StarTalk Podcast: Cosmic Queries - Until the End of Time, with Neil deGrasse Tyson & Brian Greene
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 06. 2024
- On this episode of StarTalk Radio, Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice are answering fan-submitted Cosmic Queries with the help of theoretical physicist and author Brian Greene. Brian has been a frequent guest on StarTalk and always tends to blow our minds when he shows up - this time is no different. The topic for this episode is Until the End of Time, which also happens to be the name of Brian’s new book!
How far will we journey into the cosmos during our lifetime? Neil and Brian ponder this but they also debate how long humanity will last in general. Will we outlive the predicted length of existence we’ve seen from other species? Will we destroy ourselves? What happens if we send a crew into interstellar space and when they return everyone is gone? You’ll learn how long it takes just to get out of the Milky Way alone and what humans would be like if they grew up never knowing the Earth.
We explore free choice and free will. Brian tells us why he thinks we don’t have either. Discover more about time: is it made of something? You better believe we talk about string theory. Brian shares why spacetime itself could be stitched together by the threads of quantum entanglement. You’ll hear how dark energy could rip the fabric of spacetime - and why that might not be as catastrophic as it sounds. You’ll also learn why black holes shrink down if spacetime rips apart.
We dive into the meaning of life: Is there any? And, if there isn’t, what’s the point in living? Brian explains why he thinks physics should guide us and also set us free. Neil and Brian discuss the role of religion and if that would change if we were contacted by extraterrestrials. You’ll find out where the universe ends. Lastly, we investigate entropy in the universe. All that, plus, discover more about the simulation universe and if the human brain will ever figure out human consciousness.
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
Subscribe to StarTalk: czcams.com/users/startalk...
Follow StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalkradio
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#StarTalk #NeildeGrasseTyson
This episode originally aired March 9, 2020. - Věda a technologie
The fact they deliver science in the context of 3 friends casually coming together and having fun is brilliant on so many level
I agree! It's refreshing and very pleasant!
actually Neil doesn't agree with Brian but still respects him
I would rather watch CGI film from NASA 😆
This was a maniac (Greene) with a wide audience, being corrected and reprimanded by a Scientist (Tyson).
This kind of setting makes learning new things a delight.
Brian Greene!!!! When I was in college, after years of hating reading (because of a negative school experiences), Elegant Universe was the first book I ever read on purpose. It set me on a path to learning about string theory, learning to think critically, discovering Neil deGrasse Tyson, Richard Dawkins, Steven Hawkings, reading Einstein's papers on relativity, diving into quantum space theory, and so much more. Not that you'll ever see this, but thank you!
Only if learning would have been this much fun and enthusiasticly driven back in the days when I could have changed my life to prosperity.
@@RobiFilth You can still change your life to prosperity. Go for it!
My girlfriend gets mad when I tell her all the facts I learn from watching these
@@coleenlane2312 My family barely tolerate my trivia. Luckily my cousin actually seems to be interested in the videos I recommend him, and he seems to remember the content, so there's hope for him yet.
@@coleenlane2312 i can relate to that
im like zero in mathematics and zero in physics. but this show is my favorite Ever. you make it too easy to understand. I love astronomy.
be safe. love from ALGERIA
Do you love shrooms as well?? Also how do you like algeria? :)
thought you said "love from ALGEBRA"
Free Diugh SAME
You wish his was your teacher/professional growing up i know I do!
Love from Australia kenza
My favourite part of StarTalk is that 10% of the show is everyone just laughing at all the awesome. It makes me smile ✨💫
KayleeBrowncoat Chuck is a legend
This was the most thought provoking Episode I've seen in awhile. Great show guys. Please get together again soon.
Same here except for mama tysons episode. I think the mid level astrophysics isn't evolving fast enough for new content to be available so other fields need to interact to make interesting happen.
I couldn't agree more. Been watching star talk for a while and that was definitely the most engaging and thought provoking episode.
Did you notice that Greene kept lying and making up nonsense and Tyson kept correcting him?
