The Real Problem With Linux's New BSOD System

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
  • There has been a lot of work on too resolve the issue with Linux kernel panics messages basically not working, by not working I mean not showing not showing up when you're in a graphical environment.
    ==========Support The Channel==========
    ► Patreon: brodierobertson.xyz/patreon
    ► Paypal: brodierobertson.xyz/paypal
    ► Liberapay: brodierobertson.xyz/liberapay
    ► Amazon USA: brodierobertson.xyz/amazonusa
    ==========Resources==========
    DRM Panic Video: • Kernel Panic Messages ...
    First Comment: fosstodon.org/@javierm/112619...
    Phoronix Article: www.phoronix.com/news/Linux-D...
    Second Comment: fosstodon.org/@javierm/112650...
    Phoronix Article 2: www.phoronix.com/forums/forum...
    =========Video Platforms==========
    🎥 Odysee: brodierobertson.xyz/odysee
    🎥 Podcast: techovertea.xyz/youtube
    🎮 Gaming: brodierobertson.xyz/gaming
    ==========Social Media==========
    🎤 Discord: brodierobertson.xyz/discord
    🐦 Twitter: brodierobertson.xyz/twitter
    🌐 Mastodon: brodierobertson.xyz/mastodon
    🖥️ GitHub: brodierobertson.xyz/github
    ==========Credits==========
    🎨 Channel Art:
    Profile Picture:
    / supercozman_draws
    #Linux #OpenSource #BSOD #FOSS
    🎵 Ending music
    Track: Debris & Jonth - Game Time [NCS Release]
    Music provided by NoCopyrightSounds.
    Watch: • Debris & Jonth - Game ...
    Free Download / Stream: ncs.io/GameTime
    DISCLOSURE: Wherever possible I use referral links, which means if you click one of the links in this video or description and make a purchase I may receive a small commission or other compensation.
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 520

  • @LordHonkInc
    @LordHonkInc Před 3 dny +504

    I think that the default message should be "Please reboot yo" regardless of screen size

    • @jenbanim
      @jenbanim Před 3 dny +132

      This is your Linux kernel, yo 💥
      An unrecoverable error has been encountered, *yo* 💥
      Uh-huh 💥
      You need to reboot your system 💥

    • @fabiofurtado1058
      @fabiofurtado1058 Před 3 dny +10

      ​@@jenbanimdamn you beat me to it

    • @hannescampidell
      @hannescampidell Před 3 dny +17

      @@jenbanim I hope the error message is configurable...
      if yes mine will be the wild west of error screens because why not

    • @alec1575
      @alec1575 Před 3 dny +3

      Talking like Killer Bee ya fool ya fool. Lol

    • @kensmith5694
      @kensmith5694 Před 3 dny +7

      On another channel there is someone who always writes a "hellorld" program rather than a "hello world" because he made that mistake once.

  • @immoloism
    @immoloism Před 3 dny +398

    People argue over the most stupid things when everyone really knows the real crime is no penguin with a smiley face being shown!!!

    • @placebo_name
      @placebo_name Před 3 dny +29

      Would tux with a frown be too much like a Mac? Smiling tux feels like he is mocking me after he killed my computer.
      Now we must argue about the logo's facial expressions for 8 pages!

    • @Zullfix
      @Zullfix Před 3 dny +8

      Kernel panics aren't really something to be happy about. I think it would be better if Tux was frowning, fallen over, or dazed, and maybe add a hammer/hard hat too? I'm not sure if they plan to support drawing images though. It would be really funny if people started ricing their BSOD for r/unixp with custom images.

    • @naturallyinterested7569
      @naturallyinterested7569 Před 3 dny +6

      @@placebo_name I want a tux on a tricycle with a saw mask laughing at me

    • @SirChristoferus
      @SirChristoferus Před 3 dny +1

      Perhaps it should be a black screen with a command line penguin using a maritime telescope to survey each software conflict and their respective troubleshooting instructions.

    • @RichardJActon
      @RichardJActon Před 3 dny +4

      Rico would seem like the appropriate penguin for a BSOD

  • @GibusWearingMann
    @GibusWearingMann Před 3 dny +210

    Blaming the BSOD for your computer crashing is the nerd equivalent of "why don't they move the deer crossing somewhere else?"

    • @XH13
      @XH13 Před 2 dny +5

      Or "I don't take Antipsychotics drugs, therefore I don't have Schizophrenia"

    • @sylvershadow1247
      @sylvershadow1247 Před 2 dny +1

      I understood that reference 😹

    • @danielrhouck
      @danielrhouck Před 2 dny +13

      There was a screenshot of a tweet going around recently which said something like “for every sci-fi robot that goes evil, there is an engineer that specifically installed red LEDs in the eyes for just that circumstance”. Only one person I saw responded saying that of course, that’s an important safety feature, the alternative is an evil robot without a visible indication.

