Dr. Pal proves he's PROBLEMATIC once again | Pseudoscience Police
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 08. 2024
- Dr. Pal may be a qualified doctor. But he is a terrible science communicator putting out misinformation after misinformation. He recently invited 2 pseudoscience creators on to his podcast. Let’s examine what was discussed.
Use my link to join Stayqrious to pay zero admission fees:
r.stayq.us/ddrational
One-time support:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
Buy me a coffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Website: www.scienceisdope.com
Merch: kadakmerch.com/collections/sc...
Continued support:
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
WhatsApp community: nas.io/scienceisdope
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / scienceisdope
Main Channel: / scienceisdope
#DrPal
#SatvicMovement
#DDRational
Sources:
Stayqrious:
facultycenter.ischool.syr.edu...
www.weforum.org/publications/...
Probiotics in cooked food -
indianexpress.com/article/lif...
High Fructose Corn Syrup
www.fda.gov/food/food-additiv...
Prana/Life Energy:
www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/pse...
Food freezing & safety:
www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety...
Artificial Sweeteners Human Studies:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28378...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30892...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27956...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31877...
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28502...
Videos:
Satvic Movement and their radiation fear mongering:
• How Satvic Movement SC...
My conversation with nutritionist Amita Gadre
• I asked a nutritionist...
How to lose weight:
• How I ate more and los...
Chapters:
00:00 - Dr. Pal does it again.
08:11 - Satvic Movement
11:13 - The Podcast
29:20 - Changes to the Channel
Free Pseudoscience Game - Spot the BS: bingobaker.com/#65349335c8b652a6
Biases and Fallacies:
docs.google.com/document/d/1X...
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
CZcams: / scienceisdope
Reddit: / scienceisdope - Zábava
Thanks so much Pranav for introducing StayQrious Neoschool, to your audience. It was so heartfelt. Am so happy to see your enthusiasm for the kind of education we are providing at StayQ.
Also, really like the video. Critical thinking and scientific literacy are more important now than ever.
Thanks a lot! Really happy that you chose to sponsor me!
Here's a link if you'd like to join Stayqrious: r.stayq.us/ddrational
Dude,have you ever worked in Byju's??
Sure. Let me consider it. I do think of doing podcasts with interesting folks. I'll see how soon I can make time for podcasts.
sirs ive used parts of ur videos and mahesh's in my channel for this "jee roast" video...thats ok right lololol
Anand srinivas sir was the one who actually gave me an entirely different view on how physics actually works during my schooling years
From his session, my views on physics took a huge turn for the good
And I fell in love with it
My curiosity in physics actually grew because of your lectures sir
My hearty wishes for you on this amazing venture sir
As always staying curious ( as you say)
My dumbass thought dd collabed with pranav
lmao
Same bruh
Bro 🤣🤣
same xd
Incoming copyright strike from DD
Dr. Mike's conversation with Gundry was epic. The old man kept sprouting non-sense and Dr. Mike did right by not holding back and calling out all of the BS the old man was spewing.
I still haven't been able to trust Dr.Mike since his scandal during COVID 19 but good on Dr.Mike
Dr pal is competing with Ranveer Ahalabadia 😂😂
Underrated comment, his head wobble when they say BS 😅😅
you should say prof Ranveer Ahalabadia -
@@MadeInAndhra-rk5mw 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@ranadheerreddy4136 glad you got my joke
@@aswinbabu1630 😂😂
Science is dope channel still exists.
This is his second channel, changed from 'Pranav Radhakrishnan' to 'DD Rational'
No more.. hacked
No, unfortunately, someone hacked his first channel. And then CZcams made it unavailable because of strikes. @pranav is working on it
Hey Pranav as a diabetes doctor I disagree with your logic behind not calling sugar addiction at 25:50. Sugar withdrawal leads to cravings pretty much like any drug cravings. Since you can procure sugary snacks or food easily these cravings cause snack breaks and don’t make as much noise as what a typical cocaine withdrawl makes
Sugar in itself is not addictive. Sugar when coupled with fat/sodium in hyper palatable foods is addictive.
Also when people avoid sugar, they tend to eat more healthy which means they lower their caloric intake, which keeps them hungry and when hunger kicks in, cravings are obvious.
What is a 'diabetes' doctor?? Did you take a fellowship in diabetology?
@@JonTodt775 yes
Pg Diploma followed by a couple of fellowships
@@vikram1262 ok, cool
Dr.Pal's biggest crime is his "comedy".
😂😂 poor shravan kumar
Brotha thonks he is qurky and funny
@@shrektxx8741 he sure do
Hahaha it’s not Shravan Kumar. It’s Saravana kumar
1. One of the reasons for avoiding frozen vegetables is to eat seasonal vegetables.
2. You are under the assumption that all these regulatory bodies work diligently and sincerely which might not be the case. There are a lot of stuff being sold which are marketed to be something else while having fssai approval.
