Upgrading the Flyer to a Multi-Thruster Quadcopter! (Scrap Mechanic Survival Ep.40)
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- Hey everyone back with more Scrap Mechanic Survival! Today we are finally back in survival with enough component kits to make 2 more thrusters and upgrade our flyer into a proper quadcopter setup! Hopefully this new setup will allow us to not use any stabilizers and have a more legitimate flying experience!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discord: discordapp.com...
Merch: teespring.com/...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About Scrap Mechanic:
store.steampowe...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#scrapmechanic #kangaming
Maybe you could make the thrusters that get turned off for control pulse to decrease the thrust differential between sides
I thought about this. Just need a bunch more logic gates but I could have the controls pulse.
@@kANGaming The solution should be to make the arms much shorter. Presently, the thrusters are far out from the center of mass, meaning each is creating a very large torque for a given amount of upwards thrust. When all of them are on, this cancels of course, but when one side turns off, that massive torque has no matching counter-torque, and the thing flips over very fast. If the torque were smaller, then any imbalance would have a smaller effect over a given time, so the current manual controls wouldn't be so twitchy. If you didn't want to move the thrusters further in (or if you wanted to further reduce the effect that the torque has), you can increase the moment of inertia (resistance to turning) by putting a large amount of mass far out on the craft. A larger moment of inertia would also make a given torque have less effect.
TL;DR: Shorter thruster arms and/or big weights far out on the craft.
EDIT: Gyroscopes would also be a neat idea. Not the gyro-stabilizer things you usually find in Scrap Mechanic, but just a big spinning mass. Similar to the big weights idea, but possibly more effective per mass.
@@kANGaming I think it really would benefit from tank driving 😁.
Jokes aside, instead of pitching the whole build to fly forward, you should just pitch the thruster, using the tank driving logic and the same system you have in place for yaw. If you add a second set of bearings directed along the main axis of the vehicle you could also add strafing.
What up
i was gonna comment this too but it adds even more logic. I think moving the thrusters in more would help.
Kan: "we can fly"
also Kan: uncontrollable spinning
The test flights remind me of Iron Man 1 when he's first trying out the boots.
Yeah 😊😂
Yeah😭
Who is iron man
@@diamondapocalypse5019 I am Iron Man.
Haha, yes...
Me: goes to engineering school
Person: "what did you use your degree for?"
Me: "scrap mechanic"
What a waste of $40,000
This post was made by the youtube education gang
Micah Lovejoy congratulations
@@Crummieboi56 European students are laughing :p
Same buddy
13:02 it looks as if he doesn’t have his legs anymore... terrifying and magnificent in the same time🧐
HAHAHA!!! 😂🤣😅
I was looking for a comment like this 👍🏻
You think the legs missing were scary when he lands in the water it looks like hes "hanging" out
ScrapMan: Has no component kits
Kan: Literally had 100 component kits.
Not anymore 😂😂
😂 I have around 150, but those will be gone in 6 seconds when I start building a flyer as well 😩
kAN 5 seconds later: no component kits
There is a a BIG key word there XD
For pitch and roll use a one tick clock so the thruster is on 50% of the time. this is kind of like a PWM signal for a computer fan
When you removed the first switch and saw if fly into the distance I lost it. Love your videos!
i feel like a pulse control scheme would reduce the twitchyness and possibly lower the fuel consumption, i also remember an episode of workshop hunters where a flier used suspension to soften the thrusters. the deadman safety could use a latch gate
Amazing idea
u would use more fuel but ok and i remember that episode too maybe the suspension combined with moving the thrusters in more would help a lot.
scroll up a bit and look for Disabeast's comment.
@@spacewalk3046 pulsing thrusters uses less fuel not more, check out scrapmans channel he did a test and it lasts double the time if you set it up right.
@@Mr_Tooty ik not exactly double the fuel but ok. My comment was on the wrong comment i meant to say u use more fuel to somebodys elses comment
@@spacewalk3046 if you time it to be on half the amount if time then you can double the fuel.
The large chest is not actually the heaviest thing in the world, the small one is heavier for some reason.
@Technology Boy durability is NOT weight
ik it's so weird i like the large chest much better
I think Scrapman tested it and the large chest is heavier, so maybe the weight stat is weight per block
@Technology Boy the large chest is indeed heaver, the weight is not for the entire item but for the amount of blocks it takes up, think about a 20 pound weight vs 3 ten pound weights.
