I wonder what happened to my comment that listed at least 8 citations just as an example of the proof being requested here. So much for charade of demanding evidence.
@@scienceisdope YT keeps deleting the comment with links to legit journal articles. That should not be shady. I tried putting in a Google Doc which also cannot be linked. I'm out of ideas. Let me just add what I wanted to say in summary: 1. There is a lot of hokum, self-medication, and appeal to tradition that goes on in the name of Ayurveda. If you believe in the efficacy of Ayurveda, you must also understand the context, contraindications, and dosage recommendations that come, unsurprisingly, from Ayurveda itself. There is no such thing as no side effects - even in Ayurveda. You cannot self-medicate willy-nilly without knowing the details of what you are consuming. 2. The part of Ayurveda that is probably most well researched is therapeutics or, the actual herbal remedies recommended. This is what you can justifiably be proud of and rely upon. 3. The Vata-Pitta-Kapha diagnosis methods are very high-level heuristics that cannot match the rigor of current clinical laboratory diagnosis. This is why most rational Ayurveda practitioners recommend getting tested using a modern lab and then prescribe Ayurvedic medication. 4. In most states, Ayurvedic doctors (BAMS) need to study both, modern as well as Ayurveda, so we should refrain from undervaluing them. They are well aware of modern methods of diagnosis and treatment and choose depending on patient preference. Level of interest, funding, and research in Ayurveda is still not at par with modern medicine. But let’s not throw the baby out with the bathwater by claiming the whole field is pseudoscience. Again: The links from Springer/Pubmed/NIH refuse to show up in the comment. For anyone interested search for "Ayurveda - Some Thoughts" Also, the Springer article you linked from Dr. Patwardhan is from 2014. A lot of legit research has gone in after that.
@@manabukun I thought you were gonna provide evidence. You've provided none. And that Patwardhan paper you mentioned, I've read multiple papers by him as part of the research for my Ayurveda video which you can find on my channel. Absolutely no evidence whatsoever. There are papers that claim to provide evidence, but they don't.
+@@manabukun Recently I have had similar experiences in the CZcams comments section; in order to substantiate my claims about a particular organisation's activities, I posted WebLinks to that organisations own official WebPages. Those WebPages would have served as *primary sources.* However, each and every comment of mine that contained WebLinks to WebPages outside of CZcams got repeatedly deleted.
I told my mother homeopathic is fake. She said it is a slow but permanent solution. I told her allopathy is tested and then approved before launching to public. She told that those under testing were corrupt 🙄. I told her homeopathic is even less tested She told that it benefits her. I asked her why do you go to allopathy hospitals when you are in extreme conditions rather than homeopathy She told "chup reh, jabaan bohot chalti hai teri" 😛😂😂
oh fucking heck. i literally could write an essay on how much I despise homeopathic treatments, I had juvenile arthritis and as a seven year old, I was instructed NOT TO PLAY OR EXERCISE. Bruh, it not only cost me my childhood but also led me to becoming so obese that it put more pressure on my joints (which is kinda the opposite of what should've happened) . and gosh, don't even get me started on the fake medicines, was on homeopathy for YEARS, didn't feel a difference, instead I got worse until I got on allopathy
@@dankstars5303 thank goodness they aren't, they are both in the healthcare field and initially didn't wanna go the allopathy route cuz yk, but then homeo and ayurveda was literally so shit they were practically forced to
What he is doing over you tube .....it's damm bussiness. Criticising without been junk knowledge have dump to comment over it. Think and see the body what the way Ayurveda is looking into. It's just a point of view
@@drgadwalmultispecialitycli4627 With no proper investigation and tests yea? It sounds like a joke when some Yogi baba come and tells that they found a 100% curable ayurvedic medicine for corona virus before scientists lmao
This deserves a part 2! I would suggest the Namyha Foods pitch where the entrepreneur made serious claims about how her product affects the menstrual cycle, and proceeded to blame the shark for being 'too modern' when asked for evidence. Great work as always :D
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
That is not his point. He is saying that the entrupeneur in the namhya pitch did not provide any evidence and expected the sharks to still believe her.
@Amiya kumar the majority of your answer is correct but I'd just like to point out that Hippcrates, and be extension the Greeks, while often credited as the unmitigated primordial figure of modern medicine, was/were closer to Ayurveda than medical science in it's current state, which derives primarily from the scientific method, something developed about 3 centuries ago during the age of enlightenment.
@@raghavsvlogs I'm not the same Pranav that made the video :), and no one denies that modern medicine has side effects. The tridosha model being flawed does not mean that the stretches and poses that one performs in yoga aren't good for the body. Ultimately, being able to treat the patient consistently (especially the seriously ill ones,) even with a few side effects, is much better than using a flawed system which has a very small chance of helping.
Western medicine had a concept similar to the tridosha model of ayurveda which was postulated by Hippocrates which talks of the four "humors" of the body , blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm and this theory was further adopted by physicians like Galen . He also postulated that an unbalance of these four humors resulted in illness. This lead to medieval treatments like leaching to remove excess blood etc. Cancer was then thought to have been caused by an excess of black bile, however autopsies of dead cancer patients revealed nothing that could be described as black bile and soon this humoral theory of human illnesses was discarded. Today we know that external invaders like bacteria and viruses cause human illnesses while Cancer is caused by cells that have mutated genes and divide ad infinitum. In the west no one talks about the humoral theory anymore while here in India a lot of us are still stuck with the tridosha theory. It is time we grew up.
Thank you for your video. In the era of evidence based medicine where the FDA tightens the leash on a bloody antacid before extensive phase III trials, we as a country because of motivations unknown are deciding to put faith on drugs and methods without so much of a randomised control trial. In my 5 years of oncology practice, I've seen so many patients with something curable like operable T1N1 breast cancer resort to some unproven regimen and come back in 2 years with extensive metastasis and a mean life expectancy of 5 months. No one dares to talk about it.
He also talks about quantum healing behind ayurveda despite the fact that his medical degree gives him no expertise in quantum mechanics and he owns part the sugar free artificial sweetener despite criticising chemicals. He’s just a scammer practising the hypocritic oath instead of the Hippocratic oath
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
@@raghavsvlogs the difference between ayurvedic nd allopathic medicines is that allopathic medicines state exactly what side effects are present and no doctors or scientists claim that allopathic medicines don't have side effects while ayurvedic medicines are said to have absolutely no side effects. Its absolute BS
The scary part is that ayurvedic medicines and other alternative ones don’t even food certification let alone medical certification so you don’t even know if toxic chemicals are in the medicine. At least the toxicity of modern medicines is documented/known.
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
@Patrick Bateman well actually, even the Baidyanath ayurvedic capsules and tablets contained toxic metals like lead DoctorA talked about it in his video.
@Patrick Bateman The comical part of big pharma is that pharma has regulations(yes in the United States the corruption is a problem but that’s libertarianism of healthcare for you) whereas Alternative medicine has zero regulations and requirement for evidence, just some blind belief system like the 5g conspiracies.
Holy moly, I just caught up with the channel and you're closing in on 30k subs! I remember being there from the first few videos with P-dawg, and now this. Well done bro, science is dope indeed
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
When i was the age of 7, i started having severe pain in my stomach and we went to various doctors, and i was admitted in DMC HOSPITAL(india's renowned hospital, you can search it) for 1 month but they was not able to find the root cause of my pain. And they wanted to operate me without even knowing the cause just to experiment with me to find out what is his in body. Then we went to ayurvedic doctor, he pressed my nerve and told me that there is air passing in your naarhi( hindi name) and gave me medicine. I was crying with pain when I went to him and came back with instant relief. There are some ayurvedic practitioner who have vast knowledge and there are some commercial ayurvedic practitioners who have little bit of knowledge and started practicing. So bro dont be consumed by the ego that only modern science can heal everything.
Personal anecdotes amount to nothing. If these knowledgeable doctors know something so prestigious and want to help everyone, tell them to go and prove it in a laboratory and publicise the evidence.
Why don't these knowledge and clinical skills published in journals? Because they are not true... Can you ask the doctor how air is passing in the naarhi? And how does he knows this and how is he sure about it?...
@@jackyjack9660 hey do you know what happened to that Ayurveda reply thread? The one with 150+ replies,did someone delete it or is it on a different video?
@@jackyjack9660 sorry brothers, i cant explain to the people who are so consumed by their ego's that their might be other ways of treating people. I have given my real life example. It's like a cult here in comments section who are blindly following modern science. I also take paracetamol and antibiotics when i get some fever. Those vaids are hard to find who have knowledge. Unfortunately he died 10 years ago. There are no journals because he was busy treating people rather than proving point to some ignorant people. If he had done his study and got results, you would have said it's fake cause you dont want to believe. My father had spent about 50,000 that too in 2006 for my treatment but docotors were not able to find a single thing because they were doing X RAYS and other test but air cant come in X rays and he did it in a mere 1000 rs total. I got treated and I am happy, i told you this experience so that if anyday, which i wish dont happen, someone got a disease which is not curable by modern science. Please got to a knowledgeable vaid but they are hard to find.
Bro please don't refer to Ayurveda or its concepts as a theory, just call them hypothesis. if there are no experimental evidence to support it, then we can't refer to those concepts as theory. Also string theory is a theory just by the name, in reality its also a hypothesis, but unlike Ayurveda string theory has mathematical proofs but its still a hypothesis becoz of absence of experimental evidence. ✌ennalum broyude workinu irkkatte oru kuthirapavan !
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Isn't mathematical proofs enough to call it a theory? Didn't the existence of anti particles only became accepted because all equation worked with negative counterparts? Can you say the same for ayurveda? Is string theory making money off of sick people? Ffs stop defending scams.
@@ThatControlUser mathematical proof is not enough for qualification as a theory,, for example I can prove that density can go to infinity at singularity, both singularity and infinity are mathematical concepts but which are physically non feasible. This why mathematical proof is not enough. If the mathematical equations can predict the outcome, which can be tested and verified experimentally, then its a theory. Let's take another example, Schrodinger's equation, it doesn't have a mathematical proof but it can be proven experimentally, so its a theory. In science we go where the evidence points not the other way. Mathematical proof is evidence but, that alone, is not enough. In case of anti particles, dirac predicted it using mathematics, but no body accepted it as truth until it was experimentally proven. Dirac equation came out in 1928, In 1932 positrons were discovered experimentally in cloud chamber experiment, then in the coming year dirac was awarded Nobel prize. They could have given it for mathematical proof but that's not how science works. If one experimental proof is contradictory to mathematical proof then the mathematical proof is invalid. Not vice versa. Also Dr. Higgs never got his nobel prize until higgs boson was found experimentally. I believe these examples would help you. ✌️
You should also review one episode where they created an app which can read your heart rate and blood pressure from your phone camera, which is ridiculous. How do they even let them come on such a big platform. Don't they review them before sending them on air.
