Dream's and DNA - Gattaca Analysis
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 07. 2015
- Gattaca is a seriously underrated science fiction film, exploring the idea's of how far should science take us, DNA discrimination and the power of the human dream. So today let's have a look into those.
The Multimedia clips and videos featured in this video constitutes the fair use of any copyrighted material in section '107' of US Copyright Law which allows for criticism, comment and scholarship. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
DNA - spiral shape stairs. Awesome analogy noted
lol never knew that, good catch!
I never got that till now
"In the heat of the flames, the medal isn't silver anymore!"
Wow, well said man.
Well done. There's even more we could tease out. The film works with a spirit/body dualism. In a society, totally obsessed with the body, Vincent is the only person left with a soul. Jerome Morrow (Marrow: a soft fatty substance in the cavities of bones, in which blood cells are produced) becomes Vincent's body while Vincent becomes the Spirit of Jerome. That final scene is a symbolic depiction of death. In leaving for the stars, Vincent's body is destroyed while his spirit lives on. Nicely done. Love the channel.
Ahh, Marrow! And Vincent meaning conqueror.
The doctor knew all along that Ethan's character was posing as a "Valid." Something about left handed guys don't hold it with their right... (or vice versa) And the fact that the doctor's son was " a fan" of his, implying that the doctor had told his son about Ethan's character and his accomplishments. So...letting him go at the end was nothing more than he had been doing all along. (Although, the doctor was never given a reason to blatantly let him go and tip his hand until the final scene.)
The doctor's son has a disability too which is why he was secretly rooting for Vincent.
Frank Phammy wow yes I love this. I love this movie so much.
Frank Phammy I love your observation
@@timsawyer9231 It came up on the screen when he ran the true sample - which he had likely done before.
I believe Vincent had three people at Gattaca covering for him. The doctor was one, the janitor was another as it is likely he recognized Vincent and is shown on two occasions covering for him. He is there to take the cup from Vincent, and he is at the crime scene "just doing his job" - but, of course, he is also covering for Vincent. The 3rd one who covers for him is the Director. The Director covers for Vincent because he sees the flawless nature of Vincent's work and preparation, he is likely not so political one way or the other; I suspect his reasons are more practical. But, when Vincent is discovered by one of the other Directors - his Director murders the man before he can spill Vincent's secret. When the investigation begins, the Director insures that it is Uma Thurman's character who helps the detective. This is likely an attempt to distract the detective and throw him off Vincent's scent.
"I never saved anything for the swim back..."
Very powerfull scene. He was ready to die to achieve his dream.
This phrase of Gattaca has pushed me forward for 20+ years! Thank you so much Andrew Niccol!
This line also hints at the possibility that Vincent doesn't plan to return to Earth. His heart is, as he says, 10,000 beats overdue and, I believe, he hopes to make it to his destination but does not expect to make the return trip.
My favorite film of all time. Watched it in middle school in my English class, and I really liked it. Then I got to watch it again my second year of high school in my biology class. I fell in love with it. Everything about the film is fantastic. The cinematography is stellar, the sets are wonderful, the music is gorgeous, the performances are brilliant, and the writing and characters are just amazng. But, aside from how much of brilliant film it is technically, it connected with me on a human level. It has improved my life more than any other film. Despite how much it seems to be used in classrooms, it's still a criminally underappreciated piece of fiction. There really needs to be some way to bring more attention to it.
Out of curiosity, why did you watch it in English class?
Dude this is so awesome!! Thank you so much. We are covering this in school but this film really struck me so deeply that I wanted to see more about it. This was a really interesting piece so amongst the many thank you :) . Also there's just something about the whole feel, from the beginning to the end, from the visuals to the music to the actual story...this was truly a masterpiece of a film
Miss Understood I agree I loved the film and this interpretation! I’m obsessed with space and have been becoming more so lately since this great awakening. Request me on fb to talk about all of this if you want
I'm obsessed with everything in this movie(story, cast, visuals). Really Inspiring and sad at the same time.
