Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

Arthur Tells Mary-Beth About His Sickness

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 08. 2024
  • a warm, fleeting moment amidst all the surrounding chaos.
    Password: Store711
    VSPASS: Xbsof1234
    Password#2: Mili9909
    Password#3: 4)Myoa.ru
    Password#4: Moon7727
    Password#5: X5)myappstore.ru
    Password#6: Freegame12345
    Password#7: @Appstoreoa1
    Password#8: Sub123456
    Password#9: Like2202
    Password#10: Aa889988
    Password#11: Bg334455
    Password#12: Sub2ila99123456
    Password#13: Aa226699
    Password#14: @Jellopp/001
    Password#15: Sub2ila99
    Password#16: Subme123
    Password#17: Sub1234500
    Password#18: @Oaerotsapp4
    Password#19: Cc338822
    Password#20: @Appstoreoa1
    Password#21: Defo3303

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @offlinemeeting
    @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +54

    Thanks for hanging around!
    Here's a video of me shooting projectiles in mid-air without using Dead Eye: czcams.com/video/ePTV4IB7BC8/video.html

  • @Collateral0
    @Collateral0 Před 5 lety +10313

    Mary beth was always worried for everyone, first person to notice kieran was missing. True friend.

    • @ourlordandsaviour7529
      @ourlordandsaviour7529 Před 5 lety +34

      Didn't you get blown up by a satellite?

    • @lilsnail4434
      @lilsnail4434 Před 5 lety +279

      That made me think she liked Kieran

    • @hyperpixelz8831
      @hyperpixelz8831 Před 5 lety +15

      Aren't you supposed to be in Black Ops 2? THE DAMN C.I.A!

    • @nyx4323
      @nyx4323 Před 4 lety +144

      Lil Snail Once I saw them talking one to another in camp. And it seemed like they liked each other a bit. It was cute.

    • @westondickinson5309
      @westondickinson5309 Před 4 lety +12

      @Gamingrhino 07 seeing what it was like before rads and everything

  • @becausereasons9777
    @becausereasons9777 Před 5 lety +7172

    I like Mary-Beth. She's too pure for this world.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +356

      N. Harris she ended up writing romances, the cutie

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +193

      Mary Beth you liked arthur didnt you?

    • @BudokaiTH
      @BudokaiTH Před 5 lety +319

      So she seemed to be. I got a side mission of her and Sean[R.I.P] planning to rob a stage coach. Mary Beth was picked up by Dutch and Arthur when she about 15. She was being chased by some angry men, but they later discovered that she had stolen a bag full of expensive pocket watches. Girl is a master pick pocket. XD

    • @girf4233
      @girf4233 Před 5 lety +68

      Mary-beth is my waifu

    • @seanmaguire3289
      @seanmaguire3289 Před 5 lety +9

      @@JasonToddEatsCrowbars what are you doing here Mary

  • @bi0hazard921
    @bi0hazard921 Před 5 lety +6955

    If he wouldn’t tell anyone else I’m glad he told Marybeth

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +538

      Same sentiments. But then again, everyone knew without him telling anyone

    • @arthurmorgan1200
      @arthurmorgan1200 Před 5 lety +422

      Bi0hazard He told Charles as well

    • @DiegoMartinez-ur7gi
      @DiegoMartinez-ur7gi Před 5 lety +128

      Arthur Morgan well he knew without telling him when riding he told him I saw the doctor and it’s gotten worse

    • @arthurmorgan1200
      @arthurmorgan1200 Před 5 lety +17

      Diego Martinez Huh?

    • @PLGRN8R
      @PLGRN8R Před 5 lety +152

      I just wish he told Dutch. Like, definitively. He may have been too far gone at this point, but....

  • @oddfreaks6452
    @oddfreaks6452 Před 5 lety +3856

    Mary-Beth is practically is therapist at this point

    • @Xestern
      @Xestern Před 5 lety +140

      First thing I thought when I did this in Chapter 2. Only she ain't a scam like the dude in GTA 5

    •  Před 3 lety

      Karen does this to

    • @Virtual_FPS
      @Virtual_FPS Před 3 lety +31

      @@Xestern true, I feel like since gta v rockstar has learned better character development. And characters 😂😂😂

    • @pedinhuh16
      @pedinhuh16 Před 3 lety +18

      @@Virtual_FPS We can only hope they stick with that for GTA 6.
      I absolutely abhorred everyone in V, everyone was just so terrible in general that I couldn't really sympathize with anyone besides Michael and Franklin, but that was just a little bit.
      More over, I also absolutely hated how all of GTA V felt like a forced and not funny parody of the USA that is constantly on your nose about it, like everything was just one big and dumb sitcom.

    • @Extreme96PL
      @Extreme96PL Před 3 lety +10

      @@pedinhuh16Exactly GTA V story and characters so much throw me away that i almost skipped RDR2 but RDR2 turned out to be best game i ever played i really dont know what happened with Rockstar writers when they made GTA V story and characters GTA IV also have good story and characters but RDR2 is masterpiece in all aspects.

  • @ethanpfannkuch5510
    @ethanpfannkuch5510 Před 5 lety +8282

    "Its me.... I'm sick."
    "Sick?"
    "I might die.."
    *drunken Uncle strolls by*
    "He's got the LuMbAgO"

  • @thacc8216
    @thacc8216 Před 4 lety +746

    I like how the last chapter of red dead makes you miss the previous chapters. You used to run around towns doing whatever, like in any good rockstar game, but now you’re contemplating Arthur’s death.

