Ramayan 14000yrs old ?? | Scientific dating by Nilesh Oak | Reaction

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 03. 2024
  • Come and join me to see me react to
    IG: zuzanareacts
    To support this channel, use the link: ko-fi.com/zuzanareacts
    Original Video: • Ramayan 14000yrs old ?...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 445

  • @RanaAnkesh1
    @RanaAnkesh1 Před 2 měsíci +112

    Forget everything, the fact that the position of different planets is mentioned in Ramayana during the time of birth of Lord Rama is insane to think about. We are talking about a time when people still believed in geocentrism and had no idea about the shape of Earth or number of other planets and here we find a book which gives exact description of the position of different planet is mind boggling to think about.

    • @RanaAnkesh1
      @RanaAnkesh1 Před 2 měsíci +4

      @@Yogi_The_Bitter_Truth_2408 Not for you maybe but someone thinking ahead of time is always mind boggling. People like you are already out of that belief so we dont need your preachings.

    • @Matsya87
      @Matsya87 Před 2 měsíci +6

      Not only the planets but Valmiki also described the position of various constellations during each particular event..

    • @yeagerist4979
      @yeagerist4979 Před 2 měsíci +1

      I have heard that countless times, but I've never seen any scientific paper talking about it.

    • @spiyengar6769
      @spiyengar6769 Před 2 měsíci +1

      SUURYASIDDHANTA came before RGVEDA as a prerequisite for ritual and had a few thousand years of observations already. All the numbers of orbits, sizes etc were measured and saved as book and verse numbers in Rg Veda already as described by Subash Kak in his book “The Astronomical Code of the RgVeda “. Rg Veda had a fully capable number system and a GANITHA capable of 8 digit accuracy for astronomical computation, also sperical geometry for celestial mechanics (and navigation over spherical earth). SUURYASIDDHANTA had calculated planetary sizes from a condensing solar nebula model with sise of planets proportional to orbit diameter, corresponding to a simple accretion model , pretty good in general and extremely good for gas giants because it didn’t know what the mean densities were for the inner rocky planets.

    • @RanaAnkesh1
      @RanaAnkesh1 Před 2 měsíci +2

      @@yeagerist4979 What scientific basis do you want to accept that yes there exists others planets as well and Earth rotates around Sun? It might be a common sense now but to talk about it thousands of year ago, when in the rest of the world till as late as 1400s it was considered as Falt Earth and Earth is at centre, isnt that scientific enough?

  • @prabhavtt2017
    @prabhavtt2017 Před 2 měsíci +83

    Its our history and we dont seek any validation from anyone...And also the evidence of sanatana dharma being 10000years old is what have been found so far its actually much much much older than that...Note:That is not the starting point of it.

    • @Neeleish_cr_gaawre
      @Neeleish_cr_gaawre Před 2 měsíci +2

      Please can you share references i will look at it

    • @harzh9369
      @harzh9369 Před 2 měsíci +1

      ​@@Neeleish_cr_gaawresearch sangam talks channel. It has all the reasearch and vishuddhi films , which is a brainchild of Rajiv Malhotra is a documentary format film.

    • @Neeleish_cr_gaawre
      @Neeleish_cr_gaawre Před 2 měsíci

      @@harzh9369 did you check his references personally??

    • @crombajaa
      @crombajaa Před 2 měsíci +3

      Yes, my great-grandfather also said he was from Krypton. He said he lived somewhere near the Sun and now he has moved out because of solar pollution. This was 90 million years ago. I have a record of it. I think it was written by hand by him with a "real" ballpoint pen from 90 million years ago.

    • @criticalview4270
      @criticalview4270 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@Neeleish_cr_gaawre also check Sattology

  • @RanaAnkesh1
    @RanaAnkesh1 Před 2 měsíci +39

    There are only 2 books in all our religious texts which have been termed as itihaas which means history and they are Ramayana and Mahabharata. And yes there are things which seem like science fiction and untrue but as a believer in our religion we have faith upon it. Yes the way of writing is poetic and some artistic liberty may have been taken in writing it but the story is true, the morals are true and the faith that we have on it gives us strength, unity, morality, hope and i believe that is enough.

  • @lostashmish
    @lostashmish Před 2 měsíci +8

    TWO POLE STARS, and THEY CHANGE in a megacycle of 26K years...IMAGINE, modern science found only now..

  • @vikasarya8424
    @vikasarya8424 Před 2 měsíci +34

    Ramayana is at the time of human evolution from monkeys, bears and big birds

    • @yashyadav1765
      @yashyadav1765 Před 2 měsíci +4

      We were never Monkeys , the theory is failed.

    • @nischalmehta5234
      @nischalmehta5234 Před 2 měsíci +1

      Sathya Sai Baba has told in one of his discourses that Mahabharat happenned 5100 years back and Ramayana happened 50,000+ years back !!

    • @yeagerist4979
      @yeagerist4979 Před 2 měsíci +2

      ​@@yashyadav1765 🤦.. we and monkeys evolved from the same Ape ancestors.

    • @yeagerist4979
      @yeagerist4979 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@nischalmehta5234 Nah, Ramayana happened 4.5 billion years ago, even before the formation of Earth.

    • @thesentry1434
      @thesentry1434 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@yashyadav1765 I agree. We were never evolved from monkeys or another creatures

  • @ggautamr4677
    @ggautamr4677 Před 2 měsíci +13

    Everything is True in Valmiki Ramayan

  • @anirbanganguly6678
    @anirbanganguly6678 Před 2 měsíci +8

    This is a video of encyclopaedia...a true gem 💎...

