Simon Jordan RAGES Over Gary Neville's Man Utd vs Liverpool Commentary 😱🔥
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 08. 2022
- Erik ten Hag's Manchester United beat Jurgen Klopp's Liverpool on Monday night 2-1. But was Gary Neville's commentary of the game appropriate? talkSPORT's Jim White, Simon Jordan and Martin Keown discuss!
Want content first & fastest? ✅ SUBSCRIBE here: / talksport
Enjoyed this video? 😍
Check out some of our BEST stuff!
⚽ INCREDIBLE CALL🔥 You have to hear this 𝙚𝙥𝙞𝙘 call from a very, VERY frustrated Manchester United fan - • INCREDIBLE CALL🔥 You h...
⚽ SIMON JORDAN vs KELL BROOK😱 Simon Jordan tells Kell Brook that Amir Khan will beat him! - • SIMON JORDAN V KELL BR...
⚽️ SIMON JORDAN vs DEREK CHISORA ROUND 2🔥 Derek Chisora calls Simon Jordan a "TELEPHONE TOUGH GUY!" - • JORDAN vs CHISORA ROUN...
⚽ JAKE PAUL vs EDDIE HEARN💪 Jake Paul says boxers are easier to fight than MMA fighters! - • JAKE PAUL vs EDDIE HEA...
⚽ AMAZING😂 Jason Cundy pranked by Darren Farley with fake Steven Gerrard interview - • AMAZING! Jason Cundy p...
⚽ "BE QUIET & NOT SAY A BAD WORD ABOUT HIM!"😳 Mourinho gives his honest opinion on his former players
👂Listen to talkSPORT LIVE: talkSPORT.com/Live
🖥️Personal website: /talksport.com/
📲Twitter: / talksport
📷Instagram: talksport?...
👤Facebook: / talksport
📱 Tik Tok: / talksport
🔴Download the talkSPORT app: talksport.com/apps/
🗣️ Want to have your say on LIVE radio and maybe even make it on our official CZcams channel? Call the show on 08717 22 33 44 (13p/min) or text 80189 (50p + charges).
🔎Want to see if you feature on our channel? Check out our Best talkSPORT callers playlist: • The BEST talkSPORT Cal...
#garyneville
#mufc
#lfc
#talkSPORT
#PremierLeague
#ChampionsLeague
#FACUP - Sport
But Jamie Carragher can scream like a banshee with Mo Salah "the little dancer" and lose himself with Klopp running on the pitch? The double standards on here for United is as bad as ever 😂
Cry
Both are fickle and reactionary clowns
@@CocoKobiee trust me after Monday night I'm certainly not crying 👍
And literally scream “GET UP!!” at an Everton player actually injured in the Merseyside derby
@@aarondickson824 whys that
Making something about nothing. Cara and Nev being on the game is exactly what they wanted for that result. Jordan's issues with Nev are becoming ludicrous
Neville lives in his head rent free, maybe sees Gary Neville anytime he's trying to bonk the Mrs.
Jordan’s issues with United are becoming ludicrous
Jordan’s jealous that some ex pro footballer has become a better businessman than he is
He's probably jealous he hasn't got the face for TV
The cheer he gave during that game was coming through another commentators microphone. He didn't hold his mic over his mouth and tell us how great he felt for it.
‘It’s Torres, OoooooOooooo , UNBELIEVABLE’ one of the best commentary memories I have. Never change Gary, football is an emotional game and it’s been a while since United celebrated a win🤣
I thought Gary was cracking one off when he did that commentary.
The goal gasm 🤣🤣🤣
English bias for an English club
@@jamiecook4288 Tbh most englisj fans want other English clubs to fail in Europe.
@@user-he2ou2ex2f fans, not pundits.
Didn't Sky have 3 commentators...? Martin Tylor is the impartial commentator, Carragher for Liverpool and Neville for Utd. Which to me gives you the best of everything. You have the emotion of the supporters coupled with the impartial commentating of Tylor. I think it is a well thought out way of presenting the match. Also these things must evolve to keep people interested and seeing raw emotion has become more appealing to the general public. I think there should always be an even commentating team which I think Sky gave us. I get that some people wont enjoy that style of commentating but I certainly think as a whole it was an unbiased presentation.
