Baby Reindeer producer says Fiona Harvey is a convicted stalker

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 05. 2024
  • UK parliament debate, May 2024 full video czcams.com/users/liverHQaf3Jj0uI
    #BabyReindeer #FionaHarvey #RichardGadd #PiersMorgan
    Fiona Harvey emails to Labour leader Keir Starmer • Baby Reindeer Fiona Ha...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 426

  • @cwbrooks5329
    @cwbrooks5329 Před 21 dnem +481

    If this was the story of a middle-aged MAN, stalking a young woman, we'd be asking why he isn't in prison and how can we get tougher laws.

    • @niva-vm3vy
      @niva-vm3vy Před 21 dnem +29

      Even if it's a male stalker, we don't have tough laws in this cases.

    • @cwbrooks5329
      @cwbrooks5329 Před 21 dnem +14

      @@niva-vm3vy I still don't hear/read anything about anyone saying she should have been punished. If she were a man, people would have been outraged.

    • @tobiasart8701
      @tobiasart8701 Před 21 dnem +16

      Yes because a man is more of a threat in general. Are we going to pretend its not the case or?

    • @Devi_Seona
      @Devi_Seona Před 21 dnem +13

      We are all asking why she isn’t in prison actually……
      Men do those kind of things all the time in case you didn’t know.

    • @kerrinjameson6965
      @kerrinjameson6965 Před 21 dnem

      ​@@tobiasart8701 That's utter rubbish. Women can 100% be more of a threat. Some are worse than men.

  • @simonac.926
    @simonac.926 Před 22 dny +408

    if the man were the perpetrator we wouldn’t be having this conversation

    • @69op2gg1005ify0m
      @69op2gg1005ify0m Před 21 dnem +4

      very good point

    • @willowlidstone7899
      @willowlidstone7899 Před 21 dnem +22

      Of course we wouldn't, because sexual assault and stalking by men is pretty common.

    • @you_are_welcome97
      @you_are_welcome97 Před 21 dnem +11

      literally the double standards, if it was a man there would have been no Piers Morgan interview

    • @NineandVine
      @NineandVine Před 21 dnem +8

      This should be in all CAPS!!! Everyone needs to know they have HUMAN rights too and a stalker is a stalker!

    • @MrMacbridemax
      @MrMacbridemax Před 21 dnem

      Doesn't mean we shouldn't

  • @cisnerosjerez
    @cisnerosjerez Před 22 dny +178

    This is bullshite.
    Sent from iphon

  • @sandytw5229
    @sandytw5229 Před 22 dny +175

    she outed herself, if it was Male on Woman, none of this convo would be going on….

    • @Devi_Seona
      @Devi_Seona Před 21 dnem

      What are you saying exactly? Are men and women the same?

    • @solosoyuna7784
      @solosoyuna7784 Před 21 dnem +3

      She's saying sadly this happens to women all the time but it takes a man telling the same story for an actual discussion about it

    • @LYFE_OF_PI
      @LYFE_OF_PI Před 12 dny

      You're worried about whether it is male or not and not the guy who turned him out. Also if my memory serves me correctly didn't he go over there and screw her?

    • @rachellee2515
      @rachellee2515 Před 9 dny

      I dont understand, unless i misunderstood something, didnt internet users find her within days because Netflix had her tweets verbatim in the tv series? and of course, its common for males to stalk females - sorry for the sterotype my male friends - Its not that common the other way and thats why it exploded!

    • @LYFE_OF_PI
      @LYFE_OF_PI Před 9 dny

      @@rachellee2515 yes, she stated that they were harassing her and sending her death threats.

  • @mortonheadhunter5695
    @mortonheadhunter5695 Před 21 dnem +130

    Forget Fiona Harvey we need to know who ‘Derrien’ is ffs

    • @deadeyes4626
      @deadeyes4626 Před 21 dnem +8

      Sam Bain

    • @psalmthyme8192
      @psalmthyme8192 Před 21 dnem +2

      @@deadeyes4626I googled him he’s the right age or around that age…and comedy writer… where did you hear this?

    • @DraGon-ge6po
      @DraGon-ge6po Před 21 dnem +4

      ​@@deadeyes4626 similar looking to the character.

    • @Wendy-df5lb
      @Wendy-df5lb Před 21 dnem +3

      there are some hints in the show some reddit users discovered. not only the similar looking.

    • @cyndigooch1162
      @cyndigooch1162 Před 21 dnem +2

      I totally agree with you and I don't agree with Fiona Harvey's behaviour, especially having endured stalking a few times myself, BUT the alleged (it's best to use that word in my country) r*pes are MUCH worse crimes!
      I'm pleased to know that some people are focusing on those horrendous incidents, instead of the stalking issue. 🙁

  • @BrittPearceWatches
    @BrittPearceWatches Před 22 dny +116

    I actually don't see the problem here. If they did this documentary style - they'd likely use names. Like the Tinder Swindler. They anonymised everyone in Baby Reindeer. 99% of people couldn't be bothered to try to figure out who these people are - I certainly couldn't. Gadd made a thoughtful, artistic piece to heal. Then Fiona comes out saying it is about her (Despite "not watching the show"). To me, my big take away from the show was how complex humans are - how victims return to their abusers - and how things aren't black and white. I thought it was healing and thoughtful.
    Fiona for some reason thinks she should be financially compensated for this show? Which is odd lol. "I committed a crime against you. You've made art about it. Now compensate me" lol - get WRECKED.But clearly a lady that needs some help - needs to stop stalking people.
    I do find it weird that people are saying it was easy to find her identity - but they can't seem to find these police records? That Netflix says exist. So it'll be interesting to see how this all comes out in the end.

