I never knew this video of mine would get this many views for a channel that started seeking no attention in the first place lol Never knew, again, that this little quiet mission with no gunfight at all would attract this many people hahaha No wonder this game has something that still resonates in everybody's mind after a decade. Man, Red Dead is a blessing! I thank all of you RDR fans around the world 😀
Back in those days, young women were compelled to read whatever correspondence she received aloud to her family. That's why love letters had to be dropped off in absolute secrecy rather than be sent via the post.
That part when Bonnie was looking at John when he left. I felt bad for her. She liked him and was disappointed he was taken. Then she carries on when the other rancher greets her. Still though she took another look at John as he left. As you can see, there weren't alot of smart men with honor who do the right thing. John was a gentleman with grit and maturity when the time called. What a great game.
@@Jack.Martson Jack also became an outlaw rather than leave the outlaw life. I mean I don't blame him, that's all he knew in life, but doesn't seem as cool or admirable as John.
Well it's every wagon riding mission in the game pretty much. Only on my second playthrough I took it slower, when I realised loosing dialog for riding too fast.
@@TheSpekkel1 That’s exactly what I was trying to do while recording this, but that dang time limit got the better of me 😝 Regarding the dialogues along the way, I still hear new stuff here and there if I retry any missions. I’m pretty sure the same goes for RDR2, as well. Red Dead is crazy in that aspect…
@@Great_White21 I kinda dislike the horses in rdr2 because they feel freaking slow and it's a pain when you have a tight schedule. One of the reasons rdr 2 sometimes pisses me off
@@reallysadweeb4454 A chad is a guy who thinks he's the shit and that every woman instantly wets their panties when within 1000 feet of him. John isn't a chad.
Y’know as they were talking about Jack, it made me realize no wonder the kid stepped in his fathers shoes. It’s literally ALL he knew. He literally grew up the life of an outlaw. Was raised in gang, saw that gang fall apart, chased by the Feds all his life, kidnapped twice, saw his father gunned down, and this left him scared and confused until all that was left was rage and vengeance. And he became an outlaw just like his dad. I guess it’s kinda true. For an outlaw, you can never really leave the life behind. God, I love R* for giving us RDR
Agreed. And to think that Jack literally lost everyone in his family he held dear(Rufus included) in that young age, I guess its understandable for him to be a lost & hopeless outlaw against his father's wish. I feel so heartbroken for him. If you listen carefully during a gunfight as Jack, he shouts something like "I have nothing to live for!"... Poor kid
And so, John and Abigail continued to enjoy each other's company, and continued to be good neighbors to the MacFarlane's for the rest of their long, fruitful lives, and nothing bad ever happened to them after this. And no one can tell me otherwise!
“aint the first time i had a gun to my head… remember your marriage proposal?” *john remembering a nice boat ride after some photos and a movie* “very funny…????…”
@@RedDeadReplay thats actually a dialogue from one of the hindi movies here in india.. a person advising his friend to propose his girlfriend on a boat.. so he says that 😅
This was the quickest mission to get from his ranch to her this person went the long ass way just take the shortcut via the train station at the bottom of tall trees an across the stream that was blocked off at the start. Takes like less then 2 minutes smh
@@NIGHTSTALKER848 why do you play these games? They aren't meant to be done "as quick as possible", go play fortnite or one of those other dumbass games if you want no story, and boring gameplay
The thing I like about Abigail is how desperate she is to make their live just working. It's not that she is just jelous. She is just instantly afraid that the whole life they built will fall out. That's why she sees danger everywhere. And looking at their past... Well... You can't really blame her...
Well they are both actively on the run and wanted for Murder among other things. Abignail Shot a law enforcement agent in the head the last time she escaped from captivity while being transported to be tried for murder. Murder has no statute of limitations, John is a fool for hanging around in these any of these states he needed to fake his death. His only chance was to take his family and leave the country.
Yep and they have a lot of character too with the added sharpness and this weird contrast i cant quite put my finger on, makes it look like a gritty western comic
The title says Jealous Abigale, but we all know it's Bonnie whose 'really' jealous. That end was like a silent "I hope you realize how lucky you are Abigale.."
@@RedDeadReplay Everywhere I went whether school, college, or office place female always outnumber male 3/10 ratio, sometimes i'm the only male in the class with female lecturer. At least most of them decent enough to work with. edit: I can relate Abigail with my mom.
I admire him for that. I’ve always liked the way how John dodges any BS from anybody and actually outwits them back when talking. When I was younger, I really wanted to take after him lol
Now that I'm older Bonnie has become one of my favorite female characters ever written. Tough as nails and determined but still has a bit of the sweet country girl charm. The kind of person you can turn to when times are dire but would also be more than happy to help out when her time comes to push.