  • @rishabhm16
    @rishabhm16 Před 2 měsíci +6

    Love from India. Keep up your good work

  • @AnjaniShukla-yc9vs
    @AnjaniShukla-yc9vs Před 2 měsíci +7

    I love Ramayan. Proud to be India as hindu nation.

  • @earth4009
    @earth4009 Před 2 měsíci +5

    So actually those names were names of constellations in Sanskrit. These texts were written with exact astronomical data of that time. They exactly denotes this star is in that position in this specific season etc. so this guy with the help of NASA software to study constellations did analysis of these astronomical timeframes and got the dates. It’s true or not perhaps that can be debatable.
    Ancient Hinduism (Sanatan Dharma) was more based on discovery and innovation then compared to modern form. You have to understand how they found gravity, algebra, zero, how Pythagoras traveled to India , the number system you call Arabic are actually Indian numericals transferred to Europe by Arab traders .

  • @lovepreetsingh-tc6po
    @lovepreetsingh-tc6po Před 2 měsíci +8

    He is coming soon on ranveer podcast

  • @madhuragrawal9398
    @madhuragrawal9398 Před měsícem +1

    Ram came in Treta Yug, now we are in kali yug. Hence it is more than 8 lac years

  • @trajan3413
    @trajan3413 Před 2 měsíci +6

    U must watch the video in which timeframe has been described as per ancient Indian texts....literally thousands n billions of years of time-frame has been provided...coz star were used to track the time

  • @trajan3413
    @trajan3413 Před 2 měsíci +6

    When things that are beyond thousands of years old and only specifics dates sort of mentioned.... than starmaps are used to track those time frame....so in Indian texts u come across the time which is explained by word " Nakshatra " meaning time / maps based on position of stars at that particular time.... if u understand that u can make out exact mention time-frame....

  • @animalreaction6100
    @animalreaction6100 Před 2 měsíci +7

    Congratulations for 19k ❤

  • @raunaksinghdhanjal4168
    @raunaksinghdhanjal4168 Před 2 měsíci +4

    There is a video of Raj Vednam and podcast with ranveer and on a channel called sangam talks, there he explains the basics of astrology and how it was created.

  • @ashutoshd4
    @ashutoshd4 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Ramayana is not a success story but a serial disasters in life of Lord Rama. Most important thing is the Rama maintained his character strong and constant through vagaries of human life.
    Most of Hindu gods are highest quality of one aspect of life. Human facet.

  • @animalreaction6100
    @animalreaction6100 Před 2 měsíci +6

    At first you have to know about Hindu Calendar otherwise it would be difficult to understand this video😊❤ . Love this video watching with you....

  • @nimeshbhatt7946
    @nimeshbhatt7946 Před 2 měsíci

    We have so many books and LOGIC behind what he was saying.RAM TEMPLE BUILT WHERE THE EXACT LOCATION IS GIVEN IN SANATAN VEDA WITH FULL EVIDENCE AND COURT & opposition HAD NO ANSWER FOR.

  • @coolraj1063
    @coolraj1063 Před 2 měsíci +2

    ramayan and mahabharata is our pride and greatest history of humankind ever existed and the bhagwat geeta is all sayings of lord krishna and his wisdom to us as humans like arjun in mahabharat in the battle field ,we adore lord krishna so much as god not because of his power or any super power stuffs but because of his intellect his life struggle as well as a person of a great wisdom that can change any human life and success through the geeta❤❤

  • @amitpatil6185
    @amitpatil6185 Před 2 měsíci +2

    Thank you mam 🙏🙏

  • @sondarang538
    @sondarang538 Před 2 měsíci +19

    Ramayana is as old as Egyptian if not older 😊 as india is one of the oldest nation on earth

    • @ojasneelabh2599
      @ojasneelabh2599 Před 2 měsíci +6

      Calling it near Egyptian is as calling it like it happened day before yesterday

    • @anshulchouhan1482
      @anshulchouhan1482 Před 2 měsíci +6

      egyptian is nearly 2000 years old and even mahabharata is 4000 to 5000 years old 😂😂 egyptians started at the time of indus valley not at the time of mahabharata

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci +6

      nope..itz older...atleast million years old!

    • @nischalmehta5234
      @nischalmehta5234 Před 2 měsíci

      Sathya Sai Baba has told in one of his discourses that Mahabharat happenned 5100 years back and Ramayana happened 50,000+ years back !!

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci +1

      @@nischalmehta5234forget sathya sai baba..read the scriptures to get the timeline...ramayan is million+ years old...

  • @vikramsinghrana7134
    @vikramsinghrana7134 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Oh my god finally finally someone reacted to some significant, important, breaking the propganda video, thank u so much,thanks thaks 😊❤❤❤

  • @curiouscynic4357
    @curiouscynic4357 Před měsícem

    Leaving the date aside it is hugely illuminating that Ramayana shows how a civilised and progressive society should live. There is no doubt that even by conservative yardstick Rama preceded Krishna. There is irrefutable evudence from the submerged Dwarika. This makes Ram to be at least 9000 years ago.
    Hence there is no question of giving it a status of relugion which has regularly been a devisive tool that has been weapinised to kill hundreds of millions of innocent to feed the greed of many glotified trash of mankind.

  • @umpboy8474
    @umpboy8474 Před 2 měsíci +1

    जय श्री राम जय श्री कृष्णा 🚩🚩

  • @user-ep2hw8tj1q
    @user-ep2hw8tj1q Před 2 měsíci +5

    I highly recommend that u see book's written by him. He is based in USA n has done some commendable work on Astrophysics.

