WHOLOCK - Sherlock meets The Doctor!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 12. 2013
  • "Months after an encounter with a mysterious 'Doctor', Sherlock becomes obsessed with discovering more about this impossible man... until the man makes an unexpected return."
    For future video updates, you can like me on Facebook at / johnsmithvfx
    Watch the VFX Breakdown here: • Wholock - VFX Breakdown
    In anticipation of both the Doctor Who Christmas Special and the Third Series of Sherlock, I created a small crossover story. Though it may not be perfect, I'm still pretty happy with the results.
    Hope you enjoy!
  • Krátké a kreslené filmy

Komentáře • 24K

  • @alphyy3107
    @alphyy3107 Před 3 lety +3796

    Sherlock experiences being a Watson in a situation for the first time in his life.

    • @GoldPrince2468
      @GoldPrince2468 Před 3 lety +154

      An odd way of saying The Doctor finally gets to be a companion.

    • @rganvg
      @rganvg Před 3 lety +86

      Elementary, my dear Sherlock

    • @Gustav-lj1wb
      @Gustav-lj1wb Před 2 lety +50

      @@GoldPrince2468 that’s the opposite of what he’s saying

    • @ajboysen1
      @ajboysen1 Před 2 lety +56

      We all know it'd be a constant bickering of who's the companion

    • @alphyy3107
      @alphyy3107 Před 2 lety +56

      @@ajboysen1 I think it would be pretty clear whose the companion. doctor is just on a whole different level of intelligence

  • @vootoonn
    @vootoonn Před 3 lety +3380

    Watson after they left:
    "I'm a doctor too :( "

  • @rasputinjesus
    @rasputinjesus Před 3 lety +3647

    I still can’t believe how well the editing holds up considering this was made in 2013.

  • @Cahoonap
    @Cahoonap Před 3 lety +2588

    this would have been the most epic cross over in history. Imagine the views and money it would bring in, simply explosive.

    • @spoons4414
      @spoons4414 Před 2 lety +120

      I hate to rain on the parade but it would kill Sherlock off as a show.
      Sherlock is about everything having a rational and logical explanation. Every detail is because this happened this way. No other way. The doctor being apart of Sherlocks universe ruins that by simply being oh it could be aliens.
      It would ruin Sherlock and do nothing for doctor who. As much as I’d love a cross over, it would ruin the shows

    • @elvina1622
      @elvina1622 Před 2 lety +10

      @@spoons4414 yea, good point

    • @yusufkhan-ig7dv
      @yusufkhan-ig7dv Před 2 lety +39

      @@spoons4414 They could've done something for Children in Need though!

    • @theimortal1974
      @theimortal1974 Před 2 lety +25

      imagine the two nemesis joining forces. moriarty and the master vs sherlock and the doctor.

    • @benjamansharer7969
      @benjamansharer7969 Před rokem +19

      @@theimortal1974 what if Moriarty and The Master was one and the same?

  • @darudexx3099
    @darudexx3099 Před 4 lety +4543

    When two of the most brilliant students in your class work on a project together

    • @speeddemon5339
      @speeddemon5339 Před 3 lety +30

      You call me to kill em. And if I don’t kill em you get your money back.

    • @PatitoBandito
      @PatitoBandito Před 3 lety +12

      I must know the name of the man responsible for these legends

    • @speeddemon5339
      @speeddemon5339 Před 3 lety +2

      ꧁ Pîxełs Atâmâ꧂ no it’s an edit.

    • @Boo-px8bx
      @Boo-px8bx Před 3 lety +5

      And one of their kinder and friendlier friends is stuck at the back like a third wheel

    • @warewolf2747
      @warewolf2747 Před 3 lety +1

      Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

  • @himayamata
    @himayamata Před 7 lety +9112

    Sherlock + Doctor Who = Doctor Strange
    "Dormammu, I've come to bargain."

    • @himayamata
      @himayamata Před 7 lety +85

      Von Wicked "Dormammu, I've come to bargain."

    • @himayamata
      @himayamata Před 7 lety +67

      Von Wicked "Dormammu, I've come to bargain."

    • @himayamata
      @himayamata Před 7 lety +64

      Von Wicked "Dormammu! I've come to bargain!"

    • @himayamata
      @himayamata Před 7 lety +58

      Von Wicked "No. I've come to bargain, Dormammu. Nothing else."

    • @himayamata
      @himayamata Před 7 lety +53

      Von Wicked "No. Not an illusion. I have something from my world. TIME."

  • @leena2498
    @leena2498 Před 2 lety +1426

    This video blew my mind 8 years ago, I was just fascinated by the quality and thought it was a real promo back then. After I found out it was an edit I began to learn composing and editing to recreate same stuff. Now, 8 years later, those skills provided me a full-time job. Thank you, John Smith, you're amazing!

    • @k.w.689
      @k.w.689 Před rokem +17

      This the so cool! Wow!!! Congratulations ❣️

    • @Cloudworld2912
      @Cloudworld2912 Před rokem +9

      Esa es una historia de origen brutal

    • @ScoobyandShaggy5554
      @ScoobyandShaggy5554 Před rokem +5

      Amazing, congrats

    • @AlexKuz
      @AlexKuz Před rokem +12

      WOW! This comment made me feel miserable and proud at the same time. How did you even do that? Well done, mr or mrs, I'm so glad for you

    • @ChristianProtossDragoon
      @ChristianProtossDragoon Před rokem +4

      Good

  • @rayzermaniac5218
    @rayzermaniac5218 Před 2 lety +469

    The worst part about all this is the fact that the same people were in charge of both programmes and a crossover would have easily been a possibility. Imagine a Christmas special of Sherlock and Doctor Who, with the other showing up in each others shows. Sherlock and Watson help fight off a Dalek Invasion of Earth in the year 5000 and The Doctor and Clara helped solve the mystery of a Crime spree spearheaded by Moriarty in London. Someone give Big Finish a call.

    • @ChristianProtossDragoon
      @ChristianProtossDragoon Před rokem +5

      Yup

    • @nadiahapsari3359
      @nadiahapsari3359 Před rokem +22

      That sounds too...mediocre...(?)
      I think something like Sherlock helping the Doctor with his deduction & observation skills while being complemented with the doctor's knowledge of alien lives sounds more fun.Something like a mystery/conspiracy/murder mystery in space.
      And it should be fun to see Sherlock theorize about weird things like "the impossible girl".

