Zelda Breath of the Wild VS Witcher 3 Switch
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 07. 2024
- It’s finally time for Zelda Breath of the Wild VS The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on Nintendo Switch!
#BreathoftheWild #NintendoSwitch! #Witcher3Switch
- Follow us on Twitter! / commonrealm
FerriswheelPro: / theferrisofwheels
Breath of the Wild 2 Will be More Difficult: • Breath of the Wild 2, ...
Breath of the Wild 2’s Underground World: • Breath of the Wild 2 w...
Cut Content in Breath of the Wild: • Breath of the Wild 2 w...
Zelda Timeline with Link’s Awakening Switch - • Legend of Zelda Timeli...
Secrets Underground Hyrule - • Secrets Underground Hy...
Changes Breath of the Wild 2 Needs - • Breath of the Wild 2 N...
Zonai & Sheikah Secrets in Akkala- • Zonai & Sheikah Secret...
Link, Zonai and Koroks VS Ganondorf - • Link, Zonai and Koroks...
The Zonai Mystery in Faron - • The Zonai Mystery in F...
Ganondorf and the Zonai Mystery - • Ganondorf and the Zona...
Breath of the Wild 2 Just in Hyrule? • Breath of the Wild 2 J...
Support us on Patreon and get your Pin!: / commonrealm
Subscribe to Commonwealth Realm:
bit.ly/Commonrealm
Join the Realm on Discord Today!
/ discord - Hry
This took way too long to put together, but it's finally done! Hope you enjoy the video, make sure to leave a like so more people can see it!
You know since both Witcher and BotW are both game of the years games, will there be a crossover DLC between the two games?
@@pimsutter that would be cool you could even have a dodongo that looks like a dragon
Thanks for the great comparisson video. I am personally contemplating on how to approach my personal favorites in gaming and your videos are a good approach to compare two games, I feel.
Just wondering: in terms of a personal view on games, how much do nostalgia and emotional connection towards a game impact your view on it? Would you say it's fine to love a game based of that you simply had a lot of fun with it personally, even if it might be qualitatively not the greatest nowadays?
Witcher 3 is the better game of the two. Had about an equal amount of fun playing through both (to 100%) though.
Pim Sutter I certainly hope so
I just call it The Switcher 3: Breath of the Wild Hunt
Nice.
This should be the ending of this video, suddenly both games combined and you already said its name
On Twitter though, they tweet it as switcher iii
Clever
More like "The Legend Of Witcher: Breath Of The Wild Hunt"
Boist
Ive noticed a lot of people saying they "just couldnt get into the witcher 3 after a few hours and give up". To those people I say, the game doesnt even start til after you leave white orchard which is literally a tutorial area. So pick it back up and give it a real chance. This is one of if not the greatest game ever and you're missing out fr. I say this as someone who also couldnt get into the game at first and now ive beaten it 5x with over 1000 hrs.
I agree. I was actually one of those people, I only played for an hour and I didnt feel the game maybe bec of the controls too, same with botw for the first 5 hours , its kinda boring but then it turned out fantastic. I love rpg and based on the reviews W3 is one of the best, so I just need more playing time, practice.
@@exterminateccp1642 the details and side stories in TW3 is incredible, like in White Orchard you choose to make a witcher potion to save the girl who got attacked by griffin when going out to meet her lover. I didn't know if she will be saved or not and I forgot about it until later on story, I met a soldier thanked me for saving his lover.
Spoil: At the start of the game you already met the final boss of the last DLC, I returned to that point as I remember that I asked that guy before.... and realized he never lied but his words guided me
Can confirm. Tried on PS4, played for an hour or two, never touched it again. But the Switch release invigorated my interest and I gave it another chance. Now I’m SO incredibly addicted, more addicted than I’ve been since BotW. It’s that good,
You can be 30 hours into the game and still be st the beginning lmao
Same, after 18 hours of play i finally understand how the game works and loving it till now, the first time i buy it because so many people say that it is a really great game. And i saw a 80 percent discount on steam and i buy it directly, the complete edition one. At that time i still play skyrim special edition mostly with mods. Then i started to play witcher 3 for an hour everyday. Cause i still dont feel it, understand it, dont like it. After 18 hours of gameplay, it become one of my finest game i have ever play in my life.
Finally a comment section with reasonable people, no fanboys
SEGA master system better gtfo Nintendo bitch. My console has blast processing making it run games like the ultra realistic Pac-Man at 10 frames a minute. Bet your console can’t do that ;)
Cesar Santivañez BOTW IS A BILLION TIMES BETTER!
@@isk47 thats exactly what real console fanboys always say in the comments lolol 😂😂😂
These are my 2 favourite games of the last 10 years so its hard to fan boy over one and not the other haha
Skyrim
I am just glad we have two of the best games ever made on one console :)
Ps4 has like from 3 to 6 of them
@@JozeManuLOL and your point is?
JozeManu LOL PC has like 20, but PC and PS4 are not handheld.
Wym? Skate 3 isn’t on the switch
There's also Skyrim, but still... It's incomplete without Xenoblade X, damn it! That's the best game I've ever played, personally.
Winner: ET for Atari
Do not make fun of E.T for Atari 2600. That was my childhood before Nintendo rescued me. Some random stranger gave me a 2600 and I make my mom buy me a new game every month. One of those months E.T was the game. I don't know why I'd picked it? I have never heard of ET. I remember falling into the pit time and time again and each and every time its a pain in the ass to get out but I was new to video games so I still enjoyed it. Now thinking back I'd throw that shit at a wall.
