Jazak Allah Khair. There is an extremely well-put together video by Dr. Qunaibi on YT titled "Darwin's Theory of Evolution: A Fair Discussion" you should check it out! The good thing about the video is that it covers that epistemological aspect that lead to the un-empirical assumptions introduced to it.
I agree you 100%. believe in evolution is not kufur, but isnot part aqidah. Because evoution is just model, accept or reject. Its not about faith/belief. And another things, Textually and contextually, Alquran never say adam As is first man, or adam come from in the sky/heavens. and why does Quran compare the creation of the prophet Adam as a parable of the creation of the prophet Isa?? This seems to imply the creation of the prophet Adam in the womb as well as the creation of the prophet Jesus/isa who was born from the womb. Its like partenogenesis😂. Partenogenesis of mamalia never have naturally. But artificially.
I would like to add my thoughts on the matter based on my understanding of the verses I’ve read: The conversation between Allah (S.W.T.) and the angels before the creation of Adam (A.S.) raises three things. 1: The Earth had been there long before Adam (A.S.) came into existence. In another verse, it mentions that we were created from the earth, to it we return, and from it we are raised again. The Quran comes first and foremost, and only ahadeeth that are completely consistent with the Quran should be accepted. In one Hadith, Adam (A.S.) is described as being created from a mixture of several distinct earths, like dirt. This is the origin of Adam. The term 'A-D-M' might mean the following: A state of mixing or mingling, as in the earth. It makes sense that we return to the ground from which Adam was initially created. 2: Angels do not possess information that God did not teach them or that they themselves have not witnessed. (2:32) 3: The angels mentioned something that supports the second point: “Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?” (2:30) This suggests they were already familiar with corruption and bloodshed. And they had brought it up when Allah (S.W.T.) mentioned creating a succession on earth. The significance is here: Adam was made of the earth to dwell on the earth. The Earth was most likely already inhabited if we base it on what the angels knew. The thought that Allah (SWT) made evolution possible should not be fully discarded, just as we cannot completely dismiss any religious texts that existed prior to the Quran or Injeel if we believe it was the final written record before the Quran. And the passages about the Sabt reinforce the notion that Allah (SWT) transformed one creation into another. So it isn’t far into the realm of impossibilities. The difference is this: Adam (A.S.) was formed by Allah (S.W.T.) in the form he was created in, indicating that we are a distinct species with possible links to the dirt from which we were created. And, to add to your previous video, the Dukhan, the Heaven, was present (Astwa 3la *as’sama*), but it was divided into seven (fas’sawahun sab3 samawat). If we assume that the earth and all that it contains were created through that Dukhan and that we were created of the earth, that is another link altogether. To end it, I’ll add that pushing for a new idea of what Allah (S.W.T.) did or did not do without proper knowledge is a sin in itself. Just as we shouldn’t determine where people will end up in Qiyammah without knowledge (19:78), And Allah’hu A3lam. May Allah (S.W.T) forgive us for our ignorance on such matters and for any ill conceived of it.
We Muslims need to be more open minded to these sorts of things. Allah is all powerful and there's no saying He cannot make His creations through evolution.
@@ryamsosohbajjaikoasknd just let go of something as controversial as this. in the original video he spoke about the possibility of human evolution, why do you need to believe in it so bad, you wont die without believing in evolution, stick to the traditional view of the scholars of Islam and move on with your life for Gods sake.
Remember at one time, surgeons laughed at the idea of washing hands before surgery. And drugs like cocaine and morphine were advertised as non addictive drugs. Don’t rest your faith on everchanging science.
Your original video was excellent and very nuanced mashAllah. Animal evolution is not an issue for those with an Islamic worldview, it is however for Christians (see the first page of the Bible). So many of the ignorant amongst our community have picked up from them the cause of unnecessarily fighting the field of evolutionary biology, when we don’t have to, unlike fundamentalist Christian’s. Speaking as someone with a academic background in science but always happy to be challenged :)
Ehab Abouheif is a Muslim evolutionary biologist, he has lectures on youtube that you can watch. There's also Rana Dajani, she's a Muslim molecular biologist from Jordan, she also has lectures about evolution that you can watch. Please watch
Yes we evolved, we had gigantic body now small, we were tall , now small, we were powerful, now weak , now we have more communication skills and intelligence
@@azikazikazik not to be disrespectful I'm also muslim but probably he was not as intelligent as any other person like jesus moses muhammad(peace be upon them) were actually intelligent and did something for people You cant call adam(as) really intelligent or can you who knows he might have discovered fire but still not as intelligent
What I believe now is that our father Adam is created by God's hands and then Our mother Eve was created from Adam, this is what the Quran states clearly, then the evolution occured and the differentiations appeared. Believing that evolutions occured after Adam by God's will does not contradict Islam, But believing that Adam himself is a decent from monkeys or so then this contradict the clear verses and it's Kufr.
Just found ur channel, and I honestly love the content you make. I'm a revert myself at a similar age as you so it's nice to see someone like me on here spreading Islam.
I don't see evolution contradicts Islam. I recall speaking to a Christian friend who struggled with evolution and the creation story. My simple answer is that Allah is not bound by time. We, as humans and his slaves are. A day for Allah, maybe a millennia or more. We do not know, as a day for us is based on circumventing the Sun. Evolution is simply us understanding the magnificence of the creator. We worship and believe in Allah, we learn about evolution.
And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, “Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority.” They said, “Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?” Allah said, “Indeed, I know that which you do not know.” This verse was induced before Adam was created.. which states a human-like creature.. could it be an ancient human?
We do evolve, but not from monke, we are already different from monkeys and other mammals, evolving doesnt even necessarily means we (our species) werent human at the begining of time. Besides, evolution is just a theory, no one have ever been confirming it.
@@hyumiliatedbs3355 You said "just a theory" implying that being called a theory means there is no evidence or that theories are not important in science. Gravity is a theory, germs are a theory, there are so many important and true things that are scientific theories.
@@hyumiliatedbs3355 I see you are failing to understand what I'm saying. Just look up what the word theory means in science. That might explain it to you.
According to the following verse, the possibility of evolution has been mentioned in Quran. Qur'an 2:30 is as follows: And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority." They (Angels) said, "Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?" Allah said, "Indeed, I know that which you do not know." This verse can explain that already on the earth there were some creatures similar to human being ( eg; Neanderthals ) and apparently this indicate angles already had an image of how human being might be. This can clearly explains the possibility of evaluation and the Difference between Adam descendants that came from heaven and other types of similar to human creatures
@@SenatorTalib the verse has clearly mentioned that angles asked about creation of the human and blood shed that they have caused on the earth, there is nothing about Jinns. please read the ayah before write a comment!!!
@@bahaaabwini4834 ayah clearly mentions about human creation, what Jinn?! it requires some levels of IQ to process it. its just simple, you can read the whole Chapter, its about creation of Adam, when angles question God why are you creating something that cause corruption and bloodshed on the earth! so they must have seen something similar to Adam on the earth that have done such things!
Waalaikumussalam warohmatullahi wabarokatuh. Thank you for adressing the comments, and this is a great video as always. Keep it up. May Allah always bless you in this beautiful month of ramadhan❤❤
Humans also evolve Noah (as) gave dawah for 900 years We don’t have high life expectancy than them But we did not come from apes Adam (as) Eve and people at their time were tall This hadith was narrated by Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said: “Allah created Adam and he was sixty cubits tall. Then He said, ‘Go and greet those angels and listen to how they greet you, for that will be your greeting and the greeting of your progeny.’ He said, ‘Al-salamu ‘alaykum (Peace be upon you).’ They said, ‘Al-salamu ‘alaykum wa rahmat-Allah (Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah).’ So they added the words ‘wa rahmat Allah.’ And everyone who enters Paradise will be in the form of Adam. People kept on growing smaller until now.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari, 3336; Muslim, 7092)
It doesn’t actually contradict it, only the version the atheists created contradicts it, have you ever thought about it? The model of evolution atheists created was never proven to be the real one Second islam isn’t a mythology, it’s the truth
Islam isn’t a mythology, its the true religion, as a muslim who searched about miracles of the quran and islam, i have seen enough to know that there is no doubt in allah and islam
The genetic similarity doesn’t have to mean anything. If you look at our abilities, they are similar to those of the monkeys, many characteristics are similar and this would go back to a similar DNA. This doesn’t mean though that Adam or Humans have to be from Monkeys, rather it could be that Allah created us with genetics similar to the ones of monkeys & we therefore have similar abilities. Tell people to not think about it too much since biology and science has many times shown that it shifts and isn’t static, also conclusions of biological findings or facts can differ immensely and usually the one most probable (as of the time in which the findings are analysed) are taken but this doesn’t have to mean that the most probable always happens, especially when you talk about something being created aka interventions not coming from inside
Could you please make a video about hafs warsh and the other recitations and its explanation. there are words in one that are plural in the other quran recitation or completely different word.
