Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Jinnah क्या Pakistan नहीं चाहते थे? पाकिस्तानी प्रोफेसर Ishtiaq Ahmed ने पूरा चिट्ठा खोल दिया | GITN
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2023
- Shop for Upakarma Pure Shilajit for strength, stamina & energy:
Amazon - amzn.to/436HNFw
Official Website - bit.ly/upakarm...
Flipkart - bit.ly/3MyW5rq
Full Interview Link: • धर्म के आधार पर देश से...
Pakistani writer and political scientist Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed in Guest in the newsroom. He talks about the difference between India and Pakistan. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed has written books about Jinnah's failures. He talks about the failures of democracy in Pakistan. Also talks about the disadvantages of building a country on the basis of religion. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed shares many stories of the time of partition. He shares how he reunited many families who were separated because of the Partition. Watch the full interview to know what Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed thinks on the current situation in Pakistan.
LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Ravi Gangwar
It is very interesting to listen to Dr Ahmad. My parents migrated from Multan and Bahawalpur in 1947. Best wishes from multani Indians, #multaniindians
anchor and audience sitting cross legged in front of Guest doesn't seem respectful 🙄
हाँ भाई एक जुर्म में पुलिस वाले मुझे पकड़कर ले गए थे उन्होंने भी मुझे ऐसे ही कुर्सी पे बैठाकर बलपूछताछ की थीं😢😢😢
I agree
What you can expect from lalantop.
Lallantop should first teach their staffs how to sit Infront of an intellectual .
@@waghmarenilesh5421 casual conversation me bhi etiquette hota hai cheap jaahil lalantop biradari k tum lodey
Tameez, Sanskar, Manners are absent in journalists of this news channel. Atleast respect his age and sit on chair and interview him..
You definitely need soft skills...
Tameez aur sanskar bohot subjective hai. This is the format of the show. Absolutely everyone is interviewed this way. Please dekh lo. It is not to disrespect Dr.Ahmed.
Did the anchor forgot to pay respect to elders. Though he is from Pakistan he is respectable person.Shame on Anchor.
Seed of Pakistan was sownn by sir syed ahmed khan, philosophically enriched by allama iqbaal and politically realized by jinnah, supported by two natoion theory and gifted by his opponents.
Ha sir syed ahmed khan ne bola tha jab muslim hindu soldiers the army me fir kyuki ek saath rehte hai to bhai ban jaate hai dosti ho jaati hai to sir syed ahmed khan ne bola tha inko alag karo sir syed ahmed khan ne to ashraf ke liye college banaya tha
I am very sad to see how much you lack facts.
Actually real preparators were Britishers.
Reality is Sir Syed was only a puppet of Britishers, Sir Syed only want Muslim Elites to join Britishers for Benifits.
On the other hand After 1857 Britishers main Agenda was it to completely ensure that 1857 doesn't repeat again & to break Hindu-Muslim Unity.
All AMU 1st ever Teachers Batches were all Britishers, and were sowing the Communal seeds in the mind Of Elite Muslims comming to AMU for Modern Education, they were the one who prepare Syllabus.
It was first the British Teachers of AMU who were going to Adjoining Punjab for Advertising & Teaching Urdu to Punjabis People's.
Sir Sted Ahmed Khan and Allama Iqbal both are loyal of British rullers and awarded the title of SIR from British Empire for their loyality. The two nation theory is fabricated by British rullers and promoted by their loyal agents Sir Syed Ahmed Khan and Sir Allama Iqbal and others muslim leaders to weaken the unity of Indian nation on basis of religion. Thanks.
I think one does not need to look beyond Direct Action Day August 1946 to know what Jinnah was all about and the extent he was willing to go to!!
it is all motivated by Islam
Know your history: "The Road to Freedom: Allama Mashriqi's Historic Journey from Amritsar to Lahore" produced by Mashriqi's grandson, scholar & Historian Nasim Yousaf.
czcams.com/video/iPO99tofR5s/video.html
"The British Chessboard: Jinnah, Gandhi, and the Strategic Divide of India"
czcams.com/video/L59B0amqJS0/video.html
Absolutely correct Diptiji! Thousands of Hindus were killed in Bengal for the demand. It is so stupid to even question what Jinnah wanted. After partition he did question the results.
Understanding partition and Jinnah without considering Allama Mashriqi's insights is like a puzzle missing a vital piece. His perspective adds depth to the narrative, unveiling hidden dimensions crucial for a comprehensive understanding. To ignore Mashriqi's viewpoint is to overlook a significant chapter in history's story.