All spelled out well, dear sir. She’s my favorite female character as well. She’s independent and helping, but also accepts she needs someone’s help when necessary and appreciates the good gestures. I think the two qualities complement each other in such a good way with other people, exchanging human interactions. I think we all can say the same for Sadie, too. Amazing women.
@@RedDeadReplay Sadie is a joke caricature of a """strong""" female character compared to Bonnie. Zero weaknesses, can take on dozens of taller, stronger men all by herself, and her "personality" (if you can even call it that) is just... "psycho". That's it. She kills people and acts "cool". Wow, much personality. At least Bonnie has humanity, and actual weaknesses
@@thomasvleminckx Sadie is literally traumatized by her husband's death. She doesn't act "cool," they purposely made her deranged because she's heavily grieving. She doesn't take on men in fist fights, she uses a gun, which last I checked, a man's physical advantage no longer matters with a literal gun. People who hate Sadie or call her Mary Sue/feminist propaganda don't understand her character at all OR the meaning of Mary Sue. She was far from perfect but fans liked her because she was at the very least loyal to Arthur.
Sadie is okay but not really interesting. Her character has been done to death by this point. Bonnie however is sweet and caring. And is tough. She doesn't have to act tough like how Sadie is.
@@RedDeadReplay If I remember in the proposal mission in RDR 2, Abigail mentions that they're already married. Maybe during the gang prime John proposed in unconventional ways
The way he says "STOP" at every full stop is honestly the cutest thing ever for a bounty hunter/outlaw to be saying. And the whole "read it out loud!" Is just hilarious, damn I miss this game.
I never got that feeling actually.. someone like Bonnie seemed a bit uppity.. I don’t think she would romance a mysterious fugitive with a complicated past.. Nor would her father allow her to either.
There was a clear attraction between the two, kept beneath the surface. For a video game, it was very subtle and well done, and it was the first time I remember playing a video game and thinking how effectively the performances were able to convey something like that without getting obvious about it.
Dutch: “We all had her” Arthur’s journal: “I shoulda tied the knot with ‘er” Arthur: “You don’t look like a Marston. Maybe a Williamson or Esuella.” Jack: *has a striking similarity to Javier with a bit of Dutch* Abigail: *is confirmed to have f-ed all the gang members*
Yeah, no kidding. I remember when I got to the Epilogue as John in RDR2, I felt so happy and sad at the same time to see the family living a normal life in that farm because all RDR1 fans know what’s slated to happen there later…
I had to do research on American society during the "wild" west, and you sir, are correct. Whether its intentional or not, the RDR series definitely seems like r* put a lot of time in doing their research instead of remimagining what/ how women behave and acted within a growing society
As a girl, one of my biggest complaints with video games is that they lack relatable and realistic women. Oftentimes they are overly sexualized or made to be very masculine to cover their feminine traits and justify strength. However, both Rdr1 and 2 have done a fantastic job with all their female characters. It’s such a relief to see so many women I can relate to.
@@RedDeadReplay it be nice a whole version where the whole 2 games play in the same map. You finish RDR2 and then it goes into *4 years later* screen. And rdr1 starts. And the rdr2 map is completely available. That'd be perfect. And if we could play undead nightmare in the whoooole map, that'd be even sweeter
When I first played through this game I caught the way Bonnie was acting when John was leaving and I said it even when I was young she had feelings for him and seeing this again only further confirms it for me Bonnie has feelings for John . Also I would love to see Bonnie again Inna bigger role then just a stranger mission in RDO
LoL that part cracked me up. John was smart enough to not say Bonnie was pretty. Admitting to your wife that you find other women attractive is a death sentence for most men
Man I loved the dialogue in the game and in this cutscene in particular!! The conversation flowed so smoothly and naturally and just brings out the charm out of these characters!!
"I've never felt so outnumbered!" *John has a flashback to going up the mountain for Micah, then has a vision of what happens in a few missions from that point*
That's common practice when reading telegrams. They actually said "STOP" in place of periods as well, due to the fact that punctuation was extra while four extra letters was free.
Abigail was most likely asking out of curiosity and not because of Bill's situation or past history. Bill is a closeted gay (there is several hints and comments to it in RDR2) so its most likely that when Abigail was the gang's prostitute, Bill didnt do anything with her.
If she truly had sex with the gang and it wasn't dutch messing with John, Abigail only was with Javier, Dutch, John himself and maybe Arthur (although based on Arthur's character and feelings for her, i doubt he would've accepted a one-night stand)
I really adore the way they addressed each other in the 1800-1900s Maam, Miss, Mister, Ms sounds really polite and earnest for some reason, respectful too
@@SQOUREE so in rdr2 arthur worked hard to get john a peaceful life with his family right, but in rdr1 john died as his past catches up to him and he doesn’t get a happy ending 😭 so i just consider rdr1 non-canon as a way to cope 😅 just a little joke yk?
