MOTOR INDUSTRY INSIDER spills the beans on The FUTURE of ELECTRIC CARS! (WATCH BEFORE IT IS DELETED)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 17. 05. 2024
  • The MacMaster speaks to a Motor Industry Insider who spills the beans on the future of Electric Cars. All the lies and misinformation exposed. (WATCH BEFORE IT IS DELETED)
    #electriccar #evs #electriccars #evcharginginfrastructure #whistleblower #insider #motoring
    Subscribe to The MacMaster
    / themacmaster
    Get The MacMaster Merchandise Here...
    the-macmasters-merchandise-st...

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @andrewm5566
    @andrewm5566 Před 14 dny +15

    Your mate is paid by EV car makers to give their opinion. Waste of time interviewing him. He admitted that motorway charging is not good enough but wont say how it can be fixed. His arse is full of splinters from sitting on the fence for too long.

  • @richiereyn
    @richiereyn Před 13 dny +16

    So, when asked about people who live in flats, he concedes that EV's are probably not for those people. So what happens when there are ONLY EV's available? Are people living in flats going to be disenfranchised compared to the rest of us, and be forced to use only public transport? Are they to be trapped in their 15-minute cities? Doesn't seem very fair, does it?

  • @dnoordink
    @dnoordink Před 13 dny +16

    If he's an insider, he should stay inside... because no-one believes him out here!

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny +1

      Very good, I see what you did there.

    • @whocares264
      @whocares264 Před 12 dny +1

      yes no one believes facts here...

  • @user-px1xd9if2u
    @user-px1xd9if2u Před 14 dny +22

    Your mate seems a nice guy lee but brainwashed into ev's and not in the real world

  • @FirstLast-rh9jw
    @FirstLast-rh9jw Před 14 dny +28

    This guest guys a bit of a low level smug know all IMHO... Certainly wouldn't want to spend much time with him.

    • @citizenpb
      @citizenpb Před 14 dny +10

      He's also one of those people that makes statements by asking himself a question and then answering it. I cannot take seriously anyone with that level of pomposity.

  • @lloydmillership9682
    @lloydmillership9682 Před 14 dny +38

    I have concluded this man is very pro EV and I would suggest he's an evangelist and a committed one. He could spend years telling me to buy an EV and I still tell him to bigoff. 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @truebrit3670
      @truebrit3670 Před 13 dny

      And what a loss to society that is. Thanks for warning us.

    • @stephenrussell6074
      @stephenrussell6074 Před 12 dny

      I like my EV but if you never want to buy one that’s fine. I really don’t see the issue. Also if people don’t want governments that are mandating EVs then vote in one that will keep petrol and diesel cars. So far I have had 21 cars of which 12 were petrol, 6 were Diesel, 2 were petrol plug in hybrids and one EV. In all of those the EV is the best by far. Some had too much vibration especially on idle, some were not smooth, some were noisy, some drank petrol. None were perfect. The EV is closest. I love the fact that if near empty I just head home and plug it in and it’s ready for another 230 miles the following day.

    • @waynelevett3632
      @waynelevett3632 Před 10 dny

      He's probably joining the mob of us, that just can't be bothered talking to people about it anymore. People are working it out at a manageable rate for manufacturers ATM. I'm over talking to haters about anything as it's always just crap talk. The people will decide the speed of this transition. It's getting good in Australia 🦘

    • @markwort603
      @markwort603 Před 8 dny

      I love when the Jaaaag is nearly empty, I go to the petrol station and its ready for another 300 miles in 5 minutes.😅

  • @philiplindley7384
    @philiplindley7384 Před 14 dny +16

    The fact remains that, according to the US geological survey, there isn't enough Cobalt, Lithium and maybe even Nickel to create a battery-powered future for everyone on the planet.
    An entire new technology has to be invented before this can even be contemplated.

    • @jsanders100
      @jsanders100 Před 14 dny

      There are already alternatives

    • @philiplindley7384
      @philiplindley7384 Před 14 dny +1

      @@jsanders100 True, but many years away as yet.

    • @Richard482
      @Richard482 Před 14 dny +1

      ​@@philiplindley7384LFP batteries contain no nickel or cobalt.

  • @tectoramia-sz1lu
    @tectoramia-sz1lu Před 13 dny +9

    As a motor Industry Insider, he didn't have much to say that we didn't already know.

  • @richardweyland116
    @richardweyland116 Před 14 dny +30

    I call BS on this guy. There is not a lot of interest in EV's. I talked to the GM of a dealership that sells both EV and ICE vehicles. They told me that EV buyers come back six months later to trade it in for an ICE vehicle. Hertz is dumping their EV fleet because they are too expensive to maintain/repair and depreciate faster than they go from 0-60. Of course, poor charging experiences are the fault of the owner.

    • @waynelevett3632
      @waynelevett3632 Před 13 dny +2

      Because GM has nothing to offer for sale. Without making a loss. Ever thought they might be telling porky pies to save their jobs ?

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny +1

      All EV buyers come back? Perhaps the manager should have given you the actual percentages for people that buy EVs and trade them in. Go ask him for an honest number, I bet it’s around the same number of customers that buy petrol or diesel and bring them back because they are unhappy, some people moan about everything they purchase.