  • @MNolanMillar
    @MNolanMillar Před 3 dny +100

    BSOD: Brown Screen Of Death = your computer has pooped itself

    • @kyokazuto
      @kyokazuto Před 13 hodinami +2

      Bread screen of death = your computer is bread

  • @Mishaye
    @Mishaye Před 3 dny +130

    Blue? Black? If I can't have Nyan Cat playing in a loop as my BSOD I'd rather just have a frozen GUI screen.

    • @byteingypthon
      @byteingypthon Před 3 dny +11

      I'd prefer flying toasters

    • @JasonMcGaw
      @JasonMcGaw Před 3 dny +3

      O.M.G. Yes!

    • @zerron2156
      @zerron2156 Před 3 dny +4

      Better question: Can it be an animated screen 🤔

    • @JohnSmith-lc1ml
      @JohnSmith-lc1ml Před 2 dny +17

      @@zerron2156 Computer I know you are dying but I would like you to please render this animated screen for my amusement.

    • @RC2225
      @RC2225 Před 2 dny +2

      i would prefer a Cyan Nat.

  • @knghtbrd
    @knghtbrd Před 3 dny +63

    I insist that the message be changed to "Please reboot, yo!"

    • @denisvolin7489
      @denisvolin7489 Před 2 dny +4

      Or: «Gotta reboot, bro!»

    • @semiRockethr
      @semiRockethr Před 16 hodinami

      With a penguin scull on a red background. That was a really good idea.

  • @MrDowntemp0
    @MrDowntemp0 Před 3 dny +243

    Blue is the right color. People know what a BSOD is. The blue helps communicate that.

    • @someguy9175
      @someguy9175 Před 3 dny +44

      Who cares... Each distro gonna theme the bsod to reflect it's branding. Just have clear wording and ship it.

    • @HobbitJack1
      @HobbitJack1 Před 3 dny +11

      Exactly. A lot of people are very quick to forget that everyone will instantly know what blue is.

    • @Cinkodacs
      @Cinkodacs Před 3 dny +7

      Exactly. People not getting this is just one of those things that severely hinders the "year of desktop linux"...

    • @felixfourcolor
      @felixfourcolor Před 3 dny +13

      I disagree. It's only true if you're from the windows world. In Linux, the "something is wrong" color is black, because that's the TTY background color.

    • @muizzsiddique
      @muizzsiddique Před 3 dny +3

      ​@@felixfourcolor Unless you use the tty or a terminal emulator all the time.

  • @Cmanorange
    @Cmanorange Před 3 dny +81

    "wait what is this? why is my screen blue? i dont read anything on blue, this means nothing to me. devs please fix"

    • @TurtleKwitty
      @TurtleKwitty Před 3 dny +6

      If thats what gets people to report the issue then so be it

  • @GafftheHorse
    @GafftheHorse Před 3 dny +115

    “what about this wheel thingy? It sounds a terribly interesting project.” “Ah,” said the marketing girl, “well, we’re having a little difficulty there.” “Difficulty?” exclaimed Ford. “Difficulty? What do you mean, difficulty? It’s the single simplest machine in the entire Universe!” The marketing girl soured him with a look “All right, Mr. Wiseguy,” she said, “you’re so clever, you tell us what color it should be.”
    ― Douglas Adams, The Restaurant at the End of the Universe

    • @RockyPixel
      @RockyPixel Před 3 dny +11

      I forgot about that line. In fact, I still don't remember it and I'm just going to believe you that it exists.

    • @GSBarlev
      @GSBarlev Před 3 dny +9

      Pff. What did Douglas Adams know? His big message was _Don't_ panic. 😝

    • @georgehelyar
      @georgehelyar Před 3 dny +3

      They underestimated the ingenuity of complete fools in the comments

    • @GSBarlev
      @GSBarlev Před 3 dny +1

      ​@@RockyPixelDoes the name "Golgafrinchans" jog any memories loose?

    • @a90steen
      @a90steen Před 3 dny

      I came here just for this comment! Well, at least we have found our entire useless third of our planet 😂

  • @GSBarlev
    @GSBarlev Před 3 dny +51

    The only correct color here is green. Specifically a green blob with two hands, a tongue sticking out, and the text: "DON'T PANIC! And make sure you know where your towel is."

    • @kensmith5694
      @kensmith5694 Před 3 dny +4

      Yes but I don't think our technology is advanced enough for that.

    • @kyokazuto
      @kyokazuto Před 13 hodinami

      Brat green would be good for a bsod (brat screen of death)

    • @Bob-of-Zoid
      @Bob-of-Zoid Před 10 hodinami

      Why not just a big 42 on the screen? (I think it was 42, but it's been a while).

  • @AQDuck
    @AQDuck Před 3 dny +92

    Obviously the most important feature is for the Linux BSOD to appear for only half a second and with _barely_ enough information given that would give you the slightest of hope of solving it (but not enough to _actually_ solve it).
    And of course needs a QR code to a completely useless article.

    • @felixfourcolor
      @felixfourcolor Před 3 dny +27

      And you have to login to your Linux account after rebooting.

