It's funny, I disagree highly with people who think she didn't put her spin on it. Sure she's not shredding all over it with sweeping and tapping but there is a huge difference in her vibrato. The first thing I noticed about her playing was her forceful vibrato. In order to accent notes in fast music you really gotta get there quick, she seems to have amazing left hand strength for that and you can hear it in how fast she gets to pitch in this song. It's like she's playing it with more like a cross between a Yngwie and Petrucci vibrato than a Gilmour one.
codecow Couldn't agree more. Not only that but look; this is one of the most emotive solos ever created by any musician and I couldn't say why, but it speaks to me and of course many, many others. The funny thing is this young lady's version speaks to me even louder. Perhaps it is simply that phenomenal vibrato. As you say, incredible hand strength for one so young. Now what we really need to hear of course is what she can do with a composition of her own. I'd buy it 'sight unseen'. Or should that be heard?
Yeah, it's great. But it all depends on the style of solo you like. I've heard dozens of great guitar solos, amount hundreds of solos, so it's hard for me to pick out just a few.
AND TO MAKE YOUR POINT GO FURTHIER SHE SOMTIMES AS SHE SMASHES THIS FRAKING BADD AZZ SOLOS SHES NOT EVEN LOOKING AT THE GUTAIR WITCH MAKES IT EVEN MORE IMPRESSIVE
Tina is studying at a University at present in Paris. She has put her youtube activities on hold while she concentrates on her chosen field of study. Sounds like a pretty smart move. I was fortunate when I asked about her wellbeing (the same as everyone else), because a relative of hers replied and filled me in on her activities. The conversation did not get all that deep so I am unaware of Tina's chosen field but I can just pray every night and hope to live long enough to see her, centre stage with a Symphony Orchestra. I pray also, that she's studying Music.
well she stopped 6-7 years ago it must be a dr. she's going for. as far as her playing she is the best as far as dynamics, style and inflections just to name a few. wonder why she's not playing on her time off.
Carry on Girl!!! You don't know how much joy it brings for an old guy like me to hear the new generation carrying with some of the greatest hits of all time...your the BEST!!!!
@@SaGeOwL4891 Of course she practiced, every player that ever lived practices. But she is obviously one of the most gifted guitar players that I've ever seen and she's only 16 or so. Imagine how good she would be in 10 or 20 years if she continues playing.
AutomobileFunk Of course that she plays better than me! When I say the opposite? A woman can't play better than a man? Better than you or me? Course she can. And she do. If you play better than her, prove it!!! I said "better than all of US". This includes you and me. Don't you know how to read? Are you blind? Or you are an rock star and rock on guitar? I don't think so!!! She is amazing. I even play 1% that she plays. And I recognize that without shame. Do you?
AutomobileFunk If I talk something, I need to prove if I be capable to do what I said. Otherwise, I could say that I play better than Slash. Or even David Gilmour. I don't need to prove, right? It's not about my ego. You don't need to do anything, but until there, I won't believe just in your words. I assume that she and many others musicians on CZcams plays much better than me. I'm humble. And enough to waste my precious time with your ego, that is larger than you. Say what you want. Simply I won't believe until I see if it is true.
AutomobileFunk First of all, I already said that I will not argue with you anymore, because it does not compensate. But after this offense with no reason other than the fact that you are hide behind a keyboard, I have one more thing to say: I will not lower myself to your level, if you have one, and offend you. But I will say that, unfortunately, it is not possible to have a civil conversation with people who are arrogant and who think they are better than the others, for no apparent reason. And yet it comes to say that my ego is large. A little more civility when talking to people, okay? In any moment did I offend you. And I will not do it, because it is not worth the waste of words and because my mother gave me something that looks like it lacks: EDUCATION. It does not matter to me if you're better than all the guitarists in the world. I just said that Tina plays a lot better than a lot of people. If you do not think so, I respect. Finishing, I say the following, just to show your point of view: I never give a single shot in my life. If I tell you that I hit with a 9mm, a fly that be 100 yards away, will you just believe me? This is the point. But the innocence and lack of education (offending me gratuitously) are yours. And, say what you want to say, I'm done. I just talk to educated people. Peace and Hugs!
She was only 15 years old when she played and you still call her a little girl. I definitely think it's very arrogant of you to say that you're better than her and if leonard writes original music, he's better than her. Just because you don't write your own songs doesn't mean you're bad at music. Sure, she may have played other people's songs, but she practiced a lot on the difficult songs because they represent a challenge for her to face and encourage her to practice hard and work hard. Hard work is more important than talent. She really will compose original and great music. Just give her some time. Stop being spiteful, egotistical, and demanding and give this excellent young lady some time and respect.
+AutomobileFunk I'd certainly like to see your version of this. Before you say "I DON'T NEED TO PROVE ANYTHING" yes, you do. You've made a claim "NOT THAN ME". I could make the same claim, saying I could play circles around you on an untuned guitar with a cracked neck missing two strings. Time to back it up. Otherwise people might think you are nothing but an internet troll.
God, I hate to keep harping on these transparently jealous negative comments, but I don't suffer fools. Firstly, one comment about learning to bend or apply vibrato like Gilmore takes "years of practice." If it takes you years, you may want to consider taking up the flute, or better yet the kazoo (with all due respect to flute players). or the comment on her cover of either Jason Becker or Gary Moore that she did it by "just looking at tablature." If you truly believe this, you've betrayed your own ignorance. no player at this young an age, with this level of playing ability, accomplished it by cutting corners. I'm willing to wager you could stick the charts of any song she hasn't played, and she'd be able to play it without listening to it first. and to watch this, but complain and focus on her amp/effects settings or guitar of choice is like watching someone turn water into wine, then complaining that the vintage doesn't pair right with the meal. yOu're missing the point.
