How Beerbiceps finds SCIENCE in SPIRITUALITY | Pseudoscience Police
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 08. 2024
- This is a criticism of Beerbiceps (Ranveer Allahbadia). He’s been really popular on CZcams India the last few years. But ever since he went from fitness to topics under spirituality, particularly with his podcast, he’s been endorsing a lot of pseudoscience.
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
02:16 - Ranveer’s content
04:12 - Karma - “Be open minded”
07:35 - Astral Travel
10:18 - An anti-science narrative
14:20 - Spirituality vs. Quantum Mechanics
20:38 - Spirituality - A gateway to scams
22:27 - NoFap andSemen Retention
25:23 - Alpha-males, hookup culture and more
27:51 - Conclusion
28:49 - Channel Memberships
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
Sources:
[1] - reelCSwtPP...
[2] - Astral Travel Podcast -
• The Complete Astral Tr...
[3] Astrology -
muller.lbl.gov/papers/Astrolo...
[4] ScienceIsDope_/st...
[5] Science vs Spirituality Podcast
• How Science Explains S...
[6] What the bleep do we know documentary -
• Video
[7] Reiki - about-cancer.cancerresearchuk...
[8] Nofap& Semen Retention Podcast -
• Vegetarianism, Masturb...
[9] Nofap research -
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama...
[10] Semen Retention -
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
[11] www.medicalnewstoday.com/arti...
#Beerbiceps
#Criticism
#Spirituality
#Ranveer
Music Credits:
Investigations - Kevin MacLeod
Eine Kleine Nachtmusik - Mozart
Things are going Sothampton - Verified Picasso
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
CZcams: / scienceisdope
Oh yeah I forgot to ask you guys! What do you think of my new filming location/background/lighting?
Nice but you should speed up speaking .you speaks very slowly. We have to play at 1.5 speed to save time.
Wonderful
Nice and minimalist.
Really good
Please Make a video on pseudoscience by india in details
Saying that "not harmful " practices in Hinduism should be ignored
To those who say it's unscientific she says science hasn't discovered each and every information on each and every subject
Hence it's okay if people believe it even if there is no evidence
Hey loved your content .....voice can be more clear I feel...and some funny memes can be added ...a little humour....that will increase your views....doing a good job ...keep rocking
Ranveer is sooo open minded, his brain fell out.
Hilarious 😄
He is actually open minded and open minded means making no conclusions rather than using rationality as an excuse.
@@stefano1405 idk where you get your definitions from, but open-mindedness is associated more with the willingness to listen to other ideas. Coming to no conclusions? Tf is that supposed to mean? How are you supposed to live your life without coming to conclusions about anything? How are you going to separate out truth from bullshit? You need logic/statistics for that.
@@pawarranger wild idea right that's why you need to consider the possibility, as one can live without making conclusions, and what happens when you live without conclusions you get more clarity of your thoughts and how your mind decept you it's hard for sure cause humans generally need something to fall upon that's why they make conclusion as human mind can't live in uncertainty but the time you start living in uncertainty you start seeing as they are without if's and but, As I said this idea is wild so you need to be open-minded to consider this possibility. And when I said making no it simply meant willing to consider an idea with unprejudiced attitude and how will willingness come to even consider a possible when you will have your own conclusion/prejudice about other so much so you're not willing to consider the idea. Logic/statistics what they have to do with this lol.
@@stefano1405 @Stefano you get more clarity when you live with uncertainty? wtf? You might think that what you're saying sounds very virtuous and all but that's as far as it goes. I can present any bullshit idea and then just say "you have to be open about it". open-mindedness should not be at the expense of rationality. There are infinite possibilities, not all are equally likely, trying to separate the more likely ones from the rest is what you do when you use logic/statistics. Reason is what advances civilization. If humans used your standards for the acceptance of ideas, we'd still be living in caves.
Science is not western or eastern, Science is Science.
Exactly
@@scienceisdope I am a Big fan of you brother. Your points are good. Love from Tripura
@@SebastianWilder08 thanks man, please do share the video among like minded folks
@@scienceisdope yes, My friend Circle have so many blind believers. Keep Growing bro ❤️
@@scienceisdope Amazing video bro, just upload more frequently and you will have 100k preety soon 👍
Finally an Indian skeptic channel!! I have tears of joy!
Us bro
How did your Ludovico's Technique go bro 😭?? 🤣
Great channel though, I agree with you
Well everything is a business in this world so if you believe anything you are no skeptical. I think I apply to be truly skeptical cause I don't believe in either. I doubt both modern science and religion.
Read the following concepts of Buddha's teachings found in Kalama Sutta.
1. Don't trust religious books.
2. Don't trust religious leaders.
3. Don't trust rumours.
4. Don't trust just because your trusted one said it.
5. Don't even trust me, The Buddha.
Now so called skeptics will agree to this.
But Buddha also rejected to believe in authorities such as scientists since they are doing this to earn money.
So if you want to be skeptical them show your skepticism towards everything. Just like me. I only do things that give me benifits and I read articles scientific like Healthline but I won't tell anyone that it's absolutely correct. According to Nietzsche, father of Nihilism (he was not actually a nihilist though), there are no facts only interpretations. But since religion failed you, you choose believing the opposite (science) over rejecting everything. Become an absurdist ( a philosophy by Camus which says everything is absurd)
Sorry for the long comment.
@@playmobilegamescodm Let me guess... you're that student who writes an essay beating around the bush as an answer for the question because you have no idea what the actual answer is.
You also expect to get marks for it.
I am a computer engineer and i feel voices like yours need to be heard and supported
do you have to be computer engineer to say that ?
@@sarthakgupta5064 good burn bro 😂
@@sarthakgupta5064 I was gonna say that too man!🤣🤣
u are a king bro. i am trying in the subject specifically calculus 2 and im struggling i am honored by people who complete it.
Engineer?
Lol
How do you know dragons don't exist
-Ranveer allahbadia
Underrated comment
@@shashidharbelagavi5577 yaav urr Anna?
