What Was a Jedi's Punishment for Breaking Their Lightsaber
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 08. 2021
- NEW STAR WARS MERCH PAGE:
www.fandomion.com/sale/sale?s...
For all sponsorship and business inquiries please contact:
thestupendousscrub@gmail.com
Business: tmarvelouswave@gmail.com
Twitter: @StupendousWave
I believe all content used falls under the remits of Fair Use, but if any content owners would like to dispute this I will not hesitate to immediately remove said content. It is not my intent to in any way infringe on their content ownership. If you happen to find your art or images in the video please let me know and I will be glad to credit you. End Song By WhiteSand "Eternity" • Whitesand - Eternity (...
Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
Year: 2017
Title: Eternity Additional Music Terminus by: Scott Buckley
Released under CC-BY 4.0.
www.scottbuckley.com.au
Terminus: • 'Terminus' [Epic Cinem... - Zábava
Punishment for breaking a lightsaber? Isn’t having no weapon and being forced to build a new one punishment enough?
id think ta say soo 🤷♂️ i mean comon its the same rules on real world blades 😒 sure id be pisst or w.e if somone broke a 1oo too 1k or above sowrd sure wtf wouldint but chu cant nore would 1 bother on giveing a stupid punishment for it brakeing unless they were strictly told soo 🤷♂️ but if not nahh fuck tat B.S light sabers just as any other type of wep. WILL eventualy brake down tats just how it works 😒
@@shadowdragonx07 What?
@@shadowdragonx07 engrish
@@buklau837 I’d think to say so, I mean c’mon it’s the same rules on real world blades, sure I’d be pissed of worst if someone broke a 100-1k above sword, sure who the fuck wouldn’t but you can’t nor bother giving a stupid punishment for breaking it unless they were strictly told so, but if not, fuck that Bullshit, lightsabers are just any type of weapon
It will eventually break down that’s just how it works
Edit:
final part
@@shadowdragonx07 are you Nevil? I am fluent in idiot
JEDI ORDER: Attachments are forbidden.
ALSO JEDI ORDER: This Lightsaber is your life. Never let it go.
ALSO JEDI ORDER: We shall give our live for the Republic.
Good point it is contradictory
Me, putting a 40x scope on my lightsaber: dangit
attachments are forbidden?
@@mysteriumxarxes3990 yes for Jedi
Well, with the severity of the punishment, no wonder the Jedi fear the rise of Dark Side users.
More education and study after disciplinary action is responsible, stripping all field work... Wonder why sith got abundant
@@osmacar5331 true but the sith if you remember before the rule of 2 constantly killed one another too advance in rank, this caused many of their techniques and numbers too be lost. so you could say both sides darn done goofed.
And what do you think a sith woukd do lol especially one like sidious yeah would be much worse probably get Electriculated to near death then have to go through hell to get another one
@@thestormcraft4012 well jedi are morons and sith too, they're the same just different faces
@@MACE_HINDU depends on the era i'd guess, later on the sith would mass produce the red crystals they use so I would imagine there was little to no punishment.
The Jedi: Gives child highly valuable item
Child: Loses it
The Jedi: *Surprised Pikachu face*
Master loses their lightsaber: It's alright, they can just build another one.
Padawan loses their lightsaber: We really need to question their ability and knowledge. Surely we can't allow someone to become a master if they can't keep track of their lightsabers?
Well to be fair, If the jedi was able to prove himself to gain the rank of Master and hold it for a long while before something happening to his saber than sure makes sense.
@@Tony-hv8wz but that also means that they should have the ability to never lose that lightsaber because they are a master
@@darthpablo8215 only the sith deal in absolutes so they would know that every now and then a masters lightsaber would break
Yes ok it's like if your kid wanted a dog so you tested him with a gold fish if you know your kid can't take ccx are of the fish would you give him the dog
🤔🤔it’s like Hunter Biden never going to jail after trying to buy a gun while having a criminal record (slap in the hand and go home, end of the story) vs average Joe committing the same offense (lock him/her up). It is a matter of elitism and having a status in any given society regardless of the crime being committed in question 🤷🤷
This seems to go against the whole failure is part of the learning process. To say that a Padawan losing their lightsaber in battle required remedial education and an investigation seems wrong to me, and not the Jedi way. To assume that a padawan would not make mistakes is a absolutionist theory that i'd associate more with the Sith.... As they deal in absolutes.
