The UNTOLD Story Of What Happened During The Blackwater Massacre In Red Dead Redemption 2! (RDR2)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 01. 2019
  • The UNTOLD Story Of What Happened During The Blackwater Massacre In Red Dead Redemption 2! (RDR2)
    ►Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: www.g2a.com/r/mrbossftw
    We're diving into the mystery of the Blackwater Massacre and what happened to Arthur and the Van Der Linde Gang before the start of Red Dead Redemption 2!
    RDR2 Campfire Scenes By Indo J:
    / indoomafia
    ►My Facebook:
    / mrbossftw
    ►My Snapchat:
    / mrbosssnaps
    ►My Twitter:
    #!/mrbossftw
    ►My Instagram:
    / jamesrosshudgins
    Hope you enjoyed this video! See you guys in the next one! ✌🏻
  • Hry

Komentáře • 1,9K

  • @MrBossFTW
    @MrBossFTW  Před 5 lety +358

    The UNTOLD Story Of What Happened During The Blackwater Massacre In Red Dead Redemption 2!

    • @luiscervantes5352
      @luiscervantes5352 Před 5 lety +3

      MrBossFTW first

    • @annwhyte544
      @annwhyte544 Před 5 lety +9

      You are really good at finding things to make videos about

    • @jackjacc1508
      @jackjacc1508 Před 5 lety +1

      Third

    • @NviGWarren
      @NviGWarren Před 5 lety +8

      A DLC for Dutch!!! I wanna know WHY he shot the girl...

    • @MisterNi
      @MisterNi Před 5 lety +2

      Here's some trivia: What happened on the ferry is why Red Dead Undead Nightmare is a thing.

  • @occiferfigpucker4840
    @occiferfigpucker4840 Před 5 lety +3555

    Red Dead Redemption III, young Arthur Morgan in his 20s, John in his teens. Mexico is the main map, final mission is The Blackwater Massacre. Epilogue is Red Harlow's death story. Final scene is Jack Marston in 1918 closing the final page of a book he wrote entitled "Red Dead Redemption".. Jack turns around in a U.S. military uniform, walking into No Man's Land in WW1. Cut to black. Perfect end for the best Wild West video game series. Rockstar can move on to make a pirate game set in the 1710s.

    • @andreapitre1978
      @andreapitre1978 Před 5 lety +234

      I disagree... I think a third game would require Jack to be the complete main protagonist... They didn't finish his st

    • @datGuybry
      @datGuybry Před 5 lety +154

      If they're going to a prequel that ends in the black water massacre, and judging how they treat the main antagonist in the red dead series, it's going to have to be about the Callender Bro's. These brothers died in the massacre. I imagine the third would be about sibling rivalry and would play as both and chronicles their experience in the rise of the Van Der Lin Gang

    • @poopdaddy493
      @poopdaddy493 Před 5 lety +49

      Better dlc for II not III because III should because like someone else mentioned it should be with jack and his story’s end

    • @lowqualitypizza983
      @lowqualitypizza983 Před 5 lety +21

      Occifer FigPucker yes! This gave me goosebumps omg

    • @lowqualitypizza983
      @lowqualitypizza983 Před 5 lety +20

      Occifer FigPucker red Harlow nah
      Maybe something with Landon rickets

  • @sergiovelasquez9976
    @sergiovelasquez9976 Před 5 lety +1862

    You know a franchse is damn good when people want a prequel of the prrquel.

    • @ExpressTacoVille
      @ExpressTacoVille Před 5 lety +37

      That’s the best comment I’ve ever heard.

    • @randywhite3947
      @randywhite3947 Před 5 lety +10

      Sergio Velasquez facts

    • @konstantinoskalinteris6447
      @konstantinoskalinteris6447 Před 5 lety +39

      It would be awesome if the next Red Dead Redemption started before the events of the second one and end in the robbery at Blackwater.

    • @vipinanandcpp
      @vipinanandcpp Před 5 lety +7

      I was thinking about it last night....is the prequel of the prequel in the pipeline?

    • @konstantinoskalinteris6447
      @konstantinoskalinteris6447 Před 5 lety +11

      @@vipinanandcpp Yep. But I bet Rockstat wouldn't do it. They dont want the game end like Assasins Creed. A nice idea would be if they make it as a dlc. Am saying this because the dlc hasn't released yet.

  • @eliteboy24
    @eliteboy24 Před 5 lety +431

    Dutch wanted a dramatic life Hosea wanted a simple life

    • @frostycane5134
      @frostycane5134 Před 4 lety +9

      Johnathan OldChief hosea wanted the gang to live
      Dutch wanted Tahiti

    • @limitedoriginz6109
      @limitedoriginz6109 Před 4 lety +6

      Frosty Cane Before you know it we'll be stripping mangoes in Tahiti we just need the money
      -Dutch

    • @veterannugget1389
      @veterannugget1389 Před 4 lety +1

      Wise my friend very wise words

    • @glxckz6471
      @glxckz6471 Před 4 lety

      Australia and tahiti

    • @Abdarahman1405
      @Abdarahman1405 Před 3 lety

      Blackwater massacre and the strange man Is there a link This is a personal analysis If we analyze a massacre with us here, its meanings, innocent people were killed as many, why do we not say that a strange man is among those people who were killed in the massacre, and a guide when meeting John spoke about the girl he killed Dutch Well some ask why John is not Arthur The reason why John thought was the only one who regretted this act 14:07 so the ghost of the strange man come For john. strange man did not tell John who it is This is a personal analysis

  • @ryeguy0508
    @ryeguy0508 Před 5 lety +1066

    Hosea is one of my favourite characters. May he rest in peace

  • @joshbigpp1087
    @joshbigpp1087 Před 5 lety +1662

    the gang easily could have just sen Sadie to blackwater to get the money after she turned bad ass

    • @joshbigpp1087
      @joshbigpp1087 Před 5 lety +73

      @@LanceZu that's my point its a huge plot hole

    • @zmarchal1699
      @zmarchal1699 Před 5 lety +52

      Haha thats so true

    • @dezgravity6433
      @dezgravity6433 Před 5 lety +46

      Omg that’s so true lmao

    • @justanotherperson3076
      @justanotherperson3076 Před 5 lety +126

      Well she might’ve run off with the money

    • @zmarchal1699
      @zmarchal1699 Před 5 lety +38

      @@justanotherperson3076 yeah 1 women is probably not enough fire power for if things go wrong and what not.