3. You ask about evidence based backing on everything and since it's not there , it means you can have it. But the point is there is no evidence that a lot of these are absolutely safe and cause no problems. What is okay today, may be found out to have some effect in the future because we don't know what effect certain chemicals(even if consumed in minuscule amounts) have over our body.
3. While preserving food can be critical in some cases but when there is no requirement, why do it? The kind of food we have been having over multiple generations in a particular climate has a higher probability of suiting us and they have the largest data pool (so many people over such a long time having a particular diet)
4. No company is there to do social work as its prime work, it has to earn and maximise profit and they often tend to flirt with existing regulatory rules, often finding loop holes.
5. Human body is complex, modern medicine is nowhere close. What worked for millennia will still work and the only reason they don't is because of other factors like pollution.
6. Personally, i think moderation is the key. But that is really hard. You talked about white rice. Tell me something, how many of us have the discipline to limit our portions when it comes to food? And why would anyone want to strip the bran layer when it is useful to us? Taste is the only reason i can think of.
7. You say a lot of things , some valid but you yourself function under some assumptions and it is quite natural because there has to be an undefined object and a set of axioms/hypothesis in science or we would be in a never ending cycle. We can have this structure in Mathematics but in sciences it's not possible because we don't know the the axiom equivalent, we are in the process of extracting rules from observations, making models and testing them.
All that being said, it is rather difficult to recommend anything when it comes to health. Someone i knew had a problem and we went to a doctor and he is a well established, respected doctor with a sterling career. His treatment didn't work out and this was an outlier. Irony was, something like hingoli solved her problem. Doctors are detectives in that they try their best to figure out what the ailment is and then have to figure out a treatment customised to the needs of the patient.
Studies in medicine are still done on a small subset of people.
8. We need to understand the entire human genome and how it works, how every single thing in our body works and understand the effect of every compound on our body in order to have something precise and deterministic.
9. Lastly i am not refuting everything you have said, this is not about arguing to defend a set of opinions or stance. I have merely put out somethings which came to my mind while listening to you.
Cheers
This comment deserve a reply
most of your points are bullshit but some i can agree with
👏👏👏👏
💯 agree with everything you say.
3. You ask about evidence based backing on everything and since it's not there , it means you can have it. But the point is there is no evidence that a lot of these are absolutely safe and cause no problems. What is okay today, may be found out to have some effect in the future because we don't know what effect certain chemicals(even if consumed in minuscule amounts) have over our body.
i fear the oxygen we breath is actually radioactive poisionous and made by the chinese comnunist party, proof? in future we might find proof for the epitominal predisposition of my claims😂
Changed channel name! Wow first I thought wtf "DD Rational" Is our govt. becoming "Rational" now? Anyway Pranav tirelessly waiting for this spicy video. Lots of love from Kolkata. Take care.
Thank you!
Same I thought pranav was guest in Dooradarshan 😅
lmaoo i thought did DD national make a new channel and posted pranav? great name, i love it @pranav!!!
Lolllll.
Kahi mougli ji copyright strike na maar de channel name pe 😂😂
Dr.Pal is giving me strong BeerBiceps vibe!!
I cant believe that a modern medicine doctor is shaking his head to such pseudoscience!!!
Dr. Pal had run sammy ads on youtube stating
“If you keep losing calories will your weight become zero?”
With experience comes humility, the more you learn the more you realise there is much more to be learnt.
Yes they said in layman. I myself am a practicing allopathic doctor with 11 yrs experience in oncology can boldly claim that allopathy is still naive and needs to learn a lot and discover more. The patient are over diagnosed and over medicated And western approval for everything is laughable. Earlier everybody used to laugh at "Pranayam" but when CDC came approved Cardiac Coherence breathing everyone went gaga which is practically Pranayam rebadged western clothes nothing else. If mendel noticed by his experience in his garden about trait (genes) it has to be acknowledged but if any Charaka/shusutra learned and taught something needs to be rejected straight away. When I was in residency our esteemed professor who runs a renowned cancer treatment centre in pondicherry used to ask patients to visit dharamshala for an opinion with Dr yeshi can't remember the exact name . That person was practicing Buddhist medicine and trust me the patients quality of life was improved like anything we saw after their treatment. So fellows Let go of this mentality first that if Gora babu said so everything is right. And you know what is the 4th phase of drug trial right? I can right 100's of instances where drugs and investigations were and are still pushed into the market with screwed data and false claims and silently withdrawn if caught up. It's common instances when these greedy corporation influence texts of harrison which is equivalent to Bible of allopathy. In allopathy patients are looked upon as consumers in an open market economy and the resell needs to be happening again and again for revenue. Almost 80% of gut bacteria is lost to use of antibiotics and GM food or products from hybrid cattles. When you look monsato patents and their buisness you'll realise what I am saying .
What I feel is that eat ultra processed foods in moderation without compromising on your healthy foods intake.
