2WD Winter tyres vs AWD Summer tyres: SNOW DRAG RACE
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 11. 2022
- Subscribe to our German channel: @carwowDeutschland
It’s time to find out just how essential winter tyres are!
We’ve got Mat lining up at an indoor ski slope in an Audi A1, and he’s facing off against an Audi SQ7!
In normal conditions, you’d think this would be a walkover for the SQ7. After all, it’s powered by a 4-litre twin-turbo V8 that can put down 507hp and 770Nm! In comparison, the Audi A1 only has a little 1-litre 3-cylinder under the bonnet that’s only good for 110hp and 200Nm. It’s also only available with front-wheel drive, while the SQ7 has all-wheel drive.
However, the A1 has an ace up its sleeve. It’s had some winter tyres fitted, while the SQ7 only has summer tyres on! And of course, let’s not forget that the A1 is a whole lot lighter, tipping the scales at 1,130kg. In comparison, the SQ7 weighs a whopping 2,265kg!
So how will this play out - will the A1 fly up the hill first? Or will the power output of the SQ7 prove decisive? There’s only one way to find out… LET’S RACE!
Sell your car with carwow: bit.ly/Buy-Sell-WOW - Auta a dopravní prostředky
![Audi SQ7 REVIEW on AUTOBAHN [NO SPEED LIMIT] by AutoTopNL](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/itLqH-PhnWE/mqdefault.jpg)
These Snow drag races shows us how important winter tyres are!
No shit Sherlock.
In the UK we don't need anything more than all season tyres unless you drive in the areas that still see reasonable snowfall.
Put mine on every year. They do make a big difference.
I’m in Aus so I’ve never even seen winter tires like the ones in the UK.
@@bigbalooga0455 even in Indonesia also.
Daniel is always "new German presenter" in all drag races
Yanni called in sick to work!
😂
Until they will get new new presenter
Brand new 😂😂
New but he's there for more than a month lmao
I would love to see a comparison between FWD with winter tyres and awd with all-season tyres.
czcams.com/video/bRYHlb61_9Q/video.html
Same
similiar, perhaps awd could win
One of the UK tire reviewers did that and the awd was better. I think it was tyre reviews?
@@paradox5556 For acceleration yes. For stopping with is the most important part. Nope winter tyres allow you to stop faster by large margin.
This is why I am always so frustrated when my friends and loved ones act like they are invincible in the snow because they have AWD even though they are on high efficiency highway tires
I remember back in the day when Audis has the reputation of always having the most cars in the gutter during winter. I think that was from a tow truck driver.
It literally says in my Audi handbook that Quattro will not help you avoid the laws of physics
Q7 also weighs like two times in comparison, so there's that
@@SamsomiteMight That should be an advantage on snowy terrain.
I remember last winter watching a Porsche SUV sliding down a hill with all 4 wheels locked up. The driver clearly didn't know how to deal with the situation. I hasten to add that no-one was hurt when he came to an arboreal stop in a bush.
In Sweden we are taught to reverse fwd cars if we can’t get them up a snowy slope. That gives the car better traction when accelerating since the weight of the car is pushed to the back of the car when accelerating, and to the front when reversing giving better traction on a fwd car.
Agree.
Interesting!
@@purwantiallan5089 why do you have so much comments everywhere?
@@troll2637 y not. His time his hands 😅
@@Asoka-great fair point.
I am so early that Matt hasn't changed the thumbnail and title of the video yet
Right here with you
🔥❤️
i hate when carwow changes the thumbnail and title. i am a jew
Yes sir
@@SilverScarletSpider did anyone ask?
We need a 2WD winter tyres vs 4wd all seasons test!
You can find anything about tires on this channel! czcams.com/video/a7E3GTpgvjs/video.html
@@IIIIIIIIlIIIIIIIIIIIIlIIIIIIl Thanks! I wanna see them test it in that testing area they were in in the future.
czcams.com/video/bRYHlb61_9Q/video.html
czcams.com/video/bRYHlb61_9Q/video.html You can check this link. They are testing exactly as you say.
sry what ? you mean studded vs non studded ?
Doesn't matter what season it is, appropriate tyres = safety.
Only when you adjust your speed accordingly. Drivers with winter tyres tend to cause more accidents, because they think they can drive faster on winter tyres.
Try going uphill in reverse next time in the FWD car. That usually does the trick here in snowy Switzerland!
Yep. Even Emma Verde tried that experiment before.
@@purwantiallan5089 why do you have so much comments everywhere?
