Uthman, Ali & The First Civil War | 644CE - 661CE | The Birth of Islam Episode 05
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 12. 2018
- At the time of Umar’s assassination in 644 CE, his empire stretched from Tunisia to parts of Modern-Day Pakistan. The people he ruled were of different ethnicity, languages and religion. The empire needed a strong leader if it was keep them in check.
In this video, I discuss the rule of Uthman, the third Khalifa, and how his rule changed the structure of the empire and the leading Civil War or First Fitna that ensued from Uthman's assassination.
Additional Facts:
1)The Silk Road was a network of trade routes that were used to trade goods and ideas between Europe and Asia.
2) Other areas such as Persia and Iraq also revolted but since it was started by Egypt, I only mentioned them.
3) The rebels from Egypt, Iraq and Persia controlled Madinah, the capital. Hence, they were the kingmakers who elected Ali.
4) Since Pre-Islamic times, Banu Ummayah and Banu Hashim (Muhammad’s Clan) had been rivals over things like trade.
5) The dry bed of the Nahrawan Canal near Samarra, photographed by Gertrude Bell in 1909.
Don't forget to like, comment, share and subscribe.
Disclaimer: The maps and flags in the video are not 100% accurate. Some maps and flags are difficult to find and so, are estimations.
Be sure to check out my Patreon Page. Even if you can't pledge, still visit it and check out the content I'll post there.
/ almuqaddimahyt
/ almuqaddimahyt
/ almuqaddimahyt
/ almuqaddimahyt
/ almuqaddimahyt
Music by epidemicsound.com
If you had a problem with the video, or found something to be incorrect, please send me a message, rather than being a jerk and reporting it.
Nice to see such a high level of respect for Ali ibn Abu Talib. Thank you!
No reason to hate Ali Ibn Abi Talib he is a companion and ahlu bayt iam sunni but o have nothing to compare my self with sahabi or ahlu bayt I urged the.muslim world to unite and not go against
@@lageettamim4415 I agree. As a revert I was not raised in any particular sect. And the Quran clearly states that we are not to divide the religion into groups.
Obviously Ali ibn Abi Talib was one the closest companions of Prophet and one of the greatest.
A muslim cannot have his eman completed untill he has uttermost respect for Ali ibn Talib Apart from Ahlul bait Sahabi Czn Son in Law PanjTan Imam and Caliph Ali was brave just and truthful leader, Shia Sunni origin is political not of creed and they lived ear prayed together both had same faith apart from khuwarijites, When its conflict bw our ancestors we have no right to bash one to support other cuz we aint anywhere closer to them I support Ali and Hussain over Muawiya and Yazeed even though im not Shia, im descendent of Imam Zainul Abideen yet i have huge respect for Sahaba too cuz They wre companions and did alot for our Religion.
@@blacksheep6174 as a white American revert i was not raised with any sectarian bias. Tears me up to see the ummah so divided.
Even tho I'm an atheist I always liked Ali ibn abi taleb as a just ruler
He was a good man. He was treated very unfairly.
That’s because he was the chosen successor and caliph in Ghadeer e Khumm but they (Abu Bakr, Umar, And Uthman) took his divine right
must afa czcams.com/video/u239kmIcMLY/video.html
must afa Allah swt in his Holy Quran states that actually :) “O Messenger, announce that which has been revealed to you from your Lord, and if you do not, then you have not conveyed His message. And Allah will protect you from the people. Indeed, Allah does not guide the disbelieving people.” (5:67). He also stated that the term “Wali” means friend 95% of the time when actually according the the Arabic dictionary, it means master/guardian 95% of the time. He also states how the majority of the Muslim ummah reject his wilayah and coincidentally, Allah swt says in over 70 verses about how the majority don’t want the truth, are disbelievers, are un-thankful, are ignorant, don’t listen, etc... InshAllah kheir it is Allah swt that guides not me or you. Regardless, Sunnis and Shias are still brothers and sisters in faith and we must unite
Being from a Sunni background I do prefer him by far to Muawiya.
I want to say THANK YOU.
You are one of the first people who discussed a very controversial topic in middle east in a very professional manner. Most scholars are very biased around the topic. Also, a lot of people are ignorant about the historical facts and will believe anything they are told based on ideological agendas.
i find that highly untrue. you can find many scholars that cover this topic without being biased. and if there are any facts that are a bit iffy, the scholars will mention that it's a bit iffy like the brother that made this video did. I am not saying this video is bad, not at all. just saying you make it seem like he is the only person that is brave enough to cover this topic, when in fact a lot of scholars have . Also the video seems very accurate because he didn't go into much detail at all thus he skipped all the controversial parts. I am still glad he uploaded this video just to get people more into this topic and they can do their own research. I just hope he goes into more detail next time instead of worrying whether he will get hate or not.
I second that
@@TheHbk2089 it is very hard a scholar is not biased in covering this topic even with sahih narrations. This is what is dividing us.
i found ur channel a few hrs ago and cant stop watching all the videos in one go,, you sound more like a historian then a preacher ,,very unique(modern) approach to narrating historical events, which is rare to see in muslim world,, God bless u for being who u are . . .amin
Thank you very much for the kind words. I'm not a historian but I do love history. Islamic history, I think, has been corrupted by the clergy and so, I'm trying to do my part in telling it as history, away from religion. As a Sunni Muslim, my faith is one thing but my love for history is another thing and I'm gonna try to keep them apart. I actually took my approach from a Muslim, Ibn Khaldun, who wrote the book the channel is named after.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT I love you man.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT can you reference your information pls...i understand you are trying to narrate things impartially but I would like to see your sourcing. Although you say you ommit illogical things I'd like to see those quoted to with maybe you explaining why it's illogical 🖒
@@AlMuqaddimahYT may Allah give you right to enter jannah
@A S not 'should have' but was in a way expected since he was the head of Banu Hashim after the death of Muhammad. I am Sunni and see Abu Bakr as a Rashidun. But I do not and cannot hate or ignore Shia arguments they have a point.
Almost 1500 years later, we still fighting and killing each other. :(
Don't let it deceive you that today's conflict has any religious basis. Religion is used to try to rally people. Neither the rulers of Saudi nor those of Iran have any representation of what Islam is. But both know that using religion as a means to push forth an agenda is the best way to legitimise their greed and power.
