Civic Type R vs Elantra N - The Battle for Best FWD | Everyday Driver
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 06. 2024
- Honda has always done amazing things with the Civic Type-R, but Hyundai challenges their dominance with the Elantra N. We take these two superb Front Wheel Drive choices down a favorite road to see if they live up to the hype, and who offers the best FWD driving experience.
00:00 - 1:32 The Fight for FWD
1:32 - 4:29 New R - More Power
4:29 - 8:00 Laughing in N Mode
8:00 - 10:48 BMW Breeding
10:48 - 15:04 Honda shaped dart
15:04 - 16:38 Not for the Street
16:38 - 18:34 A $44,000 Interior?
18:34 - 20:36 Styling Arguments
20:36 - Confusion and Conclusions
#TypeR #ElantraN #FWD
We’ll post another big comparison right here every month, plus long term updates and big road trips.
Subscribe and hit the bell so you don’t miss our Thursday releases.
Also watch our other channel: /TestDriveVideos for single car reviews.
Plus you can find our Adventure Trips, Twice Weekly Podcast and much more on our website:
everydaydriver.com
Thanks for watching! - Auta a dopravní prostředky
The fact that the Elantra N is constantly being compared to the car class above it (Golf R, HCR) and not it’s own class (Si, GTI) speaks wonders on how badass this car is.
I don't really think it's in either class. It is the price if the lowers but significantly out performs them. But it isn't quite as fast as the uppers. It's in a weird middle ground.
@@phattyhales exactly
not a spec. . You have to compare based on the price.
They pay the reviewers better
And as ugly as a 15k sub economy car.
The Elantra N looks like an 80's movies depicting what future cars would look like.
That is actually kind of accurate!
I see a catfish in the Elantra front end. Not good.
Like Homer Simpson's car. Freaking ugly.
and that's why it's awesome.
@@imtheonehero9305 Right, it's ugly and that's why it's awesome? I didn't care for the last-gen Type R design and this Elantra N now takes it's place.
I've been shopping both of these. Elantra N can be had at MSRP. Honda dealerships are selling Type R's for $10,000 over MSRP. So in reality the Elantra N is $20,000 less.
I ordered my N because they were all over msrp. Not $20,000 over like the Type R though
@@devn3813 Ordered for what even? Are you gonna take it on the track? LOL
@@devn3813 Where are you located? I got my veloster N for under MSRP.
That's why I went with the N... but honestly I'm glad I did because the Customization is amazing and stock exhaust sounds amazing.
@@DropkickNation why would you need to take it on a track to own it? Lol
It's the ultimate compliment to the Elantra N to be compared to the new Civic Type R ! Think about it...the Elantra N is priced like an Si ! I'm super proud to have an Elantra N in my driveway !
Can't believe just Four Years ago the Veloster N was selling for 28k and the Type R at 33k
Ditto. I love my EN.
I'm N's owner! Love this car but if I know how to drive the manual or Type R will make an auto I will go for Tyre R.....
I really like the i30n (Elantra not available in my country anyway). Test drove it 3x and it’s amazing!
5:24 The lighter clutch for N actually is a lesson learned from Genesis Coupe. The transmission wasn't as responsive and the clutch was quite heavy back then. It was one of the cars that you need some time to get used to, but with N, that time gets decreased significantly. N is more friendly to new comers into performance car, but also fun. And that popcorn noise.
Im an elantra N owner here, i would not trade my N for the R. i would have the N even if it was the same price. the N in DCT form is faster, and by a LOT I am able to sit right with 10 speed 5.0s bone stock. the civic just doesn't do it for me. No hate to my type R brothers though. i just prefer the N
I choose the Elantra N hands down. cheap. warranty. heated seats. sick exhaust. and I like the look. all hondas still look the same.
Just being compared to the type R is already a win for the elantra N. I hope they don't stop developing it. So that the type R would have a decent rival
I feel like the Sonata is just forgotten a lot , I have one and that thing is nuts, yes it sounds a bit more tame than Elantra but still better than most cars and the type R
Had an Elantra N pass me yesterday on my way to work and didn't realize it was even a model until that moment. It's nice to see that Hyundai is really making a name for themselves and giving the big dogs a run for their kibble!
Hyundai stepped up the game in design and performance when other automakers were in a dull era. Only thing Hyundai needs to step up is honoring their warranty. Numerous reports of Hyundai denying warranty claims.
LOL. Speed in a Hyundai you get lol'ed at.
My girlfriend had a 2013 Hyundai Sonata and it literally caught on fire.😒
M-N,
M performance-N performance,
M Town-N village.