  • @traytonvanderecken9329
    @traytonvanderecken9329 Před 5 lety +1008

    Now you mentioned BlackWater I wished RockStar added a secret mission involving the BlackWater robbery gone wrong event.

    • @agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818
      @agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818 Před 5 lety +32

      Dlc or jim milton dlc

    • @arthurmorgan8651
      @arthurmorgan8651 Před 5 lety +11

      @@agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818 Milton, damn Pinkertons!!!

    • @jagged6373
      @jagged6373 Před 5 lety +57

      Like gta v started off. I’m surprised they didn’t start with that. But starting in the mountains in the snow really set the story off right

    • @kylelabelle9273
      @kylelabelle9273 Před 5 lety +9

      Read Dead Online takes place pre Van Der Linde gang. Would be awesome if DLC introduces us to Arthur/Dutch and co and we play out Blackwater.

    • @traytonvanderecken9329
      @traytonvanderecken9329 Před 5 lety +5

      @@kylelabelle9273 I know but I still want a secret mission that takes place in BlackWater.

  • @greezymajor174
    @greezymajor174 Před 5 lety +420

    I Believe Red Dead Redemption 3, We’ll Play As A Character Who Died In The Blackwater Heist, And Eventually End Up Playing As Arthur Morgan At The End

    • @giseleaugustine194
      @giseleaugustine194 Před 5 lety +44

      GreezyMajor 17 I feel like we’d play as Mac or davey

    • @craftingranger7552
      @craftingranger7552 Před 5 lety +49

      Or as Dutch so we have played as the core three. John, Arthur and the man who adopted them Dutch. Then we should get a few missions as Hosea in his youth and when he meets dutch

    • @giseleaugustine194
      @giseleaugustine194 Před 5 lety +35

      Crafting ranger I don’t think anyone would like to play as Dutch after what happened in rdr2

    • @russ8676
      @russ8676 Před 5 lety +14

      Gisele Augustine we will not play as Dave. Because we already saw him. We will sure actually play as Mac.
      Like the first RDR we didnt saw Arthur Morgan.
      Then he is the Main protagonist in RDR2

    • @willgantt5385
      @willgantt5385 Před 4 lety +1

      Or play Hosea

  • @bobthebuilder7097
    @bobthebuilder7097 Před 5 lety +205

    When Sean, Lenny, Hosea all died, I fell into a deep depression

  • @Billy-vp7yp
    @Billy-vp7yp Před 5 lety +723

    It was soo quick at the time but when Lenny died I was soo shook man

  • @NviGWarren
    @NviGWarren Před 5 lety +658

    This would be a great Story from Dutch's perspective.

    • @loganleciago5663
      @loganleciago5663 Před 5 lety +83

      Red dead redemtion 3 should be a prequel to rdr2 from dutchs perspective where her first meets hosea and they build up the gang and ends with the Blackwater thing

    • @jamiemcknight7860
      @jamiemcknight7860 Před 5 lety +14

      Arvid Broström
      No. It would be too much for a DLC

    • @rokai_sky6344
      @rokai_sky6344 Před 5 lety +12

      I had a GAWD DAM PLAN

    • @LetsGetitBoah
      @LetsGetitBoah Před 5 lety +24

      @@loganleciago5663 Agreed, Dutch is a cool character, it would be interesting to see how he became the way he did. They left a lot of lore out there for it to, Annabelle, his fallout with the Colm O'Driscoll, meeting Hosea, Arthur and John, etc.
      I do think they should go that route, plus it would it knock it back further in time, and they could perhaps play around with some post Civil war content being that his dad died in it, Indian nation run-ins, etc. I really think they should make New York be the major cit, as it would be epic or run around mid to late 1800's New York.
      It would be a nice way to wrap up the Trilogy, and make it sort of the Dutch Trilogy when all is said and done.

    • @loganleciago5663
      @loganleciago5663 Před 5 lety +5

      @@LetsGetitBoah I do hope Rockstar does that and keep it a trilogy and not turn it into a new GTA where they make too many games and it gets repetitive.

  • @theinquisitorjohnston
    @theinquisitorjohnston Před 5 lety +343

    Blackwater will definitely be a dlc, everyone will buy it regardless of price, I think it will start just before the fire up north, so it's a fair amount of gameplay

    • @diegovillaneda9788
      @diegovillaneda9788 Před 5 lety +3

      Ben Johnston I hope your right

    • @harishdixit3776
      @harishdixit3776 Před 5 lety +44

      From Van der Linde origin to blackwater massacre might be the main storyline for another red dead game with a different protagonist who died saving the gang at the end with in the blackwater.. they might build up a new character out of nowhere like that of arthur.. and that'd be lit 🔥

    • @jakefitzsimons4245
      @jakefitzsimons4245 Před 5 lety +1

      @@harishdixit3776 that won't happen

    • @nori7185
      @nori7185 Před 5 lety +10

      @@harishdixit3776 Nah the dlc should be about me.

