Is the Taliban Islamic?
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- Are the Taliban Islamic? Is it enough to be claiming to follow the Quran and Sunnah to be considered proper Muslims? What about other groups like ISIS? What are the rules of interpreting hadith and Quran? How are Islamic rules created? What is shariah law? Usool al fiqh?
My Patreon: / abdullahsameer
My Support page: abdullahsameer....
Join my private mailing list: list.abdullahs...
Follow me at:
► Twitter: / abdullahadam
► Facebook: / abdullah.sameer.71
► Medium: / abdullahsameer
Intro/Outro Credit Spinnin' Remixes: / @spinninremixes
Links/Sources:
- quransmessage.c...
- yaqeeninstitut...
- tarekfatah.net...
- theprint.in/in...
I am a part of online Russian speaking ex Muslim group based in Moscow and I know how many Afghani refugees are there now, mostly women and kids… it’s heartbreaking. There is a growing presence of ex Muslim women in Russia, mostly from the Caucasus region , we often chat and they mention so many English speaking ex Muslim CZcamsrs. Thank you for being here for us, Abdullah!
Aww thanks for sharing. Happy to be part of this!
do they have youtube channels ?
zdravstvuyte
a lot of Muslim Caucasians (im from azerbaijan so I know aswell) are leaving it
Hey 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
So in conclusion "Stay Away from all versions of Izlam"😌
Hahaha yeah
Why not create your own version? 😆 wouldn’t that be, inherently, Islamic?
Whether Taliban is Islamic or not, sad part is the effect and impact on the innocent people who's lives are being destroyed. FExM you are bringing awareness and truth to the public, your contributions are invaluable and I'm confident you will be successful.
Thank you
Abdullah still crying about the evils of Islam while the new " islam" fascist tyrannical superstition
@@FriendlyExmuslim great 👍🏾 video
Just a suggestion for the intro video:
Change to “Friendly Ex-Muslim”
It’s missing a “-“ hyphen
If any cult’s book can be interpreted in such evil ways than that’s something inherently bad about the book.
So easily interpreted*
Technically, just about any book can be twisted to motivate atrocities.
The difference is that you can be both well-informed and honest, and still conclude that the Taliban and ISIS are right about Islam. That is why the Qur'an is uniquely bad.
@@Menzobarrenza but if ones book could only about love and peace there shouldnt be any problem with that. Unfortunately religion doesnt work like it.
@@Ccccccgggggggjj It is literally impossible to make such a book, even with infinite knowledge, wisdom, and power, simply because humans will figure out ways to make the text appear to say whatever they want, no matter what.
We are the problem, in that case, not the book.
Ergo, the only standard that actually works is wether you can be well-informed and honest, and still be genuinely convinced the text says a certain thing.
Wait it's not an evil cult book of you choose No67 of the 340 meanings in each Arabic word.
@Art Becher "Abstain from sex"??? The *Quran* explicitly allows r@ping the married women that you forcibly ens/laved!! In *unlimited numbers!!*
Not to mention that *in the Quran* the institution of Al-Mutah or "Temporary/Advantageous Marriage" - which is religiously sanctioned *prostitution - has never been abrogated!!* 🤦♀️🤦♀️
This, in addition to polygamy, which is a very backward social order - most societies that came to be monogamous in ancient history, *evolved* from polygamy slowly, throughout centuries.
I always wonder why we need scholars interpretation in the first place, when the prophet and sahaba never needed any. they just say "we hear and we obey" not "we hear, interpret, and obey".
Well they also had to resort to interpretation, hence all the discord among them from the first hour. It’s impossible not to interpret something if it’s written or communicated through human language. This is also true for understanding this very text I’m writing now.