  • @forceaidan8
    @forceaidan8 Před 5 lety +897

    I got this scene right after Arthur got Mary’s goodbye letter

    • @viveksingh.1729
      @viveksingh.1729 Před 2 lety +14

      Fuckkkk that tore me apart too, was kinda expecting some closure with her , and just like that , all gone and done with a letter .I was shocked

    • @yellowbirdie7182
      @yellowbirdie7182 Před rokem +12

      @@viveksingh.1729i guess that’s just how things go in such situations. Arthur couldn’t leave the gang(his family basically) and Mary couldn’t be fine with it.
      But in my opinion Mary putting flowers on Arthur’s grave is a sign that she cared, despite everything.

    • @pedinhuh16
      @pedinhuh16 Před 7 měsíci +1

      ​@@yellowbirdie7182she did cared, she also used Arthur for help but she absolutely had nobody else to help her when she needed it.
      She was the one who wanted them both to run away together on their second date, it's Arthur who shot that idea down because he was too involved with the gang to change.

  • @the_arizona_ranger0213
    @the_arizona_ranger0213 Před 5 lety +2620

    Arthur: *_Talks with Mary-Beth about sickness_*
    *_Stands up to leave_*
    *_Stares at cleavage_*

  • @ytn675
    @ytn675 Před 5 lety +1458

    Arthur was a really sweet man in the end

    • @colonelyungblonsk7730
      @colonelyungblonsk7730 Před 5 lety +32

      At least he wasn't a "nice guy"

    • @rainsplashwarrior7725
      @rainsplashwarrior7725 Před 4 lety +61

      He was always a sweet man, just more so in the end 💕

    • @codysykes5568
      @codysykes5568 Před 4 lety +12

      Arthur reminds me a lot of my grandfather and basically all of the male role models I've had in my life.

    • @coffeebeans7912
      @coffeebeans7912 Před 3 lety +2

      Not the way I played him

    • @SuperGUY12362
      @SuperGUY12362 Před 3 lety +1

      Not my Arthur...he was a savage until the end 😤

  • @1123gaba
    @1123gaba Před 5 lety +5568

    Always the doubts Arthur

    • @prowthegamer
      @prowthegamer Před 5 lety +307

      Dutch Van Der Linde
      Get out of here Dutch! You are a bad man!
      (11/27/18)

    • @stabbymcstabberson3177
      @stabbymcstabberson3177 Před 5 lety +421

      No Tahiti for you.

    • @hazardflow8141
      @hazardflow8141 Před 5 lety +162

      Your just mad that Mary liked Arthur's cute ass (no homo tho)and didnt like you 🤣

    • @elmemeking1458
      @elmemeking1458 Před 5 lety +141

      Just need alittle FAITH

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +109

      Johnny Soria lol Dutch certainly had a thing for Mary-beth

  • @Ese1Pac
    @Ese1Pac Před 5 lety +1975

    I always walked around camp after every mission looking for Mary Beth on the off chance that a romance between them might start lmao

    • @Cracknutter22
      @Cracknutter22 Před 5 lety +98

      Same

    • @vintage1520
      @vintage1520 Před 5 lety +56

      Me too hahaha

    • @DarkKnight15935
      @DarkKnight15935 Před 4 lety +169

      Me too lol especially after they both had a dance together

    • @yikes4946
      @yikes4946 Před 4 lety +25

      @@cemalkubilaytiftik2488 wasn't arthur like 36?

    • @issamaf80
      @issamaf80 Před 4 lety +69

      @@yikes4946 he died in the age of 35.

  • @mavrickmiller2755
    @mavrickmiller2755 Před 3 lety +228

    I love that Arthur opened up about his feelings and such throughout the game. He was such a well rounded character and just a real man.

    • @cassiedevereaux-smith3890
      @cassiedevereaux-smith3890 Před 2 lety +9

      The scene with the nun at the train station.

    • @Darth_atrocious
      @Darth_atrocious Před rokem +1

      There’s a whole hidden conversation in chapter 2 where Arthur tells the gang he’s struggling This game feels soo real and alive

  • @prowthegamer
    @prowthegamer Před 5 lety +2317

    Mary-Beth: “Maybe you’ll get better.”
    That right there made me sad.
    (11/27/18)

    • @stabbymcstabberson3177
      @stabbymcstabberson3177 Před 5 lety +52

      ProwTheGamer Why the date tho

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +38

      ProwTheGamer hits you right in the heart...

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +53

      conner Simmons maybe prowthegamer wanted to document the time he/she first heard the line. I do it too whenever i see or hear something elicits a strong feeling from me

    • @nathenbosher1067
      @nathenbosher1067 Před 4 lety +14

      @@offlinemeeting weird flex but okay

    • @cottony4dr
      @cottony4dr Před 4 lety +2

      ProwTheGamer that was the date I finished the game

  • @cheemythedrunkmonke
    @cheemythedrunkmonke Před 4 lety +948

    Dutch:”sees Arthur with tb”
    “Ok Arthur let’s Rob a bank

    • @Red_Beard2798
      @Red_Beard2798 Před 3 lety +82

      Or "Ok Arthur, let's rob a train"
      "Hey Arthur, blow up that bridge"
      "Hey Arthur, watch my back while I straight up murder these people"

    • @harshavardhan2836
      @harshavardhan2836 Před 3 lety +20

      @@Red_Beard2798 dutch:OrThur

    • @elcobra98
      @elcobra98 Před 3 lety +46

      I think that's the joke. Of all people he's probably the only one that doesn't realize Arthur is dying, he doesn't really care or maybe both. Even Milton or Mrs. Downes noticed Arthur's condition. Dutch has gone completely mad, blind and cares about nothing but his utopic plans and the ideas Micah's selling him.

