The Tudor Black Bay 54: What Reviewers DON'T SAY! (3 months of owning)
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- The Tudor Black Bay 54: What Reviewers DON'T SAY! I have owned my Tudor Black Bay 54 for 3 months now... And I have some thoughts! There are still a lot of things I love about this watch - I wear it A LOT! And a few new things I love and don't love have come to light after wearing this for a while. Here are some of the things reviewers DON'T say about the Tudor Black Bay 54: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.
HOW TO GET IN TOUCH WITH ME:
Sponsorships: kyle@smallscreenmarketing.com
Insta : watch.gringa
Email: watch.gringa@gmail.com
Patreon: / watch_gringa
TIME STAMPS:
0:00-0:39 - Intro
0:40-1:52 - Specifications & Wearability
1:53-3:49 - The Good
3:50-6:55 - The Bad
6:56-8:22 - The Ugly
8:23-8:39 - Outro
8:40-9:16 - Thank You Patrons! - Jak na to + styl
I have both the 54 and 58 and for me, the 54 is the perfect sized watch as I prefer thinner 36-38mm cases on my 6.5” wrist. I also love the 54’s more truly vintage look. That said, it doesn’t feel as sporty or “divery” as the 58. So for something more elegant and vintage, 54. For a more sporty presence, the 58.
Hoping they do the smaller version of the ranger in the next few years. The 54 is definitely on my list, with this smaller size, finishing, clasp, and movement.
Great informative video (as always) I have the bb58 in black and gilt, and I’m very pleased with it. My wrist size is 7 - 1/2” and sits perfectly. The bb54 is a good shout for the smaller wrists, and the differences are interesting between the two.
My personal preference is the 58.
All the best from England.
Hi Britt, I really think there is room in your collection for both Tudors. And since you promised me you wouldn't sell it, gifting it to a nephew also sounds like a very groovy idea! Re: the 54 - I am looking forward to seeing one in person. It would be the chef's kiss with a red triangle (one of my favorite features of my beloved 58). Cheers!
Love it! thanks for the content britt!
That red bezel triangle on the black gilt dial BB58…I just love it so much! Just goes so well with that dial. I love it so much, I simply can’t consider any other Black-Bay that doesn’t have that combo. Not even other variations of the BB58 itself! And including this BB54. Just crazy stuff 😆 now Tudor just add that micro-adjust clasp. It’s well overdue! Thus perfection would ensue.
ranger bracelet fits the 58 perfectly. bam new clasp and t-fit!
Great review, as usual. The 54 is really a great release. I've tried it on the wonderful rubber strap. While I ended up finding it a bit small for my 7.25" wrist and looking like a toy diver in a full mirror photo at the AD, it does wear bigger than 37mm would imply. I think for a lot of non-giants out there, it will be a nice compact wearing experience. I saw it on the wrist of an owner at Windup Chicago on a not quite as big wrist/person and it looked brilliant. I hope Tudor will add those refinements to the BB58 in the next year or two, especially T-fit. I implore people to go by more than specs and actually try on watches if possible. The same diameter watch can wear very differently. As for me, the Pelagos 39 wears like a great compact diver on my wrist, reminiscent of a vintage Sub, which I also tried on recently. If Tudor releases a blue Pelagos 39, I pity my wallet.
I’m considering this along with the tag aquaracer. Can’t really decide on which one I want but leaning towards Tudor. Just hope their quality control keeps it together.
I love what Tudor has done for the watch-world by creating the 54 & 58. As the Submariner creeps to 41mm case sizes, thank god for a modern watch with a vintage look that you can actually get WET & knock around. 😅 🙏🏾
Your timing is impeccable, I was just dreaming about this watch 😅
🤣 this is the universe telling you it’s time to get that BB54 🙈💕💕✨✨
Aunty Brittany, I love your work. Not only is it thoroughly entertaining, but also fully informative. Have I told you lately that your hair is looking stunning? Well it is!! Um........about that BB58.......
I purchased the BB54 for my birthday 2 months ago and have worn it every day since. Here are my two cents:
- I have relatively thin wrists, and the size and weight are absolutely perfect for me.
- No issues with pip alignment. It's exactly where it needs to be.
- Lume is beautiful, but fades quicker than expected. Could be better but it's not a big issue.
