Hadith Rejecter exposing Sunnis ft.
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 07. 2023
- With more than 10 years experience in trying to have a meaningful conversation with Sunnis in regards to their beliefs; all I found was the truth about who they really are inside.
Come watch me get interrupted more than 70 times in 20 minutes
In-depth lessons about the Koran:
/ @bush2g9 - Zábava
honestly i’m glad people like you exist who see the truth, Subhanallah. It’s so clear, we all have our bad days and times but when you know the ultimate truth, the only truth, you feel peace. Quran is a living miracle, should ONLY be followed.
Quran has never let me down
Surah 65.4.
@@Original.D.O what about it?
i know someone who is 22 years old and she has never had her period yet so what are you trying to prove @@Original.D.O
True, QURAN only , guided me how to come out of sects in a few days.. I'm an ex shia now Alhamdulillah
@@Original.D.O ? what is the problem?
Its sad how they keep interuppting. it shows you how insecure they are with their beliefs
I am not religious but after watching your videos and your debates, You are probably the person i would like to be educated by when it comes to Islam.
Quranists follow the lazy man version of Islam. You want to follow Islam correctly? Follow in the footsteps of the prophet (pbuh) who was the living example for all the world? Then the only way you can learn is by following his traditions. The same people whom Allah used to preserve His Book, ars the same ones who preserved the traditions of the Prophet (pbuh) - Ahl Al Sunnah Wal Jama'a
@@MH-uh7vq why there is no ISNAD of the Quran is they preserved the Quran like the traditional hadith??
@@islamuniversaltv6131 Isnad for the Quran?? Is this even a serious question?? You do know to this day when a hafidh recieves his or her certification, on that certification is provided the chain of hufadh going back to the Prophet (pbuh).
For example, Ahmed just received his certificate from his teacher Muhammad. Muhammad received his certification from Mustafa, who received it from Abdullah.... On and on until "who learned it from Prophet Muhammad (pbuh).
This is something you can even see for yourself. I can provide you with names of institutions who still do it to this very day. Every single hafidh can trace his/her line.
@islamuniversaltv6131 thats actually a very good response to sunnis when they say the quran was preserved in the same way the hadith is
@@383564 Actually this is the dumbest response. It shows you guys have absolutely no clue what you are talking about. Read my response to his comment. You guys are literally clueless with regards to these issues. Furthermore, the same people Allah used to preserve the Quran, are the very same people who preserved the teachings of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh). You Quranists need to be consistent. If you do not trust us with the preservation of the ahadith, then you need to also distrust us with regards to the preservation of the Quran. In other words... Openly state that the Quran is not preserved and find yourselves a new religion to follow
The devils get real desperate the closer you get to the truth. Keep up the good work
Watching this in front of masjid el nabawwi, while having breakfast after fajr, such a vibe
It’s always funny seeing them mock christians for having holy books hundreds of years later, but they believe all hadith that came hundreds of years later
thats what i aslo always think when i see their videos
Funny enough, in their OWN hadiths (Sahih Muslim Book 42, Hadith Number 7147) Says that the prophet saws told them to not take down from him anything but the Quran.
When you ask them why is that and why do we now have hadith. Their awnser is that the prophet saws was afraid it would be confused with the Quran.....
So Muhammad saws, the prophet of Allah swt was afraid that the Quran would not be preserved even though Allah swt LITTERALY states in the Quran it would????
If Muhammad saws was afraid that it would be mixed with the Quran but it was sooo important for the understanding of faith, would it make more sens to have it written down? If it was so important and so crucial why did no ''sahaba'' made an effort to have it written down like they did for the Quran? Why did the muslim community have to wait 230 years for a man to collect 600,000 hadiths and decide according to him and his own bias which one is worth keeping and which one should be burnt and lost forever?
You should start debating more often i love your content man! God Bless
The Quran is a recitation carried by the masses. Not like hadith from one person who to another. They question the Koran with such comparisons
i am Arab and became Qoranist after i studied deeply the books of hadith and fiqh the six books, and the Hadith science books like ibn hajar,Tabaqat ibn Saad, Al dahabi, ibn abi shayba, Al hakim fi el mostadrak,Al bayhaqi ,ibn ishak,kanz al omal, and in the those books the bitter reality how Jewish Rabbis like ibn Samaul and his student Kaab Al ahbar how they created the Hadith .
from my studies Sunni sect should be classified as a jewish Talmudic sect not islamic
and the worst enemies of the prophet and Quran is the sunni sect especially salafi the followers of the psycopath ibn taymiya Alharani
According to Shooba ibn al hajaj the first creator of hadith laws to check if the hadith is sahih or not he said from 100 hadiths your imam say may only 10 my be true as hadith of the prophets while 90 are told by evil people to support their agendas
and i noticed somthing dangerous that the translations of the books of hadith in english are mosltly corrupted and they play and change words to hide the real context of the hadith while in Arabic all thing is clear like pure water
Nothing new here my brother! And people still blindly follow these lahwa-lhadeeth!
Brother, Even though I agree with you I have accepted the Quran as the only source of Shari’ah. I became quranite straight from being Salafi. The Salafi position is so alluring. They say beautiful things and seems and feels great like “We follow the Quran, the Sunnah, with the understanding of the Salaf”. Yet when you actually treat the words of God with care, you find out that the two other sources they associate to the Quran is not commanded nor obligated by Allah at all, not only that but it assumes infallibility to the majority of the first 3 generations! Twelve Shi’ism is even worse, they say that no one has the authority to interpret the Quran except the 12 Imams, so the kalam of God has no value to them, what has value to them is the Tafasir of the 12 imams as they even believe that they are the literal representing be of God in earth, and that they can abrogate laws and principles in the Quran. We ask God for guidance to his straight path, Ameen!
