Salam alaykum everyone. There is a playlist in the Mufti's channel about this topic. You can go to the playlist, scroll down and you will see a playlist with a title "Clarifying False Hadith Which Insult Islam". Hope will gave us all benefit, God willing. Peace be upon you.
Mufti, could you send me the sources where I can read about the critics on al-Bukhari, al-Firabri and the different opinions of the students of al-Firabri in English or if not possible in arabic?
Salam Brother, you can search it on Mufti Abu Layth Channel... .go to the playlist, scroll down and you will see a playlist with its title "Clarifying False Hadith Which Insult Islam". Peace be upon you.
@Adnan Shafi, like the Hadith on “If it was not for Eve, women would not have disobeyed their husbands. 2- If it was not for Bani Israel disobedience (in the matter of Salwa ) meat would not have rotten, etc, these Israeliyyah Hadiths.
Mufti I am studying Arabic language in a Deobandi madrasa but the teacher always tells about his sect and about Deobandi scholars only and I am myself want to study neutral and I think if I argue with him on any topic like why they always call thereself Deobandi and hanafi so I think for that they can kick me out of there madrasa so now mufti sahb kindly guide me what should I do or give me any cool advise
Just learn what you are learning...do your research when you finish your academic life in madrasa . If u start to research and look into different kinds of opinions and sects at the beginning of your student life, you will go nowhere... So please concentrate on what your present curriculum is ..
@@TheQuranExplainsItself Bold talk from a midwit. Child when adults are speaking it's best you stay quiet. You know the ol' saying, "Better to keep your mouth shut and thought an idiot, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.
AsSalaamu 'Alaykum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu Mufti Ji. The Hadith about Dogs and Statues/Pictures at home. Please can you clarify. BarakaAllah Feekum
@Aakash Kumar Watch his video on Aisha where he provides his credentials , dear brother . And pertaining to the matter on qualified institutions saying yes to matters , not all qualified institutions at the same level often agree on all matters and many a times there is “Ikhtilaf” on the opinion . So such matters should be resolved with understanding. As for revering the Hadith, while I do stand with the notion of studying Hadith , I dont believe in revering it to great heights . Also , contextual matter should be understood well. Even the Quran is to be understood rather than following it blindly. Yes, it is true that these days criticising Hadith has become something of a taboo and is a thing to be shunned with.
@Aakash Kumar Its not just Islam . All religions are bound to contain a lot of stuff that is surely going to make people feel embarrassed about their faiths. If one studies Christianity, Judaism , Hinduism or any religion involving the concept of deity and supernatural, there are bound to be stuff that in their faiths that theyll discard . Everyone knows about how Christian empires have plundered many lands in the past in the name of Christ. The rules of war in Deuteronomy for the Jews are very harsh which straightaway mentions that enemy nations during war ought to be executed straight way , be it woman , child or man. The concept of extramarital relationships is also very fraught with the idea that a capital punishment should be present for them. The practice of sati, caste- based hierarchy wherein each caste is radically different than the other with some being superior and some being inferior is something that exists in the Indian sub continent even today .(Sati stopped though) Also, the concept of granting deification to animals is often criticised by others for lack of sense. However these are their beliefs and it is their right to believe what they want to . So , yeah embarrassing moments await people of every faith when it comes to religion and yes their numbers will grow in the coming years which people from each and every faith either discarding certain information or lessening its likely impact if it proves to be a source of embarrassment which cannot be properly explained. But its their right to explain their faith , just as it is the right of the Muslims to explain theirs or the Christians right to explain theirs or the Hindus right to explain theirs. You must be a Hindu so how do you explain years of Sati or Caste-based injustice or squabbles between Hindu empires ( from what I do know , it wasnt a monolithic Hindu empire , each and every kingdom was different and fights used to take place even before the conquest by Muslims)or the practice of worshipping animals especially the cow wherein care would be more for the cow than family members and the fact that inter-caste based relationships is frowned strictly. You will most probably say , these are things not relevant today or will explain something or in the end , would flat out deny it but you do know that many of these things are true and were prevalent ages ago. Its your right to explain it as its your faith , brother ( probably , you could be an atheist as well ). Even I heard other wild superstitious stuff pertaining to Hinduism pertaining to reincarnation , karma , curses but in this I do know that most of the Hindus dont follow this and it surely must not be true for them. Well , here in Canada , some of my friends are Hindus , having known them from childhood and they too have faced embarrassing moments when some people questioned what they perceived as “fallacies” in their faith. The Christians too are embarrassed big time on the movie and entertainment front . So yeah , every man or woman with a religion will face embarrassing questions when it comes to their religion.
@Aakash Kumar of course text of the quran is not altered and yes around 95 percent of the Quran can be understood easily and the rest 5 percent too is not that difficult which is where scholars should explain . Some scholars explanations are accepted , some are not .
@Aakash Kumar i didnt blame other religions , dear brother . Also , why are you stuck with Al-Azhar and Dar -Al-Ifta when you have the Ulema at Makkah as well or the Deobandi School of thought or Mutazilla school of thought as well.
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Mufti you're spreading the truth among people when others are trying to hide it.
May God protect you.
May Allah bless you Mufti abu Layth
Thought-provoking!
Keep up the good work your doing
Salam alaykum everyone.
There is a playlist in the Mufti's channel about this topic.
You can go to the playlist, scroll down and you will see a playlist with a title "Clarifying False Hadith Which Insult Islam".
Hope will gave us all benefit, God willing.
Peace be upon you.
Mufti, could you send me the sources where I can read about the critics on al-Bukhari, al-Firabri and the different opinions of the students of al-Firabri in English or if not possible in arabic?