The "scholars" created Islam the way it is today. Without the details of Mohammad and the Sahaba as their example, they could not have jurisprudence. Sharia law is like the Talmud with "interpretations". The Quran is vague and ambiguous, coming from a primitive Nabatean Arabic script, so the scholars had to find ways to explain the meaning according to a context in a supposed historical way. The hadith are just further exaggeration and propaganda of Islam. For example, how did the scholars come to the conclusion that the owners of the elephant were in the Quran 105.1? The Quran mentions no details who they were. You go to the Sunnah which is created later, then you find the who the owners of the elephant were, they were Aksumites, and the story makes no sense, and it is historically questionable. To invent a religion, you need to give exclusive authority to certain people to create an orthodoxy. The hadith and the Quran in certain things also contradict each other. The Sunnah was created at a later time. So yes, Islam can technically evolve or mutate over time just as it did coming from influences of Judaism and later Christianity.
Forgetting everything screwy about Islam for a moment ... The role of Islamic scholars in the history of the religion is actually fairly interesting. During the Islamic Golden Age, there was a great flourishing of scientific, theological, legal and mathematical thought. And that all happened in the madrasa of great cities like Baghdad. They benefitted from being right at the center of the silk road with ideas, knowledge and goods flowing in and out from both Europe and Asia.
So, the Islamic scholar is a centuries-old holdover from that great moment in the middle ages.
What's sad is that those glory days ended centuries ago. And the religion is one of the things that has held islamic civilization back from adapting to modernity. The Ottomans failed to modernize, then they collapsed - and with them came the ruin of the Middle East.
So those Islamic scholars represent a tradition that is very much stuck in the past -unable and unwilling in most cases - to adapt, even for the benefit of Muslims from Casablanca to Jakarta.
It is perhaps the greatest tragedy of the modern world.
Come on it's not that vague. We have hundreds of books explaining how Ottomans, Seljuks, Fatimids, Abbasid, Ummayads, etc practiced Islam. We have all these Madhaps etcs. I would argue that Taliban and ISIS are pretty close to the original Islam practiced by Mohammad and the early Muslims.
well those books talk of rulers so their practices are interwoven with political strategies... but the vast majority cannot live like that, so a broader understanding is needed.
Christian Prince shows us the Arabic islamic sources
@@ankitanandy6076 that’s assuming Islam is not a political as well as religious ideology, when it’s obviously both
True - ISIS still holds up the original Islamic flag by taking sex slaves.
@@ankitanandy6076 a ideology is political aswell
The Quran is very clear on killing all infidels and apostates. No interpretation needed there. You are doing interesting and informative content. 👍
The Quran doesn't have much secularism in it.
no war was for self defence only..read quran with context
The Taliban reflect a 7th century ideology, which is what Islam is.
aisha- sure, she was 18, 'playing w/her dolls'
ten years after all the other girls were married off.
makes sense.
People --Aisha is 6.
Abdul--No.
People --Aisha is 9.
Abdul --No.
People --How old is Aisha.
Abdul --She is age years old.
People ---What.
Abdul--The age of Aisha is metaphor
Aisha at six was so lucky she played with live 54 years doll How fortunate was she
@@atsuthungngullie6898 she self identified as a child when playing with dolls
@Hisham Malik czcams.com/video/1GMwR1gmZ6M/video.html
LOL this proves that she was 6 or 9 it doesn’t matter still a child and he’s old enough to be her grandfather
@Hisham Malik Aisha just started menstruation at 19 years,you know that times girl were maturing early
I love and accept "The Man Made Nonesense" Line. What surprises me though is the fact that it facinates millions of academically educated folks without any apparent effort to question it.
Haha yeah
It baffles me that for all their takbir they never seem to notice how their vision of god is so... small
Yes, they are. They follow the Quran, hadith and sharia. It is the modern muslim who isn't Islamic.
Q2:216 - Fighting is prescribed for you, and ye dislike it. But it is possible that ye dislike a thing which is good for you, and that ye love a thing which is bad for you. But God knoweth, and ye know not.
But the real test is the behavior of the early Muslims who spread their faith through conquest. That is the real Islam that Muhammad created. Interpret based upon history.
If you want to re-interpret it for today, then at least admit you are changing the faith.
Modern Muslims… Huh.. they are all the same… they never condemn the wrong actions.
@Art Becher Why should I believe Muhammad's Quran?