- Keeps very accurate time. Mine runs about +1-2 seconds per day.
- The faux rivets aren't the best, but it's not a deal breaker. As Britt mentioned you barely notice them when wearing it.
And now for my all time favorite thing about this watch...the dial. It's advertised as black, but it's actually closer to a very dark, burnt brown. Like a black coffee almost. That with the gold hands and brown text really, REALLY makes this dial a one of a kind.
The dial is beautiful and something nobody seems to dwell on, I love it too.
If pip alignment is not lined up perfectly to compass points is can be a sign of fake watch or inferior watch part supplier
When you said that the lume fades quicker, is it able to last you through the night?
@@DodyChai not really. I don't purposefully blast the lume with light before bed, so it glows with whatever ambient light it's managed to gather before I hit the hay for the night.
By the time I wake up, the lume has faded to a barely perceptible level.
I don't think it has to do with the quality of the lume, but rather to the size of the indices themselves. Given that it's a small dial, and the indices are relative to the overall size, there's simply not enough lume to go around.
That being said, I've never looked at the watch, be it during the day or at night, and were unable to tell the time.
Yo it’s me your favorite nephew complimenting your awesome channel.
I honestly really enjoy the watch. I worn it nearly every day for about the same time you have. Its my go to. I use the t clasp alot. The bezel action has me twisting it more often than people around me prob like
I relate to all of this!!! Such a great little watch isn’t it! 💕💕✨✨
Britt! We are so blessed having 2 Editing Britt appearances. Great video and happy to see you still loving the 54. So who has to adopt me to be considered a nephew? You know you are my favorite Auntie!! Long Live the Cult(s)!
🤣🤣 DON H!!! This made me audibly laugh LOL!!! You know! I’ll talk to James’ sister, we will draw up the adoption papers 😜 and we will see what we can do! Hahaha. And you know, when the real Britt misses too many important things, it’s editing Britt’s time to shine!
Thank you for posting this!! Saving up for the blue BB58, the first watch in my collection over $1k!!
This watch looks gorgeous. Haven’t been able to find one, but will definitely get my hand on this.
I took a chance at Heathrow Airport, popped in before going to a lounge a few weeks ago, low and behold they had one, bought it on the spot, fits perfectly. 6.5" wrist.
Already scratched it of course, but hey, it already has some good stories.
On the pip issue, all good as well, however I did notice the pip was out on a P39 in store when I was comparing with th BB54.
Keep my interest to the end. Nice video especially with the couple of correction edits.
Great video and content!
This looks like a perfect size for me thanks! - love how you occasionally say something with an English accent😊
Love your videos and your take on watches, much more relaxed and down to earth than any of the other youtubers out there :)
Out of curiosity, i'm not sure if you ever mentioned it, but have you thought about going for a watch like an omega or longine? Or is your love for beefy watches too strong? I figure the smaller specs of vintage men's pieces might fit your wrist better hence the question.
Keep up the great vids!
Can I just say that your eye for real world detail is so thoughtful. Pip misalignment drives me crazy and I have had it with Rolexes, Blancpain and Omega - it’s unforgivable QC laziness! As for the BB54, it has its place on the right wrist, as do all the BBs which is what makes the sizing variety so great. But, it’s also a curse - Rolex do not accommodate so much which seems to generate a ‘respect’ and air of supremacy. As for the rivets, they are up there with non-functioning cuff buttons on a suit. It’s like you’re being chaperoned by mummy until you deserve a big boy watch one day with all functioning details. Lastly and said with kindness and respect, you don’t need to worry so much about being honest in your reviews; it’s refreshing and regardless you make your points diplomatically. Adrian might be gutted he missed what you spotted though! Keep it up!
Britt! Can't believe it's been 3 months, congrats. I still can't get past the bezel color silver not matching the gilt color of the dial. For me the 54 isn't vintagey looking enough lol. I feel that especially for summer, having such an adjustable clasp is really important and I wish more watches offered this regularly. I say that you shouldn't sell your 58, you'll come back to it's lovely blue hue in due time.
WHERE DOES THE TIME GOOOO?! I can’t believe it!! Time flies when you’re wearing awesome watches! 😎 💕💕✨✨
The silver of the bezel matches... the silver everywhere else on the watch haha. You do you.