That is because Greene is a charlatan.
I recommend you listen to two years ago shows also, on the StarTalk website.
Think I learned something here 🤔 educational and definitely not a waste of my time
40:09 That moment was absolutely gold ❤️🤩
I was about to comment this myself.
what is the thing that he said?
Even my mind overheated from that answer. Such a great show :D
@@growwor He says, "like an overloading phaser," a sound processor filtering the sound so much that you can no longer identify the original input sound. See here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phaser_(effect).
Chuck is learning by osmosis and will fill in the final piece of the theory of everything equation.
Can't wait
My GOODNESS, I love how Brian Greene doesn't even bat an eye with some of these questions. It's INSANE
Such an experienced teacher, he has probably heard similar questions thousands of times.
Words might be without meaning....sooooo
I really gotta say this, thank you Neil for letting us all see the the world from the cosmic perspective. Your work has completely changed the way I perceive literally everything and helped me find something true and beautiful to hang on to. Instead of looking at the tips of my shoes, I now look up in the sky, and as the classic goes - said no more counting dollars, I'll be counting stars. Thanks a lot
S0 say all of us! 1 trillian %
trillion
well the amount of stars you can count really depends upon how much light your eyes can collect. also, note many of the lights in the sky are entire galaxies. so you're probably going to be counting your entire life.
...oh yeah and don't forget to count the sun, everyone always forgets it.
I can tell from his eyes he is suffering inside for selling his soul.
@@robmcilheney1657 One Trisha MacMillan Percent?
CHUCK CAME THROUGH AT 40:08 FOR THE AVERAGE FOLK LIKE MYSELF! SO glad he's on the show 🙌🏾
Marvel: Infinity War is the most ambitious crossover in history.
Brian Green: Hold my book.
This comment was perfect in every way
Before anyone comments about social distance....
This was recorded a little over two months ago.
Thank you for your attention ;)
I came to the comments to see if anyone posted something to this effect
Unacceptable! It is called Covid-19, not Covid-March2020
Do you mean Physical Distancing?
@@NoodleMcnoodle What is "Unacceptable"?
@@mediocritysmaze3731 the fact thet they shake hands at the end...
I have a question; why do you guys always rush through answering questions when we will all sit here for hours learning from you?
I love to see what Neil comes up with in such short time
I think because this is a "show" so it has a limit to every episode, just like any other TV show would.
Also the fact that they have a lot of things going on outside of CZcams and their time and brain power is extremely valuable means they don't have hours to pour into answering questions
the details and long answers require science and math.
They got astrophysics to do i guess
The way Brian answers that meaning question is similar to Picasso painting a masterpiece
Super interesting conversation with this guest.
He offers a broad perspective on all questions.
Do invite him more often please..............dear.
What a joy! Make Mr Greene a permanent member of the team. The three of you rock. ❤❤❤❤
My girlfriend gets mad when I tell her all the facts I learn from watching these
Stephen Edwards mad in what way?
Slater Looper mad because I don’t shut up
@@slaterlooper7012 she probably an astrophysicist
On the contrary, my girlfriend never gets mad at me for anything. Cause I don't have a girlfriend😥
Hahahahahha broo i feel like you stole my comment even though i havent commented yet😂 so relevant for me
It always blows my mind how smart Brian really is
You guys are a match made in heaven. Would love to see Brian on the show more often. And of course chuck ties it all together. This is my favorite startalk episode hands down
Neil is just as curious as a child, and I love it
That's the ideal mindset right there. Always curious, always seeking new knowledge. Never being comfortable in one's own ignorance.
No, Neil is just as curious as a man.
Chen Hali
True.
While NDT and Brian spar within their 4D mental game, Chuck just breaks them apart with a “Woof..Woof”
What does this mean?
@@PimpDaddy__ has meaning at 24:11
Hey Neil , this is my favorite show. Could you please do more shows on physics around us. I really love the way you communicate science.
A show on optical phenomena! Or all about sound (two-parter).