    • @michaelfierman3256
      @michaelfierman3256 Před 21 dnem

      Hey Britt ! Totally agree and so cool to see you in a different corner of CZcams! Wearing my 925 today! 💕

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem +5

      Respectfully, and this isn't a defence of Fiona Harvey who to my mind is more than likely guilty of some level of inappropriate behaviour towards Gadd, you're defeating your own point by stating that on one hand it's weird how there has been no one in the multiple weeks able to prove this woman is a 'convicted stalker' as stated but at the same time pouring scorn on her attempts to be compensated and telling her to get wrecked.
      If she isn't how can you then take any of the rest of the content at face value? The 40k emails, the 750+ tweets, the hours of voicemail, the assault on his gf, the harassment of his parents, the sexual assault beside the canal? Are we just to accept that these are all true despite them being caught out in the lie of her being a convicted stalker?
      Gadd himself has admitted that is not the case yet here we have a netfllix exec stating under oath that she is. Huge issues that need to be addressed.

    • @jtam222
      @jtam222 Před 21 dnem

      Gringa!

    • @skipinkoreaable
      @skipinkoreaable Před 21 dnem

      You're the last person I expected to see here in the comments. Love your channel. OK. That was the knee-jerk reaction. Now it's time to actually read your comment...

    • @skipinkoreaable
      @skipinkoreaable Před 21 dnem

      I guess the truth about the police records will come out. She seems like a total weirdo, but it'll be interesting to see whether or not she does actually have any convictions. I wouldn't trust Netflix to be truthful. They are behind Meghan Markle and her husband's documentary and another one saying Amber Heard was not a domestic abuser (yeah, I lost way too many hours binge-watching that trial... That relationship was the best drama since Shakespeare, but to anyone who followed the trial the idea that she was some kind of innocent victim is pretty absurd). Netflix just don't seem to care about the truth very much.

  • @keepingitreal618
    @keepingitreal618 Před 22 dny +103

    Stalking against men ignored by most. IF she indeed is a convicted stalker then cannot see a problem

    • @AERIEDM
      @AERIEDM Před 21 dnem +3

      The fact that she denies any stalking and even being convicted should be investigated and made public.
      Blatantly lying by both Netflix and Fiona, they're as bad as each other.

    • @shoeshoe5253
      @shoeshoe5253 Před 21 dnem

      Well said

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 21 dnem +5

      AN MP yesterday told of his horror after a stalker falsely accused him and his wife of abusing their disabled son.
      Labour's Jimmy Wray and wife Laura were visited by social workers investigating claims they had beaten four-year-old Frankie.
      The couple received death threats after Fiona Harvey, 36, was dismissed from Laura's former law firm.
      Wray, 63, said: "It is upsetting enough for Laura and myself, but for Frankie to be dragged into this was hugely distressing."
      FULL STORY - PAGE 5
      COPYRIGHT 2002 Scottish Daily Record & Sunday

  • @micheletotton9342
    @micheletotton9342 Před 22 dny +144

    Why all this sympathy for this nightmare of a woman who has all but acknowledged she was the stalker! And was before and since, ffs man

    • @intothezombieapocalypse
      @intothezombieapocalypse Před 21 dnem

      its literally because netflix is making some things up even though they are saying its all true. no one is disputing she sent all the messages and emails etc. but the attacking of the family member and her going to court and admitting to it and then going to jail seem to be false. Gadd even admitted he made up the court stuff for the show, even though this video alone the Netflix employee is telling parliament that it is true and did happen lol.

    • @ElanaVital83
      @ElanaVital83 Před 21 dnem

      Because she's a woman, and people are brainwashed to believe women are always helpless victims

    • @SpilledMerlot-bq1jl
      @SpilledMerlot-bq1jl Před 20 dny +1

      Not one comment here shows sympathy for this man's stalker! Not one!!

    • @ElanaVital83
      @ElanaVital83 Před 20 dny

      @@SpilledMerlot-bq1jl OP is talking about the video. Keep up.

    • @micheletotton9342
      @micheletotton9342 Před 20 dny +1

      @@SpilledMerlot-bq1jl The man asking questions above, numerous people of the many discussions online, in fact Piers himself had somewhat sympathetic (in keeping it balanced) moments. I never said commenters on this post per se - not that I owe you an explanation!

  • @taylorstevensonfilmmaker
    @taylorstevensonfilmmaker Před 22 dny +96

    If a man was a convicted abuser and stalker and was found similarly, there would be no cover up for him.

    • @Devi_Seona
      @Devi_Seona Před 21 dnem +10

      There was no cover up, and you have no idea about what you are talking about because you aren’t a girl and you have never been harassed by a man….. you are just saying this out of misogyny but if you looked into the subject you would have seen that it’s impossible to get your stalker arrested, women struggle to have their rap!sts arrested, do you think police is going to do anything for stalker? 3 out of 5 men are abusers, if we could get all the men who abused women in prison, it wouldn’t be much men around.

    • @user-oq7ki4sv5f
      @user-oq7ki4sv5f Před 21 dnem +3

      There was no conviction. You have missed the point here.

    • @smch6416
      @smch6416 Před 21 dnem

      🙌

    • @alternativebassist
      @alternativebassist Před 19 dny

      @@user-oq7ki4sv5fapart from the restraining order, which requires a criminal case in the UK, and her being charged for stalking numerous other people

    • @EatHere
      @EatHere Před 10 dny

      I mean Daren is a man and there is also cover up for him, so…

  • @andalltheangelssay212
    @andalltheangelssay212 Před 21 dnem +39

    Richard Gadd has said from the beginning that the court and prison parts were fictionalised for the show to bring closure to it. There are interviews that can be found online of him clearly saying this. He said that he didn’t bring charges against her but that he took out a restraining order against her. Piers Morgan , the rest of the media and Netflix wouldn’t have had to look very far to find this out, I found it out easily. Richard Gadd is covered as he said parts were fictionalised. Netflix aren’t covered and may end up getting sued a lot of money because they wrote on screen This is a true story. If they had written based on a true story or inspired by a true story they would be covered£, but they didn’t, so they aren’t.

    • @dav147
      @dav147 Před 21 dnem +4

      Thanks, this is the detail I was after and was unsure on.

    • @vegetalover1009
      @vegetalover1009 Před 21 dnem +3

      Doesn’t matter what he said afterwards it should’ve never been in the show if they said “this is a true story”

    • @stephaniedray6627
      @stephaniedray6627 Před 21 dnem +7

      there is disclamer in credit though

    • @skittles12131
      @skittles12131 Před 20 dny +4

      Fargo is also a true story - it says so in the opening credits.