    • @pugking1233
      @pugking1233 Před 5 lety

      Hope so

  • @cristhelivingradio1400
    @cristhelivingradio1400 Před 5 lety +102

    I’m pretty sure that we all can conclude it was one of Dutch’s plans gone wrong and we all gotta give Arthur his props for being the greatest artist in Rockstar’s history of games

  • @victoriar7867
    @victoriar7867 Před 5 lety +240

    Sadie Adler is so underrated honestly

    • @grapefruitjuice9473
      @grapefruitjuice9473 Před 5 lety +15

      Victoria R she is hot

    • @breandanokeefe3575
      @breandanokeefe3575 Před 5 lety +16

      I don’t understand why everybody likes her as a character

    • @victoriar7867
      @victoriar7867 Před 5 lety +27

      Breandan O'Keefe she’s a very good character, she helped Arthur and John a ton when other gang members wouldn’t (I’m not going to state specific instances since I don’t want to spoil anything)

    • @colbalt95
      @colbalt95 Před 5 lety +35

      @@breandanokeefe3575 very good character development. She starts off losing her whole Ranch and her husband to the O'Driscoll boys, starts to become annoying by just crying around for days, heals from it.
      Is egar to take a more intrical part of the crew. Kills a bunch of bad guys, gets revenge for her husband's death. Is still hurt, makes a unbreakable bond with Arthur, saves the crew from the Pinkertons, saves Abigail and kills more Pinkertons and finishes with a life of bounty hunting. Awesome character development

    • @breandanokeefe3575
      @breandanokeefe3575 Před 5 lety +17

      Bacardi Jr. I feel like she is a force fed female protagonist in the age of pc culture where you must include one . I don’t feel like she actually was a good character she was pretty obnoxious tbh but that just my opinion

  • @jedimindtrick75
    @jedimindtrick75 Před 5 lety +91

    It honestly reminds me of Reservoir Dogs.
    The whole movie is about a heist that you never see. You only see the aftermath.
    And eventually, everyone dies.
    I think it is FAR more effective if we never see the failed heist.

    • @abelinc9898
      @abelinc9898 Před 4 lety

      Justin Middleton well we never knew if mr. pink dies though. But that could be John because he makes away with money at the end of the game

  • @SortaProfessional89
    @SortaProfessional89 Před 5 lety +286

    You got it wrong, only 1 died durring the shootout. Sean and Mac got caught and the pinkertons killed Mac interrogating him. Davey got shot and died during the trip to the Grizzlies. Common man its all in the game.

    • @joshneumann2513
      @joshneumann2513 Před 5 lety +42

      InsertInsultHere no you’re wrong, you forgot about Jenny. So it’s Jenny, Mac, and Davey that died AS A RESULT of the black water massacre

    • @SortaProfessional89
      @SortaProfessional89 Před 5 lety

      @@joshneumann2513 jenny died from the trip to colter

    • @terminallumbago6465
      @terminallumbago6465 Před 5 lety +30

      InsertInsultHere No. Davey did. Jenny was dead before the start of the main story. Mac died sometime between the events of the Blackwater Massacre and Arthur's fishing trip with Jack

    • @SortaProfessional89
      @SortaProfessional89 Před 5 lety +1

      @@terminallumbago6465 dude either way believe what you want but The dude who made the video is wrong so stop giving me grief about it

    • @SortaProfessional89
      @SortaProfessional89 Před 5 lety +6

      @@terminallumbago6465 and jenny died durring the escape from boat in blackwater and died before they got to coulter. She's buried in spider gorge near the glacier so I'm not wrong. Some simple research would prove this.

  • @jboyyt477
    @jboyyt477 Před 4 lety +60

    “I have never been to Blackwater.”
    - Arthur Morgan 1899
    Chapter 2

    • @ellamcgarry2262
      @ellamcgarry2262 Před 4 lety +2

      Jboy Gamer and Vlogs if that’s the quote from jimmy brooks, Arthur is trying to cover his identity up haha

    • @truthspeaks6557
      @truthspeaks6557 Před 4 lety +1

      I believe it.. why would he be constantly asking what happened if he was there?

    • @sophiaandjohnsworld2903
      @sophiaandjohnsworld2903 Před 4 lety +2

      @@truthspeaks6557 if you ever read his journals, it CLEARLY states he HAS been to blackwater. He keeps asking what happened because he wasn't at the FERRY Job, however he WAS in blackwater either camped out, or working on a real estate scam with Hosea. M

    • @truthspeaks6557
      @truthspeaks6557 Před 4 lety +2

      No never went that far, but I was talking about the last job. :) good reading tho lol

    • @Drexzzz4
      @Drexzzz4 Před 9 měsíci

      ​@@sophiaandjohnsworld2903yes he was how couldn't he have been if he is the best gunslinger and if you go back in chapter 1 and read the dialogue you can hear Javier says that he was on the other side of town helping them escape 😂

  • @anonymoususer37
    @anonymoususer37 Před 5 lety +15

    "haven't written or drawn much in the past few months, but i was missing it more than i thought i would, so here i am, i guess" oh my GOODNESS, he's precious

  • @falcongxl5209
    @falcongxl5209 Před 4 lety +17

    "4 million dollars... that would be a HUGE heist." I was just thinking about GTA V when he said this

  • @neonpersonishere
    @neonpersonishere Před 4 lety +23

    Despite what most say, Dutch was a great leader but he also turned insane quite realistically after two of the only men that he trusted died. I kind of feel for him.

  • @jthb
    @jthb Před 5 lety +216

    you call the black water heist bad?...should've seen what i did in saint Denise. bounty should've been 10k but stopped at 1.5k

  • @JD-wi2kg
    @JD-wi2kg Před 5 lety +86

    The grave idea is like in the good, the bad, and the ugly.

  • @shurikenzed9107
    @shurikenzed9107 Před 5 lety +154

    3:27
    4 mill a big heist?
    Franklin: hold my beer
    Micheal: hold my beer
    Trevor: hold my beer

    • @darrenschlafer5159
      @darrenschlafer5159 Před 5 lety +28

      Dude, it's 1899, that is a shit ton of money.