Brother can you give an example of the mistranslated ahadith. Thanking you in advance.
The quran proves it by claiming "had it been from anyone other than God, it would have many contradictions" that's how, the hadiths are full of contradictions therefore not from God. The Quran has no contradictions therefore it is from God and been preserved by God. When God wills something it comes into existence. These people remind me of the Cow. "Which cow, what color, old or young?"
Sadly 95% of Muslims are astray by the hadiths. Hadiths caused sects and wars among the Muslims till today. I cut ties with all Muslims who follow hadiths and never felt better and more at peace. Muslims who follow hadiths all they talk is killing non Muslims...
They are jahudi sect sunni
A cult within the religion and all in the name os Islam.
How can a religion even make sense when its based on strong hadith, weak hadith, stupid hadith, dumb hadith... what a nonsense
It's not supposed to be
I don't think I've ever heard an informal debate where no one is ever interrupted.
I find it very annoying in a discussion.
These guys don’t know why they believe what they do, they just know that they believe it and they must defend it.
It’s sick and entirely defensive.
And the defend it arrogantly. Those like Mohammad hijab who said men who follow only Quran are pedophiles. Disgusting
I told a Sunni Muslim that I reject Hadith and he admittedly accused me of following my own knowledge, disobeying the Messenger and even accused me of listening to a Djinn. Completely ridiculous that they cannot argue peacefully or honestly and had to resort to saying I was possessed and say I wasn't a true Muslim.
Salamun Alaykum bro, greeting from Singapore. May Allah bless you and keep you in good health.
Oh my Lord!
They say: "We are Ahlus Sunnah wa'l jama'ah" which automatically exposes them as a SECT. This means they're MUSHRIKEEN according to the Qur'an at verses 30:31-32. But ofcourse, to quote the Qur'an to these misguided clowns is 'circular reasoning'! 😅
I can only imagine these like minded people at the time of the Messenger Muhammad (a.s) where they would reject the verses of Allah while being recited to them and say: "Hey Muhammad, this is circular reasoning! so please bring us your chains of narrators"! I mean, how else did prophet Muhammad (a.s) prove or convince the people that he was a true Messenger of Allah??obviously, through the QUR'AN ONLY and NOTHING else!
Here's a scenario to think about:
Imagine there existed a man by the name of Peter (the Satanist) and he had a book which appeared a thousand years ago. And till this day, Peter's followers have unbroken 'chains of narrators' tracing back to him. Will this CHAIN OF TRANSMISSION be sufficient for you to believe it's true and follow it??
Or ...
Would you consider the CONTENT of this book and act accordingly??
Brother, Allah has sealed their minds and hearts so it's pointless having debates with them! Wallaahi 😅
the haddith is created from the ancient fairy tail of arab... see the dajjal and imam mahdi... see the black magic...
This was an excellent video. Thank you. I learned much from you.
I like you brother you're a righteous man, and your explanation of prayer is exactly how I see it, sunni and shia see prayer as an action they peform nothing else.
No book is needed to know how to pray. QURAN discuss something else i.e beliefs.
@@muvvahhid1 I agree
I debate Sunnis and you are correct that they repeat it and want to bombard you with irrelevant questions.
(And when God alone is mentioned, hearts are disgusted)....Quran
Nice one bro iv never looked at it like that you know salam alak akhi
The truth is beautiful 😂 because it’s sharper than any two edged sword. And no matter what they can’t catch you. “SO U REJECT HADEETH!”Yeah I do, for the 14TH time . 😭😭
Thanks to Br. Shuaib for sharing this channel .
Qur’an 31:6 states that people like them take lahwal Hadiths (baseless Hadiths) as entertainment.
Sunnis say this verse refers to music how funny (when the literal Arabic word is Hadith).
Idle Talks ≠ Music
some times it can be though! like most modern music promotes zina, drugs etc. However, prohibiting background music is completely unfounded in Islam.@@darko7mc186
The early Muslims interpreted لَهْوَ الْحَدِيث to mean music and/or idle speech. Additionally, three of the Prophet's companions, whom the Prophet had praised for their understanding of the Quran, said that it means music (Sayyidna Ibn Masud, Ibn Abbas, and Jabir). You are coming 1400 years later, making up your own interpretation of a text you don’t even know how to read. Even if you were Arab, you're not even close to the level of fusha Arabi the Sahaba had. Not to mention, their understanding of the Quran was far superior to yours. Moreover, for 3-4 generations, there was not even another interpretation of this ayah, and when there was, it was interpreted as just idle talk, not what you are spreading.
@@asilmussa9312 music is not a hadith at all. even the verse completely aligns with the garbage hadith books
مَا كَذَبَ ٱلْفُؤَادُ مَا رَأَى (53:11)
I can sense your sincerity from many miles away brother. I can see it with full clarity and I commend you on this effort to pursuing the Truth and I encourage you on continuing it wholeheartedly, even if it puts at odds with those around (reflecting on 4:135).
It is unfortunate how many who consider them muslims focus on the superficial elements of the religion (how to for rituals etc) and forget the essential aspects, namely how to conduct and treat one another.
Arrogance, deceit, and insincerity are clearly from the devil, and it’s disappointing to see those who consider themselves intellectual muslims exhibiting such behaviors. May Allah guide us all. And may Allah grant you victory in your pursuit of the ultimate Truth.
So you think he is right for judging them and pointing at them as wrong,but you don't like them pointing at him like he's wrong?Maybe you will be against any fitnah in general?
