Apple AirTags vs Samsung SmartTag Plus vs Tile: Which bluetooth tracker is better?
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 06. 2021
- Let’s talk about Bluetooth trackers. Apple recently launched the AirTag, Samsung launched the SmartTag and SmartTag Plus, and Tile has been the leading Bluetooth tracker on the market since about 2014 with currently four trackers to choose from. There are quite a few similarities between these trackers and a few differences worth noting. Consider this a review and a bit of a buying guide!
Feature and spec-wise the AirTag, SmartTags, and Tile Pro are very similar aside from the UWB capability which Tile says will be coming sometime this year. But, I feel like it’s kind of unfortunate for Tile that Apple and Samsung came out with the AirTag and SmartTags because their reach is so much greater. Again, Apple has almost a billion devices on their network, Samsung has 70 million with the potential for 700 million to opt-in, and Tile has only 30 million. I honestly think that if Apple and Samsung were to add a Smart Alerts style feature, that could eliminate a huge chunk of Tile’s potential business. Remember, Tile requires others to have purchased tile devices to find things, The SmartTag and SmartTag+ work through smartphones and tablets, and the AirTag works through the multitude of products Apple sells. So, probably the only reason to go with Tile would be for the additional subscription-based services.
Let me know what you think with a comment down below. Do you have any of these trackers, do you want one?
Stay safe, everyone!
GEAR THAT I USE:
**CAMERA & LENS**
Sony a6400 with 18-135mm kit lens: amzn.to/2CPPtVB
Sony E 16-55mm F2.8 G | SEL1655G: amzn.to/3nEH36t
**TRIPOD SETUP**
Neewer 2-in-1: amzn.to/2CPQcGj
Fluid Video Head for Tripod (I use the 502AH)
Manfrotto 500AH: amzn.to/33438Tw
Tripod Wheels: amzn.to/3gV1evJ
Light Stands:
AmazonBasics Light Stands (2-Pack): amzn.to/2WYy43L
Impact Heavy Duty Light Stand: amzn.to/338tHpG
External Monitor & Accessories
FeelWorld FW279: amzn.to/3g0FFaR
SMALLRIG Camera Cage: amzn.to/3fE9L4U
**LIGHTING**
LED Key Light & Soft Box:
Godox SL-60W: amzn.to/3f6qASy
Godox VL-200: amzn.to/34ABbT9
Neewer Hexadecagon Softbox: amzn.to/2X0aS5o
Angler Quick-Open Deep Parabolic Softbox (36"): amzn.to/3phNWeL
LED Fill Light & Hair Light:
Neewer 530 RGB LED Panel: amzn.to/306PBsR
LED Practical Lights:
LIFX Smart Bulb: amzn.to/302Scnj
Feit Edison Bulbs: amzn.to/2X2cvzA
LED Light Strips:
Merkury Innovations LED Light Strips: amzn.to/30O5hAi
Govee Glow Table Lamp: amzn.to/3teS1ka
External Hard Drive For Completed Project Storage
WD MyPassport For Mac 2TB: amzn.to/3f9LjVS
WD MyPassport For Windows 2TB: amzn.to/32XnG0f
Backlit Mechanical Keyboard
Keychron K4 w/ Gateron Blue Switches: amzn.to/3jSwhay
JOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA!
/ techwithlando
/ techwithlando
For business inquires email: techwithlando@gmail.com - Věda a technologie
Yours is the third video I watched trying to learn the differences among these devices and how they work. You, by a huge margin, were the best explainer. You made the differences very clear and at a pace that I could digest them. A+ video!
Extremely glad to hear that I helped you out! Thanks for watching!
I agree on this. The best video on any smart tags
I was thinking the same I watched one before this one and it's just night and day. We appreciate you man had to follow 🙏🏽 💯
I got the Samsung Smart Tags and placed one inside my wife's car to test it. We live in a big North American city. She went out and I didn't know where. Once I engaged the tracking I started to get an unreal amount of hits "by other Galaxy devices". She drove 20 miles from our house. I got 11 "hits", one hit every 2 miles, then I got 4 more "hits" once she parked at a mall. The map even showed me the name of the mall. What is interesting is that the Smart Tag got picked up by other Samsung smartphones as she was driving 65 MPH on the highway. So those smartphones must have been from cars that she passed along the way or cars coming the opposite way. That's mind-boggling. One nice feature about the Smart Tag is that when the target has stopped moving, the app tells you from what time to what time the target was parked or stopped.
Sounds like a great tool for a stalker.
I love your provide information. Appreciate much!
