Butker commencement speech spotlights religious war on women's freedom, even Taylor Swift's
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- A commencement speech at conservative Catholic Benedictine College by football kicker Harrison Butker resonated nationally as its anti-diversity, anti-LGBTQ, traditional roles for women themes are seen as encroaching on public life for Americans who in large proportion do not support religion-based rollbacks of social progress. Leah Litman, law professor at the University of Michigan, talks with Alex Wagner about why a speech at a small college became a national flashpoint.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#MSNBC #HarrisonButker #womensrights
As a female person who lived through the 60s and 70s era of My Body, My Choice, the last decade has been quite alarming. I highly recommend the book When Abortion was a Crime by Leslie J Reagan to understand why emergency room doctors rejoiced when the Roe v Wade decision made abortion safe and legal.
On women’s independence: when I was 30, I couldn’t get a credit card in my own name. I HAD to have my husband on the account. He maxed out the card and ran off with a mistress. I had to go through bankruptcy to clear a debt I never wanted - a debt which was only possible because I could NOT have my own line of credit.
I didn’t need a no fault divorce because my state recognized infidelity as a legitimate reason for divorce, and he had admitted to having multiple dalliances. I fully support no-fault divorce. If one person wants out, they should be allowed to leave, no questions asked.
We are not property. We are people. We deserve to be paid the same amount for the same work. We deserve to decide what goes on in our own bodies. We deserve to live in safety. We are not a genie you can stuff back into a bottle.
Well said!
This is what they are achieving right now. Benjamin Netanyahu is using the slaughter in Gaza to distract & help sway the election of Trump. The Project 2025 agenda is within their grasp.
I agree, women and men should be able to walk away, and EVERYTHING is split right down the line.
It's not just sad, but actively very worrying to see from across the pond what's happening in the USA currently, and on so many levels... We may not have the abortion freedoms I'd want here in Germany (it's generally illegal for everyone involved, though the exceptions that make it legal are fairly generously set up), but it's in practice far better than with that Roe v. Wade thing taken down in the USA now. And while there are _some_ occasional attempts to make it worse here as well, there luckily are more attempts to completely decriminalize it.
And yeah, those lingering inequalities in various (other) areas are... shameful.
The _only_ thing I _may_ disagree with to some degree, depending on what you meant to refer to, is the same pay for the same work thing. Even if you mean the "cleaned up pay gap" (or whatever it's called in English), I have some issues with it. For example, is the factor taken out that physically smaller people tend to get paid less? Women are physically smaller than men on average, but that factor also affects smaller men, it may just be difficult to remove that variable from the statistics - and that's just one pretty easy example. Negotiation abilities and the role testosterone plays during negotiations play an even bigger role, and I have _zero_ idea how that could be taken into account.
Maybe the only solution would be to make collective agreements the only legally acceptable type of contract, so personal negaotiation skills and physical attributes (size, body type, looks, ...) and such play no role? No idea how one could make sure that that's actually done _everywhere,_ but it should be easy to enforce in the vast majority of employment contracts.
💯! Otoh, I have a friend who supported her deadbeat husband for years. When he left for a younger woman, he also took half her retirement income. There has to be some way to stop that. What a crime.
Notice that he didn't say anything to men about being good fathers, good husbands, et al. He should start speaking to his own gender before trying to mansplain to women what we should and shouldn't be excited about for our futures. 🙄
Because Men know their role, women don’t
@JasonDrvmz if that’s try, why so many of them in prison? The coin goes both ways! You have a lot to learn!
@@JasonDrvmz Women can do both and all.
Best he keeps his mouth shut and his mind in neutral
@@bellad1063 Can women pee standing up?
My niece is a wife and mother. She's also a veterinarian, and a darned good one too.
She is probably a veterinarian because of affirmative action. Because of affirmative action 9 out 10 veterinarian students are women.
Notice you didn't say she's a good mother.
@@racheljames7 you sound jealous
Being a mother pales in comparison to the achievement of becoming a veterinarian. To all the deadbeat homemakers out there, I would like you to take a look at your children with scold and remind them that the front seat they have taken has caused their mother's true potential to ride around in perpetual darkness in the hatchback of their minivan....
@racheljames7 Someone as judgmental as you better look into the mirror and ask if they are a good mother.
I'd like to thank the sports-ball player who I'd never heard of for putting a face to the growing threat to women's freedoms in the US.
There aren't any threats to your freedoms, Karen. Calm down.
@@Sturmvogel Brilliant argument.
@@Sturmvogelthe big one…body autonomy!
@@Sturmvogel Huh? Roe V Wade got overturned. Women in America are no longer allowed to make their own reproductive choices. We have rightwing politicians calling for pregnant women to be placed on registries so people can monitor them and make sure they're not getting abortions. You must be really out of the loop, kid. And "Karen" is a term for rightwing women who say privileged, racist things.
WHAT TO EXPECT FROM A GUY THAT GETS PAID TO PLAY WITH SOMEONE ELSE'S BALLS!?
CERTAINLY THE KICKER DOESN'T PURCHASE THE BALLS...
What makes his speech fascist is not his valourization of homemakers, but demonization of everyone who chooses differently.
Ironic, because that's exactly what the woke left does.
Saying Catholic things to Catholics in a Catholic institution shouldn't elicit such nationawide clutch your pearls moment.
What you're doing. Ironic.
@@MYJEWISHLAMPSHADES Still angry Biden had the most votes in US history, huh?
lol your comment attracted a bunch of triggered fascists
When are these religious men going to be quiet and let women make their own decisions on their own lives?
Yet they get butthurt when I tell them that there is no god.
They watched (not read) Handmaid's Tale, and thought "Let's try that!"
@@P.90.603 Trust me. We have no feelings whatsoever about that. hahaha.
never
@@faithingod5533 Christians get upset at me all the time because I'm right. Their belief is baseless.
Wow just wow. That was disgusting, degrading, and disrespectful.
Facts
What is a woman?
Exactly sit down and shut up
you forgot evil
Wanna maybe make a point instead of crying in buzzwords karen?
@@Ghost-fe1vp I think you did that perfectly well
I was a faithful homemaker for 10 years and my husband cheated on me the entire time
Silly you for choosing a bad man.
@@racheljames7victim shaming?? Come on 🤦♀️
@@racheljames7No, shame on the man for choosing to be a bad husband.
These types will tell you it’s all your fault.
In ten years you didn't figure it out?
Not the sharpest pencil in the box, are you
There is no hate like Christian love.
Naw. Just his kind.. 😂
Mind you, I’m NO supporter of the elderly blonde-haired man. Having said that, you might replace the word “Christian” with “Islamic” to be even more accurate. Btw, I’m all in on re-electing 46 so we don’t make 45 also be 47. 🙏🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇦
@@SH-dq2cy Exactly 💯
Actually, there is no misogyny quite like Islamic misogyny.