There are some things i really like about this video... 1) the song itself 2) the tone of the guitar 3) the great playing 4) most important: young people still loving this kind of timeless, great music, learning to play along these decades-old masterpieces
Bloody hell!!!! Only thing wrong with this is it finishes too early. How can there be any thumbs down? Does it really hurt that much to see a young girl play so well?
Truly remarkable, for anyone, much less a young teen. Tina S has no musical limits. I wish Tina every success, in her music and life. Blessings from an admiring 67 y/o Texas cowboy fan.
@@pomardorafa9360 listen, I don't care who this Alex S is. And I won't watch him or her unless u take what u said back. This girl can play well, now get a life
I love CZcams comments. Imagine this at a school concert or something; Tina having firstly the guts to play in front of everyone, playing her heart out and enjoying herself. Then a good number of people standing around going "Meh, She should've done this better. She should've done that better" and it then escalating into a full blown argument about what feeling is and sticking to the original solo too much/not enough and not applauding her and saying "Well done you did great!". No doubt she already has a great teacher to let her know of any places she could improve upon. I could say something like; if you've got nothing nice to say don't say it - but then again the comments section would be an extremely bland place! Not sure what point I've made by the end of that....doh!
I think that this happens when trying to cover a song that is timeless and memorable as this, people expect thing from you, I'm not saying that is ok to give shit to her and not apreciate her work, she does a pretty good job, but a timeless classic is that, and people get attached to it and starts to pay attention to every single detail. That's why I can't stand her perfomance or like her work with this one, my mind is set to experience something else, and the substance of the song or solo is not pour into this, but I can see where you're going with your comment. If people thought a bit before posting we may have better youtube comments, but that's not the case, there's lots of people that speaks out of their ass and make everything less joyfull for the rest.
I'm flabbergasted at the rude comments. I don't care about the technicality of what she's doing. I care about how it makes me feel when she's playing it. If the piece brings me joy, she's done her job. I don't judge her based on any comparisons. I base it on what she gives me. I think she's an amazing musician.
I love all these guys that bitch about how its not the same as the original , its not suppose to be same as the original, its called originality .if your going to play it the same as pink Floyd don't bother posting a vid. ill just put pink Floyd cd in the player and listen.
What a beautiful prodigy child. Flawlessly talented and calmly passionate. Something so uniquely expressive that it really transfers from the rib cage, the soul, the deeper capacity than just what this miniature universe has to offer. Thank you for being capable of reaching a fulfillment that many will never know.
+Rob H. She is only 16 and from her talent I would think she is a bit of a recluse. I'm sure besides all the customs Vigier throws at her their is a hefty salary to boot, not to mention the YT royalties. Her last name is private stock, no verbal interviews yet.
+Rob H. only original artists who write good songs get signed.. who signs kids who play youtube covers that are only 80-90% as good as originals? I mean she's good, technically, but so are thousands of bedroom guitarists.. skill is something everyone can learn if they set their mind to it.
Close your eyes when listening to this. The feel is there, the necessary technique is there, the bends are there, the pinch harmonics are there, even if in slightly different places. I’ve heard this outro 200 different times, and can tell you that Ms. Tina S. grasps it in a most beautiful and honorable way. I’ve played in rock bands for 30 years, and can attest you don’t need a “guitar face” to feel and translate soul and feeling to a solo or riff or rhythm part. Bravura performance.
Please permit me to speak oh great one , I respect and appreciate your take on this. I just happen to disagree, and like that you weren’t snarky or baiting in your commentary. Music is open to interpretation, and I love that it can land differently. Thank you for your comment.
Goosebumps. I want to hate this because I can't play this solo nearly as well as you, but it's just too damn good not to absolutely love. I realised halfway through I was grinning ear to ear, so I wanted to say well done, you absolutely smashed that!
I know everybody feels the same way this solo is never long enough. Such heart and soul. She’s so good that she seems bored. But she’s focused! Well done. I hope she reads her comments.
Watched a lot of covers to this solo. But no one can top Tina. Love the way she knows where to put her pinch harmonics and plays it as similar as possible to the original
Excuse me. Not the same. I respect this player A LOT, but... this interpretation is lightyears below Gilmour's, both in terms of feeling and precision.
She is NOT Gilmour - she is Tina S - therefore she plays her own style - I thought this was excellent. and both you two who commented above are being PICKY.
I don't want to be picky, and further more, I say it again... I respect that guitarist A LOT. But... maybe it's just that not every sound is for every guitarist. Here, as a guitarist myselfI think she tries to play a very slow solo where every note and every sound is very important.... and she gets constant guitar noise, exagerated vibratos, and not too precise attacks. That's why I don't think this specific solo suits her, and to me it sounds more like fighting the guitar, rather than Gilmour's love-making to his guitar. That's all, every1 is free to love that solo, not love it... but never hate it! PS: And I edit it.... this woman has a GREAT bending technique... but it's a fact, as true as the Earth is not flat, that no person ever in this planet, will ever have Gilmour's bending technique. That's fu ck ed up.... but it's the hard truth for all of us! PS 2: I edit again... Tina S plays WAAAAAAAY betther than me, in every level. Just to make it clear, just in case someone would think I say this just to put her down... I don't. She's in a very high level, and she's young enough to exploit it in ways that I hope I will know :)
Must say very impressive no whammy bar needed I remember when this song first came out and it just amazes me that the younger generation still grasps really good music
Love it and everything she does.How can anyone so young be so good. Brings tears to my eyes every time I hear her and I’m 67 and have listened to rock guitarists for over 55 years.
That is one of my favorite songs ever. I had a smile on my face the whole time. Awesome. I wish you wouldn't fade it out, I could listen to you play forever.
A prodigy doesn't just play the notes. Tina S.'s passion and love of music comes oozing out of that guitar affecting the heart & soul with deep & passionate emotions that cannot be conveyed with words. It is a very personal & intimate experience in each and every one of us.