    • @8LiterallyJustTheNumber8
      @8LiterallyJustTheNumber8 Před rokem +10

      It would make no sense, there have been endless references to both Arthur Conan Doyle and the existence of the Sherlock mythos throughout Doctor Who's history. The Doctor has even dressed in Sherlock costumes numerous times in reference to the character. Sherlock is a work of fiction in the Doctor Who universe. It wouldn't make sense for Sherlock to be a beloved fictional character created by Arthur Conan Doyle and also a real person living in the 20th century.

    • @Videogeek95
      @Videogeek95 Před rokem

      @@8LiterallyJustTheNumber8 Hi, I'm Rose Tyler... I'm currently sucking the face of the clone of some alien I fell in love with in a different universe I was born in...

    • @8LiterallyJustTheNumber8
      @8LiterallyJustTheNumber8 Před rokem +3

      @@Videogeek95 What?

  • @damiancaling1239
    @damiancaling1239 Před 4 lety +7717

    Sherlock: who are you
    Doctor: I’m the doctor
    Sherlock: Doctor who
    Doctor: Doctor strange

  • @diko1061
    @diko1061 Před 5 lety +5487

    "Shut up"
    "I know"
    The most British conversation

    • @hazeltree7738
      @hazeltree7738 Před 4 lety +128

      Nah it's
      "Hi"
      "Sorry!"

    • @iktanmiztonton3477
      @iktanmiztonton3477 Před 4 lety +21

      @@hazeltree7738 isn't that the most Canadian conversation?

    • @hazeltree7738
      @hazeltree7738 Před 4 lety +43

      @@iktanmiztonton3477 Well I'm British and hitting a table causes me to instinctively say "Sorry!" so...

    • @xXRagingShadowXx12345
      @xXRagingShadowXx12345 Před 4 lety +10

      Doctor strange meets doctor who

    • @ed3nn497
      @ed3nn497 Před 4 lety +30

      @@hazeltree7738 okay I'm glad I'm not the only one who apologises to inanimate objects because i bumped into them

  • @louisanimals6135
    @louisanimals6135 Před 3 lety +209

    I just realised this wasn’t actually acted out it was just insane editing

  • @joshgames719
    @joshgames719 Před 2 lety +272

    This looks like BBC actually recorded this and merged Sherlock Holmes with Doctor who it looks so real well except from the cutting around the doctor but you dont really notice it until about 3mins in the tardis very well done

  • @thepoppets1052
    @thepoppets1052 Před 4 lety +5396

    The most alien human and the most human alien, a duo to *FEAR*

    • @0623kaboom
      @0623kaboom Před 4 lety +39

      the doctor is only half human .... on his mothers side

    • @G.F.SF55
      @G.F.SF55 Před 4 lety +54

      @@0623kaboom no he's not

    • @percytrinidad4715
      @percytrinidad4715 Před 4 lety +34

      @@0623kaboom why are you making a star trek joke here?

    • @warachnid1569
      @warachnid1569 Před 4 lety +6

      He is half human? The hybrid?

    • @hellothere2052
      @hellothere2052 Před 4 lety +17

      0623kaboom we, we do not talk about that

  • @mkg2124
    @mkg2124 Před 3 lety +3147

    The Doctor is going to be pretty annoyed when he finds out Sherlock's knowledge on the solar system.

    • @randomstranger6577
      @randomstranger6577 Před 3 lety +106

      i completely forgot about that thank you so much for reminding me of what an idiot our boy is

    • @brandfordarthur2006
      @brandfordarthur2006 Před 3 lety +32

      Our boy is truly an idiot😂😂😂

    • @fastcar544
      @fastcar544 Před 3 lety +45

      Actually he did solve the last case of s1e3 with his knowledge of the solar system

    • @beepster8802
      @beepster8802 Před 3 lety +35

      "I had to delete something"

    • @suzannelemieux3357
      @suzannelemieux3357 Před 3 lety +33

      And to think Sherlock thought it was useless trivia...

  • @sarahbee3d
    @sarahbee3d Před 2 lety +174

    I watched this when it came out and I was so so stunned. Now I’m a post production and vfx student and now I’m EVEN MORE IMPRESSED. This must have taken so much work, and i’m so full of admiration for you.

    • @Kaneggic
      @Kaneggic Před 2 lety +13

      And the fact it was made in 2013 is even more impressive

    • @enzothepalekid
      @enzothepalekid Před 5 měsíci

      yeah me too, I've been learning VFX self taught for a while and this is so amazing. The rotoscoping, the custom (ai generated?) voice lines, everything.

  • @zebjavid2900
    @zebjavid2900 Před rokem +100

    I cannot believe I've never seen this before. I'm a huge fan of Doctor who and Sherlock, so even though I thought this video is probably going to be a typical fan service/ crossover type thing, I have to say, I was so very wrong. I can't believe that this video was made almost a decade ago. The time and genius effort gone into making this is just perfection. I don't think there is a single Doctor who and Sherlock fan who wouldn't have gone bonkers over an actual episode of these two characters brought together like this. Sherlock's realisation of the enormity of so much more out there than what he knows. Finding out that not only do aliens exist but one could match to his own intelligence or maybe even surpass it. And the Doctor excited to have a legendary detective as a companion for a journey. Both of them trying to one up on each other in intelligence. Sherlock at times being unimpressed by the Doctor's penchant for youthful playfulness. The Doctor pulling Sherlock on his arrogance, but ultimately having the time of their lives and forming a bond of mutual respect. Now that would be a magical episode. But thank you from the bottom of my heart to the person who made this video, you sir deserve much respect for your ability of coming up with this idea and for actualizing it. Well done.

  • @joycehoebeke9327
    @joycehoebeke9327 Před 5 lety +7258

    For a moment I panicked I had missed a complete episode

  • @navebushes5717
    @navebushes5717 Před 4 lety +2439

    BBC: Write that down, write that down!