Hyundai Motor is copying the bmw M like a fake Chinese car in an insignificant way, using Albert Biermann as a shield.🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅
Garbage vehicles
Awesome review from these guys...I have an Elantra N and i totally respect Honda's heritage the Type R is legend...Im just glad i could afford something that i like and that has decent performance.
This.. this is how it should be
M-N,
M performance-N performance,
M Town-N village.
Hyundai Motor is copying the bmw M like a fake Chinese car in an insignificant way, using Albert Biermann as a shield.🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅
public announcement for hyundai KIA genesis owner.
Jan. 31, 2023-Two of America's largest insurance providers, Progressive and State Farm, refuse to cover older Hyundai and Kia models. According to reports, the insurers say that some models of these two auto brands are too easy to steal in certain cities.9
@@MistahLogi I say, exactly. Respect both brands and enjoy them both.
@@tmeisenmann3285 that made no sense
For how many times I hear someone hating on the looks of the Elantra N on videos, I have 10x many more complimenting how good it looks in person.
Same.
It's mostly American reviewers the rest of the world that's caught up with the 21st century thinks it's great
This! All of this!! Lol I don’t get it😂 I go to a store and someone is shocked it’s a Hyundai. I drive around town people say… that’s a good looking car, I’m getting gas… wow that’s a good looking car. I love the type R too but if you ask me the type r is a little too plane for me and the after market wing. We can all talk but why not just enjoy these two amazing cars!
@@nmode22 it's because these blokes are old and don't like anything modern looking
@@mharro88 I mean I’m 36 lol but I get it. Not everyone likes the same thing and I can’t hate on anyone for that. For some reason I think the N looks way more stand out ish and the type r is basic looking. A Camry looks cooler than a type r if people gonna talk about that. I just like stuff that stands out, the old type r was amazing looking! Almost got one but the mark up is not for me lol I would have to be a Honda fan boy to pay 5k over sticker.
I took the N, and I can't be happier with this decision.
Definitely considered CTR during the purchasing process. But in the real world, I either need to wait for 2 years factory order or take 30k CAD mark up.
I am sure the CTR is a better car, but not 40k better.
I'm sure even at MSRP, it's not $10k better either than the Elantra N.
@@mistamaog to me it's not 10k better either😂
But I guess for some people, they are willing to pay at MSRP for its branding and hothatch history.
I too have an N and love it, zero regrets!
@@GingkoMister But it’s not really 10k difference. When you sell both the ctr will actually have cost you less.
Now if you simply can’t get one that’s a different story.
I took an Integra...I considered the N, and even waiting for a CTR, but the Integra ticked all the boxes. Amazing chassis, great power, and all the creature comforts to be a nice daily driver. I can drive it at 9/10's and it's so rewarding. My wife and I are in agreement, that it's almost as special to drive as her Alfa. Almost. And that's saying something, because the Alfa is a whole other class of car. We are spoiled to have so many great options for fun, fast sedans in this day an age.
I'm so glad I got an Elantra N. Its somewhat compromised and unrefined but it works for me. It looks awesome with black wheels and 5 or 10mm of negative offset. More importantly I have $12,000 more in the bank.
plenty of $$$ off top for other things like track tires/rims and something for daily driving etc tunes and so on...while paying it off vs having that extra to handle down the road. Plus most of the cars it competes with also need more gr86/wrx both need brake kits to be ideal on track. plenty of other cars in the N price segment that need more to do "more" vs the N off the lot. I just wish the 6 spd was more engaging the way the civic si or gr86 sells as. It makes the DCT look too good makes me consider the KONA lowered...but its marked up pretty tuff in my area 36k+5k....ouch. While the 2023 elantra is chilling at 34k PPL that can afford the type R will be a harsh ratio of hard parkers to actual hard drivers. About as painful as its barrier to entry
Im in the same boat, I really want the CTR but i dont think its almost 15k better of a car.
Owner of a 23 Elantra N. Definitely a fun car, with plenty of power and handling to send it. The exhaust itself probably makes me like this more than the Type R, even if that might perform a bit better. There's nothing like going under an overpass and hearing a few cracks
Yea I agree, I have one as well, couldn’t find a Type R anywhere near MSRP and had a hard time getting Honda to help me with my broken AC on my 2016 civic did not like Honda corporate at all thankfully got the AC fixed still works till it breaks again like the last time.