I grew up playing this, so needless to say i got the 2nd A.S.A.P But i tell you, playing them in chronological order... is worth the time spent. It's like watching a 12 season Netflix Western
I never knew this video of mine would get this many views for a channel that started seeking no attention in the first place lol
Never knew, again, that this little quiet mission with no gunfight at all would attract this many people hahaha
No wonder this game has something that still resonates in everybody's mind after a decade. Man, Red Dead is a blessing!
I thank all of you RDR fans around the world 😀
Good job man 👍
This game is art 🤘
Thanks man
This is nice video :)
hi
@@atc5777 lame
Love how John takes a few moments to scan it before he reads it out loud, just in case
He didn’t read the last line of the letter which said “pls John I will give u 3 pp touch and show boobies”
@@Rockaholic237 😆
@@Rockaholic237 lmao
@@Rockaholic237 LMAO 🤣🤣
@@Rockaholic237 That was not funny and you should feel bad for making such an unfunny joke.
John: "I've never felt so outnumbered"
Yeah, buddy, we'll see about that in a few missions :(
Lmao
Its sad but the way you said it sound funny....!
Foreshadowing
Hehheh
😔
Abigail : what she looks like
John : sadie adler
Just because they are blonde? Lol
Владислав Булаев true 😂
Nothing like Sadie Adler I thought she looked like Anne Stokes
Bryan Salinas bruhhhh 😂
You wish
Lmao early 1900s version of “can I see your phone?” 😂
Lmfao 🤣
You're a genius
@@user-mg7wh8zq6v no he's in a relationship
Back in those days, young women were compelled to read whatever correspondence she received aloud to her family. That's why love letters had to be dropped off in absolute secrecy rather than be sent via the post.
@@BogeyTheBear wow really..?? Maybe Abigail felt the same about Bonnie’s letter then? Getting suspicious and jealous Haha
That part when Bonnie was looking at John when he left. I felt bad for her. She liked him and was disappointed he was taken. Then she carries on when the other rancher greets her. Still though she took another look at John as he left. As you can see, there weren't alot of smart men with honor who do the right thing. John was a gentleman with grit and maturity when the time called. What a great game.
Well put. I believe that’s why people like this scene so much. So much relatability and empathy there. What a great game indeed!
She can always have Jack lmao he close enough to John
@@Jack.Martson ain’t he a little too young for her? Haha
@@RedDeadReplay John was too old for her lol
@@Jack.Martson Jack also became an outlaw rather than leave the outlaw life. I mean I don't blame him, that's all he knew in life, but doesn't seem as cool or admirable as John.
I really felt bad for Bonnie. The way she saw Jhon riding away was a nice touch.
Indeed. Poor Bonnie
*jhon*
@@rukitlas7130 YnNeL!!!
@@rukitlas7130 *Arther*
Lubmago
Abigail: trying to have a normal conversation and a peaceful ride with her husband
John: *I AM SPEED INCARNATE*
Well it's every wagon riding mission in the game pretty much. Only on my second playthrough I took it slower, when I realised loosing dialog for riding too fast.
“i might run all the way to blackwater”
@@TheSpekkel1 That’s exactly what I was trying to do while recording this, but that dang time limit got the better of me 😝 Regarding the dialogues along the way, I still hear new stuff here and there if I retry any missions. I’m pretty sure the same goes for RDR2, as well. Red Dead is crazy in that aspect…
I always forget that in RDR1 the horses are on cocaine compared to RDR2
@@Great_White21 I kinda dislike the horses in rdr2 because they feel freaking slow and it's a pain when you have a tight schedule. One of the reasons rdr 2 sometimes pisses me off
"You knew the truth John, and they hated you for it."
That line really hits hard after playing RDR2.
Indeed. After RDR2, I got more into RDR1 with all those details aligned now
The line popped up the moment I read your comment lmfao . What are the odds lol 💀
Time?
@@RedDeadReplay when John said Dutch going crazy hit Bill the hardest is also good, as in red dead 2 we saw how fanatically loyal he was
Bible quote. Also a reference to Reverend Swanson?
Man the way Abigail ran to the wagon made me laugh. Lol
1:45 lol
@@RedDeadReplay when there's a train
She is a track star
@@achturas 🏃♀️ shes a runner, a track star 🌟
She is so cute
Abigail: She did blush when she saw you though.
John: *I'm aware of the effect I have on women*
Because of course John is a mega Chad.
@@Coffeehouse_Latte No? John isn't a self obsessed douchebag who thinks he's the shit.
@@TheFirstCurse1 Nice humor you got there
@@TheFirstCurse1 real chads aren’t assholes meaning John is a gigs chad
@@reallysadweeb4454 A chad is a guy who thinks he's the shit and that every woman instantly wets their panties when within 1000 feet of him.