Put invisible block in the broken microwave from ship because broken microwave have only One inventory slot 🤔
What?
@@Neon-ws8er in the ship is the thing that is named broke microwave its near a bed in ceashed shop when you enter the room its right on right and you can open it and it has only one slot
I think I lost brain cells reading this
How is it hard to read? The sentence is not even remotely complicated.
Democracy Enforcer thats the thing he didnt even use enough words its like saying me see banana like
Isn't it possible to make a dead man switch with timers? That will cut off engine power if you didn't use any controls for x seconds?
could be helpfull
🌭GLIZZY🌭
kAN every video:
"Theoretically"
"Theoretically"
"Theoretically"
"Either way"
"Either way"
"Either way"
"Theoretically"
"Theoretically"
"Theoretically"
"Either way"
"Either way"
"Either way"
Yup
Then a perfect when it’s far from perfect
Theoretically, He has to say those to prove his point, Either way it's repetitive
@@betterclone9521 omg
Theoretically
The empty inventory block is so you can free your hands lol
24:17 Scrap Mechanic Devs: "And we are happy to announce the new, Block-Damage-Update. ;D"!
You should probably get 2 or 4 more thrusters and dedicate them to lift, then turn your control thrusters down to about 3 or 4 from the bottom. Idk if that would work, but it's just a suggestion
A couple of ideas...
- Use a timer / logic loop to pulse the thrusters instead of turning them off
- Put the thrusters on pistons (save weight on the arms)
Kan: “let me just put my imaginary lift in the chest”
I know i just thought its funny bro 🤣
My explorer uses two sets of thrusters. One is pointed back, the other is pointed down. The lift thrusters also tilt the vehicle back slightly, the 'go' trusters tilt it forward. With both sets on the vehicle is pretty much stable. So the take-off sequence is such: lift/tilt back to about 45, then pulse 'go' a few times to keep the angle and lift off clear of trees, walls, and so on. Then 'go' only to gain speed and tilt forward some. After that pulse lift to keep the craft stable. Turning is A-D with a suspension glitch, but can be done with a reaction wheel or thruster tilting for purists. Main advantage is only four buttons total and no logic or controllers involved. Though it does take a few minutes to get used to flying the thing.
As for 'player in seat' tracking for the quadrajet in this video, a sensor above the seat that goes into a nor-or-nor flip flop and a button instead of the main lift switch should ensure that once the pilot is out of the seat the system can not automatically activate until the main button is pressed even if the sensor sees something (ground, bot, player) again.
Nice Kan! I really like your garage in your base, I think you did a excellent job with the diamond plate as the floor and the metal block for the walls along with the glass roof. 👍👍
I read garage as garbage xD
The flyer reminded me of those super fast racing/stunt drones
How about eight thrusters at lower thrust. Four would stay on to essentially hover. The other four would activate for control.
200 more component kits here we go.
1-3 more gas container full gas more
i think itd be too heavy on the gas
As a safety mechanism you could have a timer that starts counting when you turn the switch on, and only resets when one of the other buttons is pressed or the switch is off. Once the timer reaches the end it turns everything off. You make small adjustments often enough that you would constantly be resetting the timer when you're actually in the flyer, but it would turn off if it flies away before it uses up all the fuel. If you feel you needed to you could also add another button that does nothing but reset the timer, and have a light flash on just before the timer ends so that you know you have to reset it.
In electronics one often have to control the "power" of something that, at any given moment, can only be on or off. To do that you can use PWM (Pulse-Width Modulation).
Basically you just constatly turn on and off the thing and control how much time it stays on or off during every cycle. That's how you control brightness in LEDs, for instance.
Maybe you can do the same in your "quad-thruster".
Put two very fast timers in a loop and then connect both of them to each thruster, to one timer directly and to the other through some AND gates. Then connect the AND gates to four normally-closed buttons (button with NOT gate).
By default the thrusters will be always on because connected to both timers, but pressing one of the buttons will disconnect the corresponding thruster from one timer making it stay on only half the time than the other (effectively cutting its everage power in half).
You could fix the
aggressive roll by adding a thruster on the opposite side on a lower power level.
