Bella ciao (1943) Italian Resistance song [RARE NON-LEFTIST VARIANT] • Kingdom of Italy (1861-1946)
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 07. 2021
- Please consider Joining our Discord for to learn and talk about History! / discord
Info about the song:
"Bella ciao" (Italian pronunciation: [ˈbɛlla ˈtʃaːo]; "Goodbye beautiful") is an Italian protest folk song that originated in the late 19th century, sung by the mondina workers in protest to the harsh working conditions in the paddy fields of North Italy.
The song was modified and adopted as an anthem of the anti-fascist resistance by the Italian partisans between 1943 and 1945 during the Italian Resistance, the resistance of Italian partisans against the Nazi German forces occupying Italy, and, during the Italian Civil War, the Italian partisan struggle against the fascist Italian Social Republic and its Nazi German allies
Versions of "Bella ciao" continue to be sung worldwide as an anti-fascist hymn of freedom and resistance.
This version differs from the main, leftist one, and was sung by Monarchist resistance forces during WW2 - Hudba
![Il Canto degli Italiani (The Song of the Italians; 1847) Current Anthem of Italy [ALL THE 6 VERSES]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1qvQ4aUw4QY/mqdefault.jpg)
!["Fischia il vento" (The Wind Blows) - Italian Partisan Song [LYRICS]](/img/n.gif)
Fun fact: if you turn your screen upside-down you’ll be able to watch the video from Mussolini’s POV
🦀🦀🦀
Proof.
Lmaaoo good one
@@americanpatriotmarcher8962 cringe American get rekt by Europe
Dude thats a dark joke you do know that musolini was hanged upside down and beaten up right?
Monarchist partisan: “never thought that I would die fighting side by side with a communist”
Communist partisan: “what about side by side with a friend?”
Monarchist partisan: “aye I could do that”
I think it would be more like:
I-a never-a thought I would-a die next to-a communistia
How-a bout a Friend
I-a could-a do-a that
As a monarchist myself, I can confirm that I would fight alongside ANYONE to put an end to democracy.
Communist partisan after getting the monarchy overthrown: sike! time for decades of terrorism
@@epistimonkapetanios based
Agree tho
Democracy in my nation is failed even at its own definition
Oppprtunity only for sons and daughters of politicians or extremly rich 2%, and the empire of brazil had done an much better job then the republic.
Ironically the republic was born from pro slavery land owners.
Sadly fake News teached on school (something that is ilegal) made people think that the republic abolished slavery despide the fact it was the ither way around.
Sadly now the word democracy is used for propaganda, when you attack an "popular" politician it is an attack against the democracy.
We r not friends of the communists.
Literally all Italian monarchist songs are catchy as heck, thanks for uploading rare versions like this one!
that's not a monarchist song but yea it's preety catchy
Sorry it is now
@@feelender7308 Yes it's a monarchist song, the monarchist version of the song that rapresents all the italian who fought against Nazis, fascists and Mussolini and the monarchist helped a lot for the achievement of freedom of all the Italians.
@@joelitti_mdccclxi maybe it is only my opinion but it sadly that Italians didn't want to remain monarchy after war. King was a patriot not fasist it is big diffirence
@@janszczygie2847I mean the referendum was close
Many partisans where monarchists that fought against fascism, all in favor of their King and Country!
Some partisans units where actually autonomous units of the Italian Royal Army, veterans of the previous campaigns in russia, africa and the balkans
@ཊꖦƬGПꖦཏ S̶c̷r̴ip̶̝͘të̵́d̸̔ And what?
@ཊꖦƬGПꖦཏ S̶c̷r̴ip̶̝͘të̵́d̸̔ communists are not people, chad.
Yes they were socalists and monarchists
@@windbreaker2432 communism will win
@@acc314 You will never be a real communist
finally a song which hasnt been ruined by netflix
@UCmLHD54xX849Vw4mJm5HnCg LEftIST BAAAA you do not understand the context of this song and just simply think of modern politics. Italy was being run by an incompetent Dictator who had become a puppet of the n*zis, the people wanted freedom from him and the only way this was going to happen was with the help of the allies. The Italian people were tired of war, and sick of the f*scists and the n*zis.