@@JC-mi8xb If you need any more info about the Samsung Smartag ask me here.
More Features: The App also has a "historygram", that shows you where the vehicle has been in the last 24 hrs. I placed one Smartag in my company's truck fleet on February 2022, in the undercarriage, not shielded from the elements, in below zero temps and it's still working now in September 2022. So the battery on this thing lasts at least 7 months, more if you place the Smartag inside the car where it's warm.
@@APlus-qx7no It isn't since the device con be reconfigured from the built in button.. also your Samsung Galaxy tells you if a tag has been following you.
Excellent comparison, clearly spoken, well thought out, spot on!
Fabulous presentation. Honest and clearly defined features of each device explained. Thank you!!!!
Great video, quick...precise...and to the point!
Thank you
Thank you, Landon! FIRST TIME watcher to your channel. Great video- well shot, concise information and no 'fluff'. You have my subscription sir!
You’re quite welcome, Paul! Thanks for the sub! 🙌🏿
Very professional. My first time watching one of your videos and i instantly liked and subscribed. You made all the information between each device so simple and wasg to understand. Thank you very much.
Really great and through video. Awesome job, Man.
Dope video man. I just bought a sprinter camper van, I work over seas and overall just trynna find a place to keep this baby while I'm gone. The smart tags are definitely a cool and great option for ease of mind to know my home is safe while I'm away. I havent bought one yet but I know when I do and if I see that thing move I got a problem 😂 thanks again brother man for the video. Super helpful.
Great review my man. All items covered with competency.
Well done! Step by step comparison with details, offering Objective conclusions, not just personal 'feelings'. The 'Air Tag' sounds great; however; where I live, the Cell Service STINKS!!! Sometimes a signal, other times nothing. Therefore, I am not able to depend on other phones reporting the location of the individual tracker. I needed to use the Bluetooth capabilities to locate locally. I did find a CZcams video: 'AirTag Distance Test - vs. Tile Pro & Chipolo One' that actually measured the Open Field operating distances of each Bluetooth tag (he did not discuss the detailed attributes of each as you have done).
A really nice clear, concise, informative comparison review, no annoying bits which is rare, well done sir
Thank you, Nick! Glad you enjoyed it 🙌🏿
Dude........your presentation, editing and overall expertise are much appreciated Thanks for helping this old dog learn new tricks
I'm so late but literally the perfect video from 2 years ago helping me decide which of these is actually worth it today. Glad I ran into this video. Thanks for the help. Everything became so clear
Nicely shot and edited, and very well researched. Thank you! 👍
Glad you enjoyed it! 🙌🏿
Your comparison was easy to understand. Thanks.
Great summary. Thank you!
Great review, thanks so much for this video 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 helped me no end!!!
Awesome comparison tutorial, full of good info
Great info!! Just got my first airtag but looking into getting smartag.
Good video, very knowledgeable and easy to understand.
Great review, man!
Excellent review!
Excellent illustration, I enjoyed you video so much bro, very smart.
Glad you enjoyed it, Anthony! 🙌🏿
Man your videos are great quality. Hope you get more subs soon.
Thanks, Franck! 🙌🏿 in due time 🙏🏿
Thanks man! I thought Smart tag would be my choice and now you have helped me to pull the trigger on it!
Excellent presentation, concise and informative, well done!
Thank you, Michelle! 🙌🏿
Good comparison. Thank you.
A very nice video explaining in good detail! Made me buy the Smart Tag ❤️
Glad it was helpful! 🙌🏿
Thank you...First time I'm delving into this
You're welcome! 👍🏿
Thanks for the thorough explanation!
You’re welcome, Lily! 😊
You are a Great presenter. I enjoyed learning from your presentation. Thank you 🙏
Thank you! 🙌🏿
Great video! You should have more likes with all these views.
This was an excellent, well-written, and well-presented video...
a really good review!
Love the vid! could you may do a test on how far you go away from it and find it with the samsung one especially? Maybe post it somewhere or leave it on friends car and see if you can track it with his permission?
first time watching your content, dope content
Thank you, man! 🙌🏿
Thanks for the video. This really helped me choose the right device for me
Glad I could help!
I purchased the tile pro to track my travel trailer if it would get stolen. I don’t have a Samsung device or Apple phone so the Tile was the only option. As an experiment I put it in my wife’s car as she went off to do some errands. I was pleasantly surprised when it located the tile and her car miles away. The app. will tell you how many members are in your area, and there were 2300 in the area at the time. It’s an inexpensive way to keep tabs on my trailer.
