Perodua Ativa vs Myvi vs Proton X50 - we compare the size, legroom, build quality, maintenance cost
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 03. 2021
- How big is the Perodua Ativa inside - bigger or smaller than the Myvi/X50? And what about build quality, maintenance cost and driving experience? We answer your questions in this short comparison video.
Details and full gallery here: bit.ly/Perodua-Ativa-vs-Myvi-v... - Auta a dopravní prostředky
Perodua is going to go for volume. This has been and still is one of their ultimate objectives. Those who can afford x50 would proceed to buy them. It's just that Perodua understands that there are more people in Malaysia who couldn't afford x50 than people who could. Perodua then simply counter offering the people with the next best thing they can afford to buy. Having said all this, proton have done a fantastic job with the x70 and x50. Those will definitely help proton to recapture some of It's market share. All the best to proton and perodua..
Wow, U got the point... My opinion, the X50 is suitable for M40 I guess...
Yeah, definitely, as always. It's good to have a lot of option nowadays. Just hope that they'll hire better designers in the future. Cheap cars doesn't always need to look cheap.
Ok agreed with you..👍🏽
Look at Ativa price... Affordable? Good there is full loan and maximum 9 years loan period which makes buyers looks pitiful
Balanced and objective comment, no fanboyism? But this is CZcams! 🧐
For those who are concerns bout the maintenance price of a SUV, shouldn't be buying any SUV in the first place..even the price for changing the tires is already high.. should just get any sedan instead,stick to budget.
True
Plus that cvt in Perodua?Prepare to shelf out maybe atleast 5k when the gearbox went kaput
Actually if u do the maths an Suv and a normal sedan hatchback maintance cost is really not even far off. Both needs changing of oil filter or any fluid such engine oil or brake oil as well and some sesan even uses an 18or 17 inch wheel just as the same as ativa
Ya very true. Most of people who wanted to buy b or c segment sedan changed their mind to go for x50 and x70 premium. Just imagine when they wanted to change the tyre 18 inch (x50) and 19 inch (x70) inch then they will realize.
The maintenance cost looks reasonable except for the spark plug. I have installed iridium plug at Perodua service center before and it doesn't cost up to RM400+.
@@anandsamy5194 my mum book a standard X50, but with a 17 inch wheel, just one up from her present preve of 16 inch wheel.
X50 is a premium suv. Ativa is just an affordable suv.
So premium since have to wait long time for spare part🤣🤣🤭
Yeah you're right about ativa and because of it's affordable i need to wait 4 months +- 🤣
Ya,myvi no turbo just n/a engine only
Proton X50 n Perodua Ativa gt turbo
@@ibalsani546 Even premium Korean cars need a really long time to order spare parts
I never saw anyone review the lowest x50 variant.
How about making a review of top variant attiva vs lowest x50 variant.
Agreed.. why not..🥴
Yeah, i think that will be a fair comparison.
ativa 1.0 + turbo suitable utk city drive ok la. Nak bawa kelajuan hingga ke syurga beli la kereta yg specific utk racing yer
Thanks bro Hafriz! as usual, contend of review absolutely easy to understand. Now everyone should know the different between X50 and Ativa. At the end all of us as Malaysian people should appreciate to both our local car maker having produce this kind of model. Ativa is affordable SUV with premium spect of safety while X50 premium SUV with affordable price.
Why all must put X50 and Ativa as compare, for me Ativa totally different category with X50..
Because its from Malaysia..but its depend on your budget as well..
I think just for fun.. well we know that this 2 company car have launched a nice car..😅
I'm agree with you but majority people still want to compare because both of them are local company.
0:26 he said just for fun 😅
Agree. For me they serve a pretty same purpose but they also target a different people. Ativa is a cheaper choice, meanwhile x50 is a more premium choice.
Wow, after the launch of the Perodua Ativa, paultan immediately make this video.
That's how it should be. The Ativa and X50 are different type of cars catered for different levels of affordability, so let's not try to compare them against each other. And Proton and Perodua (and their fans) should stop fighting each other over the same market share. Moving forward I hope Proton will continue to light fires up their overseas rivals' asses in the ~RM100k market segment while Perodua continue to focus on providing us cheap and practical cars.
One of my wish is to see the Perodua version of the latest Daihatsu Move/Tanto come in.