    • @cheemythedrunkmonke
      @cheemythedrunkmonke Před 3 lety +2

      @@elcobra98 yea

    • @zk560
      @zk560 Před 3 lety +10

      @@Red_Beard2798 "Hey Arthur, lets start a war"

  • @christianjohnson5379
    @christianjohnson5379 Před 3 lety +243

    This would have brought a tear to my dad's eye if he had lived to see it. For over a year he battled stage 4 duodenal cancer. Like Arthur he faced mortality, and used whatever time he had left on Earth to spend time with family, get closer to God, etc. Despite being an older man at the age of 61, he loved playing video games, he loved the first Red Dead Redemption game and really got into the story, it's sad that he died no less than months before the trailer for Red Dead Redemption 2 came out.
    Arthur did the right thing being open about it with Mary-Beth. The only thing that was missing in my opinion was a moment for him to let out whatever emotions he was feeling about it. Even my dad had a vulnerable moment with me where he cried. Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is take a moment to let all that emotion weld up inside you to come gushing out.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 2 lety +19

      Oh, man I'm so sorry to hear that. Your dad deserved to at least see that Red Dead Redemption 2 existed. Thanks for sharing.

    • @Enno9
      @Enno9 Před rokem +3

      Rest in Peace😔

  • @IAmNotHim97
    @IAmNotHim97 Před 5 lety +500

    You know when I heard that this game was gonna end off with Arthur dying and John would take over, I was glad that I could play as John again, but once I got to know him while I was playing all I want to do is to be Arthur again

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +27

      me too

    • @Assassino275
      @Assassino275 Před 3 lety +21

      Same as the og game, and it doesn't help that john's antagonize lines aren't as funny as arthur's

    • @thatguy.namedmitch
      @thatguy.namedmitch Před 3 lety +12

      Exactly why I started a new game after 2 years. Arthur Morgan just might be one of the greatest video game protagonists of all time!

    • @ProtagonisTeneT
      @ProtagonisTeneT Před 3 lety +7

      First time I played I got so sad and upset about Arthur dying I just stopped playing and I still haven't finished The whole game

    • @Mr.Sax.
      @Mr.Sax. Před 3 lety +7

      That's what I wanted to happen when the game got announced in 2016, I think I told all my friends I didn't want to play with this new character, I wanted John. The game then gave me that and I wasn't happy at all.

  • @Isiauwuehrifi
    @Isiauwuehrifi Před 3 lety +1166

    I hate that during all of the "therapy sessions" in the camp with the ladies, my Arthur always goes "I been murdering people for no reason" and the girls go "that's not good Arthur" like bitch what u talking bout I'm literally at max honor

    • @big_slurp4603
      @big_slurp4603 Před 3 lety +77

      Stop shooting random people then

    • @EagleEye-rw5pn
      @EagleEye-rw5pn Před 3 lety +7

      Same

    • @luckcuzlag9057
      @luckcuzlag9057 Před 3 lety +95

      Well we did kill people in missions

    • @ieatbabies6535
      @ieatbabies6535 Před 3 lety +11

      Not me I'm the lowest of the lowest of honor🤔🤔🤔

    • @bishopbrennan3558
      @bishopbrennan3558 Před 3 lety +108

      @@big_slurp4603 Yeah but it happens even if you just accidentally hit one idiot with your horse, while Arthur acts like he's going around massacring people

  • @agafebriawan5715
    @agafebriawan5715 Před 5 lety +792

    Wait, that line "try to do the good thing" ended up in arthur's last ride sequence where u just need to press x to ride. So that's where it came from. I think I didn't get that in my playthrough but other people did so I was quite confused. Too bad I didn't get this cuz this might literally be Mary's last goodbye with arthur.

    • @Satchiate
      @Satchiate Před 5 lety +63

      I didn't get this, either, and I was so confused about where that line came from, too. I guess I didn't spend enough time in the Beaver Hollow camp cause it was so depressing, lmao. I'm on my second playthrough (taking it slower), and trying to spend more time in the camps, so hopefully I see it this time!

    • @RaynBlaze91
      @RaynBlaze91 Před 5 lety +20

      Aga Febriawan Same here, I always wondered where that quote was from and after my second playthrough I still had no idea about that last conversation with her until now. She’s a sweetheart.

    • @the_arizona_ranger0213
      @the_arizona_ranger0213 Před 5 lety +17

      Yes. I love that Rockstar did that. Included little signs of Arthur's past on his last ride.

    • @kavita2937
      @kavita2937 Před 4 lety +3

      lol I thought it was Karen saying it during Arthur's last ride

    • @noorulhasan4904
      @noorulhasan4904 Před 4 lety +2

      @@RaynBlaze91 I think u can get it if u have high honor and u didn't help Charlotte the widow and the downes family and the mission where Arthur kicks out Strauss from the camp

  • @83uwb
    @83uwb Před 4 lety +126

    I've always really liked Mary-Beth. She was always kind to Kieran, her love for books is absolutely wholesome and the way she cares about Arthur just wraps her character up nicely. I'm glad she got a happy ending, she deserved that.

  • @rorycooper237
    @rorycooper237 Před 5 lety +3031

    She defo liked him

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +629

      for sure! I believe there was another opportunity to sit down and talk to her back in chapter 1 where Arthur opens up about feeling bad during the times he refused to help people

    • @anarchonazbol6768
      @anarchonazbol6768 Před 5 lety +359

      @@offlinemeeting she talked to me a couple of times because I was killing everyone I came across on the trail

    • @bobsickle2336
      @bobsickle2336 Před 5 lety +933

      Well, she goes on to become an author who wrote a story about a girl who fell in love with an outlaw. Not hard to imagine that it's based on how she felt about Arthur.

