Women's Issues: The Headscarf, Face Veil, & Women's Attire | Dr. Shabir Ally
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 08. 2024
- Why do women have to veil? How come there’s no veil for men? We sit down and discuss these questions, and much more, with Dr. Shabir Ally.
___
Please SUBSCRIBE to SUPPORT the show!
Questions: www.QuranSpeaks.com/Contact
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Twitter : / quran_speaks
I love shabir ally ! He is the reason I chose Islam after watching his debates with Christians. Islam is a beautiful religion and I like that you are non bias and straight to the point! I wish every sheikh was like this
@Ar Ra oh shut up. You are the ignoramus.. Mr Eminem Stan 😂😂
@@YA-hm5zy Hahaha Arjen got it right. These demon filled frauds love the accolades of people, but not the truth. Even Shabir Ally's daughter wears tons of makeup on her face. Hypocrisy!
Allah guided you, not Shabir Ally. DO not say he is the reason. Allah is the reason.
This comment is so cute! God bless you on your journey x
Rightly pointed out everybody that God guides you, shabbir ally was the reference through which he guided you. But here comes the main point shabbir ally is specialised in comparative study of religion (Islam vs christianity) but that doesn't mean he is specialised in the all aspects of islam.
Example: you are having fever so you visit a General Physician Doctor who you felt was good so you became a regular at XYZ hospital. Later on you are suffering from heart ailment so you visit the same XYZ hospital & they recommend you to consult a Heart Specialist. So then will you say No No I came to this XYZ hospital because of thar General Physical doctor so i will consult only him? No right! You will go consult specialist doctor.
Same way there are specialist scholars of islams whom you should consult just giving you some names : Mufti Menk, Nouman Ali, Dr Farhat Hashmi, etc.
I like this man. He speaks unbiased, and truthful. Far better than all those excited men making their own rules on what a woman can and cannot do with her body
Dr. Shabir Ally came to my mosque last week and his sermon was awesome. I was honored to meet him after and shake his hand. Keep up the good work.
Yes he is a nice man
That's cool! Wish I could meet him too one day.
MashaAllah, true there are good scholars like brother Shabir, I would love to share my humble research on Islam that hadith is wrongly declared as final word by anyone who finally wrote and published but the ( Claim of hadith) is more valid and appropriate to say and believe, since the people who recorded the saying and observation of Prophet Muhammad and they way all was recorded we can not accept it as legitimate. So, we call it CLAIM but not hadith.
Salaam Aleikum! Thank you for this. I am Christian but I veil completely. Why? Because Lady Miriyam is my model as to modesty. Christianity actually has a long history of Veiling, and until the late 1500s or early 1600s. This habit of going about with head uncovered is recent in the scheme of things (I grew up in the 1950s and 1960s and even as a child, my mum dressed me in my best including hat and gloves to go to church, because this is what decent Christian ladies did). I converted to Roman Catholicism and later Orthodoxy (I left Roman Catolicism because of all the innovations of the Vatican II nonsense). I have always preferred modest dress, so I always have worn a headcovering in churchnd often on the street as well, but about a dozen years ago I took up wearing a loose, ankle-length, dress and hijab. Lately I have begum wear a niqab as well because I believe after much thought and prayer God has led me to increase my modesty.. I found Dr. Ally's talk very interesting and informative. I will at least have a better idea of how to respond when men (and it is nearly always men, Muslim and non) ask me why I wish to fully cover. I don't fully why some Muslim men would think that I should want to run around with head unveiled or wIearing immodest fashions.
Although my ex-husband died almost 30 years ago, we remained good friends after our divorce and (God bless him in Heaven), he never hassled me over what kind of clothing I wished to wear and in fact always defended me whenever I was hassled for wearing modest clothing and head covers. While still married, I asked him for permission to dress modestly, in long skirts and headcoverings and he said that if that was what I felt God was calling me to do, I should do so and that he had no objections. I pray God will lead men, Muslim and non-Muslim to an appreciation of modesty in women. Although I will not judge another woman for what she choose to wear, or not wear, I think that now, more than ever, a lady should be as modest as she can. I know that if I was a Muslim or Christian man, I would rejoice that my wife or daughter or sister has chosen to dress modestly and I would do everything I could to encourage her. Thank you again for posting this.
As salamu Alaikum dr🌟
Mashallah good, 💟
Allah bless you with best of both the worlds 🌈
Modesty & hijab is part of faith with Intellect, 💫
Love 💞 & Attraction starts from face Value, 🎭
Dreams R Unlimited 🌈But Life is Limited,,🌐⏳️❓️
Believers do Goodness & kindness for the sake of Allah 💫☝️💯 , & pray & Obey with Understanding & Patience with Practicing Deen ☪️According to Qur'an 🕋& Sunnah🌟 for Success of both the worlds Wellwisher for Paradise/ Tranquillity 🌈
I'm not religious and I don't wear hijab but it doesn't mean I'm a bad person. I'm nice and I don't do Haram stuff like drinking alcohol, smoking, dating, etc. But people judge me like I'm an evil person just because I don't wear hijab. Yes, it's nice to see them wear hijab. But some of them are not even virgin, they dated a lot of guys and drink alcohol. I know cuz I know some irl. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against them. My point is don't judge people based on the way they choose to wear as long as they are being modest and they don't hurt people. Leave us alone and stop being judgemental. Besides, judging people is a sin.
