'Made In China 2025': Examining the scorecard of Beijing's controversial industrial policy
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- With only eight months left until 2025, how much progress has China made towards achieving its 'Made in China 2025' goal. CNA's East Asia Tonight examines the scorecard of the controversial industrial policy.
Why is it controversial
You mean China is not allowed to industrialise but the G7 countries can
What a BS news
SG is American dog evident by USA military bases there, ofc they are barking the same narrative as their master
CNA, please get the real experts and not someone who will just propagate the western narratives.....
how is some guy living in Japan an expert for China? Has he even been to China?
There is an old saying in China that if no one is jealous and criticizes you, you are not doing well enough.
As far as we can see, China hasn't given a damn whether it is on parr with the US economically, militarily or technologically. China has been planning and working extremely hard to improve its people wellbeing, and the result has been astonishing. If this leads China to surpass the US in the future, so be it. Live and let live
Why get an anti-China expert to tell China stories?
Well, don't you know this is CNA channel.
That’s because CNA gets funding from US senate.
US Congress allocated $500 million to media to spread propaganda on China.
czcams.com/video/VfJKC46L660/video.htmlsi=WN73eCaIZLubL_kV
America's continued occupation of stolen land is controversial.
The US is building a port in Gaza at the moment , preparing to extract Oil from the shore of Gaza !
Never knew CNA was a clone of BBC😂😂😂.
Gordon Chang is your daddy?
China is collapsing?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Or CNA' s sources are Bollywood movies?
Why did CNA ask a Japanese expert on China?, just like we were to ask a Malaysian expert on Singapore. The CNA's view on China is mostly misleading and not accurate since the source they get are coming mainly from the western countries.
they knew, but need to follow agenda😅
Nothing wrong with that if their analysis is factual, good and not biased.
@hieveryone2003 you are a propaganda.. lol
czcams.com/video/VfJKC46L660/video.htmlsi=WN73eCaIZLubL_kV
CNA getting more funding for CIA for this biased reporting ?
controversial=not approved by the USA
CNA is talking US empire bullcrap. What's so controversial about China's industrial policy? Singapore has its own industrial policy. Even India has its "Make In India" industrial policy. CNA, behave yourself.
Actually, "Made In China 2025" wasn't controversial at all even to Americans -- until Trump became president. I still remember rreading and watching a video of Trump saying he was angered by "Made In China 2025". That was a fine example of Trump's narcissism, and I posted about it at that time.
I could understand if Americans are concerned about it (although they shouldn't, at least not to the point of lashing out at China). But angered by it? Only a narcissist would be angered by it.
.
I have read a lot on the fascinating medical condition known as Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) because I have dealt with people suffering from NPD, and I wanted to understand the condition.
When we hear "narcissism", an image of a person holding up and looking at a mirror comes to mind. But the medical condition of NPD is much more than that. Traits of NPD include constantly seeking validation (oh, your work is great, this is so well done, fantastic, you look so good, etc), overly ambitious (even on minor matters), lying, and getting offended by almost everything and anything. The last trait is like a person who perceives he has a physical defect or a former sports person who is now fat and unfit, and the person becomes very sensitive about his condition, and very easily takes offence over people laughing or whispering nearby, even though those people may not be talking about him at all.
Trump suffers from NPD. Americans may fear "Made In China 2025", but anger is logically out of place. But not so for a person, especially a president, suffering from NPD.
@@katong1953 Trump is just a symbol. The real problem is that American fears comoetition. This is sad.
'Made In USA 2025': Examining the scorecard of Washington's controversial warmonger industrial policy
台湾人!
Why not tell the truth ? what the West concern about?
The West has set up Asia as a labor camp, and the labor camp must stay as labor camp, not allow to develop.
But China escaped and developed.
😝They feel angry/worried that other countries will follow.
We all knew It is written in U$ Foreign Policy document, to keep Asia poor and divided .
The US Foreign Policy to keep Asia poor and divided as stated in a top-secret U.S. Foreign Policy document written 76 years ago is still in force.
February 24, 1948, Declassified U.S. Foreign Policy:
Furthermore, we have about 50% of the world’s wealth but only 6.3% of its population. This disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia. In this situation, we cannot fail to be the object of envy and resentment. Our real task in the coming period is to devise a pattern of relationships which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security. ... that Japan and the Philippines will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system and that if we can contrive to retain effective control over these areas there can be no serious threat to our security from the East within our time.
