Why You Should Moderate Your Millet

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 07. 2024
  • If you find this information valuable, please like and share the video and subscribe to my channel!
    Also subscribe to my Substack, where I most often put out new content:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    JOIN THE NEXT Q&A
    I run monthly live Zoom Q&As for my members. See when the next Q&A is here so you can join:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    JOIN THE MASTERPASS
    Masterpass members also get:
    * Access to premium content. Preview the premium posts here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    * All my ebook guides for free. See the collection of ebook guides here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    * All my courses for free. See the collection here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    * And exclusive access to massive discounts. See the specific discounts available by clicking here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    Sign up for the Masterpass here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    Or click here to learn more about it:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    TAKE A LOOK AT THE STORE
    At no extra cost to you, please consider buying products from one of my popular affiliates using these links:
    Paleovalley (I have a whole closet full of their beef sticks!): chrismasterjohnphd.com/suppor...
    Magic Spoon low-carb, high-protein breakfast cereal: chrismasterjohnphd.com/magics...
    LMNT, the salty electrolyte mix:
    drinklmnt.com/pages/chris-mas...
    Seeking Health (I use their genetic report, Strategene, and their P5P and lactase drops): chrismasterjohnphd.com/seekin...
    Ancestral Supplements (I use their liver capsules): chrismasterjohnphd.com/ancestral
    Find more affiliates here:
    chrismasterjohnphd.com/how-yo...
    For $2.99, you can purchase The Vitamins and Minerals 101 Cliff Notes, a bullet point summary of all the most important things I’ve learned in over 15 years of studying nutrition science:
    chris-masterjohn-phd.myshopif...
    For $10, you can purchase The Food and Supplement Guide for the Coronavirus, my protocol for prevention and for what to do if you get sick:
    chris-masterjohn-phd.myshopif...
    For $15, you can pre-order a single format of my Vitamins and Minerals 101 book, my complete guide to nutrition, which I am currently working full-time on finishing:
    chris-masterjohn-phd.myshopif...
    For $25, you can pre-order a digital bundle of my Vitamins and Minerals 101 book:
    chris-masterjohn-phd.myshopif...
    For $29.99, you can purchase a copy of my ebook, Testing Nutritional Status: The Ultimate Cheat Sheet, my complete system for managing your nutritional status using dietary analysis, a survey of just under 200 signs and symptoms, and a comprehensive guide to proper interpretation of labwork:
    chris-masterjohn-phd.myshopif...
    For $35, you can pre-order a complete bundle of my Vitamins and Minerals 101 book:
    chrismasterjohnphd.substack.c...
    For $250-$1499.99, you can work one-on-one with me:
    chrismasterjohnphd.com/consul...
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 274

  • @coffeewinetwithdawson8939
    @coffeewinetwithdawson8939 Před 2 lety +24

    Dr Grundy says the complete opposite! And I removed most grains from my diet and this is one of the few on his ok lists! I've been wonderful!! 7 years of pain gone once I removed grains and other lectin foods from my diet now I'm healing my gut.

    • @Jb-ky1ri
      @Jb-ky1ri Před 2 lety +3

      So you eat millet now in ur diet? What kinda millet? Pearl millet? You removed all grains and feel better even though ur eating millet?

    • @coolroy4300
      @coolroy4300 Před rokem +2

      Probably the best thing g you did was quitting wheat .

    • @behealthy9398
      @behealthy9398 Před rokem +2

      @@Jb-ky1ri millet isn’t a grain. It’s a seed.

    • @oohyllab
      @oohyllab Před rokem

      I cannot Fathom giving up lectins completely! Especially tomatoes! That is I Think they contain them as well as potatoes, peppers, eggplant & nuts! Losing potatoes would hurt a might too. Are you seeing great results from this dietary change?

    • @hooglieable
      @hooglieable Před 5 měsíci +1

      By removing most grains, you removed Gluten from wheat in your diet. This is by far the most allergic food in our diet. It is the only food in the world so allergic it can cause an autoimmune disease known as. Celiac Disease

  • @tcphll
    @tcphll Před 3 lety +31

    Talk about junk science. Sure, If I consume 66%, let alone 70% of my caloric intake from one food source, I'm going to have issues. If I consumed 66% of my calories from broccoli, I'm going to have health problems. This doesn't meant broccoli is bad or that the general population should limit their intake of broccoli. What you are describing is famine conditions which inherently comes with problems, regardless of the dominant available food being consumed if it comes from one source. You're also ignoring what nutrients they may be missing from what they're NOT consuming. I don't know where you earned your PhD, but I think you need to ask for a refund.

    • @StrangerToEarth
      @StrangerToEarth Před 2 lety

      You didn't listen to the entire video, what an idiotic comment

    • @vids2click
      @vids2click Před 2 lety

      So true, completely disregarding that increase in staple food is as a result of not able to afford non staple, nutrient rich foods.

  • @dewitubeX1
    @dewitubeX1 Před 5 lety +22

    i just made a soup of millet with some veggies and meat and is very pleasant to eat. it sustains you very well and it controls your appetite.