Carragher is usually quite neutral in his commentary tbh. Neville makes neutral comments but then occasionally acts like a little fanboy. It is a bit annoying
Sure but have you listened to Lee Dixon? He’s extremely neutral whenever commentating over arsenal games
Martin Tyler impartial????!!!???
What planet are living on? Everybody knows that Tyler virulently anti-Liverpool in his commentary. And as he gets older, he is finding it more difficult to hide it.
Tyler is not impartial
Who does tyler support
this is the definition of old man yelling at the cloud.
Spot on
Not really as lots of us agree with them and miss when commentary was professionals
@@jacob4690 we love the passion in football though. On the commentary for United v liverpool there's Neville (United), Carra (Liverpool) and Martin Tyler in the middle.
I loved Gary's reaction tbh, I'd rather hear the commentary of someone invested in the performance than a neutral most of the time. Having both Neville and Carra keeps it balanced.
If you want people completely invested in the game, why not stream watch alongs on CZcams fan channels?
Disagree the best commentary was the emotion that Andy Grey used to bring, emotion because whats happened is amazing not because you support a team
@@conner1665 Spot on! We need co-commentators who get excited for great play or goals for both teams not just the one they support.
Nothing wrong with a bit of a banter between Neville & Carra
@@doubleeph8920 martin tyler.....
The failed club owner seems to have issues with Neville wanting the failing owners of his former club out. Yet he talks about objectivity?
Hate SJ. GN did it when Torres scored against Barca, Hoddle, Linekar and Ferdinand went bananas when Lucas Moura scored against Ajax. Nothing wrong with a bit of passion.
He should listen to commentary abt Manchester United in certain countries especially champions league
just like how Gary Neville who is a failed coach always has something to say how other more successful mangers coach their teams.
He would have stood a better chance of he'd spoke the same language as his players.
@@vincentvries9854 Well no bloody wonder mate, he’s literally a pundit. Lol
Neville adores man united, carragher screams out as well when liverpool score goals, theres nothing wrong with it
They are supposed to be impartial
Yes there is Man Utd + Liverpool don't account for whole of football there should be neutral ex players doing commentary
they're supposed to be impartial while commentating. Neville joked about it to carra before when Carragher said "Mo Salah you little dancer" after he scored
@@AgentRafa Yawn 🥱
@@yatesy117 it was a UTD, Liverpool game 🙄 be quiet!!!
May you all be reminded of Gary’s squeal when Ramires and F Torres scores for Chelsea to win the Champions League
Was thinking the exact same thing
There's a few examples by the mayor of Manchester, ur bang on. Also that btsport similar at times 🤮
😂 Squeal?
Hearing a grown man orgasm live on air…. I’ll carry that to the grave 😂
Didn't he do the same with Aguero as well? his squeaky "OOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHH" XD
Martin is a great addition to the panel. He provides a calmness and quiet confidence to Simon's cold, hard stance on certain topic and Jim's sh*t stirring role.....
XD Jims's sh*t stirring role...lmao
Which is a polar opposite of how he played!
Simon Jordan looks like the begger you'd meet on the street.
Martin Keown is a clown
That Jim guy is clueless
As a Liverpool fan I have no problem with GNev showing his support for United when they beat us
I think it would be weird if he didn’t, it’s not like he shouted down the microphone & tried to rub it in, he removed it when he celebrated & his views are always fair & balanced in my opinion
Agreed..we feel the same for carra when when Lfc win
I detest utd and Liverpool.... Carragher and That Cowboy Neville are 2 Comedian's and Shouldn't be Allowed on Tv...
Respect mate as a rival. If yous beat us 3-0 and carra got a little carried away. Yeah I wouldn’t like it exactly but that’s what footballs about passion and I would expect that to happen
As a Liverpool fan, I have no problem with Nevilles reaction. I appreciate honesty, enthusiasm, and joy in whatever form it comes.
