Sarah was genuinleyin tears during this scene. When u see them T pose she still has tears streaming down her face. They all got lost emotionally in this game which is why we all do as we play it
@@cilginkizseni7376 It's used by the animator to sync the real life pose to the in-game character's pose. It ensures they start and end in sync with the rest of the animations.
I really appreciate Troy admitting his pride as an actor. He really expected everyone to think he was an AMAZING actor because he can cry on the spot. It’s a very humbling experience I’m sure and I show mad respect to him 👏👏
Sorry to be that guy but he's an asshole, he was all in on NFTs and defending them as well as doing a truckload of other shaky things if you want to do the research. Great actor undeniably, but I can't say I like much else about what I've heard about him. He gives me "Trying too hard to be profound" energy.
It really says a lot for someone to be able to admit their fault and also grow from it because while I think the take where he just full on loses it is good . The one we get in the game is so much more powerful because it is so restrained. Like Joel is partially grieving but also in disbelief and he's just slowly realizng that this is happening. His daughter is gone and not coming back and the reality just hits him so hard that he doesn't even know what to do with himself
@@dignusdingus3709 yeah but it was only that one post right? After that he talked to his friend and thought about it, and in the end quitting NFT and never touched it since. Say it for yourself but now that the guy had learned progressed and move on why can’t we drop it and move on as well?
@@CN_5amSleeper Did he really drop the NFT thing? If so I'm kind of relieved to hear that. But honestly, even if NFTs are stupid, that's not something anyone should be cancelled for, and I still liked his work. But good for him, still.
Realistically though yelling and crying was how a father would be like in that situation. But for fictional purposes yeah the final one hits the most cause the players feel Joel's pain better than what they would by seeing him externalizing it more, cause in that case the attention would be more on his dramatic reaction than on what he's actually experiencing.
@@thestrong2401 well that’s kinda general, but we get to know Joel thru the entire game, and although he has his moments he is mostly the strong and silent type. You may see it differently but I genuinely believe that’s how Joel would cry as opposed to the one we see in this video
@@thestrong2401 "Realistically though yelling and crying was how a father would be like in that situation." When I lost my father to cancer, in my mind I wanted to cry, yell, curse, scream, beat the walls... but on the outside, I was in complete shock and disbelief and acted much more like the final shot they ended up using. Real life is often very different in reactions, to the point where if someone acted emotionally so little at a time of someone's death in a movie, it would feel unrealistic and shitty. But in reality, people more often than not just go silent, into a shock... Or even having watched some crazy videos about real life accidents, people missing limbs often look... disturbingly calm, as opposed to how such is depicted in movies. (Yeah I know my curiosity is screwed up...) Something that unfathomable and "impossible" just feels unreal for a long time. Especially the "Danny?" line where he pleads for some help, whatever help in despair is genius in the scene as you just want to solve the situation.. to undo it.... instead of accept it.
Bro. I have never went from almost crying to bursting out laughing quicker than I did at 1:14 when Troy was giving his emotional performance and then the scene cuts and everyone jumps up and T poses. Lmfao.
@@tajasnothere T-poses are typically used as placeholders for animation not yet completed. It also makes it especially easy for the motion capture system to identify the location of all their limbs and thus to trace which marker is which.
This was the moment in the game that I realised it was going to be amazing, it set the perfect tone and character arc for Joel to take with Ellie and it really hit me emotionally, probably one of the only games that got me crying withing the first few minutes of the game
Revisiting this. The performance that made the cut was indeed the best one because it's more painful when you hear Joel still trying NOT to cry and still bargaining -- "Don't do this to me, baby" -- instead of going straight to an anguished cry. It's several times more heartbreaking to see someone holding on and denying a death of a child for a few moments more, even when they're already holding a corpse. So that when that scene cuts to black (and leaps into the intro credits of the game), you know for sure that after those initial moments of denial and struggle not to go mad with grief, Joel does let out an anguished scream (like how Troy did it in other takes). They just don't show it to you and let your own imagination fill in the rest. That's how they make you cry. So that when the game starts with Joel years later, goddamn, the emotional weight of the darkness inside and around him hits you like a truck. 😅 And shit, you're starting the story. Phew. Wrecks your heart.