Taiwan was added to the Pacific security system after Chiang's army retreated to the island of Taiwan in 1949. South Korea was added after the Korean War in 1953. The attempt with Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia was abandoned in 1975.
a lesson for India, India should stay as big cheap labour if not USA and west will conquer India 😢
They used a Japanese from Japan to tell you "facts" about China.
Lee 阿斗 thinks Singaporeans are very easy to hoodwink.
Ha ha ha!
It's amazingly immoral that the West expect other nations with bigger population to stay impoverished & view attempts to achieve same level of prosperity as the West as an act of aggression - a desire to "overtake" "surpass" "dominate" etc. Seems like there's a 2-prong attack on others' right to a decent modern life: 1 cherry pick stats, eg measure aggregates in absolute figures rather than per person prosperity & purchasing power & use those aggregates to fabricate a narrative of foreign aggressions or unfair play. 2 instigate unrest to break up bigger foreign countries so they can never surpass the US collectively. Bonus of this is the US military industrial complex makes a killing & with US-led dominance they can raid any other country's resources as well as wholesale land theft like in Palestine.
😅This channel almost become microphone for the west.
Singapore getting so low ?
Almost??? It is a mini BBC..please don't drag Singapore into this.... Is the ppl in CNA.
@@EasternKalogerosThe people’s getting more more Ang Mo sai!
Singaporeans are descendants of the Great Britain! Or so they thinks. Ask they young Singaporeans and they will tell you their bloodline are not from China but from the UK.
Singapore wants to show allegiance to the US master.
@kennyskwong nope... only those WOKE ppl working within CNA. They don't have Singapore at heart. Always trying to drag us into conflict.
I wish CNA would have better understanding and more knowledgeable so called expert to “Made in China” 2025 strategy and it’s achievements. After all, CNA should differentiate itself from CNN and BBC etc.
The expert can't pull 2 sentences coercively ,.
Must be doing well. That's why the U.S. and E.U. accuses it of overcapacity.
China is producing too much... but also China is collapsing...
Russia's army is very weak... but also it the biggest threat to the west.
Some American companies received govt subsidies as well.
Chip act
inflation act
But they're American companies...
The experts are so often wrong......about China.
They have been all correct about China 🇨🇳, but the Chinese regime can't learn new things.
Not always
CNA's "experts" are more often wrong than right about China.
lookie here we got ourselves an expert on experts
Yes because the so-called experts are much of the time also act as part-time propagandists of the Western imperialist countires.
??? Controversial??? To the US?😅😅😅😅😅😅😅??
🤣🤣👌👌
I support China
Well, the US/EU are all company-owned states. I prefer the system state-owned companies
America playing the wrong game.. check mate..
Whether or not China achieves the vaguely-stated goals of "Made in China 2025," the important thing is that China will be *_largely_* self-sufficient. We are seeing this with China's remarkable comeback from US semiconductor sanctions. We are seeing this in China's overwhelming dominance in batteries, NEVs, and solar panels.
Actually this has been a phenomenal aspiration which has, for the most, been quite successful by any measure. This campaign has been focused on Chinese self reliance not on world domination irrespective of the Western narrative. It would appear that Western paranoia is driving the opposition.
Does it mean US and EU are privileged to be industrial leaders and rest of the world can't.
Yep that's pretty much the Western thinking.
KY Lee: " if we are not doing well, will other people still care about us?"
how is it controversial?
This channel almost become microphone for the west.
Singapore getting so low ?
Not so long ago, China's 🇨🇳 economy was known on Wall Street as the Madoff economy.
It only worked for so long.
Bot.. in and BOt out..... same old same old Bs
they have no idea about China at all.
China ..... China.....China ..... China....as if this planet has no other countries.......
Please be informed this planet has about 195 countries......
Argentina, anyone?
Why of course since China is the last hope of humankind to stop Weston continuing hegemonic domination of the global poor through colonialism, imperialism, genocide, slavery, globalization for dirt cheap labor, loot, steal, rob, bully, and sanction.
Propaganda to make them sound big and threatening but not Covid or Jack Ma which were swept under the carpets.
they talk about china all day because that fundamentally they see china as the only country that could change their whole "rule based order", stop china, others by themselves won't have the ability and means to break free even if they want to, and no matter how much they want to, even russia. that's the core of their "strategy".
it's about how they see the world.
@@josdesouza Argentina is a country of no significance. Or in other words it gained some significance when it's clown fascist president criticised China and Brazil.
CNA are so lack behind, now they are talking about new quality productivity.
😝West is very concern Asian overtake Ang Moe
@hieveryone2003 U r Ang Moe Gao ?