Spot on, I feel exactly the same. Nothing wrong with showing some passion, if he didn't celebrate I would be more concerned.
True 💯
@MADCHESTER UTD Souness is okay, not brilliant. He's very repetitive, and some of his statements are way off the mark. He also will rarely admit if he's wrong and likes to have agendas.
At times it sickens me alot and can just add to frustration like especially when the title run is going to the wire and neville is ecstatic over a man city goal but sounds completely deflated if liverpool scorw
Tbh the joy doesn't annoy me as much but giving terrible reactions to your team scoring just takes away from the moment with the price of sky it is just unfair
But when Carragher did it over the last few seasons when liverpool beat utd in games nobody had a problem
FACTS
yep...... same for the everton games, the guy is a joke, shouldnt be on the TV, tremendous watching ronaldo f**k him right off mind hahaahahahaaa! ;)
Agreed
Facts! No issue was made at all
Why would any man have a problem with another man expressing a biased, subjective opinion in public? Bizarre thing to get upset about
"We don't want someone in a Man United scarf, cheering a goal in a big game."
Meanwhile in 2012: "AGUEROOOOOOOOOOO!"
Apparently Martin Tyler is a United fan.
@@adainjarrio No he isn’t. He’s a Woking FC fan.
@@joleo1925 The internet has lied to me then. Good day.
He was celebrating the moment not the tean
@@BkuBrown Tomato. TomAto.
The utter disrespect Simon is dishing out this whole time 😂
He has a bash at someone every single day now!!! It's all about Simon
@@michaelmccarthy2369 this is true. He’s becoming cynical and says many stupid things daily. He judged Ten Haag by how he looks 😂😂😂. Apparently Simon is a man of wisdom
Don't worry about it, keown's used to it 😁
He literally hasn’t stopped for the past while 😂😂 his mrs must have left him.
Imagine how bitter losing nearly £80 million would make someone to where you just want to ruin someone else’s day everyday. Sad way to be when being nice costs nothing ✌️
I think Simon’s more obsessed with United than the fans are. He never has them out of his mouth!
he wants to run with the hares and hunt with the hounds
Simon is the man!!!
Bit ironic when Talksport literally employee people who have fan channels.
True
True True 👍🏼 👌
To commentate on games?
Martin is correct. I missed the time when commentators don't talk too much. These days they are telling us what we could see ourselves on the screen.
Or giving us their opinion on what team a or b should do better, usually if one of the beloved greedy 6 is losing
Meh. This is much ado about nothing. Old and new fans enjoy the banter. But the "get off my lawn" types don't want to see innovation come into the broadcast which is unfortunate
or apologising for swear word you kid wont even but will now take notice cos the commentators has now mentioned it.
Be great if he took his own advice
It’s saying the same historic stats every single season that does my head in
The problem with having Gary on United games especially, it doesn't matter how well the opposition play, it will ALWAYS be about how bad United were! Listen to the Brentford game, most of the match was Gary just moaning about how bad United were & the rest of it he was just silent! He is an excellent pundit but personally he shouldn't co commentate on United games & Carragher shouldn't do Liverpool games because they just become fans in the commentary so don't acknowledge how good the other team is but how bad there own team is
Gary gave his blood for that club, the trophies speak for themselves.
@@stejabrayaga - what’s your point?
As a red, personally I hate ex players like Carra, McManaman etc commentating on our games as I find it cringeworthy.
Agree that maybe Neville and Carra shouldn't do their ex teams' games if they can't keep it professional. as pundits afterwards, fine. I do like Souness and Keane, though.
Neville went from “the players are a disgrace, the dressing rooms poisonous”
To - “I’m feeling a real sense of pride watching these players”
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
It's what's called The Liberal Hivemind.
U r allowed change your mind
@Twisted Dancer 777
the right: the left politicises everything
Also the right: mentions liberals on a video about football
This is Manchester United.