Great summary, you're absolutely right. Bryan Cranston has a really good analysis of emotions in cinema where he notes that when an actor won't let themselves laugh/cry, the audience has to feel it instead. Really applies here.
This… THIS right here is why I have so much respect for actors. They have to go to places that most of us fight hard not to for our own mental health. IMO those first takes where he really loses it looked perfect to me because they drive the fact that he just lost his daughter home perfectly. Troy is a damn boss for bringing Joel to life the way he did. I don’t envy Pedro as he has some massive shoes to fill. Troy Baker is a damn beast at his craft.
hahahaha i swear to god, you people give actors way too much credit it's just lying and playing make believe, it's really not that hard, especially when you're getting paid handsomely to do so most of these actors get to where they are because mommy and/or daddy were rich and connected, but feel free to keep kissing their asses 😂😂😂
I know many hate Druckmann but I gotta say, he called it absolutely right here. When my father died, what I felt was wanting to scream, cry, yell, exactly like Troy's first take. To let all the emotion out. But funny thing is... I didn't. Because it didn't feel real yet. I couldn't process it... or accept it. So the take they ended up using, with Joel trying to "bargain"... call for Danny for help, even if he knows he can't help. Call for Sarah... He's at a complete loss and disbelief. It's something ... impossible.
Same for me, I thought I would scream, cry with both sadness and anger when my mother died. But I didn't, I became like Joel oddly and was just quiet and in denial
The true genius of Neil Druckmann is encapsulated in his vision for this scene. The more understated, restrained take that they went with ends up hitting much harder, and perfectly sets Joel's arc for the rest of the story.
the best times of my life as an actor was in my conversionary program where my teacher said that the best work you do is when you are exhausted and burned. Once your there it stops being about u or what you want to be perceived as. You are the character. And that is the best work.
To this day I still think this is the best voice acted scene in any videogame, can't think of anything quite on that same level, RDR2, GOW 2018, Uncharted 4, They all have some incredibly acted scenes. but this is still head and shoulders above.
Yes! The hole game is really good! And the acting whit the updated grafic modells in Ps5 are making the game glanz. And that is made why Part 2 are not so great from my eyes
How does an actor that young show such depth that can only be pulled from decades of life experience. Truly a very underrated actor. He’s amazing- far better than many Hollywood a-listers
Wow, this is an incredible glimpse into the mind of a TRULY great actor. The dilemma of artificial versus reality, the amount of thought and meaning he puts into that idea is really what acting is all about. What a phenomenal little peak into how real actors operate.
Great example of how common it can be to overact if you're trying to give your all for a performance, but you can see why the 'less is more' approach which Neil was looking for was more impactful as it suited the scene better and was more appropriate for Joel's character.
The thing I appreciate is that the TV show didn't shy away from this scene because its one of the most brutal, visceral, and gut wrenching scenes ever put into a video game especially for anyone who is a parent themselves.
This is such a fucking hearbreaking moment in the game, but I can't help but LMFAO at the guy playing the dead solider just laying on the floor in the background.
I hate the word perfect, but after ten years, multiple remakes, a sequel, and tv version led by another brilliant actor, I'm confident in calling his performance here perfect
If you want to play a video game that will take you on an emotional rollercoaster the last of us the number game that will do just that. The storyline alone makes the last of us the greatest video game of all-time and the gameplay solidifies its place as the greatest video game of all-time times 100. Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson they are the greatest duo ever put in a video game.
