Support our work: / adnanrashid Follow Adnan Rashid on his social networks: Facebook: / mradnanrashid Twitter: / mradnanrashid Contact: adn_rd@yahoo.co.uk
Assalamu alaikum everyone, Thank you for your comments. I would like to make a clarification that as far as we, the Sunni Muslims, are concerned the Quran does state one has to make ghusl (bathing as the prophet taught) after major impurity, as is clear from the following verses: Quran 4;43 and 5;6. The context of the terms تغتسلوا or فاطهروا only becomes clear through hadith (the prophetic tradition), as the terms could mean ablution, washing hands/feet or washing anything for that matter.The Quranists, however, have no basis to make ghusl (bath) after major impurity (janabah) without hadith clarifying the meaning of the relevant Quranic terms, hence my argument "show me where it says to make ghusl (bath) after major impurity". Sometimes the argument does not come out clearly and clarifications must be made. Sometimes one even has to plead ignorance to highlight the opponent's ignorance on the matter, hence my statements "I concede defeat"; "throw the hadith in the sea"; "show me how the Quran came to us" etc. These questions do not imply that we don't know the answers, rather these questions are rhetorical methods to highlight the opponent's error. Jazakumullahu khairan.
Adnan Rashid when he mentioned the months you should have asked him where does it say in the quraan that those months were sacred. He also mentioned that the quraan was transmitted, it was ideal to pounce on him and ask how was it transmitted. but basically it was just running away.
The weird thing is, these people do not believe in the sunnah because the transmitters of the hadith were contradicting and unreliable. But at the same time they believe in the quran as the fully word of god, although the quran is transmitted from the same people who transmitted the hadith. Allah Mustaan
Jazakallah brother Ustadh Adnan Rashid for enlightened discussion and exposing the ignorance of the Hadith rejectors. May Allah reward you and increase your knowledge. Ameen and Walaikum As Salam warahmatullah.
Nauzabillah!! I can even utter what he said about prophet Muhammad (saw) my goodness. Scary speech indeed. May Allahswt forgive his ignorance and guide him. Ameen.
Seriously man, only you have the patience to deal with all that you deal with! May Allah bless you and give you more strength! Thankyou for doing all that you do!
i have a question to the quranist,, the quran clearly command us, pray, now was the prophet also pray? the answer is yes, now how can he prayed,is it like what the quranist way? if yes then provide your proof?? question 2, who was abu lahab? q3 who was ahmad? q4 in quran 9:100,the sahabba promised by God to heaven, now the qustion is, was it not the people who transmitted the hadeeth? if no, then provide your evidence, if yes,then why Allah(swt)promised them to heaven??
Walaikkum Salam I listen this conversation.its is so heart breaking for me.Being a muslim how can he follow only quran rejecting hadees? My pain is there out my muslim brothers who rejecting the whole hadees.Ashtahfirulla..He learned Al quran for 25 years is that rejection of hadeeth? There no point on learning without beleive in allah & his quran & hadeeth. So sad about this brother..Allah show him right path.
Mosalman Khub. Not really. If you pray hands down you're probably following Imam Malik, other schools of thought teach that the hands should be in different places. But they are all equally valid.
+Mosalman Khub +Aaron Blyth The Muslim should strive to follow the Sunnah to the best of his ability. The Sunnah is to put the hands on the chest: Ibn Khuzaymah (479) narrated that Waa’il ibn Hujr (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: I prayed with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and he placed his right hand over his left hand on his chest. Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Tahqeeq Saheeh Ibn Khuzaymah. There is no hadeeth to prove that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) let his arms hang by his sides when standing during prayer. Imam Malik رحمه الله let his hands down straight because his arms were dislocated by the governor or some equivalent.
Assalamu alaikum everyone,
Thank you for your comments. I would like to make a clarification that as far as we, the Sunni Muslims, are concerned the Quran does state one has to make ghusl (bathing as the prophet taught) after major impurity, as is clear from the following verses: Quran 4;43 and 5;6. The context of the terms تغتسلوا or فاطهروا only becomes clear through hadith (the prophetic tradition), as the terms could mean ablution, washing hands/feet or washing anything for that matter.The Quranists, however, have no basis to make ghusl (bath) after major impurity (janabah) without hadith clarifying the meaning of the relevant Quranic terms, hence my argument "show me where it says to make ghusl (bath) after major impurity". Sometimes the argument does not come out clearly and clarifications must be made. Sometimes one even has to plead ignorance to highlight the opponent's ignorance on the matter, hence my statements "I concede defeat"; "throw the hadith in the sea"; "show me how the Quran came to us" etc. These questions do not imply that we don't know the answers, rather these questions are rhetorical methods to highlight the opponent's error. Jazakumullahu khairan.