    • @vegetalover1009
      @vegetalover1009 Před 20 dny +2

      @@skittles12131 “they did it too” is not a defense

  • @wellcomematt
    @wellcomematt Před 21 dnem +36

    Karma is a b*tch. When you stalk someone, sometimes your life doesn't go smoothly afterwards.

    • @tamlynn786
      @tamlynn786 Před 20 dny +2

      Yes! She has made several people’s lives a living hell. I have no pity for her.

    • @mjowsey
      @mjowsey Před 20 dny +1

      She's going to be cashing in now. I think she's going to be loving all this attention too

  • @popples50
    @popples50 Před 22 dny +70

    Let us not forget, she is now stalking Neil Sears who wrote the article for the mail online. The same paper she is suing. Plus she is harassing Piers Morgan.

    • @bobbob9619
      @bobbob9619 Před 21 dnem +18

      That’s a lie. Piers said nothing like that happened

    • @popples50
      @popples50 Před 21 dnem +13

      @@bobbob9619 She’s demanding 1 million from her appearance instead of the £250 and if you watch Andy Signore ask Piers the question, Piers is evasive, stumbling. He admitted some forcefulness on her behalf, harassing. In Piers own words “She’s had a few intemperate messages”…

    • @gillianlaing1073
      @gillianlaing1073 Před 21 dnem +4

      I don't think anybody could harass Pierce, heehee! No chance,not true

    • @popples50
      @popples50 Před 21 dnem +3

      @@gillianlaing1073 Of course he can be harassed by her, it is whether he feels harassed. He certainly becomes rattled as he proves that frequently when he is exposed.

    • @gillianlaing1073
      @gillianlaing1073 Před 21 dnem +1

      ​@@popples50 pierce is a very strong character 💪, noway could he be harassed by her he said he felt sorry for her

  • @kayhayes5114
    @kayhayes5114 Před 22 dny +102

    She is not a victim nor do I believe has mental health issues. She chose to confirm her identity and is now monetising it. There is no discussion of duty of care. They never named her. How is it that we are again victim blaming. This was a painfully honest account of what happened to this man I very much doubt he would lie about a conviction

    • @virginia3222
      @virginia3222 Před 22 dny

      You think she doesn’t have mental health issues? She can’t live a normal life, she’s so weird that everyone avoids her. Do you think she acts that way for fun? Only it doesn’t seem like her life is fun.

    • @DAGATHire
      @DAGATHire Před 22 dny

      She most certainly does have mental health issues. She's quite clearly unhinged mate. I agree with the rest of what you are saying, but c'mon now.
      Even the bloody author and real victim, Richard Gadds, has stated at length that she needs help because she's not well in the head. But YOU don't believe it. so it must not be true eh?
      Ridiculous arrogance.

    • @MrMacbridemax
      @MrMacbridemax Před 21 dnem +3

      She wasn't named but it was inevitable that viewers would identify her, as they did. It also seems there is no available evidence she was convicted. They didn't have to make the actress so similar.

    • @kayhayes5114
      @kayhayes5114 Před 21 dnem +11

      @@MrMacbridemax Maybe you should try to put yourself in the place of the victim and then tell me if you would protect your stalker. He made this show to try to explain how complicated things can be for victims of stalking. Seems people care more about out her than they do about him

    • @simsvoiceauditions1
      @simsvoiceauditions1 Před 21 dnem +8

      @@kayhayes5114 It'd be different had this been a man stalking a woman, its disgraceful tbh.

  • @VonMilk
    @VonMilk Před 21 dnem +5

    Crazy this has gone to parliament so quick

  • @johanna3470
    @johanna3470 Před 17 dny +2

    she said hey its me so she asked for it , and im just waiting to see morgan as next victim .

  • @harryhill8543
    @harryhill8543 Před 21 dnem +6

    Apparently she was served with an interim interdict by the courts for a previous stalking case which is probably what he is referring to. This notion however that the show has to be the "truth" is a nonsense anyway. The writers changed the story to make it harder for people to identify her. It was done for her benefit but shes too clueless to understand. She has yet to decide if she is the woman in the show, because she has also denied it, or what if any incidents took place she "agrees" with. She wants to go to court but cant even decide on her version of reality to stick with for a court case.

  • @iamnotfooled
    @iamnotfooled Před 22 dny +11

    I know personally of a male friend who is being stalked by an aggressive nasty woman and he’s quite at his wit’s end

    • @EloquentMess
      @EloquentMess Před 21 dnem +6

      I feel for your friend. I hope he can get this resolved asap. That's scary, and probably ruining his life.

    • @kayligo
      @kayligo Před 20 dny +1

      He needs to gather his evidence and go to the police.

  • @awhi3765
    @awhi3765 Před 21 dnem +24

    A victim has every right to tell their story without concern for the person that victimised them. The real person that Martha is based on is not more relevant than the victim. Any support she requires should come from her healthcare provider not her victim. If it was a woman telling her story would they have this much care for the man? Not even when the woman is lying do they care about the harm the man experiences. Such bs.

  • @RoamingKiwiEU
    @RoamingKiwiEU Před 21 dnem +31

    The UK is falling apart at the seams, and this MP prioritises a Netflix series discussion? Is this this a burning issue for his constituents?

    • @Sarah-J-H
      @Sarah-J-H Před 21 dnem

      @@timchipping”every aspect of our lives” I sincerely hope not 🙏🏼

    • @mast3rchief536
      @mast3rchief536 Před 17 dny

      They know what they’re doing, shame the public think they’re trying their best but are stupid which they aren’t, they like the public divided, frustrated and mentally Ill so they’re preoccupied battling those issues over battling them.

