Putin's troops don't have the tanks needed for Kharkiv breakthrough | Dr Patrick Bury
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 05. 2024
- "If Ukraine stay and fight and they buy some time for intelligence assets and surveillance assets to be brought on to the location, things are seen pretty easy and most forces, especially armour, have to disperse."
The Russian push towards Kharkiv will struggle to put much further given Ukrainian resistance without further armour as Ukraine brings forward defensive equipment, says Dr Patrick Bury.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
This could be as bad as when the Russians 'ran out' of missiles last year...
Or a week ago when the Ukrainians were pushing Russia back
Or when Putin was dying
Or when Putin had lost his grip on power
Shall I go on?
BS 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@walkaz You're just making up bs. No credible commentator has claimed any of that. Yes, there were rumours of illness. No reason to doubt that. Most people get sick.
Why not contribute something useful instead of the mindless waffle? Are you really that moronic?
Remember when Russia was supposed to have also "ran out" of ammo, shells, soldier's, food and fuel? 😂
@@robertmarks2379 Remember when Ruzzia was supposed to have taken Ukraine in a 3 day special military operation? 😂😂
If Russia cannot take kharkiv and are out of tanks, then how are they going to take the rest of europe like you've been claiming everyday?
They can't. Now.
Build some more tanks? Just a suggestion.
@@FactCheckerGuy So the Times Radio spin fits your narrative. Now.
Not only that, but according to this channel (in the last 24-hours alone):
*_´Putin Ready To Quit ´_*
*_´Putin Knows He Won´t Win´_*
*_´Putin Has Nothing Left´_*
*_´Putin Can´t Take Kharkov´_*
*_´Putin Ready To Quit (again)´_*
*_´Putin´s On The Ropes´_*
*_´Putin´s Regime Failure´_*
*_´Putin´s Incompetence´_*
And yet the EU and UK are sh!tting themselves _daily_ with regards to _´Putin Won´t Stop in Ukraine: We´re Next!!!!!´_
Quite remarkable.
The ORCS have been a punchline for 2 years 😂
that old chestnut again - supposedly Rus troops on the front line have been fighting for 18 months with shovels
Yeah yeah.., and those with abundance of weaponry are retreating!🤪
I heard that Russia captured a letterbox on the outskirts of a tiny hamlet.
its the same mighty Russia that is going to conquer all the world if everybody does not send their money to Zelensky .....
😂😂😂
This sums up their recent performance
Go read a non propaganda report and see how much russia have mo ed forward in the last 6 months!
There is video of Russia at Vovchasnk hospital! How many days before Ukraine admits that lol
That academic bloke sounds like a pub war debater at best …
Just wanted to say that the reason why Ukraine did not build defences right on the border with Russia is because the people making them would have been killed. The west has stated how Ukraine is not allowed to use western weapons on Russia, so the solution was quite simple. Build defences a few kilometres back so as not to be right under Russian noses first and foremost. Then if or when Russia did launch an attack, then Ukraine would have an area on Ukrainian territory, where they can use western weapons on the attacking Russians, thus not breaking the agreement made with the west. Plus the defences would be in place and not destroyed while people had tried to build them.
"Don't use our weapons on ruZZian territory" must go down in the history of war as one of the dumbest things the west has ever said during the time of a full scale war.
Well put, sir.
It is fairly obvious and shows that Ukraine take notice of the supplying country’s qualified instructions.
As a further thought it may well encourage home produced weapons which would hold no such restrictions!
We wait to see.
It's crazy to me that the West complains about Ukraine's tactics when it's the west that prohibits Ukraine from using every tactic available to them. Smh
@@geoffcollier8736 it also seems to have opened up some countries in the west to allow weapons to be used inside Russia
Which is even more important than losing a few small villages
Love this channel they are so funny 😂😂😂😂
why is your thumbnail of a Ukrainian tank in WII German markings?
Every Times Radio headline seems to echo the same sentiment -'Russia Can't Win'. Same for the past eighteen months. Pity Putin never seems to read them...