    • @ernestosejasmaio3363
      @ernestosejasmaio3363 Před 3 dny

      ​@@felixfourcolorPlus to login you have to send the code they send to your phone

    • @IIGrayfoxII
      @IIGrayfoxII Před 3 dny +12

      And a :( face

    • @mudi2000a
      @mudi2000a Před dnem

      On windows it’s very easy to read out the contents of all past bluescreens with a tool. On Linux I hope it is going to the usual logs. Can’t remember when I had a kernel panic the last time on Linux. Too long ago. On Windows all bluescreens I had were because of faulty graphics drivers.

    • @IIGrayfoxII
      @IIGrayfoxII Před 23 hodinami

      @@mudi2000a yes it was from nirsoft, it's called bluescteenview

  • @CEOofGameDev
    @CEOofGameDev Před 3 dny +50

    I think the only reasonable solution is to have panic messages be displayed on a pulsating multicolored screen. If it doesn't induce epileptic seizures I can't really consider it an actual kernel panic, it's merely a minor kernel dismay...

    • @notNajimi
      @notNajimi Před 3 dny +12

      Now THAT is a kill screen! Don’t call it a screen-of-death unless it has a literal bodycount

  • @tato-chip7612
    @tato-chip7612 Před 3 dny +128

    Funny thing there are two reason's why the BSOD screen is blue:
    - Lowest common denominator for video hardware that NT could run on supported White on Blue
    - The developer who wrote it(John Vert) had a MIPS RISC development PC which by default was White on Blue on the firmware.
    Btw you can change the color using the "Not my fault" utility by sysinternals on windows.

    • @framegrace1
      @framegrace1 Před 3 dny +8

      That maybe true, but I think it goes far - far before windows was even a thing.
      White on Blue was the microsoft trademark on all their MSDOS apps from the start. As it was for a lot of Text mode apps back in the era. The thing is that colored backgrounds over white text made possible to highlight words with real "bold" character, by changing to the brighter white. Of all the basic colors, the only one pleasan to the eyes was the blue. So that was it.
      Windows installers were white on blue as the ms dos installer, and all the other apps.
      Anything "text" mode was white over blue.
      BSOD just followed the same theme.

    • @erinw6120
      @erinw6120 Před 3 dny +8

      First time I encountered a BSOD, I briefly thought the PC had somehow loaded WordPerfect.

    • @framegrace1
      @framegrace1 Před 3 dny +3

      @@erinw6120 Exactly, at that time, when most people used amber or green text only monitors, white over blue was how you show off your expensive color monitor :) (I associate white/blue with the first AT, maybe was when all this started?)

    • @VitisCZ
      @VitisCZ Před 3 dny

      You don't even need a utility to change color anymore because it's the same color as your accent color set in the personalization settings

    • @tato-chip7612
      @tato-chip7612 Před 2 dny

      @@framegrace1 Not for NT, John Vert never worked on Windows on DOS or DOS. It was simply a personal choice for him.

  • @FerroMeow
    @FerroMeow Před 3 dny +69

    The real question is can I set an embarrassed anime girl as BSOD background? I think this is what a substantial part of the linux desktop configuring community would like to see from their operating system kernel.

  • @MrMediator24
    @MrMediator24 Před 3 dny +14

    "Yo dudes, kernel panic is pretty chill. You can reboot or something"

  • @7rich79
    @7rich79 Před 3 dny +29

    This video still didn't explain whether we could have a brown screen of death. It's really important to my workflow to know when the kernel craps itself.

    • @hannescampidell
      @hannescampidell Před 3 dny +7

      why not display a image of a penguin that is crapping on the ground

    • @user-cq5pz3om7u
      @user-cq5pz3om7u Před 2 dny +6

      Segmentation fault (core dumped)

  • @tflsh
    @tflsh Před 3 dny +39

    The BSOD isn't Hotdog Stand yellow on red and doesn't have a animated cat dancing in ASCII art, so it's bad.

    • @fwingebritson
      @fwingebritson Před 3 dny +2

      If that were the case, I would be "Come on dammit, CRASH!!!!"

  • @Geenimetsuri
    @Geenimetsuri Před 3 dny +26

    Aye, that's a Linux BSOD, that is a Bikeshedding Overdose.

  • @user-oj7uc8tw9r
    @user-oj7uc8tw9r Před 3 dny +19

    I was hoping for guru meditation. But "please reboot yo" should be the staple and permanent

  • @spencerallen323
    @spencerallen323 Před 3 dny +8

    make it a Brodie screen of death. Every time you get a kernel panic the background has a picture of Brodie

  • @Soupie62
    @Soupie62 Před 2 dny +7

    Hitch-hikers Guide to the Galaxy: a useless group couldn't invent the wheel, because they couldn't agree what colour it should be.
    Thank you for reminding me of that.

  • @YouTubdotCub
    @YouTubdotCub Před 3 dny +20

    I feel like a script to make the colour different every single time in a randomized way would be great but I also feel like I'd forget about it by the next time the stack crashed and be like "...why is this taupe?"