    • @Drawingb
      @Drawingb Před 3 lety +1

      Can you share the recipe, I'm dropping wheat

    • @dewitubeX1
      @dewitubeX1 Před 3 lety +2

      @@Drawingb i really didn't follow any recipe it was all eye measured. Just search for a millet soup recipe and work your way from there.

  • @1fanger888
    @1fanger888 Před 3 lety +24

    If, as you assert, millet can cause thyroid problems, have there been any studies where millet was removed from the diet, and any reduction in goiters seen?

  • @prathishbaby313
    @prathishbaby313 Před 2 lety +6

    If this theory was true there wont be any people living in my village in south india. 35 years before millets were the staple in rural parts and people remained healthy and never visited a doctor in their life. Later by the influence of wheat lifestyle diseases become common and we saw hospitals popping up in rural areas. Now the govt is pushing for the revival of old crops

    • @neshifuturo
      @neshifuturo Před 3 měsíci

      true wheat is horrible to your health

  • @hitmankofi4071
    @hitmankofi4071 Před 3 lety +35

    My GrandMother ate millet every morning and lived to be 83 years old. She died peacefully in her sleep.

    • @learnedeldersofteemo8917
      @learnedeldersofteemo8917 Před 3 lety +1

      As if 83 if old...

    • @hitmankofi4071
      @hitmankofi4071 Před 3 lety +4

      @@learnedeldersofteemo8917 old enough for quality of life on Earth... 90 is over rated

    • @michaelham2366
      @michaelham2366 Před 3 lety +2

      With very rare exceptions, medical studies base their findings by using more than one subject. The reason is that people differ greatly, and what is of interest are the overall odds. "My grandfather smoked two packs of cigarettes a day and lived to be 87" does not in fact prove that smoking cigarettes is perfectly safe.
      That said, I agree that the video is alarmist, and he fails to mention that we commonly eat goitrogenic foods (such as soybeans, flaxseed, and broccoli). All that is required is to take care that you diet includes sufficient iodine. Eating two sheets of nori a day will prove plenty. (Kelp contains too much iodine so it's best to eat kelp rarely if at all.)

    • @slappy8941
      @slappy8941 Před 2 lety +1

      It took 83 years, but it finally got her.

    • @yvonnesishuwa7500
      @yvonnesishuwa7500 Před rokem

      Mine too..she is still alive in her 80s

  • @ramakrishnann.s.5968
    @ramakrishnann.s.5968 Před 3 lety +9

    Millet was also consumed by red - Indians in America. Poor people consuming millets have known to have better health and immunity.
    This is misinformation without proper study.
    I have been eating millets for the last 1 month, and I feel energetic as ever, compared to feeling lethargic eating rice and wheat.
    This video should be deleted.

  • @Spyrit2011
    @Spyrit2011 Před 4 lety +6

    If your diet is too much of anything, it is not healthy. A balanced diet is the best diet. Millet is actually easy on digestion, wheat is pretty harsh on our digestion process.

  • @momo-tm4pw
    @momo-tm4pw Před 8 měsíci

    Thank you! This is great to know. Since my surgery I have trouble digesting wheat products so I'm always looking for Alternatives and I just bought millet it tastes great but I don't want the thyroid problems😃

  • @YYYYYYFDSDFDS
    @YYYYYYFDSDFDS Před 3 lety +8

    Which particular millet was used in the study ? Were the participants using just one millet or multiple millets?

  • @ukveganjack1566
    @ukveganjack1566 Před 6 lety +16

    I don't think the problem is so much the consumption of goitrogens (found in plant-foods such as cruciferous vegetables); the problem is not consuming enough iodine in one's diet. In the cooking process of such veggies (e.g. broccoli, cabbage, brussel sprouts, kale etc.) you render the goitrogenic compounds inactive; so, if you eat a diet high in uncooked cruciferous veggies combined with marginal iodine intake... then, you're gonna fuck up your thyroid. I find the easiest way to ensure you're getting enough iodine, is to add a liquid iodine supplement to your daily beverage of choice, or consistently add a type of seaweed to your diet such as nori sheets, or dulse flakes. Kelp has the problem of being too high in iodine - so wouldn't use that personally.

    • @strivin4
      @strivin4 Před rokem

      so a system is more important than consumption meaning as long as you get enough of other things in you can take those goitrogens?

    • @oshobaadu6272
      @oshobaadu6272 Před rokem

      Isnt salt iodine?

  • @geetus
    @geetus Před 3 lety +20

    Citations to the studies you mentioned would be helpful -- please provide them. Iodine deficiency may very well have been the culprit.

  • @susanfitch8698
    @susanfitch8698 Před měsícem

    Thanks wow such good info I had no idea

  • @yung_777drones7
    @yung_777drones7 Před 4 lety +9

    I stopped eating white rice, because gluten, stopped eating brown rice cuz its hybrid, stopped eating quinoa cuz the high lectin content. Now I cant eat millet.. I did keto almost gave me a heart attack. Nothing is healthy smh!

    • @DiDie43
      @DiDie43 Před 4 lety +2

      Fucking ridiculous pisses me off too

    • @aqua7344
      @aqua7344 Před 3 lety

      Do you have a sensitivity to gluten?