@@wintermute8315 hahaha love your comment. the gilt bezel on the 58 was the worst colorway imo and I was so relieved that the 54 came out with the silver
I do really miss the gilt on the bezel. Keeping myself from owning both but I might end up doing that.
I've had experience of shoddy Tudor QC. My GMT went back after they fixed the date issue for a smudged minute hand and then it came back with a badly misaligned bezel. In 2021 Tudor had my watch more than I did.
Your amazing! Love your content! Keep it up!
I have a 6’2”, 240lbs, with an 8.5” wrist. Tried it on at a boutique. Absolutely loved it, thought it looked awesome. Wear what you love!
Lose some weight, or you might die.
The bracelet was probably too small for you.
Love the enthusiasm 💯
I have had mine for nearly the same time. The 54 is one of my favourites and is worn most days. I have the same dilemma with the 58s. Do I keep them or not. I swap between the 54 and the Ranger.
Tudor nailed this release IMO.
It is the mini sub style vintage look without owning a sub.
Great vid Britt ❤
Fantastic video Britt! What do you make of the new BB41 on the jubilee bracelet? I think it looks even better than the 54.
I’ve always felt that the BB58 was chunky and two dimensional/bland (slabs of metal on the sides of the case). I resort the “modern” size aka larger BB58 being a result of Tudor’s ability (at that time obviously) as not being able to make a smaller/thinner complication. I really wanted their newer two tone gmt but couldn’t get over how thick the case was
I think the 58s are ok, but the regular BBs are just too chunky for me. It’s a pity, because that opaque dial GMT is sexy! They should really make a 58 GMT
Great review thanks. I have the same Pentax. They look great with the silver 28 70mm 2.
8
This watch costs less than a service on the majority of my collection (AP, Rolex, Lange and FPJ)…yet I wear this one almost everyday since I got it 2m ago. It’s incredibly good value. Also bought the rubber strap, but yet to switch. Anyway, great work Tudor
Love all your videos, but when I saw that Moonswatch in that gorgeous leather watch roll, it reminded me of that craze when kids were decking out their 10K Honda Civics with 30K worth of accessories in the early 1990's.
💀🤣🤣🤣 that is a BANG ON comparison!!!
Great lineup Tudor introduced. Now i will be waiting for the blue version 😊
The faux rivets are why I was happy to buy my 58 on the (excellent) leather. Bought the Forstner bracelet without rivets 😏 and with their FlexLink... One spring loaded link giving 5mm of stretch.. it's excellent ....
First time viewer...well done, and the 54 and 58 look great on you! I have a 7.4-inch wrist and found the BB54 to be a tad small, despite knowing it's "vintage." A 38-mm diver from Tudor would be the sweet spot for me. Keep up the great work!
Love the watch and the size. I have the BB58 in black, blue and bronze. Great sizes but I have to wait to see what they do with this BB54 platform. They can’t just do the same color combinations, right? All gold or something. Wish they came out with this size fist but really curious what Tudor do next.
Keep your BB58 blue. I don’t think they will do blue in the 54 size. 😅
Sold my 58 blue a while back. Great piece but now I’ve had the 54 on wrist for two months back and it just hits different.
It looks fabulous on you! I am going to get one and my wrist is the same size 🎉
Hi, it’s me, your nephew from Chicago! Just wanted to say that I love your content and you are the best aunt ever! 😂
🤣🤣💕💕💕 WELL! The timing is highly suspect…. BUT it all sounds legit to me! 😝💕💕
hahaha you deserve the BB58!!
Hey Aunt Britt! Your hair is looking amazing 🤩
Tudor black bay. Never heard of it.
Thanks for making the first video about it.
LOL. You're very welcome ;) Saw a real gap in the market ;)
The 58 looks fantastic on you and it is the best blue tone of any blue watch available. Keep it!
You’ve convinced me! IM KEEPING IT! Sorry nephews. 😈💕💕 Tudor has mastered blue!
Same here having both BB54 and BB58. I just change the strap with the BB58 into even more casual look and then it’s fine. No need to struggle which one to wear depending on the dress code.