The reason is arab
@@LocksLair I believe you are absolutely right, its true for all religions. Religion is what we term in modern world, is the same old story what we read about in history with different perspectives. I feel we all humans are still pagans ( Aboriginals or Adivasi they were our forefathers and we gave them such a bad name and ridicule them in the name of education and enlightenment ) ... this word is also not clear to me till date. All the son's of God or the messenger as we term are still being born and communicating to the local populations in the present times it's the people who are influenced, what we call cult in modern times.Science and scientists are also biggest messengers of God in present times. When in Bible and Quran when we say that humans are born in God's image, I wonder how many images God have?? Then where is the problem in Hindus worshiping thousands of God's. Actually there should be 1.5 billion Gods too. We are still as humans believe in ruler and subjects.
Just we have to ensure when we cannot create life we cannot take lives away that is the only religion. All the messengers have only said to be united with the close surroundings. Now the problem is everyone trying to define this close surroundings with boundaries and borders.
Universal brotherhood is only a utopian idea just like God.
Be at peace with yourself, and you will feel the whole world peaceful. Praise to all Gods in this universe 🙏.
tbf Shiites curse the wife of the prophet sooo lmao not really sunnis fault
@@area51xi No. Evil isn't our nature. Recently, researches suggest that human are actually kind and lovely creatures, especially before agricultural era. I recommend everyone to read book named "Human Kind" by Rutger Bregman
I am a fan of history from Austin, Texas - Thank you for your videos! There are so many videos made in this style about European affairs from all ages but not as many about early Islamic history made in this style. I am a huge fan!
I know this is just a summary, but the details he skipped are of grave importance and very interesting
There are so few like this
His videos are so short like he is in rush
@@mrnobody3834 I do hope future videos go into more detail on stuff he jumped over.
@@hdakahidefwhat can i read more in accurate details about this?any books recommendations?
Ali Ibn Abi Talleb (may allah be pleased with him) was treated so unfairly. Although, I am a sunni Muslim, I still have so much respect to him, there isn't much difference between Sunni and Shia Muslims, it is more of a political thing. In the end we are all Muslims. And we all respect Ali Ibn Abi Talleb, and his two sons, Hassan ibn Ali and Hussein ibn Ali as well as all other companies and friends and family of Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him)
رحمة الله على علي بن أبي طالب (كرم الله وجهه)
But some shias curse Sayyidina Abu Bakr رضي الله عنه، Sayyidina Umar رضي الله عنه, Sayyidina Uthman رضي الله عنه. And I hate it very much
@@revivalist355 Some sunni mainly Salafi wahabi curse our Imams even going as far as cursing lady Fatimah AS. But that doesn't make me hate sunni people because I know the Salafi wahabi are a minority. The scary thing is, the salafi wahabi ideology thanks to Saudi petrol dollar is spreading within the mainstream sunni four madhebs. This if left unchecked will cause many Muslim youths to leave Islam.
We are living threw a fitna. We are fighting over politics fueled by sectarian hatred. That's why the west is destroying one Muslim country at a time. They destroyed Yemen, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Palestine, Sudan, Afghanistan. Who will be next? Egypt, Turkey, Iran or even Saudi. The sad thing is, you'll see muslim cheering the west on when they destroy other Muslims.
@@revivalist355 and they will continue to curse them for it was they who had sown the seeds of hatred against Ali and his family.
@@zxera9702 if you are amongst those , prepare for the questioning on the day of reckoning
@@revivalist355 May Allah raise you with Muawiyah and Umar and his following and may Allah raise me and the lovers of ahlulbayt with Ali a.s and his following.
The signs of Allah's love for a person are as follows :
1. When Allah loves someone he puts them under trials ( the more righteous they are, the harder the trials) in order to purify them.
2. When Allah loves someone, he gives them the"understanding" of the religion of Islam.
3. Whomever Allah loves, he deviates them and their heart from disobedience and sins..
Jazak Allah'u khair
The more I watch your content and see how you treat history and sources, the more trust and respect I have for you dude.
You always present unbiased version of history. If there are contradictions or more versions of same, you either go for the most logical one or u just skip so as to not accidently propagate one side.
This is so good. I hope u reach a million subscribers and million views per video. Your efforts are radiated from the quality of ur videos.
Kudos...... Keep up the good work.
"The two battles were Battle of Camel and The Battle of Siffin. Both these battles are controversial AND I COULDNT FIND ANY ACCOUNTS OF THEM THAT ARE LOGICAL TO DISCUSS".
That sounds bias though. Would prefered if you summarized the "illogical" points, to at least enlighten people with the history, rather than remove them. It sounds like an important battle between Muhammad"s wife and Muhammad's son in law.
@@zweihanderr221 If you read into it, ifs really illogical. Hes not wrong.
I actually like how you keep out the controversy and say what you say to keep everybody happy
You, mister narrator are a person of wisdom as you consider Imam Ali to such high regards, as you mention that He was not treated right by muslims around him. May Allah flourish your love for Prophet and His Kin. Amen.
Also all the episodes are on point and impartial, great job.
Just can't overstate how much I admire the objectivity
If Hazrat Ali's (RA) sons themselves protected Hazrat Uthman (RA) during the siege who are the shias to disrespect the great entity that Hazrat Uthman (RA) is.
If everyone understands this statement Muslims wouldn't have divided into groups
@@shahriaradiat347 SubhanAllah ❤️
Sermon 30 of Nahj-ul Balagha
"If I had ordered his assassination I would have been his killer, but if I had prevented others from killing him I would have been his helper... I am putting before you his case. He appropriated wealth and did it badly. You protested against it and committed excesses therein. With Allah lies the real verdict between the appropriator and the protestor." Thus, in sending Imam Hasan (as) to try to calm the crowds, Imam 'Ali (as) was not actually siding with 'Uthman, nor supporting him, but was rather trying to prevent excessive and unlawful behaviour on behalf of the aggrieved parties.
@@zxera9702 mashallah true followers of Ali AS give answers with power of knowledge, this sermon clearly clarifies doubts. May Allah give you even more.
im shia and i respect all prophet peace upon him sahaba.