Idk much about scrap mechanic physics but realistically you should be able to use bearings to control forwards, backwards, left and right so it strafes more than flips. it will be smoother and won’t tilt the drone so much.
Maybe you can put in a timer system when you release thrust on one side, then the thrusters output power in intervals instead of a continuous stream. That might make it a bit more controllable.
What’s up con always watch your videos for tips and tricks because I know that you know how to build all this crazy stuff in the back of your head so that’s the reason why I always watch your videos and sometimes I watch it for fun
You like minecraft
My first vid will be a minecraft vud and will be posted soon
Try using a gate loop to pulse the thrusters off? You'd be able to have fraction control. Off 1 tick every 4 ticks, or whatever you need.
You could even make it so a thruster is on full power, but pulses 3/4 of the time and use the other 1/4 to yaw/roll/pitch. This would allow you to use 1/4 of the power while the thrust is off and still correct your vehicle.
Kan, maybe you could add a 2nd set of low tier thrusters for control to make it less twitchy and have your main ones work only for lifting your drone and have a switch that keeps your drone level in height?
Random suggestion for the Quad-thruster. Use 2 switches for always on. One that is definitely "always on", and another that pulses the thrusters. The pulsing ought to let you set the thrusters up higher and give you a "lower gear" for take offs or areas you want a bit more control over sheer speed.
Er kinda had an idea i created /thought of in another game.
Basically it's a floating ball rolling in a 3*1 cage that has sensors in the edge walls to detect the ball and these sensors help counter rotate the craft when the tilt gets too bad, however i suspected it may be roo sensitive since you turn the thrusters off.
This was for a flying creation but i as able to slow rotation separately and i used wedge blocks in the edges to center the ball so may not be a viable idea at this size. It functions similarly too the newly added angle sensor in trail makers. However i hoped it might inspire an idea or something.
Tried to explain it simply without the logic.
i believe the weight in Scrap mechanic is a measurement in "weight per block x volume", meaning the large chest is 5(5x4x3)
The weight and buoyancy ratings in scrap mechanic make me hurt. They just don't make sense, especially as they're two separate ratings and volume is a third thing that is already in the game.
Have you seen 00Fant's flyers? They all have the thrust pulsing on timers. This allows 3 states per thruster of off, full power and somewhere in-between. Ideally the default state has the thrusters pulsing to almost offset the weight such that the flyer very slowly drops out of the sky. This prevents the craft being lost.
I'd like to see a quadcopter battle in either scrap mechanic or trailmakers now XD
The timer/logic gates you set up for pulsed pistons, use that so instead of turning half the thrusters off for roll, it instead pulses those thrusters quickly. You can adjust the ratio of pulse on to pulse off to fine tune how finicky the controls are.
You can use 3 thurusters for flying and 1 thurester for back and forth.
You could use pistons to extend the arms. Pitch forward, extend arms backward. Pitch backward, extend the arms forward. Use it for roll as well.
with 3 thrusters you can make a really cool helicopter!!
I think pulsing the engines all the time would make sense... That way you'd get a hover mode, going up only when you hold a button.. you can also move the vehicle when shortening the pulse to two of the engines.. would take a bunch of logic tho :D
If you want to pitch down, rather than completely turning off the front thrusters, just tilt them toward each other. Their horizontal components of lift will cancel each other out while their vertical components will decrease by the cosine of the tilt angle you select. e.g. 60° tilt = 50% reduction.
Make it so that the two back thrusters are facing at an 45° angle outwards when going forward and same with the front. The reason for this is to eliminate the pitch completely so it makes it more stable. And for roll make the two side thrusters go at an 35° (less or more) angle inwards to get rid of the roll. With this, make the thrusters on the opposing side equally place as much thrust as was inputted. Ex. When you go left, being the right side thrusters outputted power to move left, the left side thrusters output just as much power as the right had inputted.
for stability improves you should put the thrusters upper than the gravity center, like 4 or 5 blocks, and correct the thrust add (in maneuvers) rotating the respective thruster on the opposite side of the moviment, and doing this with the other ones, all pointing to the outs
the weight is measured for every cube it takes up
if you have a 3x3x3 object with a weight 2, it would be equivalent to a 3x3x3 cube of material
For the roll, you could maybe flip the thrusters 70 degrees or 80 degrees in the opposite direction.