I just find incredible how a lot of people here are talking about how the scene is better in the game and bla bla bla but even Troy said that Pedro it's a incredible Joel, and that he (Troy Baker) learned something about Joel from the interpretation of Pedro Pascal, can u guys understand that Pedro Pascal nailed it?!?!?!?!?! I cried like a fucking baby watching, please, just take that emotion of nostalgia away, it's a pure fucked up thing, u think something older it's better, just because it's older, and it's older times, I'm glad that Troy loves Joel so so so much, that even he learned something, while other people just want to say shit No it's not bad acting or poor directing, not this fucking time, it's just your sentimental nostalgia of being younger and played the game in a certain time that was better, u don't fucking miss the acting of the game, u miss your feelings (of a kid/child/teenager whatever) that u had WHEN u played the game Congratulations to Troy, I cried like, 3 times?! And congratulations to Pedro fucking Pascal, that made me cry 1 more fucking time (yeah, I said "fucking" a lot, yk, english isn't my first language, and feels good to just say fucking, don't blame jkhdsajkhdsajkhdsajkhdsajkhadsjkh só sou um fodendo brasileiro pica dando uma opinião e um fato de que nenhum de vcs, e provalvemente nem eu, sabe julgar algo pq a gente se deixa levar por emoções burras e estupidas, quem diria que todo o mundo conseguiria ser tão ruim em criticar as coisas, não sei o que aconteceu tlg, mas a gente é uns merda quando se trata de apreciar ou criticar algo kjsahdjhadjahjkda)
i mean the last of us 1 was hard cause of that scene, then obviously going through that game to possibly think ellie is gonna die THEN you play the 2nd game and joels demise, i cant even watch that scene in the game cause that must of been so hard to do, i cant imagine if they do a 3rd game, something dark has to end
1:17 I always think filmmakers are pretty good at holding their laughter...the more actors do their job right the more it gets funnier when they suddenly stop acting XD. It's kind of sad their acting is translated in to GCIs. I know that's how it works but these acting look better than the one in some live action films I've watched lately.
When that happened in the game… I got so upset and emotional… That I nearly cried. I threw my game controller down and yelled “this is the stupidest fucking game I’ve ever played!“ It left me. Heartbroken. 10 minutes later, I was back to see what happens next. BEST GAME EVER! Ps to this day I still get choked up over Joel and his little girl.
This scene broke me. So... yeah... they got it! 😭 I didn't see it coming. I knew the game was about a man and a young girl, but when I started playing, I just assumed Sarah was that girl. But, nope. They got me. 10 mins into the game, and Naughty Dog had my emotions at their beck and call. And this scene was so important to the rest of the story. It needed to happen, and we needed to see it to fully understand Joel's journey. To understand why he was so resistant to Ellie. And to see the change and fully understand why Joel, in the end, would do absolutely anything for Ellie. And why we got the ending we did. Bravo Naughty Dog. Bravo Neil. Bravo Troy. Bravo Hana. 🙌🏻
geez. didn't know they put _that_ much effort into it. I kinda just watch it with a blank mind and don't put too much thought into it. I could definitely tell the acting was _unusually_ good for a video game, though.
Well, the way most actors cry on command is by remembering terrible moments in their lives. Who tf wants to constantly relive those moments over and over again?
Actually, it sounds like Troy blowing smoke up Druckman's ass. That scene in the game is tremenously moving. It doesn't mean the other takes of that scene weren't
With the game going cross platform, I cannot keep track of different actors playing the same character, i feel a pillock for leaving incorrect comments! I thought it was the actress Ashley, but its Hana!
After watching the first episode of the series, I found it incredible how Sarah's death was so... unemotional. Even a background was added so that we could become attached to her, following her for a whole day in her normal life compared to the game where we only meet her during the night of the accident and even with all that she didn't manage to generate the same impact. Perhaps it's because when I played TLOU I went into the game knowing nothing and I was shocked after watch what happen to her but the series failed to capture a moment that became iconic in the industry and a powerful moment for Joel that become much more important later in the game. Now seeing this behind the scenes (thanks youtube) one can see the importance of the direction.
I don’t think you or anyone else, not feeling the emotional impact of Sarah’s death has anything to do with bad acting or poor directing. I have seen many reactions to the TV series that were extremely emotional here, and a good amount have played the game. I think that for some people emotional responses come as a result of shock alone, and no matter how much you try you will never, not know what happens in that scene to trigger an emotional response to it. I didn't get emotional either but I still felt awful about the scene and felt its impact, because I was empathetic to both characters. Both versions of the scene are fantastic
She's a grown woman now. This video was 9 years. They probably started doing motion capture years before, so this is more like 12 years ago. She's likely in her mid-twenties now lol.
@@mortal_kombat930 It's so annoying that they did that. Like, even if one does not care about sounding "racist", bitching about it doesn't even hold up because we know she dies in the first episode. And we can't even say that we're ok with it because she dies in the first episode, because then we sound like an insensitive piece of shit.
"OH GOD NO, OH PLEASE GOD NO" *gets up and t poses*
God resurrected them but forgot to animate them
LMAO
Never laughed so hard ever
OMGG LMFAO
Lol
Sarah was genuinleyin tears during this scene. When u see them T pose she still has tears streaming down her face. They all got lost emotionally in this game which is why we all do as we play it
why'd they do the T pose?