At the first point, why do you not wear loke that. Therefore people can't read mind, rather than yr obvious Appearance.. that is the reason
Agree 100%. Religion is mainly beliefs and principles while dress is just a secondary matter which varies according to circumstances and the surrounding society. While being strict is expected in conservative Moslem societies, a more practical dressing is more acceptable in western societies and could be more attractive for people towards the whole religion. I completely agree agree to the notion that some wear Hijab and do not even observe the prayers and commit grave sins, while others do not wear Hijab but observe the important duties including good manners, ethics and morals.
I don't understand the comparison here between wearing hijab & following important Islamic duties !!!!
Allah & his messenger (pbuh) have described rules & guidelines for leading righteous life in this world that would be rewarded in the hereafter.
Now for those who are partially following the guidelines & leaving the rest (as stated in the 1st line), both will obviously get rewards for deeds they have done as per guidelines and will get sins/punishments for the deeds they have done against the Islamic guidelines.
And regarding judgement obviously that is wrong because we never know that person might be more pious in front of Allah than we are.
But at the same time seeing a person doing something wrong & turning blind eye is also not encouraged in islam, infact it is part of islamic dawa'h that they should be explained in rightful manners the wrong which they are doing so that (if Allah wills) they can correct themselves....May Allah Guide us All to the Right path..ameeen
totally agree sister ameen!
Yes, The best clothing is the Quran itself. I have met some Muslim sisters who are dressed in hijab, niqab, and jilbab and act in ways that are contrary to the teaching of the Quran. We, both men and women should dress modestly as ascribed in Quran but the conduct of all Muslims, regardless of the choice of dress should be representative of the precepts of the Quran.
I've seen so many scholars on this issue He is the first to actually articulate it in a rational way as well applying real life happenings.I believe it's important to educate yourself on Islam. you're not cattle you are bound to ask questions and learn.You gain nothing by pretending you know everything.thankyou
I love this series, and listening to Dr. Shabir Ally strengthens my faith!
I like this upload! Thank you! I want to start this comment by thanking you for reading it. It is not easy for me to say these things because I have received a lot of judgment for not wearing a headscarf anymore. Alhamdullillah I am well, and yet sometimes I still fear that maybe I got it wrong and will be punished. It takes a lot for me to admit that, but I am happy knowing that I am conscious of Allah! So, here goes:
I notice that Shabir Ally actually notes that choosing to appear modest without a headscarf is acceptable. Wearing a headscarf is not mandatory in Islam. The caption of this video makes it seem like it is mandatory in Shabir Ally's opinion, however, I have watched several videos like this and he has specifically said that it is not a sin not to wear the headscarf. I wanted to point this out because I wore a headscarf for nine years (of my own volition and following the information I had at the time) and then chose to be a Muslima in public in a different way that was closer to the culture I grew up in (showing my hair). I loved wearing the headscarf and I love not wearing the headscarf! Both are meaningful to me. I initially thought, however, that is was mandatory and that I had to wear it. I learned later (through videos like this one, reading, and from fellow sisters) that it is not as straightforward as I thought. I had initially learned from people at my masjid and observation that I had to renounce certain things from my culture because they were un-Islamic without realizing the nuance that exists in Islam, and the history of increasing pressure on Muslim women's clothing and making what is permissible, haram (Dr. Ally talks about that in this video). I see where I went wrong and where I unnecessarily condemned parts of my history and my behavior/habits thinking that Allah did not accept them. The All Merciful, The Opener, has opened my heart to how beautiful my own culture is, alhamdullillah!
My culture is diverse, vibrant, and beautiful! I love being from where I come from and I love being Muslim, and surrendering to Allah! I see the Quran (and this is a common scholarly opinion) as applying in every culture in every age and in every place. This must mean that cultural influences are acceptable while still maintaining the beauty and dignity of the faith and the deen. I wear modest clothing according to my culture and I see that Shabir Ally supports this view, especially his final comment starting at minute 11:00. I feel so much ease hearing his perspective and feeling Allah's support, while the judgement of others is still heavy on me. May Allah make it easy, whatever we are called to choose. ❤️And thank you for reading and hearing me. Your Sister.
i totally agree with you but i still don't have the courage to take it off. My family will be disgraced, I will be judged and my parents will be disapointed
If the culture goes against Islam Then We Drew the line, What every Muslim must do is not accept customs blindly, rather he should measure them against sharee’ah. Whatever is approved of is permissible for him to do, otherwise he should not do it. The fact that people are accustomed to something is not evidence that it is permissible. All the customs that people are used to in their lands or tribes must be measured against the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). Whatever Allaah and His Messenger have permitted is permissible, and whatever Allaah has forbidden must be abandoned, even if it is the people’s custom. End quote.
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in Tafseer Soorat al-Baqarah 2 (299):
Tradition does not make something that is not prescribed permissible, because Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “It is not Al‑Birr (piety, righteousness) that you enter the houses from the back” [al-Baqarah 2:189], even though that was their custom and they regarded it as righteousness. The one who takes something as a custom and regards it as righteousness has to measure it against the laws of Allaah. End quote.
Dr. Shabir Ally Is Someone Not To Take Knowledge From. He's is Not A Scholar he's Da'ee And He's Not Qualified To Give Out Fataws. If You Go To Saajid Lipham CZcams Page He's Talks More About Him
It's obligatory for every Muslimah to wear Niqab (Hijab as prescribed in Islamic teachings) in obedience to Allah and His Messenger, and so as to protect and maintain her honour, good conduct, religious commitment and chastity Hayah ie bashfulness, self-respect, shame, shyness, humility.
