I picked up a couple of the 9019s and I am impressed. No faults with writing and most of the work I performed was cosmetic. I removed the mould lines and polished the body and cap with Flitz polish. The micro scratches on the black model was really no worse than what I have experienced with the black cellulose acetate used on Pelikans. Cheers
I am so glad you did not mention the Namiki Emperor (LOL). It must be difficult for those of who are use to more expensive and precious pens to review low end pens that we common folks have the money to buy. Montblanc 149 cost from $1,000-$1,200. Namiki Emperor Kylin $8,400. At that price I know you won't find a flaw, not even with a magnifying glass. Pilot Custom 845 cost $410. Montblanc 146 - $650. Leonardo Supernova - $450. The resin found on the 9019 cost $13.99. The resin found on the Montblanc 149 cost up to $1,200 to enjoy. Cost difference between the two pens: $1,186.00 We must keep our expectations realistic as we see this rather large cost difference. Kind of like buying a purse from Walmart, expecting the quality of a Louis Vuitton or Hermes bag. Can we imagine walking out of Walmart making snide remarks about the Walmart purse failing to provide what a Housse of Hermes bag would offer you. If you want the Hermes (Namiki Emperor), then go to a Hermes Store; if you want Vuitton (Montblanc), then go for the gusto.. Of the five (precious) pens mentioned in this video, the cost would be: $11,110.00. The Jinhao Dadao 9019 is a $14 bargain of the highest order!!!! (12:56) I am thankful for a pen that not only fits my Walmart pocket, but is a smooth writer and fits well in my hand, with a large capacity converter!!! Can't ask for more for such a bargain. My oldest Jinhao is 15 yrs old and is still in use. I find that by taking care of my pens; cleaning them and storing them properly, they have endured the test of time.
You make great points. I agree with your major points, and appreciate the perspective. I really enjoy the EF nib on 9019. It is great even for use on cheap paper. I have yet to try the Medium nib.
Thanks for this review. I have two of these 9019 pens with EF nibs and agree with your findings. One of them wrote like a dream right out of the box, and the other wrote but needed a bit of tweaking to smooth out the ink flow and prevent skipping. I’m no nibmeister, and I didn’t do much but it was enough. In any case, these are amazing pens, especially for the price. I never expected such a big, fat pen to be so comfortable in my hand - I have long fingers but average width palms - but they are addictive. Now smaller pens feel a bit cramped. The EF nibs are close to a Western fine, broader than the needle-like Japanese EF. I noticed that there must have been some quality control because when I washed the pens before inking up for the first time, there was a bit of blue ink in the nib. The nib must have been tested in some way before distribution. So far the converter has worked well and I think it is better made than the Noodler’s one. This is a new design and has a very large capacity for a converter. A CZcamsr engineer (Doodlebud) measured the converter’s ink capacity by weight: over 1.6 ml. This is comparable to some piston fillers! I haven’t seen this converter sold separately (yet) but expect it eventually because the smaller converter used in earlier Jinhao pens like the x159 are available. That would fix any future issues with a faulty converter - just get another one for cheap. I like that the converter screws in and that there are supports built into the bottom of the barrel to hold it securely in place. No rattling or loosening. I expect this new #8 nib, now that it has been in two pens (x159 and 9019), to appear in future Jinhao pens. I hope nib point variants are introduced by Jinhao and by third parties. A more flexible version would be fun. I agree: this new huge pen should be tried. It really surprised me and now is a favorite. One of mine is a clear demonstrator, which I enjoy.
Very interesting review! I don't have the 9019, but I do have, and like, the x159. Drying has not been an issue in the x159; however, I use it with a pigmented ink, and so make a point of depleting the fill by steady use. I never have had to tune a Jinhao nib like you had to -- just lucky? -- but I have had to tune far more expensive nibs on a Conklin (Jowo?) and a BENU (Schmidt). When I give a pen as a gift, I always dip test the nib in ink and water test the converter and feed, to be sure the recipient has the best start possible. But, then, I give Jinhaos, not Mont Blancs!
Thanks! I am surprised, too, on how often the more expensive nibs need touchup. Jinhaos, I have had [many], have mostly written nicely out of the box without a fuss. And I have spent hours tuning a montblanc 149 and a Pelikan m1000 [don't get me started on m1000 nibs 😉 ]
@crouserm Interesting, my X159 and 9019 write perfectly every time. My Conklin All American (which I am told is made by Jinhao) with the M JOWO nib/feed randomly skips. I have gone through three (3) Medium nib/feeds and they all skip randomly (you can write half a page, then a skip). How did you fix yours?
