Best & Worst Returning ROGUE ONE Characters
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 12. 2016
- SUBSCRIBE HERE ►► bit.ly/1IQB3kh
Rogue One A Star Wars Story saw the return of a stack of fan favourite characters, Darth Vader, Grand Moff Tarkin, Princess Leia, Red and Gold Leader in scenes that reflect the original trilogy. But are all of these necessary? Some, definitely, others, weird as hell.
Rogue One Easter Eggs ► goo.gl/OmlBhn
Defeating Darth Vader ► goo.gl/JeOGFQ
Edited By Ben ► / oceansparks
Twitter ► / mrsundaymovies
Facebook ► / mrsundaymovies
Patreon ► / mrsundaymovies
T-Shirts/Merch ► www.teepublic.com/stores/mr-s...
The Weekly Planet iTunes ► itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/t...
The Weekly Planet CZcams ► goo.gl/1ZQFGH
The Weekly Planet Direct Download ► weeklyplanetpod.libsyn.com - Zábava
He wasn't on the beach because he hates sand it's coarse and it gets everywhere
Mitch Cooper you are the best :')
Mitch Cooper HAHAHA TRUE
Mitch Cooper best comment of 2016
Mitch Cooper 😂
And yet he doesn't seem to mind lava
Vader does make quips in the original trilogy too. "Apology accepted, Captain Needa." Is just an example. Throughout the movies he's always had a pretty dark and sarcastic sense of humor.
I do agree he's somewhat sarcastic and makes jokes, but I don't think he had ever said a pun, and that's why people are mad or something, I honestly thought it was okay.
I don't think he has made any puns (at least not in mainstream canon anymore) but I think it was well within his range.
"We would be honored if you could join us," Vader says to Han, Leia and the others while standing at a dinner table.
I imagine he's got the sense of humor of a more caustic 'Dr. House'.
They can recast Mon Mothma because she legit looks like a younger Mon Mothma. We don't see her again until Return on the Jedi which is years later. We see Tarkin like hours later after Rogue One, it'd have been waaay too jarring to use different actors.
isnt she like the daughter of the original?
fowlerpower1 No, she just has a striking resemblance to the original actor.
They recast all the time. I think they should have used the acting actors face.
This was the same actress from the prequels, i think her scenes got deleted and they brought her back for Rogue One
Paully808 Yes, that's completely correct.
I don't understand the Tarkin backlash, I was taken aback by how great they made him look
Tarkin* aback, surely
IMO it's all about the mouth when it comes to Tarkin and Leia in Rogue One, Superman (and the infamous mustache) in BvS, and more recently the younger Will Smith in Gemini Man, or a few moments during The Irishman when they de-aged Deniro, Pesci, and Pacino. I can handle it mostly, but when these CGI created models are speaking it doesn't look quite right. The Gemini Man young clone looks fine until it speaks, at which point it ruins the immersion because the mouth looks so unrealistic during speech.
It's VERY possible to do well, Marvel has shown us that, so it must come down to budget issues or the actual studio and/or artist doing the work.
I thought Tarkin looked great
Me too!
Same
I thought he looked great too.
Louie Barnett yeah me too
Me too I knew it looked fake ofc but i was still impressed that they managed to pull it off
I think the CGI Tarkin and Leia were both good and I got used to seeing him throughout the film.
Batman Jr. yeah
Batman Jr. didn't know Tarkin was cgi but leia looked fake
Batman Jr. yes
hayescamp see I thought it was the other way around. I thought tarkins CG started out awful but by the "you may fire when ready" he looked really good, leia looked fantastic to me (was a bit plasticy but whatever I expected worse).
I've just seen it. When he is beside Krennic, you can tell the difference
It might not have been a 100% perfect but the Governor Tarkin lookalike is the best lookalike I have seen so far. It is miles better than the lookalikes in Terminator Salvation and Genesys
Yeah, give it another few years and what they'll be able to do with CGI will be amazing.