    • @world-of-susan.
      @world-of-susan. Před 3 lety +2

      It is Pearl millet that is goitrogenic

    • @cigileyAtTR
      @cigileyAtTR Před 3 lety

      Seems like you should stop taking advice instead of stopping the food. Eat what you think is helping you.

    • @jrmint2
      @jrmint2 Před 3 lety

      There are 5 major different kinds of millet.

  • @katharinedavis4947
    @katharinedavis4947 Před 5 lety

    Thankyou Chris. I eat Millet for breakfast sometimes . I have seen recipes for eating it fo main meals like rice . But i will note your reservations and not do that often . K

  • @ravinderkaur3649
    @ravinderkaur3649 Před 4 lety +8

    In India I wish people eat more millets than gluten diet, what you said is not true at all. Please stop spreading such information which can hold back those who have not even yet tried.

    • @suetaniaemmanuel8107
      @suetaniaemmanuel8107 Před 3 lety

      I was about to buy some but now I am not sure. I might just stick to rice

    • @cigileyAtTR
      @cigileyAtTR Před 3 lety

      @@suetaniaemmanuel8107 Buy some already. Don't let fear stop you. My new proso millet tastes like a mix of rice and corn. I'm enjoying it.

  • @absolutrudy
    @absolutrudy Před rokem

    How do you reconcile with what u say when dr gundry praises millet

  • @designsKE
    @designsKE Před 5 lety

    How healthy is it to consume raw (ground) sorghum (where "ground" refers to the sorghum being ground to the state of powder form)?

  • @maremacd
    @maremacd Před 3 lety

    Is this information the same for sorghum?

  • @doletawood5061
    @doletawood5061 Před 3 lety +11

    NEVER in my life have I met an American who gets 2/3 of their diet from millet!😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂

    • @DHARMYOGCOM
      @DHARMYOGCOM Před 3 lety +2

      2/3 diet in america is burgers for most

    • @premier69
      @premier69 Před 3 lety +1

      @@DHARMYOGCOM 🤣 salt, sugar and fat. with instructions: just add water.

    • @sepaleeper5702
      @sepaleeper5702 Před rokem

      right!! what’s millet anyway 🤣🤣

  • @FlipMacz
    @FlipMacz Před 4 lety +3

    Chris, thoughts on organic millet flour?

  • @tarekanwar1335
    @tarekanwar1335 Před 3 lety

    Are peeled millet grains good for the body

  • @sjacrane
    @sjacrane Před 3 lety +1

    What’s your take on Dr Steven Gundry’s advice that millet is the best grain?

  • @CarisaRae
    @CarisaRae Před 5 měsíci

    What if you sprout it first?

  • @strivin4
    @strivin4 Před rokem

    is it okay in protein powder

  • @makedarussell6493
    @makedarussell6493 Před rokem

    Thank you!

  • @hitmankofi4071
    @hitmankofi4071 Před 3 lety +18

    Becareful with this character. Take note of the real toxins that he doesn't speak about. Research on he makes his money. Who are his pay masters?
    This is the same PHD trickster who claims sugar isn't that bad for you.

  • @sallykalya9023
    @sallykalya9023 Před 5 lety +43

    If this was true everybody in africa would be having goiter😂

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 5 lety +6

      You're missing the point that the investigations were into the African villages where most people *did* have goiter.

    • @THEFLESHGOD
      @THEFLESHGOD Před 5 lety +5

      The himba people look so healthy

    • @othernewsid2
      @othernewsid2 Před 3 lety

      @28gire where are you in africa...

    • @john0094
      @john0094 Před 3 lety +2

      @28gire This is partly because most traditional people ferment part of their millet which reduces anti nutrients and increase many nutrients and its bioavailability.Eg being dosa idli etc

    • @phionakatz
      @phionakatz Před 2 lety

      Was going to say that.

  • @natalica777
    @natalica777 Před rokem

    Thank you

  • @ToueTu
    @ToueTu Před 7 lety +6

    Hi Chris!
    Sorry for the off topic, but I hope you will talk about dairy products one day. Perhaps in a Masterclass With Masterjohn :P (just because, there are some details and details there (A1, A2, etc, etc). You probably know this better than me). But, seriously, I feel like there is such a hype and, at the same time, huge controversy around them. Now, it's like, wherever you go, it's the first thing they say to remove from the diet.
    Since I know you consume them, I am curious to know what you think about them (in a more specific and scientific way) and, perhaps, how you deal with all the information.

  • @lisagardner4814
    @lisagardner4814 Před 3 lety

    Is sorghum safe ?

  • @cactusladysouth1000
    @cactusladysouth1000 Před 2 lety

    Thank you.

  • @pauline.7566
    @pauline.7566 Před 3 lety

    How about Chia and flax seeds, should one also them

  • @fpark101
    @fpark101 Před 4 měsíci

    Isn’t it only certain type of millet give this problem?

  • @MsViva710
    @MsViva710 Před 3 lety +1

    But isn't it an alkalizing grain?

  • @payamaghs
    @payamaghs Před 2 lety

    How about quinoa?

  • @cici2369
    @cici2369 Před 3 lety +1

    Asians eat Millet porridge a lot , haven’t seen any with goiter

  • @jasmeetsingh6121
    @jasmeetsingh6121 Před 3 lety +1

    Mmmm not sure about this, do you have references?

