“You get a thanks from him a few days later, no benefits” Um . . . no? He becomes mayor and your bounty in Lemoyne will be completely removed no matter how high it is, you can do a FUCKTON of crime in Rhodes and Saint Denis and as long as he becomes mayor it’ll all get forgiven
Is that why everyone raves about what a great character Arthur is? Cuase hes a psycho just like nico belec was,both would be complete pos if they were real.but people somehow think deep down would be good or something idk I don't get it.
When you dump the corpse of a man you killed in a particular place and then fish up a rotten human arm in that same place it doesn't take a rocket scientist to guess whose arm it is.
@connorperrett9559 To be fair there's an uncomfortable trend you see in instances of a serial killer being caught where it's like "Police noticed the human bone pile in the killers front yard when responding to a 12th 9-1-1 call from a neighbor reporting an unfamiliar woman's voice screaming 'he's going to kill me'. Police spoke to the killer at the door and left without incident. Some months later when a dog walker reported his dog finding human remains on the property, a warrant was secured to search the human bone pile in the killer's yard, and what they found shocked investigators..."
After going to the mayors house for that big party he’ll send you a letter in the mail. You need to open this letter for the missions to pop up. After you’ve done that wait till it’s night time and the missions should pop up at the mayors house. 😁
@@hhdjgghfdhd765 In what way is that smart ass? It's simply a fact that if you don't explore outside of main story missions, you won't find stuff like this. This interaction isn't exactly obscure for someone who's taken the time to explore and interact with the open world.
You're right, I simply cannot bring myself to shoot an unarmed man who is begging for his life on his knees... Arthur's reaction when he fishes out Jean-Marc's arm, though 🤣
People will say anything when their life is on the line. Though considering this is a sidequest, you already know you won't really face any consequences.
I'm not granting you this wish any more. No matter how many times we go through this, you beat the game and say the same thing, "I wish I could erase my - -", Enough! I did, time and again. You don't appreciate any more the next time, because you don't know that you're experiencing it for the first time again. The wish was pointless. And I'm not wasting my time doing it anymore.
@@youdontknowmegignathe point of the wish is in fact replaying it without knowing if it's actually good. But i agree with you 100% we should appreciate every moment in life, instead of thinking of the past. When i played it for the first time i somewhat knew that it was a great game so i played it slow and careful to enjoy it better.
If you go to the railroad company near Van Horn sometime around chapter 2 you can help out the foreman just like how you can help the foreman in the timber company near strawberry
My first play through started off LH as I familiarized myself with the game and its mechanics. But slowly but surely, I turned Arthur into a better man as the story progressed. Going into the final mission with nearly if not full HH. I lost some though when I chose to go back for the money 😂
Him trekking across the country side with the severed decomposing arm of the man he ruthlessly murdered just to mess with Pearson is arguably even MORE fucked up then just being an outright cannibal.
1:17, I did the math a long time ago about how long the game is & I got to 5 months. From May (As Hosea states in the opening scene) to October. Idr all the particulars but that's what I got. Although this letter contradicts that as it says "June 1899". Though that is impossible by Chapter 4 They spend no more than a week in Colter. They spend 2 weeks in Horseshoe before we even do a mission. Another, let's say 3 weeks there before you leave (Assuming you're playing at a normal pace). And without mentioning much more, the weeks you spend recovering from the O'Driscoll capture in Chapter 3 alone would put you past June at this point of Chapter 4. Not a big deal big picture, but in a game where they payed so much attention to detail in the smallest of things, I do find this kinda interesting
@@holysol Think about it. If you're not trying to go at a faster pace than normal & sleeping like you would in real life it can realistically add up to 5 months. That's 20 weeks. 1 week in Colter. 2 weeks in Horseshoe before you play a mission. Then another 2 to 3 weeks before you gotta leave. About 2 weeks in Clemen's Point before you get captured by the O'Driscolls & then the game says "A few weeks later" for your recovery which would imply more than 2 weeks. So lets say 3 (We're at 10-11). More important side missions start to pop up when you're at Shady Belle like the Indians, the Mayor, the Slave owner at fence which leads to Sister Calderon. So what would be like 2 weeks with just main missions can easily turn to 3 (13-14 weeks). At least a week in Guarma (14-15). Then in Lakay & Beaver Hollow, between all the loose ends/ side missions on top of the main story, that could easily be 4 to 5 weeks (18-20). You can make the argument that maybe it falls a little short of October, but that's assuming they were in the very beginning of May to start. We don't know if it was mid way or late May
Low Honor Arthur gets more badass one-liners and moments (that I enjoy), but end game, High Honor/Help John feels most rewarding; if for no other reason, Arthur finally having peace (from Micah and Dutch) and taking pride in himself for what he's accomplished, and denying Micah the opportunity to kill him.