    • @hayaj8782
      @hayaj8782 Před 4 lety +27

      YOU RESPECT ME

    • @Dbusdriver71
      @Dbusdriver71 Před 4 lety +23

      Definitely write that down. The inferred premise shown here is brilliant. but not as a ride a long; the set up for a case that needs to be solved.

    • @noahthompson2912
      @noahthompson2912 Před 4 lety +12

      Step . away . from . the . notepad !

    • @elliehoward1992
      @elliehoward1992 Před 4 lety +19

      Why did I read this in Mycroft's voice?

    • @Dbusdriver71
      @Dbusdriver71 Před 4 lety +2

      @@elliehoward1992 Why stop there. Make Mycroft the DR.!

  • @volodymyrzelensky-ish6070
    @volodymyrzelensky-ish6070 Před 2 lety +50

    WE NEED A FULL SERIES OF WHOLOCK PLEASE 🥺
    john's face, in the end, is like I lost my best friend

  • @ScatteredCollector
    @ScatteredCollector Před 2 lety +162

    I remember when I stumbled upon this 7 years ago, my mind was blown. Still is. Such an amazingly well edited video

    • @Bruh-zx2mc
      @Bruh-zx2mc Před rokem +2

      Reminder that this guy now works for the Beeb and created the S11 Doctor Who intro visuals.

    • @ScatteredCollector
      @ScatteredCollector Před rokem +2

      @@Bruh-zx2mc I honestly didn’t know this! That’s so cool

  • @ZilkenianDagger
    @ZilkenianDagger Před 8 lety +399

    I love how a lot of people are all going "uh, this is fake, look the mouths!". Can't we just stop for a moment and contemplate how f*cking epic this is?

    • @StevenjFrank
      @StevenjFrank Před 8 lety +3

      +ZilkenianDagger wait, call me dull, but it IS fake, though. Right? it visually looks off, but still visually amazing.

    • @ZilkenianDagger
      @ZilkenianDagger Před 8 lety +5

      Steven j. Frank Yes is fake, he did it, but is still epic.

    • @waycomp2002
      @waycomp2002 Před 8 lety +6

      +Steven j. Frank of course it's fake but still cool

    • @Dracouto5972
      @Dracouto5972 Před 8 lety +2

      You're right. It's really awesome

    • @blackdragonstory1122
      @blackdragonstory1122 Před 8 lety

      +ZilkenianDagger Well it fooled me,but just because I really wanted to see a sherlock/doctor who episode :P

  • @BeatsByKabuto
    @BeatsByKabuto Před 5 lety +3835

    Marvel: Avengers infinity war is the most ambitious crossover.
    The doctor: *hold my screwdriver*

    • @sahatlst8708
      @sahatlst8708 Před 5 lety +74

      *Hold my fez.*

    • @carlvonstrauss2107
      @carlvonstrauss2107 Před 5 lety +4

      @@sahatlst8708 Good show.

    • @melonmode4128
      @melonmode4128 Před 5 lety +17

      Can you imagine the doctor drunk though 😂

    • @addie6546
      @addie6546 Před 5 lety +1

      @@sahatlst8708 yes

    • @addie6546
      @addie6546 Před 5 lety +7

      @@melonmode4128 Girl in the fireplace episode. he pretended to be drunk... So i guess its the closest thing we will see

  • @harry.t9523
    @harry.t9523 Před rokem +20

    Imagine if the BBC actually made this an official TV special crossover. It’s a bit late now, but it would have been amazing, especially to see both these characters play off of each other.

  • @playgamepark
    @playgamepark Před rokem +30

    Eight years later this is still a masterpiece that is only being able to be replicated today.

  • @CoolStuffHere2011
    @CoolStuffHere2011 Před 4 lety +3255

    Holy shit, for a second there I was thinking "Did I miss an episode??", the editing on this is BRILLIANT!

  • @ilikemusic2773
    @ilikemusic2773 Před 5 lety +1711

    This would make the most unstoppable duo in the history of everything

    • @jessxd1165
      @jessxd1165 Před 4 lety +66

      A genius + a genius = unstoppable

    • @chaoticarticlion3058
      @chaoticarticlion3058 Před 4 lety +49

      Add in Doctor Strange
      Now it’s the unstoppable trio

    • @yes2623
      @yes2623 Před 4 lety +7

      @@chaoticarticlion3058 lol yeah

    • @darthgandalf9485
      @darthgandalf9485 Před 4 lety +18

      tbh theyd just collapse into mass murdering maniacs and get themselves killed because of it

    • @kevin62125
      @kevin62125 Před 4 lety +13

      Poor watson

  • @evoailo
    @evoailo Před 5 měsíci +4

    This video had 13-year-old me in an iron grip

  • @botz77
    @botz77 Před 3 lety +13

    "Give me a name."
    "Aren't your parents supposed to do that?"

  • @baders087
    @baders087 Před 5 lety +3938

    If Amy Pond was in the TARDIS too, she’d be like:
    “Doctor Strange?”
    “Nebula?”

  • @underlipetx
    @underlipetx Před 3 lety +1076

    6 years later and this just makes me really miss the way they use to do music in their shows.

    • @underlipetx
      @underlipetx Před 3 lety +4

      d not gonna argue with you, you have an opinion and so do I.

    • @underlipetx
      @underlipetx Před 3 lety +7

      d I will answer your question, they would be Murray Gold and the BBC orchestra of wales.

    • @lemonjinxxy
      @lemonjinxxy Před 3 lety +18

      @@laurencelong It's not even that, but comparing just the music of Pre-Chibnal to Post-Chibnal is a certain downgrade. Unless you like spaceShipAmbience1, spcaceShipAmbience2, spaceShitAmbience3 and whatever non-instrumental/pop song you can fit in.