@@Light23K Sorry to hear your first game was ET :(
@@FirstNameLastName-oz5ij It's not really that bad as a game. It's considered the worst game ever because it almost Destroyed gaming industry. If we are Talking about absolute worst games :
-Plumbers Don't Wear Ties
- Crazy Bus
- CD-I Zelda
-Superman 64
-Big Rigs over the road racing
-Ride To Hell retribution
-Cheetah Man 2
-Action 52
you watch AVGN videos don't you? ;)
Yee
It always rubs me the wrong way when people say the lack of music is a bad thing in Breath of The Wild. Clearly those people don't realise the music was toned down on purpose so you can listen to the sounds of...well THE WILD, the clue is in the games name.
Made In Heaven also the music also represents how link is alone/lost as he explores hyrule
There are moments when this concept works perfectly, but so many scenes fall flat because of the lack of music. Why is there no majestic track when I'm riding across Hyrule field? Why is there no instrument in this game? Music was always an important element of Zelda games, some of them even had their name given in regards to an instrument. I offen enjoy tue minimalistic tunes of BOTW but climbing Hyrule Castle and suddenly enjoying the fantastic track just makes me wish that more areas featured their own songs.
Made In Heaven
You're right
But you can't be mad to zelda fans who hate it
Botw needed just a few more heroic bad ass tracks that every other zelda had
It was almost always way too calm imo
Its not bad,just could have been much more
Especially the epic trailer music not being in the actual game...what a shame
Exactly. It also perfectly fits the theme of the game, making breath of the wilds world feel all the more... well, breathtaking. The only thing the soundtrack really needs are more epic and badass music tracks for those epic and badass moments
Made In Heaven
Yep. It was clearly a design choice and they made the right one. Light ambient music works much better than overpowering orchestral pieces in an open world like that. You can actually feel and hear the wild of the world and just enjoy the subtle sounds of nature. Nintendo knew exactly what they were doing. They usually do.
To me they're both two halves of the perfect game, both succeed where the other doesn't quite get it right. Zelda has better gameplay mechanics, whereas The Witcher has a better storyline and sidequests.
Ryan blob Exactly!
True..i played zelda first and now started the witcher..and always think: how amazing it would be to have zeldas mechanics in here...
This is my opinion too!
Nah zelda has better story
@@jasonramjattan1063 I prefer BOTW over witcher anyday. But still,the story is better in Witcher. I liked the main idea in BOTW,but the memories felt very lackluster
I just finished Zelda BOTW yesterday and now im starting Witcher3.. All I can say is that both games are superb.... Doesn't matter which is better as long as we are enjoying the game
I agree what a great time to be a gamer many years ago I had little hope in gaming but oh my after playing both of these masterpieces I must say we are in a golden era once again
unknowning unknown 🤣 don’t know if you’re joking or not
I’m on the same both, I’m 5 hours into The Witcher 3, finished Breath of The Wild earlier. I bought the Witcher 3 on PC tho and it looks amazing
@This Is What Awesome Looks Like how
@This Is What Awesome Looks Like thats all
One tip: GET BOTH!
I knoowwww
It's a pro tip.
And they are even portable!!
Laughs in third world country.
@@flowerthencrranger3854 Third world country?
@@bhagenbeek
Switch games are expensive in places like Mexico, Brazil, South Africa, India,.
If you like exploring and puzzles: Breath of the Wild
If you like combat and intricate stories: The Witcher 3
EDIT: A lot of people pointed out that they think BOTW has the better combat mechanics, but that wasn't really my point. When you look at the pure content ratio of each aspect it is clear which game goes in which direction. So my point still stands.
Philly Grea not true
>TW3
>Good combat
>Good story
Pick one n1bb4
Ive heard that combat is way better in botw.
I haven't played the witcher 3 btw
The combat in Witcher 3 is boring and repetitive.
Zelda also has good combat
It was good to be back for a minute (or 20) to talk about these two games! Thanks for having me on! 😁
Welcome back! Will you be back for more videos in the future?
If u only had 60$ which one would u get ?
Hearts of Stone is the best story I've ever seen in any game.
I personally liked Blood and Wine
I preferred Olgierd's story more than Blood and Wine, ngl.
Also the Iris looked sick af with an orange rune
@@dvornikovalexei HOW MANY DLCs DOES THIS GAME HAVE?
hưng nguyễn Couldn’t agree more
@@JozeManuLOL 2. One is an extension of the main map and the other is a completely new, massive map.
I know BoTW gets a lot of criticism for its limited use of music but personally, I find this to be incredibly refreshing and makes the game much more enjoyable for long play sessions as the music adds an atmospheric presence that adds to nature of its gameplay (exploration) and momentary silences give the world a sense of realism missing in many games with continuous music
good games simply need the word "wild" in the title 😏
Zelda Gone Wild. Hrmmm...
indeed ;) Hmmm... :3
Red dead redemption (wild west)
That’s an F in the chat
and a ":"
I only just got a Switch and started playing Breath of the Wild. Once I started playing it, I knew it had to be game of the year.
Yeah i totally agree with you but if it was released the same year as the witcher 3 then it would lose in almost category.
A beautiful game, no doubt. My only issue is weapons breaking. I couldn’t get past that mechanic. Needless to say they made this Zelda title unnecessarily difficult.
