Wait, the Oscars were actually good this year
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 03. 2023
- Get Surfshark VPN at Surfshark.deals/rillas - Enter promo code RILLAS for 83% off and 3 extra months for free!
Schaff watched the Oscars and they didn't waste his time for once!
Editor's Channels:
Goop: / goopvideos
Patreon: / schaffrillas
Twitter: / schaffrillas
Redbubble: www.redbubble.com/people/scha....
Reddit: / schaffrillas. .
Esteemed $5+ Patrons:
aheaney15
Aiden Mcgillicuddy
Amaru Dejesus
Alexandra
Andre Gutierrez
Andrew Young
Anna Chanthaphavong
Ashley Forrest
BATMAN
Boolobo
CG Lemonade
Charlotte M
Childish Memphino
Clarissa Wee
ClownDuck
Cole Jackson
Crimson Court
Daniel Goldhorn
Danmccould
Delaina Rachelle
Dman990099
Dr Noe Context
Edgar Gutierrez
Emily Allen
Eric Banks
Flan
Francis Sheepie
Gabi Christie
Gabriel Vega Barreto
Gavin T360
Hankshark
Harvey Mulvihill
Ian Seebach
Jacob Baum
Jacob LaBossiere
Jake Albert
Jake G
Jonathan Kermanian
Joseph
Juan-the-Dingus
Justin Gonzales
Kim Trakartwichit
KingsDay
Leif Bradshaw
Logan McQuaid
Matt Fernandes
Michael David Rose
Michael Thomas
Migs
Milky
Milosz Kluski
MirrorWqve
Nessie
Night Man52
NoneLovesMe
Oceanechoes
Olivia Mendel
Osbers Gaming
Peri
Peter Hollens
Pierre Desbrieres
PinkiePotPie
Prismabunny
Put 9-Volt in Smash Bros. Please
Quetzal the Snek
rEactor
Reagan DeFriece
Rebel Friend
Red Mustached Alien
Rocco Damiano
RoscoesDad
Ryland Tews
Sassy
Scott St Jean
Seth Howell
Soloco
Star Giant Productions
Suarez
Sugargae
SuperJimmy978
Tailored Muffin
Teasel
That Guy Named Rai
The GAG Reflex
The TARDIS Pig/TC
Tom
Toxic shock
Tyler Rumbold
Uncultured Swine
Vellum Tony
Vintage
Volianer
Wafflegamr
Winny
YINSED - Zábava
I’m glad Pinocchio won because it allowed Del Toro to put the Academy on blast for how they’ve treated animation.
@ luoS detiripseD Ok, does this method actually work? Does anyone actually click on this bot shit?
Guillermo Del Toro is the hero we Animators wanted and needed😢
Holy Frick these bot replies gave me depression
@ luoS detiripseD sorry who are you?
I was about to comment that! Even though puss in boots 2 was my favorite, I’m glad that Del Toros Pinocchio was picked to rub it in the face of those smug big wigs who think animation is only for kids.
Was actually surprised they started off with animation off first and honestly was happy they gave it some respect.
Pinocchio earned that win change my mind
Three bots already. The comment section’s doomed.
Stupid robots. No respect for Chris and Patrick.
@@BeachioSandschannel this is honestly sad
@@MediaDroid960puss in boots was still better in my opinion
Worth mentioning Frasier wasn't just assaulted by a superior in Hollywood, he was blacklisted from most of Hollywood for coming out about it, so seeing him still win best actor is just that much better
I think you mean blacklisted
@@haraecca8251 that's correct, thank you
@@Aurelius_unofficial You're welcome!
@@Aurelius_unofficialI think you might need to replace we with he
@@First-to-last also thank you
When Jamie won during our watch party, most of us were pretty confused. But my father, as wise as he is, put it best. “Jamie Lee Curtis is an amazing actress, but her career consisting largely genre films and tv has meant she has never had a chance to be nominated. This award is not for Jamie’s performance in EEAAO, but for a lifetime of great acting. Sure, there were better performances from that category this year, but JLC *is* the Best Supporting Actress”
we understand, doesn't mean it isn't bs
that is a wise explanation, no kidding
but isn't that what life time achievement awards are for??
Sounds about right. James Horner wrote way better soundtracks than Titanic, but getting swept up in the flurry of nominations is a great way to get basically a Lifetime Achievement Award.
the same can be said for angela basset
I just really appreciated how this year, the animation category didn't start with the presenters treating animation as "kiddy stuff". Not only did Guillermo give his "animation is a medium" speech, but Dwayne Johnson explained that animation is pretty much tied to film history.
That was a good surprise, and hopefully, this continues every year, along with more animated films being nominated in the other categories.
Schaff I’m sure you won’t take it to heart but if you’re reading this ignore the bots, they’re degenerate clout-chasers and I can promise all of your fans, 100% of them, wish you the best and are really glad that you’re getting on with what you love. Great video as always
Praying to god your comment ages well lmao
I literally made this exact same comment lmao
@despiritedSoul2 man is there just a bot generator for CZcamsrs losing loved ones/CZcamsrs dying?!?
Perhaps they wanted to lower the controversy?
This is really what the Oscar’s should be: recognition. Recognition for the hard work so many people put into each area of putting together a piece of art. No forced comedy or cutting for time. Just time for saying “hey look at what these cool people have done! Isn’t that cool?!”
I think eventually we will get that as this years Oscar has taken significant steps towards that idealistic recognition of the craft.
Some facts.
It's a mix of recognition, respect but also dignity. All qualities that slowly but surely disappeared in previous ceremonies and i am damn glad this year was a complete 180 on the trend
Yes!! Idk why for so many years they’ve even *included* comedy at the Oscars. It’s not stand up night at the bar, it’s supposed to be awarding people who deserve it.
Also, Travolta tearing up at the In memoriam knowing that his long life friend was there on the screen and not beside him was heartbreaking
Two lifelong friends actually. Kirstie Alley and Olivia Newton John had both passed away within the past year and he was close with both of them. That must have been devastating to announce the In Memoriam section with that weighing on him
I thought All Quiet on the Western Front's strongest asset was its score. It wasn't triumphant, or loud, or really all that noticeable, I recommend anyone to rewatch that movie, but when it kicks in let the music take you through your feelings. It't used infrequently but, I thought that the scarcity of the haunting tones were what made it special, always I got chills hearing it. (this was kind of like certain parts of puss and boots, no spoilers, if you know you know) Additionally the first scene was so interesting and made great use of that disturbing score. At the very least I think it deserved to have won based on how unique it was to me.
i think people dont get why the score is so strong.
Nah, cinematography
Exactly, I have to disagree with Schaffrillas here, I thought the score was straight up depressing and more importantly haunting. I thought the movie accomplished exactly what it set out to do and I was not bored at any point either. Incredibly disturbing and depressing film, definitely recommend it as a watch. I think its more mature than most other war movies, not because of its violence or anything, but because of its position on war.