Ali bin abi talib a.s haq great ❤ Prohphet muhammad s.a.w brother
Ra and his the cousin
@@Gamerking-gu3mt he was often referred to as the brother of the Prophet(SAW) because of how close Imam Ali(as) was to the Prophet Muhammad(SAW).
Great Work. I like the way you summarizes the history in very short time. Long videos bores me and loses concentration. Keep it up.
such biased naration. all ansar and mohajotoun prefered uthman instead of ali. so uthman became a khalif by ijma of companions which means uthman was better than ali. and for the first 2 there is no dispute that tgey are better than everybody after prophet mohammed. and all 4 of them are the greatest companions and muslims.
This is a great video, but it's hard to understand because you speak so fast. If you spoke much slower, I think it would be much better.
this video is well made. thank you.
اَشھَدُ اَن لَّا اِلَہَ اِلّا اللّٰہُ و اَشھَدُ اَنَّ مُحَمَّد عَبدُہُ وَ رَسُوُلُہ 🙏💚🕋💚 صَلّی اللّٰہُ عَلٰی حَبِیبِہ مُحَمَّدٍ وَّآلِہ وَسَلَّمَ 💚🕋💚
Man I really admire your videos, your series on Islam, Ummayads, Abbasids and Cordoba. I'm glad we ummah finally have a narrator on CZcams from our people. And best thing is you are not biased even though a Sunni, your approach towards history is scientific, calculated and rational based on facts and logic. Keep it up pal ! Also you just cleared a lot about Islam for me with your videos on first fitnas in Islam. I guess Ulema never let much out about true events in history of Islam. May Allah guide us to righteous path as he guided his all people.
Usman [r.a]was the first Hafiz of Quran , He was the person who collected all the references of Quran and gather them into one structure which is still in the same structure , and Sorrowfully he Assassinated and martyr while reciting Quran , He was among one of the greatest person in history to be ever lived. May Allah bless him with uncountable Mercy.
He was also the husband of 2 of the prophets daughters
Please also read up why the Egyptians assassinated him and why his fellow governors did not show up for his help during the siege.
@@SuperPotatoboy Lol I am Qualified Person to Cover up whole islamic studies and there's no single evident to describe his image hostile and Hypocrite in my heart , but
rather your comment does clarify such hypocrisy and transgression
@@addictedtragedy2788 please help me with the history then if you call yourself a qualified person. Please tell me why did Egyptians come all the way to kill him and why there was no help from his appointed relatives? Answer pls. No wishy washy stories.
@@SuperPotatoboy One word 'Marwan Ibn Hakam' well mostly shows adversely concurrence and accordance to elect him as curator or there's several other Renowned historians who repute 'Abdullah Ibn Sabah' for the actual Person to create an turmoil and strife by making such conspiracy against Caliph , and even Uthman was really Culprit for policies and allegations made by these Rebellions , why would Ali himself mention and clear every doubt and misconception in his address that several allegations Constituted by these rebels on Emer of believers , not even Ali but rather Governer of Syria requested by envoy to deploy and depart caravan of thousands belligerent to massacre these jumping rats but also Amr ibn Al A'as Came along with his supplication to decamp the Militants , not even him but Hasan and Hussain also defended him in front of his apartment , but also Abdullah Ibn Salam came to uthman for request to defend him and came to address skeptically and critically a the protestants about there's misguidance to assassinate Caliph will led to an immense civil war occur by the Blood shed from caliph veins by making References fron Old testament and several others Senior companion to Witness and testify his dignity and Good virtue , and also The people related with in Gnosis and wisdom such Abu huraira , Abdullah ibn Abbas and Abdullah ibn Umer came along with there Spears and swords to participate in caliph defense , hence Prophet himself Conducted Command to uthman : Divine will bestow you from an Cloth (Authority upon caliphate) , and infidel will demand to unveil it , But not let yourself , well Sister am not rebuking you or anyone i have lot to debate on but rather i am pretty fanatic related to islam , may God bless with you with her highest Mercy , peace and tranquility upon you and People dwells in your heart
Such complex events , no-one cud hv explained it better, the way you did it.
Your videos are great keep it up
This is my fourth video. Been watching your video since the first. I like your objectivity.
Yes indeed the circumstances around Ali was very unfortunate. If He ruled long, It could certainly be the golden age of Caliphate. Islamic ummah deserved a Caliph like Ali. Caliphate of Ahlu-Bait is the most desired one. Because they are the most humble of all muslims and all humanity
Ali had no part in the conquests of the early caliphate but was bitching all the time to become the caliph based on him being son in law. he was not ahl e bayt as shias falsely believe
@@MegaBaddog you are someone devoid of any morality.
@@inter3684 dumb reply dumbo shia heretic rafidhi majoos.
@@MegaBaddog May god curse every single person with a single atom of hatred against the Guardian of God, the Commander of the Faithful, Al-Mawla Imam Ali bin Abi Talib(as), the cousin and son-in-law of the Prophet(SAW). You have absolutely no right to hate him you nasibi. What is your grandpa Yazid bin Muawiah (may God curse him, his father, his grandfather and uncle)???
“O’ Ali, the people who love you are believers, and the people that hate you are hypocrites” - Prophet Muhammad (SAW).
@@MegaBaddog
Only rafidi is you here
Saying non sense about Hazrat ali RA
Shame on you
I am a sunni too
But would never disrespect Hazrat Ali
These videos are so insightful, I really appreciate you for giving us the non biased view. Can you please make a video about the civil war from both Shia and Sunni view
Bro, you rock. Salam from Bangladesh ❤
In future can you cite sources in your description?
Or provide the sources for this video.
3:37 saying it is highly controversial and debated is actually an understatement
bro could you make more clips of these topics and more about the islamic spain im really into your work and i appreciated a lot, not many sources talks about these sensitive period
Man you are doing a great job tombs up
Great video brother short but informative, proper, and unbiased. May Al Aleem Increase you in your wisdom and knowledge And Al Hadi Makes Your Work A Guidance for today's generation of Muslims.❤️❤️
Please give the reference of your work. Name of the books that you follow to make these videos.
Please make a video on the second fitna I really love ur videos
This Channel Will be Great, i assure you....