Ativa nampak mcm mini cooper countryman
This is the video that ive beenn waiting for. Thank you PT. Major key. 👍👍👍
I m planning to settle down in Malaysia. Ur style of telling is awesome 👍 keep the good work
This video was done well. It's hard for me to choose which one. I like the X50 bang for buck, but the Ativa is still a great looking car!
I can see that Miles commented this.
Finally the review I've been waiting for
All said and done, it depends much on how deep is your pocket.
For full loan and 9 years loan period.
Excellent review. I suppose it depends on one's needs and budget. Hopefully spare parts will not be a problem with the Ativa as it has a reported 95% local content.
If you want a more premium ride, comfortable and puts a smile on your face. Get a X50...
If you don’t mind the engine noise, CVT noise and road noise...Ativa is good enough.
Ativa have a better nvh than x50 so i not sure what road sound u talking about
@Konata izumi What kind of road noise u talking about huh?? My father just test drove it and its very quiet
Price wise with premium features: Ativa
Premium quality : X50
Love the x50 and ativa but as 26yrs with a of salary less than 4k, I can only afford axia.
The Ativa interior dimension is a bit letdown here. Seems like the engine bay is unnecessarily large for a 1 liter engine compared to Axia and that takes away some passenger space.
What do u expect from this price point? U want a BMW engine bay?
Dude that is for easy maintenance. Use your brain for once.
Someone with excellent packaging planning knowledge here. Hopefully Perodua people read this. S
Good for putting in k3vet
the engine is small, not the engine bay large. the engine bay is basically the crumple zone, so regardless of how small your engine gets, you need a minimum engine bay size to pass the safety standards
Please review the ativa ADAS safety system.
Sorry, I have a different question; What's the status about NAM factory at Gurun? Is Perodua has any interest expanding their numbers via NAM?
Damn, that comment about Wapcar's tennis balls hahah
Yeah Wapcar's tennis ball crossed my mind too during that part of the video XD
Yeah. I feel that's a bit shady 😅
Paultan vs Wapcar, abit mcm Proton vs Perodua :P
Those trio cars are super lit to own but my budget only can afford me to buy proton whether saga premium auto or perodua bezza X hmmm
at the end of the day...your money, your decision
Very good comparison.. Keep it up👍
All we want is X50 with selling in Ativa price. Anyone agree with me point?
i personally think that the x50 price is justified. selling it at ativa's price point is a tad bit illogical, but that would be really fun to see tho 🤩
Same like wanna eat pizza but only want to pay roti canai price tag. 🤦🏼
Can2... use mr diy parts for the interior. Like cup holder etc
money hungry gov will not let that happen
haha😁
Thank you for good reviews.
please make side-by-side comparisons for the B-segment sedan between the latest vios, city and almeera. all full spec would be better 🔥🔥🔥
persona as well
which more comfortable for family 5 person.
aruz
ativa
tq
Maybe Perodua Ativa vs Perodua Aruz vs Perodua Alza would be more interesting...
Why do I get the feeling he keep saying his car the best 😂nice video 👍
Hahaha 😂
Of coz lo
Thought im the only one. Puji kete sndri😂
Both Ativa and X50 are good car on its own deference class, and of cause cannot compete both of them as many mistaken to do so, its totally deference lever of concept base on comfort and quality. X50 can comfortably on long distance, ativa are best for city drive👍🏽keep up the good work Proton and Perodua 🇲🇾
Nice video 👍🏻 Proton X50 vs Perodua Ativa vs Perodua Myvi 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Since activa width lenght short about 100mm compared to x50 .
Dont expect activa handling as good as x50 .
Cause when the car width shorter but taller then the body roll more significant.
It easy to understand
Well said bro. It is very comprehensive review. This is what people want to know. One of the dilemma that i have is between Ativa AV and X50 standard. I will get a better car if I choose x50 but I will lost the canggih items. I am now trying to understand more about the canggih things on Ativa. I really hope you will cover that aspect in your next review especially the adaptive cruise control bco z i think it will help driver during peak hour traffic
Samalah.. Ada sedikit dilemma skrg ni.. Rasa 50-50 pula walaupun dah booking x50 yg tak kunjung tiba😄
You know it when you test drive both cars. All those fancy2 electronics safety things somewhat u dont really need it. they just warnings system. just the airbags n safety driving will do.