John isn't a chad.
Abigail: "You know I cant read..."
John: "so you're so jealous that you can read the name of some woman but nothing else???
“Bonnie… something other” Now that suggests that’s as far as she can go there obviously lol
I thought that maybe Jack or the mailman read the name for her.
Mostly the mailman
But why he keep saying :STOP after every sentence?
@@Hungrycrib Apparently you haven't heard of a telegram
Abigal can’t read and John can’t swim well shit they’re the perfect couple
back then, illiterate is normal tho. but yeah they are perfect couple 🤣🤣🤣
I doubt Abigail can swim neither
Wait, If she can't read how'd she know the letter was from Bonnie?
@@imyourdaddy5822 My guess, Jack read it.
Technically all rdr1 characters can't swim
Y’know as they were talking about Jack, it made me realize no wonder the kid stepped in his fathers shoes. It’s literally ALL he knew. He literally grew up the life of an outlaw. Was raised in gang, saw that gang fall apart, chased by the Feds all his life, kidnapped twice, saw his father gunned down, and this left him scared and confused until all that was left was rage and vengeance. And he became an outlaw just like his dad. I guess it’s kinda true. For an outlaw, you can never really leave the life behind.
God, I love R* for giving us RDR
Agreed. And to think that Jack literally lost everyone in his family he held dear(Rufus included) in that young age, I guess its understandable for him to be a lost & hopeless outlaw against his father's wish. I feel so heartbroken for him. If you listen carefully during a gunfight as Jack, he shouts something like "I have nothing to live for!"... Poor kid
Well said.
Your* past always catches up.
Red Dead Revenge
It’s implied in the story that Jack actually became a writer, so it turned out better than expected.
"if you find yourself in a hole, the first thing to do is stop digging"
That unironically made my day much better, thank you John
A word of wisdom right there
"I've never felt so outnumbered." -Someone who has spent the last years of their life being outnumbered on a regular basis
Well I mean its as Sadie says, John is worth ten men lol
Well that's the whole point of his joke, they both know he's taken on hundreds without fear and came out alive
That's the joke, note his sarcastic tone.
No shit
Even at his last breath he was outnumbered LMAOOOOO
And so, John and Abigail continued to enjoy each other's company, and continued to be good neighbors to the MacFarlane's for the rest of their long, fruitful lives, and nothing bad ever happened to them after this. And no one can tell me otherwise!
Agreed. Don’t forget John’s happy interactions with Jack and Uncle, too. They all lived happily together ever after. Period!
"Nothing bad ever happens to the Marstons!"
@@Frazer2 N E V E R
*YES*
Boy do I have some bad news
I'll never forget that scene where Bonnie starts pawing at the ground. So brilliantly done
Agree. Throughout the course of the game there isn't one iota of personal interest hinted on Bonnie's part until that very moment late in the game.
I thought she was going to do the Joker dance 👁👄👁
@@anquoc3410 😂😂
It is even sadder when you realize it is the last time she will ever see John
@@unclelloyd no
6:23 We've all felt like Bonnie
Too true.
I can agree
Never knew this, hit me quite hard
Y’all would like to get it into somebody who’s in marriage and ruin it? Wtf
@@Chihiro143 not what they meant lmao
“aint the first time i had a gun to my head… remember your marriage proposal?”
*john remembering a nice boat ride after some photos and a movie*
“very funny…????…”
“Very funny” 😆
czcams.com/video/MUwvj51FmNE/video.html
I guess they meant his first one lmao
It must have felt to Abigail like "Marry me or get off the boat.. its my boat" 🤣
@@rohanjerry6362 hahaha too true
@@RedDeadReplay thats actually a dialogue from one of the hindi movies here in india.. a person advising his friend to propose his girlfriend on a boat.. so he says that 😅
RDR1: "Jack's been through a lot..."
Flashbacks to RDR2: Arthur smacking Jack in the face with a fishing pole
"Is that what a pure life has gotten you?! Begging me for help?!"
Thank you Bedbananas
@@Danonfire4god4GODTheGamer "I hate you Uncle Arthur!"
"Are you taking me back?"
@@armandolopezjr5906 "Oh My God... He's massive".
the most painful thing is that there's a little time thingy and if you were late you always fail the mission
Maybe John couldn't help but hurry up fearing that sweet Bonnie is starving....lol
Felt sorry for the horses as wouldnt expect them to have to gallop like that with a full wagon normally.