  • @jimpackard8059
    @jimpackard8059 Před 14 dny +29

    The fact that you have not seen an EV on fire means nothing. Not a very intelligent comment, really.

    • @barronsclose
      @barronsclose Před 14 dny +2

      Ice cars also catch fire.. seen many in my time

    • @nuthinasitseems5213
      @nuthinasitseems5213 Před 14 dny +1

      ​@@barronscloseI put out a number of car fires in the 80's

    • @waynelevett3632
      @waynelevett3632 Před 14 dny +1

      Have you seen one Mr 🔥🚒 FUD.

    • @demigog9523
      @demigog9523 Před 14 dny +3

      ​@@barronscloseYes that's true, but they are so much easier to distinguish, therefore cause nowhere near the destruction that EV battery fires cause.

    • @johnharrison373
      @johnharrison373 Před 14 dny +1

      ​@@demigog9523 Should that be extinguish?

  • @coffeebreaktheology2634
    @coffeebreaktheology2634 Před 14 dny +148

    Just because one has not seen an Ev fire, does not mean it is not a problem!

    • @wizzyno1566
      @wizzyno1566 Před 14 dny +28

      Yes. Africa doesn't exist. Because I've not seen it with my own eyes.

    • @dps615
      @dps615 Před 14 dny +5

      he didnt say it was not a problem, he just said its not a common occurance

    • @waynebarwick1404
      @waynebarwick1404 Před 14 dny +21

      All tech can catch fire. The issue is that when it occurs, it can be controlled. Batteries in evs are very hard to put out.

    • @paulcox2011
      @paulcox2011 Před 14 dny +18

      I've seen a few EV battery fires and every time the emergency services have great difficulty trying to get the fire under control! As for putting it out that's not as simple as you think!

    • @coffeebreaktheology2634
      @coffeebreaktheology2634 Před 14 dny +12

      @@dps615 doesn't need to be common to be dangerous

  • @user-ij5uz5dm5j
    @user-ij5uz5dm5j Před 13 dny +8

    You need to interview a whistleblower not a Insider who still needs to work in the industry

  • @kevinhutchinson9437
    @kevinhutchinson9437 Před 14 dny +15

    Unlike ICE's, when an EV catches fire you can't put it out.

    • @dps615
      @dps615 Před 14 dny

      Will it always be that way though? Unlikely. Sodium ion batteries are much less likely to catch fire and solid state batteries never catch fire. By 2030 its unlikely to be a concern.

    • @rosen9425
      @rosen9425 Před 14 dny +1

      @@dps615
      and how many catch-on-fireable vehicles will be put on the road by then? problem won't go away like nothing happened on new years eve 2029

  • @lonerider9037
    @lonerider9037 Před 13 dny +10

    The jokes on us, it’s all been a ruse! He’s not an insider, the way he brushes aside the mining and catastrophic fires, he’s a convert. Poor form!

  • @KevinSolway
    @KevinSolway Před 14 dny +13

    If the range isn't going down, it's because it's a sample vehicle designed to make you want to buy it.

    • @TheNige10
      @TheNige10 Před 13 dny

      The range is based on previous driving style, so if someone before @ the macmaster drove it like they stole it, the predicted range will increase with a more normal driving style. I have been driving EVs for 5 years, and it is how the GOM (guess ometer) works.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny

      Do you honestly believe that? Why would any car manufacturer build a special car as a demonstration vehicle, everyone would be disappointed with the one they purchased and bring it back wouldn’t they? 🤷‍♂️

    • @KevinSolway
      @KevinSolway Před 13 dny

      @@st200ol To take it back they would need to be able to prove that something was wrong with their car. They wouldn't be able to do that. Of course, it could also be that the computer of the demonstration vehicle hasn't had enough recharge cycles to properly work out the range - but that would be a stretch.

  • @BBanythingwithanengine
    @BBanythingwithanengine Před 14 dny +14

    Why would he bite the hand of that feeds him.
    The so called expert that is.

  • @user-rg8lj6rz4w
    @user-rg8lj6rz4w Před 11 dny +6

    Well I was held up for 2 hours on a motorway while the police closed the road to allow the fire brigade to deal with an electric car on fire. Using the expert’s logic that must mean that they all catch fire.

  • @yellowsnowman9157
    @yellowsnowman9157 Před 14 dny +5

    Things to love about EVs:
    1. Child battery labor
    2. Range anxiety
    3. Risk of garage fires
    4. Paying 20k more than a comparable vehicle
    5. Battery degredation
    6. Poor resale value
    7. Reduced performance in cold, highway
    8. Higher repair costs
    9. Awful charging network experiences in the weather without restrooms
    10. Higher insurance rates
    11. Replacing tires more frequently
    But hey theres a tax credit!

    • @TheNige10
      @TheNige10 Před 14 dny

      The oil industry is the biggest consumer of cobalt use to remove sulphur from fuel while EVs are moving away from cobalt with the use of LFP batteries so keep driving your ICE car to support child labour

    • @Richard482
      @Richard482 Před 13 dny

      Child labour cobalt is in 1-2% of EVs. Buy an EV with an LFP battery, no cobalt!

  • @AG-km6cl
    @AG-km6cl Před 14 dny +16

    I have never seen an aircraft crash or a ship sink so what does that prove?

