DJI Smart Controller VS Crystal Sky | What is the right choice?
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 02. 2019
- Check out my podcast and live show here:
/ @flighttimecast
My Latest Gear Here: www.amazon.com/shop/originaldobo
Follow me on Twitter / originaldobo
Follow me on instagram / originaldobo
Official Facebook Page / originaldobo
Upcoming events vist www.OriginaldoBo.com
Official channel partner! drone-works.com
like what I do consider buying me a coffee
www.buymeacoffee.com/Original...
People keep asking so here is the most current gear I use
NEW CAMERA SETUP
Sony A6500 amzn.to/2SQwA6Z
Sony A6300 B-Cam amzn.to/2VMEgZR
Main lens Sigma 16mm F1.4 amzn.to/2Cf5a56
"OLD CAMERAS"
Canon M50 amzn.to/2xY3kUd
Canon SL2 amzn.to/2NiNsAB
Lens 12mm amzn.to/2O0zhVY
Lens 24mm amzn.to/2OuEmFx
Lens 10-18mm amzn.to/2zPTncN
Lens 50mm amzn.to/2Ozhq7R
Fotodiox Lens adapter amzn.to/2Ozhq7R
Microphones
Rode VideoMicro amzn.to/2QuQi7z
Takstar SG598 amzn.to/2xY3LOl
Zoom H1 amzn.to/2OwH6lQ
Drones I use
Mavic Zoom drone-works.com/dji-mavic-2-z...
Mavic Air drone-works.com/dji-mavic-air-1/
Autel Evo drone-works.com/autel-robotic...
Archived Drones of 2018
Phantom 4 Pro drone-works.com/phantom-4-pro/
** All video and audio content created by myself and or used with permission from the creator.
** Affiliate disclaimer: some of the above links maybe affiliate links, which may generate me a sales commission. For example, my CZcams Gear listed above is in association with the Amazon affiliate program and I’m an amazon associate ** - Věda a technologie
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks Original! I'm a part 107 cert dude too. Already a real estate photog. I been doing slideshows. Now working video into the mix.
You add a lot to what I want to know. I enjoy your presentation. And experience.
Thanks Ken!! I really appreciate you bringing awareness to the chipset. I was very curious about this when this controller came out.
You can also use the Crystal Sky for products other than DJI. The Evo for example. Great video, thank you
Thanks Ken funny you posted this video today. I received my 7.85
Crystal Sky and hardware for the P4P
And Mavic 2 Pro today I thought is would be the right way to go since i have the different Drones. Still would like to have the smart controller some day. Thanks Again for the review
Great comparison. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on these 2 excellent products. 👍✌️
Great comparison of the two devices. You were very thorough and made some fair and well thought out comments and conclusions. I think they're both great devices, but I will stick with using my iPad mini for now. I'm not a professional, so taking a minute or two to connect my device is not a priority for me. But perhaps down the road I will consider one of these devices. Thanks for sharing this informative video.
Finally got my Smart Controller in, but have not had the chance to test it out. Thanks for the video...I think I made the right choice for my needs.
Great comparison video! I have the 5.5 CS and a Mavic Pro. Got the 12 volt car (PH3) adapter to charge the CS Battery from Amazon. Glad I bought the CS. The battery life is amazing and love when the fan comes on in the hot summer heat. It makes the world of difference flying with a CS. Couldn’t go back to using my iPad which overheated if you were in the direct sun in the summer and DJI GO4 was tough on the IPad’s battery.
The one thing that I really don't like about the Crystal Sky is the way that they sell it without the required charging cable and if you don't own the Phantom series your stuck buying one seperately. It's not a big deal I know but it's just something they do that doesn't make sense to me. I too bought the screen protector for my smart controller. I would have preferred the same screen as the CS but it's still all I was hoping for to me. Another cool informative vid. Thank you
Overpriced vs Overpriced
Excellent video Ken. I still have a Mavic Pro platinum and considering in getting a crystal sky.
I had planned on getting the smart controller but after your video I think I’m gonna go with the crystal sky, just to have the versatility.
Background looks dope! Great comparison!
I would say if you have multiple drones across the Mavic, phantom and even Inspire brands, then the crystal sky is the way to go as of early 2019. If you have multiple drones you have to bind the smart controller each time you switch aircraft.. not so with the crystal sky since presumably you already have a transmitter already bound for each aircraft you purchased previously so just attach the crystal sky to the transmitter you already have and intend to use without the need to bind it to a different aircraft. If you are contemplating just purchasing the Mavic 2 zoom or pro, then the smart controller may be the better purchase at checkout instead of the standard transmitter
Very informative and descriptive information from your tutorial Ken, as usual.