Yep like beer biceps and also a lot like FitTuber 😂
19:27 The ban from Singapore, Hong Kong and other western countries on masalas from brands like mdh and Everest, makes me lose trust over fssai. The food regulatory authorities are doing sh*t and playing with the health of crores of Indians.
Haven’t you read the news article where fssai went about relaxing with amount of pesticides in MDH so now we are subject to consume toxic pesticides loaded spices credit to fssai !!
what the hell this guy is saying apple has a life because its oxidizing and getting eaten by bacteria is hilarious
People who say sugar is as addictive as cocaine have not tried cocaine before.
True😂
Thn Don't eat sugar in ur life even if u crave.
Yeah! Sucrose and fructose are composition of most fruits.
Sugar and alcohol have identical digestion process...try absolutely avoiding eating added sugar and sugar (that obviously mean any sweetner above 30 glycemic index having no fibre or nutritional value to cover your daily needs)...not at all as hard as drugs but yeah u will feel like we were definitely high on something before this sugar restriction...
I have been there and done it.
Sir how you know?
But it releases the same hormones like drugs maybe in small quantities but it is harmful, my relative had to amputate his legs due to diabetes he is sugar addict
**I Just want to say something**
I'm a student from IIT Mandi last yead Satvik movement had a seminar at our college they were trying to promote vegiterian or vegan diet.... on that regard they had said so many illogical claims and didn't give any explanation of that..... students who were curious asked them questions and she playfully avoided all trigerring questions.....
Since then I'm reportng the these people Satvik movement whereever I see them in YT.
I used to think Dr. Pal is atleast scientific minded allthough he sometimes opposes some ideas...... but after seeing him with Satvik people....my confusion is cleared.... take Dr. Pal's words with grain of salt....
Absolutely true
an iitian my foot you people always will controlled by someone above😊
@@Adeo83jcsowhy are you so butthurt man
@@Adeo83jcso so will u be 😂
i thought dd national is collaborating with pranav 😂😂
Lol! I thought he opened some new channel and then saw it is already subscribed. Let's hope for that one day this will happen. 😁😁
Same bro😂😂😂
DD Rational😅
Pranav on his way to get huge number of boomer gen subscribers.
If boomers came here man we are doomed😂
Appeal to authority is a logical fallacy but it's something we can't get away with. We simply can't check everything we know or believe in. At some point, you will depend on someone for information.
In your own video, you depend on some other people/organisations to justify your claims.
You can critique Dr. Pal but based on "appeal to authority" stands on loose soil
I respect your videos. But the fact is that I watch Dr.Pal videos and whatever he says is general advise and not to be taken as individual advise. Dr. pal videos are harmless. All he says to eat healthy, eat moderately and promote good health.
If you dissect and debunk everything on the plant, your whole life be one hell of myth. I don’t want to do that.
Thank God any good and mature comment
Or Dr. Pal couldn't have just called out those guys when they were spewing nonsense and disrespecting his profession. But he didn't.. he's not stupid..there's a reason he didn't do that
Dope guy will never appreciate such comments and he only appreciates what he wants to hear , clearly he is unbiased
@@432hertz2 Ultimately everything points to Views, likes, money - Can't help.
I guess dr pal is deleting such comments which criticized him
Pharmacologist and Pharmaceutical Physician here. There are a lot of problematic sentences from you too. Quite superficial and discounting the strength of evidences.
However, unlike you earning from these videos, I don't have to and I sadly lack the time to create these slick videos dissing others.
Alright, you basically said " you are wrong. Goodbye then" while not even listing what's wrong.
Well said
give us evidences of these "problematic sentences" you talk about.
What is this pharmaceutical physician? BS 😂😂 😂
He/she is not lying, he/she is MD in Pharmacology, one of the subjects taught mandatorily in medical schools, it deals with researching medicinal drugs and their effects on human and animal bodies.@@uddhavkinhal1990
Taking word to word and judging someone is also problematic. Then someone would take a similar step on this video which would just lead to a debate. Rather having an open conversation and leaving the audience to decide is a better solution.
The intent was to consume food closer to nature and is minimally processed. We can't always depend on the society/govt/ any private organizations for the evidence since most of them are biased and misguided. At the end of the day, an individual has to have the knowledge to decide which is good/bad.
First, you should write better. This is horrible written.
Secondly, a person who has spent years to educate themselves as a doctor, must know the weight of their words when advising.
To defend such behaviour is dishonest.
@@TragicGFuelLet's not pick on the manner in which something is written but focus on the content! Not everyone is good at expressing themselves in a particular language but they might be putting forth a valid point that might be worth consideration.
@@benjamindsouza6736 I disagree, it's quite important to be able to communicate in a manner that is easy to understand, and gets your point across.
Neither of which were present in the original comment. Despite that, I addressed the content of his however poorly worded comment.
I may have been harsh, but I was not incorrect or misleading.