If You Like I Can Give You Some Scholars Who Qualified And Teach in the Prophets Mosque In Medina Saudi Arabia.
Umm, if you noticed(0;48) he spoke about Khimar and says that it is mentioned in the Qur'an, so wearing one is an obligation I guess.
@@mzs114 khimar is indeed mentioned in the Qur'an but when we through to know the meaning of this word,some say it refers to the traditional headscarf of that time while some say(I came to know this very recently) that it means "to cover". Even if we can take both the meanings into consideration the commandment,again the commandment is the "USE" of khimar to cover bosoms,even if it's a headcover and even if it's a tradition from so long,even if it is our identity,even if it's part of us,but the Qur'an states the use of it.
Excellent program, I like and admire both of You, MashaAllah
Yes, I did like it. Dr Ally is a great guy. I will continue to watch this channel.
Thank You! 🌺
Always rational as well as authentic...may Allah swt help you and us in pursuing the truth ie islam
ther a pl ay ll st "M u s l i m Women are the F u t u r e" Vlsi t My Chan nel then this person cha nnel called Sunnah
Very clear and articulate.
thank you
Excellent 👍🏾
Very nicely explained what is mentioned in the Quran to the point and truth. What about the supporting hadis to elaborate on this topic? Can you create a video covering Quran and sunnah? Thank you..
Well said sir
M reverted one .Following or trying to understand Islam and following as well . For me , I know headscarf should be there .The only problem is that as I don't belong to a Muslim community , it might attract the attention of everyone and people start getting biased towards me..M really praying Allah everyday to put me in a condition or setup where I can wear it ..For the time being, I can only try to be as modest as possible ..Pray for me please as I believe m committing sin
Assalamu Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh May Allah Keep You SteadFast And Make It Easy For You Sister. First Learn Who Allah Start With This Book I highly Recommend This Book is Really Good for Beginners ( Fundamentals of Tawheed Islamic Monotheism by Dr Bilal Philips.) Foundation of the Religion that Is Tawheed Witch Every Muslim Most Know Tawheed Essential It's The Root To Good Deeds With Out it Deeds Would Not Be Accepted. If You Can't Get The Book There a pdf Online but it's best if you get a Hardcopy And Really Good Chan nel I highly recommend for knowledge and Stuff
1. Khalid Green
2. AlMadrasatuAlUmariyyah
3. Saajid Limham
4. MadinahCollege
Khalid Green is Really Lovely Brother May Allah Bless him and keep him Sincere he Just Done Small Series of Tawheed To
But Start With That Book insha'Allah or do Both 📚 AllahKnowBest. If You ever need anything feel free to Ask insha'Allah. I have Pl ay llst For Muslim Women but Learn That Tawheed First Then insha'Allah Come back When Your Ready. Hope this Helps Sister 💌
May ALLAH SWT always guide us...Aamiin Ya Rabb
I think as a muslim we should look at progress in time.. Each muslim should interpret the koran in their own way because we all have our own responsibility for ourselves and not judge how any muslim decides to live in their faith
Qur'an says Muhammad pbuh will explain the Qur'an to you.
Mashaallah may Allah bless you doctor. I noticed that you discuss the problem but I feel like a solution for the matter isn't clear sometimes. So i kindly ask of you if you read this comment to make it more clear in your videos. Jizakallahu Khayr sheikh
He focuses too much on the questions than to give solution for the society. He could be using CZcams more efficiently.
I really wish this was longer, and that he elaborated on what he says at 10:50. It seems that he does not believe hijab as it's known now (headscarf) is an obligation- an extremely controversial yet refreshing opinion- but does not explain that further
No, he actually believes it is obligatory. The issue he has is that he makes wishy washy statements that are indirect and he speaks in circles so he doesn't "offend" anyone.
@@holdshiftt2run308 no he doesn't. He does not consider head covering as a necessary part og hijab, as modest dressing in general is. Nothing to do with the hair.
@@ribevej57 Actually, he does. He follows the hanafi opinion. Any way, by the Quran and by consensus and by the Sunnah the hijab is declared obligatory. If Shabir says otherwise, the point still stands because the Quran established this.
@@holdshiftt2run308 the Quran did not establish this.
Mostly about the face and hands cover he's talking that way. That some school of thought says it's compulsory, while some others don't.
This is not about headscarf. Headscarf is not a matter of debate.
thank you i love your videos, it makes so much sense to me as i was born in non muslim family, i reverted to Islam about 1,5 year ago...i have seen many videos about this matter and i am so confused...i have seen a video where one Schollar was saying that women must wear it because Prophet Muhammad ( peace be upon him) said that he will never see 2 types of women and one category was for showing hair and one for the women that wear transparent tight clothes..i am about to start wearing a headscarf because i want to but i don’t understand why some of them are actually scaring women? everyone is on a different path and he was saying it is a major sin..
stick with the quran sis.. it is our book not any thing els..
3:40 Pride and prej moment XD "...and besides all this, she must possess a certain something in her air and manner of walking, the tone of her voice, her address and expressions."
Unbiased scholar
by the way, some Christian groups have a dress code for the believer which is applied to both men and women, by the way. Seven Days Adventist is one group that comes to mind.
So, what is the answer to the question Dr. Shabbir has placed, at the end of the video? It seems that the topic is as inconclusive in my mind as it has been over so many years. Wish Dr. Shabbir would actually tell us his honest opinion of whether a hijab ( hed coveer) is necessary or not, in this day and age, basing it on the evidence he has come across. Either ways, thank you - jazaka ALlaqh kharun or all the effort and a really enlightening channel.