@@cunctator3401 salam brother, I often find nanoscopic-precision answers to human psychology and social dynamics on the holy Quran. I will hence provide an answer with verses from it at the end. Please take them with good intentions on the matter at hand and take your time reflecting on their meaning and application with regard to the interaction between the three. Please keep in mind that if you observe the situation as impartially as possible, you may notice how triggered and irritated the two got over Muhammad for his belief and general argument that the Quran should be held as God’s only book of law for mankind. not even that, I personally was disappointed how two muslim brothers would go as far as insult another muslim brother, calling him a clown, implying he’s a kafir, and interrupting abruptly on way too many occasions, and just being overall rude. Please bear in mind this is a religious conversation, hence morality is imminently at the table, in the sense that the whole discussion falls apart when there is no kindness nor akhlaq. Sure Muhammad got sucked into it at the end, but it is the two who initiated the aggression.
As for God’s words (Quran 47:29-33)
أَمْ حَسِبَ ٱلَّذِينَ فِى قُلُوبِهِم مَّرَضٌ أَن لَّن يُخْرِجَ ٱللَّهُ أَضْغَـٰنَهُمْ ٢٩ وَلَوْ نَشَآءُ لَأَرَيْنَـٰكَهُمْ فَلَعَرَفْتَهُم بِسِيمَـٰهُمْ ۚ وَلَتَعْرِفَنَّهُمْ فِى لَحْنِ ٱلْقَوْلِ ۚ وَٱللَّهُ يَعْلَمُ أَعْمَـٰلَكُمْ ٣٠ وَلَنَبْلُوَنَّكُمْ حَتَّىٰ نَعْلَمَ ٱلْمُجَـٰهِدِينَ مِنكُمْ وَٱلصَّـٰبِرِينَ وَنَبْلُوَا۟ أَخْبَارَكُمْ ٣١
“Or do those with sickness in their hearts think that Allah will not ˹be able to˺ expose their malice?
Had We willed, We could have truly shown them to you ˹O Prophet˺, and you would have certainly recognized them by their appearance. But you will surely recognize them by their tone of speech. And Allah ˹fully˺ knows your doings ˹O people˺.
We will certainly test you ˹believers˺ until We prove those of you who ˹truly˺ struggle ˹in Allah’s cause˺ and remain steadfast, and reveal how you conduct yourselves.”
@@Hyundmeko salam brother, I think you misunderstood me on the rituals part. To clarify my position, of course rituals and actions are not just important but necessary to achieve righteousness in the eyes of Allah (SWT). The Almighty says: ذَٰلِكَ وَمَن يُعَظِّمْ شَعَائِرَ اللَّهِ فَإِنَّهَا مِن تَقْوَى الْقُلُوبِ (22:32)
My actual point is that akhlaq (manners) and rituals complete one another in the path towards being sincere, righteous and achieving excellence overall. If one preaches rituals, or any other aspect of the religion in that regard, while throwing ad hominems (insults, ridiculations, being rude, etc.) at others, where is the taqwa in all of this? In fact, if we were to emulate our beloved prophet (pbuh), how would he (who Allah sent as a mercy to the worlds) act in such regards? I believe the image i’m trying to draw here is getting clearer. In any case, my Allah guide us all to the Truth, and to sum it up, the most Merciful states the following:
وَمَنْ أَحْسَنُ قَوْلًۭا مِّمَّن دَعَآ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَعَمِلَ صَـٰلِحًۭا وَقَالَ إِنَّنِى مِنَ ٱلْمُسْلِمِينَ ٣٣ وَلَا تَسْتَوِى ٱلْحَسَنَةُ وَلَا ٱلسَّيِّئَةُ ۚ ٱدْفَعْ بِٱلَّتِى هِىَ أَحْسَنُ فَإِذَا ٱلَّذِى بَيْنَكَ وَبَيْنَهُۥ عَدَٰوَةٌۭ كَأَنَّهُۥ وَلِىٌّ حَمِيمٌۭ ٣٤ وَمَا يُلَقَّىٰهَآ إِلَّا ٱلَّذِينَ صَبَرُوا۟ وَمَا يُلَقَّىٰهَآ إِلَّا ذُو حَظٍّ عَظِيمٍۢ ٣٥
And whose words are better than someone who calls ˹others˺ to Allah, does good, and says, “I am truly one of those who submit.”?
Good and evil cannot be equal. Respond ˹to evil˺ with what is best, then the one you are in a feud with will be like a close friend.
But this cannot be attained except by those who are patient and who are truly fortunate.
صدق الله العظيم
Peace be upon you
@@Hyundmeko I’ve just seen some of them and you happen to be right about the shorts. I personally don’t approve of it. May Allah guide us all
The way to approach a hadeether Muslim is to call them a Quran rejector. It makes things very exciting. And it's so easy to prove sectarians are Quran rejectors (just that they are not aware yet because of the ulema brainwashing)😊
After reading endless hadiths I just had to admit what I felt. This was like 1001 night stories. While some were solid other were ridiculous and after I went in this black hole of was there even a Muhammad? I then laid down my interest of islam. My interest is back and I am neither sunni nor shia nor this or that. I find the form of prayer sufficient and the path to God there.
Funny how you find more like minded people even after you think you're alone.
Welcome to Islam, sunni and shia are no muslims. Anyone who is of a sect is of those who have gone astray.
What? I've never heard such nonsense.
u read them? u know satan is pissing in ur ear if you dont wake up for fajr loooooool@@irfanshaikh9390
This was not a discussion of finding where's the truth, I can feel you, any logical questions I ask they connect to being possessed by shaitan 😢
If people really want to find the truth they will consider for a moment that what you're offering them is truth and then thinking whether it's 100 percent logical or not and should they accept it or not.
Our brain is the key, what the Creator of all things has given us, and the programm inside our brain (the common sense, logic) is the thing which can help us to find what is right and what is wrong.