@@kevinblack8365I used a purpose-made brass shim (Goulet Pens); however, our problems might not have been the same. My recalcitrant nibs wouldn't write from the start. I could see the ink in the feeds, but no flow. Tines too tight. If your nibs allow initial flow and then quit, I wonder if the problem could be too-dry ink or machining oil. Drew from Goulet Pens has two helpful articles on the issue; How to Fix a Pen That Won't Write at All! and How to Fix Skipping and Hard Starting Pens, that address the issue pretty well. Good luck!
I was eyeing MB 149 nibs to a Jinhao x159 but could never pull the trigger. I like the 9019 Jinhao even more, especially with the large capacity converter. I may have to explore the wonderful world of Jinblanc or Monthao.
I say you go for it. I it is one of the most enjoyable writing experiences...right up there with pilot custom urushi and Namiki emperor....and of course, the MB 149.
@@luisbalderrama8145 I have been looking at MB 149 nibs on eBay but they are nearly the cost of a pen. Are there other shops to explore (I live in the States)?
I got my 9019s delivered today. It took less than 2 weeks via Ali. They’re really good but I think just a bit thick for my liking. I will probably adjust to it with use. I love the converter and ring on the lid. I think it’s only a matter of time before Jinhao go full piston.
It is pretty thick, it is trying to match the emperor's section, I think. Piston would be nice. But I think they will milk the larger converter for a bit before they do that :)
I'm really glad I found your channel because I've been looking for a fountain pen CZcamsr with beautiful handwriting. Many have horrible handwriting, and it seems an insult to the writing instruments as well as the viewer. I really like your paper here, too. Thanks!
If a fountain pen CZcamsr who spends either hundreds or thousands of dollars, often on one pen, can't be bothered to write legibly, it's a waste of my time therefore my life, and since there are many who do this, the time accumulates. This has nothing to do with you, so I won't be replying to you anymore.@@animula6908
I have three and all write wonderful out of the box. I say better than the x159 for what ever the reason. I have the transparent one on the way. I can't wait to play.
Nice to hear your voice. I don't know what to make of these clone pens yet. I don't have any Jinhaos yet, because I'm still wondering what is the longevity and durability is. I hear good stories and stories that of the pen being junked after a couple of weeks.
Thank you, my friend. The quality and logevity are hit or miss. I have a Jinnah pen from 2015… it works fine. I have a “duke” pen from 2005, also a Chinese pen, that works great when inked. No issues. But I have also had a Jinnah x159 break the 2nd month. I like them because of how cheap they can be had, and as a way to experiment on tuning nibs, grinding, etc. That is how I started grinding nibs, and later I did grind several of my MB nibs to my liking :). Cheers!
For a moment I thought it’s a pocket sized pen (because of ‘Mini’ in its name and I’ve a Sailor Progear Slim ‘Mini’ ), but disappointed to know that it’s not ( It is not yet available in India where I live) and collecting pocket sized fountain pens has become my ‘speciality’ 😉
Hah. Sorry for confusion. I said mini, because I like to not bore with exact measurements, historical stuff....blabla. just the pen in hand...and some comparison with the writing sample. 😀. Magnacarta make some nice pocket pens. 😀
@@Shak-MD Thanks.. I’ve 60+ pocket pens, including one manufactured at Magnacarta facility with a Schmidt nib, but not branded ‘Magnacarta’ ! When I asked the promoter of Magnacarta about their pocket pens, he offered me this one which is also less expensive than the Magnacarta branded pens..
@@Shak-MD I'm sorry for my English, but I didn't find a replacement for the jinhao 9019 nib for the wing sung 630 nib on your channel, . On the channel, i'm can find a positive experience of replacing the monblanc 149 nibs, but not the wing sung. I want to buy a nib from wing sung 630, as I have heard many good reviews about it and install it in 9019, I would be grateful if you would give me your opinion, I would like to know if there will be any problems with this? thank you in advance.
@@Shak-MDI was looking at the OPUS88 frosty demonstrator, but totally got turned off (no pun intended) once I found how many turns it takes. I have a x159 that I like, but really don't use because it requires 2 1/2 turns to uncap. I take frequent short notes, so a snap cap, or quick twist off will work. TWSBI Eco requires only 3/4 turns, Kaweco Sport about 1 turn, I don't understand why the Chinese pens make their caps like this, otherwise I'd have ordered the 9019 already. I've been eyeing the Majohn P136 which supposedly only takes one turn to uncap (though it's also a bit more expensive). Still, I Iike the form factor.
My x159 dries out over time, but Yukari Royale does not; same for Preppy, TWSBIs and slightly less so for Kakuno. I wonder if the 9019 shows similar. While these cheap pens are a bargain, design consideration of the inner cap sealing mechanism would really put these homage Jinhaos to the next level.