A colonial mind can't understand beyond his sense of sight .... they just worship every thing that comes from west and everything which ancient indians have proposed is pseudoscience to them.
honestly, as i have had treatments of both allopathy and Ayurveda, and do yoga, I believe that things such as dietary advice or lifestyle advice as instructed by indian science ALONG WITH MODERN ALLOPATHIC TREAMENTS work best. Infact, I was too shoved in the face with the pitta kapha bullshit and was prescribed weird-ass medication with terrible side effects, none of which I was informed of. On the contrary, when I went through with allopathy, I quickly recovered from my condition with the only side effects being some hormonal imbalance and weight gain, which I combatted with yoga and a traditional indian diet.
you are right bro... *my friend died from jaundice..* His parents didn't took him to hospital they believed in Ayurveda so they give him ayurvedic medicine... when situation got worse they took him to hospital... It was too late.. and he died.
@@i_am_funny yes, there are various factors that cause jaundice. Ayurvedic medicine for jaundice is very famous. The most common factor, gets cured naturally without any intervention as the liver cures itself. But there are also other factors which may lead to death if not treated properly. Unfortunately, I had jaundice when I was a kid and got treated with ayurveda. But it was not the serious type so got lucky there
I don't understand why people are getting so defensive about Ayurveda. If you guys can calm down and re watch the video, all he is doing is just discrediting the tridosha model. He is in no way saying that the actual Ayurveda treatment is bullshit. The Ayurveda medicines(not all) are actually beneficial in most cases everyone knows that.
Vat Pitta Kapha might be hypothetical but they are You can experience it These are just the names given to them I respect all medical science we need all
Me too but still many theories in ayurveda is BS And Please Pay Attention!! He said advices in ayurveda is still good for your body but theories aren't
You need to understand that he's not criticising the ingredients or medicine per say that cured you or anyone. He is criticising the tridosha model on which ayurveda works. To understand his views better you can watch one of his older video on the topic.
The most famous defense of Ayurveda , "but it's 2000 years old" is laughable. That's like saying Rotary dial phones are better than an iPhone 13 because they are older 🤦♂. Modern medicine wasn't created out of thin air 50 years ago, it's a result of rigorous experimentation, continuous research, a well defined, self-critical scientific process over many many years combined with skeptical analysis of every finding to prevent biases from creeping in and an attitude to evolve things further. It became superior in the last few decaded thanks to nuclear technologies and computing. Ayurveda on the other hand is like "oonga boonga book says drink snake oil to cure cancer no further questions please". It's scary how easy it is to manipulate people through religion and emotions.
If you read the history of homeopathy, in 18th century Germany, the creator of homeopathy studied European medicine(based on 5 humoral theory of Hippocrates similar to 5 doshas of Ayurveda), went against it and called all systems of medicine which used opposites of the diseases to cure them ‘allopathy’, and his system which cured using substances similar to disease as ‘homeopathy’. So technically ayurveda,unani,sowa rigpa and other alt med is also ‘allopathy’, Today, alt med practioners use the word ‘allopathy’ for science based medicine as a derogatory term.
@@scienceisdopeit really shows the popularity of homeopathy and alt med in India, considering the fact that even Indian media uses it. Considering ministry of AYUSH is funding Western alt meds like unani and homeopathy and rejects the extremely in-depth Australian study on homeopathy for it's 'Western science' centric method is first class bs.
@@scienceisdope you could make a CZcams short or a short video on the word allopathy itself considering the usage by medicine deniers and 'holistic' practitioners.
@@scienceisdope recently a doctor who works in a liver research and treatment Institute found out liver damage by giloye... The doctor said people have liver damage by using these herbs... And ayush and NMC said the doctor is degrading ayurveda... What's going on in india?...
This reminds me of those ear wax removal candles. Not only are these candles dangerous by holding a fire close to your face, hair, and ear, it’s a complete false pseudoscience that many people that are into yoga, new age, “spirituality”, gemstones, psychics, or even some circles of massage enthusiasts fall for. Back in college, I used to work at a book and massage therapist store/gift shop at a massage therapy massage school in the USA. We sold those candles. Since I worked there are we was able to purchase them really cheap at a whole sale price, I would are a bunch home with me and show people how useless they were by taking one and lighting it, but without placing the other end in an ear, but placed just suspended in the air. When the wax candle burned down close to the end, I’d blow out the fire and cut open what was left of the wax candle, and guess what the wax candle had “ear wax” on the inside, just the same as if it was used in an ear. To the same thing with religions like Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc. Nothing but fairy tails and make believe.
U know nothing Jon snow, there was a case happened to my grandfather who was bedridden,he had a disc problem, we took him to a corporate very reputed hospital in Hyderabad, doctors told they need to do a surgery but can't guarantee normal results, then we opted to kotakkal Arya vaidya sala secunderabad and to our surprise and consistent effort from doctor and patient following strict diet, he is recovered and able to walk with a stick. " IT WAS NO LESS THAN A MIRACLE"
@@37-sonaliswain81 The most basic problem with the Indian mindset is they are ok with whatever allopathy offers them whereas they expect to get cured completely by ayurveda for each and every case
No it's not a miracle. Disk problems are known to fix themselves with time. Exercises also help a lot. If the vaidya recommend some yoga asanas, then that might have also helped him. Some practices in Yoga has evidence for it. But that does not mean that Ayurvedic model is scientific. Even some Ayurvedic medicines have been found to be effective. Not because the model is scientific, but because those medicines have centuries of trial and error. But still, it is just superficial. Ironically, Ayurveda apologists accused mordern medicine of focusing on the symptoms, whereas mordern medicine has extremely detailed models about the mechanism of the human body. Disk surgeries are recommended when symptoms persist. Also, maybe you he was getting some medical attention before that which could have contributed. Or maybe, the doctor you went to was trying a cash grab. Or maybe, he himself didn't have scientific temper. Our education system causes lack of scientific temper. This not only makes people fall for pseudoscience, but also make many doctors themselves commit many mistakes. Then those mistakes make people believe that mordern medicine does not work. Then they are propelled towards pseudoscience. So as you can see, it is a positive feedback loop. So there are several factors. But Ayurveda takes all the credit and we think it is a miracle just because we don't understand it. This is why we should anecdotal evidence is extremely unreliable and We should always look into it and should not appeal to ignorance.
@@tarunkrishna4074 I can say the converse as well. People nitpick everything in mordern medicine whereas they tend to ignore the inconsistencies in Ayurvedic. They tend to overlook the other factors that might be at play in both the cases. This is over-reductionism, confirmation bias, and appeal to ignorance all in one.
@@instantdominator2121 don't throw words,most immature way to run away from point, the most basic question I ask is what do you know ayurveda before commenting it as psuedo science, how can you come to a conclusion and pass a statement, if valid argument then present, please don't go through dictionary to win over this arguement.
If you have not complete knowledge about one science then you shouldn't criticized about that science like Ayurveda. Ayurveda is a complete Science which is practicing more than 5000 thousand ago and your father modern science is coming just before 100 years ago.
Ya he said it fantastically ie; " if u disagree come with convincing evidence."😂😂 He is now not ready to reply to those comments who are mentioning the evidence 😂😂. This man has colonial personality disorder. He didn't even heard of 'Sushruta Samhita' let him sit in his science bubble.
mathematically it is well accepted... Ashok Sen got Fundamental Physics Prize for opening the path to the realisation that all string theories are different limits of the same underlying theory... obviously this a theory only (with good maths)... experimentally nothing done yet ..like most of Quantum mechanics, Quantum Information or foundation.
I have my pov on this 5 elements. Let me explain with one example: "My neighbour had invited me in their function." What sense does it make? Ans - My neighbour had organised a party or something like gathering of people and had invited me too. But as per maths and science the meaning of "function" is completely different from the "function" mentioned above in the example. Similarly, in case when we say our body is made up of 5 elements which are fire, water, earth, air and ether then at this time we are pointing to the literal meaning (for example may be fire means anger) rather than the exact meaning of these 5 elements. Even we also know this non of these 5 things are elements as per definition of element in Moder science. Conclusion: Ayurved model of 5 elements have there own meaning and explanation in different context rather then there actual meaning as per Modern science.
@J Keshari if a friend invites someone to a function, it doesn't mean he arranged everything for the function. It is our assumption(not a proven fact) that he must have made all arrangements and invited me along with a few others. Sometimes it so happens that when we arrive at a function/party no arrangements are done and we will have to take part in arrangements too coz it's a friend's occasion. You mentioned that fire element mentioned in Ayurveda need not be actual fire and it may represent something. This is exactly what the admin is saying. To talk with proofs not with "may be", "can be", "I guess", "as we all know", "it's is mentioned by Rishis(sages)"- (which rishi? Where did he say? Where is it written? Is it a reliable source?) Or "per our tradition", etc etc. Science always need proofs. If you don't care about proofs and you want to believe just because they mentioned the word "Ayurveda" then it's fine, it's up to you. We don't know if they are just using the word Ayurveda to make money by making false statements. Because it is very easy in India to fool Indians by using words like Religion, Ayurveda, Tradition, Sanatan Dharma, 5000 year old history etc etc. All the admin is trying to say is verify before you spend money. It's ok if you don't agree with me n want to believe a random person who talked about Ayurveda. It's totally upto people.
@@itsme-wn7gr Just a small response to your comment. The name of the rishis are Charaka & Sushruta. And the concepts are documented in Charaka Samhita & Sushruta Samhita. I really like the way people question but there are ways to find answers also. I am not saying that every ancient concept are correct and errorless. But rejecting everything, by labeling it as pseudoscience is also not very acceptable.
@@TrishitBera I agree not everything is a pseudoscience. So what exactly was documented in Charaka Samhita & Sushruta Samhita? I hope that's been proved to be corrected with evidence. If it is proved then no one can question it's authenticity.
@@itsme-wn7gr well its surgical procedures and instruments or its designs are being used right now in modern medical sciences surgical procedures like nose job surgical babies surgeries on skull all the methods have been proven right and evidence like a skull with surgery has also been found The medications of herbs and shrubs has mostly been lost thanks to Bakhityarr khilji for burning Nalanda university whats left with us less than ¼ of the knowledge most herbs names are in sanskrit without any images so it creates more difficulty
I just wanted to know what is your take on Ayurvedic medicine or treatment. I also thought this are narratives even taunt on effectiveness, the medicines are so costly but it really worked for a neighbour who was almost paralysed now she can walk atleast. I think we should not have a hard opinion.