This way we understood that Quran is from God and that's why we follow it, because it's the only logical way.
Before we become true believers we analyze first, we may go through different things and ideas analyzing them and if we are logical and truthful with ourselves and want to find the truth we will eventually come to analyzing the Quran and understand it is the truth.
Christians = Trinity = Father-Son-Spirit.
Ahlul Hadith = Duality = Allah-Muhammad.
TO OBEY THE MESSENGER
DOES NOT MEAN OBEY THE HADITHS!
The commandment to obey the messenger relates to the people during his lifetime while he still lived among us. And it relates to us to nowadays by telling us to obey the messenger by obeying the message (the Qur'an). And every time the messenger is commanded to give orders to the believers (as stated in the Qur'an) if we obey those commandments we have obeyed the messenger (like with the example, i.e. 'they ask thee [oh Muhammad] about gambling and intoxication, say/.../'. And obeying the messenger relates to obeying the entire message (the Qur'an). And if you deny that there are commandments in the Qur'an that are seemingly especially related to the prophet's lifetime, then explain how in verse 33:53 there are commandments about how to uphold yourself if visiting the prophet's home and how to conduct yourself in regards to his wives. Obviously those commandments aren't directly related to us. And likewise, there is a nuanced definition of 'obey the messenger' that especially relates to the lifetime of the messenger while he was living on this earth as a living and breathing leader over Allah's devoted submitters. So to obey the messenger does not mean that Allah left us with an insufficient Qur'an that should be completed with the hadiths!
THE REAL SUNNAH OF MUHAMMAD:
[The Qur'an 6:114]
أَفَغَيْرَ ٱللَّـهِ أَبْتَغِى حَكَمًا وَهُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَنزَلَ إِلَيْكُمُ ٱلْكِتَـٰبَ مُفَصَّلًا وَٱلَّذِينَ ءَاتَيْنَـٰهُمُ ٱلْكِتَـٰبَ يَعْلَمُونَ أَنَّهُۥ مُنَزَّلٌ مِّن رَّبِّكَ بِٱلْحَقِّ فَلَا تَكُونَنَّ مِنَ ٱلْمُمْتَرِينَ
Then should I (Muhammad) seek a judge other than Allah when He sent down to you this book (the Qur'an) fully detailed [in proclaiming all matters of rules and adherences]? And those who where given the book before knows that it is the truth from thy Lord, so never be among the doubters!
Follow and message me on Instagram for more: @muslim_warner
You do understand hadiths are simply the 100% accurate historical evidence of prophet peace and blessings be upon him, doing or saying something.You understand that right?How we would know minor issues like can we pray while our hair is wet,how to perform certain actions the best way,how to speak in different situations.Prophet Muhammad is an example for us as a humans, why we should not follow his words and actions if we can 100% tell they belong to prophet?
@@cunctator3401 "he said that he said that she said that they said that she said that he said" is not 100% historically accurate and it couldn't be. Its like the chinese whisperers, HERESY. No actual proof from the Quran itself that the hadith are to be followed
May Allah reward you brother Muhammad for exposing this zindeeq. This is the same Zindeeq who said 'Without hadiths, there can be no Islam', so apparently Adam was not a Muslim. He was forced to concede his kuffri statement after I called him out on it.
He also, despite being an Arab, suddenly becomes incapable of reading when it comes to the Qur'an. He even said 'Without hadiths telling us the correct recitation, how do we know whether to pronounce 'khimar' or 'himaar'?' Yes, that's right, he is unable to distinguish between a donkey and a cloth by context. He needs hadiths to tell him this. Yet give these zindeeqs any other book in Arabic and they will read it without diacritical markers no problem.
Truly their hearts are sealed when it comes to the Qur'an.
I have a question for you
The Qur'an tells us to pray but does it tell us how to pray??
You guys are denying the existence of the prophet
I mean we have a book but who is the best representative of that book??
@@osamahal-hubishi7809 The Quran also says to be kind to your parents. Does it tell you how? Does it tell you what kind words you should say? Use your reason and follow simple instructions.
Furthermore, Allah does not need a representative for his book.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah do you hate the prophet??
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah you are correct Allah doesn't need a representative for his book but humans do
هؤلاء ان الذين كفروا سواء عليهم انذرتهم ام لم تنذرهم لا يؤمنون
The real question is, why did you put your self in a disadvantage being in the other side of a panel that is controlled by the opposite group. It is not even one discussing a matter with another ,but 1 trying to talk against 3 interrupting and directing the discussion. TBH, you need to study how to debate because this kind of debates depends on tactics of debate more than the proof of the position.
True
Spot on
Brother Muhammed You are truly blessed with honesty and wisdom ! alhamdolliah keep being so honest and friendly
I am not Muslim but I have to say, they constantly speak about proving the reservation of the Qur'an, but we know today that even in science, in order to prove something, you must try your best to disprove it, and if it cannot be disproved, it is understood as "proved to be correct in theory and application..."
Mufti Abu Layth did a really good piece on how the Quran was preserved. Quran was preserved through oral tradition like many other living traditions in Islam not through Hadith at all.
Quran alone is the only guidance given Muhammad pbuh
Good job brother
Keep it up !
Allah counts every effort 👌🏼
Sunnis have no ground to stand on unless they judge by the Qur'an.
May Allah bless you and grant you patience 🙏
Salam my man !!!
So prophet Muhammad never did anything for his companions to see and follow?
@@quranicverses.2394 isnt the Quran enough for you ?
He is a Messenger, the message is Quran.
Pls consider this verse
And is it not sufficient for them that We revealed to you the Book [i.e., the Qur'ān] which is recited to them? Indeed in that is a mercy and reminder for a people who believe.