@Art Becher Numbers is in the Torah. The Quran claims allah is the author of the Torah. So if you condemn the god of Numbers, you are condemning your allah.
So how to you explain the mutawatir hadith - On the authority of Abdullah ibn Umar (ra):
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "I have been ordered to fight against the people until they testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and until they establish the salah and pay the zakat. And if they do that then they will have gained protection from me for their lives and property, unless [they commit acts that are punishable] in Islam, and their reckoning will be with Allah." [Bukhari & Muslim]
So why would Muhammad be threatening peoples lives and property?
@Art Becher It is you who accuse God of evil when you condemn the actions in Numbers while you fail to understand that scripture is claimed by Muhammad is from allah in his Quran.
I don't consider the Quran scripture at all.
The last I checked, Afghanistan is in the hands of the Muslim Taliban. It is they who are in charge and committing the atrocities. Yet you want to blame the US for trying to police the barbaric tribal mentality of Islam.
The hadith I quoted is used by Muslims scholars to justify jeehad. You can't twist your way out by claiming it was only "I" Muhammad as the Quran tells you the Muhammad is an example for you to follow. Your sophistry is clear.
@Art Becher If you don't follow the Torah, then I have bad news for you, you don't follow the Quran.
Quran 3:3 He has revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Book in truth, confirming what came before it, as He revealed the Torah and the Gospel
4:136 O ye who believe! Believe in Allah and His Messenger, and the scripture which He hath sent to His Messenger and the scripture which He sent to those before (him). Any who denieth Allah, His angels, His Books, His Messengers, and the Day of Judgment, hath gone far, far astray.
Your task is to explain why the Quran claims that the Torah comes from allah, that allah promises to protect his word, but he didn't mean he would protect the Torah.
We have the Torah in the original language Hebrew. We also have translations so us non-Hebrew speakers can understand the meaning. Your statement is clear you are ignorant about the Bible.
What you are trying to do is deflect. We know that evil exists in the hearts of men and evil is done by all peoples and all cultures. That is just evidence that the natural state of man is towards evil. That is why we need a savior.
What I condemn Islam for is the evil it produces while claiming to be from allah. It teaches bigotry and violence to spread the message of allah. The real Jesus taught us to be peaceful and turn the other cheek. Not so with Islam. It is a faith of retribution.
Peaceful presentation 🥰
Thank you! 😃
Very informative video, thank you!!
You're welcome! And thanks for your support Patrycja 🙂
The fact that it's vague and susceptible to violent interpretations is itself a major strike against Islam. If it truly came from god, the wouldn't be debate about any verses
Wow.
These were many, many words for:
"Yes. The Taliban version is one very valid interpretation of Islam. "
Taliban is pure Jihadist.
I would also like to know what do the fundamentalist Muslims mean when say: That Muslim women’s have basic rights according to the framework of Islam “.
That's a good question I'll try to respond
It’s the false narrative that women had no rights in pre-Islamic Arabia and Islam gave them rights. A complete fallacy! Women did have rights, and in some tribes/religions more rights than those found in Islam. The perfect, although unquestioned example is Khadejah. A woman who inherited all of her husbands business, ran it successfully, proposed marriage to mohamed, didn’t wear hijab, the first convert, funded the initial spread of the religion… she had more rights as a non-Muslim woman than when she was Muslim
@@thefirm4606 other example after final revelation of allah by Mohammad its all gone ....she was whatever she was before converting to islam...she wasnt born as muslim women... considering that girl who is born as muslim case suddenly turn 180° isnt it?!
Are you saying
All arabs are liars and cheats .. and they have always been ?...???
Very good explanation! Reminded me a little of all the interpretation and translation issues in Christianity (let alone the books that were excluded from the bible). You made a very good point about how the "omnipotent creator of the universe" apparently can't express himself in a way that doesn't cause massive amounts of confusion and violence so many centuries later. It's a universal issue with all scripture based religions.
Love all your shows.. keep it up.
Thanks!
This video was very informative, and it held my attention.