The Rimas they needed Charles dance with some sharper cheek bones
I thought Tarkin was pretty good. Clearly fake (though my kids didn't notice at all), but I didn't hate it. Leia, on the other hand, made me cringe.
Dan Gilchrist At least she was only on screen for a couple dozen seconds.
True. Thank goodness! :)
Vader has said similar stuff to the "Don't choke on your aspirations" line in the OT. Like in TESB he said "Apology accepted" to Captain Needa after choking him to death. Plus in ROTJ he had that line "The Emperor is not as forgiving as I am". Both are clearly examples of Vader's dark humour.
Dont understand whats the problem with Tarkin was, i thought he looked perfect and loved all his scenes.
same
Mugen Ittoryu perfect? do you have eyes?!
It's hard to explain, but the way he moves is off, and his skin looks closer to something you'd see in a video game like The Last of Us trying to look photorealistic rather than real life. To me he really stood out when standing next to the other real actors.
Radioactive712 I didn't notice at all didn't even realize it wasn't a real person
In a New Hope Wedge says "look at the size of that thing" when he sees the death star for the FIRST time. if he was at the battle of scariff then he would've seen the death star. and Biggs is still on Tatooine at the time according to a deleted scene from a new hope
Good point
Yeah
Yeah, but in 6 Leia says she knew her real mother for some of her childhood (retconned in 3) and in 3 Anakin and Obi Wan meet Dooku for the 2nd time and Grievous for the 1st time. But that was also retconned in the CW TV series.
Basically they've ignored past movies before, why wouldn't they now?
Boinks Deleted scenes are not part of the story, you treat them as if they never happened like if they aren't canon.
Stick AKA Matthew bail had a wife she died shortly after revenge of the sith
You know why darth Vader didn't show up on the beach? Because "I don't like sand. It's course and rough, and it gets everywhere."
Cthulu Nebuchadnezzar omg that's amazing 😂😂😂
I love you
Cthulu Nebuchadnezzar haha, very good point 😂
Cthulu Nebuchadnezzar nice, very nice. Lmao.
I would totally dig a Darth Vader movie between revenge of the sith and rouge one, which features the destruction of the Kamino Cloning facility from the comics, and has a plot focusing upon how the emperor convinces Darth Vader to keep fighting for him, after Padme is already dead. Also a proper introduction for Tarkin, since he is treated like we should know him from the prequels in both new hope and rouge one.
Thinking of bring this back in addition to a Sunday video, clips from the podcast with pictures and all! Is that something you're interested in? Also this was edited by Ben, find him here, say hi: czcams.com/users/oceansparks.
Edit: I've changed the thumbnail, sorry for any spoilers.
GIMME LIKES TY
Don't like it at all
Mr Sunday Movies where did Rogue One actually end? In episode 4, the rebels claim to be on a diplomatic mission, but Vader clearly saw the ship escape at the end of Rogue. Is that a minor plot hole?
Mr Sunday Movies yes
Mr Sunday Movies I love you going back to this style. Some of the first videos of yours I ever watched were like this and I still love it
"Apology accepted" "I find your lack of faith disturbing" and "impressive most impressive" are somewhat dad jokes
"Apology accepted" definitely is, especially after you force choke a guy to death.
Yeah, 'Apology accepted' is definitely on par with that scene but I still found it somewhat lacking. Other than 'Where's Padme? Noooooo!' this is the least menacing Vader has been while speaking. Mendo's little smile after was great though.
yep...
Oh yeah. And I think the quote is "Be careful not to choke on your aspirations" (not ambitions) which is... ya know, funny because aspirate means an exhalation of breath and he was being choked.
Yeah but this movie more than made up for it afterwards with Vader's menacing...ness?
In The Empire Strikes Back, when Han, Leia, and Co open that door in Cloud City and Vader is at the table, I'm pretty sure he says like "I'm happy you could join us for dinner" or something.