😂😂😂😂😂
@@youarebest3591 hlo maccha
And if they don't, how did the Game of Thrones writer think of them? Why do so many people watch GoT? 😂
Science getting so dope here, that I'm expecting NCB raids.
Hahahahaaha epic
underrated comment : )
Great 😂
Hello atharva.
This is sodosyiance
🎤💧
Shady guy: let me tell you right now, I myself have gone through an out of body experience, I have done astral travel.
Ranvir: Same.
Shady guy: I have seen the insides of my own brains.
Ranvir: Same.
Shady guy: I am actually god.
Ranvir: Same.
😂😂😂
😁😁😁
😂😂
@Facts Overload come on mahn... Why you lying?
What about me.... THE SUPREME ONE? 😂
Shady guy: i sucked your dick
Ranvir: Same.
Shady guy: what? how?
As weird as it might sound, I watch these videos to develop critical thinking skills
atleast you are doing something
ayo i do it too..
And that's the only thing u will get. And u will not get closer to the truth. Remember, a lack of evidence doesn't mean a lack of truth.
"we are not allowed to talk about this on a public platform 😂😂😂" literally a cult
Shit I should have said that in the video lol
Not everything that is said in that light is definitely a cult practice. Here's a video I saw of the practice of Tumo, an advanced yogic practice and the monk clearly shows concerns of teaching it to the public. It's more to preserve a way of doing a process effectively. czcams.com/video/cUQ-SV092GM/video.html so don't jump to conclusions too soon my friend.... Not everyone in the world is out to con you...Secondly... obviously he didn't explain the benefits of Brahmacharya properly... Many Athletes performing in sports events abstain from sexual activity, it's more to do with the mental focus on whatever activity they are doing. The concept of yoga and words such as Ojas are more linked to self control, discipline to be able to control your mind. Obviously people who have immense control over their minds become very efficient and effective people and thus the benefits stated behind brahmacharya are mostly linked to will power and control over the mind and cravings. The concept of absorption of semen into the mind is not literal according to Patanjali. To him virya is more connected to self control and willpower than the actual liquid itself. It is a practice that's not just about abstinence from sexual pleasures rather having full control over any impulsive behaviors be it food, habits, routines. All of these are to restructure yourself to have an awareness of your self and the cravings of each of your senses. It is deep rooted within Yogic thought that you and your internal cravings are different. There might not be substantial proof for a soul but there definitely is proof for separation of different parts of the minds though they may seem as one unit.
@@scienceisdope also you made a few mistakes in your Video about the age of the universe according to Hindu thought. And your assumptions of comparing a Brahmanand to the universe is false too... You probably need to sit with a few vedic cosmology scholars and pin down what they think of ananta koti Brahmandas and how these models match to the current scientific models...
@@saheellodhia270 please tell me what those mistakes are
@@scienceisdope one day is 4.32 billion years... Similarly one night is 4.32 billion years... i think you said 4.32 for the whole 24 hours...so you might want to change that... Further this is the age of one Brahmanand -bhrahm... Expanding... "And" egg the expanding egg... To me one Brahmanand closely resembles descriptions of the Milky Way . Since there are many many more galaxies... one Brahma is for one such galaxy. But never the less it's a distinct model. However, it has a specific world view and so whether it is referring to the modern day galaxy or super cluster... Is up to anyone's interpretation. But i strongly feel that the Brahmanand is not equal to the universe since there are references to existence of multiple Brahmas in each Brahmanda. I hope i was able to articulate it clearly...
I've always been the person who's smart enough to know something's not right, but not enough to exactly elaborate why it is wrong. Thank you for putting your precious time, energy and this in-depth effort into researching so we don't have to. You and your videos give me hope. ✨
Yah pal those are my exact words. Cheers n big thanks to this genius 🙌
I love you biteach
Hahaha true for me as well. 😂
It's unpleasant yet positive so many people feel that by the amount of likes on this comment. I hope we aren't just hypocrites.
I agree too, there was something very plastic about Ranveers enthusiasm, either he is convinced or he knows how to trend in the masses,
Yeah I was trying to do the same....
I'm sick of the word "spirituality"
Such blatant spread of misinformation without claims needs to be called out 👏 Loved your way of taking on it in such a rational way.
He is also doing same bro... blatantly spreading misinformation... when you will start practicing meditation and yoga then you will realise...but who cares? He says that he is rational but actually he is not..science is actually a part of spirituality but he would not agree because I am sure he hasn't practiced yoga nor meditation in his whole life
Everyday, more globe believers are shocked to know that:
1. All earth images from space are fake.
2. No rocket has gone above 100 km in altitude.
3. Antarctica circumnavigation has never happened.
4. Satellites don't exist.
5. Flights never nose dive because of no curvature.
6. Flights between australia and south america never fly over Antarctica, instead it goes through northern part.
7. Moon landing is fake.
8. No 24 hour sun in Antarctica.
9. A huge difference in heat from the sun between noon and morning-evening.
10. Polar star trails are circular, but it should be straight lines or some other abstract shape if earth is flying at 800,000 kmph speed.
11. So-called space videos are from balloons using a fish eye lens camera and from 3D softwares.
12. Moon's night side is same as sky instead of black.
13. "A live telecast of rocket attached with a regular lens camera going up atleast 20,000 km in altitude or upto whole earth comes in a single frame" has never happened, no one even tried.
14. Go fast rocket hit the dome about 98 km.
15. During solar eclipse the alleged moon's shadow is about only 100 km wide and it moves from west to east , north-east to south-west and many directions.
16. Sometimes lunar eclipse occurs while the sun is still above the horizon.
17. Our eyes and senses tell that we are not moving and not spinning.
@@hedwig6643Personal experiences doesn't lead to empirical evidences. You need to provide subjective evidences in favour of spirituality. Though I agree scientific theories and religious principles or philosophies sometimes overlap with each other but I don't think it's the case between science and spirituality and claiming science is a part of spirituality is absurd when there is no solid evidence to prove the existence of spirituality, spritual realm or whatever.
