You facepalm, you lose
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 08. 2021
- ✨ Patreon: / mmoxreview
⚔️ Our Store: krewsade.store/
🕹️ Jeannie's Twitch: / potasticp
💡 Subscribe: bit.ly/2UFio2p
📷 Instagram:
/ mxr_mods
/ potasticpanda
/ shopkrewsade
📜 Twitter:
/ mmoxreview
/ potasticpanda22
/ shopkrewsade
Outro: • MxR Plays - Jeannie - ...
BGM: davidcuttermusic.com/ - Komedie
Level 1 of inner monologing: being able to hear your own voice read and say anything in your head
Level 2: Being able to basically deepfake anyone saying anything in your head perfectly after hearing their voice for a short amount of time
Level 3: Being able to imagine tastes, sounds, textures, feelings tec. as if you were experiencing them in real time (pretty cool that I can do all of them)
Also I'm pretty sure at least five people in the comment thread have some form of schizophrenia
Yea it is useful when I'm trying play out fake scenarios in head
Wait what? I thought everyone could do that to
WHAT IS GOING ON
I can do this
i have that, i also thought everyone else had that
I’m like this, Morgan freeman is great to talk to
Henry: "No, you guys all have an inner monologue, right?"
My inner monologue: "Yeah bro."
Yup pretty much lmao
@@sopcannon Yeah if you had more than one voice talking in your head at the same time, and if they respond to each other I would seek mental help lmao
i have a few yes. i think there should be a head count to disprove statistics
Ye idd
@@Hieraldrich it's when all the voices stop answering your weird questions that you really have to worry
I took a class in college that was literally called "dinosaurs". It was like an entry in to paleontology class and it counted as a science credit. On the first day our teacher said that he was sure most of the students were there for the easy science credit, and that on the first day we would talk about something that would never be quizzed over, just a topic that exists along side dinosaurs. The topic was evolution and carbon dating. 4 people got up and left the class...ONE of them actually started an argument with the teacher about how dinosaurs couldn't be real because all of the aquatic ones would have eaten all the whales after Noah's flood. Teacher pointed out that what the average person calls an "aquatic dinosaur" isn't a dinosaur at all and asked why the student even bothered to sign up for the class. Easiest science credit I've ever gotten. Teacher was an 80 some odd year old man who just loved to talk about dinosaurs.
'what? people are talking about dinosaurs?
RACHEL GET THE BIBLE'
I am very much a Christian and I believe in dinosaurs! Like that’s just a fact, I don’t really see how one would ever make a solid argument against them.
I also loved my paleontology teacher.
I have an inner monologue.
Interesting side fact: there's a book called "The Origin of Consciousness" written in the 70's that (if I remember it correctly) basically says that the reason belief in gods exists is because whenever ancient humans heard an inner voice, they attributed it to a god. He believed that introspection and the ability to hear an inner dialogue is something that culturally evolved in humans, largely because of the influence of language and the written word. According to the book, even the ancient Greeks lacked a developed ability to introspect, hence the "gods" often making decisions for the big heroes in Homer's tales etc.
That is insane to think about
Imagine not being able to give characters their own voices when reading books.
This is from the inner monologue gang.
cmoooooooon my G gang gang
imagine not having your inner monologue read that in your head
Inner monologue? I even had heated argument of 2 of me in my head, some camping storytelling sessions, and a speech upon a mass of me, i thought everyone does that
Worst part when they make a movie off a book and the voices don't match what was in your mind
@@chrisbinns7970 facts
Gang gang 😈
bonus of an inner monologue, when you read a book, you can hear the character's voices and it amplifies their personalities
yeah, and it's so weird cause that doesn't happen counciously!
I can only do that if I am imagining like a whole ass movie style scene. I can't do it without visual aid.
perfection in comment
I dont understand how people who dont have an inner monologue read. What are they hearing? It makes no sense.
i understand now how there can be people who don't have fun reading.
This video has been one of THE most interesting, informative videos out of their entire collection. Jeannie now makes way more sense and Henry still can't tell different animals no matter how many crazy-ass voices he hears in his head. Lol. Hell, all his voices know crap about zoology. Lol
It's been 1 week since we watched this video and my husband and I are still talking about inner monologues.
Y'all should definitely post that extra footage of everything y'all talked about for this topic. I am very interested. We need to hear more from Jeanie. My husband and I both have inner monologues and we are so curious to hear more about this.
The movie Revolver from 2005 revolves around the inner monologue "problem".....if u still want more on the subject ✌
Everyone who doesn't have an inner monologue is an NPC. Congrats Henry, Jeannie is an NPC
I actually thought myself how to "hear my self" without talking so i guess i was an NPC once
@@rooyay9164 character development
@@rooyay9164 So you're finally back from afk huh?
crazy she was serious about being a side character
@@Terreurhaas yea man looks like a player decided to play again
Me: Having an entire conversation with myself about people who have no inner dialog.
yea same
Me too
Same here. Lol
Same
I know this has nothing to do with what this Comment thread is about. I just really need to get it off my chest though. I am a Christian and I know for a fact dinosaurs are real, so are Leviathans, and Dragons. Not all mythical creatures but those three type of creatures are, of course there were also animals, and sea animals, and bugs and other creature we have now at the time also. It literally says in the Bible that there were fire breathing Dragons, and that there were Leviathans as big as mountains or a small island in the ocean depths. It's so cool and kinda trippy. Now it doesn't say anything about the Dragon taking flight just that it could breath fire, from what I remember. I believe there were dinosaurs just not exactly how we think they looked like, I could be completely wrong on that though. Always open to learning.😁👍
Dude, I dunno, my internal monologue is strong enough to where I'll have full-blown arguments with myself in my head while I'm evaluating options. I simply can't imagine NOT having an internal monologue. That's absolutely insane to me. I don't think I'd be able to make decisions, like, ever...