@hieveryone2003 Singapore use ”Ang Moe Gao “ .
You better go "Holland" 😂 fly kite
Agreed that China has never seek to dominate the global position like the US but allowing another player to break US dominance of which is clearly unhappy cos the bloodline is hegemonic
The host is so funny, I guess China can say it will be Number 2 in 2049 to comfort you
Both they US/EU/Japan have state subsidies for semiconductors and batteries, specifically to threaten China and they said so.
How is it controversial
Many Inddian PoohJEETS are comparing MAKE IN ENDDIA with Made in CHINA 2025 while eating curry with hands
😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
How many western "China Experts" actually live in China?
Actually you know more about China by living outside China.
@@AhmetTekin101 I lived both in and outside China, trust me, these experts have no clue, they're just collecting a paycheck.
@@AhmetTekin101 No, I've lived both in and outside of China. You develop assumptions about China when you live outside of it. You don't actually see the impact of the changes until you live in China.
@@AhmetTekin101 No you don't.
@@yojimbo3681 ''China should spend less on industrial development and focus more social programs'' 😆
I guess China could be more like USA, and spend less on industrial development and focus more on endless wars.
Other govs also subsidise and enact protective measures. Eg the research that developed the internet was partly funded by the US gov, and everyone levies tariffs in import. The question is who will ultimately benefit from these subsidies & protective measures - the people or a select few "captain of industries" & other capitalist-shareholders. As long as Chinese gov ensures their investments benefit the people in China as well as humanity in general, then that's a good thing. Problem with the West is the hyper-capitalism & economic autocracy, where profit for the few trumps the lives of the rest. Socialsm & communism is merely economic democracy. How can anyone supporting democracy be against democracy in more spheres of life?
South Korean tech giants also benefited from gov subsidies & undemocratic policies.
Controversial.... hehehehe
The made in china 2025 was actually a Chinese version of "German Industrie 4.0". " In German Industrie 4.0, smart factories use information and communications technologies to digitize their processes, leading to significant benefits such as improved quality, lower costs, and increased efficiency". When these concepts spred to China, Chinese industris were shocked by the advanced ideas. and China felt the emergency to catch up. Hence proposed Made in China 2025, to follow the steps of advanced German. hard to understand what is the probelm
CIA propaganda channel 😂😂😂
Low end products manufacturing provided the most employment for 1.4 billions China Chinese. Number of jobs lost in low end products manufacturing cannot be replaced by China high end production which generally hire lesser staffs. Expect high unemployment rate in China to increase.
Your daily bullshxt again?
Otelli Edwards line of questions are bias towards the Western narrative. This is clear from the clip. A big boo to CNA!
The lady is always trying to mis lead the discussion to something negative for China
Move to Mars if this is a concern.
Every country has the right to do whatever is the best for them, china could attempt the dominance ans usa has the right to not help them and restict its technology
Already accomplished in 2024.
Ultimately, is the government can afford the seed funding to grow the industry...
dog whistle report
Jai Hind. China now has Made in China 2025. However we Indians have a bigger Vision with our Made in India 2040.
More toilets in 2040 ?
Go make your chapatti
India has lots of potential. But first some basics have to be sorted out like the exam cheating culture. You cant really hire the right people unless you make them pass a proper exam. They are 30 years behind .
@@joekerr8037 😂😂😂😂
What is that guy talking about. USA subsidizes a lot of their companies 😂
Singapore's top priorities are still on National Development Desmond's plan on marine eco parks will attract many investors n gov should carefully select foreign banks n INDIAN companies ie HSBC , CIMB , Citi , Standchart etc if they are not hiring Singaporeans then it is time to ask them to relocate elsewhere to make way for many other bigger investors who are willing to hire n expand in SG. Once again CECA should be abolished immediately.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 Big giants are hungry to building growth in SG.
If we look at China's progress in accordance with the West's model, everything in China seems unsustainable. Whether China development will have to go along with the model of the West? Not sure.
Let's wait a few more years and see.
Controversial industrial policy?
If China has not made headways in telecommunication, solar panels, electric vehicles, etc the US would not have gone ballistic.
byd EV now no. 1 car in sg market. 16% market share. more than toyota.
WHY MEDIA DOESN'T INTERVIEW CHINESE ABOUT CHINESE ISSUE??? DO YOU INTERVIEW CHINESE ABOUT AMERICAN ISSUE??