﷽
❤ فِدَاكَ اَبِی وَاُمِّی وَرُوحِی وَقَلبِی یَاسَیِّدِی یَارَسُول اللہ ﷺ ❤️
ﷺاللّهمَ صَلِّ على سيْدنَا مُحَمد
وَعَلى آلِ سيْدنَا مُحَمدﷺ❤
❤ ﺍَﻟﺼَّﻼَﺓُ ﻭَﺍﻟﺴَّﻠَﺎﻡُ ﻋَﻠَﻴْﻚَ ﻳَﺎ ﺭَﺳُﻮﻝَ ﺍﻟﻠّٰﻪِ❤
❤صلی اللہ تعالی علیہ وسلم ❤
💕سُبْحَانَ الله
💕الْحَمْدُ لله
💕لَا إِلهَ إِلَّا الله
💕اللهُ أَكْبَر
💕سُبْحَانَ اللهِ وَبِحَمْدِهِ
💕سُبْحَانَ اللهِ الْعَظيِم
💕حَسْبِيَ اللهُ وَنِعمَ الوَكِيل
💕أستَغفِرُ اللهَ الْعَظِيمَ وَأتُوبُ إلَيهِ
💕استَغْفِرُ اللهَ وَأتُوبُ إلَيهِ
💕أستَغفِرُ اللهَ الْعَظِيمَ
💕لَا حَـوْلَ وَلَا قُـوَّةَ إِلَّا بِـٱللَّه
💕لَا إِلَهَ إِلَّا أَنْتَ سُبْحَانَكَ إِنِّي كُنْتُ مِنَ الظَّالِمِينَ
💕لاحَولَ وَلَا قُوّةَ إلَّا بِااللهِ
العَلِي العَظِيمِ
💕ﷺاللّهمَ صَلِّ على سيْدنَا مُحَمد
وَعَلى آلِ سيْدنَا مُحَمدﷺ
💕 ﺍَﻟﺼَّﻼَﺓُ ﻭَﺍﻟﺴَّﻠَﺎﻡُ ﻋَﻠَﻴْﻚَ ﻳَﺎ ﺭَﺳُﻮﻝَ ﺍﻟﻠّٰﻪِ
💕 صلی اللہ تعالی علیہ وسلماَشھَدُ اَن لَّا اِلَہَ اِلّا اللّٰہُ و اَشھَدُ اَنَّ مُحَمَّد عَبدُہُ وَ رَسُوُلُہ 🙏💚🕋💚 صَلّی اللّٰہُ عَلٰی حَبِیبِہ مُحَمَّدٍ وَّآلِہ وَسَلَّمَ 💚🕋💚
For the people who said Ali had no problems with Abu Bakr and Omar. Why did he say NO to uphold the sunna of those two? And Uthman did say yes?
Because the Story isn't even authentic, and the most authentic version of it in Sahih Al Bukhari don't mention it, in fact, it mentions that Ali Himself Acknowledged that Uthman is better than him let alone Abu Bakr and Umar.
@@user-dl5ln3wd6f The story is very authentic and is mentioned in many books. The problem is that many people regard Bukhari and Muslim as the most authentic books and all that is mentioned in them must be truth because its so popular when there are many books that pre date bukhari and muslim. Its just a way to pick and choose which hadith you like and which you dont, turn the whole religion into a joke...
@@muhajerhassan
It dosent matter if it's mentioned in 1000 source, Al Bukhari is still more authentic.
@@user-dl5ln3wd6f no that is the delusion of sunni's as if bukhari was a prophet or something. I bet you dont even know shit about bukhari
@@user-dl5ln3wd6fplz stup Othman, Abubakr and Omar were not better than Ali lol that's clearly fabricated also Bukhari isn't even 100 percent reliable it contains lots of bs.
loving it :)
You just did it ✌️✌️
They raised swords at each other, they were massacring each other, but somehow it was just a misunderstanding and they are all sahaba who are promised heaven...
The cognitive dissonance of the average Muslim is outstanding.
Look at this poor thing. Somebody who has to feel good by belittling others.
@@ishraqkhan8222 and from your name I am sure you don't even know arabic, at least I am a native Arabic speaker.
Don't say Muslim say bakri omaris Sunni, Muslim don't make this war a issue of murjiat or say both were right, because saying this is just like worshiping Allah then also worshipping another god but Allah have already said haqq is only one
A historian and scholar here from Kuwait, I absolutely love this video (I subscribed! I got hooked)! ❤
The graphics were outstanding & appealing, your voiceover work is amazing & soothing… plus the accuracy and objectiveness that you presented is a sign of your humbleness & professionalism.
May Allah bless you & all your works, I can’t wait to watch more of your videos ❤
Amazing.
i love how you tell the history
I don't agree with your statement that Muawiyah was not evil and I refer to the events and deeds after his coronation. He was in no way considered a pious Muslim, he founded a dynasty against the principles of Islam, he broke his agreement with Hassan Ibn Ali that obliged him not to appoint an heir for himself, he set down the tradition of cursing Ali to illegitimize his supporters which continued throughout all Ummayad rule - except during Umar ibn Abdulaziz's reign - over Islamic nation. These are verified deeds of his which are directly against any basis of Islamic constitution without needing to take a side. He's literally the very manifestation of everything that is wrong with Muslim community today. A sharp and competent but corrupted ruler who saw his own and his kinsmen interest prior to Islamic constitutions. His conquests and his reign served his own agenda, not Islam's.
As for your video, I appreciate it very much. Keep up the good work.
It's rly shocking to see many people defending muyawia n his son yazed,
Great videos,
Nice job bro,
Ummayads were cruel dictators, Ali is haq
Ali R.A
Fantastic animation and music can you please tell me name of software you used for editing and source of music
This is so interesting
i noticed that the descendants of prophet mohammad(pbuh) were exactly like him "Forgiving" Hazrat ALI(RA) and Hussein (RA) they avoided violence as much as they can. What a time will it be when imam mahdi arrives.
right there’s a story that once there came a man trying to assassinate prophet muhammed(saw) while imam ali(as) was right next to him, so of course imam ali(as) fought the man to protect the prophet. eventually the man tripped and his sword fell out of his hand and as he was lying in the ground he spit at imam ali(as). Imam ali(as) then put back his sword and started walking away and when the man asked why he said “If i were to kill you right now it would be because of my anger because you spit at me, not because i was trying to protect the prophet(saw)”
@@buzzlightyear1010 No that is wrong! The guy who tried to ' Assassinate' Muhammad was called Amr ibn Abd Wud AND ALI FOUGHT HIM IN THE BATTLE OF THE TRENCH, it was not an assassination, it was a duel.