He said in another video he does not believe it to be necessary and he is not the only educated person who says so
Hey hina, hijab simply means 2 cover not the headscarf. Men during the prophet's time covered their heads as well. Doesn't mean men have to wear it as well. It was simply a cultural practice that they took on for their benefits
There are many scholars who say women have to cover their faces or women must cover one eye when going outside. If anything it's the scholars who transgress against the faith and I blind following pathetic individuals don't bother to criticize them. That's right, extremist scholars r divided on what the hijab 4 women is. They use fabricated hadiths and abuse their authority to spread fitna
Aa. At the time in Mekkah, the women were already covering their heads in public. The ayah then confirmed this and ‘added’ that women must also cover across the bosom.
وَلۡیَضۡرِبۡنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلَىٰ جُیُوبِهِنَّۖ [An-Nur, Ayah 31]. Ws
some of them cover their head some of them put their khimar but still showing their hair from sides some are just putting it under their chest etc .. the way of wearing their khimar was diverse in their society with showing their chest and allah does not mentioned the one who cover or not their hair also doesn't correct their way of wearing it on their head our God say وَلۡیَضۡرِبۡنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلَىٰ جُیُوبِهِنَّۖ [An-Nur, Ayah 31]. mean that should cover their chest with hkimar that they already had or that they already put it in somehow and cover their (awrah) chest because is the real (awrah) refer that prudery is mandatory and have nothing with women`s hair brother .
People also have to remember during the time of the 1st Caliphate that Arabian women would also need to work part-time outdoors when not tending to their family. It would be both impractical along with dangerous to move bags of food or other manual labor with a hijab, from what I’ve heard during early Islamic history Muslim women didn’t wear a hijab during sweaty work but more so when attending events with men outside their clan. (Like going to a mosque, meeting, or festival)
Plz add captions in English so that we can understand more clearly.
the statement " could it be possible that the Muslim community has put more restriction on the female attire" is disingenuous. the correct statement is that Some Muslim community has put far more restriction on female attire.
The Quran doesn’t say to wear hijab or burqa
Insightful topic and lecture. However, Shabir Ally didn't really delve deep into the Quranic stipulations of the veil for Muslim women the way I expected. For example, are there other interpretations for "the drawing of the Khimar over their bodies" as described in the Quran? Are there any historical or cultural contexts that are connected with this?
Also, what should a muslim woman living in a modern age and society do when the wearing of the veil/hijab draws a great deal of discrimination, bullying, harassment, etc., as it is nowadays? These are the type of things I was hoping he would talk about in greater detail.
I look forward to getting more clarification on all these.
There is another video on same topic where he has touched base on the points you mentioned...
czcams.com/video/mXWPmJVdbl0/video.html
Type in YT DaarusSunnah Social difficulties Niqab Should Be By shaykh Muhammad Bazmool.
Your first question needs correction,the Qur'an in surah al-noor verse 33 tells the believing women to cover their bosoms with "khimar",it states the use of khimar,you want to wear it too,you can but the obligation is to cover the bosoms and I came across some interpretation which claims khimar isn't any headcover used in the past but it means "to cover" and that makes sense too.
@@zainabakhtar3329 thank you for going more in depth !
THIS IS REQUEST PLEASE DR SHBIR Could YOU KNOCK The SAME SENSE INTO PAKISTANI LIVING SCHOLARS THAT LIVE IN PAKISTAN. THEY HAVE MADE WOMENS LIVES HELL IN PREACHING FACE COVER IS COMPULSORY
waaw, but it´s not. How can they?
If you read prophet Muhammed Hadith, then you will know that Hijab is compulsory meaning hiding face is mandatory for females. And even in Quran where the word Hijab word is used by Allah in many other places, means behind a veil. I have a pdf book containing all the references from Quran and Hadith which clearly shows that female should cover or hide her face from Non Mahrams. If you need that small pdf just reply me
@@YasirIslam01 Hey could you send that? Seems very helpful
@@user-iq5nu7tc6x Salam brother, sorry for late response can you please send me a message at yasirksa1@gmail.com so i will send you the pdf via email to your email address. Regards, Yasir
In Pakistan, barely any woman covers her face except for in the Pashtun areas.
I have a question tho in the Quran it says something along the lines of do not show your adornments except what is normally shown. If women did wear the hijab or kumar then, is it obligatory?
It’s prescribed for women’s safety so choice is on women how much hijab they wanna wear, head cover is not obligatory in everyday life otherwise Allah would mention it
Those who talking about WR in middle east fr strict dress code...West wht r u doing??why u coping thm??
By imposing ur beleif over those women, who willingly want to wear hijab bt u banned...
Yeah, allah save those women n dnt punish those women bcoz of gvt. forcing thm nt to wear hijab...they have no fault
Well the answer is clear! Governments have no business to mandate what women should or should not wear. This applies as much to muslim countries as it does to western countries! Incidentally Islam does not require women to cover their head, so if they do so it is their choice and not a religious obligation!
Sorry, sir, but i don't think you did justice to the topic that was being discussed. Is Niqaab / face veil waajib?
If in quran, Allah didnt commanded about covering the face, so do you think its wajib or not? Quran is complete. Allah didnt forget to mention anything important. Whats not in quran, its just not so important and up to that person. If she feels safer by covering her face, then its nothing wrong. Its just wrong if we try to be god and say its wajib to cover the face
@@KenAiden Verse 24/31. Allah commands the muslim women to not show their adornments to non-mehrams. So what you r implying is that a woman's face and hands are not her adornment? the last I checked they pretty much are..