@@hedwig6643yoga and meditation are good I think he is talking about pure spirituality
Now I can Die in peace that someone had perfectly pointed out this bullshit
just checkin
He is so wannabe and woke that he woke up dead but glad to inform you Suurav that he died peacefully and absolved himself from the suffering that he faced from obsession over an Internet podcaster who sadly will never know how peacefully he died.
Physics is bullshit to a monkey
You have a long life to go btw soon believing that it was ultimately not a bullshit.
If I drink a peg everytime you say 'evidence' I will probably get liver cancer. I would then have to use 'quantum healing' to cure it. Great videos btw. Content that we didn't know we deserve.
Hahaha I know a liver specialist pretty well. Can refer you
love how you said peg LMAO
@@octs609 Indianized the meme! xD
Probably alcohol intoxication first lmao
In a certain time interval and in certain human capacity if people are unable to give evidence, does it mean that their claim is completely wrong?
When I was a kid and into my twenties, I had vivid dreams featuring different times and places around the world. When I woke up after having these dreams I was exhausted, as though I had actually been traveling. These kinds of "spiritual" beliefs led me to believe I was astral travelling or that I was experiencing different lifetimes. Spiritual open-minded adults told me it was a gift, that I was probably psychic.
So it never occurred to me to consider physical issues until i was living with a partner-- who repeatedly found me not breathing in my sleep. I saw a doctor and surprise! I have central apnea.
My fancy dreams were result of hypoxia/hypoxemia. 🤦
I hope you are doing great now 🙏🙏 god bless ya❤
"I truly believe in rebirth"
The same guy five seconds later - "Don't come to conclusions" 🤣
“It pays to keep an open mind, but not so open your brains fall out.”
― Carl Sagan
Keep the good stuff coming Pranav. Dope as usual.👌🙌
Also Carl Sagan -
"The Hindu religion is the only one of the world's great faiths dedicated to the idea that the Cosmos itself undergoes an immense, indeed an infinite, number of deaths and rebirths. It is the only religion in which the time scales correspond, no doubt by accident, to those of modern scientific cosmology. Its cycles run from our ordinary day and night to a day and night of Brahma, 8.64 billion years long, longer than the age of the Earth or the Sun and about half the time since the Big Bang."
@@yuribezmenov9257 the liberals are brainwashed by the abrahamic concept of religion.
Any resource supporting this claim?
@@Mr_Steak358 Read Carl Sagan book Cosmos or you can search on CZcams
@@a_man_jaiswal Yes i get it what you're tryin to say. But in cosmos he was not promoting the religion but rather was contrasting between different civilizations and it turns out civilization here was able to better approximate it.
This is so eye opening, India needs people like you.
Ranveer changes his personality with every guest on his podcast...
I won't be surprised If Zakir Naik comes to Ranveer's podcast he is gonna dwell on his thoughts too 🤷🏻
@@kratos7501 that's the literal definition of a true liberal being able to accept a wide array of opinions not just keep crying about things which have proofs.
Ranveer is deeply traumatized. Only he doesn't know it
Hell yeah...
Everything has happened with him ..
Whatever has happened with his Guest
CZcamsrs like beerbiceps fit tuber etc. has changed their agenda and started making videos on topics which they either don’t have proper understand or non scientific claims . With fluent English and high production quality claimed as “Research “, these guys are putting youth into wrong direction.
I don't watch TRS, but used to watch Fit Tuber for diet and weight loss, now it's laughable with the amount of claims about Ayurveda he makes
+@ aritra talapatra
I feel that persons like BeerBiceps and Fit Tuber (and even Belle Monappa Hegde) do it because they realise that the market for the exaggerated pitch of "India is the best", "Indian wisdom is the best", "the rest of the world has never been as intelligent or as wise as Indians", etc. is a very, very lucrative one.
Such assertions make a LOT of Indians feel good, never mind the fact that the veracity of many of those claims and assertions is highly dubious.
An important point -- it is all "Hindu" wisdom, "Hindu" intelligence, "Hindu" knowledge -- may be with a little bit of accommodation given to Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs (in order to coopt them).
In fact, these guys are actually doing a great disservice to genuine science-oriented intellectuals of India -- persons like Bhaskara I and II, Aryabhata, Madhava of Sangamagrama, Sushruta, Sir C V Raman, Sir J C Bose, S N Bose, to name just a few.
How long would they make videos on exercise and fasting ?
Ex hindu you just spitted pure facts. These delusional people think no ody can be better than them
Making people aware about the realm beyond this physical world you think it's putting people in the wrong direction?
The moment when someone starts to differentiate science as western science and eastern/ancient indian/ vedic science. And give excuses like science doesn't know, modern science is not advance and quantum quantum. That's the time you will realize there will be a lot of bull crap is going to be spoken from them.
Ur scientific mind just blows me up. Tell me about the origin of Big Bang 🙏
@@trinityspeaks3708 im neither this guy nor can i tell you the origin of the big bang but i can tell you something that all scientist agree on and that is that
SCIENCE IS SCIENCE it doesn't matter where it came from or when it came about and if you start to differentiate between them, you know nothing of science
(I might have interpreted what you said in the wrong way so forgive me if im wrong)🙏
@@trinityspeaks3708 there's nothing like eastern or western science.. science don't differentiate between boundary,race or ethnicity..
Western science is a term coined by insecure people to demote science & push forward their own unproved BS .
@@kaizen_monk I see many people are so simply blinded. Lack of "knowledge" I guess. Let me educate on this. For example , there is scientific term called " nasal douching". This was mentioned in Charaka samhita/ Ayrvedic science as "jal neti". Yes science is science. When we say Vedic science, we simply mean the origin. You guys have got serious colonial blinders 😂😂😂
@@kaizen_monk When we say eastern science it simply means its origin. Those things should be questioned. Infact so called western science should be questioned too. Problem with you guys are u don't question "western science". Scientific temperament requires one to constantly question and research on their own. You guys don't do any. You simply believe wat a European scientist say. You guys have turned Science into another religious cult 😂😂😂
Bro, we need people like you🙌
Thank you!