Amazing video ❤
Good review. I got turned onto Tudor by Teddy B with the Black Bay Burgundy METAS. I'm not into Divers as I think they are just too trendy and hipster-sh. But I'm digging this watch brand/model. I love the burgundy. Someone mentioned they put on a black/red RubberB strap on it for daily use. That would look super sharp and less blingy. Which is what I want for a daily driver.
Glad you included pictures of you and your husband's wrist with the watch and realized one thing: The case looks like it takes more space on his wrist. While his wrist may be bigger, it's probably a more rounded shape vs. rectangular like yours. So on his wrist, you don't see as much the band as much as on yours.
So yes, people should try on the watch before making judgements.
Great video!
Heya Britt was watching just now another old vid about the harrods bb and was thinking how about a refresh with the Tudor rose and the smiley face, and just thought now when you said it, add the 54! 😎
You know! I’m a huge advocate of the Tudor rose!! I love how oldy Worldy it is!
Would love to see Tudor come out with the BB54 Harrods edition. That green bezel is so nice.
Omg I would lose my mind!
BB54 blue dial will be a banger. Hope they make one . Love the content btw
People would LOOOOSE THEIR MINDS!!!! Also… a pelagos 39 blue…. I’d be sprinting to the AD
I’m 5’8” 72kg very medium build. My wrist is exactly 7”
I currently have the BB58 navy blue - 39mm and the BB heritage Black & gold 41mm and they both wear perfectly on my wrist.
I have just ordered the BB GMT S&G Rootbeer to finish off my little Tudor collection
I wouldn’t dream of offloading any of them, I love them all, and wear them equally depending where I’m going and what I’m doing….
EG I just went on 2 weeks vacation to Thailand , mostly sightseeing, beach and hotel pool .
Which watch should I take ?
No brainer, I put the pinstriped Tudor nato strap on the blue BB58 and it was equally at home in the daytime riding around on a scooter, or lying round the pool, dressed down, and at night out for dinner, dressed slightly better !
I love you! Made my deposit! Now the wait begins when Tudor delivers.
Is there a waiting list?
Sorry for asking, I’m looking for my first watch and I don’t know if Tudor has the Rolex thing that they don’t sell to everyone
@@miguelarguello7113 Yes, there is, depending on your location. This is a relatively new and popular watch, thus the demand is still very high.
Have owned this watch since the first week it was announced. Has not came off the wrist, honestly started selling off some of my other watches.
IM GLAD IM NOT THE ONLY ONE! It’s just such an enjoyable wear!
I'm glad you have recovered from your accident. Good as new.
For the record, I don't get Tudor. It just looks boring to me but that is my taste in things... or the lack of it. Good review.
OH bless! Thank you so much!!!
This watch is definitely on my radar for next purchase. I have always loved the BB58 and with the specs of the 54 that you mentioned put this one ahead. Have yet to see one in the wild , much less try one on. Birthday is next week sooooooo......
SOOOO IT MIGHT JUST BE THE PERFRCT TIME TO GET ONE! 😱💕💕💕✨
@@BrittPearceWatches I just got one today----yeeeee hawwww
Really do like the 58 and 54 portion and the vintage look. Just wished Tudor would have a ceramic option.
I really would love if it had a date window on it. The size and style of it is absolutely gorgeous and it’s a close enough grail piece for me. I’m torn between the 54 and the Tudor GMT Pepsi. Recently picked up a Sinn 556i but I’m still gonna chase my grail watch under $5000
I’m your long lost nephew, and your channel is the best!
Really appreciate these videos after having had the watch a while! Very informative!
I’d still go for the BB58 for me in black between the 58 and 54 however I like the GMT a lot so would probably end up springing for that even though it’s much bigger. Speaking of GMT, I love your idea of Tudor releasing a smaller more vintage one and it would be even better if they took the opportunity to make a “Diet Coke.” Thoughts?
Ahhh thank you so much! Even 3 months isn't too long, but it is long enough to start picking up on things you might miss after only a week :) OMG - if they made a smaller coke bezel.... PEOPLE WOULD LOSE THEIR DANG MINDS!!! (and by people I mean ME! ;) )
The gmt's only like £300 more, but its very rolexy
@@BrittPearceWatches I would totally lose my mind for the a Tudor Diet Coke!!