That's the thing, asking for proof calling it a pseudoscience and all of that is fine but how do people counter the fact that it freaking works!? It's worked very well for me too!
@@mmmmmm.6199 my mother had issues with sinuses and what happened was, she took medicine from ayurveda before and they said its like asthama and the medicines didn't work. So we deciced to goto actual doctors for diagnosis and they showed us that its actually sinus blockage not asma. So my mom took that report to ayurvedic doctor and they gave some kadha for it and some medicines and my mom was fine. So yeah sometimes it does work but the thing is it isn't the most relaible thing, if u take modern medicine you can rely on it (as of now) but yeah sometimes ayurveda does work(to what I've seen)(depens on case)
Lmao i salute this man ,he's literally against pseudoscience in the society filled with false narratives and pseudoscience Babas and gurus , keep it up mate good job earned and sub ,and science is DOPE for real
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
I think the panchabhuta reference is made like this: 1) water - blood 2) soil - flesh of body 3) air - space for air passage ( lungs) 4) fire - the HCL 5) atmosphere - Skin in reference to the blanket of air covering earth
Wrong interpretation. Water - is not only blood. Actually blood is fire + water. Soil is not prithvi. You can compare it with solid substance. Air is not just space. Its a medium through which sound is heard. Fire is not just hcl, its entire digestive fire and digestive juices. There is no such thing as atmosphere. Its Akasha mahabhuta. Its more like vaccum in space Which is responsible for pressure in eye.
Also he needs to ask these question to Govt of India ministry of ayush and likely get all his queries and doubts answered by govt advisers rather than promote misleading info in public domain about your heritage which the whole world is proud off
I loved the fact that vineeta backed out and didn't invest, even though she didn't question their claims, it was a bold move and we need more people with influence to call pseudoscience out
@@rohitpatil6425 she doesn't have a background in science, shez a business person who license drugs from West and manufacture them. There would be sure doctors and scientists in emcure who'd be banging their heads after hearing her
I really appreciate your efforts. But it's common sense that these things showed are false. See, people who believe in Ayurveda, you can't make them turn against Ayurveda.
Good to see some people using brain and not falling for big titles As always it was informative and entertaining video Plz make video on ham product startup and nabhi shaper
Actually my own grandmothers psoriasis was completely cured using only Ayurveda as allopathic doesn't suit her. So, I won't agree it is pseudoscience as I have seen its effect with my own eyes.
I was cured too. I had used many allopathic medicines but the problem turned worse. I agree that there are some fake people who sell ayurveda medicines. So there must be one standard certification that used to find out genuine doctors. And also there are many foreigners who come and benefit. Medical tourism.
I was expecting to watch a commentary on the 'Namhya Presentation' instead I got this. I was disheartened to see sharks supporting the product when the only data the presenter could bring forward was 'word of mouth' and that out of a cohort of a few hundred, some reached out and said it was beneficial for them when in reality, it could be either placebo, mis-report by the participants, Hawthorne Effect or a congruent use of any other allopathic medicine. I hope to see an India where people are able to see through the false narrative of mixing nationalism and Ayurveda but stand true to the immense knowledge that our country is representive of and question the preconceived notions and ask for evidence.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 I sure remember Vineeta said it is not possible. Aman on the other hand is def a believer of pseudoscience and took this Ayurvedic app deal as well.
Bro modern science is always changing! If you can't trust something that has no evidence then how can you trust something that keeps changing all the time??
Even modern science plays with hit and trial method. Corona is one game of that. modern science first create problems and then by providing solutions to the same, they claim themselves better. Even after this much ‘dope science’, average age is decreasing and inventing a new disease every day. Don’t know, what the future beholds.
Science is at child level, and joker like this channel admin pretend to be a scientist just to satisfy his ignorance.. even scientists are collaborating with eastern legends for exploring depth of magical universe.
If you really want an evidence you should seek it rather than asking for the same. If you have researched well enough to claim Vata Pitta Kapha concept as a pseudoscience then you should also research about the origin, concept, significance & authenticity of all of them in Ayurvedic texts. Now let me help you do it. Please refer to the following books : Ashtang Hridyam Bhav Prakash Nighanthu Susurut Samhita Carak Samhita Vanaushadhi Nirdeshika. Please go through all of it, LEARN and then reply here.
Charak samhita puri pseudoscience se bhari hai likha hai bukhar aye sightapatan hai ya kamjori to maas khao gaye ka agar jhooth lag rha ho to khud check kre ek baar
@@sudhanshubharti7666 Bhai, medicinal texts kisi ek religion ke liye nahi hota h. Hinduism mein beef ki sakht manaahi h toh hum usko follow krenge. Mai aapse disagree nhi kar raha hoon. Agar beef ke fayde h toh pork ke bhi hain. Isliye ayurvedic texts mein ek conclusion bhi likha gaya hai : For plant eaters - Earth par aisa koi plant nhi h jisme medicinal properties na ho. For meat eaters - Hamein aise kisi food ko consume nhi karna chahiye jisme violence involved ho/uss food mein emotions ho. Ab ye aapke/hamaare upar h ki hum decide kare ki khud ke liye best kya h. Bohot saari aisi chhezein hain jo modern world mein relevant nhi h aur ab tk hum un sab texts ko 100 percent comprehend ni kar paaye h. Iska matlab ye bilkul nhi h ki wo pseudoscience h. Maine UFO bhi dekha aur capture kiya h, aur ghost ke sath ek haunting experience bhi face kiya h. Pseudoscience ek western चोंचले बाजी है।
You can't.. Can't deny the science which is still continuing to be studied and bunch of students pursuing Ayurveda as their career.. Before just claiming any science as pseudo science just have some common sense... Don't act childish
You may not accept it but many people in India believe in Ayurveda and they have observed it's benefits too. So it's individual choice and according to me, this pitch is here to stay
Then where are the proper clinical trials and studies conducted? If you have link to any of it please provide it. Ayurvedic treatments done in personal space can be easily flawed.
2:04 even though the proof is not there doesn't mean the theory is wrong, even the equations of Srinivasa Ramanujan was hard to understand without his own help.
Sir please do visit SDM INSTITUTE OF AYURVEDA BANGALORE...you will get to see many live evidences..😊...students study around 8 to 10 years just to understand Tridoshas....life is very simple if u see but people make it complex...I have a doubt if ayurveda is really pseudoscience then why is there Sushruta's statue established in foreign medical colleges...u know what is the problem..?..it's own people try to defame it in the name of evidence....even allopathic people suggests Liv52,volini,moov, papaya leaf extracts for dengue patients and many more....u seems to well be educated sir...i hope u see it in a broad aspect...please do experience it....
There are also statue of J.J Thomson in MIT, the person who proposed plum pudding model of atom. Acknowledging contribution of these individual when science was in primitive stage doesn't mean that their theory is correct.
Mr. Pranav I respect you. What you are doing is great, no doubt. Your contribution for sure will help in creating a rational society. And you are next level when it comes to pseudoscience. Loved it. I kindly request you to make a video on how to find authentic sources of information. Coz people generally have the culture of googling and taking up any article without checking its authenticity. They don't know how to find peer reviewed stuffs and so on. That is, art of reading authentic sources is lacking. Actually most of us don't know whom to trust. So please try to address this problem.
@@scienceisdope do a short vid on the creation of the word ‘allopathy’ by the creator of homeopathy Samuel haehmann if you can. In 18 th century he learned Unani (Ancient Greek medicine) and created homeopathy in place of it. Also specify that ayurveda,siddha, unani technically come under allopathy by haehmann’s definition.
If you read the history of homeopathy, in 18th century Germany, the creator of homeopathy studied unani(ancient European medicine), went against it and called all systems of medicine which used opposites of the diseases to cure them ‘allopathy’, and his system which cured using substances similar to disease as ‘homeopathy’. So technically ayurveda,unani,sowa rigpa and other alt med is also ‘allopathy’, Today, alt med practioners use the word ‘allopathy’ for science based medicine as a derogatory term.
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
I respect this video in the comments section we exchanged statements, but I have one question to you brother Let's consider according to your theory that tri dosha model is farce Please make a detailed video on tri dosha model prakriti model and explain in detail it's farce rather than drawing parallel from allopathy
All medicine has been initially derived from organic source. Some ayurvedic medicines do work. The problem here is how you get about the diagnosis of the illness. Hope people understand this.
Nothing but my respect to you bro. Your videos are getting better with time.. Keeping going maybe one day you will recognised by Richard Dawkins for the award as our Sir Javed Akhtar. Speaking of which I guess he also deserves a video from you.
@@pradyumn2692 well how exactly is he a muslim? what argument did he use which was contradicting his previous arguments for u to reach this conclusion?
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Jab main show dekh raha tha tavi main a notice kiya tha ki bohot sare product aise hain jo claim to bohot kuch karta hain likin koi clinical approval nehi hain
Bhai, u r amazing. We need youtuber and scientific educators like u in today's world. Just keep it up and dig deeper every issue and just keep representing those with scientific analysis and critical think.. the time has come that everyone is scientific literate at basic level.. amazing.. love these vdos.. 🔥🔥🔥
the problem is that, people synonymise ayurveda with indian medicine. and by extension, with their 'nationalism' and 'patriotism'. when in actuality, ayurveda or any of the old timey systems were just that, old. Modern medicine was built on that using that, somethings were accepted and their effects amplified because now that we have the scinece for it, we could prove their use. While other stuff was dismissed cause ther wasn't the science proving it. I disagree with your stance too, although i have yet to watch that video, about ayurveda being psuedoscience. It seems to be just an old medical belief system wherein, even today, the researchers and practitioners, instead of looking forward and making more advancements, tend to take old conclusions and somehow try justifing it with reasearch papers. The conclusion is there, they're just finding evidence for it, when it should be the opposite. If any of that makes sense. tl;dr; it's old and shouldn't be a way for ya'll to practice your patriotism cause it's old.
That namhya tea founder clearly answered like "anti-science" person saying "log bol rahe hai unko fark pad raha hai" . Shen only said 100 women "said" ,not ready to give data and I was surprised she got deal !!!
First of all this shark tank video explaining Tridoshas are not appropriate. Tridoshas do exist like modern physiology and its nothing different. For example function of Praana udaan vyaan samaan Apaan vata mentioned in Samhitas are same that of Sympathetic, Parasympathetic and autonomous nervous system. Pitta functions are similar to endocrine and enzymatic activites governing metabolism and kapha includes intracellular components which holds the cellular stability and intregity. The nomenclature differs between Ayurvedic and modern physiology and anatomy.