Ali won the battle of Khaber . He killed the Jews. Thatswhy till now the Jews call him butcher Ali.
Till now the hatred remains in their heart against Lion of Allah
@@salehaali100 that doesnt make sense, the jews of khyber surrendered after Ali defeated their strongest warrior Marhab, they were the fortress that wasnt killed and made peace after the siege.
Thank you, dear. You say at the end of your video that both Muawiya and Ali didn't want to shed Muslims blood.I'm sure Ali wouldn't but as for Muawiya, I 'm sure he did it to protect his throne. To be more honest It's unfair and a kind of funny thing to put a man like Ali who is a a real Immam and who was born in Kaaba in such a comparison with a man whose heart had bever accepted Islam.I am sorry but this is the truth.
Please do not disrespect a sahabi like that. Ali is thr beloved cousin of the prophet may peace be upon him, and i do believe he was on the truth, however, who are you to judge a sahabi? As for born in the kaaba, muayia radiyah allahu anh was also born in mecca, and it doesn't matter where you are born either way. They both believed they were better for the umma.
@@TheHbk2089 DEAR.i AM NOT DISRESPECTING ANY BODY BROTHER.i JUST WANT YOU TO SAY WHOSE FAULT was IT WHEN THOUSANDS OF POEPLE of both sides WERE KILLED IN THE BATTLE OF Sifeen.Listen dear.I am not pretending to be more believer than you BUT DON'T YOU THINK THAT gOD WILL jUGE THIS BATTLE IN the HERE AFTER WHEN BOTH Ali and MUawiya stands infront of him.I don't think that God will let Muawiya go because he is a sahabi neither Ali because he is the cousin of the prophit.God punish the man into hill because he says a bad word (( Prophet's Hadeeth).HOW gOD LET THESE BLOODS GO FOR NO PUNISHMENT. wE ALL KNOW THAT gOD IS jUST.
@@mohammedalkhafagy7158 again, you don't know how allah will judge them, you worry about yourself. You do your part by not putting blames on others and let allah deal with them. Muawiyah on his death bead said "O Allah! Reduce my lapses, pardon the shortcomings and overlook my ignorance, for You are All Forgiving. My mistakes are all my own and not attributable to You; only You can forgive me and grant me refuge". You assumed that muawiyah shed blood to protect his throne, who are you to assume that? Only allah can judge and know what's a person true intention.
@@TheHbk2089 muawiya nominated his son yazid as his successor which was against what he agreed with the prophet’s grandson. The guy used to curse Ali and his family. He was a moron
If you have received any suggestions to the disclaimer you made at the end of the video. If there anything else in relation to the video facts could you send send a link to it or could you state the objections and corrections if any u needed to make.
The key of understanding the true islam and the prophet Mohammad (عليه الصلاة و السلام( is the great Man « Ali » عليه السلام
What are you talking abut
What are your sorses
Wer did you get your hestory from ?????
I dont bleve it
Your animation is good, but you bring some of your opinion for major points. For more objectivity, its better just to refer to other major sources of islamic history
I have been loving your videos and the information, but the guy with the musket kills me.
these videos create a world am so engrossed in
This is my first time watching a video from this channel and honestly I’m not surprised that it’s biased and not supported by evidence. I’m just sad when I read the comments about how objective he is!! He’s far from objective but you wouldn’t know if you don’t read for yourself.
Can you elaborate please?
@@gulfamjameel1703 he can’t, because he himself has no idea what he’s saying
I m a student of history and hasn’t studied Islam for a decade. And I can confirm what he talked abt in this video is 95 % correct. You need to start ur research again sir if u think this video is biased
If you study Muawiya life story , you will start to think that he might be the one who killed Othman , the thing that he fought Ali immediately after Othman murder , and he also betrayed his agrement with Hassan and store his son as a Caliphate . You will even thing that he might be the one who murdered Hassan the son of Muhammad .
It is confirmed that imam hassans wife posiensend him because mouwayah promised her 100,000 dirhams with the hand in marraige with his son yazid.
@@shadowsyed5493 evidence?
@quotetheraven90 would you ignore the fact that Umar II was also among the Umayyad? Cause honestly you're over generalizing rn
...
Muawiyah Is A Munafiq
Your sources are " he might" so shut your fucling mouth
AsSalam. I wish your narration could be just a little bit slower. You sound like you are in a hurry. But I enjoy your videos. I learnt something new every time I watch them. Thank you. God bless you.
Yes! I know hence I've changed my later videos where I speak slower.
Do you make all of your video like you gotta catch a train? and background musics are all same in all your videos, (You Can ImProve)
You are right. That's why it's different in later videos. Sorry.
Great work, love your research and presentation!
One question though: did I hear correctly at 5:27 that both Shia and Sunni believe that 'Ali was the fourth rightly-guided Khalifa? From what I know Shia don't consider him one of the Khalifa, as they consider the other three illegitimate - and especially loathe Omar for that whole deal at the House of Fatemeh, but only consider him the first Imam, and the other three Khalifa illegitimate. But let me know your thoughts on the matter!
Yeah, you are right. Shia belive Imam Ali a.s is the first Imam and thats mean that He should be the first Khalif. After him his sons Imam Hassan a. s and Imam Hussein a.s should be the secend and third Imam and Khalif.
Maybe you also Heard about ashura, where Imam Hussein protect the truth Islam and died with his whole family as martyr in Kerbala
Thats a fake story that umar burned house fatema
@@adamahmadbey714 where is her (SA) grave then?
The selection of uthman r.a as an emperor was by allah an indeed allah knows what's thee best for this nation and indeed uthman ibn affan r.a and ali ibn abi talib r.a we're rightly guided by allah and remember.
Good explanations on videos.
nicely explained
I loved the way you explain. Glad to see someone sharing the Islamic history with the world. But I request you to refer to the the Prophet as Prophet Muhammad S.W. Please dont call him just by name.
Ali ibn Abu Thalib RA is one of the best if not the best among the companion, It's always so sad knowing about his and his descendants lives.