    • @mrtonymunroe
      @mrtonymunroe Před 14 dny

      It shows that such disasters are very rare. People fly, cruise and drive EVs without worrying excessively.

  • @sueedwards9334
    @sueedwards9334 Před 14 dny +17

    What about a bit of realism - only the rich can afford them.

    • @ollyrukes
      @ollyrukes Před 14 dny

      how so? guess it depends what you mean by 'rich' - plenty of near-new EVs (3-4 years old) available for £10-15k which is well within the range of the average earner.

    • @Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n
      @Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n Před 14 dny +1

      ⁠@@ollyrukesif you can’t afford a Tesla new then you Can’t afford the fixes on a Used one especially not for new battery etc

    • @ollyrukes
      @ollyrukes Před 14 dny

      @@Dulc3B00kbyBrant0n had a Renault Zoe for the last 3 years. Not a single issue with it. Mechanically there is much less to go wrong in ev. Much cheaper to maintain.

    • @carolkiteley9273
      @carolkiteley9273 Před 14 dny

      How long will the battery last and how much will a new battery cost ​@ollyrukes

    • @ollyrukes
      @ollyrukes Před 14 dny

      @@carolkiteley9273 about 15 years (sometimes more, sometimes less, depends on the mielage).
      replacing battery is expensive, but then so is replacing the entire engine on a car. average ice car lasts about 15 years, so more or less a wash.

  • @jonboy9912
    @jonboy9912 Před 14 dny +24

    I was looking forward to listening to this guy however I found him to be Wooley and abstract and a bit aloof.

  • @sandralidster473
    @sandralidster473 Před 14 dny +11

    Not daft, but easily bought. Those Porches are rated as the worst depreciation of all EVs. You should have taken the cash not the trash. You're still driving a lemon.

  • @TradArcherDownunder
    @TradArcherDownunder Před 14 dny +12

    This guy is an industry SIMP and would follow any trend to protect his income "spineless"
    Thumb 👎 Lee

  • @richardweyland116
    @richardweyland116 Před 14 dny +12

    Who gives their teenager an expensive performance car to drive? This guy really lives in a fantasy land. If you've never seen an EV on fire, that means it never happens. Right. I didn't hear a tree fall in Oregon so it didn't happen.

  • @terencehardy9303
    @terencehardy9303 Před 14 dny +16

    So us peasants that live in flats will have to walk in the future thats a bit dystopian

    • @jabezhane
      @jabezhane Před 13 dny

      Yeah I do not fancy taking a whole afternoon off to queue and then charge down at Morrisons. Life is too short.

  • @freespeech3673
    @freespeech3673 Před 14 dny +15

    What about the charging infrastructure? You can build all the evz you want but if the grid can't cope?

  • @theosphilusthistler712
    @theosphilusthistler712 Před 14 dny +17

    EVs not the future, barely the present, rapidly becoming the past.

    • @robertfreeman7906
      @robertfreeman7906 Před 12 dny

      I think they will eventually be the future, but not for the next 20 to 30 years

    • @theosphilusthistler712
      @theosphilusthistler712 Před 12 dny

      @@robertfreeman7906 Not with current battery tech they won't, even if everybody decides they're great and infrastructure miraculously appears. It's been shown there simply isn't enough of the necessary material on or in this planet to replace the current ICE fleet. It can't happen, so it won't.

    • @robertfreeman7906
      @robertfreeman7906 Před 11 dny

      @@theosphilusthistler712 I can't see battery technology being good enough for at least 10 to 20 years or more, but they will be one day unless Hydrogen can be generated cleanly and economically

  • @pindiddle
    @pindiddle Před 14 dny +12

    Still not convinced. I have just driven from Suffolk to Skipton 200miles and have seen EV's sitting charging as I go past in my van and no way. My missus would never have one, she can't cope with the range anxiety.

  • @DaveJudd
    @DaveJudd Před 14 dny +10

    A better question for Dave would be " Most people drive car around the 5k price mark, will an EV of that value still have range"?

  • @glennmaxfield6618
    @glennmaxfield6618 Před 14 dny +15

    Suddenly the MacMaster is an EVangelist. Who would have believed it?

    • @SPDTDL
      @SPDTDL Před 14 dny

      Lee is a CZcamsr, 1 word… CLICKS

    • @TheMacMaster
      @TheMacMaster  Před 14 dny +1

      LOL!!! No I am not. You need to listen more carefully. I say CHOICE!

    • @rrg6625
      @rrg6625 Před 13 dny

      Looks like it. One more of these and I will EVen unsubscribe.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny

      @@TheMacMaster Lee these people don’t want us to have choice, well they do, petrol or diesel, 1.6 or 2 litre. 😂

  • @Ironbuket
    @Ironbuket Před 13 dny +12

    Is this video sponsored by the CCCP? Can’t believe that guy was praising the Chinese EVs. And that BS about the fires… If an ICE car catches fire, you can put it out pretty easy. If an EV catches fire, fire brigades are now having to get special equipment where they can lift up the entire car and drop it into a box because they can’t put it out. Haven’t seen a nuclear explosion personally, but that doesn’t mean it is safe for them to drive nuclear weapons around our streets. I thought that guy was meant to be smart?

  • @Prickly-Hedgehog
    @Prickly-Hedgehog Před 14 dny +13

    It's not about EVs catching on fire. Bearing in mind, there are far fewer on the roads. Also, putting out an EV fire is much more difficult than a diesel or petrol one.