For me? Evolution is still a question. We don't have that much resources and knowledge to claim that it's true or not. Probably you all can argue that viruses evolve each day, but compared to us it's just like we're developing a new weapon. But if we take examples of Adam AS 60 cubits tall compared to us somewhere between 140-200 cm, and our life expectancy from 60-70 compared to Nuh AS that is told could stand for 900+ years, it is possible that humans evolved (or devolved). I don't know if this is a good analogy or not, but older computer fills the entire room but now it's basically what we hold now, a smartphone. Old Nokia battery can last longer than modern smartphones, but well, that year cell phone features are limited. Please note that I'm not intending to disgrace both of them or all of the humans, I just want to share my opinion. As for Nuh AS, we don't even know whether it's only a miracle or not. I don't have any strong sources about this except what is told by Islamic scholars and Quran 29:14, which told by Allah SWT that he lives for "a hundred years minus fifty years". For human calculation logic, that's 950 years. But remember, a half day of the judgment will be like five hundred years (Sunan Abi Dawud 4350, Sahih Al-Albani). Heaven's calculations are different from our calculations. Our law of physics is different from theirs. By that logic, we don't know how many years that Nuh AS actually spent on the arc. But for sure, I know all of you feel like hours are already spent if you doing some boring tasks or waiting for someone even for some minutes. It is also told in a hasan-graded sunnah that Adam AS gave 40 years of his life to Dawud AS that destined to live for 60 years, which means Dawud AS could live for 100 years after Adam AS gave his 40 years of his life to him. (Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3076) And Dawud AS generation is far from Nuh AS or Adam AS. Conclusions? Wallahu a'lam. If we want to know all of the truth, we must wait until the day we meet Allah SWT. For now, we can just theorize all of it. We have no prophets left to tell us. Except if some family line that lived in Rasulillah SAW generation that hasn't told him saying finally reveals his words about this, which is pretty unlikely, because all of the hadits will be cross-checked among all of the family lines and currently revealed hadits. But remember, it's just a theory. A life theory.
when i look at ur channel i remember the pharse of the quran وَاللَّهُ يُرِيدُ أَن يَتُوبَ عَلَيْكُمْ وَيُرِيدُ الَّذِينَ يَتَّبِعُونَ الشَّهَوَاتِ أَن تَمِيلُوا مَيْلًا عَظِيمًا (27) سورة النساء
Nice video and I understood the premise outlined in the first video. Question, why follow a man who after having an encounter with an angel of God tried multiple times to kill himself?
@@ukasxm8245Another component is that humans are not only made of clay and water, but also the Rooh. (15:29), in which you’ll notice Shaytan reduces the human to just being clay in spite of the fact that Allah directly placed the rooh into Adam, honouring him amongst creation.
It depends on what you define as "evolved". Humans' characteristics have indeed changed. For example, we can see that the shape of the head of ancient humans was quite different from ours. But, that is because the environment of their time was vastly different. The problem comes when a person says that humans were originally apes, or bacteria. That does not work with Islam, since Allah A.W made humans "special" in this regard. Watch the video this channel made on this topic. It summarizes almost all of our beliefs about evolution.
I can kinda see that Adam AS and Eve were not evolved but all other creations on earth were. For apes, I actually think (based on my imagination) that they were humans but cursed by Allah to be apes which of course their children will also become apes. But of course, I don't have any basis on what I said, and Allah SWT knows best. edit: or all of these (evolution, and other theories), are just tests from Allah SWT to see who will submit to him.
Another proof that we humans are special in my opinion: 1- look at the difference between our intelligence and the second most intelligent species on the planet and between the difference of intelligence between all others species, the difference is massive, its almost as if the earth is designed so one day we will be held accountable for it 2- humans aren’t natural for earth: every species plays an important role to keep the food chain and the ecosystem stable, except for us humans, the earth is better without us, if we evolved from other animals then would have a role to keep the ecosystem stable, but we don’t 3- we humans are the only species that have control over our desires, animals are creatures of pure desires, and allah said he created us between animals and angels, animals are creature of pure desires while angels are creatures without desires, we are in between we have desires but we have the thoughts to decide whether to follow them or not
I respect you so much and i say sorry in advance if this might sound like demolishing all of your efforts and makes it sound like meaningless but trust me either you haven't done enough research or you've done a resesrch but it was not from source a that has an absulote neutral position because i think you might not searched about what darwin himself said about his theory that if there is a high level of complexity then this theory does not hold which is the case since at darwin's times there was no idea about the organic cell which some of the bichemichal scientist have wrote a book about which is called darwin's black box refering to the organic cell another arguement is the cambrian explosion that also you might check and alot more
{What is [the matter] with you that you do not attribute to Allāh [due] grandeur} {when He has created you stage by stage?} Surah Nuh Ayat 13 - 14 The fact alone that "creation in stages" is associated with grandeur (as shown in Surah 23 Ayah 14 too) shows that "evolution" (meaning creation in stages) can be in fact the Sunnah of Allah with regards to HOW He creates living beings. Ofc Adam(s.) is an exception but so are miracles in general emphasizing the particularly importance of mankind. Interesting note: The word translated as "stage by stage" in Surah Nuh is the arabic "atwaran" with the same trilateral root as "taṭawwara" (ta-waw-ra).. and taṭawwara literally means "to evolve". Wa Allahu a'alam
it really just depends on whether you consider a "human" a homo sapien or the whole deviations as human @@JanRyczkowski theres really no resource. arguing about this doesnt matter. you only need to provide enough different theories to please everyone since nearly all of them are valid even if you believe Allah did nothing to guide evolution and just calculated everything from the beginning of the universe, and thats what was meant by everything was written and done beforehand by 50k years before the heavens and the earth. meaning you agree with the current theory of evolution, with clay or whatever the correct translation is being a microbiome, minerals and water (what the current theory of evolution claims), im _pretty_ sure thats valid too. although i dont really recommend it since this doesnt say anything about his wife and you need speculating to figure out where she came from in this scenario, but im sure you can get where im going; its so vague you can brute force it however you want. it isnt anything important and even if it was revealed in detail it wouldnt work well as an ayah since in the end, as humans we will never really come to an answer nvm just finished the video
@@JanRyczkowski As-salamu alaykum Jan, hope all is well. As far as I know, before human creation, Allah (SWT) created jinn, and they inhabited some earth, can't say if it was the same Earth as what we inhabit now. But then again they are now with us on this Earth as unseen creatures "spirits".. There are different opinions, but most scholars agree on that, search on google: life on earth before Adam (AS) at IslamQA. But Allah SWT knows best! Maybe if you could investigate a bit more, and make a video covering this topic, that would be awesome of you, of-course no push 🙏
@@JanRyczkowski there might have been humans before him since the angels asked allah why would he create creatures that will corrupt the earth and cause blood shed
The hadith in question Narrated `Abdullah bin Masud: I asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! What is the best deed?" He replied, "To offer the prayers at their early stated fixed times." I asked, "What is next in goodness?" He replied, "To be good and dutiful to your parents." I further asked, what is next in goodness?" He replied, "To participate in Jihad in Allah's Cause." I did not ask Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) anymore and if I had asked him more, he would have told me more.
I like this video and agree with you. Honestly I dont find any clear-cut reason within islam as to why evolution for animals is wrong. It is wrong , however, if you say some early humans evolved since the quran is clear-cut that Adam was created directly by Allah. As for the part where you said that Adam was created and other humans were already there who evolved (in an attempt to reconcile the similarity between humans and animal DNA) I believe that is wrong , because as far as I know , there is Consensus (Ijma') that Adam was the first human. Note that Consensus of scholars on religious matters is considered a valid evidence , because the prophet peace be upon him said: My people will never agree on misguidance. So the clear cut belief is that Adam was the first human. In my opinion, we can reconcile this with us having similar DNA to animals by just saying : God made our DNA that way,or by saying : God created Adam in the way he would have been like if he evolved (So assuming God let us evolved, we would have similar DNA , so instead of god waiting millions of years for us to evolve he just directly made Adam that way which he would be like if he had evolved , and thus the similarity) May Allah bless you and increase your knowledge and guide us all.
I don't agree with you but I am also not knowledgeable enough on this subject. Perhaps you could maybe make a video with The Muslim Lantern? Or you could join one of his livestreams he does weekly.
Hi, I’ve left a comment on here that might help. Speaking as a person who came to islam after learning about evolution haha! I can see why it’s easy to believe otherwise though. But I personally don’t see a conflict between it and islam other than the people who genuinely believe we come from apes.
@JanRyczkowski Yes please refer to muslim lantern channel or talk to him and upload the video on your channel maybe. Because this is really causing a serious confusion .
يَاأَيُّهَا النَّاسُ اتَّقُوا رَبَّكُمُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكُمْ مِنْ نَفْسٍ وَاحِدَةٍ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًا كَثِيرًا وَنِسَاءً no there were no other humans before adam AS
I have seen enough miracles in the quran and islam to realize that there is no doubt its the true religion, its just impossible for a mohammad to make it, so we know that is undoubtedly true, now this is a valid theory, now we can fit it in the islamic narrative because so far it doesn’t contradict anything in islam maybe except for the adam part but I don’t really call it a contradiction, more like a semi one, but since we know that islam is undoubtedly true then there must be something we don’t know yet that can solve this, and allah knows best
As a Muslim, I don't have a dogmatic view on this either but it's fun to theorise the origin of Adam. I'm quite open and I see no problem with the idea that Adam was created in stages via evolution from a common ancestor. The Adam that was in Eden probably had a different form as people do in heaven - a heavenly form of clay as our bodies aren't the same in Heaven. So when he was sent down to earth, this process could've taken a while i.e evolution. It could literally be anything, science can only take us so far sadly as even the theory of evolution from a common ancestor has many assumptions and flaws in each step.
Assalamuailakum brother! Your videos are very informative and helpful. Can you please make a video answering a CZcams video titled "A question no Muslim can answer, prove me wrong and I will revert".
do you mean that adam an eve or their decendends may have like reached a point where they may had the ability to mate with "humans" or creatures close enough?
