahu akbar ☝️
Why do you neglect the verses of Allah when he tells us not to believe in any hadith except the Quran?
@@TheAdrianSmith Does it really say that tho? I think you must've misread because it doens't tell us to " not to believe in any hadith except the Quran"
@@shuush875 HERE ARE THE VERSES IN THE QURAN PROCLAIMING THE QURAN TO BE THE ONLY ACCEPTABLE HADITH
[Quran 7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things God has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which hadith, besides this do they believe in?
[Quran 31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless Hadith, and thus divert others from the path of God without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution.
[Quran 39:23] God has revealed herein the best Hadith; a book that is consistent and points out both ways (to heaven and hell). The skins of those who reverence their Lord cringe therefrom, then their skins and their hearts soften up for God's message. Such is God's guidance; he bestows it upon whomever He wills. As for those sent astray by God, nothing can guide them.
[Quran 45:6] These are God's revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In which hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?
[Quran 52:34] Let them produce a hadith like this if they are truthful.
[Quran 68:44] Therefore, let Me deal with those who reject this Hadith; we will lead them on whence they never perceive."
[Quran 77:50] Which Hadith other than this do they uphold?
Whats a Messenger? How do you obey Messenger?
@@RayB432 Hadith rejectors are beyond Iost
no need to ask him where is Mecca, just ask him how he prays 😂😂😂
Does he believe he has to pray 5 times a day ? I don’t think so also
@@MrCS-81 where in the Qur'an is tells you to pray five times a day?
@@rarebreed748 where in the Quran does it say not to eat 💩?
the quran talks about 5 daily prayers ..I can quote them all my boy ...the quran doesn't say they are obligatory..because nothing us obligatory in religion even fasting ..allah judge us from our hearts
@@rarebreed748
Sunrise - 11:114/24:58
Noon - 17:78
Afternoon - 2:238
Sunset - 11:114/24:58
Night - 11:114
😂😂😂 oh noooooooooooo
Brother may Allah SWT guide you and me but you got exposed even in your own video but you didn't see it 😂🤦
Even tho i am not a hadith rejector, it saddens me that this sunnis, instead of making Allah No 1 priority, they make both Allah & RasulAllah as their priority.
May Allah guide me to the right path, and save us from his fitnah.😢
"May God not give you good health"
That's straight up anger and arrogance
“Obey Allah AND Obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day.”
@@NotContinental
This verse means “refer the quran only”. If you pay attention, Rasul means a one who carries a message from Allah. Allah and his messanger calls us to follow Allah’s kitab/quran. So when we difer in something, we go back to Allah’s book brought by the Rasul. It doesn’t mean Allah and the Mesenger each has their own unique source of guidance.
This verse in surah Nisa says “If you obey the Rasul, you have indeed obeyed Allah”. Obey the Rasul witn what? Allah’s kitab. And we know for sure Allah sent our messenger with only one kitab, the Quran. Nothing else.
@@muslix1147you hadith rejectors are among the worst of people who went astray. Let's do this logically cause battling you with the Quran is non beneficial because you will twist the words and give your own tafsirs that contradict that of thousands of pious people that gave more to Islam than you ever did. Do you actually think that our prophet SAW spoke out of his own whim? I hope not because then you are too far gone to even have a discussion with you. If the prophet didn't speak of his own whim why are there narrations that are proven to have been authentic and have been said by the prophet SAW that are not written in the Quran like the prayer. How do you pray actually? If you reject Hadith my best guess is you don't pray at all and you are of that people that imitate christians which only follow what suits them and still want to go to Jannah. 2nd how do I prove to the ignorant people like you that hadiths are the words of prophet? well it's pretty easy actually. Because you have a chain of narrations. This is the Hadith science. And no there isn't one chain of narration. So let me explain how it works.
Prophet Muhammad SAW
|
Various narrators that were the companions
|
Many many students of each of the sahaba with some hadiths having 11 chains of narration from a single member of the sahaba
|
Finally the Sahih books of hadiths that were compiled by great minds of Islam like Imam Bukhari and his student Imam Muslim
Imam Bukhari dedicated his life to the hadiths in which he has read biographies of narrators, their students followed the trail of narration so that it would come to the prophet SAW without any missing links in the narration and without weak narrators(meaning those who were forgetful or maybe not the best Muslims)
This is the Hadith science so anyone who rejects it has been led astray. It is bold of you an internet nobody to assume that imam Bukhari or imam Muslim have lied and that all of their books are corrupted with no evidence. There are literally people who study the hadiths to this day looking through each chain of narration and narrators. People literally dedicated their lives for us Muslims to be following the steps of our prophet SAW. And now you have these ignorant people which are the worst of ummah, if they can even be called a part of ummah. But even this prophet has foreseen. That people will ease their religion and make it christianity 2.0 by taking words out of context, twisting the words of God and making Islam their religion of fun and not discipline and dedication to Allah SWT. I pray that Allah SWT will destroy those that have led you astray and will guide you to the right path. Because calling yourself a Muslim while rejecting and calling liars thousands of Muslims that did so much for the ummah and Islam in general proves that you are only that people of dissension and of those who create discord
@@muslix1147 my comments get constantly deleted and I can't even answer your ludicrous claims
Let me try by using edits so let's use logic on this matter
First of all let's begin with the belief that the prophet SAW never said anything on his own whim and that everything that he has said is what Allah has guided him to say
If you do not believe this then we won't have a discussion because this would mean that you are too far gone to even talk with you about this if you believe that the prophet saw said something that only came from his own mind and not from Allah
If you believe that the prophet Muhammad SAW said only that that Allah has revealed to him then we can have a discussion
First of all let's start with explaining what is the Hadith. Hadiths are the words and actions of the prophet SAW that have been recorded and narrated by the Sahaba. Suffice to say that if you are rejecting the companions of the prophet then you are one of the disbelievers, why? because it is written in the Quran that the companions of the prophets are those who will be the first to step into Jannah Surah 9 verse 100 [And the first forerunners [in the faith] among the Muhajireen and the Ansar and those who followed them with good conduct - Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him, and He has prepared for them gardens beneath which rivers flow, wherein they will abide forever. That is the great attainment.]
As you can see here in this surah in this verse Allah tells us that the sahaba the companions of the prophet will be in The gardens of bliss.
So if you think that the companions of the prophet deviated or lied or twisted the words of the prophet SAW which would create the discord among the believers and that is enough for a Muslim to go to hell if you believe that the companions of the prophet did that then you are one of the disbelievers my friend.
You can refer to the Quran in which it talks about the sahaba the companions only in a positive way only in a good way there are many more verses I think you as Quranist should know that(if you did read the Quran I mean)
Now when we have proved that the Hadith are the words and actions of the prophet that are narrated by the companions of the prophet which will be the ones who inherit The gardens of bliss as Allah SWT told us in the Quran now is only one question left.
How do we prove that these chains of narrations are not faulty?
And this is the easiest question if you want to disprove the Hadith that you didn't like I don't know sahih bukhari, sahih Muslim you didn't like the Hadith and you said well I don't think the prophet would have said that.
You can easily prove that by studying the chain of narration if you will find out that one of the narrators is someone who is unknown to us we don't know anything about his life anything about his biography who he was did he have a good memory or not if you can prove in chain of narration that is the only one chain of narration to one Hadith that the chain is faulty because of that one missing link this Hadith will be called weak or rejected at all if you bring enough evidence. The thing is to me it seems as if Hadith rejectors are converts that were Christian, that's how I see you people because I think that you see the Hadith as some kind of holy text that no one can criticize, of course you can criticize it if you have the evidence but if you don't have the evidence then you better shut up. If you don't like the Hadith then please be my guest become a Hadith scientist and prove to us that all these chains of narrations are faulty but you cannot prove that because let me explain to you how the Hadith work
You have first link the prophet Muhammad SAW he is the first this is who we take the Hadith from then come his sahaba the companions who wrote down his actions and words then come the students of the companions and sometimes you can have 11 chains of narrations from one companion of the prophet.
And we have Hadith that have hundreds of chains of narrations coming from different narrators that were the companions of the prophet and had their students and their students had their students and their students had their students and so on and so on and so on and so on until the day that imam Bukhari compiled all of these hadiths that were sahih and rejected those who were faulty. So in a way Imam Bukhari was the first hadith rejector that was right because he didn't reject all of the hadiths he rejected those Hadiths that didn't have a good chain of narrations or had missing links of narrations.