Jason Gooden play it for 60 hours and tell me if you still feel that way. I got so bored by the end because there’s no progression in abilities like in other Zelda games. There’s just weapons with bigger numbers to kill the enemies with bigger numbers.
@@Faint366 I agree with you, I had a blast for the first half of the game, but then the other half was disappointingly boring since there was no more progression in weapons for me since I was basically endgame by then. There are some balancing issues, like in cooking for example, and a lack of progression systems later on in the game. There is little incentive to use other options of fighting when you already have a whole arsenal of weapons later in the game really destroying that feel of freedom when you can just use weapon to kill enemies, so weapon breakings was actually a good decision to add in imo. Once the progression system fails you realise how empty the other parts of botw are, like the story, dungeons and shrines for example. Hopefully with the sequel they could improve these issues, especially not trolling completionists with korok seeds, but for the first half of the game I would definitely rate it a 9.5/10.
Faint366 I’ve played the game for 350 hours and I still have a blast when I play it
Super cool. Can't wait for BOTW 2. I'll have to check out Witcher in the mean time.
Botw 2 VS Botw 1 I wonder witch one will win I think Botw will improve on Botw 1 and get a 99 on metacritic or 98
Redman Gaming , I see what you did there (or your just bad at spelling)
Botw 2 is base on nintendo switch,they will be a lot of improvements..while botw is a port on wii u for nsw
@@Rosie_Cozy I hope the frame rate is better.
I dont recommend witcher 3 on switch unless you are a real big fan of cd projekt red and want to give them extra money.
I first played it on ps4 then pc now switch.
I payed the full price for it and its too blurry to play on handheld (update 3.4).
Things keep popping up and the world with all its textures loads in front of you.
If you dont mind that its a real awesome game! Cant believe they managed to put it in this small Card.
Let’s wait for Geralt to be added on SMASH BROS. ULTIMATE and then we’ll see who truly wins. 🤘🏼
Sadly that’s not possible :( cuz Geralt is originally from a novel and not from a videogame
Just play Soul Caliber VI if you want that, provided you have the appropriate console to do so.
CD projekt actually said officially they would love to put him in smash after the switch release, so it's really not that unreasonable
Mrky McFly SETTLE IT IN SMASH
Both are amazing games and both should be played.
Agreed.
i tried witcher. thought it was pretty dull. zelda is much, much better.
@@sufficatingdreams5605 no it's not, in fact your choice can make everything different, and got a variety of ending as well
If you are new here some tips:
Equip yourself with swallow potion during combat.
Rest/meditation will replenish your option automatically.
Control your opponent mind if they're tough to beat!
Fast travel at signpost.
Call your horse at anywhere at all.
Witcher 3 is the best game that I've been waiting after BoTW cuz after BotW other open world games doesn't interest me anymore except Witcher III
@@ranmouri5648 breath of the wild is the better game, hell I'll even go as far as to say link to the past on the super Nintendo is better than the witcher 3.
@@mr_m4613 you are wrong, I too loved Botw since 2017 played it two time already with the expansion but dont always statisfy with your game cuz it will not grow further, there are still too many can be improved in BOTW as well, don't get carried away like Nintendo after winning GOTY they rushed into releasing the expansion for champions of ballad and what do we get? A motorcycle!
After clearing BOTW I feel ackward playing another open world games until The Witcher III came on switch, simply bcuz it was the one that I need to play after BOTW. Both world are alive and feels with secrets to discover, more importantly how you can interact with the world itself
I wasn't aware that people compared these two games.
Honestly, with how much sex, nudity, blood, and general violence is in Witcher 3, I was kinda surprised to hear it was releasing on Switch.
The games that are made by Nintendo are not the same than the ones who are brought to the actual console
Switch has plenty of Mature rated games on it, most of the people who own a Switch are adults, lol.
TXF *cough Bayo *cough
Rated m for mature on all consoles
Seen lust for darkness? XD
Zelda Breath of the Wild and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt are both my favorite games!
Well can you pet dogs in the Witcher 3?
If not then they're both trash.
You can pet dragons in the Witcher 3
AVM3798 nahhhhh....if u can’t pet dogs it’s trash
You can pet dogs in Assassin’s Creed Rogue and that game is as trash as it gets
@@schedule1824 Even as a joke that really hurts me lol
You can pet yennefer and triss lol..
I didn’t play the Witcher 1 or 2, or read any of the books. I didn’t play the past 3 or 4 Zelda games and typically say I “don’t like” the Zelda series.
I have about 250 hours invested between these two games. Truly remarkable to win over someone like me who really *shouldn’t* care, but gets sucked in anyway.
I like how Nintendo put witch 3 on switch knowing there are some interesting cutscenes 😏
Witcher*
I've seen some questionable games in the eshop
Nintendo don't care about nudity or violence in third party games anymore, their own developed games....that's a different matter.
Nintendos the least censorious out of all the big 3 in modern times
Nintendo have changed. Blood, gore, nudes are all welcome now.
Imagine a game that combines the detailed world, combat, and freedom of BOTW with the story and quests of TW3...
That would belong to the upcoming breath of the wild 2
@@Sympyismoon yeah I really hope nintendo does that.
Two amazing options, so similars and so differents, masterpieces, both deserve to be played
The captions said BROTH of the wild and now I want to make some
Lol sounds good,
make it a bone broth of the wild for the healthy collagen.
