Spain update - Trouble is Brewing

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 04. 2024
  • Spain news update and fugitive from Spanish justice and troublemaker Carles Puigdemont says that it's time to 'finish the job' and again calls for independence from Spain.
    Become a member to get access to perks and help me make more content:
    / @spainspeaks
    Great mobile plans for English speakers: www.lobster.es/referral/?refe...
    Support: ► Patreon / spainspeaks
    Support: ► Buy me a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/spainspeaks
    Support: ► Merchandise: spain-speaks.creator-spring.com
    Support: ► PayPal: www.paypal.com/donate/?cmd=_s...
    Please comment and subscribe to this channel.
    I film my videos on #lumix cameras and lenses and sometimes on an iPhone.
    I also create content for curious.com. Take my lessons +20,000 more @Curious on anything from tennis, to test prep, to tango. As my student, get 20% OFF! curious.com?coupon=curiousteacher20&ref=iGRfmw4X6Wg

Komentáře • 112

  • @mattinmalaga
    @mattinmalaga Před měsícem +26

    Give Cataluña their independence if they don't want to be Spanish, providing they lose everything Spanish including their passports, DNI's, driving licences, pensions, EU membership, the Euro, free movement in the Schengen area etc, etc, etc! 🇪🇦

    • @HubbaHubba64
      @HubbaHubba64 Před měsícem +5

      Do you think the EU Dictatorship will reduce Spain's membership fees and give more financial support if Catalonia did get independence

    • @mattinmalaga
      @mattinmalaga Před měsícem +9

      @@HubbaHubba64 legally they should as contributions are based on GDP, but as the EU is a fascist dictatorship it's doubtful! My point was, as others have pointed out in the comments, I don't think the separatistas of Cataluña have thought about the consequences of independence, they can't have their cake and eat it, out of Spain then out of the EU, simple!

    • @billlynn8256
      @billlynn8256 Před měsícem

      still mad about Brexit Boris?@@HubbaHubba64

    • @HubbaHubba64
      @HubbaHubba64 Před měsícem +3

      @@mattinmalaga The EU Dictatorship will give an independent Catalonia all the help they need as it will mean another star on it's blue rag and can boast about how big it's getting .

    • @mattinmalaga
      @mattinmalaga Před měsícem +5

      @@HubbaHubba64 with Puigdemont's anti-immigration policies technically an independent Cataluña wouldn't meet the criteria required for EU membership, I think he's forgotten that there are stringent requirements in place and that all other member states have to vote on their accession to the EU

  • @neilg4208
    @neilg4208 Před měsícem +10

    Catalonia won't have independence: they'll have about 80% of their laws made for them by the EU.
    Spain, of course, can't properly oppose the Catalan independentists because Spain too has 80% of its laws made by Brussels. Madrid isn't the master in its own house and can't admit to it's own people how much of their sovereignty has been handed to the EU.
    And so it can't fight Catalan independentists because it can't admit to its own people how Spain has given its democracy away to the EU.
    Puigdemont knows this.
    Poor Spain: it gained it's democracy back after Franco only to then give it away to the EU

    • @EddyBlacks
      @EddyBlacks Před měsícem

      This is utter horse shit.

    • @subcitizen2012
      @subcitizen2012 Před měsícem +4

      Well, you're wrong and misinformed, but that's okay. Hopefully you figure it out and can contribute meaningfully to reality some day.

    • @neilg4208
      @neilg4208 Před měsícem

      @@subcitizen2012 You mean that Spain's laws aren't being made by Brussels?
      How do you work that out?
      Perhaps you could consider the meaning of the word 'reality'. Try to do so without personal abuse. Can you do that?

    • @neilg4208
      @neilg4208 Před měsícem +1

      ​@@EddyBlacksPlease say in what way? You think that the EU doesn't make Spanish laws?
      Spain accepts that they do. The EU knows that. Read up on 'competences' and Directives

    • @beccymalloy
      @beccymalloy Před 29 dny +1

      Well..poor Spain to a point - perhaps dealing more harshly with their corrupt politicians might help..

  • @therealkakitron
    @therealkakitron Před měsícem +5

    Hey Stu, since you spoke about Spanish airports being strict about liquids.. they should also get in the program of recognizing silent disability lanyards (the flower ones) for people who are disabled like airports in the UK and other countries. We had a horrible time at the Málaga Airport with our 5 year old autistic daughter when we visited last month.

  • @RichD2024
    @RichD2024 Před měsícem +8

    The whole Catalan independence movement seems poorly thought out to me. They won't be able to join the EU and thus will need to make their own currency that is bound to be highly devalued, which will create a massive inflation crisis for the people of Catalan. I've yet to hear a good reason from a Catalonian for their independence. Be careful what you wish for Catalonians, independence doesn't always go the way you think, see just about every former Spanish colony. Cuba is a failed state, Puerto Rico is begging the US to make it a state, Argentina, Guam, I could go on.