Thank you very much this video was very helpful
You’re welcome!
4:55 I love how happy the Tile sounds when you ping it
That was very helpful. Thank you
You’re welcome, Kristie!
Amazing video dude!!!! Keep it up!! Thanks for all the info, was about to buy the Samsung Tags and found out it doesn't really work with my S9+
Thanks, bro! 🙌🏿 glad I could help!
It works with all samsung devices. But the precision tracking feature only works with s20 series and above.
Excellent channel!
very nice review
Thank you. Good job.
Good info. I have an AirTag, which has helped me many times. But a relative will be visiting with an Android. I was looking for exactly the info you provided. Thanks.
Very informative, thank you! So if I was looking for a tracker SOLELY for lost luggage…. Which one would you recommend? I have a Galaxy phone, but always travel with my iPad too. If my luggage was lost, I could hook my iPad to the airport’s wireless network. So either would work for me, right? Which would you buy if you just cared about the lost luggage help?
Well done and thank you.
Thanks for the comparison and yes please, I want one.
Thanks. Great explanation.
You're welcome, Kenny!
You have a great future ahead with this !
Much appreciated, bro! 🙌🏿
Decent review - thanks, can't quite decide if I need one of these tags. But clear the Samsung offering is most complete.
Remember, if you have an iPhone you would purchase AirTag or Tile. If you have a Samsung phone purchase SmartTag or Tile.
nice, thanks man !. useful content
You're welcome, man!
Great video! thanks you
Glad you enjoyed! 🙌🏿
I have the tiles used them in my luggage. Found one of my bags in Ireland 🇮🇪. Also tile and skull candy are compatible so skull candy users also help find tiles. I'm leaning towards Samsung.
Good info and we'll explained
Being as I have a Samsung phone and tablet, the Smarttag is a no Brainer for me. Great video!
Awesome video, simple to the point treat info and great smart a... Comments ;-) in a good way😂
I've had a Samsung smart tag in my home office, still in it's box, I just haven't used it but after watching this I think I might just chuck it on my keys as I often lose them.
Solid video, very informative.
You should! It's helpful. Glad you enjoyed the video! 🙌🏿
Don't forget to subscribe! 👍🏿
@@TodaysTech I've smashed the subscribe button 👊
I'm really on the hype train for NFC, I have an implant and a few tags laying about, be awesome to see a video about that if you have any ideas.
Much appreciated! What do you mean you have an implant? Lol a literal implant?!
@@TodaysTech yeah, a literal NFC implant in my hand, had it for a few years now. I also have a contactless payment chip in my arm but it needs replacing, thanks Brexit.
no. Keep it in the box. It'll last longer that way!
I could listen to Landon all day. Another great review!
Much appreciated, bro! 🙌🏿
GOOD REVIEW
Loved your video. New sub here.
Thanks, David! 🙌🏿
@@TodaysTech your very welcome
Nice job man.
Thank you, Cristian! 🙌🏿
thanks for your explain, but why should i open the internet when i deal with smart tag even if the tag in Bluetooth range ?
is there any way to get notified when tag is out of Bluetooth range ?
Thanks 👍
Great view, thanks! The only remaining question I have is what's the batterly life expectancy with eacg if these?
about 1 year with the airtag
Thanks for great review. I have 3 samsung devices and I have to say - it is low cost to protect some of your valuable items. Just in case, above house insurance.
First of all.Great job! Do you have a teleprompter device? How do you remember so much material in one unedited take? I worked in broadcasting for over 40 years and I amazed at the delivery!
Well your review is wonderful but now I have a lot to take into consideration. One thing important to us is a tracker for out pet. Obviously needs a high level waterproofing rating and shock proofing. Not sure any of these are a good choice unless you have a suggestion. Thanks again for your expertise and knowledge.
Thank you, Paul! 🙌🏿 I memorize the a-roll portion and cover portions where I’m reading with b-roll! I’m glad that it comes across in a cohesive manner!
You're so underrated !
Appreciate the compliment, bro! 🙌🏿
Man I wish I could get my employees to brief me on items like this when I ask for "the skinny" - articulate, clear and evenly paced. Compared and Contrasted effectively - we should get him a job at one of these left or right NEWS OUTLETS. He did a great job not indicating prejudice ( except by the showing of his particular tracker) Most excellent and thank you, thank you, thank you
Yep, plus some strategic assessment and forecast at the end, really well done
Thank you!
You’re welcome!
I was hoping you would do some real time testing to see which tags pins first. Great video though.
