I can't stop on a walk for like 1 min without a bunch of whining. I can't stop to talk to anyone, nothing without my dog acting like he's dieing. I feel like this works but also doesn't.
@@tomdavisofficial I think they mean that it works, but they aren't sure how they can lengthen the duration the dog can tolerate being still before whining. E.g. dog whines after 30sec and moving works, but I'd like to progress to being able to talk to my neighbor for 2min without whining, how does someone get there? :)
For us , there are two strategies that work. My GSDs whining (there are various scales in intensity) when she's bored got worse because of my attention for it (saying leave it, eye contact, myself getting restless...) On the walk I make structured pauses , where we both sit and watch , wait , until she calmes herself (minimal radius) and the whining gets no attention. It became better and better in different situations. When the whining comes out of stress (f.e. in dog school, to many dogs around and has to wait, crowded place) we make the same as Tom describes so she can work off the stress by movement. You have to be patient, we worked for some months and still have to go on. She's 18 months old
@@Maria-lx4yt mine is 3years old lab,still winning when I just stepped out of building for walk him.Movement make it worse,and stand still also.He will start âcry-barkingâ(thats what I called it,its like I was stabbing him or torturing him)Mann it get worse when there is dog park and dogs are playing.screaming not bark,I canât describe it. But yeah,after 3 years nothing helped. Only if I was quickly moving back and force,turning like each seconds,he can stop.But if I back to normal,sounds from hell starts again. I canât just walking like that when there is people nearby or in lil bit distance.Place he wonât whining:wild and no-human&animal zone.He will whine but it can be stopped. I donât know what to do. Iâm so stressed, I can make it peace when I walk him out,and just ignore the whining.But its not the solution.
I have watched your videos for months I work with dogs and I must say the insight you have provided me when I see dogs everyday is insane. I rescued my 1-2 year old GSD and she is perfect Iâve implemented so many of your trainings into our daily routines and it helped make adjustments that bettered both of our lives
This isn't realistic for dogs that literally whine constantly like mine. It doesn't matter what we're doing. We could be out on an actual walk and if we stop for two seconds for his sister to pee, he's fucking whining again. He's done it since he was born and it's finally wearing on me 3.5 years later. I swear it's getting worse as he gets older too.
Hmm this seems like it would reinforce the whining by giving them an out, idk if this is the right move. You need to teach them how to self-soothe by working it. We would do behavioral downs where we would just wait until the dog stopped whining before giving verbal praise and moving forward. In the beginning, this would sometimes take 30-45 minutes, but after a month of working it he would transition to a calm pant within 15 seconds. You do have to train it in some different environments though so that they can learn to calm themselves wherever you go
Thank you. This is a way more logical solution. And also reassuring to see that it can sometimes take 30-45 mins in some cases because I've literally had to make my dog wait 30 mins to eat before he stops whining like he's dying. Nothing has worked. Literally nothing and I've tried EVERYTHING! I will continue making him wait it out even if it takes a long time. He seems to be getting worse as he gets older. He's also intact. Will getting him fixed help at all?
Mine was excessively vocal in the car (passed away now) but oh my gosh, sounded like he was being tortured. I didn't mind him being vocal but this was extreme. I'd love to see how you tackle anxiety in the car.
THIS is the EXACT issue I have with my red ACD mix. She is incessant in the car and nothing I do snaps her out of it. It makes me not want to take her in the car anywhere.
@@crownofhair I'm so sorry to hear you have one to. We ended up only taking him in the car when it was absolutely necessary. He hated the ride, he made us hate the ride so I was just avoided all together. He'd get so excited to get in, but once the drive started it turned into bedlam.
@@peachesandapril I've never known anyone else who dealt with this đ I'm sorry for your situation, too! They're awesome beings but come with real challenges.