When you have this many eyewitnesses so many narrators that have a sound chain of narrations rejecting the Hadith is simply illogical. Even the history of the world doesn't have this kind of chain of narration that the Hadith have. And believe me I know what I'm talking about because I am a historian so for example let's take the history of Russia we don't know anything about ancient Russia only that what was compiled later by later historians and this historians only proof of what they're writing about is someone who has said to have seen this and that without any chain of narration there is no chain of narration in that and still it is incorporated into the world history into the history of Russia because we don't have any other evidence.
Human history is full of this faulty chain of narrations let's take 300 Spartans versus Persians for example the first historian to write about this was Herodotus and he lived in first century BC and this battle happened in 480 BC so this historian comes 500 years later and tries to prove to us that this battle happened and that there were 300 Spartans fighting against 10,000 Persians. And we learn this literally in school in school we are taught this battle even though we don't have any chain of narration at all proving that this happened and this is all of humanity's history I'm a historian so I know that. So you hadith rejectors are literally ignorant because the hadith is the only historical proof that has been preserved this much with this much care
I pray to Allah SWT that he destroys those who have led you astray and so that he will guide you to the right path.
And excuse me if there will be any mistakes in the text because I'm not writing this I'm voice messaging this to the Google Kboard
@@muslix1147@muslix1147 my comments get constantly deleted and I can't even answer your ludicrous claims
Let me try by using edits so let's use logic on this matter
First of all let's begin with the belief that the prophet SAW never said anything on his own whim and that everything that he has said is what Allah has guided him to say
If you do not believe this then we won't have a discussion because this would mean that you are too far gone to even talk with you about this if you believe that the prophet saw said something that only came from his own mind and not from Allah
If you believe that the prophet Muhammad SAW said only that that Allah has revealed to him then we can have a discussion
First of all let's start with explaining what is the Hadith. Hadiths are the words and actions of the prophet SAW that have been recorded and narrated by the Sahaba. Suffice to say that if you are rejecting the companions of the prophet then you are one of the disbelievers, why? because it is written in the Quran that the companions of the prophets are those who will be the first to step into Jannah Surah 9 verse 100 [And the first forerunners [in the faith] among the Muhajireen and the Ansar and those who followed them with good conduct - Allah is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him, and He has prepared for them gardens beneath which rivers flow, wherein they will abide forever. That is the great attainment.]
As you can see here in this surah in this verse Allah tells us that the sahaba the companions of the prophet will be in The gardens of bliss.
So if you think that the companions of the prophet deviated or lied or twisted the words of the prophet SAW which would create the discord among the believers and that is enough for a Muslim to go to hell if you believe that the companions of the prophet did that then you are one of the disbelievers my friend.
You can refer to the Quran in which it talks about the sahaba the companions only in a positive way only in a good way there are many more verses I think you as Quranist should know that(if you did read the Quran I mean)
Now when we have proved that the Hadith are the words and actions of the prophet that are narrated by the companions of the prophet which will be the ones who inherit The gardens of bliss as Allah SWT told us in the Quran now is only one question left.
How do we prove that these chains of narrations are not faulty?
And this is the easiest question if you want to disprove the Hadith that you didn't like I don't know sahih bukhari, sahih Muslim you didn't like the Hadith and you said well I don't think the prophet would have said that.
You can easily prove that by studying the chain of narration if you will find out that one of the narrators is someone who is unknown to us we don't know anything about his life anything about his biography who he was did he have a good memory or not if you can prove in chain of narration that is the only one chain of narration to one Hadith that the chain is faulty because of that one missing link this Hadith will be called weak or rejected at all if you bring enough evidence. The thing is to me it seems as if Hadith rejectors are converts that were Christian, that's how I see you people because I think that you see the Hadith as some kind of holy text that no one can criticize, of course you can criticize it if you have the evidence but if you don't have the evidence then you better shut up. If you don't like the Hadith then please be my guest become a Hadith scientist and prove to us that all these chains of narrations are faulty but you cannot prove that because let me explain to you how the Hadith work
You have first link the prophet Muhammad SAW he is the first this is who we take the Hadith from then come his sahaba the companions who wrote down his actions and words then come the students of the companions and sometimes you can have 11 chains of narrations from one companion of the prophet.
And we have Hadith that have hundreds of chains of narrations coming from different narrators that were the companions of the prophet and had their students and their students had their students and their students had their students and so on and so on and so on and so on until the day that imam Bukhari compiled all of these hadiths that were sahih and rejected those who were faulty. So in a way Imam Bukhari was the first hadith rejector that was right because he didn't reject all of the hadiths he rejected those Hadiths that didn't have a good chain of narrations or had missing links of narrations.
When you have this many eyewitnesses so many narrators that have a sound chain of narrations rejecting the Hadith is simply illogical. Even the history of the world doesn't have this kind of chain of narration that the Hadith have. And believe me I know what I'm talking about because I am a historian so for example let's take the history of Russia we don't know anything about ancient Russia only that what was compiled later by later historians and this historians only proof of what they're writing about is someone who has said to have seen this and that without any chain of narration there is no chain of narration in that and still it is incorporated into the world history into the history of Russia because we don't have any other evidence.
Human history is full of this faulty chain of narrations let's take 300 Spartans versus Persians for example the first historian to write about this was Herodotus and he lived in first century BC and this battle happened in 480 BC so this historian comes 500 years later and tries to prove to us that this battle happened and that there were 300 Spartans fighting against 10,000 Persians. And we learn this literally in school in school we are taught this battle even though we don't have any chain of narration at all proving that this happened and this is all of humanity's history I'm a historian so I know that. So you hadith rejectors are literally ignorant because the hadith is the only historical proof that has been preserved this much with this much care
I pray to Allah SWT that he destroys those who have led you astray and so that he will guide you to the right path
This guy you are debating is so arrogant seeking only to win and not to listen, learn, nor reflect. Just insult, scoff, jeer at your intelligence, calling you mad. How he can think this is appropriate is difficult to understand. He looked away, ignored your points, ingored your response, yet you persisted spreading the right message. You are a true Muslim.
No he is not he is a kafir and so are you
You hadith rejector are more dangerous than ex Muslims because you spread fitnah and create confusion amongst the people. Let me ask you do you pray 5 times a day
😂 the dude rejects the sunnah and also the Qu'ran.. true muslim? Wallahi you guys are so lost.
@elafzal5866 The only Qur'an rejectors are Sunnis and Shias.
@@elafzal5866 49:11) Believers, let not a group (of men) scoff at another group, it may well be that the latter (at whom they scoff) are better than they; nor let a group of women scoff at another group, it may well be that the latter are better than they. And do not taunt one another, nor revile one another by nicknames. It is an evil thing to gain notoriety for ungodliness after belief. Those who do not repent are indeed the wrong-doers. It appears that he follows the Quran more closely than you do from our short time together
@@elafzal5866 31:18 And do not turn your nose up to people, nor walk pridefully upon the earth. Surely Allah does not like whoever is arrogant, boastful.
As someone who is agnostic and was a Christian I find it it interesting the Quran says don’t split in sects. And the Sunni/shia debate is to me pointless. At the same time I love how you say to worship God alone and Muslims should be Muslims. I see Christianity doing the same thing though, with Baptist, non-denominational, Pentecostal etc.
Quran asked people not to split and be sectors but Sunni/Shia followers of man made books have done that and ignored Allah word. Although Allah told them many verses not to do this and to just follow God's word and that is Quran. Also Allah asked the Jews and Christians to only follow Torah and Gospel and not man made books but they didn't listen.
People are easily mislead by Satan to follow other people instead of their Creator the Almighty.
@@kherona I was told to burn it if there’s something wrong with it and to rip it so people can’t alter it (people against Islam). Yet I thought it was all disrespectful.
Well the prophet companions were very sad about burning his sayings (Hadiths), however it was He who ordered them to burn these scriptures and only write Quran and maintain it, since it is the word of God. In addition he knew that many people would lie on him by referring all Hadith books to his sayings yet he didn't say what is in the books.
In summary no one was able to alter the Quran since its a Miracle, the way Arabs recite it made it easy for them to remember it. Also very early on the prophet companions had written copies of it distributed all across the regions (and we still have exact same copies to this date in many parts of the world dating back 1400 years without any letter changed).
We have many verses in Quran where Allah order us to follow his word only and not those books that are man made yet majority of Muslims today are following their forefathers teachings and ignoring the commandments of Allah the Almighty
@@xxcapxr3611
If you have any questions and want to ask me or have a discussion let me know, I'll gladly explain any questions you might have about Islam and its history. I also have fair bit of knowledge about Christianity as my best friend is Christian and we talk a lot about religious stuff.