Yeah we need this dunce like we need another pandemic. Guys like him are a virus for India.
@@scienceisdope cant help u financially right now but will definetly do so in future .........continue this good work bro...contribution to the society is the ultimate purpose of life tbh and ur on that path so am sure u r enjoying the process...wish u the best.
@@scienceisdope us din admin ne paneer khaya
@@rahul-rz5uj 😭😭😭
Ranveer Is Ultra Modern Baba Who Didn't Run Off To Some Random Jungle To Get Enlightenment But Attained All Enlightenment Sitting In His AC Room. 🙊
Accepting that there is no such thing as enlightenment is the true enlightenment.
@@highlander2980 WORD ! 😂🙌
He is really the poster boy of pseudoscience. Waiting for the video
5:30 pm!
@@scienceisdope video on ACHARYA Prashant please
Hi fellow Light Yagami, nice to come across your profile
@@lightyagami8760 Hello bro 😂😂
@@SatyamKumar-gp9ej pls don't kill me. You are the real god. The god of the new world.
Modern Science has a long way to go.. a long way to go till where? Till it agrees with your claim right now?😂
You killed it with this one statement bro! I usually find it very difficult to respond to such presumptuous claims! You though seem to have a very good hang of it.. looking forward to learn a lot more from you.. cheers 🎉🎉
Thanks a lot man :) Please share the video so that it reaches more people :)
@@scienceisdope you think it's cool to be an atheist?? This is the result of rice bag conversion. I study science as well as my hindu dharm not like you kid who just want to look cool in the name of science.
@@scienceisdope nd makes you some money
@@adityathakur9569 like ranveer is running a charity
A long way to discover, "What's behind our consciousness?, "What's the mystery of Pyramids?" "Why do we sleep?". "Why do we dream?" "What is the concept of past life?" [ In case you want evidence, search about Lubdhi Devi]. "Why out of millions of species, only the human beings are most evolved?" "Who created such a complicated machine like human brain?" "Where does our consciousness go after we die?" "Why do animals know what to eat and what not to, but we've to know from written articles?"
If you are willing to accept that you don't know anything, thn you'll be able to learn something. Until then you'll debate to prove something, that is written somewhere. But everything you need to know are within ourselves. 🤗
I have always been against this concept of pseudoscience and want to call people out, but with my mother who is into so much superstition, I cannot find the courage to publicly call out such people. You are doing an amazing job!
Anyone here after 👉 Dhruv Rathee Video...😂😂😂
I'm a medical student and I don't have time to watch videos on youtube because priorities but I still subscribed, because channels like these NEED to grow, and our society needs people like you to spread awareness on such topics. Due to such misinformed influential people, there is a loss of valuable human resource which affects all of us, and that is why what you're doing is legit, DOPE. Brilliant work, sir!
This guy must be going to astrologer ... people who act a lot goes to astrologer
Looks like this guy is perfect for your personal agenda and give your ego a Lil water
Dont waste your time on this channel, there are so many better things to watch
Ur medical student and still u have not learnt that "doctors can only treat wound& god heals it !
U can facilitate wound healing u can't heal it ...
And u still have not learnt the meaning of idiopathic 💁🏽♂️
@@34chetansuppar4 It is not god, it is our body that heals the wound. Grow up.
Ranveer is few more podcasr away from say Earth is flat. How does he know? Because many other famous people say it. How can he prove it? How can science prove eart is not flat?
Ranveer can prove it bcz he is spiritual 😂😂
Earth is flat.copy rights reserved to Bible and Quran... Don't you dare copy anything from holy books. We will silence you in a peaceful way.
Idiot it was western scientists who claimed earth was flat and denied Indian astronomers theory which said earth was round 3500 years ago in Vedic textures 😂
@@jesusite69 there is no mention that Earth is Sphere is vedas. LOL
@@SebastianWilder08 illiterate ignorant brute, Refer to Rigveda V 10.121 and also refer Brahmanda and Bhagavatha purana V 10.87 which tells about Earth's shape and dimensions . Before commenting crap, make some basic research. "Lol"😂 on your face
You sir deserve to grow as a channel… seeing a fellow Indian talking on issues that no one wants to touch on and putting out quality videos on par with other science guys on CZcams like forrest valkai gives me goosebumps. #respect
You spoke my mind. People like Ranveer and Sad guru are not really helping people, in that to to help people think critically. But they make people more vulnerable to myths and pseudo science. I appreciate your work very much. Keep it up.
These self proclaimed quantum science "experts" must be made to sit and watch NPTEL videos on electron tunneling and nanoparticles. Then they would not come up this these jargons...At least they would know "ye unki bas ki baat nahi hai" and would refrain themselves from using these terms when and wherever possible.
Kudos and loved to your comment Dhiya.. :D :D NPTEL videos is what they need.
Nah. They're simply going to use all that information to prepare an even higher quality word salad.
Thank you 😊
True😂
When you somehow clear engineering with lot of supplies and then talk about quantum physics and nano science, it really hurts ! These CZcamsrs (beerbiceps, fit tuber ) where initially joined CZcams as a normal human, now they have became something else.
Hello Pranav, most of those who evoke spirituality these days practice knowledge elitism. Good that there are channels to counterbalance the effect. Yours is one of the most underrated channels and thank you for the quality content. All the very best. it's true, Science is dope.
Thanks man :) Please do share so I can reach more people
Maybe slightly controversial, but this knowledge elitism and spirituality link seems old to me, ingrained in the caste system.
@@mayb8876 yea, true..
@@mayb8876 spirituality is ingrained in the caste system. Wow! Hats off to you.
@@pasttimer27 coz the elite was the term used for brahmins
I wish science was presented in this manner in our schools so we wouldn't have had a vast audience who fall for such claims without supporting elements.