  • @truthfinder8652
    @truthfinder8652 Před 2 měsíci +1

    In Ancient Hinduism, the positions of stars had a very important role. Nowadays bcz Roman calendar has become common in current world, ancient systems aren't that much used. An ancient times, time was was mostly recorded with the position of stars. So in this video what he is talking about is the positions of stars mentioned in the Scriptures and the way today scientists trace back the previous positions of planets and stars and big bang, through that we can calculate the time when the stars were at that particular position through which we can tell how old scriptures are .

  • @rohitpandey9920
    @rohitpandey9920 Před 2 měsíci

    Ramayan is far more older than this. It was an event that happened atleast a million years ago. Satyug lasted 1.726 million years, treta yug (which is when ramayan happened) lasted 1.296 million years, dwapar yug lasted 864k years and kalyug (which we are currently living in) will last 432k years, currently it's been just around 3000 years of kalyug.
    Ramayan happened around the end time of dwapar yug when Shri Ram killed Ravan. This is as per Valmiki Ramayan and the timelines are as per Srimad Bhagavad Gita and our Vedic scriptures.

  • @raunaksinghdhanjal4168
    @raunaksinghdhanjal4168 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Well the Astrological Significance he pointed is scientific if the names and nature of the heavenly bodies he mentioned is same as we thought then the dates should be correct, given valmiki's text is correct.

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci

      nilesh caculation is totally wrong by...million+ years minus 14,000 years!...

  • @nimeshbhatt7946
    @nimeshbhatt7946 Před 2 měsíci

    Let me tell you one amazing thing that in SANATAN holly book HANUMAN CHALISA exactly stated the Sun distance from the earth before 4500 years ago by TULSI DASJI.

  • @aravind4090
    @aravind4090 Před 2 měsíci

    Great video 🥳🤩

  • @apoorva629
    @apoorva629 Před 2 měsíci

    Actually nowadays the Gregorian calander which is a solar callander is so common that we think that the mention of months and stars is a big thing... Hindu calander is a lunar calendar hence it also takes in accounts of all the stars and planets and constilations... Even now when we are celebrating holi diwali new year etc its always on the calander its not that big thing...

  • @lkshpnd69
    @lkshpnd69 Před 2 měsíci

    Now u got some reality 👍👍

  • @babaguru_ghantaal3363
    @babaguru_ghantaal3363 Před 2 měsíci

    300 years ago galaliyo was torchered by Christian community for his confirmation that earth revolving around sun.. and our ancestors was brilliant in astronomy thousands of years ago

  • @ggautamr4677
    @ggautamr4677 Před 2 měsíci +2

    Rig Veda is the oldest book

  • @MrDarksly3r
    @MrDarksly3r Před 2 měsíci

    Just to tell you that its a common practice to write about the astronomical positioning of stars and planets. Even today our parents use this for marriage ceremony and understanding about our future.

  • @pranavrathi779
    @pranavrathi779 Před 2 měsíci +2

    Watch more short documentaries from this channel. Well researched and good production

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci

      maybe good production..but 14000 years..is just way way wrong...

  • @tatsavitar7281
    @tatsavitar7281 Před 2 měsíci

    A sage is equal to the supreme consciousness itself. So a Sage never writes using his imagination, but he uses what he sees through his eyes of inner wisdom.

  • @swapanchowdhury6034
    @swapanchowdhury6034 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Zuzana, a great! BD

  • @kb8422
    @kb8422 Před 2 měsíci

    Evolved so much that even mathematicians get shocked by our calculating parameters but also simple and humble enough to know that there is a monkey god and its not a fable

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci +1

      itz not monkey...itz van (forest) + nar (man)....get back to basics!

  • @krishnaats7141
    @krishnaats7141 Před 2 měsíci +1

    12000+ years ago the Pole star was Vega aka Abhijit. Now the pole star is Polaris. This is because of Precession of Earth's axis that takes 25000 years to make one rotation.

    • @fusionx9593
      @fusionx9593 Před 2 měsíci

      please search when was the last polar shift occurred and after that comment back..

    • @krishnaats7141
      @krishnaats7141 Před 2 měsíci

      @@fusionx9593 What polar shift?
      And who do you think you are? Why should I come back and report to you? Are you my employer?

    • @fusionx9593
      @fusionx9593 Před 2 měsíci

      @@krishnaats7141 I am just saying Ramayan happened around 800thousand years back and the last polar shift occurred after that around 780 thousand years ago. Our Sanatan civilization is much older than 12 thousands. Why are you so pissed off ?? Don't tell me & don't care but just letting you know about the polar shift. Have a great day Krishna.

    • @krishnaats7141
      @krishnaats7141 Před 2 měsíci

      @@fusionx9593 If you stick to science, that doesn't reduce Sanatan by one bit.

    • @fusionx9593
      @fusionx9593 Před 2 měsíci

      @@krishnaats7141 yeah I agree 💯

  • @somnathbose7455
    @somnathbose7455 Před 2 měsíci

    we have been worshipping and having dedicated temples of the navagrahas (nine planets) [although those nine planets included sun moon and didn't know about uranus and pluto] ...its human ignorance to think that current generation humans are far superior in knowledge than all the people of ancient world

  • @vivavois8966
    @vivavois8966 Před 2 měsíci

    Indians gave the world model of solar system, astronomical maths to predict eclipses, calendering system, Hindu leap year is true leap year based on natural celestial event. In short Indians gave the world advanced maths geometry astronomy.