Cheers
@@kherona I actually grew up Christian. Believed in the trinity etc. I had a lot things happened and left. I never truly considered myself atheist, due to the fact we had to come from somewhere, and be created. Also I believed since we can’t see God (the creator not his creations) that doesn’t negate the fact he is real. So my issue with Christianity was first Christmas and Easter being from pagan origin. Winter solstice/ saturnalia and Estore.Second never understood the son of God. Since I’m the Bible we are all children of God. Which would make us just like Jesus since he is Also the son of God. The eating bread and drinking blood representing Christ is mock cannibalism, and very pagan. Also, God can’t die do no way Jesus was God. Plus other things. What made me open my eyes to Islam and actually start slowly learning about it was everyone a Muslim would speak to me, he would be able to tell me about what they knew and show me in the Quran. Yet most Christian’s are blind faith people. They just listen and don’t know the Bible. I do think it’s cool how there’s a word (I forget the word) that means blood clot that describes a child in the womb when it starts to develop. Scientists now know that’s what happens when babies first develop. Also how it’s from the beginning to end. The Bible jumps around.
Do they think that God’s book is incomplete? That we need another book to complete it? Allah said if all the oceans were ink and all the trees were pens his words would NEVER run out. Alhamdulillah
The problem is that you guys are being overly simplistic. You say that you reject hadiths but you really don't. You accept hadiths from dictionaries, geography books, history books, etc. as tools to better understand the Quran.
And yet you reject hadiths where the Prophet(pbuh&f) explains the Quran, as Allah(swt) told us that he(pbuh&f) is to do in 16:44:
بِٱلْبَيِّنَٰتِ وَٱلزُّبُرِ ۗ وَأَنزَلْنَآ إِلَيْكَ ٱلذِّكْرَ لِتُبَيِّنَ لِلنَّاسِ مَا نُزِّلَ إِلَيْهِمْ وَلَعَلَّهُمْ يَتَفَكَّرُونَ
[16:44] Sahih International
[We sent them] with clear proofs and written ordinances. And We revealed to you the message that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them and that they might give thought.
So why would you take hadiths from dictionaries, history books, etc. and ignore hadiths where the Prophet(pbuh&f) is explaining some of this stuff?
Judge hadiths by the Quran as you would judge anything else by the Quran and look at the example of the most pious and best followers of the Quran.
@@user-ls8ks7kv8conly the Quran is sufficient as a guide book to jannah
The Quran is not incomplete. However, the deen is incomplete without hadeeth.
Bro U just make room for the hadith with that verse. If u were trying to downplay the importance of Hadith this verse is the worst pick ever. Sincerely
@@wakeurfansourlana ‘his words, HIS WORDS’
5:45 gives me goosebumps.. “God has sent down the best statement a HADEETH with consistent repetition, the skins of those who fear Allah shiver” the truth is sharper than any 2 edged sword he’s literally putting it in their face.. that’s why all they can do is interrupt and mock you can’t argue with truth can’t argue with God. Fear Allah..
How do you obey the Messenger peace be upon him as Allah commands us to in the Qu'ran?
@@elafzal5866by following the Quran. The prophet himself says to not follow anything but the Quran IN THE QURAN (Surah An'am, 114)
@Cross_Chain that is completely false??? He said that the once that will be aided by the prophet (Pbuh) in the day of judgment are the once that follow the SUNNAH, his sunnah, please research
Please read the Quran with care @@phoazmurais4991
the quran doesnt contain the prophet peace be upon him his words, you quranists dont even know that hahahahaa@@7anif
Now you're scared to go back to speakers corner, you have no arguments 😮
Yes he is so scared of mushrik intellect. WHERE IS MECCA WHERE IS MECCA
Hahahaha
@@Quran_Alone_Dawahand why couldn’t your master answer the question???🤣🤣
@ChickenTenders388 Only Allah is my master, unlike Sunnis who take their scholars as masters. The question was fallacious and nonsensical, and the brother explained why. May Allah open your heart to Islam
Anyone who calls another a kafar just because he rejects the hadiths is suspect. This is the mentality of an extremist.
Actually most Sunnis believe this
The same people who passed on the Quran passed on the Hadiths too. If you don’t believe in Hadiths how would you know how to pray?
Rejecting hadith is rejecting a part of the Quran, which is disbelief so how can you say that?
@@palmzombie3553 Your statement is literally a statement of k uffr
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah No it isn’t
Shamsi was right. Bring it back to Allah and his Messenger. Strong ayah and evidence for the quran and sunnah
Allah and his messenger = the Quran. The messenger speaks when’s God tells him say Mohammed. We don’t need Hadith the Quran tells us everything; or is Allahs word not enough? Fear Allah
@@davidela9022 by quran and hadith.
@@billyragnar2433 quran is word of God as the quran says itself. So that is not correct what your saying. You are contradicting the quran now... SMH
@@ibotijn 7:35-36 4:13-14 are very clear when they say THE MESSENGERS lead us ONLY thru ALLAHS VERSES so if we obey Allah it is impossible for us to disobey the messenger. The Book of Allah was the messenge that the messenger sent us to obey. Next time you pray ask God if what I’m saying is true to please guide you that you want to know the truth. Promise me you’ll do that atleast brother. As Muslims we know the devil entered every religion and their books which had the same message and Allah never said he will preserve the hadeeths and he’s clear when he says this is the best hadeeth with examples and explanations for everything. God never gave authority to the Sahaba or hadeeths to be attributed to him so that is shirk brother.
@@billyragnar2433 You are actually a contradiction. Then why did Allah Specifically mention Refer BACK TO Allah and HIS MESSENGER!!
You say Allah reveals everything. Yes that is true. But the verse says: "and his messenger"
We know that All of it comes from Allah so why add "and messenger" So that he i.e. the messenger can explain the Quran, such as tafsir.
Or when Allah says that we establish prayer and zakat. How do we do it???
There we have the Sahih Hadith the Messenger of Allah's words.
It is like when you want to get your license you have two examens one theoretical and then you have a practical.
if you still disblieve then i have nothing to say unto you because you are deaf, dumb and blind. No benefit will there be for you not even common sense or logic.
He really claimed he decimated the Sunni....
Subhanallah, it wasn't until Shamsi brought up ayah (4:59) and you ignored the 2nd half of the ayah that I realised the pure contradiction of Quranists.
To deny the credibility of the Prophet's teachings outside of the Quran, even when Allah is telling you to follow him.. I'm speechless... brother, fear Allah and stop misguiding the people
Qur'an is complete and certainly enough. The phrophet only teaching is the Qur'an which is the message (teaching) from God. I wish you understand this simple fact..
How do you know that what’s written in the Hadith are his teachings?
So now explain verses 45:6, 7:185, 77:50 which all ask "which hadith will you follow after the Quran?" following hadiths is literally going against the Quran. The Book of Hadiths are there as a test from Allah to see if we would fall for unintentional worship. And you blind faithed idiots are falling for it. May Allah destroy those who corrupt the religion.
(And when God alone is mentioned, hearts are disgusted)
Yes Allah alone is mentioned.
Hadith rejectors are rejector of the deen of Allah
“Obey Allah and obey the messenger”
@@LearnFromTheLightThe sentence structure 'Allah and the messenger' is found throughout the Quran. Sunnis claim that since the word 'and' is used, that obeying Allah is separate from obeying the messenger. Nothing could be further from the truth. 'And' is not always used to separate two concepts but can also be used to link them. This is called a hendiadys. We use this all the time in day to day life, but the Sunni mushrikeen do not understand this in the Quran. For example, if your teacher says 'Obey me and do your homework', would you finish your homework and then go back to your teacher and say 'How do I obey you?' Of course not. You obey the teacher by doing the homework. You obey Allah by obeying the messenger.
Here is an ayah that demonstrates this:
"And [it is] an announcement from Allah and His Messenger to the people on the day of the greater pilgrimage that Allah is disassociated from the disbelievers, and [so is] His Messenger. So if you repent, that is best for you; but if you turn away - then know that you will not cause failure to Allah. And give tidings to those who disbelieve of a painful punishment." 9:3
Does this mean that because 'and' is used, that Allah makes the announcement together with his messenger? No, Astaghfirullah, Allah makes the announcement and tells us *through* his messenger. Allah speaks *through* his messenger. We obey Allah *through* his messenger. That's why Allah says:
"He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah ; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian." 4:80
Obey Allah are the direct verses and obey the messenger are the indirect verses (verses that start with say). You sectarians never understand.
@@Ox1326 Where is Qul(say) in these verses.