You are spot on. I personally follow Satvik Movement and have also done their workshop. True to what you said, their intent is to educate people to consume food closer to nature and avoid processed food. It is plain common sense that processed food contains harmful chemicals. We do not need an approval from any body to tell us chemicals, sugar etc are bad. At times, we should use our own common sense and judgement to decide what is good or bad for us.
@@sunilrao4523 what are these "chemicals" you talk about
Hey recently Dr. Pal was on Ranveer Allahabadia's podcast too and therefore we can come to a conclusion that whoever is a guest on Ranveer Allahabadia's should not be taken very seriously 😂😂
Exclude liverdoc
including liverdoc ,pranav 's friend ?
@@rajibdattaroy9105 I was just saying that statement for fun man. There are genuine people on his podcast too like liverdoc you just mentioned but yeah I was just trolling around, don't take me too seriously too 🤪🤪
as soon as you get countered you're all "prank tha bro"@@formulaetor8686
@@formulaetor8686What if I say Pranav is full of shit as well?
Another brilliant episode - being a medical doctor myself, I never watched Dr. Pal but when I started my channel in Telugu many people advised to watch him - I could see only one or two - but I get what you are saying. It does not look like a science talk- mostly, the effort is to increase the viewership - which is a trap once you are on social media. Thank you for the reminder - I will keep this on mind as goal to bring some health science and education to Telugu audience when writing my scripts.
Yes sir, indeed im a telugu doctor myself, and Dr. pal manickam seems to always push his subjective opinions instead of speaking with evidence
@@mopes2162 good to meet you here - we all have our own blind spots and hope he works on it - but for me - this is a great learning point as we alll have this habit and while writing a script for a topic we get biased to impress people - that is my take home message
I've only reached the Oreo part and I'm on Dr. Pal's side for this. Because the USDA says it's not harmful, it's not harmful? The dosage makes the poison bucko. Its harmful due to the fact that it is extremely calorie dense chief! Added sugar is harmful as well. These two things are partially why obesity is so high right now!
One oreo cookie has 53 calories. In 4 cookies, that's 212 calories. 4 is the least you're stopping at because its the smallest packet they offer. Most people do not have the discipline to eat ONE cookie. They will eat 4+.
Its recommended for ideal health that men consume 36g of sugar max and women 20g of sugar max. For women, with those 4 cookies, they're above that limit.
As an Indian origin person, if Indians had such discipline, and people on the whole had such discipline, people wouldn't be going through health issues as we speak. But they don't have discipline.
It is better off, for the sake of weight loss, to stay away from it. Pal has also talked about moderation on his channel as well. But you stay away from certain foods for weight loss due to how calorie dense they are. Pretty standard stuff too.
These so called rationalists won’t understand . No use explaining them .
Both are not wrong,it's the context that is different. It's much more nuanced because it can't be a blanket statement for everyone. Sure for a diabetic/obese individual it is best to avoid but for a normal individual eating an extra 200 calorie in one day isn't doing anything. As long as the calorie consumption is within the required amounts for a long period of time it's fine.
Dr Pal wasn't talking about calories, but fear mongering about Fructose corn syrup... Have you heard of the Twinkie diet which a Professor used to lose weight?
What is happening with Dr. Pal and many others is so typical of social media.
If you want a huge following in a short time, you will have to take shortcuts and compromise on your integrity. Thanks to science channels and folks like you Pranav who honestly promote science and are not worried about frequency of videos released or the number of followers.
Great job, please keep going. I hope you become the next Matt Dillahunty.
Thanks! Logical fallacies and rational thinking should be made mandatory in school curriculum.
Thank you so much!!
Ya thats correct actually we are never taught about these and also we tend to use analogies too often in too vague manner that they can be mis-interpreted.
Something that's not acceptable in the scientific community.
You saying why such things like Oreo’s if they are so bad exist on supermarket shelves…..just think about cigarettes than….bad yet still being sold so openly. Not everything that is sold can be claimed to be safe
Not saying your point doesn't make any sense..but your example is totally wrong..
"Cigarette or smoking is injurious for health" is what every packet of cigarettes or any harmful stuff has on it.
While Oreo is for kids and it's safe.
So you are comparing an obvious fssai marked harmful product with Oreo which is not harmful to eat as also marked by fssai.
I hope you get what I'm saying.
Fast food like McDonald's, etc are sold widely going through the so-called 'tests from US'. But is it really healthy and good for you? So, this person's points are just as questionable. It always makes sense to eat local, seasonal, least processed, etc for better health. Stored food is there in all cultures for preserving produce. In cold places, it is usually frozen, pickling. In tropical weathers, it is drying, pickling etc. What is suitable in US weather is definitely not in India. So, a good balanced diet with local, fresh produce is the best bet (occasional indulgence in different kinds of food in moderation helps satisfying one's taste buds).