I don't know why do you need a charger to explain that this app is fake anyone with little knowledge would have known that there's no such sensor in your phone that is capable of measuring anything but distance.
@@piyushdevnath293 a dentist can't look into his own mouth from medical equipments.. But the point here is dentist don't go to a ayurvedic doctor.. Why didn't ramdev went to an ayurvedic doctor but an allopathy one?
From their webpage: "Ayurveda explains that the elements earth, air, space, fire, and earth come together in the body into three harmonious pairs called the doshas." Either they didn't bother proof-reading, or they genuinely think that contradictory statement makes sense.
@@professorelixir3351 I doubt you know anything either, if you're still buying into that pseudoscience - which makes you no better than these charlatans. But ramble on your insanity.
People should not mistake this .. the people who came for pitching they are neither Ayurvedic physician nor studied Ayurveda in detail, in fact they are engineers who just wanted to do business with the name Ayurveda ..they came up with this idea only after some months of learning . So if u really want to know about this science u should have some words with an Ayurvedic physician who practice actual Ayurveda. Not the self proclaimed gurus and baba .. please don’t misjudged Ayurveda 🙏🏻
Modern medicine also has its share of issues. For example, see the opioid crisis in USA. Science is indeed dope but large corporations (with vested interests) have influenced the outcome of scientific study, in order to do what is beneficial for them.
It's not your and their fault because you and these people didn't have any Ayurvedic background !! I must say each and every wordings of Ayurveda is scientific !! I never favour these guys nor any patanjali like brands !! True Ayurveda is very far away what you and these people know !! As you only say about tridosha and panchmahabhuta !!you only know vata represent Vayu mahabhoot ; kaph represent earth and water ; and pitta represent fire !! But you don't know that three dosha also devided in 5 subdivisions and along with that sapta dhatus and mala and upadhatus, Rasa, guna, virya, vipaak and prabhav and there panchmahabhuta combinations also there !! You should learn that !! And only learn these things from an internet is not valid and genuine !! Because it gives you only superficial knowledge !! If you really want to learn what is Ayurveda you have to understand the philosophy, padarth vijnana as from the classical texts of Ayurveda itself !! And your question is there is a only one protocol if jaundice pt. Came and we treat everyone with same parameter is totally wrong !! Because in Ayurveda everyone is different "purusham purusham vikshya" if you come to my opd with same complaints that your cousin came to me earlier I have to decide your prakriti first and then I have to select medicine!! And in our science there are different chpt. For diagnosis for Jaundice named as Pandu Kamala and halimak !! And the lakshana and types of each of them also vary !! And Ayurveda is not only just Nadi pareeksha there are 10 types of examinations criteria in Ayurveda in which one is naadi pareeksha !! I must say if you don't have a background and knowledge regarding anything you don't have a right to defame the whole science !! I also say that no machine will give you such parameter !! You have to analyse each and every pt. By your own !! I don't want to say but what you tell about normal blood pressure which sometimes ranges 120/80 and now 140/90 mm of Hg . If USG. And endoscopy reports are WNL then other pathy say pt. It is an Idiopathic. And finally treat. These pt. with sedatives and one day pt. will die. At that time you need our concept which is totally scientific !! And if you visit any Skilled and well versed Vaidhya if you go to his clinic with only one presenting complaint but you have some more complaints also you will be treated with all the complaints together and you will get total benefit this is the beuty of Ayurveda !! Your question is toxicity of Metals answer is every metal has a proper shodhan (purification) procedure and in our text there is Bhasma pareeksha mentioned if Bhasma is not properly made then it can't fulfill the criteria of bhasma pareeksha !! Still I don't support the commercial companies who made there profits in name of Ayurveda !! Your question is Ayurveda treats pt. Slowly it is your lack of knowledge in Ayurveda Shodan chikitsa and shaman chikitsa is there ! It is based on Ayurvedic practitioner what he uses in his practice !! So, I must say that if you don't know anything about Ayurveda you don't have any right to say anything against Ayurveda !!
You are commenting on Ayurveda by just seeing this video. That's not good. I have used this app on different people and the people agree with the results
I think this guy should be banned from posting any videos about his country of origin and it’s culture and sent to a country who will believe his nonsense ideology He is surely an atheist as well . Modern medical science is only 200 yrs old and he makes you think people were simply idiots prior to those 200 years as there was no evidence based stuff prior to that
I wonder what happened to my comment that listed at least 8 citations just as an example of the proof being requested here. So much for charade of demanding evidence.
Please post again here. Would love to read.
Also you're probably implying that I deleted them out of insecurity. I'll let you know that CZcams auto moderates comments with shady links.
@@scienceisdope
YT keeps deleting the comment with links to legit journal articles. That should not be shady. I tried putting in a Google Doc which also cannot be linked. I'm out of ideas.
Let me just add what I wanted to say in summary:
1. There is a lot of hokum, self-medication, and appeal to tradition that goes on in the name of Ayurveda. If you believe in the efficacy of Ayurveda, you must also understand the context, contraindications, and dosage recommendations that come, unsurprisingly, from Ayurveda itself. There is no such thing as no side effects - even in Ayurveda. You cannot self-medicate willy-nilly without knowing the details of what you are consuming.
2. The part of Ayurveda that is probably most well researched is therapeutics or, the actual herbal remedies recommended. This is what you can justifiably be proud of and rely upon.
3. The Vata-Pitta-Kapha diagnosis methods are very high-level heuristics that cannot match the rigor of current clinical laboratory diagnosis. This is why most rational Ayurveda practitioners recommend getting tested using a modern lab and then prescribe Ayurvedic medication.
4. In most states, Ayurvedic doctors (BAMS) need to study both, modern as well as Ayurveda, so we should refrain from undervaluing them. They are well aware of modern methods of diagnosis and treatment and choose depending on patient preference.
Level of interest, funding, and research in Ayurveda is still not at par with modern medicine. But let’s not throw the baby out with the bathwater by claiming the whole field is pseudoscience.
Again: The links from Springer/Pubmed/NIH refuse to show up in the comment. For anyone interested search for "Ayurveda - Some Thoughts"
Also, the Springer article you linked from Dr. Patwardhan is from 2014. A lot of legit research has gone in after that.
@@manabukun I thought you were gonna provide evidence. You've provided none.
And that Patwardhan paper you mentioned, I've read multiple papers by him as part of the research for my Ayurveda video which you can find on my channel. Absolutely no evidence whatsoever. There are papers that claim to provide evidence, but they don't.
+@@manabukun
Recently I have had similar experiences in the CZcams comments section; in order to substantiate my claims about a particular organisation's activities, I posted WebLinks to that organisations own official WebPages.
Those WebPages would have served as *primary sources.*
However, each and every comment of mine that contained WebLinks to WebPages outside of CZcams got repeatedly deleted.
I told my mother homeopathic is fake.
She said it is a slow but permanent solution.
I told her allopathy is tested and then approved before launching to public.
She told that those under testing were corrupt 🙄.
I told her homeopathic is even less tested
She told that it benefits her.
I asked her why do you go to allopathy hospitals when you are in extreme conditions rather than homeopathy
She told "chup reh, jabaan bohot chalti hai teri" 😛😂😂
oh fucking heck. i literally could write an essay on how much I despise homeopathic treatments, I had juvenile arthritis and as a seven year old, I was instructed NOT TO PLAY OR EXERCISE. Bruh, it not only cost me my childhood but also led me to becoming so obese that it put more pressure on my joints (which is kinda the opposite of what should've happened) . and gosh, don't even get me started on the fake medicines, was on homeopathy for YEARS, didn't feel a difference, instead I got worse until I got on allopathy
@@sunnysunside7954
Are your parents still into that crap?
@@dankstars5303 thank goodness they aren't, they are both in the healthcare field and initially didn't wanna go the allopathy route cuz yk, but then homeo and ayurveda was literally so shit they were practically forced to
Yeah I can relate lol
Homeopathy ka discover e kia tha ek allopathy Doctor
Fucking bullshit
He has nothing to do then make a plan to make a new pseudo belief medicine
Science is dope : why dada why
Ayurvedic companies : this is buisness
@Glovin Kumar bijnas
You're a joke mate! Wake up 😅
What he is doing over you tube .....it's damm bussiness.
Criticising without been junk knowledge have dump to comment over it.
Think and see the body what the way Ayurveda is looking into.
It's just a point of view
@@drgadwalmultispecialitycli4627 With no proper investigation and tests yea? It sounds like a joke when some Yogi baba come and tells that they found a 100% curable ayurvedic medicine for corona virus before scientists lmao
This deserves a part 2! I would suggest the Namyha Foods pitch where the entrepreneur made serious claims about how her product affects the menstrual cycle, and proceeded to blame the shark for being 'too modern' when asked for evidence. Great work as always :D
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
That is not his point. He is saying that the entrupeneur in the namhya pitch did not provide any evidence and expected the sharks to still believe her.
@Amiya kumar the majority of your answer is correct but I'd just like to point out that Hippcrates, and be extension the Greeks, while often credited as the unmitigated primordial figure of modern medicine, was/were closer to Ayurveda than medical science in it's current state, which derives primarily from the scientific method, something developed about 3 centuries ago during the age of enlightenment.
@@raghavsvlogs the amount of UPPER CASE is directly proportional to the readings of the Offended Scale
@@raghavsvlogs I'm not the same Pranav that made the video :), and no one denies that modern medicine has side effects. The tridosha model being flawed does not mean that the stretches and poses that one performs in yoga aren't good for the body. Ultimately, being able to treat the patient consistently (especially the seriously ill ones,) even with a few side effects, is much better than using a flawed system which has a very small chance of helping.
Science is dope.
Fuck Xavier, bring back Pakulo
r/FuckXavier
Xavier the danklord is here guys
Dope is science.
Ye science konsa ganja hai
Western medicine had a concept similar to the tridosha model of ayurveda which was postulated by Hippocrates which talks of the four "humors" of the body , blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm and this theory was further adopted by physicians like Galen . He also postulated that an unbalance of these four humors resulted in illness. This lead to medieval treatments like leaching to remove excess blood etc. Cancer was then thought to have been caused by an excess of black bile, however autopsies of dead cancer patients revealed nothing that could be described as black bile and soon this humoral theory of human illnesses was discarded. Today we know that external invaders like bacteria and viruses cause human illnesses while Cancer is caused by cells that have mutated genes and divide ad infinitum. In the west no one talks about the humoral theory anymore while here in India a lot of us are still stuck with the tridosha theory. It is time we grew up.