@@DuckDodgers6520 To be fair, Schaffrillas isn't the kind of person who could ever understand this movie.
@@Kyanpepper25 Why exactly ? I agree that it wasn't his cup of tea, but do you think there's a specific reason as to why ?
The fact that Del Toro's Pinocchio was the first non-CGI animated feature to win that category since Curse of the Ware Rabbit is astounding to me considering the latter came out the day I was born. I *grew up* in the time it took for a stop-motion feature to get a win again.
I watched it when I was a little kid and loved every single scene of that movie, though my all-time favorite was Chicken Run. Pinocchio's victory brought justice to the amazing world of stop motion animation.
The only two stop motion animated films to EVER win best animated fearuew
Puss in Boots 2 was a better film that tackled the issue of mortality with more focus and heart. Pinocchio just came off as pretentious with a shallow protagonist comparatively. But Pinocchio had the Oscar award darling as the director so obviously it'd win...
@@Nightman221k I think both films were great
@@LyleVSXyle I only wish another hand drawn animated film would win Best Animated Feature since the ONLY hand drawn animated film to do so is Spirited Away.
Update: Great news! Another 2D animated film won this year for Best Animated Feature with The Boy and the Heron. Was expecting Across the Spider-Verse to win, but was surprised and happy for Hayao Miyazaki winning his second Oscar for Best Animated Feature.
All Quiet on the Western Front was amazing. I've rarely felt such dread and hopelesness from watching a movie before. There was no heroic sacrifice or the hero saving the day. It just showed how pointless war is and that soldiers are victims of it too. It really felt like a true anti-war movie.
Yeah. I really feel like James just didn’t get the movie at all and was expecting it to be something different going on. Especially seeing how he ranked 1917 over it. 1917 is great, don’t get me wrong, but definitely a way more generic and typical “war hero saves the day” movie than All Quiet was.
@@Jesse-yo7uw Exactly. This one actually had real weight to it
All Quiet was probably my top 3 in War films because of how it's presented and the story
Biggest problem with the movie is probably the ending missing the point (and title to be precise) of the book.
@@Jesse-yo7uw I see it more as a biased opinion. Something a reviewer shouldnt have .. or at least not much. I mean, he downtalked the winners. Sounded like a sour loser.
Ke Huy Quan gave another speech to the press backstage after the ceremony and said that ALL of his (main) Goonies co-stars reached out to him in congratulations, it was wholesome as fuck! This is what he said:
"You know, before this night started um..Corey Feldman, one of my Goonies brothers called. I was talking to Kerri Green. And of course, tonight, Jeff Cohen - who is my entertainment lawyer - was with me in the audience, which is why I thanked him. Because, I love all of them so much! And every single one of them is so happy! Sean reached out, Josh, Martha. We are always bonded. We're family forever. Goonies never say die!"
So god damn cute!
That reunification of Short Round and Indy was some of the most cinematic and beautiful things I've ever seen on this show, and it's so genuine too.
Because they focused on the Asians. American blacks and whites are messy
It was such a hit the Oscars of this year that the rating increased by a 12%!
And I hope the Oscars start noticing WHAT WE WANT as an audience
bruh these bots are ass 😭
Omg the bots :0
I knew there was a good chance the Oscars would not let us down and make the same mistakes twice that were made the previous year with Amy Schumer, Gabrielle Union, Will Smith, Megan Thee Stallion and Lily James. 🥺 Pretty PLEASE let Patty Jenkins or Greta Gerwig win Best Director next year!
Ignoring all the other comments I agree with you, this honestly reminds me of Sonic the Hedgehog these days, the company now knows what the fans want and because of that we've had 3 years of good Sonic content. Obviously this needs improvement, but there is hope we can have another phenomenal ceremony
Side Note:
Every ceremony is better when there is no Amy Schummer
wtf with that bot saying that Schaf bro died cuz his content is better, what's wrong with those bot tho!?
I’m so very glad Brendan Fraser and Ke Huy Quan are Oscar winners now. They both supported each other so much this award season!
@Logan {UTTP} Hey! What the hell?
@@OmarTafur75 its a bot, ignore it
They were both phenomenal. I can't wait to see what they bring us in the future.
Glad Brendan Fraser won; just wish he'd won for literally almost anything else.
Both so incredibly talented, both could also be considered “ come back “ roles for the two which makes their wins even sweeter
Really happy that RRR won best song. There are so many Indian movies that have such great music, and the fact that they are finally getting recognized is amazing. The Academy rubbed me the wrong way when they didn't let India nominate Sardhar Udham, the movie about freedom fighters and Indian revolution (they said it glorified terrorism, which is just so stupid), but it looks like they are changing for the better!
The last indian submission nominated for best foreign film, was an anti colonial masala film about cricket. RRR is also an anti colonial masala film. I think they didn't nominate sardar udham was because it wasn't made to be entertaining like lagaan and rrr and provided a way more harsh and realistic portrayal of colonialism.
Hate that there were no Indian dancers
@@MutantMonke ya, it was too serious for Americans to rub the British this hard...
Seems ridiculous when basically every large war movie gets a best picture nod.
@@XrayTheMyth23 It was (this may be slightly wrong as it has been a while since I saw the film) about when a British man ordered the genocide of millions of Indians in a small village and an Indian man killing him as revenge for wiping out his village and family. The Indian Man is treated horribly in prison and his story is told to a biographer or something of that sort. It is an amazing movie, and shows the darker side of the revolution as opposed to ht lighthearted tone of RRR.
I'm crying tears of happiness. I didn't even fucking realize that Ke Huy Quan was the child actor from Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom... I've seen this movie so many times, that's what unites me and my father. I always felt like this kid drinking alcohol and driving had a hard time. I glad he finally won an Oscar. I won't watch his acceptance speech yet because I'll probably die of excessive crying.
My parents have always been longtime watchers of the Oscars, so I have done my very best to educate them on the importance of animation and how much work really goes into them. It made me feel good to see how happy they were during Guillermo’s speech, as he said, “Animation is Cinema. Animation is not a genre.”
I feel you.
My parents are also huge cinema nerds, mom is more passionate about scores and music while dad on actors and cinematography. I grew up loving animation the most, and i've been getting really discouraged in recent years seeing animation so bullied and diminished by movie industry and public alike... hope this year reignited some sparks, thanks to del toro and especially Puss in Boots
@@serenaso4669 Thanks. It’s nice to know there’s a whole lot of us out there fighting for animation’s recognition.
If you're talking about recent years it's because animated movies have been pretty mediocre in recent years. I mean encanto, soul, toy story 4 were the last three oscar winners and they were so average.
@@Robert-no3ds One word: Spiderverse.