Very well done! This is absolutely one of my favorite films of all time and though I've seen it countless times, I didn't catch the connection to Vincent and Jerome and the two swimmers on Jerome's medal. How cleverly symbolic! Also what you stated about the flames turning the silver into gold.....wow! You totally did a wonderful job at highlighting the sheer beauty of this film, and how artfully well-done the symbolisms are. Thanks much for this upload!
TronandFlynn82 I know!!!! I didn’t either I loved that!
TronandFlynn82 request me on fb to talk about these cool subjects if you want! You may be going through or feeling this great awakening on the planet. You and another persons comments specifically stuck out to me but if not I understand it’s just there you want to talk
The Doctor let Vincent go because his son is also an invalid (and probably wants to go to space too), that's why his son is a fan of Vincent's work.
There is a line where the Doctor says "my son's not all that they promised. But then again, who knows what he could do," which implies that his son is also an invalid.
do you think the doctor is Vincent's father?
@@geraldwright9841 I thought about that too... 🤔
@@geraldwright9841 No. Vincent's father is dead as his brother told him. Some theorize that the doctor is actually Jerome's (Eugene's) father in part because Jerome does tell Vincent he admires him when he is drunk one night and the doctor does say his son is an admirer of Vincent. Still, I think the line "not all that they promised" does imply an invalid - it is true that Eugene does describe himself that way, since he came in 2nd place. But, I doubt his father would view a silver medal as failure. So, I don't subscribe to that theory.
When the Doctor says in regard to his son "who knows what he could do" and that his son is not all that they promised... he is letting Vincent know that he knows Vincent's situation and if Vincent made it this far who knows what his son can do as well. :)
The humanity of the Doc would then never expose Vincent as the Doc can fully relate to Vincent's situation due to his son being similar...
That scene at the end explains a lot...remember in the beginning when the doctor complements Jerome aka Vincent on his big package....I kept wondering “there’s no way the doctor didn’t see the tube for the urine Vincent was using”...the doctor just let him keep using it
In the heat of the flames, the medal isn't silver anymore..... Thanks Nicholas for this line
I love the lighting in this movie and I am glad you reserved a small comment on the lighting towards the end of the movie
+Archana Gopal It's absolutely gorgeous! I regret not talking about it even more, the noir style worked so well!
Dan T
3 years ago
Anton is the "superior" brother because of his perfect genes. However, he is TOO perfect. He is efficient and effective, and therefore he saved energy for the swim back.
Vincent, the "inferior" brother, gave it his all and saved nothing for the swim back. He devoted himself entirely to his dream.
It is mankind's inferiority complex, our ability to wholly devote ourselves to an ideal despite our imperfections and flaws that makes us capable of transcending "perfect" genes.
Beautiful and provocative movie
no
1 year ago
GATTACA
G = Guanine
A = Adanine
T = Thymine
C = Cytosine
aka the four chemical bases of DNA.
There is so much symbolism in such a great film. The helix staircase Jerome climbs up - willpower not genes. Jermome Morrow aka Genome Tomorrow. Vincent Freeman - conquering Freeman. Eugene good gene Jerome’s middle name. The subtext on how we throw away those who can’t produce. The observation from poster below about silver medal is gold in flames is beautiful. Swimming ala olympics nude with Olympic medal where there was no knowledge of DNA it was a contest of human WILL. Irene Casinni - Cassini probe to Titan. Dr Lamarck (Also hero in that he’s helping Vincent at least for last half of film or at least from point he keeps wanting to talk about his Faithchild). Lamarckism- disproven theory but adhered to idea experience and memes could be passed on in dna- experience not just inheritance. The haunting score how in the heck did this film not got nominated and win a ton of awards? NASA scientists rate as best sci film of all time.
The scene with Dr Lamar at end resetting dna reader and Vincent’s look of thanks is so awesome Xander is awesome.
Jerome meaning something like sacred, and also sounds like genome.