Adnan Rashid when he mentioned the months you should have asked him where does it say in the quraan that those months were sacred. He also mentioned that the quraan was transmitted, it was ideal to pounce on him and ask how was it transmitted. but basically it was just running away.
The weird thing is, these people do not believe in the sunnah because the transmitters of the hadith were contradicting and unreliable. But at the same time they believe in the quran as the fully word of god, although the quran is transmitted from the same people who transmitted the hadith. Allah Mustaan
Question to Quranists, which one do you do first, Qyam, Rako or Sajood and how do you end each prayer?
RehanNWL and how do you know we pray 2 rakah for fajar quranist make my head hurt.
Jazakallah brother Ustadh Adnan Rashid for enlightened discussion and exposing the ignorance of the Hadith rejectors. May Allah reward you and increase your knowledge. Ameen and Walaikum As Salam warahmatullah.
Salaam.
Wow, common sense is a punishment. We have to deal with those who don't have it. 🤦🏼♂️
May Allah SWT guide the brother & us all.
Nauzabillah!! I can even utter what he said about prophet Muhammad (saw) my goodness. Scary speech indeed. May Allahswt forgive his ignorance and guide him. Ameen.
musa needs to stop interjecting. Ruins the flow of the discussion.
Seriously man, only you have the patience to deal with all that you deal with! May Allah bless you and give you more strength! Thankyou for doing all that you do!
I hate when people have glasses on and you cant get eye contact, specially when u are having a conversation.
MightyXP eyes expose deception, hence why he has them covered.
1st thing said is do you have a bath after discharging lol i know its to make a point though
I ALWAYS WATCH YOU ADNAN RASHID FOR KNOWLEDGE TO DEBATE AND YOU HELPT ME A LOT BARAK ALLAH FEEEEH
May Allah protect and bless you Adnan... you have amazing patience with these fools. I would last 10 minutes let alone over an hour...
This other guy kept evading the questions.
i have a question to the quranist,,
the quran clearly command us,
pray,
now was the prophet also pray?
the answer is yes,
now how can he prayed,is it like what the quranist way?
if yes then provide your proof??
question 2,
who was abu lahab?
q3
who was ahmad?
q4
in quran 9:100,the sahabba promised by God to heaven,
now the qustion is,
was it not the people who transmitted the hadeeth?
if no,
then provide your evidence,
if yes,then why Allah(swt)promised them to heaven??
Walaikkum Salam
I listen this conversation.its is so heart breaking for me.Being a muslim how can he follow
only quran rejecting hadees? My pain is there out my muslim brothers who rejecting the whole hadees.Ashtahfirulla..He learned Al quran for 25 years is that rejection of hadeeth?
There no point on learning without beleive in allah & his quran & hadeeth.
So sad about this brother..Allah show him right path.
may Allah bless you br Adnan
Does not praying 5 times a day and the means in how to establish it come from the hadith?
The hadith rejectors are funny people lol
I pray hands down straight does it make Any defference?
Mosalman Khub. Not really. If you pray hands down you're probably following Imam Malik, other schools of thought teach that the hands should be in different places. But they are all equally valid.
+Mosalman Khub
+Aaron Blyth
The Muslim should strive to follow the Sunnah to the best of his ability. The Sunnah is to put the hands on the chest:
Ibn Khuzaymah (479) narrated that Waa’il ibn Hujr (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: I prayed with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) and he placed his right hand over his left hand on his chest. Classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Tahqeeq Saheeh Ibn Khuzaymah.
There is no hadeeth to prove that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) let his arms hang by his sides when standing during prayer.
Imam Malik رحمه الله let his hands down straight because his arms were dislocated by the governor or some equivalent.
And the ahadeeth about putting the hands below the navel while standing are weak.
crazy