    • @lexcas479
      @lexcas479 Před 3 lety +17

      Seriously, I can't believe they took out the orchestra, it was such a big part of the show, I believe. The characters had theme songs that would be played, songs would represent mood and emotion. It added so much to the show

    • @cloudst1472
      @cloudst1472 Před 3 lety +1

      ​@@lexcas479 Perhaps the orchestra was a big part of the show but if you look at Doctor Who, pre-orchestra, 2005 to be exact when it returned, the show had a lot of good, memorable tracks featuring synths and samples which help give it that early 2000's feel type of music. The score from 2005 is still mostly unreleased to this day since most of it was re-recorded for the 2006 Doctor Who Series 1-2 album for some reason. Murray Gold did some truly excellent work without an orchestra in series 1 and I still think it's some of the finest music produced by the show to this day. There are people out there who seem to think that you need an orchestra to make great music but that's not necessary always true if you look at Christopher Ecclestons series, in particular two parter, Bad Wolf and The Parting of the Ways. I was a bit taken back when Jack returned without his iconic theme but since it was Ben Foster who truly gave him a theme in Torchwood and Murray Gold used elements from it in Doctor Who from time to time when Jack appeared, a new theme was written by Segun Akinola
      which felt a bit out of place.

  • @vivichan7012
    @vivichan7012 Před 2 lety +79

    This is absolutely *BRILLIANT!* I thought it’s a real crossover. You have mad editing skills. 👏🏻

  • @Noah-wx7fm
    @Noah-wx7fm Před 2 lety +29

    I remember watching this before watching either Sherlock or Doctor who and thinking this was real, now visiting it after is extremely hilarious

  • @shrek7312
    @shrek7312 Před 3 lety +3572

    this guy should be winning an award for this level of editing, you almost had me fooled there.

    • @towerbunga
      @towerbunga Před 2 lety +96

      The only thing hat breaks it is the weird way the doctors face looks at some points

    • @astgfrallah771
      @astgfrallah771 Před 2 lety +4

      Mashallah

    • @MrKrimson
      @MrKrimson Před 2 lety +26

      i watched this 8 years ago, and back then, the sam eway older folk may find the n64 realistic whilst we find that hard to believe - i found this so fucking realistic i didnt even notice the doctors face

    • @JillianRigsby
      @JillianRigsby Před 2 lety

      💯

    • @jordanmcbride9893
      @jordanmcbride9893 Před rokem +6

      I agree although the comment about the face of sherlock looking wierd is also on point along with the the eyes of the doctor while talking to sherlock. If you aren't looking for anything wrong you would likely believe this was an actual episode of Doctor who.

  • @danny00plays
    @danny00plays Před 4 lety +746

    Actually thought this was real for a bit.
    Right until the doctor started repeating some of his iconic lines.

    • @9Glaedr0
      @9Glaedr0 Před 4 lety +28

      Mine was when the Doctor was looking to the side instead of Holmes' face while having a conversation.

  • @pattychamberlin7883
    @pattychamberlin7883 Před 9 měsíci +11

    What an adventure the Doctor and Sherlock could have. I’d sure love to see that.

  • @cairocanary7706
    @cairocanary7706 Před 2 lety +21

    The way they move and how the place fades in with them makes it look like it's a virtual game where you can pick the choices,it's beyond cool,amazing

  • @riu-bi5709
    @riu-bi5709 Před 5 lety +1041

    Doctor: *Peeks out*
    Sherlock: Who are you?
    Doctor: *closes door*

    • @bangerbangerbro
      @bangerbangerbro Před 5 lety +12

      Like when speaking to animal

    • @zoelawrence6390
      @zoelawrence6390 Před 5 lety +12

      mood

    • @jamieg-q2243
      @jamieg-q2243 Před 5 lety +32

      I was hoping Sherlock would say “Well that was awfully rude.” Or something to that extent

    • @mrhegarty179
      @mrhegarty179 Před 5 lety +4

      “Not today Satan”

    • @leebronwen6125
      @leebronwen6125 Před 4 lety +7

      I've never related to the Doctor more than that moment. Literally me whenever my Mum asks about homework

  • @Hitendra_Kawale
    @Hitendra_Kawale Před 3 lety +5892

    Can we all just take a moment to appreciate the edit and efforts this guy has made

    • @KariIzumi1
      @KariIzumi1 Před 3 lety +25

      Facts! 👏👏👏

    • @Onewytlyter
      @Onewytlyter Před 3 lety +12

      Yes!!

    • @Gundam_JAY
      @Gundam_JAY Před 3 lety +7

      Most definitely 👍

    • @luciddream5055
      @luciddream5055 Před 3 lety +52

      Wait..This is edited??!

    • @KB-lp7ik
      @KB-lp7ik Před 3 lety +22

      Exactly, instead of tearing down the obvious just appreciate the possibility if those two great minds have ever met

  • @Scotsmen
    @Scotsmen Před rokem +8

    3:18 That interaction was so natural, it's unbelievable!

  • @basmalakhaled3048
    @basmalakhaled3048 Před 3 lety +11

    Whoever the creator is this is some fucking effort I can’t even imagine omg the editing- oh my gosh-

    • @boooster101
      @boooster101 Před 2 lety

      Dude spent probably weeks just removing the artifacts...

  • @hotrodjmanofficial448
    @hotrodjmanofficial448 Před 3 lety +1323

    "And still be back in time for tea."
    Tell that to Rory and Amy. And Mickey. And... basically any companion ever.

    • @vasudevraghav2109
      @vasudevraghav2109 Před 3 lety +47

      Doctor never cared for mickey, because he saw mickey as trouble while he slowly approached rose.
      But to be fair, neither did rose😂

    • @ozoravalda
      @ozoravalda Před 3 lety +18

      And Adric, who of my first crushes and the 1st character I loved who dies. Yes as a now 50 old American, it was Dr. Who who first taught me about death, love, doing the right thing and above all... “Never let me talk!” I Will talk you into doing the right thing.

    • @bratlett
      @bratlett Před 3 lety +9

      And Sarah Jane when he took her home to “South Croydon”!!

    • @mkg2124
      @mkg2124 Před 3 lety +13

      They never came back for tea...

    • @HopeAuq
      @HopeAuq Před 3 lety +3

      Katarina and Adric never came back for tea

  • @Lamar154
    @Lamar154 Před 5 lety +2241

    This explains how Sherlock survived the fall

  • @greenshirt2077
    @greenshirt2077 Před rokem +10

    I watched this thinking it was fairly new due to how incredible the editing is- only to find out this was made 8 years ago? That right there knocked my metaphorical socks off. Well done.
    Everything about this could have been an impeccable crossover episode. There was so much unsaid backstory in so little time. It’s a shame that this was never the case considering Torchwood is sort of canon in Sherlock. (Unless it was just a throwaway easter egg in which case that would be quite the disappointment.)