@@twisteddancer7773 whats this got to with liberals lol
Are these people serious? Gary have been most critical of united in the last 9 years.
Never Ole though...
Gary is a champagne socialist clown who thinks he knows everything about football but can’t manage a side for 2 minutes! And he also is a unprofessional commentator by the looks of it. It’s not about being critical, it’s about being professional, don’t you get it bro?
@@Rebelass74 yeah u know better, how many football clubs u own or managed it, many huh 😂 geez macd burger flipper talks about being Critical 🤡 Next what U decide what should be talked in football World. LoL
Anyway take a break, Go focus on
shift job😅.
@@Rebelass74 How many premier league medals do you have?
But he's critical because he's a fan. He wasn't critical of Ole at all. Instead he made non stop excuses for him because he's his buddy.
Keown says
"I try to remain impartial yes"
Hilarious 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👏👏👍
Football is about passion and rivalry and as a fan I love to hear other fans on commentary. It would be good if every game had a guest host/ex-player who was a fan on the 'other' team.
If you don’t want the positive enthusiasm, you can’t have the Roy Keane rants. You can’t have one without the other.
Unless you're talksport.
Talksport criticising anyone for having 'ranty' over the top analysis on anything is f***ng rich. Shock jocks the lot of them. Exaggerated opinion contrived to start debate and get phone ins. At least Neville is genuine and honest with his opinions.
Nailed it 👍🏻
its Talksport, they're as bad as The Sun when it comes to opinions...
So its ok for Jamie Carragher to spit on a young girl when Liverpool lose, and keep his job, but Gary Neville cant cheer on Man Utd. What a joke
I actually like having a co-commentator for each of the teams, as long as the main commentator e.g Martin Tyler remains fully impartial and leads the broadcast
Martin Tyler is never impartial though 🤣🤣 more anti pool than Everton and United fans all put together
Problem is that Tyler is biased
@@Ackshuallymmm VERY!!!🤣😂🙃 He's worse than Josef Goebels!
This comes across as extremely bitter. Keown was being respectful whereas the other two lost the plot.
I don't think Keown actually understands the question.
Simon Jordan "goes in" on everything related to United .. I mean judging the manager based on his jacket! You need help mate
Disagree......man Utd related fans pundits say an do what they want so if that's the case don't be a fuckn gloryhunter hypocrite fs deal with it
Agree. And given his style of clothing himself, he should stay far away from commenting that of another man. A middle aged man (still) trying to be dandy in his various "contributions". From that perspective alone I find it really difficult to take his words seriously.
I'm a Liverpool fan and I personally really enjoy the banter between Neville an carra, especially when they commentate derby game together. I do see how it borders on unprofessional but it's simply more entertaining. In the old days you wouldn't get on TV with a northern accent at all, so making commentary more inclusive / relatable is fine by me
Totally agree with you!And I'm a Man Utd fan!!
Agreed..United fan here..we feel the same for carra when Lfc do well 🤝😉
I think you're missing the point.
I love to witness the absolute, pure, unadulterated hatred Simon has for Neville.
The BEST commentator is Andy Townsend, you wouldn't know he played for Aston Villa and Chelsea,he is Exellent
agreed
Ally mccoist too,
Aye.
He's annoying and never has anything remotely perceptive to say.
So what, was Neville in the wrong for his similar reaction to Torres scoring against Barca which became iconic? Can he not just be argued to be reacting to the drama unfolding in front of him? It’s only because of his association to Man United that this is being viewed in this manner. I think most people would agree that Neville is impartial during his analysis of the game. But this is a journalist cherry picking an emotional moment and extrapolating it as if Gary Neville isn’t impartial on the whole… it’s ridiculous, he’s human, he’s allowed to react like that every now and then, and I think it’s more for the benefit of the game than it detracts from his expertise as a pundit.
Why bother writing paragraphs in youtube comments
@@CocoKobiee That paragraph had infinitely more merit than your one sentence of inaneity.
@@Altolin I simply do not care 😃
Why did I read that in Simon's voice?!
Well said Jim!