Uh, I'm sure the majority of low honor players would also never "realize" this as well. It's not an obvious thing, more like an easter egg/internal reference. Nothing to "realize" it's a curiosity. A very well done one at that.
As a high honour player I killed him and after went greeting people so I got all the benefits and no losses and before anyone mentions the pardon remember in chapter 4 you have the bank robbery and in chapter 6 Arthur will soon be gone I think the next playthrough I start I will try low honour
The level of attention to detail put into this game will never be short of astonishing. The fact that even now people are still finding secrets is amazing.
@@one1848 Eh, fair enough. I usually use them for the Sadie Adler mission where you fight off the O’Driscolls… basically right at the HEIGHT of the gang’s living, right before everything starts getting worse. To me, they might not be “western,” but they definitely spell out “luxury.”
I was a high honor Arthur by this point in the game, but a 10% discount still won me over. I used it to get the black Arabian horse as soon as I got back from Guarma. Only to lose it not long later because of the final mission..
dont they have that information? i thought they might have for rdr1, i remember they said it was for stuff like leaderboards or something. would be cool to see it
you can just spam fishing to get maximum high honour, or murder everyone you see to get zero honour. my last playthrough i was a bad bad outlaw all thw way through, the nnear the end spend a couple of hours fishing and throwing them back until i had maximum honour so i could get the good ending
I feel so accomplished when I watch one of those videos that are like “YoU dIdNt knOw ThIs wAs iN tHe GaMe” and then I know that it is in the game. Then I realise the amount of time i’ve put into the game and feel slightly embarrassed. Atleast i know everything about the game though😂
Rdr2 looks like the producer and animators did their work far early than given time and in course they did add more of interctive part it in...whew... amazing details
This game never cease to amaze me I've been playing it since 2020 or earlier and still discovering new things, like fishing and finding the arm of the guy
Man i need to play this game again with lowest honour, it’s just that I m soon getting married, don’t want the wife to think she got hitched with some psychopath 😅😂
Bruh you know you can just tap L1 or the equivalent to holster your gun without opening the weapon wheel, or even double tap to do a fancy little spin-holster move.
It’s just my personal way of interpretation. The mission title is Pragmatism and Idealism, by following Henry order you receive actual benefit despite knowing he’s a rat through and through, u could say it’s a pragmatic thing to do as it benefits you thru ur journey. By sparing Jean Marc you receive nothing and not even sure if Jean Marc even gonna pursue for the betterment of Saint Denis denizen successfully albeit the idealistic way. TLDR: Henry, practical way of life Jean Marc, idealistic way of life
I've played through this game 3 times and I've tried to have an high honor play throughs, and soon as I leave Valentine everytime I become a low honor, gun slingin, bank robbin, no guff takin outlaw. 😂
"You sir, are an arm."
Arthur Morgan 1956
Lmao
That would have been funny too 😆
@@thewolfgamers5061lol Arthur dies in 1899 so he’d be in heaven
You sir are not a fish
“You get a thanks from him a few days later, no benefits”
Um . . . no? He becomes mayor and your bounty in Lemoyne will be completely removed no matter how high it is, you can do a FUCKTON of crime in Rhodes and Saint Denis and as long as he becomes mayor it’ll all get forgiven
A true high honor doesn't have bounties
@@akindtroll28A good point. I would love to atleast get something worth but I guess knowing that the Mayor got ousted was satisfying
@@akindtroll28 ITS NOT MY FAULT EVERY TIME IM IN SAINT DENIS A RANDOM CITIZEN WALKS INTO MY HORSE AND THEN ENTIRE BLOCK BECOMES WITNESSES
@@kindertak5396I feel this 😂
@@akindtroll28 Legit accidents happen tbh. Sometimes you're riding a horse, hit a guy and you're in for a shitshow
Arthur reacts to seeing an innocent man who he murdered's decaying arm like hes reuniting with an old friend who he has some bad blood with
1.6k likes and no comment? Let me fix that
@@ThatGuy77574agreed.