    • @greenshirt2077
      @greenshirt2077 Před rokem

      Now I’m just thinking about how 8 years ago, 14 year old me would have killed for this crossover.

  • @TaroZak
    @TaroZak Před 3 měsíci +2

    Recommended again, 10 years later. Still just as amazing 🙌

  • @kirstenchidrome2131
    @kirstenchidrome2131 Před 5 lety +1390

    Somebody. Hire this person. Now.
    This was exquisite.

    • @tcoopervader7829
      @tcoopervader7829 Před 4 lety +8

      NOW!

    • @tcoopervader7829
      @tcoopervader7829 Před 4 lety +4

      @Playlist Person Were is he in our stuff list I don't see him there (sorry I hope I wrote everything right I'm not from the USA or UK.)

    • @sharonlynnh.1951
      @sharonlynnh.1951 Před 4 lety +11

      I was like how did we (my sister & I) missed this episode of Dr. Who or PBS Sherlock (perplexed). Yes, very "clever" editing and it flows well together. Awesome, nicely done!!

    • @sherlock2359
      @sherlock2359 Před 4 lety +10

      But you missed one thing.. From 1:42 - 1:46, the cars which are blurred move backwards.

    • @jadendaslayeryt7066
      @jadendaslayeryt7066 Před 4 lety +3

      @@sherlock2359 lol. Thanks sherlock for your remarkable observation. Don't know how I missed it.

  • @elias5558
    @elias5558 Před 5 lety +2677

    This is the most British video I've ever seen

    • @user-xt7el4nm7p
      @user-xt7el4nm7p Před 5 lety +21

      bon cucumber

    • @evelynkenrick3692
      @evelynkenrick3692 Před 5 lety +10

      Yasssssssssss! Long live the queen! 🇬🇧

    • @identity9590
      @identity9590 Před 5 lety +16

      Random commenter: "This is the most British Video I've ever seen"
      Other random commenter: "Hold my cuppa"
      czcams.com/video/kSjFVH2Zc5E/video.html

    • @melonmode4128
      @melonmode4128 Před 5 lety +8

      Not enough colonisation and tea.

    • @mariefoxy8928
      @mariefoxy8928 Před 5 lety +3

      Hey lucifer how’s Chloe, maze,detective douche and trixie 😂😂

  • @rozibelaya
    @rozibelaya Před 2 lety +46

    Так же прекрасно как и 7 лет назад ❤️
    Конечно чувствуется эффект "зловеще долины"
    Но за такую коллаборацию это простительно

    • @elenapark5153
      @elenapark5153 Před 2 lety

      Простите, вы не знаете где можно это посмотреть?

    • @rozibelaya
      @rozibelaya Před 2 lety

      @@elenapark5153 czcams.com/video/TyDR6ldcTNc/video.html
      czcams.com/video/YZFi775-eLw/video.html
      czcams.com/video/p6wllFEuRWk/video.html

    • @bruh-ch3hb
      @bruh-ch3hb Před rokem

      @@elenapark5153 нигде, это просто видеомонтаж от фаната

  • @maiseyolleh
    @maiseyolleh Před 2 lety +12

    John is to Sherlock as Mickey is to Rose
    I always come back to this video every now and then for the nostalgia trip. Still can't believe how good this looks, even today it's pretty well done.

  • @kowberry
    @kowberry Před 7 lety +752

    And This is How Sherlock became Dr. Strange huh! The Ultimate Journey Beginssss...

    • @ryanwhiteman9184
      @ryanwhiteman9184 Před 7 lety +46

      Kuber Sodari. or how Sherlock learnt he's a reincarnation of the Doctor who just so happened to lose his watch

    • @kowberry
      @kowberry Před 7 lety +10

      hhhmmm.... possible fact though

    • @yousef3527
      @yousef3527 Před 7 lety +1

      Kuber Sodari 😂😂😂😂

    • @dank_100
      @dank_100 Před 7 lety +2

      lol

    • @mohamedfarah3280
      @mohamedfarah3280 Před 6 lety +5

      stop fucking with my head

  • @Theemptythroneistaken
    @Theemptythroneistaken Před 4 lety +395

    The difference in intelligence would be a massive blow to Sherlock’s Ego.

    • @rossoakley8900
      @rossoakley8900 Před 4 lety +4

      Darth Nihilus I though dr who was an idiot (reference *i think?)

    • @John_Smith76
      @John_Smith76 Před 4 lety +39

      The doctor got a 900 year headstart. It's not fair.

    • @will6330
      @will6330 Před 3 lety +66

      In all fairness, Sherlock would impress the doctor.
      Like they get onto a planet, Sherlock deduces the whole thing whilst the doctor just flaps his hands around

    • @wify0241
      @wify0241 Před 3 lety +15

      @@rossoakley8900 I feel like the doctor couldn’t work with him to big an ego to little moral compass to little chances to have fun

    • @gildahobbs8829
      @gildahobbs8829 Před 3 lety +18

      Sherlock: *doesn't know earth orbits the sun*
      The Doctor: I've done it again, picked another stupid ape

  • @SkitSkat674
    @SkitSkat674 Před 3 lety +24

    I've watched this so many times and it's still just brilliant.

  • @WampUsThyLampUs2654
    @WampUsThyLampUs2654 Před rokem +7

    In the many years I've watched doctor who, and this fantastic edit, this has to the best TARDIS de-materialization of them all. Such an elegant disappearance that outlines the body and complements the text that would be the last thing seen. Such a great job! I also watched the VFX breakdown and that was incredibly interesting to see.

  • @dougw9239
    @dougw9239 Před 3 lety +699

    I know this was fan made almost 8 years ago, and hats off to the editor, we still need a movie or mini series of this.

  • @malkiv13
    @malkiv13 Před 4 lety +869

    If this were real is watch the hell out of it. I want an entire series of this.

    • @jimmyha2050
      @jimmyha2050 Před 4 lety +10

      spot on better than the episodes on TV.