Black holes repair the Universe!
Watch the complete "Demonstrations In Physics" with Prof Julius Sumner Miller.
I mean NDT + Brain Greene, I had to like the video before even watching
same
Brian Greene is a charlatan. Tyson keeps calling out his BS.
@@ZeroOskul you continue to state this, and yet, I have not seen a single link to any credible sources that back up your claim. Why bother making a claim that you refuse to back up with actual evidence, actual data, actual facts?
@@MaryAnnNytowl See my most recent video and that video's description.
I have no fear of reprisal.
Best Science Show on CZcams!
Have you watched ALL the science shows on CZcams?
@@ZeroOskul just wanted to reply to your comment to find out more science quality content, so please provide me more channels. Thank you !
World science festival vids are great and very informative
My life's dream has always been to have a career in theoretical physics, astronomy or cosmology but, despite being able to have deep, mind-bending discussions about the nature of the universe, mathematics and I are not friends and never have been.
Listening to scientists discuss the universe is like poetry to my ears.
I could watch these three talk about anything for hours. Thank you guys for bringing us this content.
27:53 thanks for answering my question Brian Greene ..huge fan ❤️. Also thanks to startalk for featuring it, love the show.
Let's give Chuck Nice credit. He has really progressed in co-hosting this science series, and keeps things ON TRACK. Well done Chuck. I thank you.
I just realized this rn 😂 but the great thing about startalk is the content never gets old personally I can watch old episodes allday
This has to be one of the best episodes of Startalk in recent memory. I love the chemistry you 3 have and would love to see Brian on the show more often.
This has been my favorite star talk. I love how much Brian injects into the series. Please keep bringing him back.
Ggggggu
I'm studying for be a teacher of mathematics. Here in Brazil don't have talks like that, the things about math is so limited and the people don't have access knowledge. Thanks for the videos, Is an inspiration
I love these Startalk videos!! This one is especially good, incredibly interesting / informative, and these 3 guys having a convo is also very chill
Are you a bot ??
I'm so happy to see you with Brian Green. My two favorite people!
More Brian Greene!! Best guest by far!!
One of the best episodes. Dr. Tyson Vs. Dr. Greene is always entertaining.
40:07 best moment of Chuck's life
I swear, SNL should make a skit where Neil is on Jeopardy, and keeps interrupting Alex Trebek while he's reading the clues.
Star Talks should be at least one hour and a half, there are a lot of questions to ask, and should be more time to awnser the questions. This is the best content in the internet.
Best episode in a long while. Consider re-hosting the guest!!!!
what a beautiful way to end another day of finals week!
im glad brian stood his ground from being interrupted by neil.
He was more pertinent in all the of the questions answers, i bet it tickled Neil
This is by far my favorite episode. Brian Greene is amazing. I bought his book and it has become one of my favorite book of all time.
I love professor Brian's work. Please get him back.
40:09 was so beautiful!
Thank you so much Dr.tyson and Dr.greene for Answering my question, I love you startalk♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Akshat Pathrikar Congratulations Akshat! Could tou tell me where to find star talk updates about upcoming Cosmic queries so that I can ask a question too?
I love to see Indian are interested to known more about Science.
@@lalua2112 😒😒😒
I have so much respect for Brian Greene! Truly one of the best educators of our time.
17:56...cheered me up so much . I've got the lockdown blues😥😥😥
A few of my favorite recurring guests like Green and Charles Liu make me rewind so much I end up basically watching the episode twice 😂 and I thank you for that! 🙏
Such a thought provoking episode and I am sold on buying his book. Well done.
One of the best! Again! Do not stop, and please - invite Brian more often!
No matter how down I feel. Star talk always lifts me up! It literally makes me smile. This content is much needed for so many people I bet.
What a podcast!! Really thoughtful!
Enjoyed it like no other podcast.. thank you very much!