Today I learned that some people do not have an inner monologue, and some people can't even recreate images in their head..
It's trippy to know that something so natural does not exist for some people. Reading books were the greatest experience as a child since your mind just automatically assigns voices and recreates the characters and the entire world. Nowadays I chill to some music and imagine a whole Cover AMV out of it. You can also use it to recreate memories or familiar scenarios, although with some missing parts that your mind automatically fills in.
And when you're grounded to reality, there's this convenient use of voicing out your thoughts inside your head like what I'm having when writing this comment and reading it.
Kind of makes me wonder how many people like different things because they literally don't get the same thing from it as you do. Using your example of reading books, we get this full, vibrant experience of sights and sounds from words on a page, whereas other people only ever get the words on the page.
The statistic of 30 to 50% for inner monologue is people who have it on a regular basis, it's actually pretty rare to have no inner monologue ever. Generally those people can still perceive images in their head, however it is possible to have neither.
I can't see anything but yeah I hear stuff. Stuff like this is so easy to go undetected and it's kinda fun
There are a lot of NPCs out there.
I can do the monologue and pictures and what have you if I focus, but normally don't. Except music it weird. I can get an earworm as easy as the next person, but trying to sing in my head, especially as anything but a direct memory of the song, is super tough. Makes it really hard for me to identify remixes or even it sung at different pitches.
@@denverarnold6210 There is a condition called Aphantasia where you do neither.
Most people have it, just the degree differs.
Learning that others don’t have an internal monologue is the most mind blowing thing I’ve ever heard
FACTS
Right!? It kinda scares me
same
Yeah, for me it's really shocking because i frecuently have inner monologues, read or listen to songs in my head.
This knowledge broke me, it crazy to think about not being able to debate yourself in your head.
Jeannie just seemed like the type of person to have an internal monologue.
Perhaps she is the waking internal dialogue, a mirror of herself. On the brink of a feedback loop but keeps her mental trajectory forward by not looking inward, less the mirror shatters if she did look into that dark void.
Henry: “So you can’t talk to yourself in your head?”
Jeannie: *looks confused
Holy shit
Oh my God. So Jeannie is an actual real life NPC and Henry modded her into his life just like how he modded Recorded into his Skyrim. Henry's the man.
Disrespect
Projekt Jeannie
I was just about to write this.
i knew a gammer nerd cant get a girlfreind😂😂😂
Hehe he guna do alil more then modd her when he hits 2 mill subs ay🤣
Henry: “you all have an inner monologue right?”
Me: *in my head* “yup”
@@strifeman I used Smaug
@@strifeman I had Michael rooker
Damn you all. Now I have what I imagine Michael Rooker would sound like if he played Smaug speaking with Morgan Freeman's speech patterns in my head.
i have an inner monolougue .... mines quite bad tho as I think about what people are saying and if its complex I miss what they say next cos I'm listening to my inner monologue repeat what they said so it sinks in . does that make me weird?
*Morgan Freeman voice* You gotta get busy inner monologuing or get busy dying.
"It makes sense now, why you make noises all the time" Henry over here having a mental breakdown.
I love the image of some little old lady knocking on a basement door in some alley, then a little panel in the door slides open, and a guy asks for a password to get into the Karaoke bar.
I’m so mind blown by Jeanie not having an internal dialogue
I don't either
Sometimes I wish I could switch it off
@@stavrosnikas1353 how the fuck does that work
New question. Is having an inner monologue different from having an inner dialogue?
@@ethanstillsleeping5312 honestly couldnt agree more
I didn't even know that people existed who could not hear themselves think. who knew MxR plays could be educational.
I just learned that right now
You should also know that there are people who cannot _picture_ things in their minds. Their mind's eye is blind.
I believe there is research, saying it might be possible to learn to have an inner monologue if you don't have one. But that it isn't necessarily better or worse than not having one. Maybe that goes for picturing things aswell?
@@woulfhound that is me
@@user-sb3ml8ln5q You have aphantasia?
Jeannie just had her whole reality shattered when she learned about inner monologue.
My inner monologue is unstoppable. Constant, unfiltered ideas and thoughts that are spoken to me, and sometimes, more oftenthan I am comfortable with, screamed at me. It is not a "crazy" sort of experience. It's just constant and occasionally uncomfortable. I only figured out this year that not everyone experiences this. For my entire life I thought that speaking to yourself was as common as breathing. I actually paint entire moving scenes with dialog and everything. Complete with set dressing and all that stuff. It's so weird to think that its not the same for some.
I thought everyone had an inner monologue, finding out a lot of people don’t blew my mind. You learn something new every day with MXR plays!
Lmao yes. Beside tik thots
Full on agree, I was in the same boat about your inner voice, and to find out there are some that dont make me want to ask everyone I know.
@@OG_Eisenfuchs Same! I literally ran and asked my Mom immediately, now I have to ask all my friends.
And to know that apparently we are the minority... bro im always cursing at work but in my head. "Fuck all this shit bruh" damn thats just.. made me feel weird
It's sad, cause I think they might be missing out on great silent monologuing while in the shower...
I have an inner monologue, i didnt realize it was possible to THINK without basically talking in your own head. Its how I survive my boring factory jobs where I do the same movement 8 hours a day. I am talking in my head, making up stories, singing to myself, making elaborate zombie survival plans, etc. Not a single bit of that is spoken out loud.
You do "think" it's just not through words
I do to but mine isn't only an inner monologue, i actually have full on conversations with myself verbally i genuinely think I'm going crazy half of the time
@@ridgefrost I think I might be the same. I was with Henry, but the more he spoke, the more he made it sounded like actually he actually heard a voice in his head. I can think words, but I don't actually hear them.