Dude ..The doctor knew all along that Ethan's character was posing as a "Valid... he didn't catch him out at the end...
The doctor knew......The Janitor knew.......The Director knew (and so did the other Director - which is why he was murdered).
The movie is brilliant and has a very real life application when compared with caste discrimination in India.
Yes, my favourite bittersweet story is that of the Mountain Man, a dhalit who carved a path through a mountain so that the journey to the hospital would not take so long and cost more lives, as it did his beloved wife. That's the kind of person I want to be like, and around.
Here is more clarity:
As it is written, There is none righteous, no, not one: For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;
Romans:3:10,23 King James Version
Everyone is a sinner, one sin is enough to send you to hell, however God loves us and provides a way to Heaven, through Jesus Christ. The Lord Jesus Christ paid the full price for your sin past, present and future. He offers the free gift of eternal life to anyone who puts their trust in him to save them, not in their own good deeds which can NEVER save them.
I have a clear gospel presentation on my channel by a trustworthy pastor. Watch it, understand the gospel and believe it. Get saved today, it lasts for eternity.
These things have I written unto you that believe on the name of the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal life, and that ye may believe on the name of the Son of God.
1 John:5:13 King James Version
I think this downplays the tragedy of Gerome's fate a bit too much. In my opinion, the point of Gerome is that he doesn't succeed. He gives up on life, just like Anton gives up in his game against Vincent. At first, Gerome is presented as a tragic character due to the fact that his disability robs him of his "potential". But later we learn that he became disabled in a suicide attempt; he'd already given up on life, due purely to the fact that he wasn't able to be the best. The thing keeping Gerome down is his mindset. He dismisses the idea of becoming an astronaut because he's "scared of heights". In spite of his genetics, he's a failure, and he's a failure by his own volition, not due to anything beyond his control. Ultimately this makes him a perfect foil to Vincent. While Vincent spends the movie overcoming the prejudice others have against him, choosing not to accept what his genes say he's going to be; Gerome relies on his genes to get him everywhere in life. He expects life to hand him success, without him working for it. And when that doesn't happen, he spirals. He starts out believing that Vincent attains success because Vincent is using his genes to impersonate him. But he eventually comes to realize that Vincent is successful because he truly is "superior" to Gerome in some intangible way. But he never realizes that the only thing superior about Vincent is his mindset. He kills himself because the events of the movie have cemented it in his mind that he's a failure; someone else could go much farther with his genes than he could. Essentially, Gerome is the classic child-protegy/gifted-kid who fails to live up to the "talent" everyone tells him he has. His character arc is important, because it transforms the movie from being simply a cookie cutter story about overcoming obstacles, to a commentary about how our society judges potential. We have this idea of a "natural talent" and other concepts, which essentially amount to excuses for why we don't pursue success ourselves. But the movie demonstrates that "talent" doesn't mean anything. It's only what you choose to do that matters
this is gorgeous....you described their relationship beautifully and this deserves more views!
spot on....it was humanity that sent him to the stars
+Crist Gord Thanks mate, a really poetic statement by a pretty poetic film!
Great movie... Good analysis... this video deserves more views.
+SrEHSS Thank you so much, your comments are more than enough!
Really amazing, great commentary on one of my most favorite films ever!
You nailed it . One powerful message that really made an impact on me that has only gotten stronger as the years pass ….
Well done mate. Awesome breakdown.
Really appreciate this analysis! Thank you
This was a very good analysis of this great movie. And I agree with everything you said. Great points, dude. Great points.
good analysis !!! its amazing! i cried while watching the video *sniffle love ur videos
+yazhi rao Wow, thank you buddy!
A beautiful commentary on a beautiful film. Thank you.
Wow, what a fantastic analysis, this movie is just so great.
Very well explained mate. My favorite movie. I identify with Vincent so much!
The idea that genetic discrimination would make all other forms irrelevant is the only part of the movie that made me do a double take - especially since the in-valids occupy today's economic underclass. For the entire runtime, though, every character and aspect of this world felt unquestionably real. Gattaca is an absolute masterclass in getting the audience on your side.