With some self installed mods, you can configure the vehicle to only respond if the seat is occupied. You jump out and it shuts down. Sensor works too I guess. Good call.
Maybe you need a safety second switch on an AND gate in a hard to delete apot?
I'd experiment with variable thruster positioned eliminate over adjustment of pitch and roll by altering the center of mass instead. Too complicated? You bet it is!
Make it always flat, only tilt the thrusters. Tank control for left/right. For forward tilt them forward about 30°
You could put forward and back thrusters on a clock so it acts more like reduced thrust in a actual quad or do away with pitch and just go forward and back on bearings
you could set it up to pulse the thrusters to slow things down a bit maybe even get it to hover by pulsing all 4 all the time and going full throttle when you want to go up or have a gradually faster pulse
6:25 satisfying button placement
Yes....!!! I remember scrapman mentioned you with I believe moonbo for a monday episode I'm glad u got you a new spot many good vibes
use a logic gate pulse system to run the thrusters as a PWM ORd with your 'always on' switch
Use 00fant’s player seat sensor from his mod, detects when a player is in a seat, it will solve your flyer problem I think
Like so he can see this
The Orientation block from The Modpack has a player-in-seat detecting mode, but last time I checked I think it was broken
Guys, you have any idea how troubling it is to use mods in survival even if they are designed for survival? And you are talking about bringing creative mods into survival. That IS NOT EASY
I think he wants a mod free survival
U can add 4 more level (2 or 3) thrusters to control ur flyer so there will be not such a big drop when u turn off one side of the thrusters, and have 4 other thrusters that u have now constantly working
I think you if you were to make a triangle design, you would get better performance this way, and you could use a 4th thruster as your main propulsion. You could centralize the cockpit to further balance the weight distribution. I feel that this would help reduce the overall weight of the vehicle. You might be better off with 2 small chests instead of the single large one.
I should not be laughing at the music that played when he did the test flights.
But here I am.
A reaction wheel system could allow you to have finer tuning for pitch and roll
19:15 is the greatest moment of kAN's channel in history.
@kan Gaming You can build in a protection. You could build a dead man switch. So if you press 5 a timer runs down and to keep the thrusters running you need to press a push button to reset the timer. That's the same system as every modern train has build in to prevent hazard when the locomotive driver has a hard attack or anything else happens to him so he can't operate the controls anymore. That way you could at least recover you quadcopter. What time I can't say, that is something to try.
I had two ideas for your pitch and roll problems. If you use timers on a very short loop, you should be able to pulse the thrusters instead of completely turning them off.
But I think a more mechanical solution might be better. Instead of turning off thrusters for pitch and roll, what if you moved the center of mass using some blocks on four different pistons? Pitch forward? Extend the front piston. Level off? Bring in the front piston and extend the back one for a second. Etc, etc.
kan gaming: we are playing surivival very modest
scrapboy: haha hank and my lag castle go brrr
I find plus-shaped quadcopters work better than x-shaped. You're only turning off one thruster to tilt.
You could also add logic to still activate thrusters when 5 is off.
Kan's logo: trash can with eyes
Kan:I AM TRASH
I think you dont need roll at all. Thrust at 4 points itself should be enough to keep you stabilized on X axis. Another thruster at back ponting backwards should be better than tilting uncontrolable thrusters. All you would need is keeping your vehicle oriented in direction you want to go, rotating around 180 for slowing down(another thruster at front for braking would be option too). Its not optimal, but with gentle control it should be way easier to fly.
A pitch/roll idea.
If u made pistons pull the thrusters closer it would lessen there effect relative to the further out thrusters meaning that it will be like what u have now but instead it wont cut the power just lessen it
Now i see why i like Main Assembly quads: proportional control!
I've been waiting for that for a long time
when you turn a quadcopter in real life, you need half roll(aileron):for giving trust to the side, and half yaw(rudder):for rotating (sorry for bad english)
SM survival finally!! I was going insane and had to watch moonbo's questionable content!