    • @nanopi
      @nanopi Před 2 dny +4

      Could put in lots of B colours. Burgundy bistre bisque birch byzantium barberry

  • @unknownname3703
    @unknownname3703 Před 3 dny +53

    oh boy more bikeshedding, my favorite. i love the amount of bikeshedding in linux, especially wayland. its wonderful!

    • @BrentMalice
      @BrentMalice Před 3 dny

      TRU. these fat nerds with no life are the entire reason "the year of the linux desktop" will never exist.

    • @tablettablete186
      @tablettablete186 Před 3 dny +1

      Me too!

    • @notNajimi
      @notNajimi Před 3 dny +8

      I love when solutions to problems evade us just because people like arguing :)

    • @georgehelyar
      @georgehelyar Před 3 dny +6

      Let's ignore everything you said and say that it's actually gnu/linux because that's the important part

    • @MultiMissionman
      @MultiMissionman Před 2 dny

      In this case it's just a bunch of dumbasses on a forum, at least. I went into the video expecting actual developers to be bike-shedding the feature and was pleasantly surprised.

  • @RockyPixel
    @RockyPixel Před 3 dny +40

    In addition to configurable color they should add a "surfer dude" text option where it conveys the error message in surf slang and other "extreme sports" so it can just say "Please restart yo!"

    • @jedipadawan7023
      @jedipadawan7023 Před 3 dny +1

      If there are any football/soccer related messages I will not be responsible for my actions. And it will be very expensive in terms of replacing hardware.
      [I hail from England. I am not a football fan. I am now an ex-pat. You can connect the dots.]

    • @CiaranMaxwell
      @CiaranMaxwell Před dnem

      Now I'm picturing it in Porky Pig.

  • @DePhoegonIsle
    @DePhoegonIsle Před 3 dny +13

    Geniunely I prefer the 'Blue' in BSOD, as it's sooo outstandingly 'my screen never has this much of THAT blue ever', that I noticed instantly. I get it you don't want to copy windows modern BSOD, but good lord wouldn't you want to learn from MS and their past BSOD where were all soo helpful and got used to quickly find the majority of issues, with only some being sort of related crashes because of another unrelated crash (but gathering several BSODs and the system behavior was & still is very valuable consumer information for troubleshooting)
    Windows BSOD are 'as generic' now because ... they kind of have to be really, given the insane variety of people it serves & HW it sits on. They provide most the time safe & easy to do troubleshooting tips... for even those who can't read a stack trace to save their lives.

  • @genstian
    @genstian Před 3 dny +47

    I should go make a patch to make it a rainbow screen of death, that way everyone got their color of choice in there. Inclusive!

    • @everypizza
      @everypizza Před 3 dny +26

      systemd-pride

    • @-cdz-
      @-cdz- Před 3 dny +10

      @@everypizza PSOD

    • @Dr-Zed
      @Dr-Zed Před 3 dny +8

      bsod | lolcat

    • @user-oj7uc8tw9r
      @user-oj7uc8tw9r Před 3 dny +7

      LGBTSOD

    • @SpacyNG
      @SpacyNG Před 2 dny

      Fail. I want my panic to be purple, which doesn't exist in rainbows. 😂

  • @luigigaminglp
    @luigigaminglp Před 3 dny +4

    I think it's important that the BSOD is brown Text on green Background - that way you know your system just shat itself in the forest. It also looks terrible.

  • @felixfourcolor
    @felixfourcolor Před 3 dny +14

    This thread is a testament to the brilliance of bots and their capacity for growth. 🤖

  • @KozmoPoly
    @KozmoPoly Před 3 dny +7

    to solve the very serious choice of color problem both the background and foreground should be made of random noise

  • @trajectoryunown
    @trajectoryunown Před 3 dny +8

    I've been running Linux distros regularly for around 7 years or so, and I've only ever seen maybe 3 kernel panic messages.
    And like you said, I didn't do anything with it. Rebooted and continued as normal.
    Barring some unforeseeable catastrophe, I have no personal stake in this change and can't imagine that it will reduce anyone's experience in a meaningful way.
    Still, a standard command line output just _feels_ aesthetically nicer in my opinion. The whole BSOD thing just makes me think of Microsoft.

    • @contramuffin5814
      @contramuffin5814 Před 3 dny +3

      I'm thinking from the perspective of newbies - I think blue is actually good. Sure, black is nice, but if newbies see a terminal-like screen, they'll just blank out and panic. At least if it's blue, it suggests that the OS still has things under control, the computer isn't damaged

  • @jaakkohintsala2597
    @jaakkohintsala2597 Před 3 dny +7

    Bikeshedding is my favourite past-time activity

  • @darukutsu
    @darukutsu Před 3 dny +14

    holy shit the number of bots here is shocking

    • @everypizza
      @everypizza Před 3 dny

      it's four

    • @darukutsu
      @darukutsu Před 3 dny +8

      ​@@everypizzai remember times when there were 0, haven't been on youtube for a while

  • @SirChristoferus
    @SirChristoferus Před 3 dny +3

    Perhaps the Linux BSOD can become the Black Screen Of Diagnostics, featuring a command line penguin looking through its trusty maritime telescope to inspect each inherent software conflict and the respective troubleshooting instructions thereof.