  • @wingv313
    @wingv313 Před 21 dnem +5

    WHY exactly, are we coddling a narcissistic convicted stalker? Producers can’t control what the public will do. She does seem to be enjoying the attention, which is really the goal now isn’t it? 🤨

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem +3

      She isn't a convicted stalker, that's the whole point

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      @LucyStormbringerLastic no offence but have you watched the video? They specifically DO refer to her as a convicted stalker, the rest is just word salad that has nothing to do with my point.
      She is not a convicted stalker. That's what Netflix have described her as as highlighted in this video and have done so without any proof to back it up. That's defamation.
      I think Harvey is clearly guilty of some aspects of inappropriate behaviour related to Gadd and Wray previously but that's completely irrelevant to the point of if she has been defamed.

  • @Lucylastic178
    @Lucylastic178 Před 21 dnem +21

    I know someone that works for Camden council. They claim that their tradespeople allegedly refuse to return to her flat as she’s quite difficult.

    • @marlonthomas8042
      @marlonthomas8042 Před 18 dny +3

      Those damn curtains will not stay hung
      Sorry couldn’t help myself 🤣

  • @lenadiveeva586
    @lenadiveeva586 Před 22 dny +12

    Netflix, we have a problem here

  • @kittykatz3518
    @kittykatz3518 Před 5 dny

    You can petition the Court in the UK to seal your records after you have served time. Same thing in the States. Its entirely at the discretion of the Judge.

  • @user-wy3me5nj5i
    @user-wy3me5nj5i Před 8 dny +1

    Many people forget that Richard Gad was the victim.

  • @stevenm5082
    @stevenm5082 Před 22 dny +23

    The use of the term "Convicted stalker" is legally very worrying if she is not.

    • @noviumthompson6760
      @noviumthompson6760 Před 21 dnem +2

      They must have proof to be Soo confident don’t you think?

    • @stephaniedray6627
      @stephaniedray6627 Před 21 dnem +1

      a staker convicted or not is still a stalker

    • @relaxed7745
      @relaxed7745 Před 20 dny

      ​@@noviumthompson6760 there isn't proof that's why she can sue them

    • @relaxed7745
      @relaxed7745 Před 20 dny +1

      ​@@stephaniedray6627 I can accuse you of stalking. Doesn't mean that you are a stalker

    • @alternativebassist
      @alternativebassist Před 19 dny

      @@relaxed7745there isn’t any proof that you’re aware of…it’s fairly likely Netflix have more information than is publicly known

  • @username_creates6991
    @username_creates6991 Před 21 dnem +2

    I mean… anyone can look up her convictions when offering her a job… so her own life was ruined by her actions. if someone told the truth about her… its not something they wouldn’t soon find out. Tbh I wouldn’t have even thought of looking her up if Pierce Morgan hadn’t brought her on his show… so espentially she’s also defaming herself and all I got from everything is that the actress who played Martha did a FANTASTIC job at portraying the real life person.

  • @shortcircus8769
    @shortcircus8769 Před 21 dnem +4

    All of these are getting out of hand. It seems the internet people are as worse as Martha

  • @WeShallOvercome_
    @WeShallOvercome_ Před 21 dnem +1

    What was the name of the court case, the name of the court, and the prison, please?

  • @tmoleary7179
    @tmoleary7179 Před 21 dnem +8

    Netflix made millions....exploting peoples pain

  • @DanaX09
    @DanaX09 Před 21 dnem +4

    She was found in like 10 seconds, so I call BS on the “protecting the people involved”. While what happened was terrible, it’s also decades ago and according to the Series she was convicted and went to jail. The reason our courts exist is to punish people for a crime. Once that punishment has been applied, their debt to society has been paid. If every crime was a lifetime sentence, why bother having the court system at all?

    • @cyndigooch1162
      @cyndigooch1162 Před 21 dnem +3

      She didn't go to jail at all though and Richard Gadd has stated that some of the show was dramatised, in order to give closure.
      I'm thinking that Piers Morgan could've found out more information before the interview with Fiona Harvey, which I had to stop watching due to his interviewing technique, among other reasons. 🙉

    • @marlonthomas8042
      @marlonthomas8042 Před 18 dny

      Interesting because when I first googled who the real Martha was it brought up a completely different person and that took me a good half an hour to find
      I literally didn’t hear it was this woman until weeks later

  • @michaelbishop9157
    @michaelbishop9157 Před 8 dny +1

    He can tell his story but must tell it 100% truthfully if it's positioned as such. Netflix can't have it both ways and should be held accountable if they didn't check facts

  • @MtATSEL91
    @MtATSEL91 Před 21 dnem +4

    Tiger King, Dahmer, Baby reindeer are all twisted tv shows.

  • @paulsheehan2998
    @paulsheehan2998 Před 22 dny +16

    What she did was wrong, no doubt about it.
    She was exploited, that's not right.

    • @deegralak-roe
      @deegralak-roe Před 22 dny +14

      Don't you think she deserves to be exposed and she also needs professional psychiatric help?
      Also, Netflix and Richard Gadd didn't disclose her identity, people did.
      Being a victim of a very nasty stalker myself I feel very sorry for the real victim here, Richard Gadd.

    • @badfairy9554
      @badfairy9554 Před 21 dnem +6

      Her going on TV will not help.

    • @intuitivediane
      @intuitivediane Před 21 dnem +5

      She was a stalker. Why should she get a free pass.

    • @paulsheehan2998
      @paulsheehan2998 Před 21 dnem

      @@deegralak-roe
      Help, Yes
      'Exposed', No
      It's not as though she got away with it, she's served a prison sentence.
      She does though obviously need help, she's clearly not well.

    • @paulsheehan2998
      @paulsheehan2998 Před 21 dnem

      @@intuitivediane
      Free pass? She's been to prison.
      It's clear she's not in sound mind.

  • @briarrose29
    @briarrose29 Před 17 dny +5

    What is overlooked is that Donnie Dunn’s character admitted to leading her on because he was lonely and liked having her as an audience. Not many women react that way toward a male stalker.

  • @talltrees358
    @talltrees358 Před 21 dnem +1

    It tears apart your feeling of saftey and so many other pieces that make us a normal grounded human being.Stalkers need to have harsher penalties imposed.The damage it does to the person being stalked is unrectifiable.