@wiltchamberlainisthegoat13 With any religion, there are some people who are extreme. I just wish in any religion or not, people would not push their ideology on others. We are ony responsible for ourselves.
These people aren’t kidding and they so badly want a Christian version of what Iran has here.
A white Christian version. Let's not forget his mention of diversity as one of the great evils 🤨
See; Seven Mountain Mandate
Islam is actually more Christian then the Christian are.
They are very conservative minded.
"THESE PEOPLE" i can see your finger showing, not the middle one, the judgmental one
@@yurmom-io9pc why wouldn't we judge fascists?
According to the Wikipedia, Butker's mother, Elizabeth Keller Butker, has been a clinical medical physicist at Emory University since 1988. I wonder how she feels about her son's speech.
Bet he got a phone call from his loving mother after his "indroctrination presentation"...
How does your mother feel about looking down on women who stay home to raise a family... not much of an elitist. Are you
He never said women cant work?
Ur so mad at something that you made up LOL
Considering Butker never said women have no right to work if they want to, it’s a 100% surety that she was just fine with it.
@@JAy-ct2bu If you think women who work don't get constantly belittled and mocked, I have news for you. Housewives aren't victimized b y feminists. They're protected from the garbage from men the rest of us have to deal with. But putting that aside, you seeem sstrangely ok that this guy castigated career women to their faces.
I raised my children and taught school. I believe I made a difference. It is important to be the person you want to be, reach all your goals, both personal and professional. Women, live your lives the way you want!🙏🏼
Your belief is wrong. Other people's children weren't your vocation but you put them before your own children. You made a horrible mistake.
What about societal responsibility? With the impending population collapse I think it’s imperative upon us all to have as many children as we can. It’s our responsibility to the perpetuate the human species.
@@racheljames7stop trying to impose your values on others. You have no evidence that this person’s kids aren’t thriving.
@@MarkZolezi Not if the human species is at stake. If extinction is near, there is no choice for neither man or woman. It’s not that bad yet but it’s getting there.
@@MarkZolezi I’m just watching the figures, South Korea & Japan are being hit hard right now with birth decline & it may turn into a population collapse.
What a simple, frightened little person
He also reeks of privilege.
Projection is curable
says the frightened little person
@@christopherjavens3438you trolls are so boring
@@melissawatkins7332Still can't find a man?
The saddest part for me is how many cheered at the end of it.
They are ALL eager to marry Harrison and have babies with HIM
@@tchowcpaso sad
@@GreenSharpieScience😭
And if I was there I would have to
I heard it was mainly the dudes
This male mentality gave me nightmares as a girl growing up in a Christian household.
Still does. 🤢
What's a woman?
You can't give me an answer, can you
Good! You're keeping my dating pool cleaner!
Don't you want a family and children with a man providing a good living
@@JAy-ct2bu a person who should the freedom to what ever they want ❤️
Women should be who they want to be. And can be.
So murders okay?
A woman can’t be a man that’s for sure.
Good Lord!! What an inappropriate speech at a graduation.
Said the man in drag.
@@muddywater4505I mean, I know you're trolling, badly, but if you Must jump in with a ridiculous remark, apropos of nothing, you could at least attempt to have some bona fide link or reason to do so. But I'm sure you're doing your best, such as it is.
How so? He’s catholic speaking at a religious school. What’s the problem?
@@JasonDrvmz The problem is that he didn't bother to talk about how men could be better husbands, or fathers. He went after women, who have just finished and paid for a degree which will allow them to enter the profession of their choice. He wants them to take their rather expensive degrees which they are probably very proud of having achieved, ..... and just get married and have children. I mean ..... he's f*cking ridiculous. His brain is all dogma'd up!
Think about the college recruiters trying to get 1/2 the student population to fork over $20K a year only to enjoy a career as a homemaker.
The old barefoot, pregnant and in the kitchen speech. How original.
Lol...and true!
He's got that simpleton look on his face like he thinks he's really, really smart, but he's just average, at best
Social media is really pushing this toxic "alpha" BS. Andrew Tate is still a lot of people's hero, for some reason.
Don't forget he got a standing ovation. Democrats hate freedom of speech
Having a father in the house is such a controversial subject.
It's what happens when you neglect the job of getting an appropriate commencement speaker and instead pay money to an American Football kicker with little knowledge of what he's really there for.
He expressed how both men and women should live to be maximally 'happy'
Its the most perfect kind of speech for all people these days.
@@Ghost-fe1vpTerrible speech. He's such a doosh.
So dismissive of the female graduates of this class! They have spent their resources pursuing a career. The days of "barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen" are OVER!!
Even if they wanted to, they couldn't afford to anyway! Everything is so expensive!
They're coming back because women are sick of being forced into careers they never wanted.
I'm a mom, a wife and I have a career. My husband wanted me to stay home and I pretty much still do it all and have everything I want. I stay at home and work in the home as well. As have things that I wanted from me, fulfilled my dreams and even take care of my kids as women in today's society. We can do it all men. Just don't like it because when they see women. With confidence as well as degrees and achievements, it makes it harder for them to control those women, or when they want to run off and find other women. That first woman is in a situation. She can't get herself out of.
He never said anything of the sort. He even acknowledged that these women would have careers, get promotions and titles, and some would be successful.
You people are so quick to judge, but I bet you can't even define what "vocation" means in Catholicism. You probably just assume it means "career," because you are judging from a position of ignorance.
Notice how happy he is that his wife gave up on her dreams. Then he tells all the women graduating that their accomplishments should be limited to marriage and parenthood.
He didn't say that at all😂 Democrats hate freedom of speech
She posted that she stands behind what he said %100!
No mention of giving up her dreams.
CZcams censoring people again. Can't criticize Democrats on CZcams. Just like Russia
@@jimsquirrel8944 Someday she will regret it. There is no such thing as happiness when you are a female in a relationship with an individual like Butker.
@@plpams8332 you may be right. She may regret it I’m just going by her present day posts.
My fascination about this whole situation is, he’s the kicker from the kc chiefs. Who really cares what he says?
I’m like Whoopie Goldberg from the view.
He can say it, that’s his beliefs, I don’t have to agree, we go our separate way.
Now, if he could change laws and his speech affected my way of living, okay, that’s a different ballgame.
Not going to lie I really want to know what his own mother thinks of her son. Especially considering she's a well-known scientist.
She raised him in the religion.
Yeah, I was wondering what caused him to do this. Maybe he knew his wife would see the speech and wanted to virtue signal to her that being a homemaker OK. If he gave an empowering speech to follow your dreams and career then his wife would have felt left out.