  • @xymaryai8283
    @xymaryai8283 Před 3 dny +3

    as someone who encountered frequent kernel panics when doing weird, or even just normal gaming things, please yes give me information, no, i don't care what it looks like

  • @guss77
    @guss77 Před 3 dny +3

    My system has a problem where every few weeks the compositor goes bananas and the screen freezes, nothing is responding and even vt is inaccessible - but I can still ssh into the computer. Knowing that it isn't a kernel panic because I would see a kernel panic screen is a huge improvement.

    • @chri-k
      @chri-k Před 2 dny

      i mean, it's not a kernel panic if ssh continues to work.

    • @guss77
      @guss77 Před 2 dny

      @@chri-k of course, but from outside the machine, with no network, it's hard to distinguish between the input and out being dead and actual panic - without the DRM panic feature.

    • @chri-k
      @chri-k Před 2 dny

      @@guss77 true

  • @slim5782
    @slim5782 Před 3 dny +12

    but i like the kernel vt messages, they feel so raw

    • @GSBarlev
      @GSBarlev Před 3 dny +11

      DRM crashing bringing up the kernel vt would 💯 be a valid solution for a lot of peoole. But the problem is that right now, all that happens is that your system completely locks up and *shows you nothing.*
      As Brodie says in the video repeatedly, people don't realize this, because the kernel almost never panics for most Linux users.

    • @turtlefrog-tn3ek
      @turtlefrog-tn3ek Před 2 dny

      @@GSBarlev thats exactly what i want, the kernel VT to pop up. And i had a kernel panic locking my system recently.

  • @ronslayton5270
    @ronslayton5270 Před 3 dny +10

    Who remembers the "BSODomizer"? A little remote controlled box you put inline between the victim's video card & monitor. You click a button on the remote and it would display a fake BSOD.

  • @HecUnderscore
    @HecUnderscore Před 3 dny +4

    the error screen should be a picture of linus torvalds with the text "you are going to die now"

  • @johnmoore8599
    @johnmoore8599 Před 3 dny +4

    If the kernel panics, it should dump to a kernel log. If it panics before the graphical interface starts, you get a kconsole dump. If you get a kernel panic, you are pretty screwed because there's not a lot of info on debugging kernel panics.

  • @CharlesGriswold
    @CharlesGriswold Před 3 dny +5

    I want flashing red, and the words "Guru Meditation."

  • @AlexNaanou
    @AlexNaanou Před 2 dny +3

    To continue the dance of color -- IMHO if the VT is white on black, a kpanic being the same color is too similar to the default to be simple to identify (imagine a class of computers), so blue is better than black and since we have a cultural expectation of what white text on blue background means on a screen blue also satisfies POLS...
    Thus, I'd say a BSOD actually has two functions: saying that things went wrong (and how), and to be easily identifiable.
    But, for those people who use Linux as "not a windows", yeah, I understand why blue is worse than any other color =)

  • @upgradeplans777
    @upgradeplans777 Před 3 dny +3

    I'm not at ease with the idea of a Beige Screen of Death. I think a Burgundy Screen of Death is my favorite. I'd prefer a Brass Screen of Death over a Bronze Screen of Death, but a Beryl Screen of Death would be better. And as many people have already said, a Brown Screen of Death is a complete no-go. 🤡

  • @RightHandedFridge
    @RightHandedFridge Před 3 dny +2

    Looks like this choice of colour has really got people feeling blue

  • @Mishaye
    @Mishaye Před 3 dny +3

    On a more serious note, I see no downsides to this. I got some BSOD trauma from earlier Windows versions where they popped up often due to driver problems or other things but, like you said, they are only the messenger and at least at some point they became useful in trying to troubleshoot issues.

  • @PixLgams
    @PixLgams Před 2 dny +3

    We should all agree that the ideal color scheme for the Linux BSoD should be a black background with bright red text and a blinking box outline.

  • @danielnolan8049
    @danielnolan8049 Před 3 dny +3

    2:52, I'm sorry, but Screen of Death is such a metal name for something so nerdy.

  • @Sollace
    @Sollace Před 2 dny +1

    Having a bright colour on the screen is actually quite important. It has to grab your attention.
    I've had a few kernel panics (just didn't know it was because the system just freezes) so it will be nice to finally know what causes them. I can expect some more useful bug reports once bsods start rolling out to users.

  • @AgentTex13
    @AgentTex13 Před 3 dny +4

    I'll make it purple
    Also people should stop trying to kill the messenger

  • @m4rt_
    @m4rt_ Před 3 dny +19

    A panic screen is supposed to stand out, not something you stare at for hours.
    Blue is a good color.