John Smith Yep. In Empire Strikes Back he drips dry sarcasm and irony. The aspirations line fit perfectly with that.
John Smith also apology accepted
...Captain Needa
+Relugus I remember on twitter I saw someone who disliked the movie say "you see that Darth Vader pun was what all of Rogue One was like to me" and honestly that makes perfect sense, because that person (like so many) has idolized the original movies some much they have lost complete sight of what they even were like. So many of the criticisms of FA and Rogue One could be easily applied to the original trilogy, but people have this insane idea of what those movies were, to the point that a very similar product is to them a complete bastardization of their beloved franchise.
"We would be honoured if you would join us"
We're living in an age where we get so much shit given to us, I think it's spoiled us. We complain about everything. If this technology had been used a few years ago people would have been over the fucking moon, now we get so much CGI and amazing special effects that we over analyze and complain about every little thing. It's crazy.
ErikVaughnDillinger Right? I honestly didn't think the Tarkin and Leia looked bad at all. I knew they were CGI but my friend who I saw the movie with didn't even notice.
Exactly, you have to be nitpicking to find flaws. I think for most of that know that Peter is dead and that Carrie is no longer that young we KNOW that those characters are CGI so it makes us look at them very differently than someone who might not know otherwise. I agree with you, the CGI was more than passable. I didn't mind at all.
ErikVaughnDillinger PREACH
The CG was for the most part good. It was especially stunning, when they used shadows heavily (shots of the Death Star being complete, Tarkin having half of his face in a shadow) and sometimes ... odd, like the rest shots of Tarkin, Leia and even U-wing taking off to Jedha (which's bugged me right since the first trailer). With last being quite weird. It's freaking ILM, if they take on a project it should be an eye-candy.
However, I completely disagree about nitpicking the CG. If there is no demand of getting better quality we'll never progress enough to create, for e.g. a compelling virtual reality. You can say so regarding the storytelling, actors' performance but not the technology. It's meant to evolve and develop further.
These two nuts are too young to appreciate the technology of the times. You could go into every bad detail but they complain too damm much. then they say it was bad!
Is it just me or did they use Tarkin's original "You may fire when ready"?
THey did
Jordan Swift they did
Yessss I'm so aurally attentive
No they did not. The inflection is wrong, along with the overall voice. They used American voice actor Stephen Stanton who voiced Tarkin in both Clone Wars series, Rebels, and in numerous video games to voice all of Tarkin's dialogue.
ColdWarShot actually that line was from the original, so yes, yes they did
Hologram Tarkin would not have had the presence they were going for. Yea, it looked Polar Express-y, and probably looked the best in 2D, in my opinion, it was still pretty good; and forever always giving props to Steven Stanton for voicing the character perfectly.
Yea even if we critisize the cgi, I really dont think the fans would of been satisfied if he was just a hologram or in the shadows.
Pretty sure Guy Henry voiced Tarkin in the film.
Really? I know Guy Henry was the body double, but the voice sounded too close to Stanton, since he voices Tarkin in Clone Wars and Rebels.
Well if it wasn't Stanton, then props to Henry for capturing the voice as well as being a stand in for the CGI face.
For the returning characters in CGI, only the fans noticed it. I watched it with a couple of people who aren't Star Wars fans, they couldn't even tell Tarkin or Leia was CGI.
It was James Earl Jones!!!!! You CANNOT complain about his voice!!!!!!
Gregory Bancroft I just found it a little off putting that you could tell James Earl Jones was older than he was in A New Hope (and I know that couldn't be helped because of the flow of time)
Rhys Causon Completely agree... James Earl Jones is all about his booming powerful voice. In Rogue One there was more than a hint of old age in the voice. For me they should have dropped the first Vader monologue with Director Krennic , as Vader was never really big on conversation. It sounded off, he didn't look quite right in stature/his mask. His corridor slaughter scene was amazing!! So for me less is more with Vader.