Problems of Social, Familial, Political etc have solution on Islam. It drives us to the way where we can get peace on Dunia and Akhirat too. The matter we are discussing it have nothing to do with our iman. Just like how moon get cut into two pieces or how the sea get divided in the incident of Moses. We Humans and Jinns are those miraculous creation which didn't get evolved. But other animals got. But we humans have some similarities with another animal who got evolved. What i think with my little knowledge is that,we shouldn't see in a way where we say humans have similarities with another animal so it means we human have evolved. Rather we should think that similarities of Human with another animal is a property of Human. We shouldn't make our iman dependent to Science which is a perspective of knowing the unkown which obviously get change in matter of time.
Yes my guy i get what you're saying with the animal dna similar to human but similarity doesn't make us created the same way or mean there were humanity before adam and eve but there's a hadith about the animal in the day of judgement that god will bring all of them and judge between them and will make them in the end dust so this might explain the similarity
(I don't say this out of hatred) Evolution is not right many ways. One example: how does a fish know how to make AN ENTIRE RESPIRATORY SYSTEM so it can breath and go to land (which also the fish has no reason to go to land since fish don't really eat plants). Every animal subhanallah is designed extremely precisely by Allah so the animal does it's function in the ecosystem (also every ecosystem is connected to make the earth we live in). Making such a balanced and complex nature the we live in now with trial and error is simply impossible.❤❤
Evolution doesn't work like what you said, fishes didn't evolve to get on land overnight, they've adapted generation by generation to breathe with less water because of their surroundings out of necessity, most to change ponds, the fishes that couldn't do this obviously died out. And overtime, their ability to survive on land gradually got better and better. Second, let me put into perspective here, dogs in the past centuries have evolved drastically. And you're telling me evolution doesn't make sense? You're basically saying adaptation doesn't exist which isn't the case.
@@aaz.2007 1.First of all thanks for replying in a friendly way. 2. Yes, I know evolution is said to be something that happens over many many years. 3. As for the fish example: lungs are incredibly complicated organ and simple mutation cannot be so interconnected to the degree of making an entire organ. 4. As for the dogs: dogs have been selectively breaded by humans (not naturally). Which is why there are dogs that suffer from the way their bodies are. 5. I recommend the points made by scientists such as Michael Behe and Günter Bechly. 6. Sorry if I came as rude or aggressive. I just don't like how much people integrated the theory of evolution to biology (especially taxonomy) despite it being a theory. Evolution has become more of a religion ,and beliefs shouldn't be mixed with international science (including Islam). Everyone can believe in whatever they want, but they shouldn't force it onto other people.
The integration of human organs make human highly efficient and fabnoschi principal application proves the intelligence involvement over us. Even evolution can't agree with language issues as we speak through energy and it releases and it works and we know that energy can convert to mass.that what recitation of Quran also works. The evolution happened also by involvement of intelligence within species . Every specie has programizes DNA sequence,so it seems that every specie is programmed distinctly.
Yeah it's true humans definitely evolved: Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet (ﷺ) said: *"Allah created Adam, making him 60 cubits tall.* When He created him, He said to him, "Go and greet that group of angels, and listen to their reply, for it will be your greeting (salutation) and the greeting (salutations of your offspring." So, Adam said (to the angels), As-Salamu Alaikum (i.e. Peace be upon you). The angels said, "As-salamu Alaika wa Rahmatu-l-lahi" (i.e. Peace and Allah's Mercy be upon you). Thus the angels added to Adam's salutation the expression, 'Wa Rahmatu-l-lahi,' Any person who will enter Paradise will resemble Adam (in appearance and figure). *People have been decreasing in stature since Adam's creation.* *Sahih al-Bukhari 3326* Adam was so tall and now look at us we're short, so micro evolution is true. But we reject what they say about humans evolving from apes
@@Kamal_grum lol nice try. The analogy was talking about a small quantity of things vs a big quantity. That’s the sole difference between micro and macro. Way to miss the point lol
Hi one doubt why and how do allah pray to something or some one in quran 33:56 pls helo me bro im losing my iman because of this and also explain hadith 216
@@JanRyczkowski well salah means prayer so allah prayed?And also I saw many photos of jesus,his slippers,his bible and this making me think like is this true?
@@Nowaythisshifr Let’s understand the meaning and interpretation of the verse 33:56 in Quran. Indeed, Allah confers blessing upon the Prophet, and His angels. O you who have believed, ask blessing upon him and ask peace. (33:56) Let's look into the second part of this verse. “..ask blessing upon him and ask peace” ''Swallu alaihi wa sallimu tasleema" (Arabic) Word "wa" stands for "and" in Arabic. This "wa" has many rules and conditions. One of the conditions is that there should be always a ''thaluq" or close connection between the word before and after "wa". Which means, in this verse there is a close connection between ‘Swallu’ & ‘Sallimu’. Swallu and Sallimu is nothing but Salat and Salam. Let’s see which of the below makes sense.. Salat (worship) and Salaam or Salat (Durood) and Salaam? It is Durood or Blessings and Salaam which fulfils the condition of “wa”. Because there is a close connection between ‘Durood and Salaam’ wherein both are said to Prophet Muhammad S.A unlike ‘Worship and Salaam’ wherein we worship Allah but we don't say Salaam to Allah. Hence, word Salat mentioned in verse 33:56 is not misinterpreted but rightly translated as “Blessings”.
I don't care really. Adam (as) was created with different physical attributes, but definitely with a human mind, therefore he was a human, and no human was before him. I don't believe a some sort of human some sort of animal preceded Adam (as). As for the animals, maybe Allah created whales through dogs? Maybe, maybe not. It's not really problematic.
Please don't take this in a bad way, I'm just curious. Why does everyone use the word "Revert"? Does this not imply you were a Muslim, left Islam, then came back? Is there some nuance I am not getting here?
@cyberyousef7519 sorry man i think this was a mixture of internet misinterpretation, i was pointing out the same thing you are but trying to pose it in a sarcastic manner
Brother can you make video about videos game? I mean modern game, there are musical elements, drawn characters and elements of violence and magic (all that is haram things in islam). Im corius what your perspective about this, cause many young muslim playing modern game, even they addicted to it (include me).
@@ahmadsahl9384 yes it is a minor sin tho, video games are a waste of time because it has no benefit, neither is is full filling, you might call it “enjoying yourself” but it’s only for a moment but your dopamine goes crashing down right after, so even happiness isn’t gained
@@cyberyousef7519 Alright brother, just one questions, you still playing game? I just see your video. If you not playing anymore, mind if you share to me, i mean how and why you stop. Thank you
Genuinely, isn't it stated that Adam and Eve were the first people on earth?, I'm not sure but if it is true, doesn't it just take the idea of people before them like you said in this video?
idk why people forget about the djinns and whatever intelligent lives there were before us on our planet ... so i don't think there were any humans before Adam . anyways ; one thing is for sure , adam and eve were not white , nor were they black or asian , they were unique ... different from us ,but not apes , they were superior as they survived the wilderness of earth alone (they were separated ) without even having clothes (from paradise at start) , their superior gene allowed them to survive the harsh environment and diseases , and later the inbreeding (as ordered by Allah) between their children "perhaps" deteriorated the superior gene and biochemistry in their body, reducing their superiority , making them vulnerable and closer to us modern humans , and later on travelling around the world had environmental effects "MAY" have had some sort of "change" . Scientists don't believe in our belief or any of the faith's belief , hence they have to come up with their own story , but they are picking up evidences from fossils , DNA etc etc and molding it to their own godless events / faith (fun fact : Darwin himself was not an atheist , he believed in a god or supreme being after studying the nature thinking that this can't be happening without an external supreme being's intervention from far ; he didn't believe in any religion though) . They say humans originated from Africa ; why ? : Cause they found oldest evidences there ; ok , what if you find even older or similar evidence somewhere else like .. i dunno , Florida ? hundreds or miles below ocean ? or frikin Bangladesh ? what will you do then ? You have not scanned the whole planet , you don't know what's out there , will you change yout view and re interpret things if this happens ? or will you still hold onto your "old african" faith like a religion or worse , hide evidences or dismiss them ? Also , where are the two celled organism that live independently like monocellular ones ? Science Does not Eliminate God , Scientists Eliminate models of God . idk why tf i typed all this thing , no ones gonna read this .. XD Allah knows best .
We can consider those Homo species like Habilis, Erectus and others as merely just biologically very similar, but not true humans. Basically, pseudo-humans.
Do you realize the fact that humans are considered to have evolved in Africa because our common ancestors (Australopiths) evolved and lived there too? Again, you're comment is based on un-reasonable conservative views, not Islam. As he explained, the theory of human evolution is compatible with Islam. We can just view the homo-species before him as mere 'pseudo humans', not true humans. So, Adam still stays the first true human. And also, the theory of evolution is science, not atheism. It was not made as some sort of 'crusade against religion'. It is a theory based on scientific facts of change in species, common ancestry and fossil of less developed species which show transition. Also, scientists don't make up false stories based on nothing. It's based on empirical evidences. Plenty of scientists believe in Islam and the theory of evolution. Different scientists believe in different things. However, science itself is a single body of knowledge, commonly shared by all scientists, which are based on what can be empirically proven. The things you wrote makes Islam look like some kind of false outdated belief. You aren't going to be able to demote scientists and science by saying "oh! they don't believe in the same as us! So, they are incompatible". You are only demoting Islam because science is empirical and scientists believe in what can actually be empirically proven. Each and every single thing you wrote are unfalsifiable and cannot be empirically proven and are based on nothing. This highly differentiating from scientists who base their opinion on actual facts and evidences. Again, your comment is a genetic fallacy. Just because most scientists aren't Muslims doesn't mean we should reject what they say because what they say is right regardless.