    • @xxxellbrownoxxx
      @xxxellbrownoxxx Před 5 lety +40

      RoryCooper2 yep

    • @peaaanuuutz
      @peaaanuuutz Před 5 lety +276

      No man that's weird. She's more like a daughter figure to him (well, it's how I see it) like the rest of them gals, Tilly, and Karen. But damn, she is the most gorgeous dame in the game in my book. A talented writer as well. Not like that useless Mary Linton, but still I can't deny arthur his feelings for her, that's why I kept helping her out.

  • @McBRADzzz123
    @McBRADzzz123 Před 4 lety +767

    Arthur: (Worn voice, worryingly pale, coughing all the time, severely underweight and constantly at a loss of energy)
    Anyone finding out he’s sick: :O?

    • @flyingrancidm00nfish7
      @flyingrancidm00nfish7 Před 3 lety +96

      Its not like many of them bothered to find out that annoyed me. Only Mary-Beth, Charles, Uncle and Rev. Swanson actually asked and showed due concern (Hosea and Lenny probably would have if they made it). Just goes to show everyone else in camp had a me me me attitude after all Arthur does, even with low honor doing the least possible Arthur carried their asses across The Grizzlies, West Elizabeth, New Hanover, Lemoyne and Annesburg.

    • @jambamram8441
      @jambamram8441 Před 3 lety +30

      @@flyingrancidm00nfish7 I don’t know about that, considering John, Abigail and Sadie really cared for Arthur.
      I think it was more everyone was so worried about everything that they had no time to even notice Arthur’s sickness.

    • @jesusrodriguez3728
      @jesusrodriguez3728 Před 3 lety +27

      @@jambamram8441 even when arthur was taken and tortured there really wasn't much worry. For a family they sure were pretty high in tolerance to someone dying. Maybe it was cause they were used to it or even prepared. All the people that died barely get any recognition after the first day or so. The only person I know forsures was mentioned here and there till around the end was Hosea and even he was kinda brushed aside. It's not even like a lack of reaction but more like everyone is in their own shell. Hell Arthur doesn't even show worry or anything like that when he's on death row from TB. It takes him being on the verge of death to start being open. You get things here or there but nothing major from anybody. It's just surprising because for a dude that does so much killing, so many favors, so much to appease for this camp Arthur sure didn't get much of a reaction when he ended up missing or even that much when he finds his way to camp with gunshot wounds and bruised up. Don't get me wrong this game is great, but it sure doesn't ever let you forget that everyone here can just as quickly separate, die, turn on each other, or even forget about each other, as they can act friendly and familial. It all chalks up to each of them being not so great people already. Remember this is a band of thugs, thieves, murderers. Few of them AREN'T in those categories. One of which is a kid, his mother, and a young girl that ran away from home.

    • @spicy915
      @spicy915 Před 3 lety +14

      @@flyingrancidm00nfish7 i feel like most noticed, but they didn’t want to comment about it. micah knew, hence why he called arthur “black lung.” dutch knew, he commented about it twice. the rest of the gang definitely knew, just didn’t want to face the reality of someone facing TB

    • @thecumbender1432
      @thecumbender1432 Před 3 lety

      (Coughing blood)

  • @gtrman12887
    @gtrman12887 Před 5 lety +4110

    Arthur: I...I might die...
    ...
    .......
    Mary: oh I'm so sorry...
    .....
    .....
    Arthur: Well catch ya later then....

  • @xXSilentAgent47Xx
    @xXSilentAgent47Xx Před 5 lety +502

    "The whole world seems different now"
    It always did. Some people don't change. Some turn to be different. The world is being changed all the time and poisoned by the people.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +10

      xXSilentAgent47Xx wild west no more, my friend. F.

    • @ghost2.073
      @ghost2.073 Před 5 lety

      I see you on every video

    • @ellbent
      @ellbent Před 5 lety +16

      “People don’t change, they become more of their true selves.” -Rains Fall

    • @alfredaraujo9744
      @alfredaraujo9744 Před 5 lety

      Found ya again

    • @josefrasul8177
      @josefrasul8177 Před 5 lety

      Genji, Reaper, and McCree Thats what happened with Dutch and Arthur.

  • @JaneValentine007
    @JaneValentine007 Před 5 lety +174

    "Maybe its a sign, Arthur..."
    When hearing that in the scene and riding back to camp I couldn't stop myself from cryin.

  • @JaggedSallad2004
    @JaggedSallad2004 Před 5 lety +1783

    Arthur: Hey Micah!
    Micah: Yeah?
    Arthur: *Spits In Micah’s face*
    Micah: Ahhh!!! What the hell!!!
    *A few chapters later*
    Micah: Hello Scarface- *Starts coughing blood*
    John: *Shoots Micah*

    • @prowthegamer
      @prowthegamer Před 5 lety +29

      Putridfoe 65
      Oh I understand and damn.
      (11/27/18)

    • @memecliparchives2254
      @memecliparchives2254 Před 5 lety +40

      Mine would be like
      Dutch: I ain't got no much to say no more
      (Micah coughs, split second Dutch shoots him)

    • @Ozzymandias493
      @Ozzymandias493 Před 5 lety +12

      @Rick Thornebush and if you went back for the treasure

    • @willchalloner6643
      @willchalloner6643 Před 5 lety +29

      A cough would be more appropriate, TB causes lung damage , I don’t believe it causes sneezing