    • @DustyStarrs
      @DustyStarrs Před 4 lety +3

      Sameee

    • @mathiasbttger980
      @mathiasbttger980 Před 4 lety +9

      I would want 10 seasons of this. With Matt Smith and Benedict Cumberbatch

    • @sarahnightwing2936
      @sarahnightwing2936 Před 4 lety +3

      Me toooo! This would be such a WIN! ✌

    • @robmarrin6720
      @robmarrin6720 Před 4 lety +1

      I'm glad I've looked at your comment I was literally going to scour the interbent looking for the lost episode,, but hell yes what a series it would have been,, one for the future

  • @Classheroes
    @Classheroes Před 2 lety +4

    That us absolutely incredible. It's just so well done. The effects work, the editing, and the vision to tell that story using existing footage and... well, however else it was done. Simply amazing.

  • @link2jr
    @link2jr Před 2 lety +4

    This is EXCEPTIONAL work! You should be proud, this is a great story and beautiful execution.

  • @duomaxwel1567
    @duomaxwel1567 Před 5 lety +564

    Two things.
    1. Sherlock just said shut up making the scene funny.
    2. Book, movie, or tv series I don’t care we need this as a real thing.

  • @ManuelEspinozaBronyAnimeFan
    @ManuelEspinozaBronyAnimeFan Před 8 lety +801

    BBC needs to give us this crossover *throws money* I want this now!

  • @currykingwurst6393
    @currykingwurst6393 Před 2 lety +6

    Just watched this again after so many years and it's amazing to see that it got 10 million views now and people are still discovering it.

  • @cherylpowell353
    @cherylpowell353 Před rokem +2

    Doctor: closes door, Sherlock: completely not worried about getting kidnapped.

    • @cherylpowell353
      @cherylpowell353 Před rokem

      I know it's the Doctor but Sherlock didn't know that.

  • @GrimmSmile
    @GrimmSmile Před 3 lety +1680

    they should seriously make this a real spinoff. This would be EPIC

    • @GrimmSmile
      @GrimmSmile Před 3 lety +13

      @d well thats your opinion~ I believe it would epic tho~

    • @ameliakrobensondariccha3714
      @ameliakrobensondariccha3714 Před 3 lety +8

      @@GrimmSmile I know you said this a month ago, but I think it would be brilliant, yeah? Nice little event for the telly.

    • @GrimmSmile
      @GrimmSmile Před 3 lety +2

      @@ameliakrobensondariccha3714 it would be epiccccccc

    • @guerilla2663
      @guerilla2663 Před 3 lety +4

      They can't, Sherlock Holmes is a fictive character in the Doctor Who universe

    • @vince-od1sz
      @vince-od1sz Před 3 lety +25

      @@guerilla2663 so was robin hood-

  • @luxfyre
    @luxfyre Před 4 lety +1175

    Sherlock: Who are you?
    Doctor: I'm the doctor.
    Sherlock: The doctor... strange. What a strange name.

    • @bitty4994
      @bitty4994 Před 4 lety +14

      Please tell me that there was a great joke laced through this comment....
      ( yes I see it)

    • @luxfyre
      @luxfyre Před 4 lety +7

      Omg I've never gotten this amount of likes before thx guys

    • @Vissievisvis200
      @Vissievisvis200 Před 4 lety +5

      Its all conected 🧐

    • @alfredhutchinson6566
      @alfredhutchinson6566 Před 4 lety

      @@Vissievisvis200 connected
      June 2020
      B'dos, WI

    • @gandyf2296
      @gandyf2296 Před 4 lety +1

      DOCTOR STRANGE UWU

  • @jameswheeler6079
    @jameswheeler6079 Před 2 měsíci +1

    I love this video! Sherlock is my favorite! I know there's a whole lot of clips added and this whole thing was edited, but, I still love it to this day!

  • @spatenflosse
    @spatenflosse Před rokem +7

    This is the crossover we didn't know we needed but now we need it

  • @NimbusFilmsOfficial
    @NimbusFilmsOfficial Před 10 lety +1883

    Save for some obvious keying and uncanny facial composting, this was ridiculously well edited together.

  • @bludstanes
    @bludstanes Před 6 lety +933

    Holy shit this is impressive. If I didn't recognize the scenes from each series I would totally think this was legit.

    • @stopusingthis9724
      @stopusingthis9724 Před 6 lety +22

      bludstanes I was really weirded out because the shadows, light casts, and faces looked slightly off. I'm glad someone thought so as well.

    • @crescendocoal2516
      @crescendocoal2516 Před 6 lety +1

      bludstanes yeah true

    • @mlorax6725
      @mlorax6725 Před 6 lety +6

      They all have weird mouth movements whilst they talk though, it's odd. Pay yer attention buddy.

    • @kymmicakez6316
      @kymmicakez6316 Před 6 lety

      Righhtt

    • @tamquen
      @tamquen Před 6 lety +4

      Sorry I've recently started watching sherlock. Is this not real scene? If not this is the finest editing I've seen

  • @contractor08831
    @contractor08831 Před 3 lety +4

    Sherlock, "If I said I was a Doctor, do you think that I would be Strange?"

  • @Romoi1941
    @Romoi1941 Před 2 lety +2

    Rewatching this as a former BBC Sherlock fan and doctor who fan
    God I'm rewatching everything, this is beautifully made and I fucking love it.

  • @racheltyler7185
    @racheltyler7185 Před 6 lety +330

    Sherlock left his companion to become the Doctor's companion and now Watson is the doctor.

  • @TheOneBored
    @TheOneBored Před 4 lety +627

    oh 7 years later how i wish this was real, how i wish we had the golden age of the doctor back, and sherlock, just one more season, always just one more.

    • @Reddeadowl
      @Reddeadowl Před 3 lety +12

      Oh boy...i wish we could go back to these days.

    • @Peteroranje
      @Peteroranje Před 3 lety +8

      Yes, agree. You don't know what you've got till its gone.