The main issue with your statement is that scientist's scientific opinions are based on actual scientific facts and evidences and are grounded on reality. That highly differentiates from beliefs based on scriptures which cannot be empirically proven. Again, this doesn't invalidate religions. But, the thing I am pointing out is that what scientists say are basically what evidences say. And it wouldn't matter if there happened to be species of humans which evolved outside Africa before because that wouldn't change the fact that Homo Habilis and other species evolved in Africa. More to the point, there exists empirical evidences for human migration which showcase that humans evolved in Africa first and humans reached America and other places much later. So, we can conclude that the first humans didn't evolve anywhere outside Africa. Your comment is a great example of arguments from gaps (lack of knowledge) and thinking that an entire theory is invalid because of some flaws which are more related to names and terms which do not at all refute empirical facts which those superseded statements were based on. (For example, if a homo species evolved outside Africa before Homo Habilis, that wouldn't change the fact that Homo Habilis evolved in Africa in the estimated time range scientists have figured out and it wouldn't change the fact that Habilis is included among our ancestors. Rather, Homo Habilis would simply be stripped away from the title of first homo species.)
They don't "share" genetic similarities enzymes have totally differernt sequences, for the same name of enzyme they have similar building blocks, and the reason because they were made by the same creator, same designer. Similar to the verses which questions are there any other creators ? or do they create themselves ? if there are other creators, they'd have their own building blocks or architecture There is misconception that "adaptation" is consequence of evolution. Which is a false claim. Adaptation is independant from evolution. Evolution fundamentally believes all life came from a single cell. However, adaptation can be instilled in any new creature like Humans which we believe were created, yet both humans and animals have adaptation.
Brother you are doing a great job but I think you should give some time to Saboor Ahmad. Plus Islam doesn't suport darwinism bcz it believe that we all have promise with god in alam-e-arwah, and we are here on this earth to complete that promise. our spirits are made in alam-e-arwah. you should give some time stufying Quran and hadees from a Yemeni Scholar. Blessing apon you
the thing i found problematic in the video is that you said it is possible people descended from Adam AND other human who existed before them.. while the scripture clearly tells us Adam is the father of all humans the prophet alahi al salah wa al salam said: ينتَهينَّ أقوامٌ يفتخرون بآبائِهم الَّذين ماتوا إنَّما هم فحمُ جهنَّمَ ، أو لَيَكونُنَّ أهونَ على اللهِ عزَّ وجلَّ من الجُعلِ الَّذي يُدَهْدِهُ الخُرْءَ بأنفِه إنَّ اللهَ أذهب عنكم عبيَّةَ الجاهليَّةِ وفخرَها بالآباءِ . إنَّما هو مؤمنٌ تقيٌّ ، وفاجرٌ شقيٌّ ، النَّاسُ بنو آدمَ ، وآدمُ خُلِق من ترابٍ translation of the end of the hadith (people are from Adam and Adam was created from dust so that cant be true regardless of weather these other humans were from evolution or not as for the possibility of previous human-like creatures that didn't reproduce with humans, that is in the realm of possibility. والله اعلم. الله يبارك فيك ويزيدك علم
It's a very delicate topic, and to be honest I wouldn't film videos about it. You should at least consult an established shaykh before putting a video out. In the meantime here's Yasir Qadhi's comment about it: czcams.com/video/skVAtgxtuWs/video.html May Allah guide us.
Hello! The evolution as a process in the nature is it indeed happening, I mean let's just look at the simplest animal and we can see how this worked, besides regarding the humans there were already humans on earth and it's mentioned on quran that others were already on the earth. In the contrary I find your reflection on the topic amazing and open minded, please keep it non biased like that! ,now let's go to my request if you don't mind please I would like to see you research about the saving and originality of the quran, I've been searching lately and found that the oldest manuscript found is 2 pages or surat Taha (it's in England) and dated with high probability to the prophet time, although in tradition it's told that the quran was written years after the death of the prophet, besides if we keep saying that it was saved by those super memorizing ones and it was normal back then, then we add a human factor to this process which will make it theoretically never a 100% authentic? I'm really curious and if you take this topic I would be super happy! And first commenter send reflecter also. All the best.
I'm sorry brother.... I made a mistake and I report you couse i was think that this is an anti-Islam channel..... in the video when you when you debunked the criticism on the Quran.... Im so sorry.... May ALLAH forgive me and you and all the Ummah.... Ande help you in your Da wah
Aleyküm selam brother. I also think that way. What Quran says is completely true, so Adam and Havva (a.s) were brought to earth by Allah. As far as I know, the Quran leaves the possibility of animal evolution open. Even if the animals and plants evolve they certainly evolve under the order of Allah. So evolution that scientists know can't be possible imo since the chances of getting right mutations (so that we get into the beautiful ecosystem we have now) for each animal would be insanely low. I think that Allah led or guided evolution or simply set the world setting in a way that in the end the animals and plants would take a evolution path into the world we have now. Because the first genesis theorem where random atoms forming organic molecules and than they forming into bacteria or any sort of living being is impossible according to my logic, and if people search that subject, their logic as well. I can't imagine where random molecules by random energy blasts form a living being where that living being would reproduce itself so it doesn't go extinct.
W salam, I suggest you watch this video whereby Muhammed Ali does a presentation on how evolution theory is hocus pocus basically and he points out the actual issue with evolution theory and how laymen just take it as fact when its far from that: ‘Muslims Scientifically And Rationally Dismantle Evolution! Muhammed Ali & @SubboorAhmadAbbasi’
Evolution doesn't exist. Allah creates new creatures from the same animals hence we call it as a evolution. They share genetics but they are completely different creatures. It is like in coding OOP concept. Abstract class with abstract methods can be used for different objects but objects didn't evolve. We share genetics with monkeys because like in coding we are using abstract class with abstract methods for human objects.
Salam akhi,theres this youtuber called OrthodoxKyle trying to "debunk" islam,if you can debunk at least one of his videos i would be more than happy brother!
Please let me know if you disagree or have proof against what i said
Jazak Allah Khair.
There is an extremely well-put together video by Dr. Qunaibi on YT titled "Darwin's Theory of Evolution: A Fair Discussion" you should check it out!
The good thing about the video is that it covers that epistemological aspect that lead to the un-empirical assumptions introduced to it.
Watch the video of the muslim lantern about evolution he dismantled the theory of evolution completely
@@younessboustta6525 I wanted to say that .
I agree you 100%. believe in evolution is not kufur, but isnot part aqidah. Because evoution is just model, accept or reject. Its not about faith/belief.
And another things, Textually and contextually, Alquran never say adam As is first man, or adam come from in the sky/heavens.
and why does Quran compare the creation of the prophet Adam as a parable of the creation of the prophet Isa??
This seems to imply the creation of the prophet Adam in the womb as well as the creation of the prophet Jesus/isa who was born from the womb.
Its like partenogenesis😂. Partenogenesis of mamalia never have naturally. But artificially.
I would like to add my thoughts on the matter based on my understanding of the verses I’ve read:
The conversation between Allah (S.W.T.) and the angels before the creation of Adam (A.S.) raises three things.
1: The Earth had been there long before Adam (A.S.) came into existence. In another verse, it mentions that we were created from the earth, to it we return, and from it we are raised again. The Quran comes first and foremost, and only ahadeeth that are completely consistent with the Quran should be accepted. In one Hadith, Adam (A.S.) is described as being created from a mixture of several distinct earths, like dirt. This is the origin of Adam. The term 'A-D-M' might mean the following: A state of mixing or mingling, as in the earth.
It makes sense that we return to the ground from which Adam was initially created.
2: Angels do not possess information that God did not teach them or that they themselves have not witnessed. (2:32)
3: The angels mentioned something that supports the second point: “Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?” (2:30)
This suggests they were already familiar with corruption and bloodshed. And they had brought it up when Allah (S.W.T.) mentioned creating a succession on earth. The significance is here: Adam was made of the earth to dwell on the earth.
The Earth was most likely already inhabited if we base it on what the angels knew. The thought that Allah (SWT) made evolution possible should not be fully discarded, just as we cannot completely dismiss any religious texts that existed prior to the Quran or Injeel if we believe it was the final written record before the Quran. And the passages about the Sabt reinforce the notion that Allah (SWT) transformed one creation into another. So it isn’t far into the realm of impossibilities.
The difference is this: Adam (A.S.) was formed by Allah (S.W.T.) in the form he was created in, indicating that we are a distinct species with possible links to the dirt from which we were created.
And, to add to your previous video, the Dukhan, the Heaven, was present (Astwa 3la *as’sama*), but it was divided into seven (fas’sawahun sab3 samawat). If we assume that the earth and all that it contains were created through that Dukhan and that we were created of the earth, that is another link altogether.
To end it, I’ll add that pushing for a new idea of what Allah (S.W.T.) did or did not do without proper knowledge is a sin in itself. Just as we shouldn’t determine where people will end up in Qiyammah without knowledge (19:78),
And Allah’hu A3lam. May Allah (S.W.T) forgive us for our ignorance on such matters and for any ill conceived of it.
We Muslims need to be more open minded to these sorts of things. Allah is all powerful and there's no saying He cannot make His creations through evolution.
This would be contradicting the words of Allah and whaf he said
we never said "He cannot", we only say "He didn't" because thats what he told us in his speech. What a pathetic attempt by you to justify heresy.
@@saadsaif-vt7lu Heresy this heresy that, Jan's arguments are valid and he was only saying evolution can happen with animals.
@@ryamsosohbajjaikoasknd just let go of something as controversial as this. in the original video he spoke about the possibility of human evolution, why do you need to believe in it so bad, you wont die without believing in evolution, stick to the traditional view of the scholars of Islam and move on with your life for Gods sake.