Gregory Bancroft actually you can. In the OT he has a much more robotic sounding voice which was either edited or due to his age. In the movie and rebels, he sounds like an actual guy talking
"I find you lack of faith disturbing", "Apology accepted captain Needa", "You have failed me for the last time", "I am altering the deal, pray I don't alter it any further", "I hope so, Commander, for your sake. The Emperor is not as forgiving as I am", are just a few of his quips...not talkative, yeah right...
zeiitgeist
the best retuning character behind Darth Vader was definitely those 2 guys from the Cantina scene
TheApexPlayer i freaked out when i saw them more than when Tarkin showed up
1993DJC Probably
I thought it was stupid. It just makes the galaxy "smaller". Completely unnecessary in every way.
+Dave Johnston I agree Dave. It's nerd pandering
Dave Johnston it was just for a laught as for the hardcore (like myself) fans/nerds
But where was... PORKINS?!
The Rebel base cafeteria?
Porkin' Tarkin's wife
I think buying into the CG is really subjective and depends on the individual
sanderflop exactly! So far I've seen 50/50 on people's opinions of the CGI. Half like Tarkin and hate Leia, and the others are the opposite. Showcased exactly by both James and Mason
I hated Leia personally. She just looks too smooth, and the eyes looked creepy. Loved Tarkin. I was expecting "rubber-faced Jeff Bridges" level of bad, and was pleasantly surprised. I actually leaned over too my Dad, who I was watching it with, and I said to him, "wow that's actually pretty good".
sanderflop I didn't even notice Tarkin was CGI. Leia was a surprise, but I liked the fact that they included her.
"We would be honored if you would join us" whilst stood at a fully laid out dining table...Vader was a smart ass well before his choke quip in Rogue One!
You👏🏽both👏🏽need👏🏽to👏🏽get👏🏽your👏🏽eyes👏🏽checked👏🏽
There's a lot of people who aren't huge SW fans who didn't even know Tarkin was CGI. That pretty much solidifies the visual effects were believable for the most part; which is the goal digitally. Imagine if a real person portrayed Tarkin and sucked? In the end what Rogue One gave us was the Tarkin I remember as a kid watching SW, and not someone doing cosplay Tarkin.
There's a lot of people who aren't huge SW fans who eat Tide Pods.
I think y'all are being a little too hard on them for their CGI. I thought they did a good job with them. Tarkin has a difficult face to model.
BTW, they guy that got Vader is not just some guy.
Wtf? I can't believe people thought they looked bad.
I thought Tarkin looked great.
I didn't even know they used cgi. I thought they got a look-a-like actor.
Leia was more noticable but still great.
DAYoungWolf yeah i was surprised by the negative reaction, it was genuinely fantasic
No one looks like Peter Cushing... but I know what you mean, I liked it, thought the mouth was maybe a little off, but other than that, it was quite impressive
moongirl786 I honestly didn't know Tarkin was CGI. When I saw the movie I was like
"Damn they did an amazing job getting a look a like" xD
Leia was also good for a cameo.
It ain't not planet of the apes. But it ain't as bad as people make it out to be.
DAYoungWolf I think it also depends how you saw the movie, imax 3D was obviously cgi
cjua2803
I don't watch the movies in imax or 3D, so Maybe thats the reason.
I recall Darth making a few in the original Trilogy in regards to jokes.
Like, "Apology accepted..." After he choked a dude out.
LightAndDarkMdness02 "I find your lack of faith disturbing"
isnt i find your lack of faith disturbing like the same kind of joke?
That and "Apology Accepted" after force choking a dude.
mrhypnagogia wasnt the i am your father line a joke as well
mrhypnagogia "He is as clumsy as he is stupid"
mrhypnagogia "Apology accepted, Captain Needa" is even more sarcastic/quippy than "choke on your aspirations".
No. Vader's sense of humour is extremely dry and threatening, but certainly isn't puns. "Don't choke on your aspirations" is like ending the duel on Bespin with "It looks like you could use a hand. Join me.."