  • @karthikbn8457
    @karthikbn8457 Před 2 měsíci

    Ramayan is actually more than 864000 years not 14000 years old as per constellations if you go back meaning way the same constellations again and again had occurred so i assume they haven't gone to peek way back 😅

  • @prathikgouda27
    @prathikgouda27 Před 2 měsíci

    Many of us don’t even know what happened after kurukshethra yudd bcoz majority doesn’t read Mahabharata….plz read it where krishna looses war against his bhakth bcoz of good ppl can’t be defeated by god too….krishna looses for 2-3 times bcoz of bhakthi marga of his bhakth

  • @krishnaats7141
    @krishnaats7141 Před 2 měsíci

    Jyotisha and Vedanga Jyotisha involve understanding Cosic vodies, their movements and tgeir effects on us. Today we have reduced it to some pseudo science, but it involves immense calculations of how these bodies move and interact. Astronomy and Astrology were once same thing.. we call it Jyotisha

  • @user-tj6vp7if1r
    @user-tj6vp7if1r Před 2 měsíci +2

    Zuzana you should watch ranveer podcast with Raj Vedam.

  • @rutheless840
    @rutheless840 Před 2 měsíci +1

    For your information:
    Islam texts:
    Women(6years to ..):meant for breeding purpose
    Others:Kafirs
    God:Egoistic and doest like to be painted,drawn or perceived in form which human eye can feel
    Place:Desert(neither water nor food)
    year: 1400 years back
    Earth:Flat
    After death:72 hoors(beautiful women to enjoy🙂)
    Salvation (Moksha):😑
    Meditation (yoga):😑
    Hindu texts:
    Woman:Entire Mahabharat and Gita is a result of an insult to woman.
    Others:There are no others (sarveyjana sukino bavanthu)
    God: Unlimited and Everywhere,but came down to just destroy our illusions of his formlessness,the form which can be perceived by eyes.
    Universe: correct calculation of distance between sun and earth(hanuman chalisa),Multiverse(vishnu puran),Theory of relativity etc
    year: recorded history 10000, actual (existance started with santan dharma)
    Resources:Google, ancient architectures,Archiological evidences,Carbon dating etc

  • @dharmendraprasad8751
    @dharmendraprasad8751 Před 2 měsíci

    Oldest civilization on the earth 🌍🌍 around 155.52 years old civilization

  • @singhdeepak10
    @singhdeepak10 Před 2 měsíci

    Indian delegation to Israel was told by a Rabbi, about Sanskrit words in Torah.

  • @aashish.purohit
    @aashish.purohit Před 2 měsíci

    There is a fundamental difference in the way monolithic religion (west) look at history and how Dharmic people (east) look at history.
    We are not looking for it's accuracy, we are looking it for an inspiration,
    Also There are 3 level of understanding
    Physical, Devine & Spritual

  • @MS-ov9sv
    @MS-ov9sv Před 2 měsíci

    Heaven and hell are not permanent in Hinduism. Souls time in Heaven or hell will also be determined by their Karma. But that is not the end point or goal jn Hinduism.....its 'Moksha' ....ultimate liberation of soul and going back to the source

  • @Ashutosh-lw3cn
    @Ashutosh-lw3cn Před 2 měsíci

    Thank you Zuzana for raising a concern/curiosity which represents a typical European person (no offence though). So let me answer certain questions.
    For the time being, just forget about the religious aspect of scriptures. Just on the basis of pure astrology, astronomy and astrophysics the positioning, mentioning and most importantly transit of various planets, seasons, stars and constellations etc are beautifully mentioned in The epics of Ramayan and Mahabharat and basis of that Mr. Neelesh Nilkanth Oak ji has given his theory (which mind you is an open challenge and nobody from any part of the world countered it yet).
    Now as for scriptures, its important to understand India is not merely a nation state (like many nations of Europe and America). It's a Civilizational state (probably the oldest). And I believe many of the states within India are much bigger in size than many European countries, so one can imagine how vast India is. Moreover it's not just the vastness of geography but also the cultural ambiguity is quite evident in India. For example it's said that with every 500 Km distance in India, the language/culture changes. Yet with all differences if people have embraced and adhered not just for years or centuries but also for millennia, tells a lot about the evidence that the incident did take place at some point in time.
    One more thing people have to keep in mind, regarding reading/understanding about Indian Civilization is the years of invasion and incursion it faced for the last 1000-1500 years. And it's not just a physical invasion where the primary goal of invaders was to acquire, rape, plunder the landmass of Ancient India but also these invasion were a mean to destroy the civilisation both physically and mentally. There are tons of evidence like Destruction and sacrilegious acts on temples, Burning of libraries of universities, killing in mass spree of scholar class so as knowledge won't propagate further are just the tip of iceberg of the atrocities Indian Civilization faced in past 1000-1500 years. Add to that creation of a new breed of Brown European/Mughals in Indian subcontinent who disgrace their own culture and find every means to demolish it (even if they have to spread and propagate lies). Add to that the biasness of European scholars who do their research on Indian history and many a times see everything from their own frame of reference (which is completely opposite on how ancient sages were written in the scriptures and the meaning of it).

  • @shyamsrivastava2066
    @shyamsrivastava2066 Před 2 měsíci

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @contemporarymatters8106
    @contemporarymatters8106 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Your point of view can be given. Maybe it was too fast for you to grasp. A description of a comet in a particular constellation cannot be made up unless it is actually seen. And such an astronomical event can be dated. In India, mostly, mid February to mid March can be considered spring. But in history spring did not occur at this time because of the eccentricity or wobble of the earth's rotation. It occurred in September, and such an event can also be dated. These are the descriptions he was talking about.