@@Lerian_V-My best friend for 40 years is Catholic and normal Catholics don’t support this backward thinking. They fully support women being independent, educated and most use birth control!!
He benefited from his mother’s labor on so many levels. Then he tears her down for being the mother he needed to get him to where he is now. Now he will need his mom more than ever, because marriages to athletes don’t last.
His sister too. It reads as baby being sad because Mommy wasn’t impressed by him kicking a ball far.
The funniest thing about all of it? The lyrics he used are from Bejeweled, a song about female empowerment...
...and since Butker's commencement address had nothing to do with taking anything away from females, he was fine.
If it is such an important title to be a homemaker, why don't you take that title Harry?
So he should quit his job and make his wife go to work when both of them don't want that?
Why are you so mad at people making their own life choices.
@@Ghost-fe1vp No, no, he should quit his job *where he makes millions of dollars* and make his go to work when both of them don't want that.
If you don't mention the money, it doesn't really capture the utter absurdity of it.
Because that’s not a man’s role. For thousands of years women stayed home, now in the last 50 they started to work. I think a case could be made that the results haven’t been great for men OR women.
@@beck204 The reason women worked in the home for thousands of years is because the home was the center of all economic activity for thousands of years. For most of our history, women were semi-nomadic gatherers. Then we became farmers, and for thousands of years we lived on farms and men working "outside the house" meant "in the fields."
As economies developed, the home remained the center of economic activity. A silversmith in the 12th century had his shop in his home, often with the front of his house opening to the street, where his wife would sell his wares while he worked smelting and shaping metal.
But women have worked outside the home as long as such work has been available. There are women in the Bible who support their family by working as servants in the houses of others, and women have been nurses, maids, servants, as well as innkeepers, brewers (for centuries beermaking was done almost entirely by women).
With industrialization women went to work in factories, operating looms and other machinery. With every new technological development, women have been needed in the workforce. And women have needed to be in workforce. For most of recorded history only the elite could afford to support women who had no useful employment. Princesses are not the norm.
In the 1950s, it became possible for working class men to finally provide their wives lives of luxury. The last 50 years haven't been the beginning of women working, it has been a battle between the aristocrats and the commoners. The powers that rule the material world do not want working men to be able to treat their wives as queens, lest they mistake themselves for kings.
Men and women are NOT equal. Get over it you little communist.
A kicker? For a commencement speech. Talk about low expectations for your graduates.
"Talk about low expectations for your graduates." The college where the address was given is located in Kansas, although the expectations for the graduates could have been made much lower if they would have chosen the Missouri U.S. Rep. Cori Bush (with all her public corruption) to be the one making the address to the students.
@@gregpaspatis9425 whatever it is you’re trying, you’re trying too hard
Well they are benedictines. Not really regarded as deep thinkers even among the Catholic cleric sects. The Jesuits think the Benedictines make a very nice liqueur.
A Catholic Speaker, at a Catholic Commencement. How dare they!
right. Are they supposed to have successful people give commencement speeches? like good job you kick a ball far.
Another one who feels it’s HIS place to tell women what give THEIR LIVES PURPOSE!! UNBELIEVABLY DESPICABLE even worse he thinks he NAILED THAT SPEECH!!!
These kind of men desire women who need them, not women who want them.
@@eringo-bragh4243 Absolutely!!💯
He didn't actually say that .. but whatever floats your boat / narrative ..
@eringo-bragh4243
Imho, they want women that are desperate
man /baby hating feminist alert!!!!!
I had a mom who was forced to quit her job when she married my dad. Societal norms submitted her into a "homemaker". She became intensely lonely with 7 children and no adult to speak to during the day. She wanted to be an actor. She would have been a great performer. All her talents were wasted. She was a lousy mom, depressed and alcoholic at the end of her life.
A lot of people aren't actually happy having to take care of kids all day alone. Sure women are forced to take on this role but it's not actually natural. In old tribes kids would have helped gather or hunt depending on their gender they would not stay home all day with kids the responsibility would be distributed over the entire society and plenty of adult company all day too.
Where did she live where no other mothers live?
My neighbours at work are all out on the back porch drinking tea after dropping their kids off.
Poor oppressed women, anyway I gotta go now, this 10tonne of rock wont push itself up the hill..
I'm surprised he didn't say to the ladies, "hey, you wasted your money, stupid!" And the ladies didn't walk out of the ceremony.
That’s basically what he said to them.
Surprised you're this stupid
@@danal4849 Lying at ur age?
Get a life ur 5
@@danal4849 No, it's not. I really don't think you people expressing this sentiment realize how asinine you sound. You're missing a really obvious point:
Education is a good on its own. An educated woman will always benefit from her education, even if she is a wife and mother, even if she is a homemaker. Now, Butker never said all women should become homemakers, he explicitly acknowledged that many of those women would have careers, but let's pretend he was actually suggesting all of those women should become homemakers.
Why would their education being wasted? If they have a richer and deeper understanding of the world, are better able to make informed decisions, isn't that a good on its own?
And how can anyone believe education is wasted on a *mother!?!* What child doesn't benefit from their mother's education? How can a mother encourage her children to take their education seriously if she has failed to attend to her own?
And, of least importance, what kind of man wants to devote his life to a woman who eschews education? What man wants a witless and unclever woman constantly at his side, unable to even hold up her end of a conversation.
Absurdity, all of this nonsense. You people need an education. You know nothing of value.
Not all women can be homemakers. It takes someone else earning money to have a homemaker.
Homemaker, or servant-slave? But you are right, the Moneychangers have painted themselves in a corner since it's nearly impossible to live on a single income (like the 50's/60s)
@@eringo-bragh4243not impossible at all. You have to prioritize your spending. It may be tight but it’s very possible .
@@lisariggs5688 You obviously have not been living in the lower classes; you remind me of those who say, "Why aren't you investing you're money?" The Rich have this attitude as they have no idea how we live (and most likely don't care)
A lot of couples don't even want to have children, either. And that is their right and choice.
He lives in his four million a year bubble.
for college grads, those who cheered him aren't very bright
The "education" they got at CBC leaves a lot to be desired.
They are bright enough to know that lib dems are destroying America!
Says WHO ? EwE da 🐑 sheeple? Lol hush child
Women can be homemakers while having careers, because women can be anything they chose to be,and they don't need a guy who kicks balls for a living to tell them they can't. If men love their wives or girlfriends they will help with the homemaking and support them in their lives.This guy is living in the past.
Well said
When will politicians and religions start to talk about the responsibilities of the male impregnator of the female? If females must continue an impregnated state, then child support, medical support for the "child" and the mother begins at "conception". If the males fail to present for DNA testing for confirmation of support. then they should be arrested. If they fail to pay support for their progeny and the female damaged by his actions, a work camp could be established for the law-breaking males.
