Acrylic Paint Comparison Liquitex Basics vs Winsor Newton vs Golden Quality and Colorfastness Test
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2020
- Acrylic Paint Comparison Liquitex Basics vs Winsor Newton vs Golden Quality and Colorfastness Test
• Acrylic Paint Comparis...
▷▷▷ SUBSCRIBE BELOW IF YOU HAVEN'T ALREADY◁◁◁
→ bit.ly/subscribetocoty
⮞⮞ Find Me Here ⮜⮜
My Christian Articles Site: asoulredeemed.com
My Poetry Site: cotyjschwabe.com
My books: amzn.to/3Ydgl7g
⮞⮞ Other Cool Sites (Affiliated) ⮜⮜
Cheats Codes: cheatscodes.me
Coupon Free Deals: couponfreedeal.com
Trusting God More: trustinggodmore.com
How to Mine Bitcoin: howtominebitcoin.com
Get Web Hositng here: webhositng.com
➤➤ Supplies You Can Get Online (affiliate links)
Favorite Website hosting: bit.ly/2TShuQX
Painting Supplies: amzn.to/2TAqWJR
Blick Art Supplies: bit.ly/2xuogVj
Online Art Lessons: bit.ly/34QxMil
A Way to Make Money From Home: bit.ly/2xOmLC3
➤➤ OTHER POPULAR PAINTING VIDEOS:
→ how to paint like jackson pollock: • ▷ How to Paint Like Ja...
→ Requiem of Summer (a Pollock Style Painting): • Requiem of Summer - ...
→ Streams of Mercy (Gerhard Richter Style Painting): • "Streams of Mercy" Ger...
Music Provided by Harris Heller Beats:
/ @streambeatsbyharrishe...
I hope you enjoy my abstract art and painting techniques, tutorials, and demonstrations!
This is a great vid Cody! Thanks 🙏 I’m a selling artist that actually prefers the more affordable Liquitex Basics (or Michaels Artist Loft, etc). The lower pigmentation in them means I can create paintings that are more translucent. I do finish with a final coat of gloss varnish!
I’m with you. After seeing that gloss is really the only thing affected, it makes sense to be able to produce more work, and then gloss the ones that sell.
Coty Schwabe yes! That’s exactly how I do it. Also the painting photographs better for Instagram and potential print reproductions before the gloss varnish.
Lightfastedness refers to the pigment's keeping its original color over a long period of time, so theoretically all the paint colors, in being colorfast, will still have the originally artist-intentioned color balance and contrasts.
Drying true to wet color and gloss retention is what's tested here.
came here to say this. (good video otherwise!)
Rather unfair to compare Liquitex Basics and W&N Galeria with Golden. The first two are student grade paints, and the third is a professional grade paint, hence the massive leap in price. 'Matteness' versus 'glossiness' is nothing to do with quality or colourfastness. Pull up a chair, as making paints is an artform in itself, and nothing is quite as straightforward as it is might first appear...
To test colourfastness, you'd need to leave your swatched paper in a sunny window and check it every 6 months for a few years. But we've no real need to do that as all decent manufacturers have done that _for us_ for many years and at great length, using ASTM - the industry recognised testing for pigment permanence.
Matteness or glossiness is also no indicator of quality. How matte or shiny a paint is, is more to do with the binders used for that particular pigment - this is partly determined by the pigment load the manufacturer chooses to incorporate, and quality of the pigment used. The Golden paint appeared *thicker* because it's a _heavy body_ acrylic, and would - by most professional artists be thinned using an extender, while not reducing the intensity of the pigment. The economy is ultimately a false one as you need much less Golden paint ratio to extender, and still get the same effect.
With a top-notch brand like *Golden,* the fact that they use no fillers, extenders, toners, driers or opacifiers in the paint means that each colour is formulated based on the _nature of the pigment_ - as each pigment behaves differently. This means the handling properties and appearance _between_ Golden colours (and consequently their drying times, opacity and lustre) can vary considerably. It's not as straightforward as to pronounce Golden paints are _this_ texture, because each colour varies. Colours that can tolerate being made with a high pigment-to-binder ratio will dry to be more matte and opaque. The Golden colours that can't tolerate having a high pigment content will dry to be more transparent and glossy.