    • @ItsAllJustBollox
      @ItsAllJustBollox Před 14 dny

      When they compare fire risk between EVs and ICE cars the stats are per 100k so how many ate on the road is calculated into the figures.

    • @cornishhh
      @cornishhh Před 14 dny +1

      I don't recall ever seeing any car on fire. I'm 65.

  • @Mizzkan
    @Mizzkan Před 14 dny +12

    Full EV”s are the present but will go away quite soon. It’s crystal clear they are not the future and I would love you to an interview in say 10 years time.

  • @keithboddey
    @keithboddey Před 14 dny +10

    If you let the market decide car purchases, the EV market would tank more than it is. Governments are forcing our hand.

  • @davearmstrong2296
    @davearmstrong2296 Před 13 dny +7

    You also need 12 recharging points for each petrol/diesel pump to get the same vehicle throughput per hour. So an eight pump station would need 96 charging stations. How would that be powered? Let alone the huge amount of space required.

  • @lesliecarter4295
    @lesliecarter4295 Před 14 dny +13

    Your friend is Quentin Wilson mk2 …!

  • @charlesb7019
    @charlesb7019 Před 14 dny +10

    The range indicator is broken. 😂🤣😂🤣

    • @johnwilliamson8110
      @johnwilliamson8110 Před 14 dny

      New everything, Lee driving like the proverbial … woman, new phone syndrome….

  • @hTyKn1
    @hTyKn1 Před 13 dny +5

    It's no good saying maybe an EV is not for some people when we won't have a choice come 2035

  • @timhicks2154
    @timhicks2154 Před 11 dny +7

    Here’s a man who is getting bungs from the EV industry

  • @Frank.Serpico
    @Frank.Serpico Před 14 dny +14

    I've watched all your video's, this guy is delusional, can't watch the rest.

  • @tonyhodgkinson4586
    @tonyhodgkinson4586 Před 13 dny +14

    If not many are buying ev's then they aren't the future. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink still holds true.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny +1

      Did you not watch the video? David who probably knows more about the motor industry than you or me said EVs are not the future they are the present. Literally in the video you are commenting on.

    • @Wee_Langside
      @Wee_Langside Před 13 dny

      Being the present doesn't mean it will be the future. Equally true for ICE and EV. When Liquid Crystals were invented nobody knew what to do with the technology. There may be a solution to transportation developed next week that kills both in a decade.
      Who knows what is on the future.

    • @johnelliott9415
      @johnelliott9415 Před 13 dny

      Yes a very good point that is

    • @whocares264
      @whocares264 Před 12 dny

      even less are buying ice

    • @Wee_Langside
      @Wee_Langside Před 12 dny +1

      Van sales are interesting YTD(Jan Apr) v 2023
      BEV -3.1% total 5800
      Diesel +8% total 109848
      Other +36% total 3053
      Not sure what other is, hybrid and petrol possibly. But no great take up of BEV.

  • @stevebosun7410
    @stevebosun7410 Před 12 dny +11

    Hi Lee, the "click bait" master strikes again. Balanced discussion, I'm not sure? Personally, I still hate EV's with a passion! Long live the ICE.

  • @user-zh9kc7tw4n
    @user-zh9kc7tw4n Před 14 dny +13

    It is a well know fact the more often you fast charge your battery milk float the more it reduces the life of the cells and with each charge to 100% at the faster charger it also reduces the life..

    • @adyg236
      @adyg236 Před 14 dny +3

      Everytime you start your engine it reduces it's life.

    • @Hitstirrer
      @Hitstirrer Před 14 dny

      Look it up about new generation batteries because they now thrive on being charged to 100% as that balances all the cells to the same voltage and actually makes them last longer. These new batteries will come with q 15 year warranty.

  • @simonfisher836
    @simonfisher836 Před 14 dny +7

    An all electric future involves being able to replace the battery easily and cheaply, but the manufacturers dont want that because it will mean the cars will effectively last forever and new cars sales would plummet.

    • @truebrit3670
      @truebrit3670 Před 14 dny

      Many EV platforms are designed for battery swapping. The MG4 for one. Some places even have robotic swap stations. You drive in and 2 minutes later drive off with a new fully charged battery.
      So.... sorry pal.

  • @stevegreen2432
    @stevegreen2432 Před 14 dny +9

    The real test of range is how far it will actually go--ignore the gauge that says full for ever. See how quick it drops off when its nearly empty.
    But most important--how far does it ACTUALLY go. Never trust a gauge until it proves its trustworthy.
    And I still get the felling that the gift of this car was to get you to shut up.

  • @davidorr6627
    @davidorr6627 Před 14 dny +9

    Obviously Porsche have bought some of Tesla's software which overestimates the range.

  • @Jimdirt7898
    @Jimdirt7898 Před 14 dny +10

    It won’t be doing that range in 2 years time

  • @mrgrumpy771
    @mrgrumpy771 Před 14 dny +12

    The issue here is that people talk about EV but have forgotten why they were supposedly needed in the first place. The idea was to go green as I understand it. If so, why is it ok to be sold a "green" car that costs more in terms of emissions to make (10 tonnes/car according to Volvo). It doesn't help. People need to draw breath and look at the point of this chaos.

