Pop vs Metal Singers 1| Revisited
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 12. 2020
- This video is just like the fist one, but a lot of people complained about me using studio versions for battle beast and arch enemy, arch enemy is kinda tricky because you cannot post anything of them, and their firm ends up blocking the videos. I
Life is like an RPG: if you're a Dutch Woman, you got a +15 in singing (Charlotte Wessels, Sharon den Adel, Simone Simons, Floor Jansen, Diane van Giersbergen etc)
I'd throw Anneke van Giersbergen (Ex. The Gathering) in there also. Her and Sharon were the first. And Anneke inspired Floor to start singing.
But not Anneke???
I'm Polish men. I have +15 in alkohol tolerance
Diane? Anneke.
Putting Ariana up against Tarja is seriously stacking the deck. No way Ariana could ever measure up.
Ikr
this comment is hilarious
Tarja has classical vocal training wtf it not a fair comparison
@@marisolalvarezlopez7968 I know! I enjoy metal and it's just one of those stuck up metal fan videos where they act like "if you don't sing metal or play metal, you're no good at music". Like it's honestly childish
What about Christina vs floor and Simone 😅 not even fair for Christina.
Metal is the modern music of Europe!!!!!!!
I need to relocate. 🇺🇲 👎
@@metalground212 NOOOOOOOOOOOOO EUROPE >:(
@@metalground212 zell then floor jansen isnt ur type shes from the Netherlands in europe like me and shes in my fav band and song #Nightwish #LastrideoftheDay
This comment is so ominous
Metal is original music ....the first song is thandava of lord Shiva.....check the beats on that. It was composed by demon lord raavana for his lord Shiva.
Floor is the Queen
Nah, Tarja is the queen. Floor is the Viking goddess. :P
nope its sharon
I swear almost *NOTHING* can compete with that clip of Tarja’s Supremacy high note. What an absolute madwoman, she’s incredible
its nothing too special at all
A better title for this video is Europe vs Usa
More like usa=pop and europe=metal
@@_Plague_Doctor_049 mhm-
i wonna be a metal singer when im older and this is why
#Nightwish
I in usa and unfortunately this is true. Bunch of brain dead zombies over here have sold out to depressingly inferior music.
Europe is such a good place for so many reasons, but this is one of the reasons. Good music
@@lnleywolfie7326 Don't say "when you're older". Start now. All of the good talented singers started young with their practice as well. Talent is nice to get a head-start, but it won't get you far enough without practice for a long time.
Floor Jansen make all those pop singers look and sound like amaturs
Cause they are
She also reminds me of a shield maiden 😍
Honestly while most pop singers aren't amateurs (they've usually had proper singing training) they ARE usually severely lacking in talent. They're scouted for an image their publisher wants to sell, not for their singing talent.
Agreed
@Wait What? that your opinion ok so what .
Regardless of which is better, the metal singers themselves definitely look like they're having a more enjoyable performance.
It’s funny how so many of these metal singers are more like classical singers, makes them even better.
Most of them have classical training, so that checks out.
@@Navajonkee proves how much better they are
Because most metal music, in wild ways, is just classical music with electricity. It follows that vocal stylings, range, writing, thematics, and musical arrangement would be largely the same. Fleshgod Apocalypse, WinterSun, and so many more are perfect examples.
@@jasonedward6993 I’ve seen this theory so many times, although I agree they do have their similarities (and are both amazing genres of music) I feel like this fits more with symphonic metal/gothic metal.
@@gothgirlgraveyard3539 possibly. I gave examples which suited my biases, naturally. In terms of thematics/lyrical content, a lot of what Immortal does isn't far off from what Wagner did; in terms of symphonic, early Abigail Williams would be right up there with the whole package; hell, even add some Cradle of Filth if you can stomach Dani's midget cocaine shrieking(I can, but know it's not for everyone). Åkerfeldt is another example of great writing, thematics, transition, and classical training made even more stark between Opeth and Bloodbath.
I guess the overall point, is that there's just a better command and appreciation for music overall. Besides, one cannot deny that WinterSun is just electric Tchaikovsky in more ways than not.