I also have one of those jobs, what i do as i dont have a voice in my head my head just goes blank and does the job and then kinda forgets that i was working. Because i dont have a voice in my head and just repedetive hours of doing the same thing my brains memory just deletes it. I go into autopilot and loses 90%+ of the time i was working and i just remember the times where i change location, take a break, check in or leave for the day. Thats all i remember from a 8 hours day long work day, and when i get home (the same). For me as i dont stimulate my own brain with growth by talking to myself, time just flies away. I cant remember anything from my normal day to day life if i dont go outside my comfort zone and experiment with new things.
@@jimmynicol7942 I’m so confused. I can hear my own voice in my head when thinking about different things. Is that not normal?
When Jeannie asked Henry to say hello to himself It triggered my inner monologue to go through a bunch of songs with hello in it like just burst into song with 🎵hello from the other side 🎵
Dude I come up with entire story lines and other worlds in my head with my inner monologue. The voice changes based on whichever character I picture and I can always hear it narrating my thoughts
Don't worry Henry, I'm right there with you. In fact, when I'm reading a novel, I give the characters different voices in my mind.
It actually makes us read much slower unfortunately, but I'd still chose having it over not.
Yeah I know right like male characters and female characters 😲
Exactly, well its not so much different voices for me as I don't hear actual voices. But the way I imagine their voices are each different like voices. Its really hard trying to explain an inner dialog because I can't think of words that fit. Imagine is as best I got.
Whenever I binge watch rSlash I start hearing his sodding voice when I read stuff to myself. And yeah, if I read a book the characters end up with their own voices in my head. I just thought that's how it was for everyone but looked into it a bit more and apparently not. Humans are just weird 😂
Hells yah otherwise the books sooo boring hahah
Now Henry knows why Jeannie always makes noises, and Jeannie understands why sometimes she feels Henry ignoring her. Their relationship moves a step forward.
THIS IS THE MESSAGE THEY SHOULD WALK AWAY WITH!
matrix NPC memes launch!!!!!
And panda town can have another good night.
hopefully the marriage step
i have met someone or a classmate i should say in uni like Henry but worse, in addition to the fact that he ignores(that is what it would look like when he thinks to himself) while having a coversation midway, he is also slow at processing. Every boys hated it when he does that, though only a couple of guys can endure talking to him. if we are in america, he'd probably be a subject for bullying but in asian countries you cannot bully someone easily. even if their personality is bully-worthy if he works in a field, meaning rice fields, he is stronger than someone who goes to the gym everyday for 2hrs. I consider him smart academically and let others copy his assignments sometimes. I've met him again after 6years and he hasn't changed but surprisingly he has a wife and a kid now. maybe her wife is like jeannie, but comparing looks because i saw her picture, half of jeannie i guess.
When it was talking about the range of no internal to full, it was tying in to what we call "tuning out". That's why some people can go deeper into thought than others, and just mull over background noise easily.
Not only do I have inner monologue , I have inner dialogue. When I’m bored I can even tell myself stories with many different characters with different voices. I can even experience the made up world itself through one of these characters that aren’t me and build the world around me as I travel and meet countless people. Terrible, wonderful, beautiful and heartbreaking events can even take place, and these events can effect my real feelings and state of mind.
I just realized that, if Panda Queen had inner monologue we might've never had the dig a tunnel song
Holy shit yes
And all that weird sound she make
Oh shiiieeeeet
Mindblow 😦😮🤯 !!!
We would still have the sub par original
Jinny’s lack of internal monologue is probably why she’s so relaxed and happy!? I say this cause my monologue argues with me ALL THE TIME the mongrel!
Maybe you should work things out between you.
Your inner monologue is probably the one who is correct in those arguments, seeing as you don't spell Jeannie's name correctly.
@@timferguson6192 "Brutal," said my internal monologue
I was looking for this comment; When you debate something with yourself in your mind and you just can't agree with yourself, happened to me!
I always thought internal monologue arguments were the normal, and the abnormal ones where the one's walking down the street by themselves having a verbal argument with no-one.... The further down the 'inner monologue' rabbit hole I go, the less confidence I have that those crack heads arguing out loud aren't the ones on crack...
Here's a fun thing. I'm dyslexic. And part of dyslexia is thinking 3-dimensionally. I can "render" 3D objects in my brain
Wait I've dyslexia too and I can do that too but.... I thought everyone could do that.......Bruh my mind exploding rn
I can do that and don't have deslyxia
I was once told by a psychiatry student that hearing voices in your head, having a conversation with yourself, is (or can be) an early sign of Multiple Personality Disorder. I have often asked myself questions (What am I doing here/How should I go about this? etc.), but while I've worked my way through a problem, task, whatever, there's no "voice" attached to and I've *never* once received a reply.
That said, when I read, it plays out like a movie in my mind. I have zero recollection of actually reading the words, just the images in my mind. That's why I love reading, but technical books and manuals just switch my brain off, they take actual effort to read.
I honestly thought everyone had a inner monologue, I had no idea not everyone had an inner monologue. This actually blew my mind.
True tho, I thought it is a common thing that people do.
@@theyuun it is common, it more uncommon that people NOT have an inner monologue that it has a cundition name(aphantasia) and it is mostly known as people not being able to visualise in their heads, as in they can't IMAGINE stuff, that is aphantasia and it sometimes come with no inner monologue
Me too
Same, I'm in my head right now trying to figure out how people just hear nothing.
As someone who can’t get their inner monologue to shut the fuck up, that sounds incredibly peaceful.
I do think someone should clarify that by "internal monologue" we're not suggesting that your brain thinks your ears are receiving external stimuli when they are not. So it's not so much that you "hear" someone or yourself speaking. Rather, your brain processes your thoughts or the things you read the same way it would process it if you heard someone else and/or yourself saying it aloud. So you can "hear" yourself thinking about stuff, but you are aware that no actual audible sound was received.