    • @dancarden72
      @dancarden72 Před měsícem

      Catalonia reminds me of El Salvador. Financial independence is achievable. Maybe they will take the bitcoin route or return to gold. there are options beyond bank debt. Many people are running from the banks now. Countries included. The $ is dead.

    • @simonchilli2088
      @simonchilli2088 Před měsícem +1

      A good warning for the Scots there mate.

    • @RichD2024
      @RichD2024 Před měsícem +1

      @@simonchilli2088 yes indeed.

  • @sweetmelon149
    @sweetmelon149 Před měsícem +5

    If Catalonia becomes independent, PSOE, main party in coalition government, will never able to form a central government again in Spain. That is according to results in current elections. It is suicidal for PSOE and their future.

  • @erikawallace3404
    @erikawallace3404 Před měsícem +12

    If Puigdemont wants Catalonia to become independent, he should be honest of what does really means and produce some clear answers to many of doubts which rise with such an idea. Remanining un the EU? 3rd world country? Real Catalan industry/businesses? Health? Retirement pensions? And so many other points which have never been answered. Catalonia needs a white book and this has been never been deakt with. All are emotions and thus nonsense in my opinion.

    • @richardcooley9730
      @richardcooley9730 Před měsícem

      Puidgmont has done more than anyone to ensure that Catalonia can never be succesful. His efforts in 2017 ,eant that the two banls and all financial companies moved their headquarters out of the region. No banks, no insurance, no EU membership ( the EU has made that clear) and all those shiny new startups owing money to the EU through startup loans. It won't happen.

    • @ChristineFisher123
      @ChristineFisher123 Před měsícem +2

      Politicians lied to the British people about Brexit. Now we are suffering.

    • @erikawallace3404
      @erikawallace3404 Před měsícem

      @@ChristineFisher123 How true! Unfortunately, the Brexit campaign was directed by emotional lies which is always a highly explosive mixture with a Populist such as Farage.

    • @d.tr6176
      @d.tr6176 Před měsícem +2

      @@ChristineFisher123 Remind me what good being in the EU did for you. I don't recall.

    • @junehitchcock170
      @junehitchcock170 Před měsícem +2

      @@ChristineFisher123covid cause much of the pain.

  • @paulgilliland2992
    @paulgilliland2992 Před měsícem +4

    Dublin airport security staff are the absolute worst on the planet.

    • @grahamestrathern7924
      @grahamestrathern7924 Před 29 dny +3

      You have obviously not been through Terminal 5 at Heathrow. Totally staffed by people that English is not their first language. Rude, and aggressive. I was part of a large group who went through different lanes. Same experience for all of us. At one point I was beginning to wonder if I had got off at the wrong airport, in the wrong country.

  • @user-cb9ke4xs3y
    @user-cb9ke4xs3y Před měsícem +4

    Catalonia will not be able succeed unless it solves its water shortage issue. As Mark Twain is believed to have once said, “whiskey is for drinking, water is for fighting.”

    • @neilg4208
      @neilg4208 Před měsícem

      The EU bans the building of new reservoirs

  • @antifugazi
    @antifugazi Před měsícem +24

    If independence is anything like what's happening here in the UK with Brexit then for the love of god just leave it as it is, absolutely nothing gained whatsoever by us leaving the EU

    • @neilg4208
      @neilg4208 Před měsícem +1

      Britain now has the power to make it's own laws again...by MPs elected by the citizens and who can be sacked by the citizens.
      That's the essence of democracy. In Spain they even have to submit their departmental budgets to Brussels for approval or rejection. Why do you think they are having to change pensions and the running of the public sector? And why energy bills are going up again? And why Spain can't build any more reservoirs?
      Brexit means Britain can rule itself. If the current government is not taking advantage of its new freedom then we can always vote them out... which they deserve

    • @andrewdavies8954
      @andrewdavies8954 Před měsícem +6

      @ antifugazi,you are speaking rubbish.

    • @EddyBlacks
      @EddyBlacks Před měsícem +5

      ​@@andrewdavies8954yeah, it's going great after Brexit.

    • @waltersobchak1719
      @waltersobchak1719 Před měsícem +1

      We’ve got nice blue passports………

    • @neilg4208
      @neilg4208 Před měsícem +3

      @@waltersobchak1719 Britain also has the ability once again to make its own laws. The current government is far too timid in doing so we once again have the right.

  • @EdMcF1
    @EdMcF1 Před 27 dny

    General Directorate of Information, George Orwell, Spanish Civil War veteran, surely gave it that name back in the day.