@@Robert-no3ds Isle of Dogs, Kubo, GDT Pinocchio and Spiderverse all came out in the past 5 years and all stand amongst the best in the medium
Both Brendan Fraser and Ke Huy Quan’s Speech Really shows how much the Oscar Meant to them
Wait bots are putting (making fun of bots) in their comments now these mindgames are insane
I’m so happy for Brendan ❤️
@ luoS detiripseD
HAHHHAHAHAHAHAHA SO FUNNY MAN 😐
@@KingOfGaymes Me Too, Unfortunately I haven’t seen The Whale Yet but I really want to
@lShowSрееd shorts 🅥 I almost fell for it thinking it was a rickroll. Thank god I remembered all the text in the link
An an Indian really happy to win our first Oscar, delighted to see other countries also getting better recognition
isn't our first.
@@VarunKumar-ro4ll it is. No Indian production won an Oscar before.
@@VarunKumar-ro4ll I mean it's actually big thing for South Indians tho. The shit Bollywood has gotten upto lately 💀 it's a big thing if you ask me
@@VarunKumar-ro4ll Only if you count Co-Productions, in which case Gandhi and Slumdog Millionaire would be India's first wins. For a fully Indian production, RRR is the first.
@@dustybawls7085 Speaking of which, the Tamil documentary 'Elephant Whisperers' also won the Oscar in its category this year!
The score for All Quiet on The Western front added to the feeling of dread and hopelessness. What made the movie unique is that everyone dies, there are no heroes in WW1 and this film was unique in its lense as a truly anti-war movie.
i think it is one of the only true anti war films ever made, which is what makes it so powerful
I want Ke Huy Quan to be the household name for actors, he deserves everything good that's coming to him
@Oprator did you get offended? I made fun of you then? Didn't know bots had feelings
I hope so too. He's had it so rough, despite having talent in spades.
Nah
That moment with Key Huan and Harrison was wholesome af especially for me a huge Indiana Jones fan
Indy and Short Round reunited, at long last!
That moment was so wholesome
They're an unstoppable and inseperable duo
And when he hugged Brendan Fraser during the aftershow….
@Chris The Exposer listen Chris
This isn’t you
Your better than this
Just stop trolling
And we will all be nice towards you and your family
Got that
I agree with Shaff on a lot of things, but I honestly think that him saying All Quiet was an "average war movie" is such a (metaphorical) bullet to the chest. All Quiet was honestly such a great movie and leveling it to an average war movie hurts.
And while the score (besides Remains) wasn't as memorable as some other nominations, I absolutely think that the cinematography was amazing. There were several points in this movie where I just marveled at the camera work and the shot comps. Plus, that introduction scene with the soldier dying and his clothes being recycled perfectly set the tone and was already making me prepare for the incoming doom that was about to happen. The lead actor also did a phenomenal job, the crater scene really stands out- everytime he cries, it feels like genuine tears. They're gross, uncontrolled not pretty to hear- it was almost gut-punching.
I could go on but the point is, I respect anyone's point on this movie, it is surely not for everyone. But to anybody calling it an average war movie, it really is so much more than it may seem and the team behind it are talented at their craft. I also highly recommend the BTS for the movie on Netflix, it's great.
the cultural impact of the source material also adds to my respect for this movie, i think this movie and the original movie do the book justice
The 1930 All Quiet is my favourite movie ever, but when I heard there was a new one being made by *Netflix* of all people? Let's just say I wasn't optimistic. But that crater scene? My God. I haven't felt that level of emotion since the 1930 movie. All Quiet is truly great in all adaptations and I'm glad it stayed that way with this one.
My opinion on other war films sucks, because I've only ever watched All Quiet and Gods and Generals, and Gods and Generals is the worst movie I've ever seen, but All Quiet seems a cut above the rest.
I wish all James Phyrillas a very Rewatch "All Quiet On The Western Front (2022)"
@@communistcowboyI’m so sorry you watched GaG, some war movie eye bleach for you is 1917, and another one but I forget it’s name. It’s from the WW2 movie era and from Russia so it may be divisive
How could anyone say all quiet on the western front was a boring movie ??? I honestly believe it was unreal and deserved best picture. Seeing the true realities of war and the mental development of the main character from the beginning to end of the movie was unreal.
I love when people say that about All Quiet. Because, while true, people treat it like it's a new concept. Like the two adaptations before it and the novel just never existed. Which I guess just shows how good it is. You forget it, then, just like war, you get thrown right back into it without warning.
Ke Huy Quan is such a beautiful human being. I cried when he won and never have I ever cried for a person I never met. I desperately hope he gets the career he deserves.
I loved the moment where he and Brendan Fraiser hugged
Gay
@@darrengordon-hill How? He/she was just saying he liked his speech. How does that make him gay? Also what would be wrong with he/she being gay?
@Oprator SHUT
Him hugging Harrison Ford had me BAWLING it was so cute
the Jamie lee Curtis win is something I like to call a "career" Oscar. It's more about the longevity of the person rather than the particular performance which is rarely their best work.
Not fair for the other actresses tho
@@colemacgrath2005 yeah true. She should've won one a long time ago
There's a lifetime achievement award, Stephanie hsu was still better, you can say the same for angela Bassett, and also Stephanie hsu was in the same movie a better actor a more important Character and also a white actor getting a award in a movie like that while a Chinese actor doesnr is strange
@@imayeti.4674 don’t make it about race
@@imayeti.4674 You say that like the entire rest of the cast didn't sweep most of the awards.
I'm so glad Brandon got the praised he needed. It's so nostalgic having him returned in the film industry, and I hope that he stays healthy for future films. Especially The Mummy 3!!!
There's been a Mummy 3 already
@@anmolt3840051 the what now, there's only ever 2 mummy movie
@@anmolt3840051 wait you mean the fanfiction which includes a chinese emperor? How foolish of you.
@@lordpaulphilippfernandez9904j
I think All Quiet on the Western Front deserved its wins. It’s not some, “standard war movie,” the battle scenes are literally horrifying and gruesome. The score also sells every moment making it feel real. Plus Germany usually doesn’t win anything at the Oscars so it was nice.
I wasn’t expecting this year to be such an improvement. They actually gave animation the respect it deserves. And we got to see both Lady Gaga and Rihanna singing at the Oscars.
gaga did an excellent job but GOD that camera work..... a baby could do it better than whoever did it
Have to be honest, outside of the awesome Naatu Naatu, this year's songs reached from subpar to bad for me, especially Byrne's one for Everything Everywere, wich was a surprise letdown
Fearless Hero and Ciao Papa deserved a nomination. They pale in comparison with the Indhi bois, but were way better then some actual nominees
WAIT REALLY? I GOTTA WATCH IT NOW
Sooner or later in a few years, we can imagine Richard Michael Epcar, Steven Jay Blum, Peter Cullen, Wendee Lee, Michael McConnohie, Kirk Thornton, Dee Bradley Baker, Frank Welker, Scott McNeil, Yuri Lowenthal, Bryce Austin Papenbrook, Johnny Yong Bosch, Laura Dawn Bailey and Paul St. Peter getting their very own special Oscars for themselves.