गजब एंकर है...बैठने की तमीज तक नही है...
Partition is the worst tragedy happened in history....
He who asks for answers does not show respect for elders!
जो जिन्ना डायरेक्ट एक्शन की हुंकार भर रहा है वो आखिर एक अलग देश क्यों नही चाहेगा
आखिर क्या साबित करना चाहते है ये डिबेट करके #lallantop वाले
Samajwad. Secularism bachana hai inko.
सच मे भाई डायरेक्ट ection तो हुआ था नगर बंगाल मे वो भी sihrawrdi ने करा दिया था जबकि पंजाब मे एसा कुछ नहीं हुआ था
Indian customs do not allow one to dit cross-legged in front a teacher.
Yeah! It not only seemed disrespectful toward the guest but also unpleasant to watch
That’s the first thing that caught my eye, looks very arrogant
यह अंतर राष्ट्रीय विद्वान शख्स के सामने टेबल पर बैठकें(उनसे ऊंचाई पर), साक्षात्कार लेना कितना जायस लगता है____
Unke pass chairs nhi hai shayad
Unkae pass chair toe hae but tameej nahi hae.... Mafia journalism
George Soros kae punters
Sad that the interviewer couldn't find a chair to sit despite having a fancy setup. Our culture teaches us to show respect to guests. Casually sitting on a table with legs crossed in front of elders is not something what Asians normally do.
Excellent evidence provided by Prof. ishtiaq Ahmed demolishing the thesis of Ayesha Jalal.
Dr. Ishtiak Ahmed sir is very logical
Salaam to a great man and scholar of origin of Pakistan, respected Prof Istayak Saheb who in his research work on Md Jinnah put at that time realities openly.
Jai Hind
Shekhar
New Delhi India
Where did Jinnah go wrong? He said Hindus and Muslims can’t live together..
I AM IN ABSOLUTE AGREEMENT OF THE SAME.. IT WAS OUR MISTAKE IN KEEPING SNAKES IN HOME FOR OURSELVES IN 1947 .. WE ARE FINDING A LOT PEACE TODAY ..
Are you calling our Muslim brothers snakes??? How disrespectful
सर, आपके के चैनल मुझे पसंद है और आपके विडियोज मैं देखता हूं। मगर मुझे एक बात इस विडिओ में खटक गई और वो ये है की आप के इंटरव्यूअर टेबल पर बैठके ( प्रोफेसर साहब के कुर्सी से ऊंचे टेबल पर ) उनका इंटरव्यू ले रहें है। Somehow i found it inappropriate ..
I am a regular listener of ishtiag sir
Ishtiaq sa'ab is very knowledgeable and a great thinker. No doubt that Jinnah is responsible for India's partition (and also the bloodshed that ensued, since initially he directed the trouble-makers and then never condemned them after they ran amok with loot and murder in West and East Pakistan). Nehru ji, Gandhi ji and Sardar Patel ji were not responsible for the partition, contrary to what a prevalent thinking believes and argues. Time has come that we Indians stop blaming Nehru ji and Gandhi ji for partition. The real culprits were Jinnah and the British government (even though Mountbatten also said after the death of Jinnah within a year of the partition, that had he known that Jinnah was so ill, he would have deferred the date of 'partition', so that it eventually would not have happened after Jinnah's death. But British govt. was untrustworthy. Who knows they would have changed their mind and started arguing that it is better for India that British remain in the country?) This was a big success of Nehru and Patel in convincing British govt. that it should leave India completely. The last British soldiers sailed out of the Bombay dock in 1948.
Britain wanted the partition of India for geostrategic reasons, and they used Jinnah, Nehru and Gandhi to achieve their objectives
We blame Nehru and Gandhi because they were complicit to the unfolding communal politics and did not resist it firmly. Also, after independence we could have easily taken back Pakistan but Nehru refused to do anything.
@@georgenadvi9932 when you follow ahimsa as main tool , you can't ask people to take weapons to stop the fight only thing is to condemn it and not to see it's people's mandate to kill everyone.
Partition and bloodshed was black spot and remain so, but now better to learn and avoid such mistakes with iron hand not by instigating same things
But jinnah wasnt interested...he was influenced by Alama Iqbal and Muslim League...why did he take rest in london for so many years? While everyone else was doing freedom struggle in India?
Allama Iqbal doesn't want it,
@@zafinhameed3979 what doesn't he want....whole pakistan celebrates Alaama ka khwab
@@zafinhameed3979 Iqbal was most confused or most cunt person.