Abu bakr and Umar and uthman are better than Ali and the majority of Islamic world and scholars agree in that
@@DukeLexenkarThese 3 are nothing as compared to Ali
no other three has nothing compared to ali a.s because they only had money and power but mola ali a.s has iman which is most powerful thing he had due to that even his enemy had to respect him ❤
Here is a question: The sahaba, according to Muslims, are regarded as "saints" or if you don't like that term then very righteous people. But how righteous were they when they fought with each other for power??
@Wise Wisdom don’t disrespect Ali when he is praised by the prophet who do you think you are
Can you do an episode on the election of abu bakr. Pls I'm trying to learn about this subject
Basically Khawarij was the old time ISIS. Boy these people never go away
Not only do they never go away, they're also found in every religious, culture, and nationality.
Agree with you brother. I am from Indonesia. From an islamic family. No one has ever touched a proper explanation of why islam spread in Indonesia. Because we were hindus and buddhists 5 centuries ago. I hope you can explain it in the future also. And I am waiting for the next video after the abbasid.
I'm actually very fascinated by how Islam spread to Indonesia and I will certainly cover it. The empires that the Muslims founded their are very fun to learn about. InshAllah, I'll cover it some day.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT yes. It is indeed interesting. It is such a rare occasion to find a moderate explanation like you did. Because from the islamic side we have a story that more or less sounds "too perfect" because there are rules not to speak bad about the early islamic figures (ehm. I am looking at you Muawiyah and Yazid). And in other side the western scholars tend to focus or describe the islamic history in a negative tones. They weigh more in the bad things and even never touch the brilliancy of prophet Muhammad as a leader. I think even if you do not believe Muhammad as a prophet at least you should give the guy for his brilliant political maneuver and strategy in battle.
Especially for Indonesia, I hope you touch the relationship between the Ottoman caliphate and the local islamic rulers/kings in Indonesia at that time. Because the ottoman caliph was really referred as the leader of all muslims at that time by the local kings in Indonesia. Often if there are dispute between princes about who should take the throne and they can not find a solution, they often ask the Sultan to decide for them. In some islamic kingdoms, the approval letter from sultan was considered a legitimate proof that they have right to be a king and to rule. for example it happened in the Yogyakarta sultanate and Aceh sultanate (both now a special province in Indonesia).
Anyway good luck for the next video. I will be waiting. insha'Allah
Why do you hate ISIS ??? For me they apply islam literally, are you gonna ignore "malakat alyamim" ? Or active Jihad ???
Murder by one person n murder by a mob has different laws
This was the reason behind this Fitna. Ali r.a understood law/ shariah properly but others were not so expert
Question: why hazrat Ali said no when he was asked that if he will govern the state like abu bakar and umer did
Because he doesn't want to fight he wants to made all people Muslim and then they gave him the throne of region just like prophet
Thank you. May I suggest to slow down the pace of the narration because with this speed it becomes difficult to absorb things. Regards.
Click the 3 dots in the right corner
Click playback speed
Put it to 0.75
Theres no shia no sunni only muslim
@@mustafah1821 youre the one uninformed
💯
@@mustafah1821 well sunni of Iran and well respected and live peacefully side by side with shia.
Hi Al. I was wondering do you think Muawiyah attacked Constantinople after the Battle of the Masts. I know Sebeos says that he did but in truth I feel that this might be a stretch since Muawiyah had lost considerable numbers of troops after Pheonix. I know he attacked Rhodes and the islands and perhaps he did attack the environs of Constantinople but also did he not have to get back to Syria to deal with a massive Median rebellion in Persia. Its somewhat hyperthetical but i just wondered what you thought about it? Really enjoyed the video by the way.
He did, yes. His son, Yazid was the head of that army and the Byzantines used Greek fire and the siege ended pretty quickly. Fun Fact: One of Muhammad's close friends, Abu Ayyub al-Ansari is buried in Istanbul now, he died during that siege, natural causes, and his last wish was that his remains be taken as far into enemy territory and be buried there so he's buried in Istanbul.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT That's really interesting about Abu Ayyub, I did a video about Constans II and Constantine IV that covers this period roughly and I mention both of these sieges. You could have a listen and tell me what you think
czcams.com/video/255uvl10uoc/video.html
czcams.com/video/ze8bHI5Q-PI/video.html
You are doing a brilliant job, You have real courage I must say, to reveal the facts which majority actually denies or are ignorant of completely.
love this channel but please slow down
Which governors do you think had political motives to rebel against Uthman?
Uthman in affan r.a
D M-C the governor of Egypt “ aldo maybe the son in law of Uthman”
raised unjust taxes in the name of the caliph uthman and when people complained he denied wrong doing and blamed the caliph some month and rebellions started they killed him
Then went to talk to the caliph
Talks was fruitful he sent them back to Egypt with a letter to appoint a new governor but a corrupt official changed the letter to the new governor to state “ if you receive my book kill the ones who delivered it “
The rebels obviously opened the letter saw what’s inside went back to Uthman and demanded his abdication here when all wrong doing started .
So I’m confused. Why do Sunnis like Mu’awiya and Aisha when they literally went to war against Ali? How is it possible to like all 3 of them if they disliked each other?
First of all, going to war against Ali isn't a sign of being evil. Secondly, it was for political reasons and not religious reasons. Thirdly, say whatever you want but Ali was wrong here. He didn't have the right to shelter the rebels who had the audacity to kill a caliph.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT Right
@@AlMuqaddimahYT just shut up your filthy mouth.. Having such opinion you will never prosper saying Ali was wrong.. I am sure you must be in bad books of Hazrat Fatima zehra.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT The oc didnt mention evil, but the irony of your statement is that the prophet said 'Whoever I am his mawla, this Ali is his mawla. O Allah, love whoever loves him, and be hostile to whoever is hostile to him". There actually multiple similar hadeeths at various points in the prophet's life including "Ali is from me and I am from Ali", which does kind of imply fighting Ali is wrong since fighting the prophet is wrong. He also said the same about all the members of his family. But back to the original question, how do people follow and emulate a group (sahaba) that fought between themselves? Regardless of whether you think Ali was wrong or Aisha/Muawiya. Its like telling me that there were prophets who fought eachother. If two people are on the straight path there wouldnt be bloodshed between them. Especially not between the sahaba, who I was taught are the most pious generation.