@@saadsaif-vt7lu you're literally the one who called my view heretical...
Just found your channel, very cool to see more reverts especially at a young age
May Allah reward you for this! ❤
Remember at one time, surgeons laughed at the idea of washing hands before surgery. And drugs like cocaine and morphine were advertised as non addictive drugs. Don’t rest your faith on everchanging science.
Your original video was excellent and very nuanced mashAllah. Animal evolution is not an issue for those with an Islamic worldview, it is however for Christians (see the first page of the Bible). So many of the ignorant amongst our community have picked up from them the cause of unnecessarily fighting the field of evolutionary biology, when we don’t have to, unlike fundamentalist Christian’s.
Speaking as someone with a academic background in science but always happy to be challenged :)
Salaam Alaikum, do you have any social media accounts? I’m interested in what you do.
Human evolution is also not an issue with Islam. Most Muslims in the world are simply uneducated about evolution and the Quran, that's it.
Salam Aleykum brother
Ehab Abouheif is a Muslim evolutionary biologist, he has lectures on youtube that you can watch. There's also Rana Dajani, she's a Muslim molecular biologist from Jordan, she also has lectures about evolution that you can watch. Please watch
Salam
Yes we evolved, we had gigantic body now small, we were tall , now small, we were powerful, now weak , now we have more communication skills and intelligence
More intelligence? But Adam (as) was a prophet
@@azikazikazik not to be disrespectful I'm also muslim but probably he was not as intelligent as any other person like jesus moses muhammad(peace be upon them) were actually intelligent and did something for people
You cant call adam(as) really intelligent or can you who knows he might have discovered fire but still not as intelligent
@@dblm4510 bro really just disrespected prophet Adam as
@@dblm4510wasn't he taught the name of all things however?
@@user-tx5xz5ws1d exactly
What I believe now is that our father Adam is created by God's hands and then Our mother Eve was created from Adam, this is what the Quran states clearly, then the evolution occured and the differentiations appeared.
Believing that evolutions occured after Adam by God's will does not contradict Islam, But believing that Adam himself is a decent from monkeys or so then this contradict the clear verses and it's Kufr.
Just found ur channel, and I honestly love the content you make. I'm a revert myself at a similar age as you so it's nice to see someone like me on here spreading Islam.
Is it possible that Allah by his wisdom made Animals evolve over time?
- Yes.
Is it an Islamic Aqeeda to believe in Darwinian evolution?
- No.
Awesome video, May Allah increase your knowledge and faith
May Allah bless you, thank you for the donation!
Exactly, I also believe in evolution but Adam and Eve were the first people.
Then you don’t believe in evolution, That goes directly against evolution
I don't see evolution contradicts Islam. I recall speaking to a Christian friend who struggled with evolution and the creation story. My simple answer is that Allah is not bound by time. We, as humans and his slaves are. A day for Allah, maybe a millennia or more. We do not know, as a day for us is based on circumventing the Sun. Evolution is simply us understanding the magnificence of the creator. We worship and believe in Allah, we learn about evolution.
No it does contradict hadith literature and the quran, the story is that adam was created from dust and hawa from his rib
And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, “Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority.” They said, “Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?” Allah said, “Indeed, I know that which you do not know.”
This verse was induced before Adam was created.. which states a human-like creature.. could it be an ancient human?
Most probably. And in fact, a lot of older scholar's also saw this as possible existence of mysterious beings on planet before us.
Probably, maybe could also mean there are other intelligent creatures on other planets that did the same thing
MashaAllah, you're amazing. Please please don't ever stop this form of dawah.
You are doing great brother, May Allah SWT reward you ❤
We do evolve, but not from monke, we are already different from monkeys and other mammals, evolving doesnt even necessarily means we (our species) werent human at the begining of time. Besides, evolution is just a theory, no one have ever been confirming it.
A theory is the highest level of any scientific idea. Gravity is also "just a theory" but I doubt you'll be jumping out of windows anytime soon.
@@calebr7199 yes? Besides there should be a name for the force that's pulling you from getting away from the earth
@@hyumiliatedbs3355
You said "just a theory" implying that being called a theory means there is no evidence or that theories are not important in science. Gravity is a theory, germs are a theory, there are so many important and true things that are scientific theories.
@@calebr7199 because no one have proven evolution, hence why its state is just a theory
@@hyumiliatedbs3355
I see you are failing to understand what I'm saying. Just look up what the word theory means in science. That might explain it to you.
Alhamdulillah ❤️ God bless you brother
According to the following verse, the possibility of evolution has been mentioned in Quran.
Qur'an 2:30 is as follows:
And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successive authority." They (Angels) said, "Will You place upon it one who causes corruption therein and sheds blood, while we declare Your praise and sanctify You?" Allah said, "Indeed, I know that which you do not know."
This verse can explain that already on the earth there were some creatures similar to human being ( eg; Neanderthals ) and apparently this indicate angles already had an image of how human being might be.
This can clearly explains the possibility of evaluation and the Difference between Adam descendants that came from heaven and other types of similar to human creatures
Bro this was talking about the jinn clearly mentioned to be the previous beings who existed before humans
jinns existed before humans, who spread a lot of corruption and bloodshed, that's what it is talking about as evident from narrations.
It's talking about jinn not human
@@SenatorTalib the verse has clearly mentioned that angles asked about creation of the human and blood shed that they have caused on the earth, there is nothing about Jinns. please read the ayah before write a comment!!!
@@bahaaabwini4834 ayah clearly mentions about human creation, what Jinn?! it requires some levels of IQ to process it. its just simple, you can read the whole Chapter, its about creation of Adam, when angles question God why are you creating something that cause corruption and bloodshed on the earth! so they must have seen something similar to Adam on the earth that have done such things!
Waalaikumussalam warohmatullahi wabarokatuh.
Thank you for adressing the comments, and this is a great video as always. Keep it up. May Allah always bless you in this beautiful month of ramadhan❤❤
Humans also evolve
Noah (as) gave dawah for 900 years
We don’t have high life expectancy than them
But we did not come from apes
Adam (as) Eve and people at their time were tall
This hadith was narrated by Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said:
“Allah created Adam and he was sixty cubits tall. Then He said, ‘Go and greet those angels and listen to how they greet you, for that will be your greeting and the greeting of your progeny.’ He said, ‘Al-salamu ‘alaykum (Peace be upon you).’ They said, ‘Al-salamu ‘alaykum wa rahmat-Allah (Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah).’ So they added the words ‘wa rahmat Allah.’ And everyone who enters Paradise will be in the form of Adam. People kept on growing smaller until now.” (Narrated by al-Bukhari, 3336; Muslim, 7092)
What was meant was they didnt evolve from some sort of animal.
I think Adam were tall in heaven some scholars said that
Dr. Eyad Qunaibi's series "The journey of certainty" is enough on the topic of evolution.
If people evolved from monkeys, Im a veteran who served in Iraq and Vietnam.
You are a pleasing sight
Thumma MashALLAH TabarakALLAH May ALLAH S.W.T guide and bless you and your families and may you succeed in life Ameen (S.A.W) ❤🎉😊
Dawg you do not look 16 at all
Wait he’s 16?
@zahiddilawarzada8287 I mean yeah he is 16,I mean I thought he looks like an adult and speaks like one,probably because of genetics
It's difficult for creationists to accept evolution as a whole because it would contradict their mythological scriptures.
It doesn’t actually contradict it, only the version the atheists created contradicts it, have you ever thought about it? The model of evolution atheists created was never proven to be the real one
Second islam isn’t a mythology, it’s the truth
Islam isn’t a mythology, its the true religion, as a muslim who searched about miracles of the quran and islam, i have seen enough to know that there is no doubt in allah and islam
And evolution doesn’t contradict it anyway
@@cyberyousef7519 The Quran is not a book of history and science.
@@cyberyousef7519 It does contradict it that is what I also thought but there is no evidence for Adam and Eve.
The genetic similarity doesn’t have to mean anything. If you look at our abilities, they are similar to those of the monkeys, many characteristics are similar and this would go back to a similar DNA. This doesn’t mean though that Adam or Humans have to be from Monkeys, rather it could be that Allah created us with genetics similar to the ones of monkeys & we therefore have similar abilities. Tell people to not think about it too much since biology and science has many times shown that it shifts and isn’t static, also conclusions of biological findings or facts can differ immensely and usually the one most probable (as of the time in which the findings are analysed) are taken but this doesn’t have to mean that the most probable always happens, especially when you talk about something being created aka interventions not coming from inside
I'm glad algorithm helped me --basically allah help me--, to discover this channel, here to follow your adventure in knowledge
Could you please make a video about hafs warsh and the other recitations and its explanation. there are words in one that are plural in the other quran recitation or completely different word.
For me? Evolution is still a question. We don't have that much resources and knowledge to claim that it's true or not. Probably you all can argue that viruses evolve each day, but compared to us it's just like we're developing a new weapon.
But if we take examples of Adam AS 60 cubits tall compared to us somewhere between 140-200 cm, and our life expectancy from 60-70 compared to Nuh AS that is told could stand for 900+ years, it is possible that humans evolved (or devolved).
I don't know if this is a good analogy or not, but older computer fills the entire room but now it's basically what we hold now, a smartphone. Old Nokia battery can last longer than modern smartphones, but well, that year cell phone features are limited. Please note that I'm not intending to disgrace both of them or all of the humans, I just want to share my opinion.