I purchased the 7.85” UB Crystal Sky right after it first came out (December 2017) and I had overheating problems immediately. After a few months I sent it back and DJI replaced it free of charge supposedly with the newer improved version but it still feels like it overheats somewhat. I use it for my Inspire 2 when it is extremely bright out but the Android based system is not something I am fond of. I am an iOS guy and I wish DJI would have used it as their OS instead of Android.
At this time I am not interested in the Smart Controller as it isn’t compatible with all my different aircraft. When I fly my M2P I use my iPad mini 4 unless it’s too bright out and then I use my 7.85” UB crystal sky monitor
Thx for compare vid!
Im a fan of the CS for its versatility but I worry its under-powered... I like to screen record every flight, plus Id be running the HDMI out to a pair of BT-35E's and Im worried that the CS (or even the Smart Controller) can handle these loads, with their less than stellar internal specs. Have you done any screen recording and/or HDMI output during your flights? Love to hear your experience or thoughts. Thx Dobo
i've gotten the CS/UltraBrite-7.85 since Xmas & its a fantastic monitor...! (Pros)the screen display is super crisp & awesome kinda like a 4K tv,@2000nits,with superb battery life,(Cons)way behind of older firm/software versions,which causes performance issues such as lagging,app clashes/crashes, & slow responsiveness...! but overall im hoping sooner than better DJI will fix all this with firm/software to updated versions...! overall its a super-duper monitor to pair up with M2-P/Z..... KUDOS to your video...🤙keep up the awesome vids...!
Yo bro!
Great job there and I really appreciate the time taken to do the clip!
I bought Mavic 2 pro with a Smart Controller and was looking at an extra controller, and was wondering if I should get another Smart Contoller or just a Remote controller with Crystalsky..... so i came acreoss your video. What do you think I should go for?
Anywazzzzz, it was a great video and keep up the great work buddy!
Great comparison Ken, I like the crystal sky personally but eh that’s me
I have the CS, had it for about a year, works well with my Mavic Pro and integrated well with my Mavic2 . The only thing i had wished for was that DJI made a modified mount like the mount for the MavicP1. I ended up buying an additional MP1 mount and self modifying it to fit my M2Z controller, it works the same, you basically have to shorten the mount and relocate the mounting holes the way i did it. I have a video on my channel , but i am not a youtube drone guru nor am i trying to be one hahaha, so its not detailed like some of you guys would do it. but you will get the just of what i did from it. i just hate that they didnt look out for previous owners of the Crystal Sky, that bought those expensive monitors. it was almost like a FU, here buy the Smart Controller too.
The best thing about the Crystal Sky is its adaptable to all your other drones just like moving your phone from one device to another. To sum my comment up. I would rather keep the 2 as individual, for the sake of potential problems, with either the monitor or the controller, combined a problem with one or the other is a problem with both
15 months later. The CS works great with Mavic Air also. I bought the 7+inch model, only way I could enjoy flying in the bright AZ sun. I tried all sorts of hoods with an iPad and iPhone but the Crystal Sky brightness is great. Frankly, I think it is too complex for what I want it for, it is feature rich. But definitely pricey.
Great review buddy. I have both sized CrystalSky monitors which covers both my Mavic 2 pro and my P4P however, the bracket which fitted the original Mavic wouldn't fit the new controller for the Mavic 2 pro which sounded alarm signals that DJI were up to something, hence now the new controller. I felt let down by DJI that they never produced a new snap on bracket for the M2P just so they could promote there new controller. I for one am sticking with the CrystalSky as this also works for my Osmo camera and various other equipment I have. Thank for your in depth review which I found very helpful.😀👍👍👍👍👍
Always great reviews! Honest and to the point - good or bad! Love that! I'm sticking with my iPAD mini and sun-shade. I think it sucks that DJI came out with this product after I purchased my Mavic 2 Pro, and for that reason alone I wont purchase it! I have no issue spending money on a quality device, as I've invested tons on DJI products and accessories, but I hate the thought of owning a controller that will sit on a shelf after having spent my hard earned money on it, and it doesn't appear that DJI gives a crap about that as they are not offering any kind of trade-in credits for the controllers people already have with the Pro and Zoom!
Nice review, but I think I’ll stick with my iPad 9.7” for now. I like the size of the iPad plus I can switch it and use my mavic air with it also. I have been using the same mavmount and iPad set up since MP/ MPP and spark and now with the M2pro and air. Also used the iPad with the I1. Great review.
i got the Crystal sky and i love it in sunny days its amazing
Good comparison from you. I just bought crystalsky 7.85 in instead of buying new smart controller. The main reason...if the smart controller is faulty....the whole thing needs to be returned to DJI.