Google Dictionary;
Adornment:- A thing which adorns
Adorns:- Make more beautiful or attractive.
This translates into that any bodily part of a woman, that makes her more beautiful or attractive, is not to be seen by her non-mehrams.
@@KenAiden surah 33 verse 53 and 59
@@KenAiden Fear Allah, We Follow The Sunnah To Hadiths With out it we wouldn't be Able To Know how to Pray etc.
Type In YT Niqab is NOT apart Islam ? - The Scottish Revert Teacher She Explain Will
One Of The greatest scholars of are Time May Allah Mercy on him and Bless him and give him a long life Shaykh Salih Al Fawzan Ju st Ty pe he's Name in alongside Niqab.
I don’t think answered the question as to why is this an ask from the religion itself?
One way you can tell that someone is not a scholar is that they speak in circles, make wishy washy statements, are incredibly vague, repeat themselves over and over simply by using different words each time but never actually giving you a simple a concise answer. Either give the answer or say you don't know.
the answer is yes, hijab is obligatory
@@ishwaaq191 what are your sources from the Quran?
Hijab as practiced today is based on a preislamic culture. Dr Shabir I wish you would address this topic. The women and the men would cover their heads since often times the homes didn't have roofs (nomadic areas), protection from sand storms, harshness sun. Christians, Jews, pagans all observed this regardless of religious belief. It was the clothing of the area. So when Allah said draw your khimar around you. He is talking to people in words they are familiar with. Notice he didn't say put on a khimar or something to that effect. Also the Niqab is absolutely not part of Islamic tradition.
I think you should look up vintage pictures of Muslims. Most of the women are completely covered and veiled. Even non Muslims women were fought to be modest. Pre1900 so only until modern terms is being mostly naked ok for both men and women.
I like the calm way both the host and her guest speak. The guest speaks rationally, yet still has to do mental gymnastics while attempting to interpret the meaning of the Qur'an and the hadiths.
If you think about life, the universe, and everything objectively for a few seconds you might realize that the Qur'an is just one of dozens or hundreds of holy books in the world, and that the hadiths were transmitted verbally for two hundred years after the death of the prophet Muhammad before being written down. Then it's not a far stretch to stop and ask, "Wait, who was this Muhammad guy anyways? What is so special about this particular book? Who cares what some book written in the 7th century desert says about how we should live? Who the hell is god and who created him/it/her/them anyway?" etc etc. Then you don't need to wear a veil and you just concentrated on being a good person for goodness' sake.
Iftekhar Ahmed Sharaf - exactly! There are 2b people who believe in this book and 8bn people who don’t, the majority. That majority according to this book will burn in hellfire for eternity, lovely of an all loving god eh?
The point is enjoying your life and being a good person is enough, no need to take things to extremes based on outdated scripture that tells you your sole purpose is to pray 5 times a day.
I’m sure if there’s a creator he/she will be pleased as long as you’ve been a good person that carried no prejudice
Hi Dear , I suggest you must watch this video by a Scottish white guy explaining about Mohammed and you will get all answers to your questions. Put you have to watch complete video part 1 of 2 and part 2 of 2. Here is the link: czcams.com/video/70XCMVzayuo/video.html
I think I expected more from this video and so didn't like the video. It felt like it was cut rather than being extended. It didn't come to a conclusion, or to a point as he does in other of his videos. Anyway, hope more video for the same topic will be made.
To impose too much of women clothing requirement is not only unnecessary but also damage the core of islamic teaching.
That will reduce participation of muslim women in society and even in the family life.
This is called ghuluw, and is prohibited by Allah in the koran and also by our prophet on hadith.
“Therefore stand firm (in the straight Path) as you are commanded, - you and those with you, turn (unto God); and transgress not (from the Path); Verily, He sees all that you do.” (The Holy Quran 11: 112)
Distance yourselves from being extreme in religion.” (Narrated by Ahmad, Ibn Khuzaimah, An-Nasa`ii, Ibn Majah and Al-Hakim)
I dont understand how wearing hijab prevents a woman from participating in society. Yes, she may be discriminated against by others for doing so but she can still be a part of society and wear hijab. Secondly, Allah in the Quran states 'O Prophet, tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks close round them (when they go abroad). That will be better, so that they may be recognised and not annoyed. Allah is ever Forgiving, Merciful.” (Quran 33:59).So how is wearing hijab extreme when Allah himself made it obligatory for Muslim women to wear it.
@@ishwaaq191 What I meant is such as burqa or niqab brother.
My wife is a hijab user.. That is a good thing.
She is a nurse, and hijab never become obstacle on her tasks.
My political ideas are very close to those of the Salafis and yet I'm not veiled. I'm in a very serious identity crisis
What are the problem/‘s you are facing?
I always wish I be with him always so as Rashid Adnan.
I cannot help but say that the host is extremely beautiful haha i pray to God to have a wife like her
can you please focus on the topic and answer the question!
As salamu Alaikum dr🌟
Mashallah good, 💟
Allah bless you with best of both the worlds 🌈
Modesty & hijab is part of faith with Intellect, 💫
Love 💞 & Attraction starts from face Value, 🎭
Dreams R Unlimited 🌈But Life is Limited,,🌐⏳️❓️
Believers do Goodness & kindness for the sake of Allah 💫☝️💯 , & pray & Obey with Understanding & Patience with Practicing Deen ☪️According to Qur'an 🕋& Sunnah🌟 for Success of both the worlds Wellwisher for Paradise/ Tranquillity 🌈
why is it so difficult to explain in simple words if “headscarf” is necessary ?, if it is a major sin? i guess everyone here wants to know yes or no , if one is alredy wearing clothing that covers the body, is not covering head a major sin???