  • @nimishawasthi2470
    @nimishawasthi2470 Před 2 měsíci

    you should read valmiki's ramayana(which is the original one). It is the accurate history

  • @ivarhakuse8572
    @ivarhakuse8572 Před 2 měsíci

    You found it similar to the Old Testament. The Old Testament itself was taken from Sumerians, Egyptians, and Greeks and these were themselves only only the western outreaches of Indic civilisation. The Old Testament was written by Sumerian scribes employed by the Jews ruling at that time to give them some historical and civilizational credibility. The Jews were originally sheep and goat shepherds lacking literary skills to undertake such a task. The Europeans linked their own civilisations to that of the ‘Greeks’ and the Romans. But even a concept such as of some unified Greece itself had to be made. Originally, it was formed of many different warring principalities. Alexander was made into a Greek, he was Macedonian, and Macedonians are very particular about their distinct non- Greek identity. India is left off discussions on ancient History and much of Ancient Indian History was taught to India by the Europeans, the French, Germans and British who were trying to rule India. In that process, one primary drive was to undermine Indians by undermining their History. Indian Historical texts labelled as mere mythological accounts of not much standing. Indians informed that they had no sense of writing History. Indians being told that they themselves originated in central Asian steppes. Indians told that they were but Aryan invaders to justify their own invasions. New genetic evidence however shows that around 45 000 years back, after the last Ice age it was Indians who migrated west to populate the Europe of today and that these people had small pockets of settlements scattered here and there which warred each other and later went on to make the countries we find today. One thing common in all of these is their language which all belong to the Indo-European family of languages. The most ancient of which is Indian Sanskrit. Ideas such as of a hypothetical Proto-Indo-European were also floated to pull the origin back towards the west but of which there is no proof whatsoever. Therefore, their needs be a much more honest enquiry with regards history, but honesty becomes the last thing you’d ever wish to bring to the table when you work to an agenda such as the Christian one which has a history itself of nothing other that a subversive seditionist political machinery out to cut people from their cultural, spiritual, civilizational roots.

  • @dnynashwaradagal1365
    @dnynashwaradagal1365 Před 2 měsíci

    जय श्री राम ❤

  • @desia9227
    @desia9227 Před 2 měsíci

    Yes ramayana much older... vedant upanishads are even earlier than that

  • @rayan51199
    @rayan51199 Před 2 měsíci

    To clarify, I know the languages like Hindi, English, and Sanskrit. But, even I struglled to culminate regarding Astrology. Its altogether a differe area to commence. Anyway I appreciate your effert. Keep it up. May be it will take a while. But in the end, you will be much more informed about Sanatan dharma, provided if you are interested for that long to understand a single topic.

  • @desairajtube
    @desairajtube Před 2 měsíci

    Mathematics originated in ancient Indian astronomy. It is a tough subject to grasp, just like it is difficult to attain self realisation for ordinary people in meditation.
    Ramayan is not a history, neither myth. It is itihas which means "as it happened."
    One has to come out of Western or Abrahamic framework of religion to understand the astronomical itihas and indian philosophy (darshana) of metaphysical level.
    As soon as people's analysis use Abrahamic religion or superficial science as reference point, then they get stuck at a lower orbit of insight.
    What is passed on in the ramayana story could not have been passed on over centuries and still corroborate accurately with the planetary events in the solar system. If it was made up to last the story for 14000 years then why can't NASA make up a story going into future to come true, let alone 1000s of years but even 50 years would be good enough for us to believe that " myths like Ramayana" can be made up to last. Let's do it, in the era of so called most advanced science.
    Only a few decades ago, even now some people in Abrahamic religion believe that the earth is flat. Then how would they grasp complex planetary system maths.

  • @GauravUpadhyaya
    @GauravUpadhyaya Před 2 měsíci

    Please do a podcast with Nilesh Oak.

  • @user-cw3vl1ns1m
    @user-cw3vl1ns1m Před 2 měsíci

    Ramayan isn't 14000 years old it's 18 to 19,00,000 years old. It held in first face of Treta yuga

  • @atirath1082
    @atirath1082 Před 2 měsíci +1

    There are also same videos in English.

  • @ahaohoaha5728
    @ahaohoaha5728 Před 2 měsíci

    Ramayan is more old than 14000yr.....

  • @krishnaats7141
    @krishnaats7141 Před 2 měsíci

    It isnt Ramayaanam. It is Raamaayanam

  • @bellapatel3134
    @bellapatel3134 Před 2 měsíci

    It's NOT Legend it is oir history. We can trace 39 ancestors back for Shri Ram. Can they trace another who is not Sanatan Dharma can trace all with accurate dates, year, place and correct parents

  • @pilotcyborg.gaming
    @pilotcyborg.gaming Před 2 měsíci +1

    nilesh is a genius

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      he is plain wrong..by a million+ years

    • @pilotcyborg.gaming
      @pilotcyborg.gaming Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit02 why dont you accept the challenge then lol

    • @stallionspirit9317
      @stallionspirit9317 Před 2 měsíci

      @@pilotcyborg.gaming one simple fact..totally invalidates Nilesh Oak...Ravana palace was written to have been guarded by 4-tusked elephants (Gompothere)...gompotheres became extinct 1-1.6million years ago...case closed!

    • @stallionspirit9317
      @stallionspirit9317 Před 2 měsíci

      @@pilotcyborg.gaming therefore... ramayan had to have happened atleast milllion+ years...in treta yuga..as stated in our scriptures..