I loved Rogue One. The reveal of Tarkin was awesome and the ending was awesome as well.
5:18 *"Apology accepted"* from Empire ;)
The Bat of Gotham RIGHT? THANK YOU.
it isn't a bad pun, but it is a quip.
the Empire "joke" was totally fine to me... the Rogue One was... meh :|
plus Vader is a very sarcastic person in the OG trilogy... ;)
The Bat of Gotham "joke" ?
why quotations?
yeah, it was a bad pun in rogue one, but there's precedent in the original trilogy for Vader to quip.
Though I'm kinda freaked out by the look of Tarkin I'm excited to see how this technology improves in the future.
Tarkin looked good, but Leia's CGI, I guess you could say it was a bit off.
same I thought it was the opposite of what they said. Lea looked very plastic like but with Tarkin, they took a long time and i think it payed off quite well.
Lego Ghost Rider Tarkin they had to show, there was no way round it, but Leia they could have used a silhouette shot.
Don't agree with the tarkin one. was really impressed. leia looked bad.
Yeah leia was ok, but she was only in it for like 10 seconds
Peter James Ledwith I know Tarkin looked good to me didn't notice too much things off about him, Leia didn't bother me either because I mean she was only in it for like 10 seconds and if you're going to bitch about 10 seconds than you're. You're a picky one.
EDIT: I re-rad my comment and it might sound like I was directing it towards you but no I mean like fans who are bitching about Leia, that's what I meant.
Prototype lol...I am a picky one. I thought tarkin was amazing. I guess they didn't want to spend too much time and money on 10 seconds. She fitted the scene ok. I thought it was a great film...better than episode 7. Thanks for the clarification though.
I have a reason to why Darth Vader is slower in Episode 4.
Its because he hasn't been in the bacter tank for maybe a day or two because he was chasing Leia and the death star plans???
Good theory.
EspioTheTriforce or they couldnt make him move faster in the past
Milbox R Well yeah but im try to find an In-Cannon explaination
I like to go with the theory that against obi-wan he was being more defensive and cautious because going all-offense in the last fight cost him and he didn't know what obi-wan was still capable of, and both times against Luke he held back because he didn't have any intention of killing him.
I got used to Tarkin's look, kinda like an accent!
Not Jack Douglass CGI forehead reduction anyone?
Blake Bonecutter GODDAMIT!
You may fire when you're ready such a badass line
You may fire when ready*
I thought Leia and Tarkin looked great and was a nice touch. What makes rogue one so good is that it is a return to the original trilogy. It's done so well. Darth Vader was the best part of it.
the way vader walks out from the steam is just too Sick..
To be honest, I thougt too that CGI Leia looked a bit weird. But I think that Tarkin looked stunningly great, after you get used to it in the first two minutes, and also how he looks is extremely unimportant, because his character is fantastic and a great addition! You can sit there and write a five page essay about how unreal he looked and how incorrect his lips were and that he was not so skinny like in ANH OR you can accept that he doesn't look like the Andy Serkis-ape from Planet of the Apes and enjoy the movie, that makes perfect use of him as a character.
Why? Why not Vader instead of him? He is clearly cheaper than Tarkin's CGI. Yes of course it's cheaper and easier. But it wouldn't make any sense at all, would it? Why? Because Vader is not somebody that's very much in that business thing like Tarkin is, he is not a director or a general or an admiral, he is "Lord" Vader and not "Grand Moff" Vader, Tarkin on the other hand is a grand moff, who's completely in all that business stuff. Also we couldn't have got this rivalry between a boss and someone in a lower rank, and we couldn't have seen how fucking evil Tarkin actually is, I mean yes he blew up Alderaan and everything, but he ordered to destroy a whole city (or planet?) just to test Krennic's weapon and just for why not and to fire at Scarif mainly because Krennic was there and just for why not! And the iconic "You may fire when ready" was fantastic.