  • @sophsweet
    @sophsweet Před 18 dny +1

    I. believe everything points to 'Martha' wanting to be identified after Netflix for the very reason of stirring up problems for Netflix and Gadd and to make money. All her speech and actions are pointed at coming out after the series (not the Ed show) and to claim she has been erroneously used in order to get money.

  • @chareltrihart3424
    @chareltrihart3424 Před 21 dnem +10

    I feel this is such a double standard. If it were a man stalking a woman, certainly the man stalker would get away with it. They wouldn’t even believe the woman.

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 21 dnem +2

      They would say "false allegations; innocent until proven guilty; show us proof". This woman, however, in the eyes of many, already is "Martha".

    • @cyndigooch1162
      @cyndigooch1162 Před 21 dnem +1

      That's exactly right and can attest to it since I've experienced stalking a few times myself, including in regard to dangerous ex-neighbours!
      I don't have time to go into the details now though and it's probably best if I don't anyway. 🙁

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 21 dnem

      AN MP yesterday told of his horror after a stalker falsely accused him and his wife of abusing their disabled son.
      Labour's Jimmy Wray and wife Laura were visited by social workers investigating claims they had beaten four-year-old Frankie.
      The couple received death threats after Fiona Harvey, 36, was dismissed from Laura's former law firm.
      Wray, 63, said: "It is upsetting enough for Laura and myself, but for Frankie to be dragged into this was hugely distressing."
      FULL STORY - PAGE 5
      COPYRIGHT 2002 Scottish Daily Record & Sunday

    • @relaxed7745
      @relaxed7745 Před 20 dny +1

      ​@@mobwatch8119not true. Allegations alone have ruined a lot of people's life's (where it's proven or not)

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 19 dny +1

      @@relaxed7745 Agreed - but caution should apply to both sexes equally. What are the claims made in this series if not allegations mixed with fiction (with no clarification made as to what is fictional)? Do you see people worrying about it? When a woman is accused of something, you get "body language analysis" content, somehow always determining that she's lying.

  • @Symbolsysteme
    @Symbolsysteme Před 21 dnem +10

    Why don't they just present the evidence to the public that she is a convicted stalker...?

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 21 dnem +2

      I'm confused as it was confirmed by Piers Morgan that she didn't have any criminal convictions. The matter was looked into.

    • @BrickBasherUK
      @BrickBasherUK Před 21 dnem +4

      ​@@mobwatch8119No I don't think it has been confirmed either way by Piers Morgan

    • @Symbolsysteme
      @Symbolsysteme Před 21 dnem

      @@mobwatch8119 I am talking about Netflix and even Richard Gadd. It would be very easy for Netflix to show the evidence of her conviction to the public - if they have evidence of course.

    • @Symbolsysteme
      @Symbolsysteme Před 21 dnem +2

      @@BrickBasherUK Piers said they couldn't find any evidence by now.

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 21 dnem +1

      @@BrickBasherUK He definitely said no information had been found, which should be easy.

  • @Kaytemplerose
    @Kaytemplerose Před 22 dny +8

    Ok, which is it? Is she a convicted stalker or not? Because Richard’s now saying she isn’t

    • @andalltheangelssay212
      @andalltheangelssay212 Před 21 dnem

      Richard Gadd has said from the beginning that the court and prison part are fictionalised to give closure. He said that he didn’t make any charges against her but he did take out a restraining order against her .

    • @gillianlaing1073
      @gillianlaing1073 Před 21 dnem +4

      She said she wasn't convicted,& he says he wouldn't put her through that,so it looks like it's made up

    • @gillianlaing1073
      @gillianlaing1073 Před 21 dnem +4

      You know what,if she says she's not been to jailor been convicted, then why is Netflix saying its a true story 🤔 she's gonna sue them,so I hope they checked all the facts before saying its a true story

    • @intuitivediane
      @intuitivediane Před 21 dnem +2

      @@gillianlaing1073yes I saw an interview about this to.

    • @Grammarlings-cf8yw
      @Grammarlings-cf8yw Před 21 dnem +3

      @@gillianlaing1073 because it's not a documentary - adults usually understand that stories are changed when they're made into fiction which is what this is - STILL I don't understand why on earth they didn't say: 'based on a true story' which is the usual phraseology

  • @pamelaerff1852
    @pamelaerff1852 Před 6 dny +1

    No I think it was evident to anyone with a working brain that this was FICTIONALIZED. She came out on her own. Even if discovered she could've kept her mouth shut not she's exactly as portrayed so it's truly based on a true story

  • @sisterrosetta57
    @sisterrosetta57 Před 21 dnem +2

    Also how funny John Nicholson pretending he gives a damn about women 😅

  • @AM-xe4iq
    @AM-xe4iq Před 21 dnem +1

    This is wild.

  • @stephenwonghongweng4298
    @stephenwonghongweng4298 Před 22 dny +4

    I’m sure they have tons of evidence to that effect

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      If they did have tons of evidence they would have privately briefed it to tame journalists off the record by now, the fact Piers Morgan among others is saying nothing has come to light so far doesn't look good for Netflix.
      We know for a fact she wasn't convicted for either the Laura Wray incident or the Gadd incident from the people directly involved.

  • @cameronthomson4136
    @cameronthomson4136 Před 20 dny

    Is this the full video ?

  • @user-oq7ki4sv5f
    @user-oq7ki4sv5f Před 21 dnem +1

    How is everyone missing the point?
    Where is the conviction?

  • @kingoreo3642
    @kingoreo3642 Před 21 dnem +2

    I recognize that guy from the “Rocco put your tail down” cat video

  • @phurphy
    @phurphy Před 22 dny +12

    The producer looks like Darrien

  • @dannyball9844
    @dannyball9844 Před 22 dny +2

    I think they should have done more to change the comments as that was how people found her. But she also came forward and has lied on interviews

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      Its not illegal to lie in an interview with Piers Morgan, it is illegal to defame someone

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      @LucyStormbringerLastic again, have you watched the video? That's a Netflix uk boss stating under oath that this was a true story and that she is a convicted stalker.
      I've already explained to you in a separate reply how their sloppiness in relation to the tweets used within the show was responsible for her being identified. Her identity was already widely known prior to having her interview, she also received multiple death threats as a consequence.
      If you don't understand defamation laws in the UK or are willing to accept facts then I'm not sure there's anything more I can tell you. Harvey has a King's Counsel advising lawyers relating to her case, multiple people such as Piers Morgan who is very experienced in relation to defamation laws have indicated she has a watertight case. Forgive me but randoms on CZcams channels clinging to 'they put up a disclaimer in the end credits' are as naive as they are thick. No offence.