Give patient Oreo or u eat when u r sick
But to buy Oreo you don’t need to show your age id 😅
@@geetha1968 absolutely 💯💯
Just because something is sold in the market , it doesn't mean it's good for you
Another thing he missed out is how addictive Oreos can be for a child . Most of the children nowadays have a dislike for healthy home cooked meals and prefer fast foods and processed foods
These companies never let claims that are against them go mainstream
You should also try to get in touch with Dr. Pal. Or invite him to the podcast.
Wow, the best 30 mins I have spent this week! Lit stuff.
Look who is here. Was bing watching floatheadphysics and came here just to see you again. Comment section is where now intellectuals meet.❤
Oi go and teach khan academy
Thank you Mahesh! Glad you enjoyed it!!
For boomers:
Pranav has changed his second Channel name to DD Rational!
Science is Dope exists!
Pranav, if you remember, I did tell you that he's problematic in Meghnad's live where Vimoh was also present.
You did, you did
Jinius
Awesome content bro. One request: Please dont quote US FDA blindly, they can be bought and bribed as well. I feel european regulators are equally good.
Wait when did i even subscribe to DD rational?
It's me bro :P
@@DDRational_ im kidding
Are you allowed to use that image? Won't Doordarshan have objections to someone using a mirrored version of their brand logo?
It's not the same image
Plz dont take bits and parts of Dr Pal's videos and call him out. It takes guts to say Oreo biscuits are horrible. We truly know they are. But still have them. Its a doctor's way of asking people to avoid them.
The new logo and the name is awesome.
Hoping to see many such videos on pseudoscientific topics such as Yoga which are deeply rooted in India. Anyways, nice video as always. BTW, recently there has been a creator awards of some sort in India and many prominent pseudoscience peddlers were present.
These days the doctors in India are fooling people with misinformation from their own domain.
Hm.. i am curious. How is Yoga pseudoscientific? Never heard that one- except that everyone should go with certified trainers because certain asanas are not good for certain medical conditions and things like that. Can you please elaborate on this?
Lol yoga is a pseudoscience for u. Lol lol and preventive measures are pseudoscience means then your whole life is pseudo only
@@GH-mj2tiyoga is definitely healthy but there's for sure many misinformation about it. Like yoga capable of curing diseases and improving sex performance
Who gave this guy the high pedestal? He says you should not fall back on authority n then projects USFDA as an authority. Any doctor will say oreos are bad for children. So that they will restrict it. We are humans not robots to put out textbook facts. And yes anyone will remove something when its affecting their social media image. He has not done a crime to admit it with integrity. Looks like he has lot of time on his hands to impose irrational stabdards on everybody in the name of rationality.
Lmao. USFDA and food regulatory organizations work for the people dude. Wtf are you talking about
@@RyzenRTX89 sure they do work for people as well as big pharma....Anyway it is about using and portraying authority which was called out as irrational
I need to learn this way of expressing thing - have smiling face and caring expression, no room for self questioning , act like spritual enlightened person
No You are wrong. Studies with HFCS have shown gain in body weight. Sugar is bad as well but HFCS is worse. Tell me something, if we have sugar then why do we need alternatives(if it's the same thing)?
Wrong. High fructose corn syrup IS a sugar. Look up simple and complex sugars. Also, when calories are equated there is no weight gain. Calories cause weight gain. Not "sugar" in isolation.
@@thepurplebox380 how did you counter my point? I said studies have shown worse results in HfCs than in sugarcane sugar ....
@@fer0xOriginal You said "Sugar is bad but HFCS is worse". Now you have corrected your statement to cane sugar which are now two different things.
Citation needed for cane sugar being worse than HFCS.
Here is my source: Tappy L, Lê KA. Metabolic effects of fructose and the worldwide increase in obesity. Physiol Rev. 2010 Jan;90(1):23-46. doi: 10.1152/physrev.00019.2009. PMID: 20086073.
Pranav as there is good research bad research is also there . Most research is funded by the companies who want their product sold making the research with inherent bias . Same appeal to authority argument can be use on the research presented . These multional companies have big lobying groups in the governing body itself they spend millions on the lobbying . The problem is not with food being toxic .It is about having relatively better food with positive health outcomes . It everything is fine them why does americans have so many health issues and with 70% obesity . It is just about having better food options.
Brother similar foods eaten by europeans but they are not obese.
Obese is not only due to bad 'DIET'
Overall lifestyle also matters
Ether way you can argue research papers by counter evidence not bs....
Because in research papers same size , methodologies are mentioned you can perform them again and again ......
If you got any other results you can counter that research paper
You would be correct if not for the fact that there's something called a PEER REVIEW process, and even then you can ask unrelated experts.
You presented a fallacy as a fact: "you know what is easiest food to digest by body, its processed food". Dude, get your head checked!
Exactly.
have you ever heard of complex sugars and simple sugars?? Also where is the evidence that says that unprocessed food is easier to digest.
He also said easier to digest does not equal healthy food.