@@crownofhair they sure do, but we love them deeply and unconditionally either way. No matter their flaws. Sending much love to you and your crazy car rider đđ
He whines and you reward him by moving he whines and you reward him by moving. Beautiful the dog just trained you how to give him what he wants.đ€Šââïž
I totally noticed my reactive dog whining more than normal when we went out Trick-or-Treating on Monday. I honestly thought he was feeling anxious but now I think he was bored. I mean I was bored too sometimes ( my kid can be soooo slooooowww)!
I always thought this whining was stress like "I dont know what to do with myself" from lack of structure/leadership, not practicing longer stays or calmness. Is there ever a time where it's ok to correct whining?
A question I imagine will unfortunately be ignored:: I have two purebred German Shepherd dogs that are literally cannibals. They killed two of my other adult dogs, dogs they'd been ok with for a year, and then they are them. One of the large dogs they killed and partially ate that Thus far have not dug him up and ate his remains further since I buried him. The other dog they killed -- another GSD, they literally dug her body up and ate most of it last night. What would cause this??? Sincerely, they are free fed and have tons of dog food. They have a large fenced property to run on. Btw when my cannibals we're attacking in both cases it was when I was not home. I returned during the second attack and the two stopped immediately when I verbally commanded them too but it was too late to save their victim.
My Toy Australian Shepherd whines a lot when she is excited like I do 4h with her so basically a lot of agility and she knows when we get near the building where we yrain and she gets so excited and basically yells in our ears since she is so excited
Having dogs fore more than 25 years, pitbulls, English bull terriers, cane Corso and now a Dogo Argentino/pitbull crossbreed never, ever had to use a prong collar neither a muzzle I just trained my dogs from puppy in the right way so they never pulled on the leash and all my dogs where trained to guard my property, lots of love, patience a silk glove and no fysical punishment is the only way to properly train any dog all the rest is BS
Make sure they will lay down,train them with car parked.Then find a safety place to train them not get up when you start to move the car.And slowly they would stop doin it,even they get up they will remain calm.But I still canât pass when he saw a dog aroundâŠwell after he canât see them he will stop,not that bad I think.
what about a dog with horrible pee problems? ( he pees everywhere in the house)..he also is extremely whiney. sounds like extreme anxiety..any solutions?
@@dubthabreak He is constantly around my dad who works from home...and when he's not home, my mother or I am home. We practice the solution of putting a diaper on him for no more than 2 hours at a time. Wondering it that can be beneficial for him. He's ruined so many pieces of furniture and loves peeing on the floorboards.
Iâve heard some knowledgeable stuff from this guy but wtf kinda advice is this? Youâre rewarding the dog while itâs whining and besides when your dog is genuinely whining, itâs not always with a leash in a walking situation.
if u condition them to the muzzle properly then it doesnât bother them nearly as much as u might think. my dog needed a muzzle for the first several months of training due to reactivity, i had to reintroduce it to him in a positive way because his previous owner used it as a punishment which isnât how u use a muzzle. once i showed him it wasnât a bad thing and that he did nothing wrong, he was totally okay with it. he no longer needs it and hasnât for a while. if u donât know what ur talking about, donât say anything cause ur spreading misinformation and just adding to the negative outlook on things such as muzzles. have a good day
Watch the FULL video here! czcams.com/video/PhhtfKkeGkE/video.html
I can't stop on a walk for like 1 min without a bunch of whining. I can't stop to talk to anyone, nothing without my dog acting like he's dieing. I feel like this works but also doesn't.
It works but also t doesnât ?
@@tomdavisofficial I think they mean that it works, but they aren't sure how they can lengthen the duration the dog can tolerate being still before whining. E.g. dog whines after 30sec and moving works, but I'd like to progress to being able to talk to my neighbor for 2min without whining, how does someone get there? :)
For us , there are two strategies that work. My GSDs whining (there are various scales in intensity) when she's bored got worse because of my attention for it (saying leave it, eye contact, myself getting restless...) On the walk I make structured pauses , where we both sit and watch , wait , until she calmes herself (minimal radius) and the whining gets no attention. It became better and better in different situations. When the whining comes out of stress (f.e. in dog school, to many dogs around and has to wait, crowded place) we make the same as Tom describes so she can work off the stress by movement. You have to be patient, we worked for some months and still have to go on. She's 18 months old
Move a little bit, you donât have to keep walking- that rewards the whining.