Welcome to the Jedi young padawan, to the Jedi
That is what the Jedi do, they mask and they lie, the sith on the other hand have nothing to hide.
@@abrahamelnikety151 Precisely. The statement "only the sith deal in absolutes" in and of itself is an absolute statement. It simply exemplifies the entirety of the organizations corruption and hypocrisy. At least the sith are honest about what they are within themselves.
Considering that this is based on the Clone Wars Jedi, its exemplifies them as a whole, I believe this person also went over the account of some of the Jedi Masters that though they fought for good... as a person they were almost worse than any Sith individual. The Jedi's stagnation and dogmatic adherence to their perceived view of the Force makes them as bad as the Sith and honestly why i think many couldn't see through the dark side to know what was coming... they could use the Force, but the Force lost faith in the Jedi and so not allowing them to see what was to come. However, i could be wrong and im just talking out my ass on this; just seemed right to say.
Well the Jedi order is full of hippocrits and is constantly changing illogically to benafit specific Jedi at least the sith order stays consistent
The fact that Anakin's master Obiwan also lost his lightsaber when he was captured probably gave Anakin some measure of forgiveness. That and the fact he went toe to toe with Count Dooku a former Jedi Master and Dark Lord of the Sith made a strong case for him getting a new lightsaber.
The fact that he lost his hand while going toe to toe with said Sith also makes a strong case.
He lost his first lightsaber in his first encounter with Darth Maul.
@@ahalfsesameseedbun7472 and Qui-Gon died in a later encounter, so we could argue that the counsel felt that would be punishment enough in the end.
@ Qui Gon died in the same encounter. Obi Wan lost his lightsaber when he attacked, after maul had already stabbed Qui Gon.
@@ahalfsesameseedbun7472 I thought they also encountered him while leaving Tatooine.
They were forced to give Outer Rim jobs
Bahahahahahaha!!!!!!!
WHAT
HELLO THERE
NNNNNNOOOOOOO
To master yoda of course
Makes much more sense as to why Ahsoka didn't want to tell Anakin when hers was stolen.
I never thought about that!
Which I never understood cuz didn't that f***** lose like two or three of them himself
"This is outrageous. This is unfair. How can one be a Jedi Padawan without a lightsaber?"
"Takes a crystal, young Tano."
"I'm sorry master."
THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS
Take a seat
take a seat skywalker :D lol.
Forgive me master
@@Rinth-xq6cm
ok just don't turn to the darkside :D
This is SPARTA!
Yes going from Padawan to Service corps over a lost lightsaber, definitely wouldn't bring out anger and resentment in young force users.
I could understand some kind of punishment for losing your lightsaber because of your own carelessness, but to punish a Padawan because he/she lost their lightsaber in a battle is too harsh IMO.
It just goes to show you that anything Lucas put into his film can be retcon to mean anything 😂 it’s so dumb because Anakin being the chosen one literally makes him have special treatment and he’s crying about rank of master
Exactly this, sending in padawans into battle and expecting a lot out of them is a bit much.
@@tobiwayne7725 you clearly don't know what does the rank mean to me, it allows me to get to the restricted area where I can learn some dark side holocrons to save Padme
@@anakinskywalker5088 save Padme from yourself
thats your preoblem with the jedi? there main way of recruiment is literally kidnapping
The punishment is death. When Anakin lost his lightsaber he said "Obi-Wan's gonna kill me". Obi wan sliced him in half and left him to die.
But Anakin didn't die. In fact, he got a new, nice, red lightsaber and would have killed his old master had the latter not disappeared in thin air, totally naked because his entire clothing was still on the floor.
Imagine being a knight, in your 30s, and getting knocked back down to padawan and assigned to the same mf who taught you like "ain't I tell you to not lose the damn thing? And what did ya do? That's right ya lost it!"
It's safe to say that this, among many other contradictions, helped lead the down fall of the Jedi.
The Jedi should never have treated anakin as anything special outside of getting him in the order in the first place
I mean... they didnt...
he was the strongest padawan in the whole order, being leagues ahead of everybody else but he was never promoted earlier than everyone else
@@Trathien- I mean he kinda was... he and several others were only promoted to help fill in a gap left when a bunch of Jedi fell at Genosis during the start of the Clone wars (correct me if I’m wrong)
@@vandeech7272 so he wasnt treated differently because everybody got promoted just no him...