Also, "Lucky Ducks" from the Bob's Burgers Movie!
I've never cried as much watching an award show than this. The EEAAO sweep (and especially Ke Huy Quan and Michelle Yeoh's wins) and Brendan Fraser being recognized got me right in the heart. I was so happy for all of them.
Eeaao is such a masterpiece my favourite movie EVER
im sorry i just think its incredibly funny to say "EEEH OW" in my mind when i read about comments about eeaao
Ha, same!
Bro cried over a bunch of actors that will never give a crap about you 🤦🏾♂️
You honestly should not be that attached to celebrity's
I hope they do the thing where they showed off each category every year. Like showing all the costumes from the costuming category on stage or the history lesson on cinematography. I really liked that cuz I felt it not only helped us as audience members understand those aspects of film better but it also showed a lot of respect for those respective noms
I feel like almost everyone watching this said “what?” out loud When schaffrillas said all quiet on the western front wasn’t special and didn’t need to take 4 rewards, I was definitely a bit baffled when I heard that because that was the first time I’ve actually ever heard someone say that, he should definitely make a video on all quiet on the western front so I can see where he’s coming from
I kinda agree with him tbh cuz babylon, the banshees, tar, the fabelmans and elvis deserve at least one award each and all quiet won way too many awards
@@jardinew3107to say it was boring though 💀
@@Mialikesthings yeah thats blasphemy
I have to say this, I feel that Guillermo del Toro was the one that made them put animation first. It's been years of fight among true animators out there to be taken in count, but his last movie and his speeches made everyone look at this genre as it is: art.
I didn't watch the Oscars and I don't think I ever will, but I loved how they turned out to be this year.
I think my favorite moment of this show was the intro to the In Memoriam section. It was really obvious that John Travolta was upset because of Olivia Newton-John's death, and his speech made me tear up a bit. And the actual section was really good, a HUGE improvement over last year's. Oh, additionally, when the woman who won Best Costuming color-coordinated her speech cards to match her dress. That is some queen behavior.
That was what I noticed, that Travolta's speech seemed so honest and close to him. It was really quite moving
Definitely better than the time he introduced the wickedly talented Adele Dazeem.
And Kirstie Alley as well. He lost 2 of his closest friends and co-stars last year. Poor John.
I felt so bad for him at that moment! ☹️
The thing that hit me most was when John Travolta got emotional when talking about all the actors and actresses that we had lost this year, paying homage to Olivia Newton-John. My school decided to do grease for this year’s production, and I got Danny Zuko and a great friend of mine got Sandy. It just hurts so much to think how Olivia is actually gone, and seeing Travolta say “We are forever Hopelessly devoted to you” almost brought me to tears. It made me feel ever more indebted to the character of Danny Zuko and the show of Grease, it made me feel even more devoted to that friend who took the roll with me, to my Sandy Counterpart. And it showed me the strength and beauty that art, be it film, musical, book or animation, can impose on people.
RIP Olivia Newton-John
We will forever be hopelessly devoted to you.
I think the point made at 10:55 is really dumb. It's an award competition. You give the award to the best editing. The other ones get recognition by being nominees.
I'm very happy for Jaime Lee Curtis receiving her Oscar, it's long overdue. that being said Stephanie Hsu was so brilliant in EEAAO and she definitely deserved the W
Man, these bots are out of control.
@ luoS detiripseD this is why your family thinks you are a dissapointment.
What the fuck are these bots. Spamming is one thing, but disrespecting a dead individual for clout is beyond me.
Utterly disgraceful bots. How awful of you to try and milk Schaffrillas’s brothers tragic death into clout. Whoever’s managing you should go jump into a lake
Yes its true that its long overdue, but the oscars are given out to the actors/actress and movies based on their impact and overall performance THAT year. Jamie Lee Curtis was a good actress, but in my opinion she wasnt the best supporting role of the nominees or in EEAAO
I totally understand why Mitski didn't wanted to attend the ceremony, but I would love to see her with them, because it was a really big moment for the Asian-American community in the art/entertainment industry
Wait was Mitski nominated 😦 I had no idea
@@littlemissviolet4984 yes, for this is a life
Quan was definitely the main highlight in Oscars. Surprisingly I didn't expected his speech to be more inspiring than any previous Oscar winners so congratulations to him.
I’d recommend checking out the novel of all quiet on the western front. It’s really impactful and a very important novel. The history of the author behind it is also super interesting.
Wasnt the authors sister beheaded because of his novel?
As I'm mexican, I'm very honored that Guillermo won the Oscar. Love to see Mexico winning.
Fr, so proud we’re getting recognition for something beautiful as stop motion animation
Del Toro is one of the greatest directors of the last 30 years. Easily top 5
Personally I love all quiet on the western front winning so many Oscars. It's not Just a Standard war movie, it showed the german perspective and despite it being called "all quiet" the score is frankly amazing its perfectly haunting and yet uplifting in some other moments. I think it Got the nomination simply because of the first track "remains" those 3 notes that constantlu return are simply amazing. But there, I resty case. I think AQOTWF more then deserved those nominations and wins
Totally agree with you. I thought it was well acted, well scored, beautifully shot, and very well written. I actually think it does anti war far better than 1917. One of the few times I disagree with Schaff.
Completely agree
Agreed, I think another reason why it’s good is because for the most part it is a real story
I totally agree, but the 1970s version is way better in my opinion, because it includes the part were Paul goes home, which is absolutely soul crushing. RIP ya boi Gerard Duval.
Also its called "all quiet" as its kinda a delusion. The war was not quiet, and the book ends with the "all quiet on the western front" note after the main character literally dies, indicating that it was NOT all quiet, but to the brass up top, they did not care. I think Schaffrilla's arguments here seem really petty and as if he didn't really watch the film.
All Quiet totally deserved the wins in my opinion. Wayyyy better than 1917 lol. It was one of the most anti-war war films I've seen period, and easily the most beautiful.
All quiet on the western front was amazing
"Why do they still have the best International Feature Film category?"
Well, because for the longest time, the Oscars only included American films in the big, important categories and completely ignored the work of creative minds outside their borders. And that the winner of this category is also nominated for Best Pictures is a relatively new phenomenon, because for many years it was simply unthinkable. Maybe it is an excuse from the Academy to look more diverse in their big categories.
And to save the reputation of "All quiet on the western front": I think many people struggle with this movie because they do not know or realize that these were real things that happened, that the author Remarque wrote down after he returned home from this ongoing, pointless fight. Because the fighs on the Western Front were maybe one of the deadliest fights in World War 1, and it benefitted nobody. The original titel "Im Westen nichts Neues" directly translates into "No news from the Western Front", which is one of the last sentences in the book, even though the protagonist had just died. Soldiers weren't important anymore, death was normal. I can really recommend this book if you are interested in WW1 stories. It was brilliant, I read through it in a night for my German class, it broke me, I never want to read it again.