Liquitex has it's own feature of self-levelling properties. It’s got a low viscosity meaning it won't retain your brush strokes, which to the human eye is read as 'glossier'.
You also rather prejudged the paint quality purely from price at 2:56 - before you'd swatched them or even opened the tubes! Confounding your results with confirmation bias, somewhat - tsk - did you not do science at school?! 😂
As a paint quality comparison video, it's ultimately rather frustrating if the tester doesn't even understand the _basics_ of how pigments, density, and pigment size factor in the end quality - nor what the term colourfastness actually _means._ The making of paint really is an art in and of itself, and it can't really be boiled down to three stripes on a bit of paper, drying it with a heat gun (Dear God...) and making a pronouncement 2 minutes later.
At the very least a 'blind taste test' would have served you far better, I think.
I came across to your video and i was looking for a decent Acrylic paint . I been painting for some of my family but the paints are decent .I wanted to search for a better paint that wont break my pocket .I choose Winsor Newton and Liquitex .Now it depends where i can buy it and fining the color that wont hurt my pocket. By the way im in my late 50s starting my art painting, drawing and coloring late .Had to take care family first . I hope everything goes well for you and your family .Thank You !
That's the video I was looking for. Thanks for uploading 😌
No problem 😊
Thanks for this test. I'm just learning to paint. I love abstract and often attempt different techniques. I have thought about comparing different paint brands by doing a drip test, painting the canvas with paint then spraying water on the paint and allowing it to drip down the canvas. I don't know if there is a proper name for this technique, but it seems to be used a lot in abstract work. When attempting this it seems I never get a good saturation of color with Liquitex. It most often looks watered down, barely visible when dry. I just figured it was the amount of pigment in the cheaper Liquitex. I'd love to see how other paints would fair. I've only ever used Liquitex so have no way of comparison. Anyway if you're interested in another comparison test perhaps this would be a good one to try. Could prove interesting. Thanks again. And I enjoy your channel. Keep up the good work.
Maybe I will dilute them and use them and see how they turn out dried. Great suggestion!
I appreciate the effort creating the video but this was NOT a good comparison. Actually it was a very poor one. The Golden paint used was professional/ artist quality. The others are student/basic paints. Smearing paint on a piece of paper gives very lil info. You didn't show any coverage, mixed no tint, tone or shade and mixed no secondary colours. Also the way you used some of the terms were incorrect eg colourfastness.
Yes, this!!!
"Basics" ain't student but alright
Not the best comparison. The reason for the higher cost is 1) the size of the pigment in the paint (smaller = $$$) and 2) the amount of pigment.
Next time 1) see how many coats of paint it takes to cover a black line 100% and 2) how much you can thin it using an appropriate medium and still be vibrant.
Each paint has its place.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Which acrylic (just main warm & cool colors needed to mix) & maybe a couple (like magenta or some purple) do you feel would work best w sometimes not always best acrylic paints in pbn’s & like where don’t need to add lots of different mediums (of course water & flow retard can help or hurt)!
So far have returned 3 different brands (heard not great about Arteza & do you feel decent opaque & coverage)?
So from your test, W & N has that shine, Golden still didn’t spread as long but never tried Liquatex acrylics but their gesso is good. Ty for video & so many questions, then trying 👌🏽.
@@appleknocker56 If you want a good medium grade acrylic paint, then the W&N Galeria, Amsterdam, or Vallejo acrylics are solid bets. Ultimately nothing beats Golden, though. You'll use a comparatively tiny amount (diluted with extender) due to the fine grade and high intensity of the pigment load. Have fun! 🎨
This is what i need! I would like to see layer by layer of how the paint will build up opacity and color
Hi there . thanks for your effort but unfortunately this is not an accurate comparison.