I feel like racism would still be a thing even in the world of Gattaca.
Chris not real or least i mean yes but more about Genetic discrimination and then say White man say the n word
Chris like it Will be racist but not way a White guy being race to black guy is more like
Hey in that World is does care your skin colar or gender only is care about is your DNA
Chris or is say hey we don’t need Diversity or Inclusion or Intersectionality only DNA
This is such an underrated movie to me. I think it's also a duality about dreams and death: how they drive people sometimes to their deaths--Vincent achieves his dream of going into space but will likely die there, if he gets some kind of medical procedure for his heart he'll live a longer life but his dream will end, so he chooses the dream and early death--and latching on to Vincent's dream and making it happen was the only thing keeping Jerome alive. When the dream was achieved he had no reason to continue. Dreams can carry life and bring death at the same time.
This is just what I needed to see after watching this movie
1:30 In the original script, the doctor knew all along. Maybe he did in the final version too but it isn’t obvious
I love this and had not noticed the idea that the silver metal is now gold. Thank you for that.
Thank you. I didn't catch many of these.
Thank you so much for making this! One of my favorite movies along with Interstellar and Contact. Please do Contact!
+Carson Lam I actually haven't seen Contact but I was wanting to watch it, we'll see!
Katya stan where you at
nooo not interstellar please! please no!!!!
Great analysis. Well said
excellent analysis
This clix is breath-taking
Nicely put . Thank u for this ..post
Excellent video essay.
Awesome anaylisis of so much symbolism of the scene!......something that Andrew Niccol and his team imprinted in every movie frame of Gattaca!
Amazing analysis on an amazing movie. Thank you very much for this. I hope you don't mind if I use the last line of your video for my essay on the movie. :)
+Nathan Lopez (thepumpkins) Not at all mate, in fact I would be honoured!
+Nicholas Dobbie thank you
I had a theory which i doubt but thought would be sorta interesting. The theory was that the person Jerome lost to when he get the silver medal was an invalid. Thats why Jerome was so torn up about it, he was made to win and beat by someone with no advantages, a person who from an outside point of view had no chance against Jerome
Very interesting point of view. I have not seen this movie since I saw it in the movie theater, but it has been a movie I think about often. For me the thing that resonated was the way we lose our privacy and everything-even our genetic makeup- is exposed.
Love love love love this
i always thought a twist to this could be that Jerome became a slacker due to his injury. Allowed Vincent to believe the illicit dna swap partnership. letting Jerome go through the trials and tribulations of the rocket program. then on day of liftoff, Jerome stands and shows hes in fact not handicapped at all, he does away with Vincent, and he enters the rocket ship.
Everyone is talking about the doctor and how he is rooting for Vincent but no one is talking about in their first scene together how the doc compliments his junk and says he wishes his parents gave him one like that, even tho Vincent is a god’s child lmaooo xD
Cheers to the awesome power of human spirit 🙏
Well said! Such an underrated movie
This analysis is not accurate. Eugene takes his own life in order to share in Vincent's moment of triumph. He is literally reborn in the fire (like a rebirth of the phoenix). He is joining Vincent among the stars "they say every atom in our bodies was once part of a star. Maybe I'm not leaving... maybe I'm going home.". The silver medal he holds represents Eugene's failure. As he burns it turns gold symbolising he has finally won (because he is sharing in Vincent's moment of triumph). Dr Lamar always knew Vincent was a borrowed ladder. It's foreshadowed in his earlier question to Vincent about his son.
i don't know.... i like your analysis too, but the video makes much more sense and connects a lot more with the theme of the story. Also, there is no incorrect way to analyse art, unless it is the complete opposite of the intent.
That was poetic brother
It's available on Netflix if you haven't seen it yet! So please go watch it and I’m so thankful my HS biology teacher showed it in class cause wow, what a film! ❤️
Best Movie
My favorite movie.
Never noticed the stairs/dna before. Amazing.