OK, fill me in. What is the "Diet Coke?" How does it differ from just the "Coke?" And I do mean bezels, not the soft drink!
@@jsusna1972 Diet Coke would be a Tudor GMT with black and red bezel. The Coke is the Rolex GMT Master II with black/red bezel.
I’m so close to pulling the trigger on this piece. Need a daily
Auntie Britt! You look amazing in this video especially editor version! My B-Day is coming up & I would love to celebrate it with a new-ish 39mm blue dive watch from Tudor…? 😏🤣
I love your videos and feel too in to it, I wish you make a video of 2023 41 champagne black bay!
Thank you❤😊
Ohhh finally a video!
🤣
Good hair day and the watch is nice too!
Oh why thank you! Gotta love a good hair day!
Thanks Gringa for the vid, always enjoyable! FWIW, I would recommend holding onto the BB39 for a bit longer. I have found that after many months go by, I can fall back in love with a watch I've neglected. And the blue is pretty special and it is different enough from the 37mm to make it feel unique. 🤷🏻 Thanks as always for the great content, very appreciated.
Gah, thank you so much for this advice!
Thanks, Britt, for the comprehensive review. The bezel width proportion of the BB54 is a tad big. Therefore the BB58 is more proportionate overall?
Ouuu you might be onto something here! I will need to get the callipers out and compare ;)
The 58 is better proportioned in my opinion.
I think it looks great on your wrist. Perfect!
Do you know if the rubber strap fits the existing t fit or do you need to buy another? It’s not a lot to buy just the rubber but the additional t fit pushes to over £500. My AD isn’t sure and I can’t find anything online. Any help would be appreciated.
My pip on the 54 is perfectly centre. What I have noticed though is the link that glides in/out of the t-fit clasp, there seems to be little rubbing marks on the finish on that particular link. Not sure if this is something I have done or if it came like this. Nothing major but enough for me to notice on my practically brand new watch.
Nice episode 👏
Finally had a chance to try on the 54 and it wears fantastic…but I’m still keeping my 58. I still love the gilt bezel that gives the 58 a warm touch, red triangle gives a pop of color and pays homage to the Rolex Big Crown, the large coin edge crown with matching bezel makes it unique and the crown borrows the look of the Rolex Big Crown, and I love the snow flake seconds hand. It is so unique in design as opposed to the now more common lollipop. I have no doubt the 54 is going to cannibalize sales from the 58 because of its proportions, better clasp and more derivative looks, but I feel a lot of the design aesthetic that made the 58 different and cool have been taken away. I think if you want a vintage styled tool watch with a bezel then go with the 54. If you want a modern sized dive watch with vintage cues that is not an exact replica of past models, but has its own unique design then go 58.
You’re soo rifht! The BB58 has a few more little pops of colour and little charming bits to it like the red triangle and big crown! 😍 you really can’t go wrong with the BB58!
"Sweetie", this was an excellent, informative video, keep up the good work.
Whaaat! Thabk you soo much! I’m so glad you enjoyed. 💕✨
Yes! Finally, us wonderful, beautiful, fabulous watch nerds appreciate the throwback sign-off. Gringa forever!
The bezel problem u talk about is not a problem i do believe. Because there is a small lock system on the bezel when the triangel is positioned at the 12 o'clock marker. An before you get it into lock position it is a millimeter off. This is how it is and has nothing to do with quality control at Tudor.
Love the BB esp in the black with gold gilt hence why I bought the full size BB , the faux rivets don’t even notice it when on the wrist and same goes with the thickness of my BB on my 7 1/2 inch wrist and no not exaggerating my size 😂
Love everything on this watch ! Wish it had the rose and the smiley text!
GAH! Right?! I couldn’t agree more! I freaking miss the Tudor rose!
Hi Britt! Is the lume worse on this than the 58? I haven’t seen any reviewers say so but reading some forums on users they say while it’s initially bright, it dims out much quicker.
Ouuu now THIS is a good question and I need to investigate this immediately! 🧐💕
I have mine for 3 Monts now 😊 Great stuff !
Happy Sunday Britt I really love both watches, you said that your B.B. 58 is to banged up but to tell you the truth I have seen a lot of B..B 58'S look way worse and still sell if you can sell the watch sell it if it's not been worn to maybe get a new watch why not or keep it and like you said pass it down the family line wither way it's chill live your watch dreams ha ha ha really great video c-ya- next video.