Syavish can you link the English language sources you used for this video? Thank you so much!
Can you suggest books related to Islamic History, especially from Rashiduns to Abbasids?
Lost Islamic history on amazon
www.kalamullah.com/index.html You'll find ebooks on different islamic subjects history, jurisprudence, spiritual,...
Reduce Playback speed to 0.75 to understand it correctly..
Ali ibn Abi Talib was the greatest ruler after Rasool Allah and was treated unfairly yet his heart was a heart unlike any rulers... Rulers before his or after him kill people for one mistake, this was a guy who even forgave his killer... By saying give water to my kill, give food to my killer, this was a guy who said ask me before you lose me for I am more aware of the paths of heaven then paths of earth and he said if anyone before me or after me said this they are a liar... But he was treated unfairly after Rasool Allah... 25 years he was silence, after becoming khalifa people who had problems with him attacked and fought him... Is this fair, yet his heart and so kind after Rasool Allah his heart was.the best... Don't forget all of Rasool Allah knowledge, generosity, etc rubbed out on him as well, "I am the city of knowledge, Ali is it's gate and most knowledgeable person in my nation after me is Ali"
this is a daef hadith
@@talalaijaz7875 all Hadiths is deaf according to nasibi which relates to Ali, even though there are weakest Hadiths which favor companions and you favor it, even though it goes against Qur'an. For example there's a Hadiths in sahih Muslim that says prophet Muhammad tried to commit suicide after he became a prophet, you favor it, even though it's against Qur'an.
Good channel, clear voice, and interactive animation. But perhaps it would be better if you provide us with link to read more about the topic that you found objective
*Sorry for bad English
Hey, i just found your channel..
You must do something about your narration and sound. It is very diffciult to get what you are saying. You may use a better input device for recording your voice. Also, you have a tendency to completely fade out at the end of sentece. Maybe because you are trying to sound calm and give it a mysterious vibe. You dont really have to. It almost feels like you are hiding somewhere and trying to whisper it out to us. Your content and graphis are really good.I think you are doing an Important and very very informative series. Hence, i couldn't help but write this comment for you. Wish you all the best. Thanks.
Hey, I think that happens during the editing. I'm trying to fix that. Thanks.
@@AlMuqaddimahYT it's actually fine on my end actually
Everytime I hear about assasination of Uthman I feel goosebumps
Really? How sad.
😂
Good documentary but please consider slowing down it was too rushed felt like it was played in faster speed.
It’s really not fantastic, it’s soooper your presentation 👌👌👌 it’s giving a real feeling like we are walk-in through that era.. And I think you are the same “Precusator” ?
a lot of errors in this video. Ali ibn abi Taleb and Muawiya loved each other but circumstances put them to fight. When Ali died muawiya cried and said to his wife you did not know what the ummah has lost. The narrator said that bani umayyah were corrupts. That's not true. muawiya was a just ruler and many of his successors were so.
no they hated each other. the whole “muawiya died when ali died” was a myth started by muawiya to make him look good because many of the companions of the prophet hated muawiya for fighting against ali because prophet muhammed appointed ali as his brother in religion, ali was raised by prophet muhammed, ali was the first muslim male, and he was highly respected. so when muawiya found out ppl started hating him for hating ali he completely changed and started saying things like he cried for ali at his death and things like that. if he really loved ali then why would he fight him just so he could be the ruler? If he loved ali then why would he spread lies amongst his soldiers so that they could hate ali? If he loved ali then why would he sign a treaty with alis son, hassan saying after his death Alis other son, Hussain would become the caliph, but then break the treaty and appoint his own son, yazid as the caliph. Yazid, the son of muawiya went on to murder the sons and daughters of ali. He killed hussain, who was the son of Ali and the grandson of prophet muhammed. it’s obvious the whole he cried for ali thing is propaganda, and you are falling for it.
@@buzzlightyear1010 there was no hatred amongst them Imam Ali when he was asked about the dead from the 2 armies he said that they're both in Janna. Everyone saw the truth in what he was doing we leave it for Allah to judge between them. However, we love them both because they gave islam a lot.
@@dawahinarabic730 Ok, what about Muawiyah calling Ali a murderer in the battle of Siffin? When Ammar Ibn Yaasir (ra) died fighting against Muawiya in Siffin, Muawiyah said Ali killed him because he brought him to the battle, which Ali replied So Muhammad Killed Hamzah in Uhud. Spit on Muawiyah's grave.
@@dawahinarabic730 This the age of the Internet where the rope of lies is very short.
Cursing Ali was a state policy introduced by Mu'awiya I and later pursued by the Umayyad Caliphate between 41 and 132 AH in order to discredit the partisans of Ali and enforce loyalty to the state.The caliphate of Umar II is said to have been an exception, but his reign was short and did not make serious dent in the Umayyad policies. The practice ended eventually only with the overthrow of the Ummayyads.
There are hadiths in the six hadith books of Ahul al Sunnah that clearly state Muwaiyah cursed and encouraged the cursing of Imam Ali.
@@dawahinarabic730 yes when Ali was asked he said , I hope that the dead from both armies will go to paradise and then the matter will be decided between me and muawiya in front of Allah.' he did not like or respect muawiya. stop editing his words to make ur champion muawiya look good. I am surprised how so called sunnis like you can totally ignore all the narrations in Bukhari and Muslim and other hadith collections that expose the ummayyads and their deeds starting with muawiya. maybe we sunnis should throw them away and just ask the saudi govt to give us their version of islam to follow.
There actually was a small kingdom holding up in northern Iran which fell later to Abbasids I have noticed no one shows them on maps lol
Yes, in Daylam. I completely forgot about them but I'll be making a video ABOUT them and show my mistake there.
Code the Hadith
Which hadees says Ali said no?
This is a well known fact. Imam Ali(as) was more wise than Uthman and superior in every single way as a ruler, it made sense for him to be the Caliph after Umar. But the Shura asked Imam Ali(as) if he would rule like the Caliphs before him and Imam Ali(as) said that he is his own man, he will only follow the way of the Prophet(SAW) and will not grant special benefits to companions. He said that everyone will be equal and he will get rid of corruption and saw Abu Bakr and Umar’s way of rule as unjust and created hate amongst people (this actually led to Umar’s assassination). Obviously this wouldn’t have benefited the people in the Shura council and so they chose Uthman who said he will follow Abu Bakr and Umar’s ways.