  • @americanpancakelive
    @americanpancakelive Před 21 dnem +4

    He DID not say the Fiona Muir Harvey was a convicted stalker. He never even mentioned her.

    • @kbbbnnnnnnnnnnn
      @kbbbnnnnnnnnnnn Před 21 dnem +1

      Can't just say it, show proof! No evidence even been arrested!

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      He did say the person responsible was a convicted stalker though and they also allowed tweets posted from Fiona Harvey's twitter account to be used verbatim in the show.
      They then stated proudly during promotion of the show that this is a true story and that actual tweets were used thus allowing her to be identified within hours, they've made a complete arse of it
      Theres not even a question around this, if they can't prove she is a convicted stalker they have clearly defamed her.

    • @americanpancakelive
      @americanpancakelive Před 21 dnem +1

      @@scorpiorising7694 you are assuming that Fiona Harvey is his stalker. She could have had a few exchanges with GADD and he might have lifted some of her personality quirks in writing Baby Reindeer but the real "martha' could be a skinny blond woman. Remember that GADD and Netflix said they basically hid her identity. SO Fiona Harvey could be a scammer trying to earn some money OR she could be mental and think this story is about her (when she was just used as a part of an amalgam of the character)

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem

      @@americanpancakelive What? I suggest you maybe want to do some research before you spout nonsense
      Baby Reindeer contained tweets that were described by Gadd as 'the actual tweets sent by the stalker in real life', they trumpeted this during the promo for the series launching. Those tweets were then used to search for the identity of the stalker and were matched to Fiona Harvey's twitter account and date marked in 2016 when this was said to have taken place. That is how she was identified so quickly after the show aired and her identity then spread like wildfire.
      Back to the drawing board for you......

    • @americanpancakelive
      @americanpancakelive Před 21 dnem

      @@scorpiorising7694 pretty convenient- what we haven't seen are the ipone messages that GAAD received and who sent them. As I said earlier, clearly Fiona sent him tweets but I am sure a lot of people sent him tweets. he was an entertainer with a public twitter account. There has been absolutely no concrete evidence that FH is the "martha" depicted in Baby Reindeer and there is no evidence to suggest that the series was not fictionalized for greater impact. GAAD has already stated that "martha" was not actually convicted in the end. He also didn't break down in front of an audience as depicted in BR, he revealed his trauma in a one man show named Monkey See, Monkey Do. All Films and series that say they are True Stores are always embellished. So back to the drawing board for you...

  • @pw4444
    @pw4444 Před 21 dnem +2

    Although a fan of Baby Raindear, I do feel that Netflix should have used a different actresse to play Martha . No one that has a striking resemblance to the actual stalker.

    • @asbisi
      @asbisi Před 21 dnem +2

      Also, they should not have used RICHARD GADD acting as HIMSELF. I have all kinds of problems with that. It comes across as abuse of her. He has this smirk on his face constantly, I cannot help seeing it as duping delight. I don´t like the dude, I don´t trust him one bit.

    • @cyndigooch1162
      @cyndigooch1162 Před 21 dnem +1

      ​@@asbisiI'm feeling extremely relieved about someone picking up on Richard Gadd's own highly narcissistic behaviour!
      I can attest to what you wrote as well because I used to know a troubled man who led a woman with an intellectual disability on and knew that she had a huge "crush" on him.
      She started stalking him and it has stopped now, but he did admit that knowing that she fancied him was an ego boost and he went to places with her, including her home, so did encourage it. 🙁

    • @asbisi
      @asbisi Před 20 dny

      @@cyndigooch1162 And I am relieved YOU are there. Not many see this.

  • @carolinamarin491
    @carolinamarin491 Před 19 dny +1

    Crazy or not she needs to have some credit 😵‍💫

  • @sisterrosetta57
    @sisterrosetta57 Před 21 dnem +5

    Netflix should just let this blow over. She didn't have to go on Piers Morgan's show. She effectively outed herself and has previous concerning behaviour revealed by a Scottish lawyer.

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 21 dnem +1

      yet no convictions as per the allegation? so clearly she has been defamed

  • @1398go
    @1398go Před 15 dny +1

    He’s the guy from the Zoom with his cat.

  • @vickifunk9429
    @vickifunk9429 Před 21 dnem +1

    he should not have played himself.. by doing so made it extremely easy to find the other parties

  • @Archangel21389
    @Archangel21389 Před 18 dny +1

    At the end of the day Richard is a victim and his stalker was convicted. Why should criminals be protected from the truth especially as a second time offender.

    • @scorpiorising7694
      @scorpiorising7694 Před 18 dny

      She wasn't convicted for the incident in 2002 and she wasn't convicted in relation to her behaviour towards Gadd. Is she the world's worst stalker or world's best lawyer? If she's guilty of all the allegations made against her why has she never went to court let alone jail?
      Or is it more likely that lots of people have been taken in by a story that's been heavily exaggerated and while there was probably inappropriate behaviour took place people are willing to burn anyone at the stake because they're judgemental arseholes? No multiple stalking convictions and jail terms, no sexual assault at a canal, no glass smashed off his head, no assault of his gf, no harassment of his parents, not as much communication as depicted. If that's closer to the truth it doesn't make her behaviour acceptable but it also doesn't make for a Netflix hit series either.

    • @rachellee2515
      @rachellee2515 Před 9 dny

      Sir, with all due respect you might be confusing TV events that were created for enjoyment with the reality of our world.

  • @pamelaerff1852
    @pamelaerff1852 Před 18 dny +1

    No duty of care

  • @kwickeb99
    @kwickeb99 Před 17 dny

    Why do they keep protecting these criminals...