They got washing machines. And Shovels .....looks like thats enough against 0:56 Western weapons 😂
"Middle Power Nations Like Russia." The Shade! 😂🤣😅
Largest stockpile. Is no joke.
turns out they are just a middle power ...no one more surprised than me but then I remember the Soviets...this is just the wizard of oz...looks like russia is weak after all...will see anyway.. Chinese would be a diffrent story
@@coachking5208That has been and will continue to be depleted 😅
The truth is they are a mix of everything. The are a super power on nuclear terms. Mid power ++ Navy. Mid power ++ air force and lower tier land and infantry forces. Calling them a middle power is very disingenuous and simple. I wonder what he thinks the British armed forces amounts to ? I can tell you one thing it and I’ll be kind. It’s not a middle power or anywhere close.
@@garyoconnor6131 Why would they even need navy when you have hypersonics? They have big and scary submarine fleet and thats enough. And floating boats are nothign more than a target dummies today. In terms of infantry power, make no misstake, it's the most battle harderned combat force today. Literally noone has that level of combined warfare + deeply integrated sufisticated air defence wich is a thing in its own class. Russia is hystoriclt a landpower, and US or Britts are not and never been so. And Europe is a joke even if you put'em all together. When someone calls Russia a mid power he is still living in 70s or something. Today even Iran on it's can wreck such havoc they you won't even belive.
No Buffer Zone. You Have A Border!!
Both the UK and russia have a border crisis. But they're opposite...people are trying to get into the UK, and OUT of russia 😂
@@dpelpalhave you seen how many chickens are running from Ukraine to Poland & Bulgaria ?
Seems they just ain't happy being turned into mincemeat, for Blackrock to get a few billion more.
They are important, if Ukraine is to live out its life as an independent state. Not just as a vassal 52nd state of the US - (Inc its foreign policy decisions. You and I both know Putin is playing bluff, with the west. Are they willing to test him ? Seems not. The west are full of chickens, like the western leaders).
They've been exposed.
I wonder when this channel will make a video about the assassination attempt of the Slovakian Prime Minister or (as I suspect) *not* even mention it
Buffer zone against ballistic missiles...
Not possible!
How did you know? Did u audit them?
He says “The West” when something good comes up. When it’s something bad “The Americans didn’t send the aid”
Well...that kinda sums up the last 6 months doesn't it. You have a certain mr. Trump to thank for that general viewpoint now.
Standard European bs, just know that they wouldn’t survive without US
But we didn’t!
“The Americans didn’t send the aid”
We are tired of paying for your problems.
"The West" didn't stop delivery. The US did.
Propaganda to it's fullest. Russia is not even using it's modern weapons in this special operation
This officer nails it, both good and bad. NATO slicing salami and if Ukraine 🇺🇦 fails, NATO becomes a sad joke. High stakes?
👈🤡Ukraine will not fail. Ukraine will win regardless of how long it takes, as they have something worth fighting for unlike the Russians who are being forced to fight and die for Putins lies. And How can Nato be made to look like a joke, when Nato aren't actually fighting Russia. If Nato get dragged into this war with boots on the ground, then Putin will get his quick war and STILL BE the losing side.
We are so unprepared, Putin has had 12 months to prepare while we say how great we are
Russia has the largest tank force (at least in terms of numbers) in the world. And they are producing them like mad. They could be out of a lot of things but tanks aren`t one of them!
Where exactly they are produced? As far as I know there is only one factory making them and they are getting more basic by day. Without china stepping in with military help can't see breakthrough
Oh, so now theyre running out of tanks too pmsl. In the last 18 months theyve ran out of ammo, shells, missiles, soldiers, and now tanks. Its a miracle that they still keep relentlessly advancing despite ukraine having none of these problems 😂
Thanks!
Why spend money on tanks when you’re doing so well with shovels 👍
As long as they don't run out of shovels
A giy in central London talking and analyzing about the war in Ukraine 😂
he might be an ex army officer sounds like it
Then NATO got nothing to fear, right??
Right, we do not fear Russian incompetence. Ha ha 😂😂😂😂😂
This idea that Russia is trying to create a buffer zone is ridiculous. Russia is trying to get close enough to Kharkiv to use artillery.
Whoever believes that bull chit us a dum bass.
So when they make the breakthrough does that mean God is on their side or?
Putin is a magician?