@@cilginkizseni7376 It's used by the animator to sync the real life pose to the in-game character's pose. It ensures they start and end in sync with the rest of the animations.
That part brought tears to my eyes. Seeing her still crying after. I wanted to give her a hug lol
and thats why part 2 was so bullpeep, fake emotions and woke sh*t
@Dee_the_Bee the trick is dont compare no2 to no1. As a stand alone game, lou2 is a brilliant game. But doesn't compare to no1
I really appreciate Troy admitting his pride as an actor. He really expected everyone to think he was an AMAZING actor because he can cry on the spot. It’s a very humbling experience I’m sure and I show mad respect to him 👏👏
Sorry to be that guy but he's an asshole, he was all in on NFTs and defending them as well as doing a truckload of other shaky things if you want to do the research. Great actor undeniably, but I can't say I like much else about what I've heard about him. He gives me "Trying too hard to be profound" energy.
So can I, tho I'm not an actress. I trained myself to cry on command.
It really says a lot for someone to be able to admit their fault and also grow from it because while I think the take where he just full on loses it is good . The one we get in the game is so much more powerful because it is so restrained. Like Joel is partially grieving but also in disbelief and he's just slowly realizng that this is happening. His daughter is gone and not coming back and the reality just hits him so hard that he doesn't even know what to do with himself
@@dignusdingus3709 yeah but it was only that one post right? After that he talked to his friend and thought about it, and in the end quitting NFT and never touched it since. Say it for yourself but now that the guy had learned progressed and move on why can’t we drop it and move on as well?
@@CN_5amSleeper Did he really drop the NFT thing? If so I'm kind of relieved to hear that. But honestly, even if NFTs are stupid, that's not something anyone should be cancelled for, and I still liked his work. But good for him, still.
4:07 "This scene actually works, not because of me but inspite of me"
A person cannot get more humble than this.
i just came here crying after watching the remake scene and now im laughing at T pose while still tearing
IM PISSING
Like I know it has its purpose but it looks so weird 😂
@@gingechicken7394 They do it so they could set a new animation. But yeah.. it looks weird but this is how motion capture work :D
I’m glad they went with the more slow to hit type of pain, than the yell cry they had before. It really conveys so much more emotion
Realistically though yelling and crying was how a father would be like in that situation. But for fictional purposes yeah the final one hits the most cause the players feel Joel's pain better than what they would by seeing him externalizing it more, cause in that case the attention would be more on his dramatic reaction than on what he's actually experiencing.
@@thestrong2401 well that’s kinda general, but we get to know Joel thru the entire game, and although he has his moments he is mostly the strong and silent type. You may see it differently but I genuinely believe that’s how Joel would cry as opposed to the one we see in this video
@@josephuntitled.3292 The disbelief, silent whimpers are more powerful than the crying yell
@@josephuntitled.3292 I agree.
@@thestrong2401 "Realistically though yelling and crying was how a father would be like in that situation."
When I lost my father to cancer, in my mind I wanted to cry, yell, curse, scream, beat the walls... but on the outside, I was in complete shock and disbelief and acted much more like the final shot they ended up using.
Real life is often very different in reactions, to the point where if someone acted emotionally so little at a time of someone's death in a movie, it would feel unrealistic and shitty. But in reality, people more often than not just go silent, into a shock...
Or even having watched some crazy videos about real life accidents, people missing limbs often look... disturbingly calm, as opposed to how such is depicted in movies. (Yeah I know my curiosity is screwed up...)
Something that unfathomable and "impossible" just feels unreal for a long time. Especially the "Danny?" line where he pleads for some help, whatever help in despair is genius in the scene as you just want to solve the situation.. to undo it.... instead of accept it.
Bro. I have never went from almost crying to bursting out laughing quicker than I did at 1:14 when Troy was giving his emotional performance and then the scene cuts and everyone jumps up and T poses. Lmfao.
IM NOT THE ONLY ONE THANK GOD, i died laughing, and then went to the comments for some fucking understanding of why the hell they did that
@@tajasnothere have you found the answer?
@@Loterelle not really, I just assume it's something to do with the motion capture software suits they have on?