It is not a major sin. Whether it is a sin is another discussion
Is the word "Khimar" mentioned in the Koran? Really?
Yes : "koumourihinna", it means their khimars
@@aymeneaymene111 thanks
If Muslim women are now banned from wearing a head covering in some European countries - why do they just not do what many Jewish women have been doing for a very long time now, & wear a wig instead? Their head & hair would be fully covered - though it would just look normal to anyone else.
Who is this young lady with him as a presenter? If she is a non-Mahram to him, then is it Islamically OK to have such conversation?
Wearing hijab is a choice not obligatory.
Consider this. In a country which men and women work in agricultural farming where wearing hijab is not suitable. Most important is to wear big hat to protect them from hot sun and uniform for their bodies .
How dare you when it is completely stated in the quran that hijab is obligated
Salaam..in the Philippines for example where the climate is hot and humid, wearing the hijab is not comfortable. I think that the issue should be more of not using the hair to attract men, (for example, keeping the hair tied back neatly. In fact, in olden times as told by my late mother, married women used to tie their hair into a bun (so that men won't toy with it) and let it down only at night for their husbands. As for me, a revert, I keep my hair very short, do not wear make up and I do not bat my eyelashes at anyone . 😅😅😅😅😅
@@mariaclaudettecaluban5286. Hair is not aura. Quran recommends men and women to be modest in appearance and good moral character.
Head covering was an arabic culture in pre Islamic time and became part of Islamic culture.
So in your country the tradition and culture are more civilised long before Islam came to your region.
For example : Respect for elderly and women.
In arabic culture women were treated as commodity and slavery were rampant.
So be proud of your culture and tradition.
@Mohd Jupri Shokran. Indeed women and the elderly have even higher status in our country. (BTW I was told that i look better in a hijab as opposed to not wearing it😅😅😅😅😅 so I believe that wearing one will be defeating the purpose of not attracting people. ) Jazaka Allahu khayran brother. Wassalam.
Is khimar a headscarf? Are you sure??
Fr men veil is eye
Prophet Muhammad SAW mentioned that there is a veil between him and Allah SWT when he went up to meet Allah in Iskraj Mikraj. why? because of Allah's mercy and indeed He is the most merciful. if there is no veil, all of creation will perish.
Is face included in 'Khimar'/'khumar'
no
Brief simple explanation about hijab.
But according to me I personally attract to beautiful fair big eyes faces....
yeh but imagine if a women got a beautiful eyes and she wear a niqab, but after you want to marry her...she remove her niqab and she doesn't have teeth and she got beard ...would you still be attracted to her LMAO
Is wearing niqab wajb/obligatory? He hasn't answered my questions yet!
he said it's not, because its not mentioned in the Quran at all
@@hokumaaxundova2709 he was talking about the face cover not the head cover
@@ainanmdjr8512 No neither is the head cover mentioned in the Quran!
@@ahmedakhan1 the khimar is mentioned in the Quran, which is basically a loose cloth that drops down from the head to the waist or even further.
@@ainanmdjr8512 The khimar was a customary head covering worn by the women of that period. However, in the Quran what is mentioned is that it can be used to cover the bosom. The verse does not say that women should wear a khimer or that the head should be covered, but that the bosom should be covered. By no stretch can you use this to imply that the head should be covered. That would be attributing to Allah a command He has not given! Allah says "We have revealed the Book to you which has a clear explanation of everything, and a guidance, mercy and good news to those who submit." (The Quran, 16:89). I assume from this that if Allah wanted women to cover their head He would have said so in a clear manner!
Assalamalaikum.Two Muslims meet without Islamic Greeting.Surprised!
Perhaps they did before the video began.
Head and Face covering is not a requirement from Allah.
SeeMahbub I felt the video wasn’t clear like your post thank you for the clarity
🙄
@a Neither me nor Bukhari saw them. But they surely did followed Quran.
a Yes I read about that. But is that can be trust worthy? Can you please give an example of a full narration of any Hadith here?
a How did Bukhari know the hadith is authentic? Did he meet prophet or his companions? How do you verify if a hadith is false or true? Why are you rely on Bukhari? Is he a prophet?
Off course he is much better than fatwa issuing imams... Nevertheless, it's does not pass the scrutiny of science and liberalism which the world has definitely moved to for good !
There's no debate regarding the head covering, it's face covering that was an arab cultural thing that made it's way into Islam.
Is shabir ally a Quranist?
Yes
Imagine the creator of this vast universe .....and this creator wants the women to wear the hijab or nikab and the man to have a beard but not a mustache! what utter non-sense!
Why do women ask men what they should or should not wear? This is the 21st Century. Stand up and be strong.
This comment is the lowest quality bait I've ever seen.
What niqab?
33:52 Henceforth, no other women shall be lawful to you (O Prophet), nor can you substitute anyone with other wives even if you find them attractive. None beyond those you already have. Surely, God is Watchful over all things.
I don't like the beach part on his speach
How can you trust on other part of speech.
Questions weren’t answered at all
الترجمة رايحة وطي
:'( wish he'd tell.exactly how men and.women are to dress
So the only reason women should cover is to deter men from getting sexually exited? Why not teach men that there is more to a woman than her physical body??? I am not a muslim, and I respect muslims. However, some of his reasonings are a little foreign to me.