Thank you!
Sameer, it is called MIRACLE OF INTERPRETATION
Just to be noticed by you FE is wonderful. That you replied to me, ecstatic. You are so beautiful and I treasure you and you are making a difference with your content. Thank you for speaking up. I find this channel questioning and interesting.
I also know you are a bridge. In my world I would say you are a Kabbalist like me.
Thank you!
Great video. Love to see some more content about the Taliban as the situation unfolds in Afghanistan. Keep up the great content and best wishes.
One of the first steps on my way to ex-Islamic thought was the realisation that Ali probably should have been the first caliphate but was duped by Abu Bakr. As a Sunni Muslim this was an eye-opening and treasonous thought.
Excellent as always AS
Good job my brother!
I appreciate it!
I'm sure Allah is upset that his perfect Quran, "where not a word has been changed" is being changed. Appears that there are numerous Quran over the ages and all are different. That includes those
There is no Allah but death Mohammad.
Abdullah Sameer is a very wise man and comes with actual facts which no men neither Muslim or not can deny even though many will try off course.
Keep up the good work Abdullah Sameer!!
Peace be upon you
Quran 8:12 "I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelievers. Therefore strike off their hands and strike off every fingertip of them"
very great explanation 👍👍
take care brother and please don't stop to help our Muslim brother and sister to leave Islam,
God Bless all of us💪❤
Wonderful video- I like the way you present your arguments
Thank you kindly!
Wow what a genius video Abdullah! Kudos.
Why would God send a revelation which has so much that is unclear or able to be understood in so many different ways? Why would God sow so much uncertainty?
Thank you for your work
You are very welcome
Just want to say I love your channel brother. I was born and raised in muslim family, in a muslim majority country. I was trying to be a good muslim for years, and I know exactly how confusing Islam is with so many interpretation. Scholars arguing against each other on whose version is the truest. Some more tolerant, some not, some even very harsh and rigid. So who's right and who's wrong? Nobody knows. In the end I just believe if a particular religion can make you a good person, go ahead follow it. Personally, I don't see how Islam can make me a good person so I just quit.
This. One of the reason i left islam. So many different interpretation by scholars.
Hello Abdullah Sammer , I saw many muslim youtubers who made a video about debunking you . Can you make a video about it .
So to cut a long story short to quote Yasir Qhadi, they are all Qur'an. They are all Islamic.
I disagree with Abdullah Sameer in several ways. I don't think that those who don't accept Muhammad as some sort of model for all time, and don't follow the Muhammad of the Qur'an and hadiths and tafsir are true Muslims. They ought to just accept that and declare that they have already left Islam. They are shoring up the Taliban and Isis and the salafi and the deobandi etc.
And quite frankly I am shocked to hear Sameer, of all people, saying that the apostates that were persecuted under Abu Bakr only left Islam because they didn't want to pay zakat. The truth is that they knew how false Muhammad was. They knew how he kept changing his teachings to suit his circumstances. They had heard many of the other contradictions in the Qur'an and wanted to go back to the religions of their ancestors or another religion that was at least stable.
This garbage about only not wanting to pay zakat is an islamist slur to not accept that the apostates had good reason for not believing in Islam, and were only practising it under fear of death.
The quran has never changed. But every single arabic word seems to have 9 definitions including the opposite of the most common meaning. What else would you expect from a culture of liars and cheats?
The Quran was never whole in the first place, merely random scripture that was pieced together after mohamed died. Several accepted copies exist today (200 of which 38 I believe are accepted as true).
Muslims never lie. They just employ these defences when caught:
1. The meaning is different in Arabic.
2. The Hadiths are weak and not to be relied on
3. The meaning changed over the years in Arabic
4. The meaning is taken out of context ( never mind Quran is meant for all times)
5. The verses were abrogated by Allah ( though the Quran was revealed in a short span of 22 years)
6. No such Hadiths exists
7. Sirahs( Auto biographies of Mohammad)have no strong validity
Muslims never lie . It is haram .