@@tajasnothere T-poses are typically used as placeholders for animation not yet completed. It also makes it especially easy for the motion capture system to identify the location of all their limbs and thus to trace which marker is which.
This was the moment in the game that I realised it was going to be amazing, it set the perfect tone and character arc for Joel to take with Ellie and it really hit me emotionally, probably one of the only games that got me crying withing the first few minutes of the game
wait till you watch episode 3..Absolute garbage woke shit. Game was good yes..Tv serie not
Revisiting this. The performance that made the cut was indeed the best one because it's more painful when you hear Joel still trying NOT to cry and still bargaining -- "Don't do this to me, baby" -- instead of going straight to an anguished cry. It's several times more heartbreaking to see someone holding on and denying a death of a child for a few moments more, even when they're already holding a corpse. So that when that scene cuts to black (and leaps into the intro credits of the game), you know for sure that after those initial moments of denial and struggle not to go mad with grief, Joel does let out an anguished scream (like how Troy did it in other takes). They just don't show it to you and let your own imagination fill in the rest. That's how they make you cry. So that when the game starts with Joel years later, goddamn, the emotional weight of the darkness inside and around him hits you like a truck. 😅 And shit, you're starting the story. Phew. Wrecks your heart.
Great summary, you're absolutely right. Bryan Cranston has a really good analysis of emotions in cinema where he notes that when an actor won't let themselves laugh/cry, the audience has to feel it instead. Really applies here.
This… THIS right here is why I have so much respect for actors. They have to go to places that most of us fight hard not to for our own mental health. IMO those first takes where he really loses it looked perfect to me because they drive the fact that he just lost his daughter home perfectly. Troy is a damn boss for bringing Joel to life the way he did.
I don’t envy Pedro as he has some massive shoes to fill. Troy Baker is a damn beast at his craft.
Boy did Pedro deliver
It’s an art. An extremely dedicated art that must be respected and appreciated.
hahahaha i swear to god, you people give actors way too much credit
it's just lying and playing make believe, it's really not that hard, especially when you're getting paid handsomely to do so
most of these actors get to where they are because mommy and/or daddy were rich and connected, but feel free to keep kissing their asses
😂😂😂
@@Political_Brainrot_Auditor wow, someone's bitter. I take it your take comes from decades of acting yourself?
@@papamitri196 he made Joel his own and remained true to the game version while softening him considerably. He's still a badass but a believable one.
The whimper makes me tear up every single time
I know many hate Druckmann but I gotta say, he called it absolutely right here. When my father died, what I felt was wanting to scream, cry, yell, exactly like Troy's first take. To let all the emotion out.
But funny thing is... I didn't. Because it didn't feel real yet. I couldn't process it... or accept it.
So the take they ended up using, with Joel trying to "bargain"... call for Danny for help, even if he knows he can't help. Call for Sarah...
He's at a complete loss and disbelief. It's something ... impossible.
Same for me, I thought I would scream, cry with both sadness and anger when my mother died. But I didn't, I became like Joel oddly and was just quiet and in denial
The true genius of Neil Druckmann is encapsulated in his vision for this scene. The more understated, restrained take that they went with ends up hitting much harder, and perfectly sets Joel's arc for the rest of the story.
They all did such a great job. Thank you for making awesome games.
this makes me cry more then the show and the game. its just sm more raw. they acted so well I can feel the grief.
the best times of my life as an actor was in my conversionary program where my teacher said that the best work you do is when you are exhausted and burned. Once your there it stops being about u or what you want to be perceived as. You are the character. And that is the best work.
My brother was playing and me and dad were watching and we all started crying and my dads only words after were…"Holy shit".
This is WHY. I have cried. Literally everytime I've played. Every time
Literally? Like literally? Not figuratively? Literally? Like literally? Literally?
@@adriantrusca1245 literally literally. Like literally literally literally like LIT.ER.A.LLY
LITERALLY
absolutely WOW! Can't imagine How can Pedro Pascal gonna top that scene in live action series.
And he gotta do it without baby yoda!
@@tommyliu7020 Imagine it with Teenage Yoda: "Father? A gun he has..."
@@tommyliu7020 His acting in Mandalorian honestly sucks because he has nothing to work with.
I'll be honest, they couldn't top it. The game had like a 10x more heartbreaking death scene
@@gabrielhunter4954 Honestly, the show did an equal job of it suprisingly
Pedro Pascal is a damn good actor..he also nailed this part.