4:46 sounds familiar enough... I died 😂
I love hazrat uthman. Due to him i can read and pronounce the quraan
@Abbas aboud hazrat uthman compiled it and put the harkaat so non arabs could read it. So i will thank him for this. Obviously it all happen through the will of Allah.
@Abbas aboud hazrat uthman compiled the quraan? I doubt you can deny that. I believe hazrat ali had a compiled quraan with a tafseer, but this was disregarded? Wallahualam. I love hazrat ali, i feel more of his hadith and bibi fatimas hadith should be prescribed in mosques. They were the closest to the prophet thus their accounts are most authentic. Albeit the holy prophet presented his both daughters to hazrat uthman, thus it shows how much he must have trusted hazrat uthman. The shia-sunni split must be addressed and we must try to agree on what occurred after the death of the prophet. Im sunni and i find allot of blasphemic "sahih" hadith. Albeit we are in no position to critisize the deceased, especially the sahabas!!!
After Aisha turned on Uthman for him not giving her heaps of money, Uthman was eventually killed by the Muslims as people kill their tyrants. Aisha then waged a war against Imam Ali peace be upon him after she had heard that the Muslims pledged alliegence to Imam Ali, this first "civil war" gave Muawiya the green light to wage more "civil wars" after Imam Ali refused to allow him to remain governor of Shaam. The Muslims betrayed Imam Ali after he had led them to victory against Muawiya as they grew tired of war and eventually Imam Ali was assassinated by the Khawarij who failed to assassinate Muawiya. Imam Hassan peace be upon him overpowered by the rule of Muawiya then made a treaty with Muawiya where he stepped down from power and remained the Caliph of God with no power. Muawiya eventually assassinated him to cement his power.
Qitab Qays al Hilali has many detailed narrations on what happened including letters to and from Imam Ali and Muawiya.
@Cyrus The great may Allah curse them and send you with them to Hellfire if you love for those founders of terrorism remains in your heart
RasoulAllah peace be upon him and his pure family cursed both Muawiya and Aisha in your authentic books and even hit Aisha the filthy humayra devil.
@Cyrus The great and Jesus peace be upon him clearly said to worship him in the Bible if that's the logic you want to use, we show to the Christians verses of truth from the Bible that proves that Jesus peace be upon him was a prophet and even foretold of the comming of RasoulAllah peace be upon him and his pure family after him.
You cant pick and choose what you want to believe in from your fabricated Torah and Bible ("sahih" muslim and "sahih" bukhari). Let me show you narrations that oppose this fabrication you have posted:
Narrated Ibn Abbas: I intended to ask 'Umar so I said, "Who were those two ladies who tried to back each other against the Prophet?" I hardly finished my speech when he said, They were 'Aisha and Hafsa."
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 435-438
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 119
Narrated 'Umar: The wives of the Prophet out of their jealousy, backed each other against the Prophet, so I said to them, "It may be, if he divorced you all, that Allah will give him, instead of you wives better than you." So this Verse was revealed. (66.5)
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 6, Book 60, Number 438
Narrated Aisha: That Allah's Apostle said to her, "I know when you are pleased with me or angry with me." I said, "Whence do you know that?" He said, "When you are pleased with me, you say, 'No, by the Lord of Muhammad,' but when you are angry with me, then you say, 'No, by the Lord of Abraham.' “Thereupon I said, "Yes (you are right), but by Allah, O Allah's Apostle, I leave nothing but your name."
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 62, Number 155
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 73, Number 101
Ibn Umar reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) came out from the house of 'Aisha and said: It would be from this side that there would appear the height of unbelief, viz. where appear the horns of Satan. i.e. cast.
Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Number 6938-6943
Narrated 'Abdullah: The Prophet stood up and delivered a sermon, and pointing to 'Aisha's house, he said thrice, "Affliction (will appear from) here," and, "from where the side of the Satan's head comes out."
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 53, Number 336
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 54, Number 499
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 56, Number 714
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 63, Number 217
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 9, Book 88, Number 212-213
Narrated By Ibn 'Abbas: When Allah's Apostle was on his death-bed and in the house there were some people among whom was 'Umar bin Al-Khattab, the Prophet said, "Come, let me write for you a statement after which you will not go astray." 'Umar said, "The Prophet is seriously ill and you have the Qur'an; so the Book of Allah is enough for us." The people present in the house differed and quarrelled. Some said "Go near so that the Prophet may write for you a statement after which you will not go astray," while the others said as Umar said. When they caused a hue and cry before the Prophet, Allah's Apostle said, "Go away!" Narrated 'Ubaidullah: Ibn 'Abbas used to say, "It was very unfortunate that Allah's Apostle was prevented from writing that statement for them because of their disagreement and noise."
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 7, Book 70, Number 573
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 5, Book 59, Number 717
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 5, Book 59, Number 716
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 52, Number 288
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 53, Number 393
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 9, Book 92, Number 468
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 1, Book 3, Number 114
Sahih Muslim, Book 13, Number 4014-4016
Ibn Abbas reported: I was playing with children that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) happened to pass by (us). I hid myself behind the door. He (the Holy Prophet) came and he patted upon my shoulders and said: Go and call Mu'awiya. I returned and said: He is busy in taking food. He again asked me to go and call Mu'awiya to him. I went (and came back) and said that he was busy in taking food, whereupon he said: May Allah not fill his belly! Ibn Muthanna, said: I asked Umm Ummaya what he meant by the word Hatani. He said: It means "he patted my shoulders".
Sahih Muslim, Book 32, Number 6298
now be like the fairminded Christian who accepts truth when he sees it and doesn't become stubborn, watch this series if you want more proofs:
czcams.com/play/PL3E0BC849DB40A1BE.html
@Cyrus The great ok you're a fool, may Allah curse Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Muawiya, Aisha, Hafsa, Hind and Umm al Hakam.
send my curses on your idols when you see them in Hellfire
What a just man he was!!! ❤
wrong info on death of uthman please correct that
czcams.com/video/-RcQ7G5K4OQ/video.html