@@arulsammymankondar30 8. You are taking it literally when it’s supposed to be metaphorical.
9. Are you a scholar? Only scholars understand the true meaning of the Quran.
10. That verse only applies because of X historical event happening and not for anything else.
I could go on!
According to the "thumbs down" numbers, 8 viewers suffer from extreme cognitive dissonance.
After waiting over 200k years since modern humans appeared , civilizations came, gone and buried..now aloha decides to introduce himself but it's already time to wrap up? Bad planner.
Even the new testament spoke of the end times as though they were right around the corner, widows were encouraged not to remarry etc
@@shinobi-no-bueno exactly.
That's like asking if water is wet or is fire hot ...
In Islam. There is no seclur Islam.
Exactly.
If God is true, he will against religion because religion is a politics and a business to benefit a particular section of people whereas God belongs to each and every creature.
Keep up the good work! Wat happened to ur followers.. only 15.6k 😯
New channel. Lost old one to monetization issues
@@FriendlyExmuslim ahh okay, wishing you all the best for new channel. I will be spreading the word!
Indeed! Big love and respect from Calgary Canada
Totally agree, the fact that it is open to interpretation suggests that it, like do many other religions, are man made nonsense. 1 new subscriber!
Thank you for this great insight!
Please make regular vedios or atleast a bit more 😃 we love you works ❤️
Zakir - Brother asking very good question ! But lot of questions !
After this Video I thank God that my Grandmother who married my Muslim Grandfather refused to convert nor raised her children in islam. Such a human made Mickey Mouse non sense of silly rules of life … yikes
I was not at all was a muslim. I am no longer Hindu too, just an Atheist. I would like to learn islam in an anthropology point of view, so i want more info on Islamic ideology or Quran, as i am also learning bible now.
Hope i will get an unbiased narrative of Quran from you.
Even ex muslims earn money just by talking about Islam...lol..so pathetic
Good points
This is my fav video of yours, you make more sense than all of my muslim apologist extended family put together.
If Islam was truly divinely inspired there would not be so much about the religion that is vague or unclear, leading to so many competing interpretations.
One of my good friend was Muslim in Primary school but once she started madrassa she stopped being my friend now I understand why I'm an infidel but I never saw her like that I'm a hindu but I'm not religious and I respect every living being that's what we are taught from small.
Keep up the good work brother.
Abdulla well done very balanced talk don't forget to say that Taliban translates into English as STUDENT, from Al Fadi
Interpretation is also a very controversial issue even in the Bible, interpretation does not depend on "what is should be", but "what it is". And this depends on material forces and power. Nowadays, the Islam is the Islam of petroleum. For instance, in Protestantism same case was exposed of Bible interpretation, this "liberty" turned into a national chirch. This is worse because the church becomes a state entity.
Every Jew: the Ten Commandments
Every Christian: Jesus died for our Sins
Every Muslim: Muhammad was a prophet..
Was he a moral prophet...? and do you accept his “mortality”?
Always cogent…..among the best!
Those variations and interpretations you cite are of little importance to non-Muslims. the ones that are important are that which is related to killing apostates, slavery, treatment of women, treatment of none Muslims seem to be pretty clear. remove the state power Islam would collapse
1:49 “usulah feq” (sp?) Is this what is referred to as abrogation?
Usul al fiqh. Islamic jurisprudence
A pluralistic, tolerant, love thy neighbor, islam can't be interpreted from even just the koran, let alone the hadith.
Well said...........very well said
Thanks
Great breakdown of describing the difficultly to find uniformity around a single interpretation. Coming from a Christian background, this can be seen within the Christian world. When the freedom to think is allowed, the ideologies diversify. Each individual forms their own beliefs on their own authority. We are moving toward 7 billion + interpretations of the TRUTH. Individualistic human ideologies rather than groupthink structures.
Hello my brother! I love you! ❤️
1.8 billion interpretations and arguments lol.
Let's see, what we are told that a muslim is and if the Taliban qualifies
1: Believe that allah is one god...check
2: Believe that mohammad is a messenger....check.