  • @priyankajyani9198
    @priyankajyani9198 Před měsícem

    Jai shree Ram

  • @kailashnathbansal7116
    @kailashnathbansal7116 Před 2 měsíci

    Actually ramayan happened some 17 to 18 million years ago

  • @user-zw2es8vo4x
    @user-zw2es8vo4x Před 2 měsíci

    🌻❤❤👍

  • @himanshugurjar9002
    @himanshugurjar9002 Před 2 měsíci

    He is a pop historian. Ramayana happened around 1000-900 bc.
    Mahabharata around 850-800 bc. Going by both astronomical descriptions and polity described in them.

    • @arpandebnath7656
      @arpandebnath7656 Před 2 měsíci +1

      So you are saying Mauryans/Nandas followed Ramayana and mahabharata before Ramayana and mahabharata happened?
      Broh atleast have a open mind to accept logical reasoning and facts. Even the newest form of Rigveda with Devnagari is 6000-7000 years old.Scientists are still researching and searching for the old sanskrit. Broh Ramayana is so widespread. It has influence in Celtic,eastern African,eastern asian and many cultures. For example Story of Fion mac Cumhails similar with Ramayan. Even genetic evidences are there. They brought there cultural from central and eastern europe to british isles and western europe.They had similar god like Our Mahadev(pashupatinath) (as described in harappan Civilization)

  • @MS-ov9sv
    @MS-ov9sv Před 2 měsíci

    Islamic and British colonial rule has destroyed Indian knowledge systems so profoundly. Ramayan is our history.

  • @vijaysinhrajput1459
    @vijaysinhrajput1459 Před 2 měsíci

    Jay shree ram ram ram ram ram ram

  • @playhard719
    @playhard719 Před 2 měsíci

    Most people in India does not agree with Nilesh oak especially on his dating of scriptures, his claims are generally outlandish, while the western scholars on one extreme dating anything Indian after 1500BCE, he is an example of the other extreme, but he is an excellent Sanskrit scholar, I if you have time watch his videos about Sugriva's Atlas.

  • @PrabhatKumar-ng5zp
    @PrabhatKumar-ng5zp Před 2 měsíci

    ❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹

  • @MalayaPradhan921
    @MalayaPradhan921 Před 2 měsíci

    Yes sister Ramayan is 14000 Thousands year old love from India 🇮🇳

  • @boxofchocolates2134
    @boxofchocolates2134 Před měsícem

    To be Frank, most of the commentators in this comment section must not have understood even half of what he said, just like me😂😂😂. Unless, someone understands astronomical calculations as well as the ancient names of cosmic bodies, one cannot analyse and interpret. Above all, Nilesh Oak seems to be a Genius of his field.
    A Slovakian with knowledge of Indian epics and an Indian will takeaway the same amount of information from this video.

  • @pranavjadhav18
    @pranavjadhav18 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Ramayana has 23 different version and english version is not the genuine one.

    • @Sanjuhere
      @Sanjuhere Před 2 měsíci

      Valmiki Ramayana is the right one amongst all.

  • @dididodobobo
    @dididodobobo Před 2 měsíci

    Bro we have archaeological evidence of 12000 - 9500 year old equipment and dwarka civilization asset's, like physical and scientific proof what else do you need

  • @hunza-r-aranyak2650
    @hunza-r-aranyak2650 Před 2 měsíci

    Yes..if you go Nilesh Oak CZcams channel... You get good resurch about ancient Bharata civilization, Saraswati river releted research, research related to Mahabharata etc. Etc... He is good researcher just like pravin mohan..

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      his dates on ramayan...are definitely wrong by million+ years

    • @hunza-r-aranyak2650
      @hunza-r-aranyak2650 Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit02 may be..he is wrong.. but he gives astronomy evidence for proof his words..if you have other evidence for proof your "milion year's" theory..then please put on CZcams.. we went to see!. It's pleasure for indian's.

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      @@hunza-r-aranyak2650 one simple fact..totally invalidates Nilesh Oak...Ravana palace was written to have been guarded by 4-tusked elephants (Gompothere)...gompotheres became extinct 1-1.6million years ago ...so ramayan had to happen arleast million+ years...in treta yuga..as stated by our scriptures...case closed!

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      @@hunza-r-aranyak2650 astronomy evidence is not clinching..becoz astrological patterns keep repeating...forever...as u go in the past

    • @hunza-r-aranyak2650
      @hunza-r-aranyak2650 Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit02 4 tusked elephants are alive in indian subcontinent during Saraswati Sindhu Era of indian civilization ( almost 9-10000 years ago) .. this is proof by Praveen mohan in resurch on ancient temples archeological survey in all over indian subcontinent country's.

  • @animalreaction6100
    @animalreaction6100 Před 2 měsíci +1

    First ❤

  • @lkshpnd69
    @lkshpnd69 Před 2 měsíci

    Watch all of Prachyam's content from oldest one.

  • @nidhisridhar5453
    @nidhisridhar5453 Před 2 měsíci

    Hard facts cannot be made up, with all due respect maam! You, certainly like most of us are a beginner at the Hindu scriptures. Just because it is beyond our comprehension, it does not mean it’s not possible. It’s just that everyone wants a conclusion and nobody wants to do the work it takes to understand :)
    You can’t expect to understand a masters degree lecture without first completing school!
    Edit: it is astronomy that he spoke about, not astrology!

  • @aasshhiisshh19
    @aasshhiisshh19 Před 2 měsíci

    It's not 14000 yrs old...... It's 8,00,000 years old history

  • @AnkitKumar-ve8uh
    @AnkitKumar-ve8uh Před 2 měsíci

    If you remove the magical element out of it its pretty realistic itself. But proof of places, culture, things proves it is true overwhelmingly. Just story telling make it look that way cause it was not written for a long time.