They do not need armour, they have shovels 🙂
We know. We've seen dozens of videos of Russian cannon fodder bullet catcher troops being given nothing more than shovels and making videos moaning to Putin about it. Like he cares, lol.
They did this with motorized rifle brigades. You don't always need armour.
The "shovels" joke is getting old, especially from those who claim to have destroyed the Ukrainian military multiple times over but can still barely take ground.
@@user-pd3gt3tx5e Shovels will never be old joke . . . that will always be reminder to the stupidity of the Western propaganda 🙂
@@user-pd3gt3tx5e The Ghost of Kyiv as well 🙂
Everything has been too late too little with too many strings and caveats as to how it can be used.How would you be expected to fight in such circumstances.
Russia is running out of tank barrels, converting these tanks to turtle tanks.
The west is running out of fake stories to post! Tank barrels are the easiest thing to manufacture, assuming you aren't some western nation that outsourced all its industry overseas
Excellent guest for Front Line. Thank you
RS. Canada
Russian shovel warriors are still capturing more and more land... Looks like we are in trouble.
On the topic of F-16s and air cover: Are there any Migs left in the EU/NATO countries? If so, that would be shameful that the aircraft that the Ukrainians are familiar with are being withheld.
I think most of these have already been sent to Ukraine... And they didn't have that many in the first place.
There will never be F16s in Ukraine. Not until Ukraine controls the skies, no country is risking their F16s because as soon as the land at an airport Russia will send hundreds of missiles to take out just one F16 because it's a huge price
What’s British can help without USA?
Why do we still talk about Garasimov. We have hardly seen him since he was hit by that missile in Crimea. He looked a shell when we saw him vote.
His ears are still ringing.
Where is Zalushny? He was supposed to be new Kyiv diplomat to UK, but is nowhere to be seen...
@@gandhi9936 How is that relevant?
Tactical,rather than having anything to do with shortage of heavy equipment.
In fact, Russia produces more tanks in a month
than the entire Collective West (including the US)
produces in a year.
It would be nice if (just for a change) Times Radio
booked a guest who isn't completely clueless.
Refurbished older and less capable tanks, isn't something to tout. The fact that they started with massive advantages and HAVE to produce new tanks tells us that the rate of losses is unsustainable. No supporting tanks for a new offensive front is telling.
@@slip6699
You're making all kinds of rash assumptions
based on delusional British propaganda.
Times Radio appears to inhabit an alternative reality.
They haven’t received the memo on the new talking points
Actually it's the Russians saying this themselves on telegram that everybody's following😂
I always get 2 sides of the story
Russian always get 2 sides of the story. Solyvyov's side and Putin's side, that counts as 2😅
I would always believe Russias side. They are always shooting down f22’s and Deathstars.
Note how those favouring Ukraine, will never volunteer to fight. Will always try to be funny - I stead of producing facts.
But, to your point, yes, it's ALWAYS better to look objectively, at the war as a whole.
@@fareemvenosa3774 Glad we have you to keep us informed.
@@fareemvenosa3774 "Note how those favouring Ukraine, will never volunteer to fight. " Yet Ukraine is full of volunteers. Russia on the other hand have to pay Nepali farmers to fight.
Well Russia gain alot of territory just by using shovel.
More utter drivel from the Times 😂 Russia has more tanks than America can afford to run 😂 Empire is crumbling ❤
Where are they then? The USA have 30 thousand tanks
Where do you get?
So obvious that none of the 'not russian bot' posters have even watched the video. It's actually pretty pessimistic from a Ukrainian POV.
Meanwhile from the Ukrainian people actually at the front: "Russian tanks have entered the northern part of Vovchansk and are shooting inside the city," National Police officer Ihor Kharchenko reports.
We must send a lot more defense systems to Ukraine and stop the self-reassuring commentary that Russia doesn't have enough capabilities for this or that.
Ukraine is underfunded, under-supplied and its people are being sacrificed unnecessarily because we in NATO are too slow and fall short at providing the equipment Ukraine needs to push back. It's not enough, and underestimating the enemy is a terrible strategy for Europe.
The Tzar is constructing wooden tanks.
Underfunded ok mate
News report from the Internet Research Agency. Ha ha 😂😂😂😂😂
You never had the man power to begin with
@@pauldean8638 Who owns and runs Russia 1 TV? Ha ha 😂 🤣 😆 😄 😅 😀
Good.