@@ThatGuy77574comments like these are so stupid but like congrats bud at least ur happy with it 😭
Is that why everyone raves about what a great character Arthur is? Cuase hes a psycho just like nico belec was,both would be complete pos if they were real.but people somehow think deep down would be good or something idk I don't get it.
"You sir, are an arm"
And peolple still try to argue that gta 5 is better🤡
RDR2 makes GTA 5 look like it was written by middle-schoolers who just got their parents' permission to curse.
Yeah but you can't win an argument against GTA 5 fans, their average age is about the same as the game.
GTA 5 was in 2013.
RDR2 was in 2018
i agree i've played both and rdr2 will forever be better
I can't think of any game better than rdr2
Arthur: I am not a paid killer
Me: True, you kill for free😢
perhaps minors 😂
@@TheRastafarianStuffwhat
@@TheRastafarianStuffwhat
For free? He ain't your idea of charity. Just get him the damn money.
@@TheRastafarianStuffhuh?
"OK... CATCH you later then!"
"OK...I should get back to it"
666 likes
ahahahahahahaha
His body identification skills are waaaaay better than most investigators 😂
to be fair most investigators didnt kill the body their investigating
And dump/find the same body in the exact same location...
He has a memory... It's a good memory.
When you dump the corpse of a man you killed in a particular place and then fish up a rotten human arm in that same place it doesn't take a rocket scientist to guess whose arm it is.
@connorperrett9559 To be fair there's an uncomfortable trend you see in instances of a serial killer being caught where it's like "Police noticed the human bone pile in the killers front yard when responding to a 12th 9-1-1 call from a neighbor reporting an unfamiliar woman's voice screaming 'he's going to kill me'. Police spoke to the killer at the door and left without incident. Some months later when a dog walker reported his dog finding human remains on the property, a warrant was secured to search the human bone pile in the killer's yard, and what they found shocked investigators..."
Jean-Marc: "You wouldn't shoot a sad little man, would you?"
Low-Honor Arthur: "Yeah, in the face. Why?"
Lol is that Jack Horner or Marston?
@@The14thDuskhorner
@@The14thDusk It's Marston he looks exactly like John as he has gotten older in RDR1
“You sir, are Jean Marc”
Laughed out loud
🤡🤡
😂
Anyone else get sort of Negan vibes when Arthur greets that man’s arm?
I love both characters but they are not a like at all lol
@@Rexmex9 oh I get that wasn’t saying they are alike just saying I could see Negan acting the same way Arthur did with the arm
"Big Richie? is that you? Look at you! loyal to the end"
His Jacket reminds me of Rick’s too
@@xubikiltro5263yepp that’s the part😭😭
i didnt even know this whole interaction was in the game wtf
You missed,for me after completing the story twice I realized the most interesting aspect of the game is the open world
You must've done very little exploring then.
@@Dagger_323ok so you gonna tell us how to start it or just leave a smart ass remark?
After going to the mayors house for that big party he’ll send you a letter in the mail. You need to open this letter for the missions to pop up. After you’ve done that wait till it’s night time and the missions should pop up at the mayors house. 😁
@@hhdjgghfdhd765 In what way is that smart ass? It's simply a fact that if you don't explore outside of main story missions, you won't find stuff like this. This interaction isn't exactly obscure for someone who's taken the time to explore and interact with the open world.
Even in death, Jean Marc is able to give Arthur a hand.
hopefully the mayor doesnt get all up in arms about it
sounds like he's one to get a-head pretty quick
It cost him an arm and a leg though.
underrated comment!