Then the Leia cameo came and I can't imagine why and how the hell these 10 seconds could make so much trouble, it was 10 seconds and she said one word!!! How can so many people already say something like "they ruined her" and "she was so unnecessary", of course she was kind of unnecessary, but why the hell not! They also could have completely leave out Krennic, Jyn and Cassian and all the other people, because they pretty much are sort of unnecessary too, but they didn't because why not! It's not something to argue about, it was there just to be there and didn't do anything big, what's wrong with that!
The Red five cameo was very cool, to let him die so the spot is free, as this film plays one day before ANH. But I didn't get the Gold and Red leader thing, who are they and why is everybody so excited about them? But anyway, Tarkin was amazing, and it doesn't freaking matter how he looks, it's how they treat him (if he had a lapdance with Krennic and Vader then you could say that, but gladly fortunately he didn't).
"Congratulations you're being rescued"
Videos like this is how i became aware of the podcast!! keep up the good work Mr. Sunday, you and Mason are the best podcasters i listen to!!
Wonderful video. Even though I'd heard it before in the podcast, I did like the pictures/video. Good stuff!
I didn't actually mind CGI Tarkin. Yes, his CGI-ness was pretty obvious, but I was more excited in seeing him.And yes, 2nd Vader scene was epic. Certainly topped the TRex scene from Jurassic World.
agree with the hologram idea. if it were just a minute, wouldnt make it ok, because leia was less than a minute and looked fake as hell
***** i enjoyed the movie very much. Just commenting on topic at hand. Just because they looked fake doesnt nean i did not enjoy the movie.
It just pulls you out of the movie for a second every time you see him.
It just made me sad that Carrie Fisher is no longer as hot as her younger self
How did Jimmy (Organa) not age since Revenge of the Sith but Obi Wan aged a billion years?
TriangleHat The moons on Tatooine made him age a lot quicker
TriangleHat To be fair, it's still been 11 years since they filmed ROTS, Smits just aged well
TriangleHat living somewhere hot makes your physical appearance age quicker
you're right, i have been living in Vietnam for 10 years and i have aged terribly. It's as if i moved from Hoth to Jakku.
melanin
Excellent video lads. Keep up the great work.
his cgi looked too real in 3D, I kept staring at him like damn he looks too good lol
I know it's weird, but I personally liked CGI Tarkin.
5:17 "Apology excepted, Captain Needa" -Darth Vader in one of the Original Trilogy movies (I can't remember which one) and
"We would be honored, if you would join us" -Darth Vader to Han Solo and Princess Leia in The Empire Strikes Back
Love the channel and the podcast, keep up the great work :)
Tarkin looked fine to me. Could I tell he was CGI, sure. But not as bad as you state.
Depends on the person. You say he looked fine, I say he looked like a cartoon.
Dave Johnston I certainly understand your point. My point is that it didn't distract from the experience to me at all. Yoda has always looked like a puppet being manipulated by a person to me, even as a young child. Didn't distract from the story to me.
the difference is, the puppet has actual light working on it. The CG guys need to look at the frame and sorta guess which parts are highlighted and in shadow. It wasn't the nicest CG to look at and apparently it was like really *really* *REALLY* expensive so... thats a shame, Princess leia looked much better in my opinion
Toby Brooks I know I’m very late to this, but I thought Leia looked worse, I find de aged people look too smooth and shiny like they’re robots, that’s why I prefer Tarkin, all the wrinkles and creases made him look more real for me
I actually liked tarkin
Mr Sunday you the man! My fav on CZcams!
Great clip, as always
Vader did display a dark, dry humor in the original trilogy with Admiral Needa ("apology accepted").
MetFanMac totaly agree with u
Tarkin was ALMOST there... it didn't fool me, but we're going to get these bumps along the road until true photorealism takes off.(edit) stop coming up with stupid in world reasons why "Vader is slower" in episode four... it's called bad choreography... it doesn't need to be explained away...