Cerulean blue hue is not a single pigment colour. It is a combination of different pigments like Phthalo blue, black and white etc., trying to resemble the original Cerulean blue. Every company uses different combinations . So you are actually comparing different combinations of pigments. For the comparison to be true and accurate you have to compare a single pigment colour that is the same across brands, like ultramarine ( PB29 )or phthalo green (PG7).
Great suggestion!
Actually, gloss comes from the amount of gloss medium in the paint, not so much the amount of pigment. (However, the ratio of binder and medium to pigment of course can affect the vibrancy of the paint.) You can get the gloss effect by adding gloss medium when you're mixing or varnish it at the end. If you don't like the gloss effect, you can add matte medium to the paint. I think all the paints you tested are of ok quality, just depends on the technique. The Golden paint seems a bit more heavy body, which makes it more suitable for impasto style painting. The Galleria is actually W&N's student grade acrylics, but it's good quality I think; great for its bright pop colours. I haven't tried the Liquitex, but it looks alright. Excellent vid! All the best!
Actually ... the sheen comes from the fine or coarser grind of the pigments used, and the pigments themselves when in top quality acrylic lines. Cheaper or student grades use agents to unify sheens. That's why if using a top quality line, ultramarine will be matte and Pthalo will be gloss
I've heard many cases when a beginner chooses acrylic, they should start off with Student grade paint and Professional grade paint?? Which paint is great and effective for begginer enthusiasts
Thanks for the insight brother 👍
I like liquitex
A more fair comparison would be Liquitex Heavy Body compared to Golden. This is like apples to oranges.
I have a colour of liquitex heavy body acyilic paints of seperate 24 shades
Thank you for this video. Its realy helpfull. I love the brand liquitex basics. The colours are so fibrant and the texture is realy great to work whit.
I don't prefer liquitex basics, it's glossy but not at all rich, we can see canvas surface.. Not at all thick
@@sach02 Yep, If you want vibrancy of colour nothing beats Golden imo, once people have saved and bought a little tube of their own they usually get what the fuss is all about. Ultimately, you get what you pay for. Liquitex is cheaper, but you'll plough through it by comparison.
Worth noting is that both Liqutex and W&N are student grade paint while Golden is artist quality
I appreciate your effort. Liquitex gets a bad rap because it's called student grade. It's actually high quality and holds its own against the pricey acrylics. There's only so much pigment acrylic can hold before it stops binding properly and still be capable of thinning with water or medium. It's not like oil that has a lot more holding capacity.
I've been doing a lot of comparisons between the brands lately and I've found Royal Talens Amsterdam Standard acrylics becoming my favorite. Even a better combination of pigment load, finish and price point than Liquitex. I'm going to get a set of their Expert Acrylics to see what differences there are besides price.
Royal talons lightfastness is a 3, compared to liquitex which is a 1. Wont the royal talons paint start to lose its color after 20 years?
@@honsville shop by pigment. the pigment is what really matters, not the manufacturer rating. A consistent lightfastness rating between brands is a good indication. A bad rating from a brand could be a labeling error.
@@ricosdaddyo1784 thank you for the reply. I've heard really good reviews from them. I'll have to check that out when I'm ready to order some paint. :)
You're right. When a specific color reaches its ideal pigment concentration, it's essentially the same quality, regardless of the brand. That's why I don't purchase from expensive brands for Titanium White, as even the cheapest options contain a satisfactory pigment concentration since Titanium dioxide pigments are cheap, and therefore, Ti white is cheap to manufacture.
Which one would be best for using on plastic models
I don' t understand the logic of comparing artist grade golden with student grade liquitex basics and winsor newton galeria
Just showing us what many were curious to see. A simple but interesting comparison.
What some sell as student is very high quality compared to other manufacturer's student grades.
@@user-ck4hq8vy2l May I ask what you actually learned from this video? What did it help to understand about the paints shown? Because if I was new to acrylics and someone showed me this, I'd be none the wiser after watching, tbh!
Wow, that was extremely helpful, thank you! Great video.