“We sent no Messenger, but to be obeyed by Allah’s Leave” [an-Nisa’ 4:64] “He who obeys the Messenger thereby obeys Allah” [an-Nisa’ 4:80]
“But no, by your Lord, they can have no Faith, until they make you (O Muhammad (s.a.w)) judge in all disputes between them, and find in themselves no resistance against your decisions, and accept (them) with full submission” [an-Nisa’ 4:65].
Imagine having a normal conversation where actually people can understand what is going on and take benefit.
People dont understand because they dont know or they dont want to
Exactly
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example. And these careless scholars hide it.
@@NotrandomlikeyouWhat are you gonna tell by this hadith, could explain?
@@peaceful_1_warrior This hadith tells muslims can keep dogs and eat what it brings. Can you tell this to your muslim friends.
Shamsi is 100% right while the long beard guy have no clue about islam.
If you really belive in quran as you claim you will not be here saying "i only belive in quran".
Read the quran and repent before you die
'The book of Allah is not enough, you must follow all these other sources too.' May Allah guide the Sunni mushriqeen to Islam.
@@mohamedadan3848 the Quran says to obey the messenger not the prophet...Messenger obvously derives from Message which is itself the Quran, I dont understand why you need to make a distinction between Messenger and God regarding obedience to what they are telling you to do, its the same thing
@@mohamedadan3848 no contradiction at all... our religion isn't contingent on Imam Bukhari/Imam Muslim, etc. it can't be. if they died before publishing their books, then what? would all billions of muslims in he past 1400 years be astray and misguided because 2 muslims from Uzbekistan and Persia who lived 200 years after the Prophet (saw) died before their books (many hadiths in them are weak according to many scholars, including Sheikh Albaani) were published?
also, how did the muslims before Bukhaari/Muslim/Ibn Majah, etc manage to get on w/ their life before these books were compiled? ever thought about that? was Islam not practiced after Prophethood until Sahih Bukhaari was published?
Lol, who has the most chances of going to hell. Those who follow everything the Hadiths say about the prophet and traditional Islam or those who reject the Hadiths and try to follow Islam alone by the Quran 😂🤦♂️
Surah 4:80 “Whoever obeys the Messenger is obeying God. And whoever turns away-We did not send you as a watcher over them”.
Mashallah brother
This surah is referring to the time of the people who were listening to the prophet speaking to them, not after his death.
@@TheAdrianSmithso after his death we don't kbey anything the prophet s.a.w said and follow only quran
@@beastfootball1782Muhammad followed the Quran. Why don’t you?
So if u reject the hadiths then tell me how u pray?
The guy in white never quoted any verse from the Quran as though "it is something that hurts him". To me it's a clear sign that he is a mushrik. Another thing is that the guy in black is virtually fighting to glorify Allah alone, while the guy in white wants to add a creation in glorification. And the last thing is that to many people, their minds can be compared to a "Write Once Read Many Times" (WORM media), meaning that if something is inscribed into the mind then it is forever (for majority) unless Allah Wills Otherwise. In other words, for the majority of people "It is easy to learn new things, but almost impossible to UNLEARN what was learned previously" According to,
Quran 06:116 "And if you obey most of those in the Earth, they will mislead you from the way of Allah and they follow nothing but assumption and they do nothing but guessing."
So if you find yourself on the path of the majority then you know already what you are and what you are following.
This is why hadith followers are and I cut ties with all my hadith Muslim friends and I'm more at peace
have yu ever thought of it more logically?the quran says to search for the truth and question things but yu believe something after seeing one vid?i cant with yu people sigh...
@@xXx.......how do you pray your shalah as it's never mentioned the methods in the Quranul Karim?
Some parts maybe
@@GuardianKnight07
Why do you have to perform rituals like the way you do for Salah. Prayers is a connected between you and him.
@@revelation333 where in the quran did it say this?
You were the only person with a brain in that crowd. Do not let them bring you down; in the end, it is truth that prevails.
One religion one book one god
Watch his his interview with the muslim lantern
`Say [O Prophet], "If you love Allah, so follow me. [If you does so, then] Allah will love you and will forgive for you your sins. And Allah is The Most-Forgiving, Most-Merciful."`
[Quran 3:31]
Here, Allah commands us to follow our Prophet. How are we going follow him if we reject hadiths? Hadith contains the life of the prophet, his saying and his actions. If we really want to follow him, then we have to abide by the Quran and the authentic hadiths.
Also, you cannot really and truly follow the glorious Quran without following the Prophet, as Allah explicitly commands us to obey Him and the Prophet in so many āyāt (you would have knew this of you actually read the Quran). So my question to you is that: How are you going to obey the Prophet and follow him if you reject the hadiths, which is filled with Prophet's teachings?
@@Habush2.0Yes, please show us the full unedited interview :)
What was Mohamed follow him self ?
If you don't follow the Hadith, then how do you know how to pray?
Do you know what salat means?
salat is actually not prayer. unfortunately much misconception from erroneous limited translation.
it is an act of submission to the Supreme Creator Allah and is expressed in a specific and well defined physical act embodying the spirit
Why does Shamsi try to avoid him, screa, say you’re wasting my time and on top of that have the audacity to call him a kafir when it’s very dangerous to claim a muslim is one
I don't agree with sunnis and shias because they're practically morons but I still consider them family as scripture dictates.
Shamsi asked a sincere question. If the pilgrimage in Islam is to Mecca. Where is Mecca described in the Quran as a place of pilgrimage?
since when is that b*stard p*g shamsi sincere ? that b*stards first priority is the so called sunnah that is passed down by his forefathers falsely in the name of prophet mohammed, NOT the sunnah of Allah or the actual sunnah of Prophet Mohammed(both of which are the same, coz prophet only followed Allahs sunnah)
Thats like saying what is Ramadan? Obvious words.
This is maruf, common knowledge. Does Allah tell us what a pig is in the Qur'an when he made eating them haram?
Like wise one can say since istinja isn’t mentioned in the Quran, therefore one shouldn’t do so!? Allah only speaks that which is necessary in the Quran. It isn’t befitting for the king of this universe to teach mankind step by step what istinjah is, sexual relations with a spouse, how to properly gut an animal and even basic geography. If he mentioned all this 1)the Quran would be a gigantic book that no one would be capable of memorizing and passing onto the next generation2)there would be no reason to send down messengers who’s entire purpose were to clarify what Allah and his words are commanding
@@HehLulthats extremely false allah is extremely capable of providing us with a step by step detail even if the book was triple the size of the quran it would be able to be written and passed down effortlessly so that makes no sense
Imagine if Christians had another book next to the Bible that was not divinely inspired and then they used that book to supersede the Bible in decisions. Insanity.
You know that the bible is constructed of a lot of different books right ? xD
@@onizuka3741
I am aware. However it's simply not the same.
@@OrdoMallius It’s even worse because the bible you can compare it to weak Hadith it doesnt even come close to the Sahih Hadith and never to the Quran. The bible is constructed of different books and only agreed upon by the church fathers. There are many more gospels that are not added in the current KJV or NIV while other christian sects do accept for example the gospel of Marry etc. So its far worse
@@onizuka3741
Buddy. There are over 20 000 maunscripts to compare for credibility unlike your Quran that has 6 copies from 200 years after Muhammad. Bible is the most preserved book in history. You don't even come close.
@@OrdoMallius 20k manuscripts dont mean shi, your oldest manuscript are the dead sea scrolls. Which is idk how many years after mozes. Our manuscript the birmingham manuscript is from the time of the prophet. And our first form of preservation is oral. We have hundreeds of millions of people memorizing the quran from the time of the prophet till now.
Stubborn and crazy Islam rejector, may Allah guide the rejectors of our beloved Messenger of Allah, peace and blessing upon Him
Where did you learn to pray from
These people are silly. They only cause fitna. They’re almost as bad as the shias. How can they call themselves Sunnis if they don’t follow the sunnah. We follow the example of the prophet s.a.w and those who were around him and saw what he did because he was the best example. How can you follow him if you reject the sunnah? If someone told me they reject the example of the prophet s.a.w i think it makes them straight up disbelievers. They’re rejecting his teachings. They don’t think we should be like him. It’s a form of kufr
the Quran, what else is needed? Allah gave us the Quran fully explained and clear.
@@Modelta cool where did you learn about how to pray and how many prayers etc that’s not mentioned in the Qurān
@@Modelta it just shows that so-called "quranists" didn't even read the Qur'an properly lol. You don't even know what you're talking about.