Hmm, it seems to me that they must be if they believe both things.
How is it that. Allah revealed through a book that is so difficult to understand
Nice hair cut bro :)
I think there is a correct interpretation of Islam. Mufti Layth's trajectory hermaneutics argument for slavery is simply false
Well done, correctly defined islam is .
What a mess. impossible to be truly messianic. It boils down to human conduct. "With or without religion, good people can behave well, and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil-that takes religion" (Steven Weinberg).
Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.
Quran 9:29
Explanation of verse 9:29
Allah then commanded fighting the disbelievers when He said:
(...until there is no more Fitnah) meaning, Shirk. This is the opinion of Ibn Abbas, Abu Al-Aliyah, Mujahid, Al-Hasan, Qatadah, Ar-Rabi, Muqatil bin Hayyan, As-Suddi and Zayd bin Aslam.
Allah's statement:
(...and the religion (all and every kind of worship) is for Allah (Alone).) means, So that the religion of Allah becomes dominant above all other religions.' It is reported in the Two Sahihs that Abu Musa Al-Ashari said: "The Prophet was asked, O Allah's Messenger! A man fights out of bravery, and another fights to show off, which of them fights in the cause of Allah' The Prophet said:
(He who fights so that Allah's Word is superior, then he fights in Allah's cause.) In addition, it is reported in the Two Sahihs:
(I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight the people until they proclaim, `None has the right to be worshipped but Allah'. Whoever said it, then he will save his life and property from me, except for cases of the law, and their account will be with Allah.)
The Order to fight until there is no more Fitnah
Tafsir Ibn Kathir
Fight them till there is no sedition, no idolatry, and the religion, all worship, is for God, alone and none are worshipped apart from Him; then if they desist, from idolatry, do not aggress against them. This is indicated by the following words, there shall be no enmity, no aggression through slaying or otherwise, save against evildoers. Those that desist, however, are not evildoers and should not be shown any enmity.
Surat Al-Baqarah (The Cow) 2:193
Tafsir al-Jalalayn
Verse 2:193
Fight them until there is no [more] fitnah and religion and every kind of worship is for Allah alone.
Quran 2:193
Explanation of verse 2:193
(Fight against those who believe not in Allah, nor in the Last Day, nor forbid that which has been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, and those who acknowledge not the religion of truth among the People of the Scripture,) This honorable Ayah was revealed with the order to fight the People of the Book, after the pagans were defeated, the people entered Allah's religion in large numbers, and the Arabian Peninsula was secured under the Muslims' control. Allah commanded His Messenger to fight the People of the Scriptures, Jews and Christians, on the ninth year of Hijrah, and he prepared his army to fight the Romans and called the people to Jihad announcing his intent and destination. The Messenger sent his intent to various Arab areas around Al-Madinah to gather forces, and he collected an army of thirty thousand. Some people from Al-Madinah and some hypocrites, in and around it, lagged behind, for that year was a year of drought and intense heat. The Messenger of Allah marched, heading towards Ash-Sham to fight the Romans until he reached Tabuk, where he set camp for about twenty days next to its water resources. He then prayed to Allah for a decision and went back to Al-Madinah because it was a hard year and the people were weak, as we will mention, Allah willing.
"The Order to fight People of the Scriptures until They give the Jizyah".
Tafsir ibn Kathir
9:29
"Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled."
9:28
"O you who have believed, indeed the polytheists are unclean, so let them not approach al-Masjid al-Haram after this, their [final] year. And if you fear privation, Allah will enrich you from His bounty if He wills. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Wise."
Thanks.
@Friendly Exmuslim I think a person can choose peace or violence and support it with Islamic scriptures. If a person like peace, he will choose from the peaceful side and if the person is violent he choose from the violent side. The problem is when a person that is on the peace side decide to switch over to the violence side. The two sides are all valid options that can be supported with Islamic scriptures. And when it comes to interpretation, the interpretation cannot go against the teachings of the prophet. In my opinion, I think the best interpretation will be the interpretation by the prophet and the best generation of Muslims instead of modern day scholar that invent new things and add them to Islam.