  • @sitrepSNAFU
    @sitrepSNAFU Před měsícem +2

    As you read out comments, I thought I would tell a joke: A man walks past a lunatic asylum and hears them chanting "...34! 34! 34!..." He can't see over the tall fence and carries on. The next day he walks past again, and they are still chanting "...34! 34! 34!..." and curiosity gets the better of him. He climbs up and peers over the fence and sees all the inmates staring out the window. "...35! 35! 35!..." they chant.

  • @EdMcF1
    @EdMcF1 Před 27 dny +1

    If the following countries can have independence (one way or another) from Spain: Chile, Argentina, Peru, Bolivia, Paraguay, Grand Columbia, El Salvador, Honduras, Costa Rica, Nicaragua, Guatemala, Equatorial Guinea, Mexico and Portugal, why not Catalonia?

  • @MMC_Marco
    @MMC_Marco Před měsícem

    Wonderful weather Stu, wild wet and windy Easter in Portugal, can't wait to get over to Spain. Enjoy your time in Portugal and happy Easter, best regards Marco 😉👊

  • @andresrodriguez3356
    @andresrodriguez3356 Před měsícem +1

    Its refreshing to see your point or view. I feel you are a bit less biased. Even though uk politicians might have issues, i believe that they are much more honest than the Spanish ones

  • @Simon-jj2pu
    @Simon-jj2pu Před měsícem +2

    I do feel that the channel comments are being a bit harsh nowadays. Stuart is being a good egg in doing what he does, if you don’t like it, then … do one

  • @wolf222555
    @wolf222555 Před měsícem

    I wish you a happy holiday mate, you've earned it. Weather here in Zaragoza very mixed. " Cuidete".

  • @traciebushnell1425
    @traciebushnell1425 Před měsícem

    Wow! Stuart I woke up put the MSN news on the tablet and there you popped up talking about living in Spain fame at last 😂

  • @jetpowerpasquale9828
    @jetpowerpasquale9828 Před měsícem +1

    So what is the situation on taking / buying a property with squatters in it -is evection a viable process in Spain ? - or is it as it seems - a lost cause ??

  • @davidlowum5258
    @davidlowum5258 Před měsícem

    The liquids at airports, I believe, have to do with international certification to comply with US TSA regulations. If the airport loses it's certification from TSA, perhaps by allowing Cadbury eggs through, then any flight connecting to a "certified" airport will require additional, secondary screening at the gate, with obvious increases in cost. In the end, it's much simpler and easier for a "certified" airport to retain the certification.

  • @EdMcF1
    @EdMcF1 Před 27 dny

    In the UK, you get a telegram from the King when you reach 100. They are talking about modernising the monarchy so that when you turn 13, you get a text from Prince Andrew.

  • @eldavido8249
    @eldavido8249 Před měsícem +2

    Catalan independence - you would think it would be bad for them but, if the income for that region is as you read/hear would it?

    • @harriettt9857
      @harriettt9857 Před měsícem +1

      There are many other issues to be considered not just the income, ! You have to look at the big picture

  • @victoriaevans-qr7vk
    @victoriaevans-qr7vk Před 25 dny

    Well done Puigdemont

  • @jonathangat4765
    @jonathangat4765 Před měsícem +1

    Hello from "Uruguay"

  • @anois
    @anois Před 28 dny

    Can't really blame Catalunya wanting independence ... I live in Andalucía and it appears to be a quagmire of corruption and mismanagement, forever mired in poverty and unemployment

  • @paul-gerard9488
    @paul-gerard9488 Před měsícem +2

    Why is Puigdemont not considered as being, a populist, a nationalist and his Catalunya first desires? It is somewhat biased, as to who gets to be into this category and who not.
    Maybe Rubiales can go to Brussels and live there and wait for amnesty. Only kidding folks!
    Have a great Easter Stu.

  • @NZESP
    @NZESP Před měsícem +3

    You seem almost angry at Puidgdemont and, to be honest, a little snarky about Sanchez for opening a door for him. Perhaps you could explain your views a bit more? I'm keen to gain insights on this subject.

    • @harriettt9857
      @harriettt9857 Před měsícem

      It is going to be a huge problem as Pigdemont ( purposely) wants to call all the shots . Sanchez will be a very sorry man when his plan backfires

    • @joeshmoe883
      @joeshmoe883 Před měsícem

      Puigdemont is a criminal. Anyone who isn't "angry" about this case should explain.

  • @user-fu6pk8ky5i
    @user-fu6pk8ky5i Před měsícem

    In the Sixties I worked in Germany with a young girl from Spain, but if asked if she was Spanish her eyes would fire up, her heels do a quick staccato on the floor, her chin would lift and she would exclaim "Catalan !"
    I know how she felt, I´m a Lancastrian, -- Lancashire being a Duchy, could technically gain independence from the sh**y south, and has even less chance than Cataluña.
    But I am also a grateful immigrant in this fantastic country, so I keep my political mouth shut in the pueblo.
    My nearest neighbour is a Gitane --- now if ANYONE could talk politics ...
    He knows better, and grows vegetables.