I have been loving my CrystalSky 5.5" with my Mavic Pro.
Quick question does the crystal sky give an hdmi output? Trying to live stream
Yes
nice review. this is version 1 of the smart controller. ill wait for V2. in the meantime the CS 7.85 works just fine with my I1, old school MP and i prefer the CS because its separate. if the monitor goes down i can limp back using VLOS or VO--if the smart controller goes down.. it ALL goes down.
The live-view of the smartcontroller delivers 1080p almost always smooth.
The crystalskys may in some situations be very limited because underpowered and delivers just 720p, often not smooth.
Yes that’s a couple things I don’t like about the crystal sky, 720p and lagging. But it’s still a great monitor for sunny days so I don’t have to use a sunshade.
Thank you
Thank you for this review. What if I would to connect USB-C power bank to the SC while flying ? wouldn't it extend the using time ? and about headphones, Can't I use bluetooth headphones which the SC should support ?
Very good bias review. Thx buddy..
Michael
I purchased the Mavic 2 zoom with a bundle and the smart controller came with it at a considerable price drop so it was a no brainer for me. Maybe later I would add a Crystal Sky to play around with. Everything you buy has pros and cons so this is no different.
I have the large CrystalSky and I love it. I can use it both on the MA and the M2Zoom. I love being able to change the batteries on the fly. The controller, if the battery runs out, you are down. You won't be able to fly and that is bad.
Crystalsky is the only way to go
The smart controller charges in the fly, just need a common power bank. I flew four batteries, did a 30 minute review and ran a 24in monitor from the hdmi out and the battery only went down to 30%.
@@jayrobertsager2478 yeah but how will the battery act in a year or two? Old batteries don't hold as much of a charge the more they get used. Just like older phones with original batteries.
SWF Company open up the controller, swap out the battery, close the controller. I’ve read that you can get 400 charges then 3 hours flight time and that equals 1,200 hours of flight time. I haven’t taken the time to open this one up yet but I can’t imagine it would be all that hard. I just enjoy how fast it is, open controller bag, push the ON button, open the arms on the Mavicpro2 and take off the gimbal cover, press the ON button,,,,,fly....the crystal skies needs a mount, mount bracket, cables, extra batteries to carry and is slower to boot up. It was a no brainer.
@@jayrobertsager2478 I don't have either product, I'm still deciding on what to go with. So you can change the internal battery of the controller? If so, that's not a bad deal for an updated + more compact device. If the CS offered HDMI in I'd go with it no questions asked.
have a battery pack on hand and if fully charged you will get at least an additional 3 to 4 hours of run time on the smart controller
Wondering if this is a common issue with the Crystalsky, I have High Bright 7.85 inch when I use it with my M2 zoom and my air the footage get jittery when out maybe 1000 ft. I don't lose connection but with my Ipad 9.7 it never did. Wondering if there's a fix because it cost too much for that?
Hi.
I have a mavic pro v 2 now i like to make a choice a wise one.
Shell i buy the smart controller or the crystal sky pleas give me your honest advice.
Thank you.
I love the Crystal Sky. However, currently, you cannot playback H. 265 through the sd slot on the Crystal Sky. Is it possible with the Smart Controller?
thank you for the video, as far as i see it, the crystal sky have a bigger screen option, which makes it a totally different story... my question is, if the app crashes on the smart controler, do i still have radio control on? or do i need to count on the auto come home feature alone?
I use the Crystal Sky screens on all my drones that will take them, and yes, the controller will still work if the screen crashes. It happened to me a few times. The 'return to home' feature is always your backstop. But you're flying VLOS all the time, so shouldn't be an issue, you can reboot the screen while still having control of the SUSV. Done that myself, and it works fine, just a bit of a brown trousers moment.
interconnectivity? Can the CS take the SC feed out and be used as a viewing monitor?
Thought I would look up the price for the crystal sky and I had to pick my jaw up as it hit the floor. 500 to over a grand for that tablet depending on size and brightness. Smart controller is expensive but you get everything needed to fly. Crystal clear still requires a 80 dollar mounting attachment for controller. I guess if I had money to piss away or made money from my drone, I would definitely get one.
I just received my SC and have been using my Ultra bright 7" CS for about a year now. By far the Ultra brights CS is superior in brightness in direct sunlight. The only thing I have to say is that the CS is a bit slower and not as responsive like the SC is. the SC is peppier and not sluggish as the CS. Are we stuck on the Android version on the CS or can it be updated?
thanks for the great review.