    • @girf4233
      @girf4233 Před 5 lety +8

      @@willchalloner6643 TB spreada thru blood, spit, sweat and other body fluids

  • @LouSassol69er
    @LouSassol69er Před 5 lety +389

    I never got to see alot of this stuff just because I didn't wanna be in that last camp for long

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +99

      Who Cares? Yeah it the air around that last camp was HEAVY as hell. I felt like I HAD to get away :’((

    • @maning04
      @maning04 Před 5 lety +95

      Me too.. It was too depressing to stay there.. I spent most of my time roaming around finishing the side quests and doing the right thing instead of going back to camp

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +10

      @@maning04 lol same

    • @aristonaragao3171
      @aristonaragao3171 Před 5 lety +70

      Same can be said about that fucking forest, around every corner was some creepy ass murfrees on your back, really hated the chapter 6 location

    • @the_arizona_ranger0213
      @the_arizona_ranger0213 Před 5 lety

      Thats not the last camp though. Y'all forgetting bout when Soy Boy Micah ratted them out after returning from Guarma and the Pinkertons got them in the swamps.

  • @shadowofdread7018
    @shadowofdread7018 Před 4 lety +63

    Mary-Beth: “I know... trust me I know.”
    *Arthur gets up*
    Arthur: “WeLl I’ll cAtCH yoU LaTer THen”

  • @haydenhaydo
    @haydenhaydo Před 3 lety +42

    I liked how the women in the group were always looking out for Arthur and telling him to stay away from Mary.

  • @burgercris
    @burgercris Před 3 lety +16

    “Try Arthur try and do the right thing”
    Those words hit harder during the last ride.

  • @seancoles2154
    @seancoles2154 Před 4 lety +52

    Great scene, the fact he tells 2 people this (Charles and Mary Beth) shows how much he valued her, them to had one of the closest and best relationships such a shame it wasn’t explored much

  • @yosoyyo9487
    @yosoyyo9487 Před 4 lety +28

    I just like Mary Beth so much she's exactly like my big sister, always there with you in your hardest time always seeing the best of everyone we all need a person like this in our life weather is a family member, or your girlfriend, or a friend even stranger in a street can make you feel better that's call being a true and good person there isn't many people like her that's for sure

    • @RembrandtRasmus
      @RembrandtRasmus Před 4 lety +7

      It’s good to have such people like your sister in life

  • @ArielYoursTruly
    @ArielYoursTruly Před 5 lety +372

    Did you guys know that there was supposed to have a relationship story between Arthur and Mary-Beth they decided to scrap it last minute it.

    • @TheChefShipwreckinAlaska
      @TheChefShipwreckinAlaska Před 5 lety +238

      Ariel Nivar There was also a plan to have Arthur travel across West Elizabeth to New Austin with Sadie, which was rumored to have a sort, or a hint at a love sequence. Sadly that was scrapped as well.
      Arthur gets no love man. 💔

    • @ArielYoursTruly
      @ArielYoursTruly Před 5 lety +72

      @@TheChefShipwreckinAlaska mybea it didn't fit because i guess he was planned to die from the start.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +74

      wouldve been cool to have a love sequence w charlotte though

    • @ArielYoursTruly
      @ArielYoursTruly Před 5 lety +96

      @@offlinemeeting i cant see that, Charlotte to me was a women that was helped out by Arthur and saw him a friend.

    • @the_arizona_ranger0213
      @the_arizona_ranger0213 Před 5 lety +6

      I think you pulled that right outta your anus and read it out loud. LOL! JK! I do think that is fake though. Lol.

  • @MonotoniTV
    @MonotoniTV Před 3 lety +16

    I like how calm the conversation is. It's serious but quiet and calm. The diagnosis really changed Arthur.

  • @thestonedwitch
    @thestonedwitch Před 3 lety +32

    Seeing this brought a tear to my eye, had the same conversation with my close friend a few years ago

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 3 lety +12

      Oh man, that's truly somethin. I hope you (or your friend) overcome the hardships that weigh you down.

  • @K1NG0FW0LV35
    @K1NG0FW0LV35 Před 5 lety +32

    *has a depressing conversation* "WELL LETS TALK MORE LATER" *in a happy tone*

  • @archangel6749
    @archangel6749 Před 3 lety +31

    I unfortunately skipped all of this during my first playthrough. My second time through, I found all of these redemptive moments for Arthur to be so incredibly profound. I had a newfound appreciation for the game.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 3 lety +1

      Glad for you! Love it when you get more from rewatching (or in this case replaying) something

  • @lukeharrington4889
    @lukeharrington4889 Před 3 lety +27

    On my first playthrough I didn't realize how deep Arthur was , playing through for the second time and not rushing through everything it's changed my own perception this was was one of rock stars finest

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 3 lety +3

      I agree! I hope they make a new red dead game though (or a new Bully game would be amazing)

    • @lukeharrington4889
      @lukeharrington4889 Před 3 lety +2

      @@offlinemeeting I've wanted a new bully game since I was young playing canis canem edit on ps2

    • @Will-gg1zr
      @Will-gg1zr Před 2 lety +1

      I did the exact same thing, you see people say they wish they could play the game for the first time again, I enjoyed it far more on my 2nd playthrough and the playthroughs after that. I finished it 3 days after it launched because I didn’t want anything online to spoil it for me.