This was the quickest mission to get from his ranch to her this person went the long ass way just take the shortcut via the train station at the bottom of tall trees an across the stream that was blocked off at the start. Takes like less then 2 minutes smh
@@NIGHTSTALKER848 ..and miss all the dialogue along the way? No way sir :)
@@NIGHTSTALKER848 why do you play these games? They aren't meant to be done "as quick as possible", go play fortnite or one of those other dumbass games if you want no story, and boring gameplay
Abigail and Bonnie destroying John, lmao
"I've never felt so outnumbered!"
@@RedDeadReplay They fucking muderer his ass
@@silverdays2909 nah, they didn’t get the chance.
@@jakobinobles3263 Damn thats pretty fucking dead
In most play through Bonnie proves to be a better rider and shooter
Abigail is so precious. Especially after RDR2, I love her character so much. And her jealousy is so damn funny
It's so damn cute
Ikr, like she's way better in the first game. She acts like a bish in 2nd game.
@@PrinceGummy *OuR sOn, OUr SOn!!!!!!!!!!*
@@wetube6513 *WhAt ChOiCe DiD i HaVe*
@@konoyaruda2544 *PLenTY yoU MorON, plENty!!!!!!*
The thing I like about Abigail is how desperate she is to make their live just working. It's not that she is just jelous. She is just instantly afraid that the whole life they built will fall out. That's why she sees danger everywhere. And looking at their past... Well... You can't really blame her...
Well they are both actively on the run and wanted for Murder among other things. Abignail Shot a law enforcement agent in the head the last time she escaped from captivity while being transported to be tried for murder. Murder has no statute of limitations, John is a fool for hanging around in these any of these states he needed to fake his death. His only chance was to take his family and leave the country.
man the graphics were wayyyy ahead of its time…
Yep and they have a lot of character too with the added sharpness and this weird contrast i cant quite put my finger on, makes it look like a gritty western comic
because Rockstar took advantage of the console and push it to what the console get
Funny, both RDR1 & Skyrim are Open World Game
And RDR1 graphic is x10 times better than Skyrim
@@invoker6219 yeah but Skyrim has about 20x more quests and wayyy more stuff to do so no one cares
Gta 4 came out 2 years before and looks better then this.
The title says Jealous Abigale, but we all know it's Bonnie whose 'really' jealous. That end was like a silent "I hope you realize how lucky you are Abigale.."
5:58 trust me you’ll feel more outnumbered soon
....soon 😭
I used to face this all the time
@@syntax2004 haha how come? You used to argue with sisters and your mother or something? I know men can’t win any argument with women lol
@@RedDeadReplay Everywhere I went whether school, college, or office place female always outnumber male 3/10 ratio, sometimes i'm the only male in the class with female lecturer. At least most of them decent enough to work with.
edit: I can relate Abigail with my mom.
SHUT UP DONT REMIND ME
"Awh, John's gone. Anyway.. AMOS, YA SINGLE?"
😂
I mean it's all fun and games until she accidentally calls out John's name in the heat of the moment
@@ericpalacios920 bruh
@@ericpalacios920 BRUUHHH
@@ericpalacios920 🤣🤣🤣
The way Bonnie looks at John going home at 6:13, it's just like she felt that he'd wouldn't be coming back ever again
I hadn’t realized in a long time how much better the graphics got and how different mission format was
Time makes us feel that way, right? 😉
And how much a mission changes if you do at night day sunset
Graphics where pretty awesome at the time, still aged well imo, specially for console.
@@OneofInfinity. i agree. I'd still play the hell out of the first game any day
@@OneofInfinity. Rdr aged well.
in rdr1, John has such a go with the flow kind of mindset with abigail and...everything lol
I admire him for that. I’ve always liked the way how John dodges any BS from anybody and actually outwits them back when talking. When I was younger, I really wanted to take after him lol
Yes he’s good at keeping out of trouble when he can
@@RedDeadReplay well were you able to
He can’t go with the flow otherwise he will drown
Now that I'm older Bonnie has become one of my favorite female characters ever written. Tough as nails and determined but still has a bit of the sweet country girl charm. The kind of person you can turn to when times are dire but would also be more than happy to help out when her time comes to push.
All spelled out well, dear sir. She’s my favorite female character as well. She’s independent and helping, but also accepts she needs someone’s help when necessary and appreciates the good gestures. I think the two qualities complement each other in such a good way with other people, exchanging human interactions. I think we all can say the same for Sadie, too. Amazing women.
@@RedDeadReplay Sadie is a joke caricature of a """strong""" female character compared to Bonnie. Zero weaknesses, can take on dozens of taller, stronger men all by herself, and her "personality" (if you can even call it that) is just... "psycho". That's it. She kills people and acts "cool". Wow, much personality. At least Bonnie has humanity, and actual weaknesses
@@thomasvleminckx Sadie is literally traumatized by her husband's death. She doesn't act "cool," they purposely made her deranged because she's heavily grieving. She doesn't take on men in fist fights, she uses a gun, which last I checked, a man's physical advantage no longer matters with a literal gun. People who hate Sadie or call her Mary Sue/feminist propaganda don't understand her character at all OR the meaning of Mary Sue. She was far from perfect but fans liked her because she was at the very least loyal to Arthur.