I couldn't agree more. There should be an "easy" fix for that. That is a problem with Jinhaos, that they dry out if not used regularly. But the price is so tempting!! :)
Pricing a Jinhao Dadao 9019 at $15 is absurdly too low and I am not even joking. The Jinhao 9019 literally looks like a pen that you would honestly price at $799 not $15. What I’m saying is that the Jinhao company shouldn’t sell themselves short. I would happily pay around $800 for a Jinhao 9019 model and many customers would be content with that too. I remembered complaining about a lot of overpriced products but in very seldom occasions like this I would say that the Dadao 9019 is severely way too underpriced. The true value of the Dadao 9019 is right between $550 and $950 NOT $14 or $15.
I often wonder that. It can essily make an 80 to 100 $ pen. Due to quality concerns, inconsistent performance, etc, it would get heat at that price point. However with some refinement, I can't see why it couldnt be worth much more. Look at Esterbrook and Leo....
I picked up a couple of the 9019s and I am impressed. No faults with writing and most of the work I performed was cosmetic. I removed the mould lines and polished the body and cap with Flitz polish. The micro scratches on the black model was really no worse than what I have experienced with the black cellulose acetate used on Pelikans. Cheers
Awesome. I need to polish them out as well. Don't you lobe the convertor??
That converter is absolutely superb. I hope they become available, it's good to have a spare or two on hand.@@Shak-MD
I am so glad you did not mention the Namiki Emperor (LOL). It must be difficult for those of who
are use to more expensive and precious pens to review low end pens that we common folks have
the money to buy. Montblanc 149 cost from $1,000-$1,200. Namiki Emperor Kylin $8,400. At that
price I know you won't find a flaw, not even with a magnifying glass. Pilot Custom 845 cost $410.
Montblanc 146 - $650. Leonardo Supernova - $450. The resin found on the 9019 cost $13.99. The
resin found on the Montblanc 149 cost up to $1,200 to enjoy. Cost difference between the two pens:
$1,186.00 We must keep our expectations realistic as we see this rather large cost difference. Kind
of like buying a purse from Walmart, expecting the quality of a Louis Vuitton or Hermes bag. Can we
imagine walking out of Walmart making snide remarks about the Walmart purse failing to provide
what a Housse of Hermes bag would offer you. If you want the Hermes (Namiki Emperor), then go to
a Hermes Store; if you want Vuitton (Montblanc), then go for the gusto.. Of the five (precious) pens
mentioned in this video, the cost would be: $11,110.00. The Jinhao Dadao 9019 is a $14 bargain of
the highest order!!!! (12:56) I am thankful for a pen that not only fits my Walmart pocket, but is a
smooth writer and fits well in my hand, with a large capacity converter!!! Can't ask for more for such
a bargain. My oldest Jinhao is 15 yrs old and is still in use. I find that by taking care of my pens;
cleaning them and storing them properly, they have endured the test of time.
You make great points. I agree with your major points, and appreciate the perspective. I really enjoy the EF nib on 9019. It is great even for use on cheap paper. I have yet to try the Medium nib.
I'm a Chinese,this only sells like 6 USD here,I can't afford mont Blanc even piolet,my pen is only 3 to 10 USD,and I'm enjoying of them.
Absolutely. Many of modern day chinese pens are awesome writers right out of the box or with minimal manipulation.
I use my $1-$30 pens 3x more than my +$100 pens
Thanks for this review. I have two of these 9019 pens with EF nibs and agree with your findings. One of them wrote like a dream right out of the box, and the other wrote but needed a bit of tweaking to smooth out the ink flow and prevent skipping. I’m no nibmeister, and I didn’t do much but it was enough. In any case, these are amazing pens, especially for the price. I never expected such a big, fat pen to be so comfortable in my hand - I have long fingers but average width palms - but they are addictive. Now smaller pens feel a bit cramped. The EF nibs are close to a Western fine, broader than the needle-like Japanese EF. I noticed that there must have been some quality control because when I washed the pens before inking up for the first time, there was a bit of blue ink in the nib. The nib must have been tested in some way before distribution.
So far the converter has worked well and I think it is better made than the Noodler’s one. This is a new design and has a very large capacity for a converter. A CZcamsr engineer (Doodlebud) measured the converter’s ink capacity by weight: over 1.6 ml. This is comparable to some piston fillers! I haven’t seen this converter sold separately (yet) but expect it eventually because the smaller converter used in earlier Jinhao pens like the x159 are available. That would fix any future issues with a faulty converter - just get another one for cheap. I like that the converter screws in and that there are supports built into the bottom of the barrel to hold it securely in place. No rattling or loosening.