He did great on that scene.
He did good, I still think Troy's version is way better
He wasn't bad but I didn't feel the scene in his performance.
@@blasader cause we already watched it with the game and it's just going to make you feel the original is best.
lol
To this day I still think this is the best voice acted scene in any videogame, can't think of anything quite on that same level,
RDR2, GOW 2018, Uncharted 4, They all have some incredibly acted scenes. but this is still head and shoulders above.
Yes! The hole game is really good! And the acting whit the updated grafic modells in Ps5 are making the game glanz. And that is made why Part 2 are not so great from my eyes
How does an actor that young show such depth that can only be pulled from decades of life experience. Truly a very underrated actor. He’s amazing- far better than many Hollywood a-listers
Wow, this is an incredible glimpse into the mind of a TRULY great actor. The dilemma of artificial versus reality, the amount of thought and meaning he puts into that idea is really what acting is all about. What a phenomenal little peak into how real actors operate.
Great example of how common it can be to overact if you're trying to give your all for a performance, but you can see why the 'less is more' approach which Neil was looking for was more impactful as it suited the scene better and was more appropriate for Joel's character.
First time I played this, I was single. 10 years later, when I had a baby girl, this hit me differently. I wept and wept.
troy baker is a gift to this world
🙏🏼
I always think acting cant be hard. But doing such a scene several times..I cant imagine.
Great acting tips in this one.
I've been playing video games for almost 20 years and this was the best launch of a game I've ever experienced. you did a phenomenal job!
Nice to see that Liquid Snake started doing something good as acting!
😔 miss mgs
@@josephmoore9706 Don't cry that it ended. Smile that it happened.
I love the part where they all T pose together... Such a touching scene...
Why does he look like cgi in the interview???
He’s well groomed and looks after himself probably
because all the actors in the interview are cgi. only the motion capture scenes are real
@@timt5733 I know that symbol..⛱️
it should be illegal for a man to have hair that nice.
The thing I appreciate is that the TV show didn't shy away from this scene because its one of the most brutal, visceral, and gut wrenching scenes ever put into a video game especially for anyone who is a parent themselves.
WOWWWWWWWWWWWW. I cannot imagine bringing yourself to that state, someone going 'CUT', and having to do it all over again.
This is such a fucking hearbreaking moment in the game, but I can't help but LMFAO at the guy playing the dead solider just laying on the floor in the background.
And now we have to prepare to see this scene in live action and that’s not something I’m ready for yet
I loved Sarah in the game so much.
the most powerful scene ive ever seen
Yo acting is so damn weird but amazing though, I be too embarrassed tryna cry on screen lol
I hate the word perfect, but after ten years, multiple remakes, a sequel, and tv version led by another brilliant actor, I'm confident in calling his performance here perfect
It looks so insane to see them crying on the ground, then immediately stand like that, holding their arms up 😂
I too, T pose to get away from my depression.
Thank you so much for visiting us in Perth Comic Con Troy and I hope you get a lot more cool acting work. You are truly talented!
Must be so awkward to do all those several takes, and using spandex.
Neil: We gotta reshoot a scene.
Troy: Cool, what scene are we doing?
Neil: ...
Troy: Don't do this to me...
Neil: Oh that's perfect, we got it!
I’d bust out laughing after seeing that emotional moment and then they just get up and T-pose
And that is one of the reasons I played this game so many times on PS3, PS4 and now no PC...
Best portrayal of a loss scene overall I’ve ever seen
1:25 it's funny that the scene it's dramatic and in the end they have to do a T pose xd
If you want to play a video game that will take you on an emotional rollercoaster the last of us the number game that will do just that. The storyline alone makes the last of us the greatest video game of all-time and the gameplay solidifies its place as the greatest video game of all-time times 100. Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson they are the greatest duo ever put in a video game.
Troy Baker deservedly gets a lot of praise for this, but the real star was Hana Hayes.
Troy is the christian bale of Voice acting, he VA so many notable characters Joel and the joker the most iconic
It was a Good Actors in the HBO
I just find incredible how a lot of people here are talking about how the scene is better in the game and bla bla bla
but even Troy said that Pedro it's a incredible Joel, and that he (Troy Baker) learned something about Joel from the interpretation of Pedro Pascal, can u guys understand that Pedro Pascal nailed it?!?!?!?!?!