I like how people can criticize a 14 year old girl that plays better than the rest of us, I would like to see her play after a 50 year career like David Guilmour has had. Cheers,
Wow...great tone and vibrato. The thing you notice most is how she attacks the fret board while still having a soulful sound. A real mark of a great player.
I could listen to Tina play all day! Many say she shows no feeling, but I could see it, if you look really close to her heart, and sound of her play. Excellent job Tina! God gave you a fantastic gift and I see 209 people envy you a lot for it! :)
I started the day with You Tube.. Of course with Tina. The first was Comfortably Numb, then one after the other run automatically. It was like a private concert at my house and I enjoyed 46.21 minutes. Great.
i just found this, i'm completely blown away, shivers down my spine, tears in my eyes. this music and the way she plays causes a deep unexplained emotional reaction in me. and shes gone?! no one knows what happened to her!? WTF!!
The technical achievement here is pretty obvious, but what's even more amazing to me is the emotion she manages to convey, especially for such a young player. So many mediocre Gilmour impersonations on CZcams, but this is stunning.
She knows what she is doing. All vibratos are greatly performed with the rest of the string muted with an index finger. That's why you don't hear redundant shitty sounds like when Kirk Hammett or Slash playing any solo. Also, altered a solo a bit by adding pitch harmonics. A great interpretation of the iconic solo.
If I had just been listening to the music and, not watching this video, I would have sworn that David Gilmour was playing this. Wow! Tina S is an incredible talent! Just amazing! Peace, Blessings and Grace to all.
+Alexandre Ouimet I wasnt debating how close the performance was to the original. I said it was good enough for me to subscribe. im just one guy throwing a compliment out there. and telling people who over analyze things, it was good. inless u just dont like pink floyd or guitar
+Seth Hamilton Good and liking it are twoo different things. It is very good. I like it even though it does have a metal flare that I wouldn't usually like in a pink floyd song. But I can certainly understand a Floyd purist not liking this.
PINK FLOYD is my ALL TIME favorite band on this planet and your playing of this song is right up there with David !!!!! I'm used to the sound of a FENDER when it comes to this but the sound you have is fantastic as well !!! Love that color on the guitar !!!!
I have heard countless of great musicians, and I must say, my money is in this young lady...it flows out of her veins and breathes the notes...absolutely breathtaking, for real.
Great cover and great style and great technique. The only thing that i am confused about is why 99 people have took the trouble to dislike it - there is nothing to dislike - and their time would have been better spent practising to reach your level and confidence. I have been playing over 20 years and I teach but I still don't yet have the balls to post my solo covers! Yours is my second favourite cover of that solo - my first is John Petrucci ;)
Heard this genius a while ago, just remembered and searched, Tina you would be so proud if you could see the smile on my face and how happy I now am...... YOUR A TOTAL GENIOUS :) Going to listen again and again, WOW
Holy shit, every time I hear this solo I feel like the guitar is singing for me. There are so many layers of emotion to this solo, and you portrayed them perfectly. Gilmour would be proud. Good job.
J'écoutais ce morceau des pink floyd lorsque j'avais ton âge et j'en ai maintenant 40...j'étais même allé les voir en concert à Versailles je crois ....jouer de la guitare comme tu le fais et surtout à seulement 15 ans est une véritable don....you tube non montre assez souvent des gens talentueux qui maîtrisent assez bien leurs instruments mais la progression avec laquelle tu as su évoluer sur une guitare électrique en à peine 2 ans est incroyable et dépasse tout ce que les amateurs de guitares ont pu voir jusqu'à présent....les morceaux sont tout simplement parfait et le plaisir que tu communiques aux visiteurs avec ces harmoniques, ces arpèges, ces solos sur une guitare est immense....MERCI Je te souhaite vraiment de réussir ta vie dans la musique, tu es sans doute très bien partie pour y arriver... et ces efforts seront un jour payant...j'aurais rêvé plus jeune suivre la même aventure que toi, avec tous ces groupes de rocks et de hard de ma génération, ces guitaristes comme Gary more, van halen, ou Joe satriani... j'avais aussi essayé, comme beaucoup d'autres jeunes, d'apprendre la guitare mais je suis finalement devenue conducteur de train...et ...la guitare est bien loin de moi...lol...(pour la petite anecdote, je revenais d'une permission et je repartais à l'armé, cela durait 10 mois, service obligatoire à l'époque, et en prenant le métro, j'avais oublié ma guitare sur un quai...impensable n'est-ce pas ? c'est pourtant vrai...je n'ai jamais revu ma guitare folk...lol !) Je ferais partie des amateurs qui te suivront sur youtube et j'espère sincèrement te voir un jour, en concert...car le talent ne s'invente pas et tu l'as vraiment en toi....(Fabrice)
I just cannot believe how someone at 15 is so beyond the technique that is actually focusing in emotion thus producing such a mesmerising, even more powerful rendition than the original. This is just incredible.
I have not watched a video of Tina S' playing that hasn't given me the feels. She can't be of this earth. Where ever she is now, what ever she is doing, I hope she is happy and well. I want to say thank you, just so, straight into the Universe for the gift that came along we were allowed to enjoy. A Tina S. can't happen more than once or twice a century. Pantheon of the Gods.
She's just so good! The music literally flowed from her soul! Not only was her performance flawless, but she fills her audience with a fierce expression of her own passion! Oh how I wish she would return and play some more for us.
Tina is like, “this is too easy, give me something harder.” It’s really amazing how good this girl is, even when she is playing really difficult pieces she looks like she is not even trying.
Снимаю шляпу и аплодирую! Девочка, ты просто молодец! Привет из России! Ты не просто сыграла кавер, которых сотни одинаковых, ты сделала своё личное исполнение. Уважуха!