Thank you for your video. In the era of evidence based medicine where the FDA tightens the leash on a bloody antacid before extensive phase III trials, we as a country because of motivations unknown are deciding to put faith on drugs and methods without so much of a randomised control trial.
In my 5 years of oncology practice, I've seen so many patients with something curable like operable T1N1 breast cancer resort to some unproven regimen and come back in 2 years with extensive metastasis and a mean life expectancy of 5 months.
No one dares to talk about it.
@Mahendra Singh and he is criticised because he promotes quackery
He also talks about quantum healing behind ayurveda despite the fact that his medical degree gives him no expertise in quantum mechanics and he owns part the sugar free artificial sweetener despite criticising chemicals.
He’s just a scammer practising the hypocritic oath instead of the Hippocratic oath
czcams.com/video/kwzsiCMMcHk/video.html
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
@@raghavsvlogs the difference between ayurvedic nd allopathic medicines is that allopathic medicines state exactly what side effects are present and no doctors or scientists claim that allopathic medicines don't have side effects while ayurvedic medicines are said to have absolutely no side effects. Its absolute BS
The scary part is that ayurvedic medicines and other alternative ones don’t even food certification let alone medical certification so you don’t even know if toxic chemicals are in the medicine.
At least the toxicity of modern medicines is documented/known.
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
@@raghavsvlogs Stop with the spam, I've reported.
@Patrick Bateman well actually, even the Baidyanath ayurvedic capsules and tablets contained toxic metals like lead
DoctorA talked about it in his video.
@Patrick Bateman
The comical part of big pharma is that pharma has regulations(yes in the United States the corruption is a problem but that’s libertarianism of healthcare for you) whereas Alternative medicine has zero regulations and requirement for evidence, just some blind belief system like the 5g conspiracies.
@Patrick Batemanczcams.com/video/qAfkB9jiOIY/video.html
These guys basically built an app based on the knowledge of the guy who runs "Himalayan Ayurvedic Dawakhana" in a tent outside towns.
Holy moly, I just caught up with the channel and you're closing in on 30k subs! I remember being there from the first few videos with P-dawg, and now this. Well done bro, science is dope indeed
Hey, pdawg is empty now, what was that channel for?
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Pranav is a national treasure, we gotta protect him at all cost
I dunno what to say 😅
no lol
@@scienceisdope lmao no
Iam ready to be his body guard........ 😍
@Against Church lul
When i was the age of 7, i started having severe pain in my stomach and we went to various doctors, and i was admitted in DMC HOSPITAL(india's renowned hospital, you can search it) for 1 month but they was not able to find the root cause of my pain. And they wanted to operate me without even knowing the cause just to experiment with me to find out what is his in body.
Then we went to ayurvedic doctor, he pressed my nerve and told me that there is air passing in your naarhi( hindi name) and gave me medicine.
I was crying with pain when I went to him and came back with instant relief.
There are some ayurvedic practitioner who have vast knowledge and there are some commercial ayurvedic practitioners who have little bit of knowledge and started practicing.
So bro dont be consumed by the ego that only modern science can heal everything.
Personal anecdotes amount to nothing. If these knowledgeable doctors know something so prestigious and want to help everyone, tell them to go and prove it in a laboratory and publicise the evidence.
Why don't these knowledge and clinical skills published in journals? Because they are not true...
Can you ask the doctor how air is passing in the naarhi? And how does he knows this and how is he sure about it?...
@@jackyjack9660 hey do you know what happened to that Ayurveda reply thread? The one with 150+ replies,did someone delete it or is it on a different video?
@@jackyjack9660 sorry brothers, i cant explain to the people who are so consumed by their ego's that their might be other ways of treating people. I have given my real life example. It's like a cult here in comments section who are blindly following modern science. I also take paracetamol and antibiotics when i get some fever.
Those vaids are hard to find who have knowledge. Unfortunately he died 10 years ago. There are no journals because he was busy treating people rather than proving point to some ignorant people.
If he had done his study and got results, you would have said it's fake cause you dont want to believe.
My father had spent about 50,000 that too in 2006 for my treatment but docotors were not able to find a single thing because they were doing X RAYS and other test but air cant come in X rays and he did it in a mere 1000 rs total.
I got treated and I am happy, i told you this experience so that if anyday, which i wish dont happen, someone got a disease which is not curable by modern science. Please got to a knowledgeable vaid but they are hard to find.
Bro please don't refer to Ayurveda or its concepts as a theory, just call them hypothesis. if there are no experimental evidence to support it, then we can't refer to those concepts as theory. Also string theory is a theory just by the name, in reality its also a hypothesis, but unlike Ayurveda string theory has mathematical proofs but its still a hypothesis becoz of absence of experimental evidence. ✌ennalum broyude workinu irkkatte oru kuthirapavan !
Ex god🙌🙌
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Isn't mathematical proofs enough to call it a theory?
Didn't the existence of anti particles only became accepted because all equation worked with negative counterparts?
Can you say the same for ayurveda?
Is string theory making money off of sick people? Ffs stop defending scams.
@@ThatControlUser mathematical proof is not enough for qualification as a theory,, for example I can prove that density can go to infinity at singularity, both singularity and infinity are mathematical concepts but which are physically non feasible. This why mathematical proof is not enough. If the mathematical equations can predict the outcome, which can be tested and verified experimentally, then its a theory. Let's take another example, Schrodinger's equation, it doesn't have a mathematical proof but it can be proven experimentally, so its a theory. In science we go where the evidence points not the other way. Mathematical proof is evidence but, that alone, is not enough. In case of anti particles, dirac predicted it using mathematics, but no body accepted it as truth until it was experimentally proven. Dirac equation came out in 1928, In 1932 positrons were discovered experimentally in cloud chamber experiment, then in the coming year dirac was awarded Nobel prize. They could have given it for mathematical proof but that's not how science works. If one experimental proof is contradictory to mathematical proof then the mathematical proof is invalid. Not vice versa. Also Dr. Higgs never got his nobel prize until higgs boson was found experimentally. I believe these examples would help you. ✌️
@@ThatControlUser sorry about the long essay, please read and I hope you'll find it useful.
When I saw the title I thought you were going to talk about that Sardarji's learning program scam.
This one was fun too.
This channel is a goldmine !
Amazing work brother. Science indeed is dope.
Bhakto ki ek bahut badi tadat hai.
You should also review one episode where they created an app which can read your heart rate and blood pressure from your phone camera, which is ridiculous. How do they even let them come on such a big platform. Don't they review them before sending them on air.
This guy: ayurveda is pseudoscience
WHO building a traditional medicine centre at gujarat based on ayurveda : Am i a joke to you
Exactly everything you can't see that doesn't mean it doesn't exist
A colonial mind can't understand beyond his sense of sight .... they just worship every thing that comes from west and everything which ancient indians have proposed is pseudoscience to them.
honestly, as i have had treatments of both allopathy and Ayurveda, and do yoga, I believe that things such as dietary advice or lifestyle advice as instructed by indian science ALONG WITH MODERN ALLOPATHIC TREAMENTS work best. Infact, I was too shoved in the face with the pitta kapha bullshit and was prescribed weird-ass medication with terrible side effects, none of which I was informed of. On the contrary, when I went through with allopathy, I quickly recovered from my condition with the only side effects being some hormonal imbalance and weight gain, which I combatted with yoga and a traditional indian diet.
This guy: "Placebo Effect"
People: I'm an ignorant. What does that even mean?
@@sunnysunside7954 you went to wrong vaidya/doctor.
I have also experienced the same with an allopathic doctor.
Ayurveda saved my life.
you are right bro...
*my friend died from jaundice..*
His parents didn't took him to hospital they believed in Ayurveda so they give him ayurvedic medicine...
when situation got worse they took him to hospital...
It was too late.. and he died.
People can die from jaundice ??
@@i_am_funny yes, there are various factors that cause jaundice. Ayurvedic medicine for jaundice is very famous. The most common factor, gets cured naturally without any intervention as the liver cures itself. But there are also other factors which may lead to death if not treated properly. Unfortunately, I had jaundice when I was a kid and got treated with ayurveda. But it was not the serious type so got lucky there
He didn't die of jaundice....he died of Ayurveda
@@goku007krish ooh I forgot it affects liver
@@sai_69 umm did they give him poison
The barking dogs never bites
There was also a start up where the two girls could do tricks with their "brain waves training"
i saw it,,it was just a trick that magicians use ..
I don't understand why people are getting so defensive about Ayurveda. If you guys can calm down and re watch the video, all he is doing is just discrediting the tridosha model. He is in no way saying that the actual Ayurveda treatment is bullshit. The Ayurveda medicines(not all) are actually beneficial in most cases everyone knows that.
Vat Pitta Kapha might be hypothetical but they are
You can experience it
These are just the names given to them
I respect all medical science we need all
Sahi kaha
What is 'actual Ayurveda treatment' ?? It's all rubbish frankly.
@@saintpixie2765 sahi bola
How paradoxical ur statement us ayurveda medicines are created based on tridosha method,which you are striking off.
Although people seem to tag ayurveda with pseudoscience,i myself have benefited greatly from traditional medicine having roots in ayurveda.
so much hate in the comment session..even i am also benefitted from ayurveda..
Me too
I also
Me too but still many theories in ayurveda is BS
And Please Pay Attention!!
He said advices in ayurveda is still good for your body but theories aren't
You need to understand that he's not criticising the ingredients or medicine per say that cured you or anyone. He is criticising the tridosha model on which ayurveda works. To understand his views better you can watch one of his older video on the topic.
This channel is my little bundle of joy. I feel happy everytime I remember that this channel exists.
Thanks man!
How did you fit that picture there, man?😄 It looks novel
@@Xavier.............. he is a memeber
2 of the charlatans are wearing glasses!
Couldn't they fix their dosas instead ?
This could be the failure of that particular app & not Ayurved. Before judging anything from your perspective have a deep knowledge about Ayurved.
That pitch sounded so much like our good old fittuber's video on youtube
This Ayurveda pitch kinda seems like Medical Astrology.
I still wonder what the hell they mean by 'Western medicine' ?
The same medicine (Dolo-650) he takes if he feels uneasy instead of Ayurvedic medicine 🤣🤣
And now the same sony tv is mocking that chip in ₹2000 note🤣
The most famous defense of Ayurveda , "but it's 2000 years old" is laughable. That's like saying Rotary dial phones are better than an iPhone 13 because they are older 🤦♂.