Love the video, it somehow has that quality magazine look and comfort to it. Reminds me of reading pages of GQ in the mid 2000s. I could almost smell the paper!
On another note, I have a feeling that my bank account is gonna take a hit in the near future due this video.
This is the perfect way to describe it!!!! I’m so stealing this! 😅
@@BrittPearceWatches feel free to use it! And Thank you for the enjoyable video, rewatched it on my Quest 2 and it turned out to be even more amazing.
I tried the BB54 and the new burgundy bezel BB and went with the burgundy with the jubilee bracelet. But it was a tough choice
The BB58 secondary price is sometimes 20% under retail in Australia now. I wish I have some spare coins
YES!!!! There’s a TON of them for sale as well!!!
Excellent review. Mine is perfectly aligned with 12 marker. I have owned Tudor smiley, Non smiley, 58 tudor and now 54. I find 54 the best because I have 6 and 3/4 inch wrist. Also what I have observed is 54 is much more scratch resistant than other black bays. Not sure if Tudor has played around with the alloy or something. However your’s is nice review and to the point.
The British guy review is good but too long and the dragging of coffee into every video makes it less appealing 😮.
I'm so glad you are my aunt, the best aunt ever
Realistic review. Got me thinking now to swap my black bb58 for the 54 and get the blue bb58. Keep the awesome content coming!
OUU hooo!!! Or maybe even wait to see if they release the BB54 in blue?!?! 😱
I just wanted to take a moment to say how amazing your video was! I was really impressed with the quality of the footage, the editing, and the overall presentation. You did a great job of explaining the topic in a clear and concise way, and I learned a lot from watching your video.
I also really appreciated the way you made the video engaging and entertaining. You kept my attention throughout the entire video, and I never felt bored or lost. I would definitely recommend your video to anyone who is interested in learning more about the video.
Thanks again for making such a great video! I look forward to watching more of your content in the future.
PS: I outsourced this feedback to AI.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Let Watch Papi wear the BB58. You keep enjoying the BB54 and loving it!
I do! That’s why it’s on that NATO in the video, I love it.
One point that many reviewers missed is that the lume fades quickly and does not last the night even when exposed with proper lights. Could someone comment on this?
You’re definitely on to something here. Anytime a watch is priced in that range, the lume should be superb being both highly visible and long lasting. Honestly I wish more quality brands would either significantly step up the quality of their lume or switch to tritium.
Love the insight, so thank you.
Your nephews should say, “you have awesome Greek goddess hair, aunt Britt!” If they really wanted the BB58!
I love both of the watches (54 & 58)!
Great review. Your hair looks really good. Your nephew, The Dude.
I’m good with the heritage 41. I like that they make a watch for all wrists
Right?! Big benefit of Tudor right now!
@@BrittPearceWatches They understand how to listen to the community and deliver the goods. Go Tudor, now get rid of those rivets on bracelet 🤪😂
Good clip Britt. The BB lug, I personally really dislike how they’ve just re-used the lugs from bb58, looks completely out of proportion. I can see the attraction and a solid concept but not for me.
Would love to see a blue or green bezel, and harrods had the green bezel but it’s bezel markers are different.
Also, I’d rather see a green in the color of the Rolex for the bezel (but in aluminum).
Great vid! Cheers
Ahhh I couldn’t agree more!!! More colours needed. 💚👏🏻
Good job, highly recommend this video
I also noticed the bezel lume pip being off on some videos, and I saw that in the piece that was offered to me.. I think they should tighten up the QC for the 54..
The lume on my bb54 has like 1/2 the brightness of that of my 2017 bb36.
The T-Fit clasp is a BIG selling point for me. That’s why I’m sticking with Tudor for now.
Right?! It’s a massive improvement!
I have a Submariner (16610) from the mid 90s that I love, and will never part with. I think this BB54 would be an awesome alternative to the Sub when I'm traveling or just in a situation where I don't feel comfortable wearing it.
@Watch Gringa ...Keep rocking the BB like an upcoming Tudor Princess.
I really hope Tudor keeps expanding their master chronometer offerings. That will really take them from party trick to standing on their own top tier brand.