@@ultimatepu5h yep. But what about FR cars on snow?
what? I thought you had enough money to warn up your roads in winter over there? 😅😅😅
@@daviddavidsonn3578 probably not in the countryside/rural areas, like japan
Mat Watson giving us answers to questions we didn’t know we needed the answer to.
Mat, please do a snowy experiment between SX4 WRC on Dirt tires with Lancer Group B Rally Car on Snow tires.
Except it has already been done a million times on Tyre Reviews
I needed all these trials, I had an experience with stucking in snow!
this is common knowledge, mate. Unless you live in Africa or somewhere where there isn't any snow, you'd know about this. Either that or you're an american
@@ChR0nos_7734 last winter I got stuck in a front wheel car in a little hill climb, if I knew the momentum thing I would have tried something different
A long time ago I went cruising up a steep hill with 4” of snow covering it in my Citroen C2 with snow tyres on. At the bottom was BMW X5 4x4 unable to get up. The look on his face was priceless when I went up without any drama. Since then I’ve alway fitted winter tyres when the temp drops. Great video once again Mat
I would like to see Xdrive vs Quattro vs 4Matic on this snow track with cars in same class and similar power and same tyres🤩
Yeah me too
Maybe two different Audis also, Torsen/Haldex
3:37 Mat is once again giving life changing advice to the people. What a chad 💪🏽
Matt is always the chad.
Chad Wattson?
I would honestly like to see a comparison drag race like this with rear wheel drive cars and Summer/Winter/4Seasons tires.
czcams.com/users/tyrereviews
That is (almost) exactly what Tyre Reviews does. He runs different tires on the same track in the same car in different conditions. If you want tire reviews, go to Tyre Reviews.
@@AisuruMirai I put a direct link into this a couple of hours ago. I see it was censored...
Any ways you are right, youtube tyrereveiws is the goto site, if you wanna get new tyres.
@@AisuruMirai
I know it has been done, but not with Mat Watson's impeccable style...😉
I cannot believe winter tyres aren't mandatory in the UK. I've been using them for the last 10 years and the difference is incredible. You'd be a fool not to fit them and they basically end up paying for themselves.
mate i can't believe it either they rather just wait the snow to melt..... :D
But unless you're in Scotland or North England we might only get a few days each year where there is snow on the roads
I think if all run of the mill cars at least came with all season tyres as standard it would solve many issues in winter
Winter tyres aren’t just for snow. They are much better in lower temperatures, especially when it’s wet.
@@ashterfadgadget817 I think in the usually mild UK winters, a good all season tyre can be a better choice than a fully siped winter, unless you live somewhere that gets a lot of snow like scotland. For example where I live in Yorkshire it's been below freezing for a week or so, but on monday it's forceast 13 degrees. Full winters start struggling as it warms up and it not unusual for that to happen these days. All seasons cope with the milder spells better, but will easily keep you safe and mobile when it's cold or if it snows.
That 6.9 in the gentle joke was just perfect 🤣
This guy makes for Mat Watson comedy gold. 🤣 Please have him back more often.
Mat Watson is now being Mat Wow.
@@purwantiallan5089 why do you have so much comments everywhere?
@@troll2637 bots
@@troll2637 why do you have so much comments everywhere?
I love these Winter Tyre drag races!
🔥❤️
Your programmed to.
What about experiments between Snow and Dirt tyres between 2 Lancer Evos?
I'm surprised seeing such new types of videos which I never thought, kudos to Carwow!!!
Brilliant, shows the difference between summer and winter tyres! 😍❤
Yep. Winter tyres always prevail unsurprisingly.
Audi boys getting a sense of what it’s like to have the disadvantage this time, comparing them to BMWs with summer tires isn’t so fun anymore.
Yes, that's the point of the video
I swear Mat comes up with these crazy races when he's "on the ice" 😜
Do this also on dry asphalt.
I feel like Matt just smokes a blunt and goes “you know what would be cool…” and then carwow makes it happen. Honestly feel like carwow could test any vehicle or location on the planet at this point from how much of a following they now have
hey, is that thing a scam??? 'Congratulations!
You won a prize quickly message me on telegram to claim.'
@@iamkhtray some bot scammers..
@@somerandomfella aha!!!! i knew it! cheers ,mate!!!
Thanks a lot for the video. As always really entertaining!
Really like Daniel, let's see more of him please as I love German's with a sense of humour!
Calling that a crash is quite generous 😅love the snow videos though!
Mat thank you so much for this insane video!