I have been sharing your videos so that I can create awareness atleast in my immediate circle!!
i admire the way you specify the logical fallacies write then and there. It really improves the critical thinking amongst the viewers including me.
well articulated, nice!
Thank you! Been a fan of your work for a long time!
@@scienceisdope it means you are the next😂😂
@@Sachin-pi3zu Science Journey is not about Science, it's about religion vs religion. That guy doesn't give any scientific evidence
I can understand how difficult it might be to make such a critisism video without going personal , good job!
Amazing video man !!! It kinda passes me off when people casually throw around the word "quantum" whenever they fail to explain anything....Recently I watched lectures of IIT madras(NPTEL) on introduction to quantum mechanics and I was astounded by the complexity and beauty of human genius...It makes my blood boil to see such lack of gratitude amongst people for these scientists....I mean they have given up their lives for their scientific research, they do deserve some respect...
we want this type of eye opener content please continue your journey never stop....
I don't want to believe.
I want to know.
- Carl Sagan
Unfortunately in India we lack good science educators.. Any one interested to know more on how scientific methods work in medicine, plz read trick or treatment by simon singh. The key point the treatment effectiveness study does not focus on how the treatment works , it focuses on whether a treatment works or not. So you may have a method which science does not understand, but still scientic methods can prove whether that treatment works or not..
The saying is those who believe in spirituality and those who don't believe in spirituality without evidence are on the same page. Since both are yet to explore reality. Btw I found a few thoughts about you as biased too which made me question both Ranveer and you.
Real spiritual growth is when you realise that science is the most important thing to understand what this world is all about.
When these baba, tantra mantra chanters speaks bs about quantum mechanic my brain hurts. Literally i have a Master degree in laser physics which is mostly quantum physics.
Same issue here. Doing PhD in Quantum and Statistical Mechanics, and my brain literally hurts when I hear these things said by those people.
I'm so glad people are finally calling out something which we all have doubted at some point in our life. Not only did he brought logic and science in this discussion, but also clarified the whole western vs eastern concept of science.
Just found your channel, thanks for the noble work you’re doing 🙏🏽
How Beerbiceps finds SCIENCE in SPIRITUALITY | Pseudoscience Police
**Introduction:**
The video addresses Ranveer, popularly known as Beerbiceps, directly, expressing concerns about the potential spread of pseudoscience and misinformation in his content, especially related to spirituality. The critic acknowledges Ranveer's past positive influence in fitness content but contends that issues arose when he delved into spiritual topics.
**Body:**
1. **Spirituality and Lack of Definition:**
- The critic defines spirituality as a vague and undefinable concept, suggesting that its ambiguity allows various ideas to fall under its umbrella.
- Argues against dismissing skepticism as close-mindedness, emphasizing the importance of rationality and evidence in evaluating ideas.
2. **Karma and Rebirth:**
- Draws parallels between the concept of karma and the claim of an invisible, intangible unicorn in the room, emphasizing the lack of evidence supporting exceptional claims.
- Challenges the idea of astral travel and rebirth by highlighting the absence of scientific evidence and proposing alternative explanations for reported experiences.
3. **Science and Spirituality:**
- Critiques Ranveer's argument that science is not as advanced as perceived, emphasizing the need for evidence-based reasoning.
- Raises concerns about the anti-science narrative and its potential impact on followers' trust in medicine, suggesting a dichotomy between Eastern and Western ideas that may not be valid.
4. **Pseudoscientific Endorsements:**
- Analyzes Ranveer's endorsement of pseudoscientific ideas such as manifestation, law of attraction, and quantum mechanics, providing counterarguments and clarifying misconceptions.
- Addresses the potential influence of such ideas on followers' beliefs in various pseudoscientific concepts.
5. **Sexuality and Energy Exchange:**
- Criticizes the promotion of regressive ideas related to alpha males and the exchange of energy during physical intimacy.
- Challenges the notion of energy exchange in yoga, branding it as clickbait and lacking evidence-based support.
**Conclusion:**
The critic urges Ranveer to consider the presented criticisms and encourages open dialogue. The video concludes with a call to support the critic's channel and highlights the intention to expand content production while expressing a desire for financial support from the audience.
**Nuances and Controversies:**
The critique acknowledges Ranveer's potential unintentional misinformation and attributes it to influences within his circles. It stresses the subjective nature of personal experiences in spiritual practices but also criticizes the potential harm in promoting pseudoscientific ideas. The video ultimately calls for a balanced, evidence-based approach to spiritual and scientific topics.
Pseudoscience is quite popular genre of entertainment.
I was following Ranveer on Spotify and liked a lot of his episodes, untill I heard one with Devdut Pattnaik. While I felt Devdutt was still manageable, the effort to make the guest happy was making Ranveer's claims a bit overdose and anti-science.. while I like that boy and wish him all success, I had to unfollow him. And I'm happy people are calling this out. Let scientific temper grow...
Dam right his current videos with devdutt and tapsse proves his duality jo dharm ka nhi wo kisi ka nhi..
Although Devdutt Pattanaik didn't bend down to his pseudoscience. He is a writer on Comparative Mythology, and you bring someone who is an academic then it's pretty gonna make Ranveer's Audience Uneasy who had traditionally been indoctrinated with Extraordinary Claims
@@adityanrajesh2634 yeah man devdutt is not a blind man who studies mythology and ignores science
@@ankitaman7798 yeah
@@adityanrajesh2634 devdutt doesn't know Sanskrit yet he writes about Sanskrit texts
What a joke
Whatsapp forwards for uncles/aunties and beer biceps for young Indians. Sad to see the direction we are going in.