  • @carolynjanegillis6591
    @carolynjanegillis6591 Před 2 lety +2

    Thank you doctor, for talking about millet. I was going to experiment with it as a gluten free food. Now I won't! I had an aunt who had thoiroid cancer.

  • @main2333
    @main2333 Před rokem +1

    In India they eat millet. They are fine. Add more iodine. Kelp. In US they are very low in iodine.

  • @Tamiltutor
    @Tamiltutor Před 4 lety +5

    you should remove this video. its a fake information and never be true. Millet brings wonders to one's health STOP this kind of video

    • @johnnyjack4079
      @johnnyjack4079 Před 3 lety

      If you search it up, you will see that there are goitrogenic substances in millet species and sorghum. Goitrogens affects thyroid gland. Now if they find a way to remove the goitrogenic compounds then you will be ok...but untill then...in moderation

  • @l.n.9462
    @l.n.9462 Před 3 lety

    Isn't this just because of the high fiber content? Different types of millet have different fiber content so this could be combated.

  • @Catnip2011
    @Catnip2011 Před 6 lety +9

    Perhaps you can do a topic of those with cancer who had bread & butter in their life, or drink water, or breath air ....... look, they have cancer.

  • @criconinvestments7723
    @criconinvestments7723 Před 5 lety

    Thanks for the advice. And the research

  • @rikirex2162
    @rikirex2162 Před rokem +1

    don't trust Google...the king of contradicting info

  • @ganthiramachandram8787
    @ganthiramachandram8787 Před 4 lety +2

    It's true sir when I consume millets(especially sorghum)I have severe burning sensation in my eyes.and also in throat

    • @trira1171
      @trira1171 Před 3 lety +3

      You have to soak millets for 6-8 hrs before cooking. Look up Dr Khadervalli for more info on millets.

    • @yoniash
      @yoniash Před 3 lety

      @@trira1171 will it be good to Sproute them after soaking then, for a for a few hours or a day?

    • @jorgvonfrundsberg9643
      @jorgvonfrundsberg9643 Před 3 lety

      I have Never had that!

  • @abeerabugharbiya3545
    @abeerabugharbiya3545 Před 3 lety +4

    I'm confused. Do I listen to you or listen to Dr. Steven Gundry who says millet is the best grain.

    • @jorgvonfrundsberg9643
      @jorgvonfrundsberg9643 Před 3 lety

      Don"t let this Jerk confuse you! He"s a fraud! Millet is a very healthy grain.

    • @sjacrane
      @sjacrane Před 3 lety

      Jörg von Frundsberg which one?

    • @jorgvonfrundsberg9643
      @jorgvonfrundsberg9643 Před 3 lety

      @@sjacrane I meant Chris. He is clueless about the real cause of iodine deficiency in Africa. It is malnutrition not the consumption of millet.

  • @good__enough
    @good__enough Před rokem

    Good to know!

  • @thetinytailoress4866
    @thetinytailoress4866 Před 7 lety +7

    Very interesting ! Would love to hear your thoughts on rice and buckwheat, with the same evidence based approach.

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 7 lety +1

      Rice and buckwheat are not goitrogenic. :)

    • @jirihutecka9020
      @jirihutecka9020 Před 7 lety

      Hm so I will stop eating millet and stick with rice, buckwheat, potatoes..

    • @shalinegunness5580
      @shalinegunness5580 Před 6 lety

      So glad I saw this video....I have pica and I eat millet by the spoonfuls raw, I can't help it, I love the taste and its crunch. I'm addicted to it 😕☹️

    • @lancebaker1374
      @lancebaker1374 Před 6 lety +2

      No, you should find scientific evidence that millet is goitrogenic. This quack is providing fake news.

    • @midphy6177
      @midphy6177 Před 6 lety +1

      @Lance Baker: Here is your scientific evidence www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2921306
      Care to make any other uninformed statements?

  • @butters190580
    @butters190580 Před 3 lety

    Should do test on westerners! Are whole diet overall is different we live in different environments we have more access to supplements ect it might have different results

  • @josephdupont
    @josephdupont Před 4 lety

    Isn't iodine the usage

  • @gewgulkansuhckitt9086
    @gewgulkansuhckitt9086 Před 7 lety +9

    The Sudanese millet situation involved pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) specifically - not any other forms of millet.
    ajcn.nutrition.org/content/71/1/59.full
    Millet is a catch-all term for a number of completely unrelated species.
    Eleusine coracana (finger millet) - the fourth-most cultivated millet, Panicum miliaceum (Proso millet) - the third-most cultivated millet, Pennisetum glaucum (Pearl millet) - the most cultivated millet, and Setaria italica (Foxtail millet) - the second-most cultivated millet are the most commonly used millets. Only one of these is the kind that produced the problem in Sudan.
    Technically sorghum is a type of millet, so if you count sorghum as millet, it might be the most cultivated form of millet. As far as I know, there are no thyroid issues with sorghum.
    However, I don't know if ingredient lists specify the type of millet, so it's a gamble. It could be pearl millet.