@@Trathien- He became a Jedi council member tho without being a Jedi master.
@@Sn1ffko yeah... because the supreme chancellor ordered it... not because he was the chosen one...
*Not again, Obi-Wan's gonna kill me*
Brohoof! /)
Obi-wan: *YOU BET YOUR SWEET BIPPY I DID*
I hate when he does this
Jedi council when a Master loses their lightsaber: oh dear, oh dear. Gorgeous.
Jedi council when a younger jedi loses their lightsaber: You fucking donkey!
I heard that if a Lightsaber is lost the Jedi will be sent to bed without Midiclorines.
Lol nice Jedi joke😄
Its more about responsibility and how powerful a freaking light saber is. Imagine the council watching the news and seeing a thug on a killing streak with a jedi light saber and then knowing they're going to have to answer for it. (Yes the un fair standards are bad). But also you're basically not a jedi without your saber. Every plan your partner makes is based on the facr that you both have sabers. The un fair standards are because someone like Windu or Yoda can still he very effective without them. In the army if you lose your rifle your career is OVER, dishonorable discharge is likely and even a small chance of prison time depending on how negligent the incident was. Light sabers are more important and more powerful for much more powerful people.
While it's possible that a soldier could be court-martialed for losing a weapon, it's highly unlikely, according to Richard Rosen, the director of the Center for Military Law and Policy at Texas Tech University.
Losing a weapon is often regarded as a minor offense, according to Rosen, who worked as a staff judge advocate overseeing and advising on legal proceedings, including court-martials, at Fort Hood, Texas, in the 1990s.
The punishment, Rosen said, would normally be a "non-judicial punishment," also known as an "Article 15." Under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, Article 15 is a "means of handling minor offenses requiring immediate corrective action."
The immediate commander of the accused service member is the one who decides what type of punishment is appropriate for an Article 15 offense.
The hearing for such an offense is non-adversarial; the commander conducts the hearing and there isn't any questioning from opposing sides.
For losing a firearm or weapon by negligence, meaning it wasn't on purpose, some of the most common types of non-judicial punishments include partial or full forfeiture of pay for up to one year and restricted access to certain parts of a post, Rosen said.
Depending on the value of the lost weapon, the punishment can also include a bad conduct discharge or six months of confinement at the U.S. Disciplinary Barracks, a Defense Department maximum-security correctional facility in Fort Leavenworth, Kansas.
A service member can refuse the Article 15 punishment and request a court-martial, although that often leads to a harsher sentence. Rosen said he does not remember a single case when losing a firearm has been presented at a court-martial proceeding.
While there are various types of trials depending on the severity of the offense, there isn't any automatic punishment for any particular offense, military law attorney Grover Baxley told USA TODAY in an email.
Theoretically, the chain of command could court-martial a member for losing their weapon if the circumstances are right, according to Baxley. For example, "if they took it off base, got drunk and left it in a nightclub," he said.
However, Baxley, who has been practicing military law for over 20 years and served as chief of military justice in the U.S. Air Force Judge Advocate General's Corps, doesn't recall any member being court-martialed for "simply losing or misplacing" their firearm.
Wait So the more experienced master. the ones that should be more skilled have less punishment than those who are new and are more likely to lose their saber? what? thats stupid
If you're experienced, and have done all the work, had all the training to do your job right, yes you should get harsher punishment for fucking up, it's common sense.
@@darthkenobi6726 exactly. I knew the jedi were hypocritical and Generally not acctually that nice but id didn't knew they would Shoot themselves in the foot like this 🤣
Perhaps the idea is to force the Padawan to learn, where as if the master fucks up it's assumed the situation was extreme?
Fairly sure he stated it largely depended upon the situation...
If a Padawan such as obi wan fights Darth maul and looses his light saber during the course of the battle but still ultimately wins or even escapes I'm fairly sure there wouldn't be a punishment for it... Oh wait..
basiclly to teach padawans
ObiWan lost two of his(Episode I and II) and each time got a promotion. Talk about extenuating circumstances. lol
While fighting and investigating plus he killed a sith he was like a hero of the jedi order
@@grimmshredsanguinus2915 Exactly. That's why real life situations should be considered in it's entirety. Like in the court of law.
I'm asking you fans; you wouldn't consider Grievous taking it or dropping it on Utapau as "losing it" would y'all? I took the meaning as destroyed or not retrievable.