    • @mankedek6588
      @mankedek6588 Před 5 lety +36

      *Lamar holding the beers

    • @NotMe-yh5gi
      @NotMe-yh5gi Před 5 lety +10

      @@darrenschlafer5159 yeah 121 million to be exact

    • @occiferfigpucker4840
      @occiferfigpucker4840 Před 5 lety +2

      You must not remember what happened when Trevor interacted with John in RDR2..

    • @slackerboy1488
      @slackerboy1488 Před 5 lety

      He said it would be 4 million nowadays not back then so yes 150000 would be good back then and they would be set this guys right about Franklin,micheal and trevor they had a way bigger take than 4 mill lmao

  • @Msunuwakho
    @Msunuwakho Před 5 lety +198

    Don’t forget to play at 1.25x

  • @cloudsweater
    @cloudsweater Před 5 lety +50

    This whole game is setting up for another prequel so I’m excited to see the rise and origins of the gang. I’m very excited! 🔥

  • @jamesthepeacock1919
    @jamesthepeacock1919 Před 5 lety +77

    I hope they make Read Dead Redemption 3 where you play as Arthur and it is the build-up to the Blackwater Massacre and the gang's life when it was more stable.

    • @miguelcaramel6598
      @miguelcaramel6598 Před 5 lety +2

      Mr A Morgan id love that but I don’t think rdr3 will be another prequel, there will definitely be another red dead but idk about another’s red dead redemption

    • @paigelord4378
      @paigelord4378 Před 5 lety +3

      I'd like to play the third game as Dutch. I think that would be interesting

    • @thepowerofyes8282
      @thepowerofyes8282 Před 5 lety +2

      @@paigelord4378 I got a plan!!

    • @glok1394
      @glok1394 Před 5 lety +2

      Wouldn’t it be cool to play the game as Jack after he became in outlaw at the end of RDR1

    • @paigelord4378
      @paigelord4378 Před 5 lety

      @@glok1394 omggg yes

  • @norvinzor
    @norvinzor Před 5 lety +222

    So Do we really have to wait 8 years for RDR 3 to figure out what happen in Blackwater? shit lol

    • @playboid6543
      @playboid6543 Před 5 lety +1

      norvinzor eh idrk only person we have left to play as is jack or a young dutch or sum

    • @generalgrax
      @generalgrax Před 5 lety +13

      @@playboid6543 Landon Ricketts origin story, mark my words. He'll be the Pro-tag for RDR3 & RDR4

    • @zmarchal1699
      @zmarchal1699 Před 5 lety +2

      @@generalgrax or dlc

    • @SleepyMook
      @SleepyMook Před 5 lety +6

      norvinzor I personally thing the Redemption storyline is over. They should do another red dead game that isn’t redemption.

    • @generalgrax
      @generalgrax Před 5 lety +2

      @red devil A new voice actor is needed if you're telling Landon Ricketts origin story anyway good Sir.

  • @bloodvayne8183
    @bloodvayne8183 Před 2 lety +17

    The amount of detail that Rockstar put into red dead redemption 2 is insane love this game

  • @wooza5919
    @wooza5919 Před 5 lety +107

    I feel like rdr3 will be the Van Der Linde gang before the blackwater massacre and then the Blackwater Massacre in the end causes some sort of grief and downfall kinda like the saint denis bank robbery

    • @virgoearth7185
      @virgoearth7185 Před 5 lety

      I think so too jch

    • @jakefitzsimons4245
      @jakefitzsimons4245 Před 5 lety

      That won't happen

    • @SleepyMook
      @SleepyMook Před 5 lety +7

      jesus christ himself I don’t think there will be an rdr3. There will be another Red Dead game but not in the Redemption series as I feel like the redemption series is over

    • @wooza5919
      @wooza5919 Před 5 lety

      @Moon King yeah now that I think about it, we might play as a character tho like young dutch

    • @wooza5919
      @wooza5919 Před 5 lety

      @@SleepyMook Well it wud just take a long time to make another one

  • @phd-doom2100
    @phd-doom2100 Před 5 lety +75

    Dutch probably killed the woman in Blackwater the same way he killed the woman in the bank in rd1 when John confronted him and tried to bring him in

    • @Javyz15
      @Javyz15 Před 4 lety +3

      Or the old lady that spoke spanish

    • @weed3728
      @weed3728 Před 4 lety

      Captain Headass25 he most likely killed her like he killed the old lady in Guarma

    • @williamgitchell6964
      @williamgitchell6964 Před 4 lety

      Bc he got a concussion in the trolly accident he kills unnecessary after that

    • @noose04
      @noose04 Před 4 lety

      @Turok Hilsen i thought the same

  • @thetankguy9263
    @thetankguy9263 Před 5 lety +20

    Hey ya'll I just realised something, in GTA V it started with a robbery gone wrong, and in RDR II it starts with a robbery gone wrong. See my point?

  • @D00Rb3LL
    @D00Rb3LL Před 5 lety +12

    This just goes to show that when times are good, Dutch can preach his morals and seems like a good guy, but in times of crisis, he shows who he really is.

    • @sanobunz
      @sanobunz Před 2 měsíci

      there is no fake dutch. all we saw was dutch, he wasn't always a inhumane coward, he was a person given the wrong cards but he kept playing. the anxiety and guilt of blackwater has overtaken him every time he messed up and someone dies bc he plays the fools gambit, that's when he started to self destruct

  • @rhiannamorrow-kakewash9409
    @rhiannamorrow-kakewash9409 Před 5 lety +801

    Me when i see this😀😀😀😀 when i realize it was MRBOSSFTW 😫😫😫
    Thanks guys i never get more than 7 likes like seriosly thanks guys🙏

  • @cthulhuthecritic1186
    @cthulhuthecritic1186 Před 5 lety +34

    I would like to see dlc about young Arthur, even further wear then New Austin. It would be a true wild western

    • @Sharktankgaming
      @Sharktankgaming Před 5 lety +2

      No one thought that a prequel to RDR would've worked and yet here we are. Yes, another prequel for RDR3 as Dutch, or even Hosea, with Arthur as a teen or even Marston as a child like Jack could be amazing. A REAL western like you said. However, I am also keen to see Jacks story after killing Ross.