Both great cara. I also got 23 Elantra N DCT, i wanted Type R but they were everywhere for $55-60K, got this for effectively MSRP of $36K. 90% of Type R for much much less. So far happy with it,
Too bad it's a Huyndai. Going to die before 100K.
@@MrDdz Please learn how to spell before venturing into the online realm, young one
As a Honda enthusiast and owner of an FK8, I really like the Elantra. I like the over styling (ahh, hello, did I mention I have an FK8?) and futuristic look. As pointed out in the article, the driving public are the winners here with so many brilliant turbo hatches on the market.
kimuchi much🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It manages to look futuristic without looking tacky
The futuristic look is actually cleaner and more "modern" on Elantra, especially with 2024 facelift. But yeah its great that there is still performance car that is bold on the design. It may not up for everybody, but at least drivers have more options
I’m seeing a lot of people saying the Elantra looks good……..mark ups on the type R has turned enthusiast BLIND.
Every time I watch one of your videos, I am impressed and amazed by how thorough you are covering every single feature about the cars you drive. It's so good to see someone covering the power and the way it's delivered, and the feel of the seats and the buttons. You guys are incredible!
You know when you watch enthusiast review cars, they are always so excited. The two of them are exactly that
M-N,
M performance-N performance,
M Town-N village.
Hyundai Motor is copying the bmw M like a fake Chinese car in an insignificant way, using Albert Biermann as a shield.🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅
THANK YOU for doing this comparison, and perfectly summing everyone's feelings in this video. If there were a million Type R's, we would all own one. But between availability, mark-ups, growing families, and people who cannot afford a 45K+ "weekend" car, the Elantra N, to me, is the champion. I own an Accord 2.0T 6 Speed, and I may be selling to replace as my dad hauler DD. Thank you Everyday Driver
Problem is ALSOevery dealership has the Type R marked up to at least $55k, at that price point it's out of reach for many people especially considered the luxury features you can get with $55k with other cars
M-N,
M performance-N performance,
M Town-N village.
Hyundai Motor is copying the bmw M like a fake Chinese car in an insignificant way, using Albert Biermann as a shield.🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅
@@tmeisenmann3285 the newly appointed head of Hyundai N is Thomas Schemera, who used to work as one of the top guys of BMW M division. so that's why it seems "copied" cause its the same guy
golf r is faster
@@hassyg4083 Like your mom.
Oh man the editing of the styling discussion killed me LOL
Glad you enjoyed it, thank you for watching!
I believe Todd does the editing, and this shows that a little. Haha!
Having the letters "N" and "R" in the title card is what killed me, igge...
These are both so compelling, what a great time for driving enthusiasts.
Too bad you can’t find a type r for less than $60k
I would kinda say not. It's really hard to find an interesting car without giving your soul nowadays.
Now you have the Integra type S which will probably have 10k markups.
It's why I'm seriously considering the Elantra. 34k is a steal even if the ENs interior isn't as nice as CTR
well, besides the 10k$ over MSRP by dealerships.
not sure how that is not a crime when selling gas for double the price would get you in jail.
@@JustinTorres-mp7zp I know I'm being pedantic here, but a dealership a couple hundred miles south of me was offering $55k lol
Had a type R FL5 roll up to my elantra N on the road and he geeked over mine he said he almost got the EN over the R. But nice to see how so competitive these 2 cars are with each other. By far the best FWD cars on the market to date
Hi, from Japan. Very good competitors they are. It is kind of unable to pick better one from these two cars. Only thing I can say is… I really appreciate is that Honda and Hyundai are still making fun cars for us car enthusiasts. I also appreciate existence of Todd and Paul. Thank you for distributing us nice and exciting films as usual!!
dog meat much?
@@newchannel1220 dude why
dude, it's the 21 century
@@carsketmin wrong account🤣🤣
@@newchannel1220 does you mean obesity duck lung?
By FAR the best comparison of these two cars. Love them both. 10k is a lot for the average Joe like me though. I bought the N and don't regret it. Not one bit.
Glad this resonated with you. Thanks for watching and commenting!
The type is more than 10k more expensive because dealers are adding 25-30k in markups
@@diallo1347 Very true. I've seen youtubers pay 70k. Just get an M2 competition then.....
Fantastic comparison. Been wanting to see someone do this for ages.
Ages...the R just came out, LOL
The $5000-$10000 mark up price on the Civic type R is a deal breaker for me
It's exactly why I got EN, i could pay $45 for Type R but $60??? No way
This might be the best duo comparison video of yours I've ever seen. Highly entertaining and informative!
Thank you! We appreciate you watching him and we’re glad you enjoyed this so much!