Add some sugar
i really dont understand why people hate the broken weapons in BOTW. its a great thing to make u explore more
Likom People like having their hand held in games rather than facing difficult situations
@@25_jean_dark_52 yeah that is why people sucks at playing harder games
Facts! And you always get new weapons anyway so it doesn’t matter if weapons break. Having the master sword helps too.
@@likom9813 your comment makes 0 sense. Not liking the weapon mechanics in botw dosen't = ppl like being handheld or suck at harder games. Stop with that bs statement.
Broken weapons in botw is good idea. Ever play rpg with millions combination of weapon stat but in the end players only use the best set available. While the other weapons just garbages on the road.
I've come here to validate my already existing opinion, just like everybody else here.
I think I like the Witcher 3 more. A good story just really emotionally satisfies you. I have read the books so it does add more weight, but even then the voice acting and script are so well done. BOTW is not a bad or even good game by any means. It is a great game for different reasons, but it does not have as much emotional depth. I think with BOTW 2 or whatever it may be they can reconcile between these to give both good gameplay and a great heartfelt story.
Especially the sex scene that the selling point on this game
@@AJ-dx6bn 💀💀💀😂
Gameplay > Story
@@ihatefanserviceanime364 which is why witcher 3 is better
@@ihatefanserviceanime364 witcher got it all lol and its not even close bro. im big zelda fan, i played twilight princes,windwaker,skyward sword etc. heck even tok connot be compared to witcher 3.
VERY VERY VERY GOOD VIDEO,
You explain all very well, and make the video very interesting too.
I love both games...
Thanks for the vid!
I needed this video so much. I absolutely agree with you!
Weapons breaking is not a flaw. It creates a necessary variety of gameplay and fighting. If not for breaking weapons why would you pay attention to the other 99% of weapons left in Hyrule.
I just wish the rarest weapons would not break though. It is very frustrating especially in the first few hours when you are up against a high leveled enemy and all of a sudden your weapon breaks leaving you vulnerable.
^ that would defeat the purpose though. If some weapons did break and others didn't, you would just blitz it to the unbreakable ones and be done
The element of breaking weapons makes you second guess enemy encounters. Where as in the Witcher you can fight enemy’s more often before having your weapons break and needing repairs. I’d say there two different elements one not being better then the other. I do wish you got things from enemy’s in botw like rupees or some incentive to actually want to attack them besides possibly stronger weapons.
I never really liked weapon degradation in games. If I get a cool new weapon, I just want to use it. I can understand the decision to add it but it really ruins the feeling of excitement whenever you get a new weapon because you know it’s just gonna break after 5 swings.
Toledo Christian Matthew lol that’s the point of them, item management is an integral part of the game and if you leave the wrong weapons and pick up the wrong ones, then that’s your fault not the games.
I just finished playing witcher 3 for the first time and i have to say BOTW is not my favorite anymore, its now my second favorite. I love both games dearly but the witcher 3 wins all the way. only complaint is i was wishing geralt could climb and glide like link then the game would be perfect. in the skillega mountains for example was missing link as a character to control since geralt would easily slide down mountains and hill tops, it was so frustrating.
Did you play on your switch? What it feels like?because i'm going to buy it if the games work pretty well on switch
@@kevinagriva9948 i played the switch version and its honestly worth it if you have a busy schedule and have less time to play. If i had more free time i would buy ps4 version. But a mild downgrade in resolution doesnt hurt this master piece :)
@@kevinagriva9948 I own the switch version and honestly I don't mind the graphical downgrade as it allows me to play the game even if I'm not home which is very often
i think im going to play BOTW first before the Witcher 3, I might not appreciate BOTW when i play them vice versa
@@heindiez thats a good idea. I played botw first also. Its an amazing game and definite must play. Its another game you can literally lose hours just exploring alone :)
Great video, currently I own both games on Switch, and love both for various different aspects of each game. However if I really had to pick one as my favorite, it will have to be Zelda Breath of the Wild, the main reason been Zelda overall just feel more whimsical and relaxing to me, this is a more personal thing though, never the less both are great games to play on the go~
What do you mean breaking weapons = what botw lacks?
Imagine botw, but without weapon durability? It doesn’t work, it won’t be as good.
Weapon breaking is one of the main reasons why we keep on exploring to get better weapons. And that’s also the reason why we sometimes run away from enemies or trying to kill enemies with creative ways like rolling the big boulders or using magnesis.
It’s fun.
And it helps us get better with other weapons and adapt with changes.
I haven't played BotW as I don't have a console for the last few generations, but I think weapon durability does add different elements to adapt to. It can be good or bad depending on the game, but sounds like it is a good strategic thing for the BotW. I think the way The Witcher 3 does it works well as repairs provides a good money sink, and weapons can be switched easily as there is no shortage of finding them, and repairing or using a weaker weapon is a good choice to have available.
The lack of an ability to repair weapons that you really like, I believe, hurt the game. I would explore to find a great weapon and NEVER want to use it because I didn't want it to break, but because of that I never really got to enjoy it. Permabreaking with no option to repair prior to the break penalized the desire to search for great weapons and use them.
If the durability was less harsh the it would’ve been great the weapons just break to fast
The issue isn't them being breakable. The issue is them being weak as paper, and there not being a way to craft and repair, and upgrade.
I loved BoTW but didn’t enjoy the weapon durability. Not knowing which weapons to use on which enemies for fear of breaking them and not being able to replace said weapons wasn’t fun for me. And a lot of the time my tactic was using bombs and getting enemies to chase me.