I expect this new #8 nib, now that it has been in two pens (x159 and 9019), to appear in future Jinhao pens. I hope nib point variants are introduced by Jinhao and by third parties. A more flexible version would be fun.
I agree: this new huge pen should be tried. It really surprised me and now is a favorite. One of mine is a clear demonstrator, which I enjoy.
Very interesting review! I don't have the 9019, but I do have, and like, the x159. Drying has not been an issue in the x159; however, I use it with a pigmented ink, and so make a point of depleting the fill by steady use. I never have had to tune a Jinhao nib like you had to -- just lucky? -- but I have had to tune far more expensive nibs on a Conklin (Jowo?) and a BENU (Schmidt). When I give a pen as a gift, I always dip test the nib in ink and water test the converter and feed, to be sure the recipient has the best start possible. But, then, I give Jinhaos, not Mont Blancs!
Thanks! I am surprised, too, on how often the more expensive nibs need touchup. Jinhaos, I have had [many], have mostly written nicely out of the box without a fuss. And I have spent hours tuning a montblanc 149 and a Pelikan m1000 [don't get me started on m1000 nibs 😉 ]
@crouserm Interesting, my X159 and 9019 write perfectly every time. My Conklin All American (which I am told is made by Jinhao) with the M JOWO nib/feed randomly skips. I have gone through three (3) Medium nib/feeds and they all skip randomly (you can write half a page, then a skip). How did you fix yours?
@@kevinblack8365I used a purpose-made brass shim (Goulet Pens); however, our problems might not have been the same. My recalcitrant nibs wouldn't write from the start. I could see the ink in the feeds, but no flow. Tines too tight. If your nibs allow initial flow and then quit, I wonder if the problem could be too-dry ink or machining oil. Drew from Goulet Pens has two helpful articles on the issue; How to Fix a Pen That Won't Write at All! and How to Fix Skipping and Hard Starting Pens, that address the issue pretty well. Good luck!
I’m hoping other pen manufacturers adopt this new increased capacity converter.
I definitely hope so too. I am sure Jinhao will at least 😀
I was eyeing MB 149 nibs to a Jinhao x159 but could never pull the trigger. I like the 9019 Jinhao even more, especially with the large capacity converter. I may have to explore the wonderful world of Jinblanc or Monthao.
I say you go for it. I it is one of the most enjoyable writing experiences...right up there with pilot custom urushi and Namiki emperor....and of course, the MB 149.
This. Its a great mod. It fits way too perfectly.
@@luisbalderrama8145 I have been looking at MB 149 nibs on eBay but they are nearly the cost of a pen. Are there other shops to explore (I live in the States)?
I got my 9019s delivered today. It took less than 2 weeks via Ali. They’re really good but I think just a bit thick for my liking. I will probably adjust to it with use. I love the converter and ring on the lid. I think it’s only a matter of time before Jinhao go full piston.
It is pretty thick, it is trying to match the emperor's section, I think. Piston would be nice. But I think they will milk the larger converter for a bit before they do that :)
I'm really glad I found your channel because I've been looking for a fountain pen CZcamsr with beautiful handwriting. Many have horrible handwriting, and it seems an insult to the writing instruments as well as the viewer. I really like your paper here, too. Thanks!
Thank you for the kind words. My entire purpose for getting into the fountain pen hobby was to improve my writing. I'm glad I'm making improvements.
Gosh, you feel entitled to insult people for not writing pretty enough for your standardS? That’s pretty unkind actually.
If a fountain pen CZcamsr who spends either hundreds or thousands of dollars, often on one pen, can't be bothered to write legibly, it's a waste of my time therefore my life, and since there are many who do this, the time accumulates. This has nothing to do with you, so I won't be replying to you anymore.@@animula6908
I have three and all write wonderful out of the box. I say better than the x159 for what ever the reason. I have the transparent one on the way. I can't wait to play.
I also have the transparent one on the way. Don't they make awesome gifts? To infect innocent bystanders with the fountain pen craze 😀 . Enjoy!
@shak-md8248 what I love most about them is that they are inexpensive that I started to play with nibs ....
Nice to hear your voice. I don't know what to make of these clone pens yet. I don't have any Jinhaos yet, because I'm still wondering what is the longevity and durability is. I hear good stories and stories that of the pen being junked after a couple of weeks.