Beautiful review. Concluded it perfectly .. the Type R is the one we want, but the N just makes more sense to buy! I needed that, looking to grab an Veloster N!
Thanks for watching. Glad this was helpful to you!
I have a Veloster N and it definitely gives you the best bang for your buck. Type R’s are great but unfortunately really priced over sticker
@@supertin32 In today's history the Type R has proven its place in the track performance title. The days where people say "it's only a Honda" has come to a halt when a factory Type R can out do cars that are 200-300hp+ above its weight class. Many things are over priced but people will still seek it because of the value they feel for it. When a brand has not developed its place they will have to do what every brand has, start where they can get some retention. I can see if the N keeps up its performance in the years to come, for sure they will be increasing price as well.
All things considered the Veloster N is arguably the greatest hot hatch ever made. It was "Road & Track" Performance Car of the Year, in it's very first year of production, something no other hot hatch has ever won, type R has failed to win twice. The VN DCT is the fastest FWD car that "Car and Driver" has ever tested and anyone who's ever owned one knows it's the most fun car they've ever driven.
They discontinued the Veloster N after 22 I believe
Great job on this video. Really enjoyed watching this. One of the best examples of why we watch CZcams and hate modern TV!
I think that was Hyundai's goal with the Elantra N, to make a daily driver, that is tame but fun from 9 to 5, but a fun haver after 5 and on the weekends. It can be a driver's car, but it needs more power. That's where the Civic Type R shines. I'd choose the Elantra N for myself though.
More power is easily had in the Elantra N too. Aside from adding stiffer bushings to mine which have greatly reduced the wheel hop issues, my car is stock, but a stage 1 tune has been in my mind for a while. You can easily get 50 hp from an ECU flash and colder spark plugs.
great comparison video, I guess most of us who could not get the allocation of CTR, are actually thinking to get the Elantra N
Outstanding job gentlemen thanks for the review !
Love how the styling discussion was edited!
I'm about nine months into Elantra ownership. The looks haven't grown on me, but once the newness wears off, you are left with a very capable car to hammer as hard as you want with a warranty that will last you five years. The R is nice, but something I feel I would worry about taking really good care of because the price.. N? No wash, full wot, beat on it. Came from a Fiesta ST, same thing.
Just hope you never need any work done from Hyundai. They are notoriously bad. Good luck getting them to honor that 5 year warranty too, hopefully you won't need it though.
You better not mod it or you're begging for trouble
@@interceptingfist5682 Pure ignorance. The Elantra N-line has been proven to get well over 400hp on stock internals with no issues.
I feel bad for whoever gonna own this vehicle after you lol
@@B.K.7 10 years 100K warranty. All the dealerships have bad reps with warranty. Read about Subaru scouring scca logs to deny claims of anybody who tracks or auto x.
Great comparison and super production!
one of the best videos on this segment thus far. great work mannnnnnnnnn
Glad you enjoyed. Thanks for watching!
You guys summed it up perfectly. I bought an Elantra N last week... yet I still want a Type R
It’s Ok, most Hyundai owners feel that way too lol.
Not sure why so many N owners are lying to themselves and everyone else. At least you are honest. It’s like saying I hate Porsche because I can’t have one. Lol
The Elantra N is a scrappy, over performer, and I like that. The CTR is probably a future classic but I always favor an underdog.
Scrappy, over performer in what way? Ina a bad way?
Elantra N is the type r of the "poor"
The Elantra N cannot outrun its ghettolicious ugliness even in N mode.
@@chamade166 The FK8 Type R looked way worse and it still sold like hotcakes. The N looks fine, but I do really hate the blacked-out bumper, would've preferred if they kept it body colored like the regular Elantra. Whereas the FL5 hatch looks timeless
@@lawnmower6591 in a great way. It is better than people expect.
Great review as always
keep up the good work guys
Great review guys
LOOOVE THE NEW STEERING WHEEL POSITION CAMERA ANGLES!!! It finally gives perspective on how fast the.vehicles are being drived and how it looks
AWESOME JOB On the video. I would go for the Elantra. I own for Fiesta ST and well, right now The Type R is the mainstream. Im like the salmon:.....Meh, I going back against the stream!!!
Glad you liked the POV additive. Thank you for watching!
Both cars are great and it comes down to money…I was surprised how wide the Elantra N is and the FL5 is looking more like an accord euro r. Great review as always👍
wrong, it comes down to availability.
at this point, no one cares as long as it is in stock.
@@potatochobit they are available at higher prices so it’s still about the money.