Grimmshred Sanguinus Well not completely, he was sliced in half but his other internal organs were still intact.
WHAT
I dunno about a Jedi Knight but if a PVT lost their M4, we’d make them cut the grass with scissors while sniper crawling after they found it.
Before or after the whole base gets smoked all day, every other day for a month for allowing it to happen and said privates Article 15?
@@chrismc410 after, obviously
I AM THE BROKEN LIGHTSABER
Not yet.
That'd be a Great Topic! "Normal Everyday Desires Jedi Struggled with Day to Day."
Jedi: Loses lightsaber
Grievous: A fine addition to my collection
OBI WAN IS GONNA KILL ME
The real ending of Episode 1
Just imagine a padawan being spanked for losing his lightsaber xD
Kinky
@@SilverBazooka10 they're children
@@captainshid5464 I thought the younglings were children. Palawans are in thier mid 20s.
Roasted by force lightning.
Watching both Rey Nobody and Kylo Ren break Anakin Skywalker’s saber was the most ungodly amount of disrespect projected from Disney.
Calm down its not that serious it's a saber that murdered several children CHILDREN
@@crooner5259 you shouldn't even comment to this asshole
for not thinking twice who is making star wars and who just owns the company
@@crooner5259 and that saber was the one that trained luck repaying for the sins not to mention its an object it does not control what the master does a drill doesn't control the holder but the other way around
@@cpt.arctourus7950 Luke *
She fixed it tho soooo
ORDER 66
You will leave the younglings to me
(Breaks my Force Pike)
Not again, Palpatine is gonna kill me
Ayo red crayon Yeah Guess who pays to get you those pikes, Me
They work good for closing vents
That's unfair to do to a young Padawan.
I bet Windu wanted to do it the first chance he got to Anakin
Is nobody going to mention Mace Windu used a Hurrikaine crystal in his second/third lightsaber (At least in Legends), and not an Ilum crystal?
He Thinks He Is Special. Therefore A Needs A Special Lightsaber.
A mothafuka crystal
"Hey what is this stick?"
"what stick? OH NO, WAOT DONT TOUCH THA-"
Mace windu:you are on this Council but you are not granted the rank of master
Anakin:throws lightsaber out window
Mace windu:you are now a master
Wow man, I feel stronger with my knowledge of the Force and Star Wars with each video💪
Jedi concil where they constantly make dark sided decisions and will fault you for getting even slightly angry
What if the saber is destroyed, but you recover the kyber crystal intact?
I guess you'd just build a new hilt. There's really no need to waste a perfectly good crystal
A crystal cant be destroyed or damaged
@@starkiller1650 yeah it can
@@janag1624 indeed
@@starkiller1650 Kylo Ren says hello!
It’a odd just losing a lightsaber makes you unworthy to be a jedi, if it happens one to many times that makes sense but even then it’s like losing your blade can remove you from the order.
This is just a guess, but I think Lucas may be riffing on Samurai culture with this idea. It's not just the "blade" itself but the symbology behind it (what it represents) and the knight's utter dependence on it for survival. So losing it is not just a matter of carelessness, but a matter of discipline and respect towards traditions/ideals as well as your own life.
its a religion it might be considered a sin
also you can't expect every academy to not be strict
@@irrelevanttroll3312 that’s fair but not all religions banish you from a mistake either
@@KosstAmojan he likely is since the jedi are based on them in a sense. But yeah that makes a lot of since and in that since without your blade your essentially lose part of your life.
It shows that you are careless. You are holding it, so how can you lose it? If it gets knocked from your hand during a conflict, Jedi can just use the Force to get it back. If it gets knocked off its holding on the Jedi's belt, that shows the Jedi is not mindful of their surroundings at all.
So many iconic actors have been in this amazing film series
i think it makes sense, jedi masters almost never lose their sabers probably specifically because they were trained to be skilled enough to never lose them so but if a master does lose their saber it’s most likely due to something out of their control like a betrayal or fighting someone so powerful that losing the saber would be better than losing their life.
but to learn all this and more they had to learn to not lose their best weapon for survival and through learning that you gain more skill and losing it as a padawan or a new knight shows that you have more learning and training to do.