I would go for the X50 over the Ativa (just another 30K) when you consider the premium X50 while the Ativa is an affordable SUV. Clearly Perodua is targeting the masses and not to produce a high-end, mid to premium car like Proton where not many can afford.
Feeling premium alone is not a good excuse to buy any car let alone the X50
What about ground clearance?
Nice review man
Awesome review
Very good review. I opted for Ativa simply becos my wife want a smaller car convenient to drive ard the town only and not for long distance hilly roads drive. I hv used the 1st generation of Myvi which was a very reliable vehicle therefore I trust Perodua/Daihatsu a lot. I initially wanted an X50 but was told by a friend who owned an X70 that Proton has issues with spare parts if big repair is required. My friend X70 was damaged in an accident and its already bn over 3 months and the parts to complete the repair of his X70 are yet to come🙂.
No spare part is a huge headache to owner
I think it's due to covid, parts are limited. My myvi bearing also no stock for few months, need pre order.
Yes, big brother of kelisa finally arrived....
Thanks for informative review, from safety point of view,
1) what are their 100 km/h to 0, braking distance?
2) which car has ADUI (Assist Driver Use Indicator)?
#cycleForLife
When talk about suv, ground clearance should be mention
i used to drive kancil balik kg..
highway jam during holiday even without road accident, because sub100ps car cannot go uphill especially in karak n slim river n senawang..cuma boleh laju2 turun bukit sorry ya for tell the truth..
Good simple comparison. Obviously not trying say which is the best one, but to show which one is the best for you.
Great video
My father buy 1984 corona...until now comfortable...
How laaa... I booked since day 2... shud I proceed the loan .... help me
Very nice content thank you bro
Should also include aruz
Myvi rasa luas sbb seat dia kecik seat pendek span nipis, doortrim pun mcm segment A nipis. Long distance tk selesa langsung
Activa design like a little bit outdated especially the driver cabin
should put almera, x50 and ativa as comparison. as 3 of them were equiped with turbo engine
You should compare Ativa with Haval H1
We get it bro, ur car is better than the rest
That's the truth
You must be joking if you think ativa is the best of 3
Nice review dude. As you said, you get what you pay for.
not forgetting the insurance cost which should be part of maintenance cost.
Very interesting marketing strategy. X50 beat the Japanese and Ativa beat them all. Well done Perodua.
Perduo is also a Japanese car, not a national car is just a copy of Daihatsu
@@cifer0602 its rebatch engineering...for holy sake..well if that's the pov..nothing national anymore..
Bodo
@@sangpenghujam5137 so those Malaysia who works eith perodua who help with the design and build of this Ativa or Raize or Rocky from the word go, is also Japanesr u mean? The 95% locally made or source parts are Japanese as well right?
@@cifer0602 ploton also China product
omg it looks like a mini cooper version malaysia
I love x50. But my budget just for 2nd hand ex5
Hello guys,
Boleh tolong suggest tak yang mana better for my usages
1. Kerja Kajang to Shah Alam daily x6/week
2. Ahad for sure grocery day around 5km from my house
3. Next 3 month akan kahwin
4. Outstations mungkin 1 month sekali macam tu kerja
Dari list ini mana yang better both eligible utk I but confused lah nak choose mana. Ini 1st car, mungkin next car lepas 15 tahun kot anggaran. Ada yang boleh suggest ..
Somehow it feels like this is a video to promote x50.
You look at the price difference.. Of course x50 should have been bettet
He forgot to mention double stage storage at the back
Saya prefer X50...tau lain segmen lain harga tp X50 lebih baik lebih cantik luar dalam compare dgn Ativa...
Substance over Form, Kembara!
Terbaik for Rm 20 for the Rotex
KOTEX kut🤣
@@8888cA Jilake! Berdekah tergelak aku 🤣 sampai tersembur kopi ni ha!
2:06 Wow I think the X50 is still very new but the rear tint starts to bubble already. Why is that?
Owner did not follow salesman instruction?
Owner cannot open bck window heater function, for at least 2 months.
Dang. X50 proton. This time.. n balance time in video.
Is different car. One Perak Plate, 2.06 time is KL/Fed plate
Looks wise and everything else of course X50 wins but money wise Ativa wins
Nak bayar 7-9 tahun..