    • @ollyrukes
      @ollyrukes Před 14 dny +1

      because although they create more to get made, they produce vastly less over their lifetime whioch more than offsets the initial increase

    • @robertfreeman7906
      @robertfreeman7906 Před 12 dny

      @@ollyrukes And don't forget the child labour in mining the minerals

  • @MrHemikid426
    @MrHemikid426 Před 14 dny +21

    The biggest problem with EVs is having taxpayers pay the incentives in order for them to be sold to other people. If their were no incentives, what would the sales look like?

    • @GeoffSlack
      @GeoffSlack Před 14 dny

      This sounds important, please expand on your narrative so people understand

    • @truebrit3670
      @truebrit3670 Před 14 dny

      What incentives?

    • @waynelevett3632
      @waynelevett3632 Před 13 dny

      It trickles down to the S/h buyer. As they get cheap faster as the original buyer didn't pay so much. So you don't get that amount added to the older car sale purchase price.

    • @rrg6625
      @rrg6625 Před 13 dny

      Yes. The poorer people subsidising toys of the richer people. Makes me sick.

    • @MrHemikid426
      @MrHemikid426 Před 13 dny +1

      @truebrit3670 in America, the government gives you 7500 dollars off, and some shares give up to 4500 off. The taxpayers end up footing the bill, which is BS.

  • @timhicks2154
    @timhicks2154 Před 11 dny +7

    BYD Dealership in China went up in flames last week. Perfectly safe - nothing to see here

  • @tonygreenbank8611
    @tonygreenbank8611 Před 13 dny +12

    I've passed 2 totally burned out still smoking EVs local to me in the last year. Your mate seems to know his stuff, but a vested interest can and does cloud the view. As you say "he's an insider". He says that EVs are the present not the future. History is dotted with new concepts that were going to sweep the world. Only for the people to "smell the coffee", and realise it isn't all it is claimed to be.

    • @Wee_Langside
      @Wee_Langside Před 13 dny

      Still not addressing the Elephant in the room though.
      Transport is the largest energy consuming sector and makes up just over 33% of the total, followed by the residential sector (32%). Industry just under 20%.
      So you can safely say FF is 70+% of energy consumption in the UK. To replace that with electricity means 3x the generation capacity plus extra for charging the dunkleflaute cover. Then you've got to get it from where it's produced to where it's needed and in the quantities needed. Charging 120kWh extra long range in 10 minutes takes six times the current as charging in an hour. Even a 10 hour full charge is adding 400% to domestic daily usage which is around 25kWh. That is only possible on a public charging station with a high capacity supply.
      Range anxiety is a temporary issue, recharging is a far more difficult and expensive problem to solve.

    • @vandamonium1731
      @vandamonium1731 Před 13 dny

      i passed on on a garage forecourt only 4 days ago and ev was the future 3 times before wasnt they

    • @johnelliott9415
      @johnelliott9415 Před 13 dny

      Very true you are correct 👍

  • @jjolla6391
    @jjolla6391 Před 14 dny +6

    We're NOT about to go to a new government. The Uniparty is guaranteed to retain power.

  • @philsimpson3556
    @philsimpson3556 Před 14 dny +12

    You never mention the extortionate cost of using a public charger. Approximately 10 times more than a home charger.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny

      Lee, mentions that fact in nearly all his videos, have you not watched them? I never use public charging so it doesn't bother me. As David said if you live in a place with no off-road parking or a block of flats, an EV isn't for you, I would imagine car ownership is quite low as a percentage for people living in tower blocks though. If you do have off-road parking then you owe it to yourself to at least investigate the option of going electric.

    • @vandamonium1731
      @vandamonium1731 Před 13 dny

      @@st200ol but the money spent per month and depreciation a month of your vehicle will run my vehicle all year long

    • @philsimpson3556
      @philsimpson3556 Před 13 dny

      @@st200ol They never discussed it in this video. I have off road parking and I've already investigated. I probably know more about EVs than a lot of EV owners. I'm mulling it over but I'm not yet convinced or ready to commit..

  • @lukepatten8308
    @lukepatten8308 Před 14 dny +5

    I don't know who this dude is, but I've lost a good deal of respect for him while listening to this.

  • @davidwalters313
    @davidwalters313 Před 14 dny +10

    The old saying that the only thing you can predict about the future is that it is impossible to predict. However I can predict that EVs will only become the norm when it becomes obvious that they offer considerable advantages over ICE vehicles to Mr Joe Average. Until that point they will decline in popularity.

  • @Elsie-uy2kl
    @Elsie-uy2kl Před 14 dny +7

    What a great interview. As always, I think there's room for petrol, diesel, hybrids and EVs altogether - none of them should be excluded. Technology is improving all the time so who knows what the situation will be in 10 years. 🤔

  • @alanthomson1227
    @alanthomson1227 Před 14 dny +15

    Oh so the range computer is broken already ?

    • @kellyeye7224
      @kellyeye7224 Před 14 dny

      Interesting to see if this turns into an actual issue and whether or not Lee is prepared to call Porsche out if a problem does arise.......