@@panzerofthelake506 agree comrade
@@bulkysinetv6262 yeah, the comment section is full of stupid edgy neo facists and monarchists
@the chad editor netflix didn't create la casa de papel lmao
@@panzerofthelake506 exactly. the song was literally a chant against fascism, and monarchism inherently implies the same tenets as fascism.
I didn't know there was this version of the song.
Viva il Re!!
Viva il Re!👑🇮🇹❤️🇺🇦
COVID-19: *Enters my body*
The flintstones vitamins I ate in 2014:
Fr
No hablo inglés pero tengo que decir que que es de los mejores comentarios que he visto en un buen tiempo
Viva il Re, viva la resistenza azzurra, viva l'Italia
vive les nation libra abada savie libra erica
Beautiful, viva il re!
Sempre viva il re!
Dux mea lux
Complimenti le tue versioni delle canzoni sono sempre belle.
The Fascists and Communists coping and seething in this comment section gives me a reason to live for.
You’re mad weird for that. It just says you don’t know what you’re talking about and that you’re probably 15
@@cameronokeefe8446 Cope harder.
@@cameronokeefe8446 is it wrong to be against evil?
Tbh as an Italian i think this is not non-lefties and I think it's just a jazz version of it
Lo penso anche io, Otto.
yeah same
@Comic Field A leftist monarchist is an oxymoron.
@@comicfieldand should his decendents gmbe respected for only being blood related? Why should they get the workers hard earned money because "they kinda cool" and waste millions of them that could go to the nation?
Same. I was like: Aight, slightly different text and a bongo.
Per i partigiani azzurri!
Non Rossi, ma assolutamente mai blu. Viva le Brigate GL!
Viva le Brigate Garibaldi
Viva le brigate nere.
Viva le brigate arancioni
Only few people knows that original song bella ciao was sung by Italian partisan in 1943...everyone thinks that this song is original made by money heist creators.
Viva il Re, Viva la Libertà!
Assolutamente no! Fu il re a mettete musso al potere
Viva il Re!
Solo un povero vecchio obbligato alla dittatura a causa della crisi post prima guerra mondiale
@@ilnano123-xt4mb Mussolini siezed power in a coup, and The King didn't intervene because he didn't want to risk starting a civil war.
In my opinion the best version.
*uneducated opinion
When the far-right and far-left are both against you, you screwed up
The monarchists were definitely not far right
Fascism was "Far-Right" We Monarchists are against Far-Right and Far-Left. Alot of us stick closer to the center, though some of us do go to the right or to the left a bit, for example, I am more left-wing than your average Monarchist, but I still stand by them before most Communists.
Wtf based???
che canzone epica !!
bella ciao è una delle mie canzoni preferite, Sono lieto di vedere che è stata rilevata dai monarchici.
Evviva il Re !
Durante gli ultimi mesi del regno d'italia il 25 aprile fu reso festività nazionale. Comunque l'immagine di copertina si riferisce alla giornata del 26 luglio 1943 quando la popolazione di Roma apprese delle caduta del fascismo operata dal re e da Badoglio.
Comunque I partigiani monarchici erano molti, di cui uno importante, Enrico Mauri, di cui ho conosciuto l'autista. Poi Giuseppe Cordero Lanza, caduto alle fosse ardeatine.
I Savoia sono assassini come tutti i monarchi del mondo!
@@MeMeDesimo1871And Communists aren't?
Anche Fischia il vento e Bandiera Rossa monarchica sono stupende.
Bella ciao mr Eduardo Agnelli,your name will be remembered 💖💖✌
best version
Actually the singer was a known leftist. Claudio Villa
Sounds nice
what is different?
God save the House of Savoy!