    • @ladyslick121
      @ladyslick121 Před 6 lety +2

      Thank you very much for this information!

    • @sjacrane
      @sjacrane Před 3 lety

      Did you find anything more on this?

    • @loveunbound
      @loveunbound Před 2 lety

      Thank you

    • @zremflaixhu9176
      @zremflaixhu9176 Před rokem +2

      I wonder why the video owner never responded to this valid concern..

    • @zremflaixhu9176
      @zremflaixhu9176 Před rokem

      This information kind of rounds up the whole conversation. Thanks!

  • @abcdefghijk1mnopqrstuvwxyz

    Would love to know who sponsored this study??

  • @Profile.4
    @Profile.4 Před 4 lety +2

    Fuck this I don't know what to do anymore. Everything is a damn lie

  • @krosser2123
    @krosser2123 Před 7 lety +1

    Does it apply to all types of millet? I have read some statements that only African type of millet - Pearl millet - contains goitrogens... Also can you please add the mentioned references in the description? Thanks!

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 7 lety +2

      It was extensively investigated in pearl millet and not in any other type of millet. However, goitrogens were also found in fonio millet. That said, pearl millet is the most common millet in the world. Most millets sold in the US do not list what variety they are. Do you have evidence they are not pearl millet?

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 7 lety +4

      Hi Krosser, I just talked to several companies, and Udi's uses pearl millet, which is the type that caused the epidemic of goiter. Whole Foods bulk, Bob's Red Mill, and Arrowhead Mills use proso, which is not known to be goitrogenic.

    • @krosser2123
      @krosser2123 Před 7 lety

      Thank you very much, Chris! I didn't know that pearl millet was the most common.
      I really appreciate all your answers and that you even addressed this in the new video! Amazing!

    • @candicesirju551
      @candicesirju551 Před 6 lety

      ty so much for this feedback .... ive been using bob's red mill

    • @zremflaixhu9176
      @zremflaixhu9176 Před rokem +2

      @@chrismasterjohn you need to add this as a pinned comment. Because the video content obviously generalizes what you've spoken about all millets. Please take responsibility and not mislead people.

  • @tboiflex
    @tboiflex Před rokem +1

    Funny cause I’m a Millett!

  • @shantisingh4944
    @shantisingh4944 Před 2 měsíci

    My thyroid became better by eating millets and this i monitored for two years, my stimulating hormones was working very hard and slowly it came down and I lost 10 kg of weight as well so i dont believe this video. My blood sugar became super good by millets. I diet had 90 percent millets in the last two years

  • @AlexandruNicolin
    @AlexandruNicolin Před rokem

    Virtually all salt which you can buy in supermarkets is supplemented with iodine, so unless you live in an iodine-deficient area and not have access to this kind of salt, I think there's no danger.

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před rokem

      None of the salt I uses is supplemented with iodine.

    • @AlexandruNicolin
      @AlexandruNicolin Před rokem +1

      @@chrismasterjohn maybe it's different in the US, but I live in the EU and here I think there's a legal requirement, at least in my country, Romania. I searched a lot for salt with less iodine so I can make pickles without the brine getting cloudy, and I finally found a brand with only around 32-35 mg, which should minimize the issue.

  • @wardrobelion
    @wardrobelion Před 2 lety +1

    You forgot to mention pesticides that may have been used…

  • @neshifuturo
    @neshifuturo Před 3 měsíci

    I eat a lot of millet , more I eat the better I feel

  • @sus9823
    @sus9823 Před rokem

    Millets is very beneficial for our health but only if we consume it right way

  • @rashb3994
    @rashb3994 Před 5 lety +4

    Here's why you're spot on! Just had an issue. I've been eating millet 2 months because it didn't seem to give me issue with my teeth and stomach like rice. Good energy. Then last week my open tooth in the back of my mouth and the gums around it inflamed and my hair's been thinning for the past few weeks. Thyroid was sore and tender. Skipped a few days of millet, everything went back to normal. Thought I could just go back to eating it. Tooth inflamed right then and there. That was culprit! Then I found out hair thinning for can be caused by thyroid issues for some. So despite the naysayers there is truth in what you're saying. Please let me know if you think Amaranth has the same effect? Thanks!

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 5 lety +1

      I don't know of amaranth having the same effect, but you never know what might be harmful in one particular food which is why diversification is always advised.

    • @rashb3994
      @rashb3994 Před 5 lety +3

      After a few days of Amaranth, it ended giving the same effect as millet it just took longer. Switched to sweet potatoes as my main carb and it's been great. No ill tooth or gum inflammation and gives the same energy they did. I was reading they both have phytic acid which is the alleged culprit sweet potatoes do not. Appreciate the video to make people think twice before they get caught in the newest trends.

    • @DiDie43
      @DiDie43 Před 4 lety +1

      @@chrismasterjohn is there a type of millet that is healthier to eat and does not cause these reactions?

    • @oshobaadu6272
      @oshobaadu6272 Před rokem

      @@rashb3994 Millet has been in use since ancient times in Tamilnadu, (South) India and has figured in Ayurveda texts. I have not had it though! I live in the US and a lot of tradition I have given away with. I am trying to find a good breakfast besides eggs and Silverhills 16 grain bread. Never had thyroid issue. Not sure if adding millets would cause it.