Total nonsense!
I think Dr Patrick Bury needs to go for a walk and clear that grey matter. My lord, the west have been saying this for nearly two years now. Russia CAN keep this up for years. Can the west?
Definitely, problem is that western arm manufacturers are mostly private and need time to scale up unlike state owned factories. Look what just handful of himars or long range missiles do, even Ukrainian's basic drones go through air defence
The F-16's wont make any difference, at all. They will join the rest of the aircraft on the scrapheap in short order.
Russia turned This On, Russia, can't Turn This Off!
I think "Kyiv in THREE DAYS!" is just as big a joke inside russia as it is outside these days
@@dpelpalAs if the Russians don't know it was now retired US General Milley, that started this 3 days nonsense! They do know about Kiev fantasy of 5 days to the Sea of Azov 😄
@@Robert-xy4xi Is that how russia has now lost 50% of the land they held 2 years ago? That aint winning in my book😂
@@Robert-xy4xi It was maria zakharova that said Kyiv in 3 days...
@dpelpal you literally know nothing.
And the tanks they have get kaboomed!
No the kabomed tanks were our western supplied ones with the rest on show at an exhibition just outside Moscow
Attrition is name of Russia’s game
Ah, the brilliance of the commentators below. At times you would think they know what they are talking about, even if they can't spell.
Small units plus no armor means small gains but no ultimate win in this evil war!
There was a way out. Ukraine had only to opt not to join NATO. That meant no western nukes on Ukraine/Russian border.
Ukraine is as 'independent' as Scotland is 'independent' from the UK.
@@fareemvenosa3774 Guess that worked out well, what with Finland and Sweden joining NATO, and nary a peep from the Russians about it.
@@fareemvenosa3774 "Ukraine had only to opt not to join NATO." But with an irrational bully on their border, they had to try. Meanwhile putin the genius turned the baltic ocean into a NATO lake.
@@fareemvenosa3774with a militaristic and imperialist neighbor like Russia, joining NATO is the only rational choice!
@@fareemvenosa3774 In actual reality there was never even a hint that Ukraine wanted to join NATO before Russia broke two preexisting treaties to launch a genocidal invasion. And even if you believed Ukraine joining NATO is a valid reason for war, then you must believe Russia is entitled to just take over its neighbors. NATO is a completely defensive treaty, and the only danger NATO troops inside Russia's sovereign neighbor countries pose to Russia is when they stand in the way of Russia invading those countries.
Europe should be doing twice as much as the US. This is a European war. Stop saying that the US is responsible for the situation that Ukraine finds itself in. Europe is sitting on 100 of billions of dollars in frozen Russian assets that it could use to fund Ukraine’s war effort and they refuse to use those assets for Ukraine.
I think if you look at a map rarely people do Nato moved onto Russias doorstep , Russia didn't move onto ours . And for the BOT paranoid society I'm a Yorkshire Bot , By Eck !
The only reason Russia is attempting this offensive at Kharkiv (and possibly Sumy) is because they CANNOT advance more than 90km or so beyond their own borders.
Their logistics start getting pummelled by Ukrainian strikes much further than this. They cannot get beyond what is essentially a days drive under combat conditions.
dont see why he is not using more of his hypersonic weapons.
the USA cant deal with spoilt kids at unis haha Russia is laughing
A 100km dmz in Russia along the '91 border seems like a good idea - UN controlled ...
Why don't you bring back the British Intelligence chief who was sayin in 2022 that Russia is running out of weapons...🤔
The russians only have to advance a bit more, then the city will be within regular artillery range = /oh-damn
Has the Ukraine army taken the Crimean peninsula yet?
Has Russia taken kramatosk yet it's been almost 3 years to advance 12 kilometres 🤡🤡🤡
What's new in Lubyanka?
Hilarious, as usual. Thanks Chaps 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm sure this guy knows as much as Colonel MacGregor.
@@davidowens4145bahaaaaa that's your best counter ?
Ah the hole to the North that Ukraine can't exploit.