    • @BuetifullPersun
      @BuetifullPersun Před 3 lety +9

      Doctor who is focked now :(

    • @christyjusty5635
      @christyjusty5635 Před 3 lety +3

      They ruined a show loved by many 😕

    • @tpwds7900
      @tpwds7900 Před 3 lety +2

      Matt Smith’s Doctor is most likely going to return along with Capaldi and possibly Tennant in the 60th special in a couple years, so part of the golden age of the Doctor will be back. Idk about Sherlock tho

  • @squalloogal
    @squalloogal Před rokem +1

    This is still such a wonderful idea and piece that I keep coming back to it. Years later and I’m still coming back. ❤️

  • @VeganWitchArt
    @VeganWitchArt Před 3 lety

    That was the most moving thing I’ve seen in ages! Thank you for making this, it’s magic 🥰💙💙

  • @ComputersAreRealCool
    @ComputersAreRealCool Před 8 lety +1828

    That was an animation? Someone has some serious animation and modelling skills (and alot of free time)

    • @SupremeDoesGaming
      @SupremeDoesGaming Před 8 lety +121

      Nope it's the magic of video editing, except the tardis

    • @blackham7
      @blackham7 Před 8 lety +46

      +ComputersAreRealCool Its a mixture of adobe after effects, maya and some other software for vfx i can tell as for matt and cumberbatch its there faces and voices from different episodes edited together you can tell because as matt speaks he looks a bit weird and looks as though he dosent take notice of cumberbatch

    • @AdmiralStoicRum
      @AdmiralStoicRum Před 8 lety +13

      +blackham7 although that is kind of the doctor at the same time, I like to imagine this as after the ponds are sent back in New York. He's kind of a desperate mess at this point.

    • @princeofmoths
      @princeofmoths Před 8 lety +16

      It was an animation? It explains a lot but, wow good animating skills dude, I tip my invisible hat to you sir.

    • @princeofmoths
      @princeofmoths Před 8 lety +1

      well, after i saw this i saw how it was made... so DONT SCREAM AT ME NO MORE OR EVER AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Chalky.
    @Chalky. Před 6 lety +722

    The BBC needs to do this as a one-off special for Children in need or Comic relief and just make it clear the episode isn't canon if that's what they're worried about.

    • @kobizarre2003
      @kobizarre2003 Před 6 lety +4

      The episode can be cannon

    • @Crazt
      @Crazt Před 5 lety +7

      Cumberbatch plays Sherlock in a Canon episode, everyone wins.

    • @wolfielps4411
      @wolfielps4411 Před 5 lety +2

      This should be a great Christmas special kind of a memory that the new doctor shares with his/her new companion

    • @Japed
      @Japed Před 5 lety +7

      I think the Doctor could easily appear in a Sherlock episode. Maybe not as a main focus, more of a "bumps into Sherlock while fixing his tie" sort of thing, like with Martha Jones. Sherlock in a Doctor Who episode would also be quite easy to pull off, especially if we consider the Doctor bumping into Sherlock as canon between both universes. Though, I don't think Sherlock has many aliens around so, maybe it's a pocket dimension? Anything is possible with Doctor Who involved.

    • @gildahobbs8829
      @gildahobbs8829 Před 5 lety

      Isn't there an episode where the Doctor pretends to be Sherlock Holmes? There it looked more like the traditional 19th century mockup, but ofc that doesn't need to mean anything
      I believe it's The Abominable Snowmen
      Maybe 11 took Sherlock back where the other stories happened? The one that's called The Abominable Bride, that can't be a coincidence

  • @royce6485
    @royce6485 Před rokem +2

    Coming here in 2023 because I wish there had been better content for this back in the day. The editing on this is incredible!!!

  • @Starlight-ve5wx
    @Starlight-ve5wx Před rokem +1

    I absolutely love this! First time I watched this I thought that it was a special episode. I still love it though; the editing is incredible and the dialogues fit perfectly. Marvellous job!

  • @iz723
    @iz723 Před 7 lety +2337

    Damn! That's some serious video compositing skill you have there.

    • @hibahghany7583
      @hibahghany7583 Před 7 lety +4

      look who I found

    • @iz723
      @iz723 Před 7 lety +93

      BTW, your version of the dematerialisation of the TARDIS was just perfectly mind blowing

    • @iz723
      @iz723 Před 7 lety +9

      Hello!

    • @danielrodrigues8100
      @danielrodrigues8100 Před 7 lety +27

      ISM ZAM better than the actual one they should implement that into the series

    • @volcanicashes1996
      @volcanicashes1996 Před 7 lety +11

      wait who was that wholock??

  • @Conceptcreator
    @Conceptcreator Před 4 lety +6570

    Oh man this used to look so damn real! but now you spot like the warping of the face and cutting pretty well. BUT with that being said it is still crazy well done!

    • @warmmilk5054
      @warmmilk5054 Před 3 lety +58

      I didn’t see that until you said it

    • @blahblahcvsmith668
      @blahblahcvsmith668 Před 3 lety +95

      wait this is fake?

    • @lumikkiharthri6658
      @lumikkiharthri6658 Před 3 lety +128

      Yea, looks like 3d models that are mapped when inside the tardis. Watch their mouths. Especially on the "im the doctor" line, his mouth doesnt even move correctly. That and they arent talking to each other really. If you listen you can hear the different ambience behind bith of them, as well as matt smiths changing with almost every line

    • @wolfielps4411
      @wolfielps4411 Před 3 lety +30

      Also matt Smith looks past sherlock as if there's someone over his shoulder

    • @Cipher_Paul
      @Cipher_Paul Před 3 lety +48

      Yeah, 7 years ago I thought it was real and couldn't see any of the editing whatsoever, but now it's a bit different.

  •  Před 3 lety

    I'm crying! Two of my favourite fandoms of all time brought together so smooth and perfect.
    Thank you.

  • @tanguyvettier
    @tanguyvettier Před 2 lety +1

    Still find myself rewatching this video. Give me the chill every time !

  • @DaveFlash
    @DaveFlash Před 7 lety +3417

    such a shame BBC didn't take the hint and actually made this happen when Matt was still the Doctor and Sherlock was still on as well...