I just absolutely loves these , thank you so much Neil for your knowledge and willingness to share it
Thats true
The barking comment from Chuck had me rolling!!! 😂😂😂 speaking g for all us
*LOVED THIS EPISODE* 👏🏾
I always learn something interesting on this show
Right when I finish all y’all’s other books here comes another.
Андрей Бахарковскй not if you’re from the south.
Андрей Бахарковскй lol.
@Андрей Бахарковскй Yes, just as you tried to. Sh'up.
I'd love to just sit down, have a beer, and talk about everything with these guys. Absolutely love it! 🤘🏼
This has to have been the funniest, most informative, and most thought-provoking podcast I've ever listened to xD Neil, Chuck you guys just made another consistent listener. This is about to be the best way for me to survive the quarantine!
Fantastic Episode!! 40:09 best moment on the show. It was like watching particles coming together to say "HELLO, I'M HERE"
Keep up the great content!!
Also, Congratulations on reaching the 1million subscribers.
the way i see what brian said about the repairing spacetime, i imagine spacetime as like a bunch of bubbles where the bubbles are all next to eachother connected technically and one in the middle popping would make a hole but the surrounding area almost immediately fills in/repairs the hole. it seems plausible to me
The bubble bath theory. I haven't heard that one in a while :).
Yeah, but Neil pushed and Greene admitted it was BS.
No, because bubbles have a fix amount of particles inside it, and therefore the other bubbles would thin out to refill that space. What Brian suggest if that the space it will recreate it self from nothing to repair itself, without losing any other space that is already in existence. Two different concepts.
zerooskul it’s a possibility, Neil never said it’s BS.. what is your deal? The fact we don’t even know what space consist of and it can easily be something we can’t even currently grasp, is as possible as anything else we can think of space currently not being occupied by the current known matter we can grasp. Are you mad because you can’t think at a higher level and feel so small? There are scary thoughts out there that others won’t be able to live with and go crazy.
Love u guys! Please invite brian more often!
The passion that Brian Greene discusses these questions is absolutely amazing. A man that is in love with the unknown. Inspiring
First part in and I'm laughing like a kid. Awesome content! I totally agree, I hope bryan greene can drop by more.
“I don’t believe any of us, really have free choice or free will” - Brain Greene
Its both...
if you can travel to the past, which i believe he does, future too, it implies that future already exists, right?
You can look up the experiments that prove we have no free will to a certain extent but I still think we do have some free will in a macro level. like choosing a degree or a career path. but when it comes to deciding if you want McDonald's for lunch, then that's possibly different.
Han South You can argue that the future not only exists but is also finished for any particle that has crossed over the event horizon of any black hole that is massive enough. (to our perspective, that particle basically cubes to a standstill and we are now catching up to its time.)
@@EmpyreanLightASMR i certainly believe the psychological assertion that we have parts of us without free will....
But in physics, determinism is the axiom not the proof. Its all still philosophy! If you set out your field of "hard science" is essentially "to find the clockwork in the universe" then it looks clockwork.
Except it looks random sometimes, which isnt free will either its a whim of dice.
Wish I had people who knew this stuff and would dive deep on these topics ...even the basic stuff! Everyone seems to just walk around living their life not knowing or caring about these big questions and even more the actual mind blowing answers we have found out that are facts! MORE PEOPLE should know this stuff and care,cheers to all the people in these comment section who thrive to be in a world that is so misunderstanding to the average person and never getting any chances to release all this information with someone without getting a boring not interested weird crazy look or not even get that chance you are not alone!
Wow! I was NOT expecting to enjoy that so much. That was brilliant.
I really like this show! Now I see my surroundings in a different way...
NEW DRINKING GAME!
For every time Dr. Neil interrupts, either himself or someone else on the panel, take a drink!
Of course, if you do that, you'll miss all the times he calls out Greene on absolute BS.
@@ZeroOskul lol
@@alwilsonwastheman Joe Rogan loves to hear Neil talk, too. Just ask Joe Rogan.
@@ZeroOskul sometimes, he calls BS without fully grasping the point being made.
I thought i would leave after 5 mins and leave a like, but i ended up staying the whole 49 mins. Amazing discussion.