Kalau tak beli yang kita suka..nanti bayar lama rasa nyesal.
Baik beli yang paling murah sahaja jika hanya nak kereta. Atau beli kereta used sahaja.
where is this filmed?
Looks like MAEPS open parking..
Im really, extremely sad because proton loose it drive for the new models. If geely give them a chance to change the handling, it will be excellent models.
As a second hand car dealer, I strongly approve Proton and Perodua launch more >RM70k cars.
? why
@@jameshunk7211 people will tend to buy more second hand car, because the local carmaker making more premium cars
Build quality wise... we shall see how long proton /chinese standards component can last as oppose to perodua/ toyota proven high quality.
i booked the x50 but the waiting is such a pain. Went to perodua showroom and they got readystock . So now my mind has messed up whether i should wait for x50 or just take the ativa. Currently driving an old myvi but it’s my dad’s car so sometimes it would be hard for me if he wants to use the car too
So which one do you picked?
Pink flower shirt, pink mask..haha
That was lot different of price between ativa and x50.....so the material of interior design not same like x50..... Also the power ofc not same because ativa just use 1.0 liter turbo......so for my opinion ativa is made for who want a SUV with low roadtext, low price and also low maintenance cost
The Ativa plastic in real eyes does feel cheap and same quality like Axia G spec. Feels like paid double price but only get Axia spec atas.
U pay peanut and what u expect leather
takde race ke
Hello,
I just bought X50 Premium and I have few question since I am not car experts, please do help:
1. X50 Premium headlights not leveled (right side is like 2 or 3cm lower than left light) when turn on at night.
2. X50 Premium engine when turn on, if we outside we hear like the engine mounting is shaking badly but if we inside the car cannot hear.
3. X50 Premium while driving on the road, when some car pass through right side makes the car wobbly.
So, for all 3 above? Is it normal? I even went to Proton Service Centre for the lamp problem they say its normal, they open few X50 all like that. Please help me, anyone? I really appreciate your kind advice and knowledge. Thank you in advance.
1. Its normal, left is higher due to road signage, signboard, whereby right is for cars and roads.
2. Its a 3-cylinder TGDI so shaking is normal as the engine balancing is not same as 4-cylinder
3. Wobbly its normal too because of the high ride body not like sedan
dislike the dull red color dashboard and arm rest on X50, might as well make it all black
If you plan to use for at least 9 years go for ativa, if less than 6 years, go for x50. Japan spare parts more tahan than the china one, and easier to get service too.
See a lot of comment saying how premium x50 is. But why not go for x70? Almost all review says it more premium than the x50. + money wise not much different. Both simply SUV. Why buy suv for speed and performance when you can buy honda civic for example. Confirm better handling and performance then any SUV within its price range. Just my 2cents
ativa reminds me of old toyota rav4 and suzuki vitara
Don't forget for Kembara
.... i still think myvi will be Malaysian darling for a couple more years.. the cheapest being under 50k with that reliability... my pocket decide a myvi..
Drag race please.. X50 vs Ativa and myvi king of highway...
must use MK2 myvi. lol
width?
X50 clearly looks elegant
Cannot compare la.. x50 another level. Ativa just compact suv n turbo geli2.
aktiva nampak cam besar lagi dari x50... mungkin sebab design dia yg nampak lebih gagah
Wah biar Betul Ativa gabung X50 jadi apa?
Jadi huduh
AtivaX50
Can you do a drag race for the god sake?
X50 my choice.
This all engineer malaysia can do? Which level are we now in automotive. What purpose of engineering course in university.
The ativa looks like a modernized kembara tbh. there's only one way to pick between these 3, if you have 100k to spend then get the x50, if you're looking for a basic SUV that'll get the job done then get the ativa, if you wanna go just from point A to B then myvi or Iriz would be a good buy. if you dont like malaysian cars then get a used mazda cx3 hahaha
to me it looks like a cheaper mini cooper
Yeah.. Look like mini cooper lah.
My wish: the sexy Proton x50
My want: hey you Ativa.. 🤪
All hail King Myvi 👑
boleh buka topeng muka semasa buat recording? x selesa tgk..
should have add ARUZ into comparison.
Yeah...aruz is a better comparison to x50, not ativa. Ativa and x50 should not be direct rivals.
shooting dekat hospital tuuuu