A GREED!
right-effing-on!
You sound like Hitler. You don't keep the child either you know. Give it up for adoption or better yet don't get pregnant. And there's already consequences. It's called going to jail.
You should have listened to the whole speech. He spoke at great length about his vocation as husband and father, the need for men to step up and embrace their vocations as husbands and fathers, blamed the rising chaos and violence in society on men failing to do their duty as husbands and fathers.
@@wolfofthewest8019woah slow down there bud, that's the part everyone wants to ignore
This is the man you thought you'd see in Gilead in The Handmaid's Tale😂
What he basically said to the female graduates was: ‘that’s some pretty good dinner party conversation material you spent $100,000 on ladies’. What a tosser
Yup and or a $100,000 MRs.
His insinuation is that women go to college to get their MRS degrees
So no business classes there huh? Most stay at home moms have some business of their own.
@@joannlarson6386 Just crossfit and how to ask for the manager.
His speech is very relevant... To 50's men. Women don't you dare to have any other ambition but to raise my kids for me.
…And the women in that room who clapped should apologize to their parents. $100k+ for a degree and then have you resign to be a home maker? No.
The sad truth is, many of those parents sent their daughters there specifically to get their “Mrs.” degree, and whatever they got their actual degree in - is just an “insurance policy” if all else fails and they need to use it. I grew up in this culture, and it turns my stomach…the misogyny is extremely strong in much of organized religion - especially where it merges with Right Wing politics - though they try to put a pretty bow on it.
What do you think most women major in. Social sciences.
Oh, now who's telling women what to do? What if their parents forced them to go against their wishes, the leftists have been forcing women into miserable degenerate lives for decades?
It still will open doors for them for opportunities if they want to work part time or if they have to fall back on supporting themselves
Benedictine College is where wealthy Catholic families send their daughters to get an education and meet a husband. Many of those women are doing exactly what their parents want.
Also, I'd really like you to stop and consider what you're implying. Do you really believe a woman who gets an education and does not pursue a career in the market is wasting her education? Is accumulating wealth the only reason to get an education?
Education is a good on its own, regardless of whether it is put to some utilitarian purpose. Everyone benefits from an education, even if it is just in being able to better understand the world around them. But education is *essential* for a mother. How can she educate her children, how can she teach them to appreciate and cherish their own education, if she does not attend to her *own* education?
Catholics do believe that a woman's vocation is to be a wife and mother (or a nun), but that does not mean that she should not have a career. That career does not have to be homemaker, though blessed are the homemakers, but even if it is homemaker she should be educated.
Catholics were the first champions of women's education. The very first woman in the world to earn a university degree was a Catholic woman who attended a Catholic university. In the 15th century. She went on to write one of the pioneering works on Latin translation. And she was a wife and mother.
Catholics established the first convents, where women could live and pursue their vocation as nuns. These convents raised funds by *educating the daughters of the nobiliy.* The Benedictine Sisters have been educating women for hundreds of years, long before America existed.
You have no idea what you are talking about, what the purpose and value of education is, or why those women were clapping. You see everything from such a narrow, ignorant perspective. It's sad.
If they really want more women to be homemakers, they should pay women who stay home with the kids a guaranteed livable income. This would make being a homemaker have more status, and it would make it financially possible to stay home to raise the kids. Many women would love to be stay-at-home mothers, they just can’t afford to. It would be in the country’s best interest as well, since unstressed mothers tend to create more stable, capable children, leading to less social problems and a thriving economy down the road. Children growing up in poverty are often stunted in their mental, emotional and intellectual development leading to an increase in social problems.
Same with abortion. Make childcare affordable, make medical care affordable, make housing affordable, make education affordable, pay mothers a subsidy, and suddenly the rate of women choosing not to have an abortion will go up dramatically. Most women don’t want to have an abortion but feel they have little choice.
Without implementing a robust social safety net, forcing women to stay at home, taking their choice away when it comes to abortion, is just plain cruel. It will lead to a lot of misery for both women and their children, and ultimately lead to a very unhealthy society with a lot of deep unhappiness, social ills and crime. If you are not willing to create strong social programs, you cannot ask women to stay at home, you cannot make abortion illegal. Ultimately it will lead to fewer women deciding to even have children, since now pregnancy will be much more dangerous, since in extreme cases, abortion is not even allowed to save the mother’s life. It is already having an effect on men, young men are having vasectomies at unprecedented rates so they don’t end up having to be responsible for an unwanted child. Without advocating for strong social programs to support mothers and their children at the same time as promoting stay-at-home motherhood and banning abortion, this whole debate is not about morality at all, it is about controlling women and putting them back into a state of dependence and semi-slavery. When you ban abortion to the point of sacrificing the life of the mother, you are sending a strong message to women that they are second class citizens and of little value.
Start paying your mom
Or crazy idea here, if you want a mans money you better be a proper housewife.
Dont want wife? dont take mens money.
Thank you. Your comment has me in tears. What you said about this not being about morality, it's about controlling women is so true. Thank you. Thank you.
@@Ghost-fe1vp Sit down.
I saw people try to say that Butker is getting attacked for "defending Christianity." No he isn't. He is being called out for outdate and bigoted ideals. Nobody cares about him being religious. Even here, nobody said anything about Christianity.
This has nothing to do with Christianity.
Exactly. Religion has nothing to do with it. His outdated, antiquated ideas do.
Yep
PLUS CHRISTIANS DON'T PRAY TO MARY OR HAVE A POPE EITHER BUT CATHOLICS DO 😏😅😂
Rubbish , had nothing to do with christianity, is a mindset, he was raised to think that way, holy book didn't sanction mistreating women,or enslaving them in the name of their faith,is all maga bullcrap.
I think his goal was to convince the female graduates that they completely wasted their time and money going to college.
Right! His opinion, not the worlds
What an insult. You spent four years studying and he insulted the time and money they had put into. He doesn’t even possess the basic decency.
Should alarm the college that he is telling half of their customers to take their money else where.
Most college degrees are a scam. Do you support the college industrial complex?
HE IS A MALE HYPOCRITE.
The worst part for me was the standing ovation at the end. The women in the audience actually believe him, they grew up in the faith and have been taught this their entire life. And they don't see that as grooming and brainwashing.
I give him a standing ovation I think he's awesome! Wouldn't it be great to have a man love you like his wife has. I am a Catholic. I did not grow up in the faith. I choose it. I can tell you that my life is a thousand times better with God in it, since I became a Catholic and developed a set of morals. I have lived both sides. The feminist crap was me to the tee. There are so many regrets an opportunities missed that you get from family and love. But you don't get when you just become a corporate woman making money for most everybody else. Your life at the end will seem very empty trust me on that. It will not be enough to fulfill you in the end.