I’m glad you had Brian Greene on.
The way they laugh at 34:48 is just too awesome! It was a great joke!
I'd like to take this moment to say, *cool* shirt, Neil! I'm digging it.
Just ordered 3 of Neil's books... Love this show.. It reinvigorated my love of space and physics
I absolutely love this show. The dynamics is perfect and despite the length of the show, it keeps you interested until the end. Now, I must also say(and that's because I really hearing Neil's talks), I find his habit of stopping the others from speaking in order to insert himself, unproductive and not nice. I really love the man, and as a man he is not perfect of course, but I wish he will read this comment and act upon it. I have watched over 50 of his interviews, shows(all the Cosmos series), etc... and I have noticed that in almost all the shows where someone else is involved in the show.
I will still watch your shows though. I cannot live without them :-) Thank you for inspiring me and everyone who could have given more interest to science had they have a teacher like you in school. You are BRILLIANT and this Startalk show in particular is outstanding. All my students are hooked now thanks to me. (I am language teacher).
Brian Greene is a charlatan. Neil was cutting him off from gaslighting you. He had to.
I listen to this show ever time I’m going to school in the morning and I love it
I love that I have my own "personal physicist". :D
Somewhere Upthere nooo he is mine
Thank you Neil, Chuck and Brian. I have now ordered the book in my language (Dutch) and have it delivered to my son, who studies aerodynamic technology (he is building planes for some reason) and he doesn't know its coming. I'd love to see the look on his face when it arrives :-) You guys have a truly great show! Thanks again.
48 minutes is wayyyy too short for this.. I mean, it's 3am and I gotta sleep but really, if this episode was 5 hours long... I'd still be watching, and getting up late to go to the football tomorrow.. and you know what, I'd be okay with that. Bring back Brian and make this 6x longer, dammit ;) I paused watching Episode 4 of Picard Season 2 for this :D
“this guy will never sit back and listen” so true!! Regards to you all!!
***SIT for future reference :)
@@lordperezident thanks!
Livestream the ultimate vlog: a crew living on a near-lightspeed space vessel. Oh! would we need to eventually buffer and speed up the playback before we could watch it here at home?
This episode was so great guys, thank you! It was wonderful just watching the panel kicking back & having a conversation, forgetting at times that there were running a show. For those that haven't seen, look up The Science of Storytelling (Neil & Brian are on that panel as well).
One of the best episodes.
It would be beyond arrogant to think that we, as humans, know everything that there is to know RIGHT NOW. Calculus “existed” before Newton “found” it (worked it out). Relativity “existed” in the 1700’s but was “discovered” by Einstein in 1905. There’s NO REASON to think that we know everything now. LUCKILY we live in a time (and hopefully it never is taken away from us), that RELIGION does not dictate what we “know” because THEY (religious leaders) TELL US what is fact (sorry Galileo, Copernicus, etc) and what isn’t. We (humans) have an entire universe to discover yet!
Stop being so arrogant.
Ok Boomer
The end of time : when every proton, neutron, electron, photon has decayed away and nothing can change anymore, no more gradients.
you mean entropy is even everywhere, nothing changes.
that implies that energy stops just transmitting and for energy to disappear maybe not to be destroyed but to disappear by going outside the universe or something like that where energy stops changing things and now because there are no changes then there is no time
@JS 09 can energy disappear or convert into something that isnt energy like matter or something else
@@myutubechannel_nr1 "thing" doesn't scientifically describe the essence of your point - Energy is a function of matter in an unstable system, be it thermodynamically, electrically, so on and so forth. Your simile doesn't inspire much confidence that a productive dialogue is about to take place, so I'll leave it there.
Light travels about a billion feet per second so everything you observe is one billionth of a second in the past per foot of distance.
Space is Time, it's spacetime.
From your standpoint you are the end of time and everything away from you is the past; but from the perspective of any other thing, it is the end of time and everything away from those points is the past.