I just want to know. How is Vincent suppose to see withought his glasses. Surely he didn't take a bunch on contact lenses with him.
We can see without glasses, it is only blurry, he may have not be able to read a full book
It's the future, lenses may be better so you don't need as many as nowadays.
He might've just reused them (I don't wear contacts so idk if that would work, but desperate times call for desperate measures), or who knows, he could've really just brought a bunch of contacts with him on his journey lol
And anyway, in the end of the movie Jerome left him a bunch of DNA stuff to use for when he gets back, but he said that he won't be needing it, which probably implies that he doesn't care what the world thinks of him anymore after he's accomplished his goal. So he could've also taken his glasses with him and if anyone wants to comment on that, they can, because surely they can't do anything if he's already made it to Titan, and maybe they'll accept him even if they find out
Those are just theories tho, and this isn't like a documentary so I don't think the writer thought through every possibility, but that's a good question
i guess he didnt save anything for the swim back
Nitpick, but easily explainable - they're future contacts which never dry out or need to be removed. Sorted.
this movie made me cryy
Best move of all time
Perhaps, except for a very powerful evolutionary force over which we have no control.
"Que sera, sera
Whatever will be, will be
The future's not ours to see
Que sera, sera…
My favourite movie.
We need live in that movie
I have 3 questions.
How did Vincent figure out that the detective was his brother?
Didn't the doctor see the urine bag he used for the tests?
Did Vincent leave his brother to drown after looking at the sky?
+QuantumPeter This is more of a plot question than a thematic analysis, but! Vincent knew as he could see beyond the wall of DNA, so he could see beyond the prejudice - his brother could not and didn't recognize him.
I don't really know how the Dr would have, asl it was strapped to his thigh and was out of sight.
No, he just looked up to sky and realized his dream of going up there, realized he could beat his brother again and that DNA didn't define him. I believe he would've dragged him back to shore - but it's not shown.
+Nicholas Dobbie But the doctor saw him peeing,he would have seen that urine was coming out of a tube
QuantumPeter I imagine he would have hidden it with his hand also I think it might have been strange for the doc to be staring right at Vincent as he pees!
The way Vincent talks to the doctor at the end makes me think that Vincent always suspected that the doctor might have known. Think about his words: "There is only one person that has ever come close to finding out who I am." He was talking about the doctor, and considering that Vincent's weakness is his own body, it's impossible that the doctor didn't notice.
But the doctor was actually the most humanitarian characters in the movies, we see him trying to do pleasant conversation with his patients even though he wasn't required to and we hardly see anyone else do it. It was unusual actually...
Also the doctor's words "I have a son (...) he admires you (...) he's not all that they promised." He has a son and at one time, he believed in genetic perfection and what they promised. But even in a genetically perfect world there are still winners and losers (as proved by Jerome). This loss is probably taken really hard especially by the most genetically perfect of humans. So seeing someone like Vincent who shouldn't even physically be fit to even be in the program is like seeing a rookie boxer taken on Mike Tyson in the ring and actually standing up to him. He admires Vincent for fighting with his spirit for what his body can't/shouldn't give him. He sees in him someone who deserved to achieve his dream, not entitled to.
My favorite movie ever!!!
I only lent u my body; u lent me your dream.
I reckon, the doctor (Lamar) knew all along
Luke William no shit Sherlock
Wow !!! That was Fucking Heavy !
This movie so damn special to me
Sjw need to watch it
😭 **scream cry**
That was deep
I really disagree with the movie at first, and it actually turns out what the movie was trying to tell. And I agree, only the human drive will get you places, regardless of the things in front of you. although the movie had a sad ending, it is truly a beautiful movie.
Best Movie Ever!
POGMAN
Jerome's demise represents the fallacy of the very idea upon which his society was built. Superiority and excellence are not merely matters of genetics. It's the the same fallacy our current racial hierarchy is built upon, and much like Jerome that hierarchy too is fast meeting its demise.
Fush and Chups broo!! Churrr!!