Carragher did the exact same thing when Liverpool destroyed United last season, the added rivalry between Nev and Cara is what lead to this reaction as there whole partnership is based on them being supporting rivals.
Gary and Jamie have been a great investment from sky. Two big hearted players from two rival clubs. It’s nice for fans to touch base with people who feel the same.
Jim Beglin Commentates about Liverpool even if he Does other matches
Ever heard of Steve Mcmanaman?
Jim Beglin is an excellent commentator. He’s always impartial. You wouldn’t know he was a former Liverpool player unless it was mentioned by his commentary partner.
I wonder if he complains about Steve Mcmanaman's commentary on BT sport. Just watch the highlights of Liverpool 2-3 Atletico madrid and Man city 1-3 Lyon, I've never seen more biased commentary than those games
Firmino scores 5 yard tap in vs Atletico: HE'S GOT THE COMPOSURE TO OPEN UP HIS BODY AND DO THAT!
Llorente scores for Atletico minutes later: silence
Dembele scores for Lyon vs City: he's offside, VAR is so unjust at times
Sterling misses open goal minutes later: I was celebrating, you were celebrating (didn't even try to cover up his bias)
The commentary is always awful. There should be an option to turn commentary off and just hear the fans and noise from the ground. But it's either listen to the commentary or turn your TV silent.
His a shockingly bad commentator
Spot on mate
He’s the worst, and his competition is shocking too
I remember that. You'd think someone just kidnapped his family at gunpoint.
Happens all the time. When Newcastle beat Arsenal last year for the first time in God knows how many years, all the pundits talked about was Arsenal. How it was a sad day in football that Arsenal lost and how much they let everyone down. Not once did they mention Newcastle and how good they were that day... the winners of the match, at their home ground, with a big achievement... nope, just 20 minutes of Arsenal. The bias is rife and needs sorting so all teams get a fair share of the spotlight.
This is the annoying side of punditry. Newcastle would have beaten Real Madrid that day with that performance.
Problem with having guys like Neville and Carragher is they will ensure through their reactions that players like rashford etc anybody remotely associated with these two clubs would keep getting hyped vs players from chelsea, man city, arsenal
Y’all weren’t saying anything when jamie carragher was calling Mo Salah a little dancer 🤦🏽♂️ tsk tsk tsk
Mo salah is a little dancer lol great player
Neville dancing with Brentford fans last season after Arsenal loss...i mean its always a bit biased there
You can't criticise Neville for bias without also criticising Jamie "Mo Salah you little dancer" Carragher
Passion of ex players on commentary is something I love to hear. You know what you’re going to get. I find the Neville and Carragher are very good at criticising their own teams too.
Its better when a Liverpool fan and a united fan commentate when there teams face off imo.
Only a Manchester united fan would understand how Neville was feeling at that moment . People for so many years we have suffered at the hands of Liverpool .🤦🏾♂️ 😔
Right bro
We’ve only been better than yous for about 6 of the last 32 years
So many years!?!? What have you been watching
U aged 12 or something
@@doublejumpvideogames.... nope are you?? United have not suffered at the hands of Liverpool for years. Behave
Talk sport is becoming TalkGossip, any subject that involves someone they don’t like they always take a negative view toward it… like listening to teenage girls honestly
It's a very passionate sport and incredibly emotive, that's why we love it. Personally I don't think former players of the teams playing should be commentating on the games. I remember years ago in Spain when Michel was a studio pundit and how he reacted when Real Madrid won the Champions League, needless to say it did not go down well with the audience.
Surely this is a joke right? I love the passion or "bias" from commentators. Jeff Stelling is one that comes to mind. I feel that those of us who truly love the sport and love to see it shown by players, manager or commentators. Don't be too critical of the passion you'll kill the game. The emotion is what drives it.
Also asking is this what sky want? Of course it is why else would they pick ex liverpool and and ex manchester united players to commentate on it, they knew that no matter how the game went one of those characters were going to show passion
It's talksport mate... Can we really expect anything less from these clowns?