Mark Baber facts lol
great work fella's always appreciated
Great Video! love you guys
The Vader scenes were pretty damn sexy especially the final one.
I lost my mind when Tarkin showed up, but I wish they hadn't given him so many close ups. I know some people couldn't really tell, but it was so obvious (to me) that it was CGI. It looked like a really good video game.
I thought the reflection shot when we first see him was perfect and wish that they kept doing interesting shots like that. Same with Leia. It didn't fully take me out of the movie (bcuz I ended up loving it) but still. Just a little distracting.
Ooooh! I've missed this! I loved it when you made these, made it seem like Mason contributed to the channel more.
MORE!!!!
Great video, keep it up!!!
I had a friend who'd never seeen a star wars movie before, he genuinely had no idea Tarkin was CGI until i pointed it out to him. I think the cgi was fantastic, except we all knew it was cgi.
Wow, spoiler in the thumbnail, huh?
Skip6235 is just a shore trooper from the trailers
hayescamp he changed it
Skip6235 what was it? before the shoretrooper
It was SPOILER
Leia
You should have watched it by now
"if this is a consular ship, where is the embassador?" - Vader sassyness continues.
Another great vid!
Best parts:Are you serious? I'm Blind. "Don't choke on your aspirations director." And Red 5 blowing up, giving Luke his spot in the red squad.
I already saw the movie but I really think you should change the thumbnail lol its a massive spoiler
Keanu A massive spoiler is saying everyone dies and vader has the greatest scene of all time where he kills a bunch of Rebels. Seeing Leia for two seconds at the end isnt a spoiler and she was basically confirmed before the movie even came out.
Boinks Ok but how many people actually did the research and found out that Leia was confirmed ? Its still a spoiler its the last scene in the movie personally I wasn't expecting it as well as everyone in my theatre.
I agree with Keanu, I did not know she was in the film and I was really surprised, so yeah its a spoiler for most people who havern't seen it
Keanu the thumbnail is in the trailers
I think they must have changed it already because earlier comments make it sound like Leia was in the thumbnail
I love how when Hellogreedo says he didn't like Tarkin, he got so so much hate
yet when these guys say they absolutely hated it, no one seems to really have a go
RE: Biggs - in the Star Wars timeline, he would've joined the Rebellion after the battle at Scarif - in cut footage from ANH, he visits Luke one last time on Tatooine to tell him he's going to defect to the Rebellion. As for Wedge, apparently, he was there - but only in a voice cameo.
it's not a Vader film but I'd love a Vader film later on
9:14 I laughed way harder than I should have.
What a terrible scene for a video game lol
David Manahan I want to to know what the F*** game that is from! :/
Great video!
10/10 love your videos!
My little brother (who had know idea that Peter Kushing died) saw nothing wrong. I did. I think when your looking for it it is worse but fine.
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story VS Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens = Winner?
Rogue One
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
and Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens ^^^^
rogue one
Rogue one is better
I love your stuff!
Sweet vid my dude
Didn't like vaders voice?
Wasn't it the same actor who voiced him in the original?
Yes, yes it was...
ÈIRE Yeah, but you can hear the age in his voice. I honestly thought that he sounded fine.
When James Earl Jones pegs it, they should use the voice actor who did The Force Awakens 1 & 2.
That guy sounded 100% spot on, even more so than James Earl Jones himself in this movie!
JEJ has been doing this voice for 40 years now
RoboTurkeyNinja I'm guessing you mean Matt Sloan, who voiced Vader in the Force *Unleashed* 1 & 2, as well as EA Battlefront.
yeah wtf r they on about
I dint think the Tarkin and Leia were bad at all.
"Well.. he is a dad" this line made me laugh harder than it should have lmao
6:41 I didn't realize what I wanted from this movie until you said it. Well done.