This was a very timely and hugely important intervention, Pranav. More power to your voice and the respectful way in which you take on problematic aspects of a very popular content creator. I am honestly looking to become a Patreon because if I don't have the time to do this for people, I would like to support someone who is doing an excellent job. We need voices like Rationality Rules and Cosmic Skeptic here too. I'm from the Hindi-speaking region and this content is even more desperately needed among the Hindi-speakers. Perhaps we could collaborate when you expand into Hindi. Having said that, the English-speaking North Indians carry a self-assurance and sense of infallibility that lets them get away with these discussions both at home and online. Correctives like yours are a breath of fresh air.
i am 15 and i fell down the rabbilthole of these spiritualitytubers and thanks to the sheer beauty of science and the scientific method and ppl like you i am selfaware and vigorously educationg myself scientifically. BTW u should start a podcast
I want to... But I need more support first
I wish all kids were like you.
@@BM-zi9qj no everybody shouldn't be same. Holding different opinions is useful for humanity !! Variation in biology as well as psychology has helped human survive. Only the best variation that can adjust to the environmental challenges will survive ! Therefore every kid and their beliefs should not be same.
@@scienceisdope hm
@@trinityspeaks3708 Well I think it's fair to say that the guy meant 'I wish _more_ kids were like you' but exaggerated a little bit as we all do
14:56 @scienceisdope My sympathies to you for watching the crap for us. You took one for the team! :D
Seriously, I even skipped Ranveer's part in this video, too much cringe.
On reiki topic, I have experienced that whenever I fall sick , and had a lot of pain , fever, etc,etc., and when my mum took me to a doctor, I suddenly felt comfortable in his clinic, and the doctor hasn’t seen me yet, this is definitely psychological, what I am feeling doesn’t mean I m healed., I figured this out as a kid.
Sometimes I think “kid me>>>> present me”
When you only believe in what you want to believe without questioning then definitely something went wrong.
And due to this negligence, we are influenced by stupid ideas.
Suppose if you believe in god, then question endlessly about his existence, questioning doesn’t mean you became pagan, in fact it’s the opposite, you will get closer to him.
Hi, I really liked your video and how you broke down the exact logical incoherencies in Ranveer's statment about spiritual growth.
I have a question though. Around 08:50, you refer to "altered states of consiousness." Can you give me your perspective on what do you mean by "consiousness" and its altered state ? I would also welcome any reading suggestions you may have.
Do you guys just put the word "quantum" infront of everything?
-Ant Man
Even his fitness videos aren't all that scientific, especially when it comes to nutrition. For ex. keto diet. Keto doesn't reduce fat any more than any caloric deficit diet, for example.
Interesting... I haven't seen this
@@scienceisdope I'd recommend you to check out Layne Norton's channel for the breakdown of these topics
Keto diet works in many cases ! I would suggest you to check Dr Eric Berg DC to get the actual info. Don't watch the fitness youtubers. Mostly half knowledge and dangerous at times.
@@sumitsarangi7333 I didn't say it doesn't "work". I said it doesn't reduce fat any more than any caloric deficit diet.
Thanks a lot for making videos like these. Much needed!
Spirituality does help. You have to follow the correct path.
I think he has chosen the path of babas. Babas have a simple business strategy: use unsubstantiated claims and lies to psychologically entice the audience for monetary gains.
It's difficult to belive that someone who used to give real experimental results to backup his health related videos can fall for pseudo-scientific claims.
I'm glad you DO believe Babas are fake... and the very first one that comes to my mind is Sadhguru...
Someone really needs to make a video on Luke Coutinho as well. He seems really sus-sy to me.
Ayushmaan Khurana's protein claims. Beer Biceps has made pretty zany claims, inspired from from Luke
My friend who was cancer patient was conned by this luke coutinho. He sells hemp oil to cancer patients and gives them diet advice at exorbient rates. Like he charges 45k for bottle of hemp oil and another 50k for diet advice. He has mastered art of con
Seriously!
The soul projection thing is actually them lucid dreaming. Lucid dreaming happens when you become conscious while dreaming in sleep. I deliberately induce it on myself because it's fun to control your dream obviously lol and apart from outside body experience you can also have superpowers, make world's or environment, shapeshift to different animals (my favorite entertainment in lucid dreaming), imagine people you would like to meet into existence and interact with them in your dream etc. Please note that all of this is your mind making up things in your dream and is not actually real. As much as fun it is, it also has its own dangers. It could reinforce false memories in your mind which could lead awkward situations in your life especially if you make up situation interacting with your friends or families in your lucid dream. I personally started practicing it to overcome my fear of darkness and height and it really helped me overcome my fears. I could link you the site teaching how to do it if you like.
Hi 👋🏽 I loved your explanation. Please tell me how can I learn this
@@SoulfulZenStories you really need to do meditation and do reality checks daily. Also make a dream journal to write down dreams you have memorized after you wake up in the morning. This makes it more likely for you to realise you are dreaming during a dream. It takes practicing alertness which could take even months. If you want to know detailed techniques you should watch the CZcams channel called ‘Lucid Dreaming Experience’.
Oh and one more think you can make use of it is that you can reinforce the memories or experience you would like to learn quickly like learning using instruments or information etc.
Got it man . Actually I too have had lucid dreams multiple times .
Indians just wants to say that everything that is being discovered has already been discovered in ancient India. Come on, means if we have so much knowledge already in ancient scripts then why don't we recreate it ? It's simple as that most of we Indians just want to claim everything done by others but don't want to do anything in real. Secondly, we don't want to believe in logic rather we want to believe in chamatkar.
Waiting bro...
He did conversations about bramachari and he also did videos on how to impress a girl 😂😂😂😂
I'm covering all that in the video
He just want money. He is a hypocrite.
@@kamartaj3010 He's not a hypocrite. He's a moron.
I had an ex who was his fan. Behaved like a chutiya
He is actually an all rounder not a spammer like u people ....bro stop criticizing anyone before knowing deeply about someone u know ....shut the hell up. ..plzzzz
Hey man! I just found this channel. It's so satisfying to see that someone is making the points I've been advocating for years are being spoken on a public forum. Love your content. Keep up the good work!!
U Changed the way I think, thank u 🙏
You've earned a membership. Don't stop making these.