Yes, because the secular left hasn’t done any brainwashing or grooming. I mean, here we are watching a video about a Catholic being a Catholic and the world is losing their mind. When in reality, most women I know, would love to be a homemaker if their man made $4 million a year.
Well statistically speaking most women report happier lives a homemakers then as single career women. If teaching people the most basic facts and morals we may as well outlaw all schools for “grooming and brainwashing”. Which just seems to be code for “people with different opinions than me.”
Everyone is brainwashed to some extent and he spoke his opinion so it is what it is
Who is paying their student loans, I wonder.
This is why we fight.
It’s also why you lose. You’re just shadow boxing.
That felt like a speech made in Gilead, he even looks like a commander. The fact that everyone in that crowd roared with cheers shouldn’t surprise me but it really does shock me every time how real the threat of a Gilead like nation has its foundations in contemporary Right wing politics. Indeed we should be scared.
You've never known anything else other than left wing propaganda.
Yeah, the women I see in my social media feed who are saying it was a great speech...very disappointing. Yet, they are all professional.
@@juliettebobcat704 Those women have been liberated from the lies Mr Butker is talking about.
"Under His eye, vote GOP for Gilliad"
I heard he went to a conversion camp cause he had homosexual desires. I also heard his teammates don't like him.
Voting in America is like driving a car: if you want to go _forward,_ into the 21st century, select *“D”;* if you want to go _backward,_ to the 19th century, select *“R”.*
You won't get to a destination, by staying in neutral.
Smartest thing I've heard this week!
You failed to point out that we're "going forward" directly off a cliff if you choose "D."
The D in Democrat stands for destruction because everything the Democrats stand for ends in Death and Destruction.
@pc4mlc451 Only if you're too stupid to steer!
That's the problem with the red hat crowd. They make every tiny thing into a major issue, like Drumph saying if Biden won the stock market would CRASH!! So overly dramatic and with no forethought whatsoever.
Perhaps you're not capable of facing any challenges, (women's rights, racial equality, gender issues) without falling apart in despair.
Rather than finding fair solutions for all, you're too afraid to face any challenges, and therefore, solve no problems.
@@pc4mlc451 As the DOW hit an all time high on Friday
It's scary to hear things like that come out of someone's mouth who is so young and normal looking.
He's handsome. Which isnprobably what's really driving thenfeminsist insane. They'll never have a handsome man sing their praises the way Harrison sung his wife's.
That Old Testament look is not so normal in the 21st century. He's somebody's 'beard' alright.
He's not normal looking. You'd recognize him if he had his red maga hat on.
He looks evil to me.
@@anastasiabeaverhausen8220 🤣🤣🤣🤣. He could be mine, just as long as he doesn't speak much! Lol
Why should anyone be shocked by a jock saying something stupid? If we’re going to stereotype, isn’t this what they are known for? What is surprising is a college inviting a jock to be a commencement speaker.
I prefer handsome jocks to weedy, soyboy, male femists because they always turn out to be slimy little creeps.
"Women choosing to be happy is stupid"
You must hate women
Funny how he quoted Swift who 1000x more successful than him.
What the heck are u talking about?
Yes. She’s good at her job
So is he. He was 33/35 field goal percentage last year, as good as you’re going to get in the nfl. Only the ravens kicker is better than him, and he’s a hall of famer
So they are both successful on their platforms
@@jimsquirrel8944bro she is a billionaire and all this guy does is kick a football, he doesn’t even play football like a normal player.
@@Drizake89 oh well if ur judging by money no one can touch her, I thought u was talking about being successful at what they do.
Chiefs aren’t going to cut him he is that good.
And this guy is 1000x more successful than you.
Who cares what he believes
Misogyny at its finest...
Authentic Christianity is misogynistic I guess.
Poor little boy has mommy issues because his mom's a highly educated professional
Sexist as well
How?
@@omotayosatuyi252 how????
Here is where I get frustrated nobody is pushing gender ideologies on anyone they keep saying this… what they are teaching “pushing” is awareness, acceptance, and understanding of ALL people!!! They make it sound so fear mongering!! And women are wise enough to be able to discern if we’ve been lied to by society or not. In fact, society has just provided us with more options and choices that I am grateful for.
Nonsense
Firing people for not pretending that there a female p3nises isnt bringing people together.
There are only two genders.
The GOP Members who are Christian Nationalists and the Supreme Court are taking women’s rights away daily state by state! Those choices we are used to having are going to be completely gone if Trump is elected and Project 2025 is instituted.
I find a lot of the modern conservatives that go on about how women should be homemakers and raise never say anything about how expensive it is to live these days let alone have children. Most families need both partners to work just to put food on the table and pay rent/mortgage. Not even the slightest acknowledgment of the financial realities of modern day life. It’s low intelligence thinking that keeping women in the home is suddenly going to reshape society as they want it.
You’re assuming so much just to have an argument. Be quiet and cool something.
The issue is prioritizing a career over raising your family. A lot of women would stay home if given the chance. Most men probably would want the same if they could.
@@archie8767This is really the key idea that the left, which I consider myself to be a part of, will miss. NO ONE wants a career. Having to leave your house 5 days a week 8 hours a day in order to be able to live is not ideal. Unfortunately economic systems based off of other things do not work, so the sacrifice of working a full time job is commonly made by men.
They don't both need to work just to put food on the table and pay the mortgage. They both need to work if they want materialistic rubbish, and people these days put such a priority on materialistic rubbish they act like uts as important as food.
Idk about all conservatives, but I put my money where my mouth is. Me and my gf take things further, which is my intent to pursue, I already own a house and put more than enough food on the table. In the short term a supplemental income would be a nice to have, but I don't bust my butt to advance my career so I can buy some shiny new boat. I don't mind shouldering that weight for the type of woman who makes my house a happy, loving, peaceful home.
A 28 year old making 4 million dollars a year kicking a lousy football has the nerve to give a commencent speech that was insulting to anyone with a brain.
Yes, people worship these folks who were given some talent to play a sport AND THAT IS ALL. When you get older, you realize that these values that we hold are ridiculous. It should be like the old days where sports figures made a regular salary like us.
NFL has 80% domestic violence rate and y'all want to complain about a man's heart for his wife and life at a PRIVATE commencement ceremony. DEI is a joke out of your hypocritical playbook.
NFL has 80% domestic violence rate and y'all want to complain about a man's heart for his wife and life at a PRIVATE commencement ceremony. DEI is a joke out of your hypocritical playbook.
NFL has 80% domestic violence rate and y'all want to complain about a man's heart for his wife and life at a PRIVATE commencement ceremony. DEI is a joke out of your hypocritical playbook.