25:50 as far as I have read sugar addiction is classified as a serious addiction now by the research community and it has been found to trigger the part of the brain that is triggered when you take drugs.
sugar withdrawal is also a very severe documented process.
and your logic of comparing people with weight loss as successfully overcoming sugar addiction doesn't hold up since people pit weight due to multitude of reasons, plus there are many drug addicts who have successfully stopped taking drugs after rehab. based on that we wouldn't say drugs aren't addictive would we?
its based more on the psychological and neurological state of the brain after you eat/use something
Thank you so much for this. Please keep uploading more such videos, they are a necessity in today's time of misinformation chaos
Use my link to join Stayqrious to pay zero admission fees:
r.stayq.us/ddrational
i really want the fallacy card back
Aanand Srinivas here :D Thanks so much Pranav for introducing StayQrious Neoschool, to your audience. It was so heartfelt.❤
Am so happy to see your enthusiasm for the kind of education we are providing at StayQ.
Also, really like the video. Critical thinking and scientific literacy are more important now than ever.
Just my two cents- Before the 18th century, during the pre-industrialization era, people's diets were entirely composed of organic or "natural" foods. They consumed what was closest to nature, devoid of preservatives, freeze-drying, artificial coloring, high fructose corn syrup, and other additives that naturalists such as the Satvic Movement, criticize.
Back then, the average life expectancy was approximately 35-40 years. In contrast, today's modern era showcases a significant increase in lifespan. This serves as a testament to the importance and impact of scientific advancements on human health and longevity. Science truly matters!
Life span increase is logical fallacy, bcz, before 20th century, what they say is 30-40 life expectancy, does not have sufficient data n as well no comparable data.
1. There used to be lot of wars, which is now reduced by n large. This in war torn area/era at any given point of time life expectancy is less.
2. Modern Medicine is not the solution to all. That's my own experience. Till the age is 23 I hated Ayurveda n thought Medicine means only Allopath(Modern Medicine) just 2 incident changed that my perception.
3. As per Allopaths reason for my shoulder pain no Allopath version was tellying with the other Dr. But my pain kept on increasing it reached unbearable situation n at that moment met Ayurvedic Dr. Just ₹18 medicine. No pain n nothing for the last 26 years. Absolutely fine. As per allopaths of 1998 I should have died by 2003. Lo behold I'm talking to u now. It's not my bhoota, in still alive . So allopath has to still evolve. Don't trust blindly allopaths. Yes, they saved my during COVID period, though I did not had COVID.
You know the life expectancy being 35-40 years doesn't mean that people generally used to live to 35-40 years but rather that the child mortality rate was so high that it brought the average down? Not eating processed food is good, the life expectancy has increased despite the proliferation of hyper processed food not because of it.
@@arunkumarnt
1. War was not the only reason people died early, bacterial diseases used to be more deadly due to the lack of antibiotics.
2 & 3 are purely anecdotal, cannot rely on them.
The doc Mike and Dr Gundry podcast is truly a good example that authority does not gaurranty that everything they say is correct.
I literally waited for your video on pal's video instead of watching that video 😂
adding my comment just to boost the video and also been following u since couple of years surely and i was always skeptical about foodpharmer nd dr pal giving such fear mongering creators all the best for your future endeavours 😃
Saw the podcast just the other day and was waiting for ur video debunking it. And here it is!
A few years back, I had this strange problem where one side of my cheeks and eye lids would swell up. I had to visit so many doctors, take variety of scans, like CT, MRI, multiple times, and so many pills. I would have visited some six to seven doctors in a span of one and a half years and really none of those doctors were able to provide a cure for my condition! They could not even say what it was! At last, what many would call as pseudoscience or whatever, a well known ayurvedic doctor put me on a three day panchakarma treatment to remove "toxins" from my body. All i had to do was fast for three days and then an ayurvedic powder was given for fifteen days and touch wood, i never encountered those dreadful swellings ever since! Whatever field it is, be it allopathy or naturopathy, it is good to question and be critical but underestimating and bashing them completely doesnt make sense! Many US based doctors themselves have criticised the Standard American Diet (SAD)! It is important to remember that the authorities most often collaborate with the big names from the "food industry". At the end of the day, we all do know that eating unprocessed, healthy food is indeed the best for health and this statement cannot be called as based on pseudoscience. Based on my own dreadful experience with the most experienced doctors and big hospitals, I can say that there is an area which is always unexplored and science had made huge progress but we cannot say we know it all and put down those who have different views !!!
My understanding from what you said is that the cure for sickness can come unexpecting places
Thank god someone called him out.There are many instances where he peddled misinformation to masses
Hi pranav
Some compnies(minor) put tag of fssai without approval. I saw it on my eyes. How would u expect ppl to believe fssai?
I find their ever smiling faces very sus and irritating. Nobody smiles 24*7
I saw a few videos about him, but the skeptic sensor in me started going off on him as he started celebrating Indian food by supporting them with "Science".