  • @spangeboob2041
    @spangeboob2041 Před 4 lety +91

    Arthur: "I'm gonna die from tuberculosis"
    Mary Beth: "I'm so sorry"
    Abigail: "lol, bye"

    • @McconneIIRet
      @McconneIIRet Před 3 lety +2

      Why would Abigail say that

    • @yellowbirdie7182
      @yellowbirdie7182 Před 6 měsíci

      Nah, Abigail was shocked by this but there wasn’t any time for that, plus she was more worried about the safety of her kid. And in epilogue when Uncle mentions Arthur she starts to cry. This interaction is on yt, check it out if you’re interested

  • @valentine5491
    @valentine5491 Před 4 lety +21

    I feel like when Mary said try and do the good thing, it was the game hinting at you to get the high honor ending

  • @bloodheart56
    @bloodheart56 Před 3 lety +13

    mary beth: maybe youll get better
    arthur: no i dont think so
    dutch: HAVE SOME GODDAMN FAITH

    • @Albatross0913
      @Albatross0913 Před 2 lety +1

      "YOULL BE FINE ARTHUR. I HAVE. A PLAN."

  • @noahmeme2
    @noahmeme2 Před 3 lety +17

    Marry Beth is perfect. She's cute and sweet.

    • @cprow0997
      @cprow0997 Před 3 lety +1

      Bruh I’d plough her all night

  • @Idonotexist883
    @Idonotexist883 Před 5 lety +437

    Right.....
    YOU FORGOT TO ANTAGONISE MICHA

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +9

      Who1dat2eat apologies :(

    • @snowpawwolf1123
      @snowpawwolf1123 Před 5 lety +24

      Me: (Replays entire game just so I can antagonize Micah every chance I get)

  • @freeziboi3249
    @freeziboi3249 Před 5 lety +284

    Why was there no hugging? I feel when you hear that from someone, they'd need a hug. It doesn't cure the disease, but it does make them feel atleast a little better.

    • @Konsertt
      @Konsertt Před 5 lety +53

      Would you hug a guy with tb?

    • @godlikemachine645
      @godlikemachine645 Před 5 lety +69

      @@Konsertt skin contact wont spread tb so hugging is ok

    • @freeziboi3249
      @freeziboi3249 Před 5 lety +28

      @@Konsertt I never said I'd kiss the person, a hug wouldn't contract it.

    • @CellJr.
      @CellJr. Před 5 lety +39

      Arthur was a big strong lug, and an outlaw, I don't think he would want a pity hug.

    • @blackouthorus1519
      @blackouthorus1519 Před 5 lety +9

      cause you dont always need a hug to survive maybe just a few words

  • @YodatheHobbit
    @YodatheHobbit Před 4 lety +10

    I love how if you have high honor her line during the last ride always plays. ALWAYS. "Maybe it's a sign Arthur, try, try to do the good thing".

  • @benjaminrobinson7203
    @benjaminrobinson7203 Před 3 lety +12

    "I-I'm real sick, Mary Beth... LuMbAGo."

  • @EmyLaGargola
    @EmyLaGargola Před 4 lety +22

    “Do the right thing” also sister Calderon told him the same thing.

  • @JayJay-wf2oe
    @JayJay-wf2oe Před 3 lety +13

    Mary Beth was my favorite female character in the game. She was the only one who constantly cared about Arthur's life and wellbeing. I'm happy that she got a good ending, though I'd wished she and Arthur would have a romance option.
    She deserves Arthur more than the other Mary who always asked Arthur to give without returning anything.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 3 lety +2

      Hard same over here. But sadly, Arthur had to pay for all his bad deeds.

  • @JJShalashaska
    @JJShalashaska Před 3 lety +12

    Arthur did the good thing in the end. He won, because he managed to gave a true life to John and his family. He was a good man

  • @diegovera1213
    @diegovera1213 Před 3 lety +9

    I feel that, even though they never showed feelings for each other, if Arthur had asked her to run away with him, she would've

  • @ytn675
    @ytn675 Před 5 lety +30

    R. I. P. Arthur Morgan.

  • @RM.Theaters
    @RM.Theaters Před 2 lety +6

    “Maybe it’s a sign, Arthur…try…try to do the good thing.”
    Such a good quote.

  • @TheManWhoLaughs2008
    @TheManWhoLaughs2008 Před rokem +4

    My honor was high af and everytime I sat down with her she asked what was wrong and the response was always “I been killing a bunch of animals and innocent ppl” yet I never did any of those things. 😂

  • @Nubby6370
    @Nubby6370 Před 4 lety +12

    I love how at first in the game your like "SHOOT EM UP KILL EVERYONE" than by the end your like "sob sob sob" this game is awesome/VERY sad

  • @freebooterluckless
    @freebooterluckless Před 4 lety +11

    I really liked the parts of the game where you could just talk to Mary Beth or Karen and see Arthur’s thoughts displayed in front of you. It really gives you a perspective of the type of man he was

  • @GBP242
    @GBP242 Před 5 lety +49

    Damn, I totally missed this one. Thanks for the upload

  • @James_Ketchum87
    @James_Ketchum87 Před 2 lety +3

    this is almost like counseling for Arthur, trying to help him through his problems, thats why i like Mary Beth.

  • @Shockwave99999
    @Shockwave99999 Před 3 lety +7

    It’s interesting how this dialogue, whether you interact with Mary Beth here or not, plays during Arthur’s final ride to camp when u have high honor.

  • @DEXOTAProduction
    @DEXOTAProduction Před 5 lety +73

    he should've gave her a little arthur

  • @duineeireannach6588
    @duineeireannach6588 Před 4 lety +10

    the tuberculosis was going to kill Arthur but it made him see the brighter path for his friends and the evil inside Dutch.

  • @Luke.ChristWalker
    @Luke.ChristWalker Před 3 lety +8

    It’s off screen moments like this that truly show how much soul this game has...

  • @powermasterjazz
    @powermasterjazz Před 3 lety +10

    I liked Mary-Beth. I was hoping she and Arthur would get together.