If you DO actually literally hear audible sounds, go see a doctor. That's not an "internal monologue" but probably an actual mental disorder. (Because at that point, it's not "internal" any more.)
It might just be an auditory disease, don't exagerate.
@@KubeSquared
Wait i m confused what the hk r u even talking about?
Internal monologue or the OP's comment has nothing to do with auditory disease. Auditory disease is related to the reception of external stimuli, inner monologue has nothing to do with instant external stimulus
@@btchiaintkidding7837 read his last paragraph. My reply is to that
@@KubeSquared that's still not an exaggeration of whoever having an actual reason to see a doctor
I feel like that probably is what she is thinking, that he can actually HEAR hear it as if he is next to himself talking to himself. I guess it is really hard to describe the difference between the external and the internal when you don't have the internal
When i was younger i would daydream and i dont mean just doze off or something. During recess i would say to my friends aight im gonna dream abit and i would walk alone usually with a hoodie pulled over my head and staring at the ground, walking in circles over the playground( i stopped it later on because it was getting weird ). I can dream while walking no problem while awake only in full control and be doing something else at the same time. I was a bit of a weirdo but later on in life this helped me hold pictures in my head of complicated problems and simulate different outcomes. Like thinking of the entire diagram of an elictrical circuit and beeing able to visually see what happens when wires are cut or switches are activated. 10/10 would daydream again.
OMG Henry it makes soooo much sense, I just learned this the other day that some people dont have inner monologue, it explains so many things!
Who else thinks they should put a poll up on their channel for the viewers to comment whether they have an inner monologue or not?
Damn I assumed everyone has an inner monologue... wtf
@@tommj4365 ikr heard about this the first time 😶
Oh fersure dude. How many Jerries vs Ricks we got in the community?
Absolutly then jeannie will see they our voices are not a minority
Bruh I can't imagine reading a book without a inner monologue, it would just be so stale without the different voices
The fact that not everybody at all has an internal monologue just gave me an existential crisis, great!
I know I can't figure out how you can manage to think through a problem without talking it out in your head.
That’s crazy, she can’t even get a song stuck in her head!
My mind has now combusted into a thousand shards that can no longer talk to themselves without blowing up more
Ikr I feel like everyone should have that little voice in their head
That explains so much lol 😆 I never thought of this before
0:00 - Jeannie burps in Henry's face
5:03 - Jeannie doesn't have an internal monologue
I also read some other comments and found this topic really interesting with all the pov I myself can listen to a tv show and see what's happening in my head as if I was actually watching it. Same with thoughts, they sometimes come with visuals. Pretty cool
Everyone that doesn't have a inner monologue doesnt have to worry about random thoughts keeping them up all night.
It’s those people that fall asleep straight away🤣 they have *NO* thoughts.
@@zaddybanban3128 nope,
i have inner monologues, but can fall asleep in no time.
for me it dont be like that. can still think but its just not in that way of like hearing the thoughts as a voice happening or something
What? No? I dont have a special voice in my head that says my thoughts...more like a voiceless voice that I think with.
And still have these depressive thoughts that push me to my next existential crisis.
);
This will literally keep me up at night
I'm sorry for you Henry... internal monologue - Henry is normal... Sorry there Jeannie.
clearly jeanie is a psychopath ;)
It's sociopath not psychopath
@@sadflute8639 I'm confused do sociopath not have a internal monologue?
It has nothing to do with being a sociopath or psychopath. Its something all by itself
@@chadfalardeau5396 I was thinking that, clearly david was making a joke and was very confused when sad flute corrected him. But then again i'm not a sociopath so I can't say he right or wrong
I sound like a genius in my inner monologues but as soon as I open my mouth I sound like Scooby Doo
This went from memes to finding out that Jeannie and some people that doesn't have an internal monolog and than back to memes. I love this channel.
I literally have full arguments with people in my head, using their voices. It really helps me empathize with others and keeps me from getting unnecessarily upset. Didn’t know others couldn’t do this…you learn something new everyday.
Facts I do the same for stress relief, if I want to yell at someone i do it in my head😂😂
dude i fight with this guy in my head all day
I do the same and helps me with my ADD. So I can keep my mind busy without stimuli.
So... you guys do know that's a factor in associative identity budding, right? At least on a really basic level of Dissociative Identity disorder.
I thought I was the only one
I always thought having an internal monologue was equivalent to just thinking. Who knew an MxR video would one day give me a existential crisis
lol fact.. like how do people even think.. do they think at all???? Things just fall out of their mouths, i guess.. it weird asf
@@ludwigvonn9889 How do you read without an internal monologue?
@@R0GU351GN4L I have an internal monologue, but I don't really have to read the words. I can't keep it all quiet, but lets say you make a sound with your internal monologue, and still read the words... You get me? lol. Just thinking about this is weird
@@R0GU351GN4L you just read the words... its hard to explain. You get whats going on, but you can't "hear" any voices, and if you're really (un)lucky like me, can't really picture anything either. Again, hard to explain.
@@R0GU351GN4L this puzzles me too. Like when I’m reading and understanding something I run it in my head. I debate with myself if something is unclear. I can’t remember a time that I didn’t do that.
I can't wrap my head around not having an inner monolog.
on days when I feel especially goofy, I greet the voices in my head like that bonjour scene from beauty and the beast
Henry: I have an internal monologue...
Jeannie: I don't have internal monologue... 30% see, you're the minorioty...
Me: **Having a full-on conversation in my head about locking the car door**
Relatable.