Tarja Turunen ❤️🔥🤘🏻😎
Agreed
I love her too, right. That delicious metalic sound 😂👌🖤🖤 she must be friends with Vitas (who I also love 🖤🖤 and this is not sarcasm, I know they sing incredible in real life but it is hilarious)
Lol Katy perry's roar vs Alyssa white-gluz 😂
Should have been Tatiana's roar; but, that might have scarred a bunch of viewers for life :) :) :) Metalhead for 50 years and getting rustier every day................................
willy clem lol I’m slacking, I’ve only been a metalhead for 16 years
😂
Lol I feel that
Did Katy Perry roar? Must have missed it.
So many metal singers have classical training, there's no comparison between these singers. Floor Jansen and Simone Simons compared to Christina Aguilera? No contest!
But you need some Ronnie James Dio in here!
+1 for Ronnie
second I seen Katty Perry "Roar" I had either Tatiana from Jinjer or Alise from Arch Enemy on mind
That clip of Tarja makes me want to charge into war, that clip of Ariana made me fall asleep. Bad idea to compare the 2, Ariana could never measure up to that.
delusional 🤣🤣🤣
@diascrive seriously dude😑 don’t spread negativity
@diascrive They didnt sack her because she was bad or they didn't like her. It was horrible for all of them. They sacked her because they wanted to move into a direction she couldnt follow. Whether it was the right direction is certainly up for debate since many would say it didn't work out with Annette. They were damn lucky they got Floor.
@@chrism2964 actually no, the real story is a loooot more complicated than that. Tuomas was in love with Tarja but she was married and he got jealous. He fired her when he couldnt handle it anymore and accused her of being "unprofesional"
@@nightguardian01 The point really is that they didn't fire her because she was a bad singer. What you said may be true, but they did also want to change direction, even if that was because of the tension as much as for creative reasons. Tarja couldnt really deliver on where they went, but Anette couldnt really deliver on the older work either. Floor is the complete package.
I’ll pick Metal/Rock singers over Pop any day, and Floor Jansen has got my #1spot in Metal/Rock....she can sing anything she wants & it sounds unbelievable!!
Ikr, like it’s obvious that Amy Lee > Ariana Grande. More people should learn that
You're still comparing apples and oranges. Some of these metal singers have operatic vocals. Not being able to sing opera though does not make you bad singer. Would it be fair to say you simply like a specific vocal type?
Ok, you want non operatic training, you’ve got it, Ann and Nancy Wilson “covering” Led Zeppelin’s stairway to heaven with Jason Bonom filling in for his father “and Led Zeppelin sitting in the audience with tears in their eyes because of how good the tribute was. Metal and rock is just better because you feel it, in your soul, pop you don’t. To put it another way, metal/rock is a steak dinner, pop is bubblegum, one is filling and memorable, the other is to cure boredom
No, because there are undisputably some singers in the metal genre that just blow at least at lot if not most of those pop singers out of the water. Really, give Floor Jansen ANY kind of song and most of those mainstream popsingers won't ever see the light of day again... and I am not even talking about those popsingers trying to sing rock, metal or classical. Sure this video is a bit of a stretch, not all metal singers are good and not all pop singers are bad - but unfortunately a lot of humankind has seldom - if at all - listened to a REALLY good singer.
Yeah, I don't get the point of this video. All I see in is examples of singing, mostly very good, in a variety of styles.
Wow the difference between Lady Gaga and Floor Jansen !!
Look I'm a metal fan, not a huge pop fan, but this video isn't fair. All of these artists are good and talented, but they all have different strengths. It's not like your comparing apples to apples. All of the pop musicians that you show have proven to be strong live performers just like the metal performers. Most of these metal performers are classically trained, which pop singers don't tend to have. It doesn't make them less then, it just gives them a different sound and that doesn't make them bad. We really need to stop pitting women against women in the music industry. It doesn't prove anything.
And why do does Metal Ground think pop singers need to be "humiliated" by Metal singers?Is this trying to be controversial click bait or what?There's room for different music, it's not a competition.This is just "let's trash pop singers for the fun of it."
It actually does matter. See my comment above...think about it in that context. When you start to realize what the agenda of the elitists is with pop music, youll never see the music industry the same again.