    • @rashb3994
      @rashb3994 Před rokem

      @@oshobaadu6272 If you can eat 16 grain bread consistently without issues then you might be someone that can handle millet just fine, so I would try it in once or twice a week doses. It is tasty especially if you toast at first. It cooks fast. Just don't add anything else new to your diet at the time so you can monitor if anything pops up. Based on the legends of those grains there's got to be some people out there built to handle them! :)

  • @michaelham2366
    @michaelham2366 Před 3 lety +3

    I'll point out that, while millets may be goitrogenic, so are soybeans, flaxseed, and broccoli. The problem exists only for those whosediet includes insufficient iodine. Those who use iodized salt, or eat sea vegetables (e.g., a couple of sheets of nori a day), have no reason to avoid millets, some of which are nutritionally rich. Your warning strikes me as alarmist. (BTW, kelp should be avoided: too much iodine in that.)

  • @yateeshbc2593
    @yateeshbc2593 Před 4 lety +1

    Seriously? do you know how many people who eat wheat have Diabetes, heart attack, BP and what not?

  • @justsomeguy2211
    @justsomeguy2211 Před rokem +1

    Wow! I find this very confusing ..... and alarming! The goitrogenic effect of other foods can be removed or greatly reduced by fermentation and cooking. Why not millet? That millet's goitrogenic effect INCREASES through fermenting and cooking is worrying, if true.

  • @deosiewilson732
    @deosiewilson732 Před rokem

    That's very interesting and the study of millet seems to of been very thorough......
    I was here looking for millet bread recipes. I just decided to drop the flour only to discover millet is no good either..... Is nothing safe.....?

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před rokem

      Everything has some trade off.

    • @sepaleeper5702
      @sepaleeper5702 Před rokem +1

      Millet is safer than flour!! Everyone’s body is built differently! I made my bread from millets and it works for me, much better than regular bread..

  • @peggyhall5363
    @peggyhall5363 Před 5 lety +1

    Wheat has gluten. Is it the millet or the lack of other foods to balance the diet. If a person eats too much spinach, they get kidney stones? Is it true kidney stones can be avoided by increasing water consumption according to research this is true. So if a person can not eat millet, & avoiding grains, gluten along with restricting lectins, so no bread?

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 5 lety

      Well the more things you restrict, the less you can eat.

    • @peggyhall5363
      @peggyhall5363 Před 5 lety

      Chris Masterjohn, PhD, exactly. Isn't that your point.

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 5 lety +1

      My point was that 30-70% of the diet as pearl millet can hurt the thyroid gland.

    • @peggyhall5363
      @peggyhall5363 Před 5 lety +1

      Chris Masterjohn, PhD, good Saturday. You avoid millet completely. Most people eat more high gluten & lectin, sugar, GMO; "S.A.D.", type foods, than millet. If millet is all the people you refer to had, then your point is pointless. Those people have no choice. Perhaps listening to Dr. Gundry and lectins; researchers like Sebi about mucus and Hulda Clark about bacteria. Dr. David Glidden; Dr. Eric Berg; B. N. and T. R.; or the big blue book encyclopedia would broaden the view. A person with issues with gout, or gluten intolerance, parasites, allergies or healing from so many others, must limit mostly everything in large amounts of certain foods, some none at all: sugar or delicious milk chocolate etc.. There are free foods to consume in large amounts daily. While other foods are limited to planning, if and when to comsume. We that are healing fight to eat and still enjoy life's bits of fun with foods, that are considered safe, so not to compromise our progress. It is not an easy road. The road map for us is trial and error, with risk of pain at the wrong choice, if not our life or a set back of progress. It is true the more foods we restricted, the less a person has to eat. Your video info does this by limited info. Look at our list in do not eat to heal and be well. Then some one gives us an opportunity to eat something in limited amounts of once a wk. or a month or just a special celebration times. Then some one else comes with, woe to you, if you eat it. Then the shadow of, wow, I already have this & those on my page. Information like in my previous comment about spinach along with so many others in research, reports and ducumented proof this does that & that or does this & this. We in a fight are surrounded by the voices and in them all comes a voice of look, if you do this you can still enjoy this on a moderate amount, still avoiding those other foods. Then you state your points, which have a basis of information dealing with people in a situation in that area. In an area where people with less or limited money, consumed this amount of millet; while people with more money ate less millet & other foods. You see the people with less chose with limited choice. Maybe if they knew this information & had options to eat for a wk at the same cost, perhaps their choice would be different. To them perhaps millet is their only choice: bread, cereal, pancakes, a cake, tart, muffins, whatever.The alternative meant same old same old for the wk. Did they have the opportunity to make a choice? I thank you, that you informed us of thyroid compromise, could or would(?) happen from millet at all or over load? Yet, from the list of thyroid compromising foods it is, but one. The foods you listed as alternatives either do the same or cause havoc in some other organ or place in the body. Choose wisely when the info is presented and give all info on any info presented. The point was limit millet or do not consume. You avoid millet completely, yet would choose foods with high lectins and gluten plus GMO over limited amounts a millet, which is less of these? We that choose to eat for wellness take your info under advisement and thank you. We are winning as we reason what to do. Our choices though limited somewhat compared to all maybe few. Our imaginations planning the limited score of those with this, 'n' that a rare & satisfying personal menu. To thine own self & others be true. If helping is intended, do all you can do. Words can inform or make a person's day feel blue. We strive to survive and persevere through. I am no doctor, just me. I ask for myself & others, think of us daily. The words can mean the difference between limited or a horn full of plenty. A table laden with limited can still have variety.