  • @TravelonlineWalk
    @TravelonlineWalk Před měsícem

    Top, like from Jandia

  • @frgv4060
    @frgv4060 Před měsícem

    I remember two decades ago that the whispering among some circles was that Telefonica and El corte ingles helped the state avoid bankruptcy. Probably the same BS as the jam of Luis Miguel 😂. But from that point of view would be returning the favor hehe.

  • @craphead9842
    @craphead9842 Před měsícem

    10% in Telefonica isn't a lot that leaves 90% in the hands of private investors... Tony cuenca

  • @stevo728822
    @stevo728822 Před měsícem

    Stu, did you know your comments in one of your videos about expats moving to Spain has been reported on the GBNews website. The title of the article is called "'Absolutely sucks': Expat lists three 'negative aspects' about living in Spain that Britons should know before moving". They report that you say the Spanish are unfriendly and the job market is crap.

  • @Kolach0
    @Kolach0 Před měsícem +4

    Just my 2 cents on the matter, Spain is a soviet block. Everyone works for the ayuntamiento

    • @dancarden72
      @dancarden72 Před měsícem

      so wrong

    • @Kolach0
      @Kolach0 Před měsícem +1

      @@dancarden72 In Spain, you need an appointment to get an ID. 1 year to get a DL. I ain’t comparing the US to Spain. But take for example Colombia vs Spain as a local. Which I’m both, need an ID in Col, walk in the same day. DL a month and a half later in Col. Need Spanish citizenship? Wait 10 years, meanwhile 5 years in Colombia. But all means go to Spain. Just saying it’s a soviet block imo

  • @martindouglas9839
    @martindouglas9839 Před 23 dny

    Gracias por el vídeo Stuart don’t think Mr Sanchez gives a flying f K as long as he is captain of the vessel

  • @j.d.malonemalone2397
    @j.d.malonemalone2397 Před 25 dny

    The people of Cataluyna should decide their future.

  • @allandonovan4620
    @allandonovan4620 Před měsícem +1

    RE SQUATTERS. The State of Florida just passed a series of laws making squatting illegal. Perhaps other States and Countries will follow suit. 😊

    • @cineffect
      @cineffect Před 27 dny

      Florida is light-years ahead of anything EU can offer 😂

  • @janetlombardi2314
    @janetlombardi2314 Před měsícem

    😊

  • @peterforfun210
    @peterforfun210 Před měsícem

    It's your holiday money.

  • @HubbaHubba64
    @HubbaHubba64 Před měsícem +1

    The reason why Madrid and the EU Dictatorship won't allow Catalonia to have Independence is Catalonia is the region with the second-highest GDP, after Madrid, accounting for 19% of Spain's total GDP. With a population of 8 million inhabitants (16.4% of the Spanish population)

    • @EddyBlacks
      @EddyBlacks Před měsícem +2

      You really think the EU cares about a few euros less paid by Spain?

    • @subcitizen2012
      @subcitizen2012 Před měsícem +1

      If any of that were true then they wouldn't have let UK leave. Don't worry so much about these big adult conversations, worry more about where you're getting your info sources. Everyone votes, these are democracies. EU isn't fully a political entity yet anyway - they hasn't been out up for vote yet anyway. Losing in democracy doesn't mean you've been dictated to, it means your politics are the politics of losers and need to sort yourself out accordingly.

    • @HubbaHubba64
      @HubbaHubba64 Před měsícem

      @@subcitizen2012 The EU dictatorship tried every trick in the book including threats to keep the UK as a vassal state but real democracy allowed a vote and the result was Brexit

  • @mr-vet
    @mr-vet Před měsícem +1

    The government in Madrid just doesn’t want to lose the tax revenue…and the government fears that other autonomous regions with their own distinct language and culture may want to follow suit.

  • @europeanliving6077
    @europeanliving6077 Před měsícem +3

    EIREEXIT & ESPANAEXIT 💚💚❤❤

  • @titirangi113
    @titirangi113 Před měsícem

    Mr Puigdemont may have negative consequences for the Spanish speaking people of Spain, but Mr Puigdemont is a politician and as such, he represents the people who vote for him. Those people are not Spanish, they are Catalans, and they live in Catalonia and would prefer to have their own country. And what is wrong with that?

  • @michaelholt7994
    @michaelholt7994 Před 29 dny

    Boycott Catalonia as a tourist.arresst that loon,division in any country is very dangerous.ill be in Spain in a couple of weeks,and smoking on the beach. Not as dangerous as broken bottles in the sand,nails,bottle tops.

  • @LeedsUnitedJohn
    @LeedsUnitedJohn Před měsícem

    If someone kissed my Wife on the lips they would incur my displeasure.