Don’t get me wrong, I LOVED the game, but this one aspect was the biggest drawback for me (well, maybe the lack of traditional dungeons and variety of dungeon bosses too)
The wrong questions are being asked here the real question is who would win in a fight
Aaron9 I think peter from family man would win
I think link would win
Ivan Perez 🤣 no chance
EChicken 54 who has no chance, link?
Ivan Perez yeah🤣
4:30 - just a fact check. Breath of the Wild is NOT just 61 square kilometres, it's 360. Breath of the Wild's map is about three times the size of the Witcher 3. It also has significantly more vertical space, making it even larger than a width times height map area would suggest.
You haven't played TW3 have you... it has three huge areas, three maps. Instead of fanboy-ing at it, you should play it.
@krono069 Except you're doing the exact same thing, hypocrite. BOTW has objectively a larger map. Measurements have already been done, and the above comment is just reiterating that. Quit fanboy-ing, and look into facts.
@@heckingbamboozled8097 >> Google it genius. Holy crap. BotW fanboys are the worst. It's not as big as W3 with all maps combined and that's not including the DLC! How about YOU take your OWN advice and look it up before you fanboy out with your stupid little Link avatar. lol
World - Botw i agree with the physics and climbing
Story - hands down its witcher 3, botw story is too straight forward
Gameplay - botw simply because of the combination of different element like physics, weather and etc in the battle, witcher 3 combat can be repetative especially if you stick to one style like pure sword or pure element
Sidequests - witcher 3, no need to explain!
Bosses - witcher 3 for variety
Controls - botw, complicated but super satisfying. Witcher can be dull when it comes to controls.
Music - witcher 3, their musics can hype your adventure and adds to the mood of the world
But the point here is botw and witcher 3 are 2 very enjoyable game. Spent 100+ hours on both of them.
Zelda BOTW is easily one of my favorite games of all time. I’ve always been a fan of these types of games.
Before that it was oblivion and Skyrim I sunk many hours into. But after playing BOTW and finishing the game to 80%-100% five times, I can say it’s my favorite game of all time. It has its flaws but the life of this game is fantastic.
I’m saying this as someone who has never played a Zelda game before BOTW.
The Witcher 3 is also a great gale but I’ve only put about 10 hrs into it. And the switch port is my first time playing it..
So far I think the gameplay mechanics leaves something to be desired but the story and the monsters, and all the characters seems to be great. I’m looking forward to playing more of it and I really appreciate the realism in this game. It makes all the fantasy/ Sci-Fi Have a real aspect.
Yeah the witcher 3 is best played alone with headphones after the bloody barron quest the game gets better and better just saying the family matters quest is amazing just put more time into it
@@tennisthelegend I really hope because I’m truly enjoying this game, but the family matters quest is really testing my patience.
World- Witcher
Story- witcher
Gameplay- BOTW
Side quests- witcher
Bosses- witcher
Controls- BOTW
Music- Witcher
Was kinda disappointed with BOTW bosses
Subhodeep Das yeah me too I always found them really easy except lynels whereas in witcher 3 I find them not only more difficult but also more unique
Witcher 3 has voice acting which is Zelda doesn't. But both are amazing for me. Can't decide.
WalkingHumanGarbage id say witcher because it has a much more fleshed out world and better combat
Tigar0411 Arkham
In actual ways they can be compared. RPG vs Adventure game.
World (Design) - BOTW and it shouldn't even be argued.
Story - Subjective. Writing goes to The Witcher 3 though it is worth mentioning that the story of BOTW is optional. The Witcher 3 isn't.
Gameplay - BOTW
Bosses - Witcher 3
Controls - BOTW
Music - Subjective. Use of music probably works better in BOTW's case though being an open world game and all but they are too different to compare.
There isn't a whole lot that can be compared between the two games fairly but if we take each into consideration Breath of The Wild ends up being a superior open world action adventure game than The Witcher 3 as an open world action RPG. Since the open world and action aspects are clearly in Breath of The Wild's favor as far as actual game design is concerned. And both do amazing jobs at the last aspect. RPG for TW3. Adventure for BOTW.
Sounds like Witcher is more Lord of the rings than Zelda.
Witcher is far more involved than Zelda. Very much more an RPG, whereas BoTW is more action adventure.
To fully appreciate Witcher I feel that you need to fully experience and immerse yourself in the whole story, which means if you have got 100 odd hours spare, you won’t appreciate, whereas Zelda is very much a game you can easily dip in and out of in intervals and go explore the beautiful open world.
For the record, have only just started Witcher III on Switch and barely a few hours in - it’s crafted MAGNIFICENTLY from the point of view of a story but can already tell BoTW is more accessible and more fun to play - the joy of Witcher lies in unravelling the story, whereas the joy of BoTW is in the world that’s been crafted to fully explore.
Witcher has a more Game of thrones vibe to it
Well, Witcher 3 in (my opinion) is far more similar to Shrek than LoR.
@@flowerthencrranger3854 not a fan huh?
@@easy3088
I mean, I watched the movies and I am reading Fellowship of The Ring, but I do not consider myself a LoR fan.
Great video, man! Very reasonable and thought through.
Good to hear you again, Joseph!
Music of breath of the wild is underrated. It completely fits it's world.
I love it
it does, but its hardly underrated.. its just not as great as in other games with world class game music
@@Zoyar i don't say it is best.i just say it is great.