Dude, she fucking shredded the shit out of that! So awesome seeing a younger generation actually feeling the music
100% unik y original y unik e irrepetible xd xd xd de tu envidia nace mi fama
bro, that's a compliment, did you read the last half of the comment. Some people need to calm down. Isn't that a big complaint about Americans?
Daniel OLIVIERI# Lay off the drugs!
+Daniel OLIVIER I do believe something was lost in translation. it was a compliment.
Pf is amazing ❤️❤️❤️
It's funny, I disagree highly with people who think she didn't put her spin on it. Sure she's not shredding all over it with sweeping and tapping but there is a huge difference in her vibrato. The first thing I noticed about her playing was her forceful vibrato. In order to accent notes in fast music you really gotta get there quick, she seems to have amazing left hand strength for that and you can hear it in how fast she gets to pitch in this song. It's like she's playing it with more like a cross between a Yngwie and Petrucci vibrato than a Gilmour one.
Exactly!
codecow Which she could easily do if she wanted to.. lol
codecow Yea not all like gilmour same thing i thought
codecow Couldn't agree more. Not only that but look; this is one of the most emotive solos ever created by any musician and I couldn't say why, but it speaks to me and of course many, many others. The funny thing is this young lady's version speaks to me even louder. Perhaps it is simply that phenomenal vibrato. As you say, incredible hand strength for one so young. Now what we really need to hear of course is what she can do with a composition of her own. I'd buy it 'sight unseen'. Or should that be heard?
bcmeighty1 Yeah no doubt.
This is easily one of the best guitar solos I've ever heard
Funny you say that, this solo is collectively regarded as the best guitar solo of all time by quite a few music websites ;)
@@grahamvandyke the pulse version is my favourite in my opinion
Yeah, it's great. But it all depends on the style of solo you like. I've heard dozens of great guitar solos, amount hundreds of solos, so it's hard for me to pick out just a few.
@@metalmark1214 No one cares.
@@grahamvandyke boomer websites, maybe.
I wish I knew how many times I've watched this video over the years. I still love it
same
Two times?
Me to 😊
I swear this solo gets better every time I listen to it...
Just reminding you to listen to it again :)
Just reminding you to listen to it again🤗
Hey, don’t mind me, just dropping by to give you a quick reminder to listen to it again.
I have the same
I can't stop listening to it.
When a Poem don't need Lyrics
realest comment I've ever read.
+Dauntless Guardian sim
THIS. COMMENT.
That's deep Man ! 10/10
Omg... Your Comment it's fucking truly.
I love how she hangs on to notes as long as possible. Those extra nanoseconds make a difference.
Yes, she's so fast and clean that she wrings each note out of the fretboard and doesn't miss anything. Incredible talent.
AND TO MAKE YOUR POINT GO FURTHIER SHE SOMTIMES AS SHE SMASHES THIS FRAKING BADD AZZ SOLOS SHES NOT EVEN LOOKING AT THE GUTAIR WITCH MAKES IT EVEN MORE IMPRESSIVE
OMG I have listened to this a gazillion times over the years and I am still listening to this.
Its not only you ... we are a lot out there !
Yeah dude, i miss her my negga 😔
@@lamar5307 Man fck you I see you at work
Me too bro… me too
2 million (and rising) of those views are me.
Tina is studying at a University at present in Paris. She has put her youtube activities on hold while she concentrates on her chosen field of study. Sounds like a pretty smart move. I was fortunate when I asked about her wellbeing (the same as everyone else), because a relative of hers replied and filled me in on her activities. The conversation did not get all that deep so I am unaware of Tina's chosen field but I can just pray every night and hope to live long enough to see her, centre stage with a Symphony Orchestra. I pray also, that she's studying Music.
SIMP.
She is phenominal
@KingKokos we get it you don’t pray, move on and let people live lol
well she stopped 6-7 years ago it must be a dr. she's going for. as far as her playing she is the best as far as dynamics, style and inflections just to name a few. wonder why she's not playing on her time off.
Jon. That's good to have a little news of her. Thank you.
Carry on Girl!!! You don't know how much joy it brings for an old guy like me to hear the new generation carrying with some of the greatest hits of all time...your the BEST!!!!
Every time I watch this, the rest of the world ceases to exist. There is nothing but her and that guitar. I'm so glad to hear that she is back.
She is just awesome. I don't know if I can even find the right words. The musicality of her playing is so great. A very gifted person.
She practiced a lot, it is not just "talent", its dedications.
@@SaGeOwL4891 Of course she practiced, every player that ever lived practices. But she is obviously one of the most gifted guitar players that I've ever seen and she's only 16 or so. Imagine how good she would be in 10 or 20 years if she continues playing.
@@SaGeOwL4891 jfc, youre dumb.
@@dorseyblack9833 Hey Dorsey. Yup, she's amazing. Give little Miumiu a listen to, "The Best of Times", I love her rendition.
871 people has envy of her, because she plays much better than all of us together!!!
AutomobileFunk
Of course that she plays better than me!
When I say the opposite?
A woman can't play better than a man? Better than you or me? Course she can. And she do.
If you play better than her, prove it!!!
I said "better than all of US". This includes you and me. Don't you know how to read? Are you blind? Or you are an rock star and rock on guitar? I don't think so!!!
She is amazing. I even play 1% that she plays. And I recognize that without shame.
Do you?
AutomobileFunk
If I talk something, I need to prove if I be capable to do what I said.
Otherwise, I could say that I play better than Slash. Or even David Gilmour. I don't need to prove, right?
It's not about my ego. You don't need to do anything, but until there, I won't believe just in your words.
I assume that she and many others musicians on CZcams plays much better than me. I'm humble.
And enough to waste my precious time with your ego, that is larger than you.
Say what you want. Simply I won't believe until I see if it is true.
AutomobileFunk
First of all, I already said that I will not argue with you anymore, because it does not compensate.