Essentially the new civics are accords. Most people would not be able to tell the difference of the sedans without the name badges.
@@wanglee21 “baby accord”
Awesome comparison. The type r is awesome but that price is rough and hard to justify for most people. The elantra n really hits a perfect middle ground where you can get most of that performance while staying budget friendly.
Thanks for another great review. Appreciate your time and efforts.
Thank you for watching! Glad you enjoy our work!
Excellent video, as always!
The R is better, but it should be at 10k more. I own a 6spd Elantra N and daily drive it. 6 months and 17k miles and I am still smiling. Pop Crackle pop .... 😄
Type R is worth it if it’s going for MSRP. I honestly thought the MSRP was to expensive for the Type R I think under 40k is perfect. But the Type R is going for at least 50-60k which is just wild. Elantra N is definitely worth every penny you get so much for your money. Can’t say the same for the Type R.
Yeah the Elantra N is an amazing car to drive, I have had a 6spd manual for around 8months and 12k miles. Its a fun car!
is it pretty quick?
@@buildmorefarms1007 It is pretty quick, i dont really gas it cause it has wheel hop some times, but once when you are going in second, it keeps going.
@@buildmorefarms1007 dct a lot faster than manual
@@akunamatata4266 Maybe s but a lot less fun than a manual.
Looks like a really fun filming day.
You summed up every hatchback buyer's thinking perfectly! The TR is the better car...until u factor the huge price difference. To me $10k more for barley better performance is not worth it, but at $60k that TR's are selling for, you have to be nuts or not value your hard earned money very much to pay twice as much as an N for slightly better performance. If the TR was only $5k more than the N, I'd be Type R all day, but it is not!
Love the Paul "ramble edit". With all due respect I'm with Todd on the styling; I don't think I can get over that.
Enjoyed this video loads. Brilliant comparison 👏
Thank you for watching!
Can't tell the last time I've seen a rivalry like this. I hope Hyundai continues developing the Elantra N
Not a rivalry, CTR is better objectively. EN is a performance bargain though.
@@postalpancho I understand ur point however being better doesn't mean that it doesn't rival the CTR. Because even though its objectively the better car the EN is almost as great all while being 10k less if that makes sense.
@@danielmcintyre7405 it does, but that is irrelevant lol
If somebody wants a CTR, they will never buy the Hyundai
@@amatureskater15 wrong 30k vs 60k completely different league of pricing doesn't even make since get the R
@@amatureskater15 wrong I wanted a ctr test drove one and still bought a VN better warranty less space but oh well it’s way more fun and has more character than a type r and even tho they updated the new R our settings are still better and more easily customizable on the go ctr Is king but it’s just not good enough for the price and I love Hondas had an integra I wrecked that I wish I could get back to this day still have my 05 coupe but it’s not nearly as fun just a commuter. Id feel like I wasted my money to pay an extra 10k only to be faster by a second at the most I do like the body lines and it looks better than EN but that’s about it I’m not paying all that extra money for appearance.
The fact that you can have nearly the same performance and more amenities plus just a more fun car to drive all for $10k cheaper than the type R is just remarkable. Easy choice if you ask me. Wish you guys had the white Elantra though cause it looks so much better than the blue. Although the type r definitely looks better than the Elantra n.
Agreed. The first N I went to buy was Performance Blue, which is my favorite colorway, but on a car it was just too much blue for me. I ended up with the Ceramic White MT even though I had to drive 2 hours to get it XD
The civic is also a hatchback, so you're getting a lot more practical use if you need it.
I saw the Elantra N the other day at a light and it is NIICEEEEE
IVE BEEN WAITING FOREVER FOR YOU GUYS TO REVIEW THE ELANTRA N
I like these guys review. So detailed.
My realistic "dream car" used to be a badass stang or charger. But the past few years I've been thinking of N cars. It's a shame the veloster is gone. I wanted the VN soooooo bad!
- I love it when you guys struggle between the enthusiast’s heart versus livability. Great review!! One more thing, the Hyundai’s styling is just too much. And I drive a Predator-Mobile! 😂
Glad you enjoyed. Thanks for watching!
Great review
If you're willing to drive a high performance FWD car, buy the one that's $10k cheaper (before markups) and does 95% of what the Civic Type R does.
The Hyundai will never make 700hp on its stock engine - the Type R will
It's not even a contest when it comes to value to performance.
@@TheFK8LifeLol 99% of consumers don’t want a 700 hp car even in this segment. A light car with 300 hp with 300 lbft of torque is already way more than enough for the road.