    • @CaptainRawlings-1-SFOD-DTFW
      @CaptainRawlings-1-SFOD-DTFW Před 4 lety

      It is a true western this is the shit that happened in 1890s all outlaws were hunted down

    • @viveka2994
      @viveka2994 Před 4 lety

      @@CaptainRawlings-1-SFOD-DTFW wrong.... Wild west ended in 1913 i think with the last state being admitted into the US

  • @louzer2566
    @louzer2566 Před 5 lety +91

    150k in 1899 is worth WAY MORE than 4 million due to inflation.

  • @billcasey3492
    @billcasey3492 Před 5 lety +59

    I want a New Austin/Blackwater DLC where you play as Mac Callander...
    He has the best ending getting left behind with Sean and shot by the Pinkertons...
    Get to know his brother Davey and Jenny Kirk, get to spend more time with the gang, beat up 15 sailors...

    • @bentomlins785
      @bentomlins785 Před 5 lety +2

      Yeah if there is another prequel I reckon that's what it would be

    • @shepherd8878
      @shepherd8878 Před 5 lety

      Bill Casey I was thinking that too.

    • @despacitosuarez
      @despacitosuarez Před 4 lety

      @Scorpion Stings maybe pull off what gta 5 did and play as multiple people

    • @chumby2862
      @chumby2862 Před 4 lety

      @Scorpion Stings Jenny is the only gang member to die IN blackwater. Mac and Sean kinda escape but we know that Sean is caught and by the time the Pinkertons catch up with Mac, he's basically dead already. Milton interrogates him and then kills him.

    • @weed3728
      @weed3728 Před 4 lety

      Fat Pancake Jenny Kirk DID NOT die in Blackwater and neither did Davey lol they were both fatally injured and succumbed to their wounds before the gang could reach colter which is why Jenny was buried in spider gorge which is really really close to colter Mac was the only one that we know who could have potentially died in Blackwater..John was also shot but he didn’t have a fatal wound like Jenny & Davey so conclusion Davey & Jenny died as a result of the Blackwater massacre but they didn’t die during the Blackwater massacre so please learn your lore before making a comment also as for Mac he could’ve died during interrogation but Milton says when he came across Mac he was shot up really bad Milton also says his death was slow but merciful meaning he probably let him die of his wounds or Milton himself finished him off

  • @chrisneal6374
    @chrisneal6374 Před 5 lety +4

    Touching dialogue by John. I need to start hanging around the gang more. Thanks for the video bro!

  • @cpt.roosto2097
    @cpt.roosto2097 Před 5 lety +8

    Very well-done, dude. I really hope Rockstar does more with this. It would be awesome to play as Arthur again and relive this heist. It would be even cooler to a prequel to RDR2 that takes place long before, and maybe you play as Dutch and build the gang up and prosper.

    • @ViolentGenius
      @ViolentGenius Před 9 měsíci +1

      Arthur wasn't at the Black Water heist. He and Hosea were elsewhere working on a different job.

  • @emmanueldeita5362
    @emmanueldeita5362 Před 5 lety +68

    Black water massacre is mentioned in RDR1

    • @uashookonecaesar3481
      @uashookonecaesar3481 Před 5 lety

      I don’t remember , when do they mention it ?

    • @jtg2k10
      @jtg2k10 Před 5 lety +2

      @@uashookonecaesar3481 when John talks to ricketts in Mexico

    • @uashookonecaesar3481
      @uashookonecaesar3481 Před 5 lety

      sweeg yolo thanks , What do they say ?

    • @thedarksaber
      @thedarksaber Před 4 lety +3

      @@uashookonecaesar3481 the strange man also talks about it which is really creepy

    • @weed3728
      @weed3728 Před 4 lety

      BessySwordSaberDark SpankenheimerGloryGreatest he also describes how the girl looked after Dutch shot her in the head lol

  • @Dean0mac
    @Dean0mac Před 5 lety +1

    Your videos are so well done and done in such a way that keeps me coming back. Keep up the great work

  • @samOG97
    @samOG97 Před 5 lety +7

    Red dead redemption 3 we are absolutely playing as Dutch van der linde

  • @dacastardust
    @dacastardust Před 4 lety +3

    Great video man, thanks! Ever since I completed the game the first time, I've really wanted them to either give us a DLC or even RDR3 set even further back than RDR2 so we really get to see more backstory, character growth and finally what went down in Blackwater. Who knows if we'll ever get anything, but they placed so much emphasis on Blackwater that it wouldn't make sense to NOT go back and fill in the blanks. I guess we just wait and see!

  • @DigitalMirage0303
    @DigitalMirage0303 Před 5 lety +49

    It wold be cool if Rockstar made another Red Dead Redemption, but you get to play as a younger Dutch Van Der Linde

    • @brianames35f
      @brianames35f Před 5 lety

      I was going to say that

    • @nigilandrews7848
      @nigilandrews7848 Před 5 lety

      What duch going to die at age 21 or 30 that what i know or be

    • @nigilandrews7848
      @nigilandrews7848 Před 5 lety +1

      Or we can play as john marston dad since he died at a Chicago bar fight

    • @vankatalaz6850
      @vankatalaz6850 Před 5 lety +1

      Well I think that Rockstar made a statement in which they said that there will be a 3rd game where you play as Dutch a create the gang,and the forth where you play as jack during the prohibition era and it's going to be the last one

    • @ElRosco187
      @ElRosco187 Před 4 lety +1

      @@vankatalaz6850 That I can get with, that way everybody gets what they want.