NFL has 80% domestic violence rate and y'all want to complain about a man's heart for his wife and life at a PRIVATE commencement ceremony. DEI is a joke out of your hypocritical playbook.
I thought commencement speeches were supposed to be motivational?
It is very motivational. As a mother, I appreciate that he lifted up my vocation!!!
@@flowergirl-pp7vzThat's what's so stupid about the non-controversy controversy of the address he gave at the college, this is no different than anyone else who would encourage graduates to consider a life of any number of things: becoming a missionary, a career in law enforcement, taking a risk in starting a small business or more than a hundred different types of careers including, yes, becoming a homemaker. And it's also no different than if someone else had encouraged the graduates to consider getting themselves a house pet to own. It's almost laughable, this non-controversy controversy is straight from the same basket from where the controversy made three decades ago by the speech at the San Francisco Commonwealth Club by Vice President Dan Quayle about the TV series character that was played by actress Candice Bergen having a out of wedlock kid and the prevailing pop culture of the time considering that to be nothing less than a personal decision by the character in the TV series.
@@gregpaspatis9425 You clearly watched a different speech entirely.
@gregpaspatis9425 - Yeah they went to uni for 4 years and spent $100k to take up a “career” as housewife.
@@mscheese000 Of course he did. He's a typical man.
I'm sorry, my life doesn't begin until I get married? Um...
My life began after i got divorced.
But you won't because no one wants you
A wifes life does not begin til she is married, because a women is not a wife before the day she actually gets married, shes only a wife to be at that point.
You got mad the most normal part of what he said.
But you were too dumb to actually understand him and came to a conclusion that made you mad.
@@Ghost-fe1vp Perhaps it would behoove you, then, to listen to the written response from the nuns at that university... or are they too dumb as well?
“According to a 2019 Pew Research Center study, the United States has the highest rate of children living in single-parent households in the world, with 23% of children under 18 living with one parent and no other adults.” In the African American community 7 out of 10 families are single-parent. As an African American this topic is relevant for me and should be for every American. This discussion needs to start in middle school and be further discussed in college. American families are in a crisis and don’t let the deceptive media fool you. What they did is diabolical because he never said women should stay at home. Listen to the speech and don’t let the media frame it for you.
Why didn't he spend his time telling the men to take responsibility for their kids? Why didn't he tell them that they've been fed a bunch of lies about having it all? Why didn't he tell the men that they should stay home with the kids if his wife wants to pursue a career? You missed the message.
As a catholic I found everything he said disgusting and fearful.
Really? Maybe time for some RCIA refreshers
He went full Mel Gibson. Just minus the antisemitism.
I'm not Catholic but a woman and feel the same!🤔👱♀️😏🤨
i dont understand how religious women havent caught on to the fact these religious men hate women, they think theyre going to treat them and the family well because they talk about god ect but all these men are basically steven crowders who sell women the dream of a traditional life then leave them with nothing.
Same here. “Homemaker” is a luxury for oh 3 decades +. Peace be with you. 💙💙
there are millions of these men . wake up people
100 s of Millions and the same with Woman that want to be Wife and Mother.
@@amercanmade2685 as well as control over thier lives and bodies
@@amercanmade2685 You're literally afraid of stay at home moms 😂 It's beautiful 😂😂😂
No one is afraid of stay at home moms. We dont want you all pushing roles on all women. You do you@racheljames7
@@RoadrunnersOfCA You hate them for being happy because your miserable.
See a psych
That speech was despicable.
Call in the Minions.
The applause, rather than booing, as he tearfully described his own wife's "fulfillment as a homemaker" was a real shocker for me. 😠
Hes happy shes happy.
Most affected: american leftists.
As a cradle catholic who attended parochial school for 12 years, am a mother and a homemaker and I work, I am highly offended. I assume some of those women are as well. Thanks for giving the democrats more votes!
Well, don't the polls usually say that white men are the ones voting for Trump?
I commend your efforts and dedication to your family and yourself. We also are offended. We are several generations of Catholics. He is basically insulting working moms everywhere.
Cradle Catholic here too. At my older sister’s HS graduation our bishop gave a speech. It was a girls’ school and most students were expected to attend college. The bishop’s speech was encouraging not anything like this. This was 1973. When I graduated in 1976 our valedictorian went on to be an aerospace engineer. I had many doctors and lawyers in my class. I worked in accounting until retirement.
@@nancytrevino9750 What's really funny is that Nuns are usually very talented and do not fit Butker's narrative
How incredibly dismissive of all the women in that graduating class. More women are going to college now, many households can’t financially support a family on one income. How insulting.
For the last decade women actually graduating with a degree and working in a professional field has been outpacing men and that gap has been growing. Instead of working to lift up those who are putting in the effort this muppet wants them to slow down to his pace.
Families are not (anymore ) able to support themselves based on 1 income, why is that?
Frankly, I went to college to get educated about the world NOT contribute to supporting a family.
Do you notice many of these woman in college are protesting for men to control their lives completely. The Palestine protests? Father chooses your religion and spouse, then spouse controls what you wear, eat, say etc. it’s amazing to see others upset for the words that Butker spoke when he was speaking truth. He was explaining marriage and family as it has been since the Garden of Eden. He never said he controls her but shows admiration for who she is and sacrifices she makes for her family. Which is beautiful! Great man! ❤️
@@MarkZolezi no one said that nor did Harrison.
Butker should be reminded that the NFL stands for " Not for long"....
I was educated by the Sisters of Scholastica and I am sure that they were not pleased.
No one knows who that is and no one cares
They weren't pleased. They wrote a response.
It's the same group that get butthurt if you got on your knee at a sports game.
I would love to know if he gets treated like Kaeppernick.
He didn't give the speech at a sports game. That would be wrong because not everyone in the stadium shares his beliefs.
@@Lerian_V Oh no, a silent knee on the sidelines during a song is soo bad! Okay Karen.
@@Lerian_Veveryone at the school shared his beliefs?
If we deploy "shared beliefs" as a baseline, the consumption of alcohol is not a shared belief. What gets consumed at a football game with 50,000 people who don't all share beliefs?
@@Lerian_V I went to a Catholic high school and not everyone there was Catholic
Did you see his emotional blackmail with that fake tear of “his wife’s story”?🙄🤡 Absolutely pathetic!
Yes…🤮
Crocodile tears.
happiness and thanking God for his true faith ; the Catholic faith
Tremendous uplifting speech and we need more of this each day
Yeah what a creep
Pure theatre! What I find so offensive is that mr. football kicker is part of a larger movement .... so narrow and dogmatic. So boring!
Best thing anyone can do is IGNORE everything But head said
You must hear that a lot
Women at home = happy,
you say women dont stay at home
What do you think will happen to a womens happiness when you tell them not to do something that actually makes them happy.