Will any of these work with a Black view 9900 Pro? BV9900 Pro W/ Android 10
This video should have more likes!!!!
The smart tag that shows your camera is that smart tag or smart plus and is it compatible with note 20 ultra
Can’t you do a field test for all three trackers to check how efficient each one for tracking down a stolen item?
It's very situational you'll have a very high chance of finding your device if it's an Apple (airtag or chipolo Spot) or Samsung (smarttag, I would avoid using the smarttag+ the battery doesn't last very long and it randomly reboot playing the battery inserted sound)
With other tags companies they use) don't use Samsung or Apple network so you have a very close it of recovering your object (well basically tell you where you last left it/went out of range)
Recommend using Panasonic cr2032 batteries
the factory Panasonic supplied battery with the airtag lasted a year and 6 months before low battery warning and finally stopped responding after another 3 months (apple uses a pull tab to connect the battery so battery is full out of the box), do not use Duracell cr2032 in an airtag as the bitter taste on the battery and design flaw of the airtag prevents connection
the Samsung one lasted about a year and 3 months but they had my own installed duracell battery's used as, testing with Panasonic now (the factory ones lasted less then 6-9 months because smarttag does not use a pull tab so battery has been used and brand of battery never heard of before)
I agree, I had two bikes in storage, both with Tiles attached and after I visited storage and had my phone on me the app reported the last contact was over a month ago .. Hmmm. I am now using Air Tags and though they need a short time to update I am pleased with the response.
@@leexgx utilize, no, use yes. Using utilize comes across as pompous and self-ingratiating. Also, utilize does not mean what folks think it does.
Is one of this good to put in like my kids' backpack and that way can track them? Or this is a poor idea for that? Please be kind in your answers I just need a good person tracker one of my kids is on need of that, just trying to find the right thing
professional. Thanks.
You’re welcome, Jack!
Great video did Tile ever come out with wide band?
Yes, it’s called the Tile Ultra!
@@TodaysTech thanks for the info and reply . Good work
I had two bikes in storage, both with Tiles attached and after I visited storage and had my phone on me the app reported the last contact was over a month ago .. Hmmm. I am now using Air Tags and though they need a short time to update I am pleased with the response.
Tile will report when the battery is low, I assume the others do as well.
Does smart tag work with Google phones ? My husband has a tile that sometimes it will not work. Or the app freezes constantly.
Can you do a field test? That's the main difference I'd like to know...
Samsung tag does have smart alerts that notify you if you leave your tag behind
Good shit my boy
You deserve more subz
Thank you, Imran! 🙌🏿
I'm planning to buy Samsung tag
Nice! So far, so good in my experience! 👌🏿
Don't . They suck. I have 4 .. waste of $$$
@@gosttunter can you elaborate?
I love mine. Works great
You will love it
Great video but lets say I place the samsung smart tag in my luggage for travel, say it gets lost in another country will I be able to track it (just roughly where it is) ?
As long as their are Samsung devices around; yes!
great review I just picked up the air tag.
A must-have, for sure!
Can you use the apple airtag without having any apple devise andmake it work only with an icould account?
That's the feature I miss about my headband earbuds.
Even if they were just hanging around my neck, if I walked away from my phone, I'd hear "out of range...."
Smart tag has the left behind feature also now.
Tile needs people to have downloaded their app only. You do not need to buy a unit or have a subscription. Also they work on other devices like HP laptops. Location other phones (apple or android) for anyone in your family with the app is helpful as well
Would Tile be OK for your luggage
I also have around 1000 tiles in my area... however looking closer it actually meant within a 50km area...I can understand the tests where the tile practically didn't work.
Wow ! This is a very mkbhd like video
Thanks, Wayne!
About the Samsung SmartTag, How long does the battery last? Can we change the battery ourself or only Samsung can change the battery?
does a fold /
flip 3 or s22 s22+ s22ultra work with the smart tag +
Yes!
I have a Samsung Galaxy S10 and will likely get the Smart Tag. Last month I went on a cruise with friends. The cruise line had arranged to get our luggage tags and check our bags directly to the airport. When we got back home to Chicago one of my friends was missing a suitcase. Her Air Tag app wasn't working initially and the airlines spent 3 days looking for her suitcase. Once her app started working she was able to find it still sitting on the cruise ship dock in Seattle with all the identifying and luggage tags torn off and the cruise line shipped it to her via Fedex. Without the Airtag she likely wouldn't ever have found it.
0:38 are you saying that SmartTag can work for Samsung devices only?? I cannot track to my other android phone??