Quran 29 51
Indeed the Quran is sufficient.
Can anyone send me the link for the debate?
Your videos and shorts have send me on a rollercoaster for the last few days. I just lost my dad and started praying for the first time in my life - voluntarily. Even though I’m giving myself to ibadat I still had questions about Islam creep up in the back of my mind. The Quranist view makes a lot of sense and resonates with me on a deep level. I still haven’t declared my stance on the matter as I’m still learning and seeking guidance.
However the reason writing in first place is, to let you know, that you need to keep a more calm head and temper when discussing and debating. Become more stoic. Realize when in a debate, the people you are actually speaking to is the audience and not the opposing fraction. Don’t get involved in pettiness. Them misrepresenting your stance doesn’t need to be met with instant rebuttal from your side which often is in form of interruption and resulting in half finished sentences. You end up looking weak in return. I look forward to see more debates, because that’s where iron gets sharpened and you performing good will adherently make more people interested in the quranist views.
May GOD unite you with your father in heaven.
I appreciate your kind advice and sentiment and I will keep it mind
the best comment I've seen in the last month. Peace be with you
I subscribed just now. You are the first Muslim that i hear firsthand to confidently stay true to what you claim to be, a Muslim. I am not a Muslim but i adore the fact that you stick to the Qur'an instead of relying on matters written centuries later. Peace be with you my brother.
You do understand hadiths are simply the 100% accurate historical evidence of prophet peace and blessings be upon him, doing or saying something.You understand that right?How we would know minor issues like can we pray while our hair is wet,how to perform certain actions the best way,how to speak in different situations.Prophet Muhammad is an example for us as a humans, why we should not follow his words and actions if we can 100% tell they belong to prophet?
@@cunctator3401 czcams.com/video/5zR8UsTIMUs/video.html
@@cunctator3401hadiths are the words of the prophet Muhammad SAW PBUH, they arent much realiable because over the years a lot of people changed these a lot which makes some of the hadiths kind of misunderstanding, so its better to use Qur'an more, but that doesnt mean hadith should not be sued at all, there are still so many hadiths that contain valid information.
@@xtrop6159 brother you are not familiar with a science of researching them,there are literally dozens of factors used to really filter the authentic ones.If one of the narrators is suspicious of being a liar that's all, hadith is rejected.This is a very strong tradition,by this tradition we as ummah preserved Quran, don't you think pious muslims will preserve the facts about the life of the prophet pbuh the same way?
@@joerdim why,if you can prove,100%, taking into the consideration all possible factors,that this was said or done by the prophet may peace be upon him,why not to use it? There are weak hadiths as well
35:18- these zindeeqs have abndoned the book in favour of hadiths
There argument is humans wrote down the Quran they give the credit to man for keeping the Quran complete and not changing it. They don't give credit to Allah. And they give credit to people when they get there religion from other then the Book from Allah
I my self is a muslim who reject hadith and only believe in Quran and previous books that revealed from God. I started to learn Quran from my early years, and looking back in my old days, I am so happy that I only read Quran. Now it's my 45 years this year...To the best of my knowledge, your understanding of Quran is very good and you have sabr or patient to deal with them. I hope Allah makes your heart warm, calm and peace even after many other sunnis would call you many names. In my younger years, I had a debate with sunni and they also called me names that make you feel as astray or disbeliever. Actually, it was hurt me and i was started thinking why my understanding of Quran is different with them but they put me as someone who is worst than a kafir, while in fact, I was just telling them everything from the Quran.
Now a days, I just want to learn more about Quran and I hope Allah gives me wisdom and teach me the Quran. I hope Allah forgives all my sins and guides me to the right path.
Alright. I want you to prove to me the Quran is preserved without using the Hadith.
If your belief is that the Qur'an is preserved through men...then you do not believe in the Qur'an, but rather you believe in men
@@tj8487 You did not answer my question. I asked what is the PROOF of Quran being preserved. Torah and Gospel were also the revelations of God according to the Quran, why do you believe in their corruption then?
@gaminghd4716
I did answer your question. U don't believe in the Quran until someone says to you it's from Allah it's preserved it's Real.. Men made u believe in the Quran.
I will make it more clear to you. You do not believe in the Qur’an in itself, so why do you care whether it is preserved or not? It does not concern you if God guarantees the preservation of the Qur’an or God challenged those who write like the Qur’an or the miracles in it. I hope the idea is clear.
Really appreciate the work you are doing, they're ignorant and probably have never opened their mind. They initiate conversation with a person who admits that he rejects hadith, then they ask him questions to accuse him of not following the hadith. These people fear logic and reasoning. They're examples of 25:30
I want to know where and from who you learn about Islam?
how do you explain the different qirrats without the hadiths? which qirrat is the true Quran??
Love peace brother May Allah protect you We albanians are dealing with this and its mainstream and there is alot of debates alot of people are waking up
Albanians are dealing with lies from ahadeeth too?
Oh my gosh I understand wow why wouldn't they just let you explain it was so simple.
Beautifully said 100% correct
When they mention Sahaba , ask them what the verse , wa ma sahibikum bi majnoon was referring to ???
True, QURAN only , guided me how to come out of sects in a few days.. I'm an ex shia now Alhamdulillah
[7:11] yep, you are right, there are verses that say they ask you such a such so answer with such a such, the questions of theirs are in the Quran, and so are the answers to their question, the Quran literally has a long list of Q&As, amazing, even though the concept and the fundamental idea of Q&As was "invented much later" and used on websites, by organizations, by businesses, by companies, by corporations, by anyone in any industry, on leaflets, posters, flyers, in books and booklets, the concept of Q&A is much older than our modern-day usage and is heavily utilized in the Quran.
يَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ ٱلْخَمْرِ وَٱلْمَيْسِرِ قُلْ فِيهِمَآ إِثْمٌ كَبِيرٌ وَمَنَـٰفِعُ لِلنَّاسِ وَإِثْمُهُمَآ أَكْبَرُ مِن نَّفْعِهِمَا وَيَسْـَٔلُونَكَ مَاذَا يُنفِقُونَ قُلِ ٱلْعَفْوَ كَذَٰلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ ٱللَّـهُ لَكُمُ ٱلْـَٔايَـٰتِ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَتَفَكَّرُونَ
They ask thee about wine and games of chance. Say thou: “In both is great sin, and benefits for men; but their sin is greater than their benefit.” And they ask thee what they should spend. Say thou: “The surplus.” Thus does God make plain to you the proofs, that you might reflect
(2:219)
يَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ ٱلسَّاعَةِ أَيَّانَ مُرْسَىٰهَا قُلْ إِنَّمَا عِلْمُهَا عِندَ رَبِّى لَا يُجَلِّيهَا لِوَقْتِهَآ إِلَّا هُوَ ثَقُلَتْ فِى ٱلسَّمَـٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ لَا تَأْتِيكُمْ إِلَّا بَغْتَةً يَسْـَٔلُونَكَ كَأَنَّكَ حَفِىٌّ عَنْهَا قُلْ إِنَّمَا عِلْمُهَا عِندَ ٱللَّـهِ وَلَـٰكِنَّ أَكْثَرَ ٱلنَّاسِ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ
They ask thee concerning the Hour: “When is its arrival?” Say thou: “Knowledge thereof is but with my Lord; none reveals its time save He. It weighs heavily in the heavens and the earth; it comes not upon you save unexpectedly.” They ask thee as though thou wert privy thereto; say thou: “Knowledge thereof is but with God”; but most men know not.
(7:187)
وَيَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ ٱلرُّوحِ قُلِ ٱلرُّوحُ مِنْ أَمْرِ رَبِّى وَمَآ أُوتِيتُم مِّنَ ٱلْعِلْمِ إِلَّا قَلِيلًا
And they ask thee about the Spirit. Say thou: “The Spirit is by command of my Lord; and you have been given of knowledge only a little
(17:85)
وَيَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَن ذِى ٱلْقَرْنَيْنِ قُلْ سَأَتْلُوا۟ عَلَيْكُم مِّنْهُ ذِكْرًا
And they ask thee about Dhūl-Qarnayn. Say thou: “I will recite to you a remembrance of him: -”
(18:83)
وَيَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ ٱلْجِبَالِ فَقُلْ يَنسِفُهَا رَبِّى نَسْفًا
And they ask thee about the mountains. Say thou: “My Lord will scatter them with a blast
(20:105)
Hadiths tells you that you get "hasanat" by killing geckos [Allahs creation]
Only Shaitan could make a obscene game out of killing harmless creatures.
Yes im aware what ONE Gecko did to Ibrahim, not all of them.
LOL, yes! ONE gecko out of billions apparently blew fire onto Ibraheem (a.s). Therefore, Sunnis want to kill ALL OF THEM! So, if you got bitten by a dog, tell the authorities to go kill ALL OF THEM! 😅
The logic of the Sunni mind 😊
They (sunnis) do not know that those hadiths are EXTREMELY against the prophet, his family etc.
As you rightly said tht the seal was put on prophet hood and not on messenger and I got message from you .. I always never related to several so called sahih hadeeth and openly proclaiming glory of Quraan and Quraan only
Why do they ask for rakat number if you reject Hadith . What is fiqh for ?
You where live? I missed it. Daimn
Brother, you could have answered them even easier. I would have said the following:
I know that the Qur'an is traced back to the prophet based on it being a miracle, Allah fulfilling His promise of protecting it being a miracle. And how can I prove that it is a miracle? By refering to its unmatched intrinsic and asthethic value. In other words, Allah says in the Qur'an 2:23 i.e, that if you have any doubt in it, then come with a chapter like it. Then, if you do not, and you will never, then be in precautionary fear of the Fire. It's fuel being the people and the particular stones, prepeared for the defiant deniers.
How do you know how to pray without hadiths?
@@dominicksherzai8560 I understand the word al-salah (الصلوٰة) to mean i.e: 'the closely following connection and observance (the referenced one)'. And in the Qur'an we read numerous verses in relation to it. Making ablution before it is stated step by step in 5:6, the timings of it can be found in 11:114 and elsewhere, and body movements such as standing, bowing and prostrating seems to be suggested in relation to it as well. About the direction of prayer, I'm somewhat unsure if 4:144 actually speaks of a direction of prayer. Nontheless, my point is the following: as long as you fulfill the objective of the salah by fulfilling its criterias as stated in the Qur'an and benefiting from it by increasing in remembrance of Allah and your duty to Allah throughout the day, and to be hindered from evil, sins and indecencies from the remembrance of Allah thereby (that's a benefit of the salah that's mentioned in 29:46), then you have accomplished the salah. So if you end up for example prostrating 1, 3 or 10 times is not specified in the Qur'an, and therefore it is optional. The purpose is - as I've mentioned - to fulfill the criterias of it as mentioned in the Qur'an and to fulfill its objective. As long as you do that, you have fulfilled your Salah.
@@dominicksherzai8560 if hadiths are so important for praying why does the 4 school of sunni islam all pray differently? Also did you learn how to pray from hadith? No you did not everybody learn the same way, as tought by either a parent, the mosque you go to or online now a days.
@@dominicksherzai8560 Abraham prayed without Hadith.
MashaAllah, good job brother in keeping your cool. I'm called a deviant myself because I don't just blindly take Hadith. If it applies it applies and matches the Qur'an I use it. I think Islamic history is important, but Qur'an is #1 and complete.