I'm starting to think you're a bot. Same comments over and over again.
@@vibingwithvinyl it is..
Every f#cking video the same...c'mon carwow program your bot better..
My wife has the same SQ7 V8 and we just put winter Michelins on it. Even without snow in UK, performance in
Love my A1, gonna have to put some winter tires on it this year and test it out 😂
Race 1 starts 2:51 summer tyres on SQ7
Race 2 starts 3:44 summer tyres on SQ7
Race 3 starts 5:10 winter tyres on SQ7
Race 4 starts 6:11 winter tyres on SQ7
no
@@makkie8593 yes
@@Jsnwrd may the Lord bless you for doing a good work 👍🏾
Would be cool to see a RWD/FWD on snow tires vs a AWD on all seasons to see see which is better
Interesting test! Well done guys!
Great video guys,just like Watching an episode of top gear! And honestly you guys should have your own Show. Also with an Awesome demonstration of why having winter tires fitted is so important and makes a Massive difference
I like that little A1 !! 😎👌🏼
Can you test all-season tires next? Wondering how much of a difference they make compared to winter/summer.
Big difference
all season tires = no season tires
@@MuriloBauerAYYLMAO yes and no, the ANWB (AA of NL) did a comparison and a couple of AS tyres did really well in both coming in the top 3 of all tyres in all seasons
@@MuriloBauerAYYLMAO Michelin cross climate 2s disagree with you bud
@@MuriloBauerAYYLMAO BS , high quality all season are the thing .
Hankook 4s set the tone , still is probably best 4s tire.
A few years ago I bought a set of budget winter tyres for my fabia monte carlo and worked so effortlessly in the snow but haven't got a set for my golf R-line and doesn't work in the snow most of the time with premium summer tyres fitted so definitely a good idea
Love informative videos like this.
This opens up a whole new category of content for you guys. Please make more videos in snow/winter conditions.
I'd be interested to see which transmission is best for snow
Easy:
Manual.
@@-NEH- Yeah I think so too. However, the modern automatics are really capable too. Specially when paired with say, snow mode. However, I haven't compared them myself so it'd be interesting to see the results
@@muazqamar I have a modern automatic now, a BMW. Nothing for slippery ice and deep snow I tell you... :-) I had a Saab with a ZF automatic 20 years ago. That thing had "winter" mode, it was pretty decent actually. But manual is manual.
@@-NEH- Saab are amazing. Thanks for your reply
Manual all the way, but second: _torque converter_ automatic.
Back in high school I drove a TrailBlazer (I'm American, it was a midsize SUV) and when you put the gear selector in 2nd, the (automatic) transmission would start in 2nd. Very easy to control wheelspin, no "snow mode" necessary.
Carwow reviews, drag races and all the videos never fails to entertain us!
Repeat...
@@rasherbasher8203 👍👍
Great test - more like it please!
Very interesting this new format 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Daniel is a great addition to the channel, well done
I'd love to see the Haldex version fo Quattro vs the Torsen version of Quattro in one of these tests! Say a Q3 vs a Q5 to see the difference!
@Mat: You have to try going up the hill in Reverse (with the FWD car) when it's so steep you can't do it going forwards. This idea has saved me in the past ✌.
The idea is that the traction has to be on the wheels that are towards the bottom of the hill where all the weight is transferred.
For anyone asking about the ad with all weather tyres-I had a hire car in France 3 years ago, had requested winter but car came with the all weather. No issue all week because it didn't snow, on the day before we left it snowed very heavily and I decided to get bring the car out to try the snow chains that came with it(I'd bever used before), the all weather's seemed fine, UNTiL, it came to hill starts, they were no good, the car could accelerate for a while but once the hills became steeper the car would spin and and every occasion the car slid backwards. There's no way I'd ever drive again on ice or snow without anything other than winter tyres, on any type of vehicle
All of the videos never cease to amuse us!
Both you Mat and Daniel are brilliant presenters. Very entertaining. Well done!
We want more Snow drag races with hypercars and SUVs!
Do we. It's not really entertaining more informative... carwow bot🤔
What about Maserati Gran TurismoS both on Snow and Dirt drag race?
Great video shows you how important the right tyres are, would have liked to see one with the traction and stability stuff on or off also.
I have a FWD and didnt know with tee tires mattered this much, thank u VERY MUCH Matt and Mr.German Matt
I'd like to see this same competition between the Range Rover and the Land Cruiser used in the off-road challenge.