Be me
19
Still a jedi padawan
Lose my lightsaber after watching my master be slaughtered by General Grievous
Forced to work in the achieves for a month
Demoted to youngling
The war ends
Chilling in the council chambers with the other younglings
Jedi Council member Anakin Skywalker comes in
“Not again, Obi Wan’s gonna kill me..”
I'm pretty sure the circumstances matter greatly. Obi Wan lost his lightsaber while defeating Maul and got promoted to Jedi Knight as a result.
I would imagine that Jedi have some kind of connection with their lightsabre and are able to sense it
Why do Jedi continue to construct new lightsabers even if they're old ones still works?
Why do people buy a new car when the one the got 10+ years ago still works fine?
@@toradora1439 I just was wondering if there was some more Jedi cultural answer. But this works
@@richardleach-beeching9542 Improvements in design I assume. Maybe you craft a new lightsaber that is better suited to yourself and priorities. Supposedly the last lightsaber Anakin makes, the iconic Skywalker lightsaber was built to be more sturdy and combat attuned. Makes sense as this was the dawn of the Clone Wars.
@@toradora1439 Decadence And Stupidity.
Because they can lol
In ANY military, if you lose your weapon, there are severe consequences
Of course its a lethal killing weapon
Yet they weren't a military force. They were a religious order that kidnaps children and then forces them to become a part of their order. They are a government backed cult.
@@CarbonTheCrab Couldn’t have put it better.
What’s the punishment for Obi-won as a padawan. When maul kicked his lightsaber and lost it, but in return cut him in half? Does he still get punish or does it cancel out?
I’d imagine being the first Jedi (and a padawan at that) to defeat a sith in battle in a few hundred years would outweigh it.
Or maybe it was a thousand years. I don’t remember, so I tried to low ball it lol
@@Old_Gregg it was a thousand years, as started in the film.
He got qui gons so they over looked it lol
Obi-Wan didn’t receive any punishment. This double standard rule is newer bs.
Anakin Skywalker losing his lightsaber was a form of foreshadowing.
To me this is really messed up because most Padawans are around the age of 12 and it would make sense that they would lose their weapon because THEY ARE LITERALLY CHILDREN but they end up getting the most severe punishments. Meanwhile Jedi Knights and Masters get barely any punishment if at all and they’re adults so it would make less sense that they would lose their lightsaber. The more your hear about the Jedi Order the more you realize how broken it really was even before Order 66.
Clone Wars Anakin dueling with two lightsabers is awesome.
The punishment was death by Obi-Wan.
"Not again... Obi-Wan's gonna kill me..."
that was informative. thanks.
"What is punishment for breaking your lightsaber"
me: uuhhh.... death? You lose your weapon you die...
To just have train more or study is actually acceptable
I mean Anakin lost more than just his lightsaber that day on geonosis. He lost two lightsabers
I didn't actually know Jedi can be demoted
I mean it is a very dangerous weapon even to the user. I cant imagine to many floating around the galaxy...or what the jedi would do if they found out some civilian had it as a display piece.
They forced them to insert the broken part inside their annnussses and then they had to keep it for a period of several cycles until their master allowed them to push the part out with the force. That was very strict jedi code at that time about lightsaber negligence. The worst was if they lost their lightsaber, the punishment was far beyond what we can conceive. But this will be exposed in an other video.
What. 😃
@@GamerGeekThug yes...hard to believe but true.
Yeah, I have a rare copy of the comic this was shown in, but they stopped making them pretty early on. How much do you think I could sell it for?
That would explain why half of them walk and act like they have something stuck up there.
This sounds like a punishment palpatine would do
A Jedi’s weapon deserves more respect
I think it’s very appropriate… just like a martial artist should wear his/her uniform in class, belt and all, shows discipline and respect
Yeah, but punishing a Padawan for losing it in battle. That's a bit shitty. No wonder everyone turns to the dark side.
@@minihalkoja590 they analyze the situation… the video states that if they lose it in a battle then that can be overlooked
This weapon is their life... so I'm assuming they get put down.
Anakin's lightsaber gets cut in half
Anakin one movie later: gets cut in half (basically)
Edit: Also Maul like 2 minutes after his saberstaff got cut in half.
Like was a weapon anyone could make and use for slicing
Anakin: Not again, Obi-Wan is gonna kill me...
Over 20 years later
Obi-Wan: kills him
This was new to me and interesting to watch
THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS ITS UNFAIR
Everyday the phrase, "only the Sith deal in absolutes" is proven a lie. Sith rarely deal in absolutes and Jedi abound in them.
preach
This reminds me of fallen order
In Attack of the Clones, they were tossing lightsabers around like crazy, like they didn’t matter.