Guys recommend some songs like this ❤for the love of 🎶
"Non leftist variant"
My brother in Christ, this is the 1975 version of Cladio Villa
How the hell is this a non leftist version if Claudio Villa was a former communist and then socialist
Average monarchist moment
What’s the difference in this one?
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Viva il Re! Long live the King!🇮🇹👑💪
I don’t get what makes the other version “leftist” and this one non-leftist. Is it just that this version was used by non-leftists while the other was used by leftists, or is there some ideological nuance to the lyrics that I’m just not grasping?
My thought exactly. Bella Ciao, while often associated with the left wing part of the Resistance, has really nothing to do with left and right, it's an apolitical anthem against fascism and repression
Normal Bella ciao is completely apolitical, but right-wing partizans were illiterate and mislead by hatred.
@@Erga_Stolanoit was appropriated by the left because:
1) they had quite a long term game in mind about the resistencw
2) the conservatives lost interest
3) the fascists were never prosecuted and were more than happy to confound themselves with the conservatives.
@@Erga_Stolano "apolitical anthem against fascism"
Jesus christ do you people even listen to yourselves.
@@siraethelwulf8914 tell me then, where exactly in the song you can hear the lyrics and say "there, thats clearly leftist"
L Commies and L Fascist
Sí
as a actually communist (not stalinist, stop calling me that lol, im marxist (WHICH IS DEMOCRATIC AAA)) this is based
@@BlazeTrickShotsOgImagine being such a slack-jawed shite that you think the Italian monarchy (which had been getting along fine with Mussolini for the last 20 years) was more "based" than the anti-fascist partisans
@@nicolaysalazar1939 I don't really know how to respond to that idiotic comment.
What's the "non leftist variant" part of this song, the swing?
This is not monarchist at all. And Bella Ciao was written after the war, when Savoia were already exiled and Italy was a Republic. This is at least 4 years after 1943. Bella ciao participated in a song festival in Prague in 1947 for the first time, and the lyrics were published officially in 1953.
Ofc the best version of this song is non communist.
It's still communist. Just because one verse changed doesn't mean the song changed. I would argue that this version is more communist as it signifies a continued struggle, which monarchists would not have faced.
@a70770 LOL this was the version made and used by the monarchists
“NOooOoO iTs GoOd SO I WanT It”
There’s like no different between the “monarchist version” and the regular “Bella ciao” version, nothing distincts it from being ideologically different.
@@Paul_Mattick the instruments and the actually writing of the song is different and this is the best one I’ve heard so far
@@OuwetboaPoliticsAndMemesyeah... unfortunately this "non leftist version" was wrote and sang by Claudio Villa, an actual communist and came from 1975
Lol
In addition, this song's melody replied by "Faiyen Band" with the song title "Liberate and Change!" (ปลดปล่อย เปลี่ยนแปลง)
czcams.com/video/rv5tbROr4_Q/video.html
Love Italy from Tai-Kadai ethnic
🇹🇭🇱🇦❤🇮🇹
Ngl this version is better then the leftist version, something i can listen to while not hurting my ears
Sounds like you have no taste and even worse political affiliation
@@cameronokeefe8446 I am apolitical.
"Vincere! Vincere! Vincere!" - Old Italian Patriotic Song
czcams.com/video/NbThuOwH__o/video.html
I don't get it. What is the difference between this version and the "leftist" version?
Some verses are different
@@MattiavonSigmund Yes, but in meaning what is the difference? What do we have on the other version that makes it leftist?
@@rose72br This version was used by monarchist partians
@@MattiavonSigmund what about Republican Bella ciao? Would that be leftist or non leftist since Italy became a republic after 1947 and some partisans were republicana
@@rose72br There is no difference, they use some different words for a more "accurate" grammar but that's literally about it.
The Kingdom of Italy, but also the communists, joined this song...