    • @VolpeJosesk
      @VolpeJosesk Před 3 dny +2

      That doesn't means it can't be cool uwu
      Red with a penguim skull is better

  • @a7i3n93
    @a7i3n93 Před 3 dny +2

    I really liked the idea about the penguin skull at the bottom of the screen. Reminds me of the ancient "Guru Meditation Error" of my now very dead Amiga Computer. This is not important of course, like the information concerning the cause of the crash etc... but let's face it - as in other important areas of life, using Linux occasionally requires a sense of humor.👀

  • @lowellcamp3267
    @lowellcamp3267 Před 3 dny +1

    People being angry at the “your operating system quit unexpectedly” popup is indeed a little funny when you think about it.
    I do, however, feel my stomach drop when the audio buffer underflows and you get the last buffer full of audio playing on repeat. Oh boy, something must have gone horribly wrong…

  • @Mordecrox
    @Mordecrox Před 3 dny +10

    This "don't use blue" mentality is why Gimp keeps struggling with adoption - they go out of their way to not be proprietary-like as possible to user's detriment.
    Congratulations you solved no problem and also caused confusion and delay

    • @MegaManNeo
      @MegaManNeo Před 2 dny +3

      WEIRDO FOSS GATEKEEPERS UNITE!
      Insert my eyes rolling here.

    • @gwentarinokripperinolkjdsf683
      @gwentarinokripperinolkjdsf683 Před 2 dny +3

      Yeah gimp has always been really obnoxious to use

    • @turtlefrog-tn3ek
      @turtlefrog-tn3ek Před 2 dny

      pretty weird to compare a colour to proprietary.

    • @Mordecrox
      @Mordecrox Před 2 dny

      @@turtlefrog-tn3ek which is the point.
      These people think intuitive easy to use and standardized UX or COLORS are proprietary THEREFORE we must make the exact opposite everywhere everytime.
      Makes no sense and that's the point.

    • @the-answer-is-42
      @the-answer-is-42 Před dnem

      ​​​@@Mordecrox To be fair, some companies have tried (not sure if they succeeded) with slapping their UI designs with an "intellectual property of us" sticker, to prevent their competitors from using it. Not sure how likely an open source project is of getting sued because of that, though. My uninformed intuition tells me it's a pretty negligible likelihood, but as I said, I don't really know.
      EDIT:
      Might have been patents and not intellectual property, was a while ago I read about it.

  • @lmanstl
    @lmanstl Před 3 dny +2

    I want every letter and the background of that letter to be a different color and each word to be in a different font. And each new line changes the font size.

  • @robw3610
    @robw3610 Před 2 dny +1

    Lmfaoooo this is hysterical to watch unfold.
    In all seriousness though. In more than a decade of running various Linux desktops and servers, I may have seen a kernel panic once, which was hard to tell because my computer froze, my wife spilled coffee on my Desktop which some landed on my GPU and I think caused the thing to crash the display driver. Ironically, it survived after drying it out with some paper towels. EVGA's build quality is / was astounding.

  • @AndrewSchott
    @AndrewSchott Před 3 dny +2

    The reason that people of a certain age are more concerned with the BSOD rather than, as you astutely pointed out several times, is that Win3,xx - XP BSOD'ed _alot_. This is one area that MS has vastly improved in. Take a 15 yro from today where its either crap applications or bad RAM stick and go back to 1998 they would lose their mind, just because all the troubleshooting skills of today are virtually worthless. The BSOD is literally PTSD for some folks. In fact this is what got me onto Slackware back in 1995 and Red Hat pseudo-permanently in 2000 (when 2.6 kernel dropped in beta, had to have it due to hardware I was waiting on a kmod for). People don't appreciate how much better things have been on the MS from since Vista (ought to be with a 10 year dev cycle). Still won't use MS or Apple anymore.

  • @WaylakeAnimations
    @WaylakeAnimations Před 3 dny +1

    6:30 I want my error screen to give me information, and without PTSD included...

  • @GYTCommnts
    @GYTCommnts Před 3 dny +3

    What I don't like nowadays is the tendency of software in general to hide information from the users. Any BSOD, no matter the color 🤦‍♂️, should give the essential minimal information (if possible) of what triggered the error. Of course there are the LOGs to investigate, but the BSOD could always give the first step for investigation, for the chance you can't see the LOGs later...

  • @lipepaniguel
    @lipepaniguel Před 3 dny +1

    To be fair, my first thought seeing the screenshot was "why blue"

  • @jupitersky
    @jupitersky Před 2 dny +1

    My first thought was literally "ew, blue... reminds me of Windows, can we change that pls?"
    Typical accidental Linux PR disaster lol, glad to have error messages finally!

  • @devnom9143
    @devnom9143 Před 3 hodinami +1

    Obviously the correct color is in fact out a single color the error info encapsulated in a black rectangle that sits on top of a TV test card/pattern
    Also, a favepalm gif background would be fun too

  • @WyvernDotRed
    @WyvernDotRed Před 3 dny +2

    As silly as this colour debate is, the amber screen of death suggestion seems like a great choice to me.
    I might configure the system to display like that once this gets released on Arch.
    This definitely is a great addition, but the complaint's of Windows's (modern) BSODs not being verbose enough is valid, gauging by the ones I experienced.
    Though even this is a rarity, both my Linux systems randomly crash more than the family Windows laptop.