Should have recast Tarkin, Cgi was so obvious
No-thing i didn't know he was dead, i didn't even know who he was and it bothered tf out of me
***** who would it have confused? He's not a character the general audience immediately recognizes or at all
I feel like the CGI was only obvious to people who are familiar to Star Wars and know Peter Cushing is dead my girlfriend didn't know he was dead and she couldn't tell that he was CGI until I told her and to me I thought it was really good
I agree with Hufflepuffed, didn't know about the actor being dead, still bothered me, no one is confused about Mon Mothma, so a recast would only have bothered whiny Star Wars fans.
What was weird was in his first scene he looked pretty off-putting but later on he almost looked like a real person. Guess the CGI was inconsistent?
Can't we just make a whole movie of Darth Vader walking through a corridor and killing people
Tumetron3000 I'd watch that.
Tumetron3000
A corridor full of Gungans and Ewoks.
Love this channel lol
Just got a SW Force Arena ad showcasing Darth Vader while you were talking about him!
how the fuck can they say it looks awful???? please tell me HOW THE FUCK?!? it looks fucking great , Leia looks like shit and creepy .....its just because you guys know hes dead , otherwise you wouldnt say shit
BlackoutKalico Beta t
I'd say that Leia and Tarkin's first appearance looked pretty iffy, but the later scenes with Tarkin look so much better for some reason.
Leia looks creepy? I happen to think she looked beautiful.
What does that say about you mate?
Enjoy getting your shit pushed in
BlackoutKalico Beta Wow. You're like a prequel lover. Completely backwards.
MysteriousStranger420 Gladly.
legend says mr sunday movies replies to comments
Jason Fegan legend would be wrong
there is still time
Jason Fegan This isn't canon anymore
That ending....you guys are awesome.
"apology accepted Captain Needa"....that was very tongue in cheek....
he wasnt that bad
What do you think of a Darth Vader R-rated movie?
MrbackFX possibly the best idea in the history of cinema!
MrbackFX it's a good idea, but the rated r part is totally irrelevant. Star wars isn't bloody and nobody really swears so if it becomes this way then it isn't star wars.
True. But it has to be dark
Disney will never do it because it would disrupt the consistency of their universe.
If they did it, it couldn't contain ANY existing characters.
It would have to completely break free, in order to establish its own tone.
Otherwise it doesn't make sense and is super short sighted.
A videogame can get away with that however
Yes, i don't think Disney will do it :( But it would be nice
Hahah really liked the song at the end
Thoughts on people saying the cloaked figure in Vader's castle is future Snoke?
You seem fun
Matt Peee Okay so what if Snoke is Vader's secret apprentice and fills palpatine's void when Vader and Palpatine dies?? just a thought
Cult Dun Studios Exactly! Can't say I'd love it if that's what they did. But they seem hell bent on tying everything together, so it wouldn't surprise me. Could even see Vader being responsible for his disfigurement (in a fit of rage after the first Death Star destruction)
I assumed it was, based on the guy's appearance.
It's clearly somebody important, otherwise why have him in a scene at all?
They could have just had one of the red Crayola looking guards come and tell him to get out of the fish tank and put his suit on to meet the Admiral guy.
I liked tarkin cgi
Visual effects =/= character
After all, the Transformers visually look spectacular in the live action films, but they are lousy characters (technically they're not even characters at all). :( Character-wise, I found Tarkin to be just fine. Leia's appearance was a brief cameo, so she had no characterisation in Rogue One.
Vader does sadistically joke when Force choking Imperials.
"Don't choke on your ambition, Director Krennic."
"I find your lack of faith disturbing."
"Apology accepted, Captain Needa."
"You have failed me for the last time, Admiral. You are in command now, _Admiral_ Piett."
...he's just full of laughs.
He never jokes when physically or Force choking non-Imperials though (e.g. Padmé, Obi-Wan, Cpt. Antilles etc.).
P.S.: As for Vader's voice, it's still James Earl Jones, so I'm not sure what people don't like about it considering that it's the same voice.
great stuff
Vader chokes out one of his admirals and says apology accepted.