I own both of the Chrystal sky’s the 5.5 and 7 ultra bright as well as the new controller. Battery life on the CS is 3 hrs max on the 7UB the 5.5 I do get 4hrs max. The smart controller is just plan better to use and a much smoother device to operate! I will also guess the SC will have updates way before the CS check that as a big positive.
Crystal sky gets updates at the same time now. They changed the firmware so that DJI go could be updated on its own. Also the battery of the CS is hot swappable so you can have infinite battery life if you really wanted
Good review, I’m in the UK and had the SM for over a month now, love it.
I think the two screw areas on the base of the SM along with the connection is for a future additional detachable battery to maybe give 5 hours plus running time ?
What FW are you running on the Crystalsky? I can't seem to update mine
For me, it's all about a safe flight. As per the video, I like to have the screen above my control surfaces. So the DJI Smart controller is a fail out of the box for me. Yes, my Spark and series 1 Mavic have screens below the sticks. But as someone who takes piloting a drone/SUSV seriously, I don't want to move my hands to see important information on the display.There is one possible plus to the Smart Controller, possibly also a downside. An inbuilt battery. So when travelling by plane, you probably don't have it in carry on baggage. I always have at least one spare battery for each of my Crystal Sky monitors, but have never had to change one while the drone was in flight.
Do you know if we can use the CrystalSky with the Mavic Air 2?
Crystalsky you can use it with any dji and newers
I have the smart controller and absolutely love it
The CrystalSky only has GO 4 app and does not support the Mini that requires DJI Fly. As of today (February 2021), the Smart Controller supports Phantom 4 Pro V2, Mavic 2 Pro/Zoom, and Mavic Air 2. I tested all of these. To fly the Mini and Mini 2, an iPad Mini with max brightness could be a better idea.
Smart controller also works with Mavic Air 2, just purchased from dji
Need to upgrade the firmware
Is there a way to use my Crystalsky 5. on my GH5 as a monitor... thanks
Will either of these work with mini 2?
They Have a Crystalsky update you may want to do a video on released today 12-16-19
I thought it the controller worked with the P4P V2 which is occusync 2.0
Nice content ODB
In late September 2020, is the Smart controller still a good buy? I have a Mavic 2 Pro and Mavic Air 2...would you still recommend?
Absolutely
@@OriginaldoBo Thanks, appreciate your feedback!
Hi, in my opinion there is one very important consideration and that is versatility. As you say the smart controller only works with the Mavics. It doesn’t cover the Phantoms or Inspires. The Crystalsky is a monitor that works across the entire range.
Currently DJI are on Ocusync 2. Will the smart controller work with Ocusync 3, 4 etc?
Based on their previous history with different, non compatible batteries and controllers why would anyone believe that the smart controller is going to be compatible with the future incarnations of DJI products ?
I believe the smart controller is a good product but it’s going to have a limited application and at the current price it not worth it. The Crystalsky has the versatility to go forward, albeit with it’s delayed firmware updates (I con myself into believing the early role outs are beta versions and us CS owners get the proper “debugged “ update🤫).
Take care and catch you later. Peter
Thanks for clarification. So, just to get it straight in my mind, are you saying that the smart controller will be every bit as versatile and compatible going forward with future DJI models as Crystalsky?
Originaldobo Ok, thanks for the clarification. Take care.
Would you be able to use crystal sky with air 2?
Have you had any lag problems with the video that is recorded in the crystalsky?
Any solution?
Does anyone know if you can purchase the controller that’s used with the cell phone separately.?
I like my Crystal Sky 7....it's just that it shows jerky side to side motion. When I view my videos thru my laptop the videos are smooth...just not on the Crystal Sky...maybe it's just me.
Roger
Hi the smart controller has the battery in it - when continually charging the whole unit - how long will it last? Does it mean you then have to throw the unit away?????
Pretend the controller is your phone. How long does your phone last after you've been using it for a year or two? Not long.
I still can't believe this won't work with the Mavic Platinum .
I want to use my DJI condence with a mavic pro 2
The smart controller only works with mavic 2. I have the crystal sky which works with both my Mavic Air and mavic 2. :)
Love the crystal sky for the $ it’s perfect
It works with P4 Pro V2
DJI doesn’t do security updates. Check the Android security levels on them. 2017 🤦♂️
I agree with you but that price Ken... did I miss that part? Smart controller is too damn much and it just seems WAAAY limited. I don’t see myself using it even if it’s compatible for P5; I would MUCH rather use crystal sky... crystal sky can be used as external monitor as well, coupled with the things you’ve highlighted in this video - it’s a no brainer. Smart controller should have been a $150 option with Mavic 2 or maybe even included with Mavic 2 Pro for that pricepoint.