    • @Erizedd
      @Erizedd Před rokem

      A lot of people did. lol

  • @tomdylan2074
    @tomdylan2074 Před 5 lety +114

    She's in love with Arthur (duh)

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety +25

      I don't blame her

    • @stadbab
      @stadbab Před 5 lety +5

      girl would jump that so fast

    • @ayrtonw8840
      @ayrtonw8840 Před 5 lety +5

      If you look at other videos she actually had something toward Kieran. Maybe when he died she began to like Arthur? Idk

    • @theyoungwolf9852
      @theyoungwolf9852 Před 4 lety +16

      She definitely had a crush on him I walked past her in camp after the poker job and had a shave and hair cut and she said something along the lines of oh nice haircut Arthur who you trying to impress

    • @pavlegrebenarevic382
      @pavlegrebenarevic382 Před 4 lety

      yeah you can tell by her shitty reaction right?

  • @yagfiremoobko9059
    @yagfiremoobko9059 Před 5 lety +9

    "Were thieves.. in a world that dont want us anymore..."

  • @ethangatenby2547
    @ethangatenby2547 Před 3 lety +5

    Mary-Beth was always caring, in the end it turns out she got to do what she loved, u can find her as John and she says she writes romance novels

  • @Luka-ty4qr
    @Luka-ty4qr Před 4 lety +4

    Mary-Beth is such a sweet character, making sure everyone is ok in the camp and has someone to talk to ❤

  • @Asher8328
    @Asher8328 Před rokem +2

    I don't think I ever saw this scene, thanks for posting it. I would still get Mary - Beth's quote about trying to the good thing during Arthur's final ride but not know where it came from.

  • @alejandrobonilla3049
    @alejandrobonilla3049 Před 5 lety +40

    Mary-Beth is best girl

  • @Kooaid-9
    @Kooaid-9 Před 3 lety +5

    Crazy how much his death really hurt me... I miss him as if I knew him in person. One of the greatest characters in a long time..

  • @jackwarr4251
    @jackwarr4251 Před 3 lety +3

    “It ain’t always clear what that is, not with the big stuff.” a very important line.

  • @chokoon21
    @chokoon21 Před 5 měsíci +1

    The only Mary who’s always there for Arthur.

  • @thecowboy9698
    @thecowboy9698 Před 3 lety +4

    Mary-Beth seemed to be an angel, in a camp full of devils.

  • @ohmanhotham8823
    @ohmanhotham8823 Před 3 lety +8

    Actually insane I didn’t watch spoilers for 2 years. I’m in the point in the game where he is sick just didn’t do this convo yet. Fuck man, Arthur was so wholesome even tho I made him into a killer.

  • @reympab29
    @reympab29 Před 3 lety +11

    How lucky were those people who were in close contact with Arthur and didn’t got sick or infected of Tb. Just like Mary here.

    • @Albatross0913
      @Albatross0913 Před 2 lety

      It's not an easy sickness to spread like covid or the flu. With Tb you have to be in close contact in a closed space for days on end, which they weren't for the most part. It spreads easiest if you, say, spit blood in someone's eye. It spreads easiest through bodily fluids, for the most part it's not a huge risk airborne.

    • @reympab29
      @reympab29 Před 2 lety +2

      @@Albatross0913 Tb is also a risky airborne disease. And given Arthur lifestyle is miracle he didn’t develop the illness earlier. And he did coughed directly to some of his partners. And there’s the fight with Micah…
      While it’s true the risk is higher in close spaces, there’s still a risk in open areas, specially if you’re this close to a carrier like Mary Beth and several others were.
      You reading this from a Doc. 😉. Stay safe and healthy, mate. 💯

  • @milesupshur4179
    @milesupshur4179 Před 4 lety +10

    That campsite was really nice, Shame everyone started hating each other there

  • @geargrinder87
    @geargrinder87 Před 3 lety +4

    - "Why don't you just fix it with some Potent Miracle Tonic?"
    -"Sh."

  • @davisbowe8668
    @davisbowe8668 Před 5 lety +83

    Watching this scene just makes me disappointed that Arthur couldn't romance any of the women in the game. The game would have been completely perfect if Rockstar had added a Bioware-esque romance system.

    • @Death-jl1cv
      @Death-jl1cv Před 4 lety +35

      It’s perfect because he didn’t do that even tho he could.
      His stubbornness & being too loyal are part of his character development.

    • @avapilsen
      @avapilsen Před 2 lety +1

      Nah, I absolutely love that he was focused on the gang and the gang only. I mean, it wouldn't make sense if he can romance the women in the camp because he's always loved Mary and never left the gang for her.

    • @cassiedevereaux-smith3890
      @cassiedevereaux-smith3890 Před 2 lety

      'course, then they'd die of TB.

  • @HarleyQuinn_93
    @HarleyQuinn_93 Před 3 lety +5

    I would kill to have friends like Tilly, Karen (before the bottle), and Mary Beth. The way they force Arthur to talk without actually forcing him is just what I want. They just have this way of opening him.

  • @frozzytango9927
    @frozzytango9927 Před rokem +1

    I love these straight and deep talk we dont get much these days.

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před rokem +1

      Agreed. Spent hours upon hours just talking to NPCs in my first playthrough

  • @thepaperninja3123
    @thepaperninja3123 Před rokem +2

    Ah yes Mary Beth, the gang's own therapist

  • @syteanric
    @syteanric Před 2 lety +7

    This scene is so touching yet entirely missable!
    You won't hear Mary Beth in the last ride scene if you don't get this completely random encounter.... I was lucky to get it on my playthrough...
    "Trust me, I know... " she'd already decided to leave at that point.