@@amg863 i do, you havent read or remembered, though i dont reject hadith
the Quran is insufficient for the sectarians. And when you come with the clear verses of the Quran they will immediately change the subject and ask how do you pray? or in this case where's Mecca? Recently a sunni asked me: what are the names of the Muhajirin and Ansar? LOL
So the Messenger of Allah was just a postman who delivered the message and thats it? Allah said in the Qu'ran, obey Allah AND the Messenger. How do you obey the prophet of Allah peace be upon him? Wake up.
And you will never answer how you pray cause you don't have an answer and neither this kafir you are following.
@@elafzal5866 you need to wake up from your deep sleep and re-learn true islam.
Bro I want to cry for you !! How he turned you to a hater of the prophet whilst you are like the prophet asking not to separate one and others .. may Allah bless you Allah was with you the whole time... Don't forget all the prophets faced what you were facing that day ...
Indded, these zindiqs would have tried to k ill the prophet if they met him.
You reject 99% of the authenticate existence of the prophet pbuh, even attested to by nonmuslim historian and academics. How siIIy these Hadith rejectors are
@@sirdook2761 I don’t even get what ur saying. You are a sunni yet don’t know any arguments against these siIIy Hadith rejectors? Why u asking me to debate and debunk, go Iearn from the Ulama. Also are u saying we should be tolerant towards kufr, Something Allah condemns? Are you more tolerant then Allah. This is the siIIy Hadith rejector k’fir Iogic, not a Muslims
nobody has to believe in what so called scholars come up with. Scholarship is process of continuous change and research.@@LearnFromTheLight
@@LearnFromTheLightwhy is there a hadith where muhammad says dont write anything from me that isnt quran?😂😂😂😂
"Is Hadith telling me where Mecca is?" 😂
How do you know how to pray then?
I wanna see how this man prays…….
i think for praying they follow hadith.
@@harriskhan7671 by the he is Hadith rejector…..
@@Sulimen-nt7tc yes jazakAllahhukhairan.
@@harriskhan7671 No they don't follow hadiths for praying. They just do what everybody else has been doing 5 times a day for 1400 years
No hadiths needed - every Muslim prays the same without hadiths.
So now answer me this: Why would the way people pray get lost if everybody does it the way the prophet did it? Everybody did the same thing 5 times a day everyday for their entire lives... so... in what way is it possible to forget how to do something like this that all people in the world do thesame way? I don't understand. Please explain to me what you mean
@@marioluigi9599exactly they keep saying that like people didnt start praying until hadiths came along😂😂
Wooow, Shamsi destroyed you, thanks for the subtitles so I could see your destruction 😂😂😂
Do you really believe that the Prophet marry a 7 years old girl according to the satanic hadith?
'WHERE IS MECCA WHERE IS MECCA' 🤣
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah whereis Rome whereis Rome. Lol
Where is Mecca = Shamsi destroyed you?
Are you dumb?
People who don't obey prophets, I want them to read ayat of Surah Nisa 59 and Surah Anfal 20.
The fact that he uploaded this thinking he won lol. How embarrassing.
He did win he keeps on changing subjects plus he answered shamsi saying modern day Saudi and just because Quran alone Muslims doing take hadith as a source of law doesn't mean they are kafir
@@mandatedmarrow7261Anyone who take hadith as a source and reject the verses of the Quran that prophet was only a messenger to deliver the message is a kafir.
Thanks for finally exposing yourself that you are a hadith rejector. Will avoid you from now.
May Allah reward brother Muhammad for defending the honour of the prophet against the lies of Bukhari, and warns people that the ahsan al hadith, the holy Quran, is sufficient.
thank you so much! peace be upon you, we dont need people like you here.
How do you perform Salah? Can you upload a video of that
Salah wasn’t written in hadiths the prophet preformed it infront of thousands of people and it was passed down same as wudhu and hajj
@Ikyt337 so you are using a source other than Quran? I.e a chain of learned actions rather than words?
Hadith rejectors don't agree amongst themselves, many of them say there are only 3 daily prayers rather than 5 and they all offer it differently.
@@f.b250 I agree with you quranists have many different beliefs when it comes to prayers and that’s a big problem. But how the prayers were passed one were very different from the hadiths. Hadiths came 200 years after the prophet died and they were a sense of culture rather than religion. And we can’t even confirm if they were true or not.
@@Ikyt337It is written in ahadeeth what are you on about.
@@elafzal5866 there is not a single Hadith that tells you how to pray
Those who reject the hadith completely with no reason for their being fake rejected the 100s of verses in Quran like 3:31-32 ,47-33 where Allah orders to obey and follow the Messenger too .the above 47:33 calls them as disbelievers too. Even if you reject one verse of Qur'an is disbelief.
Where in the quran does it say hadith will be protected by god?
The prophet peace be upon him recited the Quran verbally to sahaba just like he did with Hadith (he spoken) so if quranis reject Sunnah they should reject Quran as well cause Allah subhano WA taala did not talk to us humans directly, so both of em were recited by prophet.
Hope that helps insha'allah (excuse my English)
Such was the Sunna of God for those who passed on before. You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God. 33:62
2- The only sunna decreed for prophet Muhammad was the Sunna of God.
No blame falls upon the prophet concerning what God has decreed for him; the Sunna of God, as was decreed for those who passed away before. God's command is a pre-ordained decree. 33:38
3- No one is to divert from the Sunna of God
You will find that there is no substitute for the Sunna of God, and you will find that there is no diversion from the Sunna of God. 35:43
Shamsi smashed you.... 😂😂
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? (45:6)
Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail. (6:114)
Then in what statement after it (the Qur’an) will they believe? (77:50)
Allah has sent down the best statement (ahsan hadith): a consistent Book wherein is reiteration.(39:23)
And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled / completed in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing. (6:115)
There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was the Qur’an a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of all things and guidance and mercy for a people who believe. (12:111)
Alif, Lam, Ra. [This is] a Book whose verses are perfected and then presented in detailfrom [one who is] Wise and Acquainted. (11:1)
And [mention] the Day when We will resurrect among every nation a witness over them from themselves. And We will bring you, [O Muhammad], as a witness over your nation. And We have sent down to you the Book as clarification for all things and as guidance and mercy and good tidings for the Muslims. (16:89)
And they do not come to you with an argument except that We bring you the truth and the best explanation (ahsan tafsir). (25:33)
And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed - then it is they who are the disbelievers (kafirun). (5:44)
And of the people is he who buys the idle / frivolous tales (lahw al-hadith) to mislead [others] from the way of God without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. (31:6)
My Lord, make me an establisher of prayer, and [many] from my descendants. Our Lord, and accept my supplication. (14:40)
And We made them leaders guiding by Our command. And We inspired to them the doing of good deeds, establishment of prayer, and giving of zakah; and they were worshippers of Us. (21:73)
Then We revealed to you, [O Muhammad], to follow the religion of Abraham, inclining toward truth; and he was not of those who associate with Allah. (16:123)
I like when they debate but still call each other akhi and habibi :)
Shamsi has no right or authority to call the other guy kafir when he believes in Allah alone and not excepting the abbasi stories. Because shamsi has no knowledge , he thinks rasool only means the prophet Mohammed, but in that particular verse rasool means the quraan because the Mohammed (pbuh) his not with us but the QURAAN is with us and complete has everything
I converted to Islam from Christianity but I don't understand what the basis is for accepting content of hadiths from people as religious laws. I don't know how many times I've heard the same talking points yapped at me, then when I try to answer sincerely and explain my concerns it falls on deaf ears.
It's not even that all anti-hadith arguments make sense, but they're better than hearing nonsense like "Where is Mecca in the Qur'an" yelled at you by people who lack the ability to understand where someone else is coming from, let alone explain and promote their own position.
welcome to islam The God willing.. yah don’t fall trap to hadith and sunnis or shias etc the truth is in the Quran :) and only The God gives guidance so seek it from Him only.. peace upon you The God willing 🙏 🤲 😊
Wallahi this heretic religion (hadith rejectors )
Is developed in the west .
And I ask Allah to guide them or May Allah silence them forever before they spread their misguidence more .
Learn knowledge habibi
Not read it all but believe me reject it
Qur’an and hadeeth go together don't listen to these ignorant people
Quran 2:125 "And take, [O believers], from the standing place of Abraham a place of prayer". Which is located in Mecca. The standing position would not be anywhere else but Mecca.
Quran 2:269 "He gives wisdom to whom He wills, and whoever has been given wisdom has certainly been given much good. And none will remember except those of understanding." Alhamdulilah.