  • @pawankhatuwala3582
    @pawankhatuwala3582 Před 5 lety +2

    Thx for the info man it is very helpful . I just started the game and wondered the same question u mentioned, thx a lot man

  • @jacobmiller9106
    @jacobmiller9106 Před 5 lety +2

    I like your videos, you don't beat around the bush trying to get more play time, you actually tell the story and entertain.

  • @SnowyRains
    @SnowyRains Před 5 lety +5

    I really hope they expand on this story and time in their lives

  • @weeman5520
    @weeman5520 Před 5 lety +5

    During the last mission when you’re riding back to camp. You hear horsea say “we’ve turned into a bunch of killers, I mean it” so horesa was right all along

    • @erikallen3804
      @erikallen3804 Před 4 lety

      Hosea* And he also predicted Dutch becoming a careless murderer in RDR1, relentlessly killing anyone who stands in his path for money, which he tries to hide in RDR2.

  • @frazerfox9813
    @frazerfox9813 Před 5 lety +1

    Great vid keep it up

  • @kbrad86
    @kbrad86 Před 5 lety

    Great video been watching you for ages also love red dead redemption 2

  • @justanotherdayor2752
    @justanotherdayor2752 Před 5 lety +13

    Rdr 3 should be a prequel too and it leads up to the black water job at the end. You should play as Mac since he died and we didn’t even get to see it and since John and Arthur both die at the end of their games

    • @luisp7919
      @luisp7919 Před 5 lety

      Ju Mane yeah the only problem would be who took revenge for macs death apparently agent Ross killed him but Arthur kills him or Sadie on the mission they go save Abigail and all these haves have revenge that’s the only problem I see

    • @Mvxzzz
      @Mvxzzz Před 5 lety

      @@luisp7919 that was'nt Ross that was Milton and Abigail shot him not Saide or Arthur
      Edit: Ik since I did the mission the other day, I'm not trying to be rude but I wanted, to correct you also, Jack Marston killed Ross in RDR 1

    • @ElRosco187
      @ElRosco187 Před 4 lety

      Just needs to be full on DLC.

  • @kadinho6302
    @kadinho6302 Před 5 lety +10

    Red Dead Redemption III confirmed

  • @vicariousgamer2871
    @vicariousgamer2871 Před 5 lety +1

    OMG, there is so much untold/unknown lore. I'm really looking forward to more RDR. This awesome title has captivated me. Rockstar must have quite the number of cards up their sleeves containing the awesomeness of the continuing sage of RDR.
    Personally... I CANNOT WAIT ! 'Currently', wringing hands in anticipation.

  • @taivitolo4482
    @taivitolo4482 Před 5 lety +2

    Thanks for the infovi never really knew exactly what happened

  • @awesomejwiz5929
    @awesomejwiz5929 Před 5 lety +26

    I think Heidi died because she was taken hostage by Dutch so the gang could get out, the eye wouldn’t pop out unless she was shot in the side of the head which would only be possible if she was taken hostage a gun being held up to her head. And the brains got plastered on the wall sideways because the gun was so close.

    • @manaswin123
      @manaswin123 Před 5 lety +4

      @crusty0123 That genius!! (in the plot term, of course) it will be tragic that everyone start to question themselves and flashback (or foresee) to the event in RDR1 that Dutch is not change, he just become true to himself (as Arthur suspect in the end) too.

    • @pugking1233
      @pugking1233 Před 5 lety

      You ever seen buck shot to the face it's possible but unlikely

    • @ozpoz645
      @ozpoz645 Před 4 lety

      You're dumb.

  • @cebgaming1740
    @cebgaming1740 Před 5 lety +52

    I hope there is a third red dead

    • @irvinalexanderflores
      @irvinalexanderflores Před 5 lety +6

      This is the third "red dead"

    • @cebgaming1740
      @cebgaming1740 Před 5 lety

      What do you mean

    • @irvinalexanderflores
      @irvinalexanderflores Před 5 lety +4

      Red Dead Revolver the first Red Dead game Red Dead Redemption is the second one and Red Dead Redemption 2 is the third one

    • @tavish4699
      @tavish4699 Před 5 lety +1

      Hopefully not ! The third Part Is allways shit ....

    • @dangerousboxx666
      @dangerousboxx666 Před 5 lety +1

      @@irvinalexanderflores red dead revolver isnt canon as far as red dead redemption 1 and 2 go.

  • @kelgoneimy
    @kelgoneimy Před rokem

    Excellent job!!!

  • @Benny_g3
    @Benny_g3 Před 5 lety

    Thank you boas this was a great video

  • @justacommentator8298
    @justacommentator8298 Před 5 lety +8

    16:25 look in the background at miss grimshaw

  • @verysillydeepfakes1583
    @verysillydeepfakes1583 Před 3 lety +3

    I find it kinda unsettling, that I already know what will happen to John and Abigail. It kinda takes out the joy of building up a new life for them.

  • @MrDAYing
    @MrDAYing Před 5 lety

    I like your videos bro just subscribed thanks for the content

  • @Relic67
    @Relic67 Před 5 lety

    Thank you for all your research and for sharing.

  • @all-stargamingentertainmen1157

    We also know it was micahs score...and pretty much any job with him ends the same way...makes you wonder who was setting the gang up....trelawney was gone for months...john keeps popping in and out making you think he cut that deal with the pinkertons earlier than we seen in rdr...

  • @tubz6591
    @tubz6591 Před 4 lety +6

    It hasn't answered all the questions like when Micha told John he's got the money from blackwater when john collect the money he only has $20,000 and that includes all of Micha's gangs robberies and also the blackwater money. So wheres the other $130,000

  • @jayswanson1621
    @jayswanson1621 Před 5 lety

    Great job on the vid keep it up man🙂

  • @ashtube6801
    @ashtube6801 Před 5 lety

    Hi, mr boss. I Love you’re vids. I think they are high quality content. You are the best CZcamsr.