Nice ❤️
I need more examples of such ahadeeths where narrators are authentic while matn is not. Thanks
Salam Brother, you can search it on Mufti Abu Layth Channel...
.go to the playlist, scroll down and you will see a playlist with its title "Clarifying False Hadith Which Insult Islam".
Peace be upon you.
@Adnan Shafi, like the Hadith on “If it was not for Eve, women would not have disobeyed their husbands. 2- If it was not for Bani Israel disobedience (in the matter of Salwa ) meat would not have rotten, etc, these Israeliyyah Hadiths.
Mufti I am studying Arabic language in a Deobandi madrasa but the teacher always tells about his sect and about Deobandi scholars only and I am myself want to study neutral and I think if I argue with him on any topic like why they always call thereself Deobandi and hanafi so I think for that they can kick me out of there madrasa so now mufti sahb kindly guide me what should I do or give me any cool advise
Where can i find Maliki madrasa or any institute of that fiqh in Karachi?
Just learn what you are learning...do your research when you finish your academic life in madrasa .
If u start to research and look into different kinds of opinions and sects at the beginning of your student life, you will go nowhere...
So please concentrate on what your present curriculum is ..
👍
Drop the bloody Hadiiths why’s that so difficult?
How would you know how to pray and prepare for prayer, absent the hadith?
@@oisinofthefianna3246 besides your indoctrination why do you believe prayer has a “ how “?
Everything we do in this life has a how and methods, that is a really bad formulated question
@@darrenrichards3351 how do you eat? Walk? Should I continue?
Prayer has a definition, you fulfil the definition.
@@TheQuranExplainsItself Bold talk from a midwit. Child when adults are speaking it's best you stay quiet. You know the ol' saying, "Better to keep your mouth shut and thought an idiot, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.
Make bukhari gate in urdu...
YES! Our desi folk need this!
I do not believe Hadith this things are not 100% correct.
Please Mufti sahab
I request Make A Video on Allama Khadim Hussain Rizvi Funeral Prayers
And Non-believers Reacts
Etc.
thanks
AsSalaamu 'Alaykum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu Mufti Ji.
The Hadith about Dogs and Statues/Pictures at home. Please can you clarify.
BarakaAllah Feekum
mufti you did not give any proof for your claim.
@Aakash Kumar Watch his video on Aisha where he provides his credentials , dear brother . And pertaining to the matter on qualified institutions saying yes to matters , not all qualified institutions at the same level often agree on all matters and many a times there is “Ikhtilaf” on the opinion . So such matters should be resolved with understanding. As for revering the Hadith, while I do stand with the notion of studying Hadith , I dont believe in revering it to great heights . Also , contextual matter should be understood well. Even the Quran is to be understood rather than following it blindly. Yes, it is true that these days criticising Hadith has become something of a taboo and is a thing to be shunned with.
@Aakash Kumar Its not just Islam . All religions are bound to contain a lot of stuff that is surely going to make people feel embarrassed about their faiths.
If one studies Christianity, Judaism , Hinduism or any religion involving the concept of deity and supernatural, there are bound to be stuff that in their faiths that theyll discard .
Everyone knows about how Christian empires have plundered many lands in the past in the name of Christ.
The rules of war in Deuteronomy for the Jews are very harsh which straightaway mentions that enemy nations during war ought to be executed straight way , be it woman , child or man.
The concept of extramarital relationships is also very fraught with the idea that a capital punishment should be present for them.
The practice of sati, caste- based hierarchy wherein each caste is radically different than the other with some being superior and some being inferior is something that exists in the Indian sub continent even today .(Sati stopped though)
Also, the concept of granting deification to animals is often criticised by others for lack of sense.
However these are their beliefs and it is their right to believe what they want to .
So , yeah embarrassing moments await people of every faith when it comes to religion and yes their numbers will grow in the coming years which people from each and every faith either discarding certain information or lessening its likely impact if it proves to be a source of embarrassment which cannot be properly explained.
But its their right to explain their faith , just as it is the right of the Muslims to explain theirs or the Christians right to explain theirs or the Hindus right to explain theirs.
You must be a Hindu so how do you explain years of Sati or Caste-based injustice or squabbles between Hindu empires ( from what I do know , it wasnt a monolithic Hindu empire , each and every kingdom was different and fights used to take place even before the conquest by Muslims)or the practice of worshipping animals especially the cow wherein care would be more for the cow than family members and the fact that inter-caste based relationships is frowned strictly. You will most probably say , these are things not relevant today or will explain something or in the end , would flat out deny it but you do know that many of these things are true and were prevalent ages ago. Its your right to explain it as its your faith , brother ( probably , you could be an atheist as well ). Even I heard other wild superstitious stuff pertaining to Hinduism pertaining to reincarnation , karma , curses but in this I do know that most of the Hindus dont follow this and it surely must not be true for them. Well , here in Canada , some of my friends are Hindus , having known them from childhood and they too have faced embarrassing moments when some people questioned what they perceived as “fallacies” in their faith. The Christians too are embarrassed big time on the movie and entertainment front . So yeah , every man or woman with a religion will face embarrassing questions when it comes to their religion.
@Aakash Kumar which is why explanations are given brother so that one can understand
@Aakash Kumar of course text of the quran is not altered and yes around 95 percent of the Quran can be understood easily and the rest 5 percent too is not that difficult which is where scholars should explain . Some scholars explanations are accepted , some are not .
@Aakash Kumar i didnt blame other religions , dear brother . Also , why are you stuck with Al-Azhar and Dar -Al-Ifta when you have the Ulema at Makkah as well or the Deobandi School of thought or Mutazilla school of thought as well.
Stick with the collared shirts. :-)