Modern medicine wasn't created out of thin air 50 years ago, it's a result of rigorous experimentation, continuous research, a well defined, self-critical scientific process over many many years combined with skeptical analysis of every finding to prevent biases from creeping in and an attitude to evolve things further. It became superior in the last few decaded thanks to nuclear technologies and computing.
Ayurveda on the other hand is like "oonga boonga book says drink snake oil to cure cancer no further questions please". It's scary how easy it is to manipulate people through religion and emotions.
Starts with S rhymes with dam 🤣 😂 Scam! Brilliant!
If you read the history of homeopathy, in 18th century Germany, the creator of homeopathy studied European medicine(based on 5 humoral theory of Hippocrates similar to 5 doshas of Ayurveda), went against it and called all systems of medicine which used opposites of the diseases to cure them ‘allopathy’, and his system which cured using substances similar to disease as ‘homeopathy’. So technically ayurveda,unani,sowa rigpa and other alt med is also ‘allopathy’,
Today, alt med practioners use the word ‘allopathy’ for science based medicine as a derogatory term.
That too only in India. I haven't seen that term used anywhere else
@@scienceisdopeit really shows the popularity of homeopathy and alt med in India, considering the fact that even Indian media uses it.
Considering ministry of AYUSH is funding Western alt meds like unani and homeopathy and rejects the extremely in-depth Australian study on homeopathy for it's 'Western science' centric method is first class bs.
@@scienceisdope you could make a CZcams short or a short video on the word allopathy itself considering the usage by medicine deniers and 'holistic' practitioners.
@@scienceisdope recently a doctor who works in a liver research and treatment Institute found out liver damage by giloye... The doctor said people have liver damage by using these herbs... And ayush and NMC said the doctor is degrading ayurveda... What's going on in india?...
Epic music can u plz any link of your information
This reminds me of those ear wax removal candles. Not only are these candles dangerous by holding a fire close to your face, hair, and ear, it’s a complete false pseudoscience that many people that are into yoga, new age, “spirituality”, gemstones, psychics, or even some circles of massage enthusiasts fall for.
Back in college, I used to work at a book and massage therapist store/gift shop at a massage therapy massage school in the USA. We sold those candles. Since I worked there are we was able to purchase them really cheap at a whole sale price, I would are a bunch home with me and show people how useless they were by taking one and lighting it, but without placing the other end in an ear, but placed just suspended in the air. When the wax candle burned down close to the end, I’d blow out the fire and cut open what was left of the wax candle, and guess what the wax candle had “ear wax” on the inside, just the same as if it was used in an ear.
To the same thing with religions like Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc. Nothing but fairy tails and make believe.
Wow that's dangerous and disgusting kinda
U know nothing Jon snow, there was a case happened to my grandfather who was bedridden,he had a disc problem, we took him to a corporate very reputed hospital in Hyderabad, doctors told they need to do a surgery but can't guarantee normal results, then we opted to kotakkal Arya vaidya sala secunderabad and to our surprise and consistent effort from doctor and patient following strict diet, he is recovered and able to walk with a stick. " IT WAS NO LESS THAN A MIRACLE"
People need to realise what you felt n said. Thank you for sharing it.
@@37-sonaliswain81 The most basic problem with the Indian mindset is they are ok with whatever allopathy offers them whereas they expect to get cured completely by ayurveda for each and every case
No it's not a miracle. Disk problems are known to fix themselves with time. Exercises also help a lot. If the vaidya recommend some yoga asanas, then that might have also helped him. Some practices in Yoga has evidence for it. But that does not mean that Ayurvedic model is scientific. Even some Ayurvedic medicines have been found to be effective. Not because the model is scientific, but because those medicines have centuries of trial and error. But still, it is just superficial. Ironically, Ayurveda apologists accused mordern medicine of focusing on the symptoms, whereas mordern medicine has extremely detailed models about the mechanism of the human body. Disk surgeries are recommended when symptoms persist. Also, maybe you he was getting some medical attention before that which could have contributed. Or maybe, the doctor you went to was trying a cash grab. Or maybe, he himself didn't have scientific temper. Our education system causes lack of scientific temper. This not only makes people fall for pseudoscience, but also make many doctors themselves commit many mistakes. Then those mistakes make people believe that mordern medicine does not work. Then they are propelled towards pseudoscience. So as you can see, it is a positive feedback loop. So there are several factors. But Ayurveda takes all the credit and we think it is a miracle just because we don't understand it. This is why we should anecdotal evidence is extremely unreliable and We should always look into it and should not appeal to ignorance.
@@tarunkrishna4074 I can say the converse as well. People nitpick everything in mordern medicine whereas they tend to ignore the inconsistencies in Ayurvedic. They tend to overlook the other factors that might be at play in both the cases. This is over-reductionism, confirmation bias, and appeal to ignorance all in one.
@@instantdominator2121 don't throw words,most immature way to run away from point, the most basic question I ask is what do you know ayurveda before commenting it as psuedo science, how can you come to a conclusion and pass a statement, if valid argument then present, please don't go through dictionary to win over this arguement.
If you have not complete knowledge about one science then you shouldn't criticized about that science like Ayurveda.
Ayurveda is a complete Science which is practicing more than 5000 thousand ago and your father modern science is coming just before 100 years ago.
Ya he said it fantastically ie; " if u disagree come with convincing evidence."😂😂 He is now not ready to reply to those comments who are mentioning the evidence 😂😂. This man has colonial personality disorder. He didn't even heard of 'Sushruta Samhita' let him sit in his science bubble.
Multiverse is an *interpretation* of quantum mechanics (meaning no new theory, same equations) and it's not an "consequence" of string theory.
and string theory is well accepted though..
I don't think so. Elaborate pls.
mathematically it is well accepted... Ashok Sen got Fundamental Physics Prize for opening the path to the realisation that all string theories are different limits of the same underlying theory... obviously this a theory only (with good maths)... experimentally nothing done yet ..like most of Quantum mechanics, Quantum Information or foundation.
@@manasbhattacherjee92 no man it isn't scientifically approved theory
@@timepassscript pls elaborate
Dude. The most important question is that your charger is a concoction of fire and wind. Don’t even think of plugging that in anywhere.
I have my pov on this 5 elements. Let me explain with one example:
"My neighbour had invited me in their function."
What sense does it make?
Ans - My neighbour had organised a party or something like gathering of people and had invited me too.
But as per maths and science the meaning of "function" is completely different from the "function" mentioned above in the example.
Similarly, in case when we say our body is made up of 5 elements which are fire, water, earth, air and ether then at this time we are pointing to the literal meaning (for example may be fire means anger) rather than the exact meaning of these 5 elements. Even we also know this non of these 5 things are elements as per definition of element in Moder science.
Conclusion: Ayurved model of 5 elements have there own meaning and explanation in different context rather then there actual meaning as per Modern science.
Well said
@J Keshari if a friend invites someone to a function, it doesn't mean he arranged everything for the function. It is our assumption(not a proven fact) that he must have made all arrangements and invited me along with a few others. Sometimes it so happens that when we arrive at a function/party no arrangements are done and we will have to take part in arrangements too coz it's a friend's occasion.
You mentioned that fire element mentioned in Ayurveda need not be actual fire and it may represent something. This is exactly what the admin is saying. To talk with proofs not with "may be", "can be", "I guess", "as we all know", "it's is mentioned by Rishis(sages)"- (which rishi? Where did he say? Where is it written? Is it a reliable source?) Or "per our tradition", etc etc. Science always need proofs. If you don't care about proofs and you want to believe just because they mentioned the word "Ayurveda" then it's fine, it's up to you. We don't know if they are just using the word Ayurveda to make money by making false statements.
Because it is very easy in India to fool Indians by using words like Religion, Ayurveda, Tradition, Sanatan Dharma, 5000 year old history etc etc.
All the admin is trying to say is verify before you spend money. It's ok if you don't agree with me n want to believe a random person who talked about Ayurveda. It's totally upto people.
@@itsme-wn7gr Just a small response to your comment. The name of the rishis are Charaka & Sushruta. And the concepts are documented in Charaka Samhita & Sushruta Samhita.
I really like the way people question but there are ways to find answers also. I am not saying that every ancient concept are correct and errorless. But rejecting everything, by labeling it as pseudoscience is also not very acceptable.
@@TrishitBera I agree not everything is a pseudoscience. So what exactly was documented in Charaka Samhita & Sushruta Samhita? I hope that's been proved to be corrected with evidence. If it is proved then no one can question it's authenticity.
@@itsme-wn7gr well its surgical procedures and instruments or its designs are being used right now in modern medical sciences surgical procedures like nose job surgical babies surgeries on skull all the methods have been proven right and evidence like a skull with surgery has also been found
The medications of herbs and shrubs has mostly been lost thanks to Bakhityarr khilji for burning Nalanda university whats left with us less than ¼ of the knowledge most herbs names are in sanskrit without any images so it creates more difficulty
I just wanted to know what is your take on Ayurvedic medicine or treatment. I also thought this are narratives even taunt on effectiveness, the medicines are so costly but it really worked for a neighbour who was almost paralysed now she can walk atleast. I think we should not have a hard opinion.
He won't reply to this... Dont worry
That's the thing, asking for proof calling it a pseudoscience and all of that is fine but how do people counter the fact that it freaking works!? It's worked very well for me too!
@@amanthakur2264 he would have, if that was some western medicine
@@mmmmmm.6199 my mother had issues with sinuses and what happened was, she took medicine from ayurveda before and they said its like asthama and the medicines didn't work. So we deciced to goto actual doctors for diagnosis and they showed us that its actually sinus blockage not asma. So my mom took that report to ayurvedic doctor and they gave some kadha for it and some medicines and my mom was fine. So yeah sometimes it does work but the thing is it isn't the most relaible thing, if u take modern medicine you can rely on it (as of now) but yeah sometimes ayurveda does work(to what I've seen)(depens on case)
Ayurveda is not really reliable
Lmao i salute this man ,he's literally against pseudoscience in the society filled with false narratives and pseudoscience Babas and gurus , keep it up mate good job earned and sub ,and science is DOPE for real
pseudoscience is more dangerous than hocus-pocus..
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Haha, I can see babas all around the globe,
Halaallluya
@@raghavsvlogs Thank you ❤️ 20th century kids will never get it
Because it actually is my friend.
Guys congrats, we found a PCMB student
Very well explained Pranav 👍
Thank you!