The whole purpose of modesty is to draw ourselfs away from sin and temptations, from both males and females respectively. Like Shabbir Ally stated, Muslim Men also have to be modest around strange women. Most importantly, you are choosing to be modest for God so we can live a more righteous lifestyle.
katsan88
Biologically, that would be impossible.
katsan88
Women shouldn't have their sexual organs on display and men should quell their hardened sexual organs too ;)
Let’s be honest biology can not be changed
katsan88 agreed
Can some one please shut some women like Ayan Hirsi Ali and few others who go on ranting their lies against Islam, claiming that Islam teaches FGM. I am from East Africa and I know that FGM is an African culture practised by almost all Christian African tribes. Somali being Muslims also practise this. Ayan has been mutilated not by teaching of Islam but by her own Somali culture.
So you agree Muslims practice this. So then Aayan is not ranting but providing her lived experience backed up with fact. No one will shut down, or should shut down Aayan as she has the right to speak free and open her opinions and ideas. If you have better ideas or would like to challenge them you need to bring better arguments.
Chris D No I don't agree. This is a barbaric. It is only practiced in Muslim countries where people have converted in mass to Islam from Christianity, like North Africa. People have converted to Islam but have kept their older traditions.
It is also practised by Christian African tribes.
Ayan knows that it is not a religious requirement in Islam yet she keeps ranting that her genitals were mutilated because she was a Muslim.
If this was an Islamic practice, then how come my family were never involved in this? I am a born Indian Muslim.
Islam is a pure religion free from dogmas like 3=1 trinity. Nor does it worship any man or idols. Not of the holy prophet Jesus or any other idols.
Chris D I think the point he's trying to make is that fgm is not an Islamic precept. Even if the practice appears to be more common amongst Muslims in areas where it already existed. the fact remains that it is also widespread in Coptic Christianity.
To be clear, I find all religions equally vile and profoundly mysogynistic. Islam is no exception in that regard.
It seems pretty clear from this (and what Zakir Naik too says), both referencing the Quran, that the hijab as worn by Aisha isn't what Islam prescribes for a woman! Alhamdulillah!
Is jilbab obligatory for women???
Yes it is
@@zahednow no it's not
@@sh6161 it is mentioned in the Quran, how can you still deny it
@@zahednow it doesn’t necessarily have to be a jilbab, just dressing modestly lol. Modern Clothes today can fulfil those criteria
@Free Palestine 🇵🇸 you can dress modestly and not wear jilbab. I’m not arguing about this
not xovering up ur whole skin doesn’t make u a bad person. hijab takes away ur basic human rifhts of showing ur haur, honetsly, ppl never talk about how men shouod lower their gaze 😒
I wear hijab and I certainly don't feel like any rights have been taken away from me. Looking not so far back in history women used to cover their hair even in Europe and America.
SHE IS NOT A LOWLY O͏B͏J͏E͏C͏T͏
Allah, the Glorified and High, has protected the women and covered her and made Her a covered and Preserved Pearl which is not permissible for any to remove her Covering expect her husband who Allah has made her permissible for and made him permissible for her.
And he has prohibited the Women displaying her a͏d͏o͏r͏n͏m͏e͏n͏t͏s͏ f͏o͏r͏ f͏o͏r͏e͏i͏g͏n͏ m͏e͏n͏ a͏s͏ a͏ p͏r͏o͏t͏e͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏ f͏o͏r͏ h͏e͏r͏ a͏n͏d͏ p͏r͏e͏s͏e͏r͏v͏a͏t͏i͏o͏n͏ o͏f͏ h͏e͏r͏.
She is not a lowly O͏B͏J͏E͏C͏T͏ to be handled by the hands and gazed upon by the eyes (of the people) . Rather, she is a preserved pearl ; safeguarded for her husband who Allah has made permissible for her and made her permissible for him. This is the woman within Al Islam.
Book: The Status of the Woman in Islam
By Shaykh Saalih Al-Fawzaan
Ghirah (protective jealousy) for your Husband
Shaykh al-Muhaddith Muqbil ibn Haadi Al Wadi'ee dul said, "the intelligent woman does not like for her husband to look and have his heart tempted, by gazing at young ladies (on the TV). She does not like this. And happiness is not achieved between the woman and her husband unless she is obedient to him and far from looking at other than him. And likewise for him himself, he should be far from looking at women other than her. This is the fitnah of the gaze."
[Source: Shaykh Muqbil's fatwa concerning the Television. Taken from Ijabatus-Sail alaa Ahim il-Masaill
Shaykh Sulayman Ruhaylee May Allah have Mercy on him Said
"From the rights of the wife upon the husband Is that he should have Jealousy for her.
She should see from her husband's Jealousy for her, but It Is a rational Jealousy.
It brings good and repels evil. He Is Jealous of his wife lest she reveal something of her body.
He Is Jealous of his wife lest she turn her glance towards unrelated men, and mixes with unrelated men and speaks with unrelated men without a necessity."
@@diruholic ther a pl ay ll st "M u s l i m Women are the F u t u r e" Vlsi t My Chan nel then this person cha nnel called Sunnah
Don't show this video to a feminist! _/\_
Mary wasn't veiled when she cleaned & wiped Yeshua's feet with her tears & hair. Yeshua didn't have a problem with her being uncovered. - The Bible teaches that God's ways are equal. If men don't have to cover their hair then women shouldn't be required or compelled to either.