  • @Victor77070
    @Victor77070 Před 5 lety +7

    RDR2 DLC Wishlist:
    Undead Nightmare 2 & Blackwater Massacre
    Jack Marston Prohibition Era DLC or third installment of RDR

    • @AK-pr6hj
      @AK-pr6hj Před 4 lety +1

      I hope they make a game about a mafoso (either jewish or italian) during the prohibition in which Jack is a significant side charakter who makes alcohol and is associated to either the italian or the jewish mafia (idk of which).

  • @thesinistergambino5922
    @thesinistergambino5922 Před 5 lety +9

    Ironically, the same day this video came out, I am now hearing that this said agency sent a cease and desist to Take Two. Interesting timing with this video.

    • @KremsonKills
      @KremsonKills Před 5 lety

      What

    • @goes2four82
      @goes2four82 Před 5 lety

      The Sinister Gambino wut, thats like police sueing Rockstar

    • @thesinistergambino5922
      @thesinistergambino5922 Před 5 lety

      Cold Water I heard about it from GTA Series Videos, on their Twitter they have something about it with a link to official documentation or whatever as well. I even see IGN and Gamespot or whatever etc. bringing it up now.

    • @KremsonKills
      @KremsonKills Před 5 lety

      @@thesinistergambino5922 i dont understand whats going on here

    • @sell7825
      @sell7825 Před 5 lety

      What are you talking about

  • @DBLCreations
    @DBLCreations Před 5 lety

    Ha, a prequel of a prequel? I surely would like a story expansion of this blackwater events! Great video, thank you! :-)

  • @oc1omaen
    @oc1omaen Před 3 lety +2

    I picked this game up last year and put it down because I found it a bit overwhelming, especially with the controls and I died a lot easier than I expected. Picked it back recently and gave it another chance, started all over and I’m addicted to it. Even if I’m not playing any missions to advance the story, I like just looking around and discovering new things.

  • @thatlazguy
    @thatlazguy Před 5 lety +8

    Just had a mad idea boys. Red Dead 3, prequel to Red Dead 2, You play as Dutch himself, form the gang and play up until where Red Dead 2 starts. Bingo, all the story is then told.

  • @williamchitwood8758
    @williamchitwood8758 Před 5 lety +10

    I'd like to go as far back as the beginning. When Arthur and John first meet Dutch

  • @swblermusic5228
    @swblermusic5228 Před 5 lety

    Honestly you just answered all my questions :p

  • @mrfox9618
    @mrfox9618 Před 5 lety

    Keep it up bro!

  • @totallyquakerz6976
    @totallyquakerz6976 Před 4 lety +3

    Blackwater would have made a good for a good Prologue, like when R* did a prologue in GTA V

  • @epicmonkey6663
    @epicmonkey6663 Před 5 lety +8

    I hope for the next game it's another prequel where we see how the van der linde gang start out and this time you get two players Arthur again I think it should show when Hosea and Dutch first met all the way up to when we play as young Arthur and instead of him being as grumpy as he is he's more relaxed personally I think this makes sense because the first game was set at the very end with John Marston capturing former Gang members and getting his Redemption the second game starts out with them on the Run losing there cool and being more obvious basically becoming incompetent and desperate along with Dutch and his non-existent plan but the 3rd game should be when the Gang forms and then when they are in their Prime committing Train Robbery bank robberies without the law being down on them so quickly and they are more competent and able to get away with crimes and the end credits scene should show the Blackwater massacre in it's entirety

    • @ItDies.
      @ItDies. Před 5 lety

      @Stephen Murray 😂😂

    • @ItDies.
      @ItDies. Před 5 lety

      @Stephen Murray tbh dutch was scared shitless and he had micah in his ear all the time and also in rdr 1 when micahs dead dutch nevr came to iill john even tho he knew john was alive

    • @ElRosco187
      @ElRosco187 Před 4 lety

      That can be DLC.

  • @jessicagregory4683
    @jessicagregory4683 Před 5 lety

    Good job at this nice story to catch on

  • @Xetenor
    @Xetenor Před 5 lety +1

    Really loving the content man. Playing the game from beginning thanks to the awesome videos you put up :) I never did the valentines prostitute serial killer quest before and got to do it last night. Pretty satisfying capturing her and turning her in haha

  • @rootytootymcshooty9568
    @rootytootymcshooty9568 Před 5 lety +6

    When you hear that more than 37 people died in Blackwater but you realize can kill 300 cops in saint denise
    "Its rewind time"

    • @loganpretty6499
      @loganpretty6499 Před 4 lety

      Communist Comrade wait what I fought Saint Denis was a little worse than black water

  • @EgoCityGamingUK
    @EgoCityGamingUK Před 5 lety +33

    Surely blackwater will be a dlc?

  • @PhoenIXPhantasies
    @PhoenIXPhantasies Před rokem +2

    3 years later and Rockstar still didn't give us anything.. I want more. I need more. I miss this world.

  • @cabron1984
    @cabron1984 Před měsícem

    This is game has so much detail, when John was speaking by the fire his animation is real life like. Like he was really telling the story

  • @Colinmafia
    @Colinmafia Před 5 lety +25

    All the money is in Dutchs strongbox at the end of the game in the mountains, dutch walks off into the snow but as John Marston i killed Dutch in Red Dead Redemption 1 and ill do it again if its remastered as a DLC like they are saying Lol

    • @StrifeRixa
      @StrifeRixa Před 5 lety +4

      It'd be cool to have yet another epilogue chapter where you play as Jack

    • @ragingpug8344
      @ragingpug8344 Před 5 lety +1

      RDR3 👀

    • @stevencook1078
      @stevencook1078 Před 5 lety +5

      Dutch jumps off a cliff, Dutch kills himself but you almost got it

    • @RedDragon91
      @RedDragon91 Před 5 lety

      I'm wondering why they would make it a dlc considering rdr1 has already been remastered.... It would be a waste of money to remake the game a 3rd time

    • @agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818
      @agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818 Před 5 lety