Sadie is okay but not really interesting.
Her character has been done to death by this point.
Bonnie however is sweet and caring.
And is tough.
She doesn't have to act tough like how Sadie is.
"It ain't the first time I've had a gun to my head, John. You're forgettin' your marriage proposal." Oh man that caught me off guard lmao
Hahaha Rockstar really turn that line around in RDR2 with John being the most romantic guy in the entire Rockstar games lol
@@RedDeadReplay If I remember in the proposal mission in RDR 2, Abigail mentions that they're already married. Maybe during the gang prime John proposed in unconventional ways
sweet grind at 7:52
Hi
Oh my driving 🤣
Seems strange for you legends to be commenting on this random video
Tokyo drift is what we peasants say.......
S H R E D D E D C O R N
John: -scans the letter-
Abigail: "can you read it out loud?"
John: "I ain't nothing to hide."
-skims the letter-
AHAHAHAHAHHA John keepin' it safe.
The way he says "STOP" at every full stop is honestly the cutest thing ever for a bounty hunter/outlaw to be saying. And the whole "read it out loud!" Is just hilarious, damn I miss this game.
He does it in RDR2 as well lol
Does anyone get the feeling that bonnie was in love with john?
She was and In a way I’d love to see an alternative love story for them
I never got that feeling actually.. someone like Bonnie seemed a bit uppity.. I don’t think she would romance a mysterious fugitive with a complicated past.. Nor would her father allow her to either.
There was a clear attraction between the two, kept beneath the surface. For a video game, it was very subtle and well done, and it was the first time I remember playing a video game and thinking how effectively the performances were able to convey something like that without getting obvious about it.
I mean she spent a whole 15 dollars just to save his life that must have been any indication
haha yeah I thought that was obvious in so many places among the MacFarlane's Ranch missions
Love how Abigail literally has taken more sack than a medieval grain merchant and she gets jealous that John’s talking to someone
Maybe Abigail has secretly been a philanthropist….? Oh boy that sure gets me curious too 😂
Dutch: “We all had her”
Arthur’s journal: “I shoulda tied the knot with ‘er”
Arthur: “You don’t look like a Marston. Maybe a Williamson or Esuella.”
Jack: *has a striking similarity to Javier with a bit of Dutch*
Abigail: *is confirmed to have f-ed all the gang members*
@@epicc1o1official You mean there was some lumbago involved in there? :s
@@carlosaheca yeah probably
@@carlosaheca it has been said that lumbago introduced her to the gang members so there was some funny business before
*"I like Abigail she's sully but strong...."*
*-**_Micah Bell_** -*
-the legendary rat
Do not say the name of the one who shall not be named
9:13
Abigail: “he grew up with the gay”
John: “he what!?”
Bill was in the gang and i don't think he's into women
It's sad, when you play rdr1 John die, rdr2 Arthur die, and the epilogue play as John... The small amount of happiness, then you remember back rdr1.
Yeah, no kidding. I remember when I got to the Epilogue as John in RDR2, I felt so happy and sad at the same time to see the family living a normal life in that farm because all RDR1 fans know what’s slated to happen there later…
yeah me to when I get some nostalgia when riding in black water and exploring armadillo Damm the town was really bad shape
In RDR3 we will be playing as a Callander boah.
@@OneofInfinity. yeah it pretty much is confirmed! Let's just wait now for rockstar's announcement
Honestly I just felt sad that Arthur was dead
"I've never felt so outnumbered" well... that aged like milk...
Yikes
It's a joke
Wow ur dumb. He was being sarcastic. John has fought dozens at a time and lived he was joking about both of them making fun of him
@@idk5716 he means the end of the game doofus
@@WUNDER64 doofus?💀💀💀😂
Abigail’s redesign in rdr2 is so good. Her model is definitely what they were imagining this version to be.
I'm a bit late but in rdr it's like age ravaged her
@@boartusk4983 stress
@@ciacco6711 and the sun
@@boartusk4983 if only sunblock existed back then lol
RDR2 Abigail is gorgeous, much better looking than RDR1 Abigail.
3:28 they NAILED Bill’s character in Rdr2 from the way John and Abigail describe him
This is the most accurate portrayal of a woman in fiction
Haha I agree!
I had to do research on American society during the "wild" west, and you sir, are correct. Whether its intentional or not, the RDR series definitely seems like r* put a lot of time in doing their research instead of remimagining what/ how women behave and acted within a growing society
As a girl, one of my biggest complaints with video games is that they lack relatable and realistic women. Oftentimes they are overly sexualized or made to be very masculine to cover their feminine traits and justify strength. However, both Rdr1 and 2 have done a fantastic job with all their female characters. It’s such a relief to see so many women I can relate to.