    • @Hitstirrer
      @Hitstirrer Před 14 dny

      No. It was previously driven hard - we saw that. So the prediction of future range would be based on the poor efficiency caused by that. Now that Mother Nun Lee is driving sedately the range will start to show much higher. The range computer is called the GOM ( Guess-o-Meter) because it changes depending on the present drive conditions from the previous ones. It can't predict that the car would be driven by Lee next day and just showed the driving style from yesterday at the start of the next day. Then adjusts as efficiency gets better due to slower driving.

  • @burgundyexpress
    @burgundyexpress Před 9 dny +4

    My neighbors EV went up in smoke on his driveway; nearly took the house & kids with it. Your "expert" is being paid.

  • @MahatmaLevolence
    @MahatmaLevolence Před 11 dny +6

    Sustainability has been a UN buzzword since Limits to Growth was published in '72, however, we're not short of abiotic oil (not a 'theory' but validated by researchers at the Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm). The batteries in EVs are made from rare earth elements which are finite, so it's a physical impossibility that they are the future. The Club of Rome are clubbing us to death.

  • @DeanMackenziebelldmb
    @DeanMackenziebelldmb Před 14 dny +9

    The tycan will only out run a 911 from the lights a few times then the 911 will carry on all day when the taycan is overheating or charging

  • @stuartmckelvie446
    @stuartmckelvie446 Před 14 dny +9

    Yesterday in my wife’s all electric Nissan leaf we went to Penrith. Enjoyed our day out etc. We had 38 miles range left. Nowhere near to get home. All 4 charges at Booths In Penrith had a queue and the 1 at Morrison’s across the road was out of order. And a fellow EV driver mentioned the 3 chargers at Keswick booths are not working. And at Tebay service station they have taken out a certain type of charger that chargers the Nissan leaf up. I was certainly not convinced when she wanted to go all electric and after yesterday she is thinking the same.

  • @citizenpb
    @citizenpb Před 14 dny +10

    This dude thinks politicians take notice of how the public vote. 🤣

  • @mikeolly67
    @mikeolly67 Před 13 dny +13

    I’ve never seen a plane crash , I guess that means it doesn’t happen then.

    • @foppo101
      @foppo101 Před 13 dny +1

      Or a ship sinking what is your point? Bizarre.

    • @wakeywarrior
      @wakeywarrior Před 13 dny

      Good analogy- a plane crash is an extremely rare event. If you are driving an ICE it’s at least 20X more likely to burst into flames than an EV. Fact.

    • @mikeolly67
      @mikeolly67 Před 13 dny

      @@foppo101 ​​⁠what’s bizarre is that you can’t decipher my relevant sarcasm.

  • @kellyeye7224
    @kellyeye7224 Před 14 dny +10

    It's not about EV's - it's about the infrastructure to support them. We only have HYBRIDS that can work in an 'EV sense' as they carry their own infrastructure with them! The amounts of energy that EVs require for FAST charging are 'impossible' to manage - either in the delivery to the point of need or the ability of the batteries to take it without suffering degradation. HYBRID is the future. EVs.....? Maybe in another 30 years they'll sort them.

    • @kellyeye7224
      @kellyeye7224 Před 14 dny +3

      ...and, unless manufacturers can deliver a battery with the same lifespan as an ICE engine (or make the battery replacement cost manageable) then we are staring the end of the second hand car market right in the eye.

    • @marumaru6084
      @marumaru6084 Před 14 dny +1

      Well batteries are toxic and there is no recycling so yeah it is about electric cars.

    • @richardbartlett6932
      @richardbartlett6932 Před 14 dny

      @@marumaru6084 Nonsense, there are already recycling facilities.. Do keep up

    • @marumaru6084
      @marumaru6084 Před 14 dny

      @@richardbartlett6932 Lol sure all the toxic batteries are being recycled. They are so very green!

  • @colindarroch4022
    @colindarroch4022 Před 13 dny +7

    Absolutely a load of bollocks.

  • @johnelliott9415
    @johnelliott9415 Před 13 dny +7

    One bigger problem is the Insurance costs because of the huge expense with accidents and potential fires

  • @philiptidmarsh
    @philiptidmarsh Před 14 dny +11

    Trouble is a new Taycan in 3 years time will make the one you have been lent seem obsolete and therefore worthless. It is the same business model as Iphones etc but at much more cost. This is my problem , they are encouraging rampant consumerism which is not good for the environment.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny

      Lease it then, when colour TV's and VCR's first came out a lot of people rented them, because the tech was changing and we had different competing standards. Its the same currently with EVs each new generation of battery technology is 10-30% better than the previous generation. Either buy a cheap EV, yes cheap used EVs do exist BTW with good ranges, despite what your mate told you down the pub, that will meet your needs, or lease a fancy £100k+ one like the Taycan or the Audi e-tron. We all have the choice.

    • @norriaty
      @norriaty Před 13 dny

      How is this any different to ICE vehicles? The VW Golf for example has had eight different versions, many of which are updated mid life cycle with different specs and features.

    • @philiptidmarsh
      @philiptidmarsh Před 13 dny

      @@st200ol How is your comment relevant ? I am pointing the issues of depreciation and the encouragement of rampant consumerism, Why would leasing something I don't want be the answer to those specific points. There is also no need to be condescending but sadly that seems to go with the territory amongst you Ev enthusiasts . This puts me off them even more.

  • @ducthman4737
    @ducthman4737 Před 13 dny +4

    EV's and all new ICE cars are Big Brother is watching you cars. The future is not freedom if we go on like this.