But after this offense with no reason other than the fact that you are hide behind a keyboard, I have one more thing to say: I will not lower myself to your level, if you have one, and offend you.
But I will say that, unfortunately, it is not possible to have a civil conversation with people who are arrogant and who think they are better than the others, for no apparent reason.
And yet it comes to say that my ego is large.
A little more civility when talking to people, okay?
In any moment did I offend you. And I will not do it, because it is not worth the waste of words and because my mother gave me something that looks like it lacks: EDUCATION.
It does not matter to me if you're better than all the guitarists in the world. I just said that Tina plays a lot better than a lot of people.
If you do not think so, I respect.
Finishing, I say the following, just to show your point of view:
I never give a single shot in my life. If I tell you that I hit with a 9mm, a fly that be 100 yards away, will you just believe me?
This is the point. But the innocence and lack of education (offending me gratuitously) are yours.
And, say what you want to say, I'm done.
I just talk to educated people.
Peace and Hugs!
She was only 15 years old when she played and you still call her a little girl. I definitely think it's very arrogant of you to say that you're better than her and if leonard writes original music, he's better than her. Just because you don't write your own songs doesn't mean you're bad at music. Sure, she may have played other people's songs, but she practiced a lot on the difficult songs because they represent a challenge for her to face and encourage her to practice hard and work hard. Hard work is more important than talent. She really will compose original and great music. Just give her some time. Stop being spiteful, egotistical, and demanding and give this excellent young lady some time and respect.
+AutomobileFunk
I'd certainly like to see your version of this. Before you say "I DON'T NEED TO PROVE ANYTHING" yes, you do. You've made a claim "NOT THAN ME". I could make the same claim, saying I could play circles around you on an untuned guitar with a cracked neck missing two strings. Time to back it up. Otherwise people might think you are nothing but an internet troll.
God, I hate to keep harping on these transparently jealous negative comments, but I don't suffer fools. Firstly, one comment about learning to bend or apply vibrato like Gilmore takes "years of practice." If it takes you years, you may want to consider taking up the flute, or better yet the kazoo (with all due respect to flute players). or the comment on her cover of either Jason Becker or Gary Moore that she did it by "just looking at tablature." If you truly believe this, you've betrayed your own ignorance. no player at this young an age, with this level of playing ability, accomplished it by cutting corners. I'm willing to wager you could stick the charts of any song she hasn't played, and she'd be able to play it without listening to it first.
and to watch this, but complain and focus on her amp/effects settings or guitar of choice is like watching someone turn water into wine, then complaining that the vintage doesn't pair right with the meal. yOu're missing the point.
+tim white Ain't that the truth!
+tim white Bravo!
+tim white Right on. It apparently didn't take her years, unless she started when she was 6.
I agree .
+tim white the bit about considering taking up the Kazoo is golden! i reckon the flute would be way too challenging for those people though lol
There are some things i really like about this video...
1) the song itself
2) the tone of the guitar
3) the great playing
4) most important: young people still loving this kind of timeless, great music, learning to play along these decades-old masterpieces
I have actually been listening to this guitar solo since 1979. This is perfection
Bloody hell!!!! Only thing wrong with this is it finishes too early. How can there be any thumbs down? Does it really hurt that much to see a young girl play so well?
They are just jealous assholes
Oui c est cela jaloux de sa performance 😊🎸
@@cocoelectric3022 unless they dislike because she disrespected gilmour by playing better than him
@Jocelyn Corbeil other than the vibratos which sounded like she drowned in coffe before filming this
The first tone i saw rima whenshe was 8 yrs old itreally nice and crisp and i love it
Truly remarkable, for anyone, much less a young teen. Tina S has no musical limits. I wish Tina every success, in her music and life. Blessings from an admiring 67 y/o Texas cowboy fan.
Et d'un fan ébahi et stupéfait
des années rock 70
Holy f**** dude this is epic, best solo I've ever heard. Blown away at this
Jesus christ! We all wish we could play like that.
She doesn't play well
@@pomardorafa9360 ur life must be miserable. I feel sorry for u
@@leemac1561 check Alex S. viver, THAT is a Nice playing, you probably don"t know about guitar
@@pomardorafa9360 listen, I don't care who this Alex S is. And I won't watch him or her unless u take what u said back. This girl can play well, now get a life
@@leemac1561 No go wath Alex S. viver play the song. THAT is how you play it.
I love CZcams comments. Imagine this at a school concert or something; Tina having firstly the guts to play in front of everyone, playing her heart out and enjoying herself. Then a good number of people standing around going "Meh, She should've done this better. She should've done that better" and it then escalating into a full blown argument about what feeling is and sticking to the original solo too much/not enough and not applauding her and saying "Well done you did great!".
No doubt she already has a great teacher to let her know of any places she could improve upon. I could say something like; if you've got nothing nice to say don't say it - but then again the comments section would be an extremely bland place! Not sure what point I've made by the end of that....doh!
I think that this happens when trying to cover a song that is timeless and memorable as this, people expect thing from you, I'm not saying that is ok to give shit to her and not apreciate her work, she does a pretty good job, but a timeless classic is that, and people get attached to it and starts to pay attention to every single detail. That's why I can't stand her perfomance or like her work with this one, my mind is set to experience something else, and the substance of the song or solo is not pour into this, but I can see where you're going with your comment. If people thought a bit before posting we may have better youtube comments, but that's not the case, there's lots of people that speaks out of their ass and make everything less joyfull for the rest.
I'm flabbergasted at the rude comments. I don't care about the technicality of what she's doing. I care about how it makes me feel when she's playing it. If the piece brings me joy, she's done her job. I don't judge her based on any comparisons. I base it on what she gives me. I think she's an amazing musician.
Paula B. I do agree 100 procent with your comment, music = emotion. thanks and enjoy music.