@@razor5694 I'm don't watch much of their stuff and I'm shocked that it's possible to have as many stupid takes as they do
@@ks5397 Yep, a failed chairman a failed presenter and failed footballers giving their "expert" views 😂😂
Simon Jordan - ‘Don’t attack him Jim, he could turn easy…unlike on the pitch!‘😅
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Honestly, the amount of dribble coming out of commentators' mouths when the match is on is so frustrating. I loved the idea that we could turn commentary off with the Amazon Premier League games. I wish more broadcasters would give us the choice.
better of listening to arabic or spanish/Portuguese commentary
keown just shows a micro reaction when he realises what's going on.😂
Martin can’t talk he did the exact same in his article for the NLD derby and then admitted to it after.
Carra did it for us vs Richarlison which I didn’t agree with either
I might be wrong but commentating and writing an article are different things. Commentary is supposed to be reflective of what’s happening in the game. While writing an article has an element of subjectivity
@@amakky1989 Yes however Martin didn’t put any spurs players in a combined XI and then said it was to rattle spurs player and spur arsenal on (mind the pun)
He admitted to trying to have a bearing on the game , that’s more than commentary imo because it’s pre game , Neville has no bearing , Martin did
@@VR46314 And I’m saying that wasn’t right of him. But for an article there’s more margin for expressing opinions compared to commentary on a football match
@@VR46314 Also he said that Arsenal won’t get top 4 before anyone else (and repeated that before the Newcastle game)
Carra annoys me more than Neville and I’m a Liverpool fan
Funny that , Neville annoys me more than Carragher, and I am a United fan.
The worst bit on Monday wasn't the cheering. It was the last 15 mins when Neville and Carragher went silent and Tyler was talking to himself.
Why we need any commentators is beyond me. Really wish they'd bring back the crowd noise only option they once had. End up turning the sound down when Carragher's co commentating as he never shuts up.
Coming from some old dorky dude who dose nothing but hate on everything & anything he’s on a show equivalent of E news Simon criticising Neville one of the best pundits in football is the biggest joke
You're definitely under 25. Old dorky dude? 😂
Pointless debate. Carragher was on co-commentary to give balance.
I was wondering if he was; I think it’s cool if there is a balance but you can’t have one person going crazy about their team and leaving the other team out
exactly, if Liverpool had won Carra would be celebrating like Neville
Fast forward 6 months Rio complains about Carragher and Souness behaviour after the 7-0. Glass houses.
Carragher is actually a bigger offender than Neville for bias behavior. I don’t think they should comment on their own teams if they can’t remain neutral.
"For a very decent newspaper." Err, the Telegraph? No way Simon thinks that.
He’s a tory, hardly surprising
Keown can’t stand Jordan!!! 😂😂😂
Keown is a cake
Wish we could have Martin Tyler doing every game on his own. Because Andy Grey has never been replaced or matched. The two GOATS of the Sky era. Period.
SkyDigital when it launched offer the option of Fan commentary; regular commentary or stadium sound. Would be nice to bring that back (crowd noise would be great - granted language disclaimer)
Martin sounds so envious!
Wasn't Carragher commentating also? There lies the balance if so
Well said Martin. I want my co com to give short insights into aspects that might be missed by others. Less is more.
I agree whole heartedly. Gary is excellent when he's not invested in the two teams playing.
What a load of rubbish, they all do it. Ian Wright says we when talking about arsenal. Carra is pro Liverpool, mcmanaman is pro Liverpool, we know who neville supports, it means sod all to me if he cheers when utd score
Who supports Brighton, Brentford, Forest, Villa, Leeds, Newcastle, Palace...?
That's the problem.
@@cockoffgewgle4993 Shearer, does it Really matter in the grand scheme? Just moaning for the sake of moaning
Another United bashing video when United haven’t played
Cos they scum
I like the passion that the pundits bring for their club, as long as it doesn’t effect your analysis/ bias towards players or teams. Neville is always very honest in his criticism of his own team and praise of others
Not arsenal.