@@Maria-lx4yt mine is 3years old lab,still winning when I just stepped out of building for walk him.Movement make it worse,and stand still also.He will start âcry-barkingâ(thats what I called it,its like I was stabbing him or torturing him)Mann it get worse when there is dog park and dogs are playing.screaming not bark,I canât describe it. But yeah,after 3 years nothing helped. Only if I was quickly moving back and force,turning like each seconds,he can stop.But if I back to normal,sounds from hell starts again. I canât just walking like that when there is people nearby or in lil bit distance.Place he wonât whining:wild and no-human&animal zone.He will whine but it can be stopped. I donât know what to do. Iâm so stressed, I can make it peace when I walk him out,and just ignore the whining.But its not the solution.
I have watched your videos for months I work with dogs and I must say the insight you have provided me when I see dogs everyday is insane. I rescued my 1-2 year old GSD and she is perfect Iâve implemented so many of your trainings into our daily routines and it helped make adjustments that bettered both of our lives
This isn't realistic for dogs that literally whine constantly like mine. It doesn't matter what we're doing. We could be out on an actual walk and if we stop for two seconds for his sister to pee, he's fucking whining again. He's done it since he was born and it's finally wearing on me 3.5 years later. I swear it's getting worse as he gets older too.
Maybe this isnât for you then. not every dog is the fucking same and you need to try something more advanced? Idk just a common sense thought
Hmm this seems like it would reinforce the whining by giving them an out, idk if this is the right move. You need to teach them how to self-soothe by working it.
We would do behavioral downs where we would just wait until the dog stopped whining before giving verbal praise and moving forward. In the beginning, this would sometimes take 30-45 minutes, but after a month of working it he would transition to a calm pant within 15 seconds.
You do have to train it in some different environments though so that they can learn to calm themselves wherever you go
Thank you. This is a way more logical solution. And also reassuring to see that it can sometimes take 30-45 mins in some cases because I've literally had to make my dog wait 30 mins to eat before he stops whining like he's dying. Nothing has worked. Literally nothing and I've tried EVERYTHING! I will continue making him wait it out even if it takes a long time. He seems to be getting worse as he gets older. He's also intact. Will getting him fixed help at all?
Mine was excessively vocal in the car (passed away now) but oh my gosh, sounded like he was being tortured. I didn't mind him being vocal but this was extreme. I'd love to see how you tackle anxiety in the car.
THIS is the EXACT issue I have with my red ACD mix. She is incessant in the car and nothing I do snaps her out of it. It makes me not want to take her in the car anywhere.
@@crownofhair I'm so sorry to hear you have one to. We ended up only taking him in the car when it was absolutely necessary. He hated the ride, he made us hate the ride so I was just avoided all together. He'd get so excited to get in, but once the drive started it turned into bedlam.
@@peachesandapril I've never known anyone else who dealt with this đ I'm sorry for your situation, too! They're awesome beings but come with real challenges.
@@crownofhair they sure do, but we love them deeply and unconditionally either way. No matter their flaws. Sending much love to you and your crazy car rider đđ
My friends dog does this too. It's an awful noise. I put the music up and sing to him and he sings back đ€Ł
He whines and you reward him by moving he whines and you reward him by moving. Beautiful the dog just trained you how to give him what he wants.đ€Šââïž
Doesn't work at all especially if they're not on leash. You're doing what they want to do so definitely reinforcing the whine.
My pitt does this when thereâs rabbits/mice running around
He whines move but what if i want to stay
I totally noticed my reactive dog whining more than normal when we went out Trick-or-Treating on Monday. I honestly thought he was feeling anxious but now I think he was bored. I mean I was bored too sometimes ( my kid can be soooo slooooowww)!
What about when I am having dinner and they are with us on a down-stay?