@@ThatsShowbizBabyy agreed :)
@@ThatsShowbizBabyyyeh but you have seen the male characters they are literally 90% muscle
5:58 now THAT is how you foreshadow future events rights!
OOFF maybe if he had the gatling gun stowed away :*( or if he really tried
*7:20** "She did blush redder than a shepherd's sunset when she saw you, though."*
I don't know why but the way Bonnie looks and acts when John leaves is the most heartbreaking thing 😭 So well done
1:48 damn she ran fast😂
Tf😂
I like this Abigail's voice. It sounds different in RDR2
Shes played by another person in rdr2, thats why she sounds different
but Abigail’s in RDR2 is prettier
@@rielbignell30 yes she has more pixels xD
@@rielbignell30 se is like 13 years younger to
@@PepeBote11a 4 years
6:22 Awww poor Bonnie, she really liked John
Dang glad to see people still talk about this masterpiece of a game
So am I, chief!
So am I
Wish it was on steam or somethin. I could only play it with PlayStations shitty cloud service which was, on a technical level, not a good experience.
“Not exactly the most romantic letter ain’t it?”
Damn son
"She's a woman in a man's world" is the most badass thing you said to your special one. My late mom is exactly that, strongest woman I ever knew.
“I’d never felt so outnumbered”
EPIC FORESHADOWING MOMENT
The way she kicks her foot around when he leaves 🥺😭 poor Bonnie
I wish they’d remaster this game
Well I’d want a remake version, if possible. We fans can only wish.
@@RedDeadReplay it be nice a whole version where the whole 2 games play in the same map. You finish RDR2 and then it goes into *4 years later* screen. And rdr1 starts. And the rdr2 map is completely available. That'd be perfect. And if we could play undead nightmare in the whoooole map, that'd be even sweeter
@@Zokalex Absolutely. What could be better?
It’s actually in the works as we speak
@@DaltonSligh For real...?
0:39 hey Uncle
The One-shot Kid!
A guy who has literally taken on platoons of hardened killers faces two sneering women and says "I've never felt so outnumbered" lol classic Rockstar.
"... two sneering women..."
Super epic, dude!😂
1:35 the gesture lol.
1:23 “well Y’know, little bit like Sadie”
Rockstar can make some fun and interesting female characters, they just don't want you playing with them.
To be fair, you could play as Abigail in the online portion of the game lol.
@Xavier Viera lmaooooo what a menace😂
Play with a female in the wild west would be like a cooking game
Too bad there's no fun and interesting female characters in real life. 😎
@@mywifesboyfriend5741 i didn't find one yet, so I have to agree
Ooooh I just realized that sadie adler’s letter was inspired be bonnie’s LMAO
Haha you’re right
Wait how?
@@LS-kr3sh the way she’s just making a disaster in the grammar and the STOP
@@inl2024 oh, I think that the STOPs were in every telegram back on the day. They represent when the speaker stopped speaking and paused.
@@LS-kr3sh idk about that
When I first played through this game I caught the way Bonnie was acting when John was leaving and I said it even when I was young she had feelings for him and seeing this again only further confirms it for me Bonnie has feelings for John . Also I would love to see Bonnie again Inna bigger role then just a stranger mission in RDO
Just make Jack and Bonnie meet ez
"I know better than to change a man" Bonnie is the opposite of Abigail
Oh I love Bonnie :)
The sheer speed of Abigail getting to the wagon is scary.
2010, I remember playing this in awe. It looked and played so well. Probably still does. After RDR2, this looks like a shock.
And you’ll feel the same way about RDR2 when you compare it to whatever you’ll be playing another decade from now….
That’s life.🥸
@@kgpspyguy That's life, that's what all the people say. You're ridin' high in April, shot down in May.
to be honest, it still looks great to me. Really great for a game of that time time
This game and Rdr2 has 8 years difference.That is why graphic in video games has massive improvement even in just 5-10 years
The chemistry between John and Abigail is spot on 💯
John : "she saved me from dying"
Abigail : "she touched you???"
4:01
Abigail: "A family that left you for dead, you knew the truth John, and they hated you for it"
John: "Arthur didn't."
Arthur didn’t properly address that in the beginning
The way john also did the little hand thing back to abagail was funny
“I’ve never felt so outnumbered” oh you will john… you will
I love how when Abigail points out Bonnie blushed when she saw John he’s so smooth with it “I have that effect on women”
"normal as in two eyes, a mouth, nose, that kind of normal"
Love that line
LoL that part cracked me up. John was smart enough to not say Bonnie was pretty. Admitting to your wife that you find other women attractive is a death sentence for most men
Man I loved the dialogue in the game and in this cutscene in particular!! The conversation flowed so smoothly and naturally and just brings out the charm out of these characters!!