Unpopular opinion: meglio la versione monarchica che comunista. Da neutrale visto che non sono né monarchico nientemeno comunista
Umberto II ✋️🇮🇹
Umberto II was an anti fascist, he wanted to create a new kingdom
Ma nasconditi
Ma auto-killati
ma cosa c’entra lo stemma sabaudo con Bella ciao?
Era il simbolo dello stato italiano all'epoca,
@@MattiavonSigmund ma non c’entra assolutamente nulla con i partigiani, in questo contesto avrei messo il simbolo del CLN o delle brigate Garibaldi per simboleggiare i partigiani, non i Savoia
@@marcon2323 Una volta l'Italia fu liberata, i partigiani estremisti furono disarmati, e per un anno l'italia fu nuovamente unita e libarata sotto la monarchia... Quindi no. In più questa versione della canzone fu escusivamente usata dai partigiani Azzurri
Maaaa tipo lasciare stare e ascoltare la canzone no eh? TINTIN? OPPURE MARCON? miiii la sezione commenti è una zona di guerra vera e propria
@@bulkysinetv6262 tranquillo, ho fatto una domanda…
Mussolini 🙃
VIVE LE ROI DE SAVOIE SAVOIE LIBRES ERICA
ciao means hello, not good-bye. 😥
It's both.
it means both, i see so many americans commenting improper grammar here (and on other music videos)
*wow an american, couldnt be me...
couldnt be me...*
ciao is a corrupt for sion... thus We can have here a ciaonist song. because only sionists love that scum bela ciao. ridiculous song. giovinezza so much better.
arrivedece is the italian word for good-bye 😥
Lmao no it is not💀
é una canzone di origine ebraica dell'est e non è mai stata cantata dai partigiani
vive le roi erica de savoie
VIVE UNBERTOT HERITIER VIVE LE ROI ERICA
VIVA IL RE!🇮🇹👑
In teoria anche l'altra versione non è di sinistra visto che dice "il fiore del partigiano" appunto perché ognuno può identificarsi con un suo fiore che sia la rosa alpina o il garofano o altro 😅
Ah yes, non-leftist...that tells me everything.
Surprise: not everyone opposing mussolini were socialists or stalinists
lol
Wow a monarchist bella ciao? Thats exactly what we need lol
vive le roo erica
VIVE LE ROI DE SAVOIE ERICA
Viva Savoia
vive le roi de savoie et italie le roi de france je le laisse tonbe erica elika pelisone je suis sinting bull vive les sioux
Bella Ciao was never sung during the inner Italian conflict (1943-45). The song was actually created in the 60s.
Actually, youll find that the first verion of bella ciao was sung by the "Mondine" (the de-weeders) of crops, who had hard lives working in paddyfields as a form of protest. While it was never recorded, the song was sung atleast 150 years ago... so it is likely many partisans did sing this during la seconda guerra mondiale
@@russellbird373 Again, Mondine or not, when survived partisans were questioned if they ever sang this song during the invasion, they didn't remember or recognized Bella Ciao.
Citation needed
o finalmente na versione diversa da quella comunista origi...ah....c eravate anche voi nella resistenza?????....ora mi ricordo perche non sono monarchico...
Monarcist socalist
Certo che i monarchici c'erano nella resistenza. Era una coalizione tra Partigiani Bianchi (Cattolici/Liberali) e Partigiani Azzurri (Monarchici)
@@lawrencebico1861 davvero???
ottimo....chissa che reazione hanno avuto al referendum monarchia-reppublica o al fatto che l assemblea costituente era fatta da comunisti,socialisti e democristiani...
I carabinieri erano leali solo al Re, per dirne una
SALUT DE LA PART DU RN MARINE DANS 4 ANS COURAGE AUX PATRIOTE S
It's good that The Partisans fought against The Axis Powers, but it's just a shame that for some reason the vast majority of them were Far-left Republicans. Obviously there were also Partisans that were loyal to The King, but unfortunately they seemed to be in the minority. And of course after The War the country fell to Republicanism.