WHEN I HEAR A DOG WHINING IT BREAKS MY HEART BC I THINK THEY'VE BEEN HURT AND ARE IN PAIN
I always thought this whining was stress like "I dont know what to do with myself" from lack of structure/leadership, not practicing longer stays or calmness. Is there ever a time where it's ok to correct whining?
What if it's more when left alone?
A question I imagine will unfortunately be ignored:: I have two purebred German Shepherd dogs that are literally cannibals. They killed two of my other adult dogs, dogs they'd been ok with for a year, and then they are them. One of the large dogs they killed and partially ate that Thus far have not dug him up and ate his remains further since I buried him. The other dog they killed -- another GSD, they literally dug her body up and ate most of it last night. What would cause this??? Sincerely, they are free fed and have tons of dog food. They have a large fenced property to run on. Btw when my cannibals we're attacking in both cases it was when I was not home. I returned during the second attack and the two stopped immediately when I verbally commanded them too but it was too late to save their victim.
My Toy Australian Shepherd whines a lot when she is excited like I do 4h with her so basically a lot of agility and she knows when we get near the building where we yrain and she gets so excited and basically yells in our ears since she is so excited
Having dogs fore more than 25 years, pitbulls, English bull terriers, cane Corso and now a Dogo Argentino/pitbull crossbreed never, ever had to use a prong collar neither a muzzle I just trained my dogs from puppy in the right way so they never pulled on the leash and all my dogs where trained to guard my property, lots of love, patience a silk glove and no fysical punishment is the only way to properly train any dog all the rest is BS
What about whining in car when he recognizes where we are going ?
What if they whine at the back door or in the car? If there any way of helping that?
Ridiculous. It's whining for attention and anxiety. You ignore the dog until it's stops whining, it learns whining doesn't get it attention.
Chew toys dont work-???
My puppy whines alot in night somebody help
What do you do if they only do it in the car?
Make sure they will lay down,train them with car parked.Then find a safety place to train them not get up when you start to move the car.And slowly they would stop doin it,even they get up they will remain calm.But I still canât pass when he saw a dog aroundâŠwell after he canât see them he will stop,not that bad I think.
Ok so what if they whine in the crate ?
Keep my dog busy all day nah I have stuff to do and he has his aunt tiny
What if the dog is in your car tho
what about a dog with horrible pee problems? ( he pees everywhere in the house)..he also is extremely whiney. sounds like extreme anxiety..any solutions?
Give him more attention, walk at least 2 hours a day with him and don't leave him alone to much
@@dubthabreak He is constantly around my dad who works from home...and when he's not home, my mother or I am home.
We practice the solution of putting a diaper on him for no more than 2 hours at a time. Wondering it that can be beneficial for him. He's ruined so many pieces of furniture and loves peeing on the floorboards.
Iâve heard some knowledgeable stuff from this guy but wtf kinda advice is this? Youâre rewarding the dog while itâs whining and besides when your dog is genuinely whining, itâs not always with a leash in a walking situation.
How to handle whining in car .
Yes, but heâs whining when heâs in his cage and he needs to be in his cage
Not a solution
Too much energy, exercise the dog more mentally and physically.
lol is this video for real
No they're not bored they want out of the damn muzzle.
So what about my dog which doesnât wear a muzzle but will whine if stationary outside of her home, but while moving around is quite as a whisper.
someone doesnât know anything about muzzles
â@@kaden593 facts đ
Are you suggesting adding danger to the situation is the better option?
if u condition them to the muzzle properly then it doesnât bother them nearly as much as u might think. my dog needed a muzzle for the first several months of training due to reactivity, i had to reintroduce it to him in a positive way because his previous owner used it as a punishment which isnât how u use a muzzle. once i showed him it wasnât a bad thing and that he did nothing wrong, he was totally okay with it. he no longer needs it and hasnât for a while. if u donât know what ur talking about, donât say anything cause ur spreading misinformation and just adding to the negative outlook on things such as muzzles. have a good day