Great vid as normal
I've been using a brand called Sennelier its great paint and comes in a bag instead of a tube...a few video's on you tube showing it used
Never heard of it but there are so many brands. And yeah - the colors look about the same but the shine is definitely different afterwards for each.
@@CotySchwabe the bag design of Sennelier is different but it's definitely a help
@@CotySchwabe Sennelier is old French brand. They have excellent oil paints.
I love the dullness of a matte paint like with her liquitex.. I don’t buy satin or gloss
#Artist #Are #Risnes #acquired #Winsor #and #Newton, #Galeria #Acrylic
🎉 The secret to maximising your paints lies in enhancing their qualities: Galeria Acrylic is a high-quality acrylic paint which delivers professional results, ideal for artists who want high quality more accessible range. The Galeria Acrylic range offers excellent brilliance, professional quality pigments, opacity and permanence with a smooth, satin finish. Galeria uses either the same pigments as the professional range or a similar pigment, but in a lower concentration. This makes it easy to use with, or transition to artists' grade when a wider choice and higher pigment strength is needed.
I think the liquatex has more pigment and that's why its not shiny. Shiny means the surface has less tooth so layers won't stick. So liquatex being more matt, more pigment is better for what I do. Its best to varnish paintings at the end anyway to make the surface shine uniform.
Hi I used liquitex basic acrylic paint on canvas, but I'm very disappointed that it's not at all thick. I can see the canvas through the paint even though I apply two layers it's not getting opaque..
Is there any way I can make my paint rich in pigment
Yes, save your money and invest in some Golden paints and extender! You can't _"make_ your paints rich in pigment". That's down to the manufacturing stage. Thickness is not what you need, what you seek is coverage through *density of pigment,* and that means spending a bit more money if you don't want to lay the cheap stuff on with a trowel. Your frustrating experience this far bears this out - you've already used well over twice what you'd have used with Golden, so the economy is a false one, and you've also the disappointment of paint and time wasted, when ultimately I imagine you're painting for pleasure. And your canvas may not hold up to repeated overpainting if you get another unsatisfying result.
If you look on the side of your tube of paint, it should be graded for opacity, permanence, light-fastness etc. You're heading for something that ideally says 'O' (EDIT: Liquitex has a little scale of squares near the cap: ▣ ◪ ▢), and then AA or A (permanence scale) .
*T/O - (Transparency/Opacity Scale)*
Transparent colours are usually marked ‘T’
Semi-transparent ‘ST’.
Relatively opaque colours are marked ‘O’
Semi-opaque ‘SO’.
Here's the info for Golden Paints: www.goldenpaints.com/technicaldata/pigment
Winsor & Newton have a little video here: www.winsornewton.com/uk/masterclass/permanence-in-colour/
Have fun!
Hello Coty Schawbe's Art. Can you review these colours of liquitex basics and winsor and Newton galaria? Cadmium red middle hue Cadmium Yellow middle hue Cobalt blue hue Titanium white Mars black Silver and Gold. If you do thank you and thanks for this video
so shouldn't you have compared Liquitex Heavy body instead of the basics?
Colourfastness is not a thing. Comparing student grade to professional grade is nonsense, naturally they will be different. Each brand has different characteristics and you choose what works best for you.
some people genuinly want to see the comparison to see what fits them best without having to buy a bunch of paint
@@woelchar1797 But they're not able to 'see the comparison', though. The info provided in this video is both ill-informed and useless unfortunately - how can anyone see what 'fits them best' from this word salad video?!
Crucially, it doesn't compare the things that _actually_ matter - whether you're a student, _or_ a pro artist, with deep pockets or _shallow_ ones. There are YT videos that give far more useful comparisons to anyone on a budget.
I use winsor products. They aren't the best but they always deliver a decent product be it oil or otherwise. Get used to products that will stick around and work it out. Even in this test I like that winsor blue color...it's familiar.
For the price, you can't go wrong with Liquitex. Not to mention, that they have a professional grade as well.