"Save the reputation" as if the comments aren't flooded with rabid defense for that movie lol
The ending ties into one of my problems with the All Quiet movie: so the original title "nothing new on the western front" is because Paul dies on a day that is relatively uneventful for WW1. There's just nothing special about the day he dies and that's part of what's so pointless and tragic about it. Conversely, the movie makes him die at the very last second, on the day of the armistice. Like Armistice Day is not a day where there's nothing new to report lol. I feel like that's sort of a microcosm of the issue. The whole movie was just unnecessarily bombastic IMO.
I'm doing my A-Level in Germany right now and boi, we watched the movie "Im Westen nichts Neues" during german class. It broke as all. The whole class was so close to lose it and just cry. Especially since our topic of the past years was the horror of the first and second world war. We were filled with so much sorrow and disgust trough the whole movie, becaue everything was based on the true story.
Evertime we thought the movie would end now, something new horrofic happened.
@@thefilmseeker yes, and this is one of them... Duh
I was so
Excited when pinnocio won. Also my mom and I cried during all the eeaao speeches 😭 especially ke’s . I felt this show was so genuine and appreciated the fact they took the criticisms and *changed* it instead of ignoring it.
My siblings and I all burst into tears during Ke’s speech and eeaao’s win. Like being kids of immigrant, conservative/traditional parents, the movie hit home and we were so happy to see a movie that helped us feel seen win. We missed the animation win but when it was out on Spanish/Mexican news, we cheered and almost cried. This was my favoritie oscars to watch, and I loved the special things they added to it.
"It is a standard war movie and it isn't really special"
Me, a German, knowing the history of the book an the movie and the role it played in German history and still plays in the present: Um...
I’m just glad All Quiet on the Western Front, a film made in Germany by German producers, got the recognition it deserved despite it being a foreign film
After hearing about how disastrous last year's ceremony was, I was shocked at every turn by how respectful this one was. The acceptance speeches by Guillermo del Toro, Jamie Lee Curtis, the two Daniels, the Natu Natu guys, Michelle Yeoh, and especially Brendan Fraser and Ke Huy Quan were absolute highlights, and the overall presentation felt like what I once imagined the Oscars to be: a respectful examination and celebration of film. And I haven't even seen most of the nominees. That's how you know they cared
Also, James, this is like the third time in memory that SMG4 clips have been used in your videos, so I am now demanding a discussion of Glitch Productions and SMG4
"The two Davids"?
@@VicenteTorresAliasVits the directors of EEAAO
Ikr? I was surprised how much the 95th Academy Awards improved from the previous ceremony and actually took itself seriously and professionally. It was the best Oscar ceremony since the 92nd Academy Awards and even Everything Everywhere All at Once was the best Best Picture winner since Parasite. Definitely had a good time with an Academy Awards ceremony than I had with last year’s.
@@ThenewTchannel Oh. They're called Daniels. Anyway, yeah, I agree with what you wrote.
@@VicenteTorresAliasVits oh, Daniel, right. My bad
A requiem for “All Quiet on the Western Front”: I thoroughly enjoyed the movie. This is the first truly anti-war movie and, even if it is the remake of a remake of a book, the execution and cinematography sent it over the top. For me, this is one of the greatest war movies of all time, and most certainly the greatest WW1 film of all time. I have a lot of heritage in WW1 so I set a lot of my creative writing stories there and I’m glad to see Hollywood filmmakers showcasing the freedom of writing stories in that time period. You can’t write WW2 from the Nazi’s perspective without some hero against the regime, and you can’t write an American Civil War movie from the Confederate’s perspective without someone fighting who’s antislavery. WW1 truly shows the psychology of soldiers on both sides in a way you can’t truly do with other conflicts. As a war movie enjoyer, All Quiet on the Western Front deserves all of its awards this year (Except for the score.) Bassett got robbed too.
Yeah I agree. While 1917 is very good the final 30 minutes dragged it down for me a bit. Turning the protagonist into some kinda selfless hero who "feeds the kids and safes the day" felt like a cop out. The way WW1 was tought to me in school it was always described as a horrible waste of people and ressources in the name of "justice" and I think movies that focus on the war aspect of the time period should reflect that.
If you think that film is good, watch Stalingrad (1993). That's a real war film.
Schafrillas didnt watch movie and considers it award nomination shit fucking genius
Yeah that’s what I thought kinda got annoyed by the slander of the movie
First anti war film?! Surely you didn't watch "come and see".
Another thing they got right was bringing best editing back to the main show. Relegating what is arguably the most important aspect of filmmaking to the non-televised portion was absolutely insane.
I feel like they gave the Oscar to Jamie Lee Curtis instead of Stephanie Hsu because she's getting old and they wanted her to have an award. I genuinely can't justify another reason. She did an absolutely fantastic job, don't get me wrong, but Stephanie Hsu was probably the best part of the movie. Every time she was on screen she just had such a demanding presence and left a lasting impact with her performance.
The Little Mermaid thing was funny for me. My boyfriend's mom was watching the show when it was airing. When the Little Mermaid bit came on, I made an off-handed comment along the lines of "It's gonna be bad, because they're all bad." But then she was like "How do you know, the actors all seem happy with how it all went," because she thought the movie was already released. (she's smart enough to stay out of Disney train wreck news, unlike myself.) I had to explain "No, the film isn't actually out yet, they put an ad in the middle of the show." She was not very amused by Disney doing that. "It's very cheeky of them to do that," she said. That lead into a fun conversation where my boyfriend and I told her all about how Disney is imploding, how specifically they got to this point, and how they're becoming very desperate.
Also very happy Pinocchio won. On top of really loving that movie, I hope that means Del Toro's At the Mountain of Madness movie gets greenlit.
All this because they changed Ariel to be black. America deserves to be de-dollerized.
@@suzygirl1843 if you think that alone is the reason why people don't like what Disney is doing then you need a reality check
No, fr. Disney is kind of going down the toilet right now, and I don’t even hope they recover. I hate that company. All they really care about is making money from mediocre live action remakes and charging people asinine prices to go to their stupid amusement parks. Oh and don’t forget buying out all the smaller companies they can get their hands on (RIP Blue Sky). I’m genuinely so glad that movies from other companies are getting lots of recognition, and the only thing I really hope is that if Disney does end up falling apart their animators and writers and such can find well-paying jobs elsewhere.
@@suzygirl1843 no, “all this” because Disney is a money hungry corporation and has started prioritizing money over making honest quality content. From the censorship in their shows on Disney Channel to their live action remakes (that only exist to spark nostalgia so that people who liked the originals will watch), Disney is absolutely going down the toilet in terms of content. Sadly, they’re still making boatloads of money because of course they are. I genuinely hope they change their ways or fall apart like wet paper, and I genuinely don’t care about the Little Mermaid controversy.
@@chickennuggetpaw Everything in USA is low quality because of Nepo babies running things.