At first I thought he was trying to show the advantages of Indian food, so that Indian food is MORE than just taste.
But as he kept doing it more, I started to think maybe he's just doing it for views from Hindhu Indians, and once "Hindhu" came into my mind, I became skeptical.
So, thank you for exposing him.
I hope you understand that being skeptic is one of the most laziest think you can do in todays time. The real thing is not to be swayed by others propaganda and have a critical mindset of your own who is open to receive new avenues of thought.
Pranav is one of those virtue holders who think he knows many things but if you will dug deep with Pranav he knows nothing about the topics he speaks about, atleast not like someone who has really given some time.
He is one of those pseudoliberals who have liberal thoughts for only one section of the society, the section which is non violent and allows free thought.
You say hindu a hindu will appear on your reply 🤣🤣
@@knowledgeiswealth. Why you people behave like you are in a cult?
Rarely I have seen a proper coherent argument from you people. You went for the cheap tactics when you knew you cant stand a chance.
You are not convincing anyone by this behaviour, you are only making our convictions stronger about you guys and Pranav.
@@knowledgeiswealth.
That's fine
@@devilback8871
That's exactly how we feel about you.
awesome. won't you get copyright infringement issue for mocking original DD logo?
I've inverted it
Bro be careful though.
Pranav you are a gift to scientific temperament in India ❤
Sir how can u hold the logo of DD..DO u faced any legal notice..or knowingly the legall problem u face on logo design and DD name...hope u r aware?..
I thought DD collaborated with Pranav 😂
15:34 Fibres are not at all digested they are required for normal flora of the gut, for regular bowel movement and to increase the bulk of feces.
Just small correction
Thank God someone called him out.
Just a way of saying. There's no god whatsoever.
That's pretty clear Dr. Pal delete any critical comments. I just went on the Dr. pal podcast to see the comments. Not a single comment questioning the authenticity or critical about the podcast. I know most Indians believe in those B.S.. But we have not fallen so much to let them get away with it.
You severely underestimate the proportion of rational thinkers in India..
Many CZcamsrs do this
Congratulation for the channel rename. It's really catchy & also very apt name.
Hey Pranav brother , i m a big fan of your channel and i owe a lot to you for leading me to the path of rationality and skepticism ( started watching as a middle school student. the early access to your channel has i believed solidified my scientific temper. ) . Although i was extremely disappointed with Dr.Pal promoting pseudoscientific channels , he is not all bad. Infact i believe his contribution on the youtube health space has been pivotal, there has been a change in people's attitudes with junk food. Any video that indulges in gluttony has been received with caution which i think is a positive change as people no longer encourage binge eating ( all thanks to Dr .Pal) . A major cooking channel had to stop their series of cooking dishes accompanying alcoholic beverages , once again because people charged with rage at their promotion of alcoholism ( owes to Dr Pal). He has never outrightly prohibited eating junk food and has always advocated for moderation and exercise. Therefore i think cherry picking one incident with the oreo episode doesnt settle well with me and i think it is an unscientific , deliberate attempt on your part to undo all his goodness. I may have misinterpreted your intentions , im happy to be proved wrong.
His wife on the other hand, promoting quacks like detoxifying diets
My sister has a daughter but she is just 6 months old I will sure use be curious platform in future
Damn, how do you manage to make good points with evidences without getting confused by giving benefit of doubts and without getting carried away from main points?
I loved the video and the way information was presented in a simpler, direct manner.
idk why but getting a heart on comment by Pranav is more addictive than sugar (cocain) ...
Enjoy your high
@@DDRational_ zero calories consumed
Dr Pal taking lessons from the king beerbiceps, especially in nodding
Sometimes CZcams suggests wrong videos😂😂...
Fructose , unlike any other substance ,is metabolized completely by the liver which causes a high probability of liver fat deposition , which is a big cause of metabolic syndrome....
Please research properly before making a video
Need to have boxing match Dr Pal Va TheLiverDoc
Omg, i have been following stayqrious and aanand sir from the start, I even took their coding classes and it was really beneficial? They really deliver what the preach!
I am glad seeing you collaborate with them!!!
Sir What is your thoughts on Kashish Gupta he is A biomechanics Guy Can i Follow Him?
Hey pranav, Is that you in a byjus video where they interview people asking them about female condoms?
@@user-pj1wv1ns9x it's real. I even have that video with me.
Hey Pranav! The name of this channel is so dope!
Did you change the name to dd rational because dd is showing temple darshans now?
Hahaha not really, i just liked the pun lol
"Oreos are okay"
Would really appreciate if you could recommend us some really great books that you liked the most. It could be about anything, maybe Science, logic or about rationality. Your videos are really well researched and tightly scripted. Thank you
Will do soon :) will make a video :)
The podcast is still on his CZcams channel
czcams.com/video/kWgSzyP8B9E/video.htmlsi=EnJNoV27ZVxP84IM
Great informative video man. Now days people only fear mongering about sugar and preservatives without any conclusive evidence.