I think the panchabhuta reference is made like this:
1) water - blood
2) soil - flesh of body
3) air - space for air passage ( lungs)
4) fire - the HCL
5) atmosphere - Skin in reference to the blanket of air covering earth
Aree wow ya, metaphor se hi heal hojao phir
@@tapz110 Mene thori bola he ki heal hojayenge, mein khud ayurveda mein nei mantha, sirf itna bola hei ki shayad vo log te kehna chahte hein
czcams.com/video/b88KyJ2Kifs/video.html
@@dharanikrishna257 lot of liberal interpretation of doshas is used as excuse for justifying ayurveda. Don’t give them more ideas.
Wrong interpretation. Water - is not only blood. Actually blood is fire + water.
Soil is not prithvi. You can compare it with solid substance.
Air is not just space. Its a medium through which sound is heard. Fire is not just hcl, its entire digestive fire and digestive juices. There is no such thing as atmosphere. Its Akasha mahabhuta. Its more like vaccum in space
Which is responsible for pressure in eye.
Also he needs to ask these question to Govt of India ministry of ayush and likely get all his queries and doubts answered by govt advisers rather than promote misleading info in public domain about your heritage which the whole world is proud off
आप modern science पे ही चलो जब तक पृथ्वी का विनाश नही हो जाता
Pov: this app is really designed to test the health condition of your charger .
😂😂
Bro it's been 18 days since last video......
Been working on something... Still not done
I loved the fact that vineeta backed out and didn't invest, even though she didn't question their claims, it was a bold move and we need more people with influence to call pseudoscience out
She also called out Namhya and other ayurvedic bullshit
@@kumaraayush ikr, she was courageous enough!
She the logical one, even ashneer wasn't buying the pseudoscience
ya but only representative of pharma sector Namita Thapar said she is a great believer in Ayurveda
@@rohitpatil6425 she doesn't have a background in science, shez a business person who license drugs from West and manufacture them. There would be sure doctors and scientists in emcure who'd be banging their heads after hearing her
in part 2 ask the people about evidence of God's existence also😂😂😂
You are the hero India deserves and the one it needs right now.
Thank you!! Means a lot!
@@scienceisdope Huge fan of your work man.
lol
Why India ?
I really appreciate your efforts. But it's common sense that these things showed are false. See, people who believe in Ayurveda, you can't make them turn against Ayurveda.
It’s not about turning anyone against anyone he is just stating facts
Good to see some people using brain and not falling for big titles
As always it was informative and entertaining video
Plz make video on ham product startup and nabhi shaper
Actually my own grandmothers psoriasis was completely cured using only Ayurveda as allopathic doesn't suit her. So, I won't agree it is pseudoscience as I have seen its effect with my own eyes.
Only your perception changed nothing else
@@samiahmed7056
Meaning?
@@samiahmed7056 have you tried ayurveda ?
@@swatisatpute6435 hahaha
No meaning..he wanted to just blab something & he did it. Side effects of too much of Science "DOPING", I guess😂😂
I was cured too. I had used many allopathic medicines but the problem turned worse. I agree that there are some fake people who sell ayurveda medicines. So there must be one standard certification that used to find out genuine doctors. And also there are many foreigners who come and benefit. Medical tourism.
It takes huge research to decode these Pseudo science Scams Common in India...
Great Content...Ur Making Our India Proud...
Fantastic video mate. These were the exact thoughts that ran through my head while watching the pitch.
I was expecting to watch a commentary on the 'Namhya Presentation' instead I got this. I was disheartened to see sharks supporting the product when the only data the presenter could bring forward was 'word of mouth' and that out of a cohort of a few hundred, some reached out and said it was beneficial for them when in reality, it could be either placebo, mis-report by the participants, Hawthorne Effect or a congruent use of any other allopathic medicine. I hope to see an India where people are able to see through the false narrative of mixing nationalism and Ayurveda but stand true to the immense knowledge that our country is representive of and question the preconceived notions and ask for evidence.
The Sharks supported it bcz they know there is a market for it not necessarily bcz they believe in it.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 I sure remember Vineeta said it is not possible. Aman on the other hand is def a believer of pseudoscience and took this Ayurvedic app deal as well.
@@Akhil-gd7lp lol, who hired you for posting such things.. obviously the medical lobby.. thanks for your upfront. But ayurveda wins.
@@AnadiMishraone 'Ayurveda wins' 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@AnadiMishraone what??? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Is this a competition?
If you question Aurveda and Yoga, you will become anti-national.😂
Bro modern science is always changing! If you can't trust something that has no evidence then how can you trust something that keeps changing all the time??
Even modern science plays with hit and trial method. Corona is one game of that.
modern science first create problems and then by providing solutions to the same, they claim themselves better. Even after this much ‘dope science’, average age is decreasing and inventing a new disease every day.
Don’t know, what the future beholds.
Bach gaye to humari medicine kam kar gai, nahi bache to apki immunity kamjor thi.
@@ankitaggarwal3233 😂😂 good one.
@GivemeGainz so u are comparing sciences with water. I really feel sad for ur logic 😂
Science is at child level, and joker like this channel admin pretend to be a scientist just to satisfy his ignorance.. even scientists are collaborating with eastern legends for exploring depth of magical universe.
next video is going to be on "NAMAYA" ayurvedic tea 😂😂🤣🤣. she was literally tell customer feedback is my proof that it workssss🤣🤣
If you really want an evidence you should seek it rather than asking for the same. If you have researched well enough to claim Vata Pitta Kapha concept as a pseudoscience then you should also research about the origin, concept, significance & authenticity of all of them in Ayurvedic texts.
Now let me help you do it. Please refer to the following books :
Ashtang Hridyam
Bhav Prakash Nighanthu
Susurut Samhita
Carak Samhita
Vanaushadhi Nirdeshika.
Please go through all of it, LEARN and then reply here.
Charak samhita puri pseudoscience se bhari hai likha hai bukhar aye sightapatan hai ya kamjori to maas khao gaye ka agar jhooth lag rha ho to khud check kre ek baar
@@sudhanshubharti7666 Bhai, medicinal texts kisi ek religion ke liye nahi hota h. Hinduism mein beef ki sakht manaahi h toh hum usko follow krenge.
Mai aapse disagree nhi kar raha hoon. Agar beef ke fayde h toh pork ke bhi hain.
Isliye ayurvedic texts mein ek conclusion bhi likha gaya hai :
For plant eaters - Earth par aisa koi plant nhi h jisme medicinal properties na ho.
For meat eaters - Hamein aise kisi food ko consume nhi karna chahiye jisme violence involved ho/uss food mein emotions ho.
Ab ye aapke/hamaare upar h ki hum decide kare ki khud ke liye best kya h.
Bohot saari aisi chhezein hain jo modern world mein relevant nhi h aur ab tk hum un sab texts ko 100 percent comprehend ni kar paaye h.
Iska matlab ye bilkul nhi h ki wo pseudoscience h.
Maine UFO bhi dekha aur capture kiya h, aur ghost ke sath ek haunting experience bhi face kiya h.
Pseudoscience ek western चोंचले बाजी है।
@@guptaji_rk pseudoscience kese ek western चोंचले बाजी है kese hai?
@@onlystudy9690 Achha ye bataiye ki pseudoscience hota kya hai?
@@guptaji_rk kisi belief ya practice ko mistakenly keh dena ki wo scientific methods par based hai .
You can't.. Can't deny the science which is still continuing to be studied and bunch of students pursuing Ayurveda as their career.. Before just claiming any science as pseudo science just have some common sense... Don't act childish
They just don't want to accept ayurveda, that's why they are talking about evidence without any research from their perspective
Science and it's rules are simple.
Just prove it and we will take it.
@@athul4416 we are trying our hard on this.. Just the government need to take some initials very strongly about Ayurveda students
You may not accept it but many people in India believe in Ayurveda and they have observed it's benefits too. So it's individual choice and according to me, this pitch is here to stay
Then where are the proper clinical trials and studies conducted? If you have link to any of it please provide it. Ayurvedic treatments done in personal space can be easily flawed.
These people to Pranab be like ye to dhoti khol rha ha🤣🤣🤣
2:04 even though the proof is not there doesn't mean the theory is wrong, even the equations of Srinivasa Ramanujan was hard to understand without his own help.
Sir please do visit SDM INSTITUTE OF AYURVEDA BANGALORE...you will get to see many live evidences..😊...students study around 8 to 10 years just to understand Tridoshas....life is very simple if u see but people make it complex...I have a doubt if ayurveda is really pseudoscience then why is there Sushruta's statue established in foreign medical colleges...u know what is the problem..?..it's own people try to defame it in the name of evidence....even allopathic people suggests Liv52,volini,moov, papaya leaf extracts for dengue patients and many more....u seems to well be educated sir...i hope u see it in a broad aspect...please do experience it....
They want EBM (which probably 50 years old and it will keep changing) to prove Ayurveda which is approx 2000 year old.
he'll ignore it lol
There are also statue of J.J Thomson in MIT, the person who proposed plum pudding model of atom. Acknowledging contribution of these individual when science was in primitive stage doesn't mean that their theory is correct.
@@pburny8830 first see with whom you are comparing...
@@lalkrishna7030 what do you mean ?
What is your views about Namyha in Shark tank?
“There must be some science behind it”
There is science behind everything if there isnt something behind the something that something isnt a something
I was suffered from Jaundice and cured by Ayurveda
So no hate comments against Ayurveda
Sorry
You didn't watch the full video did you
@@abhigyanshrivastava6393 No I leave it
You are right
Did I missed something
Mr. Pranav I respect you. What you are doing is great, no doubt. Your contribution for sure will help in creating a rational society. And you are next level when it comes to pseudoscience. Loved it.
I kindly request you to make a video on how to find authentic sources of information. Coz people generally have the culture of googling and taking up any article without checking its authenticity. They don't know how to find peer reviewed stuffs and so on. That is, art of reading authentic sources is lacking. Actually most of us don't know whom to trust. So please try to address this problem.
This is coming for sure. Im planning a video on how to evaluate scientific papers
@@scienceisdope thanks i also get lost when I am finding authentic sources
@@scienceisdope do a short vid on the creation of the word ‘allopathy’ by the creator of homeopathy Samuel haehmann if you can.
In 18 th century he learned Unani (Ancient Greek medicine) and created homeopathy in place of it.
Also specify that ayurveda,siddha, unani technically come under allopathy by haehmann’s definition.
If you read the history of homeopathy, in 18th century Germany, the creator of homeopathy studied unani(ancient European medicine), went against it and called all systems of medicine which used opposites of the diseases to cure them ‘allopathy’, and his system which cured using substances similar to disease as ‘homeopathy’. So technically ayurveda,unani,sowa rigpa and other alt med is also ‘allopathy’,
Today, alt med practioners use the word ‘allopathy’ for science based medicine as a derogatory term.