Salam,
Also the Quran teaches that the ways of God are the same, but actually male's and female's body are different.
Actually the Quran doesn't say to wear a headscarf, but it asks women to cover their chests. The "headscarf" interpretation is force.
Believe it not, so does the Quran, but with male dominant middle Eastern culture that spread as part of the religion. The Quran asks women to cover parts of sexuality not anything about keeping a headscarf.
Wheres the salaams?? Arent they muslims?
Adoracion Scott wasalam
☺️🌙
Please watch arabian prophet channel
How do you get a decent job covering your entire face lol
Mi__ly G We have Muslim women in Germany covered there face and they are working as a Dr. in an hospital.
Mission Islam
They should ban the niqab, burqa, and veil
MrEvldreamr and they should also ban high heels and tight clothing
Pixus
None of the things you listed are security issues. The only one you could argue is high heels bc ppl trip and hurt themselves...covering the entire face and shape of the body is a completely different animal.
@anonymous guy they should be able to dress however they want so long as it is not a detriment to others or society as a whole
Esselamun Alejkum
This Brother have a lot of knowledge but to some area is modernizing them to much.
Second this deep topic male female should not be interviewed by women it just doesn't fit right this tells me how they try to show others hey we are not fanatic.
Who cares what others think.
Have our true Islamic morality value.
Thanks.
Ref. D. ... what’s wrong with Aisha? She is great host! Having uncomfortable feeling about women owning her own agency and great abilities and perform in high standard? Feel too small mate?
Elisa Lopez De la Cruz
Do to respect for women language is of topics is little to much between the talk
In my culture I can't have this kind of topic with my mother or my daughter.
We should have scholars women's for women's and male scholars for man.
It's is so much privacy in knowledge of Islam.
But now with Internet is mixed up anyway.
I'm not talking about discrimination but about the respect for the genders .
Ref. D. as you said... your culture and it’s limited familial communication... our culture that have the agency of free speech and personal development. There is no shame in talking any topic as Muhammad (peace be upon him) and actually Allah himself didn’t retrained from...
Elisa Lopez De la Cruz
I agree my culture must be more limited more than 1400 years ago as use to be .
Knowledge and truth should be me open minded.
Completely agree with your first point it appears as if Dr. Shabbir is always trying to give diplomatic and open answers that will suit the western & convert muslims.... which is wrong, he should present the true picture of Islam
The meaning of jilbab is not the body cover. ONCE explained by the Abdul bin Omer AL-KHATTAB as it full cover from head to toe, except one eye opening to see. And according to ayesha radiyallahu anha every women used to fully cover with jilbab.
See, if anyone asks questions like that.
You asked them, is it legal for a woman to talk in the streets of Newyork bare chested?
Or rather, why are men allowed to walk bare chested but females are not?
Because the body of men is completely physiologically different than that if a women
C'mon when men see women they get more aroused compared to a woman seeing a man
Thanks to Umar!.....For the Vail and Burka!...Thanks to Umar also for the Kaaba!.....
Toatalitarianism.
I know I spelt it wrong.
There are no issues in Islam . but only man created, especially when he gives INTELLECTUALITY, HUMANITY and SPIRITUALITY a precedence above the Religion. Remember that with Iblis (The Jinn), the problem was that he got preoccupied with his intellectuality and logic by asking the question "How Come?" He was questioning "How Come" should I bow to Adam? "How Come" should I do it when Allah made me from the Fire and him only from the Clay?. "How Come" overtook the Iblis and he became one of the Losers.
In Islam we should not focus merely on "How Come" but keep everything checked in balance. WHY, WHAT, WHERE, HOW, HOW COME, WHEN, WHO, WHOM, etc and if we don't get the answers we are seeking, then it does not mean that we are not obligated anymore. Especially after the matter has been made clear to us.
So the woman that are governed mostly by their intellectuality and not by the religion will ask themselves "How come" men are not obligated to wear the same Hijab like of the woman. How come they are not suppose to wear the Burka/Nikaab/Jilbaab. How come? Sounds familiar doesn't it?
-Nike- Islam. Just Do It.
The question isn't of How come, but of whether or not it is in fact an obligation or not. Nice try.
@@ririretasu2779 czcams.com/video/I_LePqCLgGw/video.html
The question isn't 'how come' but what is actually indicated in the Quran about wearing a headscarf. It turns out a headscarf is not an obligation but rather covering parts of ones sexuality is. Nice try indeed!
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=%23&ved=2ahUKEwibnK3P7sjjAhUMh-AKHeCDALAQwqsBMAJ6BAgDEA4&usg=AOvVaw0VTJzWxrN8ZFOD4xbU2nov
Bismillah. I think we need to read the Quran. The ayah of covering come after Aisha RA was the victim of backbiting and slander. The idea of covering is to protect the woman from those who wish them harm. I’ve seen women get catcalls as they walk down the street and being accused of “asking for it” this is no fault of the woman but why would you not take precautions. Just like you wouldn’t live your wallet or phone on the table or your front door unlocked saying that it’s nobody’s right to come into my house or still my stuff. There are bad people and their are people who wish other people harm. FYI men do have a hijab as well even though they may not follow it. On the most basic level men and women are different and that is that. Men don’t get periods they don’t carry babies. But that is why the woman can be a way for men to get into Jannah.
I bet if the norm in Canada is to walk out side naked or you must stay home shabir will allow that for the MUSLIM woman to go with the norm.
Shabir Ali - What's the problem with this man ?
Honour killings is an issue. Let's talk about that barbaric tradition.