He wrote " Saare Jahan se aacha Hindustan Hamara"
He also wrote " Muslim hai hum Chin, Hindustan,Russia saara jahan hamara ( as a Estate) "
@@Strawhatzz if they celebrate it doesn't mean that he from there,
@@zafinhameed3979 just state ur position....ur giving 1 line response, as if it's all obvious‼️
Wasn't Jinnah resting in London fr years also mourning the death of his child bride?
Wasn't he sent many letters from muslim league to return to India and lead the movement for separate pakistan ? Wasn't he influenced by Alama Iqbal for separate muslim nation?
Isn't it true that muslim league got only 4 seats back then..cuz they can't win elections they thought of taking advantage of disrupt freedom struggle...while all the national freedom fighters were in jail?
Why is he sitting on the table Are there no chairs available
Style maar raha hae chumtiya
Dr.Ishtiaq is true and unbiased scholar...
Mr anchor of LT seat respectfully front of guest speaker, absolutely not crossed legs on desk. Its not according interviewing etiquettes.
Respect the senior citizen and knowledgeable person. Look at the anchor how he is asking questions. Over smart.
Guys Ye video bhot acchi h
This anchor has no sense how to sit in front of such a great Personality Prof Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed. Absolutely wrong how he is sitting on table. Simply like a 3rd class Student..
Creation of Pakistan was international politics.
For get pass start good relation with India start trade and easy Visa policy for reginal country
Now its headline that SC Bose had offered jinnah to be PM of india,but he declined had that been his motive why would he decline that,these baseless narratives are circulated only to create a sense of confusion in youth of pakistan,though partition had very severe impacts as well but seeing the kind of cummunal disruption emerging in india is a kind of hint y he was at some point right..
Although the type of nation state he would always talk about pakistan has hugely failed to attain so,and it would be hugely hypocritic if I say only outside powers destroyed pakistan but it's own politicians and corrupt leaders played a huge part in it.
1.09 Don't know if it was deliberate to show ad of 'Shilajit' when Dr ahmed started but was funny.😅
Dr professor Istiyaq Ahemed Sir , actually Jinnah doesn't accept Nehru as the prime minister of United India , but he agreed with the leader ship of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose . When Gandhi Nehru forced Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose to Regine from the post of president of then Indian national Congress . Netaji Subhash Bose was elected president of Indian national Congress in 1938 & when again he elected 2 nd time , Gandhi & Nehru planned to Regine from the post of president of Congress . Hence Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose went to Germany & Japan to form Azad Hind 🇮🇳 Fauj . After leaving the Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose , Jinnah started the two nations theory i e in 1940 onwards ; when Jinnah realised that Nehru will be the Prime minister of India . Jinnah was suffering from T B & it was kept so confidential that only Jinnah & his doctor knows . In 1946 his doctor told him that his life is only for 2 years . Hence in the year 1946 Jinnah agreed to be P M of India for first 2 years & after that Nehru will be the P M of India for remaining balance years . But Neheru disagreed with this proposal . Hence the division ➗ of India . After 15 August 1947 Jinnah died within one year . It is also quoted in the diary of lord Mauntbaton , Who was then in charge of British India . He wrote in his diary that if he knows the disease of Jinnah , he might have been prolonged India:s freedom by one year
Lollipop bechara Inka jinna to secular hai
But yaha to Pol khul gai
..nanga kar diya bolo.🤣
Kaha gae liberals comments mai dikh nahi rahe😂
Great Fact!
ध्यान से सुनो अब इस तरीके की बातों का कोई फायदा नहीं है देश खंडित हो गया 60 लाख व्यक्तियों का कत्लेआम हो गया एक समुदाय को देश के एक चौथाई हिस्से से वंचित कर दिया गया अब इस तरीके के वाद विवाद से कुछ नहीं होना है
No. Mr. Ahmed, you are wrong. Ayesha Jalal is an authoritative historian on Jinnah.