@Sam Rastagar Can't afford is very different from. Don't want
People who value performance want reliable power and the Type R offers much much more reliable power over the shit engine Hyundai products.
@@TheFK8Life But some people don’t wanna pay 10-15k more when there really isn’t much of a difference except for reliability and even then Hyundai offers a 100k mile powertrain warranty. Also, there’s an option for a DCT transmission I’d take a DCT over a manual any-day of the week especially for a daily driver
The verdict is simple. Don't buy the civic type R to stick it to honda for raising the price.
Think about it this way, they were selling an accord with this same motor and gear box for 29k in 2018. Sure, its around 34k now...but the Civic type R is a whopping 10 grand over a LUXURY SEDAN with the same engine. The Bill of Materials just doesn't add up in my mind.
If the Civic cost 39,000 it would already be more appealing simply because its technically "sub 40 grand".
The elantra is fantastic, I don't think anyone should be skipping it just because the civic is 1% better. The fact that they can do it, means honda can to, and that is just the reality. You are paying for the name brand. Its the same reason people are fed up with over priced toyota trucks that use dinosaur parts. Its just a brand name.
You would think car nerds would be hyper technical and notice this, but alas, like Orwell said in 1984, emotions trump truth.
Elantra N wins this one for me. Much nicer car, more daily driveable, and 10,000 USD is a lot of money.
Hyundai engines are garbage - the Type R can make 700hp on the oem engine
Hyundai is just a cheap car - the lap times already show the Type R is superior with more potential than the FK8 which is already a fwd legend on tracks around the world
The Hyundai is for guys who make excuses vs just stepping up to the superior car in class.
20yrs from now people will still want a Type R - the N will be long forgotten
@@TheFK8Life Type R's are for guys that make excuses rather than stepping up to the superior car in class. The average M comp shits on your over-priced 20K Marked up Type R. By your logic you've been settling for substandard and always will be 😅 because of brand fanboyism.
Great comparison guys! Looking through the comments, it’s all the same typical nonsense about not trusting Hyundai quality, or I wouldn’t be caught dead driving a Hyundai, or it’s so ugly, blah blah blah. The fact that these cars exist should be celebrated regardless of brand. I own an Elantra N DCT. It’s an incredible drivers car and has been rock solid as far as reliability. I’ll be honest, the Civic Type R was never even a consideration to me because of the ridiculous dealer markups. Plus, I prefer an automatic so that in a pinch my wife could drive it. It’s by far the better all-in-1 car. The DCT is really, really good and would keep up better with a Civic Type R than a manual EN, but I get the apples to apples comparison. Anyway, I’m just happy to see more Elantra N comparisons.
That’s a shame because Hyundais reliability has long been among the best. I had a 2009 Genesis sedan that I drove everyday to 236k miles and it never needed anything besides oil changes in 7 years (well, I did have an O2 sensor go bad but that was it). I never even needed brake pads lol! Now, I do agree with the styling criticisms because this car just looks awful, but I could get over that considering it’s price/performance.
my wife is assed out. got the manuel
@@rickygalvan1969 ha ha I tried to get my wife to learn, she refused. The DCT is a great transmission though.
The comparison we all needed…
This elentra reminds me of why I got an srt4 in 2004. Awesome fun fwd with the right noise out back.
I’ve owned both…2019 Type R and 2023 Elantra N. The CTR is amazing but not that much better than the EN. Factor in the ridiculous market adjustments on the CTR and that $10k difference is now $15k-20k difference. Styling is subjective but in person the EN looks better than pictures and video. All the creases and angles that I was unsure about, I now love. And the exhaust…EN all day.
@VR JA it's obvious you haven't seen videos of the FL5 vs FK8. There's literally no difference in performance as they were neck and neck. Just admit it dude. You are jealous that Hyundai made such a great car. It is what it is. Deal with it 🤷🏽♂️
@VR JA New Type R has had a styling downgrade, 10th gen was beautiful. Elantra N has a wild design, I love the way it looks.
@VR JA The new design looks like what an old Lady would drive to Church on Sunday.
@VR JA If the majority like Cars designed to appeal to Senior Citizens more power to them but I say the 10th gen Civic Type R looked stunning and so does the Elantra N, The new Civic is plain and a ripoff too, I bet there wont be many on the road.
I like both - the Elantra Ns factory exhaust note is crazy addicting to hear, however, I can't get over the looks, the Veloster N was so much better looking. The Civic looks perfect inside and out, just wish it was a little louder.
It’s incredibly annoying when owning the car.