Great, western world has Scientists like Neil de Grasse Tyson, Michio Kaku, Richard Dawkins, Brian green, Sean Caroll, Sam harris etc... debunking the pseudoscience....
India needs more people like you, Great work my man.
Well, that's not a very good comparison, but, the problem is most people who are scientifically educated don't want to take up this as they would get so much hate
Do you think india is capable of producing the likes of Richard Dawkins, same Harris and Christopher Hitchens? Lol. We can't even drive properly without sitting in that horn. Lol.. I blame it on the genes.
@@NordicPolestar dude others are all right but Dawkins is a laughing stock among inner scientific communities.
In Kerala we have C Ravichandran, Vaishakhan Thampi, Dr. Augustus Morris, EA Jabbar, Krishnaprasad, Arif Hussain etc.. also they getting lakhs of views 🙌 It's a positive sign 👍
Ultra nationalists would address him as a communist
😂😂😂For quite sometime I was expecting someone to call out this spirituality fanboy.
I think he fully knows the bs he is peddling (he has hosted not just sadhguru but also GD Bakshi). In a society like ours rife with narcissism and superstition this is a sure recepie for success.
Sadguru and Bakshi 🤮🤮. Eww. Anyone who hosts them germs isn't right in their mind.
Yup, it's his business strategy.
Bro this is the first video that I have watched of yours. I really liked it. You have put a lot of effort in making this video. I am your new subscriber now.
I just discovered your channel and hats off bro, the effort you put into this channel and the effort you put into your videos to not let people misled is absolutely commendable. Keep doing you bro. Being logical and rational is one of the most appreciative quality one can have.
8:40 “I can’t believe nobody is calling this out”
You are! And thank “god” for that. High time. Christianity has seen its share of reformers and modernizers. High time that we had reformers of Indian philosophy as well.
Any ideology that has closed itself off to new thinking is going to go stale and then rotten. There are lots of good ideas in Indian philosophy but the BS that’s mixed in there has not been challenged for far too long.
Thank you for your service to our country!
Service to country???😂
@@Bharat-qe8pp I mean it could be seen as a bit of exaggeration, but it has some truth to it.
Oh my my 😂 comparing Christianity to Hinduism. Hinduism has in fact evolved from most number of debates and scientific enquiries. You should know about the 6 Darshanas. Indian philosophers were (n are still) far ahead of western philosophers. Western philosophers were killed for speaking against orthodox practices (don't need to take names) Indian philosophers were celebrated on doing the same. Class apart. Christianity is fictional, Sanatan has involved like nothing other filled with Physics, Mathematics, Logic (Nyaya Vaiseshika school..did you even hear about them?)
The Britishers have done their job well to spoil the minds of Indian youth. Mental slavery.
@@professorelixir3351 I have a lot to say about your tactic of throwing meaningless jargon at me instead of saying something substantive. However, seeing your last line personally attacking me as ‘spoilt’ and “mentally enslaved” tells me you are intolerant of opinion that runs counter to yours. Ironic given your lecture on Hindu tolerance!
To draw parallels is not to say that Hinduism and Christianity are the same. Hate to get personal but it’s precisely hypocritical intolerance and intellectual bullying by people like you that is stifling debate and progress in Hindu thought, which indeed was more tolerant and advanced than its peers many centuries ago.
@@professorelixir3351 cut short the bs, show me the evidence.
Philosophy cannot be more or less ahead. It's not something that you can compare. All cultures develop their own branches of philosophy so your statement is meaningless.
There's a lot more fiction in sanatan than in christianity, so that's one thing you can celebrate.
We need more people like you Pranav. There is lot of BS going around in India.
Instead of banking on hate agonst other channels. Make content on science .
Thanks. Could you please recommend me some books or videos on principles of science and scientific methodology.
Thank you for calling out Beer Biceps, his NoFap and Semen Retention gives me headache.
he and his fit tuber guy ...
Semen retention will make you superman, batman, etc..
.
Covering a fittuber podcast in the video xD
Yeah that FitTuber guy too. His bs needs to be called out.
True shit .. they spew out bullshit jargon everytime... i feel pity for their dumb viewers
This video was lying in my Watch Later for a long time. Fortunately, I watched it today and it opened my eyes. I always knew something was wrong with Ranveer's content but was unable to say it in verbose. I refrain from watching such pseudo videos of Ranveer and watch only selected videos as per my choice. Thanks for saying it out loud what was necessary to be done. 👏🏻 ❤️
Awesome video!
And love your content in general man. Keep up the great work.
I agreed to almost everything but the karma part as I do have a reasoning why the concept might have originally come into existence (although it lost, as it seems, the actual meaning).
I do believe that the concept of "karma" is simply the increased (or decreased) probability of a negative or positive (relative to one's POV) event occuring due to continuous actions that triggers a chain reaction of events. Like I don't believe in 'good or bad' but 'wise or foolish' decisions (again, relative to one's POV). So continuous foolish decisions might have you end up in a situation you consider 'bad'.
For example, you keep on helping random people and nothing but you are increasing the chances of helping someone who actually remembers your help and happens to help you back sometime in the future (imagine just the opposite to make it a negative experience).
This does seem logical to me. We don't have many (or any) thing(s) in control but can just try and increase the probability of something happening in our favour. No 100% efficiency for anything.
Do correct me if there are any logical fallacies :)
I'm a fitness professional man and trust me when I say he doesn't know anything about fitness science either. 😂 Great content !
Aah the mystic Mac strikes again!
I think this video is important because in his channel he humiliated researches of scientists by comparing them with ancient gurus. Things got worse when he said about modern astronomy in one of his videos.
@Rational Indic Correct, I don't know about other gurus. But, shusruta samhita contains some wonderful surgical procedures like Rhinoplasty. But, these gurus did not promote spirituality, they are actually contributing to science by providing something with empirical evidence.