You're right, I simply cannot bring myself to shoot an unarmed man who is begging for his life on his knees... Arthur's reaction when he fishes out Jean-Marc's arm, though 🤣
He’s only unarmed after he dies.
@@jamskinner Your "unarmed man" comment made me straight up think of that one achievement from Max Payne 3
10% discount is 10% tho
People will say anything when their life is on the line. Though considering this is a sidequest, you already know you won't really face any consequences.
@@RedNightFox You're so right! I didn't think about that one, well done!
I wish I could erase my memory and play this game again
I'm not granting you this wish any more. No matter how many times we go through this, you beat the game and say the same thing, "I wish I could erase my - -", Enough! I did, time and again. You don't appreciate any more the next time, because you don't know that you're experiencing it for the first time again. The wish was pointless. And I'm not wasting my time doing it anymore.
@@youdontknowmegigna CURSES !!!!!!!!
@@youdontknowmegignathe point of the wish is in fact replaying it without knowing if it's actually good. But i agree with you 100% we should appreciate every moment in life, instead of thinking of the past. When i played it for the first time i somewhat knew that it was a great game so i played it slow and careful to enjoy it better.
You've got a deadpool pfp, so you're def. low on neurons.
Gotta wonder if we'll ever discover everything this game has to offer.
If you go to the railroad company near Van Horn sometime around chapter 2 you can help out the foreman just like how you can help the foreman in the timber company near strawberry
Most high honor players are just reformed low honor players lol. We know this exists
Eh, I just chose to go high honor since the beginning, why do you think micah's first mission was my bane?
@@bcgazero6472Because it meant freeing the rat from prison instead of just letting him swing?
@@jasonlewis3742 that and it's a major strike on my honor
My first play through started off LH as I familiarized myself with the game and its mechanics. But slowly but surely, I turned Arthur into a better man as the story progressed. Going into the final mission with nearly if not full HH. I lost some though when I chose to go back for the money 😂
@@bcgazero6472 I feel the same way I spent 3 days trying to find a way to let Micah die. Disappointing
I’m may be a High Honor Player, but I wouldn’t say nah on killing for 10% discount.
Especially when there's nothing really to buy in the game and you have a whole bank vault in your saddle. I only really ride one horse.
@@urbansk8r231same, I just go with white arabian my whole playthrough
They shouldve made an option to keep the arm and donate it to pearson for some special encounter of him questioning your sanity
Him trekking across the country side with the severed decomposing arm of the man he ruthlessly murdered just to mess with Pearson is arguably even MORE fucked up then just being an outright cannibal.
"This will help the stew"
1:17, I did the math a long time ago about how long the game is & I got to 5 months. From May (As Hosea states in the opening scene) to October. Idr all the particulars but that's what I got. Although this letter contradicts that as it says "June 1899". Though that is impossible by Chapter 4
They spend no more than a week in Colter. They spend 2 weeks in Horseshoe before we even do a mission. Another, let's say 3 weeks there before you leave (Assuming you're playing at a normal pace). And without mentioning much more, the weeks you spend recovering from the O'Driscoll capture in Chapter 3 alone would put you past June at this point of Chapter 4. Not a big deal big picture, but in a game where they payed so much attention to detail in the smallest of things, I do find this kinda interesting
what? you're real bad at math.
@@holysol Think about it. If you're not trying to go at a faster pace than normal & sleeping like you would in real life it can realistically add up to 5 months. That's 20 weeks. 1 week in Colter. 2 weeks in Horseshoe before you play a mission. Then another 2 to 3 weeks before you gotta leave. About 2 weeks in Clemen's Point before you get captured by the O'Driscolls & then the game says "A few weeks later" for your recovery which would imply more than 2 weeks. So lets say 3 (We're at 10-11). More important side missions start to pop up when you're at Shady Belle like the Indians, the Mayor, the Slave owner at fence which leads to Sister Calderon. So what would be like 2 weeks with just main missions can easily turn to 3 (13-14 weeks). At least a week in Guarma (14-15). Then in Lakay & Beaver Hollow, between all the loose ends/ side missions on top of the main story, that could easily be 4 to 5 weeks (18-20). You can make the argument that maybe it falls a little short of October, but that's assuming they were in the very beginning of May to start. We don't know if it was mid way or late May
@@koolkat518 i have yet to beat the game and have def spent more than a few in-game months just roaming and fishing.