    • @AnkitKumar-ve8uh
      @AnkitKumar-ve8uh Před 2 měsíci

      If someone write a story say, only one person cant know those places, cannot create multi generational proofs. Its not story but history mixed with fantasy to teach children and rememberd in temples through story songs and acts. Not written for long long time

    • @AnkitKumar-ve8uh
      @AnkitKumar-ve8uh Před 2 měsíci

      We can see difference in tech and society with time in mahabharat. And they also know about king ram lived long before them.

  • @towardstruth2125
    @towardstruth2125 Před 2 měsíci

    Nilesh Oak is a fraud. Neither he has a historian degree nor an archaeologist certificate. What an irony! 😂😂

  • @user-cl9bd1tz3b
    @user-cl9bd1tz3b Před 2 měsíci +1

    Zuzana Actually Nilesh Nilkanth Oak is not a Scholar neither a Historian to rely on He is an Extreme Right Person that Ramayana Dating of 14,000 Years old itself is impossible as Agriculture itself started around 12,000 years ago anyone with sane knowledge of History can understand this fact Ramayana might have Happened as a Historical thing but definitely not around 12,000 BCE Rather more closer to 2,000 BCE and there are many scholarly reasons for that like we know for sure that Kings Existed at that period in 2,000 BCE even though there is no Archaeological Discovery which can be attested specifically as This is what Ramayana kingdom's Remains are because offcourse it is 4,000 years old thing.
    Now there is a king list mentioned in Purana's according to that there are 50 generations of kings before Mahabharata happened which would be roughly 850 years of period before Mahabharata if we take 17 years as average succession to pass on to next king and Mahabharata has been dated by scholars like BB Lal from 1,200-900 BCE so even if we take 1,200 BCE it would not go beyond 2,000 BCE. Ramayana text has been composed in 500 BCE and the sage Valmiki who wrote Ramayana mixed Yuga Cycles with Ramayana Yuga Cycles themselves were not created for mentioning Ramayana due to which all errors have crippled out due to this 12,000 BCE thing is happening. YUGA CYCLE IS LIKE THIS : 43,200 Years of Yuga cycle
    As we know Precession of Equinox ends in 2082 AD
    43,200-2082 AD = 41,118 BCE
    Satya Yuga : 41,118 BCE-25,556 BCE(Main phase) Hunter-gatherer lifestyle and ignorance.
    Satya-Treta Transition : 25,556 BCE-23,878 BCE(Discovery of Yoga as a factor of Cognitive Evolution)
    Treta-Yuga : 23,878 BCE-12,174 BCE(Yoga continued generation to generation)
    Treta-dwapara transition : 12,174 BCE-10,878 BCE(Development of Agriculture and Popularization of Yoga and Meditation throughout India by God Shiva and as a contribution due to Settlements and Agriculture)
    Dwapara Yuga : 10,878 BCE-3,102 BCE( Continuation of Agriculture and settlements)
    Dwapara-Treta Transition : 3,102 BCE-2,238 BCE ( Urbanization and Bronze use first writing system and Pashupati seals with Yoga and Meditation found in Indus Valley civilization)
    2,238 BCE-1,650 AD(Continuation of Urbanization)
    1,650 AD-2082 AD(Scientific Revolution)
    This is the basic and Original Yuga cycle and it has nothing to do with Ramayana and Mahabharata it's just that when Indus valley civilization falled down this Yuga cycle got passed down to Eastern India when Harappans migrated to Eastern India and Core India during that same period around 2,000 BCE when Harappan civilization was ending Ramayana also took place but when these people settled with each other after 1,500 years from this in 500 BCE Ramayana was composed by a Sage named Valmiki and until then the concept of Yuga cycles was very misunderstood and a Utopian state was developed which Resulted Exaggeration of Ramayana to 12,174 BCE and that Period but Ramayana has nothing to do with Yuga Cycles and Neither Mahabharata has to do Anything with Yuga cycles the purpose of Yuga Cycles itself is clear and was created by Ancient Indus valley people.
    That's why many people in India say Mahabharata happened around 3,102 BCE even though that's the period when Urbanization started because of Myths regarding Yuga cycles. YUGA CYCLES SHOULDN'T BE USED TO DATE WARS AND EVENTS.
    Ramayana has lot's of Exaggeration in it but that part is understandable because that was the style of Author to convey the deeper messages like Hanuman didn't really took whole Mountain on his hand to save laxman it's just an emphasis given on how much effort has Hanuman put on to find the sanjeevani Herbs similarly If someone is said as Demon or Asura it doesn't really means he is a flying human 😂 it's just a poetic exaggeration on real events, that how powerful and vicious the king was, Ravana had Golden Kingdom of gold that's an exaggeration for wealth but probably at that time Gold might not be found itself but around Valmiki's time Gold was present.
    HANUMAN JI were not any different species of Monkey and Humans which is extinct but Rather it has something to do with Animistic Religions in earlier period many tribes lived in India which were Nature worshippers similarly Hanuman were also part of similar tribe who used to copy the Monkey god's and worshipped then whereas Shri Ram were from Kingship background so it's not an easy to understand thing a little bit understanding of History is also required geography customs traditions and many more things to understand fully the Ramayana

    • @MrDarksly3r
      @MrDarksly3r Před 2 měsíci

      Kaha se aate hain yeh log

    • @user-cl9bd1tz3b
      @user-cl9bd1tz3b Před 2 měsíci

      @@MrDarksly3r kya mene kya galat likha hai bta de bhai

    • @user-cl9bd1tz3b
      @user-cl9bd1tz3b Před 2 měsíci

      @@MrDarksly3r bhai emotions chor kar pura samajha kar padhio phir bolio

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      chor de..tum se naa ..ho paayegaa...

