Manual Transmission vs Automatic vs CVT! BeamNG. Drive

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 12. 2021
  • The ultimate transmission comparison!
    Enjoy!
    Maps:
    www.beamng.com/resources/car-...
    www.beamng.com/resources/ssrb...
    #BeamNG #Transmission #ForgottenMustard #BeamNGDrive #TractorPulling #Experiment
    #AutomaticTransmission #ManualTransmission #TopSpeed

Komentáře • 848

  • @evoemperor3776
    @evoemperor3776 Před 2 lety +2

    A cvt that can handle this much torque only exists in beam ng

  • @ChrisRand-gf7lz
    @ChrisRand-gf7lz Před 2 lety +1

    Not a bad video. Though I have to say if you tasked a current CVT with towing 2-tons, it may have other plans.

  • @ramadhanisme7
    @ramadhanisme7 Před 2 lety +1

    Cvt actually is the fastest transmission, old williams f1 team if I'm not mistaken tested the cvt in f1 and their laptime is reduced by a quite margin

  • @rajgill7576
    @rajgill7576 Před 2 lety +585

    a CVT has many benefits people dont realise, beyond the "quicker" shifts because it has constant ratios. You can design your engine to run best at 1 specific RPM, like a 2 stroke powerband or where your turbo makes the most torque, and set up your CVT accordingly. In the real world, we just don't have heavy duty CVTs in the mainstream yet.

  • @floodtheinbox
    @floodtheinbox Před 2 lety +231

    CVT's are technically superior to other transmissions, but they're SO DAMN UNFULFILLING to drive.

  • @Calthecool
    @Calthecool Před 2 lety +240

    I love the CVTs in BeamNG, I wish they were real

  • @popeyeandstraussmx4165
    @popeyeandstraussmx4165 Před 2 lety +31

    CVTs could not do that in a million years in real life without shattering even with 0 miles. They’re awful transmissions trust me

  • @voodoochild7232
    @voodoochild7232 Před 2 lety +60

    cvts are probably the best transmission but they have no money or time backing them unlike the more traditional ones. if you could somehow make a chain or more sturdy belt im sure they would be good for hauling

  • @qoxx
    @qoxx Před 2 lety +1

    diff wasn't locked with the auto..

  • @risitiaina2965
    @risitiaina2965 Před rokem +1

    Did the CVT really win the uphill tow? Cause to me if the vehicle is smoking and the engine is flashing that usually means something went wrong. I feel the manual won that one since it wasnt even smoking by the time it reached the top

  • @kmemz
    @kmemz Před 2 lety +226

    You found something BeamNG doesn't simulate fully: CVT friction and slip!

  • @AE86FTS
    @AE86FTS Před rokem +18

    Of course in any simulated environment like this, a CVT would definitely win. Although in the real world CVTs would break easily with this kind of load

  • @sgt.scrooge4998
    @sgt.scrooge4998 Před 2 lety +118

    There is one thing manual transmissions will always have; Reliability.

  • @mr_knowcargt5007
    @mr_knowcargt5007 Před 2 lety +39

    Cvts keep the car in the power band, so if they were durable, irl they would be good for towing

  • @SalveMonesvol
    @SalveMonesvol Před 2 lety +51

    If you have 100 HP or less, the CVT rules. Start adding power, and it stops being so nice. The thing is, you can optimize that engine to be very efficient while giving those 100HP.

  • @carlos4731
    @carlos4731 Před rokem +1

    Finnaly, first channel I see using Beam NG for other stuff different than crashes

  • @Dia1Up
    @Dia1Up Před 2 lety +18

    I mean, top speed doesn't have THAT much to do with what type of transmission. More to do with how it gets there

  • @qweebey
    @qweebey Před 2 lety +11

    Had a Lexus with a CVT and drove over 220,000 km without issues it was a GS450h

  • @Stiinno1
    @Stiinno1 Před 2 lety +9

    Fun fact: the CVT is a Dutch invention by Daf.

  • @johnnneh3585
    @johnnneh3585 Před 2 lety +4

    Can you do a Durability test next I love ur vids! Keep up the good work!