“You sir, are a fish.”
There will never be a game like this again
stupid thing to say
@@lovethyneighbor3401 I bet some people were saying that over atari beeps and boops. Pretty short sighted.
Baldur's Gate 3 and possibly RDR3 if it gets done.
@@legocontrollerjr my hopes are not high for RDR3 Rockstar has changed since then. Not to mention gta VI will overshadow it
@@ben-frey7864Yep. We never even got any DLC's for RDR2. I was hoping for Undead Nightmare 2, but R* focuses purely on GTA.
I spared him and he IMMEDIATELY reported me to the authorities. I never felt more betrayed in my life.
Must be a bug, did you shoot the air or something?
Still funny to hear jack and Geoff in the game
Man I didn't even know that there is a mission for the mayor of saint denis
Low Honor Arthur gets more badass one-liners and moments (that I enjoy), but end game, High Honor/Help John feels most rewarding; if for no other reason, Arthur finally having peace (from Micah and Dutch) and taking pride in himself for what he's accomplished, and denying Micah the opportunity to kill him.
The story was so captivating, I felt so immersed with the way it reeled me in.
Uh, I'm sure the majority of low honor players would also never "realize" this as well. It's not an obvious thing, more like an easter egg/internal reference. Nothing to "realize" it's a curiosity. A very well done one at that.
Bruh….this game has so much lol. Hard to imagine another game with this much detail coming out again.
Who says crime doesn't pay?!
As a high honour player I killed him and after went greeting people so I got all the benefits and no losses and before anyone mentions the pardon remember in chapter 4 you have the bank robbery and in chapter 6 Arthur will soon be gone I think the next playthrough I start I will try low honour
The level of attention to detail put into this game will never be short of astonishing.
The fact that even now people are still finding secrets is amazing.
"You sir, are an arm"
U get this interaction for a quest later on too, if I am not wrong.
The Low Honor option comes in real handy when buying a pair of the two 1899 pistols… basically THE MOST EXPENSIVE guns in the whole game.
Low honor option then raise your honor again. 60% discount.
I never use those anyway. Not nearly western enough for my taste. Single action revolvers all the way.
@@one1848
Eh, fair enough.
I usually use them for the Sadie Adler mission where you fight off the O’Driscolls… basically right at the HEIGHT of the gang’s living, right before everything starts getting worse.
To me, they might not be “western,” but they definitely spell out “luxury.”
😢😢😢🎉😢
This guy doesnt have that problem, he can buy everything in the game with his 1 mil
This game has been out for almost 6 years, and I'm still learning about new details in it. Can you think of anything else like this in any media?
Still finding new things about this game. Amazing
I don't even remember this being a mission at all
I did the exactly same thing with high honor at max.
Bro I got the platinum trophy and i've never seen anything like this that's crazy
even the music playing after you shoot him, this game is a masterpiece
I was a high honor Arthur by this point in the game, but a 10% discount still won me over. I used it to get the black Arabian horse as soon as I got back from Guarma. Only to lose it not long later because of the final mission..
I have never seen this scene
Would be interesting if Rockstar have stats from every rdr2 player. Over all honour % high or low
dont they have that information? i thought they might have for rdr1, i remember they said it was for stuff like leaderboards or something. would be cool to see it
you can just spam fishing to get maximum high honour, or murder everyone you see to get zero honour. my last playthrough i was a bad bad outlaw all thw way through, the nnear the end spend a couple of hours fishing and throwing them back until i had maximum honour so i could get the good ending
You can tell the right option based on the music
i would literally have never found that arm encounter
I feel so accomplished when I watch one of those videos that are like “YoU dIdNt knOw ThIs wAs iN tHe GaMe” and then I know that it is in the game. Then I realise the amount of time i’ve put into the game and feel slightly embarrassed. Atleast i know everything about the game though😂
Amazing this game is 5 years old and still revealing secrets.