Winsor and Newton is almost the same as liquitex but the paint from golden is thicker. That doesnt mean one brand is better than the other. Like u sayed its what the painter prefers
Sheen is determined by the final grind characteristics (coarse/fine) of each pigment in top quality lines. ie. ultramarine=matte Pthalo=gloss. Unified sheen lines add gents to unify.
Student grade is fine until mixing colours you will notice drastic differences. Student also has longer shelf life due to higher water content. There is a Canadian company called Tri-art that makes everything including tubes/containers. They are as good if not better than Golden at 40% less cost. They also have an older line called True Colour which is slightly lower pigment amount for a good $ reduction, and then their pro student line Rheotech is by far the best student line and guaranteed to be so.
Not my thing but Tri-art also is the only line that has patent on a colour they uniquely developed called liquid mirror, that is not a silvery/sparkle or fake mirror but ext. luminous something, it is a series 11 or higher so $$$ ... $$$ lol
Yep, mixing student grade paints = mild peril as muddiness often follows.
You do pay more for Golden Acrylics, I have tried a lot of 'brands' for professional artworks and some are just too thin or the quality is just not there...*cough* W&N. Old Holland are pretty good too. I have learnt the hard way, cheaping out on materials actually costs you more, especially when it comes to the purity and range of the pigment and binder.
You can make quality paintings with all three brands here. You just have to adjust your technique to suit the materials, and you might end up requiring more layers with the lighter pigment load in the Basics. I don't agree that you can charge more money for your art simply because you used more expensive materials.
I’m not saying you have to ramp the price up but if your goal is to make a profit then you would have to charge more to cover higher costs.
I wanna try from winsor and Newton the galaria 7 colours Cadmium red hue,Cadmium yellow middle hue,Cobalt blue hue Titanium white Mars black Silver and Gold. Its the same pallet of colours i like to use for my acrylic paints from liquitex so i can compare the two. Cause liquitex basics is getting expensiver than winsor and Newton galaria. I like this video
I hate galleria paints they are so watery !! Try system 3
😂 he got a blue glove on so he can go wrong. I can agree the color look different
The title of the video is partly deceiving. 'Colorfastness' typically refers to how a paint accurately maintains its colour integrity over time when exposed to light - both ambient and direct (as in sunlight). Most but not all acrylic paint varies in colour from wet to dry, and this is what your test is actually comparing. Colour-fastness will vary from brand to brand and from colour to colour depending on pigment composition, with pinks and violets usually being most prone to fading. Almost universally all fluorescent colours are not colour-fast and will fade very quickly when exposed to light.
Windsor.
_Winsor._ There's no 'D' in it. It's not like Windsor Castle! 🏰 _If_ you're going to correct someone's spelling at least know what you're talking about before you start.
I bought winsor and i find it horrible to use
Golden is a professional paint, Winsor and Newton Galleria and Liquidex Basics are both student paint. This comparison is non-sense.
You Can compare those paint, but none of the 2 student paint reach the quality of golden, golden is more bodyied paint, if you mix with their fluid Line you Can have the same concistancy of the two others, the pigments used in the paint are different, golden use Real Cobalt pigments, that is more sightly more lightfast than the mix with phtalocyanin blue the others use, golden is more pigmented, if you add medium, you Can reach the pigment level of the student paint
I was thinking the same....
Golden is arguably the best brand of acrylic. It's also very pricey, but the pigment load is incredibly high
Liquitex heavy body acrylics (their artist grade acrylics) is on one level with Golden, also Winsor and Newton artist grade acrylics. Those should have been compared.
Winsor Newton is a true cerulean the other two not.
I learned nothing.
Same.
@@CotySchwabe i did.. thanks
You can use the cheapest paint and still sell your paintings. One of the biggest art forgers used cheap wall paint and sold the paintings as originals. If you don't sell your paintings for millions don't be so narrow-minded, it comes across as snobbish, and this philosophy got berried in the 1900s.
الللهم صل و سلم على نبينا محمد وعلى آله الطيبين الطاهرين وعجل فرجهم الشريفف💕
Why?