    • @mike.21gigawatts
      @mike.21gigawatts Před rokem +1

      Do you know at what point of the chapter you need to be at to get this event? Or if there are any specific requirements. In all my 4 years of playing this game, it only occurred once for me.

  • @parquito4395
    @parquito4395 Před 3 lety +6

    I honestly think Mary Beth and Arthur had something, they always had these heart to hearts

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 3 lety

      same

    • @Erizedd
      @Erizedd Před rokem

      Well we know for sure that Mary Beth had a crush. I think Arthur knew she did, and found her sweet, but never acted on it first because of the feelings he still had for Mary, and second because he probably didn't want to stifle her light: her opportunity to become a writer (which he supported/encouraged several times) and actually make something of herself outside of this life of crime. I really loved them together.

  • @Childishxmarkeeloo
    @Childishxmarkeeloo Před 4 lety +2

    It’s crazy how even in negative honor Arthur is still kind a bit, like there’s good

  • @Hunk456
    @Hunk456 Před 2 lety +2

    1:32 "be gratefull that for the first time you see your life... clearly"

  • @bastiisalive
    @bastiisalive Před 5 lety +47

    *insert Hurt by Johnny Cash*
    How I wished Arthur couldve spread the seed to MaryBeth, Sadie and Charlotte, so at least when he died..he left some legacy

    • @freeziboi3249
      @freeziboi3249 Před 5 lety +43

      Shit a half Arthur half Sadie Adler baby? That kid would be a God among men.

    • @colinpreston80
      @colinpreston80 Před 5 lety +6

      bastiisalive Definitely with Charlotte. If John meets her later, you could have had a great scene with John telling the child about Arthur.

    • @TheChefShipwreckinAlaska
      @TheChefShipwreckinAlaska Před 5 lety +10

      While I’m no physician I can probably go on a limb here and say that wouldn’t be a wise decision. TB, otherwise known as Tuberculosis is a contagious lung disease that spreads through air contact associated with coughing or bodily liquids such as spit. Spit or saliva to be exact would also fall under the category of semen, and if Sadie or any of the other woman got preggers they’d not only get the disease but subsequently die. The cure for TB would be excessive amounts of antibiotics however they wouldn’t be available until the discovery of it in 1907 in Germany, the first use of it in France in 1911. and wouldn’t go nationwide in the US until the mid 1920’s, and even then the morality rate would well be over 50%.

    • @BrownxPrid3
      @BrownxPrid3 Před 5 lety +4

      Red dead redemption 3 confirmed

    • @offlinemeeting
      @offlinemeeting  Před 5 lety

      my top 3!

  • @Ace-fi8vs
    @Ace-fi8vs Před 2 lety +3

    always loved Mary, tilly, and karen. Karen was funny to me, tilly and mary were kind, i felt so bad for arthur..

  • @Xaevryn
    @Xaevryn Před 3 lety +2

    "Sit down, Arthur."
    "I'm trying, damnit!"

  • @aryanarthur4486
    @aryanarthur4486 Před 3 lety +1

    This just cured my tuberculosis. Thank you Mary-beth, i am glad i told you about it.

  • @AsuraDarkKnight
    @AsuraDarkKnight Před 2 lety +4

    I’m really glad Mary-Beth was one of the ones who went on to live a good life

  • @dismayingmist7868
    @dismayingmist7868 Před rokem +5

    The part we’re Mary said Maybe you well get better made me tear up , I think Mary is a pure hearted character , I wanted to Antagonize Ms Grimshaw for screaming at her , I don’t know if she slapped her , but I almost lost respect for her , This video is heartwarming, great video

  • @tnty1561
    @tnty1561 Před 4 lety +1

    In this day and age, I just can’t help but WONDER how two human beings can actually SIT with each other and just....be social.

  • @YodatheHobbit
    @YodatheHobbit Před 4 lety +2

    I was so proud to see Mary Beth in an office, employed, in beautiful clothes during the credits.
    Like John, Mary Beth and Tilly and Person also made it!

  • @roachy72
    @roachy72 Před 2 lety +4

    I really liked how i had the meter completely in the red, being full evil but after Arthur got TB, I managed to get the meter to swing over to completely good morality before talking to the nun at the train station (and no, i didnt do it by spamming the horse brush, just by always choosing the good choice in every story mission/random encounter from that point on). what an awesome game

  • @getbamboozled2096
    @getbamboozled2096 Před 3 lety +3

    “That which is killing you will help you, finally to see. And see clearly friend. See and hear”
    -Blind man

  • @UnPokemon
    @UnPokemon Před 3 lety +2

    "You don't like fine"
    You do be looking fine however Mary-Beth

  • @stephenmason9527
    @stephenmason9527 Před 3 lety +1

    Mary-Beth always seemed like she never belonged with a bunch of outlaws in a gang. Soft heart and all that

  • @wolfymie8265
    @wolfymie8265 Před 3 lety +2

    Classic The Arthur scene Bootiful TwT

  • @SWildMF
    @SWildMF Před 4 lety +5

    I always liked Tilly. I would talk to her the most.

  • @drakehanna9044
    @drakehanna9044 Před rokem +2

    The older you get the more you realize That even if Arthur didn’t die of tuberculosis he wouldn’t have had a happy life or a very long one he was wanted by many men and wanted many men dead by the end of the game I don’t know if he could’ve let that go or outran it so I’m glad he got his good in when he could

  • @TheXbandit
    @TheXbandit Před 6 měsíci +1

    I hate to admit this but 5 years on it still breaks my heart😂 i remember when i first played this i was 14 and when Arthur died i cried like a baby🤣🤣