Rdr2 looks like the producer and animators did their work far early than given time and in course they did add more of interctive part it in...whew... amazing details
You can double tap L2/RB to holster your gun with style
This game never cease to amaze me
I've been playing it since 2020 or earlier and still discovering new things, like fishing and finding the arm of the guy
I literally gasped when he pulled up the severed arm 😂
its 2024 and we can still find something new no one ever found before in this game..
the level of detail in this game is insane
That arm would be absolutely disgusting to be near after a few days of decomposing in water, and he just holds it bare-handed
Eugh
Had this encounter on high honor
How did you fish his arm out of the river if you didn't kill him?
@@luke7834 at the mayors house and I never said I killed him not killing him itself it's high honor.
Shocked me when I caught an arm in that river
How the hell did I miss all of this
Man i need to play this game again with lowest honour, it’s just that I m soon getting married, don’t want the wife to think she got hitched with some psychopath 😅😂
Just finished my first max high honor play through, next will be max low honor.
You've committed suicide anyway. Don't get married guy! You'll thank me 😂😂😂
Then you teach her to play and next thing you know she's at lowest honor possible
Maybe she's trying to get you to save her brother from the Chelonians, and later her father from pawning her mother's jewellery. Aight there, boah?
Well, no point in killing him, i suppose. Reward is useless.
Exactly. Should've put a Rolex on it or something
Pretty sure you can still find an arm if you spare him or fish there before this mission
“You are a good man, Arthur Morgan”
imma be honest i forgot this mission line existed
It's a hidden mission with the mayor
This is clickbait, you can do this mission with high honor
Who said you couldn't?
I’m thinking about doing another play through but low honor this time
Now that's a new way to disarm someone
You sir are not a fish
You can still find the arm even when you don’t kill Jean-Marc
This game continues to blow me away
RDR2 has one of, if not, the most detailed and organic world I've ever seen in a video game
Arthur cain’t escape the long arm of the law.
Bruh you know you can just tap L1 or the equivalent to holster your gun without opening the weapon wheel, or even double tap to do a fancy little spin-holster move.
This guy got very lucky I only got around to these missions by chapter 6
The music after u kill him 🤌🏻✨
No way I've never seen that before that's actually crazy
you find the arm regardless of honor level
You get up to 50% in all stores, even low tier high honor nets you more than a measly 10% off
That was GREAT. KEEP THEM COMING..
2:38 i love arthur response
Oh- DAMN
"and don't mention me BOAH" 🤣
Geoff making an appearance.
Arthur’s reaction to the arm kills me😂
We spared him. ❤
DAMN THIS GAME IS FILLED WITH THESE!!!
You get the same choice regardless of what level your honor is at.
It’s just my personal way of interpretation. The mission title is Pragmatism and Idealism, by following Henry order you receive actual benefit despite knowing he’s a rat through and through, u could say it’s a pragmatic thing to do as it benefits you thru ur journey. By sparing Jean Marc you receive nothing and not even sure if Jean Marc even gonna pursue for the betterment of Saint Denis denizen successfully albeit the idealistic way.
TLDR:
Henry, practical way of life
Jean Marc, idealistic way of life
No one can ever explore this game on their own completely🔥🔥
0:48 "I'm just a little guy! You wouldn't shoot a sad little guy would you?"
Well, at least he said he was sorry
High honor benefits: thank you letter, no use
Low honor benefits: an arm. Cook it
You, sir, are an arm
2:37 i cant decide if Arthur is childlike or a psycopath here 😂
Mr. Pearson could probably make something with that.
I’ve never even seen this mission before.
"You, sir, are a fish."
"You sir are a fish"
its insane people are still finding things like this. wow
Strange man set up
thats so fucking insane wtf. so much detail
Jean marc becomes mayor and sends you a letter later on if you let him live.
I've played through this game 3 times and I've tried to have an high honor play throughs, and soon as I leave Valentine everytime I become a low honor, gun slingin, bank robbin, no guff takin outlaw. 😂
He fished up that arm and might as well have said "DAMNIT JEAN-MARC M'BOY........stop sloping off on me!"