Islam
Peace Neutral Violence
100 ----------------------------------- 0 ----------------------------------- 100
There is no reason why anyone should ever do other than as he pleases. Be Muslim or Christian or atheist, what ever pleases. Kill, not kill. Enslave, not enslave. Manipulate, or not. What can possibly outside a mans desires have anything to say about it? If one insist on analyzing it, surely this is the obvious answer?
The Taliban’s is part of a school/interpretation of Islam(don’t remember which).
But what we see around the world in these movements(religious extremism) are a effect and combination of social political issues and so on.
And if we take a historical look at Islam we see that the standardization of the faith didn’t begin until over 100 years after Muhammad’s death(Sira and Sunnah). Especially since the conflicts within the faith was becoming to be a problem.
And as you are pointing out, the sects and the interpretations within the faith has grown since the early days and are still ongoing.
Very interesting
Thanks!
Just like thor: god of lightning, allah: god of terrorism and mohamad: messenger of god of terrorism.
Violent islam .... not Peaceful Religion
In a twitter-sized sentence: what do you reply when someone claims: They (the ISIS et al) are "missunsing" the Islam?
People in a position of power in a religion will use the parts that religion that suits them to maintain that power. They "cherry pick" what suits them.
Misusing is the wrong way to think about it.
I would respond
These groups are Using Islam to justify their position.
Did u find out about the contradictions in the Quran
Read 39:53 and 4:48
Where are your 40k+ subscribers
New channel
i could live with such a version of Islam. the reason why i dislike it so much is because of all the HATE it has in it, and promoted by prominent figures like Ali Dawah and Muhammad Hijab.
When I was young , I thought that The Quran was sent directly by Allah as a book
Sorry to break your heart - its not
What is your opinion on Judaism?
Agree with you that there is no one true version of Islam but do you agree that Islam being basically based on the Quran and hadith is not a peaceful religion anyway you look at it.
interesting that there is a ex-muslim on youtube...
2:00
...ofc, this is all human effort, therefore to read or lets better say to study the Quran and the Sunna is a Must for every Muslim.
It is like Working and getting Money as a Reward. Of Course, the Reward by learning about the Islam and the Quran is higher :)
2:25 yep, nice said, an Hadith can not cancel something from the Quran.
Because the Quran is the Word of God. And the Hadith are (allegedly, as long as not proven by Science) something said or done by the Prophet Mohammad.
2:55 If you are not sure if a Hadith is authentic or within the logic of the Quran, then dont take it into consideration.
(There is a whole Science behind checking if hadith are authentic or not.)
3:55 ou come on... That God is not like his Creation should be clear every Muslim. Ever Muslim who prays, prays it every day, often (Sura Ihlas)
04:30
Islam is not about Khalifat-Things. This is Politics.
05:03
the twelve tribes are (so know i) alsways related to the Children of Israel.
05:20
yes, thanks. The Teerorists make Assumptions without studying the Quran. That God is Mercyful, is so often mentioned in the Quran and that we greet each other with Salam (Peace or: i wont harm you)...should be enough. Besindes that is selfmurder haram. Besides that, killing someone is haram.
So i really dont know how this psychopats come to their conclusion.
6:55
hahaha... ok... that was your prepared point. How i said, hadith are within the logic of the Quran or they dont count.
Because the Quran is Preserved. The Hadith are not.
Hadith are more like a "Best Practice". So Dividing or making Groups, just because you think that this or that hadith is true and that not... is totally irrational for a Muslim. But you are right, they divide themselves, it happens.
07:08
You know what, the hate is strictly going against the "Disbelievers"... Who are they? That was the Elite from Mekka, who chased away Mohammed, his Family and his Friends. And after that they tried to kill them in Medina. After Islam was accepted by the Medina-People, the attacked Medina.
They made up some contracts with Mohammed and broke it then, to take advantage and to kill Mohammed.
This are the "Disbelievers".