As for Nuh AS, we don't even know whether it's only a miracle or not. I don't have any strong sources about this except what is told by Islamic scholars and Quran 29:14, which told by Allah SWT that he lives for "a hundred years minus fifty years". For human calculation logic, that's 950 years. But remember, a half day of the judgment will be like five hundred years (Sunan Abi Dawud 4350, Sahih Al-Albani). Heaven's calculations are different from our calculations. Our law of physics is different from theirs. By that logic, we don't know how many years that Nuh AS actually spent on the arc.
But for sure, I know all of you feel like hours are already spent if you doing some boring tasks or waiting for someone even for some minutes.
It is also told in a hasan-graded sunnah that Adam AS gave 40 years of his life to Dawud AS that destined to live for 60 years, which means Dawud AS could live for 100 years after Adam AS gave his 40 years of his life to him. (Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3076) And Dawud AS generation is far from Nuh AS or Adam AS.
Conclusions? Wallahu a'lam. If we want to know all of the truth, we must wait until the day we meet Allah SWT. For now, we can just theorize all of it. We have no prophets left to tell us. Except if some family line that lived in Rasulillah SAW generation that hasn't told him saying finally reveals his words about this, which is pretty unlikely, because all of the hadits will be cross-checked among all of the family lines and currently revealed hadits. But remember, it's just a theory. A life theory.
I like the way you are speaking similar to the game theory
Wat u said is very correct
Walekumasalam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu
when i look at ur channel i remember the pharse of the quran
وَاللَّهُ يُرِيدُ أَن يَتُوبَ عَلَيْكُمْ وَيُرِيدُ الَّذِينَ يَتَّبِعُونَ الشَّهَوَاتِ أَن تَمِيلُوا مَيْلًا عَظِيمًا (27) سورة النساء
Nice video and I understood the premise outlined in the first video. Question, why follow a man who after having an encounter with an angel of God tried multiple times to kill himself?
If animals evolved, why shouldn’t humans?
Animals dont have Aql' whilst humans do
@@ukasxm8245Another component is that humans are not only made of clay and water, but also the Rooh. (15:29), in which you’ll notice Shaytan reduces the human to just being clay in spite of the fact that Allah directly placed the rooh into Adam, honouring him amongst creation.
It depends on what you define as "evolved".
Humans' characteristics have indeed changed. For example, we can see that the shape of the head of ancient humans was quite different from ours. But, that is because the environment of their time was vastly different.
The problem comes when a person says that humans were originally apes, or bacteria. That does not work with Islam, since Allah A.W made humans "special" in this regard. Watch the video this channel made on this topic. It summarizes almost all of our beliefs about evolution.
Actually there is way out
It's called "Adam exceptionalism"
maybe we do
I can kinda see that Adam AS and Eve were not evolved but all other creations on earth were.
For apes, I actually think (based on my imagination) that they were humans but cursed by Allah to be apes which of course their children will also become apes.
But of course, I don't have any basis on what I said, and Allah SWT knows best.
edit: or all of these (evolution, and other theories), are just tests from Allah SWT to see who will submit to him.
Your beard is going out of control bro
Could you make a video on Palestinian Israeli war
Another proof that we humans are special in my opinion:
1- look at the difference between our intelligence and the second most intelligent species on the planet and between the difference of intelligence between all others species, the difference is massive, its almost as if the earth is designed so one day we will be held accountable for it
2- humans aren’t natural for earth: every species plays an important role to keep the food chain and the ecosystem stable, except for us humans, the earth is better without us, if we evolved from other animals then would have a role to keep the ecosystem stable, but we don’t
3- we humans are the only species that have control over our desires, animals are creatures of pure desires, and allah said he created us between animals and angels, animals are creature of pure desires while angels are creatures without desires, we are in between we have desires but we have the thoughts to decide whether to follow them or not
That's exactly make sense when I look animals and humans..
I respect you so much and i say sorry in advance if this might sound like demolishing all of your efforts and makes it sound like meaningless but trust me either you haven't done enough research or you've done a resesrch but it was not from source a that has an absulote neutral position because i think you might not searched about what darwin himself said about his theory that if there is a high level of complexity then this theory does not hold which is the case since at darwin's times there was no idea about the organic cell which some of the bichemichal scientist have wrote a book about which is called darwin's black box refering to the organic cell another arguement is the cambrian explosion that also you might check and alot more
are you from poland?
Pls pls make videos on apostate prophets
And remind me what religion Darwin was?
(Christian)
{What is [the matter] with you that you do not attribute to Allāh [due] grandeur}
{when He has created you stage by stage?} Surah Nuh Ayat 13 - 14
The fact alone that "creation in stages" is associated with grandeur (as shown in Surah 23 Ayah 14 too) shows that "evolution" (meaning creation in stages) can be in fact the Sunnah of Allah with regards to HOW He creates living beings. Ofc Adam(s.) is an exception but so are miracles in general emphasizing the particularly importance of mankind.
Interesting note: The word translated as "stage by stage" in Surah Nuh is the arabic "atwaran" with the same trilateral root as "taṭawwara" (ta-waw-ra).. and taṭawwara literally means "to evolve".
Wa Allahu a'alam
There *were* no humans before Adam 😮 Hawa (Eve).
They are literally the first humans, and we didn't crossbreed.
could you show me some sources?
it really just depends on whether you consider a "human" a homo sapien or the whole deviations as human @@JanRyczkowski
theres really no resource. arguing about this doesnt matter. you only need to provide enough different theories to please everyone since nearly all of them are valid
even if you believe Allah did nothing to guide evolution and just calculated everything from the beginning of the universe, and thats what was meant by everything was written and done beforehand by 50k years before the heavens and the earth. meaning you agree with the current theory of evolution, with clay or whatever the correct translation is being a microbiome, minerals and water (what the current theory of evolution claims), im _pretty_ sure thats valid too. although i dont really recommend it since this doesnt say anything about his wife and you need speculating to figure out where she came from in this scenario, but im sure you can get where im going;
its so vague you can brute force it however you want. it isnt anything important and even if it was revealed in detail it wouldnt work well as an ayah since in the end, as humans we will never really come to an answer
nvm just finished the video
@@JanRyczkowski As-salamu alaykum Jan, hope all is well. As far as I know, before human creation, Allah (SWT) created jinn, and they inhabited some earth, can't say if it was the same Earth as what we inhabit now. But then again they are now with us on this Earth as unseen creatures "spirits".. There are different opinions, but most scholars agree on that, search on google: life on earth before Adam (AS) at IslamQA. But Allah SWT knows best! Maybe if you could investigate a bit more, and make a video covering this topic, that would be awesome of you, of-course no push 🙏
define "human"
@@JanRyczkowski there might have been humans before him since the angels asked allah why would he create creatures that will corrupt the earth and cause blood shed
Don't worry brother, u still young, long way to go
Help could someone debunk Sahih Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Hadith Number 41??pls
What are you talking about??
This si a hadith of the prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. There is nothing to disprove
The hadith in question
Narrated `Abdullah bin Masud:
I asked Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! What is the best deed?" He replied, "To offer the prayers at their early stated fixed times." I asked, "What is next in goodness?" He replied, "To be good and dutiful to your parents." I further asked, what is next in goodness?" He replied, "To participate in Jihad in Allah's Cause." I did not ask Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) anymore and if I had asked him more, he would have told me more.
"Thanks, I already won the debate,@@abaan8911
@@abaan8911what's the issue with it tho
I like this video and agree with you. Honestly I dont find any clear-cut reason within islam as to why evolution for animals is wrong. It is wrong , however, if you say some early humans evolved since the quran is clear-cut that Adam was created directly by Allah.
As for the part where you said that Adam was created and other humans were already there who evolved (in an attempt to reconcile the similarity between humans and animal DNA) I believe that is wrong , because as far as I know , there is Consensus (Ijma') that Adam was the first human. Note that Consensus of scholars on religious matters is considered a valid evidence , because the prophet peace be upon him said: My people will never agree on misguidance.
So the clear cut belief is that Adam was the first human. In my opinion, we can reconcile this with us having similar DNA to animals by just saying : God made our DNA that way,or by saying : God created Adam in the way he would have been like if he evolved (So assuming God let us evolved, we would have similar DNA , so instead of god waiting millions of years for us to evolve he just directly made Adam that way which he would be like if he had evolved , and thus the similarity)
May Allah bless you and increase your knowledge and guide us all.
can you please make a video responding on al Fadi from CIRA international's videos
Can u discuss the topic of drawing like is it haram or not
draw living thing haram
draw not living thing halal
I don't agree with you but I am also not knowledgeable enough on this subject. Perhaps you could maybe make a video with The Muslim Lantern? Or you could join one of his livestreams he does weekly.
Hi, I’ve left a comment on here that might help. Speaking as a person who came to islam after learning about evolution haha! I can see why it’s easy to believe otherwise though. But I personally don’t see a conflict between it and islam other than the people who genuinely believe we come from apes.
Thatd actually be really cool. Does he talk about evolutiona lot?
@@JanRyczkowski he made a video about evolution
@JanRyczkowski
Yes please refer to muslim lantern channel or talk to him and upload the video on your channel maybe.
Because this is really causing a serious confusion .