I cried like a fucking baby watching, please, just take that emotion of nostalgia away, it's a pure fucked up thing, u think something older it's better, just because it's older, and it's older times, I'm glad that Troy loves Joel so so so much, that even he learned something, while other people just want to say shit
No it's not bad acting or poor directing, not this fucking time, it's just your sentimental nostalgia of being younger and played the game in a certain time that was better, u don't fucking miss the acting of the game, u miss your feelings (of a kid/child/teenager whatever) that u had WHEN u played the game
Congratulations to Troy, I cried like, 3 times?!
And congratulations to Pedro fucking Pascal, that made me cry 1 more fucking time
(yeah, I said "fucking" a lot, yk, english isn't my first language, and feels good to just say fucking, don't blame jkhdsajkhdsajkhdsajkhdsajkhadsjkh
só sou um fodendo brasileiro pica dando uma opinião e um fato de que nenhum de vcs, e provalvemente nem eu, sabe julgar algo pq a gente se deixa levar por emoções burras e estupidas, quem diria que todo o mundo conseguiria ser tão ruim em criticar as coisas, não sei o que aconteceu tlg, mas a gente é uns merda quando se trata de apreciar ou criticar algo kjsahdjhadjahjkda)
sarah >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
When the game came out for the first time. That scene made me know, that game is gonna be, a legend❤
I wouldn't be able to use real life emotions. For some reason, my grief suppresses itself. Any grief is a split second, just 'Hi!', then 'Bye!'.
i mean the last of us 1 was hard cause of that scene, then obviously going through that game to possibly think ellie is gonna die THEN you play the 2nd game and joels demise, i cant even watch that scene in the game cause that must of been so hard to do, i cant imagine if they do a 3rd game, something dark has to end
Hey, maybe Part 3 will have a theme of redemption, we can dream!
Hana is so tiny here omg 🥺
At 1:21 I was expecting him to just drop her 🤣
These 15 minutes here in Brazil and nicknamed crying daddy. For almost a redubladinhas
My birthday was on December 17th, and my grandfather died yesterday.....(December 18) so I can relate to Joel, except I have no kids....
Reminds me of what Bryan Cranston said in his latest appearance on Hot Ones
This hurts so much...
1:17 I always think filmmakers are pretty good at holding their laughter...the more actors do their job right the more it gets funnier when they suddenly stop acting XD. It's kind of sad their acting is translated in to GCIs. I know that's how it works but these acting look better than the one in some live action films I've watched lately.
And now Pedro has to go through it
Yes 😢😢
Michael Scott: "NO GOD PLEASE NO! NO! NoOoOoOoOo!!!"
Pedro even didnt acted like baker in this scene mannnn
the t pose is killing me
When that happened in the game… I got so upset and emotional… That I nearly cried. I threw my game controller down and yelled “this is the stupidest fucking game I’ve ever played!“
It left me. Heartbroken.
10 minutes later, I was back to see what happens next. BEST GAME EVER!
Ps to this day I still get choked up over Joel and his little girl.
ugh i love well-spoken men
The T posing just makes me laugh. I understand why they do it, but it just makes me laugh every time.
This scene broke me. So... yeah... they got it! 😭
I didn't see it coming. I knew the game was about a man and a young girl, but when I started playing, I just assumed Sarah was that girl. But, nope. They got me. 10 mins into the game, and Naughty Dog had my emotions at their beck and call.
And this scene was so important to the rest of the story. It needed to happen, and we needed to see it to fully understand Joel's journey. To understand why he was so resistant to Ellie. And to see the change and fully understand why Joel, in the end, would do absolutely anything for Ellie. And why we got the ending we did.
Bravo Naughty Dog. Bravo Neil. Bravo Troy. Bravo Hana. 🙌🏻
Y do they have to do the arms out, legs spread pose after the scene?
geez. didn't know they put _that_ much effort into it. I kinda just watch it with a blank mind and don't put too much thought into it. I could definitely tell the acting was _unusually_ good for a video game, though.
Cries because daughter is shot and killed in a terrible setting and feel pain.
Proceeds to T-pose.
This was the saddest scene in the whole game. Enough said.