Tbh he's never honest in his praise of other teams. He's always too preoccupied with his own team to bother about the other one. It's not fair on other fans watching at home
I've listened to so many Tyler commentaries on Liverpool games and the way he describes a Liverpool goal compared to an opposition goal are miles apart. Liverpool goals are so understated and an opposition goal is described with such glee, excitement and joy. The guy is a joke
I remember when Balotelli first got to Liverpool after Suarez left, and they played their first champions league game, and Balotelli scored and it was great call from Tyler. I’m sure that you have heard more calls from Tyler on Liverpool than I have, but I especially remember that champions league night, and that call was on point.
I think its usually an underdog thing. You hear it in other games too with Tyler . And yes I know he went mental with Aguerooooo but that was a mad moment
I don’t think he’s been excited for a goal by any club for years.
@@rodafowa1279 hahahahaha… lol
I agree… but to me, keeping his emotions in check actually gives the person sitting at home an opportunity to feel the emotion in the stadium. Too many commentators yell and scream and make it about themselves, or talk through songs and major moments.
@@Dbo_Sports I agree about not talking 100% of the time and ruining the atmosphere inside of the stadium. However, Martin has clearly lost all passion for the job. Whenever I watch a match and he's commentating, I'll actively search for a different stream with someone else.
Martin Tyler has been doing it for years, next time martin tyler commentates even if United are not playing he will find some way to mention United in some way shape/form. So dont get why they are targeting Neville
I agree but Tyler supports city, always has
Did Simon mention Martin tyler screaming agueeeeerrrrrroooooo a few years ago?
As a passoinate fan of a football club i love having actual fans on commentary. They should have fans from both teams. You gotta be able to take the bad with the good. I personally just love the banter it creates
It’s hard to be impartial when you have a connection to the club
I must have missed it - i was waiting to see Neville Podcast and so on.. and nothing appeared (i'm subscribed to the channels).
Its called Passion, not everyone has to be negative 24/7 like you Jordan. who shat in your cereal these days?
When speaking about being objective both Neville and Carragher have a huge influence over the fans of their supported clubs. Liverpool fans listen to every word Carragher says and his OPINIONS become facts. Neville is the same for Man United.
It isn't surprising when a player plays well for a few weeks at these clubs, everyone is talking about them as world class.
There are numerous examples of this. Alexander-arnold at Liverpool who has been poor defensively and only had 2 assists since mid Jan 2022 from over 170 crosses. Thiago was up for TOTS when he only played 50% of PL minutes. I'd say the majority of Liverpool fans I speak with believe they have the best GK, LB, CB, RB, DM, CM, LW, RW (when mane was there) and possibly manager.
Similar when a Man united player plays well, he goes from ok to world class, we're already seeing that this week with Malacia and Martinez after 1 game.
Their opinions inflate players performances. I used Alexander-arnold as an example as recently Carragher has said he is Liverpools ALL TIME best RB and he's the player he'd most like to play with in the world right now. He's a fantastic player but carragher cant be objective when it comes to TAA. The fact he's had 2 assists since mid Jan 22 along with multiple poor defensive performances, you wouldn't think that's the case when carragher speaks about him. This is one of many examples
Love how you reduced TAA's prowess to all he's done between mid Jan and now.
This is 100% more a rant about Liverpool fans, disguised as an opinion on modern day commentating🤣
@@bensurgenor5355 none of it is incorrect and made you comment on it 😁
2:51 That was completely different.
Carpenter was commentating for a British channel that was broadcasting a fight between a British fighter and an American fighter.
Practically everybody watching that broadcast would have been cheering for Bruno as well.
Carragher and Neville did commentary for Utd vs Lvp for years and as a united fan i accepted it and it was very entertaining when Lvp battered us several times. Since its the biggest rivalry in England and you have a Lvp and Utd legend on the Gantry at all times its perfect!
It always amazes me that Jordan takes a few quid from talking about football. He is the modern equivalent of ‘the bloke in the pub’ with a slightly nicer (artificial) accent.