The distant edge of the universe is the dawn of time, not the end of time.
From the perspective of every point in the universe, relative to every other point in the universe, right here right now is the end of time and every point at any distance is the past.
It is in the right here, right now where the future unfolds based on occurrences in the past effecting the present.
I love Brian. One of the top communicators in science and promoters of it.
First he rocking the early Einstein look. Cool. My hero too.
Great show. Ty.
I love everytime, these two guys get together. I can listen them all the time. More of this guest please :-) great work.
Whats time made of ? Ouch my brain hurts!
I had a dream that black holes were the counter to the expansion of dark matter slowing it down. If I were to ever share a dream I would only do it here.
Except both dark matter and black holes have gravity which would normally slow the expansion of the universe . . . However the combined gravitational pull of EVERYTHING, every single particle, planet, black hole, galaxy, etc. Is nowhere near as powerful as it would have to be to stop the expansion of the universe that is caused by dark energy which means, as best we can tell, the fate of our universe is unavoidable and only ever expands faster and faster.
@@godless1014 Except Gravity was debunked by Einstein who replaced it with General Relativity in 1916, and GR was first proved in 1919 with the Eddington Eclipse Experiment and it has never been repeatably proved wrong.
There is no gravitational pull.
That there is no force acting on a body in freefall was Einstein's happiest thought, remember?
There is no force of gravity and there can be no carrier particle for that force since it does not exist.
It is just the general motion of everything in the universe relative to everything else warping spacetime.
The constant increasing expansion has also recently been challenged.
Also, the stuff expanding is Dark Energy, not Dark Matter.
Dark Matter holds galaxies together.
Dark Energy expands forever.
I had a dream my legs where broken and I was in a hospital but nobody could help me because all the doctors where pigeons. But to each his own.
@@ZeroOskul um . . . Dude . . . I don't know where you get your info from but . . . Um . . . No lol. Gravity is still a thing lol. GR doesn't say that gravity doesn't exist but that our classical Newtonian interpretation of it wasn't the full picture. Also I already said that the thing doing the expanding isn't dark matter but dark energy. Thanks though. I got this.
What an incredible show. Thank you very much
PLEASE do a tour of your office. I'd love to get a better look at your collection of books, globes, the doll, everything and the stories on how you acquired them.
I am addicted to you and your teaching style. Your shows are out of this world. 🙂
Chuck Nice is an awesome cohost.
Much love from Canada 🇨🇦
Plz for the love of the spaghetti monster, centralize the pop filter foams of the mics
I DO NOT LIKE YOU VERY MUCH EUDUARDO, I DIDNT NOTICE BEFORE I READ THIS
If only Neil will let others speak. Every show he does he has this habit of inserting himself. He can’t let others be
I love him but trueeeee LOL
This is the most annoying thing he does. Neil always interjects himself into the conversation ans tries to make it seem about himself. Smh
Agree
True
....or u can make ur own show and demonstrate how it's done....
27:53. Best question and answer ever
Wow! My favorites together. Love it. I'm saving this one to watch again later. By the way, your sponsor , The Great Courses Online is awesome and well worth the time and money.
"Dear" lol
Too much IQ going on probably warping the fabric of space time in that room! The Brain Greene edition!
Brian Greene is a Charlatan and Tyson calls him out on abject BS at least 3 times.
@@ZeroOskul You have no idea how apt a name you chose for yourself, zerooskull.
@@Edruezzi Yeah, zero skull, all brain; all skull would be no brain.
It actually says Zero O'skul, but who cares about reality?
Yes, it is apt.
Hey, check out my latest video to see just how inept I truly am.
I would pay to be in the presence of these 2 geniuses and be able to ask questions. wow! what a great show. Brian and Neil are so interesting to watch. Cant get enough of the amazing universe
It's such a treat to hear from these two greats sitting together and discoursing on such a profound and mindblowing topic. My mind expands to new horizon each time I hear you guys. Thanks.👌👍
I tried to make a comment but Neil interrupted me
You're soooo funny omfg