Thank you, my friend. The quality and logevity are hit or miss. I have a Jinnah pen from 2015… it works fine. I have a “duke” pen from 2005, also a Chinese pen, that works great when inked. No issues. But I have also had a Jinnah x159 break the 2nd month. I like them because of how cheap they can be had, and as a way to experiment on tuning nibs, grinding, etc. That is how I started grinding nibs, and later I did grind several of my MB nibs to my liking :). Cheers!
Mine have lasted pretty stalwartly, even when I’ve wished they’d quit on me so I can rationalize buying more pens I don’t need. 😂
Thanks for the informative review. What can you say about the model Jinhao 9016 ?
Thanks.
About 9016: I have a review.
czcams.com/video/RQzHflsgVUY/video.html
I hope you like it.
For a moment I thought it’s a pocket sized pen (because of ‘Mini’ in its name and I’ve a Sailor Progear Slim ‘Mini’ ), but disappointed to know that it’s not ( It is not yet available in India where I live) and collecting pocket sized fountain pens has become my ‘speciality’ 😉
Hah. Sorry for confusion. I said mini, because I like to not bore with exact measurements, historical stuff....blabla. just the pen in hand...and some comparison with the writing sample. 😀.
Magnacarta make some nice pocket pens. 😀
@@Shak-MD Thanks.. I’ve 60+ pocket pens, including one manufactured at Magnacarta facility with a Schmidt nib, but not branded ‘Magnacarta’ ! When I asked the promoter of Magnacarta about their pocket pens, he offered me this one which is also less expensive than the Magnacarta branded pens..
Wow, the mb149 nib works, thats pretty awesome haha. That nib cost as much as 100 of the pen its in 😅
Yes, true. Have you seen the close writing sample video? Or works awesome!
i got one. the body is brilliant but the nib i got was scratchy af
True. The QC is a problem. Generally, the nib can be foxed to write well, though. I hope you get it going and enjoy it. Tried 9016? Smaller version.
¿Where they sell the Montblanc 149 nibs?.
Ebay and the pen shows.
@@Shak-MD Aha, thanks for the info.. 👍👍🇪🇸🇪🇸
Hello! Jinhao x159(or 9019) and wingsung 630 nib are interchangeable?
I'll make a youtube short and show if it does 😀
@@Shak-MD I'm sorry for my English, but I didn't find a replacement for the jinhao 9019 nib for the wing sung 630 nib on your channel, . On the channel, i'm can find a positive experience of replacing the monblanc 149 nibs, but not the wing sung. I want to buy a nib from wing sung 630, as I have heard many good reviews about it and install it in 9019, I would be grateful if you would give me your opinion, I would like to know if there will be any problems with this? thank you in advance.
Hello!
I just checked. Yes, you can use the Wingsung nib #8 on Jinhao 9019.
@@Shak-MD Thank you, friend.
You are welcome!
Maybe I missed this, but 2+ turns to uncap?
Yes. A bummer. Not nearly as bad as the OPUS 88''s 6 million turns.
@@Shak-MDI was looking at the OPUS88 frosty demonstrator, but totally got turned off (no pun intended) once I found how many turns it takes. I have a x159 that I like, but really don't use because it requires 2 1/2 turns to uncap. I take frequent short notes, so a snap cap, or quick twist off will work. TWSBI Eco requires only 3/4 turns, Kaweco Sport about 1 turn, I don't understand why the Chinese pens make their caps like this, otherwise I'd have ordered the 9019 already. I've been eyeing the Majohn P136 which supposedly only takes one turn to uncap (though it's also a bit more expensive). Still, I Iike the form factor.
My x159 dries out over time, but Yukari Royale does not; same for Preppy, TWSBIs and slightly less so for Kakuno. I wonder if the 9019 shows similar. While these cheap pens are a bargain, design consideration of the inner cap sealing mechanism would really put these homage Jinhaos to the next level.
I couldn't agree more. There should be an "easy" fix for that. That is a problem with Jinhaos, that they dry out if not used regularly. But the price is so tempting!! :)
Pricing a Jinhao Dadao 9019 at $15 is absurdly too low and I am not even joking. The Jinhao 9019 literally looks like a pen that you would honestly price at $799 not $15. What I’m saying is that the Jinhao company shouldn’t sell themselves short. I would happily pay around $800 for a Jinhao 9019 model and many customers would be content with that too. I remembered complaining about a lot of overpriced products but in very seldom occasions like this I would say that the Dadao 9019 is severely way too underpriced. The true value of the Dadao 9019 is right between $550 and $950 NOT $14 or $15.
I often wonder that. It can essily make an 80 to 100 $ pen. Due to quality concerns, inconsistent performance, etc, it would get heat at that price point. However with some refinement, I can't see why it couldnt be worth much more. Look at Esterbrook and Leo....