My mom was home when I grew up, but she was free to do whatever she wanted, and she wanted to be home despite being the valedictorian. My mom was always there and I respect her mighty deeds. She was the strong one. Just stop.
The joke is on him. In every developed nation, where women are able to forge their own careers, rather than being forced into being homemakers, the nation benefits both economically and socially. Giving women more power over their own lives does in fact reduce such things as unwanted pregnancies and abortion, while boosting the economy with a larger workforce.
The simple truth is that empowering women benefits us all.
Yes! Exactly! The economic success of the United States since WW2 came from the inclusion of women in the workforce and granting women full rights as citizens (starting with voting rights in 1920).
These christofacists want the return to the US social structure of 1900 and will bring the US economy to that of the US in 1900 as a result.
And in a society where women can work, the pressure on men to produce is reduced. This creates a more peaceful society as men are less agressive, less likely to commit serious crimes, or have mental issues. Women have spent decades working on doing their part, yet when it comes to men doing the work to do more in the home, in the family care and there is immense pushback cause ego is more important that family.
There is a _little_ bit more nuance to it all than you're making it look... For example, the social and economic expectation now is that women have their own careers. It's significantly harder for couples/families to live on just one income now than it was, and polls show that far more women are unhappy in their careers than men.
Don't get me wrong, going back to the stereotypical gender roles would be an atrocity, all I'm saying is that it's not just black and white, it's all shades of gray, it's just a much lighter gray now.
Population in developed countries is dropping around the world. Babies' are expensive and so is rent. Late stage capitalism. Women should live well, no matter their lifestyle. The end.
It didn't benefit you. Google relationship between crime and single parent families.
Did any women graduates walk out? I would have.
Me too!
Hostages, er graduates remain there in their seats until they get diplomas.
It's a Catholic thing, you probably just wouldn't understand it, lol.
@@gregpaspatis9425Having been raised in a catholic school and Kindergarten: no, it is not a catholic thing. We would have walked out... together with the nun who ran the Kindergarten and school.
@@sisuguillam5109 He said it's a catholic thing not athiests running a catholic school thing.
Your experience being raised by non god fearing people isn't relevant to actualy religious people.
Taylor Swift did NOT coin the phrase "familiarity breeds contempt" .
That's hardly the point, if he mentioned his "teammate's girlfriend" he is the one tying her into it.
Haha yeah she did…It’s in the Bejewled chorus. Get your facts straight
@@isabellaspiers7463It may be in her lyrics, but she definitely did not coin that phrase! It was around long before she was born. 😉
@@ruthd5041 exactly. I am nearly 70 years old and it was spoken by my grandparents when I was a child.
@@rachelk4805 so he is just name dropping.
For those that didn’t catch on, all the women applauded after that speech and there were no boos.
Because they heard the whole speech.
Its just disgusting.
Yeah, he spoke against the disgusting degeneracy in the society.
How the woke left and the media (same thing) are dogpiling him for perfectly reasonable views is indeed disgusting.
/ex-Democrat
@@Lerian_V And what particular degeneracy is top of the pops on Fox News to day...fill me in.
Yeah who needs a dad
@@brianmartinez7530 We can have a Dad but please can we have one that's not a arsehole?
For those of us who don't follow sports, this fool will be known for this speech alone.
Every venue that the Chiefs will play at this upcoming season, this jerk will be booed.
@@juju-xx5xn only the venues that are full of beta males and feminists. I bet you go to all the football games and will experience this first hand.
He is a kicker so nobody really cares about him anyway
I don't even know this guy exist before this and I sure don't know his name and don't even want to know
Except he will likely be recruited and groomed by the RNC to run for office. A sports win/lose mentality works well when one views politics as a team sport. It's a big part of the problem.
As a woman with multiple degrees and has been home now with my children for the past 4 years, I wholeheartedly agree with his sentiment. Money 💰 can't buy the valuable moments shared with my children in the home. ❤
Butker by name, Butthurt by nature.
Butthead!
Yes, date of butthurt: birth!!
Try Champion 🏆 n life and Fatherhood... something men swimmin vs women know nada about... but that's eWe 🐑 son
woman can have careers and families 🤬 guess what? many of us can do it BY OURSELVES!!! no man necessary for survival 😝😝😝
I think that's what scare them
You might want to remind these men that before the pandemic, there were more women in the workforce than men. OK, so where were all these alpha men that were suppose to be working? They can't all be in prison or in the basement.
That's false. You absolutely need men for survival. The entire infrastructure of this country and every country was built and is maintained by men. Everything you need. Your home was built by men. Your plumbing, water, gas, electric, manufacturing, your vehicle and its maintenance, the roads you drive on, firefighters, law enforcement, farming, logistics for products to get on shelves are all worked by well over 80%-90% men in those fields. If you want to live your life independent with no men in your romantic life, that is absolutely your life and choice. I salute you. But like I said, you absolutely need men for survival. You take these things for granted until something goes wrong
Best of luck with that
@@T_WILL77 I think you missed her point. This was about women can fend for themselfs in their private lives. A woman doesn't need to marry a construction worker to get her house build, does she?
There is nothing salvageable about that man’s speech. I’ve seen it several times now and it just disgust me more and more each time. As a survivor of a marriage to someone later diagnosed as a narcissist, it absolutely churns my stomach to know that this is what some young women are hearing in today’s world. My daughter, my daughter is educated, her approach to life is eloquent, and her definition of a partner includes total equality- she would accept nothing less than. THAT is what the young women of today should be hearing and shame on anyone trying to place value on anything that includes hiding the light of our beautiful girls.
oh, and make that, "UNPAID baby factories." My mistake.
He is the one who should LOSE HIS NFL CAREER, not Colin Kaepernick!!!!! The misogyny is literally killing us women.
💯
Colin wasn't a good player, so why should he because he had most cops fired and the prisoner emptied.
@@joannlarson6386 Stop the excuses. He wasn't fired because he wasn't a good player.
It literally isn't, Karen.
@@joannlarson6386 Can you please explain how the "prisoner" was "emptied," and what Colin Kaepernick had to do with this travesty of the English language?
Can’t just be a homemaker anymore. Both people have to work. Not everyone is a rich football player Harrison. Jesus Christ what planet are these idiots on?
100 freaking percent.
Well, that's just because we've allowed the Rich to absorb the majority of the wealth. This is what the Christ warned us about with the Moneychangers; the current business model shifted benefits from the workers to management & the shareholders unlike the 50s & 60s
Not really, but one does need to know certain things to be able to afford to. If you were not taught those skills it is hard .