I want to live in this world
M T if people say racist and sexist i am stfu and watch gattaca
M T i do not care i rather sit at home writer book and no i am No interesting go to space
Beautifully done, crafted - and now, to think that some ARE using a fake penis etc, to pass a drug test
I want cludia Brown to watch the movie 10000s times
damn movie has a tear gas canister attached to the end. watch out people.
This will happen one day sadly...like covid did and like great replacement...dark times are ahead sadly and we wont learn from this movie
You can not gage a person's will through DNA.
Wow " I've been getting dreams about being A ..3rd way up A spiral light house ' ... With A crack in the side .. Then 2 weeks ago I had another dream were I saw my body cells being zapped bi miny lazers ' ... And just befoure I woke ' I herd DNA to RNA "... Watt does this mean my freind " thanks ".❤️❤️❤️⚔"
Wouldnt jeromes/eugenes death be a nazi reference because eugenics and he killed himself with the incinerator.
*Dreams. Nothing possessive about it, mate, just plural.
Bully!
Most perfect movie ever? Its not to complex yet perfect ...from writing to story to pacing
Sjw expsing this
czcams.com/video/r8QHJYK7ffU/video.html
They're not really genetically engineered.
The best sperm and egg combinations are chosen.
There is some true genetic engineering but it's mostly choosing the best possible combination of sperm and eggs.
Jerome was weak! It was not a noble deed (his suicide) nor was it a sacrifice for the cause! He gave up on himself and Vincent never gave up! This shows two men who are on two Completely different paths! One looked up and the other looked down! They were opposites!
Jerome actually put himself in that wheelchair. Late in the film, Vincent learns that Jerome's paralysis is by his own hand; after coming in second place in a swim meet, Jerome threw himself in front of a car. Jerome maintains that he was designed to be the best, yet wasn't, and that is the source of his suffering.
Vincent is a jerk who never kept in contact with his parents not even on there death bed smh.
@JAFREEN KHAN Dude his mom gave birth to him feed him wiped his ass for him and she still has to call him?
@JAFREEN KHAN Also Vincent changed his identity.
I want every sjw person to watch the movie
Max Nyström I don’t get it, what would an SJW have to gain from watching Gattaca? I mean I cried like a lil bitch and listen to the soundtrack all the time, but that’s all the effect it had on me. And a new appreciation for Ethan Hawke if you catch my meaning. ;3
S-IV no is just fun react thing
Like in this movie racist and sexist don.t exist and should be judge by dna
Is for laugh thing
S-IV is more react then say the true
S-IV and tumblr like the film i geuss
If in this future racism doesn't exist then why are there so few blacks in the movie? And if in the future genetically babies will determine who gets the best opportunities, I can only guess what racial group would benefit most from this technology.
Joe Johnson the asians :(
Joe Johnson this topic
Joe Johnson in that World people judged genetic so whi care
Boring film. Watch A.I.
Dude ..The doctor knew all along that Ethan's character was posing as a "Valid... he didn't catch him out at the end...
There is so much symbolism in
such a great film. The helix staircase Jerome climbs up - willpower not genes. Jermome Morrow aka Genome Tomorrow. Vincent Freeman - conquering Freeman. Eugene good gene Jerome’s middle name. The subtext on how we throw away those who can’t produce. The observation from poster below about silver medal is gold in flames is beautiful. Swimming ala olympics nude with Olympic medal where there was no knowledge of DNA it was a contest of human WILL. Irene Casinni - Cassini probe to Titan. Dr Lamarck (Also hero in that he’s helping Vincent at least for last half of film or at least from point he keeps wanting to talk about his Faithchild). Lamarckism- disproven theory but adhered to idea experience and memes could be passed on in dna- experience not just inheritance. The haunting score how in the heck did this film not got nominated and win a ton of awards? NASA scientists rate as best sci film of all time.
The scene with Dr Lamar at end resetting dna reader and Vincent’s look of thanks is so awesome Xander is awesome.