I like to think that there is some Jedi that has an entire collection of lightsabers and that the Jedi built the copy's of anakins and obi-wans lightsabers that grievous has in revenge of the sith
And here I thought the punishment for a jedi loosing their lightsaber, was not having a lightsaber.
How do I feel about it? Same way I feel about the Jedi Council approving the use of a padawan pack.
*rip and tear plays aggressively in the background*
Well, the Jedi’s rules on lightsaber tech definitely make sense, considering how fucking OP it is, and how important it’s secrecy remains even after the 3rd fall of Republic in the newer movies.
Id argue that its worse for a jedi master to lose their light saber than a young padawan. One is experienced the other is a child.
I think it depends how you lose your lightsaber. If a Jedi master gets almost killed and you have a plot armor moment when you want to help and save him even though you are prepared to die and very sad deep monologue shit during the despair run to the Sith and somehow it brakes during the fight it’s alright.
You wont be granted as rank of master
Sad anakin noises
So you’re telling me if I boot up Blade and Sorcery with the Outer Rim mod and disarm younglings that they would simply just be forced to work as force farmers and servants? Daaaaaaaaaamn
The punishment of a *Jedi* for breaking their *lightsaber* is to clean all of the toilets in the *Jedi Temple* with a used toothbrush while blindfolded wearing a sign saying.... "Leroy Jenkins is more responsible then this padawan!"
Its like basic training.
If you lost your rifle, left it unattended, gave it to someone else, or handed it over, you were in some shit.
“Obi-Wan’s gonna kill me.”
I think it's kind of too harsh to demote someone's ranking status just for losing a weapon. Although losing a Lightsaber is no different than losing weapon or handgun. So I guess that justifies as a punishment🤔
Except for the fact that lightsabers are considered an extension of a Jedi body…therefore a part of you
@@alexbourgeois7863
So they’re taking something away from you for losing a part of you. Totally fair
In most countries, if a police officer lost an assigned handgun, he or she would be really lucky to only get demoted
@@noeeleazardelarosagallegos1283 then I guess it makes sense for the Jedi to be demoted if they lose their lightsaber or weaponry.
@@emperorpalpatine5559 jedi bad sith good
They are sent to their room with no supper or dessert 🤣🤣🤣🤣
quite strange for an order against personal attachment to punish you for loosing an item we know can be replaced
I was not aware of this
I don't consider that a harsh punishment for any Jedi, it's more of a kind disciplinary punishment, giving them life lessons and learning from their mistakes and adapt, that's part of a Jedi's humanity.
Perfect example of the Jedis dogma..choosing when,where,and why to enforce their own rules.there should've been either no punishment or fair towards everyone. Except only if you lost it in a reallyyy really stupid way lol
jedi master after accidentally dropping it into a chasm: its aight man just make a new one
jedi padawan after defeating a sith apprentice and having to sacrifice their lightsaber: *this is completely unacceptable young one you will never serve on the field again you are a disgrace*
Lectured by Obiwan
ADHD Padawan: *Oh no,I'm in danger*
From my point of view the lightsaber is evil
If I was a Padawan and I was demoted, I would slowly turn to the darkside and sabotage the Jedi from within... and construct a new lightsaber...
Can you make a video on what force sensitive who were not jedi did exactly?
That would mean Luke Skywalker would get such a punishment where he would be stripped of his jedi knighthood for losing his lightsaber in ROTJ, provided he didn't retrieve it before leaving the death star.
take a shot evertime he says "heat of battle"
It should depend more on the circumstances
In A Normal World, Yes. In A Lazy World, No.
Yes, the Jedi who are more experienced and wiser should get away with losing a lightsaber, while the young Jedi who have little experience should get punished for losing their lightsaber.
I don't know what special force weed the Jedi council uses, but I need some
The masters should face a punishment too if you can't teach your padawan to hold onto their blade
I honestly think it would make more sense if a master or elder jedi had punishments since they are more skilled and less likely to lose their saber
But punishing a Padawan also drives the point deeper. Don't lose the saber.
But if they lose it in a fight with a sith, then it's stupid as hell to begin punishing them.
NNNNNNOOOOOOO
YYYYYYESSSSS