I 100% disagree :D
Music was the greatest disappointment for me in Zelda BOTW, esppecially after remembering awesome Zelda Ocarina of Time's music
Use of music is pure art in breath of the wild you just have to think about it and go deaper than „yeah there is not enough“
Anyone else find the shrines to be extremely underrated?
Good to have you back you American besturd!
Even if it's just for this video!
I am plesantly suprised for how close this was, which makes me extremely hyped for how amazing BotW 2 will be!
I work as a music producer and mixing engineer, so i always listen carefully all music and sound fx in every game I play.
For my personal opinion, the music point is going for both the titles because how the music is treated in relation to the story and the gameplay.
In Breath of the Wild, I found they’re artistic choice perfect. You have few tracks going on so you’re mostly focusing on the natural environment. But than the music pops up and when it does, it feel so good, so precious, enhancing the moment perfectly, and that’s because the game wake you up from the habit of not to ear it.
It serves your senses.
In The Witcher 3 the music is used in a more “canon” way, giving every place and situation a clear identity, and the composition level is stunning. Every track is memorable and perfectly placed, just think about how beautifully is riding over the Skeillege Islands... The Witcher world is so stunning also because of this.
So, both games use music for serving 100% the purpose of the gameplay, the identity and ofc, the world surrounding the player. And that’s why for me they both deserve the music point!
Sorry for the long comment and my poor English grammar ehehehe, thx
(P.s. I totally agree with you in any other point. Nice video and nice examination!)
Lmao literally all of the witcher soundtrack is in D minor
I actually really enjoy the breaking weapons in BOTW. Gives fights an added layer of strategy
Lou Ryan just gonna disagree with you. I understand tree branches and such, but swords and clubs should have way more uses before they break. I prefer repairing weapons than to have them copied (or whatever botw has). Inventory management shouldn’t be that tedious.
@@midnightfury4584 but like after you expand your inventory weapons no longer become an issue
You are a suck person
wtf kind of comment is that?? LoL
Lou Ryan I just avoided most fights because the reward for winning the fight was just one more royal sword to replace the one you broke killing the enemies.
To this day I listen to the Witcher 3 soundtrack in my car whenever I get tired of the radio haha .. tbh I love both these games so so much and wanted to make a video similar to this because I do love both games very very much but genuinely felt insanely sucked into The Witcher 3 zelda always holds a special place in my heart and I loved Botw but something about Witcher 3 just captivated me - nicely done video comparing the two(:
Radio music is trash these days nothing beats the beautiful melodic artistic music from video games
@tom gu NieR Automatta is another one of my favorite games as well as one of my favoriteee soundtracks 😍😍
For me Breath of the wild is the best game of the history, I mean... We are talking about videogames and the gameplay, mechanics and FUN, that's why I choose Zelda games, if I wanna watch stories is better to play a movies or tv series
If The Witcher 3 uses
the same art-style, it'll run better.
I prefer BoTW. 😭♥️
The 200 hours I’ve put into botw are 200 amazing hours I’ll never forget. I haven’t played Witcher 3 so I can’t really form an opinion but the game looks amazing am I’m gonna give it a shot
@Mus-taarD pourquoi tu dis ça : chacun ses goûts !
Great video...great script good analysis...enjoyed both games and i have to say i agree with every point given on both games 👌👌👌
Watching this makes me wonder how the playing experience would change if you could swap the dynamic soundtracks.
The Witcher 3 doesn’t have daddy Sidon
It has daddy Geralt, and some other baddies. Both games worth it
But BOTW has no Sex scene with Shani...
It has sex scenes
dani n Zelda doesn’t have daddy geralt and uncle vezimir
That’s good, cause if it did I’d cut him in half and use him as a trophy as a warning to other mediocre characters
Another interesting category: replay value. While both games will feel different with multiple playthroughs, BotW will only change depending in what you're decide to do first. The decisions made in The Witcher go deeper and will present you with alternate endings to quests and stories. For me, the option to choose between Triss or Yennefer for romance was enough to warrant a second playtrough.
^not even to mention the ways of doing (SPOLIER) who you want to rule THAT country... or how you want the main ending to be. Add to that Blood and wine, and ive had like 3 playthroughs and are all fantastic. Replay value i would say goes to witcher. But.... you can always keep playing BOTW. More stuff to do in the game world, imo
Was all of this footage captured on switch?
Idk why, but everytime i play witcher 3, everything feel so small. Like everytime i fight monsters, the map shrunk. Or maybe its just me.
What i really hate in botw is the enemy variety. It makes me bored fighting the same monster again and again. The game only chance the colour of the monster. I hope there are more enemy types in botw 2, like the witcher did.
George Massora
Yea. I hated all those small copy/paste points of interest in The Witcher 3 myself and the way they left the marks by default of each one before you even discover them. They both still have some things that can definitely be improved in future titles.
its not so different from the repetitiveness of korock seeds and same monsters defending a chest. witcher at least put a diary that you can read to get immersed in the story of what happened at the ? location. zelda is just monsters waiting to be killed. @@gamersinger5118
Gwent is amazing ,so much strategy for such a simple game.
You are wrong about witcher 3 , yes it gives you the option to switch off it's marker but it is not playable in this state. One man in a side quest tells you about where to go by stating location's geography. But when i reach that location. I find that location is completely different from what he says. For example he state that their is a board which tell you where to go but it is not located there.