  • @HojoNorem
    @HojoNorem Před 3 dny +1

    Been tinkering with my A1200 lately so I'm going to say... What's wrong with the good ole' "Guru Meditation" error?

  • @m4rt_
    @m4rt_ Před 3 dny +2

    I don't think I have encountered a kernel panic... but if I have, or if I do end up seeing one, my reaction is probably just going to be:
    Oh no! Anyway.

  • @proxxyBean
    @proxxyBean Před 3 dny +1

    I want a blood-red screen with instructions on reporting the panic to the devs.

  • @jefferson-tan
    @jefferson-tan Před dnem +1

    “Don’t shoot the messenger”

  • @kensmith5694
    @kensmith5694 Před 3 dny

    I have seen quite a few kernel panics. There are two places where it seems to happen.
    1) When I am shutting down Linux Mint the very last thing the process tries to do is turn off the power. For whatever reason, sometimes the power doesn't go off and instead the code gets to the kernel panic state. I suspect this is a hardware issue on the PC involved.
    2) On Puppy Linux, you can make your own version by "remastering". If the result of "remastering" is a squash file system that doesn't fit into RAM, you get a kernel panic.

  • @commanderguy-rw7tj
    @commanderguy-rw7tj Před 2 dny

    there's something to be said about white on black being objectively better. that is, if one or more color channel(s) of your monitor dies, you will still be able to see it fine with white on black, but might not with other combinations.

  • @Jackpkmn
    @Jackpkmn Před dnem +1

    The most hilarious thing in the Linux space to me is how people think that if windows does a thing then Linux has to either not do that thing or do it in a completely different way. The only considerations for if Linux should do a thing the way Windows does a thing or not is if it's a good idea to do it that way and if interoperability with the way Windows does it is important. Is it a bad idea? Don't copy it. Is it a good idea? Do copy it.

  • @TommyCrosby
    @TommyCrosby Před 3 dny +1

    I never heard anyone ever say "BeeSOD"

  • @zeckma
    @zeckma Před 3 dny

    Something else kernel panics are useful for is when you compile the kernel yourself and set custom options. They provide great insight into what is wrong when you boot up so you can recompile the kernel and resolve the issue. I had my fair share of kernel panics, and they always happened at boot time for me.
    Also, the screen isn't aggressive enough, it should be a white background with yellow text.

  • @H3cJP
    @H3cJP Před 3 dny +1

    just for the record, arent kernel panics stored on a log file? like, wouldnt you be able to reboot and then do cat so some specific file on some route, where all kernel panics are stored? if not, i think that would be handy

    • @w01dnick
      @w01dnick Před 3 dny +2

      When kernel panic happens you can't be sure in filesystem modules integrity, so any writing to FS could potentially break it.

    • @H3cJP
      @H3cJP Před 3 dny

      @@w01dnick thats true, however i think it should be possible (idk if it actually is)
      what i mean is having it disabled as default, but being able to enable it, assuming the risk but you might prefer that in some specific case

    • @w01dnick
      @w01dnick Před 2 dny +1

      @@H3cJP well, earlier there was a way to write dump into swap partition but it seems it's not used anymore (as still not safe, needs intact block device modules).
      Now you can use kdump+kexec, that will boot into another kernel that will dump crashed one into dump file, but you need to preload another kernel at boot time in reserved memory that couldn't be used. So usually it's not active.

  • @Blink_____
    @Blink_____ Před 2 dny +1

    video description has broken my brain

  • @yayuuu
    @yayuuu Před 3 dny +2

    I hope we can customize it with some anime girl ascii arts, or even use colorful squares to create low resolution image, that wpuld be so linux...

  • @vccs6348
    @vccs6348 Před 2 dny

    FYI
    On windows, BSODs are actually called Bugchecks
    Windows bsod color can also be changed, and is different depending on the os branch you are on^
    For example insiders get a green GSOD
    During a short period of W11, they were also Black, not Blue
    I dont get why people call blue the "windows color", blue is blue, not windows

  • @Aliamus_
    @Aliamus_ Před 2 dny

    Can't wait for the color to be a choice you make on install (or after).

  • @DryPaperHammerBro
    @DryPaperHammerBro Před 3 dny

    Phoronix's comments're golden. I highly recommend having a read, the links're in Brodie's description, up above

  • @Dr-Zed
    @Dr-Zed Před 3 dny +6

    I want mine to say "Ah shit, here we go again"

  • @briannamorgan4313
    @briannamorgan4313 Před 2 dny

    Did something change in the way kernel panics occur over the last decade? When I first started using Linux it was on Gentoo 15 years ago and as a result regularly triggered kernel panics because of my own ignorance. I would reboot my computer, load up the dmesg log, and see what my system was doing before it crashed along with some valgrind output. I haven't seen a kernel panic in nearly 15 years, which is a testament to how good Linux is compared to the alternatives, but I assumed things hadn't changed from useful logs after a kernel panic.