Zinha ka mul muslim nahi tha
Woh gujrati thakkar lohana me se aata tha
Purani adavat use prarit kar gai Pakistan banane ko
WhatsApp University se bahar..qu®an ne usey prerit kia alag nation bnane k liye na ki advait ne
Uski family muslim nahi thi vo muslim ban gaya tha
Accha hua Pakistan and Bangladesh broke out. Nahi toh aaj India mein 40 crore Musalman aur hote. Aur ye wo tried and tested Musalman hain jinhone apne Desh mein hinduon ka khoon aur balatkaar kiye hain
Ishtiag is great respect man
Agree sir my grandfather used to write in urdu
Subah ka bhula sham ko vapas ajaye to use bhula nahi kahte batavare me sabhi videshi takato ka hath tha unhone batavara krvaya aaj bhi vahi horahahy "hinsa aur dvesh bhaichaara nahi hosakata" tum hame pak dedo ham tume hind dede MAKE POWER OF ASIA🌏
Jinnah and Jawahar Lal Nehru and Mahatama Gandhi together for Broke India in Two Parts
@lalantop ...somehow you need to get your studio setup right.. it's looks disrespectful in the way interviewer is sitting. The Guest should get more respectful gesture from the interviewer. Just a suggestion.
Britishers divided India, subjects had no right to divide India.
Church had decided before leaving break indian subcontinent, long back.
Of course Jinnah Pakistan chahtay thay...why not..he wanted Pakistan ànd GOT IT! Alhamdulillah
Achaa hua ek bheekari tayar kiya Jinnah ney.
भूखे मरने के लिए ,, 😂😂😂
Hi! The L top guys
So u hv learn from USA to sit on table in fronts of ur guests....elders... ???
Copy good things ...
What to expect from stooges of George soros
Man sometimes you are not just a writer but a businessperson and you do everything to sell your product ...
Please call satinder sartaj sir for interview
Jinnah's life can be broadly classified in two phases acc to my limited knowledge, first the secular phase where he opposed intermingling of politics and religion which was done by gandhi ji during non cooperation movement.
Second would be radical phase were after lot deliberations he got to know that he won't be able to secure the electorate for Muslim in india under congress, which could be true as congress didn't even have 1% representation of muslims.
Mind you i m not taking sides here but he was a pretty learned man what he created havoc on both sides.
I have read the book almost 50%
This woke interviewer can he not use a Chair and sit properly maintaining decorum..???
Lallantop is synonym of wokism. They personify woke.
He is a nice man
Just get couple of chairs or couches.
वाह👌
No sir. It is not a fiction. I personally listen to a man who was Jinha's closed right hand man. He said on TV in USA that Jinha did not want Pak. They put it in his neck. And the reason was and is obvious today, they wanted to make a Hindu Raj which Modi is doing today. If Muslims did not go away, it will be hard to build Hindu Raj. that is the truth sir.
So why didn’t Muslims leave completely?why r remaining not leaving/migrating ?
People who face persecution look like Hindus /sikhs of Afghanistan /Pakistan/Bangladesh!!
@@Sskaushik878 Congress ko apni position bnani thi independence k baad
दूसरा tarek fatah,,,,,,,😂
He talk a lot about Pakistan
Lage hath India ke halaat par bhi bol dete
Visa cancell ho jataa.
Upgrade your knowledge...he is older than Tariq Fateh...has more research based account of history of Pak India division.
Actually India is perfect now a days it doesn't have any problem with jobs home land security money food water electricity child abuse women abuse gambling extortion religious tension education job security roads schools colleges intellectual crises and much more these problems are not in India may be that is the reason he didn't speak about 😂😅
@@ashishdixit8720 yeah ..as if that pet typical list of armchair elitists is only available in India... probably he is educated more ..practically.
Program bahaut acha tha, per aik choti se suggestion,
Kisi old age ya kisi bhi guest Kay samnay taang pe taang rakh Kar bethna aur us se unchi jagha pe behtna ... Acha nahi samjha jata, bad-tehzibi lagti hai. Suhkriya.
Jinnah wanted partition so islam is not annihilated in India, but now look at the state of pakistan.
He is right jinna want pm or ruler on india but greedy nehru
But, the way the interviewer is sitting in front of the guest is disgraceful.
i think this man want indian citizinship
Jinnah saab ko indus see le jana chaiyee kuch log to India me kyo rakh gayee.
Not Jinnah but British divided ; that was their political policy . They had 400+ princely States and Punjab of Khalsa Darbar . They wanted it . Nehru Patel Jinnah were basically power hungry communal men who made that happen .
but the fact is muslims vote for partition? isn't it
Patel saab kicked this PM chair even after getting majority. He was nt power hungry. That Iron man combined all states in making modern India
Here is another lutyens parroting the oft repeated lie...400+ states ..so what.?? They wanted...who wanted?? If Nehru Patel were communal what were Islamic bodies e.g., Muslim League?? Who voted overwhelmingly (90% votes) for creation of a state based on a communal religion..?? Shame even in the face of such glaring truths keep just blaming British.