@@kraenk12 exactly, imagine hearing it every day with every shift
Great conclusion now I’m getting the Golf R.
It’s so funny how the running theme is how no one likes the look of the Elantra but that’s what drew me to it initially! I can’t wait to buy one if only they weren’t so hard to find
Two amazing cars. The Type R will surely be remembered for years as one of the very best in any category. For the Elantra to come a close second to the Type R is an amazing achievement!
It better than that overrated Type R
@@wdnalo what u smoking the TypeR overrated trash for $40k you can get better stuff for that price
I'll keep my MK7 GTI. A few mods later & I've a better quality vehicle, a decent bump in power than either of these guys (& the current Golf R), & a car that drives much better on a daily basis. Knobs & buttons are underrated. :)
@Sam expects the type r holds records and has a heritage at 40k. The civic is also a bit more practical than the elantra since it's a hatchback.
The Elantra N is the car you buy to avoid a $20k dealer markup. At MSRP, Type R is the clear choice.
Great review.
Please tell me I wasn't the only one who noticed the 'song' they had queued up while running the Type R? ;-P
Nice touch guys. LOL!!!
You guys just made me really happy that I bought my Elantra N
“It’s about throwing it in and adding power, before you even thought you could.” Perfectly explained what Type-R is all about. Liked and subbed.
You guys should have tested the 8spd DCT. Quicker at the drag strip/racetrack, has more power and stays in the boost longer because of superior gearing and lightning quick shifts. Also, the DCT makes daily driving less of a chore, or you can play F1 driver and play with the paddles so it's a no brainer win/win option.
We have a different comparison with the DCT Elantra N. Thanks for watching!
Great shots, awesome comparo, thanks for the specs guys. Keep up the great work.
Thanks for the video, guys. Still, once you test drive the N, you won't want to go back to any other FWD hot hatch. For the money, N is the obvious choice over Type-R. For everyday driving and racing purpose, N is the new King in town. Period.
Conclusion was exactly what I thought. Sure, the Civic is better - but is it 10 grand better if it’s going to be your only car? No. Not for me. Especially with dealer markups.
I’d probably buy the Veloster N because I like the looks more, and I don’t really need a four door. If money was no issue it would be the Golf R, but they’re not even close to my price range.
You could also just get a brz, but the civic hatchback space and practical use are its advantages.
So Elantra won this battle also.
I’m 100% with the type r. But sadly the comparison isn’t 10k different right now. It is almost 30k due to mark ups, at which point there is no comparison. Honda dealers are out of whack.
If money is no object, always Type R
The Honda dealer I went to recently had a $17,500 markup on their only Type R. 😒Another one told me the Type R is “too valuable” to let people test drive. Countless others don’t even have a price listed online. Seems like greedy Honda dealers are determined to ruin things for anyone interested in buying a Type R but not interested in paying absurd markups.
Real price difference isn't $10K, its $20-30K unless you are Savagegeese, Topher, Joe Raita or Tedward, then Honda will get you one for retail because you can promote the Type R on youtube, the world we live in.
Therefore you should have included the Audi RS 3 for $65-ish, 000. That is the true price of a Type R and the RS 3 leaves both the the Type R and bargain Elantra N for dead because the Audi is a luxury car that does everything better.
Yup, $65K or about $20K over MSRP for a 'Civic' is the going rate for the new Type R. A fool and his money. Lots of fools out there.
100% true but also rs3's have mark ups too!!
Well to play devil's advocate it's a special car and a dying breed so of course the dealerships are going to charge more The only realistic way I see that not happening is if you're like Canada and you literally made a loss saying you have to charge MSRP you can't mark up
@@TwoDollarGararge I live in Canada and we actually do have mark ups on these type of cars too!! Dealership owners buy the car and sell it as “used” instead over MSRP
Very true. A Civic Type R is "affordable" in exactly the same way a Nissan GT-R is. It's attainable with a car payment of well over $1000 a month and while I'll acknowledge how sweet of a car it is all day, any day, for that kind of money there are WAY more badass cars to be had.
@@Nimasis Yes ! I saw a new Civic Type R in BC with 500km on it with an asking price of $89K CAD ! What a joke ! 😂
For me, a good gearbox action is a precious thing. It made me lust after a 240Z after driving a friend's car in college. It is a real advantage the S2000 I used to own over the Boxster I have now. Worth $10,000? That's tough, but between that and other factors like track readiness, it would push me to the Type R.
With dealer markups the ctr is like $20k more than the N
@@G0ddEityawesome
It's only $20K if you are impatient enough to want a Type R right now. That will calm down over time.