  • @ashtonbrooks
    @ashtonbrooks Před 3 lety +3

    5% of my diet. Just had a bowl of Arrowead Mills puffed millet and puffed wheat (because I don't eat "normal" cereal aka overly processed cereals with additives). My bowl was 3/4 cup which is 75 cal. Out of my approximate 1,500 calorie per day diet, it's 5%. And i don't have it every day. I just got into it actually. I found my notes the other day about thyroid (had an underactive thyroid once upon a time in college) and to my surprise, millet was on the list of what to avoid. I think for overactive though. I'm not sure. Nonetheless, kale was on that list too, and so were pine nuts. And i love kale! It's my favorite food along with raspberries. When i started eating more of it, and more food in general, my thyroid fixed itself. So idk why they were on the "avoid" list. Maybe it's because anything I eat is alreadg in moderation by principle. I don't eat much especially for how active I am, but what i do eat is a low-carb diet (not to lose weight or anything-- I reached a normal weight 3 years ago and i ain't turning back), but because there are so many refined carbs out there and carbs that are just plain bad for you. I get the carbs i need through plenty of fruits, veggies, legumes, the occasional glass of almond milk, etc. And now some occasional millet and wheat ever since i saw it in the store and it looked good-- it reminded me of the cereal i had once in a while as a kid, Honey Smacks, with the frog on the front.

    • @oshobaadu6272
      @oshobaadu6272 Před rokem

      Do you use or drink milk at all? Is Almond milk good?

    • @ashtonbrooks
      @ashtonbrooks Před rokem

      @@oshobaadu6272 iIlove drinking whole milk! Delicious and an easy way to get my protein in to balance with my other macronutrients.

  • @QUINTUSMAXIMUS
    @QUINTUSMAXIMUS Před rokem

    Well, you're talking 2/3rds of their calories and what not consisting of millet. I plan on just having two tablespoons of millet. I think the study is flawed anyway. They found people having thyroid issues, but that's not evidence that the millet caused it. Doesn't sound very empirical to me.

  • @ibrahimjunaid8317
    @ibrahimjunaid8317 Před 4 lety

    Where to go then, is depressing

  • @guitarlearningtoplay
    @guitarlearningtoplay Před 3 lety

    “Not anything” true genius here! hahah Never heard of SPROUTING? You can make Manna and eat Millet sprouts raw!no cooking!

  • @coolroy4300
    @coolroy4300 Před rokem

    The best diet is everything in moderation, well balanced and lots of variety. No you shouldn't eat the same thing everyday especially not French fries and Pizza .And never eat late at night .

  • @premier69
    @premier69 Před 3 lety

    so, let's say one meal a week is, fine?

  • @josephdupont
    @josephdupont Před 4 lety +3

    Isn't this a matter of diversity of food.

    • @premier69
      @premier69 Před 3 lety

      thats one aspect, another is easing up on the carbs.

  • @bensonnlp
    @bensonnlp Před 2 lety +1

    That mean Birds organ are stronger than Human Being.:)

  • @shelleymitchell7912
    @shelleymitchell7912 Před 3 lety +1

    millet is a seed mr phd

  • @sharamighandi5740
    @sharamighandi5740 Před rokem

    Maybe the goiter came from the salt they consumed, that has no iodine. I used to live in North Africa and a whole population in one particular village had an epidemic of goiters because they were consuming salt that was extracted from a mountain close to the village- the salt didn’t have iodine. In your presentation, you didn’t say why millet was causing goiter!!! What’s happening physiologically! I am not convinced at all!

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před rokem

      On my substack I have a report that goes into detail but it’s for members. Not having iodine in salt doesn’t cause goiter. Adding iodine to salt is a way to prevent goiter. Salt does not naturally have significant iodine.

  • @JavaughnJPorter
    @JavaughnJPorter Před 3 lety +1

    Obviously paid wheat companies

  • @hermes8258
    @hermes8258 Před 3 lety

    Thanks, very useful info. But... Details, shmeedetails. Two thirds way through video and I don't know how frequent or how much is too much. OK, at the end you get to the point - maximum 10% of diet, notice not 10% of *grains* eaten, just of all foods eaten (vegetables, seeds, dairy, etc) making it even less recommended. But, if I eat 15 meals per week, this means that 0.75 to 1.50 meals per week that are entirely made of of millet would be safe. And since I would never eat an entire meal of just millet, but perhaps 1/4 to 1/2 of the meal, this leaves 1.50 to 3.0 meals per week. Sounds like twice per week is no big deal, for me anyway. I am not living on a pittance in Khartoum. I eat salad, soup, beans etc. And yes, millet
    I will read any links you provided to see what millets were tested (barnyard millet, foxtail millet?) and in what form, and also which studies were done on humans rather than animals and the robustness of the studies.