Well it didn’t help that by then everyone in the north on both sides (fascist and partisan) was anti-monarchist
If you look at an electoral map of the referendum you’ll see it pretty much follows the front line at the end of the war
The republicans freed you from mussolini. Who was it who strung the mf up? Socialist republicans.
Bruh get out of the Middle Ages stop simping for monarchs
I cannot possibly imagine why the people fighting against Mussolini were also against the monarchy that had teamed up with Mussolini for the last 20 years. It sure is a doozy isn't it!
@@nicolaysalazar1939 The King didn't 'team up with' Mussolini; he took power in a coup. The Italian monarchy likely didn't intervene because they didn't want a civil war to happen. Besides by the time of the referendum it wasn't even the same King in power, because he had abdicated in favour of his son.
"Non leftist version", oh so the regular version? Bella ciao is a non-political song.
@SocialNazionalista What I meant was it doesn't support any politics, just discredits fascism. As such, there is no "leftist version".
@SocialNazionalista Alright well what politics is this song peddling other than being anti-fascist? And why do none of the lyrics change, but all of a sudden it's "non-leftist"?
Tell me you are not Italian without telling me you are not Italian
@@FlagAnthem Ah scusa, apparentemente tutti gli Italiani hanno solo una mentalità.
@@FlagAnthemnon c'entra essere italiano o meno, semplicemente questa canzone non è una versione "non leftist" dato che semplicemente cambia una strofa e quella strofa di per sé è piuttosto apolitica, ma sopratutto non fa in alcun modo intendere che questa sia una versione politicamente schierata in modo diverso (alias: anti fascista ma non di sinistra) dalla versione più conosciuta.
ni fachistes ni comunistes nationaliste intregral anticomunistes et antifachistes erica
I hate my life
Dont, go to church, God loves you
Don't be sad, you're not the only one who hates you
It's not monarchist nor pro monarchy.
non leftist? lmao
Me ne frego
Yup I know
the original wasn't even leftist anyway
it was leftist
it was originally used by striking workers in the 20s, and the WW2 lyrics were made by the communists, and eventually adapted by other resistance
was actually (still based af) it was by socialist feminist rice farmers wanting fair wages
Viva la repubblica e i partigiani! The king was guilty!
Finalmente un sano di mente
Mussolini had all the power, the King couldn't do anything about it. The fact that some American knows more about your country than yourself should say something.
Mussolini seized power in a coup, and The King didn't intervene because he didn't want to risk starting a civil war. Besides, by the time that the referendum was held it wasn't even the same King in power; he had abdicated in favour of his son.
non-leftist?
This song is literally about opression of the labor force. THAT'S HOW IT CAME TO BE
Thi is not about oppression of labour force. Is about the italians who fought against germany in ww2.
You can just tell the person who posted this doesn’t have a clue what they’re talking about
Not based at all. Giovinezza better.
Viva il Duce e viva il Re! 🇮🇹⚡️⚡️from 🇷🇴🥂
Cringe
Why do you think it's cringe it just sounds like a 40s Revolutionary song
@@AndersHintionThis person is most likely either a Pro-mussolini Fascist or a Marxist.
This is really bad.
ew this version is fucking cringe lol
Your hair loss makes me comittee suicide 😢😢😢
you're cringe
U cant call a partisan song bad like cmon they fought for their country to be free from facist shit
@@socialfascista1943 ofc you have fascista in your username 🤦
@@socialfascista1943are you talking about Fascists right?
Because i'm 100% sure that forcing the king of your country to give you power and then join alongside a different country to occupy italy while your king chose that you shouldn't be prime minister is pretty much being a traitor.
Bella M.
Anti fascist song, “non-leftist” version. So this version is pro Mussolini? 😂
Nope. Its the monarchists, fascists and the monarchists were not exactly aligned. They maybe right wing but mussolini did not like the Monarchy. In 1943 following italys split between fascists in the North supported by the Nazis the South would be Monarchists, Socialists, and anyone anti fascist supported by the Allies