So if I had to pick one which should I get ?
I'm a Nintendo / Zelda fan, but I think TW3WH deserves more credit, BOTW lacks lots of details compared to The Witcher
*Which ever game wins between the two... The real winner will always be the gamers to have such great games*
i think you should've included the interaction (eg user interface, micro interaction, inventory layout design, maps, etc) to the comparison
What I hate most in witcher 3 is that there's a lot of question marks on the map. You can take a look at different stuff to find or fight monsters on these question marks.
This is good but however, it gets rid of that exploration and suprise factor to it as the question marks doesn't show up when just running around without having to open up the map to mark the waypoint to these question marks.
It could've been done better if they just didn't show the question marks on the map. This way there's that sense of adventure, exploration and rmrandomly finding stuff when just exploring and roaming around randomly
I don’t agree with the soundtrack one. Botw has an amazing soundtrack system. It has a lot of “invisible sound mechanics” for example the combat music changes based on the enemy, but not enough to make you notice, but enough to make you not start to get irritated by it, also when fighting, when you land a hit it actually plays the hit sound to the closest beat in the song, making it satisfying. The soundtrack seemingly changes during night, because it was recorded in a studio using real instruments, not digitally. There are a lot of sound tracks for the game. Told me you leave a village or a town you will most likely hear the wild soundtrack kick in, but what’s cool about it is that it actually changes a lot of times, making random notes and creating unique combos. The music is amazing and the fact that it sometimes doesn’t play is a good thing, because the sound design is amazing in this game
Nailed it
It may be good but isn't anywhere close to tw3.
@@Based1889 Just your opinion
@@ihatefanserviceanime364 i don't even like witcher 3 now lmao, its an ass game.
Both are masterpiece
I agree with every category other than music , the music makes the world so much more immersive for me
This gon be some heated debate
The amount of times he used the work "organic"
Namco, just put soulcalibur 6 on the switch and we can make this happen. Link vs Geralt
Anthony Harris for as cool as that’d be, he can’t be in. Characters need to have originated from a video game to be in Smash while Geralt is from a novel.
Soul Calibur 6 on the other hand...now this, I like
@@appl3s0ft Surely that's quite ignorant as they could of easily added The Dragon born and Gerald lol
Great video, I've played 200+ hours on BOTW, and loved it. And yesterday I began The Witcher 3 for my first ever play through. After seeing this video, I'm even more excited to get into it and explore the world of Geralt.
I wonder if this is gonna remade when TotK is gonna come out
You know, I'm getting SICK of people harshing on BotW's music. Just because it's not EVERYWHERE doesn't mean it's bad. Not only that but BotW has more variety in it's music. Also, Witcher's music applies to a specific tone. So, sorry but Witcher should get the point for music.
Chris Griffin It’s a minimalistic OST, it’s supposed to be a substitute for the world & its’ atmosphere, not some grandiose, orchestrated Hans Zimmer shit!
More variety? Lmao fuck off the music is so unmemorable and trash in botw
@@CrowofYharnam the music being lowkey is the whole point but i guess smooth brains cant comprehend that
@@kenpresbi you're a child if you play zelda
I think the music design choice for Zelda BOTW is logic as part of the spirit the game wants to convey. I think it did not make much sense to compare them in this cathegory
Me too
I think you should’ve included sound design with the music category, the level of detail in botw sounds are incredible. There’s a great video by the youtuber Scruffy that explains it all.
The witcher 3 would win the sound of the forests are amazing the wind howling is so beautiful
Why does Ciri have the catschool medallion of a witcher at 8:44 ? She was trained at Kaer Morhen under Geralt was she not?
The physics of BoW might be better, but W3's world is literal art. I dare you be a be in grimy Vellen and then not have your breath taken away by a golden sunset as you see how a little light change reveals its beauty.
The arts from BoTW
are so pleasing to the eyes. The ones
from TW3 are too striking. It hurts my
eyes when I PLAY it.
I remember being genuinely shocked when rain didn't put out fire in TW3 and that my torch stayed lit even when it was storming. Idk what the point of the weather was if it didn't really effect anything. And I know for a fact there's at least a freezing buff of sorts in TW3, not sure why he didn't get cold in extreme weather outside of that world overtaken by the White Frost. The only place I've found so far where it matters outside of that is a few of the decoctions + potions which have special effects during certain weather.... but I live absolutely fine without them, I only use a few select ones and so it's still pointless to me xD
(That said... the workd and story and how it firs the world is a BIG thing for me. That's why I ended up preferring TW3 even though I played it after BotW. I really got into the world that was set up and really got my teeth into characters, so to speak. I loved the dynamics between them and I enjoyed that gray area the game constantly put me in. I'm the type to pour hours and hours into just reading everything in the game available, from random books lying around to bestiary entries. I did the same thing with the Wizard's Companion in Ni No Kuni, I swear half my hours in the game was just me reading things xD Buuuut that's my tangent over)
One thing 4 sure 4 me
When ever u find a kool new wps
The hype is lose when u know how quickly it can break
Does take the found out of finding loot
Story and side quests of the Witcher, Exploration/physics/music of zelda, and the combat of Dark Souls. That would be my perfect game.
YES YES YES
@SmokeSesh520 I will almost certainly be buying it (Miyazaki FromSoft titles usually are guarantee buys for me). I'm definitely eager to see what the gameplay looks like when they reveal more information.