  • @UnrealObserver
    @UnrealObserver Před 7 lety

    Thanks so much! Very very useful video.... especially reviewing the ingredients for all the "wonderful" gluten-free baked goods... I have just been reminded about my gluten sensitivity after eating tortillas made from organic whole wheat and organic corn... some joint pain that goes away when the gluten goes away
    I am eating 5oz of organic brown rice per day... any problems that are universal (like the millet results?)
    Thanks for your help and keep up the good work!

    • @chrismasterjohn
      @chrismasterjohn  Před 7 lety

      No goitrogens. Some people are concerned about arsenic in brown rice but I'd need to research that more carefully before making a conclusion.

    • @MsViva710
      @MsViva710 Před 3 lety

      @@chrismasterjohn this is amazing. When I was VERY ill malaria. I felt so weak and like I was made of straw. Till the day I ate millet. In about 20 minutes or less I felt like me again . I gave some to a cancer patient and she b e lives it saved her life.

  • @trem876
    @trem876 Před 6 lety

    sorghum is millet...

  • @PeaceLoveAndRico
    @PeaceLoveAndRico Před 4 lety +3

    Dont eat just millet...

  • @thestuffedvegan9471
    @thestuffedvegan9471 Před 5 lety

    Great info. and video, thanks!

  • @mreudeco
    @mreudeco Před rokem

    Agreed it’s dangerous

  • @GizmoFromPizmo
    @GizmoFromPizmo Před 3 lety

    I guess if your intake of Russell Sprouts was 1/3 to 2/3 of your diet then you'd have a thyroid issue too. Sounding an alarm against a beneficial "grain" like this is... alarmist, at best. Everybody should take an iodine supplement once or twice a week anyway to guard against thyroid insufficiency but freaking out over an occasional bowel of millet is ridiculous. Celiac disease is a much more serious problem in our gluten rich economy.

  • @nautilusmd
    @nautilusmd Před 4 lety

    You should make this video in Sudanies language where people consume it as a main food

  • @vinnettepope8255
    @vinnettepope8255 Před 5 lety

    Thank you for sharing this wonderful teaching information on millet🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Dragon34th
    @Dragon34th Před 7 měsíci

    I didn't know it has a link to goitre. In the Republic of Central Africa or the CAR's northern villages, my parents native homeland, the consumption of millet, millet wine, bread, porridge has always been high but goitre was rare. I saw that goitre was associated with the poorest people in fact no-one in my entire and distant family in the villages had goitre yet they live off millets. And I'm talking about a region very close to Sudan. What do you think about India's FSSAI Authority promotting Millet consumption in this video? Surely if Indians hear about the goitre link, they're going to pannick :) czcams.com/video/KBQIesZVw4g/video.html

  • @videomedicine-behealthy200

    most birds in my town be dead by now... it eats millet everyday!!!

  • @MH-up1xe
    @MH-up1xe Před 4 lety

    If you only eat millet maybe lol eat a varied diet.

  • @joeborisson4609
    @joeborisson4609 Před 4 lety +3

    You sound crazy

  • @monaasmr2936
    @monaasmr2936 Před rokem

    Ok

  • @yangkeesherpa6971
    @yangkeesherpa6971 Před 5 lety

    Lets put your thoughts under a different topic of nutrition efficiency and remove the millet completely out of it. At this point your post has come into a completely wrong prospective. First you have to see laboratory tested elements of millet. In a 100 gram serving, raw millet provides 378 calories and is a rich source (20% or more of the Daily Value, DV) of protein, dietary fiber, several B vitamins and numerous dietary minerals, especially manganese at 76% DV (USDA nutrient table). Raw millet is 9% water, 73% carbohydrates, 4% fat and 11% protein (table).

  • @dk2356
    @dk2356 Před 3 lety +2

    Please don't spread false info...why can't you provide actual info.. that's wrong...

  • @hiddysonday435
    @hiddysonday435 Před 10 měsíci

    The glycemic index (GI) of millet equals to 70.0, which classifies it as a high GI food. The glycemic load (GL) of millet is equal to 51.1, which classifies it as a high GL food.

  • @ianpoliti8982
    @ianpoliti8982 Před 13 dny

    Yeah I need to agree with the other comments, your point is BS. 70% calorie intake from ANY food would be a big problem...

  • @milou753
    @milou753 Před 3 lety +2

    i dont trust you, you have lost your hair and trying to tell me about hormons??? sorry you failed

  • @ngufanikojo6430
    @ngufanikojo6430 Před 6 lety +2

    You are saying that if i do not eat wheat, im hurting my thyroid, and if i eat other grains, im hurting my thyroid, so i should only eat wheat, no matter how i react to it. All based on a 'study'
    done in sudan in the 80s.
    Guy, you are lying.

  • @mel90able
    @mel90able Před 5 lety +6

    looks like you have goitar.

  • @TheIaluma
    @TheIaluma Před 4 lety

    All most anything we eat is not good for you. Don't eat whole grains, don't bread. Maybe I would just stay and just starve to death. What is there that is good to eat without a video warning you not to eat this and that?