  • @PETAL19
    @PETAL19 Před 21 dnem +1

    Do not like this slimey Netflix exec...and his answers are pathetic

  • @intothezombieapocalypse
    @intothezombieapocalypse Před 21 dnem +2

    wheres the proof of this conviction?? also... Gadd has said they made that part up and he had never reported her soooo. here there be lies lmao

  • @Michelle-wk4ek
    @Michelle-wk4ek Před 21 dnem +4

    Richard was using heavy drugs, so how can anyone take his word for anything remotely truthful.?

  • @tiffanyh1274
    @tiffanyh1274 Před 21 dnem +2

    He doesn’t say she’s a convicted stalker. Clickbait. I never get why creators do this. You instantly lose trust with your audience when they see that you’ve lied. Don’t get it.

  • @MeanEileen916
    @MeanEileen916 Před 18 dny

    Hold stalkers accountable. Stalking is a CRIME!!! Stalkers lie because they know full well what they are doing is WRONG!! They are hoping the public is both sympathetic and gullible.

  • @TruckieLooks4Aliens
    @TruckieLooks4Aliens Před 8 dny

    Amazing how she changed her name

  • @bluj5917
    @bluj5917 Před 20 dny +1

    Did they actually show proof she was convicted??? I haven’t seen one iota of proof that she has.

  • @christiegrows2022
    @christiegrows2022 Před 21 dnem +2

    What about the rapeist???

  • @martinemulholland5012
    @martinemulholland5012 Před 21 dnem +7

    Prove she been convicted of stalking him. Cos if you can't. She gonna take for every penny

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 21 dnem +1

      AN MP yesterday told of his horror after a stalker falsely accused him and his wife of abusing their disabled son.
      Labour's Jimmy Wray and wife Laura were visited by social workers investigating claims they had beaten four-year-old Frankie.
      The couple received death threats after Fiona Harvey, 36, was dismissed from Laura's former law firm.
      Wray, 63, said: "It is upsetting enough for Laura and myself, but for Frankie to be dragged into this was hugely distressing."
      FULL STORY - PAGE 5
      COPYRIGHT 2002 Scottish Daily Record & Sunday

    • @blazedray9903
      @blazedray9903 Před 19 dny

      Who do you trust a stalker or someone who beats their disabled child

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 19 dny +1

      @@blazedray9903 She made it up the child was never abused she lied to get these people into trouble as she had beef with them. She is a dangerous sociopath.

  • @stevenwoodman1032
    @stevenwoodman1032 Před 18 dny

    It is SO great that they made her look and sound exactly like the real woman so Richard would be ok. What a weasel they guy talking is.

  • @jellybaby9630
    @jellybaby9630 Před 9 dny

    It's FICTION. Not Documentary.

  • @booradley0x0
    @booradley0x0 Před 20 dny

    That woman is terrifying

  • @AERIEDM
    @AERIEDM Před 22 dny +13

    It was named 'Baby Reindeer'. A phrase 'Martha' used in the show and a phrase Fiona used. Surely, if you're going to hide the identity of the character you would provide an alternative name for the show?

    • @Moishe555
      @Moishe555 Před 22 dny

      It's a great name though you have to admit. let's think of alternatives for fun though. Cariboo boo, seal pup, baby narwhal, wee lil' duck. Baby Reindeer is one of those things you only get from Hawley Arms banter as Fiona so eloquently refers.

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 21 dnem +2

      They are insulting people's intelligence by claiming they had tried to mask her identity. Using her social media posts and a reference to a specific stuffed toy? Then claiming she "wouldn't be able to recognise herself"? Maybe she did stalk him; who knows. But they're lying about these issues. Dishonesty never looks good.

  • @misskitty4901
    @misskitty4901 Před 21 dnem

    She's a "convicted stalker"??!!! Didn't she deny that she was on the Piers interview?? Woahhh and if she is one, then Fiona has no leg to stand on because then this would actually make it a true story. Since that's what is the major point of discussion

  • @lisajayne71167
    @lisajayne71167 Před 20 dny

    What is this?

  • @MeanEileen916
    @MeanEileen916 Před 18 dny

    I think it is important that we as a society not focus on the gender aspect because it takes away from the fact that stalking is WRONG. HARMFUL, and can be perpetuated by anyone. Baby Reindeer brings the problem to the forefront and I think it’s beneficial that it can be seen from a perspective that brings more attention to stalking being a problem that be experienced from either a male or female.

  • @laurapitmon1253
    @laurapitmon1253 Před 21 dnem +3

    I saw her interview with Pierce Morgan and she's clearly disturbed. She kept contradicting herself which would make one think she's an habitual liar too. Donnie being raped and abused by Derrian was hard to watch. Why would Gadd put such a an intimate and demoralizing action out there for the world to see and make up a story about Martha stocking him. It doesn't make sense. I think there is truth to the story.

  • @pamelaerff1852
    @pamelaerff1852 Před 18 dny

    I loved it perfection

  • @Fussyfarro7
    @Fussyfarro7 Před 22 dny +10

    What is happening to the woman is very very wrong... very ver

  • @angelamarsters9169
    @angelamarsters9169 Před 21 dnem +2

    What I dont understand is if this woman is so concerned about having been identified, why put yourself out in the public forum instead of just going to ground, right ot wrong.

  • @mikekemp9877
    @mikekemp9877 Před 20 dny

    where was the convicted stalker mentioned?

  • @bladeaok
    @bladeaok Před 21 dnem

    don't understand why they keep claiming they attempted to hide anyones real identity, such bullshit

  • @Rubia91562
    @Rubia91562 Před 21 dnem +3

    Netflix exec "says" the Martha character is a convicted stalker in real life, but provides NO PROOF.
    #showreceipts

  • @danh5637
    @danh5637 Před 19 dny

    Well I hope he has the evidence that she went to prison for stalking Gadd otherwise she’s gonna sue you into oblivion.