Hope this type of videos will counter that narrative and spread awareness among the people.
I watch Dr Pal, although his videos are very entertaining and informative. I was really disappointed with the satvic movement podcast he did😂
I guess overall he has been doing well to change people's dietary habits but has been caught up in the social media views game and wants "all sections" of people to click on his videos including anti science ones. I feel generally people are not anti science perse but they just equate modern medicine to corporate hospital greed and that is why most of them become disillusioned with modern science and these naturo guys prey on such people and try to make a quick buck from these guys.
Hey a suggestion, great video, but i think so you could improve the video quality by shooting the videos in 4k and uploading in 4k as well. The sharpness matters when on high resolution display. It would just look better. Great production quality nevertheless
Hey have you made any video on fittuber? Many years ago I called him out but got no response. His videos and misinformation are beyond anything.
Pranav, Please add that DD National's intro also, that would be perfect.
I was just wondering when you will make a video about Dr. Pal's satvik movement podcast. And here it is!!!
Dr pal asks you to eat healthy whole food. If that is pseudoscience then I feel bad for you man.
Mostly agreeing with you bro but the fact you are pulling up research of food quality/ approval etc from US, a country which has bad food habits compared to India makes me think twice on trusting them...
Exactly
US People's bad food habits have nothing to do with the scientists working from all over the world in FDA.
Dude what r u saying
@@aesthetic15912 exactly
I FOUND ONE MORE "Appealing to authority" : appealing to US FDA
you really just compared 1 person to the general consensus and thought you did something.
@@suyashtiwari4698 that one person is not some tom dick or Harry, he is an experienced gastroenterologist
Actually the facts which this guy said is also not right.... he is just showcasing whatever he googled....
I had been a fan of satvic movement channel when they initially started. And oh boy! I did start “fearing” all “un natural” food. I admit I had gone all crazy checking every food label, trying to do everything “natural” but ultimately it stressed me out. I just realized that the diet they are promoting is not feasible and practical for many of us.
And soon I starting raising my eyebrow on their ‘cell phone radiation causing cancer’ claims and all that. I watched your videos and it really helped me see this information from another perspective.
This is my conclusion- if even 75-80% of the time you are eating a well balanced diet , controlling the amount of sugar you consume, and keeping your total calories in control, exercising moderately -you are good!
And be healthy mentally
Isn't that what Dr pal is saying??
Satvic movement is scam.stay away.their enema and wet packs are bullshit.I have stopped taking any health advice from CZcams.
Everyone knows tobacco and alcohol is bad for health but they are still available in market, same way Oreos and similar snacks ara available in market.
Both Cigarette and Alcohol has disclaimers that they are injurious to health and isn't accessible to children. So its not the same as Oreos and snacks.
Perhaps they need to include these warning on most processed food labels! @@aswinvv666
Thanks, this was awesome. Many smiles and much metta.
I just thought mannn were going National !!! by seeing your face on "DD Rational"😄😄. Im positive this rebranding will work.
I was waiting for this, I could not stand watching that podcast, or even listening, I watched like a minute or two and I could not take it lol
thanks for this bro, satisfied my roasting cravings
Link for your discussion with the nutritionist? Sorry couldn’t find it
Very cool channel name Pranav. Nice.
Bro about to be get sued by doordarshan
You brought out all the best points. Superb work.
In India, most of us became doctors and engineers without a thorough college education (we are just achievers in one single 2-3 hour MCQ exam) -thanks, Pranav, for filling that gap in our society. Love from the USA, Dr. Kiran (pun intended here, but I am a Radiologist, so I am still not a full doctor, Lol)
Hahaha ..what do you mean not a full doctor 😂😂😂...here in india radiology is the most sought out branch 😂😂
@@thestealth293 agree here in USA too - I mean - we do not see patients directly and some people even in US think - do they really go to Med School?
@@MadeInAndhra-rk5mw hahaha yes sir , I'm taking internal medicine as soon as I get a good rank in neet pg ( July 7th ) ...I don't like the darkroom 😂😂😂 & i also like the stress which comes along with medicine residency makes me feel like some kind of solider in a war 😂😂
@@thestealth293 all best - 2000 entrance exam - I wished to take internal medicine - but it was already taken by better ranks at that time - and between anae and rad - I picked rad - retrospect this is better fit for me
Lol my guy here thinks there would be regulations if it was harmful for body. My guy is too innocent for this wirld.
For people reading this,just don't go around eating Oreo's after seeing this video, they still very unhealthy.
The point was, the content of process foods are checked to ensure that a person's life is not endangered by consumption in small amounts.
Not that Oreos specifically are 100% healthy. That's a logical error where you derive a conclusion from statements unrelated to it.
The only conclusion you can draw from his statement is that regulations restrict the meals from using anything extremely harmful.
I was waiting for someone to call out these dumb satvic fallacies... these people are so dangerous