Well, yes industry is biased but that doesn’t mean these singers aren’t talented or can’t sing. For instance ariana grande is a trained broadway dancer/singer/actress. I always feel like metal music should be exclusive to selected few of us who can feel and understand because you can’t expect everyone, especially the ones who are caught up by this consumerism era to “get” these songs. I know at the end I’ll be listening Nightwish in my 80s(if ever I live that long) but not an ariana grande song. These comparison videos make metalheads look pretty much loser crying teenagers.
@@ravenonthewindow Funny thing is, rock and metal was actually quite common on the radio here in the Netherlands in the 90's and early 2000's. But they phased that out for more American pop, R&B, and other stuff like that. And I hate that they did that. We used to have at least one radio channel that played rock/metal music. (Arrow classic rock it was called) But even that one got bought out pretty much because it was a smaller channel that couldn't afford buying a bandwidth when they decided to re-auction them a while back.
@@Sanquinity It’s the same in here, Turkey. Now non-mainstream songs are only played in alternative channels or university radios which I enjoy listening to, but most of the people consider this as marginal lol because we had the “satanic student group epidemic” in 90s (total bs, manipulations of media) and since the music they were listening was most commonly metal music, the genre has kinda demonized.
@@devox3291 Finally, someone who has seen behind the glittery pink curtains of the famous pop singers, and says out loud the ugly truth. There is a reason, why those few pop singers are pushed everywhere, and why only they get highlighted...
Floor be like "dis my song, now."
There's plenty of reasons why Metal isn't accepted in main stream. One of the reasons and I like to believe is this, personally. It's because pop artists know that deep down that they can't compete worth shit against these talented vocalists. Sure Ariana can hit high notes but it's nothing like Simone Simmons or Tarja. Plus Ari sounds nasally as hell. Beyonce though, I'll give her that. She's gifted but I still think she isn't up to par with Metal.
America elitists have been pushing pop over rock here in the USA for decades. Rock promotes, creativity, individuality, expressiveness and true artistry, most ( not all) of pop has a tendency to promote the opposite of these things. The elitists are trying in every way possible to suppress the human individual spirit. They want a society filled with mind and spirit-numbed zombie slaves.
perfect summary.....
@diascrive you're right metal bands dont have singers they have vocalists as they are broader with their voices rather than alot of pop singers who use auto tune because they cant sing
@diascrive Except there ARE plenty of bands with actual singing. A very large part of metal doesn't use the "grunting" at all. Yet it's still not that widely known or accepted. So your argument for why metal isn't popular falls flat.
Pop is just the for the image.
In Rock n metal one needs immense talent to survive and make it to the top.
adding Floor Jansen to the list is not even fair she easily out sings anyone
Floor v Gaga. Great song, both great singers if the truth is told, but Gagas version elicits little emotion in me. Floors version is like a punch to the heart, its instant tears.
The Gaga vs. Floor comparison was the most "apples-to-apples" comparison of the entire video. And clearly, Floor took Gaga's own music and brought it to a higher level. Unsurprising, since Floor could pretty much destroy any vocalist on the planet.
And, in the next one, Simone herself could have taken Aguilera down. Adding Floor to that one is the definition of "overkill."
Honestly Adele is the only one who actually sounds good live when it comes to non metal
Her high pitch is actually terrible..
Agreed. The others are like pop-children.
i think mariah carey sounds pretty good, at her prime
@@ihcuhcalaK Who?
Um.... u forgot Aguilera, i think. She is extremely good live.
Come on, man. You can't just put Lady Gaga up against Floor and Elize. That would be like putting Justin Bieber up against Hansi Kursch.
Um, that's the point of this video. To show how much better metal singer are to the pop shit.
Lady Gaga can sing and very good. Just listen her.
@@multikody6481 Que a vos no te guste el pop y otros géneros no significa que haya malos cantantes. De hecho los hay, pero en poca cantidad.
@@almajuls3889 that's also the point. Even she is utterly eclipsed by the force of nature that is Floor Jansen. When you can claim Anne Wilson, Lady Gaga, and Tarja on your vocal pwn list, you are in a league of your own. She's compared to Freddie Mercury for a reason, after all...