Please watch eyad el qenaibi on evolution@JanRyczkowski
يَاأَيُّهَا النَّاسُ اتَّقُوا رَبَّكُمُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكُمْ مِنْ نَفْسٍ وَاحِدَةٍ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًا كَثِيرًا وَنِسَاءً no there were no other humans before adam AS
I have seen enough miracles in the quran and islam to realize that there is no doubt its the true religion, its just impossible for a mohammad to make it, so we know that is undoubtedly true, now this is a valid theory, now we can fit it in the islamic narrative because so far it doesn’t contradict anything in islam maybe except for the adam part but I don’t really call it a contradiction, more like a semi one, but since we know that islam is undoubtedly true then there must be something we don’t know yet that can solve this, and allah knows best
Might be it's test for this era believers with our intellect and common sense we need to accept the things.
mashallah
As a Muslim, I don't have a dogmatic view on this either but it's fun to theorise the origin of Adam. I'm quite open and I see no problem with the idea that Adam was created in stages via evolution from a common ancestor. The Adam that was in Eden probably had a different form as people do in heaven - a heavenly form of clay as our bodies aren't the same in Heaven. So when he was sent down to earth, this process could've taken a while i.e evolution. It could literally be anything, science can only take us so far sadly as even the theory of evolution from a common ancestor has many assumptions and flaws in each step.
That exactly happens Adam a.s not looking like this era humans he's different.
Assalamuailakum brother! Your videos are very informative and helpful. Can you please make a video answering a CZcams video titled "A question no Muslim can answer, prove me wrong and I will revert".
Akhi read the works of Abul feda ibn masood , you wont regret InShaaAllah
Salam akhi
@@SoldierOfAlIah wa alaikum salaam akhi
Bro it's 1am what are you doing here😭
do you mean that adam an eve or their decendends may have like reached a point where they may had the ability to mate with "humans" or creatures close enough?
Problems of Social, Familial, Political etc have solution on Islam. It drives us to the way where we can get peace on Dunia and Akhirat too. The matter we are discussing it have nothing to do with our iman. Just like how moon get cut into two pieces or how the sea get divided in the incident of Moses. We Humans and Jinns are those miraculous creation which didn't get evolved. But other animals got. But we humans have some similarities with another animal who got evolved. What i think with my little knowledge is that,we shouldn't see in a way where we say humans have similarities with another animal so it means we human have evolved. Rather we should think that similarities of Human with another animal is a property of Human. We shouldn't make our iman dependent to Science which is a perspective of knowing the unkown which obviously get change in matter of time.
Yes my guy i get what you're saying with the animal dna similar to human but similarity doesn't make us created the same way or mean there were humanity before adam and eve but there's a hadith about the animal in the day of judgement that god will bring all of them and judge between them and will make them in the end dust so this might explain the similarity
(I don't say this out of hatred) Evolution is not right many ways. One example: how does a fish know how to make AN ENTIRE RESPIRATORY SYSTEM so it can breath and go to land (which also the fish has no reason to go to land since fish don't really eat plants). Every animal subhanallah is designed extremely precisely by Allah so the animal does it's function in the ecosystem (also every ecosystem is connected to make the earth we live in). Making such a balanced and complex nature the we live in now with trial and error is simply impossible.❤❤
Evolution doesn't work like what you said, fishes didn't evolve to get on land overnight, they've adapted generation by generation to breathe with less water because of their surroundings out of necessity, most to change ponds, the fishes that couldn't do this obviously died out. And overtime, their ability to survive on land gradually got better and better.
Second, let me put into perspective here, dogs in the past centuries have evolved drastically. And you're telling me evolution doesn't make sense? You're basically saying adaptation doesn't exist which isn't the case.
@@aaz.2007
1.First of all thanks for replying in a friendly way.
2. Yes, I know evolution is said to be something that happens over many many years.
3. As for the fish example: lungs are incredibly complicated organ and simple mutation cannot be so interconnected to the degree of making an entire organ.
4. As for the dogs: dogs have been selectively breaded by humans (not naturally). Which is why there are dogs that suffer from the way their bodies are.
5. I recommend the points made by scientists such as Michael Behe and Günter Bechly.
6. Sorry if I came as rude or aggressive. I just don't like how much people integrated the theory of evolution to biology (especially taxonomy) despite it being a theory. Evolution has become more of a religion ,and beliefs shouldn't be mixed with international science (including Islam). Everyone can believe in whatever they want, but they shouldn't force it onto other people.
@@mugmug6415 you're welcome, thanks for recommending me sources and taking the comment also in a friendly way.
The integration of human organs make human highly efficient and fabnoschi principal application proves the intelligence involvement over us.
Even evolution can't agree with language issues as we speak through energy and it releases and it works and we know that energy can convert to mass.that what recitation of Quran also works.
The evolution happened also by involvement of intelligence within species .
Every specie has programizes DNA sequence,so it seems that every specie is programmed distinctly.
I believe in micro evolution but not macro evolution.
Yeah it's true humans definitely evolved:
Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet (ﷺ) said: *"Allah created Adam, making him 60 cubits tall.* When He created him, He said to him, "Go and greet that group of angels, and listen to their reply, for it will be your greeting (salutation) and the greeting (salutations of your offspring." So, Adam said (to the angels), As-Salamu Alaikum (i.e. Peace be upon you). The angels said, "As-salamu Alaika wa Rahmatu-l-lahi" (i.e. Peace and Allah's Mercy be upon you). Thus the angels added to Adam's salutation the expression, 'Wa Rahmatu-l-lahi,' Any person who will enter Paradise will resemble Adam (in appearance and figure). *People have been decreasing in stature since Adam's creation.*
*Sahih al-Bukhari 3326*
Adam was so tall and now look at us we're short, so micro evolution is true. But we reject what they say about humans evolving from apes
that's like believing in sand but thinking beaches aren't real. LMAO
@@enlightenedvagabond3556 Bad example. Sand exists in places where are no presence of water such as deserts for example the Sahara.
@@SuperSonic-9999 changes, in human characteristics is not the same as evolving from one species into another
@@Kamal_grum lol nice try. The analogy was talking about a small quantity of things vs a big quantity. That’s the sole difference between micro and macro. Way to miss the point lol
Do a video on dinosaurs man 😀
Nice video, I would love to talk to you in real life lol, you are very smart
this guy is just clever , i love him in allah
I dont think the evolution is true. Like do u think that the soul can evolve too?
Hi one doubt why and how do allah pray to something or some one in quran 33:56 pls helo me bro im losing my iman because of this and also explain hadith 216
Allah sends blessings. Angels pray. look at the tafsirs
@@JanRyczkowski well salah means prayer so allah prayed?And also I saw many photos of jesus,his slippers,his bible and this making me think like is this true?
@@Nowaythisshifr Let’s understand the meaning and interpretation of the verse 33:56 in Quran.
Indeed, Allah confers blessing upon the Prophet, and His angels. O you who have believed, ask blessing upon him and ask peace. (33:56)
Let's look into the second part of this verse.
“..ask blessing upon him and ask peace”
''Swallu alaihi wa sallimu tasleema" (Arabic)
Word "wa" stands for "and" in Arabic.
This "wa" has many rules and conditions. One of the conditions is that there should be always a ''thaluq" or close connection between the word before and after "wa".
Which means, in this verse there is a close connection between ‘Swallu’ & ‘Sallimu’.
Swallu and Sallimu is nothing but Salat and Salam.
Let’s see which of the below makes sense..
Salat (worship) and Salaam
or
Salat (Durood) and Salaam?
It is Durood or Blessings and Salaam which fulfils the condition of “wa”. Because there is a close connection between ‘Durood and Salaam’ wherein both are said to Prophet Muhammad S.A unlike ‘Worship and Salaam’ wherein we worship Allah but we don't say Salaam to Allah.
Hence, word Salat mentioned in verse 33:56 is not misinterpreted but rightly translated as “Blessings”.
omg is this real question brother
I don't care really. Adam (as) was created with different physical attributes, but definitely with a human mind, therefore he was a human, and no human was before him. I don't believe a some sort of human some sort of animal preceded Adam (as). As for the animals, maybe Allah created whales through dogs? Maybe, maybe not. It's not really problematic.
I feel like you explained perfectly in your evolution video with the two theories that you put forward.
Please don't take this in a bad way, I'm just curious. Why does everyone use the word "Revert"? Does this not imply you were a Muslim, left Islam, then came back? Is there some nuance I am not getting here?
we are all born with the disposition to be a monetheist who is submissive to God (muslim)
@@JanRyczkowskiInteresting, thank you for the explanation.
We share dna with bananas
Fine but doesn’t really do anything tbh, we share the same molecules as rocks, doesn’t mean i evolved from rocks
@cyberyousef7519 sorry man i think this was a mixture of internet misinterpretation, i was pointing out the same thing you are but trying to pose it in a sarcastic manner
Brother can you make video about videos game? I mean modern game, there are musical elements, drawn characters and elements of violence and magic (all that is haram things in islam). Im corius what your perspective about this, cause many young muslim playing modern game, even they addicted to it (include me).
haram (unless theres no magic, no music, nothingthats haram irl. then, jts fine)
but its stil better not to play becausd its a waste of time
@@JanRyczkowski Waste of time is also haram?
@@ahmadsahl9384 yes it is a minor sin tho, video games are a waste of time because it has no benefit, neither is is full filling, you might call it “enjoying yourself” but it’s only for a moment but your dopamine goes crashing down right after, so even happiness isn’t gained
@@cyberyousef7519 Alright brother, just one questions, you still playing game? I just see your video. If you not playing anymore, mind if you share to me, i mean how and why you stop. Thank you
Genuinely, isn't it stated that Adam and Eve were the first people on earth?, I'm not sure but if it is true, doesn't it just take the idea of people before them like you said in this video?