  • @clivereid
    @clivereid Před 11 dny +7

    Talking about Chinese EVs one minute and fire statistics the next...maybe look into the evidence of censorship in China covering-up the many incidents and accidents surrounding these vehicles.

  • @TrumanShow-im2ve
    @TrumanShow-im2ve Před 13 dny +8

    The battery on that is probably software glitching. Pile of crap and a cancer box.

  • @davymac5366
    @davymac5366 Před 14 dny +8

    This bloke has had more jobs than Mr Benn.

  • @noelward8047
    @noelward8047 Před 14 dny +8

    Interesting chat which went more or less as I expected.
    The silliest comment was that people do not need to queue at a motorway service to charge because there are empty chargers a mile away !?!

  • @colvinator1611
    @colvinator1611 Před 14 dny +7

    Yes ! STEAM is the future !

  • @davidglover6672
    @davidglover6672 Před 13 dny +5

    Toyota / Lexus have done self-charge hybrid models for years, and are the industry leaders. No range anxiety using this technology, and just fill up with petrol as normal.

  • @davearmstrong2296
    @davearmstrong2296 Před 13 dny +5

    The 30mph speed limit means the same speed no matter what you drive, as do 40, 50, 60 and 70mph limits. So it doesn’t matter at all how fast the car speeds up. While my ICE car is quite quick, the best bit is that it is fantastic to drive.

  • @HarryJensen-kr4qz
    @HarryJensen-kr4qz Před 13 dny +4

    Once everyone looses their petrol cars it'll be announced it's impossible to supply the demand. Only option is "15 minute city."

  • @martyngarner7961
    @martyngarner7961 Před 14 dny +4

    If the new Taycan is so much better than a 3yr old one, that makes your 3yr old car worthless. That's not a good thing.

  • @RobH.
    @RobH. Před 14 dny +10

    Let Geoff interview him!

    • @irwinmorrow1267
      @irwinmorrow1267 Před 14 dny +1

      100% agree! Geoff would kick his ass!!!

    • @dps615
      @dps615 Před 14 dny

      And get the same answers??

    • @RobH.
      @RobH. Před 14 dny

      @@dps615 depends on the interviewer, and what they are wanting to cover in the interview!

    • @cornishhh
      @cornishhh Před 14 dny +1

      Scotty Kilmer.

  • @peterritchie8554
    @peterritchie8554 Před 13 dny +5

    Isn't the problem with EVs catching fire is that once the fire starts it's incredibly difficult to contain? The source might not even be the EV.

  • @sirsploy7640
    @sirsploy7640 Před 14 dny +6

    You've been had Lee, range, fire risks all side news. The environmental disaster making these things and the controlling tech is very very clear to see.

  • @IanSixbikes-by6ei
    @IanSixbikes-by6ei Před 11 dny +5

    Interesting interview, I'm not particularly anti EV and believe they have their place and should be sold alongside ICE powered vehicles , my main issue with EV's is I really don't like is being forced by legislation to adopt a technology that just doesn't 'rock my boat' or meet my personal transport needs, the more they push me to switch to an EV the more I dig my heals in and push back. The powers that be should get back in their box and leave the option as to what I want to drive down to personal choice.

  • @andrewthompsonuk1
    @andrewthompsonuk1 Před 14 dny +8

    I think he was slightly optimistic. I just cannot see the 2035 mandate ever happening as it stands with pure EV the only option. Hybrid vehicles will be the norm even in the next year or so. Liquid fuels will become greener. Oil will continue to be needed for far more purposes than just cars. Hopefully a sensible balance will be reached where far less oil is extracted from the ground without affecting ones right to affordable transportation wherever one lives.

    • @EdVanMeyer
      @EdVanMeyer Před 14 dny +1

      Ironically Pterol can be made from Wind Turbine Operation, Porsche and Siemens have done this - Syntehetic petrol made by Aspen in Sweden is available. It will take 400 years to replace ICE vehicles like for like. This won't happen by 2030 or whatever arbitrary figure politicians pluck from the sky!

    • @Ifitwerks
      @Ifitwerks Před 14 dny +1

      Rights and ideology don't mix, we know that now.

  • @kevincross9206
    @kevincross9206 Před 13 dny +6

    Very balanced views. EV’s are not THE answer, but part of it.

  • @davidmarshall5596
    @davidmarshall5596 Před 14 dny +6

    Mister Macmaster! Lee this guy knows his stuff, the Chinese are flooding the car market with all their stuff & are ,if not controlled will cause major headaches for lots of manufacturers! Still Don't want an EV & still won't have an EV ! ice cars are for now still the dominant factor & hopefully for a lot longer to come ! 😊🎉

  • @oilburner225
    @oilburner225 Před 13 dny +5

    Petrol and electric in the same vehicle? ……..Absolutely not! As Basil Brush would have said, Boom Boom!

    • @whocares264
      @whocares264 Před 12 dny

      Er that is in all ice cars...that is why evs are so safe, no petrol to boom boom

  • @ICEFREEDOM
    @ICEFREEDOM Před 13 dny +4

    As Diesel engines can run on Vegetable Oil why isn't this being developed ? And regarding EV fires, its not how many catch fire, its what happens when they do and the danger to responders and the public who may breathe in the toxic fumes.