Not to also say that specific performance of Gaga is not really representative of her vocal range. She can sing without a mic and fill up the room.
Regardless Katy Perry is a joke compared to these ladies here 🤙🏻
Pop music literally means popular. The more well-known an artist is, the less likely it's gonna pack a punch.
Metal artists give a sense of adrenaline. At the same time, they can level the playing field with emotional power ballads. An example of this is An Ordinary Abnormality and True, both by Amaranthe. Another could be Upsidedown and One Cold Day by Lacuna Coil
When talking power ballads by Amaranthe, Amaranthine is probably the poweriest of ballads in their repertoire.
That time in my teens when stage was ripe with Simone collaborating with Floor collaborating with Tarja collaborating with Sharon.... Ahhh
Jinjer would have worked perfectly one of these videos
When you showed Adele i was like, aw, she's actually a pretty good musician, i kinda like her... but then you go and put her up against Noora and I'm like, never mind.. xD
That doesn't make her a bad singer, though.
I‘m pretty sure Adele has a way better stage presence than Noora, but is way less versatile when it comes to singing, probably.
Music is so much more than just amazing technique.
@@The_real_Arovoryou make it sound like Noora's is a slouch when it comes to stage precense, when in fact she's really strong in that aspect.
I think your need to make sure you dont confuse production value or fame with stage prescense. There's no doubt Adele, as one of the biggest artists in the world, is going to have much better production value.
Also being so well known, is it the actual stage precence or the precence of someone's fame or reverence.
There's a clip on CZcams where Michael Jackson pops up on stage and just does nothing for minutes. He just holds a pose. Fans go totally bonkers. Is that stage prescense or the fact he so famous his fans are hard-core.
A more like for like comparison is If you compare against Adelle doing a club gig before she blew up. You will see a more like for like comparison.
I'm a fan of both singers so my comment is to point out the difficulty in taking an objective view of something like stage presence.
I kept thinking Adele was going to miss a note and that's not the case with metal singers.
I think we mostly have a difference of priorities. Metal is a genre which loves virtuosi. It loves to the most difficult singing lines, the most intricate guitar solos and that's truly what artists work towards. In pop I guess it's a lot more about the entire package, a song that many people will like, a good public image and a lot of spectacle around it. It's not about raw musical talent and years of training in pop, so that's why for me it's definitely no surprise that pop singers have no way of keeping up with metal singers
My friends: Ariana, Bieber, BTS, 1D 😘💋🎀😍
Me:
No need to revisit this, we already know that the metal gals sound the same live and in studio
"noora louhimo" sounds like female Ronnie James Dio btw lolllll
Nicki Minaj sounds terrible
I mean then again, she’s a rapper, not a singer. At least she could hold a note or two 😂
@@atlf3357 a rapper who sounds terrible
Male/female, black/white, it doesn't matter metal vocalists are usually going to win any contest w pop singers on most merits.
They have more power, they have to in order to be heard though their accompaniment. They have more control, as it's harder to really control your voice at their levels. And since so many seem to be attempting to mimic auto-tune w their own voices, they tend to have insane range as well.
It's like a tai-bo student sparring one of the Graceys...
1) You can't compare because both styles aim for different purposes. Since both want to reach different kinds of publics, they aim for different details in voices, music (and performances).
2) You can always find live performances that sound better/worse of any artist. e.g.: It's well known that Simone Simons doesn't hit some notes live sometimes and you can find that with a quick search. And please, don't tell me Tarja can sing low notes and sound "normal/good" because she simply can't, at least not since ~2005 (And I'm a fan don't attack me) it's not about what someone can or can't do. It's about much more. Do you enjoy their product? Good. That's all you need to do.
3) Playback exists and pop singers are not the only ones who use it. I've seen Tony Kakko and Tarja live playbacking and screwing it up. Does it mean we should hate them? Answer that yourselves. Is it about being virtuous? Because we can make a video about opera/bel canto singers humilliating metal singers with their own perspective of "perfection".