If you look at Russian deployment, there are just hectares of land that don't have a soul in them. I mean the Pensioners are gone, the old villages are dusty and empty and there are just these little country road that the Russian Liberation Militia could just take a drive and might just end up in Kursk or Voronezh before anyone noticed. Imagine trying to guard a 20,000 kilometer land border across 10-11 times zones? Russia does not have that.
But like any invading army, the reality is you run out of gas and food and bullets pretty fast once the fun begins.
We won the war in Iraq but lost in Afghanistan
Afghanistan was won militarily for 19 years, with negligible US casualties during the entire Trump administration. Unfortunately, those gains - and the measure of freedom that we had produced for Afghani men and women -- were thrown away by the stupidity and weakness of US politicians. This was mainly Biden, but Trump gave an opening to the Taliban that they exploited.
But that ignores a bear in the room, Russia can't afford to have its economy 75% geared for war for any length of time will simply run out of 💰 it's a question of resources, buy also will st this point who will blink first. Before they run out?
😂😂😂 Keep the deluded nonsense coming TR. Its comedy gold.
I hear that there's lots of Chinese golf carts to go around. Maybe they can put large cardboard tubes on them. The orc crews can make the "pew pew" sounds, that is until the drones find them. Like they always do. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Lol yeah that is the reason why russia have only 40 k kia unlike nazies who have 600000
@nemanjaljubicic5282 according to who?
Ukraine is using cardboard drones to deliver explosives...
one thinks only one side has Chinese golf carts eh, I heard your mom likes to "pew pew" when she rides them lad.
@@nemanjaljubicic528210,000 APCs destroyed,
Typicaly 6-10 men for each veihacle, not counting dismounted light infantry that dont use them.
Only 40,000 casualties?
Your figures are a low ball estimate for 2022's losses alone.
What BS
I think Ukraine was spread across thinly because of lack of soldiers so Russia moved in weak areas. Desperate to win something.
Russia’s Achilles heal is that I doesn’t have an air power doctrine of any substance.
Russia has only fought one modern high intensity conflict against a near peer rival, before Ukraine. That was WW11.
And the allies had massively degraded the German Air Force before the Soviets went on the offensive. So the only other Russian high intensity conflict Russia has fought was largely a land war.
So Russia will never attain air superiority over Ukraine. (Particularly with F16’s on the way).
And without air power, armour will always be vulnerable. Russia will not be able to launch an effective offensive.
American channel very very reliable channel 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Jokers joking.
Proposed BZ, 80%...no longer 20%.
Wishful thinking
Well i dooesnt seemd. to😅 matter
Are the Ukraine armed forces still in Robotyne?
If they were not, the clowns on ruzzian state TV would not let you forget about it.
It would be nice if Ukraine could reach out and hit SU-34's at altitude 50 miles back before they deploy those glide bombs. Russia can still afford Jet Fuel and Glide Bomb Kits. But what it would have trouble replacing is the Jets and the crews to fly them.
They use to move a Patriot battery around at night near Donbas trying to hit Russian aviation over the Sea of Azov and it worked for a couple of weeks. But loose one Patriot Battery and everyone's freaking out. They cost the equivalent of tens of Bradley IFV's or maybe a hundred of those M777 field cannon.
The cost of supplying Patriot missiles to Ukraine is approximately $1.1 billion. This includes $400 million for the system itself and $690 million for the missiles1. The U.S. Army operates 15 Patriot battalions,
Depending on the variant and contract, the M777 ranges in the 2-3 Million dollar price. Which is why I wanted Biden to be sending the M777 and the M101 Howitzers way back in 2021 but he was too busy packing up and leaving Afghanistan. Those cheaper and technically much more easy to operate and move around the battle field plus to arm would have meant that Ukraine would have had a very big artillery force by end of 2021 for the cost of ONE Patriot battery with missiles. I was also dreaming of the M142 mobile artillery with the longer range ATACMS being in Ukraine in 2021 too. Just that kind of reach and mobility would have been a great kind of layered artillery force that would have made Russia more vulnerable.
But let's face it Biden is no Military General. He's a lawyer. I always say, you can't win wars fighting with Lawyers. Maybe that's it. Biden is not trying to win anything. He's just hoping Putin will stop, or the Europeans will be stronger. But except for the French, British, Poles and the Baltics and Romania too, much of Europe is just trying to adapt to the new business environment without cheap Russian gas.