  • @timhicks2154
    @timhicks2154 Před 11 dny +6

    Future, my arse.

  • @TheChodax
    @TheChodax Před 11 dny +4

    Notice he wouldn't answer your questions on EV fires? He deflected and tried to turn it back on you, really should asked for an answer as you were good enough to answer his.

  • @williamthompson9532
    @williamthompson9532 Před 14 dny +11

    Sorry Lee you've become an evangelist bud, wots that all about???

    • @kaybee2930
      @kaybee2930 Před 14 dny

      He's having an ev mid life crisis. I don't know what he's become, stick to fish & chips Lee

    • @TheMacMaster
      @TheMacMaster  Před 14 dny

      Lol. 😂 no I've not.

  • @delonghi2593
    @delonghi2593 Před 14 dny +7

    Why would they not optimise the battery regardless of where you're going without using sat nav? Why does the sat nav become part of everything? If I know where I am going I am not going to use the sat nav.

    • @adrianwood2566
      @adrianwood2566 Před 14 dny +1

      The battery is heated to the optimum temperature to receive charge. If it’s not going to receive charge you are using more energy and decreasing your range. It’s optimising the battery for charging not for performance.

    • @delonghi2593
      @delonghi2593 Před 14 dny +2

      Catch 22.

  • @KookaburraAU9908
    @KookaburraAU9908 Před 13 dny +6

    I've got a Toyota RAV4 hybrid AWD and very happy. If I was given a free EV, I would sell it immediately.

    • @rwalkenhorst
      @rwalkenhorst Před 13 dny

      We have a '23 Corolla hybrid AWD sedan, and are awaiting delivery of a new Corolla Cross hybrid next month. My only complaint is that they don't come with a spare tire, and if you buy one you can't put it in the spare well because they stuck a small electrical component (presumably for the rear motor) right in the middle of it. Really dumb.

    • @serraios1989
      @serraios1989 Před 13 dny +1

      I ‘ve got a 2007 Toyota RAV4 XT4 2.2 D-4D and very happy. If I was given a free hybrid or EV, I would sell it immediately, too.

  • @stevenwatson3963
    @stevenwatson3963 Před 14 dny +6

    Electric Formula 1, what a joke.The noise of a screaming V10, was 80% of the appeal of watching them....

    • @stevebaker9709
      @stevebaker9709 Před 14 dny +1

      It makes me laugh when I see them racing around the track and when the battery goes down they have to go into the pits and change cars how stupid is that

    • @cornishhh
      @cornishhh Před 14 dny

      Formula 1 has been like watching paint dry for decades. There's far too many rules.

  • @mongo64071
    @mongo64071 Před 11 dny +8

    Politicians love diversity except when it comes to the fuel used to power your car. There is wisdom in the old adage about the danger of putting all your eggs into one basket. Diversification and moderation is needed in life as well as cars.

  • @pindiddle
    @pindiddle Před 14 dny +7

    Its not how many catch fire its thermal runaway that's the issue. Once alight nigh on impossible to extinguish.

  • @ItsAllJustBollox
    @ItsAllJustBollox Před 14 dny +7

    So who is your mate Dave because I cant find anything about him on the tinternet, he says he has done so much but seems to be unheard of except here as your mate Dave.

  • @Carrera90
    @Carrera90 Před 13 dny +6

    What about the majority of people that live in rows of townhouses/terraces/multistorey dwellings……?

  • @gerardowen7495
    @gerardowen7495 Před 13 dny +6

    EV do not catch fire more often but they are harder to put out and give of dangerous chemicals into the air

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol Před 13 dny

      ICE cars put out dangerous byproducts into the air for the whole of their life-cycle so there is that.

    • @vandamonium1731
      @vandamonium1731 Před 13 dny

      @@st200ol but they dont put out instant environmental damaging chemicals like an ev ... when they burn and ev are also responsable for higher green house gasses during the product.... as you say there it is

    • @johnelliott9415
      @johnelliott9415 Před 13 dny

      They will become the worst polluting car in time

  • @charvais
    @charvais Před 14 dny +10

    Got to say your friend is very smug & conceited with a hidden agenda !!

  • @radio-g4-rm3dz
    @radio-g4-rm3dz Před 14 dny +8

    There are a few questions I would like to have asked, how much raw materials are in the ground waiting to be mined? What countries have the largest resources raw material? China is one, Africa is probably another, have to be careful with that because China have got a foot in those countries as well and maybe Russia? The other questions is how much effort has been put into recycling old LI batteries to reclaim the needed material to make new ones? No a lot it seems at the moment.
    There are still a lot more questions than answers it seems.

    • @barronsclose
      @barronsclose Před 13 dny

      There are companies out there buying used batteries and they said they can’t get enough of them.. sorry can’t remember what they use them for but they are definitely repurposed.

    • @radio-g4-rm3dz
      @radio-g4-rm3dz Před 13 dny

      @@barronsclose Thanks for that, I hope being repurposed means making new EV batteries and not something else, I'm concerned that they keep digging stuff out of the ground and I'm not sure they know exactly how much is in there, we do know about oil and how much there is, but the materials to make new batteries? I'm not so sure.

  • @1407Dave
    @1407Dave Před 14 dny +9

    Keep my petrol car you can keep your electric cars