In conclusion, enjoy what you listen to, let others enjoy what they listen to. And if you will, start listening to things other than metal, whatever it is. Try finding what you may consider "good artists". You may surprise yourself
That last one got me
1:44 dark souls be like
Whats that intro song called? Sounds so fucking good
Supremacy but it's not the original by Muse...there it was sung by Tarja Turunen, the woman you see after Ariana
Its so nice that the creators of this series of videos didn't include the mega geniuses of metal vocals like Bruce Dickinson, Rob Halford, Howard Jones and Geoff Tate. If you did that then pop would stand no chance.
As if Tarja and Floor aren't mega geniuses as well... (the others might be too, I just don't know them well enough to comment on them.)
And Roy Khan
Yo... What the hell what that second queen her voice makes my hairs stand all over.
Floors voice is so byoot even in #Nightwish as the best lead singer ^^
@diascrive nAw fLoOr
Floor is the best thing that ever happened to nightwish
What’s the name of the intro song
The cringe of these video my man this is pretty insane
Can't compare Floor to anyone.
I need help, I’ve been trying to find the pop artist that did a metal rendition of her own song, what or who was the artist
I'm late but Ashnikko? She did a metal version of Tantrum
Doja cat?
ASHNIKKO FT EMPLOYED TO SERVE DID HER SONG CRY AS A METAL VERSION
I am floored by floor.
What's the Intro song
Pop stars are basically bubble gum. They come in all flavors and tend to be consumed by children. Metal is like wine, the best are aged well and take true talent to do it well. I have and always will be a metalhead. I appreciate the talent and will always listen and try to understand before I judge. This video is absolutely brilliant in its comparisons. Im sure the pop stars can do better but in an almost direct comparison, they are left behind.
When you're using a clip of Ariana Grande doing an impersonation, I can't really take the video seriously.
ngl. Stopped the video after Tarja. That was the mic drop, right there.
Isn't it a LITTLE BIT arbitrary to cut from "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" to "Sacrimony (Angel of Afterlife)"? xD
yes because 2 completely different genres and 2 completely different vocal styles should always be compared to prove talent 🙄🙄🙄
The only fair comparison was Lady Gaga & Floor Jansen singing the same song. The rest is still pretty random and not much of a comparison at all.
Only the girl from Jinjer, Tatiana? would mop the floor with everyone.
The only difference is POP live performance is so boring while Metal Rock is powerful
Gud
can anyone name the starting riff?
Well, this video just says the OP is a metal fanboy. Music is music and there are different talents and different genres but art is art. You wouldn't put up artworks of Warhol and compare to Monet for example. If you're trying to shame great singers like Christina Aguilera, Adele, Lady Gaga and Ariana Grande you're just showing how piss poor your understanding of music as an artform is. Grow up and put your big boy pants on ffs. If you limit yourself to a single genre you limit the whole experience. Don't listen to what this knob has to say. Open yourselves up to all the fantastic music that's out there and let your spirit soar.
You're still balancing different artists from different performances unfairly.
If it were the artists trying to do the same thing then yeah sure.
But there's a full school of different vocal techniques being used here and unfairly paired to each other (yes even the girls wannabe have fun, it's a very specific vocal technique and phrasing)
Exactly!! I mean literally the start of the video is just showing that Tarja hit a higher note than Arianna but they literally had no technical comparison, these videos are a joke, and neither the person that made this video or most of the people commenting are musicians clearly. Just a bunch of people that say metal is better because its metal
Lol!! Nicki/Katy vs Elize/Alissa....I mean....How's that even fair?
Who's the woman in the left of the thumbnail?
Alissa White-Gluz
This should really be titled Pop vs symphonic metal singers since most of the metal is in that genre. Which is not really a fair comparison since the genre uses classically trained singers most of the time. And only 1 extreme metal singer which you only showed her holding a yell. Try the same Arch Enemy singer with the 3 styles she uses in "Reason to Believe" instead of cutting her off. Clean vocals, metal vocals, and extreme metal vocals in 1 song. Mine ass well just compare Opera singers vs pop singers instead of this charade.
I just think people who like metal like the bite, while people who like pop prefer a nibble.
Add Dio, Bruce Dickinson and Rob Halford next time for the ultimate humiliation.
You need Angela for that last one. From the Tyrants DVD.