The Quran is perfectly explained and clear 🙏🏼
Where in Quran Allah says you have to keep beard??
maybe he likes it fool
They dare to call a Quran follower a non Muslim. Just look at how arrogant they are, they think they are perfection and also St seem as they believe they are perfection aka. God Allah
yeah cos quran says follow god and prophet, but they only follow God and not prophet. Therefore they are wrong lol
It's pretty simple logic, which part you dont understand?
@@marioluigi9599no it’s not logical at all, because who did the prophet follow = Allah’s revelations. Don’t fool yourself, the prophet cannot make laws himself
@@Koko70816 Yeah he followed Quran and what was God put in his heart. And all the things Jibreel told him when he asked him questions. These things are not all in the Quran. Like for example when they went to heaven together, of course they were talking to each other and Jibreel was explaining things to him. All these conversations, none of it is in the Quran. So some things were only revealed to the Prophet in that way
@@Koko70816 a'd what does the quran say? follow the prophet. Or else ur a kafir. End
CATEGORICAL DENIAL BY THE QURAN FOR THE REQUIREMENT OF ISLAMIC SECONDARY SOURCES
Much to the contrary, the Quran is replete with verses which categorically deny the requirement of any other source for religious guidance.
045:006
"These are the verses of God that We recite to you with truth. Then in what 'Hadith' (statement / narrative) after God and His 'Ayat' (verses) will they believe?"
Now read Qalam 44. Allah saying if u reject 'hadith' he will destroy you. Thank you now shut up
which qira'a of the quran do you read? Do you read maaaliki yawm ideen or maliki yawm iddeen?
That man on a white robe is so arrogant
He behaved such many times and these are the Muslims who spoils Islam and the cause is hadith. Hadith by Satan Bukhari created to split Muslims organise by Zoroastrians jews
How do you know how pray or how much zakat to give or how to perform haj without Hadith. You can’t reject all Hadith brother
all of that is in the quran. How do you turn to hadith when you have yet to even read the words of Allah? These days people preach and know HADITH (the words of man) more than the Quran itself. Your comment is evidence of this.
If it’s not in the Quran, then it’s not part of Islam.
@@madj7120 okay if what you say is true then please answer my question, what verses show us how to pray and what to say in prayer? What verses tell us how much zakat to pay? What verses show us how perform haj ?
@@user-kl1pl2cg1r they don’t know you have to pay 2.5% of your salary for zakat lmao
@@pointofview5921 What if it's really the words of the prophet...
I've been told that Quran is the Guidance to Life
and the Hadith is believed to be our beloved prophet pbuh biography.
on What's the Do's and Dont's.
Sure you can reject it or accept it.
But Allah knows best, if it's the words of the prophet or not. May Allah guide us.
9 mins the dude couldn't answer where mecca is in the Quran
But like what does that refute or prove? It's a pointless question...
@@dedopest3305It prove that we should go back to Allah and Rasulullah
@@discharm210To learn basic geographical knowledge?
@@discharm210You do not follow Allah'sword by following hadith. Only kafirs follow hadith
A Book (Quran) has been brought down to you, so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers. Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember! 7:2-3
Those who rejected prophet are not Muslim.
Yo they literally worship Prophet Muhammad. Wow
Of course they do lol Quran is the way
Quran doesnt mention Muhammad in shahada, doesnt say Muhammad will be like thier lawyer on judgment day & doesnt mention fake story of Muhammad asking for prayers to go from 50 to 5.
We don't worship prophet Muhammad s.a.w
But merely follow his sunnah
@@wazirakbarkhan.wardag.. through his word? or the word of the authors of the shia/sunni texts? May Allah guide us all.
@@e-leven7407 through his words and actions
Bro, The Qur'an is the words of Allah, if we recite one letter of it Allah will reward us 10 goodness, it is the holiest book in the world, it is recited in Sholah, BUT it is not the only guidance in Islam. Hadiths, which are the records of The Prophet's words, actions, and traits (shollallaahu'alayhiwasallam) are Islam's second guidance after Al-Qur'an Al-Karim. Hadiths explain Al-Qur'an. May Allah bless us Muslims with unity and solidarity
Haddith itself most of the time needed to be interpreted...
Instead of wasting time interpreting hadiths why not read and understand the Quran.
Next time please tell those who recite the prayer (Talqin) for those who have passed away to say that his/her reference are Quran + hadith by a, b, c d etc... Do not be hypocrites. Dont tell me the dead too need to lie to Allah!
thats the thing, Quran tells you to pray and hadiths tell how to pray. without Hadith you can't pray how prophet prayed khalas@@tittosayang9886
@@tittosayang9886Bro, I’d rather follow the majority of Muslims who actually read Hadith. Thank you.
@@MrBanana2000following majority is dangerous read Quran 6:116.
@@MrBanana2000 We are totally aware of what they say, and you are not to be a tyrant over them. So remind with the Quran those who fear My promise. [50:45]
o
Quran 16.44,another deliberately abused verse to claim muhammad was here to "explain " the Quran , it Does NOT mean that.
Where is mecca? Lol lol lol 😢😂😅
The Quran says very simply: You must obey Allah's orders AND the orders of his messenger. Allah's orders are in the Quran. And the Prophet's orders, where are they in the Quran? Nowhere. They are within the hadith. By your logic Muhammad, we do not even need Tafsir because Tafsir is not Quran but just interpretations. By your logic, a man can beat his wife mercilessly for disobeying him but, we know this to not be the case. Why? Because in the Tafsir Ibn Abbas it is clarified that you are to strike you wife in a "mild and unexaggerated manner". Why is the Tafsir Ibn Abbas so important - even more so than that of Ibn Kathir? Because Ibn Abbas was given explicit and premiere authority to interpret the Quran by the Prophet Muhammad pbuh himself.
All good until Muslim 3004 explains that ur a dumbo
Dude was trying to avoid a simple question from shamsi lol
Sunnis can't see points of an issue and connection so when you make a relevant point they have no understanding that your answering their question.
The where is Mecca question? He answered it well imo God doesn't explain things we know as humans, such as what a tree is.
Did god explain to you what a pig is in the quran? No. So how do you know what a pig is so that you may avoid eating it? Cus its a known fact that doesnt need explanation. Just like where mecca is doesnt need explanation. Its common sense and a known fact. To even ask where is mecca is a stupid question.
@@Biekoeno but the Hadith does in detail
@@Player_Zeesh give me one hadith that explains in detail what a pig is and how we can identify it.
This Shamsi can be insufferable pfft, he needs to learn to listen
How do you pray?
I have utmost respect for you and I hope to learn arabic so I can be a force for truth and strive in the same way that you do. These munafiq must be exposed by knowledgeable, respected and good mannered people.
I have enough conviction, but every time I argue they attack me for not being a native arabic speaker and it is very annoying.
you are a revert so you dont know even quran how can you talk when you dont even know basic arabic its basic logic
Shut up zindeeq
رَبَّنَا وَٱبْعَثْ فِيهِمْ رَسُولًا مِّنْهُمْ يَتْلُوا۟ عَلَيْهِمْ ءَايَـٰتِكَ وَيُعَلِّمُهُمُ ٱلْكِتَـٰبَ وَٱلْحِكْمَةَ وَيُزَكِّيهِمْ إِنَّكَ أَنتَ ٱلْعَزِيزُ ٱلْحَكِيمُ
“Our Lord: raise Thou up among them a messenger from among them who will recite to them Thy proofs, and teach them the Writ and wisdom, and increase them in purity; Thou art the Exalted in Might, the Wise.”
(2:129)
Sunni: this verse is referring to the Quran and Sunnah (Hadith)
Those who follow the Quran: no, it's referring to the Quran
وَٱلْقُرْءَانِ ٱلْحَكِيمِ
By the wise Qur’an!
(36:2)
Hakeem means wise and is an adjective for the Quran as it contains Wisdom.
Hikma is a noun meaning Wisdom and its referring to the Quran as the Quran is (Hakeem) Wise and contains Wisdom.
The majority embraced sectarianism, not Islam.
These are God's revelations (Quran) that We recite to you with truth, so in which hadith other than God and His revelations (Quran) do they believe? 45:6
Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in? 7:185
So in which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe? 77:50
Or do you have some book in which you are studying? 68:37
In 68:37 God is mocking those who have other books besides the Quran which they follow.
And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. 6:155
If Quranism has any daleel to deny the Ahadeeth, where were the first Quranists during the time of the prophet (SAW) and the time of the Tabieen?
Prophet Muhammad was the first Quranee.
Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali didn't compile hadeeth but wear working hard to compile and save the Quran.
Please bro...