Type R is an instant classic, don't compare it to any korean car ever made
@@G0ddEityawesome And it worths every single penny
The CTR has a double axis strut design on the front axle which gives it more tyre patch under steering load to the Hyundai standard macpherson strut.
Only Honda will charge $50k for a new car and not even bother to match the rear seats with the front. CTR is a great fwd car but it’s too much money for me. I would never pay that for a fwd car.
Looks like fun.. i only do manual trans for me so love that they both come w manuals..
Love the seats.. glad they added cooling
Between these two cars I would absolutely go with the CTR just due to its pedigree, build quality, and the kind of dynamics that only 30 years of development can bring you. But then I look at the price gap (as well as the laughably superior warranty) of the Hyundai and I start to think that, while the CTR is the superior sports car, is it really worth so much more money? As a Honda fanboy I say absolutely but as a poor person I just can’t justify the price. The Elantra N is an incredible bargain when you consider just how good it really is. I just wish I liked the odd styling, like even a little bit.
Idk if you’ve seen it in person but videos don’t do it justice. I thought it was ugly until I saw a black one in person. The lighter colors in my opinion don’t look good but black made me understand what they were going for.
Well said
I’m looking forward to your assessment of the Lotus Emira.
How did you guys feel about the pros and cons of the mechanical vs. the e-differential?
For the bucks spent, give me the N any day 😜 oh, I Already own one 🤟
You guys nailed it, I’m currently 19 and I bought an Elantra N back in March of 2022 and I was looking at the civic type R as a competitor and I couldn’t bring myself to buy it cause I needed a good daily that was fun and I couldn’t bring myself to spend 10k on a slightly better car that is going to be used daily
30k vs 60k in reality because mark ups
My thoughts exactly when I bought an i30N over an FK8 Type R. It's also more fun and sounds better!
@@FATmenDRIVEtrucks 40 vs 50 in reality
@@MeltingRubberZ28 35k vs 50k Hyundai made it so thier cars canted be marked up more than like 3k or they will punish the dealership
@@zimxyz984 I've definitely seen them sell for around 40 after taxes.
Good review and agree... I completely get the love/love relationship with these two cars.
I have the 2023 Elantra SEL and I love the style of the car but man I wish I got the N though, it just wasn’t out yet when I got mine.
Great review! I'm going to take a leap and get an Elantra N. A little worried about reliability but the warranty is solid so it hopefully isn't a big concern
Same, I really want one but ive been reading on N pages that its very hit and mess with reliability. Not MK8 GTI bad but not civic SI reliable
@@simonpz4159 Hey man, 6 spd Elantra N owner here. Bought car around 4 months ago, coming up on 10k km beat the shit out of it daily in the snow and commute. Got it tuned and running aftermarket parts, car has not thrown a single light or ran poorly. Biggest things is finding a good dealership. They can be the biggest hit or miss part about the Hyundai experience. When it comes to warranty and if in the states the mark ups.
Until they won't honor the warranty, lmao.
Don’t be worried, I got an Elantra sport and just about to hit 90k miles. Car has giving me no trouble and I drive it hard because it is fun to drive. Best car I have ever bought for 16k a couple years ago.
@@jamessephar9458 like I mentioned it depends on the dealership relationship you have. I have bought a few cars from them and same with my family. I spoke to them before hand telling them about the tune and mods and they have no voided warranty when I’ve gone in for service. Also not running an insane tune with 40 psi. If you’re being a dumbass and over pushing things it’s a different story.
As a automotive technician and fk8 owner and avid honda enthusiast! I almost couldn’t agree more with what they say … my only concern would be hyundai reliability , wich is yet to be proven! Good channel , keep up the good works
Glad you enjoyed. And thanks for watching!
In Australia Civic Type R is $72,600 and Hyundai Elantra N is $57,393. That's $15K difference. If I was buying performance car I would get Golf R $75,000 but if I was on a tight budget Elantra N.
I currently own the Veloster N which is a blast to drive but if I were to spend $45 k for a performance car it would not be a Type R, it would be a C7 Corvette which is a way better car than a Type R for the money. Type Rs are to expensive for what you get...just saying.
Crazy how people are hung up on the $10k. No one thinks about what happens when you go to sell each one. The CTR Will actually end up costing you less. That’s all but guaranteed.
Exactly
Too close to call imo . I'll take the N and save me $15k plus I think the N looks better and sounds better.
Good work
I'll keep my FK8 but i'm really glad to see these choices here.