I love all quiet on the western front, and i’m willing to die on this hill. While I do agree it drags on a little long, but what makes it so amazing is how so unsettling the movie is. Unlike 1917, tragedy is the main focus, and I think it’s a perfection adaptation of the original. For history buffs, this movie is a no-brainer.
Word. I've gotten tired of the slander. Like do people just not understand war movies? I think All Quiet had the most memorable soundtrack out of them all. Like it's so creepy and industrial while being beautiful when needed.
@@fen1x_64the biggest bit of criticism I’ve seen of it is that the movie literally replaces the scene in which ‘all quiet on the western front’ is used to describe the day the protagonist died, to replace it with a bombastic final set piece, which yeah kinda ruins the point of the protagonists death, he didn’t die in some final blaze of pointless glory, he died on a relatively boring day pretty much randomly and for no reason at all.
i feel like saying you're "willing to die on this hill" is a very ironic way to phase that when you consider what the movie was about
I just think that the depiction of the war in the novel didn’t need the extra dramatization of being placed in the final days of the war.
@@deeznoots6241 Exactly. I was so mad they cut the furlough scene too. I don’t like the movie because of that. Just read the book, it’s 10x better.
That Puss in Boots meme at 11:28 always annoys me because there was also over a decade between the two Puss in Boots movies lol
I don't understand the thought process of depriving editors of an Oscar that they above and beyond deserve just because it's the most obvious choice lol. That was wild to hear. But yeah this was by far one of the best ceremonies in a long time!! Hard to decide whether this or 2020 was better
Yeah, that was totally nonsensical of goop.
I teared up so bad seeing Quan and Brendan Fraser winning Oscars what a moment seriously they deserve this so much I'm so happy for them
All quiet on the western front deserves way more respect! Its an incredible movie
I thought it was somewhat of a let down compared the older 1930 film and the book.
agreed
Although it didn’t follow the book, I think this one is definitely my favorite of all three. The movie definitely deserves the credit it deserves even if it does leave out some important parts that make the whole point of the movie
Yeah it changes things from the book and while i think some parts are worse then outher movies i do think the movie has the overall stronger points
While I always respect Shaffs opinion, vid is a good example of how theater kids and certain genres aren't a good mesh and distance should be kept lol
Agreed. Love schaff, but it’s clear he is entirely not the audience and maybe not that well versed on why war movies are what they are, what importance they serve, and most importantly, why they’re necessary enough to continue being made. That and this was Germany’s first big attempt at adapting it and they knocked it out of the park in my opinion. The metaphor that “war kills all soldiers” was visually displayed perfectly, especially by the ending.
Also, goop being all "EEAAO" shouldn't have won Best Editing, even though it was the most deserving." Like, sure.
The moment when Gel Del Torero made his speech on “Animation is Cinema” gave me needed hope for the future of animation.
Animation being treated with a slight hint of respect is an event worthy of an international holiday.
Pinocchio earned that win fair and square
These bots have gotten more annoying
@@MediaDroid960 no they didnt, puss in boots was better
@@jaroj1112 glad to see you don’t respect people’s opinions
All quiet on the western front was a great movie. It is such an honest depiction of war and could move me so much. I feel that schaff didn't like the movie because they are not as passionate about the history, which is completely fine.
He called it boring which rly rubs me the wrong way.
The reason most war films blend together is because they are just 2 hours of saving private ryan-esk violence, so to see one focus more on the characters and the banter between them, only then to show them be killed in battle made the film so much more impactful, even if it was a bit slow
@@couldntthinkofayoutubename6498 Yeah, can you imagine if there was a WWII film that wasn't about America beating Germany or Japan?
Rare Schaff shit take
It was a weak movie.
"if it's called all QUIET how does it have the best score??" is a line that I think is supposed to be a joke but like... come on james
Saying All Quiet is a standard war movie is the most brain dead take I think i've heard yet. The movie is a true anti-war film. It does not glorify, heroisize or revere the violence and waste of life. It is a war film from a German perspective. The score is amazing, the cinemetography is top notch, it absolutely deserved those oscars. You need to give it a second watch because if all you got from it is that it's a standard war film, then you did not understand it.
@Hope He did, but I understand his opinion. There are some generic themes like “War is hell” type stuff. The score especially, I believe the award should have gone to Babylon. But All Quiet is still pretty good
RRR is better though
@@beans00001It doesn't feel fair to compare the 2, since they're completly different movies
I REALLY wanted "Argentina 1985" to win, but I'm glad for the rest of the Oscars overall❤
I've followed this whole film award show circuit, and Brendan Fraser has been trying to hold back tears of joy this whole award show run. There's a clip where Ke Huy Quan hugs him after their wins and he just couldn't help but cry. Humans are so heartwarming.
You can tell from both Quan & Fraser's speech that they have both been through alot and I am glad both got the award & recognition they deserve!
Didn’t necessarily enjoy all quiet, but the score, whilst simple, was one of the most effective scores I’ve seen in a movie. It was so disorientating and unpredictable - fitting for the nature of the film. Babylon might’ve had a more technical and fun score, but all quiet made me feel incredibly on-edge😅 in the best possible way
Just hearing these speeches being described made me happy I’m so glad so many people got their favourite movies winning and even I’ve never seen them I could see the impact on the recipients faces
This was my favorite oscars ever. EEAAO was my favorite movie of 2022 so it was like watching my team win the superbowl but even more because I identified with the film so much as a Taiwanese-American. Truly one of the awards shows of all time
10:02 All quiet on the western front is the english translation for the book/movie, the original name is “Im Westen nichts Neues” which is actually means “nothing new in the west”. It’s based on how the author, who was a WW1 veteran, saw a newpaper that said the same thing even though he was there and it was absolutely horrible and full of typical war stuff. That being said I understand why you wouldn’t like it, because, while I haven’t finished the 2022 version, I doubt it’s better than the book or the 1930 movie. They seem pretty tame and normal when it comes to war media, but back then it was pretty unheard of to tell a story where war was shown in a bad light.
I think it was deserved it every category, except the score... Like it was electrifying in the moment but John Definitely deserved it. And I say that as it being my top 5 favourite movie this year.
The new movie was mediocre. The 1930 version is by far the better film and the book is the best.
it's definitely better than the 1930 movie without a doubt and I would prefer the new movie over the book any day personally from how great the movie was.
I haven’t even watched Everything, Everywhere all at once yet but it’s settled that I’d officially die if anyone did anything to make Ke Huy Quan Sad or say anything bad about him , sleep with one eye open folks.
I watched it for the first time yesterday. I HIGHLY recommend it. Beautiful, vibrant film, with stellar acting, directing, writing, cinematography, and music. It kept my attention and was easy to understand (something I didn't expect).
i was happy and impressed how most of the speeches were humble and greatful the number one being short rounds return speech that made everyone emotional
Of course the only time I miss the Oscars is when it's actually good and I've actually watched the movies nominated 🗿🗿🗿
All Quiet’s score win was deserved and I’ll go down with that opinion. Loved it. Eerie and edgy and contemporary without trying too hard. Fit the film great and I was psyched hearing it every time the movie won something.
