Reasoned Analysis -"Did God create man or did man create God?" Part 2

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 24. 07. 2024
  • The discussion centred on whether human beings invented God/s or the supreme Creator.

Komentáře • 123

  • @Crazyadmirer
    @Crazyadmirer Před 2 lety +1

    knowledge is power.tnx Dr SHABIR

  • @ultiumlabs4899
    @ultiumlabs4899 Před 2 lety +2

    this type of deep discussion would be really beneficial compared to a discussion in the park that never got to a conclusion. Yes, please answer the question one by one, deep talk. jazakumullah khairan.

  • @waheedali2429
    @waheedali2429 Před 2 lety

    جزاك الله خيراً

  • @jj19961
    @jj19961 Před 2 lety

    Maa sha Allah! A logical, coherent, and clear explanation of what constitutes searching the truth rationally. Both speakers must be praised for their highly elevated and beneficial conversation. Please continue these kinds of discussions.

  • @RoofingConnecticut
    @RoofingConnecticut Před 2 lety

    No offense to other Dawah people but this is so much more beneficial than the argumentative discussions they tend to do

  • @firozsanullah9571
    @firozsanullah9571 Před 2 lety

    MashaAllah brother Shabir impressive

  • @godisone578
    @godisone578 Před 2 lety

    Allah bless you Dr Shabir

  • @fahadal3607
    @fahadal3607 Před 5 měsíci

    We need more videos

  • @YahyaibnZaqariah
    @YahyaibnZaqariah Před rokem

    Is it just me or is anyone else having issue’s with the sound.
    Roughly a whole min of no sound.
    21:30-22:30, and same again later on!
    Otherwise awesome conversation!

  • @elliot7205
    @elliot7205 Před 2 lety

    Hi shabir, to clarify your point on our last disscusion, did you mean that all of the various readings are actually one reading? Even some of the words when recited do change the meaning slightly?

  • @imanurhayati1027
    @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

    Imran Khan has failed to fulfil his promises to the people of Pakistan, yet he has not accepted his failures in public or admitted to his Government’s mistakes. The sooner Imran Khan steps down the less people of Pakistan will suffer - Jan 2021

  • @travels29
    @travels29 Před 2 lety +1

    Why not debate apostate prophet like you debated the rationaliser

    • @sycorez
      @sycorez Před 2 lety +1

      No point. AP looked a fool debating Thought Adventure Podcast and several times with Daniel Haqiqatjou.

  • @imanurhayati1027
    @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

    Media, Journalists and Opposition party will continue to criticise the PTI Government and its members, but Imran Khan will continue to ignore their responses. Then troubles for Pakistan grow so much that Imran Khan will fail. Muhammad Qasim’s dreams

  • @imanurhayati1027
    @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

    The way Imran Khan prostrated in the shrine is a major form of shirk and until he repents to Allah(SWT) for that very action, he will not be successful. Muhammad Qasim was shown this in his dream in July 2018.
    Until Imran Khan makes a firm and sincere promise that he will never bow down to anyone except Allah(SWT) as he used to say in the past, his troubles and difficulties will remain the way they are today.
    When Imran Khan realises his mistake and listens to the message, he will acknowledge that he used to only bow down to Allah(SWT) but unfortunately he got surrounded by such people that he went in the wrong path. Qasim Dreams are True

  • @scottholder4431
    @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety +1

    Morality is subjective AND objective.
    it's subjective because we as a society decided(came up with) that in order to live communally, we must have rights and restrictions. If you interfere with my rights, then your action that interfered with my right is wrong.
    It's objective when viewed through the lens of harm. Harm can be measured, or seen. if you steal all my money, we can see the harm that has been done. If you punch me in the face, you have physically harmed me.

    • @gr3atestthink3r86
      @gr3atestthink3r86 Před 2 lety +1

      I agree with your comment, on a side note, if a "God" is real it cannot be this nonsense preached from this religious books. On separate side note, every Muslim comercial ad is about asking for money by using a nice tone when speaking taking advantage of the religion and low emotional IQ people, the biggest scam business ever invented, by the way Shabbir is a fool that actually has doubts deep inside but likes to hear himself sound "smart"

    • @shzi9090
      @shzi9090 Před 2 lety

      I dont see the harm in punching you or stealing your money, i enjoyed punching you, and loved it when i got rich stealing all your money. So guess its not objective.