I've owned Subarus with all season tyres and summer tyres. Even summer tyres with plenty of tread are hopeless in snow.
I've just swapped tyres on a Yaris and gone for a mid range all season, the difference in grip on wet and leaf covered surfaces is very noticeable.
Oliver, u seem to be a big fan of Subarus, huh?👍
This is a very good video showcasing the importance of tires. I have never seen snow.
I love these!!!!!! Do more!!!!
Hi Mark. Would love to see a test done between FWD and RWD BEV’s with snow tyres. I’ll never be able to afford a BEV AWD but reckon the RWD may be all I need?
Stick winter tyres on and put a concrete slab or two into the boot of the RWD and you’re good for winter. I lived in South Germany for a long time and that’s what we all did with our BMW or Mercs
difference between winter and all season tyres would also be interesting :D
There's a CZcamsr tyre reviews that does all of this. In one of his videos he tests a front wheel drive with all season on the front and summer tyres on the rear which I've actually seen on a van recently. It's entertaining and absolutely lethal.
So I have an AWD Audi a3 hatchback and I’ve been driving without winters and I just got some out on today and i already felt a crazy difference I’m not slipping at all where without them I was basically doing a burnout at every red light. original wanted a gti but needed awd and watching this makes me feel like I made the right choice for sure. Awd plus winters will give you almost no problem 👍👍
Another disadvantage for the A1 is it has dual clutch transmission. When pulling away it basically dumps the clutch and makes it almost impossible to control wheel spin on slippery surfaces. The Q7 has a torque converter which is much smoother at applying power.
Weird that they'd put an extra-expensive and compromise-laden transmission type into such a low-power vehicle. What, are they trying to shave a few tenths off the A1's Nurburgring time?
@@nthgth No. It’s because they’re compact and very efficient, with minimal losses.
@@egocd then I wonder why Honda and Toyota don't use them in their small (or large) cars.
@@egocd for that matter, is Audi not interested in increased efficiency and minimal losses for the Q7?
@@nthgth They’re also unreliable. That’s why Honda and Toyota don’t use them. They’re also not suitable for big heavy cars due to clutch wear.
The light weight of the hatchback would also have helped a little here, but those tyres are king
Agree
very nice vid mat!!
The german started like Clarkson: "Speeeeed and POWEEEER!!!"
We need the same car with FWD winter vs AWD summer tyres
So sad they never made an S1 of this generation would have been epic proportions and power!
They made a 200bhp version which is not far off the old S1
RS1 with an NA V10 would be nice
@@harric9864 yeah the old S1 just looks weird. The new shape would be the perfect fit for a S1 as it’s already so aggressive looking!
@@canadianaviator i dont think the v10 will fit but the inline 5 will do
half of the v10 is good enough for the tiny a1
@@canadianaviator where tf would they put it?😂
awesome demonstration!
Great video! I would recommend doing another video with Chris from Arma RC cars, that race with the formula 1 car was wicked!
Can you test a theory I’ve had for awhile with my FWD/winters? If you start facing downhill, you *should* be able to reverse up a steep hill (since you’ll have more weight over the driven wheels)
Not sure though, so it’d be interesting to see
Yeah that’s actually a thing. It works
@@tobik2627 thank you!
What you should have learned form the demonstration is its all about traction/grip. Remember, the first race the V8 weighs a lot more.
It's not a theory but common knowledge for anyone driving in winters.
@@tobik2627 yeah it has worked for me. I got stuck in a work van and had to reverse up the hill.
The A1 is a super tidy looking hatch. Really smart wheels too.
Yeah but £30.000? Pass
I think the £21'000 base model parked next to mats £30'000 example would be an eye opener.
@@brianiswrong yeah, the poor person speck with the steelies is a looker for sure lol
So glad I ordered some verdestein snows for my R32 turbo. It's gonna be crazy with all this power AWD and snow!
Great video!
If you have poor traction in snow you dont want to push pedal in the floor and all wheels spinning. This just does not work at all.
Ideally you want manual car and very gently lift up clutch with low revs and feel that traction. (Yes i am from Finland and over 20 year snow driving experience with RWD cars).
Just a thought…..Should try all season tyres as it is more logical to buy on uk road and cheaper than 2 set of tyres. I use cross climate 2 and they are very good.😊
Wish we could see this more.
Daniel is a legend, Great character!!
First of all, amazing content as usual.
Request: FWD vs RWD on road/wet road/ice etc
Cheers
Narrower tyres tend to work really well in the snow in comparison to wider tyres.