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
I respect this video in the comments section we exchanged statements, but I have one question to you brother
Let's consider according to your theory that tri dosha model is farce
Please make a detailed video on tri dosha model prakriti model and explain in detail it's farce rather than drawing parallel from allopathy
Ah knew it was coming.
All medicine has been initially derived from organic source. Some ayurvedic medicines do work. The problem here is how you get about the diagnosis of the illness. Hope people understand this.
Nothing but my respect to you bro. Your videos are getting better with time.. Keeping going maybe one day you will recognised by Richard Dawkins for the award as our Sir Javed Akhtar. Speaking of which I guess he also deserves a video from you.
@@pradyumn2692 well how exactly is he a muslim?
what argument did he use which was contradicting his previous arguments for u to reach this conclusion?
WELL PRANAV DO YOU FOR 1 SEC IN THE 14:55 SEC LONG VEDIO CARED TO EXPLAIN THE SIDE EFFECTS OF YOUR FAVOURITE WESTERN MEDICINE THAT IS TESTED PROPERLY AND REASERCHED TOO?? DID YOU SHARE THE SCREENSHOTS OF THE SIDE EFFECTS THAT WERE CAUSED BY ALMOST 90% OF THE STEROIDS IN MODERN MEDICINE ? DID YOU?? NO BRO YOURE HYPOCRITE !! DID YOU FOR ONCE MENTIONED THAT THE FIRST PLASTIC SURGERY WAS DONE IN INDIA 5000 YEARS AGO ... DID YOU? DO YOU ALSO IGNORE THE FACT AND STUDIES SHOWING YOGA AND ITS BENEFITS THAT ARE SHOWN IN EVERY MODERN STUDY ARE ALSO DERIVED FROM THE SAME AYURVEDIC PRINCIPALS? OF VATA PITA KAPHA? DID YOU>? NO BECAUSE YOURE A LIAR!!! AND IF YOU WANT PROOF KINDLY SEARCH ANY DISEASE AND WRITE AYURVEDIC TREATMENT AND SEE ITS REASEARCH IN
Arree bhai your first half of the sentence gave me hope but second half mein tune Aisa haga hai na ki kya bataun
czcams.com/video/b88KyJ2Kifs/video.html
How a camera can be a fingerprint sensor or body monitor
Beware of copyright claims
You deserve 10 million subscribers
Jab main show dekh raha tha tavi main a notice kiya tha ki bohot sare product aise hain jo claim to bohot kuch karta hain likin koi clinical approval nehi hain
Reminds me of that stupid Kashmiri chai🤣
Kai saare products due diligence me fail ho jaate hai
Hasi ki baat yeh hai aise fudu startup ko itni high valuation pe funding me mil gayi
Bhai, u r amazing. We need youtuber and scientific educators like u in today's world. Just keep it up and dig deeper every issue and just keep representing those with scientific analysis and critical think.. the time has come that everyone is scientific literate at basic level.. amazing.. love these vdos.. 🔥🔥🔥
the problem is that, people synonymise ayurveda with indian medicine. and by extension, with their 'nationalism' and 'patriotism'.
when in actuality, ayurveda or any of the old timey systems were just that, old. Modern medicine was built on that using that, somethings were accepted and their effects amplified because now that we have the scinece for it, we could prove their use. While other stuff was dismissed cause ther wasn't the science proving it.
I disagree with your stance too, although i have yet to watch that video, about ayurveda being psuedoscience. It seems to be just an old medical belief system wherein, even today, the researchers and practitioners, instead of looking forward and making more advancements, tend to take old conclusions and somehow try justifing it with reasearch papers. The conclusion is there, they're just finding evidence for it, when it should be the opposite. If any of that makes sense.
tl;dr; it's old and shouldn't be a way for ya'll to practice your patriotism cause it's old.
czcams.com/video/kwzsiCMMcHk/video.html
That namhya tea founder clearly answered like "anti-science" person saying "log bol rahe hai unko fark pad raha hai" . Shen only said 100 women "said" ,not ready to give data and I was surprised she got deal !!!
i think there is a difference in homeopathy and ayurveda, it works for some, but not for me, good job bro!
@@CAptaincitzen to be honest yeah, it is a placebo because ppl have too much believe in a medicine, and then due to placebo they get fine.
Ironical that CZcams is showing ad of Silva method on this channel
First of all this shark tank video explaining Tridoshas are not appropriate.
Tridoshas do exist like modern physiology and its nothing different. For example function of Praana udaan vyaan samaan Apaan vata mentioned in Samhitas are same that of Sympathetic, Parasympathetic and autonomous nervous system.
Pitta functions are similar to endocrine and enzymatic activites governing metabolism and kapha includes intracellular components which holds the cellular stability and intregity. The nomenclature differs between Ayurvedic and modern physiology and anatomy.
I don't know why do you need a charger to explain that this app is fake anyone with little knowledge would have known that there's no such sensor in your phone that is capable of measuring anything but distance.
When Even the Ramdev goes for modern covid 19 vaccines, u know how much he trusts Ayurveda ..
To iska mtlb yeh nhi whole ayurveda is wrong from this prospective why a dentist go to another dentist for cure dental problems
@@piyushdevnath293 because he can't open his mouth wide and eyes at the same time and work on his teeth with the sharp tools.
@@cecilmessi6972 legendary reply
@@piyushdevnath293 thanks for taking his reply literally instead of understanding the example. You are so smart.
@@piyushdevnath293 a dentist can't look into his own mouth from medical equipments..
But the point here is dentist don't go to a ayurvedic doctor..
Why didn't ramdev went to an ayurvedic doctor but an allopathy one?
Hi, this video is good. Can you please make video on start up Namyha Food that also appeared in Shark tank.
From their webpage:
"Ayurveda explains that the elements earth, air, space, fire, and earth come together in the body into three harmonious pairs called the doshas."
Either they didn't bother proof-reading, or they genuinely think that contradictory statement makes sense.
Are you Indian?
@@AnadiMishraone what would that prove?
You don't know anything about Doshas. 😂 They are not to be removed but balanced.
Also what those people were doing isn't at all ayerveda. They are just using it's name to make money.
@@professorelixir3351 I doubt you know anything either, if you're still buying into that pseudoscience - which makes you no better than these charlatans. But ramble on your insanity.
People should not mistake this .. the people who came for pitching they are neither Ayurvedic physician nor studied Ayurveda in detail, in fact they are engineers who just wanted to do business with the name Ayurveda ..they came up with this idea only after some months of learning . So if u really want to know about this science u should have some words with an Ayurvedic physician who practice actual Ayurveda. Not the self proclaimed gurus and baba .. please don’t misjudged Ayurveda 🙏🏻
I'm still not getting what's that word
Starts with S and ends with rhyming of dam🤔💭
Scam
@@amey409 thank you
I feel very stupid now 😂
Nice brother. Destroy pseudoscience in every religion.
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing .
JAY AYURVEDA
Undeserving people are always unsuccessful
Unsuccessful people are always oversmart
Pseudoscience toh bohot bikta hai lala
Modern medicine also has its share of issues. For example, see the opioid crisis in USA. Science is indeed dope but large corporations (with vested interests) have influenced the outcome of scientific study, in order to do what is beneficial for them.
true
Science IS dope! AF! Pseudo science is a joke, however.
Kudos. Is it just me or did you increase your talking pace? 🤔 Dr. Abby Phillips will be happy to see this video
It's not your and their fault because you and these people didn't have any Ayurvedic background !! I must say each and every wordings of Ayurveda is scientific !! I never favour these guys nor any patanjali like brands !! True Ayurveda is very far away what you and these people know !! As you only say about tridosha and panchmahabhuta !!you only know vata represent Vayu mahabhoot ; kaph represent earth and water ; and pitta represent fire !! But you don't know that three dosha also devided in 5 subdivisions and along with that sapta dhatus and mala and upadhatus, Rasa, guna, virya, vipaak and prabhav and there panchmahabhuta combinations also there !! You should learn that !! And only learn these things from an internet is not valid and genuine !! Because it gives you only superficial knowledge !! If you really want to learn what is Ayurveda you have to understand the philosophy, padarth vijnana as from the classical texts of Ayurveda itself !!
And your question is there is a only one protocol if jaundice pt. Came and we treat everyone with same parameter is totally wrong !! Because in Ayurveda everyone is different "purusham purusham vikshya" if you come to my opd with same complaints that your cousin came to me earlier I have to decide your prakriti first and then I have to select medicine!!
And in our science there are different chpt. For diagnosis for Jaundice named as Pandu Kamala and halimak !! And the lakshana and types of each of them also vary !!
And Ayurveda is not only just Nadi pareeksha there are 10 types of examinations criteria in Ayurveda in which one is naadi pareeksha !!
I must say if you don't have a background and knowledge regarding anything you don't have a right to defame the whole science !! I also say that no machine will give you such parameter !! You have to analyse each and every pt. By your own !!
I don't want to say but what you tell about normal blood pressure which sometimes ranges 120/80 and now 140/90 mm of Hg .
If USG. And endoscopy reports are WNL then other pathy say pt. It is an Idiopathic. And finally treat. These pt. with sedatives and one day pt. will die.
At that time you need our concept which is totally scientific !!
And if you visit any Skilled and well versed Vaidhya if you go to his clinic with only one presenting complaint but you have some more complaints also you will be treated with all the complaints together and you will get total benefit this is the beuty of Ayurveda !!
Your question is toxicity of Metals answer is every metal has a proper shodhan (purification) procedure and in our text there is Bhasma pareeksha mentioned if Bhasma is not properly made then it can't fulfill the criteria of bhasma pareeksha !! Still I don't support the commercial companies who made there profits in name of Ayurveda !!
Your question is Ayurveda treats pt. Slowly it is your lack of knowledge in Ayurveda Shodan chikitsa and shaman chikitsa is there ! It is based on Ayurvedic practitioner what he uses in his practice !!
So, I must say that if you don't know anything about Ayurveda you don't have any right to say anything against Ayurveda !!
You are commenting on Ayurveda by just seeing this video. That's not good. I have used this app on different people and the people agree with the results
I think this guy should be banned from posting any videos about his country of origin and it’s culture and sent to a country who will believe his nonsense ideology
He is surely an atheist as well .
Modern medical science is only 200 yrs old and he makes you think people were simply idiots prior to those 200 years as there was no evidence based stuff prior to that