That's me when I ask myself if I locked the apartment door or not while already otw to work
I have an internal monologue too! I was today years old when I found out that not everyone has this 0.0
i was about to comment something similar but glad you did it for me
Holy shit same
05:03 - Henry's face when he realizes Jeannie is either a synth or a sociopath...
Hey psychopaths have inner monologues too
@@reapercoconut7308 but not sociopaths
@@helltaker6865 I'm on the border of sociopathic, and I definitely have an inner monolog, I just don't feel the same emotional stuff like 'normal' people. Lol.
Chris Strayed so if an atrocity was committed in front of you you wouldn't feel much of anything.
@@hainleysimpson1507 Not at all what that means. Most sociopaths just don't have the same reaction other people would. We're more logical. In tense situations, you want someone like us to think through things instead of reacting emotionally which could like to dire mistakes. Do I FEEL emotions? Sure. Do they overtake my demeanor? Not really. I'm very calm in most situations.
As for the question itself, it's hard for me to determine how I would feel in a hypothetical, it just doesn't work that way for me, I would actually have to have been in a situation to answer. I would imagine I would get to a safe place and call authorities. If the atrocity was, say a murder, I would not want to add to the list of victims. But how would I FEEL? Not sure. I suppose most would FEEL scared, then they freeze up or run. I would probably quickly just access what's happening and take the action I described above.
When I'm reading a book my internal monologue has accents and cadence depending on how I've interpreted the characters. Can't imagine this not happening. Poor Jeannie!
I can change the voice in my head to talk in a high pitched voice, a deep voice, etc. I also have “scenes” in my head that are like seeing a picture in front of my eyes of a time back in history.
I’m so mind blown by Jeanie not having an internal dialogue almost as much as finding out not all people have one O_O!!!! i am now going to ask every person I know
Look into aphantasia bc its similar
Whats crazy is that she studied to be a doctor... seems to me being a doctor without an internal dialogue would be hard.
Do you mean literal sound in your head or just internal thought?
You are about to find out inner monologue strongly correlates with ethnicity.
@@TheZapan99 wait what? What people tend to have it more?
Jeannie: *thinks it is creepy that Henry has an internal monologue*
Henry: *claims Jeannie is the weird one for NOT having an internal monologue*
Krewsaders: "You are both weird, & that is why we follow you."
This was very intresting o.0
But Jeannie is weird for not having an internal monologue
Nxaaaw
amen brother
bruh noice
A couple of tests for the inner monologue: 1) When reading a book, do you mispronounce words? If you have no inner monologue I assume you would just get stuck on any word you couldn't pronounce. With an inner monologue, you would mispronounce it then go "what was that?" and either correct it or look up the word. 2) Do you practice saying things in your head before you say them live? "When I see Henry I'm going to remind him we need to pick up eggs at the store." You might then practice how you will say it--- "Thanks to you eating all the eggs, we need to pick up more" or "Can we pleeeaaaaasssseee pick up some more eggs? We're out of them." You then decide which one you want to go with. Sometimes you would use your inner monologue to figure out which version of a statement will go over better. Very very interesting revelation.
When I read a book, not only the characters have their own voices, but I can hear background noises from the places they are. Birds in a forest, the fish jumping out of the water of the lake, and all that is described in the book. It feels more vivid than watching a movie. If those who have no inner monologues read a book... it is just words? No worlds forming and playing in their heads?
Me with my inner monologue right now: “do people really not have inner monologues? Huh, that’s weird how do the make decisions?”
Dude same lol. I immediately had an internal discussion with myself
They can still think, their brains still work. Thoughts just don't present themselves as a voice for them.
@@DragonZerul Yea, my inner monologues are usually a combination of vague imagery and garbled english, but if I focus I can talk in my head the same way that I would talk out loud, and that's what I generally do when I read to myself
@@DragonZerul yes they can "think" but how can they cross-examine an idea, or create mental cross off lists and mentally verbalise about priorities and how to break the task up.
next q for other inner monologue people, is how many languages do you have?
for non-inner monologue people, you get it lucky because when I try to do speeches or presentation I get an echo , and sometimes it's at the speed that switches off the thinking which is difficult to handle when speaking to groups.
I don't have inner monologue unless I force it.. I guess it's hard to describe but the pondering does occur, same as everyone else, it's just.. silent. Not visual either (at least for me), just immaterial, not-quite-put-into-words thoughts.
That is absolutely mind-blowing for me to realize some folks can't hear internal voices/monologue. It just illustrates another way two people can exist on the exact same earth, with the exact same sensory input, but perceive and experience it completely differently. Both a lesson in being kind for each person's differences, but also cautious because they can seem exactly like us but not be.
It's such a handicap too. Whenever I want to remember something someone else said I'd replay their voice inside of my head. It helps a lot with names.
I have an internal monologue but, I'm unable to recall past events.
Although i find it also interesting, ive often thought that maybe there is only one person in the world, you. If life was like the matrix, how can you verify there are other people? What if there is just one main character, and everyone else is in your world? i know its crazy talk, but how would someone disprove it? you can only know about your own life.
Question for u do u have inner taste buds
@@suatae so u can hear voice but can't see pictures
That was mindblowing about the inner monologue part. I don´t have that, I have to say it out loud to have a conversation with myself which I often do.
I have an internal monologue and dialogue. I think in full technicolour pictures. I can have conversations with people in my head as myself, sometimes hear their voices as well.
Henry: "you guys have a inner monolog right?"
Me in my head: "Hepatitis B is not made of Imo's pizza therefore there are no spoons."
Got to give you a thumb's up for a random Imo's pizza reference.
Bum fight crew! Very tasty!
"Aaaay Macarena! Ahheight!"
"DID YOU JUST RELOAD! IN FRONT OF THE GODDAMN ENEMY??"