  • @brianorca
    @brianorca Před 3 dny +1

    A kernel panic should be a different color than the default terminal background. Blue, deep red, chartruse, anything other than black.

  • @omfgbunder2008
    @omfgbunder2008 Před 3 dny

    My only beef with the bsod screen is that the text is going to get cut off the top of the screen, because that's what always happens with panics and oopses.

  • @ernestoditerribile
    @ernestoditerribile Před 3 dny +7

    Nice 90's song on your whiteboard

  • @JessicaFEREM
    @JessicaFEREM Před 3 dny

    it's still a BSOD, just "Black Screen Of Death"
    the windows was only blue because the person working on the BSOD just happened to like the color that their computer's terminal was by default so they made the BSOD (actually called "BugCheck") into blue.

  • @PixLgams
    @PixLgams Před 2 dny

    The correct quote is "I'm blue da ba dee da ba *da*". The autotune just made it sound wonky.

  • @wittywilla
    @wittywilla Před 3 dny

    The whiteboard was a nice touch

  • @rogo7330
    @rogo7330 Před 3 dny

    I actually in situation where I'd like to see the whole kernel panic. But I can't. The only think that I know is that kernel panics, black screen comes up, nothing else happens. Kernel panic only seeing if I boot from archinstaller in BIOS mode, and it's only part of the message that says something broken about high precision timer. And debian boots just fine. So yeah, kernel panic in less-like mode would be very helpfull to know wtf is happening with my system and why it sudennly stopped working after update.

  • @DennouNeko
    @DennouNeko Před 2 dny

    An option to make everyone happy: let's make both font color and background random. Bonus points for a chance to roll same color for both.

  • @Raspredval1337
    @Raspredval1337 Před 2 dny +1

    well, I've got my first kernel panic cases last week on my laptop, something battery related. But again, I'am on an Arch-based(😎) system, so the problem went away after a couple of updates.
    But still, having a meaningful message would've been nice. Plus, I'd prefer it to be white-on-blue screen, for nostalgic reasons

  • @thechillhacker
    @thechillhacker Před 2 dny

    Yeah, I have faced this when building and troubleshooting what turned out to be nvidia nonsense and one bad core out of 32 on a previous monster build, my main workstation. I set up a serial port (server motherboard) as a tty, dumping dmesg, which I then fed into either a dos machine, or at other times, a trs-80 model 102 to capture the deathknell. For normal running I now keep a second monitor set up with local dmesg -w, htop, s-tui, and my network monitoring. I may have a mental problem lol.

  • @angeldude101
    @angeldude101 Před 3 dny

    After recently setting a global color scheme for my installation which includes the TTY, I look forward to at some point seeing an _orange_ screen of death. (It's a _very dark_ shade of orange, but the websites I can find seem to call it orange none the less. One website called it close to "Bokara Grey". The exact color is #1b1918.)

  • @hacxman1
    @hacxman1 Před dnem

    so can we turn it off then? i want to see blinking led, and stuff i had on display so i can rescue some information. not some random fullscreen error. thats windows nonsense

  • @No-mq5lw
    @No-mq5lw Před 3 dny +1

    I kind of want the option to bake in some information with it. Maybe a kernel kersion, or a distro release name. Just so we aren't left hanging too much when someone inevitability just posts a BSOD taken with thier phone.

  • @stuartnorman8713
    @stuartnorman8713 Před 2 dny

    Poor Brodie! I haven't seen a Linux kernel panic screen in decades. Sure, my computer has locked up a few times, but I suspect the kernel is happily running, it just can't be accessed. Panic screen color should be a bright, flashing red!

  • @gregoryreimer869
    @gregoryreimer869 Před 3 dny +1

    Random color every frame. Compromise means everybody's unhappy, right?

  • @skelebro9999
    @skelebro9999 Před 2 dny +1

    sanest Phoronix comments

  • @Ekce
    @Ekce Před 2 dny

    I've had kernel panics a few times over the years (like several over a given period) and I think every time I root caused them to being a hardware failure of some sort (e.g. dying ram stick).

  • @BlogingLP
    @BlogingLP Před 2 dny

    Just as an idea in general: Why not resurrect the good old reset button? Getting rid of it was the dumbest idea humanity ever had, right after the invention of nukes.

  • @SeekingTheLoveThatGodMeans7648

    Why can't there be an orange window of resurrection that makes it possible to see what happened, upon the next reboot? And you can actually cut and paste from it.

  • @ahettinger525
    @ahettinger525 Před 2 dny

    in fairness bikeshedding named for arguing about the color of the bikeshed, rather then it's actual construction, location, if a bikeshed is even needed, etc.
    Now guru mediation numbers are where it's at.

  • @hermdude
    @hermdude Před 3 dny

    I read the thumbnail as bikesh-ed, was wondering who Bikesh is, then realised it’s supposed to be bike-shed. Well, I don’t know what bikeshed is either.

  • @Sypaka
    @Sypaka Před 3 dny

    Sometimes those devs behave like little kids. "I want blue" - "Nooo, but I want red." - "Green. Period."