Not really true though is it
I like garry ....
hi gents. great show, watching this clip again after watching the show on Friday. In my opinion this not only happens in football but in other sports as well such as rugby, formula 1, cricket. We are able to handle comments passed in cricket and rugby because points made are valid but still biased towards a certain team or player/s. Having been an avid F1 fan for 20+ years, yes, Murray Walker had his favourites, but the David Croft and the Sky F1 team all seem to be cheerleaders for Lewis Hamilton with only Karum Chandok giving an unbiased view towards all things going on in the paddock and other rumours. I have since watched F1 coverage on the official F1 website and found their interviews and commentary to be unbiased and gives a different perspective towards all drivers not just the one driver.
Even Carragher sounded like a Utd fan too. It wasn't until the Sky camera zoomed out that a certain Sir Alex could be seen sharing the same gantry. Funny that.
Me hearing Gary cheering or being upset isn't going to make me change sides and start cheering United is it?
He has more insight than I do and he's entertaining enough to listen to which is sometimes echoed by the people at this station, usually Jamie, Jason, Sam, Andy, Alan, Laura, Natalie, Hugh, Darren and a few others. Jim is somehow still employed but I suppose making outrageous statements is a way to get clicks, however immoral and ill informed.
Silly to expect someone whose given their life to a club to be impartial. The question should be laid at the feet of the network executives who hired him, not him.
Great Job Mr Martin. The other two had a bad day at the lake🐟.
Simon said ‘this is a article representing the masses’ how can he say this?
"the facts of the matter are that at this moment in time" Gary has started to think he's the voice of football. Someone needs to tell him we've tuned in for the match not his opinion.
he is groomer followes for nis potential political career
I remember Carragher going mental when Allison scored a late equaliser for Liverpool a couple of seasons back. Is it really such a big deal? Plus, Neville wasn't screaming directly into the microphone, but his cheers were inevitably picked up. Storm in a tea cup for me tbh
Yes it is a big deal.
Not everyone supports Liverpool and Manchester United.
@@iandavis1723 Dunno why it would bother you then tbh Liverpool fans I could understand at least. Did it really detract from your experience if the game?
If you’re a fan your a fan some people try to make a story out of everything these days 🫣😉😂
@@tonyjonesbassoonwhippet2271 Try telling the Everton fans that after the game at Anfield last season. Caragghers's commentary was a disgrace.
exactly, and I don't remember anyone being outraged by that. Making mountains out of molehills.
Did Simon “GO IN” on Carra when he came out with “Mo Salah you little dancer!”… no? Thought not.
Didn’t pipe up when Carragher was screaming down his mic at us YA LITTLE DANCERRRRRR 🙃
I rate keown very much for the way he shoots down the bs
Agree he's an excellent analyst. I like how he isn't reactionary and is quite fair rather than just pushing a narrative. No gut reactions very measured
Yess Gary! 😅👌
Nothing wrong in showing passion when the players and the team is doing well. I just wish Gary would bash Rashford, Shaw or Maguire or for that matter, other PROTECTED English players just like he does to others. Hardly seen him bashing OGS, too. Where is the passion when the players are showing none of it on the pitch? praise all you want, but take part in the criticism also.
I was watching this and the first thought that came into mind for me was Tom Miller on Rangers TV. What a professional...
If all the legends face each other, soon there won’t be many legends left 🤔.
Noticed we haven't seen souness on since Monday 😂😂😂😂😂
Since he said Casemiro is not a good player he can’t be found
Yeah?........ He only does a Monday
Considering he only works Mondays you probably won’t see him the rest of the week
Fernandinho did offer more than Casemiro to his team
@@richardlefleur4957 so you reckon if had got hammered, he wouldn't of phoned in or zoom call, just criticise and talk his nonsense first thing on Tuesday
I like how no one said anything when Carra was celebrating in damn near the same manner 2 yrs ago vs United. I don't remember there being any outrage when that happened. It's even in Sky's CZcams channel😂
Curious question:
Do Simon and Martin have something they’re fighting over behind the scenes?