Originaldobo Ken your getting sent these items, it’s a little different circumstance when you got to nut up your own money; especially when your on a budget. The general conscious from the entire community is the smart controller is just too damn much money. I wish I knew the actual numbers of what they are selling but I would imagine it’s not matching crystal sky’s numbers when sky first launched. Definitely appreciate your opinion, but I respectfully disagree in this circumstance.
Originaldobo and that is why I said I respectfully disagree with your opinion. I will NOT stop complaining when I think an item is overpriced. Price has got to figure into the utility of the item. As I said from my previous post IMO crystalsky is a better option for this reason. I apologize for incorrectly assuming you received the smart controller for free as a demo unit, but you have been receiving a number of items from your channel sponsor - I’m sure you can see how I incorrectly arrived at that conclusion. I enjoy your channel and your content Ken.
When buying Fly more kit with a new drone drops the smart controller cost. You pay a little over $ 300 vs. the $750 they are asking for it. This is great if your looking for a new drone, if your not looking for a new drone, I think the $750 is steep for what your getting... Just saying...
I have the 5.5 and the 7.8 Ultra and I like the Crystal Sky Ultra, not the 5.5, better than my Smart Controller. First, the stock Mavic 2 controller gets way better range than the smart controller. With the Crystal Sky Ultra and the stock controller, I have had my Mavic Zoom and Pro both out to around 32.000 ft (6 miles) and made it home with good signal in a suburban area. The Smart Controller only manages about 24, 000 ft.(4.5 miles). I have an adapter that puts the crystal sky below the sticks similar to positioning of a phone and I love the extra screen size and 2000 nts. Also, the adapter fits any of the Mavics and my EVO so I can fly any of my drones and the position below the sticks, which balances perfectly with good feel and control.
I’m calling bs on that. The Mavic 2’s
Don’t have the battery life to make it out 32,000 ft and back. I’ve tried many many many times. Your extremely lucky if you hit 30,000 and make it back.
Just look at Dustin Dunnill’s channel, he was the first to do it and I just duplicated what he did. Some people just don’t have the balls to try.
Incredible information
More screen time for the devices and less screen time for the tool. Lol
What about the mini 2🤷🤷 new video idea maybe will crystal sky even fit the remote ??? I need answers 😂😂
Seems like there are many things DJI could have done to improve both. For starters, use iOS.
Can't use iOS, Apple does not licenses iOS for any products. Only Apple products run Apple Code Legally.
cd/m ?
No choice for me I bought the 7.85 crystalsky before the controller came out the only thing no way points for crystalsky
Why is there no way points on the CS?will there be an update in order to have way poits on CS?
I’m the only kid begging for a drone. Were has my life hpne😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Don't buy neither of them! DJI will let you all hanging with dated software as they did with Phantom 4pro+ owners like me...I bought my P4P+ brand new two years ago when they released it, and back then DJI swore that they will allow us to download third party apps through our controllers, but guess what, that never happened. I promise that the Same thing is going to happen to all you Crystal Sky and Smart Controller owners... You'll see...
I sold my P4P+ and bought a Mavic 2pro which I use with an IPad Mini 4... I'll never buy any DJI product that runs Android because they aren't Android friendly... Apple products works better with DJI...
My 2 cents...👍🏾
I've still got my P4 pro+, it was the first drone I bought, and still a great 'go to' for me. I'm comfortable flying it, I've got a shed load of hours on it. But I have to agree with ricardopr541 here. Why did DJI release a controller with an onboard screen when they do seem to be more biased towards the Apple ecosystem? As an example, where is the ground station pro app. for Android?
The SC is no option, 650$ are just a ridiculous impudence, noting else. 😡
@cameraflyer Nope
I think it's a very good choice when you buy it bundled with the mavic.
@@merlin4574 nope, only usable for two drones, screen to small and price ... no words.
@@merlin4574 and no 3party app i.e. Litchi 😡
@paul smith Not true. You see nothing on this mini screen! 🤣 You can use the controller only for the two newest DJI drones. DJI was easily able to make this controller also working for older models, except for there WiFi only drones i.e. the Spark. The controller is way to expensive and again, the screen is also way to small for any real " Professional" use.
neither!r prefer moverio myself
👍👍✌️
smart controller....to small....crystal sky 7.85 perfect
the 2000 nit brightness ultra bright 7.85 costs $1000 brand new, so your saying your going to pay the same price for the drone? or are you talking about the $750 1000 nit brightness model?
7,85 is to big for backpackers
Just look a Dustin Dunnill’s channel, he was the first to do it, I just duplicated what he did. It’s close and most people don’t have the balls.