    • @scottholder4431
      @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety

      @@shzi9090 If someone stole all your money.......are you harmed? yep.

    • @shzi9090
      @shzi9090 Před 2 lety +1

      @@scottholder4431 so its not objective then, its subjective.🤷🏽‍♂️

    • @scottholder4431
      @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety

      @@shzi9090 It's both as my OP laid out.

  • @imanurhayati1027
    @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

    Muhammad Qasim saw in his dreams, that after many unsuccessful rulers, people of Pakistan will lay their trust and hope in Imran Khan, but even then nothing will change. This and many other dreams of Muhammad Qasim are coming true today.

    • @AllTruthRevealed
      @AllTruthRevealed  Před 2 lety

      Which Muhammad Qasim?

    • @imanurhayati1027
      @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

      @@AllTruthRevealed Muhammad Qasim ibn Abdulkarim
      Muhammad Qasim is a simple Pakistani Muslim man who has been blessed with divine dreams for Muslim ummah. His dreams indicate how the events of the future will unfold until Qiyamah including major signs of Qiyamah as discussed in numerous Hadiths. Muhammad Qasim has no political affiliation. He has merely just seen these dreams since the age of 7 (he is now 45), and began sharing dreams when he saw Prophet Muhammad SAW in his dreams in 2014, asking him to share his dreams to save Pakistan and Islam.

    • @AllTruthRevealed
      @AllTruthRevealed  Před 2 lety

      @@imanurhayati1027 Where is he residing?

    • @imanurhayati1027
      @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

      @@AllTruthRevealed Lahore

    • @AllTruthRevealed
      @AllTruthRevealed  Před 2 lety +2

      @@imanurhayati1027 Thank you. Is there a way of contacting him?

  • @imanurhayati1027
    @imanurhayati1027 Před 2 lety

    Muhammad Qasim saw that PM Nawaz Sharif will be exiled, PM Imran Khan will struggle and fail, Chaos & civil unrest will rise in Pakistan, enemies of Pakistan will attack from Afghanistan and India. All these dreams have now come true.

  • @scottholder4431
    @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety +1

    What does rape, murder, robbery, assault, kid napping......all have in common? Harm. It only seems logical that your god uses the harm principle too or these things are wrong just because he says so. What reason does god say these things are wrong?
    Is his reason harm or just because he says so???

    • @MansMan42069
      @MansMan42069 Před 2 lety

      Who says harm is bad? And trying to frame this as God being arbitrary is fallacious.

    • @scottholder4431
      @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety

      @@MansMan42069 Well, what's god reason? He just says so???
      Or is rape wrong because it harms???

    • @scottholder4431
      @scottholder4431 Před 2 lety

      @@MansMan42069 Who says harm is bad?"
      Many of the muslims I speak to.

    • @777Godsgift777
      @777Godsgift777 Před 2 lety

      @@scottholder4431 define harm

    • @777Godsgift777
      @777Godsgift777 Před 2 lety

      @@scottholder4431 stealing doesn't harm anyone

  • @waheedali2429
    @waheedali2429 Před 2 lety

    The voice Cut many times
    Muhammad need to be fired for the bad work.

  • @Rama-Vana
    @Rama-Vana Před 2 lety

    I'm Hindu, if Allah wants me to follow him who are you to convince me, it's between Allha & me... Why you guys get into arguments & force something... Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏🙏

    • @AllTruthRevealed
      @AllTruthRevealed  Před 2 lety +3

      Thank you for your comment. Respectfully your comment lacks reason. We engage in reasonable discussions because on a logical, rational and reasonable basis Islam is the complete system of guidance from the Creator supreme. It therefore is logical to share it.

  • @morikm4154
    @morikm4154 Před 2 lety

    You promote Islam but not even your close indicates your on culture. We call your Islam in middle east . British islam .
    People like you promoting new ideology for west to improve they weapons for East , the same things Romans did by Christianity .

    • @AllTruthRevealed
      @AllTruthRevealed  Před 2 lety +4

      Sincere apologies but your post does not make sense. Please make it legible.