I think the music is perfect in The Witcher 3, but I agree that the combat could be improved. Love Dark Souls, though I wonder if it would get tedious if the Witcher 3 had such a combat style as the game is just so vast with so many enemies to kill.
Witcher 3 music is 10x better.
Zelda only has a few piano strokes lmao
You should do mario odessey vs a hat in time
Well i just LOVE both games so i cant even compare them! I love to be alive in a time where both these game exist.
If the story category is my number one attraction. Are there games you would recommend for a new switch owner?
I should say I’ve played the Witcher multiple times and I plan on playing breath of the wild already.
Zelda is an action and puzzle game with rpg elements
The Witcher is an rpg with action and puzzle elements.
Witcher 3 has adult contents.
Lol botw had the worst puzzles of any zelda game I've played. Only a few were good, the rest were easy and unsatisfying. Skyward sword had the best puzzles.
@@farisakhtar4824 They sacrificed the puzzles for a more interactive world.
@@tyrael43 that's an excuse, Nintendo could have delayed the game to give more time to other aspects if they wanted to. Shigeru Miyamoto has a famous quote about how a delayed game is eventually good, but a rushed game is bad forever. However, they had a deadline though for the switch release date which was important. They had to sell the console and obviously the launch games were a big part of that so they needed botw ready for then.
@@farisakhtar4824 They still had enough time to completely remove the dual-screen features from the game sadly.
I do think you disregarded the fact that BOTW has a ton of secrets. The story might not be good, but one of the things I found so great about it it's the fact that you can only imagine what happened to the dozens of abandoned villages, statues, temple-like structures and so. I think it gives it a different feeling to its own story.
The best thing about Witcher 3 is even a corpse lying on a open field has a story to tell
@@dvornikovalexei Ive actually never played Witcher 3 haha, I cant wait to play it in my Switch!
I actually really dislike that about BotW. It takes hardly any effort to just copy/paste a few broken buildings and say “oooooh what happened here? How mysterious! It’s totally just as interesting after we do the same thing 5000 times right?” The fans are the ones putting in the legwork to make those areas interesting because the game doesn’t give us any actual information about them.
Ya there are tons of areas to find in BotW, but what can you actually discover? A shrine? A treasure chest with some rock salt inside? Another Knight’s Sword? Cool... Think back to ALttP when you could actually find completely unique items by exploring hard to reach areas. What does BotW have that’s even close to that?
Faint366 you can explore Hyrule castle and find both Zelda’s and King Roam’s diary to see further into the lore. The story is filled with little nods to what had happen that the developers put in, not the fans
What's the song around 2:45 through 3:00?
why is music a category? I just find it odd since graphics and sound isn't it.
This is a tough one cuz this two are the best game there is, however for the Expansion and DLC I got to give to Witcher III
Everything else is cool with these two simply cuz the world is alive and full with secrets to discover! Congrats both!
Both of these games are masterpieces, in the truest sense of the word. Idk if I could even pick which I enjoyed more. They’re both excellent, each in their own way with their own strong points and weak points. When a game is as good as these, it’s like comparing infinity to infinity. Which is greater? Even mathematics itself cannot tell.
There are 7 Battles here.
BOTW vs Witcher 3
BATTLE #1: Game World - 3:00
BATTLE #2: Story - 6:51
BATTLE #3: Game Play - 9:41
BATTLE #4: Side Quests - 12:35
BATTLE #5: Bosses - 14:39
BATTLE #6: Controls - 16:23
BATTLE #7: Music - 17:50
Wrong I know the blight ganons but you have to give it to master Kogah the yiga boss I found him really fun
Man I'm torn between these two...I like the playstyle, physics and simplicity in Zelda but I also like the story, challenge and making your own story in Witcher. To be honest no matter which one I choose I'll be busy for quite a while before I'll able to afford to buy the other one as well lol
Despite this fair comparison , These 2 games are my best game of all time , actually they are my top 2 .
BotW would be in my best games of all time if not for some serious issues I have with it. As it stands, Xenoblade X is my top game.
-Weapons are too fragile and there's no way to repair/craft them.
-Side quests, aside from maybe one or two, are terrible.
-I wish there was more to do with the "new champions", especially Teba. Teba's my favorite Zelda character.
-Motion control rotation in shrines was horrendous.
-Korok Seeds were a bad idea. Makes 100%ing very discouraging.
-I wish photography was more rewarding.
-Best way to get arrows is to abuse the guaranteed diamond at Satori(?) Mountain, sell it, and buy arrows.
-No way to properly craft armor.
I enjoyed this video guys. Thanks. 👍 I am still torn to pieces over whoch one to keep playing. I am playing Wither 3. Botw and also Sekiro at the moment. I can not stick to just one and its taking me forever to beat all 3. 🤣🤣
I found Witcher too difficult to understand. The simplicity of BOTW makes it more appealing. Witcher 3 had me so confused and frustrated. I didn't know if I was doing things right. Also, mixing potions? Taking elixirs? How do you beat a boss if the game doesn't teach you how to do these properly? At lest with zelda it's easy to know when you cook something how it will turn out. Maybe I missed something in the Witcher tutorial, or maybe the game falls short of teaching and it's not my fault. Or, on another level, maybe Witcher 3 is simply just not for casual gamers like myself. I bought Witcher 3 digitally on my switch so there's no returning it. I will give it a shot later, but for now, I'm way happier with BOTW. and that is from a huge Witcher book and TV show fan.....