    • @user-cl9bd1tz3b
      @user-cl9bd1tz3b Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit02 abbe ohh bache history ki knowledge nahi hai na to psuedohistory mata phela yaha akar kal se dekh raha Teri bakchodi

  • @mash99700
    @mash99700 Před 2 měsíci

    Ist not 7k agi it is 750k year ago. is was mistake by nasa😅
    In scientific perspective that era was evolutionary era of human form moneys

  • @sss-on1zs
    @sss-on1zs Před měsícem

    World not 2000 years old 😂

  • @claverbabu2213
    @claverbabu2213 Před 2 měsíci

    If u look closely All Religions are always telling u to be a good Human being 😊

  • @stallionspirit
    @stallionspirit Před 2 měsíci

    one simple fact..totally invalidates Nilesh Oak...Ravana palace was written to have been guarded by 4-tusked elephants (Gompothere)...gompotheres became extinct 1-1.6million years ago...case closed!

  • @kamalsurati241
    @kamalsurati241 Před 2 měsíci

    I doubt ild or new testaments proves the dates as Indian texta state. The Indian civilisation was advanced when western civilisation was not even in nesscent stage. Even now the greagorian calender is not perfect as Indian one upto 11th century the west had Roman numerals, that means they could not count really huge numbers. Numerals went from India to Arab countries and then to Europe and west. But Arabs did not learn negative intigwra from Bharat that is india . Som on in 14th century in Europe discovered that. So please imagine what India was and is even now. You still find trouble about anciant dates in gr gorian calander. But or t xyw stated th constellation in th sky and the weather at that time!!! This leaves out any doubt about dating!!!!

  • @jaybhavani8416
    @jaybhavani8416 Před 2 měsíci


    We expect truthful scientific research oriented videos on
    Theoretical and Practical
    Spiritual science and philosophy
    of
    Sanatan Vedic Hindu Dharma
    on the basis
    ( Religious literature -
    like Geeta , .....)
    Sadhan Marg , Sadhan Padhati , experiences , consciousness , physical -mental-spiritual state of sadhak , mukti -moksha
    Guru Parampara
    for
    Self realisation , iternal spiritual awareness , peaceful life and
    Peaceful bright future of human and world .
    Towards the Truth .

    • @jaybhavani8416
      @jaybhavani8416 Před 2 měsíci


      Please discuss with CZcamsrs -
      Sangam Talks
      Citti Media
      Siddh Santo ki khoj
      Amsu tube
      Yogesh voice
      Gita online
      Raman Maharshi
      Aanandmai Maa
      Nisargdutta Maharaj
      Chinmaya Mission
      Yogi Arvind
      Pandit Gopi Krishna
      Gopinath Kaviraj
      Swami Premanand Govinda Sharan das ji Maharaj
      :

  • @Rahulkumar-tk5vv
    @Rahulkumar-tk5vv Před 2 měsíci

    you should watch his presentation type video. there he gives evidence based presentation rather than just talks.

  • @grve_wlkr
    @grve_wlkr Před 2 měsíci +2

    Here is a video for you (its in English), this will help you with understanding what he said here, its a long video though
    Dating of the Ramayana and Mahabharata | Nilesh Oak
    czcams.com/video/RedV48OCEFg/video.htmlsi=sDmG5VSVATIvrT3e

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci

      nilesh is wrong...stop spreading misinformation!

    • @grve_wlkr
      @grve_wlkr Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit1576 He gave an open challenge
      Debate with him, prove him wrong, you will become famous if nothing else

    • @stallionspirit1576
      @stallionspirit1576 Před 2 měsíci

      @@grve_wlkr why reinvent the wheel...when the infomation is clearly in th e scriptures!

    • @grve_wlkr
      @grve_wlkr Před 2 měsíci

      @@stallionspirit1576 that is the separate thing
      Nilesh came up to a conclusion from his own understanding of the scriptures
      The argument he has put forward is based on the 4 types of evidence he was talking about.
      Now when you say that he is spreading misinformation, then the simplest thing you can do is put forth your own argument based on evidence as well as references and prove him wrong
      or find someone who can debate with Nilesh ji on this topic
      It is an open challenge after all

    • @stallionspirit02
      @stallionspirit02 Před 2 měsíci

      @@grve_wlkr one simple fact..totally invalidates Nilesh Oak...Ravana palace was written to have been guarded by 4-tusked elephants (Gompothere)...gompotheres became extinct 1-1.6million years ago...case closed!

  • @ishikabebortha3690
    @ishikabebortha3690 Před 2 měsíci

    Bring Abhijit chavada podcast ❤❤❤

  • @shivamanand7754
    @shivamanand7754 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Start listening Acharya Prasant(english chanel 2M followers & hindi chanel 38.9M followers), you would like his words. He has most profound knowledge about Hinduism maximum scriptures. He speak directly without manipulation. He is also quite famous now. On other hand Sadguru speak very indirectly.

  • @sinsunjai
    @sinsunjai Před 2 měsíci

    Reading translation, many things are lost in translation? I wouldn’t believe any Indian English translation!

  • @vikashkumar-wp2xx
    @vikashkumar-wp2xx Před 2 měsíci

    Subtitle is wrong.