And how was khalsa secular ever?
@@media-rn6zc Khalsa has been Iron Dome of Sanatan. Avoid Abduls in fake accounts
Ye constitution ke khilaf hai ye andhbhakt professor ko bula ke jinna ki galtiya ginana yha ke minority ki rights ke khilaf hai . Lallantop bhi andhbhakt hai
Badiya udaa diya... pSickular ka😄🤣
Anchor sahab aapko tu ek respected professor ke saamne bethne tak ki Bhi Tameez nahi h
Teaching profation ke kuch tu laaj Rakhte aap ?
Jinnah behaved like kid wanted to rule and angrezon ney fayde liya Aaj aadhey sey jayada log unhi ki country mein pannah leker baithien hein
You should not make it look casual while sitting on table .. while talking to a elderly person .. Allthough i loved the way u handled it 😊
टेबल पर बैठ कर बातचीत और इन्टरव्यू करना गलत है
Ye hote hai padhe likhe log
Watch: The truth about Muhammad-Robert Spencer
It will change your entire outlook towards izlum
Ek sikshak k samne ise nahi bathna chahiye..
निखील बडे आदमी के सामने ठीक बेठा करो
Nikhi 1 number kae chaman haen
Ye tou sabko pata alag desh ki maag hindu maha sabha rss ne hi ki ye sab history mei he
Teri history kya Saudi Arabia se aayi hay
Chal jhoote 🥴🥴
आरएसएस का चिट्ठा कौन खोलेगा ?
The anchor is disrespecting the guest by sitting on a table with crossed legs.
Its not abt jinnah.muslim have same mentality everwhere in world.making islam hellholes is in quran
❤
Table pr baith kr jyada Gyani ho jate ho Q
Ghantae kae gyani
Kis desh may kon say dharm kay log km ho rhe h, ye sab k saamne h,
Bala ho jinna sahab jo in jahilo ko le gye apne sath
Matlab ultra chor Kotwal ko daante
Bohot hi batyameez anchor hai ak professor ke samne kaise baytha jata hai itni vi tameez nahi
एक इतने पढ़े लिखे व्यक्ति के साथ मेज पर बैठकर इंटरव्यू करना कहां की तहजीब है कुर्ती अच्छी नहीं लगती अगर तो स्टूल पर बैठ सकते थे आप
# कुर्सी
MAULANA ABUL KALAM AZAD.... Pak agor bongya to hindustan me hindu muslimun k sath jiyadati korenge or Pak kuch nahi korpayga or Pak k muslim kabhi upod ja ke kuch kornehi payenge .... gam ki baat ye hai aaj ye sahi nikla
Bhai, kuch to tameez seekh lo…. Interview le rahe ho ya Interrogate kar rahe ho…. Mana youtube channel hai but kuch to parameter honge …. This is unethical plus insulting …. Kitna bhi casual kyon na ho I will not sit like this in front of someone who is senior in age as well as knowledge
Jinnah was a trader
Bhai saab baitha nahi jata to khud v ek sofa le lete fir tang ke uper tang chadake baithte.or agar koi Gupt Rog he to baat alag he.
Discussing Jinnah , Nehru is unwanted now and is a tactic to divert attention from present issues... totally waste of time....
Anchor is so I'll mannered... He is sitting on head of guest....
But what do you expect from lallantop 😮
Jina ak tukta tha or h or rvja❤
O god completely new perspective
not at all
Phelhi bat to hindustan hi nahi hai ya ha India😅
Daddy को ही पिता जी कहते हैं बेटा जी
हिंदुस्तान ही India है
Whats his take on hindu girls still been kidnapped and rape.
Aise Indian chahye...
Need person like you..
Lelo issko aur hamari jaan churaao iss Jinnah virodhi say
@@saimaahmed8759 jinnah ne khudko kabhi Pakistani nahi mana even after partition to bhai tum logo ko itna garur q hai ? Muslim hai to Kya hindustani hone pe fakar nahi ?
Table par bedh kar ek senior high lable historical insan ka interview lena unse uchi jagah par beth kar ye behavior tehjeeb ke khilaf he chaliye tumhari bebkuf I ko maaf kiya
Dr Ishtiaq is ex muslim
Ab bolo 😆😆
To kya chahta tha 72 hoor😂😂
तू पहले यह समझ की किसी के सामने किस प्रकार बैठ कर बातचीत करना आवश्यक है
Ayesha Jalal nahi dalal he 😂
Jinah mcd