Bruh I can't imagine reading a book without a inner monologue, it would just be so stale without the different voices
Yeah I read sometimes books and it suddenly becomes like a movie for me. As a writer it actually helps a ton in making storylines and Character Dialogue. I swear though, sometimes I get random storylines that are just really ridiculous.
I read Ready Player One once and while reading it I got a random idea for a Yuri plot based on Video Games. I think I'm more mad that I wrote it out and it's good than the fact I sat there and dreamt up an entire Yuri Storyline in 2 hours. Imagining the voices, looks of the characters and their names I still have it and sometimes I contemplate turning it into a full series.
I swear this is the first thing i thought.
It's the reason why it takes me so long to finish books. I'm my own narrator. 8-)
I mean I have an inner monologue and I'm not saying that it's wrong or weird but I actually don't have different voices for the different characters while reading. I guess it does make sense and I could do it if i wanted to just like how if I was reading aloud I could change the voices for the characters but I just never have. Also now I think about it when I read I recognize the words but it's not the same as when I'm thinking to myself. I think people that dont have an inner dialog is really interesting, i imagine also that some people have inner dialog that is processed in a way thats not translated to a verbal language
I don't have an inner monologue so sometimes I read every characters dialogue under my breath and visually imagine what is happening but even when I don't do that I never get bored reading so idk
2 million, yall deserve it.
my biggest surprise is not only learning that some people do/do not have and inner monologue, but that no one mentions how easy it is to turn it off and on
My inner monologue sides with Henry on this one, I especially felt in when he said that thing about getting a thought and conversing with yourself in the middle of a conversation. That happens all the time and I'm like aw man what were they just saying. Also this is amazing, it gives whole new context to all their videos, this entire time Jeannie was just thinking out loud and we were watching her thoughts form before our very eyes.
Choose whether or not to have an internal monologue but generally it's just playing some Guns N Roses song lmfao
I straight up paused this video, and had conversations with 5 people about inner monologues, and it was amazing. Take my like!
Same and I'm here alone.
@@Damas089 i see what happened here... take my like...
Oh yeah exactly i will literally make a 24 minute long anime ep 1 hour because i pause every 5 minute to make my own scenario and its actually more enjoyable than the anime it self xD
Imagine that... If your Mother or Father is dead, you can't remember how thier Voices sounded like. That's sad. 🙁
@@mushycookies6470 that's help u forget faster tho🤨
I had to go back to play this gem of a video. The arc of Jeannie is a wild one. Her face of realization is so pure.
It's also called sub vocalalization. When I took a speed reading course they tried to get us to stop that and absorb the text on the page. It was weird.
I've got an inner monologue, honestly it makes books way more interesting as characters can have individual voices. I can also properly recall images, with one exception. I can't remember what people's faces look like. I can remember everything else. The more I focus on it the less detail I can recall. Imagine seeing something out of the corner of your eye but when you look it's not what you thought. It's like that. If I picture seeing something on the side, I get more detail about someone's face than I do when I focus mentally on it.
For me my memories are stored mostly as images, however I’d say if it was actually photographic memory than it’s a terrible camera that constantly has corrupted save files. I can’t choose which images to remember but those ones I do remember are vivid and stay for quite awhile. If I see a picture from that time I can remember more. I say mostly because I also still remember songs and dialogue from movies. For thinking about images however it’s a whole other ball game, I can see little parts of an image but never the full picture, kinda of like I’m constantly zoomed in on photoshop.
I can talk inside my head and see images very well, ive used that ability to make a crap ton of plots for games, although i havent made any of them yet cuz i suck, im honestly supprised that the amount is that low.
I can make cartoon characters talk to themselves about anything. Not tryna flex but i didn’t people couldn’t do it...
Facts
Same here
Not only do I have inner monologues, I can also have whole movies playing in my head, like I can totally disconnect myself from reality and watch a movie of my own making, it's kinda like having a dream that I actually control, it's awesome.
I'm the exact opposite and have aphantasia
oh, an hyperphantasia dude.
meanwhile, i'm also part of the aphantasia club, but my internal monologue works great, I can have orchestras in my head \o/
(well, to be clear, I can't hear it as in replace / cover other sounds with that, I can "feel" as if the sounds were there)
You are perfect for being hypnotized and mind controlled.
Dude me too, I feel like a director when I play a movie then change it when I didn't like it.
I do too, i was creating superhero movies or shooting collegues in my head, just to survive classes, and when i closed my eyes, i could imagine lines to where sound came from around me, i know it sounds strange but invision a point in a dark background and lines coming from that point in the direction of the sound, and if i moved my head in any direction, the lines would follow the sound, the mind is quite a powerfull and gnarly thing.
8:49 - In olympic target pistol shooting, you have to fire with only one hand, unsupported. Also, the pistol is usually a very low calibre or even an air pistol (depending on the category) and has a very light recoil.
I've got an inner monolog that can switch voices. For instance when I read a book I can assign different voices to each character and it can follow different accents, customs, and dialects. Also when I read LOTR, I can assign the voices from the movies to their characters in the books.
As a writer, I rely on my internal monologuing to come up with ideas. I like to lay down, close my eyes, and imagine entire worlds, the people, and everything else come to life in my mind. I also can come up with badass fight scenes while listening to epic music.
Bruh we are so much similar, like I like writing fanfics and novels and it honestly helps when you can spiritually render the story and fight scenes, infact when I am imagining the fight scenes, I tend to get so immersed that I forget that I have to advance the story.
@@I_am_a_man_of_science Ah, same. I also have the habit of breaking out into tears when I come up with something particularly sad and get depressed for the rest of the day.
@@darkshado124 well not so much, but whenever I read zombie type or survival or apocalypse novel, I start to imagine what would happen if it started happening right now, and I can easily play it like a movie in real time, while staring somewhere without blinking.