@@MuhammadfromGOD then what of the instances where they had mentioned the words of Mohammed (SAW), to other Sahabis, and if the sahaba or ahlul bayt knew that the Quran was all they needed, and not the word of Mohammed, why didn’t they ensure that future generations of Tabieen would also understand the negative impact of Hadith,
And if so, is the word of the prophet (SAW) not important enough to be noted down as advice and knowledge of the man who had almost single handedly returned Islam to the world?
And for the scholars who have done this wrong (according to you) which is the writing down or presumed writing down of the prophets word, where were the scholars who should’ve gone against them, it’s not like a fundamental part of Islam simply ceases to be taught to the majority of people. Allah surely helps the righteous and pious especially in preserving not just the Quran, but the ideals as well, so where are these scholars then?
I simply ask respectfully for evidence. I am curious about the Quranist narrative and am speaking as a seeker of knowledge.
@@YousifYuri The only word that the Prophet gave was Allah's, not his own, and anything he said personal, they weren't allowed to write that down because they would've mixed it up with the Quran, also what instances did the sahabah mention the words of Muhammad (SAW) to other sahabis, where's the evidence for this? there's no evidence for these instances, you are just assuming such instances ever happened, fictitious instances that hold no basis.
@@flyinglegion5697 Then is it strange that Allah orders us in the Quran to obey the prophet?
@@flyinglegion5697 When the prophet (SAW) told his companions to eat chicken, Abu Musa al-Ashari had followed it and even told people alongside fellow Shabi's who had come to his house as company (and was presented with a plate of chicken) "Come on, eat from it, for I have seen Allah's messenger (SAW) eating from it (i.e Chicken)"
He must feel very accomplished calling you an infidel Astaghfirullah
Hadith rejectors are out here still tying string to their thighs to know when to fast 😢
yeah you're sooo funny. The whole world is laughing...
....not
I wish i was joking
@@golden12078 Sorry I don't know what you're talking about. But anyway, you keep on putting your faith in Prophet Bukhari and Muslim
What does Allah say in the Quran about when to start your fast?
Or how to pray?
@@golden12078 Plenty. Try reading it, instead of just following whatever scholars say. You listen to scholars as tour intermediaries; yet you never read God's book cover to cover
It’s crazy most Muslims worships prophet muhammed . Shamsi said “ he thinks the prophet as a mailman”
Uh that’s what the shahada says too. Muhammed is the messenger of Allah
We don’t worship, we obey, there’s a difference
@@NasheedsForYouuuwhat does the word ‘ obey’ mean?
@@TheAdrianSmith to follow orders/ commands
@@NasheedsForYouuu in old English the word obey comes from latin word ‘ obedio’ which originally means to listen, to harken . In the new English the additional meaning was concocted so today it can also mean carry out orders. so people who lived when Muhammad was revealing the verse of the Quran listened, but majority of them did not believe and thus did not follow the message. So , you see , obey did not mean follow back then. the people at the time of the Muhammad prophetic period who obeyed , believed and followed Muhammad became muslims.After Muhammad died those who read the Quran and obeyed God and followed his commands in the Quran became muslims as well. Same thing happens today.
You can’t even answer a simple question about the location of Mecca.
Try Google Maps. Quran/Hadith not needed for that one
@@marioluigi9599 Where is Mecca mentioned in Quran?!
@@bhsecurity 48:24
why you asking?
How many rakat in maghrib from the Quran, ya akhi?
Someone please explain 77:50
The Quran not only appeals to reason, but it nourishes and develops it. Allah says that We have made the Quran unambiguous (2:2; 4:82) and absolutely clear (16:89) showing the truth, so that humans can understand it by using their intellect; so that they can use reason and logic to understand it (47:24). This will develop and nourish their intellectual abilities. The Quran addresses realities of life; it provides real solutions to real problems of life facing humanity (16:64). Its teaching is a guiding light (5:15) of truth and therefore it illuminates the path of humanity (6:122). This is the essence and reality of the Quran. When people asked the Prophet (PBUH) for miracle he said the Quran itself is the miracle that I am presenting to you (17:88; 2:23-24)
Masha Allah
Why do you quote half of the ayah:
This is the full ayah
هُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَنزَلَ عَلَيْكَ ٱلْكِتَٰبَ مِنْهُ ءَايَٰتٌ مُّحْكَمَٰتٌ هُنَّ أُمُّ ٱلْكِتَٰبِ وَأُخَرُ مُتَشَٰبِهَٰتٌۖ فَأَمَّا ٱلَّذِينَ فِى قُلُوبِهِمْ زَيْغٌ فَيَتَّبِعُونَ مَا تَشَٰبَهَ مِنْهُ ٱبْتِغَآءَ ٱلْفِتْنَةِ وَٱبْتِغَآءَ تَأْوِيلِهِۦۗ وَمَا يَعْلَمُ تَأْوِيلَهُۥٓ إِلَّا ٱللَّهُۗ وَٱلرَّٰسِخُونَ فِى ٱلْعِلْمِ يَقُولُونَ ءَامَنَّا بِهِۦ كُلٌّ مِّنْ عِندِ رَبِّنَاۗ وَمَا يَذَّكَّرُ إِلَّآ أُو۟لُوا۟ ٱلْأَلْبَٰبِ
English - Sahih International
It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.[1] As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding,
English - Tafsir Ibn Kathir
This is a very important part.
May Allah bless you all
@@ibotijn yes ..nothing changed ..the quran is from God hadith is from men ..and is a cult ( too many rules ) Allah guides who he wills ..we shall know who was guided amongst us on judgement day
@@ASEH-yx6nh a lot changes if you understand the ayah
Their are ayah unambigous and ayah open for interpretation. So you need scholars as the ayah also says. The quran itselfs and all the campanions say you need the sunnah and the priphet himself said it to. Alhamdoulillah is perfect and the sources are preserved.
the sunni you argued with didnt respect the sanctity of the Quran. pls argue with a better person
We can all see that the Sunni sheikh in the video was deaf dumb and blind, a hypocrite, if he continues like this for the rest of his life he's gonna find himself in hell
And the shia the sunni argued didn't respect the hadiths he should argue with a better person
Tell me, why is jaywalking haraam from Quran - Great brother shamsi 😂
Shamsi shows his true nature to his own people being extremely rude. To others he will act like he has intellect.
The salaf used to je harsh with ahlul bidah
@@Abu-qittNO
Stop lying. Yoyr false belief is against Quran verses where believers are described as gentle to one another
@@asr2009 ok but innovation is worse then sin, and did the salaf contradict the Quran ?
@@Abu-qitt i guess sahabas were usually righteous so they usually did not go against the Quran. This is why i find it hard to believe your first comment. They would be harsh maybe ONLY AGAINST mushrik and kafir, not muslims.
He’s a misguided intellect.
Love this
Please can some quote me the Sahih Hadith (with clear chain of narration) that discribes the location of MECCA?
7:42 and 7:43 show the difference between sectarians and quran-only believers.
"And the servants of the Almighty who walk on the earth in humility and if the ignorant speak to them, they say: Peace." 25:63
people fail to realise, Subhunallah. Quran only is the only way.
The Qur’an and the Sunnah
@@user-yv4mq3rc7c Quran alone
How do you pray?
@@user-yv4mq3rc7c Where is Sunnah.......it's biddah to claim and follow two sahih books
@@faizanraza6234
Do you know what biddah means first?
For the Quranists... name 1 companion of Muhammad sallahu alayis wa salaam that share the came beliefs as yall..
It was narrated that Ibn ‘Abbaas said: When the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) was dying, there were men in the house among whom was ‘Umar ibn al-Khattaab. The Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Come, let me write for you a document after which you will not go astray.” ‘Umar said: The Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) is overcome with pain, and you have the Qur’an; the Book of Allah is sufficient for us. The people in the house disagreed, and they argued. Some of them said: Come close and let the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) write for you a document after which you will not go astray. Others agreed with what ‘Umar said. When their debating and argument in the presence of the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) became too much, the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “Get up and leave.”
‘Ubayd-Allah said: Ibn ‘Abbaas used to say: What a calamity it was when the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) was prevented from writing that document for them because of their disagreement and arguing.
Narrated by al-Bukhaari (6932) and Muslim (1637)
According to Sunnis then Umar was also a “quranist” as he said that the Quran is enough for us, when the Prophet (pbuh&hf) asked about a pen & paper.
Let's talk slowly and clearly.
Quran is perfect and uncorrupted. Hadith is more like Christianity the sayings of Muhammad (pbuh) just like the gospels according to mark matthew luke and john.