I love all these guys that bitch about how its not the same as the original , its not suppose to be same as the original, its called originality .if your going to play it the same as pink Floyd don't bother posting a vid. ill just put pink Floyd cd in the player and listen.
The point you've made is that some of the critique comments are quite annoying.
I already saw tons of guitarists shredding this solo. It's the first time I listen to someone doing it right!
I've seen this vid over 20 times. I'm speechless. Pure talent.
What a beautiful prodigy child. Flawlessly talented and calmly passionate. Something so uniquely expressive that it really transfers from the rib cage, the soul, the deeper capacity than just what this miniature universe has to offer. Thank you for being capable of reaching a fulfillment that many will never know.
seeing on CZcams at BLACK METAL TEENS HEARING PINK FLOYD
For the love of God, will someone sign this young woman?
+Rob H. She is only 16 and from her talent I would think she is a bit of a recluse. I'm sure besides all the customs Vigier throws at her their is a hefty salary to boot, not to mention the YT royalties. Her last name is private stock, no verbal interviews yet.
+Rob H. What would be the point? She hasn't shown any proof of good writing, just doing cover songs.
+Rob H. only original artists who write good songs get signed.. who signs kids who play youtube covers that are only 80-90% as good as originals?
I mean she's good, technically, but so are thousands of bedroom guitarists.. skill is something everyone can learn if they set their mind to it.
Soooooo true
+BenjaminMJ "only original artists who write good songs get signed"
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAA... good one :^)
Close your eyes when listening to this. The feel is there, the necessary technique is there, the bends are there, the pinch harmonics are there, even if in slightly different places. I’ve heard this outro 200 different times, and can tell you that Ms. Tina S. grasps it in a most beautiful and honorable way. I’ve played in rock bands for 30 years, and can attest you don’t need a “guitar face” to feel and translate soul and feeling to a solo or riff or rhythm part. Bravura performance.
it was hard to translate to English my feelings. thanks dude. nice comment.
The pinch harmonics, or at least the way she plays them, do not sit well in this piece.
100% THIS.
It's all there
Please permit me to speak oh great one , I respect and appreciate your take on this. I just happen to disagree, and like that you weren’t snarky or baiting in your commentary. Music is open to interpretation, and I love that it can land differently. Thank you for your comment.
Right! It's like she doesn't waste any energy with her body. It all goes out her fingers into the guitar. Powerful and beautiful! ✌️
Goosebumps. I want to hate this because I can't play this solo nearly as well as you, but it's just too damn good not to absolutely love. I realised halfway through I was grinning ear to ear, so I wanted to say well done, you absolutely smashed that!
You can do it🖤
Кто в лес,кто по дрова..😢
I know everybody feels the same way this solo is never long enough. Such heart and soul. She’s so good that she seems bored. But she’s focused! Well done. I hope she reads her comments.
Watched a lot of covers to this solo. But no one can top Tina. Love the way she knows where to put her pinch harmonics and plays it as similar as possible to the original
+Joshua mejia you gotta watch kobiba's cover than
lol Thomas75s' version is the best by far
Afuentes44 agreed
Noone can top Andrey Korolev's version => czcams.com/video/ynSc2oYemsE/video.html&ab_channel=AndreyKorolev
You nailed it!
Miss you Tina...you’re still my favorite after all these years.😓
Me too bro!
Is my too.
What is arguably the greatest guitar solo of all time and Tina just nails it. Absolutely awesome stuff. Well done.
Why is this considered the best solo of all time?
この人しか出来無い才能ですかねー
@@oceancrosby4578 because best
Not really.
Absolutely love the talent Tina S has. I can't wait for the day she comes back with more. I can't get enough.
Omg I get tears in my eyes just listening to this, simply perfect !
If you think that was good, try this one: czcams.com/video/o6rBK0BqL2w/video.html
SimonO89 gtdth
822 people dissliked this??/ are they on drugs?? She played that epicly
Those are the people that think playing it the same as the original makes you bad.
Excuse me. Not the same. I respect this player A LOT, but... this interpretation is lightyears below Gilmour's, both in terms of feeling and precision.
She is NOT Gilmour - she is Tina S - therefore she plays her own style - I thought this was excellent. and both you two who commented above are being PICKY.
I don't want to be picky, and further more, I say it again... I respect that guitarist A LOT. But... maybe it's just that not every sound is for every guitarist. Here, as a guitarist myselfI think she tries to play a very slow solo where every note and every sound is very important.... and she gets constant guitar noise, exagerated vibratos, and not too precise attacks. That's why I don't think this specific solo suits her, and to me it sounds more like fighting the guitar, rather than Gilmour's love-making to his guitar. That's all, every1 is free to love that solo, not love it... but never hate it!
PS: And I edit it.... this woman has a GREAT bending technique... but it's a fact, as true as the Earth is not flat, that no person ever in this planet, will ever have Gilmour's bending technique. That's fu ck ed up.... but it's the hard truth for all of us!
PS 2: I edit again... Tina S plays WAAAAAAAY betther than me, in every level. Just to make it clear, just in case someone would think I say this just to put her down... I don't. She's in a very high level, and she's young enough to exploit it in ways that I hope I will know :)
For that well thought out analysis of her playing then yes you have a
good point. I however do not know guitar and just what my ear likes to
hear.
My favorite solo of any song, and you make it easy?? I love it
Come back Tina... You are an artist all to your own, and show others it is possible
Still floored, 9 years later.
Dear Tina S,
Please comeback!
FAN
DFL8eD I just want to know that she’s okay
@@rockygraziano5215 someone else wrote she died but I don't know. I really hope she's fine. Incredibly talented girl.
mik ric OMG, I hope that’s not true
Nowhere to found, please tina,please let us know,give us a sign that you're alright! We mis you!
Where is she now 😭😭
I think this women is at god level playing.