God bless you sheik! I know they get so mad when they see me call a “Hadith rejector” a sheik 😭😭😂😂😂 peace and blessing be upon you brother
Exactly they add additional meanings to Arabic terms, like muslim, Islam, shahada, sheikh, etc.
We pray 5 times a day ? How many salah you pray per day ?
You telling me that Ramzi isn't Christopher Abbott from Girls HBO?
God guided me to uphold the Quran. But they call you a kafir for following Gods book
Where is the verse that says Allah will protect the quran? Are we talking about 15.9?
Indeed, We We have sent down the Reminder, and indeed, We of it (are) surely Guardians.
There are problems thinking that is the quran which is used 69 times as there was no actual quran at that time and the verse uses the past tense (sent).
The word for reminder l-dhik'ra is used for other books such as Torah and Injeel which was already in existence while quran was still being revealed (not sent down).
21:48 And verily, We gave Musa and Harun the Criterion (fur'qāna) and a light and a Reminder (dhik'ran) for the righteous.
We see Musa was given a Reminder (Torah)
21:7 And not We sent before you except men, We revealed to them. So ask (the) people (of) the Reminder (l-dhik'ri), if you (do) not know.
16:43 And not We sent from before you except men, We revealed to them, so ask (the) people (of) the Reminder(l-dhik'ri) if you (do) not know.
Clearly, this is not speaking of quran but prior books, Torah, Zubur and Injeel.
So to say Allah will protect quran is presumptive as that word is applied to the other books.
13:27 so if someone is always aware of God either because he has such a personality or has notification on his phone reminding him then they could live their whole life without praying a single prayer and they would even considered to be better than some who prayed their whole life?
i am sunni but im not like them if you answer a question then he asks you the same question over and over and he lied i know
they clearly don't know how to have a proper debate lmao
I get your point, but, you cannot throw away the beloved prophets sunna just like that. I agree, you cannot trust bukhari or muslim or any hadith books completely, but it doesn't mean that hadith as a whole is wrong. To me personally, the age of our mother Aisha is what get's into my nerve. I know those narrations are false. Give the sunna another chance, brother...
Great video, agree with most of what you said and obviously these guys are fools. No idea what they’re talking about and part of the reason for the image of Muslims.
But a question to Muhammad. At the end you say: In the Quran it says to follow the Injeel and Torah and you kinda imply that, that should be done. But isn’t the whole point that those books are corrupted and there is no point to them at all? Just like how the ahadeeth are corrupted and there is hardly/no point to them?
They did not even read their own hadeeths. They said that you need hadeeth to "explain/understand" the quran.. but guess what... When a hadeeth sounds ridiculous or does not make sense .. it is because "you just did not understand it" it's because of its context and blah blah. So you need to use "X book" to explain the "difficult Y book" and the "X book" is even more complicated than the "dofficult book".... And because both are difficult amd it seems that the sencond book failed to explained the x book... You meed a scolar because you're ignorant. Taraaaaa.... Worship my scholar.
If God asks you why did you not pray women. Tell him coz my imam said I shouldn't coz I am on my period. Said by mr scholar.
If I have a book and a dictionnary. And I need to read the dictionnary (million times bigger than the book amd its variations and explanations) then it's easier to read the "difficult short book" again and again and get more understanding of it gradually bit by bit as I read it.
Even if this decision is not the best. On the day of judgement. It's better to tell God "I did this because here is my own understanding of your verse Y ans Z". It waaay muchbetter than saying "I did thia because a person - not a prophet/ messenger certainly- said so... (It is clear who is my leader... For me to worship you I need my leader.. WITHOUT MY LEADER I CAN NOT BECOME A MUSLIM)
As if prophet abraham has a leader... The least a sunni can do is to read his so beloved hadeeths with a heart of a good person who can put himself in the shoes of others (dogs, non muslims, women, victims - of those who believe they can enter paradise through شفاعة) just be modest enough to read those hadeeths instead of hearing about them.
What physical activity? Where does it say in the Quran how to pray? Or how to make wudu?
Surah maidah ayah 6.
@@Biekoe how to pray?
may i ask u where you learnt your solat? 😅
Where did u learn ur slat?
the Quran, it tells us enough
@@Modelta😂😂😂
I don’t completely reject the hadiths but I think when you consider them too much, you inevitably will consider the Quran less. I mean, they call themselves, Sunnis, knowing that is a sect in the Quran says don’t divide yourself into sects
With this people don't use a normal conversation , you should be the one asking questions and you should be the one talking , you should shut them off or do not go and "debate" them .
You should use their odience and let them hear what you have to say .
You have to call me i like youre way of thinking.😂
How do you pray without hadiths? In the quran it mentions salah and zakat dozens upon dozens of times so how do you pray? Keep in mind the quran does not describe how to do salah
can we do one on the bible.....and how it connonised!
Assalamuailaikum brother, i just want to know if your a muslim or not
We know the Quran IS the word of God because he tells us how to tell many things irl. For example, how to tell who the disbelievers are. They do exactly what you’re doing… No matter what language you speak if God wills you to understand the Quran you will see it. ITS SO SIMPLE you don’t need to be a scholar to understand this basic simple detailed book 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The Quran is not sufficient. The Hadith are essential to Islam
@@blackpalacemusicare you Muslim? because that is a blatantly blasphemous statement.
Real muslims ALWAYS refer to the Qur'an. Ahlul Hadith (those who love hadiths the most) ALWAYS refer to hadiths such and such.