Oh is it now? Then show me a verse in the Quran that explains how to pray the prayers
@@burakcoskun1865 try really hard to think now okay? Did people pray before the Quran and go to heaven?
@@mrBusssss try really hard to think now okay? Does the Quran tell u to the month of the hajj or how to do wudu and istinja?
@@burakcoskun1865 yes it tells you how to clean yourself? Look at what your asking your like a child that doesnt know how many time to wash one arm and what order all these extra steps that are arab traditions not what supposed to be the religion islam. God made it simple in the quran but that wasnt enough you did exactly what he said not to do and made other books to try match the quran and now you follow them books as law. Its so obvious and sad the same thing that happen to bible n Christians is what is happening to muslims.
@@mrBusssss oh did it? Then show me the verse instead of throwing a temper tantrum like lil kid and i never told u to show me a verse about how to clean yourself i told u to show me a verse or multiple verses where the Quran specifically explains how to do wudu, istinja and pray learn to read and comprehend ure butthurt because u couldn't find a verse that describes all the things i told u to show me from the Quran
Isnt the whereabouts of Mecca now debated as well? lol It's where Petra is. Plus does the hadiths actually give us the exact location of Mecca?
“And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it)”
[al-Hashr 59:7].
Write the whole verse and talk about the context
..Blessed is in who is in the fire and who’s around it… (27:8)
If you don’t show the full verse it’s misleading
The verse you quoted is about cutting up the war bounty.
@@MuhammadfromGOD So if you reject Hadith then it's pointless to mention Tafsir. So your own interpretation becomes your understanding. The Command From Allah is to Follow the Prophet of Allah and All other Prophets he sent before. Surah An-Nisa 63-65 Answers Any Doubts about Following the Prophet. (Peace be upon him). May Allah guide you.
A kafir is someone who says the Quran isn't complete
The quran isn't complete :
The changed and CORRUPTED quran dilemma = allah(peace be upon HER) is 100% FALSE :
'A'isha (Allah be pleased with, her) reported that it had been revealed in the Holy Qur'an that ten clear sucklings make the marriage unlawful, then it was abrogated (and substituted) by five sucklings and Allah's Apostle died and it was before that time (found) in the Holy Qur'an (and recited by the Muslims).
sahih muslim 1452a, book 17, hadith 30
Show me in the quran the verse of the 5 sucklings
@@polokucoch8112The Quran isn't complete when Allah says the Quran is complete????? Now you are a kafir.
33:21. Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often.
60:04 - A 'usswaton hasana' (good example) has been set for you in Abraham and those with him, when they said to their people, "We are innocent of you and what you worship besides God, and we reject you. Animosity and hatred have set in between us and you, and will remain forever until you believe in God alone.
Where is Abraham's sunna?
@@AesiedaWe don't need Abraham's sunnah because Allah says in the Quran:
Al-Ahzab 33:40
مَّا كَانَ مُحَمَّدٌ أَبَآ أَحَدٍ مِّن رِّجَالِكُمْ وَلَٰكِن رَّسُولَ ٱللَّهِ وَخَاتَمَ ٱلنَّبِيِّۦنَۗ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ بِكُلِّ شَىْءٍ عَلِيمًا
English - Sahih International
Muḥammad is not the father of [any] one of your men, but [he is] the Messenger of Allāh and seal [i.e., last] of the prophets. And ever is Allāh, of all things, Knowing.
Since prophet Mohammad saws is the seal of the prophets/the last one, and he is the perfect example for all mankind until the end of times, we only need his sunnah because he is THE PERFECT EXAMPLE.
And you don't know his sunnah since you reject it.
This verse proves you are in the wrong.
How would we know the Quran if not from Prophet Muhammad pbuh. And how would we interpret some verse of Quran if not from information of hadiths.
Shamsi don’t listen he’s just talks and talks without trying to listen or understand! Humble yourself!
The funniest part about this is that Allah is very clear about where Mecca is in the Quran.
So simple and elegant Allah explains that it is the house of worship that people circle around, pray and meditate (2:125) - there is no place else on earth that people circle than at Mecca.
So it's in there, plain and simple. But these people who follow the sects do not care, and they yell and bluster and close their ears. You can not show them the light.
They are addicted to Bukhari and every other demon. They will not listen to Allah.
💯
Have you seen what the shias do in Iran? They might now circle anythingthey before pilgrimage
Could the Quran be referring Iran?
" (57:16) IS IT
NOT time that the hearts of all who have attained to faith should feel humble at the remembrance of God and of
all the truth that has been bestowed [on them] from on high,22 lest they become like those who were granted
revelation aforetime,23 and whose hearts have hardened with the passing of time so that many of them are [now]
depraved? "
17:22
DO NOT set up any other deity side by side with God, lest thou find thyself disgraced and forsaken:
34:49
Say: "The truth has now come [to light, and falsehood is bound to wither away60]: for, falsehood cannot bring
forth anything new, nor can it bring back [what has passed away]."
(14:52) THIS IS A MESSAGE unto all mankind. Hence, let
them be warned thereby, and let them know that He is the One and Only God; and let those who are endowed
with insight take this to heart!
42:35
And let them know, those who call Our messages in question, that for them there is no escape.
18:110
Say [O Prophet]: "I am but a mortal man like all of you. It has been revealed unto me that your God is the One
and Only God. Hence, whoever looks forward [with hope and awe] to meeting his Sustainer [on Judgment Day],
let him do righteous deeds, and let him not ascribe unto anyone or anything a share in the worship due to his
Sustainer!"
30:31 [Turn, then, away from all that is false,] turning unto Him [Alone]; and remain conscious of Him, and be constant in prayer,
AND BE NOT AMONG THOSE WHO ASCRIBE DIVINITY TO AUGHT BESIDE HIM.
30:32 [or] AMONG THOSE WHO HAVE BROKEN THE UNITY OF THEIR FAITH AND HAVE BECOME SECTS, EACH GROUP DELIGHTING IN BUT WHAT
THEY THEMSELVES HOLD.
6:112
AND THUS it is that against every prophet We have set up as enemies the evil forces from among humans as
well as from among invisible beings that whisper unto one another glittering half-truths meant to delude the
mind 98 But they could not do this unless thy GOD had so willed: stand, therefore, aloof from them and from
all their false imagery!
59:21
HAD WE bestowed this Qur'an from on high upon a mountain, thou wouldst indeed see it humbling itself,
breaking asunder for awe
And [all] such parables We propound unto men, so that they might [learn to] think.
22:8
And yet, among men there is many a one that argues about God without having any knowledge [of Him],
without any guidance, and without any light-giving revelation
6:65
Say: "It is He alone who has the power to let loose upon you suffering from above you or from beneath your
feet, or to confound you with mutual discord and let you taste the fear of one another."
41:3) a divine writ, the messages whereof have been clearly spelled out as a discourse in the Arabic tongue2
for
people of [innate] knowledge,
(41:4) to be a herald of glad tidings as well as a warning.
54:22
Hence, indeed,; We made this Qur'an easy to bear in mind: who, then, is willing to take it to heart?
Translation (Muhammad Asad)
Brother dont despair that they call u a disbeliever, when we go to God he will inform us everything.
Muhammad Asad wrote one of the only good traditionalist translations, he was a traditionalist but not a sectarian traditionalist, his views contrasted to other traditionalists, the Wahhabis of Arabia banned his book because he referenced the Ash'aria and also referenced Zamakhshari a Mutazilite scholar in his explanation.
@@flyinglegion5697 yep, if I need a good tafsir I like to read Muhammad Asad's. But when I recite I prefer neat, direct translations like Talal Itani's
In the end it's not about Quranist vs Traditionalist, it's about people who believe in the Quran and people who don't. Even among the Quranists there are lots of hypocrites, just as there are among the Sunni, Shia, Ibadi etc. You can recognize them by what they say after a while if you are a righteous person.
@@sasino I agree, I believe Muhammad Asad was genuine and honest, sadly he left too soon and sadly his library caught fire and got burnt, which lead in destruction of a lot his writings which weren't preserved in publicated copies, we only have his translation and tafsir of the Quran and his other publicated writings.
@@flyinglegion5697 Thanks for sharing that knowledge brother, I didn't know that. How did he die?
Should've asked him where's Mecca from haddith or rewayat, and let's claim that qur'an or Hadiths said it's in Hijaz.. WHERE'S THE HIJAZ? Brother just asked the dumbest question and supposed himself to make since; like, that was worse than asked their famous questions "how do you know how to pray?", but I guess he realized this one was so worn out so he decided to ask a dumber one lol