@@I_am_a_man_of_science Umu!
play with it but do not embrace it ... for your good
Not only do I have an inner monologue, but I can do it in other voices.
I find that Obi-Wan is applicable for just about any situation at least one stage of his life.
being able to play my favorite anime osts in my head is also pretty pog ;)
hello there
Hello there. I have spent 37 years thinking I was the only one with a skull haunted by Alec Guinness. Thanks man.
My voices in my head never have my voice
You should try in Morgan Freeman's voice.. it instantly becomes a narrative story..
I have a inner monologue, like if I read a book written by an author who I have heard speak before it sounds like that person is reading the book to me in my head. I also hear my voice in my head if I'm thinking to my self, or if I'm recalling a conversation I had with someone I can hear their voice as I'm remembering the conversation we had.
Man my inner monologue is so loud I’ve accidentally ignored other people
Henry: You all have an inner monologue right?
Me Outside: Yeah of course.
Inner Monologue 1: Wait… there are people who don’t???
Inner Monologue 2: Apparently…
Yea, apparently there are people without inner monologues, saw it ona YT vid title once, weird huh
Accurate
I don’t understand how people can like… properly think through situations, plan, solve problems without in inner monologue.
I wonder if a lack of inner monologue is why some people freeze up during stressful situations?
I have an inner monologue and work a job that has random bouts of extreme stress and I never freeze or panic.
@@VeeDub_in_da_House nah, I freeze despite my inner monologue.
@@VeeDub_in_da_House try not freezing when your panic causes you to run 5 inner monologues simultaneously that are all telling you to react differently.
@@jamaluddinkhalifa8371 Damn! Sometimes more is NOT better.
@@VeeDub_in_da_House I think that is why people freeze up. I sometimes get in trouble because I look like I'm ignoring/dodging a dialogue. Can't always say "Sorry, answer is still to be computed."
I absolutely GUARANTEE that most people have an inner monologue, this is the first I hear that it's not simply everybody, LOL! I never knew there were people without inner monologues, :) Austin Powers even had a joke about how the freezing process turned his temporarily off: "How do I tell them that due to the freezing process I have no inner monologue?", something like that. Yes Jeannie, hearing THAT in his head is how it usually goes. Like Henry said, this has OFTEN been portrayed, and not just in anime, where we get to hear a character's inner monologue to know what they're thinking. Anxiety is often portrayed like that, when a person can't stop their inner monologue from obsessing about potential issues and things that can go wrong. Wonder Years and The Goldbergs (and Fresh Off The Boat in the beginning) combine the inner monologue with a look back by an adult version of those characters. I think there's OFTEN been a nervous teen trying/wanting to approach a crush and we hear "OMG, what am I doing? I'm about to talk to _____, I must be insane, AHHHHH!!!!!", stuff like that. This is their inner voice.
I estimate that 30 to 50% stat is SPECIFICALLY how many people have it FREQUENTLY. It's not how many people have it AT ALL. Now that I found that CBC link you didn't click, that little preview blurb cut out that the scientist says most people have it: "not many people have an inner monologue 100 per cent of the time, but most do sometimes"
Watch the movie What Women Want with Mel Gibson, the ENTIRE MOVIE, the entire concept, is Mel hearing women's inner monologues. THOSE are inner monologues. It's what those women are hearing in their heads. And the movie doesn't portray ONE. SINGLE. WOMAN. without an inner monologue, :) (That 30-50 link reminded me of that). Another article said "The lack of an inner monologue has been linked to a condition called aphantasia - sometimes called "blindness of the mind's eye.""
The inner monologue thing I can do it both ways. Either speak my thoughts internally with the words or or just think the thoughts internally without the words. For example if I am reading I can 'read' faster if I don't 'voice' the words in my mind just think the concepts.
I can turn my inner monologue on and off, I can "project" images and memories like videos while still doing another thing. I can imagine objects (like an apple or a car) and change features about them, like colour or size, I can rotate them and combine all these effects. I can read a book and have it play like a movie with a narration, or just be words on a page. I can imagine a scenario and have it play like a movie in my head, then I can go back and edit or change things about it. And what do I get on top of all this? Short term memory loss.
Lol a necessary sacrifice
because of stress from work, my inner voice has been particularly noisy this week. haven't been sleeping well because of it.
And I can do none of that at all. Yet I'm really good at certain creative things, even though I can't picture anything, and I have really good spacial awareness. The brain is weird man
@@SmileyTom666 lol humans are just mech pilots
Chimps have incredible short term memory, compared to humans. But everything is on a spectrum, so you've gained in abstract thinking and imaging what you've lost in short term memory. Just more so than the rest of us.
I actually have full on debates and conversations inside my head, and when dreaming I can see myself talking to a person that resembles me. This actually helps me understand stuff because if I have a question I ask my head and then we analyze it together.
Same. “Ok, so if this is a poisonous chlorine gas, and this is explosive sodium, why it make table salt?!” “Dunno Play Poor, maybe they cancel out the toxicity of each other?” “Prolly”
Exactly 😂
What about when using language to monologue other than your mother tongue? I'm not a english speaker (not a english speaking country, family or such) and a still sometimes discuss things in english in my mind. Usually related to some english language media i'm consuming at the moment: movie, game, video...
Never had any visualization of my being though.. It's just two speakers with the same voice having a debate. Either in my mother tongue or english.
same but i hate it cuz now i always overthink simple things that i do like closing/opening a door or turning my phone on /off. I have to do it again and again until my brain finally thinks i close/open the door or turn my phone on/off. I HATE It. im not like these before lockdown so i think its because of lockdown i turn crazy
edit: I HATE IT
I can't remember a Day in my Life were i haven't had a inner conversation in my Head. Maybe in early Childhood when you're not thinking much and just act and react to everything. Imagine that... If your Mother or Father is dead, you can't remember how thier Voices sounded like. That's sad. 🙁
I think more in images than in words, sometimes I hear words when I’m reading but throughout the day or when I’m writing something ( like now), but most of the time I think in moving images. When I make plans I see myself doing what I’m going to do.