And ofc after years of attacks, enough is enough, so this Sura has stricter tone. Thats it.
(This was valid for the time of the Prophet, for him and his tribe.)
07:15
Only again this mentioned "Disbelievers".
Which is understandable who knows about the history that The early Muslims were murdered as often as possible by the Elite of Mekka (the so called Disbelievers)
07:47
"for whatever reason" 🤣🤥
...maybe because the Islam is a peaceful Relgion? Thought about it?
What would happen if the more than 1 Billions Muslims were as violent as you want it to show to your audience?
Think about it 🤔😄
08:08 ... yes, more than a billion People are Violent on this planet... dude... come on, really?! 🤣
08:40 no my friend, the Quran (Not the Book itself, the words) is a miracle. Surely the Author is God himself.
08:43
In Sura El-Fatiha, we pray every day, 5 times:
"...Guide us along the Straight Path,
the Path of those You have blessed-not those You are displeased with, or those who are astray."
There is one Gods straigh Path. Thats it.
This is no Philosophy, where after a discussion everyone is right and has his own truth.
So your argument is weak man...
08:57
i dont see any arguments here. There are no Contradictions in the Quran (The Word of God). The Valiances are sometimes not that exact. Thatswhy you have to study the Quran in Arabic. The Arabic from the Time of the Prophet. With all the Meanings of the words. This is studiying. Although, the valiances are ok to read as a non-arab. You should get a version with the wordsmeaning at that time. And you are ready to start exploring a wonderful religion.
09:58
hm... let me think
islamic law...the so called sharia...
The arabs used to burry their newborn alive, if it was a girl. Therefore God sends a Verse. (So you are for such a practice?) Wait... it is aswell part of the islamic rules that The people who took Orphans in their home, that they dont spend the money of the orphans like they want (So you are for such a practice?).
So what are you talking about?
A ok... the Chopping thing. How many robberies are now in our "civiliazed world"? How many people die by robberys?
I was in Dubai a long time ago. I lost my wallet, with cash, credit cards, an more. Easy for bad people. You know what... i got it back in an hour, because the taxi driver was so scared, that he brought it back personally and as soon as possible.
I dont mind if criminal people get a hard penalty, when the law protects the innocent people. I think alone the thinking of walking without hands, would prevent a huge percentage of possible robberys to happen.
10:53
"men-made nonsense"... you showed at the end of the video your true face. Your Manipulations are to obvious. You will not get some "new muslim haters", because this attempt was too amateur..
What happen when you join the patrion?
The question is silly. Fundamentalism means true. By definition.
Abdullah...I honestly respect0 the manner you conduct yourself and the manner you address Islamis flaws.
There is no fundamentalist or moderate Islame, just Islame.
To answer your first question, *YES*!
What is your qualification to comment on Islamic Shariah ?
And what's ur qualifications
Let's discuss here
Yes they are
Nice video. This is a point where my friends and I discuss about, and I am confused. According to you (and them) it just all depends on your own interpretation as a Muslim. But according to AP and David Wood, that not seems the case. They quite know for sure what Islam is.
So, what is it? And, by not knowing what Islam is, it's quite difficult to critique it. Taliban? Not real Muslims. IS? Not real Muslims. Sharia? Not the real Islamic law. Etc.
Guys im thinking about making a new religion ironically my name is Mohamed too what are your thoughts should i allow drinking water?
Islam is like a Pick and Mix store. Muslims believe what they want to believe.
So you agree that it's futile, as a non-Muslim, to try to argue that some Muslims are interpreting the Qur'an or the Hadith wrong, or that they should choose a different, more peaceful interpretation because it's possible? It's all moot, because Muhammad clearly wasn't a prophet, and that's the message that should be promoted.
But I think it'd be kinda hypocritical of a Christian or a Jew to say that Islam is made up. To some extent, all god-believers help perpetuate the idea that there's an invisible ethereal ultimate authority whose commands are above all human laws, and that some things can and even should be held as true without evidence. All unfounded assertions should be questioned, even if they are called "religion" and held "sacred" by billions.