Lol
Ill have to send you my "carrier" design. It takes some practice to learn but it has full controls for every direction, it can carry cargo, and its pretty darn balanced
To not loose it by accident try to make some kind of a system that will be like a sensor switch. If you put a sensor above driver seat and it will read your presence, then it will allow all thrusters to work. Like sensor that reading driver-AND gate-everything else (sorry for my eng)
edit: oh... you did this later in a video xD
Have your thrusters on a pulse loops using logics for when you do the turning and roll to slow down the movement then have 5 just bypass the pulse loop for steady power.
A pulse loop could be a simple loop like you would use on a spud turret
After seeing the thumbnail i unnderstand why its been so long. Good job!!
Suspension glitch: am I a joke to you? Kan: yes also suspension glitch: ...
Even the craftbot thought this was a bad idea
"T"F"G"H" controls are harder for flyers because you have to press the thruster-on key too,
Except when you put a switch, which is risky if you accidently hop out of your seat
If you have one of those big Desktop Keyboards, It's easier to Remap them to
"Home" "Delete" "End" "Page Down" and control them with the Right hand
They need to add a kill switch to the seat for when the player gets out. Have a setting to have it activated or not. Like a lawn mower IRL. Haha
Using the unlimited inventory command you can get rid of the repeated tools in your inventory.
I had the same deal with the lift twice.
You could try adding 4 more thrusters only dedicated to roll and pitch. You wouldnt have to upgrade them all the way, and they wouldnt be at full power, therefore allowing easier movement changes.
Just add additional thrusters to the sides. Very low thrust amount so its not as aggressive and keep them closer to the body so they can't manipulate the body as easily.
It’s like a flying mechanical bull 😂
Hate to say it,but you might need a set of flight thrusters, and a set of control thrusters. That would avoid the sudden shut off of flight thrust when trying to adjust position.
Well, its flying nice thats sure. :)
Put a sensor in front of your seat so it can detect the player. Hock it up to an AND-Gate with the switch. If you are not in the seat the thrusters are off even when the switch is on.
He did that but when the player characters moved around it stopped detecting him...
Cool. Also, i made a quadcopter who's really cool too. And guess what. Same thing, faster and smaller. Also, idk if yours does too but if mine doesn't have the thrusters to go up it doesn't steer
*and you don't have to hold buttons continously*
Can you control the roll and pitch by just turning the thrusters themselves? Set a third bearing in the joint where the "arms" connect at the "wrist" perpendicular to the two that you already have allowing the thrusters to rotate outwards or inwards. then the only time you need to modulate the thrust is when you need to roll in which case a fast pulse timer should allow you to toggle the roll in fractions of a second and give you more precise control.
Either way it looks like you could have a good idea here
it would require another 2 bearings per thruster, but if you set it so that the thrusters on a given side pitch either towards or away from each other that should reduce the vertical thrust on that side in a less all or nothing manner than shutting the thruster off completely.
actually, you could still get it done with just 2 bearings per thruster, they just have to be at right angles to each other. pitch and roll the thrusters still point towards or away from each other on a given side, and yaw you have front left back right rotate on the X or Y axis and front right/back left on the other, and switch axis to yaw the other direction.
Were glad your back
Groovy tunes
Maybe 4 lvl 1 thrusters for roll and pitch can do the job?
So you always have the max thrusters to fly/hover and the low thrusters for steering
You could use flywheels to control instead of angling/pulsing the thrusters
You could add a sensor that detects if you are sitting down, then if you accidentally jump out the thrusters will turn off
Yesss some survival
Before I watch this video (Im sorry if KAN already pointed this out), a heli coptor has one rotating part with rotor blades, so a quad copter is four rotating parts with rotor blades. So a flyer with no rotors or rotor blades is not a quadcopter, it is a thruster drone.
For the sensor, you might be able to adjust the range to compensate for your player moving.
I lol so hard when the flyer took off after kAN delete the button 🤣
Lmfao I lost it when you removed the button
Rather than turning off individual thrusters for pitch and roll, why not go the full monty on gimbal controlled thrust? To pitch down, for example, just have the forward thrusters tilt forward. That should give them less upward thrust (but not 0) and a little forward thrust as well, which usually is the reason for pitching down anyway. Repeat this for both directions in both axes. It'll take some more controllers and bearings, but should run a lot smoother.
Scrap Mechanic - The home of really fantastic bad ideas. :D
kAN: We are crashing!
Also kAN: doesn't talk for 8 years
kAN: realized hes in danger, after 8 years of not talking.
24:17