Refer suboor ahmeds study will help you alot in sha Allah
idk why people forget about the djinns and whatever intelligent lives there were before us on our planet ... so i don't think there were any humans before Adam .
anyways ; one thing is for sure , adam and eve were not white , nor were they black or asian , they were unique ... different from us ,but not apes , they were superior as they survived the wilderness of earth alone (they were separated ) without even having clothes (from paradise at start) , their superior gene allowed them to survive the harsh environment and diseases , and later the inbreeding (as ordered by Allah) between their children "perhaps" deteriorated the superior gene and biochemistry in their body, reducing their superiority , making them vulnerable and closer to us modern humans , and later on travelling around the world had environmental effects "MAY" have had some sort of "change" . Scientists don't believe in our belief or any of the faith's belief , hence they have to come up with their own story , but they are picking up evidences from fossils , DNA etc etc and molding it to their own godless events / faith (fun fact : Darwin himself was not an atheist , he believed in a god or supreme being after studying the nature thinking that this can't be happening without an external supreme being's intervention from far ; he didn't believe in any religion though) .
They say humans originated from Africa ; why ? : Cause they found oldest evidences there ; ok , what if you find even older or similar evidence somewhere else like .. i dunno , Florida ? hundreds or miles below ocean ? or frikin Bangladesh ? what will you do then ? You have not scanned the whole planet , you don't know what's out there , will you change yout view and re interpret things if this happens ? or will you still hold onto your "old african" faith like a religion or worse , hide evidences or dismiss them ?
Also , where are the two celled organism that live independently like monocellular ones ?
Science Does not Eliminate God , Scientists Eliminate models of God .
idk why tf i typed all this thing , no ones gonna read this .. XD
Allah knows best .
We can consider those Homo species like Habilis, Erectus and others as merely just biologically very similar, but not true humans. Basically, pseudo-humans.
I read it, and you makes sense
Do you realize the fact that humans are considered to have evolved in Africa because our common ancestors (Australopiths) evolved and lived there too? Again, you're comment is based on un-reasonable conservative views, not Islam. As he explained, the theory of human evolution is compatible with Islam. We can just view the homo-species before him as mere 'pseudo humans', not true humans. So, Adam still stays the first true human. And also, the theory of evolution is science, not atheism. It was not made as some sort of 'crusade against religion'. It is a theory based on scientific facts of change in species, common ancestry and fossil of less developed species which show transition. Also, scientists don't make up false stories based on nothing. It's based on empirical evidences. Plenty of scientists believe in Islam and the theory of evolution. Different scientists believe in different things. However, science itself is a single body of knowledge, commonly shared by all scientists, which are based on what can be empirically proven. The things you wrote makes Islam look like some kind of false outdated belief. You aren't going to be able to demote scientists and science by saying "oh! they don't believe in the same as us! So, they are incompatible". You are only demoting Islam because science is empirical and scientists believe in what can actually be empirically proven. Each and every single thing you wrote are unfalsifiable and cannot be empirically proven and are based on nothing. This highly differentiating from scientists who base their opinion on actual facts and evidences. Again, your comment is a genetic fallacy. Just because most scientists aren't Muslims doesn't mean we should reject what they say because what they say is right regardless.
The main issue with your statement is that scientist's scientific opinions are based on actual scientific facts and evidences and are grounded on reality. That highly differentiates from beliefs based on scriptures which cannot be empirically proven. Again, this doesn't invalidate religions. But, the thing I am pointing out is that what scientists say are basically what evidences say. And it wouldn't matter if there happened to be species of humans which evolved outside Africa before because that wouldn't change the fact that Homo Habilis and other species evolved in Africa. More to the point, there exists empirical evidences for human migration which showcase that humans evolved in Africa first and humans reached America and other places much later. So, we can conclude that the first humans didn't evolve anywhere outside Africa. Your comment is a great example of arguments from gaps (lack of knowledge) and thinking that an entire theory is invalid because of some flaws which are more related to names and terms which do not at all refute empirical facts which those superseded statements were based on. (For example, if a homo species evolved outside Africa before Homo Habilis, that wouldn't change the fact that Homo Habilis evolved in Africa in the estimated time range scientists have figured out and it wouldn't change the fact that Habilis is included among our ancestors. Rather, Homo Habilis would simply be stripped away from the title of first homo species.)
Also, I'm a Muslim and I am heavily against materialism and atheism (not in a violent or toxic way tho).
Can you please make a video about Adam and eve and that we came not from apes
They don't "share" genetic similarities
enzymes have totally differernt sequences, for the same name of enzyme
they have similar building blocks, and the reason because they were made by the same creator, same designer. Similar to the verses which questions are there any other creators ? or do they create themselves ? if there are other creators, they'd have their own building blocks or architecture
There is misconception that "adaptation" is consequence of evolution. Which is a false claim. Adaptation is independant from evolution. Evolution fundamentally believes all life came from a single cell. However, adaptation can be instilled in any new creature like Humans which we believe were created, yet both humans and animals have adaptation.
We do evolve but very small and not a ridiculous transformation like going from fish to human.
Brother you are doing a great job but I think you should give some time to Saboor Ahmad.
Plus Islam doesn't suport darwinism bcz it believe that we all have promise with god in alam-e-arwah, and we are here on this earth to complete that promise. our spirits are made in alam-e-arwah. you should give some time stufying Quran and hadees from a Yemeni Scholar. Blessing apon you
the thing i found problematic in the video is that you said it is possible people descended from Adam AND other human who existed before them.. while the scripture clearly tells us Adam is the father of all humans
the prophet alahi al salah wa al salam said:
ينتَهينَّ أقوامٌ يفتخرون بآبائِهم الَّذين ماتوا إنَّما هم فحمُ جهنَّمَ ، أو لَيَكونُنَّ أهونَ على اللهِ عزَّ وجلَّ من الجُعلِ الَّذي يُدَهْدِهُ الخُرْءَ بأنفِه إنَّ اللهَ أذهب عنكم عبيَّةَ الجاهليَّةِ وفخرَها بالآباءِ . إنَّما هو مؤمنٌ تقيٌّ ، وفاجرٌ شقيٌّ ، النَّاسُ بنو آدمَ ، وآدمُ خُلِق من ترابٍ
translation of the end of the hadith (people are from Adam and Adam was created from dust
so that cant be true regardless of weather these other humans were from evolution or not
as for the possibility of previous human-like creatures that didn't reproduce with humans, that is in the realm of possibility.
والله اعلم.
الله يبارك فيك ويزيدك علم
It's a very delicate topic, and to be honest I wouldn't film videos about it. You should at least consult an established shaykh before putting a video out. In the meantime here's Yasir Qadhi's comment about it: czcams.com/video/skVAtgxtuWs/video.html
May Allah guide us.
Hello! The evolution as a process in the nature is it indeed happening, I mean let's just look at the simplest animal and we can see how this worked, besides regarding the humans there were already humans on earth and it's mentioned on quran that others were already on the earth. In the contrary I find your reflection on the topic amazing and open minded, please keep it non biased like that! ,now let's go to my request if you don't mind please I would like to see you research about the saving and originality of the quran, I've been searching lately and found that the oldest manuscript found is 2 pages or surat Taha (it's in England) and dated with high probability to the prophet time, although in tradition it's told that the quran was written years after the death of the prophet, besides if we keep saying that it was saved by those super memorizing ones and it was normal back then, then we add a human factor to this process which will make it theoretically never a 100% authentic? I'm really curious and if you take this topic I would be super happy! And first commenter send reflecter also. All the best.
Angels are made of light
Iblis is made out of fire
Adam (as) is made out of clay.
Am i right?
Brother debunk rob christian
I believe in deistic evolution
The Perfect cannot change.
islam and evolution is contradictory. there is no such thing as first human in evolution, yet there is in islam.
Even if evolution is true, HUMAN consciousness does not came alone with it anyway
I'm sorry brother.... I made a mistake and I report you couse i was think that this is an anti-Islam channel..... in the video when you when you debunked the criticism on the Quran.... Im so sorry....
May ALLAH forgive me and you and all the Ummah.... Ande help you in your Da wah
Aleyküm selam brother. I also think that way. What Quran says is completely true, so Adam and Havva (a.s) were brought to earth by Allah. As far as I know, the Quran leaves the possibility of animal evolution open. Even if the animals and plants evolve they certainly evolve under the order of Allah. So evolution that scientists know can't be possible imo since the chances of getting right mutations (so that we get into the beautiful ecosystem we have now) for each animal would be insanely low. I think that Allah led or guided evolution or simply set the world setting in a way that in the end the animals and plants would take a evolution path into the world we have now. Because the first genesis theorem where random atoms forming organic molecules and than they forming into bacteria or any sort of living being is impossible according to my logic, and if people search that subject, their logic as well. I can't imagine where random molecules by random energy blasts form a living being where that living being would reproduce itself so it doesn't go extinct.
Exactly mine thoughts also same.
W salam, I suggest you watch this video whereby Muhammed Ali does a presentation on how evolution theory is hocus pocus basically and he points out the actual issue with evolution theory and how laymen just take it as fact when its far from that:
‘Muslims Scientifically And Rationally Dismantle Evolution! Muhammed Ali & @SubboorAhmadAbbasi’
Evolution doesn't exist. Allah creates new creatures from the same animals hence we call it as a evolution. They share genetics but they are completely different creatures. It is like in coding OOP concept. Abstract class with abstract methods can be used for different objects but objects didn't evolve. We share genetics with monkeys because like in coding we are using abstract class with abstract methods for human objects.
Haha, i see your video "DEBUNKING" everything you do when you get proven wrong is say gibberish like "DEEZ" HAHA, cant defend your religion
What?
Proud to be Christian
Salam akhi,theres this youtuber called OrthodoxKyle trying to "debunk" islam,if you can debunk at least one of his videos i would be more than happy brother!
akhi i was wondering if you have discord me and my friend wanna talk with you with something my friend is polish muslim