I know Abigail and Bonnie have 2 different women playing them, but in this scene, it sounds like the woman that plays Bonnie is the one doing Abigail.
And there 3 people playing uncle the first 2 died this uncle in rdr1 and rdr2 2
John: “I’ve never felt so out numbered” Me: thinks of the ending of the game…
I love Bonnie, I’m glad we get to meet her again in Online.
Same actress to surprisingly
When John throws his hand back at Abigail when she did it to him has me dead 💀
“I ain’t hidin’ nothin’” *walks away quickly*
The most adorable thing to a loyal man is a jealous woman.
I want a girl like abigail.
Illiterate?
@@the_succ_ hahahaha
Jealous and vindictive? Trust me, you don't want that.
@@MinnesotaSvensk yeah so true and then when you call her out on it she’ll say something like “you are a horrible man John marston”
I think I'd prefer bonnie, hot blonde farm girl
rdr1 John is a thing to be enjoyed and cherished.
He is one of the best characters in the video game industry, in my opinion
I LOVE the distinction as RD2 John just isn't the same no matter what the new age try to argue.
5:35 Meanwhile in RDR2 *_john chillin at a campfire roasting thyme big game meat on a knife_*
"I've never felt so outnumbered!"
*John has a flashback to going up the mountain for Micah, then has a vision of what happens in a few missions from that point*
Bonnie being sad was actually really sad.
Yep she’s normally bubbly and energetic except this mission
I find it hilarious that John says stop everytime there is a period. He does it in RDR2 also. 🤣🤣🤣
That's common practice when reading telegrams. They actually said "STOP" in place of periods as well, due to the fact that punctuation was extra while four extra letters was free.
Thanks
CSReeves987 interesting fact
@@CSReeves987 You're right. I went and played the mission where John gets the telegram from Sadie and it says stop all over on it.
@@CSReeves987 that’s so awesome
Ironic that Abigail was jealous of bonnie but yet had no problem asking how bill was when she had history with nearly all of the gang
Abigail was most likely asking out of curiosity and not because of Bill's situation or past history. Bill is a closeted gay (there is several hints and comments to it in RDR2) so its most likely that when Abigail was the gang's prostitute, Bill didnt do anything with her.
If she truly had sex with the gang and it wasn't dutch messing with John, Abigail only was with Javier, Dutch, John himself and maybe Arthur (although based on Arthur's character and feelings for her, i doubt he would've accepted a one-night stand)
Well, Bill was probably one of the few men in the gang who didn’t touch Abigail, because… well, you know why 😂
I really adore the way they addressed each other in the 1800-1900s
Maam, Miss, Mister, Ms
sounds really polite and earnest for some reason, respectful too
Some of my grandparents still say that and you'll see some old folk in the southeast and midwest do it
Just realized RDR2 Abigail voice actress did a really good job. They sound super similar
I love John giving it a quick once over to make sure there isn’t anything bad on it lmao
5:58 he’s gonna feel outnumbered at the end
0:40 way to walk right in the shot Uncle
Haha yeah that’s Uncle being himself right there
Uncle: Lumbago's very serious condition. Need to spread awareness.
4:17 i love how they talk like an old married couple, they really deserved eachother
rdr1 isn’t canon to me 😍
@@tigrispanthera5496 what?
@@SQOUREE just a joke
@@tigrispanthera5496 but it's not that good of a joke, you can give me some details?
@@SQOUREE so in rdr2 arthur worked hard to get john a peaceful life with his family right, but in rdr1 john died as his past catches up to him and he doesn’t get a happy ending 😭 so i just consider rdr1 non-canon as a way to cope 😅 just a little joke yk?
I grew up playing this, so needless to say i got the 2nd A.S.A.P
But i tell you, playing them in chronological order... is worth the time spent. It's like watching a 12 season Netflix Western
She’s the same height as marston in RDR2 but 5 inch shorter in RDR1.
I think it is because of the mo-cap actress.
Heels were just invented
Also in rdr2 he looks like Arthur morgan...
@@wetube6513 True and the only thing that looked obvious was head , they reuse Arthur Morgan headshape and body
Most of the characters in RDR2 are the same height but Arthur is tall as shit and so is Dutch compare to John
god, i love how much context rdr2 adds to this game.
Abigial: Talking about life-
John: *NEARLY FALLING OFF THE DAMN BRIDGE.*
Is it just me or is Bonnie bout to ride that feller that tilted his hat to her?
Haha maybe. She didn’t seem to think high of him(Amos) being too countrified and all though lol
But he's loyal and hardworking. Sure he's not gritty but end of the day they have a business to run.