Excellent comment, but Biden was not even an effective lawyer. He practiced law only for a couple of years, switching from a corporate law firm to a stint as public defender. He ran for the Senate in 1972 when he was 29, and won, mostly on good looks and charm against an incumbent more than twice his age. For the next 52 years - professional politician and hustler.
Glide bombs are HORRIBLY demoralizing to the Ukrainian troops. And they can NOT hit the aircraft that are beyond Ukrainian range.
And everyday they have less
Pure fantasy from the Times as usual.
Dude!! You don't have any idea on Russian strategy.
One of your best shows on the War in Ukraine - Dr Bury was insightful, I’d like to see him more often
Yes, Russias lack of tanks. 300 priduced a month. He be a Brit. And how many Challenger you guys produce?. What? 15 a year
@@bendikkirkbakk1833👈🤡Russia certainly IS NOT producing 300 tanks a month. 😂😂😂 You bots certainly are a funny breed, with the BULL 💩 that you continue to make up and post. 😂😂😂
Love times radio, all the delusional sheep in one place 🤡
Sooooo many bots. Russia must be getting desperate
The bots are annoying. They repeat the same talking points over and over. Some bots even create an entire thread talking to themselves with many sock puppet accounts
the amount of cope from Times Radio is so large it attracts all the bots
@@golmgolm Orc
They are cheaper than golf carts
@@golmgolm "the amount of cope from Times Radio is so large it attracts all the bots"
That makes no sense. Classic bot post.
Russia has ran out of tanks? How come they are advancing and taking town after town?
Where are the Ukrainian tanks, aircraft, patriot missile defense, Ukraine troops. Ukraine is relying on NATO long range missles and drones. Ukraine soldiers are surrendering.
🇺🇦🇬🇧
Waste of time … again !
sjbjfsk didnidnduddjdjdhdjdjdndjdudjsjsjsjs bsusinsjssisn
I don’t know what to believe- According to this channel Russia lost this war on day one yet Here we are retreating!
Patrick Bury: good choice!
Prop.A.Ganda.
B.O.T
@@user-pd3gt3tx5efool
Stalemate
🇺🇦👍🙂
The lies will catch up to you. We all know Russia can produce a couple hundred tanks a month. Some newly manufactured the rest rebuilds of existing tanks. Ukraine is completely reliant on the west for armor. They received 31 abrams, 14 challengers and abou 80 leos 2. Many of these were destroyed in the last summer offensive. The leo 1s promised need complete rebuilds which wasn't done before handing some to Ukraine. That has delayed the delivery date for the majority of the leo 1s. Captured tanks make up the bulk of their forces now but that number is dwindling since Russia isn't using tanks in the numbers it once did at the beginning of the war. Tanks are now outdated on the Ukraine battlefield because of drones.
Yes and the challengers have been hiding in the basement for a year now.
They will make some money if they sell them to the Saudi’s and use the money to bug 2x T72s from Morocco
Russian woman: Is it possible to make ends meet on salary alone, and also support russian army?
Answer: We don't know, we never tried.
Did WW2 never happen?
Is this a result of your 'western' education?
Ha ha ha ha well miss 3day war , where is Russia since we last spoken ? Didn’t what I say would happen has happened ?
James ..Rabotino has fallen to the Russians...this must be very depressing to this channel..even the small gains of the counter offensive are being eroded by the Russians
Running out Tanks now are they? Like they ran out of missiles, aircraft and fight with shovels, pathetic journalism
Not being able to replace every tank lost is not running out. If they were building plenty of replacements, than why are they using obsolete Soviet made tanks from storage?
Maybe if sort out independent journalists, you'll get the truth.
The Uktainians mansged to get through the Rusdian Air Defence with one ATACM's and hit 1 S-400 and 2 Mig 31's . Anybody that thinks that is enough to degrade Crimea's defences has rocks in his head. So the AFU have used almost 50 of the 100 ATACM's already, the rest were shot down. These missiles are no longer in production. Why dont your so called 'experts' know this info,bits sll out there
They do have the tanks.
They have at least one years supply.
Be patient and they will work through them.