Although to be fair I would have preferred Michael Abel’s work on Nope for the win (mind-blowingly good imo) but it wasn’t even nominated so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ oh well I guess
I think the score definitely was deserved too. It's mechanical and eerie score really made you feel like "So this is how the German War Machine sounds" type of feeling. I really think Schraff didn't understand the movie at all.
Ikr? That was one of my favorite scores of 2022 and everyone is clowning on Volker Bertelmann for winning and it hurts my feelings :(
Edit: These bots are insane
@@Sam-kz5sx I believe the context would have helped better understand what it was all about, both when it came to actual history and the previous AQOTWF movies, and even the book. To just chalk up All Quiet as just another war movie without understanding its significance is a bit unfair.
@@Sam-kz5sx yeah, not everything is gonna work for everyone but I really think a lot of people either straight up didn’t even watch All Quiet and just assumed they knew what it was or they zoned out/fucked around on their phones through it and then got mad later. Seen some really weird opinions on this movie and a lot of them genuinely make me think the people saying them didn’t even watch it and are just straight-up lying. Not at all saying Schaff’s in that camp and I get certain stuff being hit or miss with folks but I just can’t agree with anyone writing it off completely. It is very artistically impressive at the absolute bare minimum even if nothing else worked for the viewer. And it was among the lowest of my choices for BP! I didn’t even like it THAT much, just feel like it’s really not getting a fair shake at all.
Putting 1917 above All Quiet On The Western Front is the craziest take I have ever seen from James
I know like he really is shit talking all quiet on the western front for no reason it was a good movie
I know right he talks shit about it for no reason when it deserved all the awards it got
@@andromidathegalaxy6082 when he said that it was just your average war movie my soul died like it was a very good movie and the part where all the tanks start too come over the trenches is beautiful
It was a great film but am I the only one that thinks that the ending sucked, like really sucked. For me the film would've been so much better if the film ended when Tjaden died. Kat getting killed so close to the end felt like a cheap way to add brutality to a film that already had plently of it considering the subject matter, it really struck me as an incredibly forced gutpunch.
On top of all that the whole "last victory before armistice" sequence just genuinely felt like one of the writers really wanted to show off how much they liked Battlefield 1 and wanted to appease to the crowd that need all their war films to be packed full of epic combat where the protag is a one man army. Idk it just felt really out of touch with the rest of the film and how disempowering it was. It was such a curveball that it kind of ruined an otherwise excellent film for me.
@@no.7893 I disagree, there's no better way to show the pointlessness of war than a soldier dying in a conflict that's already over.
A lot of people seem to agree that Jaime Lee Curtis received the Oscar in recognition for her career as a whole (rather than for her specific role in EEAAO). While I'm very happy for Jaime, I do hope that Angela Bassett gets her flowers. 💐
(Also, I've loved Stephanie Hsu since she was Karen the Computer and Christina Canigula, and I can't wait to see what she does next!)
While I strongly dislike BMC, I loved her in SpongeBob, she was awesome
I don't watch the Oscars, but I'm glad you enjoyed this year's ceremony! And I'm glad most of the wins this year actually seemed deserved. 🙂
I'm so happy Pinocchio won, it's gonna be a huge boost for the stop motion medium that so badly needed. Puss in Boots 2 would've been a great winner as well, sure, but not as impactful i'd say. It'd be another win for DreamWorks, but also just another CGI winner. Pinocchio winning is much more meaningful and it's sending the message of "there's value in this medium". And someone like Guillermo carrying that message is very important.
Despite Puss in Boots 2 being objectively one of the best movies of all time, i was not surprised (but also glad) that Pinocchio won instead.
Sure a step in the right direction, but we have a long way to go before hollywood goes back to respect animation.
Outside of that ugly Sea Beast being nominated instead of stuff like My Father's Dragon, no animated movie was featured in other categories despite being more then deserving: tell me with a serious face that Puss did'nt deserve a nomination in screenplay and Pinocchio in direction, at LEAST
Honestly, ain't nobody have a chance to defeat Guillermo Del Toro. Dude is basically The Oscar's Golden Boy because The Oscar always like him. Remember he won the Oscar at 2018 by making Fish Banging movie.
are you totally forgetting marcel
@@edwardfalcus4417 I'm not! I loved Marcel the Shell with Shoes On and would've also been a worthy winner, as well to push forward the medium of stop motion
Thing is that the Oscars may reward Independent cinema, but not independent animated films, so it didn't have much of a chance other than being the runner up
Still, I'm glad it got it's spotlight in the Annie Awards
@@serenaso4669 As someone who loved My Father's Dragon and would've loved to see it nominated, I still think The Sea Beast was an extraordinary film. All the 5 movies nominated were amazing, a rare thing in this category (there's usually one or two that are mediocre or bad)
Seeing the rock’s character arc come full circle was incredible.
“ everything’s come full circle baby” - luz noceda
It was better depicted in the manga, imo
@@sandyr5407 yeah, the live adaptation doesnt slap as hard as the manga panel
I really doubt he gives a shit. It’s just good PR.
@@SaberRexZealot who knows, maybe acting in moana changed his mind
I always tear up seeing Brenan happy. Good tears. It's always so wholesome.
The Banshees of Inisherin not winning at least something is honestly really sad to me. I really enjoyed that movie, but oh well. The Oscars being actually good this year (and animation getting at least an ounce of respect) is good enough news for me.
Jamie Lee Curtis may not have been this year’s Best Supporting Actress, that honor goes to Stephanie Hsu no doubt about it, but she’s earned that award over the course of many years. The recognition was long overdue.
Absolutely.
It was almost like what happened when Di Caprio won best Actor: The Remenant was far from his best performance, but everyone was happy because that award for him was long overdue
I don't think she should've won either because Stephanie Tsu steals every scene in the movie either as Joy or Jobu Topaki and it should be Angela Bassett either because she's carrying Wakanda Forever on her back playing as a grieving mother who lost her family (except her daughter, Shuri who becomes the last survivor of Wakanda Royal Family) and her grieving is way more make sense than Wanda in Multiverse of Madness.
Just give her an honorary award then.
@@margarethmichelina5146 I am seeing a lot of people coming to bat for Angela Bassett, but the fact remains that no one ever will/should win an award for a Marvel movie.
All Quiet on the Western Front absolutely deserved to win something - I know its Schaffs opinion, but I think calling it a standard war movie and boring is an insult to this great film.
I don't like to be that guy who is like, "You just don't understand it." I think in this case Schaff just genuinely didn't.
@@machintosh3008 Yeah, but as a reviewer, you shouldnt be biased. And Schaff was completly biased for everything and ... antibiased? against Quiet, because it is a War movie.
I really dont like that he trash talked everything about it AND didnt even give them a fair share, like talking about the acceptance speech.