I mean Ariana doesn't sound too bad. Do Metal vs Gospel singers next 👀
👏
Does Nicki remind you of Stewie Griffin with that hair style
What about Brittney Slayes?
Clear lack of Brittany Hayes in here
Y que se gana haciendo un VS ...
Nada
Sólo más odio y celos entre metaleros y fanáticos de el pop por comparar 2 cosas completamente diferentes 😒
Los metaleros siempre siendo infantiles, tratando de recordarle al mundo su "superioridad". Pero hablamos de los fans, porque muchas de las cantantes de metal han mostrado abiertamente su gusto y apoyo hacia la música pop. Tarja por ejemplo, no es secreto que admira mucho a Lady Gaga y Whitney Houston, y gente como Tarja o Floor saben más de música de lo que la persona que hizo este video podrá llegar a saber en su vida. Es mejor disfrutar lo mejor de ambos géneros.
1. Metal
2. Both
3. Metal
4. I mean I liked both but Metal won
5. Metal
6. Metal
Though for real I never noticed how awesome Metal is and never paid it much attention, but now I will. I’d love to do it as a singer but I don’t have the voice for it and I’m more acquainted with Pop and R&B than Metal
Floor Jansen, really.? That's like saying who is better at Hockey, Wayne Gretzky or the whole Mighty Ducks team....
Honestly, I can't think of a vocalist right now to topple Floor but to be fair Aguilera and Adele both have great pipes. Ariana shouldn't try to do anything form Whitney. That was another inhuman set of lungs
Most comments are pretentious. If Lady Gaga would do Metal (which she did and it was good) you would sing her against some Pop singer Gag would win. To compare her with Floor Is unfair and though it was tight. The Cindy Lauper tune was like a metal arrangement and I liked it too. Katie would make a decent metal Chantress. And Adele is without any thought a great singer too. I am a Metal Head and also a musician and as such one needs to appreciate different styles and genres if they were made by talented people.
Says the person who can't even get the name of an adele song correct
FYI "pop" is simply short for "popular music" and not a genre.
Metallica (a metal band) is also "pop" due to their platinum status, talent, international fame, diversity of fans etc.
They might even be more pop than Brittany Spears... although they're popular for their contribution to the metal genre.
That's why heavy metal is so unpopular right now. Metal tards are just ridiculous comparing things. Ariana Grande is better than 99% of the metal vocalists - male or female, and in the clip she's singing a song that she's not used to. The most important: you're comparing apples to oranges - metal and pop require different vocal techniques. You won't hear Jessie J doing guttural as you won't hear Tarja doing melismas.
like any indirect comparision , you need to set it up like a scentific research, ir comparisonision results orentiation etc, does pop win because they sold more etc?, many singers culd perhaps have one the same song better, it makes it sounds like a 2nd place losers plea like tis!
I do not, and I don't need to be a scientist to realize how bad pop artist in general are. They sell more because they work with a whole marketing team that make them popular but yet they don't even own their music or image. They generally produce music that please the masses with two different lines on their lyrics but their content is empty only full of se*x dru*gs drama and abuse etc. They might have money but that says nothing about being successful. Pop artist are slaves of their ego and their management. See Britney spears for example I would not call her career successful when she even needs to do a lawsuit against her own father. I am sorry but the industry is full of sh*it
All 3 nightwish singers can take out all pop singers. Tarja is insane in this video, but floor jansen is the most flexible in styles.
Geez I love metal and I love symphonic metal but putting Ariana Grande in a round with Tarja Turunen could consider it unfair competition and I love Tarja from NightWish ❤️. Actually both genres are wonderful and there are very good pop singers from Madonna to Adel that I really like very much. But this ranking with Sopranos like Tarja or Simone Simons is putting the major leagues against rookies 😅🤦🏻♀️. You have to lower 2 lines of volume to our metal ego and see how wonderful both genders bring to humanity ❤️ . After all, it is not the horrendous regeeton or his auto tune 😅😅😅😅
Bro why Nicki Minaj? XD
If that was Ariana,trying Whitney Houston’s beautiful song-she failed miserably. Floor Jansen by far in first place. Then Sharon from Within temptation. Also Amy from Evanscence. All brilliant. The only musician who’s rendition of a particular song is better than the original is David’s Song if Silence by Paul Simon. David is the lead singer with heavy metal band Disturbed. Even Paul Simon gave it his thumbs up-that’s saying something. Ultimately all a gift from God! God bless all musicians.