    • @DanteYewToob
      @DanteYewToob Před 7 lety +62

      David Daniel Wouters Sherlock S4 starts jan 1st lol it's very much "still on" :]

    • @DaveFlash
      @DaveFlash Před 7 lety +16

      danteelite oh, my bad, didn't know that, haven't kept up with it, also didn't know of the new DW spinoff Class, until yesterday

    • @DanteYewToob
      @DanteYewToob Před 7 lety +13

      David Daniel Wouters I didn't know about it until you just said it, it looks like older skins with aliens lol I usually wait for stuff to go to netflix, I don't have myface or anything so I'm not bothered with spoilers.. But sherlock is worth watching asap lol

    • @shiningflower100
      @shiningflower100 Před 7 lety +45

      It would be very pleasent for benedict cumberbatch because he loves doctor who and even wanted to be the actor of him. So why BBC don't just, you know, do it?

    • @NutshellLP
      @NutshellLP Před 7 lety +14

      Cookie- Chan In many interviews Cumberbatch said he would never play the doctor. lol

  • @loganmoon9132
    @loganmoon9132 Před 5 lety +1339

    Doctor Strange meets Doctor Who meets Sherlock.
    Make it happen.

  • @evocationimages
    @evocationimages Před 3 lety +3

    WOW! GREAT FANTASY! Especially poor Dr Watson's reaction when left behind😂😢The edit of the MUSIC in their respective themes certainly makes this feel entirely MAGICAL for me! Thanks so much!😆🌟❤️ Love to see more from Melbourne Australia!

    • @evocationimages
      @evocationimages Před 3 lety

      and yes it seems that they are off to thwart both the Master and Moriarty......! and have a bit of flirty fun meeting up with Captain Jack along the way😉😂

  • @thesonicgaminggod6956
    @thesonicgaminggod6956 Před 2 lety +1

    So well edited and still holds up all these years later

  • @Ghostturas
    @Ghostturas Před 5 lety +898

    Wow i really thought this was a special from bbc.
    You're genius.

  • @elk2261
    @elk2261 Před 5 lety +526

    **extream rages cause Watson was left behind**

  • @narahanock2720
    @narahanock2720 Před rokem +2

    The editing! so amazing!

  • @paultenerelli655
    @paultenerelli655 Před rokem +1

    Just stumbled across this at the end of 2022. Wow! Great editing and an awesome idea. I would SO watch this.

  • @RitrishaRC
    @RitrishaRC Před 4 lety +624

    So Sherlock just exchanged one doctor for another? Cool.

  • @onechaoticneutral3061
    @onechaoticneutral3061 Před 4 lety +185

    Imagine how confused John would've been with his 'best'friend going into a small box with another guy. Then the door closing and it just disappears. Poor him.

  • @gailscrypto1536
    @gailscrypto1536 Před rokem +1

    Just heard of this and it filled the tiny hole in my soul i didnt know was there! The adventures of sherlock and the doctor is a series that would let me die happy lol. well done on the editing - amazing work!

  • @CrovelAnimation
    @CrovelAnimation Před 9 měsíci +2

    Can we all just take a moment to think of all the work that must have been done with like all the perspectives and changing the background from the characters to the other show and THAT IS AN AMAZING TARDIS ANIMATION!!!
    I love how the TARDIS has sort of like an outline for the edges and stuff as it goes away. The effort that must have been put in is insane!

  • @foxx.on.saturn5143
    @foxx.on.saturn5143 Před 5 lety +460

    Can bbc actually do a crossover episode I’d be so happy to see the two smartest fictional characters talking. To eachother

    • @jimbob7568
      @jimbob7568 Před 4 lety +24

      who would write it? the writer would need to be an absolute GENIUS

    • @samurai_bassist4422
      @samurai_bassist4422 Před 4 lety +6

      @@jimbob7568 and thats why we have sherlock and the doctor on it!

    • @larrybraden6600
      @larrybraden6600 Před 4 lety +4

      Fictional? What are you talking about?

    • @acleamofhope
      @acleamofhope Před 4 lety +3

      @@jimbob7568 Well, didn't the creators of 'Sherlock' came up with the idea of the show while filming 'Doctor Who'? Wouldn't be that difficult to find that writers I guess.

    • @itsokaytobeclownpilled5937
      @itsokaytobeclownpilled5937 Před 4 lety +5

      Mud Fox BBC is too busy making black people look British and Homosexuals look like regular people. They’re ashitshoww

  • @singingintherain4750
    @singingintherain4750 Před 4 lety +974

    First half: ah wow that's damn good editing
    Second half: wtf this really happend?

    • @valor9968
      @valor9968 Před 4 lety +37

      thank god i thought i’d gone mental

    • @aconite538
      @aconite538 Před 4 lety +40

      They probably got tired and they couldn’t use scene clips (they had to make it seem like they were saying it like how the Doctor said ‘do I even look like people?’ Outside the TARDIS to Amelia Pond)

    • @thanushehehe7302
      @thanushehehe7302 Před 4 lety +10

      I feel it’s real because it says bbc ome

    • @thewillow581
      @thewillow581 Před 4 lety +2

      Oh god I just noticed

    • @shaniphie115
      @shaniphie115 Před 4 lety

      I've not gotten what it is yet!!!

  • @charlottemulryne
    @charlottemulryne Před 11 měsíci +2

    I can't believe how well this is edited

  • @Spyral_The_Syren
    @Spyral_The_Syren Před 2 lety +1

    Wow... Just... Wow. It looked brilliant. The interacting, it sounded just like they were truly talking to one another. It's the best thing I've ever seen.

  • @vertigo9328
    @vertigo9328 Před 6 lety +329

    John is like, "why did he cheat on me -_-"

  • @justanerd0
    @justanerd0 Před 4 lety +685

    This almost looks like this was supposed to be part of this movie

    • @KantHandleThis
      @KantHandleThis Před 3 lety +31

      I thought this was a real thing done by BBC until we saw the inside of the Tardis. Fantastic editing, and the way the doctor hides himself after giving a glimpse of himself to sherlock

    • @melwugon3687
      @melwugon3687 Před 3 lety +2

      "movie". BBC Sherlock is a series. It is completely separate from films made by Guy Ritchie.

  • @olivertoole8172
    @olivertoole8172 Před 2 lety

    The editing on this is impeccable. Love how u had Sherlock there without under playing his intelligence, all with old footqge. Genius

  • @lukkon_tuk
    @lukkon_tuk Před 2 lety

    Good job with this crossover Man!!!. Amazing work.