:) Planet Privilege, for sure... In any other setting he would have been taken behind the house by all the other girl's dads for spoiling that occasion!
they are planet God
You cherry picked segments that you thought would Make your speech sound like what he said was crossing the line somehow. He did not say that women had to become homemakers. He just simply mentioned that the best part they can play is being mother. I will bet you that if you ask 1000 women with children, what is a happiest part of their life they will tell you it is being a mother. Do not take things out of context.
He never said the only thing for woman is being a homemaker, what he said was ONE of the most important things will be a homemaker, you guys need to get it right. We can make a list of NFL players that have committed haneous crimes against woman and no outrage?? But this (Catholic) man speaking at a (Catholic) college to (Catholic) grads sharing basic (Catholic) beliefs, this man is the villain?? By the way he received a standing ovation that no one seems to notice. The outrage over this speech is the reason our current society is in decay. This was the best speech I’ve ever heard in my life!!
How was he not mercilessly heckled through the entire speech???
Yap, that`s what is actually worrying.
They all agreed with him.
It was a Catholic University, he was a Catholic Speaker. Ask why the MSM would decide to share this with an audience that doesn’t share the same values and doesn’t have to?
@@AwakenedFromWokeBecause they want to police the behavior of non-Catholics. We deserve to know about it.
@@Maelstromme as in they’re trying to virtue signal to their viewers that the highly edited clips and contextless commentary are something to be shamed?
Man what sexism an I'm so tired of these conservatives and this is coming from someone that is religious, it's insane stop it
Coward
My freedom to say I disagree with what he said, is equally protected.
Only thing missing is that the Female Grads were required to where Red Robes and white bonnets
The American Taliban! Love the sharia law much?!
I hope you don’t support hamas then. You definitely throw a fit if you knew what they believed him
This person is saying religious extremism is the same whereever radicalised religion is involved. @joeydiaz5927
It's at a catholic college. What do you expect?
Because he thanked his wife? You actually sound ridiculous.
@@kylermichael3972Diabolical lie? His wife's life didn't begin until she became a servant? Evil ideology of diversity and acceptance? Some point of views don't deserve respect
One step forward two steps backward. And then another 10 steps backwards.
Said the man in drag.
@@muddywater4505 A man in drag is funnily enough, typically more forgiving and understanding than a Conservative. Probably because of how much mud gets slugged at them for no reason.
more than 10 steps.....
The next step for the republican party is most likely will be is to remove the right to vote for women.... Welcome back to 1920
(Passed by Congress on June 4, 1919, and ratified on August 18, 1920, the 19th Amendment granted women the right to vote. The 19th Amendment legally guarantees American women the right to vote.)
@@muddywater4505 huh?
@@muddywater4505 troll bot.
It never ceases to amaze me that people in this country who claim to espouse freedom so much are the first to tell you how you ought to live your life. As as man, I would encourage women to live their lives in the way that is most fulfilling for them and certainly not listen to any men on that matter.
This guy needs to view the motion picture, "The Hours", to see Julianne Moore in a role that surprised me. It was heartbreaking for her character to submit to being a housewife. It changed my view on woman.
This conservative movement wants stopping!
Greetings and solidarity to all women in America from the UK.
Shocking address!
Yeah, Catholic teachings are shocking.
So only your opinions are important and should be tolerated right? hahahahahahaha
((( YAWN))) 🥱
It's a redundant ideology. Hi from Australia.
We fought for freedom from you people for a reason.
He’s either brainwashed or very slow…
Fox News?
Or both
Or maybe he just has a different opinion and we just need to accept that
@@vbrown4610 Stupid need not spread their ignorance and prejudice.
This is fair, congratulations for your unbiased reporting , MSNBC once again.
God bless this guy
God and misnbc have nothing in common. I'm only here to read the comments for opp research. You are like 500th and the first rational comment here.
If a woman wants to be (and, more importantly, has the MEANS to be) a wife and mother, then that is her right and privilege.
But to say that it is the way for ALL women is presumptuous at best.
This is Christian Nationalism and the platform of the GOP. This is what they are working toward and they want king trump at the helm.
I makes no sense to me why they back a man who is the opposite of everything Jesus taught! With “Christians” like these, no wonder that religion is dying.
See; Seven Mountain Mandate
Loving your wife is now Christian nationalism ..
@@dendradwar9464- That isn't love, it's control.
Well imagine if they were Islamic.
You really wouldn't like their conservative views then 😄.
Oh delusional religious people...
Religion is going to destroy this country.
Very delusional and contradiction religious people.
Delusional people are the ones that think that men can become women.
I found the when the bullets started to fly, we were all Christians!
Delusional AND hypocritical!
I guessing most of this audience didn't watch the speech.
I'm 74 years old and I see his speech as just a traditional values speech. It reflected the values most people believed when I was a kid. Most women didn't work when I was a kid. Most stayed home and raised their children. There were no child care businesses. I don't see anytime wrong with stating his point of view. There is no reason for this to upset the apple cart.
FYI. Taylor Swift is not a multi-millionaire. She is a BILLIONAIRE.
And she actually did it the old fashioned way….she earned it on ability.
Debatable...@@jjohnson796
@@jjohnson796 nobody can ever do anything to "earn" a billion dollars, without exception
I am sure Taylor would like to be excluded from this narrative.
She'd be much happier if she were married with kids.
He's not old enough or had enough life experience to give a commencement speech. He doesn't know women's minds.
Home maker is definitely the most important title a woman can hold and it’s very significant and important in society. Every woman will know this deeply after they hit 35 and have no marriage/ family.
"The tyranny of diversity, equity, inclusion." This is Orwellian double speak, pure unadulterated bullshirt. I get it, coming from Butker, intelligent thinking not being one of his strong attributes. He believes that words go together because "I dont' like that" so "I don't like diversity and I don't like tyranny so tyranny of diversity" makes sense to him. Except that isn't how words and ideas work, that isn't how thinking works. And, Butker will be the first one in line to follow some tyrannical authority. That there was an applause is saddening. What is amazing is how, like an AI ChatBot, he can speak with such seeming eloquence while having no capacity for intelligent thought.
My greatest sympathies to this man’s wife.
I feel more sorry for their daughter
@@ClowderOf3
That’s an excellent point!
@@ClowderOf3their daughter will be just fine. He’s entitled to his opinions, just like you are too. That’s how democracy works!!
@@kwamebushman606 No it isn't. Democracy is a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives. What you are trying to allude to is that he is entitled to his opinions because in the USA you have the right to free speech. Just like all of us here in the youtube peanut gallery .
@@kwamebushman606 Children who grow up with that gender roles nonsense often end up wounded and traumatised by unnecessary guilt, and they curse their upbringing for the rest of their lives. These teachings cripple marriages. It's good to point out when somebody's opinion can hurt people.