  • @amirkarim2307
    @amirkarim2307 Před 19 dny

    Select committee MP got ripped apart

  • @melissajay7227
    @melissajay7227 Před 21 dnem

    She committed a crime, she is an adult, nothing to stop her being named and shamed. Why the he'll should Netflix call her and pamper her?!
    Would they call a murderer or burglar and ask them if it's ok to do a programme on them? Would 'Dispatches' or 60 minutes or the like do so?
    This is pathetic, imagine a man doing this to a woman.
    She's the one trying to get £1m for her sob story.
    She's a horrible woman.

    • @kayligo
      @kayligo Před 20 dny

      Innocent until proven guilty, which is why it’s important to file charges. And lying about pressing charges when you didn’t is not ok. They said it’s a true story and it’s not. That’s a problem.

  • @katjaxxx7353
    @katjaxxx7353 Před 21 dnem

    Surprise surprise 😳

  • @misskathleen490
    @misskathleen490 Před 19 dny

    fyi going to jail isnt BEING convicted either. So she has a case.

  • @Iwas20in2000
    @Iwas20in2000 Před 21 dnem

    i find this very confusing. in most interviews they all say she was never convicted but here they say she was ???

  • @keiranward6164
    @keiranward6164 Před 22 dny +1

    Where does he say she IS a convicted stalker I never heard him say that what you say in the title he didn't say SHE Fiona did go to jail and was is a convicted stalker

  • @joseparcenary4706
    @joseparcenary4706 Před 21 dnem +3

    He says the person Martha is based on is a convicted stalker. So he's either refuting reports the character is based on Fiona Harvey or he's accusing Fiona Harvey of being a convicted stalker or he's just lying.

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 21 dnem +1

      AN MP yesterday told of his horror after a stalker falsely accused him and his wife of abusing their disabled son.
      Labour's Jimmy Wray and wife Laura were visited by social workers investigating claims they had beaten four-year-old Frankie.
      The couple received death threats after Fiona Harvey, 36, was dismissed from Laura's former law firm.
      Wray, 63, said: "It is upsetting enough for Laura and myself, but for Frankie to be dragged into this was hugely distressing."
      FULL STORY - PAGE 5
      COPYRIGHT 2002 Scottish Daily Record & Sunday

    • @alternativebassist
      @alternativebassist Před 19 dny

      Harvey has other victims. At least two of whom did get charges against her.

  • @hereiam2942
    @hereiam2942 Před 21 dnem

    This producer is nutts

  • @lesleyboyle7479
    @lesleyboyle7479 Před 21 dnem +2

    Its Richard gadds story but that doesn't mean its the truth.
    This is a very private story.
    Feeling sorry for all involved.

    • @cyndigooch1162
      @cyndigooch1162 Před 21 dnem

      I've heard many counsellors etc on CZcams advise people to stop oversharing, which is right, yet they do it themselves and some even give detailed accounts of their personal lives!
      I'm thinking that Richard Gadd had a right to do the show; however, I do agree that it's extremely personal and a lot of survivors, or anyone, would be traumatised by the content. 😥

  • @mangostripes2335
    @mangostripes2335 Před 8 dny

    I get she’s mentally ill. But we name the stalkers that follow celebrities around and invade their space, even if they are mentally ill too. In this case I think he did her a favour by protecting her identity. As long as he didn’t slander her, which to the best of my knowledge he didn’t (stating the parts that were dramatised and those that are not), then it’s his fair game to use his story of stalking anyway he sees fit.

  • @joeletaxi821
    @joeletaxi821 Před 22 dny +1

    Was she ever convicted? Anyone know?

    • @kathleenj01
      @kathleenj01 Před 21 dnem +1

      Apparently not.

    • @Grammarlings-cf8yw
      @Grammarlings-cf8yw Před 21 dnem

      no evidence has been given either way yet

    • @mobwatch8119
      @mobwatch8119 Před 21 dnem +1

      According to Piers Morgan, she has no criminal convictions.

    • @samuelbarrett9403
      @samuelbarrett9403 Před 21 dnem

      @@mobwatch8119Oh well that’s settled then if that wanker says so!

  • @Lynne9070
    @Lynne9070 Před 18 dny

    Team Richard

  • @gavinmaitland80
    @gavinmaitland80 Před 19 dny

    What IS this?! WHy not explain what it is we are watching???

  • @Dorset_tanker_driver
    @Dorset_tanker_driver Před 21 dnem

    Am I misunderstanding something here or are politicians discussing a TV show? Taxpayer money well spent as usual.

    • @BrickBasherUK
      @BrickBasherUK Před 21 dnem

      I'd rather they do that then piss all my taxes away on 4 star hotels for illegal immigrants

  • @SavannahHybridCubs
    @SavannahHybridCubs Před 17 dny

    Why is it horrific abuse of the stalker all the time rather than the character Darrian? Makes no sense but keep harassing the old lady 👵

  • @tennisace40
    @tennisace40 Před 21 dnem

    Well where is the proof?Show it to me. Where is the court document?….This is incredibly easy.

  • @KateSimpkon
    @KateSimpkon Před 21 dnem +2

    I’m yet to see proof of her convictions, stop all talking about it and show us the proof, if not Netflix need to lawyer up.

    • @unasperanza9803
      @unasperanza9803 Před 21 dnem

      AN MP yesterday told of his horror after a stalker falsely accused him and his wife of abusing their disabled son.
      Labour's Jimmy Wray and wife Laura were visited by social workers investigating claims they had beaten four-year-old Frankie.
      The couple received death threats after Fiona Harvey, 36, was dismissed from Laura's former law firm.
      Wray, 63, said: "It is upsetting enough for Laura and myself, but for Frankie to be dragged into this was hugely distressing."
      FULL STORY - PAGE 5
      COPYRIGHT 2002 Scottish Daily Record & Sunday

  • @kbbbnnnnnnnnnnn
    @kbbbnnnnnnnnnnn Před 21 dnem +6

    No one identified the rapist! She isn't convicted! Show the public her criminal record, as nothing has been found!
    You can't say that without proof!

    • @asbisi
      @asbisi Před 21 dnem +1

      100% agreed!

  • @Kittiesdawn
    @Kittiesdawn Před 20 dny +1

    Click bait!