@Rational Indic yes, Without ARYABHATTA, Mathematics would not be possible and we never could know the distance of planets, stars and galaxies ever. but that time also, lots of Pseudoscience Gurus existed...lmafao
Yeah I truly believe that those ancient gurus were able to understand the universe and they were very intelligent but the thing that I don't like is that today we behave as if they knew everything and some do all this for politics and in the case of 🍺 biceps views.
This is some serious good work ! It's dope 👍🏼, Haven't seen any other channels putting out such convincing contents with logical reasoning.
The woman talks about how kissing causes an exchange of energy at 26:48, which may be true if we take into account the fact that many chemicals, such as dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin, are released during a kiss; additionally, some chemicals and pheromones-I am not a scientist, so as far as I know, a lot of research needs to be done on these substances-are also exchanged. However, the way this is presented and the use of the word "energy" is just not very effective. Could you please create a video especially discussing these topics, so that people can see how loving someone may be a chemical reaction rather than a spiritual thing?
I literally die out of laugh when ravnveer guest described Entanglement, Tunneling etc 😂😂.
People must read griffth some times.
Reading david Griffith or any other book on quantum mechanics required rigorous background in mathematics, it is not cup of tea of people who believe in these kind of nonsense, yes at that time ancient india was usa of world like invention of zero , hindu numerical, pythagoras( budhiyana ) theorem, sushustra plastic surgery but discovering some geometry theorem and arthematic is different from discovering quantum physics and terms like spin , work , superposition, tunneling, entangled have very different meaning what we usually thought about them, you should have mathematical background for understanding these terms
bruh do you think they are qualified enough to read griffith🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@XtenstialKrysis i mean they could read, but wouldn't understand shit
@@XtenstialKrysisbook found on desk of every good bsc physics student
Yeah they r just people who learn science from marvel movies🤣.Cant help them.
Somebody delete that guy's channel , he literally throws science out of window and his 17 year old followers start their fanboy thing
Bro do you know what meditation contains?
Hey, your work is very good. I just started following. Keep doing the excellent work
The semen flow theory didn't work for me for first 24 years. 🙄
😂😂
Bachpan se hi semen nikal gya kya tera 😂🤣😂
But y ever give a 24 hours rest😂
Dude, I was into all this spirituality nonsense a while ago, I used to be fascinated by the existence of a study superior to science, but later on I just realized that it's merely bullshit. Luckily, I got rid of this thought process fairly early. It sucks how so many have fell into the traps of pseudoscience.
Nowadays I just practice meditation and yoga, because I've noticed actual benefits, and there is sufficient evidential basis to back this up. But anytime I realize meditation and yoga is also BS, I will quit it without hesitation.
Well actually there have been studies suggesting Meditation is helpful for mind and Yogic poses and Surya Namaskar are good for body
@@shashidharhegde1193 not talking about meditation, mostly about all these spiritual concepts and practices of karma, trataka and that nonsense. Meditation might be helpful, most studies can't really be completely trusted.
@@dhruvdust1812 Bro I understand. But these words like "Karma" "Dharma" are thrown around by these so called Gurus, who don't actually understand it. Just like "Quantum " "Dimension " etc . I request you give one last chance and watch Acharya Prashant on CZcams. I'm sure you won't be disappointed
@@shashidharhegde1193 ok, shut up, i dont wanna waste my time
@@dhruvdust1812 ok it's your choice!
really you opened my eyes ..😇 keep uploading these kind of videos sir🙏
The popular ideas regarding NoFap are not something scientific. But porn addiction is pretty real!!
I am not an atheist, but I liked your content. You have done a lot of hard work in making this video & I genuinely appreciate it.
Bro there is nothing like atheist people even I don't believe any god but I like reading bhagvat gita and ramayan and I read them as stories to get morals from them but I don't think there is something like God or anything so everyone in my circle says that I'm atheist but I'm not
@@sahaskamble4467 Bro, why are you so confused? You said you don't believe any god exists. That's the definition of an atheist!
@Aashish Telgote yaa probably your right :) have a good day
@@209kranthi 🙂
i will repeat again n again one quote of my hero Dr. CARL SAGAN
*"SCIENCE is more than a body of knowledge, it's a way of thinking"*
*"if we are not able to ask skeptical question, to be skeptical of those in authority, then we're up for grabs"*
Absolutely!
Exactly, when I see these people hating science or as they call it "modern" Science. As a science enthusiast I feel horrible. Scientists have invested their whole life performing experiments to prove their thesis. Here, these so called evolved people are making such big claims in front of millions of audience
Also by carl sagan
The Hindu religion is the only one of the world’s great faiths dedicated to the idea that the Cosmos itself undergoes an immense, indeed an infinite, number of deaths and rebirths.
It is the only religion in which the time scales correspond to those of modern scientific cosmology. Its cycles run from our ordinary day and night to a day and night of Brahma, 8.64 billion years long. Longer than the age of the Earth or the Sun and about half the time since the Big Bang.
@@scienceisdope Then become an atheist. Be a religious is itself a spirituality. Do some videos on Zakir naiks fallacies also. Be collective not selective. It just your opinion.
@@scienceisdope Did you have any evidence of God's existence
Beerbiceps kind of guy to add BEER in diet to grow Biceps
Just found this channel a couple of days ago. Absolutely brilliant work Pranav, such detail and patient science education is very important in India. Please keep it up.
Nobody: Have you read HP lovecrafts the call of cthulu?
Ranveer: Cthulu spotted in himalayas by a yogi
The way he talks seems absolutely deliberate rather than unintentional.
I remember discussing these stuff in my teen and they usually fade away but for some it may affect their mental well-being
even i found some of ranveers thoughts and believes about spirituality misleading. but i wasnt able to find words to express it. after watching your video, i came to know that i also had similar thoughts like yours regarding ranveer's content. and after ranveer has gone through so many breakups relationships only then he came to know what is right for him. so let others also try and find the person who is right for them. having physical intimacy is the couples choice of comfort and if they have given their consent, but no one has right to say that it is wrong or bad.