Alissa White Gluz iz A Goddess ..
Comparing diverent generes of music to eachother is a waste of time.
Well depends, what you call a pop artist or a metal artist. I give You only 3, and not only woman.
Sia
czcams.com/video/2vjPBrBU-TM/video.html
Vibeke Stene
czcams.com/video/gqHinKtgTwU/video.html
Roy Kahn
czcams.com/video/_GUX5DXin6Y/video.html
They are in my opinion outstanding and very unique😁😁
this is the SAME video of your previous one just in a different order, again not a fair comparison as they are all singing different songs, find them all singing the same song and add a comparison, we all know Lady Gaga can Rock with Metallica she proved it on stage, do a fair comparison or stop making fanboy videos, please
still dont get it... different singing voices... different songs.... what do you want to compare... "well as you can cleary see in this video.... Fish are better at riding a bike than watermelons" ?? pinking the clasical trained metal singers against "normal" singin trained girls and the conclusion is they better park and bark?? whats next stepdance against walzer?
Ok. Metal wins with these pop singers. Now I'll ask you to compare to the biggest pop singers. Because they were missing here. I would like to ask you to:
Cher
Celin Dion
Madonna
Annie Lennox
Mylen Farmer.
@Doğaç Tanrıverdi no
But why? Do people forget personal preference in music? Why do we pit artist against artist in attempt to make a genre more popular? Or more elite? Like who fucking cares just enjoy the music. Music isn’t meant to be compared. Like why do these videos exist still??
Nah people can listen to bad music if that's what they like. I mean that's what they do lol. I do wish metal was more popular tho that way I wouldn't need to be listening to "call me maybe" in 2021!!! I make this videos to show people what they believe to be great is not so great after all. Maybe you would give a chance to metal one of these days.
Christina Aguilera was clearly lip syncing
Lmao y’all don’t see it! Ariana grande could never be a metal singer as well as Adele or anyone singing pop. It’s a lot harder to make metal voices then to have a “perfect voice” just a joke comparison not trying to come for them
Watch her SNL sketches, she imitated some of the best vocalists in the game..like it was NOTHING.
Adele has an amazing voice and lady gaga is Juilliard trained singer..
Metal will always be a part of me but I don't let it cloud my thinking.
Adele is the only one talented as metal singers
Putting the world up against Floor is seriously stacking the deck. No way the world could ever measure up.
Yup, Whitney Houston wouldn't fit your narrative at all. So convenient she's not in the video.
The only female pop singer who is good enough is Adele
All of these singers are great, but Donald Trump beats them all, and I'm not even kidding. He did a karaoke cover of Queen of the Reich and it was better than Tate in his prime.
Do you know anything in singing to do that ?
You compare artists who use their voices in different way… like chest mix in pop and then show a head mix in a lyric way … it’s not the same thing…
You just want to proove yourself métal singers are the best with no argument …
Have you ever heard of Brenden Urie? He can literally sing anything, he has sang both pop and metal. One of the best male vocalists of all time.
As much as I ❤ the Tarjas of the world, it's unfair to compare them to the skills of others in their respective genres (ie Adele and Grande have superhuman ranges. Grande even did SNL where she impersonated most "pop singers" in this video like it was nothing).
Also, much of the symphonic power metal bands (w female vocals) often have predictable sounds/structure..(scared to try something outside their genre's "rebellious rules" so if one listens to Nightwish, they more or less have an idea of what to expect, while "pop singers" experiment with a myriad of genres and keep evolving/growing..
Looking back, I often see metal heads as somewhat close minded and will judge and bully you based on your taste. Where as pop aka "popular music" is full of risks, experiments, collaborations, moods, FUN and HUMILITY..
But behind the scenes, talent respects talent and I can imagine Brittany going out for lunch with Tarja while their fans stubbornly argue. Lady Gaga went to Juilliard so come on huh?
Anyway Maynard of Tool has the greatest voice in metal so...shrug lol