Definitely had a inner monologue. I also hear music when reading musical note sheet or partiture. 😜
I can relate to Henry 100 percent, having conversion with someone and then all sudden I'm in a deep conversion with myself thinking about other situations and absolutely miss everything they had said too me
To me its not so much words and talking as its me thinking and visualizing the conversation.
Okay, try this for the whole "internal monologue" thing, Jeannie. Picture an apple on a desk. Now imagine Henry walking over to the desk and placing a second apple on it. That image in your head would be like how internal monologues work. Internal monologues are a form of memory. If you can replay/recall images, videos, and other sensory inputs you've experienced, those memories are tied to the ability to have an internal monologue. Remembering how something LOOKS is no different than remembering how something SOUNDS, and an internal monologue is simply remembering how yourself sounds and using that memory of your own voice to formulate thoughts. A dog barking, a baby crying, your mom calling your name - if you can remember how these things sound and replay them in your mind, that's more or less the same as people replaying their own voice in their head.
When we hear imagine an apple...we don't actually see it. Its like a book without pictures.
Very nicely explained.
@@rjdrakon2492 nah I 100% see it, with every little color and texture variation you can imagine. Same with sounds, touch, smells, emotions, you name it.
A lot of people with no internal monologue also report being unable to picture things with their minds, not even memories.
I see it. A little movie even played in my head while reading that in what I might think your voice would sound like. Same with books or anything like that. Better the detail, clearer the mind movie. Different voices for each character.....
This is one of the best videos imho it gets so real and explains a lot.
Eyyy, my 5000th liked video!
I have an internal monologue, but I also see detailed imagery and films, and I often associate colours and emotions to everything. I can also imagine exactly how random noices sound like, how different things feel towards my skin, and what different foods and drinks taste like.
jeanie: no voice in her head
henry: has 1 voice in his head
me: currently hosting my own talk show in my head, and typing out a small part of the script as a youtube comment
Bro I thought having Arnold Schwarzenegger sing 'Pretty Girl Rock' was a common pastime
Wow I just learned that Henry is a girl. Interesting.
@@connorallgood0922XD
@@connorallgood0922 oof. fixed it lol
Fersure my guy, you and me both.
I'm on Henry's side.
I hear my thoughts, music, all the typical monologue of a normal human being. 😂
Same
My Brother used to read me bedtime stories when we were young. But he slowly stopped making sounds out of his mouth while reading. I was like "How am I gonna know whats going on in the story when you are not reading it? I can't even read yet"
same here, my head even randomly play any song i like or lastly heard sometimes :/
@@bjarne4108 hahaha. Yeah. Like sometimes it's so right there they I often bang my head to it or rock in my seat when so focused on it lol
ya same
I had to pause this video half way because my mind is just so blown and I feel like this has become an intervention.
Honestly inner monologue is just the memory of how something sounds. and being able to imagine hearing that sound. like when you are reading to yourself you imagine you are speaking the words. this is a hard concept to explain, but I also have inner monologue and talk to myself, but I can also imagine others talking back to me if I've heard there voice before. I legit can play out potential conversations in my mind. depending on how well I know the people, there is some accuracy to them, but with so many factors its really pointless, but I digress. I think it is a spectrum tho, like asking someone to imagine camping some might think of the word camping or a feeling or picture a campfire or telling story's. I'm sure it depends on the person and how they where raised and best learned and where able to process that learn information. because with deaf people you can ask them what boom is and they might see the word in there mind and know what it means but have no concept of recreating the actual sound.
It's so freaking weird that Jeannie doesn't have a monologue voice in her head.
So she is ALWAYS on the maximum meditation level! She's is the new Buddha.
I think the much more likely scenario is that she's misunderstanding what an inner monologue is. I'm betting that she is thinking that Henry actually hears audio in his ears when he thinks to himself
@@Verdigo76 have u ever considered that maybe that is but maybe ur version of thinking is the without hearing it?
Next, you should look up aphantasia.
@@qcklu Woah you just blew my mind. We dont know, that might actually be the case!
@@Verdigo76 I wonder how she's so good at imitating voices and doing accents then?
This whole inner monolog thing is one of the most interesting things I've ever seen on youtube. I had absolutely no idea some people couldn't recreate sounds, pictures, videos, smells, and tastes in their mind. I wonder if those people sleep easier than the rest of us.
I can't
Hold on, you can recreate smells and flavors in your mind? I can do everything else but not that
@@MiffedMonkey1
I test out new recipes sometimes.
I don't have a working stove/oven, though.
I just go through flavor profiles in my head. I can also cycle through how different meats smell when cooked.
They still smell much stronger in real life, but I can smell them in my mind without having food around.
I mean you still can sleep easier if you recreate lovely things in your head tho, I personally see it as a tremendous ability that I like to practice and have fun with and also think everyone can do it since the weirdest thing is if you focus on a rose you can actually smell it or you can feel the difference between a tennis and golf ball by imagining it lol
@@MiffedMonkey1 I used to take a liquid medication twice daily as a child. For lack of a better term, I had to snort it through a plastic tube. I could taste it on the very back of my tongue. To this day, whenever I think about it, I can still taste it.
i can hear voices in my head that i cant even recreate with my mouth and mix voices together to make "original" voices, it never once occurred to my that other people dont have that ability thx mxr
I have the inner monologue. When I read books, I also try and come up with unique voices for characters.
Whats fun is arguing with myself in several voices and accents. And no, none of my inner monologue voices have tried killing each other. They just have checklists incase that day comes.