Code 19 rashid Khalifa problems: the miracle of 19 make the Quran true
Sunnis:sunnah of bukhari makes the Quran true
Quran alone Muslims: quran is true 💪
People were starting to believe when only 10 percent of the Quran was revealed and bukhari came 200 years after. How did those people know it’s from god when they only had 10 surah at the time
LOL, i need neither of the hadiths nor rashad's fraudulent code 19(he changed spellings and rejected Quran 9:128 and 9:129) to prove my faith.
@@asr2009 based 😎
Why reject Hadith my friend?
Which hadith after it will they believe?
Guess who said the above words?@@TheUnknownVeil
Muhammad id love to talk with you. I’m a Sunni Muslim would you be interested in talking with me?
but the sahaba had questions about the quran and asked the Prophet ﷺ. and everytime we have questions about it we see what he ﷺ said.
Thank you
At least you understand unlike him
@@osamahal-hubishi7809 yeah and he made videos about “early scholars” and they all studied what the Prophet ﷺ said as well. 1000 years ago!
@@xaviertr6240 it's better for us to follow the Qur'an and the prophet
@@osamahal-hubishi7809 You follow prophet by following Qur'an.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah But the companions asked him questions as well when they were not sure about the Quran. Like the verse on hitting wives.
This question troubles me. Why the ahadith are not compiled in writing and authenticated by the first four caliphs?
Furthermore, it was reported that the second caliph said “Quran is enough for us”.
And the most worrying issue for me is the statement in the Quran by our prophet pbuh that his ummah neglected the Quran.
the hadith were not authenticated by the first four caliphs bc they all knew the prophet personally, so they simply spread what they have heard. and the second caliph only said that in a specific context that you for some reason left out
May Allah punish these hadith worshippers. They mislead so many people
Why not leave a link yo the orignal video instead of cutting it and putting it out in such a subjective manner..
Im sure people are intelligent enough to come to the right conclusion themselves..
Because of bias. He wants to show his audience what he wants
what bias, the video is clear but the eyes are blind.
Hipocrite he just showing How hipocrite mushrikuns ur sects are yeah people Can see only ur sect cant see Becouse u refuse to see it
Primary source should always be the quran and not the sources that are made by scholars like ijma qiyas and fatwas all made up things that has got nothing to do with quran and even hadith.
People can follow hadith if they want at the same time reject it because following hadith is not mandatory allah never mentioned to follow hadith even if sunnis say this no Its not true allah never said this but still history is important we can check and reject that is also possible.
The prophet who brought the quran he was following torah which is why we always see quran and hadith is always against each other there maybe some truth there.
Instead of fighting with every sect we should just discuss with each other to come to the truth and we should always put the quran first and not make hadith a primary source.
Actually the quran is allahs arabic and not the arabs arabic which is why they still cant find meanings we need to learn meaning of the words that we dont understand from the quran.
We should not fight with eachother quran only and sunnis they have the same attitude towards each other they just label each other instead of discussing which is not good.
لا يوجد حديث بعدد الركعات ولا بماذا تقول في الصلاة بالتفصيل من التكبير الى التسليم
I get both sides. How was the Quran preserved? By a group of men - who were ordained by Allah (swt)). That does not mean Allah (swt) had anything to do with the hadith written by the same men.
My Lord there is no god other than you. My Lord protect me from devils guide me in the right path
There behaviour alone convinces me I only need the Quran
So you don’t pray 5 times a day?
Brother you should not nourish yourself from this Chajara, the fruit is poison
Answer this question please:
Is it not the case that the same people from who we learned the Quran these same people also participated in transferring the Hadith?
Because if this is the case, we should trust the chains and or at least not disrespect the people who participated in remembering the words of the prophet. What btw is done out of love for him.
The Hafs copy of the Qur'an which was transmitted from Abu Bakr 'Asim is used by about 90 - 95% of the Muslim world! However, he was WEAK in hadeeth! And you say BOTH the Qur'an and Hadeeth were transmitted by the same people???
Let that sink in...
@@negeto2460 would this be a problem? That we have distinctive speciality? It would be weird if this was not the case…
@@MohamedSherifQexactly! DISTINCTIVE - which means the Qur'an and hadeeth were NOT transmitted the same way!
@@negeto2460 but this is known. The prophet peace and blessing did say that we should not write down the sayings of the prophet, because otherwise it would be not possible to make distinction. Or it would be possible that it would be difficult for us to separate this two realities.
but imam al shafii did live during the mutazilites and he even debated hafs al fard حفص الفرد but u said shafii came 200 years after the mutazillites ?
also rumzi is annoying here
It's really simple: God made a promise to preserve the Qur'an, but God did not make any promises to preserve any texts beyond the Qur'an. Nonbelievers can question the fundamental validity of that promise all they like because they're questioning the very existence of God, too. But a believing Muslim can't question that promise by God to preserve the Qur'an, because it's fundamental to Islam as religion. That is indeed a circular argument but that is not a problem at all within the framework of religion, the framework that believers operate in.
It's a question only a disbeliever would present, because the answer is not one of anything but pure belief. Either you accept the Qur'an as the word of God based on belief, or you reject it based on disbelief.
Those guys are confusing the frameworks of belief and objective reasoning. Many questions of faith can be analysed within the framework of reason, but some questions of faith have answers that depend on belief and nothing but belief.
That's kind of what the whole concept of RELIGION is about: faith and belief. Questions that have objective evidence-based answers (like in science) do not require belief, only acknowledgement of the evidence and the conclusions drawn from it. It's very different from belief and faith.
And these questions just happen to reveal the true disbelievers and hypocrites. Or they might be mushriks, if they admit to holding the hadith on the same level as the Qur'an and thus elevating their scholars as partners to God. Because God never promised to protect anything else than the Qur'an.
Dawah over dunya guy and his sidekick are annoying, this was such a waste of time 😂😅