Druckmann made a great call, but honestly he should have communicated what he wanted sooner.
Why am I just now seeing all of this
why didn't the actor of Sarah audition for the last of us series ?
This was 9 years ago so she probably grew up alot by now
@@hubertsangma537 true true I didn't even think of that! Dumb of me to assume that she could be perfect for the role
Yea at first he was kinda screaming but that take that nails it. It feels genuine not like a big whole "Noooo!" *pounds fist into the dirt*
Does anyone know where I can find the full version of this? Of all the mocaps and the talks of the actors...
“Grounded: The Making of The Last of Us” on CZcams
Amazing
Hana Hayes should of played Sara in the show... 100%
yeah no. this was 9 years ago and she no longer looks sarah age. nico parker was perfectly cast as sarah.
@@alazjaw.8968definitely not perfect, not terrible like the show as a whole, but definitely not perfect
@@SaijeMage yes, perfect. nico was perfect as sarah.
@@SaijeMagelooks wise obviously nico looks nothing like sarah. but she played her perfectly, especially her death scene
i have never cried and started laughing this instantly in my whole life 1:09
You goddamn wraith. What an actor. Best scene ever
So Troy Baker's ego is actively a hurdle the director has to snuff out to get a desireable performance.
Well, the way most actors cry on command is by remembering terrible moments in their lives. Who tf wants to constantly relive those moments over and over again?
What’s the name of this full video?
The Last of Us Grounded Documentary or something like that.
Actually, it sounds like Troy blowing smoke up Druckman's ass. That scene in the game is tremenously moving. It doesn't mean the other takes of that scene weren't
This was The Last of Us
Hannah Hayes would be perfect as Sarah in the series
She’s 23 now. A bit too old.
nico parker was perfect as sarah.
Not available in my country):
Did you manage to play it ?
@@DarkS707YT hi this is mt new acc, i couldnt back then because i was in north korea, i escaped.
@@Matt-bk2rt lmao
@@Matt-bk2rt 💀
@@Matt-bk2rt Lol 😂🤣
With the game going cross platform, I cannot keep track of different actors playing the same character, i feel a pillock for leaving incorrect comments! I thought it was the actress Ashley, but its Hana!
Hanna plays sarah
After watching the first episode of the series, I found it incredible how Sarah's death was so... unemotional. Even a background was added so that we could become attached to her, following her for a whole day in her normal life compared to the game where we only meet her during the night of the accident and even with all that she didn't manage to generate the same impact.
Perhaps it's because when I played TLOU I went into the game knowing nothing and I was shocked after watch what happen to her but the series failed to capture a moment that became iconic in the industry and a powerful moment for Joel that become much more important later in the game.
Now seeing this behind the scenes (thanks youtube) one can see the importance of the direction.
I don’t think you or anyone else, not feeling the emotional impact of Sarah’s death has anything to do with bad acting or poor directing. I have seen many reactions to the TV series that were extremely emotional here, and a good amount have played the game. I think that for some people emotional responses come as a result of shock alone, and no matter how much you try you will never, not know what happens in that scene to trigger an emotional response to it. I didn't get emotional either but I still felt awful about the scene and felt its impact, because I was empathetic to both characters. Both versions of the scene are fantastic
I really hate this scene! Great work.
He's so handsome that he's look like made form unreal engine
Who's the guy at 4:07 ? He doesn't look exacly like Neil.
The actor who played tommy
They should have just casted Hannah Hays as Sarah in the HBO live action.
This was 10 years ago dude. She’s too old for that role
@dessieangel1021 Whats so different when they have 30-year-Olds playing high schoolers? 😒
@@naboorruu clown take
Wonder why they couldn't just cast Hayes again to play Sarah. Too old? Doubt it, some make up and you good.
because we need black people.
She's a grown woman now. This video was 9 years. They probably started doing motion capture years before, so this is more like 12 years ago. She's likely in her mid-twenties now lol.
She is 24 now. And taller. A bit too old to be playing a 12yo.
@@mortal_kombat930 It's so annoying that they did that. Like, even if one does not care about sounding "racist", bitching about it doesn't even hold up because we know she dies in the first episode. And we can't even say that we're ok with it because she dies in the first episode, because then we sound like an insensitive piece of shit.
@@mortal_kombat930 Sarah's race wasn't an integral part of her character.