@@machintosh3008 YMS and rest of Sardonicast didn't think it was anything special either. And I agree with them. The problem with it is the fact that the original 1930 film is just better. Not to mention those bad CGI effects.
Yea it managed to be a war movie that successfully avoided glamorizing war completely. Most films that intend to be anti war still end up with audiences who are inspired to join military service because of scenes in the movie but All Quiet was just so overall demoralizing and really showed the pointlessness and brutality of war in a way I haven’t seen any other movies accomplish. None of the characters feel like heroes and the combat scenes are terrifying and suspenseful whereas in a “standard war film” the combat scenes would feel exciting. Calling it a standard war movie was a serious and rare lapse in judgement on his part
@@edwardrichtofen611 your bias LITERALLY makes up your reviews. this is the dumbest take i've ever seen. i haven't seen all quiet on the western front but schaff is allowed to not like war films and therefore not like all quiet.
I just wanna say I really like the editor putting in his input here, his input is really good to hear and I really like having a 2nd opinion during this
my head cannon is that the oscars watch schaffrillas video and took notes
I disagree with what you said about "All Quiet on The Western Front". It was probably one of my favorite movies of the year. I loved the score in relation with the scenes they were in. It helped completed the scenes and I still love to listen to the track. But then again I'm just a sucker for war movies and books.
Ke Huy Quan getting recognition made me very happy. He is probably one of my favorite actors. Like C'mon his performance in the Goonies and Indiana Jones is unforgettable.
Both The Rock, and Guillermo Del Toro showed immense respect for the medium of animation. I would have preferred if _Puss In Boots: The Last Wish_ won, but at least it wasn't _Turning Red._ Also, Jimmy Kimmel wasn't that cringy of a host, (this year anyway,) and of course, most of the award winners absolutely deserved their wins and their speeches were really moving. Overall an improvement, and I hope the Oscars continue to get better.
Agreed. I really love Turning Red but i think other animated movies deserved it more:)
Yep definitely more respect than actresses that literally portrayed Disney Princesses talking about how these movies are for kids and parents will be sick of them because they're not meant for adults
@@sarinabina5487 cringe
Turning Red was really good, but I think all the other movies in that category were better.
In all honesty, Turning Red was one of my favorite movies of last year, one of my favorite Pixar movies *ever*, but it didn't deserve the win, at least not in this year.
you and your family stay in my prayers. thank you for still making us content and making us smile
I rarely comment on CZcams videos but FANTASTIC TOUCH putting music from the persona soundtrack over the "best original score" section. Im shocked at how well the tone matches up to the video.
I liked All Quiet on the Western Front. It's a pretty good movie. Problem is you do have to understand the tragedy of WWI to experience the full impact of it. It's great when it comes to giving you an experience of the war from the German side. It shows you the desperation for the German men to get supplies. It shows how the men went into the war imagining it as a fun trip, which is how so many soldiers actually went into it. It displays how not even the main character is immune to death (although he does have some plot armor during the French armored assault). Overall it perfectly displays the tragedy of the war.
Schaff of course has a different opinion but I think it was good. It did not deserve Best Original Score though.
Just want to say the boy the mole the fox and the horse was so incredibly deserving of best animated short. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT TO EVERYONE. When I was going through a really rough patch I watched that film and I cried. Not only is every frame a beautiful masterpiece, and does so much justice to the book, but it also contains such a powerful message about kindness and compassion for one’s self that brings anyone to tears. I bought the hardcover version of the book for my 20th birthday and the artistry is simply phenomenal
Can 100% vouch. I got to watch it with my mum in the cinemas as it was showing with all the other oscar animated short nominees, and we absolutely loved it. My Mum just quite literally said, “I feel like I just got years worth of therapy in one short movie” and I couldn’t’ve agreed more. I was so happy to hear that it won.
i disagree. Every line feels like an ai generated motivational quote
I watch this movie since it came out like once a week. I cry every time
Will check it out, thanks for the recommendation
Looooove the book! We actually own two copies: one I bought for myself, and the other was given to my mom as a retirement gift with the gifter having no knowledge of me also having it.
I'm probably biased since I'm argentinian, but I really, really wanted Argentina 1985 to win; Not only for the gag of winning the third one (Ganamos la tercera), but also because it is simply, in my opinion, a great movie. It taught me about my country's history with the storys of the witnesses, that were truly heartbreaking, and that final speech that Darín's character does, that "Nunca Más" really brought me to tears. To put it simply, it made me quite emotional.
Despite my bitter thoughts, however, it was a well deserved win for All Quiet in the Western Front. All in all, like you said, a surprisingly good Oscar's.
And to anyone who is interested in documental-like movies, that talk about a dark period in a country's history, I hugely recommend Argentina 1985.
i actaully really like listening to both of your voices going over stuff
The original All Quiet On The Western Front was a special movie, especially for when it was released. I am not as qualified to explain all of it, since I haven't seen it yet. However, Wendigoon covered the whole thing and why it mattered.
The Novel is one of my favorite books, and 1930 adaptation is the absolute perfect version for me, and one of my favorite films of all time. The new adaptation just doesn’t hold a candle to it for me. Imo, the new version is *just* ok, Nothing more, nothing less.
Also, Overly Sarcastic Productions has a video on the book. And boy, both vidos get very depressing.
My respect for the editor went wayyyy up when he mentioned one piece, that movie has incredible music and ado is an extremely talented artist
All quiet on the western front is the first war movie that’s truly made me sob and despise humanity. There’s no uplifting moment just pure despair and brilliant acting.
i was at a rehearsal dinner for my friend's wedding during the oscars, but the oscars were playing on the tv in the background. every once in a while someone would tune in to what was going on, but naturally we didnt pay a whole lot of attention to the screen. but whe ke huy quan one an oscar, everyone stopped what they were doing to listen to his speech. it was a really cool moment to see a room of 20 to 30 people all celebrate the success of one actor whose character and integrity really strands out
My mom and I both think the same thing about Jamie Lee's win. The Academy is making up for ignoring her for so long. Stephanie Hsu really deserved to win it, but I'm not too mad it went to Jamie. I'd pretty much given up on the Oscars but this year was amazing.
I think part of the reason why jamie won it was because horror is not respected at the oscars (parasite is the cloest horror-ish movie I can think of) and her nomination kind of gave her a way in for that (I didn't see black panther but Stephanie deserves an honorary oscar she did amazing)
y’know considering how good this year’s show was, it retroactively made the 2022 show worse
this year felt like everyone involved really cared about the mediums of film, music and animation
last year felt like the Kids Choice Awards with a little slap thrown in
That's an insult to the kids choice awards
@@Shadamyfan-rs8xc yeah true, they at least feel a little professional
As a chinese/asian girl, I’m so happy Everywhere Everything all at once cast won! Gives me hope
I agree with everything except all quiet on the western front. It’s probably because I have an emotional attachment to that movie as I watched the 70’s version sophomore year of high school, but I still think it’s a top tier war movie