True if there is e.g. 20 cm of snow on the road, because the narrow tire cuts the snow more easily. On the other hand, on a plowed road, you would think that a wider tire would work better, because more of the tire hits the road and thus gives more surface area (friction) to pull / push the car forward.
@@Sm00th-0peratorthe reason wider tires are better on the road is due to subtleties of how tires grip the road at the microscopic level, and how it deforms when applying grip. A narrower tire will have about the same contact patch size ("surface area"), it'll just be longer and narrower.
Would be interesting to see a RS3 and a Etron gt at this place.
Is more weight better for this test or worse?🤔
Also is it better to accelerate while sliding back down or are you sliding sideways if you do so? 🤔
Absolutely!
Less weight is better in a "newtonian sense". Of course, often the surface you are running on doesnt conform to such a simplified physics model, and neither does tires for the most part.
@@GoldenCroc or what about 2 Subaru Imprezas on Snow and Dirt tires?
Good Test, It isn't just one thing that gets you through snow. But it definitely helps to be prepared.
great vid sir
Hey Matt, next time try the front-wheel car climb in reverse you will be surprised how far you will go. It really works well, it is the same reason why Porsche has a great grip when accelerating from 0. Hopefully, you gonna read this 🙏🏻😊
Porsche even has capabilities to drive on those snowy roads.
@@purwantiallan5089 Man you have a problem
3:42 6.9 mpg what a coincidence 🤔
Audi + winter tyres = a winning combination!
My A4 Avants were like tanks!
The translation "I want the donut" was hilarious! 😂He just said "oh yeah"
My 320d got stranded last year in the snow. I’ve just replaced all the tyres for winter ones so I’m looking forward to seeing the difference if it snows this year. The tyres already feel grippier on greasy or wet roads
It’ll be wayward rather than lethal 😂 (330e with winter tyres)
In the Netherlands winter tires aren't compulsory, even for hire cars. So I hired a car once and it had summer tires and it was snowing. Most terrifying drive of my life.
Great video. ☺️
Great video
Now that we've got this winter tire promo done, know that all seasons work just fine.
all seasons are no seasons
All seasons are shit in the snow.
@@fishfinners And also worse in the summer
All seasons - worst of both worlds.
Maybe in jolly old England all season are fine for winter driving. New England not so much.
"Careless Whisper" and that eyebrow wiggle will haunt my dreams tonight. XD
Thanks for the info. I am glad I have all-season tires on my car.
My 2014 Q3 150TD Quattro came with 235/55R17 summers. Tried Audi WInterpackage - Wheels and Dunlop 215/65/16 but as we see little snow in my part of UK I then sourced some OEM Q3 Audi 16" wheels from Germany [seen on a German base spec in a carpark] and fitted 215/65 R16 Bridgestone A005 Weather Control EVO All Season. Great grip in all conditions I face and better ride than the 235/55R17 summers. PS - never sure how the quattro wanted to split power before slippage and jiggerpokery takes over until the latest MOT showed 60 % rear bias
Daniel’s reactions is genuine entertainment
I love those snow races
Great clip guys! Winter tyres have just become compulsory here in France but not in every department. Here in Lyon (not compulsory) we had a couple of cm's last week and nearly no-one was equipped for it!! I always have winter tyres on the family car and they performed brilliantly last week. Smug? Moi?
Amazing to see Daniel with you guys! He is by far the best german "Carguy" out there :)
Car Ranger & JP: Am i a joke to you?
Nice video. I have Goodyear vector 4 seasons on my transporter 4motion. The difference between theses and the stock tyres is night and day. Used them on ice, slush and snow in the Peak District. We’ve had way too much fun in the snow with then. Failing getting stuck behind abandoned vehicles I know I will always get home. Also pretty good in a wet field towing a caravan. They weren’t cheap, but to be able to stop dead on snow is amazing. Just as good in reverse as well. #notsponsored….but if there’s anyone out there from Goodyear….😉
Nose heavy front drive cars do very well in such tests. Especially so with tread patterns a couple of decades ago.
What do I do? I fit winter tyres every winter.
Editors went on a field trip with this one, noice!
I love the way the guy was shouting "Stop stop stop stop"... LOL I think he would.... If he could!!! LOL
I want to see a race with all season types vs winter tyres.
What a surprise to see Daniel Hohmeyer in your video. That's a plus!
This duo is so good, lol.
WOW, I ASKED YOU TO MAKE THIS VIDEO !!!!!! THANKS !!!