Must say very impressive no whammy bar needed I remember when this song first came out and it just amazes me that the younger generation still grasps really good music
Hands down one of the best covers of that solo ever.
I’m a huge Pink Floyd fan. And I love Gilmore. And I could listen to this minute and a half for centuries.
But still don't know his name....Gilmour
Gilmour.
Love it and everything she does.How can anyone so young be so good. Brings tears to my eyes every time I hear her and I’m 67 and have listened to rock guitarists for over 55 years.
She put in thousands and thousands of hours’ work to get that good....no magic just graft and ain’t she great!
She plays notes with utmost precision
This is the best guitar solo cover i've ever seen
She suddenly disappeared
I come back to this clip at least once a week (for real).
gosh I honestly think one of the best solos of all time
Wow! That girl is something else....how could she do that! This is extraordinary...superhuman! I'm now a fan!
I listen to this cover at least once a day. Hits me straight in the feelzzz everytime. Chills right from the get-go!
I honestly think that metal style she adds complements the solo greatly. Also the technique and phrasing is spot on.. good job!
+Nobel Barakat AGREED!!!
That is one of my favorite songs ever. I had a smile on my face the whole time. Awesome. I wish you wouldn't fade it out, I could listen to you play forever.
> I wish you wouldn't fade it out, I could listen to you play forever.
Ditto
A prodigy doesn't just play the notes. Tina S.'s passion and love of music comes oozing out of that guitar affecting the heart & soul with deep & passionate emotions that cannot be conveyed with words. It is a very personal & intimate experience in each and every one of us.
You give this solo a new energy I have never heard in it before. Really beautiful.
Tina, you are a force of nature, like a typhoon or a hurricane... and you glow and shimmer like an aurora borealis.
Raucous applause!
I like how people can criticize a 14 year old girl that plays better than the rest of us,
I would like to see her play after a 50 year career like David Guilmour has had.
Cheers,
Gilmour, you clown. For the record, Gilmour plays this with more feel. Tina is more of a "Metal" guitarist.....not a "Prog Rock" guitarist.
She's an AMAZING guitarist....just not "prog rock".
I'd like to see her compose a solo of this quality at any point in her life... Just fuck off comparing her to Gilmour.
Awwww, poor wittle baby. Did you soil your pampers? :'(
Markus Maxwell That comment defines 'cringe'... If cringe is in the Oxford Dictionary that genuinely ought to be the description.
Wow...great tone and vibrato. The thing you notice most is how she attacks the fret board while still having a soulful sound. A real mark of a great player.
June 21, 2023 'Comfortably Numb' passes the 12 Million mark, and it's deserved! Bravo Tina!
I could listen to Tina play all day! Many say she shows no feeling, but I could see it, if you look really close to her heart, and sound of her play. Excellent job Tina! God gave you a fantastic gift and I see 209 people envy you a lot for it! :)
I am now going to go call my children and tell them that they have all failed me.
LOL!!! Brillant :)
maybe you were comfortably numb and you have failed them too
+brujoraz lol
;)
LOL
She is one of the best guitarists at this age that i’ve ever listend to🔥
I started the day with You Tube.. Of course with Tina. The first was Comfortably Numb, then one after the other run automatically. It was like a private concert at my house and I enjoyed 46.21 minutes. Great.
i just found this, i'm completely blown away, shivers down my spine, tears in my eyes. this music and the way she plays causes a deep unexplained emotional reaction in me. and shes gone?! no one knows what happened to her!? WTF!!
I'm listneing to this solo over and over in a loop IT'S SO GOOD
This actually made me tear up because of how good it is. Watching how she nails the complexity... brilliant.
Imagine being a director, trying to blend in this solo with a dramatic scene ; gives me goosebumps thinking about it 😁
It's not just the technique in question! There's a feeling that's incredible!
Isn't that the same?
coco latte I think when people refer to technique they forget that bending and vibrato are still techniques.
The technical achievement here is pretty obvious, but what's even more amazing to me is the emotion she manages to convey, especially for such a young player. So many mediocre Gilmour impersonations on CZcams, but this is stunning.
I think the emotion has lead to the technical achievement :)
No it's not
Haha. There is no emotion in this playing. You are deluded.
Uh, out of key, shrill vibrato. Kid has talent but to elevate this is a bit of a reach. It shows me how tone deaf people are.
She knows what she is doing. All vibratos are greatly performed with the rest of the string muted with an index finger. That's why you don't hear redundant shitty sounds like when Kirk Hammett or Slash playing any solo. Also, altered a solo a bit by adding pitch harmonics. A great interpretation of the iconic solo.
Still listening to this since 2014...
If I had just been listening to the music and, not watching this video, I would have sworn that David Gilmour was playing this. Wow! Tina S is an incredible talent! Just amazing! Peace, Blessings and Grace to all.
Thats heavy metal sound. Gilmour sound is very very different. If you say what you have said then you never listened enough of gilmour
This gave me chills...damn.
didnt excpect to see you here
BeRAD you’re here?
It gave me chills to......
listen to David Gilmour and compare. David gives chills. Tina doesn't - she's the Steve Vai of solos.
@@Piotrus31492 try again. Don't give ME chills.
I come back here every so often to listen to this. Genuinely the best rendition of this solo I have ever heard
Absolutely awesome. Not only are you nailing it… you give it a more aggressive edgy metal sound. You own that solo and then some. 🤙🏽
Well that's the best cover I've ever heard of this, by a long way. Speak to you guys in like 5 years when I'm still coming back for this!
Pure Genius! I love her playing.
Freakin awesome ! I hope she nevers loses the desire to play this kind of music !
Of all the covers I’ve heard, she is THE BEST! Rock on , young lady👍
If you say you dont like this your only trolling.
period.
This was the video that made me subscribe just strolling threw for sure.