      If they do a remastered thry can change thr story with good moral bad

  • @dylanbiddle8207
    @dylanbiddle8207 Před 5 lety +4

    4 mill is a big heist?
    Franklin: hold my weed
    Michael: hold my cigar
    Trevor: RON!! HOLD MY METH

    • @IMNTV
      @IMNTV Před 5 lety

      Lamar: holds weed
      Amanda: Holds cigar
      Ron: holds methamphetamine

  • @theCurbSide
    @theCurbSide Před 2 lety +2

    I'd really like it if they made a prequel showing the evolution of the gang, from the very beginning, all the way to the blackwater massacre. Maybe even play as Dutch so u can understand his thought process a little better

  • @CowboyJon97
    @CowboyJon97 Před 5 lety

    Yo MBFTW love your work bro. Everything has been super helpful since day 1 gta days. I need help.. I absolutely fell in love with buel he was my favorite horse and I was distraught once I was in the final moments in game and he was killed. Then of course Mr Morgan topped it off in the saddest way. Was buel the only Cramello gold in game or is there a location to tame a wild one. If you take the time to respond to this if you even see it. I’d be above grateful. Keep living your best life.

  • @thatonefpsgamer1339
    @thatonefpsgamer1339 Před 5 lety +4

    Landon Rickets may have been in it to let's not forget

  • @10ksubswithoutavideo78
    @10ksubswithoutavideo78 Před 5 lety +73

    Hi hope you reading the comments have a great day 😃✌

  • @lonewolfgamingplus379
    @lonewolfgamingplus379 Před 5 lety +1

    John’s campfire story at Bunchier’s Keep freaking scary man. He’s scared of knowing the gang is coming to a end.

  • @leveliiientertainment2212

    MrBossFTW i would like to thank you for taking the time to help with this stroke of brilliance that is this game red dead redemption2! This has changed my whole outlook on what these games are and what they will be. And also to all these haters to just come here to down the guy making the video just be lucky that there is someone like james. You sir are really why I have gotten so far in this game! This game and not gta will set the tone for what future masterpieces should be like. Btw gta is a griefers fuckin dream and a workers curse! GTA is armadillo!!!

  • @darksinner6916
    @darksinner6916 Před 5 lety +3

    Awesome

  • @mekhiFR
    @mekhiFR Před 5 lety +3

    Hey love the vids

  • @billymidnight5911
    @billymidnight5911 Před 5 lety +1

    Rock star should make a DLC about the Blackwater massacre. Make new missions and what Dutch did. Cut scene: Dutch holding a young girl hostage. Bill, Javier, and John holding up hostages. Second scene: the massacre begins. See Davey get shot, sean get knocked out, Mac makes a run. The whole gang makes a run for it while the streets are raining bullets. Third scene: where they left the money and which way they flead off too. Now that would be a great DLC.

  • @mawicorey
    @mawicorey Před 4 lety +2

    It would be cool to see a DLC that starts when they come to Blackwater.Seeing Arthur and Hosea running their scams,then going to the Ferry job and seeing what happened.Frop the 1st game when the Strange man said Dutch shot the preety girl I always wondered what happened.Hope rockstar goes into this 1 day!

  • @ccorter1985
    @ccorter1985 Před 5 lety +3

    hidy mocoy is related to the deputy in rodes in chapter

  • @GreenSteedaGT
    @GreenSteedaGT Před 5 lety +16

    The robbery on the ferry isn't the same thing as the Blackwater Massacre......

    • @indy3130
      @indy3130 Před 5 lety

      Oryx The Taken King your thinking of the strawberry massacre

    • @jakefitzsimons4245
      @jakefitzsimons4245 Před 5 lety +2

      Yes it is

    • @GreenSteedaGT
      @GreenSteedaGT Před 5 lety +3

      @@jakefitzsimons4245 No, it isn't. 22 outlaws and 15 police officers were killed in the Blackwater Massacre. They are separate events. Even the Red Dead wiki is wrong.

    • @jakefitzsimons4245
      @jakefitzsimons4245 Před 5 lety +1

      @@GreenSteedaGT no dude there the same
      The lore was just changed in rdr2
      The 15 outlaw 22 lawmen thing is no longer Canon in the universe
      Trust me

    • @GreenSteedaGT
      @GreenSteedaGT Před 5 lety +1

      @@jakefitzsimons4245 Bullshit. The massacre was outlaws vs. police and Landon Ricketts, not a robbery gone wrong.

  • @youngtriadbeats4932
    @youngtriadbeats4932 Před 5 lety +2

    I know what this game needs, another DLC that takes place in Blackwater that would give players an idea of what exactly went down and a chance to know the dead characters you don't see in the game.
    But it would be cool if I played as Dutch this time.

  • @seanmichalek9830
    @seanmichalek9830 Před 5 lety

    Okay fine I take back what I said you’re legit this is a good video.

  • @markvickers6776
    @markvickers6776 Před 5 lety +4

    Notification sqauddd!!! Love the vids

  • @dannywisher1078
    @dannywisher1078 Před 5 lety +41

    The gaming community has the worst type of haters because it's made up mostly of nerds who have been bullied all there life.

    • @bobofinn5550
      @bobofinn5550 Před 5 lety +7

      Wh community do you belong to

    • @whatislife459
      @whatislife459 Před 5 lety

      Or dads with abusive asses maybe bosses which can be hell

    • @atease7651
      @atease7651 Před 5 lety +8

      *their

    • @atease7651
      @atease7651 Před 5 lety +8

      *lives

    • @beatdown5215
      @beatdown5215 Před 5 lety

      I was actually the bully in school. I love getting suspended from school just so I could stay home and play Video games lol

  • @ryuman757
    @ryuman757 Před 5 lety

    Crazy to think that some of the most intense conversations you hear in this game, are 𝘖𝘗𝘛𝘐𝘖𝘕𝘈𝘓.