Following the September 11, 2001 attack, the U.S. shifted attention from China to the Middle East, easing China's entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO) in December 2001. As China emerged as the "world's factory," producing inexpensive goods that lowered global inflation, central banks, including the U.S. Federal Reserve, maintained low-interest rates, fostering excessive leveraging in the U.S. and Europe. This, coupled with risky financial practices and the housing market's collapse, led to the 2008 Global Financial Crisis. Despite feeling unsettled by China's economic growth, the United States actively pursued financial support from China, for China to continue purchasing U.S. Treasury bills.
In 2011, Obama proposed the "Pivot to Asia" strategy, which shifted the focus of US foreign policy from the Middle East to Asia. This, along with the wargaming of a sea blockade of Chinese commercial ships on a global scale, the formation of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), which deliberately excluded China, the establishment of a 2500-strong US marine air-ground task force in Darwin, and an increase in the rotation of both US Air Force planes and US Navy vessels through Australian bases, alarmed the Chinese leadership.
Unable to remain passive, hide their strength, and bide their time, Xi Jinping was selected as the leader of China in 2013 to make China more secure. These included the establishment of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, the Belt and Road initiative, and the building of artificial islands in the South China Sea. In 2015 the "Made in China 2025" initiative was announced. These policies directly responded to the perceived threat posed by the "Pivot to Asia" strategy. No country is excluded from joining the AIIB or the Belt and Road Initiative. Obama's intentions were clarified when he responded to Xi Jinping's proposal on September 25, 2015, to make the South China Sea (SCS) a non-militarized zone by initiating freedom of navigation operations in the SCS on October 27, 2015.
It was more cost-effective for China to purchase reliable Western chips, benefiting both sides. China spends more on chip imports than on oil. The US sanctions forced China to develop its domestic supply chain. When self-sufficient, China can provide the world with more affordable chips.
The US and its allies are developing their own supply chain, but it cannot be competitive without access to a large market. The US is sparing no effort in its Tonya Harding competition strategy. The Chinese are very grateful to the US for pushing them towards self-sufficiency. Thanks to the US, China now has its own GPS system and space program. The US chips sanction is converting its biggest chips customer to be its biggest competitor. More sanctions, please.
Curious why so many countries love to have very big celebrations in Singapore.
State ownership has an advantage of suppressing the ultrarich from dominance of the economy like the Big Techs.
Private ownership has the advantage of free market competitions and efficiency.
To overcome shortfall, state companies in China set their competition against western big leaders. So its very frightening to the west.
However China has to take note that if ever they managed to achieve peak global dominance, they will lose their motivation and decline too. Such is the sad case of worldly pursuits with disregard of eternity.😢
Chinese is so funny they are producing many robots but they don't have much younger generations. Poor or rich doesn't matter, the world is ruled by human not by robots.
Propaganda channel😂😂😂
Made in India vs made in China, Singapore must import everything from India
Prof. E... e.... e... e... e....
China is declining.
India 🇮🇳 is projected to become a developed nation in 25 years.
- At the same time, third-world China will become a second North Korea.
IQ < 0
Are you related to Gordon Chang?
@@tanc.h8675Related to all the Indiots in the world.
'India 🇮🇳 is projected to become a developed nation in 25 years"
ROFL
Maybe India's present insufficient toilet facilities will finally be achieved in 25 years.
- In 10 years time, third-world India will become a second Bangladesh.
Good analysis by Japan Professor. 👍👍👍
Your dad ?
Chinese 🇨🇳 property sector, which accounts for 30% of GDP, is crashing.
- Exports and imports, accounting for 37% GDP, are down.
- Foreign investment (FDI) is falling over 90%, lowest in 3 decades.
- Foreign visitors are down 96% compared to the pre-pandemic level in 2019.
- Consumer prices are experiencing deflation.
- Youth unemployment hits over 21%, a record.
- Its fast-shrinking workforce is 10 years older than neighboring countries.
*Still, China keeps reporting outrageous GDP numbers.* Lol
Where does the growth come from?
LOL your figures are not even right, or deliberately misrepresented. This is the level of thinking in the west. It is little wonder why it is in decline.
Exports and Imports are down??? Where did you get your figures?? Domestic consumption is up, Investments is up. How is that not represented in GDP growth.
@@skydragon23101979 because lying to themselves is how they can sleep at night.
Kumar, build some toilets and decent drinking water in your country 1st
ya what bot babble with rubbish again.
Can't you find a guest who can speak English fluently?
China leading US in technology race in all but a few fields, thinktank finds - The Guardian, 2 March, 2023
China leads in 37 of 44 technologies tracked in a year-long project by thinktank the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.
Please pardon the stance of CNA. They just don't want to get sanctioned in USA like TikTok!