+Alexandre Ouimet I wasnt debating how close the performance was to the original. I said it was good enough for me to subscribe. im just one guy throwing a compliment out there. and telling people who over analyze things, it was good. inless u just dont like pink floyd or guitar
+Seth Hamilton Good and liking it are twoo different things. It is very good. I like it even though it does have a metal flare that I wouldn't usually like in a pink floyd song. But I can certainly understand a Floyd purist not liking this.
PINK FLOYD is my ALL TIME favorite band on this planet and your playing of this song is right up there with David !!!!! I'm used to the sound of a FENDER when it comes to this but the sound you have is fantastic as well !!! Love that color on the guitar !!!!
Nice joke comment.
McCoy Genfan Wow! You are so remorse! You must wake up to the sound of you in severe pain! lol
***** tina s
Girl you squashed everyone that has ever played that. You are guitar goddess! BRAVO!
Never thought someone could play the greatest guitar solo ever without Glimour.But you did a great job Tina👏
I have heard countless of great musicians, and I must say, my money is in this young lady...it flows out of her veins and breathes the notes...absolutely breathtaking, for real.
Great cover and great style and great technique. The only thing that i am confused about is why 99 people have took the trouble to dislike it - there is nothing to dislike - and their time would have been better spent practising to reach your level and confidence. I have been playing over 20 years and I teach but I still don't yet have the balls to post my solo covers! Yours is my second favourite cover of that solo - my first is John Petrucci ;)
Matt, the technique and style was ass. Clean out your ears.
FYI, Petrucci doesn't come close to Gilmour.
Heard this genius a while ago, just remembered and searched, Tina you would be so proud if you could see the smile on my face and how happy I now am...... YOUR A TOTAL GENIOUS :) Going to listen again and again, WOW
Those high notes are piercing my soul. Wicked good.
Holy shit, every time I hear this solo I feel like the guitar is singing for me. There are so many layers of emotion to this solo, and you portrayed them perfectly. Gilmour would be proud. Good job.
Man, I wish this kid was my daughter....I'd be so fucking proud! Awesome guitar player
Yeah, and do like her's.... collect money from ads......
I wish this girl was my fiancee.. I'd be jamming with her all the time.
Michael Barnes So what? I'll be 18 till I die, and 15-18 is not a bad combination. ;)
Music_Man
you sick bastard !
You guys drunk or what? Bollocks.
A small glimpse of what music is played by the angels in heaven. Awestruck and beyond my earthly understanding.
Des Mädel hat echt Musik im Blut !! Einfach Klasse !!!!!!!!
J'écoutais ce morceau des pink floyd lorsque j'avais ton âge et j'en ai maintenant 40...j'étais même allé les voir en concert à Versailles je crois ....jouer de la guitare comme tu le fais et surtout à seulement 15 ans est une véritable don....you tube non montre assez souvent des gens talentueux qui maîtrisent assez bien leurs instruments mais la progression avec laquelle tu as su évoluer sur une guitare électrique en à peine 2 ans est incroyable et dépasse tout ce que les amateurs de guitares ont pu voir jusqu'à présent....les morceaux sont tout simplement parfait et le plaisir que tu communiques aux visiteurs avec ces harmoniques, ces arpèges, ces solos sur une guitare est immense....MERCI
Je te souhaite vraiment de réussir ta vie dans la musique, tu es sans doute très bien partie pour y arriver... et ces efforts seront un jour payant...j'aurais rêvé plus jeune suivre la même aventure que toi, avec tous ces groupes de rocks et de hard de ma génération, ces guitaristes comme Gary more, van halen, ou Joe satriani... j'avais aussi essayé, comme beaucoup d'autres jeunes, d'apprendre la guitare mais je suis finalement devenue conducteur de train...et ...la guitare est bien loin de moi...lol...(pour la petite anecdote, je revenais d'une permission et je repartais à l'armé, cela durait 10 mois, service obligatoire à l'époque, et en prenant le métro, j'avais oublié ma guitare sur un quai...impensable n'est-ce pas ? c'est pourtant vrai...je n'ai jamais revu ma guitare folk...lol !)
Je ferais partie des amateurs qui te suivront sur youtube et j'espère sincèrement te voir un jour, en concert...car le talent ne s'invente pas et tu l'as vraiment en toi....(Fabrice)
I just cannot believe how someone at 15 is so beyond the technique that is actually focusing in emotion thus producing such a mesmerising, even more powerful rendition than the original. This is just incredible.
Absolut eines der besten Solos das ich je gehört habe...Was für ein Talent....
I have not watched a video of Tina S' playing that hasn't given me the feels. She can't be of this earth. Where ever she is now, what ever she is doing, I hope she is happy and well. I want to say thank you, just so, straight into the Universe for the gift that came along we were allowed to enjoy. A Tina S. can't happen more than once or twice a century. Pantheon of the Gods.
Well said!
David Gilmore would be proud.
...and not only David Gilmore
Gilmour*
haha the david GILMORE girls :P
Hell yea he would !!
facepalm
She's just so good! The music literally flowed from her soul! Not only was her performance flawless, but she fills her audience with a fierce expression of her own passion! Oh how I wish she would return and play some more for us.
SHE'S BACK!!! 🤯
Stunning!!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 What an amazing rendition to David Gilmour 🎸👑
Tina is like, “this is too easy, give me something harder.” It’s really amazing how good this girl is, even when she is playing really difficult pieces she looks like she is not even trying.
Try "Machine Gun" or "Midnight". (Hendrix)
Снимаю шляпу и аплодирую! Девочка, ты просто молодец! Привет из России!
Ты не просто сыграла кавер, которых сотни одинаковых, ты сделала своё личное исполнение. Уважуха!
ты шутишь? это же не то...
holy shit, to be able to play both Through the Fire and the Flames and this - totally different styles and feel and you nailed both, stunning.
precision notes full of energy , a solo with personality